Folksociology explains ethnic reasoning better than Folkbiology does!
Cristina Moya1, Joe Henrich2 & Rob Boyd1!
1UCLA Department of Anthropology, UCLA Center for Behavior, Evolution, and Culture!
2University of British Columbia Department of Psychology and Department of Economics!
!"#$%&'()*$+,-.,+$/*01%-.-2"1(.$(#(/3(4-)*$
5-6$6+(*-)")2$(7-&3$,(6"(4-)$")$+3%)"1$26-&/$
'+'7+6*%"/$()#$-3%+6$36("3*8!!
!
"!#$%&'(!$')*+,(&--.!/,0&')1+!23+%(+-*+(!)'2/!4$-2$,&--.!+*/-*+5!+23')4!0,/$6(7!!
"!8/4)&-!-+&,')'0!3&(!9++'!4,):4&-!)'!6,/5$4)'0!9+3&*)/,&-!*&,)&:/'!)'!3$%&'(7!
!-$/+-/.+$3+)#$3-$7+."+,+$"#+)430$"*$
7"-.-2"1(..0$")%+6"3+#8$
Beliefs about the inheritance of identity are culturally
variable
!-$/+-/.+$6+(*-)$#"I+6+)3.0$(7-&3$3%+$2+)+41$
()#$*-1"(.$")%+6"3()1+$-5$36("3*8$
People believe: morphological traits are biologically
inherited; beliefs are socially inherited
9-.:7"-.-2"1(.$1-)*36(")3*$-6$$
9-.:*-1"-.-2"1(.$(#(/3(4-)*8$
"!9-.:7"-.-2"1(.$1-)*36(")3*;!;23')4!0,/$6(!(3&,+!(/%+!(2,$42$,&-!()%)-&,):+(!<)23!9)/-/0)4&-!
(6+4)+(!=)7+7!4&2+0/,.>9&(+5!+'5/0&%.?!5+(4+'2>9&(+5!%+%9+,(3)6@7!A3+,+B/,+?!3$%&'(!4/>
/62+5!,+&(/')'0!&9/$2!9)/-/0)4&-!(6+4)+(!B/,!,+&(/')'0!&9/$2!+23')4!4&2+0/,)+(!=C)->D3)2+!EFFG@7!
A3)(!,+($-2(!)'!/*+,$()'0!9)/-/0)4&-!)'3+,)2&'4+!4/'4+62(!B/,!+23')4!4&2+0/,)+(7!
"!9-.:*-1"-.-2"1(.$(#(/3(4-)*;$8+-+4:/'!B/,!,+&(/')'0!&9/$2!3$%&'!0,/$6(!3&(!6,/5$4+5!
(+6&,&2+!6(.43/-/0)4&-!%+43&')(%(!B/,!,+&(/')'0!&9/$2!(/4)&-!H)'5(!=#),(43B+-5!GIIJ@?!)'4-$5)'0!
+23')4!4&2+0/,)+(7!
US
Perceptions of morphological traits cluster more
than, and separately from, belief traits
5-.:*-1"-.-2"1(.$1-2)"4,+$*0*3+';$
q!9&2!2++23!
9//2(2,&66+5!I\o!4/'^5+'4+!)'2+,*&-($
"!Q+,$*)&'(!9+-)+*+!)5+':2.!)(!-+((!9)/-/0)4&--.!2,&'(%)U+5!23&'!M%+,)4&'(!5/7!!!
!!!"##$%&'(")%*+,%-)*./0%
"!W)X)&'(!9+-)+*+!)5+':2.!)(!%/,+!9)/-/0)4&--.!2,&'(%)U+5!23&'!M%+,)4&'(!5/7!!
!!"##$%&'(")%1*23%-)*.20%
B//5!2&9//!G!
9+-)+B(!
%$()4!6,+B+,+'4+!G!
:0+,(!)'!&B,)4&!
3+&-23!(2,&2+0)+(!G!
/6:%&-!B&%)-.!()1+!G!
H'/p'0!H'/<-+50+!
(H)--(!
0//5!^(3+,!
(+'(+!/B!5),+4:/'!G!
36("3$
<6+,"-&*$=-6:$*&22+*3*$3%(3$6+(*-)")2$(7-&3$3%+$")%+6"3()1+$-5$
*-1"(.$"#+)430$()#$36("3*$+,-.,+#$56-'$5-.:7"-.-20>!
Fijians believe some social identities are more
biologically transmitted than others.
• !K,/((>4$-2$,&-!,+(+&,43!($00+(2(!&5$-2(!&'5!43)-5,+'!+L6+42!(/4)&-!0,/$6!)5+':2.!2/!9+!
9)/-/0)4&--.!)'3+,)2+5!=#),(43B+-5!GIIJ?!C)->D3)2+!EFFG?!9$2!(++!M(2$:!+27!&-7@7!
• !M5$-2(!)'!(+*+,&-!4$-2$,+(!+L6+42!9/5)-.!2,&)2(!&,+!9)/-/0)4&--.!)'3+,)2+5!&'5!9+-)+B(!&,+!(/4)&--.!
)'3+,)2+5!=8/-/%/'!+27!&-7!GIIN?!O&3&-)'03&%!GIIJ?!P-/43!+27!&-7!EFFG@7
V8!
R$)4H!2/!&'0+,!
6+,(/'&-)2.!
B,)+'5-)'+((!
)'2+--)0+'4+!
+.+()032!
+&,!(3&6+!
-)*+,!()1+!
F!
F7G! F7E! F7Z! F7[! F7\! F7N! F7n! F7J! F7I!
/6-/-64-)$-5$/(641"/()3*$1%--*")2$P.":+$7"-.-2"1(.$/(6+)3P$
G!
G7!A,&)2!'/2!$(+5!)'!W)X)!
J-)1.&*"-)*$
• !Q&,:4)6&'2(!)'!23+!V8?!Q+,$?!&'5!W)X)!<+,+!2/-5!&!(2/,.!&9/$2!&!43)-5!<3/(+!6&,+'2(!5)+!)'!
)'B&'4.!&'5!)(!&5/62+5!9.!'/'>H)'!6&,+'2(7!!
• !A3+.!&,+!23+'!&(H+5!<3+23+,!23+!43)-5!<)--!9+!23+!(&%+!&(!23+!9)/-/0)4&-!/,!&5/6:*+!6&,+'2!
&-/'0!23+!B/--/<)'0!5)%+'()/'(Y!!
G@!(/4)&-!4&2+0/,.!%+%9+,(3)6?!E@!%/,63/-/0)4&-!2,&)2(?!Z@!6+,(/'&-)2.?![@!(H)--(?!&'5!\@!9+-)+B(7!
E%+$/(K+6)*$#+*16"7+#$%+6+$(6+$'-6+$1-)*"*3+)3$="3%$($5-.:*-1"-.-2"1(.$3%()$($5-.:7"-.-2"1(.$
'-#+.$-5$%&'()*L$+3%)"1$1(3+2-6"M(4-)$()#$1-)*/+1"N1$/6+#"14-)*>$
@6-&/$A+'7+6*%"/$
• $A3+,+!)(!4,/((>4$-2$,&-!*&,)&:/'!)'!3/<!)5+':2+(!&,+!9+-)+*+5!2/!9+!)'3+,)2+57!
• !`'2,&>4$-2$,&-!*&,)&:/'!)'!3/<!5)S+,+'2!)5+'::+(!&,+!6+,4+)*+5!&(!)'3+,)2+5!%&.!,+d+42!+&(+!
/B!%)0,&:'0!9+2<++'!5)S+,+'2!0,/$6(7!
F"3+*$
!
Q+,$!
(+-^(3!
%/,63/-/0.!
A+3%-#$
E%+$*-1"(.$1(3+2-6"+*$(16-**$=%"1%$3%+$1%".#$=(*$(#-/3+#$,(60$$70$*"3+;$
• !GF;!^4::/$(!,+0)/'&-!4&2+0/,)+(!
• !<+6&;!,&'5/%!&(()0'%+'2!2/!G@!,+0)/'&-!=a)%&!*(7!#$&2&(&')@!/,!E@!-&'0$&0+!=]$+43$&!*(7!
M.%&,&@!4&2+0/,)+(7!
• !9"H";$,&'5/%!&(()0'%+'2!2/!G@!,+0)/'&-!b&:*+!W)X)&'!=c&5&*$!*(7!_&(&<&@!/,!E@!b&:*+!W)X)&'!*(7!
`'5/>W)X)&'!4&2+0/,)+(7
W)X)!
^'0+,!-+'023!
!
<(641"/()3*!!
• $GFY!ZFE!&5$-2!6&,:4)6&'2(!<+,+!,+4,$)2+5!/'-)'+7!
• !<+6&Y![E!&5$-2(!<+,+!,+4,$)2+5!)'!23+!&0,/>6&(2/,&-)(2!2/<'!/B!#$&2&(&')!)'!23+!A):4&4&!P&()'7!
A3)(!2/<'!)(!/'!23+!]$+43$&>M.%&,&!-)'0$)(:4!9/,5+,7!
• $9"H"Y!G[G!&5$-2(!<+,+!,+4,$)2+5!)'!23+!^(3)'0!&'5!3/,:4$-2$,&-!*)--&0+!/B!A+4)!)'!23+!_&(&<&!
`(-&'5!43&)'7!!!
Fiji
9//2(2,&66+5!I\o!4/'^5+'4+!)'2+,*&-($
<6+#"14-)*$#+6",+#$56-'$($5&)14-)(."*3$(11-&)3$-5$($=+..$#+*"2)+#$
?7-&3$@6-&/$A+'7+6*%"/$B)%+6"3()1+$
• !Q+/6-+!<)--!'/2!+L6+42!(/4)&-!0,/$6!%+%9+,(3)6!2/!9+!&4R$),+5!9)/-/0)4&--.7!
• !8/4)&-!)'(:2$:/'(!23&2!&S+42!)%%)0,&:/'?!4$-2$,&-!&(()%)-&:/'?!/,!&4R$),)'0!23+!,)032(!/B!
0,/$6!%+%9+,(3)6!<)--!&S+42!6+,4+6:/'(!/B!)5+':2.!)'3+,)2&'4+7!
?7-&3$B)#","#&(.$C(6"(4-)$")$D3%+6$E6("3*$
• !Q+/6-+!(3/$-5!+L6+42!/23+,(!2/!,+(+%9-+!H)'!&-/'0!3)03-.!3+,)2&9-+!5)%+'()/'(T!
• !!&'5!+L6+42!9+-)+B(!2/!9+!2,&'(%)U+5!23,/$03!(/4)&-!43&''+-(7!!
Peru
82/,.!
I\o!4/'^5+'4+!)'2+,*&-($
"!`'!23+!&5/6:/'!(4+'&,)/!W)X)&'(!9+-)+*+!`'5/W)X)&'(!&,+!-+((!-)H+-.!2/!9+4/%+!
b&:*+!W)X)&'(!&'5!777!
b&:*+!W)X)&'(!B,/%!c&5&*$!&,+!,+-&:*+-.!%/,+!-)H+-.!2/!9+4/%+!_&(&<&'7!!"##$%
&'(")%N,%-)*..N0%
B)%+6"3()1+$-5$-3%+6$/6-/+64+* $$
• !e+(6)2+!5)S+,+'4+(!)'!)5+':2.!)'3+,)2&'4+!9+-)+B(?!6+/6-+!&2!&--!()2+(!9+-)+*+!%/,63/-/0)4&-!
2,&)2(!&,+!9)/-/0)4&--.!2,&'(%)U+5!&'5!9+-)+B(!&,+!(/4)&--.!2,&'(%)U+57!
• !Q&,:4)6&'2(!)'!W)X)!&'5!Q+,$!<+,+!%/,+!-)H+-.!2/!,+(6/'5!23&2!9+-)+B(!<+,+!9)/-/0)4&--.!
2,&'(%)U+5!23&'!6&,:4)6&'2(!)'!23+!V87!!
O+5+6+)1+*!
• !M(2$:?!f7?!K&,+.?!87!g!8/-/%/'?!C7!EFF[*%4"5$6&'756$%"5%8"589-6:';%#9<9;"-=956%>%'%8'$9%$6:#?%"@%6A9%'8B:7$7("5%%"@%@";CD7";"E78';%'5#%@";C$"87";"E78';%C5"F;9#E9%
75%G'#'E'$8'&*!B/,5Y!P-&4H<+--7%
• !P-/43?!O7?!8/-/%/'?!C7!g!K&,+.?!87!EFFG!h&^%&'),.Y!M'!$'5+,(2&'5)'0!/B!<3&2!)(!6&((+5!/'!B,/%!6&,+'2(!2/!43)-5,+'7!M!4,/((>4$-2$,&-!)'*+(:0&:/'7!H":&5';%"@%
4"E57("5%'5#%4:;6:&9!G?![Z>NJ7!
• !C)->D3)2+?!W7!=EFFG@7!M,+!;23')4!C,/$6(!P)/-/0)4&-!i86+4)+(i!2/!23+!#$%&'!P,&)'j!;((+':&-)(%!)'!k$,!K/0'):/'!/B!8/%+!8/4)&-!K&2+0/,)+(7!4:&&956%I56A&"-";"E?3%1/
=[@?!\G\>\\[7!
• !#),(43B+-5?!a7!M7!=GIIJ@7!J'89%75%6A9%='C75E%>%8"E57("53%8:;6:&93%'5#%6A9%8A7;#K$%8"5$6&:8("5%"@%A:='5%C75#$7!K&%9,)50+?!O&((7!l!a/'5/'?!;'0-&'5Y!O`A!Q,+((7!
• !O&3&-)'0&%?!f7!=GIIJ@7!L$$95(';7$=3%-"F9&3%'5#%&9-&9$956'("5%"@%8'$69>%I%#9<9;"-=956';%$6:#?7!V'6$9-)(3+5!5/42/,&-!5)((+,2&:/'?!V')*+,()2.!/B!Q)U(9$,037!
• !8/-/%/'?!C7!;7!M7?!m/3'(/'?!87!K7?!h&)243)H?!e7?!g!K&,+.?!87!=GIIN@7!a)H+!B&23+,?!-)H+!(/'Y!_/$'0!43)-5,+'i(!$'5+,(2&'5)'0!/B!3/<!&'5!<3.!/S(6,)'0!,+(+%9-+!23+),!
6&,+'2(7!4A7;#%M9<9;"-=9563%NO=G@?!G\G>GnG7
!