CyberKnife® Robotic Radiosurgery System

CyberKnife® Robotic Radiosurgery System
CyberKnife Robotic Radiosurgery System
®
ƒ
Agenda
ƒ Defining radiosurgery
ƒ The right dose to the right place
ƒ The right dose at the right time
ƒ Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ System comparison overview
ƒ Extracranial system utilization
Defining Radiosurgery
Defining Radiosurgery
ƒ
ƒ
Radiosurgery and conventional radiotherapy are often confused
Radiosurgery
Radiotherapy
Description
Focused radiation delivered precisely
to the target sparing surrounding
normal tissue
Large field radiation delivered to the
target and surrounding normal
tissue
Typical Dose Per
Treatment
High dose
Low dose
(~ 6 to 25 Gy per treatment)
(~ 2 Gy per treatment)
Typical Treatment
Duration
1 – 5 treatments
30 – 40 treatments
These differences present specific challenges
ƒ Safe delivery of radiosurgery requires treatment delivery
techniques different than those used for radiotherapy
The right dose to the right place
The right dose to the right place
ƒ
Non-coplanar beam delivery is the proven approach for safe
delivery of radiosurgery
ƒ Demonstrated by more than 30 years of radiosurgical studies
ƒ Enables greater dose conformality
ƒ Enhances rapid dose fall-off
ƒ Reduces potential for critical structure toxicity
The right dose to the right place
ƒ
Intracranial Radiosurgery
Image courtesy of Barrow Neurological Institute
Image courtesy of Google images
CyberKnife® System
Conventional Radiotherapy Systems
208 beam non-coplanar treatment
6 beam coplanar treatment
The right dose to the right place
ƒ
Prostate Radiosurgery
Image courtesy of NCH Regional Cancer Institute
Image courtesy of Google images
CyberKnife® System
Conventional Radiotherapy Systems
130 beam non-coplanar treatment
5 beam coplanar treatment
The right dose to the right place
ƒ
Spine Radiosurgery
Image courtesy of University of Pittsburgh Medical Center
Image courtesy of Google images
CyberKnife® System
Conventional Radiotherapy Systems
103 beam non-coplanar treatment
7 beam coplanar treatment
The right dose to the right place
ƒ
Dose Gradient and Conformality
Ring Gantry System
Conventional Gantry System
Coplanar Radiosurgery Dose Gradient
Varian Novalis Tx™ / Varian Trilogy™ / Elekta
Coplanar Radiosurgery Dose Gradient
Axesse®
Tomotherapy Hi-ART®
Non-Coplanar Radiosurgery Dose Gradient
CyberKnife® Robotic Radiosurgery System
Brown, William T., et al. Image-Guided Robotic Stereotactic Radiosurgery for Treatment of Lung Tumors. Robotic Radiosurgery Volume I. p 255-268.
The right dose to the right place
CyberKnife® Robotic
Radiosurgery System
Conventional
Radiotherapy Systems
Image courtesy of Google images
Ring Gantry
Radiotherapy Systems
Image courtesy of Google images
Image courtesy of Google images
ƒ Robotic mobility enables beam delivery
from a wide array of unique angles
ƒ Motion constrained to clockwise / counterclockwise rotations
ƒ Motion constrained to clockwise /
counter-clockwise rotations
ƒ Typical treatment includes hundreds of
non-coplanar beams delivered in routine
clinical practice
ƒ Non-coplanar delivery creates collision
potential with gantry and imaging system
ƒ Always delivers beams in a single
axial plane
ƒ Almost exclusively delivers 5 to 7 beams in a
single axial plane
The right dose at the right time
The right dose at the right time
ƒ
Tumors and patients can move during treatment delivery – even
when immobilized
ƒ Necessitates continual corrections for intra-fraction target motion
ƒ
Without this capability:
ƒ The risk of missing the target increases
ƒ Sub-optimal outcomes resulting from under-dosing the tumor
ƒ Increased risk of healthy tissue / critical structure toxicity
The right dose at the right time
ƒ
Intracranial Radiosurgery
ƒ Immobilized intracranial targets can shift during treatment delivery
Image courtesy of CIVCO
