The Charities SORP 2015/2016 and the larger charity Annual Conference - 17 October 2015 Association of Church Accountants & Treasurers Greyham Dawes, FCA, DChA, Hon. Treasurer www.croweclarkwhitehill.co.uk Overview of this one-hour session Is yours a “larger” charity - or do you just enjoy technical challenges? The Charities SORP’s “Methods & Principles” - what’s new in them? FRS102’s new terminology from its global “Conceptual Framework” basis Trustees’ Annual Report: new/changed disclosures from then on … SoFA & Balance Sheet: format/disclosure changes from 1 January 2015 Accounts Notes: new/changed disclosures from then on … The Cashflow Statement – what FRS102 requires, with what choices? ‘First–year’ options under FRS102; but meanwhile: the FRSSE Options Thresholds changes for the SORP, for Group Accounts and for audit Compliance-planning for your charity: years starting in 2015 or in 2016 Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 2 About “SORP Methods & Principles” SORP(FRSSE) vs SORP(FRS102) - each follow FRS102’s Methods & Principles SORP(FRSSE) requires “current practice” (ie, FRS102) for all “non-exchange” transactions (where practicable) and for transactions “not covered by an existing accounting policy” under the FRSSE (or were you not using it before 2015?) Both new SORPs also redefine “Related Party” for transaction-disclosures The SORP’s 2008 Regulations apply until 2015 Regulations made: CC15c says Reg.2 & Reg.8(5) specify SORP2005 “methods & principles” for all non-company charities – so can auditors accept use of SORP2015 as a ‘true and fair’ override? SORP(FRSSE) lasts for one year only – so why may it be best for you to use it? FRC withdrawal of FRSSE w.e.f. 1 Jan.2016 leaves charities with only a revised SORP(FRS102) which will disapply FRS102’s new Section 1A (“small companies regime”) in favour of the SORP’s reliefs only for charities < £500k gross income: SORP2005’s successor is being amended for year-ends after 30 March 2015 to redefine the “larger charity” as everyone exceeding £500k gross income as above – thus ignoring the doubling of the Charities Act’s audit threshold from that date … Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 3 These new “Methods & Principles” – how might they affect your charity? Income/Assets and Expenditure/Liabilities become accruable at the point when an inflow/outflow of economic benefit becomes “probable” Until then, disclosure as a “contingent” item is required by way of note (cf SORP2005’s “reasonably certain” receipt/payment for its accruability) Non-current assets/liabilities (> one year): NPV at a ‘suitable’ interest-rate ‘Fair value’ accounting is required for any non-basic “financial instruments” (this mainly means derivatives, forex, interest-rate caps/collars &c) FRS102’s PBE Sections provide ‘anchor-points’ or hooks on which all the SORP’s FRC-approved specialised accounting treatments are now hung New terminology used by FRS102 categorises charities’ gifts, grants, donations & legacies as “non-exchange transactions” (as distinct from the commercial world’s value-for-value trading or “exchange transactions”) But will all this change the look of your charity’s next accounts? Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 4 Terminology used in FRS102 from its global “Conceptual Framework” basis UK company law terminology Accounting reference date Content level 1 Accounts Content level 2 Balance Sheet and Content level 3 Capital Reserves Debtors Diminution in value [of assets] Group [accounts] Individual [accounts] Interest payable and similar charges Interest receivable and similar Minority interest Net realisable value [ current asset] Parent undertaking P & L Account (I & E Statement) Related undertakings Stocks Subsidiary undertaking Tangible assets Trade creditors Audit | Tax | Advisory FRS 102 terminology Reporting date (alias “financial year-end”) Financial Statements Statement of Financial Position Equity <CHARITY-equivalent = Total Funds> Trade receivables Impairment Consolidated [financial statements] Individual [financial statements] Finance costs Finance income / Investment income Non-controlling interest <SORP: Group Accts.> Estd. sale price less costs to complete and sell Parent Net Income Statement (or: “Comprehensive” Income) Subsidiaries, associates and (corporate) JVs Inventories Subsidiary Property, Plant/Equipt vs Investment Properties Trade payables © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 5 Trustees’ Report: the key changes “Key Management Personnel” names*; remuneration policy for them (all charities > £500k - was: auditable charities only) “Major Risks” disclosure now prospective (for small charities: any “uncertainties” over the charity’s continuing solvency) Total Reserves, derivation of any freely available reserves, steps needed to match up to the trustees’ Reserves Policy *complemented by the new Accounts Notes disclosure of the aggregate cost of all their “employee benefits” (per FRS102) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 6 Trustees’ Report checklist for the SORP’s small charities Charities not exceeding £500k gross income (for 2015/6 onwards): Administrative Information (name, any regn. nos., regd./main address, current trustees’ names (or directors of any corporate trustee), also any ex-trustees’ names, as well as any trustees for the charity (ditto) Governance/Structure/Management: Type and [latest] date of charity’s written constitution How any new trustees are (i) recruited, (ii) appointed Public Benefit purpose(s); the year’s [main] activities Declaration of due regard for published CC guidance on Public Benefit Achievements of the year’s activities – best with SoFA-correlation Reserves Policy/Level; Details of any fund-deficits; Review of Financial Position; Review of any ‘going concern’ uncertainties And that’s it – except (if yours is also a custodian-charity): Details of assets held, for which other charities and why; segregation Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 7 Trustees’ Report checklist for the SORP’s ‘larger’ charities Administrative Information: as for “small” charities, plus retained advisers Charitable Companies outside the “Small Companies” regime: – Directors’ Report (admin. information) – can be combined with: – Strategic Report (ie, as a special section) – to comprise: [Public Benefit] aims & objectives; strategies; KPIs; significant activities; achievements; impact/outcomes (must be for parent and subsidiaries) “Key Management Personnel” names & policy for their remuneration Main fundraising activities/achievements/efficiency* (ditto) Investment performance; policies (+ for grantmaking & social investing) Principal sources of income; Contribution made by volunteers Financial review, Reserves, Solvency, Future Plans, Principal Risks & Uncertainties = disclosure & mitigation-plans, going forward Declaration of due regard for CC guidance on Public Benefit Companies Act audits only: “Relevant Audit Information” declaration * + any impact on efficiency if spending on ‘fundraising for the future’ Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 8 “Key Management Personnel” for the larger charities’ required disclosures Consider who are your “key management” (and thus also “related parties”): FRS102: “persons having authority and responsibility for planning, directing and controlling the activities of the entity, directly or indirectly, including any director” FRS102/33.7: Accounts Note disclosure* of their aggregate “employee benefits” SORP(FRS102) disclosure requirements (and SORP(FRSSE) similarly): 1.51 (TAR): “arrangements for setting the pay and remuneration of key management personnel and any benchmarks, parameters or criteria used in setting their pay” 9.31. “Although the trustees control and manage the administration of a charity, the day- today management of its activities may be delegated to senior management personnel who report to the trustees. …” 9.32. “All charities must disclose the total amount of any employee benefits received by trustees and key management personnel for their services to the charity. … charities subject to charity audit should [consider] the information needs of their funders and other stakeholders in making their accounting disclosures. SORP then suggests disclosing for “the charity’s Chief Executive Officer or highest paid staff member, or … “its key management personnel on an individual basis”! Q: Which staff in your Senior Management Team directly exercise trustee-powers? Q: *Cost of employee’s taxable emoluments as well as non-taxable retirement benefits? Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 9 Operational reporting in the TAR - a more detailed checklist … What the SORP continues to require – now for all ‘larger’ charities: “aims” [cf mission statement] (as well as Objects summary) [impact] changes/differences sought through [operational] activities? [targets] main objectives [previously set] for the year (eg, KPIs) strategies (ways & means) for achieving those objectives significant projects/services (per the Accounts) contributing to achievement of the annual objectives Beneficiary-selection policy for any material grant-making or for any material “social investment” activities Volunteers’ contribution, if significant (total hours? indicative value?) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 10 Achievements reporting in the TAR What the SORP continues to require – now for all ‘larger’ charities: Objects-related operational performance for the charity and subsidiaries against your objectives as set for the year Explanation of any benchmarks/milestones/success-indicators you use (qualitative or quantitative) for assessing outcomes from your activities Comment on (external) factors affecting performance that are (a) within or (b) beyond your control (staff-, beneficiary-, funder-relationships and “position in the wider community”?) Investment performance against your investment objectives (if material investments held) Fundraising performance against your objectives - distinguishing current results and “fundraising for the future” (ie, for legacies, or donordatabase start-up, etc.) (this was non-mandatory under SORP 2005) Future plans/strategy and “key objectives” for the future, also any special factors/influences involved Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 11 TAR: Reserves Disclosures The charity must explain any policy it has for holding reserves and state the amounts of those reserves and why they are held. If the trustees have decided that holding reserves is unnecessary, the report must disclose this fact and provide the reasons behind this decision. – SORP(FRS102), Module 1.22 Module 1.48 says this statement should split the total funds held between: (i) restricted funds (ie, endowment capital* and special-purpose income) (ii) designated/committed funds (with the timescale for spending them) (iii) funds locked up in fixed assets for the charity’s own use (includes “social investments”) and (iv) the balance of funds held as reserves and (if need be) what steps the trustees are taking to align that figure with the policy figure that is considered appropriate given their future plans as disclosed. *there is no duty to spend trust capital – unlike the duty to spend trust income … Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 12 What if Free Reserves are nil? Even low reserves must have a policy statement – if only for fundraising or risk-management reasons … When don’t you need to retain any income in reserve? How (and why) to avoid negative free reserves resulting from over-designating retained income to ‘ring-fence’: Fixed Assets needed for church use in future funds internally committed for future church projects Any fund-deficits must be explained (ie, to show that no ‘breach of trust’ is involved), together with details of any remedial action [to be] taken … Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 13 SoFA principles checklist – or is your charity unaffected? ‘Probable’ assets & liabilities are all accruable (cf ‘contingent’: disclose only) ‘Fair Value’ of goods donated for sale/spending, for own use or for free distribution FRS102 “transitioning” option to ‘freeze’ a property’s revaluation or its “fair value” Charity-mergers at book values (cf revaluation to ‘fair value’ for an acquisition) Restructuring of a charity – or only of its trustee-body? Donor-imposed restrictions: capital-retention or ‘purpose’ vs ‘administrative only’ Branch-accounting vs Group-accounting for corporate charity branches FRS102: Equity-accounting for a corporate JV, as for an Associate (unless already having been using the “Gross Equity” method and still using the FRSSE) Grant-accounting and the SORP’s solution to the problem of the ‘contract culture’ Governance Costs; Volunteer Help; Investment Gains/Losses ‘Total Return’ endowment investment accounting: the options Columnar presentation for a discontinued/acquired ‘business’ vs fund-accounting Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 14 SoFA format: Income & Endowments 1. Voluntary Income & Endowments from all sources, including Donations, Legacies and also some Gifts/Grants 2. Charitable Activities fees &c (inc ‘performance-related’ Grants) 3. “Other” trading-type activities, inc. all fundraising proceeds, also from selling donated goods, from Social Lotteries, &c 4. Investment income/interest, also property rentals/lettings 5. Other – eg, a disposal gain on non-investment fixed assets; any conversion of trust capital* into income &c (= inter-fund) (*endowments) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 15 SoFA format: Expenditure “Larger” charities (>£500k: year-ends after 30 March 2015; previously: those above the Charities Act audit threshold): Purpose-related summary of total costs, as previously Support Costs now includes “Charity Governance” costs Cost apportionment methodology and results (£ or %) Care: apportioning “core costs” to Restricted Funds Fundraising costs versus Charitable Trading costs: External borrowing costs (“finance costs”) Sales-administration; Marketing & Publicity costs &c “Small” charities: follow your Standard Form of Accounts (eg, natural classification by expense – or any ‘suitable’ way) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 16 SoFA: ‘Holding’ Gains/Losses Realised and unrealised investment gains/losses on a single line within net income (using a sub-total line?) Charitable companies with material fund-movements in endowment capital (in or out): I & E Summary needed Gains & Losses section (the new ‘STRGL’): revaluation of operational (ie, non-investment) assets Actuarial gain/losses on a DB pension scheme &c Other gains/losses (eg, on foreign currency) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 17 Related Party disclosures Redefined in the new SORP to include any donor of land and also to make all RP transactions “material” (no de minimis level) Trustee-benefits – individual disclosures, as previously Trustee-donations – aggregate disclosure for FRS102 compliance SORP: Total staff costs (unless shown on face of SoFA) Split: Pay; NI; DC Pension Contribns; DB Scheme operating costs (not: finance costs); Other Benefits; Severance Pay Average staff numbers employed (plus their FTE, if you like) FRS102: Total* for all “key management personnel” (SMT) SORP: all staff employed (including by a Related Party) ‘Higher-paid’ emoluments** from £60k up, in £10k bands SORP 2005: Nos. in (i) DB and (ii) DC pension schemes * Emoluments (“employee-benefits”) – in aggregate for non-trustees ** now all charities: no. (if any) in each band Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 18 Balance Sheets – the key issues Heritage Assets rules will cover FRSSE charities also (see next Slide) Operational Fixed Assets - FRS102 transitioning* option to ‘freeze’ at “fair value” now (or at previous valuation) as their deemed “historical cost” Mixed Motive Investment Assets to be classed as commercial investments Social Investment assets (held primarily for Objects–related purposes) are separately shown (ie, investment in a charitable project through a third party (can be a Subsidiary/JV): Historical Cost basis; Impairment writeoffs (as grant-expenditure) for irrecoverable amounts as at year-end Basic financial assets/liabilities: no change; “fair value” for ‘complex’ ones (ie, hedging; options; forward contracts; interest-rate ‘swaps’ ,etc.) ‘Probable Assets’ to be accruable: Legacy-marketing & Donor-database development costs still can’t be capitalised - but under the new SORP donor-pledges, pipeline legacies, etc., will be accruable if counting as ‘probable’ assets (but of course no accrual of ‘contingent’ assets!) ‘Probable’ Liabilities to be accruable: inc. DB#/DC pension commitments (#no longer “notional”) but also staff holiday &c entitlements … (*refers to prior year figures as the comparatives in first FRS102-based accounts) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 19 Heritage Assets – if any FRS102 concept: assets of special historic, artistic, scientific, technological, geophysical or environmental significance “held principally for the asset’s contribution to knowledge & culture” SORP(FRSSE) applies the above to “small” charities also: Investment assets are excluded from the definition Operational use for unconnected purposes: only if only incidentally Other qualifying assets are heritage if normally “held for preservation /conservation”, eg, museums/galleries; church assets (SORP-18.7-11)? Balance sheet segregation of any capitalised heritage assets Nature, extent, purpose, access-details; five-year movements history build-up for capitalised & non-capitalised assets; or else a pointer to this information elsewhere (eg, website?) Policy disclosures on acquiring, preserving, disposing of assets Accounting otherwise as for operational fixed assets inc. annual reviews for evidence of ‘impairment’ (cf ‘service potential’ test) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 20 Investment Asset accounting Valuation and classification largely unchanged – except that the bid price (“fair value”: FRS102-11.27) is now to be used for quoted investments under the new SORP “Social Investment” assets – same as SORP 2005 Mixed-motive investment: commercial rules apply Investment-pooling as before: endowed and other restricted trust funds (in addition to unrestricted funds) Charity Commission Schemes creating a pool charity Trustee Act 2000 arrangements for ‘DIY’ pooling Principle: pool entry/exit only with same-day revaluation Internal versus external Investment Pools Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 21 Charity ‘Branch’ accounting Under English law “Charity Branch” accounting takes precedence – Charities Act 2011 “Special Trust” = “Restricted Fund” of the related charity Charity Commission ‘directions’ can determine all branch-accounting* A charitable company’s trust funds are always branch-accounted Its charitable subsidiary company (if any) can only be consolidated* Under Scottish law In Scotland, ‘collating’ connected** charities together as one avoids (i) separate filing with OSCR and (ii) consolidated accounts **wide definition: common or related charitable purposes OR common control# OR unity of administration (#same trustees) *The New SORP excludes all ‘corporate’ charities from “charity branch” status (ie, ‘sub-audit’ charities’ entity accounts will omit them, and if taking the cash-accounting option (also for CIOs) can just ignore them completely) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 22 Charity Groups for consolidation Charities Act requirement catches all groups above the £1m audit threshold: S.I.2015/322: years ending after 30 March 2015 SORP: group accounts must be prepared if required by law: this makes them optional best practice for ‘larger’ charities < £1m … Specific exemptions – the SORP follows FRS102: Immaterial “results”; insolvent liquidation (cf duty of care) severe long-term restrictions (preventing “subordination”) ‘Control + Benefit’ rule interpreted to include benefit to Objects Commercial interpretation only for a non-PBE ‘parent’ (FRS102) Line-by-line SoFA consolidation for all group trading activities Unmodified charity-unfriendly ‘equity-accounting’ for Associates, corporate JVs & Consortium undertakings, even though the lack of equity-investors in a charity makes the FRS102 distinction of income/assets under shared (not: sole) control irrelevant in any charity’s consolidated accounts – Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 23 The Cashflow Statement (FRS102) Required for all charities under FRS 102 (2015); optional for small charities under FRS102(2016) = those up to the SORP’s £500k ceiling only Cash inflows and outflows for three basic kinds of activity: ► Operating Activities* (includes all voluntary income; also “social investment”) ► Investing Activities (also includes purchase/sale of functional fixed assets) ► Financing Activities (inc. endowment capital cashflows; also any borrowings) *Gross or net** cashflows can be shown here **Note required for adjustments from SoFA net income/expenditure to derive the figure of net operating cashflow for year Note required: Reconciliation of Balance Sheet to net cash inflow/outflow for year Cashflow Statement is not needed for a parent or a subsidiary if group Cashflow Statement is presented Gross operating cashflows summarise Receipts & Payments by type, but in total for Charity/Group – not by type of fund, as needed for SORP compliance. Whilst readily understandable by the general public, this needs more work than showing net operating cashflows – hence its unpopularity among trained accountants … Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 24 ‘First –year’ options for SORP(FRS102); but don’t overlook the FRSSE Option! Adopting SORP(FRS102) where SORP2005’s 2008 Regulations still apply – see CC15c (March 2015) Guidance until the new SORP’s delayed 2015 Regulations are in place: The TAR’s new disclosures are non-mandatory; the old ones (see CC15c) are mandatory Accounts required under company law must follow the new SORP for a ‘true and fair view’ Q: Will your auditors agree that for accruals-based accounts prepared under charity law, you can invoke the “true and fair override” to adopt the new SORP instead of SORP2005? Reconciliation of any restated Accounts figures on first adopting FRS102 (eg, 2016/7): Applies to any restated comparatives for (i) opening balances in 2016/7 Accounts ie, = adjustments to B/F carrying values of assets/liabilities/funds in 2015/6, and (ii) net income for that prior year ie, = adjustments to figures in previously published 2015/6 SoFA; Summarise all changes to previously published accounts figures, as at prior year-end, for: any property revalued* to “fair value” – aggregate increase or decrease in BS value any employee-benefit liabilities not previously accrued any multi-employer pension fund deficit-funding commitment not previously accrued any changes to the carrying value of “non-basic” financial instruments/securities *as that property’s deemed historical cost going forward Summarise all (material) changes in restating the 2015/6 SoFA figures as comparatives NB: SORP(FRSSE) exempts you from Cashflow Statement and delays FRS102 adoption Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 25 FRS102 “transitioning” explained FRS102-35.12/.13: “An entity shall explain how the transition … to [FRS102 has] affected its reported financial position and financial performance [eg, for 2016/7]”, as regards: (a) the nature of the change in accounting policy [from old to new GAAP] (b) reconciliation of [total funds] at (i) date of transition [prior-year start-date under new GAAP] with (ii) [previous Balance Sheet date to that under old GAAP] (c) reconciliation of [net income for 2015/6] under old GAAP and under new GAAP Example: If adopting* a “fair value” of £2.5m for a long-held property being used by the church charity (land £1m; buildings £1.5m), carried at a depreciable cost under FRS15 of (say) £0.5m, and now with a 50-year UEL and ultimate disposal value at current prices estimated at (say) £1.5m (ie, land £1m; buildings £0.5m): (b) Funds* restated from (say) £15.1m as at 2014/5 year-end to £17.1m on transition (c) Net income for year 2015/6 restated from (say) £473,000 to £453,000 *Nil adjustment under (b) if “freezing” an existing “current value” as deemed cost – but material changes in estimates of residual value and depreciable amount under FRS102 affect depreciation prospectively from 2015/6 – hence the change reported under (c). Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 26 Regulatory threshold-changes Company Audit exemption (only if “claimed”): “small” company/group size-limits*: £10.2m (was: £6.5m) T/O; £5.1m (was: £3.26m) B.S. gross assets; 50 staff (max) Rule: company must not exceed any two of these this year if it did so last year Non-company charities and “small” companies/company-groups: 1. Charities Act audit by an eligible auditor** becomes mandatory if: > £1m*** gross income (£250k if gross assets value >£3.26m); but also if: > £25k gross income unless opting for Independent Examination**** * S.I.2015/980 w.e.f. 6 Apr.2015 for years from 1 January 2016 (or 2015, if wished – but not for claiming Company Audit exemption if that is not otherwise available) ** FRC-supervised auditors – ie, members of CCAB bodies or of AAPA or AIA *** S.I.2015/321: effective for financial years ending after 30 March 2015 (was: £500k) **** Above £250k, IE is only by an eligible auditor, or else by a fellow of ACIE or member of CIMA, ICSA, AAT or (for year-ends from 31 March 2015) of IFA or CPAA 2. Charities Act consolidated accounts: all Charity Groups > £1m*** gross income 3. SORP(FRS102) ‘smaller charity’ reliefs: < £500k gross income (all UK jurisdictions) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 27 Planning for change: your financial year starting in 2015 – versus 2016 Charity-size affecting regulatory requirements >£500k? And > £1m? Property ownership – freehold or leasehold? Functional versus investment property carrying values Property’s existing (gross) carrying value on the Balance Sheet? Options under Old GAAP: either historical cost or a current valuation Options under the new version of the Charities SORP for your charity: - a year ending after 30 March 2015 if > £500k income and < £1m (audit) - a year starting in 2015, under SORP(FRSSE) or else SORP(FRS102) - years starting in 2016 or later, under the revised SORP(FRS102) Impact of FRS102 on Standard Accounts Formats (eg, C of E; Methodists) Other issues under FRS102 (inc. charitable company merger/restructuring) Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 28 Issues for the Larger Charity under the new SORP from 1st January 2015 onwards Time for questions? Or write them down for the Q&A Panel in the Conference’s final session? Audit | Tax | Advisory © 2015 Crowe Clark Whitehill LLP 29
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz