!"
#!$%&! % '( )%*!&%+,- .%%+-%+,/+0' .%%! 1 +2!-+%3
4!&$! /5 67869
:'(; ; <' !=
#!$%&! % '( >*3-+'';3 ?+'$*3-+,1 +2!-+%3 '( )+&+ )!+, ! %!
)+&+ @ AABAC
D'E!% . F+-! E!;G
#!$%&! % '( )'!,H ?+'$*3-+,- >*3-+'';3
DH-* )!+, ! %!
*+,;' I CJCB8
KLMNOPQNRSMTUVMWXVQOXY Z[\[]^_` \abbc^d[e fg b]^d hi jkZlk age[^ m^]gd nkk
opqorY
st PuPPQNRvUNuSMVSQOVSwMSwVQOXY Z[\[]^_` \abbc^d[e fg b]^d hi xyz{x|} age[^
m^]gdƒ„ Zop „~ €r‚pqopY
QwWQP QRNXWUVQOXY Z[\[]^_` \abbc^d[e fg b]^d hi jkZlk age[^ m^]gd nkk opqorY
!
" # #$ %&'()
* * + , , ! - - # * . * . !
/
01234 5 6 7284 1
9:;<;=:>?< >@<<A @B>C?D=@ >C@E :>?<A ?DF @<@>GH:> >C?H=@ I:GC GC@:H @DJ:H;DK
E @DGA GCH;L=C :;D:> >C?DD@<AM NH;G@:D GLDD@<A O<<@F I:GC :;DA ?DF I?G@HM :D
GC@ >@<< E @EPH?D@ I?<<A QA@@ R@ST UVW S;H ? >;E NH@C@DA:J@ :DGH;FL>G:;DXT Y:=K
D?<:D= :D GC@ D@HJ;LA AZAG@E [ >;;HF:D?G:;D ;S ELA><@ >;DGH?>G:;D :D><LF:D=
GC@ NLE N:D= ?>G:;D ;S GC@ C@?HG[ ?DF :;D GH?DAN;HG :D @J@HZ >@<< ?DF ;H=?D
?H@ >?HH:@F ;LG GCH;L=C :;D:> >C?DD@<AT
\@ >;DA:F@H ? ];I ;S N;A:G:J@ ?DF D@=?G:J@ :;DA Q>?G:;DA ?DF ?D:;DAX :D
I?G@H :D ? >C?DD@< Q;H N;H@X N<LA ALHH;LDF:D= P?GCA :D ?D @<@>GH:> O@<F ^ Q_ ` a X
?=?:DAG ? P?>b=H;LDF ;S >C?H=@F ?G;E A ;D GC@ >C?DD@< NH;G@:D T cC@ F:A>H@G@
F:AGH:PLG:;D ;S >C?H=@A :A F@A>H:P@F PZ >;DG:DLLE UdWe UfW N?HG:><@ F@DA:G:@A
gh Q_ ` a X S;H GC@ E ;P:<@ :;DA Qi j kl [ m<n [ o?l [ m?ll [ T T T X ?DF p Q_ X S;H GC@
>C?H=@F ?G;E A QqF;N:D=r :D GC@ <?D=L?=@ ;S A@E :>;DFL>G;H F@J:>@ NCZA:>AX
;S GC@ NH;G@:D T cC@ N@HE ?D@DG OB@F >C?H=@ F@DA:GZ p E ?Z :D><LF@ P;GC
N;A:G:J@ ?DF D@=?G:J@ >C?H=@A[ PLG GC@ NH;G@:D :A NH@F;E :D?DG<Z D@=?G:J@<Z
>C?H=@F T o;G@ GC?G p J?D:AC@A PZ F@OD:G:;D :D GC@ P?GCAT
sD GC@ @BN@H:E @DG?< A@GLN [ ? J;<G?=@ P:?A t :A ?NN<:@F ?>H;AA GC@ >C?DD@<
N<LA P?GCA PZ E @?DA ;S ? J;<G?=@ ><?E N T cC@ >C?DD@< GH?DA:G G:E @ S;H ?D :;D
:A ;D GC@ ;HF@H ;S Vu DA[ IC:<@ @BN@H:E @DG?<<Z GC@ OD@AG G@E N;H?< H@A;<LG:;D
