WSIAT Decision

WORKPLACE SAFETY AND INSURANCE
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
DECISION NO. 756/13
BEFORE:
M. Crystal: Vice-Chair
HEARING:
March 17, 2015 at Windsor
Oral
Post-hearing activity completed on June 18, 2015
DATE OF DECISION:
September 10, 2015
NEUTRAL CITATION:
2015 ONWSIAT 1979
DECISION UNDER APPEAL:
WSIB ARO decision dated November 8, 2011
APPEARANCES:
For the worker:
Ms. D. Carmichael, Union representative
For the employer:
E. P., Lawyer
Interpreter:
N/A
Workplace Safety and Insurance
Appeals Tribunal
Tribunal d’appel de la sécurité professionnelle
et de l’assurance contre les accidents du travail
505 University Avenue 7th Floor
Toronto ON M5G 2P2
505, avenue University, 7e étage
Toronto ON M5G 2P2
Decision No. 756/13
REASONS
(i)
Introduction
[1]
This appeal was heard in Windsor, on March 17, 2015. The worker appeals the decision
of Appeals Resolution Officer (ARO) S. Hatley, dated November 8, 2011. That decision
determined that the worker is not entitled to benefits for osteomyelitis.
[2]
The worker appeared and was represented by Ms. Debbie Carmichael, union
representative. The employer participated in the appeal, by teleconference, and was represented
by Mr. E. Persad, lawyer. The worker testified at the appeal hearing. Submissions were provided
at the hearing by Ms. Carmichael and by Mr. Persad.
[3]
At the hearing, an issue arose concerning the clinical course of the subject medical
condition, i.e., osteomyelitis. Post-hearing, I requested that the Tribunal’s Medical Liaison
Office (MLO), seek some authoritative information on this aspect of the case, to share with the
representatives. A medical article entitled “Overview of osteomyelitis in adults” was identified
by MLO and shared with the representatives on or about May 15, 2015, and the representatives
were invited to make final submissions on the merits of the appeal, in light of this additional
medical information. Written submissions, dated May 19, 2015, were provided by
Ms. Carmichael. Mr. Persad also provided written submissions, dated June 9, 2015.
(ii)
A synopsis of the case under appeal
[4]
The worker was employed as a letter carrier by the accident employer, a government
agency mandated to deliver mail. The worker began her employment with the employer in
June 1992. The worker was 47 years old as of the date of the appeal hearing.
[5]
At the hearing, the worker described an incident that occurred on January 11, 2010, while
she was delivering mail to a customer’s residence. The worker testified that that day was a
snowy day, and that as she was going up stairs towards the customer’s door, her right foot
slipped on some ice and she “jammed” her left foot against a riser on the steps leading to the
front door. The worker testified that when this incident occurred, she experienced immediate
pain in her left foot, which she described as a feeling similar to that which one experiences when
one “stubs” one’s toes. The worker testified that she was wearing winter hiking boots at the time
of the incident that occurred on January 11, 2010.
[6]
The worker testified that, on January 11, 2010, she continued with her delivery route after
the incident referred to above occurred. She stated that her left foot was sore after the incident
occurred, but that she did not consider the incident to be highly significant, and she “shook it
off”. The worker testified that, when she finished her delivery route, she reported the incident to
her supervisor, as a precaution, in that she wanted to ensure that there was a record of the
incident, in case the problem developed into a more significant injury. She stated, however, that
when she returned to the employer’s offices at the end of her shift, the pain that she experienced
at the time of the incident was persisting. The case materials included a handwritten note, dated
January 11, 2010, signed by the worker. The note stated:
While delivering mail I slipped going up the stairs at [address of customer’s residence].
The porch is painted and slippery. On the first step I jammed my left foot against the
back of the step and injured my toe (3rd). This is the same toe I had surgery on in April of
2008.
Page: 2
Decision No. 756/13
[7]
The worker testified that her left foot continued to be sore on the day following the
incident, but that she worked her regular shift on that day.
[8]
The worker testified that she had a prior condition affecting her left foot which required
surgery on the left foot in 2008. She testified that she had the surgery to remove two neuromas
from her left foot, on either side of the middle toe. She stated that, prior to the surgery in 2008,
she experienced significant pain in the left foot, but that after the 2008 surgery, her left foot
condition improved significantly. She testified that she had been told at the time of the 2008
surgery that she had sustained permanent nerve damage in the left foot, which would diminish
sensory feeling in the foot. The worker testified that, after the 2008 surgery, her left foot was
typically pain free, although after the surgery, she occasionally experienced a sensation which
felt like she was “walking on a golf ball”. She stated that she experienced this feeling from time
to time when she was walking on a cold floor with bare feet. The worker testified that she did not
consider this feeling to be pain, although it occasioned some discomfort, and was more of an
“annoyance” than anything else. The worker also testified that, from time to time following the
surgery, the toes on her left foot appeared somewhat blue in colour, although her toes looked
normal on the morning before the incident on January 11, 2010.