Murphy MJ, Chang SD, Gibbs IC, Le QT, Hai J, Kim D, Martin DP, Adler JR Jr. Patterns of patient movement
during frameless image-guided radiosurgery.. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2003 Apr 1;55(5):1400-8
The right dose at the right time
ƒ
Prostate Radiosurgery
ƒ The prostate can shift during treatment delivery
Kupelian P, et al. Multi-institutional clinical experience with the Calypso System in localization and continuous, real-time monitoring of the
prostate gland during external radiotherapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2007 Mar 15;67(4):1088-98. Epub 2006 Dec 21
The right dose at the right time
ƒ
Spine Radiosurgery
ƒ Immobilized spine tumors can shift during treatment delivery
Immobilized Spine Intra-Fraction Target Motion
Hoogeman, Mischa, ErasmusMC, Daniel den Hoed cancer Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
The right dose at the right time
ƒ
Intra-Fraction Imaging Capabilities
Immobilized Spine Intra-Fraction Target Motion
Immobilized Spine Intra-Fraction Target Motion
Immobilized Spine Intra-Fraction Target Motion
IGRT / Cone Beam CT
One pre-treatment image and correction
Varian Trilogy™ / Tomotherapy Hi-ART® / Elekta Axesse®
Image Capture
Target Shift Correction
Beam Delivery
Conventional Orthogonal Image Guidance
One image and correction prior to each delivered beam (5-7)
Varian Novalis Tx™
Continual Image Guidance
One image and correction prior to each delivered beam (>100)
CyberKnife® Robotic Radiosurgery System
Hoogeman, Mischa, ErasmusMC, Daniel den Hoed cancer Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
The right dose at the right time
CyberKnife® Robotic
Radiosurgery System
Conventional
Radiotherapy Systems
Image courtesy of Google images
Image courtesy of Google images
Ring Gantry
Radiotherapy Systems
Image courtesy of Google images
ƒ Continual image guidance throughout
the treatment
ƒ kV CBCT image guidance limited to pretreatment set-up
ƒ mV CT image guidance limited to
pre-treatment set-up
ƒ Automatic corrections for intra-fraction
target movement
ƒ All imaging capabilities often disabled
with couch yaw rotations
ƒ Intra-fraction target motion is not
recognized
ƒ Acquires images and corrects beam
delivery approximately every 5-10
seconds of delivered dose
ƒ Intra-fraction target motion is limited
and infrequent - or most often not
recognized
Targeting tumors that
move with respiration
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ
Respiratory-induced motion of
tumors causes significant
targeting uncertainty
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ
Respiratory-induced motion of
tumors causes significant
targeting uncertainty
ƒ
Conventional respiratory
compensation techniques
demand large planning margins
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ
Respiratory-induced motion of
tumors causes significant
targeting uncertainty
ƒ
Conventional respiratory
compensation techniques
demand large planning margins
ƒ Respiratory Gating
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ
Respiratory-induced motion of
tumors causes significant
targeting uncertainty
ƒ
Conventional respiratory
compensation techniques
demand large planning margins
ƒ Respiratory Gating
ƒ Breath Holding
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ
CyberKnife® System
ƒ Dynamically track target motion
throughout the respiratory cycle
ƒ Continual beam delivery while
the patient breathes freely
ƒ Unprecedented targeting accuracy
ƒ 0.75 mm targeting accuracy*
ƒ Significantly smaller planning
margins
ƒ Maximizes surrounding
healthy tissue preservation
* Dietrich S, Taylor D, Chuang C, et al. The CyberKnife Synchrony Respiratory Tracking System: Evaluation of Systematic Targeting
Uncertainty. Synchrony® Respiratory Tracking System clinical accuracy specification of 1.5 mm for moving targets.
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ
Gross Tumor Volume (GTV)
ƒ What the surgeon feels
ƒ
CTV
GTV
Clinical Target Volume (CTV)
ƒ What the pathologist views
ƒ
Planning Target Volume (PTV)
ƒ Margin added to accommodate for
error due to motion compensation /
tracking
CyberKnife® Radiosurgery
PTV
CTV
GTV
aa
Conventional Respiratory
Compensation Techniques
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
ƒ
CyberKnife® Radiosurgery
ƒ Smaller additional margins
to account for targeting errors
ƒ Minimal normal tissue included in target
volume
CTV
GTV
CyberKnife® Radiosurgery
ƒ Reduces risks of potential toxicity
ƒ
Conventional Respiratory Compensation
ƒ Significant margin expansion
to account for targeting errors
ƒ Considerable normal tissue in target
volume
PTV
CTV
GTV
aa
ƒ Increases risks of potential toxicity
Conventional Respiratory
Compensation Techniques
Targeting tumors that move with respiration
Conventional
Radiotherapy Systems
Ring Gantry
Radiotherapy Systems
ƒ Dose delivered continuously
throughout the breathing cycle
ƒ Limited system mobility requires the
beam to repeatedly turn on and off as
the target moves through fixed crosshairs.
ƒ Delivers high doses of radiation to the
entire envelope of target motion –
encompassing both healthy and
cancerous tissues
ƒ Requires 1.5 mm or less CTV to PTV
margin expansion
ƒ Requires 5 to 10 mm CTV to PTV margin
expansion
ƒ Requires 5 to 10 mm CTV to PTV
margin expansion
CyberKnife® Robotic
Radiosurgery System
ƒ Beams move in real-time with 3D
target motion
System Comparison Overview
Delivery System Comparison
CyberKnife® Robotic Radiosurgery
System
Total Targeting
Accuracy
< 1 millimeter for stationary tumors
Applications
Intracranial and Extracranial
Image Guided Radiation Therapy Systems
Conventional Radiation Therapy Systems
(Varian Trilogy™, Elekta Axesse®),
Tomotherapy Hi-ART®))
(Varian Clinac™, Elekta Synergy®)
Dedicated Cobalt 60 Radiosurgery
Systems
3 – 20 millimeters
5 – 20 millimeters
< 1 millimeter
Intracranial and Extracranial
Intracranial and Extracranial
Intracranial only
(Elekta Gamma Knife®))
< 1.5 millimeters for moving tumors
ƒ Limited spine capabilities (Perfexion™
only)
Ability to
Fractionate
Unlimited
Unlimited
Unlimited
Typically limited to a single fraction due to
time, resource and pain constraints
Image Guidance
Continual image guidance throughout the
treatment
Limited to pre-treatment, patient set-up only
Typically limited to MV portal imaging on a
weekly basis
None, relies exclusively on target’s fixed
relative position to the stereotactic frame
ƒ kV or mV cone-beam CT
ƒ Frame mechanical accuracy may introduce
1.2-1.9 mm error*
ƒ High resolution kV imaging
ƒ Automatically track, detect and correct for
tumor and patient movement
Robotic mobility enables a large noncoplanar workspace capable of seamlessly
delivering more than 1200 unique beam
angles without treatment interruption or the
need to manually reposition the patient
Limited clockwise / counter-clockwise gantry
mobility enables a single plane typically
delivering 7 or less unique beam angles
Moving Tumor
Targeting
Delivers tightly contoured beams
synchronized precisely to tumor motion
resulting in minimal healthy tissue exposure
Stereotactic
Frames
No frames required
Non-Coplanar
Delivery
Capabilities
Limited clockwise / counter-clockwise gantry
mobility enables a single plane typically
delivering 7 or less unique beam angles
Hemisphere with fixed collimators enables a
non-coplanar workspace capable of
delivering a maximum of 201 (190
Perfexion™) unique beam angles
Utilizes gating / breath-holding techniques
resulting in large contour margins and
unnecessary healthy tissue exposure
Utilizes gating / breath-holding techniques
resulting in large contour margins and
unnecessary healthy tissue exposure
N/A
Required in most Intracranial & Extracranial
cases
Immobilization devices used. Low dose per
fraction reduces need for accuracy
Requires invasive frames in all cases
ƒ Additional planes can be achieved with
manual couch yaw rotations, however without
image guidance due to patient / OBI collisions resulting in less than ideal targeting accuracy.
Further, the impractical nature of manual
patient positioning has resulted in little or no
clinical adoption
* RJ Maciunas, RL Galloway Jr, JW Latimer. The application accuracy of stereotactic frames. Neurosurgery 35(4): 682–695, Oct 1994
CyberKnife® Robotic Radiosurgery System