Vitamin D and falls: what you need to know

TOPIC
1O
Topics
in reducing harm from falls
7
Vitamin D and falls:
what you need to know
International falls prevention guidelines recommend
vitamin D supplements to reduce falls in older
people, particularly those at higher risk of falling.
Recommendations for preventing fractures by taking
calcium and vitamin D supplements, either used
alone or together, are not consistent, and taking
calcium supplements has been highlighted recently
as increasing cardiovascular risk in older people.
Topic 7 presents the current complex evidence base and expert opinion
on the safety and efficacy of vitamin D and calcium supplements in
preventing harm from falls in older people in New Zealand. Our aim is
to support health professionals in giving consumers clear and consistent
messages, and for this reason Topic 7’s required reading includes a
consensus statement, consumer information and prescribing advice
developed in New Zealand. Note that conclusions from the evidence
presented here may change and the guidelines mentioned will be
updated as the results of new clinical trials are published.
The roles of vitamin D
and calcium
Vitamin D plays an important role in building and
maintaining healthy bones and teeth through facilitating
intestinal calcium absorption. It is also needed for joint,
muscle and neurological function. There are two main
forms of vitamin D:
• vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) is the form synthesised in
the skin from 7-dehydrocholesterol after exposure to
sunlight – the main source of vitamin D.
• vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol) is the form available in a
few naturally occurring food sources or manufactured
and added to foods.
Calcium helps form and maintain healthy teeth and
bones. Around 99 percent of total body calcium is
found as calcium hydroxyapatite (Ca10[PO4]6[OH]2) in
bones and teeth, where it provides these hard tissues
with strength.1 Even though
only 1 percent of calcium in the
body is found outside of bone,
this form of calcium is critical
for many functions including
muscle function.1 Calcium is
not manufactured in the body,
therefore is an essential dietary
nutrient.
Vitamin D and calcium are essential
for good health
Vitamin D and calcium interact to suppress bone turnover, so that
during vitamin D deficiency states, bone metabolism is significantly
affected. It is important to maintain adequate vitamin D levels all year
round.2 Low levels have been associated with reduced bone mineral
density, high bone turnover and increased risk of hip fracture.3 Vitamin
D deficiency may cause muscular impairment even before adverse
effects on bone occur.4
Proper levels of calcium over a lifetime can help prevent osteoporosis,
however, as we age the balance between continuous bone resorption
and deposition of calcium changes.1 In older people bone breakdown
exceeds formation, resulting in bone loss that increases the risk of
osteoporosis over time.
Calcium and vitamin D in the diet
Both men and women need enough calcium in their diet to offset
bone loss with age. While a diet high in calcium cannot reverse agerelated bone loss, it can slow down the process.
Calcium is available in food and should be part of a balanced diet.
Dairy products – milk, yogurt, and cheese – are rich sources of calcium,
providing the major share of calcium from foods. At least three servings
per day are needed to achieve the daily intake recommended by
the US Institute of Medicine for those aged ≥70 years of 1200 mg
and the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council
of 1300 mg.1, 5 However, the evidence base underpinning these
recommendations is not robust6 and this intake is usually difficult
to achieve.
Some foods contain small amounts of vitamin D, for example, oily fish
such as salmon and tuna, milk and milk products, eggs and liver, and
some food products have vitamin D added. However, most adults are
likely to obtain only 5 to 10 percent of their vitamin D requirement
from food.3
Continued over
National
Patient
Safety
Campaign
2
Vitamin D supplementation and falls
Sunshine is the primary
source of vitamin D
For those who are deficient in vitamin D and unable to increase their
exposure to direct sunlight, supplements can be prescribed as a course
of tablets or intramuscular injection. Studies have shown that vitamin
D supplementation improves neuromuscular and psychomotor
performance in older people living in the community and in agerelated residential care facilities.10 This mechanism explains why vitamin
D supplements may prevent falls.
Health messages about sun exposure are conflicting
because ultraviolet B rays in sunshine on exposed skin are
the main source of vitamin D, whereas ultraviolet A rays in
sunshine cause skin damage.
Healthy adults who are ‘out and
about’ and physically active
Older people may
outdoors are unlikely to lack
not absorb enough
vitamin D.2 Being outside in the
vitamin D from
early morning or late afternoon
sunshine.
in summer (6 to 7 minutes) and
around noon in the winter (7 to 40
minutes, depending on geographic
region), with face, arms and hands
in the sun is recommended.2, 5 However, older people have
thinner skin than younger adults and this may mean they
can’t produce sufficient vitamin D.
A recent Cochrane review of falls prevention
interventions in care facilities and hospitals
reported evidence from five randomised
controlled trials that included 4603 residents in
age-related care facilities.11 Those randomised
to vitamin D supplements alone or with
calcium supplements had 37 percent fewer
falls compared with control groups taking a
placebo or calcium supplements alone.
From the Cochrane review of falls prevention interventions in
older people living in the community that pooled trials of vitamin
D supplements alone or with calcium supplements, overall, vitamin
D supplements did not reduce falls (seven trials, 9324 participants).12
However, there was a reduction of 30 percent in the risk of falling in
the subgroup of trials only recruiting participants with lower vitamin
D levels at enrolment (mean levels below 55 nmol/L, four trials, 804
participants).
It is important to be ‘SunSmart’ (cover up with clothing, use
a broad spectrum SPF30+ sunscreen, and wear a hat and
sunglasses) at any time of the year when outside in the
mountains or near shiny surfaces such as water and sand. Sun
beds increase the risk of melanoma and other types of skin
cancer.2 Sunshine through glass should be avoided because
glass allows through the harmful ultraviolet A rays and not
the beneficial ultraviolet B rays.
Results from other meta-analyses suggest that the effect on falls from
adding calcium to vitamin D supplements is more marked than with
vitamin D supplements alone, but this remains uncertain.13
Several groups are at risk of low vitamin D levels yearround because they do not absorb enough vitamin D from
sunshine:2
• people who can’t move about easily, who are frail, or are
housebound
• people with very dark skin
• people who wear veils and full-body-coverage clothing
• people who must avoid sun exposure because they have
had skin cancer or are on certain medications.
The US Preventive Services Task Force concluded that vitamin D
supplements can reduce falls in adults aged ≥65 years who are at
increased risk of falls, probably by improving muscle strength and
balance.14 The potential harms were “no greater than small”, although
not many trials reported adverse events. The guidelines from the
American Geriatrics Society and British Geriatrics Society Panel
on Falls Prevention in Older People also recommend vitamin D
supplementation should be considered for people with suspected
vitamin D deficiency or who are otherwise at increased risk of falls.15
People who live in the southern regions (West Coast,
Canterbury, Otago and Southland) and spend little time
outdoors in the middle of the day,2 and those who are obese,7
may also be lacking enough vitamin D.
Is a blood test for vitamin D level
necessary?
The major form of vitamin D circulating in the blood is
25-hydroxyvitamin D. Serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels ≥50 nmol/L
are considered prudent, below 25 nmol/L deficient, and levels >125
nmol/L could have potentially adverse effects.2
Treatment of vitamin D deficiency
Vitamin D supplements should only be prescribed to people at risk
of vitamin D deficiency and people with low serum levels, when they
are unable to increase their exposure to direct sunlight and unable to
modify their diet to include more vitamin D-rich foods.8
When vitamin D is obtained on prescription the prescriber will
review the person’s clinical history, since contraindications include
hypercalcaemia, renal function impairment, atherosclerosis or cardiac
function impairment, and sarcoidosis.2 Buying over-the-counter vitamin
D tablets or multivitamins containing vitamin D is not recommended.
ACC information sheets provide vitamin D prescribing advice
for general practice teams and pharmacists. Three case studies
demonstrate interdisciplinary approaches to increase vitamin D
prescribing rates in New Zealand residential care facilities.
Evidence suggests an increasing tendency to over-test the population,
resulting in unnecessary expenditure.16 In Australia the cost of testing
for vitamin D increased from $1.0 million in 2000 to $96.7 million in
2010, an average increase of approximately 59 percent per year.
Vitamin D deficiency can be assumed for the following groups and
a blood test is not necessary: those who are housebound, require
support services, are resident in an age-related care facility, frail, dark
skinned or obese.8
continued over
REFERENCES
In New Zealand, the standard PHARMAC-subsidised form for vitamin D
deficiency is the 50,000 IU (1.25 mg) vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) tablet.
The dose prescribed for older people is two tablets (2.5 mg) in the first
month, then continue with one tablet (1.25 mg) per month.8
A recent Australian trial, where the annual dose of 500,000 IU of vitamin
D2 was given in a single mega-dose (10 x 1.25 mg tablets), showed
an increased risk in falls and fractures.9 Overdose is very unlikely with
monthly dosing.
Vitamin D
supplements
reduce falls in
residents of
care facilities.
1. Institute of Medicine (US) Committee to Review Dietary Reference Intakes for Vitamin D
and Calcium. 2011. Dietary reference intakes for calcium and vitamin D. Ross AC, Taylor CL,
Yaktine AL et al (eds). Washington DC: National Academies Press (US). URL: http://www.
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK56070/pdf/TOC.pdf (accessed 20 September 2013).
2. Ministry of Health and Cancer Society of New Zealand. 2012. Consensus statement on
vitamin D and sun exposure in New Zealand. Wellington: Ministry of Health. URL: http://
www.health.govt.nz).
3. Nowson CA, McGrath JJ, Ebeling PR et al. 2012. Vitamin D and health in adults in Australia
and New Zealand: a position statement. Medical Journal of Australia 196(11): 686–7.
4. Glerup H, Mikkelsen K, Poulsen L et al. 2000. Hypovitaminosis D myopathy without
biochemical signs of osteomalacic bone involvement. Calcified Tissue International 66(6):
419–24.
5. Ebeling PR, Daly RM, Kerr DA et al. 2013. Building healthy bones throughout life: an
evidence-informed strategy to prevent osteoporosis in Australia. Medical Journal of
Australia Open 2 Suppl 1: 1.
6. Reid IR, Avenell A. 2011. Evidence-based policy on dietary calcium and vitamin D. Journal
of Bone and Mineral Research 26(3): 452–4.
7. Earthman CP, Beckman LM, Masodkar K et al. 2012. The link between obesity and low
circulating 25-hydroxyvitamin D concentrations: considerations and implications.
International Journal of Obesity 36(3): 387–96.
8. BPAC. 2011. Vitamin D supplementation: navigating the debate. Best Practice Journal 36:
26–35.
9. Sanders KM, Stuart AL, Williamson EJ et al. 2010. Annual high-dose oral vitamin D and falls
and fractures in older women: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 303(18): 1815–22.
3
Vitamin D plus calcium supplements
Recommendations for the use of calcium and vitamin D supplements
for preventing fractures are inconsistent.1,17 Most meta-analyses have
pooled the results from trials testing vitamin D or calcium alone, or in
combination, therefore the effect of each of these interventions is unclear.
Meta-analyses have shown that vitamin D supplementation (used
alone or with calcium) has a small, beneficial effect on fracture rates,18
particularly with higher doses.19 However, calcium supplements alone
have been shown to have a similar beneficial effect on total fractures
as calcium plus vitamin D supplements in combination.20 Vitamin D
supplements alone do not provide a clinically relevant benefit to bone
density.21 Given the inconsistencies of the conclusions from metaanalyses, further large randomised controlled trials are needed to show
whether vitamin D alone is beneficial for reducing fractures.22
Recent studies have linked calcium
supplements to an increased risk of heart
attack and death from cardiovascular disease
in older people.23 Therefore the benefits of
calcium supplements for fracture prevention
– either used alone or with vitamin D – do not
outweigh their poor safety profile. Instead,
calcium should be from the diet.6
Dietary calcium
is safer than
taking calcium
supplements.
What are the key messages?
A wide range of health benefits have been claimed for vitamin D
supplementation and further studies are currently underway testing
efficacy and safety in terms of falls and fractures,24 including the
Auckland-based Vitamin D Assessment (ViDA) study.
We need to base practice for falls prevention
on the current evidence, and endeavour to give
consumers consistent messages:
REFERENCES continued
• Both vitamin D and calcium are essential for bone health and
muscle function.
• The two main ways to get vitamin D are by exposing bare skin to
sunlight and by taking vitamin D supplements. The body can’t get
the amount of vitamin D needed just from food.
• Residents in age-related care facilities taking vitamin D supplements
have significantly fewer falls than those not taking this supplement.
• Overall, in the general older population vitamin D supplementation
does not reduce falls or fractures.
• Vitamin D deficiency is more likely (no need for a blood test) for
people who are housebound, require support services, age-related
care facility residents, frail, dark-skinned or obese.
• The standard treatment in New Zealand for people with vitamin D
deficiency who are unable to increase their sun exposure is
2 x 50,000 IU cholecalciferol tablets in the first month, then continue
with 1 x 50,000 IU tablet per month.
• The benefits of calcium supplements for fracture prevention – either
used alone or with vitamin D – do not appear to outweigh their
poor safety profile.
• Adequate dietary calcium is important and is considered safer for
older adults than taking supplements.
10. Bischoff-Ferrari H. 2010. Health effects of vitamin D. Dermatologic Therapy 23(1): 23–30.
11. Cameron ID, Gillespie LD, Robertson MC et al. 2012. Interventions for preventing falls in
older people in care facilities and hospitals. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (12):
CD005465.
12. Gillespie LD, Robertson MC, Gillespie WJ et al. 2012. Interventions for preventing falls
in older people living in the community. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (9):
CD007146.
13. Murad MH, Elamin KB, Abu Elnour NO et al. 2011. Clinical review: The effect of vitamin
D on falls: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and
Metabolism 96(10): 2997–3006.
14. Moyer VA, on behalf of the US Preventive Services Task Force. 2012. Prevention of falls in
community-dwelling older adults: US Preventive Services Task Force recommendation
statement. Annals of Internal Medicine 157(3): 197–204.
15. Panel on Prevention of Falls in Older Persons, American Geriatrics Society, British
Geriatrics Society. 2011. Summary of the updated American Geriatrics Society/British
Geriatrics Society clinical practice guideline for prevention of falls in older persons.
Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 59(1): 148–57.
16. Bilinski K, Boyages S. 2013. Evidence of overtesting for vitamin D in Australia: an analysis
of 4.5 years of Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS) data. BMJ Open 3(6).
17. Moyer VA, US Preventive Services Task Force. 2013. Vitamin D and calcium
supplementation to prevent fractures in adults: US Preventive Services Task Force
recommendation statement. Annals of Internal Medicine 158(9): 691–6.
18. Avenell A, Gillespie WJ, Gillespie LD et al. 2009. Vitamin D and vitamin D analogues for
preventing fractures associated with involutional and post-menopausal osteoporosis.
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2): CD000227.
19. Bischoff-Ferrari HA, Willett WC, Orav EJ et al. 2012. A pooled analysis of vitamin D dose
requirements for fracture prevention. New England Journal of Medicine 367(1): 40–9.
6O
MINUTES
of professional development
Undertaking this learning activity is equivalent to
60 minutes of professional development and can be
added to the personal professional record you keep for
competence framework requirements.
Learning objectives
Reading and reflecting on TOPIC 7 and the materials in this teaching/
learning package will enable learners to:
1 Review the actions, interactions and sources of vitamin D
and calcium.
2 List risk factors for vitamin D deficiency in older people.
3 Outline the clinical implications of current research findings on the
effect of vitamin D supplementation on falls in specific groups of
older people.
4 Describe standard approaches to treatment for vitamin D deficiency
in older people in New Zealand.
Teaching/Learning package
Gather up the resources you’ll need by using the hyperlinks in the text, or
download or print them as separate items.
REQUIRED READING
On vitamin D and sun exposure
These readings will help you give sound advice about vitamin D and
safe sun exposure.
1 The Ministry of Health and Cancer Society’s Consensus Statement
on Vitamin D and Sun Exposure in New Zealand.
2 Cancer Society consumer information Vitamin D and SunSmart.
On vitamin D supplements
Case Studies of improvement projects which increased vitamin D
prescribing rates in residential care – read at least one.
Information for consumers. ACC4940 Stay on your feet and stay
active with a little help from vitamin D (Dec 2008).
Information for general practice teams and staff working in
residential care. ACC4937 Vitamin D – A proven D-fence against falls
(Dec 2008). ACC6508 Vital D-fence. An update for general practice
teams (Aug 2008).
Information for prescribers. ACC4697 Vitamin D prescribing criteria
– residential care (Nov 2008). ACC6444 Vitamin D prescribing criteria –
community (Oct 2012).
RECOMMENDED READING
BPAC. 2011. Vitamin D supplementation: navigating the debate. Best
Practice Journal 36: 26–35 via webpage or pdf.
FURTHER READING
See Topic 7 Vitamin D and falls: more you can read for an annotated list
of general and clinical reading.
OTHER RESOURCES
Posters: Vitamin D supplementation.
Consumer information sheet: Vitamin D supplements (formatted for
reading online, easy print version).
Consumer information brochure: Vitamin D supplements (print and
fold version).
20. Tang BM, Eslick GD, Nowson C et al. 2007. Use of calcium or calcium in combination with
vitamin D supplementation to prevent fractures and bone loss in people aged 50 years and
older: a meta-analysis. Lancet 370(9588): 657–66.
21. Reid IR, Bolland MJ, Grey A. 2013 ePub. Effects of vitamin D supplements on bone mineral
density: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet.
22. Scragg R. 2012. Do we need to take calcium with vitamin D supplements to prevent falls,
fractures, and death? Current Opinion in Clinical Nutrition and Metabolic Care 15(6): 614–24.
23. Reid IR, Bolland MJ, Avenell A et al. 2011. Cardiovascular effects of calcium supplementation.
Osteoporosis International 22: 1649–58.
24. Kupferschmidt K. 2012. Uncertain verdict as vitamin D goes on trial. Science 337(6101):1476–8.
November 2013 v1
4
1O Questions
TOPIC
7
Professional
development
activity
Vitamin D and falls:
what you need to know
Answer these questions to check that you have retained the knowledge reviewed in this topic and reading (Select one option)
Safe and effective ways to obtain sufficient vitamin D from skin exposure to sunlight include:
having a sunbed session at least once a week in winter.
being regularly physically active outdoors during the day.
sitting behind a full-length glass window in sunlight twice a day.
2
Which of these 75-year-olds is most likely to have lower levels of vitamin D?
Mr Brown, who plays golf several times a week.
Mrs Jones, who is a keen gardener and belongs to a walking group.
Mrs Smith, who is frail and housebound.
3
The required reading, Consensus Statement on Vitamin D and Sun Exposure in New Zealand, states that the cost of vitamin D
supplementation is less than the cost of blood testing for vitamin D, and in general, identifying those at risk of deficiency can rely
on risk factor profile.
True False
4
Research cited in this article suggests vitamin D supplementation in older people is effective in reducing falls in those with:
lower levels of vitamin D.
adequate levels of vitamin D.
5
Current recommendations cited in Topic 7 are for older people to achieve a calcium intake of:
1200–1300 mg/day by taking calcium tablets in addition to a balanced diet.
1200–1300 mg/day from calcium-rich foods as part of a balanced diet.
answer
1
Assess the processes used in your care setting for assessing vitamin D status of older people
What process is used in your care setting for assessing whether older patients/residents/clients might be deficient in vitamin D?
What would need to change (if anything) to put in place a methodical and consistent approach to assessing all older people for
their vitamin D status?
7
assess
6
Describe three specific things you already do (or could do) to promote safe sun exposure with your patients/residents/clients?
Outline three learnings or insights and how you will apply them in your practice
I will apply it in practice by….
9 My second learning/insight is…
I will apply it in practice by….
10 My third learning/insight is…
apply
8 My first learning/insight is…
I will apply it in practice by….
LEARNER NAME:
PROFESSION:
DESIGNATION:
DATE:
REGISTRATION ID:
WORKPLACE:
Validation of completion of this professional development activity
Signature:
NAME:
PROFESSION:
CONTACT:
DATE:
REGISTRATION ID:
WORKPLACE:
Email [email protected] when you have completed this learning activity for an automated reply with the answers.