Impact and Evidence series Baby Steps in a prison context Parents perspectives Helen Brookes and Denise Coster NSPCC Evaluation department November 2014 Impact and Evidence series This report is part of the NSPCC’s Impact and Evidence series, which presents the findings of the Society’s research into its services and interventions. Many of the reports are produced by the NSPCC’s Evaluation department, but some are written by other organisations commissioned by the Society to carry out research on its behalf. The aim of the series is to contribute to the evidence base of what works in preventing cruelty to children and in reducing the harm it causes when abuse does happen. Contents Acknowledgements4 KEY FINDINGS: YOUNG PEOPLE’S VERSION 5 KEY FINDINGS 6 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 7 Method7 Key findings and implications 7 Chapter 1: Background and Method 1.1 Background 1.2 Method Chapter 2: Outcomes for Parents 10 10 11 13 2.1 New knowledge and skills 2.2 Confidence and reassurance 2.3 Recognition of ‘parent status’ 2.4 Relationships with partners 2.5 Relationship with babies 2.6 Reoffending 2.7 Support and informed advice 13 14 14 15 16 18 18 Chapter 3: Impact of the Prison Context 20 3.1 Lack of control 3.2 Social isolation 3.3 Relationships 3.4 Additional challenges 20 21 22 22 Chapter 4: What Worked Well and Suggested Improvements25 4.1 What worked well 4.2 Suggested improvements 25 28 Chapter 5: Conclusion 30 Appendix 1: Interview topic guide (female prisoners and female partners) 31 Appendix 2: Interview topic guide (male prisoners) 35 Impact and Evidence series 3 Acknowledgements We would like to thank the Baby Steps practitioners and administrators for their help and support in recruiting service users for the interviews on which this report is based. We are also grateful to staff at HMP Newhall, HMP Bronzefield, HMP Armley, HMP Parc, and Wetherby YOI for helping to set up interviews with parents who attended the programme in these prisons. 4 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives KEY FINDINGS: YOUNG PEOPLE’S VERSION Baby Steps is a programme to help new parents. The NSPCC has done some research to find out what parents who participated in the programme in prison thought of it by talking to 18 people who had done it. These are the main things they told us: • Mums and dads liked spending time with each other and with their babies on the programme and said that they felt closer because of it. • Mums and dads who were in prison said they had found out a lot about how to be a good parent from Baby Steps. They had enjoyed being able to talk about their baby with the staff and other parents. • Dads were happy that the programme had helped mums to cope on their own while they were in prison. It made them feel less guilty about not being at home to help them. • Parents really enjoyed being able to come to the group and talk to the other parents. They also liked the fact that the staff answered all their questions. • Pregnant women in prison said that they could not always do the things they had learnt on the programme because of the prison rules. • The programme works best when mums and dads come to the group together, and when they carry on coming to the group after their baby is born. Impact and Evidence series 5 KEY FINDINGS Baby Steps is a perinatal education programme the NSPCC has developed in partnership with parenting experts at Warwick University. As part of the evaluation of the Baby Steps programme, 18 interviews were undertaken with a sample of parents who had completed the programme in prison because either they or their partner were a prisoner. The key findings were: • Parents said that important benefits of the Baby Steps programme were that it improved their communication skills and enabled them to spend extra time with their partner. Some parents also said their relationships with their partners and babies had improved as a result. • The programme was seen as an important source of information for parents in prison because there was little other information or guidance about parenting available. The sessions were also valued as a place where prisoners’ status as a parent was recognised. • For fathers in prison, an additional benefit of the programme was that it helped equip their partners to cope better without them. This lessened their feelings of frustration and guilt about not being able to provide the support they wanted to. • A key factor in the success of the programme was the sense of having dedicated time and space for parents to address their concerns and to share experiences with other parents. • The lack of control that female prisoners felt they had over their lives, and the social isolation they experienced as a result of being in prison limited the extent to which they felt they could implement what they had learnt on the programme. • The findings suggest that the programme works best when both parents are able to attend together and when it includes both preand postnatal sessions. It is also important that the programme is flexible enough to take into account the constraints of the prison context and the transient nature of the prison population. 6 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Baby Steps is a perinatal education programme developed by the NSPCC in partnership with parenting experts at Warwick University. The intervention is a group-based programme delivered to disadvantaged parents from the 28th week of pregnancy. The programme aims to help vulnerable parents manage the transition to parenthood successfully, with a particular emphasis on the relationship between partners and the development of a positive parent-infant relationship. As well as being run at a number of sites for parents in the community, the programme has also been delivered in two men’s prisons, two women’s prisons and one young offenders institute in order to make it accessible to couples where one partner is a prisoner. Qualitative interviews conducted as part of a formative evaluation of the programme during the first year suggested that attending the programme in a prison context may affect parents’ experiences of the programme and the outcomes they identify. As a result, further interviews were conducted with a sample of parents who had completed the programme in a prison setting to explore their experiences in more depth. Although the primary aim of these interviews was to explore parents’ experiences of taking part in the Baby Steps programme in a prison context, the interviews also probed their experiences of pregnancy, childbirth and early parenthood. This was in order to gain an understanding of the context in which they were doing the programme; what other information, services and support were available to them, and whether this affected their experience of the programme. Method The component of the evaluation that explored experiences of taking part in the programme in prison involved 18 face-to-face semi-structured interviews conducted with a sample of prisoners and their partners. It was not possible to employ a purposive sampling strategy due to the small number of parents who had completed the programme and the challenges of recruitment in prisons. A convenience sample was therefore selected. Impact and Evidence series 7 Key findings and implications Parents who had completed the Baby Steps programme in a prison context were able to identify a range of positive outcomes of attending the programme. As was the case for parents who had completed the programme in the community, they had acquired new knowledge about what to expect during pregnancy, labour and birth, and in their role as a new parent. They had also developed new skills in practical baby care and learnt how to communicate effectively with their partners and babies. The programme was a particularly important source of information for parents who were prisoners because limited information was available to them within the prison. Parents felt more confident as a result of being better informed about what to expect during the perinatal period and having a forum to ask questions. Fathers who were prisoners felt reassured by the fact that the programme had equipped their partners to cope better without them, which lessened their feelings of frustration and guilt about not being there to support them. As was the case for parents in the community, participants said the new skills they had learnt in conflict management and effective listening