City of Fraser CENTENNIAL COMMUNITY MAYOR Doug Hagerty COUNCIL CITY MANAGER Dan Accavitti, Mayor Pro-Tem Richard E. Haberman William A. Morelli, Acting Mayor Kathy A. Blanke Michael C. Carnagie CITY CLERK Paul A. Cilluffo Kathy Kacanowski Barbara L. Jennings FRASER CITY COUNCIL – REGULAR MEETING THURSDAY – DECEMBER 8, 2011 – 7:00 P.M. CITY HALL A G E N D A - amended 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA 4. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION ON AGENDA ITEMS 5. PRESENTATIONS a. Proclamation expressing appreciation to Angie Morelli for her many years of success and involvement with Toys for Tots. b. Presentation of donations from the Fraser Lions Club c. Update and review presented by Fraser Public Schools 6. PUBLIC HEARINGS a. There are no items scheduled for public hearing. 7. CONSENT AGENDA a. Approval of Minutes of the Regular Council Meeting of November 10, 2011 and Organizational Meeting of November 21, 2011. b. Approval of Bills for the Weeks of November 1, 2011 through November 30, 2011 in the amount of $725,556.31 c. Receive and file the minutes of the October 10, 2011 Library Board meeting. d. Receive and file the minutes of the August 29, 2011 and October 3, 2011 Historical Commission meetings Motion to approve the Consent Agenda as presented. 33000 Garfield ● Fraser, Michigan 48026 ● (586) 293-3102 ● Fax: (586) 293-7470 ● www.fraser.govoffice.com REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING DECEMBER 8, 2011 PAGE TWO 8. REQUESTS FOR COUNCIL ACTION a) Request Council consider closing City Hall an additional 3 days, December 27, 28 & 29, 2011 for the holidays. Motion to approve closing City Hall an additional 3 days, December 27, 28 & 29, 2011 for the holidays. b) Request Council approve an employment agreement with the City Manager for a period of three years with terms and conditions as presented to the Council. Motion to approve the employment agreement with the City Manager as presented. c) Request Council approve the 2012 meeting schedule as presented. Motion to approve the 2012 meeting schedule as presented. d) City Manager to discuss GASB-45 with respect to OPEB liability and its impact on the City moving forward. e) City Manager to provide Retiree Pension Fund update and analysis. f) Discussion to develop a City-wide technology strategy to include items such as on-line participation in public meetings, podcasts and other technologies available to enhance community outreach, transparency and communications. 9. REPORT OF THE CITY ADMINISTRATION/PENDING ITEMS 10. REPORT OF MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL/NEW BUSINESS 11. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION 12. ADJOURNMENT (Posted Friday, December 2, 2011 4:30p.m.) THE CITY OF FRASER WILL PROVIDE NECESSARY REASONABLE AUXILIARY AIDS AND SERVICES TO INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES AT THE MEETING UPON FOUR DAYS NOTICE TO: RANDY WARUNEK, BUILDING DEPARTMENT (586) 293-3100 EXT 154 IT IS THE POLICY OF THE CITY OF FRASER THAT NO PERSON, ON THE BASIS OF RACE, CREED, COLOR, RELIGION, NATIONAL ORIGIN, OR ANCESTRY, AGE, SEX, MARITAL STATUS, OR DISABILITY SHALL BE DISCRIMINATED AGAINST, EXCLUDED FROM PARTICIPATION, DENIED THE BENEFITS OF, OR OTHERWISE SUBJECTED TO DISCRIMINATION IN ANY PROGRAM OR ACTIVITY FOR WHICH IT IS RESPONSIBLE. 33000 Garfield ● Fraser, Michigan 48026 ● (586) 293-3102 ● Fax: (586) 293-7470 ● www.fraser.govoffice.com 33000 Garfield ● Fraser, Michigan 48026 ● (586) 293-3102 ● Fax: (586) 293-7470 ● www.fraser.govoffice.com Fraser City Council - Organizational Meeting Monday – November 21, 2011 - 7:30 P.M. Municipal Building A Special Meeting of the Fraser City Council was conducted on the above date at the City Municipal Building, located at 33000 Garfield Road, Fraser, County of Macomb, Michigan. Present: Mayor-elect Hagerty and Council Members Accavitti, Blanke, Carnagie, Jennings, Morelli and Council-elect Cilluffo Absent: None Also Present: Richard E. Haberman, City Manager Kathy Kacanowski, City Clerk Jack Dolan, City Attorney 1. Call Meeting to Order – Mayor ProTem Morelli called the regular meeting to order at 7:30 p.m. 2. Swearing In – Oath of Office a. Presentation of Flags by Fraser Honor Guard – Fraser Honor Guard posted the colors and National Anthem was sung by Athena Salvagno. b. Invocation by Pastor John Merrill – Pastor Merrill of St. John Lutheran Church led the audience in prayer. c. Introductions and Oath of Office State Representative Marilyn Lane administered the Oath of Office to Mayor Doug Hagerty; Judge Joseph Boedeker administered the Oath of Office to Councilman Daniel Accavitti; Judge Catherine Steenland administered the Oath of Office to Councilwoman Barbara Jennings and Judge Marco Santia administered the Oath of Office to Councilman Paul Cilluffo. 3. Organizational Activity a. Request Council elect Councilor Dan Accavitti as Mayor Pro Tem Mayor Hagerty moved, seconded by Member Morelli, to APPROVE THE APPOINTMENT OF DANIEL ACCAVITTI TO MAYOR PRO-TEM. The motion carried unanimously. b. Request Council elect Councilor Bill Morelli as Acting Mayor Attorney Dolan explained the City Charter provides for the position of an acting mayor. Councilmember Jennings added that this title allows Councilmember Morelli to continue performing weddings and Councilmember Blanke noted that Councilmember Morelli is ordained. Mayor Hagerty moved, seconded by Member Accavitti, to APPROVE THE APPOINTMENT OF WILLIAM MORELLI AS ACTING MAYOR. The motion carried unanimously. 4. Citizen Participation Gary Niedojadlo, Hanover Grove Joe DiStefano, 32102 DiStefano Ct. 5. Closing Prayer Pastor John Merrill of St John Lutheran Church offered a closing prayer at this time. Fraser City Council - Organizational Meeting Monday – November 21, 2011 - 7:30 P.M. Page Two 6. Adjournment Member Carnagie moved, seconded by Member Accavitti, to ADJOURN THE SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING OF MONDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2011 AT 8:21 P.M. The motion carried unanimously. Respectfully submitted, Kathy Kacanowski, City Clerk Doug Hagerty, Mayor /kk Fraser City Council - Regular Meeting Thursday – November 10, 2011 - 7:00 P.M. Municipal Building A Regular Meeting of the Fraser City Council was conducted on the above date at the City Municipal Building, located at 33000 Garfield Road, Fraser, County of Macomb, Michigan. Present: Mayor Geromette and Council Members Accavitti, Blanke, Caloia, Carnagie, Jennings and Morelli Absent: None Also Present: Richard E. Haberman, City Manager Kathy Kacanowski, City Clerk Jack Dolan, City Attorney 1. Call Meeting to Order - Mayor Geromette called the regular meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. 2. Pledge of Allegiance 3. Approval of Agenda Mayor Geromette added two presentations and Member Morelli requested one additional presentation to the agenda. Member Carnagie moved, seconded by Member Morelli, to APPROVE THE AGENDA AS AMENDED. The motion carried unanimously. 4. Citizen Participation on Agenda Items - none 5. Presentations a) Mayor Geromette presented Councilmember Caloia with a plaque in appreciation of her service to the city. b) Councilmember Carnagie presented Vania Apps, representing Fraser First Booster Club, with a check for $1250 from the Fraser Volunteer Firefighters. c) Mayor ProTem Morelli presented Mayor Geromette with a certification of recognition for his years of service to the city. 6. Public Hearings - none 7. Consent Agenda Member Accavitti moved, seconded by Member Blanke, to APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS AS PRESENTED. a. Approval of Minutes of the October 13, 2011 Regular Council meeting. b. Approval of Bills for the Weeks of October 1, 2011 through October 31, 2011 in the amount of $1,186,260.51. c. Receive and file the Minutes of the September 21, 2011 Planning Commission meeting. d. Receive and file the Minutes of the September 12, 2011 Library Board meeting. e. Receive and file the Minutes of the June 7, 2011 Parks and Recreation Commission meeting. f. Receive and file the Minutes of the September 6, 2011 Parks and Recreation Commission meeting. g. Appointment of Lori Bargowski to the Historical Commission with term to expire June 30, 2014. Fraser City Council - Regular Meeting Thursday – November 10, 2011 - 7:00 P.M. Page Two h. Reappointment of Betty Slominski and Laura Robinson to the Board of Review with terms to expire 12/31/13. The motion carried unanimously. 8. Requests For Council Action a. Request Council approve the purchase of a 2012 Chevrolet G4500 ambulance with a diesel motor that will include a type III patient module manufactured by Medtec in the amount of $155,144. The price includes custom paint and striping and a three year 36,000 warranty. Joe DiStefano, 32102 DiStefano Ct., spoke regarding this item. Member Carnagie moved, seconded by Member Caloia, to APPROVE THE PURCHASE OF A 2012 CHEVROLET G4500 AMBULANCE WITH A DIESEL MOTOR THAT WILL INCLUDE A TYPE III PATIENT MODULE MANUFACTURED BY MEDTEC IN THE AMOUNT OF $155,144. THE PRICE INCLUDES CUSTOM PAINT AND STRIPING AND A THREE YEAR 36,000 WARRANTY. The motion carried unanimously. b. Request Council proclaim the month of November as National Family Caregiver Month in Fraser to match the Presidential Proclamation to honor the 65 million volunteers who provide 80% of the long term care services in the United States. Member Caloia moved, seconded by Member Jennings, to PROCLAIM THE MONTH OF NOVEMBER AS NATIONAL FAMILY CAREGIVER MONTH IN FRASER TO MATCH THE PRESIDENTIAL PROCLAMATION TO HONOR THE 65 MILLION VOLUNTEERS WHO PROVIDE 80% OF THE LONG TERM CARE SERVICES IN THE UNITED STATES. The motion carried unanimously. c. Request Council approve a resolution to the Congress of the United States and our local Congressional Representatives to support the full funding for the F-35 Joint Strike fighter. A local Fraser business has been identified as one of the subcontractors of this project and we support both our military and business needs through this resolution. Member Blanke moved, seconded by Member Carnagie, to APPROVE A RESOLUTION TO THE CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES AND OUR LOCAL CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATIVES TO SUPPORT THE FULL FUNDING FOR THE F-35 JOINT STRIKE FIGHTER AS PRESENTED. Joe DiStefano, 32102 DiStefano Ct., spoke regarding this item. WHEREAS, the City of Fraser has a proud history of supporting our nation’s military and will continue its critical role as part of the supplier base for the F-35; and WHEREAS, the F-35 program creates advanced-technology jobs that build a highlyskilled workforce essential to our national security and economic prosperity here in Fraser. The members of our armed services need the latest technology supporting them as they protect our nation and ensure peace around the world; and WHEREAS, there is currently discussion in Congress about continuing full funding and production of the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter. Threats to peace and our national interests are continuing to emerge and the F-35 is the most advanced fighter aircraft ever built and is needed to replace the aging fleet of military aircraft that have been in use for thirty years; and Fraser City Council - Regular Meeting Thursday – November 10, 2011 - 7:00 P.M. Page Three WHEREAS, the F-35 will not only provide needed support for our nation’s military but will also strengthen our international alliances and ensure the success of our peace keeping missions. The United States has been investing in the production of the F-35 for more than a decade and will lose the benefits of this investment if full funding and planned production are not continued. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City of Fraser memorialize the United States Congress to recognize the importance of the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter to Michigan, the United States and our allies around the world by supporting full funding for the F-35 program. IT IS FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this resolution be transmitted to the President of the United States Senate, the Speaker of the United States House of Representatives, Senators Carl Levin and Debbie Stabenow, and the additional members of the Michigan congressional delegation. RESOLUTION DECLARED ADOPTED. The motion carried unanimously. 9. Report of City Administration/Pending Items Manager Haberman provided an update of various items. 10. Report of Mayor and City Council/New Business Mayor and Council discussed various topics. 11. Citizen Participation Public Safety Director George Rouhib presented gifts to Mayor Geromette and Councilmember Caloia thanking them for their service. Paul Cilluffo, 31640 Cyril Vania Apps and members of the Fraser First Booster Club presented a picture to the Mayor. Mike Lesich, 15201 Fairview Lt. Dan Kolke, Fraser Public Safety Jodie Horan, Plaza East Joe DiStefano, 32102 DiStefano Ct. 12. Adjournment Member Morelli moved, seconded by Member Carnagie, to ADJOURN THE REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2011 AT 8:01 pm. The motion carried unanimously. Dori Guoin, 33171 Utica Rd. requested to speak under Citizen Participation. She spoke briefly and then meeting adjourned at 8:03pm. Respectfully submitted, Kathy Kacanowski, City Clerk Moe Geromette, Mayor /kk 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser Check Date Bank CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Check Vendor Vendor Name Description Page: 1/9 Amount Bank PNC GENERAL CHECKING 11/01/2011 PNC 105652 DTEENG DETROIT ENERGY 1065 413 0118 5 1065 413 0112 8 1065 413 0107 8 4,829.96 33.94 22.85 4,886.75 11/03/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC 105653 105654 105655 105656 TRICOU ACCMED 999AMB AFLAC TRI-COUNTY INTERNATIONAL TRUCKS INC ACCUMED BILLING, INC AETNA AFLAC SEWER VAC AMBULANCE 10-126792 AMB RUN 08/4/10 EMPLOYEE PAID INSURANCE 11/10/2011 PNC 105657 AIRGAS AIRGAS GREAT LAKES LRG HELIUM/SM PROPANE LRG ACETYLENE/LGR OXYGEN LRG ACETYLENE/ARGON/OXYGEN 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105658 105659 105660 105661 105662 105663 105664 105665 105666 105667 105668 105669 105670 105671 105672 105673 105674 105675 105676 105677 105678 AMEFIN AMEMES ANDDAV APOEQU ASPUNL AT&T AUBDON AUDIO AUGMAC AUSAUS AUTMOT BSBRIC BANKNY BARPAV BELEQU BIEJON BOUTRE BOWROY BRETHO BRIFRA BUSAND AMERICA'S FINEST AMERICAN MESSAGING ANDARY, DAVIS, ANDARY PC APOLLO FIRE EQUIPMENT ASPHALT UNLIMITED, INC AT&T DONALD M. AUBREY AUDIO SENTRY CORPORATION AUGUST MACK ENVIRONMENTAL AUSILIO & AUSILIO PLLC AUTOMOTIVE ENHANCERS, INC B'S BRICK PAVING & LANDSCAPE THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON BARRETT PAVING MATERIALS INC BELL EQUIPMENT COMPANY JON C. BIERNAT, PLLC BOUND TREE MEDICAL ROYCE V. BOWMAN JR PC THOMAS M. BRENNAN FRANCESCO L. BRIGUGLIO ANDREW D. BUSS IMPOUND VEHICLE RECEIPTS-PS CITY PAGERS ATTORNEY FEES-CT LEATHER HELMET FRONT-PS DPW YARD PAVING 586 285 1420 PHONE NOVE 2011 ATTORNEY FEES-CT GENERAL LIFT STATION REMEDIAL ACTIVITES-KELLY RD ATTORNEY FEES-CT REPALCE PTO BELT #25 TRK PAVERS AROUND CLOCK-CITY HALL AGENT FEE-FRASIMPO2 UPM SWEEPER REPAIR ATTORNEY FEES-CT INTRAVENOUSE DRESSING PICTURE FRAME-PS ATTORNEY FEES-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT 11/10/2011 PNC 105679 C&GNEW C & G NEWSPAPERS LEGAL ADS LEGAL ADS LEGAL AD-ZBA 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC 105680 105681 999FIN CANTOR C.B.S. BORING & MACHINE CO. CANU, TORRICE & ZALEWSKI PPLC TAX REFUND ATTORNETY FEES-CT 11/10/2011 PNC 105682 CHRCON CHRISTIAN CONCRETE CUTTING INC. CONCRETE SAWING CONCRETE SAWING 275.00 275.00 550.00 11/10/2011 PNC 105683 CHRSUS SUSAN R. CHRZANOWSKI ATTORNEY FEES-CT 175.00 11/10/2011 PNC 105684 CINTAS CINTAS CORPORATION #354 TOWELING/TOILET PAPER/CANLINERS-CH FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-SR CENTER FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-C.H. FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-SR HOUSE 515.00 122.94 367.82 129.14 94,854.00 2,350.57 30.14 1,946.52 37.95 62.62 120.96 221.53 203.00 27.30 225.00 41.98 4,275.00 130.28 175.00 47.50 2,660.00 175.00 95.60 1,425.00 125.00 182.81 6,160.25 200.00 39.72 225.00 175.00 175.00 150.00 293.00 169.00 162.00 624.00 2,847.76 175.00 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser Check Date Bank CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Check Vendor Vendor Name Description FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-LIB FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-DPW Page: 2/9 Amount 79.46 356.62 1,570.98 11/10/2011 PNC 105685 CINFIR CINTAS FIRST AID & SAFETY FIRST AID SUPPLIES-REC FIRST AID SUPPLIES-DPW 14.80 23.34 38.14 11/10/2011 PNC 105686 CLANCY CLANCY EXCAVATING CO CRUSHED CONCRETE DELIVER 588.35 11/10/2011 PNC 105687 COMCAS COMCAST CABLE/INTERNET-SR HOUSE PHONES 74.32 131.96 206.28 11/10/2011 PNC 105688 COMINN COMFORT INN 4 NIGHT STAY NOV 27-DEC 1 275.60 11/10/2011 PNC 105689 CONCEN OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH CENTERS DPW NEW HIRE PHYSICAL RETURN TO WORK PHYSICAL-DPW 91.00 41.50 132.50 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC 105690 105691 CONENG CONPIP CONSUMERS ENERGY CONTRACTORS PIPE & SUPPLY CORP SR HOUSE #314 GAS WATER DEPT SUPPLIES 11/10/2011 PNC 105692 CROJAS JASMIN CROMWELL ADULT OGA FALL - REC SENIOR CHAIR YOGA 300.00 100.00 400.00 11/10/2011 PNC 105693 CRUISE CRUISERS FEDERAL SIGNAL FACTORY REPAIR-PS LIGHT LENS/LIGHT BULBS-PS 166.00 58.47 224.47 11/10/2011 PNC 105694 CYNERG CYNERGY PRODUCTS TILT SWIVEL MONITOR MOUNT ADAPTER-PS 11/10/2011 PNC 105695 DALES DALE'S LANDSCAPING SUPPLY, INC HAULING OUT DIRT BULK FILL SAND 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105696 105697 105698 105699 105700 105701 105702 105703 105704 105705 105706 105707 105708 105709 105710 105711 105712 105713 105714 105715 DATLTD DEMCO DETELE DTEENG DTEENG DTEENG DETWAT DINGRE EBSCO EHIM ERASER FIRCHO FOSTER FRALAW 999FIN FRAWAT FROMED FUGMAR GLOWOR GRAIMA ALLIED AFFILIATED FUNDING, L.P. DEMCO DETROIT ELEVATOR COMPANY DETROIT ENERGY DETROIT ENERGY DETROIT ENERGY DETROIT WATER & SEWERAGE DEPT DINNING & GREVE PLC EBSCO EMPLOYEE HEALTH INSURANCE MGNT, INC ERADICO SERVICES, INC FIRST CHOICE SERVICES FOSTER'S TOWING & REPAIRS, INC FRASER LAWN CENTER, INC FRASER MANOR LLC CITY OF FRASER FRONTLINE MEDICAL MARK J. FUGOLO GLOWORKS GRAPHIC IMAGE METER READING SYSTEM MAINT OFFICE SUPPLIES ROUTINE MAINTENANCE-LIB 33233 KELLY RD ELECTRIC ELEC-#307 SR HOUSE CITY ELEC BILLS DETROIT WATER ATTORNEY FEES-CT CREDIT RX CHARGES 10/17-10/31/11 PEST CONTROL-SR HOUSE FIRCHO DPW TOWINGS KAWASAKI STARTER/REPLACE ROPE-DPW TAX REFUND CITY WATER BILLS REPAIRS TO GURNEY-PS ATTORNEY FEES-CT TRI-COLOR GLOW NEKLACES-DARE ELECTION TESTING 7.92 65.67 20.00 3,820.50 480.59 4,301.09 481.79 408.34 151.00 256.66 16.94 7,004.74 74,382.46 225.00 57.26 39,869.76 55.00 170.60 775.00 21.56 1,454.68 1,926.93 830.91 175.00 140.00 506.80 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Page: 3/9 Check Date Bank Check Vendor Vendor Name Description Amount 11/10/2011 PNC 105716 HABRIC RICHARD HABERMAN CELL PHONE 40.00 11/10/2011 PNC 105717 HAKMEH HAKIM & MEHANNA PLLC ATTORNEY FEES-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT 200.00 300.00 500.00 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC 105718 105719 HOFLAW HOMDEP LAWRENCE M. HOFMANN HOME DEPOT CREDIT SERVICES MONTHLY BENEFIT PAYMENT MATERIALS & SUPPLIES 175.00 75.72 11/10/2011 PNC 105720 INACOM INACOMP XEROR PAGE PACK COMPUTERS-ASSESSING/BUILDING 11/10/2011 PNC 105721 INGRAM INGRAM LIBRARY SERVICES BOOKS-LIB RETURN BOOKS BOOKS-LIB BOOKS-LIB BOOKS-LIB BOOKS-LIB BOOKS-LIB 11/10/2011 PNC 105722 9999CT JASON ADAM GRAY OVERPAYMENT OF COURT COSTS 11/10/2011 PNC 105723 JOHNTT JOHNSON THERMOL TEMP INC SERV CALL/MAINT/REPAIR-LIB SERV CALL/SWITCH/BOILER-PS SERV CALL/MAINT/FILTER-PS MAINTENANCE-REINDEL PARK STEFFENS PK-MAINT/WIRE/FILTER CITY HALL-MAINT/GREASED BEARING/FILTERS 11/10/2011 PNC 105724 9999SR JOSEPHINE WILKINSON REFUND OF SECURITY DEPOSIT 11/10/2011 PNC 105725 KERALB KERR ALBERT OFFICE SUPPLY CHAIRMAT-MGR RETURN DESK PAD-LIB OFFICE SUPPLIES-LIB 11/10/2011 PNC 105726 KONICA KONICA MINOLTA BUSINESS SOLUTIONS COPY CHARGES-FIRE PS 2.53 11/10/2011 PNC 105727 LESTIR LESLIE TIRE TIRES FOR CAT LOADER TIRES-BACKHOE 4,390.00 2,771.88 7,161.88 11/10/2011 PNC 105728 LOWES LOWE'S BUSINESS ACCT/GEMB MATERIALS & SUPPLIES 59.71 11/10/2011 PNC 105729 LUCMAN LUCIDO & MANZELLA PC ATTORNEY FEES-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT 225.00 300.00 525.00 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105730 105731 105732 105733 105734 105735 MCCA MCPWK MCTRCT MCTRS MCTRS MAIPLU MACOMB COUNTY MACOMB COUNTY MACOMB COUNTY MACOMB COUNTY MACOMB COUNTY MAIL PLUS LUNCHEON-CLERKS JG FOOD POLLUTANT SURCHARGE CO. LIBRARY FEE TAX REFUND TREASURERS MEETING-FIN MAILINGS 46.00 168.29 692.70 95.93 20.00 V 99.60 CLERK'S ASSOCIATION PUBLIC WORKS COMM TREASURER TREASURER TREASURER 448.82 4,244.00 4,692.82 129.73 (29.41) 284.53 73.51 189.01 328.34 21.56 997.27 25.00 318.30 265.50 205.68 37.50 40.32 1,027.34 1,894.64 510.00 89.00 (133.50) 74.97 30.47 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser Page: CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 4/9 Check Date Bank Check Vendor Vendor Name Description Amount 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105736 105737 105738 105739 105740 105741 105742 105743 105744 105745 105746 105747 105748 105749 105750 105751 105752 105753 105754 105755 999FIN MARASS MAVER MCCTIM METMET METMAR MIDNR MACEO MACP MAMC MWCOMP MWCOMP MIRCT MICCEN 9999BB MILGAR MINMIX MOOMED MORCOR NEXTEL MANZO TITLE COMPNAY MARKETING ASSOCIATES MAVERICK ON-SITE FLEET SERV. LLC TIM MCCULLOCH METRY & METRY MARK S. METRY PLC MI DEPT. OF NATURAL RESOURCES & ENV MICH ASSOC/CODE ENFORCEMENT MICHIGAN ASSOC OF CHIEFS OF POLICE MICHIGAN ASSOC. OF MUNICIPAL CLERKS MICHIGAN MUNICIPAL WORKER'S COMP VOID STATE OF MICHIGAN TREASURER MICRO CENTER A/R MILLER MODERNIZATION GARON LUCOW MILLER PC MINI MIX, INC MOORE MEDICAL, LLC LAW OFFICES OF CORA MORGAN NEXTEL CANELLATION FEE REGARDING TITLE SEARCH 1 PG AD-2012 MACOMB CO. MAGAZINE FUEL WATER SEP-S DUMP TRK-DPW MILEAGE OKEMOS-ADV CASH MGT ATTORNEY FEES-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT ANNUAL FEE MACEO MEETING MEMBERSHIP DUES-MACP-PS MAMC MEMBERSHIP-CLK WORKERS COMP 3RD QTR 150.00 1,200.00 276.98 83.25 175.00 175.00 4,137.73 25.00 115.00 100.00 32,495.00 RECEIPT PROCESSING DIVISION COMPUTER SUPPLIES BOND RETURN PERMIT 11-191 ATTORNEY FEES-CT CEMENT HEAD IMMOBILIZER MULTIGRIP ADT ATTORNEY FEES-CT CITY CELL PHONES 17,725.00 35.90 100.00 175.00 1,996.25 285.45 175.00 789.24 11/10/2011 PNC 105756 OFFMAX OFFICEMAX INCORPORATED OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105757 105758 105759 105760 105761 105762 105763 105764 105765 9999BB 999REC PETTYC PIAPAU PBRESE PLAJOS POIAUT PRADIS PRISYS PAUL & MARGARET NOWAK PAULA AGUSTYN PETTY CASH PAUL PIATT PC PITNEY BOWES RESERVE ACCOUNT JOSEPH J. PLAWECKI POINTE AUTO WASH 9YU-PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION INC PRINTING SYSTEMS, INC BOND RETURN PERMIT 11-242 KIDS NIGHT OUT REFUND SUPPLIES FOR ELECTION WORKERS ATTORNEY FEES-CT POSTAGE REFILL ATTORNEY FEES-CT CAR WASHES OXYGEN-PS BALLOTS-ELECTIONS 11/10/2011 PNC 105766 PYKDON DON PYKE SOCET TRAY-DPW TOOTH SFTGRP LNG/HANDLE-DPW 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105767 105768 105769 105770 105771 105772 105773 105774 105775 QMIGRO R&RFIR 999FIN RAYELE REINDE RICDEN RIZZO SCHGRE SERANT QMI GROUP, INC R&R FIRE TRUCK REPAIR, INC RAY CHAPTINI RAY ELECTRIC REINDEL TRUE VALUE DENNIS J. RICKERT PC RIZZO SERVICES GREGORY SCHUELLER ANTHONY SERVITTO SCREEPLATE NAMEBADGES-REC QUARTERLY EQUIPMENT MAINTENANCE-SCBA REFUND OVERPAYMENT ELEC SUPPLIES-YARD MATERIALS & SUPPLIES ATTORNEY FEES-CT REFUSE/RECYCLING/COMPOST ATTORNEY FEE-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT 11/10/2011 PNC 105776 SHEKEN KEN SHEPARD POWERWASH & STAIN FORT FRASER EXT. POWERWASH DIRT FROM CONSTRUCTION 4,875.00 300.00 5,175.00 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC 105777 105778 105779 105780 SHIJAM SOWMIC SPADIS SPEEDC JAMES SHIMKO MICHAELENE SOWINSKI SPARTAN DISTRIBUTORS SPEED CLEAN SERVICE PLUMBING INSPECTIONS ATTORNEY FEE-CT TORO REPAIR EMERGENCY SERV CALL-PS RESTRMS 380.00 175.00 1,007.55 145.37 V SUPPLIES SUPPLIES SUPPLIES SUPPLIES 264.24 107.60 72.99 75.84 520.67 100.00 20.00 48.69 175.00 4,360.00 175.00 103.00 114.05 2,458.98 69.99 150.45 220.44 45.00 135.78 18.38 110.49 892.18 225.00 58,073.81 225.00 250.00 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Page: 5/9 Check Date Bank Check Vendor Vendor Name Description Amount 11/10/2011 PNC 105781 SPEOIL SPENCER OIL COMPANY UNLEADED FUEL DYED DIESEL FUEL 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105782 105783 105784 105785 105786 105787 105788 STAIND SUBFOR SLC SUNMED SUPDEN 999REC TOMLAR STATE INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS SUBURBAN FORD OF STERLING HEIGHTS SLC PROPRIETARY FUND SUNSHINE MEDICAL SUPPLY, INC SUPPLY DEN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY CLUB LARRY TOMLINSON SPECIAL PURPOSE WAX-DPW REPAIRS TO BATTERY PS CAR #31 LEXMARK TONER-LIB AMBULANCE SUPPLIES KITCHEN PLASTIC PRODUCTS 25% DEPOSIT ACCT #8-45315 ATTORNEY FEES-CT 185.44 580.45 253.31 167.00 61.75 163.88 75.00 11/10/2011 PNC 105789 TRACT TRACTION-GENUINE PARTS CO FULL-FLOW LUBE SPIN ON PANEL AIR ELEMENT LEAFER STARTER 24.72 61.26 164.67 250.65 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105790 105791 105792 105793 105794 105795 105796 TRAROY TRIINS 999FIN UNIAUT 999FIN VANJUS VANROB ROY TRANSIT TRIDENT INSURANCE SERVICES TRIO PARTNERS LLC UNITED AUTO PARTS USPS JUSTIN D. VANDE VREDE ROBERT J. VANHOUTTE ATTORNEY FEES-CT MALICIOUS PROSECUTION-LEGENZOFF TAX REFUND AUTO PARTS CHK/RETURN CK FEE ATTORNEY FEE-CT ATTORNEY FEES-CT 11/10/2011 PNC 105797 WINPOL WINDER POLICE EQUIPMENT BADGES-PS BADGES-PS 196.88 25.03 221.91 11/10/2011 PNC 105798 WOLRON RONALD WOLBER MONTHLY BENEFIT PAYMENT 225.00 11/10/2011 PNC 105799 WOLFRE WOLVERINE FREIGHTLINER-EASTSIDE ANTI FREEZE FOR VEHICLES-DPW SEWER LIFT STATIONS FOR PUMPS SENSOR GP/SEAL-O-RING 606.23 492.01 353.74 1,451.98 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/10/2011 11/16/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105800 105801 105802 105803 105804 105805 105806 105807 WOOPHY WOWCAB XPEDX YOUBOB ZYBPAU 999FIN DATVOI 360SER PHYLLIS WOOD WOW INTERNET-CABLE-PHONE XPEDX STORES BOB YOUNGBLOOD PAUL F. ZYBURSKI MACOMB COUNTY TRASURER'S ASSOC. DATA AND VOICE SERVICES 360 SERVICES, INC ATTORNEY FEES-CT CABLE/INTERNET-CENTER GOES CERT BLU -MGR ELECTRICAL INSPECTION ATTORNEY FEES-CT NOV 2011 MEETING-MCCULLOCH/POMPO VOICE MAIL SYSTEM POSTAGE 237.50 93.29 20.39 711.00 175.00 20.00 2,250.00 2,272.87 11/23/2011 PNC 105808 39THRS 39TH DISTRICT COURT ROSEVILLE NON REPORTING FEES-CT NON REPORTING FEES-CT NON-REPORTING PROB FEES-CT 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC 105809 105810 ABCWAR ABRGAF ABC WAREHOUSE ABRAHAM & GAFFNEY, P.C. WASHER/DRYERS-SR HOUSE AUDIT FIELD WORK-FIN 11/23/2011 PNC 105811 ABSWAT ABSOPURE WATER COMPANY MONTHLY ADMIN. CHARGE-LIB 5 GAL/ BOTTLE DEPOSIT-LIB C&C COOLER-LIB 4,597.16 2,429.56 7,026.72 125.00 4,475.40 1,673.20 230.67 45.00 175.00 175.00 250.00 150.00 250.00 650.00 918.00 5,000.00 1.55 13.90 8.00 23.45 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Page: 6/9 Check Date Bank Check Vendor Vendor Name Description Amount 11/23/2011 PNC 105812 ADTSEC ADT SECURITY SERVICES INC. PRO-RATED CHARGES 11/23/2011 PNC 105813 AEW ANDERSON, ECKSTEIN & WESTRICK, INC NPDES PHASE II PERMIT HAYES MASONIC SANITARY INTERCEPTOR GENERAL-DPW HMSI PROJECT PERMIOMANCE CERT 2011 S2 GRANT APPLICATION 950.00 1,531.50 810.00 3,023.70 436.50 6,751.70 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC 105814 105815 105816 105817 AISCON ABPA ARGHAZ AUDIO INTERSTATE BILLING SERVICE AMERICAN BACKFLOW PREVENTION ASSOC. ARGUS-HAZCO AUDIO SENTRY CORPORATION REPAIR STARTER ON BACKHOE-DPW YRLY MEMBERSHIP FEE-DPW SURVIVAIR REPAIR-PS FIRE ALARM CONTROL PANEL-SR HOUSE 1,431.37 97.00 106.20 135.00 11/23/2011 PNC 105818 AUTMOT AUTOMOTIVE ENHANCERS, INC TRANS FLUSH KIT-06 CHEVY SILVERADO-DPW EMERG. LIGHTS-07 CROWN VIC-PS 891.95 86.70 978.65 11/23/2011 PNC 105819 BARPAV BARRETT PAVING MATERIALS INC UPM UPM 134.33 283.81 418.14 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105820 105821 105822 105823 105824 105825 105826 105827 105828 105829 105830 105831 105832 105833 BEABRO BELEQU BLNET BC003 BC005 BC900 BC902 BC903 BC905 BOUTRE BSNSPO COPSPL CAMREN 999FIN BEAN BROS. TROPHY & AWARD BELL EQUIPMENT COMPANY BLUE CARE NETWORK BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN BOUND TREE MEDICAL SPORT SUPPLY GROUP, INC C.O.P.S. HEALTH TRUST PLAN RENEE CAMPION CBS BORING GOLD BACK PLATE/ENGRAVING-COUNCIL LEAF MACHINE REPAIR BC NETWORK HEALTH CARE CURRENT EMPLOYEE HEALTH CARE CURRENT EMPLOYEE HEALTH CARE RETIREE HEALTH CARE RETIREE HEALTH CARE RETIREE HEALTH CARE RETIREE HEALTH CARE GLUCOSE TEST STRIPS/BAG VALVE MASK-PS NETTING FOR BASEBALL DIAMONDS-PKS POLC HEALT/VISION INSURANCE DISPLAY EASELS-DARE OVERPAYMENT 11/23/2011 PNC 105834 CINTAS CINTAS CORPORATION #354 FLOOR MATS/SUPPPLIES-CENTER FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-C.H. FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-SR HOUSING FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-LIB FLOOR MATS/SUPPLIES-DPW LINERS/PULL TOWELS-C.H. 11/23/2011 PNC 105835 CINFIR CINTAS FIRST AID & SAFETY FIRST AID SUPPLIES-DPW 22.04 11/23/2011 PNC 105836 CONCEN OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH CENTERS FLU SHOT-HABERMAN-MGR NEW HIRE PHYSICALS-DPW 25.00 251.00 276.00 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105837 105838 105839 105840 105841 105842 105843 CONPRI CRUISE 9999BB DATVOI DELDEN DTEENG 999FIN CONCEPT PRINTING SYSTEMS, INC CRUISERS CUSTOMKRAFT HOME IMPROVEMENTS DATA AND VOICE SERVICES DELTA DENTAL OF MICHIGAN DETROIT ENERGY DIVERSIFIED PROPERTY SOLUTIONS LLC LETTERHEAD-CT REPAIRS-2010 CROWN VIC-PS BOND RETURN PERMIT 11-195 RE-RECORD COURT GREETING DENTAL BENEFITS CITY ELECTRIC BILLS REFUND FOR SUMMER TAXES 233.10 33.80 3,152.84 13,848.07 2,685.39 48,565.89 52,602.09 8,332.70 1,779.42 6.36 259.80 1,999.75 21,504.44 51.91 2,984.40 141.50 386.38 147.70 98.02 375.18 636.00 1,784.78 98.30 240.00 100.00 115.00 12,368.00 1,892.16 16,639.24 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Page: 7/9 Check Date Bank Check Vendor Vendor Name Description 11/23/2011 PNC 105844 DOLJAN JANET DOLLAND HOLIDAY APPETIZERS-LIB 11/23/2011 PNC 105845 E-SHRE E-SHRED SHREDDING-COURT SHREDDING-PS 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC 105846 105847 9999SR FIREXT ELSIE DAYNEY FIRE EXTINGUISHER SALES & SERVICE REFUND SECURITY DEPOSIT FOR #318-SR HOU FIRE EXT RECHARGE & TAG-PS 11/23/2011 PNC 105848 FRAUBO FRASER AUTO BODY, INC REPAIR 2010 CHARGER-PS GLASS LAWN MOWER TRACTOR DOOR-DPW REPAIRS-2010 CROWN VIC-PS 961.55 200.00 517.20 1,678.75 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105849 105850 105851 105852 105853 999FIN FRALIB 999LIB 999FIN 999FIN FRASER BLDG. ASSOCIATES LLC & FRASER PUBLIC LIBRARY FRASER PUBLIC SCHOOLS GARFIELD PROPERTY MANAGEMENT & GPN-72 LLC REFUND SUMMER TAXES MATERIALS AND SUPPLIES BOOKMARKS & MEMO PADS-LIB REFUND TAXES REFUND SUMMER TAXES 9,577.81 124.02 99.00 593.15 3,132.14 11/23/2011 PNC 105854 GUNMET GUNNERS METERS & PARTS, INC 3/4" WATER METERS ARB METER READING GUN 1,700.00 1,100.00 2,800.00 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105855 105856 105857 105858 105859 105860 HALFIR 999FIN HARCOM HDSWW HEBSAR INDNEW HALT FIRE HANOVER GROVE CO-OP & HOFFERT HARRIS COMPUTER SYSTEMS HD SUPPLY WATERWORKS, LTD SARAH HEBERT INDEPENDENT NEWS, INC MOBILE REPAIR LABOR-AIR COMP-PS MTT #277142 TAX REFUNDS SPECTRUM ONSITE SUPPORT-REC 10-CLAMPS-WTR MILEAGE-COURT LEGAL ADS 352.00 9,106.87 850.80 1,200.00 55.50 324.45 11/23/2011 PNC 105861 INGRAM INGRAM LIBRARY SERVICES RETURN BOOKS-LIB BOOKS-LIB BOOKS-LIB 11/23/2011 PNC 105862 JOHNTT JOHNSON THERMOL TEMP INC SERV SERV SERV SERV SERV SERV 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC 105863 105864 105865 KACKAT 9999BB KLOCHR KATHY KACANOWSKI KEITH D. MAIER CHRIS KLOSKI SWEARING IN SEREMONEY SUPPLIES BOND RETURN PERMIT 11-202 OLIVE THE OTHER REINDEER-LIB 11/23/2011 PNC 105866 KONICA KONICA MINOLTA BUSINESS SOLUTIONS COPY CHAGES-DPW COPY CHARGES-CT 11/23/2011 PNC 105867 L3COMM L-3 COMMUNICATIONS MOBILE-VISION KEY USB-PS 413.50 11/23/2011 PNC 105868 LABSAF LAB SAFETY SUPPLY FIRE BT INSULTD BUNKER-PS FIRE BT INSULTD BUNKER-PS 181.32 288.58 469.90 CALL/ADJUST SET PT-C.H. CALL/FILTERS/MAINT-CENTER CALL/BEARINGS/BELT ETC-LIB CALL/MAINT/FILTERS-SR HOUSE CALL/NO HEAT-SRHOUSE #307 CALL/DEFECTIVE INDUCER MTR-CENTER Amount 200.00 40.00 50.00 90.00 490.00 20.80 (45.00) 36.22 242.21 233.43 187.50 639.70 677.00 161.28 2,807.50 3,301.50 7,774.48 91.51 100.00 150.00 6.13 25.21 31.34 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Page: 8/9 Check Date Bank Check Vendor Vendor Name Description 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105869 105870 105871 105872 105873 105874 105875 105876 105877 105878 105879 105880 105881 105882 9999BB LEBRO MCROAD MCFIN MCPWK 999FIN MAJGRA MEIJER MELSTE MIREC MTCTRE MRPITA NANJAC OCC LAWRENCE DEMONACO LEBRO CHEMICAL COMPANY MACOMB COUNTY DEPARTMEMT OF ROADS MACOMB COUNTY FINANCE DEPARTMENT MACOMB COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS COMM MACOMB COUNTY TREASURER MAJIK GRAPHICS INC MEIJER STEVE MELLING MICHIGAN REC. & PARK ASSOC. MOUNT CLEMENS TREE SERVICE INC MR. PITA JACQUELINE G. NANNI OAKLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE BOND RETURN PERMIT 11-225 ICE MELTING COMPOUND-DPW TRAFFIC SIGNAL MAINTENANCE PAPER ORDER IWC CHARGES-OCTOBER 2011 OVER PAYMENT TAXES GRAPHICS-WTR DEPT/ASSESSING SHOP W/ A HERO AT MEIJER SANTA CLAUS-LIB MRPA INDIVIDUAL MEMBERSHIP GROUND 4 STUMPS FOOD SWEARING IN CEREMONY 11/21/11 ATTORNEY FEES-CT TRAINING-PS 11/23/2011 PNC 105883 OFFMAX OFFICEMAX INCORPORATED OFFICE SUPPLIES OFFICE SUPPLIES 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC 105884 105885 PBEASY PBRENT EASYPERMIT POSTAGE PITNEY BOWES POSTAGE PAID REATAL CHARGES 1,567.71 612.00 11/23/2011 PNC 105886 RAYELE RAY ELECTRIC ELEC ELEC ELEC ELEC ELEC ELEC ELEC 323.26 57.48 750.75 178.39 356.78 61.38 349.15 2,077.19 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105887 105888 105889 105890 105891 105892 105893 105894 RICDOR 999FIN ROYOBR SHEKEN SPEEDC TERMIN 9999BB WHOTRE DOREEN RICE ROBERT & RITA CUBBA ROY O'BRIEN, INC KEN SHEPARD SPEED CLEAN SERVICE TERMINIX TMC CONSTRUCTION WHOLESALE TREES, INC MRS. CLAUS-LIB REFUND ON TAXES FOCUS FLOOR MATS-DPW BATHROOM PAINTING-CITY HALL POWER WASH/SANITIZE JAIL CELL PEST CONTROLL BOND RETURN PERMIT 11-246 ACER RUBRUM RED SUNSET TREES-PKS 100.00 166.06 227.58 495.00 575.00 222.00 100.00 420.00 11/23/2011 PNC 105895 WINPOL WINDER POLICE EQUIPMENT BADGES-PS BADGES-CLOTH BARS-PS COLLAR BRASS-PS 66.19 108.34 22.51 197.04 11/23/2011 PNC 105896 WOLFRE WOLVERINE FREIGHTLINER-EASTSIDE REPAIRS-DUMPTRK #10 375.68 11/23/2011 PNC 105897 WOWCAB WOW INTERNET-CABLE-PHONE CABLE/INTERNET-DPW CABLE/INTERNET CABLE/INTERNET-CITY HALL 94.92 81.68 77.50 254.10 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 11/23/2011 PNC PNC PNC PNC PNC 105898 105899 105900 53(E) 54(E) WRIMAR XEROX YORDOL CONENG SBC MARILYNN WRIGHT XEROX CORPORATION YORK, DOLAN & TOMLINSON, P.C. CONSUMERS ENERGY SBC POSTAGE-LIB BASE CHG COPIES-LIB LEGAL SERVICES CITY GAS BILLS CITY PHONE BILLS' PNC TOTAL of 249 Non-Void Checks: SUPPLIES-PS SUPPLIES DPW SUPPLIES-BARN SUPPLIES-BARN SUPPLIES-BARN SUPPLIES-BLOSSOM STREET SUPPLIES-PS Amount 100.00 504.15 764.10 275.83 10,952.66 402.23 580.00 500.00 200.00 115.00 100.00 323.36 175.00 350.00 156.05 (23.24) 132.81 44.00 26.69 11,214.00 1,002.83 3,519.55 725,536.31 12/01/2011 10:03 AM User: TONI DB: Fraser Check Date Bank CHECK REGISTER FOR CITY OF FRASER CHECK DATE FROM 11/01/2011 - 11/30/2011 Check PNC TOTAL of 2 Void Checks: PNC TOTAL - 251 Checks: Vendor Vendor Name Description Page: 9/9 Amount 20.00 725,556.31 City of Fraser MAYOR CENTENNIAL COMMUNITY Doug Hagerty COUNCIL Dan Accavitti, Mayor Pro-tem William A. Morelli, Acting Mayor CITY MANAGER Kathy A. Blanke Michael C. Carnagie Richard Haberman Paul A. Cilluffo Barbara L. Jennings MEMORANDUM TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council FROM: Toni Misch, Accounts Payable DATE: December 1, 2011 RE: Accounts Payable PAYMENT OF CHECKS DATED AMOUNT The month of November 2011 $725,556.31 33000 Garfield ● Fraser, Michigan 48026 ● (586) 293-3102 ● Fax: (586) 293-7470 ● www.fraser.govoffice.com Fraser Public Library Board Minutes of Monday, October 10, 2011 Meeting convened: 7:00 p.m. by Nancy Ehrke. Attendance: Jean Slivka, Director; Mitzi De Santis; Nancy Ehrke; Tina Bullis; and Dee Laramie. Absent: Linda Champion (excused) & Bill Kelley (unexcused). Agenda approval: The agenda was approved on a motion made by Nancy, seconded by Dee. Motion carried. Approval of minutes: Motion to approve the minutes was made by Nancy, seconded by Dee. Motion carried. Secretary’s Report: None Treasurer’s Report: We spent $4,993.14 on processing and office supplies, books and materials, programs and membership dues. Chairperson’s Report: None Director’s Report Jean Slivka reported on the following items: • The luncheon was well liked by all. Compliments to restaurant, Jan Dolland, Donna Mylenek and all the friends. Decorations were simple and attractive. It will be hard to top. Many political people showed. One hundred seven tickets were sold. Mayor Moe Geromette made a donation to the Friends of Library. • Statistics for September: Reference, 1,120; Internet, 960; Door, 6,190; Circulation Desk, 2,049; New Users, 68; Materials Circulation, 8,850; Holds Sent, 918; Mel Cat, 153; EBooks Users, 29; Acquisitions, 237 (Adult 113, Juvenile 51, DVDs 73); & Internet Fees $16. • Library card month was not seen by many on cable, was on the website. • C & G paper has new reporter to represent us. • Mitzi cannot hold supervisor position since she is in the union. She will no longer have the title. • Chocolate basket for Fraser Historical Commission Dinner to be held on Wednesday, October 12, 2011 t 6:30 p.m. was donated by the library. • Donation was sent to Nancy from Ron & Vicki Kirkman in memory of Susan Vickers, Nolan B and Josephine Kirkman. Jean will send a thank you letter. • Unique Management: We collected $3,112.97 and $1,212.65 worth of materials was returned. • The City Manager has sent a letter stating all inquiries for any outside contracts must be approved by him. • EBooks: 29 people have been on EBooks in September. Kindles are now on EBooks. We have $2,700 each month to pick books. Different libraries make the selection of books. • The Christmas Party will be held on December 11, 2011 at 3:00 p.m. upstairs. Friends will be invited to join the party. Name tags suggested for all. • The white elephant /book sale items are being priced. Nancy Ehrke and Mary Koch are pricing. • • • • • • • • • Twenty-two people joined the psychic event. The folk singers were well liked. Seniors were singing along. The Cat in the Hat Suessical was fun. They may come back this spring. The Detroit Opera House called to offer library programs for hit tunes. The joy, wonder and fun of mathematics by Bill Hart for ages 8 and up with parents coming. SLC –Warren Arthur Miller branch and Troy may open on Sundays. Roseville Library will become PA 164 Library at the end of December. They have no more money to run this library Bill made two used book sale signs from PVC at no charge. They are very nice, “A” frame style and can be reused. The Library for the Blind and Physically Handicapped will no longer be on Hall Road. Clinton-Macomb will have it in their former gift shop. The library on Hall Road will close mid-October. Large type books will be integrated into the Clinton-Macomb collection. It will be free of charge. Ken Lamparr is the new administrator of the Macomb Literacy Program. It will remain in the Wayne State Building. Legislature wants to filter all library internets. House bill #4890 amends Act 455 of Library privacy. Look to state representatives for help in stopping this bill by Tom Hooker. Friends have been having regular meetings. Donna and her husband have been taking care of the sign. Joan Bernacik did the flower boxes. The friends will decorate our Christmas tree. Library will look for a new one, possibly one that has lights already strung onto it. Last state aid check came in A new DVD drop box will be paid for by trust fund. Looking to buy one to hold 85 DVDs, CDs and Books on CD. Old Business: None New Business: None Audience Participation: None Adjournment: On a motion made by Dee, seconded by Tina, the Board adjourned at 8:35 p.m. Next Meeting: Monday, November 14, 2011, at 7 p.m., at the library. Respectfully submitted, Tina Bullis, Trustee Fraser Historical Commission Minutes Monday, August 29, 2011 Present: Joe Chimenti; Harry Hodgson; Nancy Ehrke; Jean Slivka (liaison); Dori Guoin (memberat-large); Linda Champion; Marilynn Wright; : Bob Buffa; Dee Laramie; Donald Coveny; & Beverly Kucharski Excused Absence: Betty Slominski (arrived at end of meeting) 1. Call to order at 7:00 p.m. by Marilynn. 2. Approve Agenda: Linda made the motion, seconded by Dee. The motion carried. 3. Minutes were approved on a motion by Nancy, & seconded by Don. Motion carried. 4. Liaison report: Jean was emailed about the tree & acted upon it immediately. The sign has a $1,000 deductible on it from the insurance company. BJ thinks he can repair it. The delivery of the wood chips was made (Betty wanted them). Jean has asked for a copier, which we may, or may not, get. The City information has to be deleted, which is expensive to do. 5a) Bookmarks: Linda mocked up 4 on a page bookmarks, took corrections/suggestions, and will make these changes. Both Dori & Joe said they’d take new pictures of the House as well as pictures of the Barn & get to Linda so she can put these newer ones on the bookmark. 5b) Donations: Don said that all businesses are hurting, financially, but has sent 6 letters. He also requested food donations, to no avail so far. 5c) Storage Area Project: Joe talked more with Bob about this project. He really had nothing more to add to our previous discussion. The Society has money available, so if we asked it we could build the 8 x 18 structure. We will do this project next spring. 5d) Flea Market: Bob or Joe will set up the signs. Linda will purchase the 2 dozen doughnuts, none w/glaze, per Beverly. We have 29 sold spots. We need volunteer help to put items in the Depot out on our tables. Jean has 4 tents (or Joe can get 2). Tents will be used for Xmas, hot dogs, diners, & the book tent; possibly for glassware. Vince will come for 4 hours. Parks & Rec have tents. Jean will submit a requisition for them. Joe mentioned about having a $2/bag sale during the last hour we’re open. We will do this. Don will get the bags, but only the Barn & Book Tents will be available for this special $2 sale. Jean will make signs stating this. 6a) October Open House: The date is October 2. Dori hired the blacksmith & rope/broom maker. The cost for these 2 craftsmen is $30/per man for the 3 hours. They will sell their wares. Dori will advertise & get it on Fraser’s electronic bulletin board. Linda suggested making it a Civil War event. 6b) Elections Next Month: Since Lori Bargowski had to leave the Commission, we need a corresponding secretary. 7. Commissioners’ Reports: Marilynn asked Commissioners to bring their money or unsold Dinner Show tickets to the October meeting or at the Flea Market on 9/11/11. At the last Open House, the Barn & Museums Sales made $102.78; Gift Store, $61; & a $100 donation from Sandy Caloia. Barb Jennings will be at the Flea Market at Noon to start relieving people for lunch breaks. Harry got the weed killer flyer for Betty to see. Betty said she will have lots of plants for sale at the Flea Market. She will have hostas planted at the Museum. David will attend the Flea Market. Adjourned at 8:15 p.m. on a motion from Nancy, seconded by Dee. Motion carried. Next meeting: Monday, October 3, 2011, at 7:00 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Linda S. Champion, Recording Secretary LSC:9/10/11;amd.9/23/11 Fraser Historical Commission Minutes Monday, October 3, 2011 Present: Joe Chimenti; Harry Hodgson; Nancy Ehrke; Dori Guoin (member-at-large); Linda Champion; Marilynn Wright; : Bob Buffa; Dee Laramie; Betty Slominski; Donald Coveny; & Beverly Kucharski Excused Absence: Jean Slivka (liaison) 1. Call to order at 7:00 p.m. by Marilynn. 2. Approve Agenda: Linda made the motion, seconded by Don. The motion carried. 3. Minutes were tabled, to be approved at next month’s meeting, since Linda forgot to bring print copies of them. 4. Liaison report: None. 5a) Barn Sale/Flea Market: Nancy liked the bag sale, but didn’t hear the announcement telling about it. Joe said the way the bag sale was handled will have to be tweaked for next time, as there were some problems. Beverly wanted to know how the popcorn sales did. Betty said if people could have smelled it, it would have sold better. We’ll check into it for next year. The net profit came to $1,140.97, compared to June, 2011, sales of $1,124, & September, 2010, of $1,173 (the profit was higher in 2010 because Don was able to get the food donated, which we had to pay for it in 9/11). 5b) Donations: Don sent letters to both Sander Levin & Carl Levin. Sander Levin responded about federal grants. He said he would write a supportive recommendation letter once we knew the grant for which we wanted to apply & then wrote it. New federal grants become available to write in February, 2012. The Gates Foundation doesn’t fund organizations such as ours, just educational ones. Don has not checked into State grants. 5c) Elections: The new or re-elected officers for the Commission are as follows: Chair, Marilynn Wright; Joe Chimenti, Vice-Chair; Linda Champion, Recording Secretary; & Beverly Kucharski, Corresponding Secretary. All positions were nominated, seconded, & approved by the Commission. 6a) Dinner Show: The “Frank Sinatra” impersonator is giving Marilynn a list of other impersonators at the Show so we can see who else we may want to hire for next year. Black buckets will be used for the drawing tickets. The schedule for this event is as follows: 6:30, dinner; 7:30-8:15, entertainment; 8:15-8:45, prize announcements; & 8:45-9:45, entertainment. Linda will take tickets; Don will sell 50/50 tickets near the door; Joe will count money (Linda will help if he needs it), as well as selling tickets & being our MC; Nancy will make the gift announcements; Betty will scotch tape the winning number on the gift & put it on the prize table; & Beverly will monitor the prize table, checking the winner’s number against the prize s/he takes. Dee, with Marilynn, will do the Silent Auction. Dori will help Catherine Huetter at the Chinese Auction table. Harry will count the raffle tickets into strips of 20 & tear them, as well as counting the number of guests at each table for which we will have to pay. Bob will help with this task for the buckets. Marilynn asked for volunteers to wrap prizes. Nancy, Dee, Dori, & Marilynn volunteered to do this. 6b) Christmas Resale: Nancy & Dee volunteered to set this up. 6c) Duties: The following Commissioners volunteered to take on these added responsibilities: Website Monitoring, Dori (to update it, we have to go through Jean at the Library to ask City Hall to make our changes); Paver Brick Orders, Linda (who has been doing so since Lori Bargowski was not reappointed); Housekeeping, No One—we will wing it. On Wednesday, 10/19/11, Betty, Dee, Nancy & brother, John, will pack up items from the Barn to donate to the St. John rummage sale. No Christmas items or House goods will be included in the donation. They will meet at the property by 10-10:30 a.m. Betty said the picnic tables should be moved closer to the Barn, which will help make it easier to do this project. Harry volunteered to do so. The pump board is loose & needs cleaning, with the board re-nailed. Harry will take on this task, too. 7. Commissioners’ Reports: Marilynn reported that we made $31, Barn; $73, House, & $8.50, Gift Shop at the Open House on 10/2/11. After Linda corrected the bookmarks, Marilynn sent them to the printer, who said he can’t do them in color, so the 2 pictures will be in black & white. They, along with our notepads, should be to us by 10/10. The Baumgartner sign is covered by the City’s insurance, with a $1,000 deductible. The sign will cost $1,900, so $900 of that will be paid for by us. Master Gardener Kurt Kleinert made a donation of $100 & Vania Apps, $100, & then another $50 in honor of Betty & Al Slominski’s 50th wedding anniversary. We donated 2 dozen doughnuts to the DPW for a yearly thank-you for their help, we bought 2 mum plants from the Fraser First Booster Club (Nancy will plant them), & the Library took items from us for its November White Elephant Sale. Joe talked about Lori Bargowski’s reappointment to the th Commission. We need to fill that 11 position, & Lori has reapplied. A letter was drafted by the Commission asking the Mayor & City Council to reappoint her. After Joe read the letter, it was sent around the table for the Commissioners to sign. Dee apologized for forgetting about the Open House yesterday (as did Harry). Linda ordered another paver brick. Harry said he has paver sand. Linda also re-edited & abridged “The History of Fraser,” as originally researched & written by former Fraser Library Director, Barbara Myers. Nancy talked about the Fraser History Project, saying the Committee has gotten 10 Chapter Titles, a few which have been taken by members to write. It’s going, but slowly. Betty announced that the Gardeners are working in the Garden this Thursday, if anyone would like to join them. Adjourned at 8:13 p.m. on a motion from Linda. Next meeting: Monday, November 7, 2011, at 7:00 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Linda S. Champion, Recording Secretary LSC:10/4/11;amended11/6/11&11/8/11 CITY OF FRASER Employment Agreement EFFECTIVE DATE: Name: Classification: Title/Position: Richard Haberman Non-Union Status, Management City Manager 1. Health Benefits The City will continue to provide health insurance and dental insurance as currently provided to Management Employees. Notwithstanding, Haberman shall be subject to provisions of SB7 as enacted by the City of Fraser effective January 1, 2012. 2. Life Insurance The City will provide a term life insurance policy in the amount of $50,000 with premium paid by the employer throughout his employment with the City of Fraser. The term policy is to allow for conversion by Haberman upon his separation of employment if he so chooses. 3. Pension Mr. Haberman is permitted to participate in the City of Fraser ICMA-RC 457 Deferred Compensation Plan. The City will match Haberman’s contributions up to 8%. 4. Vacation The City will provide Mr. Haberman four (4) weeks paid vacation each year. Vacation time will be credited upon each anniversary of employment. Vacation time not used shall be allowed to roll over and accumulate. The City will compensate Haberman for any unused vacation time upon separation from employment. 5. Sick Leave Mr. Haberman will be provided up to 12 days per year of sick leave. Any unused sick leave may roll over to the following year; however, there will be no payout of any sick leave accumulated upon separation from City employment. Haberman shall have access to a bank of 90 sick days to be used in the case of serious medical conditions. This leave can be used to provide coverage during the waiting period between the onset of illness or disability and the point at which short or long term disability insurance coverage takes effect and may be renewed after each occurrence. Haberman Employment Agreement -1- Page 2. 6. Vehicle Allowance Mr. Haberman will be provided $500 per month in lieu of a city-owned vehicle for his use. Haberman is responsible for all vehicle related expenses including insurance sufficient and with terms to meet the requirements set forth by the City’s liability carrier. It is understood that all city related business travel within the State of Michigan will be done with a personal vehicle provided by Mr. Haberman. 7. Worker’s Compensation Insurance Should Mr. Haberman become injured or incapacitated in the discharge of his duties he shall receive such pay for injuries as provided under Michigan’s Workers Compensation. In addition to the minimum amount required by the Law, the City shall pay an additional sum not to exceed the difference between the Haberman’s regular salary and the amount of compensation. In the event the Haberman receives a lump sum payment, it shall be treated as if weekly compensation had been received and paid out as above. Haberman’s return to work after injuries incurred on duty or off duty shall require he is capable of performing their assigned duties. This agreement is not intended to extend Worker’s Compensation benefits beyond those allowable by law nor for any time after Haberman’s separation from employment from the City. 8. Holidays (13 Per Year as follows) New Year’s Day President’s Day Good Friday Memorial Day Fourth of July Labor Day Veteran’s Day Thanksgiving Day Day after Thanksgiving Day Christmas Eve Day Christmas Day New Year’s Eve Day Birthday or Date of Hire 9. Funeral Leave Mr. Haberman shall be entitled to leave with pay in the following cases without charge to other paid time off. 1. Death in the immediate family of the Haberman and/or his spouse for a period not exceeding five (5) working days. Immediate family shall mean mother, father, brothers, sisters, child, wife, husband, grandparent, grandchild, stepmother, stepfather, and mother in law and father in law. 2. Death of other relatives or members of the household or Significant other, for a period of not exceeding one (1) day. Haberman Employment Agreement -2- Page 3 3. In the event that the funeral leave provision is applicable Haberman shall suffer no reduction in compensation and/or time off which he or she otherwise would have received but for utilization of the funeral leave provision. 10. Compensatory Hours This position shall not accumulate compensatory time for any hours worked beyond the required 40 hours per week for any additional time worked for attending meetings or any other required activities. 11. Starting salary The starting salary for Mr. Haberman under this agreement will be $90,000 per year. Mr. Haberman will be evaluated by the City Council on an annual basis commencing on the anniversary date of the execution of this agreement, and increases may be approved by the City Council. 12. Separation The term of this agreement is three (3) years from the date of execution. If the Employee is terminated or forced to resign, the Employer shall provide a minimum severance payment equal to eight months salary at the current rate of pay. This severance shall be paid in a lump sum unless otherwise agreed to by the Employer and the Employee. Haberman shall also be compensated for all accrued vacation time, all paid holidays, and executive leave, if any. The City agrees to make a contribution to the Employee’s deferred compensation account on the value of this compensation calculated using the rate ordinarily contributed on regular compensation. For a minimum period of eight months following termination, the Employer shall pay the cost to continue the following benefits: 1. Health insurance for the Haberman as provided in Section 1 above. 2. Life insurance as provided in Section 2 above. 3. Disability as provided in Section 5. 4. Vehicle allowance as provided in Section 6 above. If the Haberman is terminated because of a conviction of a felony, then the City is not obligated to pay severance under this section. Haberman Employment Agreement -3- 13. Authorized Signature & Effective Date Effective Date of Agreement Authorized Signature Name & Title Maurice Geromette, Mayor Haberman Signature Richard E. Haberman, City Manager Haberman Employment Agreement -4- City of Fraser City Hall Municipal Complex 33000 Garfield Road Fraser, MI 48026 2012 CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS Held the second Thursday of each month in the Council Chambers at 7:30 p.m. JANUARY 12 FEBRUARY 9 MARCH 8 APRIL 12 MAY 10 JUNE 14 JULY 12 AUGUST 9 SEPTEMBER 13 OCTOBER 11 NOVEMBER 8 DECEMBER 13 Pension Update: DEFINITIONS Defined Benefit: A pension benefit that is clearly defined often based on earnings, time of service and certain other factors to calculate the pension amount. The employer is obligated for the full term of the retirement to ensure the benefit is paid. Defined Contribution: A pension benefit in which the employer either matches an employee contribution or provides a specific annual contribution usually using a 401 or 457 plan as the pension vehicle and the employee chooses the distribution method for his/her retirement. After retirement the employer has no further liability. ARC: Annual required contribution, which is a combination of employer/employee contributions. In the case of Fraser it is currently $1.77 million. UAL: Excess of actuarial accrued liability over the actuarial value of the pension fund assets. In the case of Fraser that ratio is 57%. * *These numbers are based on several assumptions. First, annual earnings as assumed to have an average investment gain of 8% per year. In calculating the liability the assumptions are annual inflation at 5% and employee earnings increase at the same 5%. Finally, these numbers are calculated based on a 29year time period. Smoothing techniques are actuarial way of removing the volatility in the investment markets with the intent of stabilizing ARC. This is done by recognizing only a portion of the investment loss or gain for the current and prior years in any given year. Fraser uses a five-year smoothing. FAC: Final Average Compensation. In Fraser this is calculated using the final five years of employment, except Public Safety Command which uses the highest three of the last five year to arrive at this figure. Multiplier: This a percentage used to multiply the FAC for the purposes of arriving at the final compensation amount used to determine the final pension due the retiree. For all employees in Fraser this multiplier ranges from 2.5 - 2.75%. Years of Service: This varies from 10 to 25 years for employees in the City. Final Pension Amount: The final pension calculation is the product of the FAC X Multiplier X Years of Service. Spiking: A term used to describe the process wherein employees can significantly increase their FAC by adding in overtime, special pays and other compensation in the last few years of employment to inflate their final pension amount. Currently the employee group with the greatest impact on the pension system is FPS. COLA: Cost of Living Adjustment. Currently the only employee group that has a COLA in their Union Contract is the Public Safety POAM group and the COLA adjustment is 10% after 5 yrs retirement and 10% after ten yrs retirement. Pension Update: NARRATIVE The City of Fraser has a consolidated defined benefit pension plan that is made up of 6 specific employee groups. There is some differences with respect to employee contributions, how benefits are calculated and additional post retirement benefits. Since 2009 the City has been moving away from this plan substituting a Defined Contribution plan for all new employees. 47% of all public pension funds in the US have a 60-69% UAL. The City of Fraser currently has a 57% UAL. However, even the worse pension plans, such as Providence, RI and Pittsburg, PA at 34% can be corrected with as little as a 2% increase in annual funding. While the UAL is determined on a 25-30 year cycle, liabilities often exceed this cycle time by many years. For example, using standard mortality tables some of the retirees in 2010 are expected to be receiving their benefit for 35 years. As a result a small change in contribution or limiting benefits this year will have a significant impact over time. At 2% you will double your money every 36 years, at 5% 14.4 years and every 9 years at 8%. The UAL is an important number as it provides an equal measure for all pension plans making it easier for pension managers to determine the relative health of their specific plan. However, it is a limited measure in that it is the assumptions that have a significant impact on the outcome and without those assumptions you can run the risk of reacting to a perceived problem. In Fraser, our UAL is based on the assumption that salaries are increasing 4-5% and inflation will increase at the rate of 5%. Finally, the current assets are presumed to be earning 8% per year. Given the City has not experienced inflation at 5% in more than 20 years and wage increases have been less than 3% for over a decade, we know the liability is overstated. The City of Fraser has a steady history, as has most pension plans in the US of earnings averaging 8%. So, while the UAL in Fraser would appear to be comparatively low, if that were calculated based on actual experience the UAL would increase. Coincidently, the ARC for the City would also decrease. Given the relative numbers we see and the positive impact of maintaining our current ARC it is best to maintain our status quo. Smoothing of investment returns also impacts the pension plan UAL. The intent of smoothing is to reduce the volatility of the asset value due to radical shifts in the investment market. As we are all too well award, investment markets since 2007 have been volatile. Most recently in the past few months we have seen the Dow Jones average shift as much as 700 points up and down in a matter of weeks. Smoothing over a five-year period means only a portion of the investment loss or gain is booked when calculating the UAL. The effect of this is demonstrated best when looking at the asset value of the pension plan since 2007. In that time frame, 2007 through 2010, while the liabilities were steadily increasing, approximately 14% in the four year cycle, smoothing the investment return reduced the asset growth to approximately 4% over that four year cycle. The 2010 actuarial study noted that during the past year investment return exceeded the long-term assumed rate of 8%, but smoothing recognized only a 1.48% increase. So, while smoothing helped in a down market, the opposite effect is now occurring in that full investment return is not being recognized. The UAL is also a number that represents the combined UAL measures of each of the 6 employee groups. When reviewing those numbers we find interesting trends. For example between 2001 and 2010 we note: • • • • DPW Clerical: Dispatcher: Public Safety: 2001-101% 2001-83% 2001-56% 2001-84% 2010-79% 2010-86% 2010-88% 2010-54% The last employee group is of particular interest as it very closely tracks the overall UAL for the pension plan as in 2001 the overall UAL was 84% dropping to 57% in 2010 with little variation on a year-to-year basis. When you compare the assets of each of the groups you also will find that Public Safety assets represent 60% of the total asset value of the pension plan. As such, there appears to be a direct correlation between the experience of the Public Safety group and the experience of the overall pension plan. What characteristics of the public safety pension group make it differ in experience form the other groups? I would suggest it is primarily in two areas, spiking and COLA as these benefits are not available to other employee groups who basically use their final salary only in calculating their pension benefits. There are no uniform allowances, special pays and significant overtime available to the other employee groups. The pension plan that has received most news regarding abuse and problems is the New Jersey state pension. There liberal provisions for calculating the final pension amount were fraught with many examples of spiking that seriously skewed the pension liabilities leading to a near collapse of the system compounded by regular COLA increases. Other pension plans that are having problems can trace them back to these same issues. So, I do not believe it much of a leap to conclude that these issues are affecting our local pension plan. Finally, there is another dynamic that is demonstrated by the remaining two employee groups, supervisors and management. • Management: 2001-78% 2010-39% • Supervisors: 2001-87% 2010-50% While together they only represent 20% of the overall assets of the pension plan the reduction in UAL can be directly traced to the fact that only a single active employee is in each group. All other employees in these groups have since retired. The dynamic at work here is when the pension plan is reduced to a finite number and the ratio of active employees to retirees reaches 0, the UAL will increase and the only contributor from that point forward is the City. This reality was driven home to the Governor of Rhode Island. From an article on the subject: Cutting pensions saves states money, right? Maybe eventually. Rhode Island Governor Don Carcieri received some discouraging financial news recently. Carcieri would like to change his state's pension system for new employees. His hope, naturally, is to save money. But like other policy makers, he is finding that such a switch could prove costly, at least in the short run. A study commissioned by Carcieri's office found that moving state workers toward a 401(k)-style retirement system would cost the state $151.5 million the first year and $520 million over seven years. After that, the state should start seeing some savings and begin to get out from under its heavy pension liability load. We noted a similar dynamic in my last position where the City had eliminated all DB pension benefits for new hires. The City’s contributions would increase significantly over the next decade before finally beginning to reduce. All of this is from the dynamic I noted above… the number of employees (payers) continually reduces and the number of retirees (payees) increases leaving the government entity to pay all of the remaining contributions. As a result, many communities are beginning to turn to so-called hybrid plans with significantly reduced DB benefits combined with a DC element all with higher employee contributions. I have received material on this from our actuary and am in the process of reviewing this to determine if there is a hybrid formula that will be better for the City than just eliminating the DB for all new employees. Recommended Changes to our DB Pension Plan: 1) Eliminate all COLA’s from our pension plan. 2) Change all FAC calculations to be based on a five-year average salary only eliminating all other compensation from the formula. 3) Increase pension contributions to 10% for all covered employees from the current 5%. 4) Change salary multipliers consistent with State recommendations of 2% for employees not eligible for Social Security and 1.5% for those eligible. 5) Increase the minimum retirement age to 55 and 60 depending on the years of service instead of the current 50 and 55. 6) Continue using the current UAL assumptions until the pension plan UAL exceeds at least 80%. Then review to determine if investment proceeds and liabilities support reducing the assumptions to actual experience levels. 7) Maintain the current smoothing formula until markets stabilize and then revisit this issue with our actuaries to determine if the current formula needs to be changed. 8) Review and determine if the fiscal health and stability of the pension plan and City would be better served with all new employees enrolling in a hybrid DB/DC pension plan as opposed to the current DC option only. Items 1-5 will require that changes are done during contract negotiations. While it would be best if the change impacted all employees it may be difficult to sustain such a position if we are moved into 312 arbitration. So, I would recommend the changes impact all employees not currently vested which would incorporate employees hired since 2005. As far as item 5, IRS published rules dictating the minimum age for retirement be raised to 55 with a preferred minimum age of 62 on June 30, 2010. The deadline was changed to January 1, 2011 then suspended in the wake of significant labor opposition, primarily form public safety unions. If this change is made all pension plans, including ours, would be forced to comply. IRS Update: During my research on the pension plan and the early retirement incentives offered in 2010 I found that our pension plan had not requested a letter of determination form the IRS stating our compliance with all IRS regulations governing pension plans. The deadline was January 1, 2011 and time was too short to accomplish this task. As an alternative we requested IRS enroll us in their Voluntary Compliance Plan. We have been accepted into the plan and are now working with the IRS to bring our plan into compliance. Essentially, the City of Fraser failed to amend its plan at least 4 times from 2001 through 2008 to meet new guidelines. Our enrollment in the VCP preserves the tax exempt status of our pension plan and allows us time to properly amend the plan ad receive approval from the IRS.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz