! "
'
#$
$
% ! $$&
'
(
)
•
!
•
"
!
•
#
!
)
#
!
)
#
$
$
#
!
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
1
*+
(
*+*+
)
,
%&&'
"
/
1
,
*''*
/
.
2
*''456
%&&456
%
(
%&&)
*
-
.
+
3
0
/
8 )''
*''4
.
788
7%6&
8 4''
*''6
+
*''9
*''6
1
*''*
:
.
/
" ;
*'%%
<
/
,
<
1
/
.
" -
/
/
,
8
=
*'%*
3 %>
:
?
:
?
@
+
:
*'%*
%
*
8
=*'''>
$ 11" =*'''> /
B/
C/
<
=*'%*> / /
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
/
%&&6.&&$ 1
=D/ &)>
,
/
2
1
"
=%&&A> @
$
.+
.
$
$
/
(
+
$
:
.
E
=
=
>
$
.+
>
.
.
$
/
1
$
"
*'%4
8 46'
8%
*'%*
*'%% 4
*+.+
*''9
/
(
%*
)
1
?
1
2
3
@
4
<
D
/
*6 1
D
*'%*
/
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
<
=
3
> 1@(*'5*'%*
:
+
3
1
1
F1/
/
3 "
F1
B
•
/
(
6
E
1
A
1
*''8
"
9
3
.
.
.
.
.
.
98G
D
)
(
&*G
9%G
%A =
> 1
&
(
&&
%8
*8G
%'
1
.
=4AG
%9G>
=8AG>
6
; =*''*> D .
"$
$#
I
$
.
"$
$#
I
: =*''8> ,
9 *8C88$ 1
D
;
A
1
9
1
=*''4> ,
)
(
/
/
H@
&
(
/ H
;
%'
1
; 1
D
//@
I
0 <
:
!
" =*''6> @
:
1
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
/
=*''A>
3
4
H @
1
#
!
" =*'%'>
D
D
=*''4>
*) 4&.6)
=*''A>
/
/
# J
3
1
//@
D
" =*''6>
=A4G>
//@$ 1
//@
,
46 )99C))8
.
:
-
%%
3
=8*G>
@
F1
%*
3
?
%8
3
%4
K
•
/ F1
=*'%%>%6
D
D
.
D
E
F1
3
%%
%*
0 <
(
%8
;
%4
@
F
%6
D
1
D
1
" =*'%'>
//@
- 2(
/ D
L
D
/ =*''9>
,
%%& =*> 88A.844
;
- < =*'%%> /
1
A 4 *%'.**9
<
D
< =
>#
<
<3
D .
2
D
0 @
0
1
" =*'%%>
/
(
D .
D
;
I
<
( , =*'%%>
K
1
(
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
5
.
.
0
;
0
,
I
88 =*'%%> %8)8C%8&%
@
$ #
,
-
C
;
(
/
=*''8>%A
1
=6*G
.
88G
>
<
.
2
?
FI
3
*+0+
'
"
)
3
!/
"
FI
!
A9 '''
*'%*
%9
9 ''' =
%8G>
<
*'') =
%>
66G
6
&G - 3
9G
46G
4G /
/
.+
=94G>
#
1
=
*'G
8AG>
*6G>
%'.%6
=
*'')
4%G
2
-
*'%* =6AG>
*'')
4)G
@
*''9
*'%%
-
*'%%
%A
;
%9
1
=
8% -
=*''A>
<
8% -
%>
*'%*
8 46'
4''
<
*'%*
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
6
=
%*G>
.
0
8% *'%*
%AG =4 %&'>
@
/
89G =%' %A'>
.
1
:
*''6
D
1
(
:
)G =* %8'>
6G =% *&'>
3
/
2
8% -
*'%*
! "
?
94G
C
#$$%&#$ #
#$$%
6& 8A'
#$$'
A' )&'
#$ $
A4 4%'
#$
A6 6*'
#$ #
A9 '6'
*8 *6'
*6 9''
*) '&'
*9 8%'
*) **'
*4 6''
*6 '8'
*6 8%'
*A )8'
*9 86'
8 %)'
8 88'
8 *''
8 '6'
8 46'
%)
@
/
+
=
,
@
3
>
B
B
%&
•
6
%)
@
*4G
<
;
(
%&
1
1
(
98G
<
2
<.( L.%'.'6
H =%&&)>
*' =%> %8.*)
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
?
=*'%'> /
K
7
%'
8G
%6
89G
4
/
*'
•
)4G
#
9G
*G
/
6G
*G
3
&G
%'G
3
/
="
,
2
/
>
*%
**
1
/
3
E1
+
C
C
3
•
(
*''6*8
1
.
3
.
.
@
=
>
*'
J
(
,
@
21
2
**
<
1
;
/
/
*8
1
/
#
,
1
<
/
/
; =*''&>
BD
/
1@ ((*4
, J
3
@
1
=*''6>
0
B
$ @
/
=%&&)> ;
; (
@
#
0
,
M 1 # ?
#
F
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
8
0
@
; 1
D
,
/
; =%&&%>
,
- =*'')> ,
(
.
.
*4
•
)
1
*6
1
3
.
?
.
*+1+
2
2
'
(
-)
8G
*'%* =&'
>
*
*A
9
A6G
.+
=94G
*9
1
*'%%>
%*
%8'
&A
=
%%
3
A*G /
=)8G>
%8'
+
*AG> )'
B
%*G
"
1
3
*4
1
*6
=*''9>
89 =9>
#
1
,
F
1
1
:
E 3
%%98.%%))
; =*'%'> /
/
;
D
1
:
1
=*''A>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
<3
/
/
*A
*9
<
9
/
@
1
*)
2
*&
@
-<
3
= N8*>
1
=9'G>
8'
/
@
.
=4%G>
3
.
=%)G>
=8'G>$
=%4G>
+
5
84G
@
69
5
8%
#
.
C
3
+
#
.
=
"
6>
#
8*
*)
*&
1
@
=*'')>
<
;
(
8'
8%
8*
@
#
#
<
2
<.( L.%'.'6
?
=*'%'>
#
-
<(
.:
<(
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
< ( =*'%'> "
<.( '68
=*'%*> "
@<.( *'&
10
=*'%'> /
*
+
,
3
3
3
@
FI
3
(
+
(
,
3
+
.
?
"
3
3
.+
3'
)
"
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
11
.+*+
/
D
F
88
"
#
$
$
+
$
$
$ 3
$
$
2
&*
&AG
"
.
0
3
3
#
&6
%* 6
3
=
>
3
B
/
3
2
.
88
,
B
B
1
1
#
D 1
;
D
+
2
( =*''4>
@
,
"
+
(
D
$ #
;
D
I
1
$#
;
#
%8 =%> )'.&'$ #
D = > =*''A> F
(
F
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
D
1
; =*''A> B1
1
*''A F
12
I
,
; =*'')>
D =*'')>
@
0
/
1
84
B
86
8A
B
3
B
?
/
B
?
=
.
+
B
>
.
%)
?
=
>
+
3
%A
89
?
/
%)
786* '68
?
%6
7*8 49'
?
9
%)
3
78&8 69&
/
?
%A
76A **A
8'
/
F
/
%A
8'
7*' %%&
7% 489
7%%% &*8 79 &&4
1
3
?
/
.
?
.
3
84
D
D
1
,
86
#
=*''A> F
8A
; =*''6> BD
1
D
; =*''A> B1
*''A F
D =*'%'> "
<
D
1
1
M
#
89
+
/ #
0
I
,
1
,
3
?
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
!(
B
13
?
,
/
1
(
D =
F
>
.+.+
,
FI
1
1
=11 >
=*''8> 8)
1
11
=
>
11
2
/
"
B
=
6
9
%%
-
>
7*6 9)*
/
7%* '96 =
8&
2
7& 84A 7*& *&8>
3
1
%&G
5
99G
?
5
*G
/
2
7A '&*
7%%9
7*% 7*A'
88G
64G
A4
2
2
11
3
.
=
7* 884 =746
7%8 6''
4'
/
1
/
*''*>
>
.
79%
*''&
3
786 84' 4%
3
=O// >
O//
8)
1
8&
; 1
B
&A
78A &'6
8'
# J
3
=
/
=*''8>
>
D/
88
2
786 84'
0
.
/
*''*
6
9
3
+
4'
4%
B
1
;1
1@.((%4&
;
,
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
# ?
=*''&> /
14
(
(
O//
D/
O//
B
O//
3
.
1
PD
P
=
+
>
.
P
3
Q
R
3
=*'%'>4*
:
1
O//
.
#
3
%)
7*6 '''
2
3
48
@
74 48'
76 )86
7%8 8A&
.
@
.
3
7A *9' /
2
7* )4*
3
7&)'
1
1
7A A'4 /
@
3
4*
48
:
@
;=*'%'> 0
=*'%'>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
,
<3
15
?
11
1
-
/
3
*
,
#
3
+
#
3
2
3
(
3
1
?
.
#
O//
"
3
3
3
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
16
,
0+
)
0+*+
4
(
-
•
.
3
1
3
3
$
44
$
3
3
46
4A
3
(
C
.
49
/
4)
-
+
"
B
3
/
/
'C4
44
#
- =*'''>
K
1
/
1
(
4A
(
49
J
1
<
4)
4&
6'
6C%'
4&
=A9 )G>
6'
-
46
=%) 4G>
1
1
;=*'')>
;#
-
< (
M
D =*'%'> "
,
1
(
** &5%' A)6.9'8
; =*''&> 0 .
86 4 6A%.6A9
; =*''&> /
K
1
(
8% %%%& . %%*A
,
1
;
" =*'')>B<
,
,
%8
* =*'')> **%C88
;
#
O =*''8>
(
,
/
/
@
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
17
,
3
+
1
?
"
.
+
(
+
.
3
+
6%
2
•
-
2
"
B
"
B
3
6*
=*''6>68
1
%)G
3
=4AG>
/
/
2
>
,
=
/
?
0
"
6*
+
64
3
6%
6*
1
68
1
64
I
:
=*'%'>
=*''A>
=*''6>
, 2
;
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
-
I =*''9> ,
18
,
0
"
/
"
/
66
1
3
- 3
/
"
6A
69
"
2
.
6)
#
I M
=%&&4>6&
B
2
1
F1/
%&)'
FI
%&&'
B
B
<
A'
I M D =%&&&>A%
1
? /
@
8% 8
- =*'')> B(
;
2
I =*''A> /
@
1
%% %8&.%4A
69
=*'%'>
6)
=*'')> ,
K
1
(
8' %% %88A.%844
6&
I M D (
1
0 =%&&4>
1
D
1
1
A'
#
O <
(
; =*''A> ,
,
/
@
66
A%
I M D =%&&&>
<
;
9%
66
1
6A
I
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
19
%4
% *'') 86C44
,
#
,
"
,
;
1
#
$ ; 5@
"
1
#
8A 4%C
%&&&$ 9) %$ , J
B
C
1
1
=I M
3
&'
>
@
/
3
+
O
+
=
>
!
"
.
"
,
,
#
I M
/
+
#
=
.
.
>
/
?
I M
A*
I
"
*A
1
•
#
A*
I
;=*'%'>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
=*> B
/
20
@
O
84=*>
"
3
=*'%'>A8
1
/
K
A4
#
@
A6
*
5
,
.
.
-
+
.
.
/
"
C
+
=
3 *>
/
H@
0
<
A8
A4
1
#
; =*'%'>
;=*'')>
;
A6
-
;
1
#
,
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
8) % 8&.64
/ = > =%&&&> D
D
21
@
//@
84 =8> 8*.89
-
=*'')>
0+.+
5
#
AA
@
/
+
O
/
#
+
.
3
$
(
1
.
?
=
>
A9
J
3
A)
(
+
-<
3
A&
C
9'
<
9%
9*
1
-<
-<
AA
@
A9
=*''8> F
A 8 8.8'
A)
J
A&
1
9'
"
9%
-
9*
1
=*'%'>
1
: =*''4> ,
=*'%*> (
=*'')>
=*'%%> ,
1
1
, H
; =*''%> B2
O
;
=*'')>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
.
D
/
//@ 0
J
//@
:
A*
22
"
(
<
-<
?
?
98
=
1
94
J
>
/
C
96
@
,
+
@
@
9A
B
2
C
99
3
9)
/
K
(
9&
)'
F1
1
?
)%
C
FI
98
94
1
96
@
9A
@
99
9)
1
1
)'
)%
/
9&
=*'%'>
J
=*'%'>
=*'%'>
=*'%%>
;
1
=*'%'>
=*''6>
;=*'''>
( ; =*'%'> / 3
.:
<
<
K
HK
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
1
(
23
8* 8&&.4')
1
;(@
=*'%'>
*
,
.
$
-<
3
$
C
C
0
&
$
"
+
?
$
=
-
1 J
3
>
$
+
"
$
)
B
$
+
1
$
+
/
3
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
$
24
(
+
+
C
3
$
=
2
>$
3
$
+
@
-
0+0+
$'
#
@
*''&
3
;
40
+
2
*'%%>
=
-
%'G
0
.2
B
"
$
$
$
-
$
?
5
)*
/
•
)*
/
"
$
;=*''A>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
#
D
25
//@
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
"
$
=
,
@
,
D
"
D
,
D
>$
.
$
$
$
$
$
3
$
$
$
$
FI
)8
F1
•
0
5
)4
"
3
3
.
)6
)A
)9
Although
3
))
=*''A>)&
(
)8
; @
1
)4
(
3
)6
1
)A
1
I
(,
)9
))
;
=*'')> (
(
,
*'') %8$ %'%C%%* / (
=*''4>/ 1
1
(
,
,
,
,
;
;/ 1
- H
; =%&))> ,
%' %'%C%%9
1D H
;/ =%&&%> /
A6 *4)C*A6
H
=%&&%>
/ H1
@ =%&9%> /
- K
( :
(I H
- D =%&))> ,
88 **9C*88)
=%&))>
$
- H
( , =%&&'> /
A& *'&C**6$ 1
H
=%&&%>
$
#
(
(
*''4
&
@
/
% )&.%'A
%A 8*C8) $
( =*''6> 1
*9 9%9C
984 >
)&
(
H
=*''A>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
26
$
$
$
?
•
&'
3
"
F1
8&G
%&G
&%
&*
1
$
?
$
3
=
&8
>
/
&4
•
&
C
.
(
J
3
=
>
F1
&6
" @
FI
&A
=%&&'>
$1
3
.
86G
&'
(
=%&))>
$
=%&&'>
;
,
H
=%&&%>
; 1
-
&%
&*
1
1
94
I
&8
,
&6
1
K
&A
H
H
=%&&%>
H
1
/
- (
(
H @
;
;/ H
%' %%&C%8'
=*''4> #
;(
. .
*) =*>
?
=%&))> ,
@
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
27
3
FI
+
&9
/ *'%%
A%G
*)G
8'G
9G
&)
@
@
?
%AG
+
O//
"
5
/
&&
.
+
=*''9>%''
*8G
(
.
%9G
+
.
=*'%%>%'%
.
=*'')>%'*
1
-<
#
1
+
=*'%'>%'8
1
3
1
/
1
.
&9
(
&)
,
&&
%''
(
,
%'%
%'*
%'8
1
1
/ H
=*''*> /
FI
D
//@
< =*'%%> "
=*'%'>
/ =*''9> B2
%8 8'6C%%
=*'%%>
=*'')>
1
;=*'%'>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
.
/
/
FI
/
28
+
%'4
#
/
.
%'6
.1
(
%'A
)'G
%'9
+
%')
*
,
/
=
>
,
,
@
,
=
&
3
"
%'4
(
105
/
I
%'A
D
0
1
< =*'''> B
%')
0
< =*''&> <
0 =*''6> B
- =%&&&> 1
@
%'9
>
<
1
=*''4>
#
/
,
(
K
/
//@
#
.1
O *& 0
D
@
4 84.44
//@$
.
6 4 8'8.8%A
D
=*'%'>
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
$D
"
/
O
3
29
//@
"
,
.
<
+
"
C
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
C
30
Acknowledgements
This paper was commissioned by Barnardo’s and Coram as part of the National Early
Permanence Centre initiatives in 2012 to promote understanding and evidence based
practice in achieving early permanency. The writers are Di McNeish and Sara Scott from
DMSS.
A special thank you to individuals who gave invaluable advice during the production of the
paper:
Professor Sir Michael Rutter, Institute of Psychiatry, London
Professor Julie Selwyn, Hadley Centre for Adoption and Foster Care Studies, Centre for
Family Policy and Child Welfare, University of Bristol
Lisa Holmes,
John Simmonds, British Association for Adoption and Fostering
Professor June Thoburn, University of East Anglia
© Coram and Barnardo’s 2013
31