had led to improvements in their relationship with their partner. Similarly, parents said that they felt closer to their baby as a result of learning about the importance of interacting with them, and how to do this at different stages of development. What had improved their relationships the most however, was the extra time that they were able to spend with their partners and babies during the Baby Steps sessions. In particular, they valued the relaxed nature of the sessions, which enabled them to engage in activities they could not do on a normal prison visit. This included feeding and changing their baby, and having a degree of physical contact with their partner. As was the case for parents in the community, parents in prison felt supported by having a dedicated space in which they could raise concerns. This was particularly helpful for this group of parents because they felt that the support available to them within the prison was limited. They also found it useful to share experiences with other parents in the group, with whom they developed supportive relationships. One outcome that was specific to parents in prison was that attending the programme had helped them to come to terms with the reality of the pregnancy, which some had struggled with because there had been little acknowledgement of pregnancy or parenthood in prison. The Baby Steps sessions were valued as a place where their status as a parent or parent-to-be was recognised. 8 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Although parents identified a range of positive outcomes, they also highlighted a number of ways in which the prison context impacted on their experience of the programme and limited the extent to which they were able to implement the learning. Pregnant women who were prisoners said that there were many aspects of their lives over which they had little control. This meant that although they found the information and advice helpful, they were constrained in terms of how much of it they were able to implement. For example, the programme aims to promote healthy eating, but prisoners have to eat the food that is provided to them. In some cases, this had led to them feeling anxious and frustrated. The social isolation of the prison context also impacted on the extent to which parents could implement the learning from the programme in relation to strengthening their social networks, as they only had limited contact with partners, family and friends. And although they had developed supportive relationships on the programme, they only had the opportunity to interact with other parents from the group if they were housed in the same prison wing. In some cases, parents perceived the NSPCC as being able to provide a service beyond the scope of the Baby Steps programme, which had led to disappointment. This was exacerbated by practitioners being unable to provide additional support outside of the sessions, or to signpost them to any other services not available in prison. The implications of these findings for the delivery of Baby Steps or indeed any antenatal programme in prisons is that a lot of flexibility needs to be built into the programme to take into account the constraints of the prison context. The need for a flexible model also arises from the transient nature of the prison population, which requires practitioners to adapt content to the specific needs of the group of parents attending a particular session. The findings suggest that the current format for delivering the programme works well with this population of parents. However, the programme works best when both parents are able to attend together and when it includes both pre- and postnatal sessions. Impact and Evidence series 9 Chapter 1: Background and Method 1.1 Background Baby Steps is a perinatal education programme developed by the NSPCC in partnership with parenting experts at Warwick University. The intervention is a group-based programme of nine sessions delivered to disadvantaged parents from the 28th week of pregnancy, including three sessions after the birth. The programme aims to help vulnerable parents manage the transition to parenthood successfully, with particular emphasis on the relationship between partners and the development of a positive parent-infant relationship. The programme also aims to create social support for parents and to foster their resilience. As well as being run at a number of sites with parents in the community, the programme has also been delivered in two men’s prisons, two women’s prisons and one young offenders institute in order to make it accessible to couples where one partner is a prisoner. Qualitative interviews conducted as part of a formative evaluation of the programme during the first year found that parents identified a range of positive outcomes as a result of attending the programme. They said that it had helped them become more confident in their parenting and they had gained new skills, which meant that they communicated better with their partners and babies, resulting in stronger relationships. This first phase of the evaluation included interviews with some parents who were in prison and their partners. The findings suggested that although they reported similar outcomes to parents in the community, their experience of the programme may have been affected by being in prison and in future it may be necessary to tailor the programme to cater for these parents. To follow up on these findings, a second round of interviews was conducted with a sample of 18 parents who had completed the programme in a prison setting in order to explore their experiences in more depth. The interviews also explored their experiences of pregnancy, childbirth and early parenthood in prison, to gain an understanding of the context in which they were doing Baby Steps; what other information, services and support were available to them, and whether this affected their experience of the programme. The number of sessions attended by parents varied due to the transient nature of the prison population – as did the content of the programme, due to adaptions made at a local level to accommodate the challenges of the particular prison. 10 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives 1.2 Method This component of the Baby Steps evaluation used a qualitative approach because the aim was to gain more understanding of the barriers and facilitators to the programme being delivered in a prison setting, and also to explore in detail the experiences of those who take part in that setting. A qualitative methodology is the most appropriate for those objectives. Sample As only a small number of parents had completed the programme at the time the study took place and gaining access to them within prison was challenging, a convenience sampling strategy was used. The final sample consisted of 18 prisoners (and partners) between the ages of 17 and 43 who were drawn from four prisons: Armley, Parc Bridgend, Newhall, Bronzefield, and one young offenders institute, Wetherby YOI. Of the 12 women prisoners, four were still pregnant at the time of interview while the other eight had already had their babies and were housed in a mother and baby unit. It was decided not to wait until those who were still pregnant had had their babies to interview them, as they would be released before the birth and interviewing them in the community would have posed logistical difficulties. Table 1. Composition of sample by gender and prisoner status Female prisoner Male prisoner Female partners of prisoners 12 4 2 Sample size (N) 18 Recruitment Practitioners who delivered the programme to parents sought written consent from them to take part in the evaluation at the beginning of the programme. Consent forms were collected by the evaluation team, who selected a sample of interviewees and then contacted the prisons directly to establish which parents were still in custody and available for interview. The evaluator requested that prison staff seek confirmation from parents who had consented that they were still happy to proceed before setting up the interviews. This was checked again by the evaluator before the interview started. Prisoners’ partners who were living in the community were contacted directly. Impact and Evidence series 11 Data collection Semi-structured face-to-face interviews were conducted with the parents. Male prisoners were interviewed in a room used for legal visits and female prisoners were interviewed either in the legal room or in their cell. Partners of prisoners living in the community were interviewed at home. Participants were reimbursed for their time either with a voucher, a postal order or a nursery rhyme book to the value of £10. Interviews were either recorded with a digital recorder, or detailed notes of the interview were taken. Transcripts were then produced for analysis. Informed consent, confidentiality and data protection It was made clear to participants that all data would be kept confidential unless a child protection concern was identified, in which case standard NSPCC child protection procedures would be followed. All electronic data was stored securely in password-protected electronic files, and hard copies of information were stored in locked cabinets. Data has been reported on an aggregate rather than individual basis and therefore does not include any identifying details. Names used as quote labels in this report are pseudonyms. Limitations of the research Due to the fact that the analysis was based on data from a convenience sample, it is unlikely that the views expressed reflect the full range and diversity of those in the wider population of parents who have completed Baby Steps in prison. Three out of the 12 women in our sample were still pregnant at the time of interview, so only nine were able to talk about whether they had used the information from the programme during the birth of their child and when caring for their baby in a prison context. Though every effort was made to obtain informed consent, it may have been compromised by the fact that those parents who were prisoners may have felt obliged to take part in the interviews. This may have affected their willingness to express their views and share their experiences. 12 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Chapter 2: Outcomes for Parents Parents who had attended the Baby Steps programme in prison were able to identify a range of positive outcomes from attending the programme. While many of these were similar to those reported by parents in the community, there were some key differences both in the outcomes that they reported and in the mechanisms by which they occurred. 2.1 New knowledge and skills Parents who had attended Baby Steps in prison had acquired new knowledge about what to expect during pregnancy, labour and birth and in their role as a new parent. This was useful both for first-time parents, who gained valuable new information, and to those who had older children, for whom it provided a refresher. The programme was seen as a particularly important resource in a prison context because there was little other information or guidance about parenting available. Female prisoners did have regular midwife appointments but, as is the case in the community, these were short and there was little opportunity to ask questions. Also, although parents were aware that there was a prison library, there was a lack of clarity about how to access it and parents were not sure whether it held books relating to pregnancy and birth. The main sources of information other than the programme were other prisoners, prison officers, or television programmes. This meant that they worried that the information they were getting may not have been comprehensive enough or possibly inaccurate. For example, it was felt that some television programmes focusing on labour and birth presented an unrealistic and unhelpful portrayal. I’ve been watching One born every minute to prepare myself, but it’s all drama and screaming. On Baby Steps though, the midwife said it’s not really as bad as that. (Anna, aged 27) Mothers said they were able to put their new knowledge into practice during pregnancy. Those who had already had their babies at the time of interview also described ways in which they had used their new knowledge and skills during labour, birth and in caring for their new baby. Impact and Evidence series 13 2.2 Confidence and reassurance As was the case for mothers who had completed Baby Steps in the community, those who had done the programme in a prison context felt that they had grown in confidence as a result of gaining knowledge and skills, particularly in terms of communicating with babies and practical baby care. It has made me feel much more confident that I can be a good mother. I don’t have the support of the father and I wasn’t sure that I could do it but I can and it will be fine. (Summer, aged 27) Practitioners were also able to address concerns that individuals had about specific issues. For example, one mother who had a history of mental illness had been worried about the risk of experiencing postnatal depression, but felt less concerned about this having discussed it with practitioners during Baby Steps. Mothers also found that spending time and sharing experiences with other pregnant women who were in the same situation as themselves increased their confidence. For those who were pregnant, being in groups alongside women who had already had their babies was reassuring because they could see they were coping well. Fathers in prison who attended the programme recognised that their partners had grown more confident and felt that it had equipped their partners to cope better alone. This helped allay their feelings of frustration and guilt about the fact that they were unable to support their partners through the challenges of pregnancy and birth. The biggest thing was that it gave my partner more confidence about giving birth on her own because she was naturally anxious about it. So knowing she was feeling more confident put me more at ease. (Angus, aged 38) 2.3 Recognition of ‘parent status’ Some prisoners said that being pregnant in prison can make the pregnancy feel unreal because there is a lack of acknowledgement of it. Mothers said that they did not have the opportunity to interact with other pregnant women or discuss their pregnancy until they got transferred to the mother and baby unit shortly before their due date. When they attended Baby Steps sessions they felt that their pregnancies were valued and their status as a parent was recognised. They could also share their thoughts and feelings about their babies. 14 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives It made me feel like a normal pregnant woman, not a pregnant woman in prison. It was nice to be able to go and talk about babies and being pregnant and not think about being in prison. (Sophie, aged 30) The programme encourages parents to form an attachment with their unborn child through learning about their baby’s stage of development, and imagining his or her future characteristics. Parents said that this information had helped them to come to terms with the reality of the pregnancy, which some said they had been struggling to do. It made me realise more about how I was going to be a mum and stuff like that because it didn’t feel real when I first come to prison. I was only like a few weeks pregnant, it just felt weird, I don’t know. When they showed us the books and stuff like that and like what stage the baby was at then that’s what made it feel more real. (Suzie, aged 21) The information provided was particularly important for fathers in prison because they said that they had felt disconnected from the pregnancy as they were not living with their partners on a day-today basis and did not have the opportunity to observe the physical changes associated with pregnancy. For some fathers the recognition of impending parenthood provided by the Baby Steps groups helped them to process how they felt about the forthcoming changes to their lives. Doing the programme made me feel excited about having a baby, before that I was just really worried about it changing my life too much. (Kyle, aged 17) 2.4 Relationships with partners As was the case for parents in the community, participants who had attended Baby Steps with their partner said that they had learnt new conflict management skills and how to listen to each other more effectively, which they felt had brought them closer together. They also felt that their relationship had improved because of the extra time spent together during Baby Steps sessions, which were longer and more relaxed than normal prison visits. The programme sessions also Impact and Evidence series 15 permitted some physical contact between couples, which was not the case on a normal visit. It’s improved our relationship because we got to see each other more and got closer and we had a laugh and he got to spend time with the baby; we could sit next to each other, not like on a visit. It was a longer visit too, two hours. (Hannah, aged 20) The fact that a crèche was provided during the sessions also meant that parents had quality time together as a couple without their older children being present, which enabled them to focus more on the baby. This was in contrast to normal prison visits, where older children are always present. Baby Steps also helped men understand what their partners were going through physically and emotionally, which facilitated greater mutual understanding and improved relationships. This was especially important because mothers whose partners were in prison said that they often avoided talking about their feelings or about anything negative during prison visits or phone calls because they felt that they should focus on positive things as they had such limited time together. Both mothers and fathers were anxious about fathers missing out on the pregnancy due to either they or their partner being in prison, and valued the fact that attending the programme enabled them to feel more involved. My husband missed nearly the whole pregnancy, it was so disappointing and I was really worried about it. But the programme helped because it meant that at least he got the chance to see me getting bigger every week and he could hold my stomach and feel the baby kick, which was nice. (Janine, aged 22) 2.5 Relationship with babies For fathers in prison, having the extra time that the postnatal Baby Steps sessions afforded helped them develop the relationship with their son or daughter. As the sessions were more relaxed, they were able to do things with their baby that they had learnt on the programme, which they would not normally be able to do on a prison visit – for example, standing up and walking around with their baby or changing their infant’s nappy, which they felt promoted bonding. 16 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives I really enjoyed the time with my son and can’t emphasise enough how beneficial it was. It meant that we already had some sort of bond when I got released. (Angus, aged 38) The fact that sessions were longer than a normal visit also enabled fathers to observe their baby exhibiting a wider range of behaviours, which again helped them in developing a relationship. Obviously the length of time the session was on a particular day was a big help as well, because you can see them doing different things like smiling or crying, ‘cos as I say sometimes he would come in on a normal visit and he would be asleep for the whole time and it was like, “Oh he’s getting big,” and that’s it. (Angus, aged 38) Like parents in the community, those who had completed the programme in prison said that they had learnt about the importance of interacting with babies and how best to do this at each stage of development. One woman said that she had been talking to her unborn baby to try and familiarise him with her older children’s names because she was aware that he could hear her. Parents felt that these efforts had helped them feel closer to their babies. Another mother talked about using information gained from the classes to soothe her baby. I used the advice about soothing babies to sleep by keeping going up to them and putting your hand on their chest to let them know you are there. It worked, and I was so glad. (Janine, aged 22) Some fathers spent time talking to their babies on a regular basis over the phone because they realised the importance of this from attending Baby Steps. Fathers who had been released from prison and who were involved in the day-to-day care of their infants at the time of interview said that they were able to fully implement the advice from the programme. Both mothers and fathers who were prisoners felt that they would be able to put more of the learning into practice once they were released. Impact and Evidence series 17 This time around I’m going to do things differently. When I get out, I’m not going to smoke in the house. My mum taught me to just put the baby to bed and leave it whether it cries or not but I won’t be doing that this time, and I’ll put her to sleep in the same room as me like they told us to do. (Sara, aged 31). One father also talked about his intention to forge a positive relationship with his child once he would get of prison, partly because of information he gained on the programme: … I think I’ll be closer to this baby. I’m away from him now and…I don’t want to let him go… I used to drink a lot with my other kids… I was drunk half the time and I missed loads… when I was doing this course and I was on about this baby I used to think like what I’d missed out with my other kids… and I feel guilty…yeah I will be closer to him. I think it’s partly because of being in here, and partly because of the course. (Paul, aged 43) 2.6 Reoffending The Baby Steps programme played a role for some in framing the way they thought about parenthood and made them aware of the importance of their role in their child’s life. This, along with the positive changes in their relationships motivated some parents to want to stay out of prison in the future. I need to get out of here for her and the baby. Before the course I was fighting all the time, terrorising the officers, but now I have calmed down. It’s made me realise that my daughter is worth more than anyone in this jail and I want to be out for the birth. It’s made me realise a lot. When I get out I need to figure out how I’m going to get a job so I can support them. (Kyle, aged 17) 18 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives 2.7 Support and informed advice The Baby Steps sessions were valued as a dedicated space in which parents could raise concerns and worries and gain support. This was particularly helpful for parents in prison because they felt that the support available to them was limited. Although a range of ‘listening services’ were provided for prisoners who needed emotional support, including the Samaritans, talking to the chaplain, or talking to ‘listeners’ (other prisoners who have been trained by the Samaritans), parents were reluctant to use these because of concerns that conversations would not be kept confidential. Some parents who had used the listening services also expressed frustration that the services could not provide advice in general, and that they were unable to provide advice about concerns relating to pregnancy, birth or parenthood in particular. I was stressed out when she was bleeding all the time like and I wanted to know what’s happening with this placenta thing, why is she bleeding, what happens next. I talked to the chaplain.…well, he was a great guy you know, but he couldn’t help me because he didn’t know anything about it. (Paul, aged 43) Like parents in the community, this sample of parents found it helpful to spend time with other parents or parents-to-be who were in the same situation as themselves, and share their experiences. Pregnant women who were still in the main prison felt reassured by having made contact with women who were already in the mother and baby unit, because they would already know people when they were transferred over to the unit. This made them feel less anxious about moving there before they had their baby. Some parents said that they had made contact with other group members outside of the Baby Step sessions, with whom they had developed supportive relationships. For some mothers, socialising with other parents on the Baby Steps programme had given them the confidence to join parent and baby groups in their local area when they got out of prison. Last time I was pregnant I didn’t want to talk to anyone because I felt like I was different to other mothers because I was a drug user. The course showed me that I can make contact with other mums. When I get out I’m going to give it a go and go to groups. (Julia, aged 41) Impact and Evidence series 19 Chapter 3: Impact of the Prison Context The Baby Steps programme aims to prepare new parents for the transition to parenthood by providing them with new information and parenting skills, strengthening their relationships with their partners and babies and creating a social support network. Although parents did identify a range of positive outcomes as a result of attending the programme, they also highlighted a number of ways in which the prison context affected their experience of the programme and limited the extent to which they were able to implement the learning from it. This chapter looks at these barriers in more detail and explores some additional challenges faced by parents. It also looks at barriers to delivery of the programme mentioned by parents. 3.1 Lack of control Pregnant prisoners said that there were many aspects of their lives over which they had little control. This meant that although they found the information and advice from the programme helpful, they were constrained in terms of how much of it they were able to implement. Baby Steps aims to promote healthy lifestyle choices among parents in terms of diet and exercise, but prisoners are limited to the food that is provided for them. Similarly, they have to exercise at set times and the choices in the types of exercise that the women can take part in are limited. The programme also attempts to prepare women for what to expect during labour and birth, and to recognise the signs of labour so that they can make an informed decision about when to go to hospital and what to bring. Women prisoners, however, said that they did not have any control over the decision about when they should be admitted to hospital. Moreover, some women were unable to use the advice about what to pack in their hospital bag, because they did not have anyone to bring items to the prison for them (as was the case for foreign nationals). They were obliged to use a bag provided by the prison, and had no control over what it contained. The programme aims to equip parents with a range of practical baby care skills and to empower them to feel confident about their parenting decisions. However, in prison the ability to implement the advice given on the programme and for mothers to use their own judgement is often curtailed due to the rules of the mother and baby unit. An example of this is that on the programme, parents are advised to carry their infants in slings as this helps the mother and baby become emotionally closer. In one prison however, parents were not allowed to use slings and had to transport babies in buggies at all times, 20 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives which they resented. In addition, the buggies provided for new born babies did not enable them to lie flat, which contradicted the advice given on the programme. It’s awful to have to have her in the buggy all the time and not to be able to carry her around. On the programme they said that babies should be able to lie flat in the buggy. They can’t do that in the ones we have to use here, they’re not suitable. (Patricia, aged 33) Finally, the prison health care system acted as a barrier to mothers using their own judgement to decide at what point their child should see a doctor. Instead, prison staff assessed the child’s condition and decided what action to take; mothers themselves were not allowed to have any input. 3.2 Social isolation The programme encourages parents to seek help from friends and family, other group members and from local support services during the perinatal period. Although parents did feel supported by the programme, the prison context posed unique challenges to implementing this advice. Obviously the contact that parents in prison had with their family and friends was limited. Also, they were only able to draw support from other parents in the group if they happened to be housed in the same prison wing or if they attended an education class together which was not always the case. The situation was different for mothers on the Mother and Baby Unit, who had more opportunities to interact with each other. Even some of the prisoners’ partners, living in the community, did not have much opportunity to spend time with other partners on the programme because they lived in different geographical areas to each other. When Baby Steps is delivered in the community, practitioners are able to work flexibly and provide a certain amount of additional support outside of the sessions to parents either in person or by telephone. In the prison context, however, the only contact that practitioners had with parents was during the sessions, so the support they could offer was more limited. Parents participating in the programme in the community also receive information about local groups for parents and babies, and are signposted to other support for issues such as mental health concerns or financial management. In a prison context however, this was not possible as parents were unable to access these services. Impact and Evidence series 21 In some cases, practitioners were also unable to signpost prisoners’ partners living in the community to local services. This was mostly because they lived far away from the prison, in areas the practitioners were not familiar with. 3.3 Relationships The programme aims to strengthen the relationship between partners by teaching them new communication skills and promoting mutual understanding. In a prison context, however, not all partners were able to attend, either because it was against the prison rules or because they lived too far away. Prisoners who had attended without their partners said that they regretted this and wished that their partners had also been able to be there. This was especially true for those who did not feel that their partner was well prepared for parenthood. I would have really liked my girlfriend to attend. It would have made the bond stronger between the three of us; it would have been a lot better. She asks me a lot of questions on the phone and I can’t answer them. I used to ring her up after the session and tell her everything I’d learnt that day and she was buzzing, she always used to ask for more. She’s shy, she won’t go to an antenatal class on the outside on her own, she’d feel stupid without me there. I sent her all the booklets and bits of paper but it’s not the same. (Kyle, aged 17) In some cases, mothers in prison had arrangements in place for their babies to spend time in the community with their partners for a period of time each month and felt that the fathers would have benefited from attending the programme in order to prepare them for this. Parents who said that they had learnt new communication skills on the programme and used these in their interactions with their partners also highlighted that they only had limited opportunities to do so, as the contact that they had with each other was limited to prison visits and phone calls. 3.4 Additional challenges The Baby Steps programme aims to increase participants’ awareness of the importance of their role as a parent and of the impact that their physical and emotional wellbeing can have on the wellbeing of their baby both during the pregnancy and the postnatal period. As parents are constrained in terms of the extent to which they are able to implement the advice however, this led to dissatisfaction and 22 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives frustration for some. For example, parents were more aware of the importance of a healthy diet to the wellbeing of their child, but were not able to access this. Similarly, the programme had empowered them to use their judgement in caring for their baby but prison rules prevented them doing this fully. In some cases parents believed the NSPCC would be able to provide more support than it in fact was able to, leading to disappointment and frustration. This was compounded by the NSPCC being unable to signpost them to any external services within the prison context. I thought with the NSPCC that I’d be able to get support but it was just information. I’ve got a lot going on outside with domestic violence that is causing me stress and I need specific help and advice about the situation and what I’m going to do when I get out. (Lola, aged 30) Due to the transient nature of the prison population, some parents only attended one or two Baby Steps sessions. In some cases this led to anxiety: for example, one mother in the sample had attended one postnatal session in the early stages of pregnancy, but then was left with more questions than she had before. It was a lovely friendly group and wish it would come back. I only found out about it in time to attend a couple of sessions, I’ve got a lot of unanswered questions as a first-time mother. (Maddy, aged 28) For fathers in prison, being more aware of the importance of communicating with babies in utero, and knowing that they could hear their voice, exacerbated their anxiety about being separated from them. I’ve been here for the whole pregnancy and she only sees me like two times a week. She hears my voice two times a week. So I get scared in case she won’t know who I am for the first couple of weeks after she’s born. (Kyle, aged 17) Impact and Evidence series 23 Parents valued the support that the Baby Steps programme provided, and some experienced a sense of loss and sadness when it ended. In addition, for some parents, an increased level of awareness of the importance of their role as a parent and of the impact of their behaviour on their children led to feelings of guilt about their previous attitude to pregnancy and parenting. I didn’t acknowledge my last pregnancy, I was in denial, I didn’t even feel the movements of the baby. I didn’t realise how special it was. I feel ashamed about that now. (Julia, aged 41) Although challenges to the delivery of the programme are not the key focus of this report, parents did make reference to these throughout their interviews. One of the key issues was that prison populations are transient, so that participants in the Baby Steps programme changed from week to week as new pregnant women or new mothers arrived and others were released or transferred elsewhere. In addition, because of the limited number of parents in custody who are expecting a baby, the groups were made up of women at different stages of pregnancy rather than being at the same stage, which is how the programme was intended to be delivered. This meant that practitioners had to be flexible in terms of what they covered in any given session, in order to meet the needs of the individuals who were attending, and that topics were not necessarily covered in the order outlined in the manual. In some cases, practitioners were not able to take materials that are normally used to deliver the programme (such as DVDs or scissors) into the prison due to security rules. This meant that they had to find alternative methods of running some of the activities. 24 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Chapter 4: What Worked Well and Suggested Improvements This chapter looks first at what elements of the content and delivery of the programme worked well in a prison context, and second at improvements that parents suggested could be made to it. 4.1 What worked well Overall, respondents were very positive about the Baby Steps programme and felt that much of it worked well within a prison context. They identified seven aspects that were particularly important. Attending with partners Where both parents had attended, this had worked well and couples felt that it had strengthened their relationships with each other and with their baby. It was brilliant having him there, it worked really well being able to learn all of that stuff together on the programme. (Janine, aged 22) Programme structure The postnatal sessions of the programme were highly valued and parents appreciated having the opportunity to share their experiences of being a new parent. These sessions were particularly significant for fathers who were prisoners as they enabled them to spend time with their infants. Those who had only had prenatal sessions said that they would have liked the group to have continued after their babies were born. Just to be able to see how other mums are coping and to talk about how you are coping gives you that bit more confidence, so I think some extra classes after she had been born would have been brilliant. (Kathy, aged 24) Impact and Evidence series 25 Approaches to delivering the programme As with the parents in the community, parents who attended the programme in prison liked the participative methods of delivery and found the range of activities engaging, including the group discussions, ‘talk and listen’ exercise and the practical activities. The leaflets that were given out at the end of sessions were particularly useful for parents in prison, who have more time to read while alone in their cells. They felt that having these leaflets to refer to helped them remember the information better. The video of the parents interacting with their baby and the family photos that were taken were highly valued by parents because they did not have any other opportunities to take videos or photos. One prop that male prisoners had found particularly useful was the pregnancy suit, which gives a father has the opportunity to feel the extra weight his pregnant partner is carrying around. They felt that this had helped them empathise with the physical challenges that their partner was experiencing. It really was surprisingly heavy and obviously it helped you empathise with what they have to carry around. Yeah, it was certainly beneficial and an eye opener because when you’re expecting your partner to come up every week for a visit and they come in tired and a bit ratty and they’re not all cheery to see you, even though it’s your one visit, it gives you a bit more understanding of why that is and what they’re actually going through. (Angus, aged 38) In one prison practitioners were able to source a sonogram, which was brought into one of the sessions and enabled the fathers in prison to hear their baby’s heartbeat for the first time. This was particularly significant for them because they were not able to attend regular scans with their partner. Practitioners’ skills and attitudes Aspects of the practitioner approach and personal attributes valued by parents in this sample reflected those cited by parents in the community. Practitioners were described as friendly, caring, approachable, responsive, and knowledgeable. As was the case with parents in the community, the ‘partnership’ approach to learning used in the programme, where parents are guided to draw their own conclusions and make their own decisions as opposed to just being given advice, worked well with this sample of parents. Parents said that they had been treated the same as they would have been if they had attended an antenatal group in the community and did not feel 26 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives that they had been discriminated against in any way because of their prisoner status. They was proper down to earth. It was like we was out and we’d just gone into a class. It weren’t like we was in prison at all. It made us feel proper welcome and everything. It was wicked. (Kyle, aged 17) While prison officers were always present in or just outside the room during the Baby Steps sessions, they usually remained at a distance from where the group of parents were sitting. Parents appreciated this, and said that they would have felt inhibited if the officers had been within earshot. In one instance, the pregnancy officer participated in the group and that was felt to work well, although parents would not have felt comfortable if any of the officers from the main prison had done so, because they felt that some of these staff were not supportive of prisoners being allowed to attend interventions like Baby Steps. Group setting: This sample of parents found that participating in the programme in a group worked well. Groups sometimes comprised only mothers, fathers, or couples. Other groups were attended by a mixture of couples and single mothers or fathers. Perhaps surprisingly, all of these formats were felt to work well. One mother who was in a mixed group said that she had initially had reservations about the presence of men, but felt reassured by the setting of ground rules and in retrospect found it heartening to see men showing an interest in babies. Like parents in the community, they felt that the relatively small size of the groups was conducive to creating a ‘safe space’ where they felt comfortable talking about personal issues and also enabled them to ask questions. The ground rules about respecting other people’s points of view and about confidentiality were felt to have been crucial in creating this environment. One-to-one advice Although they felt it was advantageous to attend the programme in a group, parents still appreciated the opportunity to speak to staff on an individual basis during the breaks. This was even more important for parents in prison than for those in the community, as they did not have the option of making contact with practitioners outside of the session. Impact and Evidence series 27 Timings and refreshments Parents in prison did not have any difficulties attending the programme in terms of timing. They would usually have been in work or education at the time that the Baby Steps sessions were running and were happy to attend the programme instead. Like parents in the community, parents in prison appreciated the healthy snacks and drinks that were provided during the sessions. They were particularly highly valued by this population of parents because they perceived their diet within the prison to be inadequate both in terms of quality and quantity. 4.2 Suggested improvements Parents made a number of suggestions for additional content and modifications to the way the programme was delivered in prisons, which are detailed in this section. Additional content Parents said that they would have liked the programme to include content on how to manage and maintain relationships with loved ones on the outside while in prison, because this was something they struggled with. In particular, they were concerned about maintaining positive relationships with their older children and would have welcomed guidance around this. Mothers in prison would also have liked some advice on how to promote relationships between their baby and older siblings on the outside. One father, who had been released from prison at the time of interview, felt that it would be helpful for the programme to prepare fathers in prison for how to establish a relationship with their babies when they are released. He felt it would be useful to consider ways of promoting bonding during what could be a challenging transition period, and recounted the initial difficulties he had faced when he returned home. When I came out of prison there wasn’t that instant bond that I had with my first child, you know, holding her from birth and being there every minute of the day or as much as I could. Yeah, it took about a week for him to get used to me being home all the time, it was hard. (Angus, aged 38) 28 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Fathers also suggested some additions to the programme they felt would help strengthen their relationship with their baby while still in prison. One was for them to make a recording of their voice talking to their baby, which their partner could then play back for the baby to become accustomed to their father’s voice – much like the ‘Story Book Dads’ programme, already running in prisons, where men record themselves reading a story to be played back to their older children. Another suggestion was for fathers to be able to bathe their babies during one of the postnatal sessions, which was felt to be a valuable bonding experience. Topics that women would have liked the programme to include were C-section, which they did not feel had been covered in much detail, and what to expect when a baby withdraws from methadone. One woman would have liked specific advice about issues of domestic abuse she was experiencing. Mothers in prison also felt that they would have benefited from learning some relaxation exercises on the programme to do while pregnant, as they felt that the prison environment had an adverse effect on their stress levels, which they realised could affect the welfare of their unborn babies. Additional contact with practitioners Parents felt they would have benefited from being able to contact the practitioners by telephone outside of the sessions, as is the case for parents doing the programme in the community. As previously discussed, they did not feel that appropriate advice and support was available to them in prison. I was worried about my Missus, I didn’t understand what was happening to her and there was no one to ask. If I could have just spoken to one of them [practitioners], you know, had a phone number to ring, it would have been a big help. (Steven, aged 23) Better publicity It was felt that the Baby Steps programme could be better publicised within the prison because some parents had not been aware of it until it had been running for a few weeks and were then disappointed to have missed some of the sessions. Impact and Evidence series 29 Chapter 5: Conclusion The findings from this study suggest that attending the Baby Steps programme was beneficial for parents in prison and their partners. Many of the outcomes they identified as a result of the programme were similar to those identified by parents who had completed it in the community, such as acquiring new knowledge and skills; feeling more confident about their parenting; feeling supported, and improvements in their relationships with partners and infants. The programme was an important source of information and support especially for these parents, because access to such information is limited in prison, and they felt isolated. Although the learning from the programme was valuable for these parents, there were elements they were unable to implement because of the rules of the prison and the lack of control they had over their day-to-day lives. The implication of this for the delivery of Baby Steps – or indeed any other antenatal programme in prisons – is that a degree of flexibility needs to be built into the model so that it can be adapted to take into account the constraints of the prison context. Ideally, preliminary work should be done with prison staff to establish current practice in supporting pregnant women and soon-to-be fathers within the particular prison, so that programme delivery can be tailored accordingly. The need for a flexible model of delivery also arises from the transient nature of the prison population and the likelihood that parents will be at different stages of pregnancy or parenthood. Therefore practitioners need to be able to deliver content that best suits the needs of the group of parents who attend a particular session. However, the current approach and activities used to deliver Baby Steps worked well with parents in the prison population. Prison rules about security affect what materials can be brought in, so that adaptions need to be made to some activities used to deliver the programme. Although parents said that the programme had been an important source of support for them, this was limited by the fact that practitioners were not able to make contact with parents outside of the sessions or refer them on to other services, as they would normally do in the community. Practitioners can signpost them to support within the prison, however, so it is important for practitioners to identify what services are available in advance. It would nevertheless also be beneficial for parents in prison to be able to contact practitioners by telephone with specific worries that they have between sessions. 30 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Appendix 1: Interview topic guide (female prisoners and female partners) Key objectives of interview • Explore parents’ experience of pregnancy, childbirth and early parenthood. • Explore participants’ experience of the programme (including any modifications) and the range of factors that affect their experience of it. • Explore what other services and support were/are available to them both in prison and outside. • Identify any gaps or additional needs they have. Introduce evaluation. Explain purpose of evaluation and reporting. Explain confidentiality, data protection, and permission to record. Background Before talking more about your experience of Baby Steps, it would be helpful to have some idea of your background and how you are finding things now. • Can you tell me a bit about yourself and your family? (Probe: number of children; family situation; how long been in prison?) • How are you finding being pregnant/having a baby? (Probe: crying; sleep patterns?) Initial engagement in Baby Steps and expectations I would like to talk a bit more now about how you found out about Baby Steps and what you thought the programme would be like. • Can you tell me a bit about how you found out about Baby Steps? • Have you ever attended any other antenatal classes in the past? • What were you expecting from Baby Steps? Impact and Evidence series 31 Experience of the programme Thinking about the actual programme now, I would like to talk about your experience of being on the programme. • Once you started the course, can you tell me how easy it was for you to attend the course? What made it easy or difficult to attend the programme? (Probe: timings, other commitments etc?) • Who did you attend the programme with and how did this work out? Topics covered by Baby Steps: • Baby Steps covers lots of different topics. Can you describe to me the topics or sessions that you found most helpful? Were there any sessions that were not so helpful to you? What were the reasons for this? • How easy did you find it to remember the information you were given? Did it feel like it was important to you? • There are lots of different activities that you take part in when you attend the Baby Steps programme (group discussions, practical exercises with dolls putting nappies on etc). Which activities did you find most useful; which were less useful? Can you tell me why you thought this? Relationships on the programme I am really interested to hear about how you got on with other people on the programme. • Can you describe the experience of being in the group with other parents; how did this work? What were the good things about this; which things were less helpful? (Did you make friends; have contact outside the class?) • How did you feel about your relationships with the staff who delivered the programme? Can you explain why you felt this way? • Was there a member of staff from the prison present during the sessions? How did you feel about them being present? (Would it matter which officer it was? If so, why?) 32 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Experience of the perinatal period and impacts of Baby Steps I would like to talk about how you felt during pregnancy, birth and after your baby was born. Thinking about when you were pregnant: • How did you find being pregnant? (How did you feel physically/ emotionally?) • How often did you see the midwife? Could you describe what happened during these appointments? Did you find them helpful? • Did you have any other support during your pregnancy? (Other professionals; other prisoners?) • How does this compare with previous pregnancies outside prison (if applicable)? • Do you think that the programme helped you when you were pregnant? (In what ways?) Thinking about the birth of your baby (if applicable): • Can you tell me about how the birth of your baby went? (Natural birth or C-section; location; pain relief?) • How did you get to hospital? (Length of time; transport?) • Did you have a birth partner? (Who; how did it go? Any chance to prepare with them?) • How were the hospital staff during the birth and aftercare? (Probe: breastfeeding support?) • How did this compare with previous birth experience (if applicable)? • Do you think that the knowledge or information provided during the programme helped you during the birth? (If yes, in what ways?) Thinking about the first few weeks with your baby (if applicable): • How did you find the first few weeks with your baby? How did you feel physically and emotionally? • What support or help did you have during that time? • Do you think that you used the knowledge or information provided during the programme during the first few weeks with your baby? • How easy or not was it to follow the advice and information that were suggested on the programme? What made it easy or not so easy? • How would you describe the effect that the programme has had on you? Impact and Evidence series 33 • Can you describe how attending the programme made you feel, and why it made you feel like that? Conclusion • Are there any changes you would like to see in the Baby Steps programme? • Is there anything else you would like to say about the Baby Steps programme at this stage? 34 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Appendix 2: Interview topic guide (male prisoners) Key objectives of interview • Explore parents’ experience of their partner’s pregnancy, the birth of their child and early parenthood. • Explore participants’ experience of the programme (including any modifications) and the range of factors that affect their experience of it. • Explore what other services and support were/are available to them in prison. • Identify any gaps in the programme or additional needs they have. Introduce evaluation. Explain purpose of evaluation and reporting Explain confidentiality, data protection, and permission to record. Background Before talking more about your experience of Baby Steps, it would be helpful to have some idea of your background and how you are finding things now. • Can you tell me a bit about yourself and your family? (Probe: number of children; family situation; how long been in prison?) • Do you have regular visits from your partner (and children)? How often? For how long? Initial engagement in Baby Steps and expectations I would like to talk a bit more now about how you found out about Baby Steps and what you thought the programme would be like. • Can you tell me a bit about how you found out about Baby Steps? • Have you ever attended any other antenatal classes in the past? (Or been offered any?) • What were you expecting from the programme? Impact and Evidence series 35 Experience of the programme Thinking about the actual programme now, I would like to talk about your experience of being on the programme. • Once you started the programme can you tell me how easy it was for you to attend the programme? What made it easy or difficult to attend the programme? (Timings; permission; other commitments, etc.) Topics covered by Baby Steps: • Baby Steps covers lots of different topics. Can you describe to me the topics or sessions that you found most helpful? Were there any sessions that were not so helpful to you? What were the reasons for this? • How easy did you find it to remember the information you were given? Did it feel like it was important to you? • There are lots of different activities that you take part in when you attend the Baby Steps programme (group discussions, practical exercises with dolls putting nappies on etc). Which activities did you find most useful; which were less useful? Can you tell me why you thought this? Sessions after the baby was born (if applicable): • After your baby was born you came back to the programme for two sessions. Can you describe these sessions to me? How did you feel? Relationships on the programme I am really interested to hear about how you got on with other people on the programme. • Can you describe the experience of being in the group with other parents? How did this work? What were the good things about this; which things were less helpful? • Did you spend time with any of the men from the group outside of it? Would you have wanted to? • How did you feel about your relationships with the staff who delivered the programme? Can you explain why you felt this way? • Was there a member of staff from the prison present during the sessions? How did you feel about them being present? Would it have mattered which prison officer had attended? If so, why? 36 Baby Steps in a prison context: Parents perspectives Experience of the perinatal period and impacts of Baby Steps I would like to talk about how you felt during your partner’s pregnancy, birth and after your baby was born. • How did you feel during your partner’s pregnancy? Was it difficult to be living apart? • Do you feel that the Baby Steps programme helped you during your partners’ pregnancy in any way? Thinking about the birth of your baby: • When and how did you find out that your baby had been born? • Would you have wanted to be present at the birth if it had been possible? • When did you first see your baby? Any extra visits? Were you allowed to hold the baby? • Have you used the knowledge or information provided during the programme during the time you have spent with your baby? Do you think you will use it in the future? • What is it like to be a dad in prison? Do you think that attending the programme has helped your relationship with your baby in any way? • Are there ways that your relationship with your partner has changed since you have been in prison? Do you think Baby Steps has had any effect on your relationship? • Have there been any changes in your relationship since your baby was born? Did Baby Steps prepare you for these changes? • How would you describe the effect that the programme has had on you? • Can you describe how attending the programme made you feel, and why it made you feel like that? Just thinking about what support is available in prison: • If you were feeling a bit down, is there anyone that you could go and talk to about that, like a counselling service? Is it a walkin service? Conclusion • Are there any changes you would like to see in the Baby Steps programme? • Is there anything else you would like to say about the Baby Steps project at this stage? Impact and Evidence series 37 www.nspcc.org.uk Registered charity numbers 216401and SC037717. Photography by Getty Images, posed by models. 7080/11.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz