International Relations
in a “Dangerous,
Multinational World”
89i`\]:fem\ijXk`fen`k_
9i`^X[`\i>\e\iXci\k% K_fdXjBfc[`kq
PA@81Gif]\jjfiBfc[`kq#fliAflieXcj\\bjkfYi`[^\k_\^XgY\kn\\e`ek\ieXk`feXc
i\cXk`fej@I jZ_fcXijXe[giXZk`k`fe\ijXe[kf_\cg`e]fidgfc`Zp%8jYfk_XZXi\\i
8idpf]]`Z\iXe[XjXgif]\jjfiXkknfkfgL%J%le`m\ij`k`\j#n_Xk[fpflk_`ebXi\
jfd\nXpj`en_`Z_@IjZ_fcXijXe[giXZk`k`fe\ijZXeY\e\]`k\XZ_fk_\i6
Bfc[`kq1N_XkjZ_fcXiji\XccpYi`e^kfk_\kXYc\`jX[\gk_f]le[\ijkXe[`e^%N_Xk
k_\pZXe[f]figiXZk`k`fe\ij`jkf[\]`e\k_\jgXZ\`en_`Z_giXZk`k`fe\ijnfib`ek\idj
f]`kj[\gk_#`ek\idjf]`kj^iXelcXi`kp#`ek\idjf]k_\dlck`kl[\f]mXi`XYc\jk_XkXi\
^f`e^kfX]]\Zk`ek\ieXk`feXci\cXk`fej^f`e^]finXi[%N_XkgiXZk`k`fe\ijZXe[fXi\#@
k_`eb#knfk_`e^j%K_\]`ijk`jkf[\m\cfgi\cXk`fej_`gj%F]k\ek_\jlZZ\jjfi]X`cli\f]
k_\j\b`e[jf]`ek\ieXk`feXc\e[\Xmfij`ji\XccpYl`ckfeg\ijfeXci\cXk`fej_`gjXjdlZ_
Xjjfc`[gfc`Zp#Xe[jfgiXZk`k`fe\ijZXeYi`e^k_\\og\i`\eZ\Xe[jb`ccjkfZi\Xk\k_\j\
i\cXk`fej_`gj%K_\fk_\ik_`e^k_XkgiXZk`k`fe\ijYi`e^`j`ekl`k`m\al[^d\ek%
N_XkjZ_fcXijZXe[f`jj\klgk_\mXi`XYc\jXe[Xe`ek\igi\kXk`fef]k_\mXi`XYc\j`e
XiXk`feXcnXp#`eXe\m`[\eZ\$YXj\[nXpk_Xkc\X[jkfZ\ikX`eZfeZclj`fej%9lkg\fgc\
n_fnfib`e`ek\ieXk`feXci\cXk`fejXe[[fk_Xkb`e[f]nfibXcck_\k`d\Xcjf[\m\cfg
jfd\`ekl`k`m\al[^d\ekXe[`ekl`k`m\gifZ\jj\jk_XkXi\efe$c`e\XiXe[efe$cf^`ZXc
Ylkk_Xkefe\k_\c\jjki\d\e[fljcp`e]cl\eZ\flkZfd\j%Jf@k_`ebk_Xk½ji\Xccpn_Xk
giXZk`k`fe\ijYi`e^`jk_\Xik]lcXjg\Zkkf`ek\ieXk`feXci\cXk`fej#n_`Z_d`^_kj\\dX
Y`kc\jjgli\cpiXk`feXcXe[jk\i`c\k_Xek_XkZfd`e^]ifdXi\j\XiZ_\i½jg\ijg\Zk`m\%
PA@81PflkXl^_kXkN\jkGf`ek]fikn\cm\p\Xij#Xe[pfl_Xm\_X[Xcfe^i\cXk`fej_`g
n`k_PXc\Xjn\cc%8i\k_\i\[`]]\i\eZ\j`ek_\nXpjk_Xkd\dY\ijf]k_\d`c`kXip
XggifXZ_@IgifYc\djZfdgXi\[kfgif]\jj`feXcj`efk_\i]`\c[j6
Bfc[`kq1@k_`ebjf%@k_`ebk_\d`c`kXipXggifXZ_@IgifYc\dj`e]XikffZfej\imXk`m\
X]Xj_`fe#n`k_nXpkffdlZ_\dg_Xj`jfej\Zli`kp%@½cc^`m\Xe\oXdgc\%N\XkN\jk
K_fdXjBfc[`kq`jXGif]\jjfi`ek_\GiXZk`Z\f]C\X[\ij_`g`ek_\PXc\Le`m\ij`kpJZ_ffcf]DXeX^\d\ek%
8i\k`i\[8idpYi`^X[`\i^\e\iXc#Gif]\jjfiBfc[`kq_\X[\[k_\;\gXikd\ekf]9\_Xm`fiXcJZ`\eZ\Xe[
C\X[\ij_`gXkN\jkGf`ek]fikn\cm\p\XijXe[_\c[c\X[\ij_`ggfj`k`fejfe]fliZfek`e\ekjfm\ik_`ikp$
]flip\Xijf]d`c`kXipj\im`Z\%?\`jXe`ek\ieXk`feXccpi\Zf^e`q\[\og\ikfeZi`j`jc\X[\ij_`g%
:"-&+063/"-0'*/5&3/"5*0/"-"''"*34
*/5&3/"5*0/"-3&-"5*0/4*/"§%"/(&3064.6-5*/"5*0/"-803-%¨
Gf`ek [`[ X j`^e`]`ZXek Xdflek f] nfib n`k_ :_`e\j\ jZ_fcXij Xe[ c\X[\ij_`g Xe[
dXeX^\d\ekgiXZk`k`fe\ij%9lkk_\d`c`kXipc`d`k\[fliXY`c`kpkf`ek\iXZkn`k_k_fj\
fk_\ijZ_fcXijYXj\[fej\Zli`kpZfeZ\iejk_Xk#Xkflic\m\cXe[]fifligligfj\j#j\\d
kfY\hl`k\\oki\d\%Jf@k_`ebk_Xkk_\d`c`kXipXggifXZ_\j`ek\ieXk`feXci\cXk`fej`e
Xm\ipZfej\imXk`m\nXp#n`k_Xºj\Zli`kp]`ijk»d\ekXc`kp#Xe[k_Xk^\kj`ek_\nXpf]
Y\`e^XYc\kfX[mXeZ\i\cXk`fej_`gjXe[\m\eklXccp`e]cl\eZ\gfc`Z`\j%
PA@81@epflik`d\fm\ij\Xj#n_Xkb`e[jf]`ek\ieXk`feXci\cXk`fejgfc`Z`\j[`[pflj\\
k_Xkpflk_`ebn\i\\]]\Zk`m\#Xe[n_`Z_fe\j[fpflY\c`\m\e\\[\[`dgifm\d\ek6
Bfc[`kq1 Jfd\ gfc`Z`\j k_Xk @ ]\ck n\i\ gXik`ZlcXicp \]]\Zk`m\ n\i\ JkXklj f] =fiZ\j
8^i\\d\ekj JF=8j % K_\j\ X^i\\d\ekj fg\e\[ lg fggfikle`k`\j ]fi 8d\i`ZXej#
d`c`kXipfi[`gcfdXk`Z#fi\m\e\ogXki`Xk\Ylj`e\jjg\fgc\n_fXi\XYifX[RXe[TZXe
i\Xccp\eld\iXk\nXpj`en_`Z_`ek\iXZk`fejZXefZZliY\kn\\ed\dY\ijf]k_\knf
Zfleki`\j%Jf#@k_fl^_kk_fj\n\i\m\ipn\ccZiX]k\[#k_\pj\im\[Yfk_j`[\jm\ipn\cc%
K_\gi`eZ`gc\jlgfen_`Z_JF=8jn\i\Yl`ckZflc[i\XccpY\^ff[^l`[`e^\oXdgc\j
f]_fndlklXccpY\e\]`Z`Xcgfc`Z`\jZXeY\`dgifm\[%@k_`ebk_XkdXepf]k_\kiX[\
gfc`Z`\jn\_Xm\n`k_fk_\iZfleki`\jXi\`e\]]\Zk`m\Xe[Zi\Xk\Xe`dfj`kpXe[gi\m\ek
k_\i`^_kb`e[f]Ylj`e\jji\cXk`fej_`gj]ifd[\m\cfg`e^%Jfk_fj\Xi\k_\knfk_`e^j
@k_`ebZXeY\`dgifm\[%
PA@818YffbZ_Xgk\ipflZf$Xlk_fi\[`e)''0nXjk`kc\[#¸C\X[\ij_`g`e;Xe^\iflj
Dlck`eXk`feXc:fek\okj%¹?fnZXe@IjZ_fcXijY\jk_\cggiXZk`k`fe\ijgi\gXi\]fi
fg\iXk`e^`eX¸[Xe^\iflj#dlck`eXk`feXc¹nfic[6
Bfc[`kq1Jfk_\]`ijkk_`e^k_XkjZ_fcXijZXe[f`jXZbefnc\[^\k_Xkn_\ec`m\jXi\fe
k_\c`e\#k_\i\Xi\j`^e`]`ZXekgi\jjli\jk_Xkk\e[kf`e]cl\eZ\k_\nXpg\fgc\e\^fk`Xk\#
[\m\cfggfc`Z`\j#Xe[[\m\cfgi\cXk`fej#Xe[k_\pe\\[kf]fidXccpjkl[pk_Xk[peXd`Z%
N_Xkn\]fle[`ek_\c\X[\ij_`gXi\eXnXjk_Xkk_Xk[peXd`ZnXjefkjkl[`\[%N_\en\
[`[k_\i\j\XiZ_n\]fle[k_Xkc\X[\ij_`g`e[Xe^\ifljZfek\okj[f\j_Xm\jfd\le`hl\
Z_XiXZk\i`jk`Zjk_XkZXeY\jkl[`\[\dg`i`ZXccpXe[ZXeY\
Xik`ZlcXk\[%@k_`eb`ek_\`ek\ieXk`feXci\cXk`feji\Xcd#`]
;\m\cfgd\ek
g\fgc\ jkl[`\[ e\^fk`Xk`fej Xe[ gfc`Zp [`jZljj`fej k_Xk
n\i\[fe\n`k_k_\YXZb[ifgf]g\fgc\[p`e^#k_Xkk_\p
ZXe½ki\XccpfZZli
nflc[j\\jfd\le`hl\Z_XiXZk\ikfk_Xk%8e[kfY\XYc\
\oZ\gkle[\ik_\
kfXik`ZlcXk\k_XkXe[k\XZ_g\fgc\XYflk`knflc[Y\Xki\$
d\e[fljZfeki`Ylk`fek_Xk@[fe½kk_`eb_XjY\\edX[\p\k%
PA@81Knff]k_\dXafi]`\c[jn`k_`e@IXi\j\Zli`kp
Xe[[\m\cfgd\ek%@epfli\og\i`\eZ\#Xi\k_\j\]`\c[j
Zfdgc\d\ekXipfiZfdg\k`k`m\6;fk_\pnfibkf^\k_\i
n\cc#fiXi\k_\pf]k\eXkZifjjgligfj\j6
Bfc[`kq1N\cc#k_\pj_flc[Y\Zfdgc\d\ekXip%@ek_\`i
Y\jk]fid#k_\pi\XccpXi\%;\m\cfgd\ekZXe½ki\XccpfZZli
\oZ\gkle[\ik_\YcXeb\kf]j\Zli`kp#Xe[Zfleki`\jXi\c\jj
jkXYc\Xe[efkj\Zli\n_\e[\m\cfgd\ek[f\jefkfZZli%
YcXeb\kf]j\Zli`kp#
Xe[Zfleki`\jXi\
c\jjjkXYc\Xe[
efkj\Zli\n_\e
[\m\cfgd\ek[f\j
efkfZZli%
8*/5&3 #3*("%*&3(&/&3"-3&5
5)0."4,0-%*5;
Knf[`]]\i\ek^iflgjf]g\fgc\Xi\f]k\eZ_Xi^\[n`k_k_fj\gifZ\jj\j#Xe[n_\ek_\p
kipkfgifj\Zlk\k_\`i`ek\i\jkj`ek_\XYj\eZ\f]k_\fk_\i#`kZXeXgg\XiZfdg\k`k`m\fi
[pj]leZk`feXc%9lk`e`kjgli\jk]fidXe[n_\e[fe\gifg\icp#k_\pXi\Zfdgc\d\ekXip%
Jfn_\eg\fgc\j\\Zfe]c`Zk#k_\pj_flc[^fX]k\ik_Xkgi\kkpX^^i\jj`m\cpkfkipkf
i\jfcm\`kY\ZXlj\`k`j^f`e^kfdXb\\m\ipfe\½jafY\Xj`\i`ek_\\e[%
PA@818jjfd\fe\n_fdfm\j]i\\cpY\kn\\ek_\XZX[\d`ZXe[giXZk`k`fe\infic[j#
n_XkkiX`kjfiXY`c`k`\j[fpfl]`e[`ejlZZ\jj]lcgiXZk`k`fe\ijf]@I6
Bfc[`kq1Knfk_`e^jk_Xk@k_`ebXi\m\ip`dgfikXek%=`ijk`j]c\o`Y`c`kpkf]`e[jfclk`fej
k_\pn\i\e½kj\\b`e^`ek_\]`ijkgcXZ\Ylkk_Xkn`ccjXk`j]pk_\eXk`feXc`ek\i\jk%8e[
k_\ej\Zfe[cp#k_\dfjk`dgfikXekkiX`k`jkfgifa\Zki\jg\ZkXjXdXkk\if]k_\`ig\ijfeXc
Z_XiXZk\i%Jf`k½jefkaljkjfd\k_`e^k_\p[f2`kZfd\jeXkliXccpkfk_\d%9\ZXlj\feZ\
pflZfee\Zkn`k_fk_\ig\fgc\#k_\pj\ej\k_XkXlk_\ek`Zgifa\Zk`fef]i\jg\Zk#RXe[T
@k_`ebXcfkdfi\ZXeY\XZZfdgc`j_\[%
PA@81Fe\f]pflidXafiXi\Xjf]\og\ik`j\`j`ek_\]`\c[f]c\X[\ij_`g%8jGi\j`[\ek
FYXdX\ek\ij_`jj\Zfe[k\id#n_XkX[m`Z\d`^_kpflf]]\i_`dn`k_i\^Xi[jkf
dX`ekX`e`e^fi`dgifm`e^flii\cXk`fej_`gjn`k_fk_\ieXk`fej#gXik`ZlcXicpeXk`fej
c`b\Efik_Bfi\Xfi@iXe#n_\i\_`jkfi`ZXccpk_\i\_XjY\\e^i\Xkk\ej`fe6
Bfc[`kq1@nflc[X[m`j\_`dkf[fknfk_`e^j%?\e\\[jkfY\dfi\X^^i\jj`m\XYflk
g\ijfeXci\cXk`fej_`gjXe[_\e\\[jkfY\Zfd\g\ijfeXccp]Xd`c`XiXe[Zcfj\n`k_\m\ip
eXk`feXcc\X[\in_f`j`dgfikXekkffliZflekip%K_\j\Zfe[k_`e^@k_`eb_\j_flc[
[f`jkf^X`ekiljkYp\oZ\\[`e^k_\\og\ZkXk`fejf]fk_\ic\X[\ij%Jf`]k_\eXk`feXc
c\X[\i\og\Zkj_`dkfgifm`[\XZ\ikX`eXdflekf]X`[#k_\e@k_`eb_\j_flc[\oZ\\[
k_Xk\og\ZkXk`fe%@]k_\eXk`feXcc\X[\i\og\Zkj_`dkfdXb\Xgfj`k`m\jkXk\d\ekXYflk
L%J%i\cXk`fejn`k_k_\`iZflekip#k_XkjkXk\d\ekj_flc[^fY\pfe[k_\\og\ZkXk`fe%Jf
@k_`eb_\ZXedfi\iXg`[cpYl`c[kiljk`ek_\j\i\cXk`fej_`gj`]_\`jlegi\[`ZkXYc\`eX
gfj`k`m\nXp%K_`j_Xj`kjfne[Xe^\ij#Xkk`d\j_\ZXeY\XZZlj\[f]^`m`e^fm\ikfk_\
fk_\ij`[\#fifk_\in`j\j\cc`e^flk#Ylk@k_`ebk_Xk`kn`ccY\ki\d\e[fljcp\]]\Zk`m\%
8e[@k_`eb_\ZXekXb\dXepc\jjfej]ifd_`jJ\Zi\kXipf]JkXk\#n_f`jm\ip^ff[Xk
[f`e^Yfk_f]k_fj\k_`e^j%
PA@81?fnZXeYfk_XZX[\d`ZjXe[giXZk`k`fe\ijf]@I_\cg[\Z`j`fedXb\ijZiX]k
Y\kk\i@Igfc`Zp6
Bfc[`kq1@k_`ebk_XkYfk_e\\[kfY\`ek_\iffd#k_Xk½jjk\gfe\%K_\pe\\[kfefk
fg\iXk\`e`jfcXk`feXjk_\pXi\[`jZljj`e^gfc`Zp#Xjk_\pXi\[`jZljj`e^fgk`fejXe[
jkiXk\^`\j%@k_`ebXcjfk_XkYfk_k_fj\Z_XiXZk\i`jk`Zje\\[kfY\i\gi\j\ek\[Ypb\p
gcXp\ij%N_Xk@d\XeYpk_Xk`jXZX[\d`Zjj_flc[j\\bkf\e^X^\`egiXZk`ZXcdXkk\ij
XjjfZ`Xk\[n`k_gfc`Zp#Xe[giXZk`k`fe\ijj_flc[Y\n`cc`e^kfjkl[p`efi[\ikf^X`eX
^i\Xk\iXZX[\d`ZXggi\Z`Xk`fe]fik_\`i]`\c[%Jf_Xm`e^Yfk_g\fgc\`ek_\iffd#Xe[
Yfk_hlXc`k`\jdXe`]\jk\[`e\XZ_g\ijfen_f`j\e^X^\[@Igfc`Zp`jk_\Y\jkZflij\
f]XZk`fe%@i\Xccp[fe½kk_`ebjfd\fe\n_ffecpkXb\jfe\f]k_fj\g\ijg\Zk`m\jZXeY\
Xj\]]\Zk`m\Xjjfd\fe\n`k_XYc\e[\[YXZb^ifle[%
:"-&+063/"-0'*/5&3/"5*0/"-"''"*34
*/5&3/"5*0/"-3&-"5*0/4*/"§%"/(&3064.6-5*/"5*0/"-803-%¨
PA@818i\pflnfib`e^feXepgifa\Zkj6DXpY\X]fccfn$lgkfpfliYffb#@e<oki\d`j
C\X[\ij_`g1C\X[`e^Xj`]PfliC`]\;\g\e[\[Fe@k6
Bfc[`kq1I`^_kefn@½dnfib`e^feXYffbk_Xk]fZlj\jfe_fnkf[\m\cfgc\X[\ij`e
Ylj`e\jjjZ_ffcj#n_`Z_`ji\Xccpk_\Zfi\f]dpnfib_\i\XkPXc\%N\_Xm\\dYXib\[
fek_`jgifZ\jj`enXpjk_XkXi\j`^e`]`ZXekcp[`]]\i\ekk_XeXkfk_\iYlj`e\jjjZ_ffcj%
Jf@nXekkfZXgkli\k_fj\giXZk`Z\jXe[k_\\m`[\eZ\]fik_\`i\]]\Zk`m\e\jjXe[j_Xi\
P
k_Xkn`k_fk_\ig\fgc\%„
µ?dj[hl_[mYedZkYj[ZXo9^Whb[i<W_dj
JhWdiYh_X[ZWdZ[Z_j[ZXo9^Whb[i<W_dj";mW:ºI_blW"WdZB_dZi[oMWbj[hi
8*/5&3