BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 1 of 16 Home » Resources » White Papers » White Paper Detail News » News Monitor » News Summaries » Search News Summaries » CSR News Releases Library » Issue Briefs » Featured External Resources » News Monitor Archives » Community Investment Resources » Environment Resources » Human Rights Resources » Workplace Resources » Labor Law White Papers Ethics Codes/Values Introduction Business Importance Recent Developments External Standards Implementation Steps Leadership Examples Sample Policies Awards Resources Introduction A growing range of stakeholders - including customers, investors, activist groups, and the media - are paying close attention to the ethical behavior of companies and their employees. In addition, companies are recognizing the business benefits of creating comprehensive ethics programs. The cornerstone of any company's ethics program is its set of values. The key mechanism for articulating those values are ethics codes, also known as codes of business practices or principals. Ethics codes and business principles are instrumental in enhancing brand name and reputation, creating a cohesive corporate culture, avoiding litigation and fines, and helping to stabilize volatile markets. Ethics codes also help create globally consistent "fixed reference points" for employees. Ethical decision-making procedures, spelled out in an ethics code, arm employees with the information needed to act in accordance with the values that are at the core of a company. Increasingly, companies are also seeing the value of sharing their codes with suppliers, business partners, shareholders, and other stakeholders. The code serves as a set of concrete statements about how the file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 2 of 16 companies conduct business. Companies' codes are supported by differing philosophies which influence their development, presentation, and distribution. These codes range generally range from a compliance-based to a values-based approach, and companies usually fall somewhere along the spectrum between the two. At the most progressive end are "valuesbased" codes, which are not as a list of "do's and don'ts," but rather state certain principles that are at the base of what it means to be an employee of that particular company. "Instrumental" codes stress that employee behavior directly affects the company's bottom line. "Compliance" codes usually only address employee conduct, and are designed primarily to protect a company from prosecution or litigation. Business Importance l l l Back to the top ^ Enhance Corporate Reputation/Brand Image: A company's reputation and brand image are some of its most valuable assets. A 1998 survey of 178 British companies known to have ethics codes conducted by the Institute of Business Ethics entitled "Company Use of Codes of Business Conduct" found that 75 percent of respondents cited supporting the company's reputation as the motivation for developing an ethics code. Establishing a code is an effective way to communicate the value a company places on good business practices internally and externally. Improve Risk and Crisis Management: In times of crisis, having an ethics code can help make the case to shareholders, activists, and the media that a company has made a good faith commitment to ethical behavior, and that a mistake or transgression is the exception, not the rule. Also, developing and promulgating a code of ethics can help all employees be more alert to potential problems, and bring them to the attention of management before a crisis occurs. Create Cohesive Corporate Culture and Make Values Come Alive: Ethics are central to every decision an employee makes, and affect every facet of an organization's operations. Whether a firm's employees all work at one location, or whether they are scattered around the world, a widely distributed code of file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 3 of 16 ethics can help build a sense of community in the workplace. Many companies see their ethics codes as the vehicles which turn broad, conceptual values into tangible guides for employees. For instance, pharmaceutical company SmithKline Beecham used the development of its code in 1998 as a way to articulate the five core values that define its culture: customers, innovation, integrity, people, and performance. l l Avoid fines, sanctions, and litigation: Companies and their employees are required to comply with local, national, and international laws governing their operations and actions. An effective ethics program with a clearly presented code at its center - greatly reduces the likelihood of fines resulting from a range of illegal activities including fraud, conflict of interest, corruption and bribery, and insider trading. As an example, the U.S. Federal Sentencing Guidelines for Organizations state that companies that develop "good corporate citizenship" actions can potentially see reduced penalties, or no prosecution at all, when misconduct occurs. The guidelines state specifically that in order to demonstrate due ethical diligence, a company "must have established compliance standards and procedures to be followed by its employees and other agents that are reasonably capable of reducing the prospect of criminal conduct." Boost Development in Emerging Economies: A 1999 Conference Board report on global ethics codes found that a consensus is developing among business leaders throughout the world that sound business practices, stemming from ethical foundations, will help improve development prospects in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Global codes set an ethical standard which can be followed despite differences in cultural and national approaches, and in laws and standards between jurisdictions. (For more information, see Corruption and Bribery Issue Brief) Recent Developments l Back to the top ^ Globalization of business: According to a 1999 Conference Board Report on "Global Corporate Ethics Practices," the rapid internationalization of business and increased pressure from non-governmental file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 4 of 16 organizations (NGOs) has led to more comprehensive business ethics programs on a global scale. More and more, companies face the challenge of communicating values and ethics programs to thousands of employees in dozens of countries with many legal systems, cultures, and ethical priorities. Global company ethics codes enable managers to act in ways that are morally consistent with the values and principles of the company. For example, the U.K. Foreign Office plans to produce a "practical, down to earth" ethics manual on best practices for British companies investing and operating overseas that addresses issues such as protecting the environment and preventing child labor. The Foreign Office is consulting with large companies such as BP Amoco, Cadbury, and Royal Dutch/Shell, as well as with NGOs, and is gearing the guide to smaller companies which may not have the resources to conduct environmental assessments or link up with local NGOs. l l l Boards Setting Up Ethics Codes: A 1999 Conference Board study of 124 companies in 22 countries found that 78 percent of boards of directors are setting up ethics standards, up from 41 percent in 1991 and 21 percent in 1987. The study also found that one-third of those surveyed said that their board of directors' participation in the development of ethics codes is "heavy." Technology/Cyber-Ethical Dilemmas: Employees now have access to a range of new technologies including the Internet and e-mail - that have created new ethical dilemmas and accelerated the pace at which ethical decisions must be made. In response, companies have targeted issues such as appropriate use of office email and viewing of inappropriate websites and incorporated them into existing codes. For example, while Bell Atlantic's Code of Business Conduct recognizes that personal use of company communication and computer systems are permissible, it also addresses "proper" employee use of these technologies. Expanded Content: Until recently, the majority of ethics codes addressed two major sets of issues, those that deal with contracts (such as conflict of interest, bribery, security of proprietary information, and receiving gifts) and those that are mandated, either legally or through other generally-accepted standards file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 5 of 16 (sexual harassment, workplace safety, political activities). Increasingly, however, companies are seeing the value of codes that address additional issues such as the environment, child labor, and human rights External Standards l l Back to the top ^ UN Global Compact, UN Human Development report on globalization. UN Secretary-General, Kofi Annan, has called upon the international business community to enact nine principles in the areas of human rights, labor standards, and the environment to be used as the base for ethical codes of conduct which address issues of inequality in the global marketplace and the widening gap between the world's poor and wealthy. http://www.unglobalcompact.org/ Relevant Legal Standards: Full compliance with relevant laws regarding labor rights is typically incorporated into company codes. This occurs most frequently with respect to issues such as wages, benefits, working hours, anti-trust, and corruption and bribery. Industry/Business Association Standards: l Defense Industry Initiative (DII) on Business Ethics and Conduct: A number of U.S. defense industry companies have signed the DII Principles of Business Ethics and Conduct that address their corporate responsibilities under federal procurement laws and to the public. The six DII principles address: (1) written code of business ethics and conduct, (2) employees' ethical responsibilities, (3) corporate responsibility to employees, (4) corporate responsibility to the government, (5) corporate responsibility to the defense industry, and (6) public accountability. Implementation Steps Back to the top ^ On the surface, many company ethics codes look similar. What sets an effective code apart is how well it is institutionalized and implemented. Companies planning to develop and implement an ethics code should consider the following steps: file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 6 of 16 DRAFTING THE CODE: l l l l l Start With Values: When ethics codes are congruent with clearly stated values, many companies find them more effective. Involve Employees Early in the Process: The ultimate success of an ethics code depends on the extent to which employees embrace and relate to its language and spirit. For instance, before drafting its code, Merck & Company embarked on an organizational analysis in which it asked 10,000 employees (22 percent of its total workforce) in 21 countries: "How do we want to be perceived as a company by shareholders, customers, suppliers, employees, and the general public?" The original draft of the code was based on the results of this survey, as well as information from employee focus groups and interviews. After an advisory board composed of senior executives completed a final draft, it was tested on focus groups of employees throughout the globe, then implemented. Include public endorsement of CEO, Ethics Office: Make explicit the involvement of senior management in the drafting of the codes. A 1999 study by Arthur Anderson found that employees' perception of senior management's commitment was the most important component of a successful ethics program. The above mentioned 1999 Conference Board report on global ethics codes found that of the companies surveyed, 95 percent of CEOs were involved in drafting codes. Also, some ethical practitioners have found value in making a list of the cost of other companies' ethical lapses to make the case to senior management of the importance of funding comprehensive ethics programs. Involve Key Company Managers: Companies have found that drafting a code in conjunction with the functional area representatives responsible for some aspect of its enforcement is critical in getting the "buyin" necessary for its effective implementation. Departments to involve may include: Community Affairs, Sourcing, Product Development, Quality Assurance, Purchasing/Buying Agents, Sales, Legal Affairs, Human Resources, Public Affairs/Communications, and Government Affairs. Make Codes Both Global and Local in Scope: Involve international personnel as early as possible in the development of the code to make sure it is file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values l l l l Page 7 of 16 understood and embraced by all employees. Ensure that codes are translated into the native languages of employees working abroad. Cover All Relevant and Important Issues: Outright bans on certain practices are found most often on subjects where clear, internationally-accepted principles are applied. This is the case with child labor, forced labor, or bribery. On issues where practices vary, and widely-accepted, measurable standards are less available - such as conflict of interest -- companies are more likely to insert language which permits some flexibility. Include Enforcement and Implementation Mechanisms: A 1998 Institute of Business Ethics survey of 178 British companies found that while many companies have codes of ethics, a large percentage do not enforce or implement them. The survey found that 30 percent of those polled had no formal whistleblowing procedures, 30 percent do not give a copy of their code to every employee, and only one-third make their codes available to the public. Include Resources in the Code: Ethics codes by definition deal with issues that contain gray areas. Employees must know where to turn in case of a need for clarification on certain issues. Consider including contacts or other information resources where employees can go when ethical questions arise. Include Staffing Plans and Implementation Efforts: A code's effectiveness depends on successful enforcement mechanisms, which vary from company to company. Some companies dedicate staff solely to overseeing implementation of codes of conduct. Other companies assign implementation duties to personnel whose core job responsibilities lie in other areas such as sourcing, quality assurance, or production engineering. DISTRIBUTING THE CODE: l l Ensure Wide Distribution of Code: The code should be sent to all company employees in a clear and readable form, and should be given to new employees upon joining the company. Communicate Code Clearly Both Internally and Externally: Communicating the code to all key company managers, as well as to business partners, workers, and the public, is essential to clarifying the file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 8 of 16 provisions of a code and its importance. Communication can take several forms, including workshops for internal staff and vendors, meetings and signed agreements with business partners, posting codes on office and factory walls, and making the codes available to the general public so as to demonstrate a company's dedication to creating an ethical climate. EVALUATING THE CODE: l l Revise and Update Code as Appropriate: The code must evolve so that it remains applicable to the daily operations of the business. The above mentioned 1998 Institute of Business Ethics survey on company uses of codes of conduct found that 86 percent of companies have a formal procedure for reviewing their code. Consider Involving External Stakeholders: Royal Dutch/Shell considers discussion with external stakeholders "essential" to creating and maintaining a dynamic of trust between the company and society. The company asks NGO representatives and academics to discuss the effectiveness of its code and to hear how they view the company's adherence to its ethics statements. Leadership Examples Back to the top ^ These "leadership" practices have been chosen as illustrative examples in the area of corporate social responsibility addressed by this Issue Brief. They are intended to represent innovation, higher than average commitment, unusual industry practice or a comprehensive approach to this issue. Periodically, the examples listed may be changed. If you wish to share information about your company's leadership practices or policies, please contact [email protected] with the relevant information. (Many of the company examples and policies cited in this report have been verified and approved. Final approvals for others are pending and information will be modified if necessary.) McMurry Publishing : In its early years, Phoenix, Arizonabased McMurry Publishing did not have any written ethics codes; its values were passed along orally and through the actions of its employees. When the company decided it was time to codify these values, its management invited the entire staff to spend a day brainstorming values the company held to be important in how it does business. Employees and file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 9 of 16 mangers came up with: Do the Right Thing, Help One Another, Deliver Raving Customer Service, Produce Quality Always, Embrace Change, Accept Social Responsibility, Earn a Reasonable Profit. Each new employee spends half a day becoming oriented to the code, and employee performance evaluations are based on how well employees adhere to the values set out in the code. To ensure the statements do not grow stale, every employee sets aside an hour a month to discuss one of the values with colleagues. In addition, the company has instituted a scorecard system in which employees can give themselves or their colleagues points redeemable at local stores - for shows of teamwork. (Small/Midsize, Publishing, United States) Sample Policies Back to the top ^ The following sample policies represent the broad approaches companies have taken to develop effective and thorough ethics codes. If you would like to submit your own, please click the button at the bottom of the screen to send an email. l l l l l l Dow Chemical Company : http://129.33.63.85/about/aboutdow/ethics.htm Royal Dutch/Shell : General Business Principles: http://134.146.1.138/royalen/directory/0,5029,25461,00.html Boeing : http://www.boeing.com/companyoffices/aboutus/ethics/epolicy.h Bell South : Commitment Booklet: http://ethics.bellsouth.com/ Nortel Networks : http://www.nortelnetworks.com/corporate/community/ethics/ Lockheed Martin : http://www.lmco.com/exeth/html/code/print.html Awards Back to the top ^ At this time, BSR is not aware of any awards given to companies specifically for their ethics codes. Resources Back to the top ^ The following list is not comprehensive. It is an illustrative group of the many nonprofit, public sector and/or academic resources working with the private sector in the area of corporate social responsibility addressed by this Issue Brief. The resources identified below have been included because they provide information or support that is relevant to file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 10 of 16 companies, and they are national or international in scope. Periodically, the examples listed may be changed. At this time, the list does not include for-profit resources. If you would like to provide information about additional helping resources that meet our criteria, please contact [email protected]. Business for Social Responsibility http://www.bsr.org/ Back to the top ^ Organizational Overview: Founded in 1992, Business for Social Responsibility (BSR) helps companies of all sizes and from all sectors achieve commercial success in ways that respect ethical values, people, communities and the environment. A leading global business partner, BSR provides information, tools and advisory services to make corporate social responsibility (CSR) an integral part of business operations and strategies. BSR promotes cross sector collaborations and contributes to global efforts to advance the field of corporate social responsibility. BSR member companies have nearly $2 trillion in combined annual revenues and employ more than six million workers around the world. Products and Services: l l l l Membership. BSR membership provides companies with access to information resources, advisory services, and collaborative and networking opportunities. Advisory Services. BSR helps companies to plan, implement and measure the impact of strategies, policies and practices across the full spectrum of CSR issues. Conferences. BSR's annual conference convenes more than 1,000 business leaders from around the world. Participants stay informed of changing requirements of CSR, network with peers and thought-leaders in the field, and learn to apply innovative strategies and practices that add value to their companies and to society. Resources. BSR provides information resources to members, clients and the general public. Members enjoy a weekly summary of CSR news from around the world in the News Monitor. In addition, BSR Magazine, a free online magazine, offers CSR-related interviews, columns file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 11 of 16 and trend analyses. A range of reports, guides and training modules can be purchased online at the BSR Store. Contact Information: 609 Mission St., 2nd Floor San Francisco, CA 94105 United States Phone: 415.537.0890 Fax: 415.537.0888 Email: [email protected] Ethics Officer Association http://www.eoa.org/ Back to the top ^ Organizational Overview: The Ethics Officer Association (EOA) is a U.S.-based non-profit professional group for leaders of corporate ethics and compliance programs. For its more than 650 members, the EOA serves as a "forum for the exchange of information and strategies among individuals responsible for setting ethics, compliance and business conduct programs in their organizations." Products & Services: l l l l l Research on Corporate Ethics & Compliance: The EOA conducts research on ethical issues, including workplace pressure and ethics, and new technologies and ethics. Online Forums and Information: A member-only online discussion group, and on-line ethics and compliance libraries. Annual Conference: EOA's annual conference addresses current ethics and compliance issues. Professional Development Program: In conjunction with the Center for Business Ethics at Bentley College, the EOA offers "Managing Ethics in Organizations," a week-long professional development program for ethics officers and others with responsibilities for their organization's ethics, compliance, or business conduct programs. Ethics Administration Software: The EOA has developed an ethics software program that "assists ethics officers in collecting, managing, reporting and graphing details regarding ethics allegations, inquiries file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values l l Page 12 of 16 and human resources." Corporate Ethics and Compliance Library: The library contains codes of conduct from member companies, as well as videos and other internal communication tools. EOA News: The EOA News is published four times a year. Website: Provides information on its activities and services, and provides links to other ethics organizations and to a selection of corporate members' websites. Contact Information: Ethics Officer Association 30 Church St., Suite 331 Belmont, MA 02478 United States Phone: 617.484.9400 Fax: 617.484.8330 Ethics Resource Center http://www.ethics.org/ Back to the top ^ Organizational Overview: The Ethics Resource Center (ERC) is a "nonprofit, nonpartisan educational organization whose vision is an ethical world. Its mission is to be a leader and a catalyst in fostering the ethical practices in individuals and institutions." The ERC focuses on institution and coalition development, research and knowledge building, education and advocacy, and consulting and technical Assistance. Products and Services: l l l Institution & Coalition Development: The ERC has created or provided assistance to international ethics centers including the Hong Kong Ethics Development Centre, the Gulf Centre for Excellence in Ethics, and centers South Africa and Colombia. Research and Knowledge Building: Members of the ERC Fellows Program, a group of business leaders, ethics officers, and ethics scholars meet biannually to research a range of topics such as compliance in a global economy and ethics as a leadership issue. Education and Advocacy: The ERC serves as an ethics advocacy center for companies; publishes a quarterly file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values l Page 13 of 16 newsletter, Ethics Today; shares information and research through its website and speakers bureau; and convenes conferences and meetings worldwide. Consulting & Technical Assistance: The ERC provides consulting for U.S. and international companies on effective ethics and compliance programs. Website: The organization's website provides information on its publications, videos, management tools, surveys, and research. Contact Information: Ethics Resource Center 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Suite 400 Washington, DC 20006 United States Tel: 202.737.2258 Fax: 202.737.2227 Hong Kong Ethics Development Centre http://www.cuhk.edu.hk/icac/edc.htm Back to the top ^ Organizational Overview: The Hong Kong Ethics Development Centre (EDC) was established in 1995 under the auspices of the Community Relations Department of the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC), which was established in 1974 to fight corruption in both the public and the private sectors in Hong Kong. The EDC operates under the guidance of the Hong Kong Ethics Development Advisory Committee, comprising members from leading chambers of commerce in Hong Kong. Products and Services: l l l Resource Centre: The Centre has more than 1,000 local and overseas reference publications on business ethics. These include books, journals, teaching and information packages, videos, and sample codes of conduct from different trades and professions. Consulting Services: The Center provides consulting services on various ethics issues including the formulation of codes of conducts for companies. Ethics in Practice: This newsletter is published on a quarterly basis and is distributed free of charge both locally and internationally. file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 14 of 16 Website: The Center's website provides past issues of the newsletter. Other products and services are not profiled on the site. However, the site does provide a link to Hong Kong's Independent Commission Against Corruption. Contact Information: Hong Kong Ethics Development Centre 1/F, Tung Wah Mansion 199-203 Hennessy Road Wanchai, Hong Kong Phone: 852.2587.9812 Fax: 852.2824.9766 Institute of Business Ethics Back to the top ^ Organizational Overview: The Institute of Business Ethics was launched in 1986 by Sir Allan Davis, then Lord Mayor of London. It seeks to "clarify ethical issues in business, to propose positive solutions to problems and to establish common ground with people of goodwill of all faiths." The Institute holds consultations and conferences, undertakes research, and offers practical advice to companies wishing to establish and implement ethical policies. Products & Services: l Publications: The IBE's publications cover areas such as ethics and information technology, codes of ethics, ethics and the environment, and global ethics. Website: The IBE's website provides information on the organization's history, objectives, and publications, as well as "Twelve Steps for Implementing a Code of Business Ethics." Contact Information: Institute of Business Ethics 12 Palace Street London SW1E 5JA United Kingdom Phone: 44.171.931.0495 Fax: 44.171.821.5819 Center for Business Ethics, Bentley College file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values http://ecampus.bentley.edu/resource/cbe Page 15 of 16 Back to the top ^ Organizational Overview:The mission of the Center for Business Ethics CBE) at Bentley College is to provide an "international forum for the advancement of business ethics. The Center is committed to developing strategies for ethical business conduct and providing a bridge between theoretical research and practical business activity." Products and Services: l l l l l l l Annual Conference: Addresses a range of in-depth and emerging ethics issues. Corporate Education and Training: CBE provides companies, organizations, and their employees with specialized ethics education and training programs. Kallman Executive Fellows Program: CBE hosts academic and executive scholars to assist "in building relationships with the business community, to create an atmosphere of intellectual discourse on matters of business ethics, and to recognize and respond to public concerns on ethical business practices." Consulting: CBE consults with companies in setting up ethics guidelines and programs. Surveys: The Center conducts surveys on a range of business ethics issues. Research Library: The CBE's library has a database of business ethics books and articles. CBE News: The Center's newsletter is published biannually. Website: Provides information on membership, publications, activities, and advisory board Contact Information: Center for Business Ethics Adamian Graduate Center, Room 108 Bentley College Waltham, MA 02452 United States Phone: 781.891.2981 Fax: 781.891.2988 E-mail: [email protected] Author: BSR Staff file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004 BSR » Business for Social Responsibility - Ethics Codes/Values Page 16 of 16 Site Map » Legal » Contact Us » Email this Page Home » Join BSR » About BSR » Search » Member Login Services » Resources » Forum » Store © 2001–2004 Business for Social Responsibility file://C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\Conflict%20of%20Interest%20Websites%20and%20Fil... 16/01/2004
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz