Starving the beast: The psychology of budget deficits
Jonathan Baron and Edward J. McCaffery
USC CLEO Research Paper No. C04-21
USC Law and Economics Research Paper No. 04-24
CLEO RESEARCH PAPER SERIES
LAW & ECONOMICS RESEARCH
PAPER SERIES
Sponsored by the John M. Olin Foundation
University of Southern California Law School
Los Angeles, CA 90089-0071
This paper can be downloaded without charge from the Social Science Research Network
electronic library at http://ssrn.com/abstract=589283
! "# $%%&
!
" " !
#
" $ " " % " &
$ $ ! " #
! "
#$% &
'
( ( ) '
* ) * + ' ,
-
% ! .
/ . '
/ !
#01% -
'
2 '
-
, 3 " #0# 3 3
" ## % & 4 & '
'
,
-
67, " ! 881%2 ' '
) .
/ 9 + : :;
'
- 6
: + < = !
> -
-
) '
' 7 ? > ! * & ' -
>
#@1% '
> -
4 ,
! = ' & '
'
-
6 3 " A ##52 7 " A ###%* > -
,
, ' - '
B " B 885%
- ' -
' .- / , C " A
##02 " A
8852 3 " : 881% 9-
= = -
Æ = ' - - '
= '
= = = D88 '
E5 E1 8F8 % + ! 885%
7
'
% > G' '
-
= '
= > '
-
= -
' '
-
G'
-
'
G' = - 4
8 0
50%2
#H 4
' *
'
+ ) '
'
-
= '
+ 5 B % : ' = - '
) '
> > : ) 8H '
'
% ' % '
4
>
*
¯ I ¯ %
¯ ) - ¯ ) %
¯ B )>9 ¯ - ) ' ) 4
J K %*
DH J8H DHK ;
'
% DH J8H DHK ;
= ' ;
?
%
7 DH DH
7 DH 8H
A DH >
DH 8H
>
DH DH
= '
' ;
? %
7 '
DH DH
7 '
DH 8H
A '
DH >
'
DH 58H
>
'
DH 5DH
J - K L , ' G % 4
.= ?/ @ ) ;
% .= ? : ; %/ )
.9
/ .M / .>
/
24
20
Short Term
18
Chosen percent spending
22
24
22
20
Long Term
14
14
16
18
Long Term
16
Chosen percent tax
Short Term
16
18
20
22
24
16
18
Initial percent tax
B * ' G' 20
22
24
Initial percent spending
9 %
B
; ' B
'
N ' > DH% 8H% ' ' > DH% '
' 8H
- '
5H
O 1#8
O 88888
% - , -
* - - @ =
L ##5
9 < 885% '
' ( '
- ! :
O 5$#
O 888812 ' ' Æ
% '
O 5D$
O 88880 -
' % ! '
, - -
'
O 5$
O D8D
O 88888% O 8888D% G'
' - < '
! N G' G' ' P = ' + % > -
' G' ;
G' -
*
4
>
%*
7 I DH
%
8H
) - DH
) %
DH
B )>9 H
- DH
& # @ $H 8H 1H ' -
@H% I ' 1H '
8H 1H
-
1H ;
'
8H ;
= ? %
7 '
8H 8H
>
'
8H 58H
= ? %
7 1H 1H >
1H 51H
& # @ 4
% -
4
' )
' = ? : %
I DH $H %
7 $H 8
7 $H 5H
A >
$H #H
>
$H H
= 1H 4
1H 51H 4
H
11@H 4
@ @0 8 $@ 5#% 1H B ' 4
' ' ' 4
4
4
,
' ' > ' ' )
G' N % !
-
& -
'
) - 2
888
%
' ' , -2 ' 4
-
4
25
20
15
10
16% 20% 24%
16% 20% 24%
16% 20% 24%
Tax1
Spend1
Tax2
Spend2
0
5
Percent of personal income
Starting
point:
16% 20% 24%
B * A
' G' A
%
67, ! 885% 4 % 4 '
% , -
D11
O
O 88888% ) O 55 O 888 1% B % 0H 6 ' -
O 88888% '
O $88
O D0@
O 88888% - 4
B 5 .4/ ' ' #H % > I 4 B 5% -% % - , , & .
/ > 4;
- ' > ' 1
0
−1
−2
−4
−3
Percent change in spending
Equal
Actual
Health
Pensions
Poor
Defense
Foreign
Science
Spending category
B 5* 7
4 - - -
4 & ' % - , 67, " ! 885% ' ' ) - & - -
'
! - . /
G' : Æ ( , ) - % ' % -
& * G'
-
6
+ 4 +
) * - = '
'
+ > ' '
< ##@%2 ' ' + ' ' ) '
67, " ! 885% -
%
> N )
'
.&3 =? G' ?/ . / ( ( Æ ! ! :
#01% ) ?
! C 6 " <
#$%
@* 8#D
0
) )* +
6 7 7 B " A 9
###% &- '
* ) ' !"
58$F5 @
9 " < L 885% ! : * B 7 7 " B A ) 885% B ' * ) 4 0DF 5@
#$
< G
##@% I
* ,
4
' % & C 3 G " A
<
% #*
* D8 D$#
##0% G' .- ,/
)
5DFD0
3 9 " A 9
'(
##5% * ) + , $"
3 9 )
G 10 %* $5# 0F5 #0#% /
* ) /
3 9 3
CA :I
4 ## % )
* , (#
#58$
3 " : > 881% .- / ,* - ? I +
C
67, GC ! C 885% I 9 * 9
' - . / 0 1 "#
581
67, GC " ! C ' +7 7AG& :
M 781 82 +7
A & :
M 81 5 *PP
P
OD$00$0
#@1% / /
& &2
7
* I +
9 ) " A
< 885% I * )
>-
=
I " L DF $
) % 3'
##5%
4
M L* C = " ##5