Data Distortion for Privacy Protection in a Terrorist Analysis System

 ! "# $ % & # ' (
)*+,-./*0. 12 31/+4.*- 567*06*8 907:*-;7.< 12 =*0.46><8
?*@70A.108 =B CDEDFGDDCF8 95H
IJKLMNOLP Q-7:,6<G+-*;*-:70A 7; , /,R1- 6106*-0 70 .S* ,++T76,.710 12
U,., /7070A .*6S07V4*; .1 U,.,;*.; 610.,7070A +*-;10,T8 ;*0;7.7:*8 1- 610G
WU*0.7,T 7021-/,.710X ),., U7;.1-.710 7; , 6-7.76,T 61/+10*0. .1 +-*;*-:*
+-7:,6< 70 ;*64-7.<G-*T,.*U U,., /7070A ,++T76,.710;8 ;46S ,; 70 U,.,
/7070AGY,;*U .*--1-7;. ,0,T<;7; ;<;.*/;X Z* +-1+1;* , ;+,-;7W*U 570G
A4T,- [,T4* )*61/+1;7.710 \5[)] /*.S1U 21- U,., U7;.1-.710X Z* ,T;1
+4. 21-.S , 2*^ /*.-76; .1 /*,;4-* .S* U7_*-*06* Y*.^**0 .S* U7;.1-.*U
U,.,;*. ,0U .S* 1-7A70,T U,.,;*. ,0U .S* U*A-** 12 .S* +-7:,6< +-1.*6.710X
`4- *@+*-7/*0.,T -*;4T.; 4;70A ;<0.S*.76 ,0U -*,T ^1-TU U,.,;*.; ;S1^
.S,. .S* ;+,-;7W*U 5[) /*.S1U ^1->; ^*TT 70 +-*;*-:70A +-7:,6< ,; ^*TT
,; /,70.,7070A 4.7T7.< 12 .S* U,.,;*.;X
a bcdefghidjfc
' # "&#klm# & n o poq rs tr&#m urtl #urorq # &n u#
rs s k & uroo#ur #uv#k & # wrm& poq rs n k nrot# rs & krm # &#nu#k & rs n mrk x&k m# uroo#u#& lm#u#&##& kl##& &
ku o#y z# ##& srm &#mk & & t x k# rs # uroo#u#& & kl mxk
m##"#& #m#k k&q & &#n#orl & t #uv#k y#y #
k# rs urtl#m{ &#& k ku o #uv#k r |urtp} mr o m# tr rs
& srm rt u & k#t{ rt u #~lorm r & l #m &kurn#mqyzr& q
& k r# rs # trk tlrm urmlrm # kk#k rs urtl #k rn#mt#k
& m#k# mu krk €‚ & k k#& srm n mrk lmn # & lpou #m#ky
z# k# rs & t #uror#k ur#m#mmrmkt & rt#o & k#u{
mq k p## ƒrmk ku# # „yy …rn#mt# #urm #& # k# rs ku
#uror#k ††‚y $r"#n#m rn#mt# uu#kk r & k# rs l#mkr o srmt r
urtt#mu o & p k#k m k#k uru#mk pr # lmr#ur rs lmn uq & &#
‡ ˆ*6S076,T ‰*+1-. Š1X C‹ŒGDE8 )*+,-./*0. 12 31/+4.*- 567*06*8 907:*-;7.< 12 =*0G
.46><8 ?*@70A.108 =B8 ŒDDEX ˆ S7; -*;*,-6S ^1-> ^,; ;4++1-.*U Y< .S* =*0.46><
6101/< 5,2*.< ,0U 5*64-7.< \Š55Ž] 310;1-.74/X
‡‡ Š*^
G/,7T ;@4Œ6;-X4><X*U4X
‡ ‡ ‡ ˆ S* 61--*;+10U70A ,4.S1-X G/,7T R‘S,0A6;X4 ><X* U48 9‰?
” S..+’’^^^X6;X4><X*U4’“R‘S,0AX
U7,0^*7S6;-X4 ><X* U4X
• G/,7T
G/,7T R^,0A,6;-X4 ><X* U4X
€
lmru#kk  ‚y #u# lmn uq umukt smrt op#m m k r ! k z#mmrmkt
srmt r " m##kk mrm t o#& r # &#s& rs ! k srmt r
" m##kk u#y zk k #u#kk mq & t #uror#k &#k#&
srm ur#m#mmrmkt & k#umq lmlrk# n# k u# lmn uq " m##kk r
lmr#u # lmn uq rs ru# l#rlo#y „srm #oq trk #~k & t
#uror#k m# r n#mq # u# #mtk rs lmn uq lmr#urk k #q "#m#
rm ooq &#n#orl#& t oq srm urtt#mu o llou rk "u &w#m# rm {
rk uroo#u & r" #m & p k#k & t# #m & p k#k srm kl#u
u
urtt#mu o lmlrk#ky # u k#k rs k#umq & ur#m#mmrmkt & t
t q t# r ooq &w#m# y …rn#mt# t q lr# ooq n# uu#kk
r q & p k#k & t q #~m u q srmt r smrt #k# & p k#ky zk
lr# ooq ot#& uu#kk r & & srmt r m k#k # s# m rs lrkkpo#
pk#y
! u p# uroo#u#& u#m o #& oru r rm uroo#u#& &w#m# oru {
rk p #m #& u#m o #& oru r & " m#rk y o#m n#oq
& u p# uroo#u#& & krm#& &kmp#& oru rky !w#m# & krm #
l #mk t q n# &w#m# lmn uq uru#mky s # & krm # k u#m o #&
# t rm lmn uq uru#m k r k#o& # #~ u n o#k rs # mp#k smrt #
& oqkky zk & &krmr k #uv# k k ooq urk&#m#& ku k r €€ ‚y # r#m & &kmp#& & p k# k r
# t rm lmn uq uru#m k r t &#l#&#u# rs # &kmp#& & r"#mkl & r lm#n# # #~u # rs #~ u n o#k rs # mp#k p#"##
&w#m# l m#k rs # &kmp#& & p k# r"#mkly zk uru#m k m#o #&
r # kk# rs & t &kmp#& #nmrt#  €‚y zk l l#m &# ok
" # mk k r y#y "# k&q & &krmr #uv#k srm u#m o #&
& p k#y
'# lmrlrk# uo kk rs t#r&k srm lmn uq lmr#ur & lmru#kk
t q p# k#& krt# #mmrmk oqkk kqk#tk & r#m & t
llou rky '# kkt# # n#urm{kl u# tr&#o €€‚ k k#& r po& #
lrlo r & k#k srm oqkky & k# u p# m#lm#k##& pq t m~ y
u mr" rs # t m~ m#lm#k#k rp #u & # u urot rs # t m~
m#lm#k#k mp#y tr&#o lrlo rk " &n& o l#mkrk #
& k# t m~ k k ooq kl mk# k t q rs # mp#k m# r x# pq
trk rs # rp #uk kto #rkoqy z# rp #uk u p# &n& o l#mkrk rs #
##m o lrlo ry z# mp#k u p# l#mkr k t# &&m#kk # rt#
&&m#kk um#& u m& tp#mk #uy zk srmt r ur #& ku & k#k
k oq ur &# oy z# ur &# oq rs # l#mkr o srmt r kro& r
p# urtlmrtk#& # lmru#kk rs & t llou rky
rm&#m r lm#k#mn# & lmn uq "# kkt# r r# #~u#l # & r"#m rm rm #& k#mk n# # m r uu#kk # rm o & y z# oqkk
"oo roq k## # &krm#& & k# t m~ r # rm o & k# y z#
&krm#& & k# t m~ &r#k r n# rpnrk t# srm # &n& o
mp#ky z# t m~ u r p# k#& r m#urkmu # rm o t m~ )H‰QH ;.,0U; 21- )*2*0;* HU:,06*U ‰*;*,-6S Q-1R*6.; HA*06<8 , T7,.*U ^7.S .S*
)*+,-./*0. 12 )*2*0;* 12 .S* 907.*U 5.,.*; Œ‹ X
†
"r xr" # #mmrm l m y k " q # oqkk "r "oo
m # & t ormtk r # &krm#& & k# t m~ "oo r p#
po# r xr" # rm o mp#k rm # &kmpr rs # mp#k o#kk
llmrlm # l#mtkkr k m #& pq #m o#n#o r u ok r &r kry zk & t #uv#k llo#& r # &krm#& & k#k "oo t # #m#
lmrl#mq rs lmn uq lmr#ury
k l l#m "# "oo &kukk k#n#m o & &krmr t#r&k u p# k#&
lmr#u lmn uq krt# #mmrmk oqkk kqk#tky '# lmrlrk# kl mk
#&
o m o# !#urtlrkr ! t#r& srm & &krmry z#m# m#
krt# lpou rk pr k !{m#o #& t#r&k ur#m#mmrmkt & t #uv#k ku k &##u oru o urmm#o r €‚ kru o #"rmx
oqkk € ‚ rn#o srmt r &kurn#mq †‚ & srmt r #~m ur †€‚
#uy $r"#n#mr # p#k rs rm xr"o#&##m# k p## r "rmx r k !{
m#o #& t#r&k & &krmry '# okr lmrlrk# krt# t#muk r t# km#
# &w#m#u# p#"## # &krm#& & k# & # rm o & k# & #
&#m## rs lmn uq lmr#ury m #~l#mt# o m#kok k pr kq#u &
m# o "rmo& & k#k "oo kr" # kl mk
#& ! t#r& k n#mq # u# x##l pr & lmn uq & & oqy
z# kmum# rs # l l#m k k sroor"k #ur † "# mr&u# kt{
lo
#& tr&#o rs #mmrmk oqkk kqk#t " lmn uq lmr#ur krt# & &krmr t#r&k & # lmrlrk#& kl mk
#& ! t#r&y '# okr l srm
krt# lmn uq t# km# t#muk #ur y '# pm#ƒq mr&u# # & oq
t# km# #ur y z# urtl r o #~l#mt#k m# u mm#& r & #
m#kok m# &kukk#& #ur y '# kt l k l l#m #ur y
c
j
d
cg d j dfedjfc
!!!"# $%&"" &"#
ktlo
#& tr&#o #mmrmk oqkk kqk#t u p# urkk#& rs "r l mk #
& t lo r l m & # & oqkk l my k ookm #& ' m#
€ roq # & r"#m rm rm #& k#mk u t lo # # rm o & y
s#m # & &krmr lmru#kk # rm o & k# k m ksrmt#& r
urtlo##oq &w#m# & t m~ & k lmrn&#& r # oqkky oo urk # & oqkk l m m# rl#m #& r # &krm#& & t m~y 'rm #~ tlo#
# oqkk u lloq & t #uv#k ku k uo kk
u r m#o rkl
oqkk rm uok#m r # &krm#& & y k # & oqkk n# r uu#kk
r # rm o & p k# "r # rm r rs # & r"#m # lmn uq
ur #& # rm o & k lmr#u#&y
( %#% ( "#!#$
! &krmr k r# rs # trk tlrm l mk # lmrlrk#& tr&#o #mmrm{
k oqkk kqk#ty z# &#km#& &krmr t#r&k tk lm#k#mn# # lmn uq
& # k t# t# tk x##l # oq rs # & s#m # &krmr † ‚y
Data Classification
Original
Database
Authorized
User
distort
Data
Matrix
Data Clustering
Relation Analysis
Data Manipulation
Data Analysis
Analysts
P P ŽTT4;.-,.710 12 , ;7/+T7W*U /1U*T .*--1-7;. ,0,T<;7; ;<;.*/X
rt# & &krmr t#r&k p k#& r m &rt n o# n# p## lmrlrk#& &
llo#& † € ‚y '# "oo m#n#" "r rs # urttroq k#& m &rt n o# & &krmr t#r&k k "#oo k lmrlrk# uo kk rs !{p k#& t#r&k srm & &krmr k k#ury
$ ! & "#! # $" k t#r& # rm o & t m~ k &&#& pq srmtoq &kmp#& rk# t m~ †‚y k rs # k t#
k # k & k #o#t#k m# m &rt tp#mk urk# smrt # urrk
srmt &kmpr r # #mn o smrt r y z# &krm#& t m~ k y
! %& "#! # $" to moq k # lm#nrk t#r& #m# # rm{
o & t m~ k &&#& pq rmt ooq &kmp#& rk# t m~ "u
k # k t# k # k †‚y z# #o#t#k rs m# m &rt tp#mk urk# smrt
# rmt o &kmpr " l m t##mk t# & k & m& &#n r y z#
&krm#& t m~ k y
( o m o# !#urtlrkr ! € ‚ k lrlo m t#r& & t & srmt r m#m#n o ‚y k k ooq k#& r m#&u# # &t#kr{
oq rs # rm o & k# y $#m# "# k# k & &krmr t#r&y
# p# kl mk# t m~ rs &t#kr m#lm#k# # rm o & k#y
z# mr"k rs # t m~ urmm#klr& r & rp #uk & # urotk r mp#ky
z# ko m n o# &#urtlrkr rs # t m~ k € ‚
"#m# k rmrrmt o t m~ &  ‚ t k & r o t m~ "rk# r# n# & r o #m#k m# &#ku#&{
rm&#m & k rmrrmt o t m~y z# tp#m rs r #mr
& r ok rs k #v o r # m x rs # t m~ y
!# r # mm #t# rs # ko m n o#k # t m~ &#ku#&{
rm&#m # ! m ksrmt r k # lmrl#mq # t ~t o n m r
tr # rp #uk k u lm#& # mk &t#kr k ! " srm # ! †y
to moq tu rs # m#t n m rk k u lm#& # k#ur&
&t#kr
& kr ry zk m ksrmt#& t m~ " tu or"#m &t#kr u p#
urkmu#& r m#lm#k# # rm o t m~ s sooqy !# #
"#m# ur k # mk urotk rs ur k # mk r #mr
& r ok rs & ur k # mk mr"k rs y z# m x rs # t m~
k y '
p# k ooq kt oo # &t#kr oq rs # & k# k p##
m#&u#& &m t u ooq smrt t r kkt oo mp#k m# o# moq
&#l#&# y k p## lmrn#& k # p#k &t#kr o llmr~t {
r rs # k#k# rs 'mrp#k rmty
& t llou rk # k# rs r m#lm#k# k r#m tlrm{
sury z# m#trn#& l m u p# urk&#m#& k # rk# # rm o & k#  ‚y zk t q u k#k t r # m#&u#& & k#
t q q#o& p##m m#kok t r # rm o & k# y '# k#&
srm lmn uq lm#k#mn # &krm#& & u lmrn&# lmr#ur srm & lmn uq # k t# t# t q x##l # oq rs # rm o & k u s sooq m#lm#k# # rm o & y
%!" ( '# lmrlrk# & &krmr t#r& k p##m !
lm#k#mn lmn uq kl mk
#& !y
s#m m#&u # m x rs # ! t mu#k "# k# krt# kt oo k # #m#k
"u m# kt oo#m u#m m#kro& & r #mry '# m#s#m
r k rl#m r k # &mrll rl#m r €†‚y 'rm #~ tlo# n# m#kro&
n o# "# &mrl " s " y to moq #o#t# " k okr
&mrll#& s " y # &#r# " &mrll#& #o#t#k & &#r#
" &mrll#& #o#t#k "# u m#lm#k# # &krm#& & t m~ "
z# kl mk
#& ! t#r& k #vn o# r sm#m &krm # & k# y
!#r# "# n#
z# & lmrn&#& r # oqkk k "u k "u# &krm#& # kl mk
#&
! t#r&y
z# ! kl mk
u r uru#l " k lmrlrk#& pq … r & €†‚ srm
m#&u # krm # urk & # u # l#msrmt u# rs ! #~ m#m#n o
llou rky #n#m o kl mk
u r km ##k "#m# lmrlrk#& & #~l#mt##&
€†‚y z# r# "# k#& k l l#m k # ktlo#k r#y
ej i he rt# lmn uq t#muk n# p## lmrlrk#& o#m m# €†‚y $r"#n#m # t#mu
k#& †‚ k p## lmrn#& r p# urtlo## €‚ & # r# k#& €‚ ##&k
r xr" # &#kq sur rs # u mp#
"u t q p# & uo
r rp srm # m# o "rmo& & k#ky '# lmrlrk# krt# lmn uq t# km#k "u
roq &#l#& r # rm o t m~ & k &krm#& ur#ml m y
% ( !$ s#m & t m~ k &krm#& # n o# rs k #o#t#k u #ky z# n o#
&w#m#u# rs # & k#k k m#lm#k##& pq # m#o n# n o# &w#m#u# # 'mrp#k rmty zk k # m r rs # 'mrp#k rmt rs # &w#m#u#
rs & r # 'mrp#k rmt rs 'rm #~ tlo# srm # sroor" & k# k &krm#& & t m~ k
rp #& pq lloq # l mk
#& ! " † &  €y z# #
n o# urtl#& srm k &krmr k y € y
 € €  € †  
† †  †
†
€
€
  €  € €  †
€ € †
"#$
( !$ s#m & &krmr # m#o n# rm&#m rs # n o# rs # & #o#t#k
u #k rry '# k# k#n#m o t#muk r t# km# # lrkr &w#m#u# rs #
& #o#t#ky
'# k# r &#r# # n#m # u # rs rm&#m srm oo # mp#ky s#m
# #o#t#k rs mp# m# &krm#& # rm&#m rs # u "#o#t# u #ky
kkt# & k# k & rp #uk & mp#ky &#r#k # k{
u#& rm&#m rs # #o#t# mp# # & " &#r#k # ku#&
rm&#m rs # &krm#& #o#t# " y z# k &#
#& k "
" " s "r #o#t#k n# # k t# n o# "# &#
# # #o#t# " # or"#m mr"
&#~ r n# # #m rm&#my & k# # rm&#m n#urm srm # mk
mp# u p# m#lm#k##& k € †‚ y s#m # &krmr † € ‚ y z# r o u # rs rm&#m srm k mp# k y '# u u ouo # #
r o u # rs rm&#m srm # r#m mp#k & # €y†y
m#lm#k#k # l#mu# # rs #o#t#k x##l #m rm&#mk rs n o# # u urot s#m # &krmry k urtl#& k "
" "#m# " m#lm#k#k "##m rm r #o#t# x##lk k lrkr # rm&#m
rs n o#k "
"
"
€
s
 r#m"k# rm #~ tlo# # rm&#m n#urm rs # k#ur& mp# k † € ‚ &
s#m # &krmr k koo † € ‚ y zk oo # #o#t#k x##l #m rm o
rm&#my srm k #~ tlo# k y €y
# t q s#m # ur# rs mp# smrt k m#o n# n o# &w#m#u#
urtl m#& " # r#m mp#ky zk k &#km po# # rm&#m rs #
n#m # n o# rs # u mp# n m#k s#m # & &krmry $#m# "# k# #
t#mu r &# # # u # rs rm&#m rs # n#m # n o# rs # mp#k '
" " " "#m# " k # ku#& rm&#m rs # n#m # n o# rs mp# # "o#
" &#r#k k ku#& rm&#m s#m # &krmry 'rm k u# # rm&#m
n#urm rs oo mp#k t m~ k † €‚ y z# rm&#m n#urm srm #
&krm#& t m~ k  € †‚ y z# # r o u # rs rm&#m k kr k
#v o r €y†y
to moq k "# &#
# r t# km# # l#mu# # rs # mp#k
x##l #m rm&#mk rs n#m # n o# s#m # &krmry r k u ouo #& k "#m# " k urtl#& k "
" € s " "  r#m"k# # lm#nrk #~ tlo#  † y
z# #m # n o# rs & & # or"#m # n o# rs &
# trm# lmn uq k lm#k#mn#&y
dj jd he z# & oq t# km#k kk#kk "##m & k# x##lk # l#msrmt u# rs
& t #uv#k s#m # & &krmr #yy "##m # &krm#& & u t # uum uq rs # & t #uv#k ku k uo kk
u r
uok#m #uy k l l#m "# urrk# # uum uq llrm #urm u#
uo kk u r k # & oq t# km#y
k p k#& r kmum o mkx tt r #rmq † ‚y k p## ku{
u#kksooq llo#& r t q llou rk ox# s u# &#
u r #~ u #rm r
prsrmt uk #uy  €‚y
ql#mlo # k#l m #k #
uo kk u r # r o k r &
#~ tlo#k " t ~tt t my …n# #~ tlo#k yyy "
" & " € € srm oo # uo kk u r u p# k #& k v &m u
lmrm tt lmrpo#t €
tt # † "
" " " " € "
kp #u r " ! 

"#m# k k#m{k#o#u#& m#o m r l m t##m & " k ko ux n m po#
uur srm #mmrmky s#m kron # v &m u lmrm tt
lmrpo#t "# u # # sroor" &#ukr sur €
"" " " "#m#  " y
'rm # ro# m u k# "# lloq t ll r t l # l
kl u# r krt# s# m# kl u# y $#m# "# k# x#m#o sur " " "u k kqtt#mu sur & k k #k # #mu#m k ur&ry
'# kpk# " srm # &r lmr&u "u t lk # l kl u# r
krt# m#lmr&u#& x#m#o s# m# kl u#y z# v r € u p# m#"m# k "
" " " †
ej cd cg h d '# ur&u krt# #~l#mt#k r #k # l#msrmt u# rs # & &krmr
t#r&k ! kl mk
#& ! ! && srmtoq &kmp#& rk# „! & && rmt ooq &kmp#& ! rk#y
&$# # %#%"#
mk "# urtl m# # l#msrmt u# rs # srm & &krmr t#r&k k
kq#u & k#y z# & k# k † pq € t m~ m "rk# #m#k
m# m &rtoq ##m #& tp#mk " # #mn o €€‚ rp#q srmt
&kmpry '# uo kksq # & k# r "r uo kk#k k m &rtoq urk#
mo# s
k m # € m # urk m # m # € # m#urm& # k kk#& r uo kk € r#m"k# k kk#& r uo kk €y '# k#
uo kk
u r €‚ r urkmu # uo kk
#m & {sro& umrkk n o& r
r rp # uo kk
u r m#koky z# srmtoq &kmp#& rk# k ##m #&
smrt # #mn o  y‚y z# rmt ooq &kmp#& rk# k ##m #& " 
&  y 'rm ! & ! # m x k urk# r p#  & !
# &mrll m#kro& n o# k € y
z po# € kr"k # n o# rs # lmn uq t# km#k & # oq t# km#
rs lloq # & &krmr t#r&ky 'rm # kq urtl mkr "# k# # n o# rs „! ! & ! r p# llmr~t #oq #v oy z k "# urtl m# #k#
'
NJ P 31/+,-7;10 12 U7;.1-.710 /*.S1U; 21- .S* ;<0.S*.76 U,.,;*.X
),., H664-,6<
`-A G G G G G XF 9) DXFC‹ D D FXE Š) DX FFŒX DXDDŒF D EX
5[) DX Œ FFFX DXDDD XŒŒ DXE XŒ 55[) DXFC FF X‹ DXDDDŒ ‹FXC Œ D FX
t#r&k &#m # ur&r #q orkk llmr~t #oq # k t# tr rs
n o# s#m # & &krmry k #~l#mt# „! x##lk # m#o n# rm&#m rs
# u #o#t# & # u mp#y zk "# x lmrn&#k # o# k lmr#ur
srm lmn uqy ! k p##m „! u # rm&#m rs # #o#t#k p x##lk # rm&#m rs # mp#ky r ! & ! m# p##m x##l #
lmn uq srm # #o#t#k & # mp#ky ! k #n# p##m !y k kto m n o# " ! n o# p k n o# k tu or"#m "u
t# k s#"#m #o#t#k x##l #m rm&#m s#m # &krmry k n o# k trm#
m## t#k #m rs !y z# n o# srm ! k  "u
t# k oo # mp#k u # #m rm&#m n#m # n o# s#m # &krmry
'rm ! roq pr os rs # mp#k u # #m rm&#my
#~ o# k orrx r" #k# &krmr t#r&k x##l # & oqy z#
uum uq urot z po# € kr"k # l#mu# # rs # urmm#uoq uo kk #& & m#urm&ky z# uum uq rs uo kksq # rm o & k# k y y „k „! &
! or"#mk k uum uq oo# py 'o# k ! & ! # uum uq
k u ooq tlmrn#&y z# uum uq rs k ! k m k#& r y† "o# k
! k y y
% ! %#%"#
'rm m# o "rmo& & k# "# &r"or & krt# srmt r pr € #mmrmkk
smrt #mmrmk oqkk "#p k# † ‚y '# k#o#u#& † mp#k † ku
k #m r oq &w#m# kpo m#o rklk lor m oru rk rs
#tlrm mq m#k&#uq "#&& #& u# t## #& u# #uy z# rm o
t m~ k rs &t#kr € †y zr #k # m# o "rmo& & k# # srmtoq
&kmp#& rk# k urk# smrt # #mn o  y ‚y z# rmt ooq &kmp#&
rk# k ##m #& "  &   y z# m x srm ! & ! k
urk# r p# † y z# &mrll m#kro& n o# ! k € y
z po# † "# uo kksq # #mmrmkk r "r mrlk rk# m# m#o #& "
&# & rk# m# ry z# uum uq rs uo kksq # rm o & k# k
y z# „! & ! t#r&k x##l k uum uq "o# k ! # uum uq
mk#k r  y z# uum uq rp #& pq k ! k okr tlmrn#k oo#
py zk ! & ! m# oo# p##m & oqy
rm&#m r p# s m urtl m # lmn uq t#muk "# okr t x# # n o# rs „! ! & ! r p# otrk # k t#y 'rm lmn uq lmr#ur „!
&r#k r l#msrmt "#ooy &r#k r u # q rm&#m rs # #o#t#k mp#k
NJ P 31/+,-7;10 12 U7;.1-.710 /*.S1U; 21- 6T,;;7W6,.710 \ 70 ?,U*0 ,;;167,.710]X
),., H664-,6<
`-A G G G G G F 9) DXDEFF D XC DXE F Š) DXDE‹ ‹ X DXDŒ ŒXŒ DXŒ FF 5[) DXDEŒE ‹ XŒ DXDŒE ŒXŒ DXŒ D 55[) XDCŒŒ ‹ XE DXDDFF ‹X DXDE F & k # or"#k & n o#ky ! k p##m „! p k
k
u oq "rmk# ! t# km#y z# n o# rp #& pq k
! k y† "o# ! m#&u#k trm# os r y€†y tr # srm
&krmr t#r&k ! k # p#k r lm#k#mn# lmn uq k #~l#mt#y k # #k & n o#k "u t# k k # p#k x##l #
lmn uq rs # rm&#m rs # &n& o #o#t#ky okr k # p#k & n o#k "u t# k okr #~u##&k r#m t#r&k u # rm&#m rs #
mp#ky
NJ P 31/+,-7;10 12 U7;.1-.710 /*.S1U; 21- 6T,;;7W6,.710 Œ \HT ,*U, ,;;167,.710]X
),., H664-,6<
`-A G G G G G F 9) DXDE E ‹ X DXD FF XE DXD FF Š) DXDEFF ‹CX DXD‹ D ŒXD DXD FC 5[) DXDEŒE ‹ XŒ DXDŒE ŒXŒ DXŒ D 55[) X‹ Œ ‹EXD DXDD D XE DXDŒ FE z po# kr"k # m#kok rs l#msrmt r#m uo kk
u r r # m# o
"rmo& & k#y zk t# # #mmrmkk m# mrl#& uurm& r "##m rm r
#q n# m#o rkl " # #mmrmk rm r o #& y z# lm#nrk
m# mp# pr "##m l#mkr k m#o rkl " &# k
k#m#& r # & t m~ & # mp# pr "##m l#mkr k
m#o rkl " o #& k x# r k # m# mp#y zk # rm o
& t m~ srm lmn uq oqkk k oo# &w#m# smrt # r# k#& #
lm#nrk uo kk
u r kxy oo # &krm#& t mu#k m# ##m #& smrt #
#" rm o t m~y
"# x##l # n o# r p# n#mq kto m srm „! ! & !y
! k # p#k srm # uo kk
u r m#ko tlmrn#k # uum uq  rn#m
k # rm o & k# y z# r#m m## t#r&k &#um# k# # uum uq
kooqy 'rm # lmn uq lmr#ur ! "rmxk p#k x##l # lmn uq rs
# u #o#t#ky k # #k & or"#k n o#ky k n o# k
kooq or"#m rk# rs ! & ! p k n o# k trm# m##
t#k or"#m rs ! & k~ t#k or"#m rs !y ! k
€
r rk & lm#k#mn lmn uq k #~l#mt#y ! #~u##&k & n o#ky k #~ tlo# ! k koo # p#k x##l # lmn uq
rs & y
fci hgjc e '# lmrlrk#& r k# # kl mk
#& ! t#r& srm & &krmr ktlo
#&
tr&#o #mmrmk oqkk kqk#ty z# #~l#mt# o m#kok kr" ! k #
p#k lm#k#mn & lmn uqy k okr # u# x##l & oqy !
"rmxk "#oo rry r m# p##m # k & m& & &krmr t#r&k
"u && rk# km srm" m&oqy '# p#o#n# # !{p k#& t#r&k u p# k#& & t #uv#k srm & &krmr lmlrk# rm&#m r lmr#u
lmn uq & r#m k#kn# srmt r ur #& & nkpo# # rm o
& k#ky 'm#m m#k# mu u p# &r# r #k # uru# rs &w#m# kl mk
#& ! l m t##mk ku k & r # #w#u rs # & &krmry #m !
kl mk
u r km ##k €†‚ u okr p# #k#& # & &krmr llou rky
kro& p# lr#& r # llou r rs # lmrlrk#& !{p k#& & &krmr t#r&k k r ot#& r # #mmrmk oqkk kqk#tky q & oqkk lmru#kk#k "u #m# k ##& srm & &krmr t q p##
smrt
# lmrlrk#& !{p k#& & &krmr t#r&ky
e ci X )X HA-,^,T ,0U 3X 3X HAA,-^,TX `0 .S* U*;7A0 ,0U V4,0.7W6,.710 12 +-7:,6< +-*;*-:G
70A U,., /7070A ,TA1-7.S/;X Ž0 !" ! # $$%$ &8 5,0., ,-Y,-,8 3,T721-07,8
95H8 ' ,< ŒDD X
ŒX ‰X HA-,^,T ,0U ‰X 5-7>,0.X Q-7:,6<G+-*;*-:70A U,., /7070AX Ž0 $$# $$ $$ 8 ),TT,;8
ˆ*@,;8 ' ,<8 ŒDDDX
‹X ‰X HA-,^,T8 HX :W/7*:;>78 ,0U ‰X 5-7>,0.X Ž021-/,.710 ;S,-70A ,6-1;; +-7:,.*
U,.,Y,;*;X 70 ( $$# $$ $$ 8 ++X FG 8 5,0 )7*A18 3H8 ŒDD‹X
CX ' X Z X *--<8 ) X )-/,68 ,0U X ‰X * *;;4+X ' ,.-7@8 :*6.1- ;+,6*8 ,0U 7021-/,.710
-*.-7*:,TX +&8 C ‹‹E, ‹FŒ8 X
EX 3X 4-A*;X "$# "!! - $ $ X =T4^*H6,U*/76 Q4YT7;S*-;8 X
FX 3X 3,/+Y*TTX =*-0*T /*.S1U; H ;4-:*< 12 64--*0. .*6S07V4*;X . " ! " 8 C \ŒDDŒ] F‹G CX
X 5X ),..,8 / X =,-A4+.,8 ,0U =X 57:,>4/,-X / 1/*T,0U U*2*0;*8 +-7:,6<G;*0;7.7:* U,.,
/7070A8 ,0U -,0U1/ :,T4* U7;.1-.710X Ž0 01 ! $$ " $
" 2 3(4 8 5,0 5-,067;618 3H8
' ,< ŒDD‹X
X 5X )**^*;.*-8 5X )4/,7;8 $#& Ž0U*@70A Y< T,.*0. ;*/,0.76 ,0,T<;7;8 6& & &
& &8 7 ‹ , CD 8 DX
€€
X X X )*/+;*< ,0U QX ‰1;*0‘^*7AX ˆ*6S01T1A7*; .S,. 6,0 +-1.*6.
+-7:,6< ,; 7021-/,.710
7; ;S,-*U .1 61/Y,. .*--1-7;/X ?*A,T ' */G
1-,0U4/ 8 ˆ S* / *-7.,A* 5140U,.7108 ' ,< ŒF8 ŒDDCX H:,7T,YT* ,.
& $ & $ #$
# & X
DX [X ;.:7TTG3,;.-18 ?X -,0>1:768 ,0U )X ?X )1^*X Q-7:,6< 70 U,., /70G
70AX H4;.-,T7,0 31/+4.*- 5167*.<8 Š5Z -,06S8 H4;.-,T7,X H:,7T,YT* ,.
&$& &$" $# & #X
X Z X 5-,0>*; ,0U ‰X ,*‘,GB,.*;X $ +$# $$ "" $
#
X Q-*0.76*G / ,TT8 0AT*^11U 3T7_;8 Š * 8 ŒX
ŒX * X ,1 ,0U * X ) S,0AX 5+,-;7W6,.710 ;.-,.*A7*; 70 T,.*0. ;*/,0.76 70U*@70A8 70 ( 01 ! 8 ' X Z X *--< ,0U Z X ' X Q1..*0A*-8
\*UX]8 ++X ‹, D‹8 5,0 5-,067;618 3H8 ' ,<ˆˆQ
‹8 ŒDD‹X
‹X X 7TY4-U8 HX 56S4;.*-8 ,0U ‰X Z1T_X =G
 , 0*^ +-7:,6< /1U*T 21- T,-A*G;6,T*
U7;.-7Y4.*U *0:7-10/*0.;X 70 $$#
#
+ $
$$ \=)) DC]8 5*,..T*8 ZH8 95H8
ŒDDCX
CX X / X 1T4Y ,0U 3X 5 X :,0 ?1,0X $
! "$ 8 * 1S0 / 1+>70; 907:X8 ‹-U
UX8 FX
EX ˆ X * 1,6S7/;X ' ,>70A T,-A*G;6,T* 5[ ' T*,-070A +-,6.76,TX +$ #
"!! - $ 8 X 56S 1T>1+28 3X 4-A*; ,0U HX 5/1T, \*UX]8
' Ž ˆ GQ-*;;8 X
FX 3X =X ?7*^8 9X * X 3S178 ,0U 3X * X ?7*^X H U,., U7;.1-.710 Y< +-1Y,Y7T7.< U7;.-7G
Y4.710X $$ $$%$ 8 [1TX D8 Š1X ‹8 5*+.*/Y*- E8
Q,A*; ‹ EGC X
X BX ?78 5X 10A8 / X ?7UU*TTX 54++1-. :*6.1- -*A-*;;710 ,0U 6T,;;7W6,.710 Y,;*U /4T.7G
:7*^ 2,6* U*.*6.710 ,0U -*61A07.710X Ž0 & $$# " $ $ $
" 2 34 8 -*01YT*8 5-,06*8 ŒDDDX
X )X X 5>7TT761-0X 3T4;.*-; ^7.S70 6T4;.*-; 5[) ,0U 6140.*-.*--1-7;/8 70 ( 01 ! $$ " $
" 8 Œ +,A*;8
5,0 5-,067;618 3H8 ' ,< ‹8 ŒDD‹X
X )X X 5>7TT761-0X 5167,T 0*.^1-> ,0,T<;7; :7, /,.-7@ U*61/+1;7.710; ,++T76,.710; .1
,T ,*U,8 ˆ*6S076,T ‰*+1-.8 56S11T 12 31/+4.70A8 4**0 ; 907:*-;7.<8 H4AX ŒDDCX
ŒDX )X X 5>7TT761-0
,0U ŠX [,.;X Š1:*T 7021-/,.710 U7;61:*-< 21- 70.*TT7A*06* ,0U 6140G
.*-.*--1-7;/8 ˆ*6S076,T ‰*+1-. ŒDDCGC 8 56S11T 12 31/+4.70A8 4**0 ; 907:*-;7.<8
5*+X ŒDDCX
Œ X HX 5408 ' X Š,70A8 $#& 9;70A ;4++1-. :*6.1- /,6S70*; 21- .*--1-7;/ 7021-/,.710
*@.-,6.7108 8 ŒDD‹ G ŒX
ŒŒX =X HX ˆ,7+,T*X ),., /7070A ,0U U1/*;.76 ;*64-7.< 6100*6.70A .S* U1.; .1 /,>*
;*0;* 12 U,.,X #" & & & $ +&8 E \ŒDD‹] , ‹X
Œ‹X ˆ X ˆ*.S*-X 5.,.*/*0. Y*21-* .S* 54Y61//7..** 10 ˆ*6S01T1A<8 Ž021-/,G
.710 Q1T76<8 Ž0.*-A1:*-0/*0.,T ‰*T,.710; ,0U .S* 3*0;4;8 31//7..** 10 1:G
*-0/*0. ‰*21-/8 9X5X / 14;* 12 ‰*+-*;*0.,.7:*;8 ' ,< F8 ŒDD‹X H:,7T,YT* ,.
& $& + ! ( ( & #X
ŒCX ^^^X.-,6>70A.S*.S-*,.X6 1/
ŒEX [X ŠX [,+07>X $$# $ X *1S0 Z7T*< 510;8 Š*^ B1->8 X
ŒFX [X 5X [*-<>71;8 X *-.7018 ŽX ŠX 51:7018 $#& 5.,.*G12G.S*G,-. 70 +-7:,6< +-*;*-:70A
U,., /7070AX 8 ‹‹ \ŒDDC] ED, E X
*
۠