Nutrition and Weight Management Unit 9 – Energy balance Lesson 9.2 – Calculating energy expenditure Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Step 1 - Lesson objectives In this lesson we’re going to find out how to calculate and analyse a client's activity levels. This lesson will enable you to: Calculate energy expenditure and understand why this is necessary Understand the different factors that contribute to total energy expenditure Calculate basal metabolic rate Identify the methods available to gather information on energy expenditure Analyse a client’s activity diary and estimate their total energy needs from the diary Estimate the energy needs of a client using BMR and PAL This lesson involves some calculations, so you may find it useful to have a calculator handy as you complete the lesson. Step 2 - Introduction During this lesson you’ll see how to calculate Phil and Lizzie’s basal metabolic rate (BMR) per hour or 'calculated hourly rate'. You’ll then need to calculate the number of kcal they used during each activity on their activity diaries using a physical activity ratio (PAR) value. PAR values and BMR help you to calculate the energy (kcal) used for different activities. You can also use physical activity level (PAL) tables from Report 41 to help you estimate their daily kcal expenditure and energy needs in a day. It will also be important to consider ways of increasing their energy expenditure with small changes in general physical activity. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 1 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Step 3 - Components of energy expenditure As a Nutrition and Weight Management Advisor you’ll need to give your clients accurate and reliable nutrition advice as well as be able to analyse their activity levels. This will help you to consider both sides of the energy balance equation: energy intake versus energy expenditure. There are three components to energy expenditure: Basal metabolic rate Thermogenesis Physical activity Each of these factors has a different contribution to the total calories a person uses. The energy expenditure side of the energy balance equations can therefore be written as follows: Energy expenditure = Basal metabolic rate + thermogenesis + physical activity Step 4 - Basal metabolic rate Basal metabolic rate or BMR is the energy required to maintain the body's normal function. It will vary depending on your client’s gender, weight and age. In order to calculate your client’s energy expenditure you first need to calculate their BMR. Maintaining BMR BMR is a measure of how much energy is expended by an individual who is at rest. It contributes around 75% of the total energy expenditure and is determined in part by the amount of lean tissue (muscle) in the body. The more lean tissue your client has then the higher their BMR is likely to be. This is why it is so important for clients to maintain muscle as much as possible to ensure they maintain a significant BMR. Where muscle is lost, for example during extreme starvation diets, then BMR will drop. This would ultimately mean a lower kcal requirement. Measuring BMR BMR can only accurately be measured in a laboratory using specialised equipment. Obviously this is not feasible to undertake with your clients, so you will need to use an indirect calculation of BMR that will give you an estimated value. Estimating BMR You can estimate your client’s BMR as long as you know their body weight in either lbs or kilograms. Bear in mind that this is only an estimation. The method used to estimate BMR in kcal of the average healthy adult man and woman is the Schofield equation which takes into account your client’s age, weight and gender. The equations are very accurate for the average adult. However, they do not take into account body composition and may therefore slightly underestimate the kcal needs of the very lean and muscular clients. They may also overestimate the kcal needs of the very obese. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 2 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Step 5 - The Schofield Equation The Schofield equations vary with differences in gender and age groups. Each equation provides an approximate figure for how many kcal your client may use in a 24-hour period at rest. If your client is a 27 year old man who weighs 84 kg then the equation you would use to calculate his BMR is: 15.1 x W + 692 Since his weight is 84 kg the equation can be rewritten as: 15.1 x 84 + 692 1268.4 + 692 = 1960.4 kcal/day The clients estimated BMR before any activity is therefore 1,960 kcal/day. Step 6 - Phil’s BMR Let’s now see if you can calculate Phil’s BMR. Phil is 52 years old and weighs 92.5 kg. Use the table to calculate how many kcal/day Phil may use before any activity. 1,613 kcal/day 1,800 kcal/day 1,842 kcal/day 1,961 kcal/day Feedback: Phil’s estimated BMR before any activity is 1,937 kcal/day. As Phil is aged 52 and male, we use 11.5 x W + 873 for BMR male. His weight is 92.5 kg, so if we put that into the Schofield equation we get: 11.5 x 92.5 + 873 1,063.8 + 873 = 1,937 kcal/day Step 7 - Lizzie’s BMR Now try calculating Lizzie’s BMR. Lizzie is 29 years old and weighs 63 kg. Use the table to calculate how many kcal/day Lizzie may use before any activity. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 3 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure 1,369 kcal/day 1,491 cal/day 1,613 kcal/day 1,778 kcal/day Feedback: Lizzie’s estimated BMR before any activity is 1,419 kcal/day. As Lizzie is aged 29 and female, we use 14.8 x W + 487 for BMR. Her weight is 63 kg, so if we put that into the Schofield equation we get: 14.8 x 63 + 487 932.4 + 487 = 1,419 kcal/day Step 8 - Factors that affect BMR When you have calculated BMR for a range of clients you will notice that BMR tends to decline with age. Your clients gradually lose lean tissue (muscle) with increased age unless they do activities that maintain or improve muscle. You’ll also note that women have a lower BMR than men of the same age and weight. This is due to men tending to have greater lean tissue compared to women. The greater the weight your client carries, the higher their BMR will be as the body has to work harder to carry the additional weight around. Step 9 - Thermogenesis Let’s return to our energy expenditure equation. Energy expenditure = Basal metabolic rate + thermogenesis + physical activity Having looked at BMR the next part of the energy expenditure equation that you’ll need to consider is thermogenesis. What is thermogenesis? Thermogenesis means the creation of heat, when the core temperature of the body is increased. It is defined as the generation or production of heat or the burning of kcal, through physiological processes. In other words it’s the process in which the body raises its temperature or energy output. What causes thermogenesis? Thermogenesis occurs when the body undergoes any physiological process. This can range from the digestion of food right up to undertaking physical activity. The triggers can be from eating a meal, be work induced or as a result of exercising. It is necessary for our muscles to create heat because warm muscles work much more effectively than cold muscles. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 4 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Can thermogenesis be measured? The thermogenesis of some physiological processes can only be measured in a laboratory. These processes are called spontaneous physical activity (SPA) and create what’s called non-exercise activity thermogenesis (or NEAT). They include things such as fidgeting, rubbing your eyes, and other involuntary movements that tend to occur ‘spontaneously’ without us really being aware of them. How much do SPA activities contribute to the total kcal burned in a day? Spontaneous physical activity or SPA types of movements only account for approximately 5% of the total kilocalories burned in a day. For the purpose of estimating total energy expenditure we will not take these into account. What we do need to take into account is the thermogenesis created by physical activity, which we will look at on the next step. Step 10 - Physical activity Energy expenditure = Basal metabolic rate + thermogenesis + physical activity The final part of the energy expenditure equation is physical activity, which can be measured. This is also the factor that you are most able to influence. The more activity your clients do, the more energy they will use. Bear in mind that physical activity in this instance is all activity, including eating and driving - in other words, everything your client does on a daily basis. Step 11 - Recording physical activity Let’s see how you can get your client to record their physical activity. Methods of measuring To determine how much energy your client uses during physical activity, it is important that you have a record of what they actually do on a daily basis. The common methods for measuring this are: Physical activity diary Physical activity recall Pedometers Heart rate monitors Physical activity diary Get your client to write down every activity they do and how long they do it for. They should carry the diary with them throughout the day. Tracking should include any exercise or walking as well as prep activities, eating or work as well as what they are doing during periods of inactivity such as watching television. When you get your clients to fill in the activity diary they should record the time spent to the nearest 15 minutes. So 15 minutes will be 0.25 hours, 30 minutes will be 0.5 hours and 45 minutes will be 0.75 hours. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 5 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Physical activity recall Physical activity recall is similar to the physical activity diary except you ask the client to recall to you what they did over the last 24 hours or 1-2 days. Since this approach relies heavily on memory it can give you less accurate information than an actual activity diary. Pedometers Pedometers measure the number of steps that your client walks. A mile is about 2,000 steps. This is great for getting an idea of how generally active a person is with very little input from the client. They simply have to ensure they wear the device accurately and record the number of steps at the end of the day. Some models will allow you to estimate how far the person has travelled as well as the number of steps. Pedometers are a good motivational tool but you will be unaware of the intensity of the activity and the kcal your client will have used. Heart rate monitors Heart rate monitors help provide an insight into the intensity of an activity. A chest belt detects your client’s heart rate and transmits it to a wristwatch receiver. It provides an accurate reflection of how hard they're exercising. Some heart rate monitors may calculate the kcal used based on a person's weight. Heart rate monitors are not always practical to use all the time and the more complex hightech types can be expensive. Step 12 - Phil’s physical activity diary Take a good look at Phil’s activity diary that Tanya has asked him to fill in. When working with your clients, in order to get more accurate results use 2 methods in conjunction with each other. You could combine a physical activity diary with a 24hour recall. Make sure the column 'Hours spent in activity' adds up to 24 hours. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 6 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Step 13 - Calculating the kcal used for each activity Tanya needs to calculate the kcal used for each activity that is listed on the activity diary. First, Tanya needs to convert Phil’s information into the number of kcal expended (energy expenditure). She needs to calculate the BMR as an hourly rate (known as 'calculated hourly rate'). This is simply the client’s BMR divided by 24. You may recall Phil’s BMR is 1,937 kcal per day. 1,937 ÷ 24 = 80.7 or rounded to the nearest whole number is a BMR hourly rate of 81. Step 14 - Knowledge check Lizzie’s BMR is 1,419 kcal/day. What is her hourly BMR rounded to the nearest whole number? 19 42 59 67 Feedback: Lizzie’s BMR hourly rate is 59. (1,419 ÷ 24 = 59.1) Step 15 - Physical activity ratios Now that you have calculated the hourly BMR, you need to calculate the number of kcal used by your client during each activity in the activity diary. To do this, you need to use something called a physical activity ratio (PAR). So what are physical activity ratios? Physical activity ratios or PAR summarise the relative intensity of everyday and common activities. Sleep has a PAR value of 1.0 and all activities are relative to this. The more intense your client’s activities are, the greater the PAR value. The PAR values are summarised in tables and are put together from the results of many studies that specifically looked to find out the relative intensities of activities. Where can I get hold of the physical activity ratios tables? Physical activity ratio tables can all be found in Report 41 at annex 3 and 4. These tables can also be downloaded from Resources (PAR activity analysis handout). You will need to view these tables to help you with the calculations in the following steps. How do PARs work? PARs are put into categories and each category is the average of a range. For estimated calculations you only need to use the PAR average given. For example, for the activity 'standing ironing', you could use PAR 1.6, which is the same as 'sitting sewing'. Some occupations are also classified into PARs and therefore March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 7 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure these can also be used as a guideline and included in the calculation for overall calorific needs. Step 16 - PAR tables PAR 1.2 (1.0-1.4) Lying at rest Sitting at rest Reading Watching TV, reading, writing, calculating, playing cards, listening to radio, eating Standing at rest PAR 1.6 (1.5-1.8) Sitting Standing PAR 2.1 (1.9-2.4) Standing PAR 2.8 (2.5-3.3) Standing beds Walking March 2015 Sewing, knitting, playing piano, driving Preparing vegetables, washing dishes, ironing, general office and laboratory work Mixed household chores (dusting and cleaning), washing small clothes, cooking activities, hairdressing, playing snooker, bowling Dressing and undressing, showering, ‘hoovering’, making 3-4km/h, playing cricket © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 8 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Industrial PAR 3.7 (3.4-4.4) Standing Walking Industrial Tailoring, shoemaking, electrical, machine tool, painting and decorating Mopping floor, gardening, cleaning windows, playing table tennis, sailing 4-6km/h, golf Motor vehicle repairs, carpentry, chemical, joinery, bricklaying PAR 4.8 (4.5-5.9) Standing Polishing furniture, chopping wood, heavy gardening, volleyball Walking 6-7km/h Exercise Dancing, moderate swimming, gentle cycling, slow jogging Occupational Labouring, hoeing, road construction, digging and shovelling, felling trees PAR 6.9 (6.0-7.9) Walking Exercise Sports Uphill with load or cross country, climbing stairs Average jogging, cycling Football, more energetic swimming, tennis, skiing This chart provides the PAR of most common activities. If you cannot find the activity you want then you have to select an activity that you think is roughly the same intensity. Use the occupation PARs as a guideline for calculating overall kcal needs. PAR 1.2 (1.0-1.4) Lying at rest Reading Sitting at rest Watching TV, reading, writing, calculating, playing cards, listening to radio, eating Standing at rest PAR 1.6 (1.5-1.8) Sitting Sewing, knitting, playing piano, driving Standing Preparing vegetables, washing dishes, ironing, general office and laboratory work PAR 2.1 (1.9-2.4) Standing Mixed household chores (dusting and cleaning), washing small clothes, cooking activities, hairdressing, playing snooker, bowling PAR 2.8 (2.5-3.3) Standing Dressing and undressing, showering, ‘hoovering’, making beds Walking 3-4km/h, playing cricket Industrial Tailoring, shoemaking, electrical, machine tool, painting and decorating PAR 3.7 (3.4-4.4) March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 9 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Standing Mopping floor, gardening, cleaning windows, playing table tennis, sailing Walking 4-6km/h, golf Industrial Motor vehicle repairs, carpentry, chemical, joinery, bricklaying PAR 4.8 (4.5-5.9) Standing Polishing furniture, chopping wood, heavy gardening, volleyball Walking 6-7km/h Exercise Dancing, moderate swimming, gentle cycling, slow jogging Occupational Labouring, hoeing, road construction, digging and shovelling, felling trees PAR 6.9 (6.0-7.9) Walking Uphill with load or cross country, climbing stairs Exercise Average jogging, cycling Sports Football, more energetic swimming, tennis, skiing Light occupations PAR = 1.7 Professional and technical workers, administrative and managerial, sales representatives, clerical and related workers, housewives, unemployed. Moderate occupations PAR = 2.7 in men and 2.2 in women Sales workers, service workers, domestic helpers, students, transport workers, some construction workers such as joiners, roofing workers. Heavy occupations PAR = 3.0 in men and 2.3 in women Equipment operators, labourers, agricultural such as animal husbandry, forestry and fishing, some construction workers such as bricklayers masons. Step 17 - Using PARs March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 10 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Let's now return to Phil’s activity diary. As you can see, Tanya has filled in the PAR values for each activity. You can check these using the PAR tables from Resources. Now that Tanya has the PAR values she can calculate the number of kcal Phil uses undertaking each activity. Step 18 - Calculating kcal used With the PAR values for each activity Tanya can now calculate the number of kcal Phil used undertaking each activity. To do this she used the equation shown above. You may recall that Phil, who weighs 92.5 kg, has an hourly BMR of 81 kcal. In Phil’s diary he noted that he spends 8 of his 24 hours asleep. Let’s calculate the number of kcal he uses whilst sleeping. The equation above can be rewritten as: 81 (Hourly BMR) x 1.0 (PAR activity value) x 8 (No. of hours) = 648 kcal So Phil uses 648 kcal just being asleep! Step 19 - Knowledge check Use the PAR tables to find out to the nearest whole number how many kcal Phil uses walking to lunch. 45 58 75 92 Feedback: Phil used 75 kcal walking to lunch. The equation used is 81 (Hourly BMR) x 3.7 (PAR value for that activity) x 0.25 (hours spent in activity). March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 11 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Step 20 - Calculating kcal used Phil’s total kcal expenditure for the day shown in his diary is 2,966 kcal. This is just one day and his energy expenditure will vary from day to day. It’s therefore important to get a mean average of a number of days, including weekend days. Total kcal used Phil’s energy expenditure of 2,966 kcal is higher than what the Government recommends is adequate for the average healthy adult. Phil, at a BMI of 32, is not considered 'the average healthy male' for his age. It is essential to remember that many of the clients you will be dealing with are not always 'average'. BMR and weight The heavier a person is at a set age and gender, the higher the BMR, and the higher the hourly rate the BMR will be. This means there will be a higher energy cost to that client for every activity. That's why the more obese or heavier they are, the more energy they use doing any activity. Step 21 - Estimating energy needs using PAL You now know how to go about making an estimation of a client’s total energy expenditure using an activity diary. There is also a second simpler method you can use which does not require an activity diary. This involves calculating the client’s BMR and then assigning the client a PAL value based on what they tell you about their job and leisure activities. A table of PAL values can be found in Report 41. Occupational and non occupational activity This table is from Report 41 and shows 3 levels of occupational activity (work) and 3 levels of non- occupational activity (leisure time activity). Non-occupational activity is classified as either non-active (or sedentary), moderately active or very active. Occupational activity is classified as light, moderate or heavy. By classifying your client’s occupational and non-occupational activity the table will provide you with what is called a physical activity level or PAL for a typical day. Occupational classification If you are not sure which occupational category your client falls into you can use the classification in these occupational PAR tables to decide what category best applies to your client. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 12 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Lizzie’s PAL Lizzie works in an office at home. This is sedentary work for the most part designing and carrying out administrative work. Tanya categorises her activity level for her job as 'light'. In Tanya’s initial consultation with Lizzie she found out that Lizzie did very little activity in her leisure time. Tanya therefore categorised Lizzie’s non- occupational activity as 'non-active'. Using this information you can see that the overall PAL for Lizzie is 1.4. Step 22 - Knowledge check Another client of Tanya’s is Pete, who is a tree surgeon. He has been training for triathlons. What do you think his correct PAL would be? 1.4 1.6 1.7 1.9 Feedback: Pete has a PAL of 1.9. His occupational activity as a tree surgeon would be classed as 'heavy' since it is a manual based job. Since he also trains for triathlons, his non-occupational activity would be classified as 'very active'. Knowledge check Once you have the PAL and have calculated the BMR using the Schofield Equation you can now estimate the total energy needs of the client as follows: Estimated energy needs = BMR x PAL Let's consider Phil’s activity again. From his activity diary it is clear that he is engaged in sedentary work. He is not very active in his leisure time but does manage to walk for a total of 1 hour each day. What are his overall estimated energy needs? Feedback: Phil’s estimated energy needs is 2,906 kcal. In his leisure time Phil would be classed as moderately active so his PAL would be 1.5. His overall estimated energy needs using this method can be calculated by multiplying 1.5 by his daily BMR: 1,937 x 1.5 = 2,906 kcal. If you recall from the calculations you did to estimate his energy needs using the activity diary and PAR values, you found that his energy expenditure was 2,966 kcal. By using the PAL method you arrive at a similar value. Remember no method is 100% accurate. They are both estimations but the fact that they have provided similar answers suggest that they are reasonably accurate. They do have similar values. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 13 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure Knowledge check Let's also consider Lizzie’s activity again. As you may recall Lizzie is 29 years old and weighs 63 kg. She has a sedentary job and does no activity in her leisure time. What is her overall estimated energy needs? Feedback: For Lizzie we use the equation 14.8 x 63 kg + 487 so her BMR is 1,419 kcal. Her PAL would be 1.4 as her occupational activity is light, and she does no activity in her leisure time. Her estimated energy needs = BMR x PAL. So we calculate 1.4 x 1,419 which equals 1,986.6 and rounded to the nearest number is 1,987 kcal. Step 23 - Increasing Phil’s activity levels Tanya is keen that Phil increases his daily activity levels if he wants to lose weight. She has made some recommendations to help increase his energy expenditure. Recommendation 1 - After dinner Phil should exchange half an hour of watching TV for half an hour of housework or playing football with his children. Recommendation 2 - Phil should try taking the stairs at work instead of the lift and walk rather than drive to the local shops whenever he can. Recommendation 3 - Phil should not remain seated at his desk hour after hour but get up regularly to get a glass of water or talk to a colleague, rather than sending an email. Recommendation 4 - As time is limited during the week, Phil should try to plan in a family activity at the weekends, such as going cycling or swimming with his children. Recommendation 5 - Tanya has given Phil a pedometer and asks him to aim for 5,000 steps a day as the average number of steps a sedentary office worker walks can be as little as 2,000 steps a day. Recommendation 6 - As Tanya continues to work with Phil she hopes that he can gradually increase his steps closer to the daily target for health benefits of 10,000 a day. A handout with more ideas you can give clients on being more active is available from Resources. Step 24 - Recap Take a moment to recap the key learning points in this lesson. Energy expenditure There are 3 components of energy expenditure: Basal metabolic rate (BMR) Thermogenesis Physical activity March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 14 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure BMR Basal metabolic rate is the largest contributor of these, contributing up to 75% of a person's total kcal expenditure. The Schofield Equation The Schofield Equation is a method used to estimate the BMR in kcal of the average healthy adult man and woman. These equations vary to take into account an individual’s age, weight and gender. Thermogenesis Thermogenesis is the generation or production of heat or the burning of calories, through physiological processes such as the digestion of food right up to undertaking physical activity. Measuring physical activity Physical activity is measurable and is the factor you can influence most in terms of how much energy you use. It can be measured by: Physical activity diaries 24 hour physical activity recalls Pedometers Heart rate monitors Calculating energy expenditure In order to calculate a client's energy expenditure from an activity diary you need to calculate: BMR as an hourly rate (known as 'calculated hourly rate') The kilocalories used for each activity, as shown on the activity diary PAR Physical activity ratios (PAR) can be used to calculate the kcal used for each activity in the activity diary. PARs summarise the relative intensity of everyday and common activities and can all be found in Report 41. Overall energy expenditure If you do not have an activity diary for your client you still need to calculate their BMR. You can estimate their overall activity levels based on what they tell you about their job and leisure activities. You can then use this information and the PAL tables in Report 41 to estimate the overall energy expenditure (BMR x PAL). Increasing activity Finding ways of exchanging currently sedentary activities with more active ones will help increase energy expenditure. Step 25 - Lesson assessment 1. What is the PAR value of sleep? March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 15 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure 1 2 2.4 3 3.5 2. Is the following statement accurate? The Schofield equation may overestimate BMR in those who are obese. 3. What contribution to total energy expenditure does BMR make? 25% 50% 65% 75% 4. Is the following statement accurate? A heart rate monitor gives no insight into exercise intensity. 5. As weight increases and all other factors being equal what happens to BMR? It decreases It increases It stays the same Step 26 - Lesson summary Now that you have completed this lesson, you’ll be able to: Explain that BMR contributes three quarters of your client’s kcal expenditure and is calculated using a Schofield equation Inform clients that their physical activity can be measured using a diary, recalls, pedometers and heart rate monitors Use PAR tables to calculate energy expenditure for various activities Estimate your clients’ overall energy expenditure by multiplying their BMR by PAL Advise clients of ways to improve their physical activity levels In the next lesson you’ll look at how to establish a client's dietary energy intake. March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 16 of 17 Nutrition and Weight Management Lesson 9.2 Calculating energy expenditure March 2015 © Future Fit Training, 2015 Page 17 of 17
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz