ARTICLES Chinese Science Bulletin 2006 Vol. 51 Supp. I 101—109 DOI: 10.1007/s11434-006-8213-0 Topographical changes of ground surface affected by the Tarim Desert Highway LI Shengyu1,2,3, LEI Jiaqiang1, XU Xinwen1, WANG Lixin2, ZHOU Zhibin1 & LI Hongzhong1,3 1. Xinjiang Institute of Ecology and Geography, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Urumqi 830011, China; 2. Institute of Geographical Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; 3. Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100039, China Correspondence should be addressed to Li Shengyu (email: [email protected]) Received July 20, 2005; accepted January 16, 2006 Abstract The Tarim Desert Highway is the longest highway crossing the mobile desert in the world. The highway and its sand protection system were established in 1995. This great project must have significant effect on the aeolian environment in its neighborhoods. In 2004, we investigated the topographic changes of ground surface within the sand protection system and its external adjacent area in the hinterland of the Taklimakan Desert. The results showed that (i) the original topographic patterns of ground surface were greatly changed, and erosion as well as deposition was distributed clearly on the ground surface, affected by the road and its sand protection system; (ii) sediment deposited in the sand protection system gradually heightened the ground surface, but each part in the system changed differently: in the sand-blocking belt, a transverse sand ridge was formed in the same direction as the upright sand barrier; in the sand-binding belt, sediment was aggraded on the original surface in a certain thickness; at the initial stages since the establishment of the sand protection system, erosion had taken place in the un-stabilized area named by the deposition belt between the sand-blocking belt and the sand-binding belt, the inner of sand-binding belt, the windward slope of dunes in the sand-binding belt, and the neighboring leeward area of the sand protection system. Keywords: topography of ground surface, deflation and deposition, sand protection system, the Tarim Desert Highway, the Taklimakan Desert. www.scichina.com www.springerlink.com There exist mutual acceleration and dynamic equilibrium between blown sand movement and aeolian bed ― surface [1 3]. Ground surface topography mainly depends on wind, but underlayering surface can also feed back on the wind flow field and aeolian movement, which further lead to topographical changes of ground surface. Many field investigations about the deflation anddeposition on the ground surface have been con― ducted by scholars[4 7], but studies on topographic changes of ground surface affected by large-scale de― sert projects are very rare[8 10]. Highways are very common large-scale projects in deserts. The researches in the past mainly focused on the sand disaster control[11,12] and the sheltering effect of the sand protection ― system[13 15]. The long-term topographic changes of ground surface along the Tarim Desert Highway will lead to the alteration of disaster-causing environments. So that, studies on the topographic changes of ground surface affected by the sand protection system are of significance in the process of aeolian topographic development affected by artificial behavior in the modern times, and are of practical application in the development and evolvement of sand disasters along the Tarim Desert Highway and the highway’s sustainability. 1 Aeolian environmental backgrounds of the study area The Tarim Desert Highway crosses the Taklimakan Desert in the Tarim Basin, northwest of China, from Luntai in the north fringe of the Tarim Basin to Minfeng in the south fringe. With the whole length of 562 km and 446 km in the mobile desert, it is the longest highway across desert in the world (Fig. 1). About 50% length of the highway in the mobile desert lies in the areas with the topography of high-complex sand-ridges, thus the landform along the Tarim Desert Highway is dominated by high complex sand-ridges, and the topographic pattern along the highway is high complex sand-ridges and broad flat inter-dunes. The physical sand protection system in combination with the windbreaks and reed checkerboards was applied in the Tarim Desert Highway. Windbreaks, namely erected sand barriers, with a void fraction of 30% to 40%, being 1.1 meter high above the ground surface, are made of reeds or nylon meshworks, and are settled in the outmost of the sand protection system and run parallel with the highway. The reed checkerboards are made of reeds 101 ARTICLES Fig. 1. Map showing the location of the highway crossing the Taklimakan Desert. embedded in the sand in a roughly 1 m×1 m grid, and are settled on both sides of the highway[12]. The east part of reed checkerboards in the sand protection system is about 50 to 70 m wide, and the west part is about 40 to 60 m wide. The deposition belt between windbreaks and reed checkerboards in the sand protection system is about 10 to 20 m wide. The shelter forest belt,constructed in the Tazhong Oilfield Base ever since 1997, includes the sand-blocking forest belt and the sand-binding forest belt. The study area lies in the hinterland of the Taklimakan Desert, in the Tazhong Si area, northwest China (39°00′N, 83°40′E). Site elevation is 1100―1150 m. Sand-ridges, covered by sand chains of 5-15 m high, and running with a mean strike of 50°―60° north by east[16], are 30―70 m high , however, inter-dunes, covered by some sand chains, barchan dunes and small sand ridges[17], are flat, and 1―3 km wide. The ground surface is mainly composed of shifting sand dominated by fine sand and very fine sand with a mean grain diameter of 0.1―0.05 mm, but sand on inter-dunes is also composed of fine gravel with a diameter of 0.5 mm, or even greater than 2 mm[16]. Wind in this area is very strong and predominately frequent from March to September[18]. The annual average wind velocity is up to 102 2.5 m·s−1, the annual maximal instantaneous speed is 20.0 m·s−1, and the annual frequency of sand-driving wind is grater than 500. The annual main direction of sand-driving wind is ENE, NE, NNE and E, and the wind in direction of ENE is the most frequent and the strongest. 2 Experiments and methods Inter-dune areas along the Tarim Desert Highway are the simplest and most universal (accounting for approximately 70%) under-layering surface. So if experiments are settled in inter-dune areas, not only the interference of other environmental factors can be reduced to the least, and make the experiments approach ideal conditions, but also this kind of under-layering surface can represent the main topographical types along the Tarim Desert Highway. A physical sand protection system and biological sand protection system were constructed in the selected areas. Some dunes in the shelter systems were selected. Many metal bars were embedded in sand with uniform interval along transects settled in the shelter systems. The over-ground length of these metal bars was measured several times in the windy seasons of 2003 and 2004. The topography of ground surface was also surveyed with the instrument of total station. Chinese Science Bulletin Vol. 51 Supp. I June 2006 ARTICLES 3 Results and analysis In contrast with the original topography in and near the shelter systems, some micro-relief was generally developed due to the deflation and deposition, and the mode and intensity of the topography changes had a clear spatial distribution[13]. 3.1 Aeolian depositional micro-relief Aeolian deposition can result from wind velocity weakening due to barriers and changes of constitution or property of the ground surface. Because the highway shelter systems increase the barriers of sand flow, sand depositional micro-relief was developed. This sand depositional micro-relief can be classified into ridgelike sand deposition and sheet-like sand deposition according to the scales of micro-relief changes. (i) Ridge-like sand deposition. Aeolian deposition began to develop on the ground surface in width of 15-fold height of the upright nylon net fence just after the fence was settled (Fig. 1). The range of sand deposition in the leeward of fence was gradually widened as time went on. It added up to 20 meters in the early period of the second windy season, and extended to the reed checkerboards at the end of the second windy season. The height of sand deposition also increased with time. The highest point of sand deposition lay at fence or slightly deviated downwind at the same height or a little greater as the fence. The mass of sand deposition increased linearly with time in the two windy sea- sons, but in the middle and later period of the second windy season, the mass leveled off at 11 m3·m−1. So we can see that the mass of sand deposition around the upright reed fence will not increase without limit, and finally level off at a certain amount. The sand deposition transect around the nylon net fence continuously changed during the windy seasons in 2003 and 2004. It had two peaks on the windward and leeward sides of fence respectively at the early stage, and the two base angles of transect were small. At metaphase, it was triangle-like or trapezium-like with a peak and a clear slip-face on the leeward side of fence, and the base angles increased as well. At the anaphase, it was triangle-like, and the windward side of the transects tended to stabilization, but the leeward side changed frequently (Fig. 2). The survey along the Tarim Desert Highway also indicated that the stable form of the sand deposition around fences was ridge-like along fences; the transects were generally triangle-like with gentle windward slope and steep leeward slope, and the windward and leeward base angles were 10―20 degree and 20―30 degree respectively; the sand deposition depended on the fence and was not able to migrate like dunes, but once the fences were seriously damaged[13], the sand deposition should be decomposed and disappear finally. The sand deposition on the verge of shelter forest belt was also ridge-like, but it changed unlike the sand deposition near fences. Its transect was just like the Fig. 2. The dynamic changes of the deposit transect across the sand-blocking nylon net fence. www.scichina.com www.springerlink.com 103 ARTICLES Fig. 3. The dynamic changes of the deposit transect in the verge of sand-fixing forest. vertical section of barchan dunes with a gentle windward slope and a clear slip-face on leeward slope. Due to the high porosity of forest belt, the maximal height of the sand deposition in it was lower than the forest. The sand deposition was independent of the forest verge; therefore, it should gradually progress in the forest belt (Fig. 3). (ii) Sheet-like sand deposition. The transect of sand deposition in the windward verge of new-settled reed checkerboards in a 1 m×1 m grid was triangle-like with a clear peak, a gentle windward slope and a steep leeward slope. As the range of sand deposition in checkerboards increased gradually in the early period of the windy season, transect was trapezium-like with a flat top and gentler slopes; the peak migrated gradually into the inner part of checkerboards. In the latter stage of windy season, the range of deposition enlarged further, and transect was also trapezium-like with flat top and unclear peak. At the end of the first windy season, the width of sand deposition reached 38 m, but in the early period of the second windy season it added up to 45 m. When the checkerboards were entirely buried only with reeds of approximately 5 cm high aboveground, the deflation and deposition on the ground surface should reach equilibrium (Fig. 4). The aggradations of sand deposition in checkerboards in inter-dune areas heightened the ground surface by 20 to 30 cm. Some information about ground surface on the verge of checkerboards is also represented in Fig. 3. The mobile ground surface in width of 5 m outside the checkerboards on the windward side was also dominated by 104 the deposition. The sand deposition transect was stable with a thickness of 4 to 10 cm or so. With the influence of the inverse wind, the sand deposition on the mobile ground surface in width of 5 m outside the checkerboards on the leeward side was very stable in a triangle-like form, with a thickness of 15 cm or so. When checkerboards were buried completely, the sand deposition outside the checkerboards was merged with that in checkerboards. After long-term interaction between sand flow and ground surface, a stable concave surface came into being in each grid of reed checkerboards, and the ratio of its maximal depth to its length of grid side was 1:10[19,20]. The investigation about checkerboards in the shelter system in the Xiaotang area was made in 1991 and it indicated that concave surfaces were generally developed in checkerboards in a grid of 1 m×1 m, and also varied in space. The concave surface, which developed on the flat sandy ground surface in inter-dunes, was smooth, and its maximal depth was 5 to 6 cm, about 1/20 of the length of grid side. But the concave surface, which developed on the windward slope of dunes, was coarse with a depth of 6 to 8 cm or 13.8 cm at the most, larger than 1/10 of the length side of reed grid. The depth of the concave surfaces, which developed on the leeward slope and wings of barchan dunes, was only 3 to 5 cm and 5 to 6 cm, respectively, on average. The depth of the concave surfaces on the windward slope of dunes increased from the foot? to middle of the slope, but decreased from the middle of the slope to the top. This spatial distribution shows the difference Chinese Science Bulletin Vol. 51 Supp. I June 2006 ARTICLES Fig. 4. Dynamic changes of deposit transect across the sand-fixing checkerboards in a roughly 1 m×1 m grid. of the wind velocity and the saturation among sites of dunes. However, surveys in the Tazhong area showed that the stable concave surfaces in grid of reed checkerboards did not develop well[14]. This phenomenon may relate to the high sand availability and the high frequency of sand-driving wind. The mobile dunes in inter-dunes and complex longitudinal sand ridge have a relatively stable form, with a slip face in the angle of sand repose, the middle and the lower parts of the windward slope in 10°―15°, the middle and upper parts of windward slope in 7°―11°. Due to the uneven distribution of sand deposition at all sites of dunes in reed checkerboards, the middle and lower parts of the windward slope declined slightly in 10°―19°, but the middle and upper parts of the windward slope increased slightly in 8°―12°, and the slip face decreased little. Because sand deposition firstly formed in the verge of the shelter forest, then slowly migrated into the inner pars of the forest belt, and only the fine particles in suspension were able to deposit firstly in the inner pars of the forest belt, the deposition in the verge parts was thicker than that in the inner parts. After four windy seasons, the thickness of sand deposition in the inner parts of the forest belt only reached 7.5―14 cm; but sand deposition on a dune in the transition area between sand ridges and inter-dunes was greatly affected by topography. Sediment was mainly deposited on the leeward slope and dune top other than on the verge of the forest belt, and the maximal thickness of sediment on the leeward slope, dune top and windward slope was 70 cm, 28 cm and 24 cm respectively (Fig. 5). 3.2 Deflation micro-relief Wind erosion results from the transformation of sand www.scichina.com www.springerlink.com flow from under-saturation to saturation. When the sand flow was over-saturated in some parts of the shelter system, some sand grains were unloaded on the ground surface. Due to the speedup of wind and limited sand availability in areas like deposition areas around fence or forest, the inner parts of checkerboards and the leeward neighborhood of the shelter system, sand flow tended to be under-saturated, and the ground surface was dominated by the deflation. (i) Deposition areas. The leeward neighborhoods of fences and forest belts are called deposition area. Wind speed generally falls to be the lowest in the middle of deposition areas and the majority of sand particles in sand-flow deposit here. Wind speeds up gradually on the downwind side of this area and sand flow tends to be unsaturated, so wind erosion on the ground surface occurs. The deflation intensity of deposition areas on the windward side of road was not very high, being about 1―3 cm near fences and about 7―30 cm near forest belts. Owing to burial by sand deposition migration forward and ground surface stabilization by checkerboards, deflation micro-relief could not develop extensively and disappeared finally. But as a result of alternation of prevailing wind and reverse wind, deflation could develop extensively in the deposition area of leeward side of road. Survey in the K110 of the Tarim Desert Highway where transverse sand ridges are developed showed that the depth of wind erosion in inter-dune areas was more than 0.5 m, and that on top of sand ridges was even larger than 0.5 m so that the buried petroleum-transferring pipe was exposed to the ground surface[15]. Wind erosion was developed in the maximal width of 10―16 m in the verge of checkerboards (Fig. 6). 105 ARTICLES Fig. 5. Dynamic variations of thickness of deposit in the shelter forests in inter-dunes (a) and transitional area between ridges and inter-dunes (b). Fig. 6. Deflation developed in the deposition areas near fences on the leeward side of the road in inter-dunes (a) and on the top of the ridge areas (b). (ii) The inner parts of checkerboards. Sand flow is over-saturated in the windward verge of checkerboards, and the majority of sand particles in sand flow deposit there. Sand flow tends to be under-saturated due to limited sand supply in the inner parts of checkerboards, thus wind erosion occurs. The experiments also indicated that erosion was commonly developed in the five types of checkerboards before checkerboards were buried, but their intensities and ranges were not very large only with a depth of 1 cm and a width of 4―12 m except the row-like checkerboards at intervals of 1 m, whose intensity and range added up to 1.9 cm and 31 m respectively resulting from strong northerlies, and there were not significant differences between these types (Table 1). Prof. Xunmin Wang also found erosion occurrence in the inner pars of checkerboards after its settlement [15]. With the increasing range of sand deposition, deflation areas were gradually buried by sediments, and disappeared completely at the end of the 106 first windy season. On account of the differentiation of wind force near dune surfaces affected by itself relief, the speedup in some parts of dunes leads to erosion of checkerboards on the ground surface and changes of dunes’ micro-relief. The investigation along the Tarim Desert Highway showed that deflations were developed extensively on the windward slope besides on the top and prozone of the dunes in shelter systems, especially on the leeward slope and top of dunes on the leeward side of road[16]. For example in the K6 of Qiemo Highway, the width of erosion in the middle lower part of dune windward slope was 12.6 m, the grade in the blowout was 25―32° in an increase of 15―21° compared with the original grade (Fig. 7(a))[17]; because of the alteration of prevailing wind and reverse wind, the dune in the checkerboards on the leeward side of road tended to be symmetrical in an isosceles triangle-like transect, the windward slope was buried in a grade of 13―25°, and Chinese Science Bulletin Vol. 51 Supp. I June 2006 ARTICLES Table 1 Dynamic changes of deflation in checkerboards (2003) Date Scales 1m×1m 1m Row 1.5m×1.5m 2m×1m 2m×2m Apr. 9 Apr. 20 May 6 May 30 Jun. 12 Jun. 24 Jul. 31 3 4 1 1 − − − −0.4 31 −0.3 30 −0.4 28 −0.2 19 − 16 − 17 − 4 −1.9 4 −1.9 5 −1.7 4 −1 4 −0.9 −1.1 −0.6 − − − −0.3 2 −0.4 5 −0.2 4 −0.1 3 − 2 − 1 − −0.4 12 −0.5 11 −0.2 10 − 7 − − Range/m −0.5 12 − Intensity/cm −0.5 −0.5 −0.6 −0.4 −0.8 − −0.3 Range/m Intensity/cm Range/m Intensity/cm Range/m Intensity/cm Range/m Intensity/cm − − Fig. 7. Longitudinal profile changes of dunes in sand-fixing reed checkerboards. (a) Dune in the windward part of road shelter system; (b) Dune in the leeward part of road shelter system. the checkerboards on the leeward slope erode entirely in a gentle grade of about 11―26° (Fig. 7(b))[18]. (iii) Leeward neighborhoods of the shelter system. The sand materials are transported continuously downwards due to the remarkable prevailing winds along the Tarim Desert Highway. But the majority of sand particles in the sand flow across the highway are intercepted by the shelter systems. Coarse sand grains cover the ground surface in the leeward neighborhoods of the shelter system in inter-dune areas. So the sand supply for sand flow was very rare. With the speedup of wind in this area, the sand flow near the ground surface tends to be extremely unsaturated and remains high energy to erosion. Therefore, the ground surface in inter-dunes erodes greatly and neighborhoods in the leeward side of the shelter system are dominated by deflation. The experiment showed that deposition and erosion occurred on the ground surface on the leeward side of the shelter systems in inter-dunes. In the whole windy season of 2004, about 83% of the ground surface in the range of 2.5 m to 19.5 m on the leeward side of checkerboards was eroded; the rest was deposited or kept balance between erosion and deposition. The erosion sections were distributed in a uniform interval about 5 m. The intensity of erosion was not very large www.scichina.com www.springerlink.com only with a maximal depth of 2 cm. The farther from the checkerboards erosion sections lay, the less the erosion depth was. The intensity of erosion also changed with time, for example, the average erosion depth on October 7 was larger than that on May 25, but the erosion depth in the sections of I and III changed very slightly (Fig. 8(a)). In a near windy season, the total volume of erosion from 2.5 m to 19.5 m outside checkerboards added up to 0.103 m3·m−1, being equivalent to 155.74 ton.km-1 (sand bulk density in 1.512 g·cm−3); the volume of erosion in the end of the windy season was larger than that in the beginning of windy season. We also found that the ground surfaces on the leeward side of the checkerboards, whose types was grid in 1 m×1 m, rows in 1 m interval, grid in 2 m×1 m, grid in 1.5 m×1.5 m, grid in 2 m×2 m respectively, were also dominated by deflation (Fig. 8(b)); the range of deflation was about 20 m. The downwind ground surface beyond this range was in a balance between erosion and deposition. The monitored shelter forest in inter-dunes includes two parts. The windward part of the road is composed of a column of nylon net fence settled prior to the forest, two columns of sand-obstructing forest belts in width of 6―7 m, and sand-stabilizing forest in width of 20 m. 107 ARTICLES The leeward part of the road is composed of sand-stabilizing forest in width of 18 m and checkerboards in width of 36 m settled prior to the forest. Accordingly, the width of shelter systems’ coverage, including forest interval, road surface and shoulders of road, amounts to 142 m. Metal bars were implanted in the middle of grids of reed checkerboards and mobile ground surface on the leeward side of the road in a line vertical to the shelter systems (Fig. 9), the variation about the overground length of metal bars can show changes of ground surface. In checkerboards, the volume of sand deposition in windy season changed a little, but the volume of deflation varied greatly in a maximal erosion depth of 6.5 cm. Moreover, on May 25 and Oct. 7, ground surface was in a state of net deflation[11]. The depth of sand deposition in the mobile ground surface covered by coarse sand particles was very small in windy season and tended to decline with time, but the intensity and range of deflation increased with time. For example, on Oct. 7, the whole ground surface was in a state of erosion or balance between erosion and deposition. The maximal erosion depth added up to 4.2 cm, and the total erosion volume in the mobile sand section with a length of 28 m amounted to 0.544 m3·m−1, equivalent to 822.5 ton·km−1; but the total erosion volume in the checkerboards section with a length of 36 m only amounted to 0.318 m3·m−1, equivalent to 480.8 ton·km−1. So the survey indicates that in the middle and latter of windy season, the ground surface in a range of 64 m on the leeward side of shelter forest systems is in a state of deflation. Based on the theory of blown sand movement, we can infer that with departure from the shelter systems, the volume of erosion increases, so sand flow gradually tends to saturation and the ground surface also turns into a state of balance between erosion and deposition from erosion. Therefore the range of deflation on the leeward side of shelter forest is larger than 64 m. The range and intensity of deflation on the leeward side of shelter forest are larger than those on the leeward side of physical shelter systems. 4 Conclusions On account of the effect of the shelter systems of the Tarim Desert Highway on blown sand movement near the ground surface, the micro-relief in shelter systems and its neighborhoods changed regularly. (a) Sand deposition formed a new micro-relief in the shelter systems, which heightened the ground surface. The form of sand deposition varied among different shelter measures, for example, ridge-like sand deposition formed around the sand-obstructing measures in large scales, but sheet-like sand deposition formed in the checkerboards and the inner parts of the shelter forests. Fig. 8. Deflation on the ground surface in the leeward side of physical shelter system. (a) Type of blocking and binding; (b) type of binding (2004). Fig. 9. Deflation on the ground surface on the leeward side of shelter forest in inter-dune area (2004). 108 Chinese Science Bulletin Vol. 51 Supp. I June 2006 ARTICLES The concave surface can be developed in the checkerboards with limited sand supply, but can’t in abundant sand supply. (b) Deflation was developed in the partial area of the shelter systems during the early and middle stage of its settlement. Ground surface was depressed by the deflation. For example, the deflation in the sand deposition area around fence and forest intervals was developed in low intensity and persisted for a short time; but the deflation in the sand deposition area and the neighborhood of the shelter systems on the leeward side of road were developed extensively and lasted for a long time. (c) The leeward slopes of dunes in the checkerboards were in a state of deposition, but the windward slopes of dunes were eroded extensively and mobile sand was exposed. We also found that the locations of dunes in the shelter systems also had effects on the changes of dunes’ form. With artificial persistent maintenance and renewals of the shelter systems along the Tarim Desert Highway, the transverse sections of highway should be modified as a result of long-term deflation and deposition in the shelter systems. So this also leads to changes of sand damage formation along the highway. Thus we can predict the development of sand damages through topographic changes in and out of the shelter systems. The deflation on the leeward side of shelter systems should have effects on the stability of the roadbed. Therefore, when the road intersects with the local prevailing wind direction in large angles, sand stabilization belt in a certain width must be settled in this area for road safety. Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank their colleagues and workers who made great efforts in experiments settlement and surveys. This work was supported by the Major Orientation Foundation of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (Grant No. KCCX3-SW-342), Science and Technology Foundation of Western Development (Grant No. 2005BA901A2), and West Light Foundation of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (Grant No. 20052118). References 1 Ma S W, Ma Y M, Yao H L, et al. Study of Desert (in Chinese). Huhhot: Inner Mongolian Press, 1998. 17―18 2 Skidmore E L. Soil erosion by wind. In: El-Baz F, Hassan M H A, ed. Physics of Desertification. Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1986. 261―273 3 Zhu Z D, Zhao X L, Ling Y Q, et al. The Engineering of Sand Control (in Chinese). Beijing: China Environmental Science Press, 1998. 26―36 www.scichina.com www.springerlink.com 4 Bagnold R A. The Physics of Blown Sand and Desert Dunes (in Chinese, translated by Qian N). Beijing: Science Press, 1959. 172―218 5 Zhu Z D, Chen Y P, Wu Z. Study on the Geomorphology of Wind-drift Sand in the Taklimakan Desert (in Chinese). Beijing: Science Press, 198l. 27―80 6 Wang X M, Dong Z B, Qu J J, et al. Dynamic processes of a simple linear dune-A study in the Taklimakan Sand Sea, China. Geomorphology, 2003, 52: 233―241 7 Dong Z B, Wang X M, Chen G T. Monitoring sand dune advance in the Taklimakan Desert. Geomorphology, 2000, 35: 219―231 8 Zhen J G. Changes of surface feature of the stabilized mobile dunes at Shaqotous Southeast Egqe of Tengger Desert. Journal of Desert Research (in Chinese), 1987, 1: 10―17 9 Hang S L. The effect of windbreak and dune fixation forest on form and structure of dunes. Inner Mongolia Forestry Sciences and Technology, 1998, 1: 42―44 10 Huang Q, Lei J Q. Sand-obstructing effect on the upright sand barriers in the different morphological sections along the Tarim Desert Highway. Arid Land Geography, 2000, 3: 227―232 11 Dong Z B, Chen G T, Han Z W, et al. Blown-sand disasters of the Tarim Desert Petroleum Highway. Environmental Science (in Chinese), 1997, 1: 4―9 12 Wang X Q, Lei J Q, Huang Q. Study on spatial distribution of wind-sand hazard along the Tarim Desert Highway, China. Journal of Desert Research (in Chinese), 1999, 4: 438―442 13 Han Z W, Chen W N, Chen G T, et al. The protective efficiency of the drifting sand devil controlling systems along the test section of the Tarim Desert Highway. Journal of Desert Research (in Chinese), 1993, 4: 44―51 14 Xu X W, Hu Y K, Pan B R. Analysis on protection effect of various measures of combating drifting sand along the Tarim Desert Highway. Arid Zone Research, 1998, 1: 21―26 15 Wang X M, Chen G T, Han Z W. The benefit of the protection system along the Desert Highway in the Tarim Basin. Journal of Desert Research (in Chinese), 1999, 2: 120―127 16 Wang X M, Dong Z B, Chen G T. Characteristics of blown sand environment in the middle of the Taklimakan Desert. Journal of Desert Research (in Chinese), 2001, 1: 56―61 17 Lei J Q, Wang X Q, Wang D. The formation of the blown sand disaster to the Taeim Desert Highway, Xinjiang, China. Arid Zone Research (in Chinese), 2003, 1: 1―6 18 Li H P, Chen G T, Xue D Q. Wind field over complex dune-chains and the dynamic features of the dunes overlaying on the dune-chains in the hinterland of the Taklimkan Desert. Arid Land Geography (in Chinese), 2001, 1: 80―85 19 Wu Z. Topography of Blown Sand (in Chinese). Beijing: Science Press, 1987. 59―61 20 Ling Y Q. The protective efficiency of grass checkerboards barrier. In: Shaqotous Desert Research Station, Institute of Lanzhou Desert Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, eds. Collection of Studies on Mobile Sand Control and Protection at Shaqotous Area of Tengger Desert. Yinchuan: Ningxia People Press, 1980. 96―97 109
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz