Water, water everywhere

Cover story |
Water, water
everywhere
There’s plenty to go round, so why is the world
facing a water crisis, asks Jonathan Chenoweth
28 | NewScientist | 23 August 2008
www.newscientist.com
RACHEL WHITING/UNTITLED
●
www.newscientist.com
TODAY’S focus on the credit crisis and
rising prices for food and oil has
temporarily put another global scarcity
in the shade: water. The UN predicts that by
2025, two-thirds of us will experience water
shortages, with severe lack of water blighting
the lives and livelihoods of 1.8 billion. According
to the UN World Water Assessment Programme,
by 2050, 7 billion people in 60 countries may
have to cope with water scarcity. At this
year’s World Economic Forum, UN secretarygeneral Ban Ki-moon recommended that
water scarcity should be at the top of the
international agenda. “As the global economy
grows, so will its thirst,” he said, warning
of a future marred by conflicts over water.
There is no doubt that we need to rethink
how we use water, especially with the human
population growing rapidly, and global
warming likely to produce unpredictable
patterns of rainfall and drought. Nevertheless,
my own research suggests that the situation
may not be as dire as many are suggesting.
Nations can thrive on surprisingly meagre
quantities of fresh water – provided they
adopt water-efficient technologies and
encourage economic activity that doesn’t
guzzle water. I believe the looming water crisis
is primarily a problem of distribution and
management rather than supply. And we can
solve it with existing technologies, increased
investment and political will.
The definitions of water scarcity most
widely accepted and used today by the UN
and others were proposed in 1986 by Malin
Falkenmark, then at the Swedish Natural
Sciences Research Council. She defined a
country as “water-stressed” when it cannot
extract more than 4654 litres of water per
person per day (equivalent to 1700 cubic
metres per person per year) from its rivers and
aquifers. One with less than 2738 litres available
per person Falkenmark classified as “waterscarce”. Anything below 1369 litres constitutes
“absolute water scarcity”, and threatens
economic development as well as human
health and well-being.
Most of the Middle East is already classified
as being water-scarce according to these
definitions, but perhaps more surprisingly
so are Malta and Singapore, while Denmark,
Poland and the Czech Republic are classed
as water-stressed. In total, approximately
290 million people live in countries that are
classed as water-scarce, and another
440 million live in countries that are waterstressed. However, I believe these benchmarks
Reservoirs provide the mainstay of the physical water
supply; meanwhile, virtual water is a prized commodity
need to be re-examined, and when that is
done, a very different picture emerges.
The main problem with Falkenmark’s
figures is that they refer to the amount of
water required for a country to be selfsufficient in food production in a semi-arid
region. Agriculture is among the most waterintensive human activities, particularly where
crops need irrigation. According to the report
Water Footprints of Nations, published in
2004 by the UNESCO-IHE Institute for Water
Education, producing a kilogram of wheat takes
more than 1300 litres of water, for example.
For rice, the figure is almost 3000 litres.
However, such self-sufficiency is no longer
essential because the global food supply is
much more integrated than it was even
20 years ago. Research by Tony Allan at King’s
College London, for example, reveals that
countries across the Middle East have
increasingly compensated for water scarcity
by importing grains grown elsewhere. Allan
coined the term “virtual water” to describe
this trade, since the imports substitute for
water that would otherwise be required locally
to grow crops. Recent figures from the UN
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) show
the trend of rapidly increasing global trade of
“virtual water”. Between 1970 and 2001, food
trade increased 60 per cent in calorie terms.
Trading virtual water
Some of the world’s least developed countries
now participate in the global food trade,
breaking the link between local water
resources and food security. Figures from the
FAO show that in 2002, imports made up a
fifth of the grain supply across sub-Saharan
Africa, the region with the lowest average
national incomes in the world, with food aid
making up less than a fifth of the total food
imports in least developed countries. Since the
1960s the world’s least developed countries
have changed from being net exporters to
being significant net importers of agricultural
commodities, and hence have become major
importers of virtual water, even though most
are not particularly short of water.
Of course, trade in virtual water does not
reduce overall demand for water but rather
shifts it from one place to another. However,
with such a growing trade in virtual water, it no
longer makes sense to use self-sufficiency in
food production to define water scarcity. As
with so many other commodities that are
traded globally, self-sufficiency in food
production is not a requirement for individual
countries so long as water resources remain
adequate at the global level, in the same
23 August 2008 | NewScientist | 29
M7J;H=E;I=BE87B
Fb[dj_\kbikffb_[i_diec[fWhjie\j^[mehbZYWdX[ki[ZjecWa[kf\ehi^ehjW][i[bi[m^[h[
DeZWjW
+&&#'&&&
2+&&
'&&&#'-&&
'-&&#+&&&
MWj[hm_j^ZhWmWbf[h_d^WX_jWdjc)f[ho[Wh
DeZWjW
'&&#(+&
2'&&
4+&&&
(+&#+&&
+&&#'&&&
Fhefehj_ede\mWj[hh[iekhY[im_j^ZhWmd
4'&&&
'&#(+
2'&
(+#+&
+&#-+
4-+
DeZWjW
Ckd_Y_fWb
7]h_Ykbjkh[
IEKH9;07GK7IJ7J
JejWbh[d[mWXb[mWj[hh[iekhY[if[h_d^WX_jWdjc)f[ho[Wh
7h[WiWhekdZj^[]beX[ik\\[h_d]\hecZ[fb[j[ZmWj[hh[iekhY[i
F^oi_YWbmWj[hiYWhY_jo
MWj[hh[iekhY[Z[l[befc[dj_iWffheWY^_d]eh^Wi
[nY[[Z[ZikijW_dWXb[b_c_ji$Ceh[j^Wd-+e\
h_l[h\bem_i[njhWYj[Z\ehW]h_Ykbjkh[
7ffheWY^_d]f^oi_YWbmWj[hiYWhY_jo
Ceh[j^Wd,&e\h_l[h\bem_i[njhWYj[Z$
J^[i[Wh[Wim_bb[nf[h_[dY[f^oi_YWbmWj[h
iYWhY_jo_dj^[d[Wh\kjkh[
IEKH9;0?DJ;HD7J?ED7BM7J;HC7D7=;C;DJ?DIJ?JKJ;
;Yedec_YmWj[hiYWhY_jo
B_c_j[ZWYY[iijemWj[h[l[dj^ek]^dWjkhWbbeYWb
ikffb_[iWh[WlW_bWXb[jec[[j^kcWdZ[cWdZi$
B[iij^Wd(+e\mWj[h[njhWYj[Z\eh^kcWdd[[Zi
B_jjb[ehdemWj[hiYWhY_jo
7XkdZWdjmWj[hh[iekhY[ih[bWj_l[jeki["
m_j^b[iij^Wd(+e\mWj[h[njhWYj[Z\eh
^kcWdfkhfei[i
Dej[ij_cWj[Z
L_hjkWbmWj[h\bem_dYkX_Ya_bec[jh[i
;ij_cWj[ZmehbZmWj[hki['/&&Å(&&&
H[i[hle_hbeii[i
?dZkijh_Wb
*&&&
4'+
'+je+
30 | NewScientist | 23 August 2008
+je&
;nfehji
&je+
+je'+
4'+
Dej[ij_cWj[Z
(&&&
'&&&
&
'/&&
'/(&
'/*&
'/,&
'/.&
(&&&
www.newscientist.com
IEKH9;0<7E
?cfehji
IEKH9;0M7J;HH;IEKH9;I7JB7I
ac)f[ho[Wh
)&&&
perfect as a measure of whether a country
provides its people with a decent standard
of living, the Human Development Index
established by the UN Development
Programme is arguably the best global
indicator now available. It combines
various measurements of health, education
and wealth to provide a broad overview
of development, ascribing countries such
as Qatar, Mexico and Tonga a high level
of development alongside countries more
countries. However, figures from national
sources are not always consistent with those
of the FAO. In the UK, for example, the
government regulator OFWAT finds that the
average person uses 151 litres a day. The
Association of Dutch Water Companies gives
a figure of almost 125 litres a day for people in
the Netherlands. These are the figures I used.
A breakdown of how the Dutch use water in
their homes shows that the average person uses
52 litres for showering, 36 litres for flushing
“A nation could offer a high quality of life with as
little as 135 litres of water per person per day”
commonly considered developed.
With this as my starting point, I examined
domestic water usage in countries with high
levels of human development to get an idea of
how little water people can get by on in their
homes and still have a decent standard of
living. FAO figures indicate that of highly
developed countries, the Netherlands, the UK
and Uruguay are the most water-efficient.
People there use fewer than 100 litres a day,
compared with more than 700 litres in New
Zealand and Canada, which have the highest
consumption among highly developed
toilets, 20 litres for washing clothes, 8.7 litres
for preparing food and washing dishes, 1.6 litres
for drinking and 6.4 litres for other uses.
If conservation were prioritised, consumption
could be reduced even further. Replacing all
toilets with the most efficient dual-flush models,
for example, could halve consumption in this
area, while flushing with recycled shower water
would save the full 36 litres. So with more waterefficient appliances, the Dutch could have a very
high quality of life using as little as 85 litres of
water per person per day in their homes.
Next, I considered non-domestic water
DIGITAL VISION/GETTY
way that so many countries are heavily
dependent on the global oil trade, without
which their economies would grind to a halt.
Globally, there is adequate fresh water
available, and that looks set to continue in the
long term. Figures from the FAO indicate that
we currently extract less than 10 per cent of
the 43,750 cubic kilometres of fresh water
returned each year to the Earth’s rivers, lakes
and aquifers. The water is not distributed
evenly, of course. Within a given country water
consumption can vary from less than 1 per
cent of available resources to more than
100 per cent, meaning that in some cases
resources are being overexploited and
degraded. Nevertheless, countries such as
France, Germany, Italy and Spain have all
shown that it is possible to extract 20 per cent
or more of renewable water resources a year
while maintaining acceptable environmental
quality. Globally we are still some way from
hitting any real environmental ceiling on
consumption, and the growing trade in virtual
water means that scarcity in one region can
be compensated for by increased production
in places with more plentiful supplies.
I am also dubious that water scarcity,
as defined by Falkenmark, determines a
country’s economic development. My own
comparison of basic indicators of human,
social and economic development with
national water availability reveals no such
relationship. Knowing the size of a country’s
fresh water resources does not allow you to
predict how developed it is. In many desert
states in the Middle East, for example, you will
never lack safe drinking water, whereas in
many water-rich countries in Africa you will.
So how much water does a country really
need? The lowest estimate on the table is just
20 litres per person per day, put forward by Guy
Howard at the UK Department for International
Development and Jamie Bartram at the World
Health Organization in Geneva. This figure,
however, considers only the water required
for drinking, cooking and very basic hygiene.
My own assessment, to be published next
month, considers domestic, agricultural and
commercial water use, and aims to show how
much fresh water a country needs to provide
its people with a decent standard of living –
and it puts a very different perspective on the
global water crisis (Desalination, vol 229, p 245).
Any calculation of this kind is bound to
involve value judgements, such as what level
of development is adequate and what sort of
development is acceptable. Although far from
Water-guzzling countries use up to seven times as much
domestic water as their more efficient counterparts
www.newscientist.com
23 August 2008 | NewScientist | 31
9ekdjh_[ij^WjWh[mWj[h#ijh[ii[Z"mWj[h#iYWhY[eh\WY_d]
WXiebkj[mWj[hiYWhY_jo"WYYehZ_d]jej^[<Wba[dcWha_dZ[n
78IEBKJ;
M7J;H
I97H9?JO
M7J;H
I97H9?JO
M7J;H
IJH;II
AkmW_j
K7;
IWkZ_7hWX_W
CWbZ_l[i
CWbjW
I_d]Wfeh[
@ehZWd
?ihW[b
Jkd_i_W
;]ofj
9ofhki
Iekj^7\h_YW
:[dcWha
9p[Y^H[fkXb_Y
Ioh_W
FWa_ijWd
Low water mark
FebWdZ
&
'&&&
(&&&
)&&&
*&&&
<h[i^mWj[hh[iekhY[if[hYWf_jWf[hZWob_jh[i
IEKH9;0<7E%KD:F
P_cXWXm[
MWj[h\eejfh_dji0Wl[hW][l_hjkWbmWj[hYedj[dj
CW_p[
M^[Wj
IeoX[Wdi
H_Y[
;]]i
9^_Ya[d
Feha
BWcX
9ejjedb_dj
&
(
*
,
. '& '( '* ',
J^ekiWdZb_jh[if[ha]e\fheZkYj
32 | NewScientist | 23 August 2008
'.
IEKH9;0KD;I9E
8[[\
Admittedly there are also water-hungry
sectors such as chemicals manufacturing,
textiles and paper, but a country with scarce
water supplies could steer its economy away
from these areas and rely on trade. The concept
of virtual water increasingly encompasses
these products as well as food. By importing
virtual water, a nation could offer a high
quality of life with as little as 135 litres of water
per person per day – allowing 85 litres for
household needs and assuming a wellmaintained water supply system with
distribution losses of around 10 per cent.
If 135 litres is the bare minimum that will
allow a country to prosper, where does that
leave us? At present, only Kuwait and the
United Arab Emirates fall short of this lowwater mark in terms of their naturally
available renewable water resources, but both
make up their shortfall through desalination,
and human development in both of these
countries is already classed as high.
Even countries without oil wealth have
shown that water scarcity need not impede
development. For example, FAO figures show
that Malta has just 346 litres of extractable water
GLOWIMAGES/GETTY
usage. In countries with high human
development, the amount used in the
industrial and service sectors (excluding
agriculture) ranges from just over 3 litres of
water per person per day in Malta to more than
2800 litres in Canada and Bulgaria, according
to the FAO. Again, locally produced figures are
somewhat different. Maltese sources indicate
an average of 51 litres per person per day –
which includes just 7 litres for agriculture –
and puts household water use at 81 litres per
person per day. So Malta shows that a country
can have a high level of human and economic
development with as little as 125 litres of water
per person per day, if it used only recycled
waste water for its agriculture.
I also looked at water consumption within
different economic sectors to find out how a
country with limited water resources of its
own might still maintain a healthy economy.
While few countries publish such informaton
it is available from the UK’s National Statistics
agency. This shows that the UK’s service sector
consumes just 30 litres per head of population
per day – less than 4 per cent of the country’s
total water usage – yet contributes nearly
80 per cent of national wealth. Add in other
water-efficient sectors such as construction
and electrical equipment manufacturing, and
you find that 90 per cent of the UK’s economic
activity uses just 34 litres per person per day.
;L;HO:HEFC7JJ;HI
Irrigation makes agriculture in arid countries
among the thirstiest of human activities
per person per day, while the Bahamas has just
183 litres of water per person per day. Both have
already achieved high human development.
Plentiful water is clearly beneficial for
national development, and it is imperative
that total water resources remain sufficient
for global food production. However, the
fundamental problem many nations face is
not water scarcity but distribution both
within countries and between them.
Nevertheless, there are positive signs that
we can overcome these problems. According to
the WHO and UNICEF, between 1990 and 2002
the percentage of the global population with
access to safe drinking water rose from 77 to
83 per cent. Meanwhile, the trade in virtual
water continues to grow, shifting agricultural
production from areas of water scarcity to
those with relative plenty. Governments are
also starting to rethink their water
management policies – although admittedly
these are still often fragmented and
contradictory. What’s more, with desalination
now as cheap as 50 cents per 1000 litres, all
but the world least developed countries can
afford to supplement their natural supplies
of fresh water as long as they have a coastline.
Millions are suffering because of a lack of
water, but ensuring the supply of 135 litres
per person per day is not beyond our reach. ●
Jonathan Chenoweth is at the Centre for
Environmental Strategy, University of Surrey, UK
Read previous issues of New Scientist at
www.newscientist.com/archive.ns
www.newscientist.com