;S >LHH@DGA :A ;D GC@ ;HF@H ;S Vuevu wA[ A; @BN@H:E @DG?< E @?ALH@E @DGA ?H@
?J@H?=:D= ;J@H Vuuuevuuu :;DAT
x<GC;L=C :D GC:A :DJ@AG:=?G:;D I@ S;>LA ;D GC@ AG@?FZKAG?G@ ];I ;S :;DA[ I@
A;<J@ GC@ yz{ |}~| |€~|€y FH:SGKF:LA:;D @‚L?G:;DA P@>?LA@ I@ ?H@ L<G:E ?G@<Z
:DG@H@AG@F :D GC@ FZD?E :>A ;S :;D GH?DAN;HG Q@AN@>:?<<Z :D =?G:D=X ?A I@<<[ ?DF
P@>?LA@ GC@ >;E NLG?G:;D?< G:E @ S;H A:EL<?G:D= GC@ G:E @KF@N@DF@DG @‚L?G:;DA
G; AG@?FZ AG?G@ :A >;E N?H?P<@ G; ;H S?AG@H GC?D GC?G ;S AG@?FZKAG?G@ A;<J@HA[
IC:>C ELAG @E N<;Z ? <:D@?H:ƒ?G:;D A>C@E @ <:b@ o@IG;D „A E @GC;F T
d
8 1 5 12 38 2 8 6 84 1 4 5 ?GC@E ?G:>?<<Z GC@ ];I ;S :;DA >?D P@ ?NNH;B:E ?G@F PZ GC@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D ;H
;:AA;DKo@HDAGK <?D>b Q o X E ;F@<[ GC?G :A[ PZ N?HG:?< F:@H@DG:?< @‚L?G:;DA
S;H >;DA@HJ?G:;D ;S @?>C :;D AN@>:@A ?DF ;:AA;D „A @‚L?G:;D S;H GC@ @<@>GH;K
AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< Q_ ` a X gh
QVX
hju
a QdX
h j h w hgh ^ h gh
Q X j p hgh ` ^ j Q X
h IC@H@ :A GC@ NH;G;D >C?H=@[ :A GC@ F:@<@>GH:> >;@ >:@DG[ ?DF IC@H@ S;H @?>C
:;D AN@>:@A i[ h :A GC@ DLEP@H >LHH@DG F@DA:GZ QN?HG:><@ ]LBX[ h :A GC@ :;D:>
N<@[ j d X[ h j h [ w h :A GC@ E ;P:<:GZ >;@
>:@DG[ ?DF
>C?H=@ QS;H @B?E
h :A GC@ F:LA:;D >;@ >:@DGT cC@ G;G?< @<@>GH:> >LHH@DG F@DA:GZ Q>C?H=@ ]LBX
:A
j
QfX
!"!# h h h $
cC@ NCZA:>?< N?H?E @G@HA [ w h [ ?DF h ?H@ SLD>G:;DA ;S _ T
cC@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D @‚L?G:;DA S;HE ? N?H?P;<:> % @<<:NG:> AZAG@E ;S &' A GC@ GH?DAN;HG @‚L?G:;D QVX QI:GC h AN@>:O@F PZ ' ‚ T QdXX :A N?H?P;<:> ?DF
GC@ P;LDF?HZ >;DF:G:;DA S;H P;GC gh
;:AA;D „A @‚L?G:;D Q X :A @<<:NG:>T cCLA
?DF ?H@ & :H:>C<@G ?DF % ;H o@LE ?DD T
xA ?D @B?E N<@ ;S ? NCZA:;<;=:>?<<Z :E N;HG?DG >C?DD@<[ I@ I:<< S;>LA ;LH
?GG@DG:;D C@H@ ;D GC@ k >C?DD@< :<<LAGH?G@F :D ( := T V QGC@ k>Ax >C?DD@<
AGHL>GLH@ AC;ID :A F@H:J@F SH;E ) KH?Z >HZAG?<<;=H?NCZXT k >C?DD@<A N<?Z ?
>@DGH?< H;<@ :D @<@>GH:>?< A:=D?<:D= :D GC@ D@HJ;LA AZAG@E T x GZN:>?< D@HJ@ >@<<
C?A CLDFH@FA ;S GC;LA?DFA ;S k >C?DD@<AT
cC@ k >C?DD@< :A * | + |, yz - | . :T@T[ :G ?<<;IA kl :;DA G; ];I SH@@<Z P@GI@@D
GC@ :DG@H:;H ?DF @BG@H:;H ;S GC@ >@<<[ PLG D;G QS;H @B?E N<@X o?l ;H m?ll
:;DAT Qm<n :;DA ?H@ NH@J@DG@F SH;E ];I:D= GCH;L=C GC@ k >C?DD@< PZ GC@
@<@>GH;AG?G:> O@<F :D GC@ >C?DD@<TX \@ I:<< E ;F@< GC@ >C?DD@< N<LA H@=:;DA ;S
GC@ P?GC :<<LAGH?G@F :D ( :=T d ;LG G; ? F:AG?D>@ IC@H@ GC@ :;D F@DA:G:@A ?DF GC@
@<@>GH;AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< G?b@ ;D GC@:H ?AZE NG;G:> J?<L@A :D GC@ P?GCA gh j p / h [
j u ?G GC@ <@SG P;LDF?HZ[ ?DF gh j p / h [ j t ?G GC@ H:=CG P;LDF?HZ QA@@
( :=AT f ?DF vXT cC@ ;J@H?<< H@=:;D :A @<@>GH:>?<<Z D@LGH?<T cC@ F:LA:;D ?DF
E ;P:<:GZ >;@ >:@DGA ;S GC@ E ;P:<@ :;DA ?H@ GZN:>?<<Z EL>C AE ?<<@H :D GC@
>C?DD@< GC?D :D GC@ P?GCA QA@@ c?P<@ VXT
( :=LH@ V k >C?DD@<[ E @EPH?D@[ ?DF :DG@H:;H ?DF @BG@H:;H P?GCAT
interior
bath
ambient BC
membrane
exterior
bath
no-flux BC
rc
lb
channel
lc
lb
no-flux BC
membrane
ambient BC
far-field BC
far-field BC
r
ambient BC
rb
z
ambient BC
( :=LH@ d & :?=H?E ;S >;E NLG?G:;D?< H@=:;D S;H >C?DD@<[ E @EPH?D@[ ?DF
P?GCAT 9;LDF?HZ >;DF:G:;D GZN@A ?H@ <?P@<@F :D :G?<:>A S;H GC@ & NH;P<@E T
f
9;LDF?HZ >;DF:G:;DA AC;L<F D;G P@ ?NN<:@F ?G GC@ @DFA ;S GC@ >C?DD@<[ FL@
G; GC@ S?>G GC?G P;LDF?HZ <?Z@HA :D :;D:> >C?H=@ F@DA:GZ ?DF :D GC@ @<@>GH;K
AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< F@J@<;N GC@H@[ ?A :<<LAGH?G@F :D ( :=AT f ?DF vT cC@ :;D:> >C?H=@
F@DA:G:@A ?DF GC@ @<@>GH;AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< H@?>C GC@:H @‚L:<:PH:LE S?HKO@<F J?<K
L@A ?NNH;B:E ?G@<Z GI; & @PZ@ <@D=GCA :DG; GC@ P?GCA QGC@ & @PZ@ <@D=GCA S;H
kl ?DF m<n ?H@ ;D GC@ ;HF@H ;S V DE :D GC@ P?GCAXT sD GC@ ;D@KF:E @DA:;D?<
?NNH;B:E ?G:;D G; GC@ k >C?DD@< NH;P<@E I:GC GC@ >C?DD@< Tv DE <;D= [ GC@
P?GCA ?H@ H@NH@A@DG@F PZ >;D:>?< SLDD@<A Q( := T X @BG@DF:D= v DE :DG; GC@
P?GCA ?DF ;N@D:D= ?G fv ?D=<@A ;D @:GC@H A:F@ ;S GC@ ?B:A QGC@ ;N@D:D=
?D=<@ C?A ;D<Z ? I@?b @@>G ;D GC@ >;E NLG@F A;<LG:;D ?DF G;G?< >LHH@DGXT
cC@ SLDD@<A AC;L<F P@ I:F@ @D;L=C A; GC?G GC@ :E N@F?D>@ ;S GC@ P?GCA G;
GC@ :;D ];I :A J@HZ AE ?<< >;E N?H@F G; GC@ :E N@F?D>@ ;S GC@ >C?DD@<T
rc
lb
channel
lc
lb
far-field BC
far-field BC
rf
z
( :=LH@ & :?=H?E ;S V & >;E NLG?G:;D?< H@=:;D S;H >C?DD@< ?DF P?GC SLDD@<AT
cC@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D @‚L?G:;DA QVXe Q X >?D P@ IH:GG@D :D GC@ S;HE
gh
Q h w h ^ gh X j Q h gh X
a j Q w ^ h gh X
!"!# h h h hgh
v
QvX
Q X
Q X j p hgh ` ^ j $
h cC@ P;LDF?HZ >;DF:G:;D Q9mX GZN@A :D ( := T d ?H@ F@OD@F PZ
QX
gh j p / h ` j u Q:DG@H:;H P?GC S?HKO@<F 9mX
gh j p / h ` j t Q@BG@H:;H P?GC S?HKO@<F 9mX
gh j p / h ` j u Q?EP:@DG P?GC 9mX
j
u
j u QD;K]LB 9mX
gh ` IC@H@ :A ? LD:G D;HE ?< J@>G;H G; GC@ P;LDF?HZT
cC@ >C?DD@< NH;P<@E :<<LAGH?G@F :D ( :=T V C?A ?D ?NNH;B:E ?G@ >Z<:DFH:>?<
AZE E @GHZ . :D ;GC@H I;HFA[ GC@ A;<LG:;D gh [ F@N@DFA G; ?D @B>@<<@DG ?NNH;B:K
E ?G:;D ;D<Z ;D ?DF [ IC@H@ >Z<:DFH:>?< >;;HF:D?G@A ?H@ F@D;G@F PZ Q ` ` X[
I:GC GC@ ?B:A ?<;D= GC@ <@D=GC ;S GC@ >C?DD@<T Q\ :GC >Z<:DFH:>?< AZE E @GHZ[
D;K]LB P;LDF?HZ >;DF:G:;DA ?H@ :E N;A@F ?<;D= GC@ ?B:A ?A I@<<TX sS I@
D@=<@>G GC@ F@N@DF@D>@ ;S gh ?DF ;D :D GC@ >C?DD@< ?DF GC@ D@?H P?GC
H@=:;DA[ IC:>C :A ? =;;F ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D :S GC@ >H;AA A@>G:;D?< ?H@? Q X J?H:@A
A<;I<Z I:GC QGC:A :A GC@ AG?DF?HF ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D LA@F :D GC@ ?D?<ZA:A ?DF
A:EL<?G:;D ;S D;ƒƒ<@ ];I :D =?A FZD?E :>AX[ GC@D I@ ;PG?:D ? ;D@KF:E @DA:;D?<
?NNH;B:E ?G:;D G; GC@ >C?DD@< NH;P<@E T
sD ;LH OHAG E ;F@<[ I@ I:<< GH@?G LAG ? ;D@KF:E @DA:;D?< ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D
;S GC@ >C?DD@< N<LA SLDD@<A ;N@D:D= :DG; GC@ P?GCA ;D @:GC@H A:F@T (LGLH@
A:EL<?G:;DA I:<< @BG@DF GC@ A:EL<?G:;DA G; GI; ?DF GCH@@ F:E @DA:;DAT
c; IH:G@ F;ID GC@ V & @‚L?G:;DA[ H@>?<< GC?G GC@ F@OD:G:;D ;S GC@ F:J@HK
=@D>@ ;S ? J@>G;H O@<F :A
V Q X
j <:E
IC@H@ :A ? J;<LE @ >@DG@H@F ?H;LDF _ I:GC P;LDF:D= ALHS?>@ T (;H
Q_ X j Q X ?DF j Q X [ ' ‚ T Q X H@FL>@A G;
V
V
j <:E
U Q X Q X Q X Q XW j
Q X Q X
PZ
@BN?DF:D= :D T Qo;G@ GC?G GC@ =H?F:@DG :A LD>C?D=@F j
c?Z<;H
S;H Q_ X j Q XTX
cC@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D @‚L?G:;DA GCLA P@>;E @ :D GC@ V & ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D
V
V
gh
Q h w h gh X j h gh ` gh Qu ` a X j p / h j gh Q ` a X QVuX
a QVVX
j h h w hgh h gh
!"!#
h
V j p hgh ` j ` QuX j u ` Q X j t QVdX
h IC@H@ GC@ A:EL<?G:;D H@=:;D IC:>C :D><LF@A GC@ >C?DD@< N<LA P?GCA HLDA SH;E
u G; j d / ?DF gh Q_ ` a X j gh Q ` a X[ Q_ ` a X j Q ` a XT (;H P;GC GC@
# „A @‚L?G:;D QVdX ?DF GC@ N?H?P;<:> GH?DAN;HG @‚L?G:;D QVuX[
@<<:NG:> ;:AA;D
& :H:>C<@G P;LDF?HZ >;DF:G:;DA ;D ?DF gh ?H@ :E N;A@F ?G GC@ <@SG ?DF H:=CG
P;LDF?H:@AT
o;G@ GC?G :D GC:A V & ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D [ GC@ >LHH@DG F@DA:GZ Q?DF GCLA GC@
:;D J@<;>:GZX ?DF GC@ @<@>GH:> O@<F I:<< <:@ :D GC@ F:H@>G:;D T c; A:E N<:SZ GC@
E ?GC@E ?G:>?< ?D?<ZA:A ;S GC@ V& E ;F@< QVuXe QVdX[ GC@ >H;AA A@>G:;D?< ?H@?
Q X E ?Z P@ A@G G; ? >;DAG?DG :D GC@ >C?DD@< :GA@<S[ PLG D;G :D GC@ P?GCAT
cC@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D E ;F@< S;H ? ANC@H:>?<<Z AZE E @GH:> NH;P<@E gh Q_ ` a X j
gh Q ` a X[ Q_ ` a X j Q ` a X[ IC@H@ ANC@H:>?< >;;HF:D?G@A ?H@ F@D;G@F PZ Q ` ` X[
G?b@A @B?>G<Z GC@ A?E @ S;HE ?A ' ‚AT QVuXe QVdX I:GC H@N<?>@F PZ T Y:D>@
GC@ @‚L:N;G@DG:?< ALHS?>@A ?DF GC@ <@J@< A@G >LHJ@A ;S gh ?H@ D;HE ?< G; GC@ >@<<
E @EPH?D@ I?<<A QA:D>@ GC@H@ :A D; :;D ];I GCH;L=C GC@ I?<<A ?DF A:D>@ G; ?
=;;F ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D GC@H@ :A D; @<@>GH:>?< ]LB GCH;L=C GC@ I?<<AX[ GC@ A;<LG:;D
:D GC@ P?GCA D@?H GC@ >C?DD@< ;N@D:D=A E ?Z P@ E ;F@<@F ?A ?NNH;B:E ?G@<Z
ANC@H:>?<<Z AZE E @GH:> UvW S;H ? E ;F@H?G@ H?F:?< F:AG?D>@ :DG; GC@ P?GCAT cC@D [
?A <;D= ?A GC@ ];I ?DF @<@>GH:> O@<F <:D@A H@E ?:D ?NNH;B:E ?G@<Z H?F:?< :D GC@
P?GCA D@?H GC@ >C?DD@< ;N@D:D=A[ ' ‚AT QVuXe QVdX I:GC H@N<?>@F PZ E ?Z
P@ LA@F I:GC GC@ >H;AA A@>G:;D?< ?H@? Q X D;I GC@ ALHS?>@ ?H@? ;S ANC@H:>?<
AC@<<A AG?HG:D= ?DF @DF:D= ?G ? >@<< E @EPH?D@ I?<<T cC@ V & >Z<:DFH:>?<<Z
AZE E @GH:> A;<LG:;D :D GC@ >C?DD@< :A qN?G>C@Fr ;DG; GC@ ANC@H:>?<<Z AZE E @GK
H:> A;<LG:;D :D GC@ >C?DD@< ;N@D:D= ?DF GC@ P?GC T 9;GC GC@ ?AALE NG:;D ;S
ANC@H:>?< AZE E @GHZ ?DF GC@ N?G>C:D= G;=@GC@H ;S A;<LG:;DA :DGH;FL>@ @HH;HAT
cC@ J?<:F:GZ ;S GC:A ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D I:<< P@ G@AG@F ?=?:DAG d & >Z<:DFH:>?<<Z
AZE E @GH:> A:EL<?G:;DAT
2 5 2 2 38 2 8 6 84 1 4 5 x<GC;L=C I@ I:<< A;<J@ GC@ G:E @KF@N@DF@DG FH:SGKF:LA:;D @‚L?G:;DA P@<;I [ S;H
>;E N<@G@D@AA I@ ?<A; =:J@ GC@ AG@?FZKAG?G@ @‚L?G:;DA ?DF ?AA;>:?G@F P;LDFK
?HZ >;DF:G:;DAT
(;H GC@ ];I ;S >?G:;DA ?DF ?D:;DA :D AG@?FZ AG?G@[ GC@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D
@‚L?G:;DA QVXe Q X G?b@ GC@ S;HE
h j u[ ;H :D ;GC@H I;HFA
Q h w h ^ gh h gh X j u
QV X
j Q w ^ h gh X
QVfX
!"!# h h h hgh
Q X j p hgh ` ^ j $
QVvX
h sD V & [ GC@ AG@?FZKAG?G@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D @‚L?G:;DA ?H@
h w h gh h gh j u ` gh QuX j p / h j gh Q X
QV X
QV X
j h h w hgh h gh
!"!#
h
V j p hgh ` j ` QuX j u ` Q X j t $ QV X
h 6 387 2 4 5 4 3 7234 5 8 6 84 1
?H:?P<@A gh ?DF ?H@ F@OD@F ?G =H:FN;:DGA u[ V[ T T T [ p [ IC:<@ ?DF ?H@
F@OD@F ?G E :FN;:DGA ;S =H:F >@<<A V d[ V % d[ % d[ T T T [ p V % dT :J@D g h ?DF
?G G:E @<@J@< g [ ? G:E @AG@N >;DA:AGA ;S GI; N?HGAT Q:X ( :HAG I@ A;<J@ GC@
GH?DAN;HG @‚L?G:;D QVuX S;H g h
l I:GC j T Q::X cC@D I@ A;<J@ ;:AA;D „A
@‚L?G:;D QVdX S;H l LA:D= g h l ;D GC@ H:=CGKC?DF A:F@T
\@ LA@ GC@ :E N<:>:G[ KAG?P<@ cR9 &( d U [ W QGH?N@ƒ;:F?< HL<@ % A@>;DFK
;HF@H P?>bI?HF F:@H@D>@ S;HEL<?X E @GC;F S;H GC@ G:E @KF@N@DF@DG FH:SGK
F:LA:;D GH?DAN;HG @‚L?G:;D [ IC:>C ?<<;IA A:EL<?G:;DA G; LA@ <?H=@ G:E @AG@NAT
cR9 &( d :A ? ;D@KAG@N A@>;DFK;HF@H ?>>LH?G@ E @GC;F . GC@ G:E @AG@N :A ?FK
LAG@F FZD?E :>?<<Z PZ ? F:J:F@F F:@H@D>@ S;HEL<? @AG:E ?G@ ;S GC@ <;>?< @HH;HT
xSG@H F:A>H@G:ƒ:D= :D AN?>@[ GC@ GH?DAN;HG @‚L?G:;D QVuX E ?Z P@ IH:GG@D
?A ? AZAG@E ;S ;HF:D?HZ F:@H@DG:?< @‚L?G:;DA a j Q XT cC@ cR9 &( d
E @GC;F GC@D G?b@A GC@ S;HEM QVX cR AG@N ;S a l a l j d
a
d
?DF QdX 9 &( d AG@N ;S a V
V
QV X a l j
l $
l d Qd X
Qd X
\ :GC GC@ @<@>GH:> O@<F SH;ƒ@D IC:<@ LNF?G:D= GC@ GH?DAN;HG @‚L?G:;D [ Q X :A
<:D@?HT \@ G?b@ GC@ LAL?< J?<L@ j d d IC:>C E :D:E :ƒ@A GC@ E ?=D:GLF@
;S GC@ <;>?< @HH;HT
(;H ;:AA;D „A @‚L?G:;D I@ LA@ ? GH:F:?=;D?< F:H@>G A;<J@HT
8 6 284 1 4 2 1 1 \@ I:<< >;DA:F@H C@H@ GC@ ];I ;S kl :;DA Q:D I?G@HX GCH;L=C ? >C?DD@< ;S
F:?E @G@H V DE ?DF <@D=GC Tv DE T
(;H J?H:;LA A@>G:;DA ;S GC@ k >C?DD@< ?DF ALHH;LDF:D= km< P?GCA[ GC@
<@D=GCA [ P?>b=H;LDF N@HE ?D@DG >C?H=@A ;D GC@ NH;G@:D IC:>C =; :DG; p [
F:@<@>GH:> >;DAG?DGA [ E ;P:<:GZ >;@ >:@DGA w [ ?DF F:LA:;D >;@ >:@DGA ?H@
=:J@D :D c?P<@ VT cC@ E ;P:<:G:@A ?DF F:LA:;D >;@ >:@DGA A?G:ASZ GC@ ' :DAG@:D
H@<?G:;D w j V fu @ T
|z €
P?GCA
v
u
u
f =H;LN
uTd f u
D;DN;<?H
VTV
u
f
>@DGH?< >?J:GZ V d u
O<G@H
VTd d u
VTv
uTf
uTf
uTf
uTf
c?P<@ V @D=GCA :D DE [ P?>b=H;LDF N@HE ?D@DG >C?H=@A ;D GC@ NH;G@:D [
F:@<@>GH:> >;DAG?DGA [ E ;P:<:GZ >;@ >:@DGA w :D Vun >E % Q AX[ ?DF F:LA:;D
>;@ >:@DGA :D Vun >E % AT
w
u
V
V
V
V
cC@ P?GC >;D>@DGH?G:;DA S;H GC@ N;A:G:J@ ?DF D@=?G:J@ :;DA ?H@ uTVv E ;<?H
j Vu >E n T \@ ?<A; ?AALE @ GC?G GC@H@ ?H@ @‚L?< >;D>@DGH?G:;DA ;S
:;DA :DA:F@ ?DF ;LGA:F@ GC@ >@<< E @EPH?D@[ A; GC?G D; >LHH@DG ];IA IC@D
t j uT cC@ P?GCA ?H@ E ;F@<@F PZ SLDD@<A IC:>C ;N@D SH;E GC@ >C?DD@<
>H;AA A@>G:;D?< ?H@? j QV DE dX ?G GC@ >C?DD@< ;N@D:D= ;LG G; j
QVV DE dX ?G v DE :DG; GC@ P?GCAT cC@A@ N?H?E @G@HA =:J@ ? <:D@?H >LHH@DGK
J;<G?=@ >LHJ@ I:GC ? >LHH@DG ;S ddTv N:>;?E N@H@A ?G ? P:?A ;S Vuu E :<<:J;<GA
Q( := T XT ' BN@H:E @DG?<<Z GC@ >LHH@DG ?G Vuu E :<<:J;<GA :A ;D GC@ ;HF@H ;S
due u N:>;?E NA S;H GC:A GZN@ ;S >C?DD@<T
LogHDensityL
1
0
-1
-2
-3
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
z
( :=LH@ f Y:EL<?G:;D ;S GC@ k l F@DA:GZ g QH@F [ F?HbX ?DF m<n F@DA:GZ g
"
Q>Z?D [ <:=CGX S;H t j Vuu E :<<:J;<GAT cC@ NH;G@:D N@HE ?D@DG >C?H=@ F@DA:GZ
p :A AC;ID :D P<L@ QF?AC@FXT cC@ J@HG:>?< A>?<@ :A <;= ;S F@DA:GZ % QVu >E n XT
cC@ >;E NLG@F :;D F@DA:G:@A ?DF @<@>GH;AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< ?H@ AC;ID :D ( :=AT f
?DF v :A :D DE [ ?DF GC@ >C?DD@< <:@A P@GI@@D j u ?DF j $vT cC@ P?GCA
@BG@DF v DE ;D @:GC@H A:F@ ;S GC@ >C?DD@< Q;D<Z N?HG ;S GC@ P?GCA :A AC;ID :D
( := T fXT cC@ :;D ];I :A SH;E GC@ :DG@H:;H Q<@SGX G; GC@ @BG@H:;H QH:=CGX ;S GC@
>@<< E @EPH?D@T cC@ G;G?< >C?H=@ ;D GC@ >C?DD@< :A . GC@H@ ?H@ f T k l :;DA
;D ?J@H?=@ ];I:D= :D GC@ >C?DD@<[ I:GC ?P;LG GI; kl :;DA ;D ?J@H?=@ :D GC@
D@:=CP;HC;;F ;S GC@ f >C?H=@ =H;LN ?DF ?P;LG ;D@ kl :;D ;D ?J@H?=@ :D
GC@ O<G@HT QcC@ FH:SGKF:LA:;D E ;F@< NH@F:>GA ?P;LG V % Vv m<n :;D ;D ?J@H?=@
Vu
0
Potential
-25
-50
-75
-100
-125
-150
-4
-2
0
4
2
z
6
8
( :=LH@ v Y:EL<?G:;D ;S @<@>GH;AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< :D E :<<:J;<GA S;H t j Vuu
E :<<:J;<GAT
20
I
15
10
5
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
V
( :=LH@ mLHH@DG :D N:>;?E N@H@A JAT J;<G?=@ :D E :<<:J;<GAT
VV
];I:D= :D GC@ >C?DD@< . GC:A :A ? H@?A;D?P<@ >;DG:DLLE ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D G; GC@
?>GL?< P:;<;=:>?< N:>GLH@ ;S F:A>H@G@ :;DA :D IC:>C m<n :;DA ?H@ @B><LF@F PZ
GC@ @<@>GH;AG?G:> O@<F SH;E GC@ k >C?DD@<TX cC@ A:EL<?G@F H@=:;D ;S >C?DD@<
N<LA P?GCA :A @<@>GH:>?<<Z D@LGH?< ;J@H?<<T
xG t j Vuu E :<<:J;<GA[ GC@ >LHH@DG l >?HH:@F PZ GC@ kl :;DA :A ddTd
N:>;?E NA[ IC:<@ GC@ >LHH@DG n >?HH:@F PZ GC@ m<n :;DA :A uT N:>;?E NAT ?DZ
@BN@H:E @DG?<:AGA P@<:@J@ GC?G D; >LHH@DG AC;L<F P@ >?HH:@F PZ GC@ m<n :;DA .
C;I@J@H E @?ALH@E @DGA ;D<Z H@AGH:>G n duT
4 1 7 6 84 1
cC@ S?>G GC?G GC@ A:EL<?G:;DA ;S GC@ kl ?DF m<n :;D F@DA:G:@A ?DF GC@ >LHH@DGK
J;<G?=@ >LHJ@ ?=H@@ I@<< I:GC @BN@H:E @DG?<<Z E @?ALH@F ;H F@H:J@F NH;N@HG:@A
;S GC@ k >C?DD@< =:J@A >H@F@D>@ G; GC@ >;DG:DLLE ]L:F ?NNH;B:E ?G:;D G; GC@
:;D ];I T (;H t j Vuu E :<<:J;<GA[ GC@ A:EL<?G:;DA NH@F:>G ?P;LG f Tv kl :;DA
:D GC@ >C?DD@<[ IC:>C :A >;DA:AG@DG I:GC GC@ >C?H=@ AGHL>GLH@ ;S GC@ NH;G@:D
bD;ID SH;E ) KH?Z >HZAG?<<;=H?NCZT sD ?FF:G:;D [ GC@ P;LDF?HZ <?Z@HA :D GC@
:;D F@DA:G:@A ?DF @<@>GH;AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< @BG@DF H;L=C<Z GI; & @PZ@ <@D=GCA
:DG; GC@ P?GCA[ ?DF GC@ E ?B:ELE E ?=D:GLF@ ;S GC@ @<@>GH;AG?G:> N;G@DG:?< :A
A?S@<Z P@<;I GC@ P:;<;=:>?<<Z F?D=@H;LA J?<L@ ;S duu E :<<:J;<GA ?G IC:>C GC@
<:N:F E @EPH?D@ P@=:DA G; PH@?b F;ID SH;E >C?H=@ ?H>:D= ?DF GC@ >C?DD@<
NH;G@:D :GA@<S :A F@S;HE @F PZ GC@ @<@>GH;AG?G:> S;H>@AT
(LGLH@ I;Hb I:<< :D><LF@ A:EL<?G:;DA S;H GC@ d & >Z<:DFH:>?<<Z AZE E @GH:>
?NNH;B:E ?G:;D G; GC@ >C?DD@< N<LA P?GCA[ ?DF ? A@N?H?G@ E ;F@< S;H =?G:D=
?DF =?G:D= >C?H=@ E ;J@E @DGT
Vd
3 1 7 UVW 9 T :<<@[ €z ,
?L@H[ V dT
€€|+* ,zy + | |{ €|* T YLDF@H<?DF [ x Y:DK
UdW R T YT ' :A@DP@H=[ T T k<;A@b [ ?DF T Y>CLAA[ q& :LA:;D ?A ? >C@E :>?<
H@?>G:;D AG;>C?AG:> GH? @>G;H:@A P@GI@@D OB@F >;D>@DGH?G:;DA[r € +
|{ z , + * z ,* [ J;<T Vud[ NN T V e V u[ V vT
U W \ T o;DD@H[ & T mC@D [ ?DF R T YT ' :A@DP@H= [ qxD;E ?<;LA E ;<@ SH?>G:;D
@@>G[ @<@>GH;AG?G:>A[ ?DF P:DF:D= [r z  * z , + € + [ J;<T f [ NN T d d e
d f[ V T
UfW \ T o;DD@H ?DF R T YT ' :A@DP@H= [ qs;D N@HE @?G:;D ?DF =<LG?E ?G@ H@A:FL@A
<:Db@F PZ ;:AA;DKo@HDAGK <?D>b GC@;HZ :D KGZN@ >?<>:LE >C?DD@<A[r z }
 * z , + € + [ J;<T v[ NN T Vd e V uv[ V T
UvW & T :<<@AN:@[ \ T o;DD@H[ ?DF R T YT ' :A@DP@H= [ qm;LN<:D= ;:AA;DKo@HDAGK
<?D>b ?DF F@DA:GZ SLD>G:;D?< GC@;HZ G; >?<>L<?G@ :;D ]LB [r € + * z ,* €~|€ * |~ yy| [ J;<T Vf [ NN T VdVd e VdVfv[ duudT
U W R T ' T 9?Db [ \ T T m;L=CH?D [ \ T ( :>CGD@H[ ' T T H;AA@[ & T T R;A@[ ?DF
R T k T YE :GC [ qcH?DA:@DG A:EL<?G:;D ;S A:<:>;D F@J:>@A ?DF >:H>L:GA[r € * ,yz € * € {  y| } z~|~ |* z €[ J;<T f [ NN T f efvV[ V vT
U W R T 9 T (?:H[ m T T ?HFD@H[ T T ;CDA;D [ YT \ T k@Db@<[ & T T R;A@[ T ' T
R;A@[ ?DF R T YLPH?CE ?DZ?D [ qcI; F:E @DA:;D?< NH;>@AA A:EL<?G:;D LAK
:D= J@H:O@F NC@D;E @D;<;=:>?< E ;F@<A[r € * , yz € * € {  y| }
z~|~ |* z € €y| y|~ z, zy* €~ * y|{ * [ J;<T Vu[ NN T f e vV[
V VT
V