[9]
The worker testified that she did not seek medical treatment immediately following the
incident that occurred on January 11, 2010, but that she experienced constant pain at the tip of
the middle toe on her left foot, and that that toe was more painful than her other toes. The
worker testified that she saw her family physician, Dr. I. McLeod, on or about January 13, 2010,
about two days after the incident, and that Dr. McLeod was concerned because the toe appeared
blue in colour. Dr. McLeod prepared a Health Professional’s Report (Form 8), dated
February 10, 2010, which noted that the worker had had a painful blue left third toe, which the
worker had stubbed at work two days before her initial visit concerning this problem, on
January 13, 2010. The Form 8 stated that the worker had developed an ulcer at the tip of the left
third toe, which was “2° [secondary] to cellulitis.” The Form 8 also stated that the ulcer was “2°
[secondary] to neuropathic changes.”
[10]
The worker testified that after she saw her family physician on January 13, 2010, she
continued with her regular duties, although her toe was sore. She stated that a few days later, she
noticed something on the tip of the affected toe that looked to her like a “blood blister”. She
indicated that she bandaged her toe, noticed that there was blood coming from toe, and it became
more painful. She stated that she stopped work on or about January 19th or 20th, 2010, due to the
painful condition of her foot.
[11]
The worker testified that she saw her family physician again on January 21, 2010, and
this is reflected by an entry in clinical notes made by Dr. McLeod for that date. The entry stated:
That toe has developed a bit of ulceration on the tip. Now infected and getting
lymphangitis. She is to go to ER [emergency room] and needs IV [intravenous]
antibiotics and vascular specialist. Her arterial dopplers were normal. What is going on
with that toe? Is it a form of Raynaud’s or not? Off to ER with note.
[12]
The worker testified that after she saw Dr. McLeod, on January 21, 2010, she went to the
emergency room of a local hospital where she was given intravenous antibiotics immediately,
and was sent home with a 10 day supply of oral antibiotics. The worker returned to see
Dr. McLeod on January 26, 2010, and his entry in clinical notes for that date stated:
Page: 3
Decision No. 756/13
Since being seen last, has been under IV antibiotics, moved over to oral Keflex. Was told
she must have banged that toe. She was wise not to argue with ER doc because it was
going nowhere anyway. In my opinion, the open areas underneath seem to be healing up
to a degree. The toe is still deep purple, cold sensitive and swollen. There is a vascular
issue going on here. Told to stay off [cigarettes]…
[13]
The worker was seen again by Dr. McLeod on February 1, 2010. His entry in clinical
notes for that date stated that the condition of the worker’s toe appeared to be improving, in that
the discolouration of the toe had improved although the toe was “still very hyper-sensitive.” The
entry indicated that the employer had raised the question with the worker as to whether her
current symptoms could be “a late complication to either Morton’s neuroma neuralgia or the
surgery” and he stated that he was “not certain”.
[14]
The worker was seen on February 8, 2010, by Dr. Craig Pearce, cardiovascular and
thoracic surgeon, upon referral from Dr. McLeod. Dr. Pearce prepared a report, dated
February 8, 2010, on his consultation with the worker. The report stated in part:
As you know, [the worker] is a 41-year-old letter carrier who was treated for Morton’s
Neuroma third toe, left foot with surgery in April 2008. Since that time she has had blue
discolouration and recently developed an ulcer on the tip of this toe and severe infection.
It has been hypersensitive since that time.
….
She has scars on either side of her toe from her previous surgery. The toe is slightly
swollen and discoloured. She has an ulcer in the pulp of the toe.
She has decreased sensation in the toe.
It appears that this is a neuropathic ulcer related to decreased sensation in the tip of her
toe. It appears that infection is not an issue at this time, but it would be important for her
to wear orthotics and for us to rule out an underlying osteomyelitis. I am sending her for a
bone scan and will make arrangements to see her in follow-up. I have also written her a
prescription for orthotics.
[15]
The worker was seen again by Dr. McLeod on February 10, 2010, at which time
Dr. McLeod prepared the Form 8, referred to above. The entry in clinical notes for that date
stated that the worker’s discomfort was “settling to a degree” but that she continued to have
“significant sensitivity”, noting that she was unable to tolerate wearing a shoe and also was
experiencing cold sensitivity. In addition to the information noted above, the Form 8 also stated
that the worker was to use “slipper style footwear” and elevate her foot as required.
[16]
As noted above, Dr. Pearce ordered a bone scan for the worker, which she underwent on
February 17, 2010. The report on the bone scan stated, in part:
There is hyperemia on first pass and immediate images in the left third toe. Delayed
images show poor soft tissue clearance. 24 hour images show focal uptake in the distal
phalanx of the left third toe. This may be post-traumatic but osteomyelitis cannot be
excluded…
OPINION:
POSSIBLE OSTEOMYELITIS LEFT THIRD TOE AND A WHITE CELL SCAN IS
PENDING.
[17]
On March 8, 2010, the worker underwent the white cell scan that was recommended at
the time of her bone scan. The report on the white cell scan stated, in part:
Page: 4
Decision No. 756/13
There is focal white cell accumulation in the left 3 rd toe distal phalanx which corresponds
to uptake on recent bone scan. Mild white cell accumulation is shown as well at the left
3rd MTP joint. There is no white cell accumulation in the right foot of any significance.
OPINION:
OSTEOMYELITIS IN THE LEFT 3rd MTP JOINT AND IN THE DISTAL PHALANX
OF THE LEFT 3rd TOE.
[18]
The worker returned to see Dr. Pearce on March 11, 2010. His report of that date stated
that the worker “appears to have significant osteomyelitis” and that he was arranging a
consultation with Dr. C. Quan, specialist in both internal medicine and infectious diseases.
[19]
The worker was seen by Dr. Quan on April 21, 2010. Her report on the consultation,
dated May 1, 2010, referred to the accident in January 2010, at which time she slipped on the
stairs and her left foot hit the stairs. The report recounted much of the history, referred to above,
including her surgery in April 2008 to remove a Morton’s neuroma of the left third toe, and
noting that since the surgery in 2008, she had experienced a loss of sensation in the left third toe,
blue discolouration and some hypersensitivity in the toe. The report noted that more recently the
ulcer on her toe had closed and the discolouration of the toe had was “less red than previously
and is purplish color now.” The report also referred to the worker’s recent bone scan and white
blood cell scan, and that “this showed osteomyelitis in the left third MTP joint and distal phalanx
of the left third toe. The report concluded by stating:
IN SUMMARY: [The worker] is a 42-year-old female who had osteomyelitis of the left
third toe, related to trauma and subsequent ulcer which likely developed due to her
neuropathy. She has finished six weeks of Clavulin, which would treat the Group G
streptococcus that was isolated previously as well as other bacteria. The ulcer has
resolved. She’s had a good response to antibiotic therapy. I don’t think she needs any
further antibiotics at this time.
(iii) Applicable law
[20]
The workplace accident, as alleged, which is the subject of this appeal, occurred on
January 11, 2010. Accordingly, the worker’s entitlement to benefits in this appeal is governed by
the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997.
(iv) The issue under appeal
[21]
The sole issue to be determined in this appeal is whether the worker is entitled to benefits
for osteomyelitis.
(v)
[22]
Analysis
In the circumstances of this appeal, I am satisfied that the worker sustained a trauma to
her left foot as a result of a work accident that occurred on January 11, 2010, while the worker
was in the course of her employment. The worker testified that she stubbed her toe on the riser
of a step, while she was delivering mail at a customer’s residence. The worker reported the
accident to her employer on the day that the accident occurred. The worker saw her family
physician, Dr. McLeod within 48 hours of the accident, and provided a consistent accident
history. Although, at the hearing, the employer’s representative questioned how the worker
could have injured her middle toe within her winter boot, the employer has not taken the position
in this appeal that the incident described by the worker as having occurred, on January 11, 2010,
Page: 5
Decision No. 756/13
did not in fact occur. I am satisfied that the worker stubbed her toe in the course of her
employment on January 11, 2010.
[23]
[24]
[25]
[26]
Further, the employer’s representative has not indicated that the employer disagrees that
osteomyelitis is a correct diagnosis of the worker’s condition which arose in early 2010. The
diagnosis emerged following the worker’s white blood cell scan on March 8, 2010, and was
subsequently supported by the reports provided by Dr. Pearce, Dr. McLeod, and Dr. Quan. I am
satisfied that osteomyelitis was the correct diagnosis.
There is significant medical information on file to support the conclusion that the trauma
sustained by the worker on January 11, 2010 made a significant contribution to the development
of her osteomyelitis. This includes:

The statement by Dr. Quan, in her report in her report, dated May 1, 2010, which
stated that the worker developed osteomyelitis “related to trauma and subsequent
ulcer which likely developed due to her neuropathy [emphasis added];

A report, dated July 21, 2010, prepared by Dr. McLeod, in which he stated that he
agreed with Dr. Quan that “prior to the ulcer there was a neuropathy, but within a
week of the trauma she had developed an ulcer on her toe which was distinctly the
precursor in Dr. Quan’s opinion and also in my opinion to the osteomyelitis”;

A report, dated March 15, 2012, prepared by Dr. Deborah Hellyer, a specialist in
internal medicine, and consulting physician with OHCOW (Occupational Health
Clinics for Ontario Workers Inc.), who saw the worker in March 2012, which
concluded by stating that “trauma to the area can result in a localized inflammatory
response with subsequent infection. The area of trauma occurred at the tip of the toe
where the ulcer subsequently developed. Therefore, it is consistent with the
development of osteomyelitis.”
I find that it is probable that the worker’s history of Morton’s neuroma, surgery to treat
the neuroma, and the subsequent residual symptoms, which included ongoing discolouration and
sensitivity in the area of the worker’s middle left toe, also played a significant role in the
development of her osteomyelitis. This is consistent with the latter part of the statement by
Dr. Quan, set out the first bullet point included above that, in addition to trauma, the worker’s
osteomyelitis developed “due to her neuropathy.” I interpret Dr. Quan’ statement to mean that
there were two factors which contributed to the development of the worker’s osteomyelitis,
namely, the worker’s pre-accident condition of ongoing neuropathy following the excision of the
neuroma in 2008, and the trauma that the worker sustained to her left foot, as a result of the
accident that occurred on January 11, 2010.
It is well established in Tribunal jurisprudence that, in order to be entitled to benefits for
an injury or a medical condition, it is not necessary to establish that the injury or condition is
exclusively related to work-related factors. The Tribunal’s jurisprudence provides that
entitlement will be in order if it can be demonstrated that work-related factors made a significant
contribution to the injury or condition, notwithstanding the fact that non-work-related factors
may also have made a significant contribution to the injury or condition (see Decision No. 915, 7
W.C.A.T.R. 1 at 134, under the subheadings “The Accidental Injury Need Only be One of the
Significant Contributing Factors” and “The Effect of Predispositions – the Thin-Skull
Doctrine”).
Page: 6
[27]
Decision No. 756/13
I have considered the internal Board memorandum, dated June 3, 2010, prepared by
Dr. C. Lau, the Board’s medical consultant. The memo referred to the fact that the worker
underwent a surgical excision of her Morton’s neuroma in 2008, and that she had residual
symptoms of blue discoloration prior to the accident in January 2010. The memo concluded with
the statement:
The diagnosis of left third toe ischemia and subsequent ulcer with osteomyelitis is not
compatible with a work injury on [January 10, 2010].
[28]
I prefer the medical information that is highlighted above in bullet points, to the medical
information provided by Dr. Lau. I note that Dr. Lau did not have the benefit of the medical
information prepared by Dr. McLeod and Dr. Hellyer, referred to above, and that he was not able
to take that information into account when formulating his view on the matter. In my view,
Dr. Lau’s memo, as well as a later memo from Dr. Lau, dated November 10, 2010, provided
Dr. Lau’s conclusions, without providing a clear explanation for how the evidence led to his
conclusions.
[29]
I have also considered a statement in another internal Board memorandum, dated
June 14, 2010, prepared by the Board’s eligibility adjudicator (EA), in which the EA recounted a
conversation that the EA had with Dr. Lau. The memo stated that the EA “explained to Dr. Lau
that [the worker] said that her discolouration presented only after she hit her left foot” but that
Dr. Lau indicated that “this does not alter his opinion”, that “likely the condition was present
prior to the incident and just happened to appear following the incident” and that “he again stated
it was not compatible.”
[30]
The memo also stated:
[Dr. Lau] further clarified that osteomyelitis is a bony change and takes 6 – 12 weeks to
present itself.
[31]
[32]
At the hearing, the employer’s representative relied on this statement, attributed to
Dr. Lau. I note that Dr. Lau provided a further Board memo, dated November 10, 2010, which
provided a more detailed account of the medical information on file, and again repeated his
conclusion that the worker’s osteomyelitis was not compatible with the worker’s accident
history. If Dr. Lau believed that osteomyelitis “takes 6 – 12 weeks to present itself”, and that the
worker’s trauma on January 11, 2010 could not be the initiating event for the osteomyelitis,
because signs of the worker’s osteomyelitis presented after only about two or three weeks postaccident, he likely would have stated this in his second confirming memo.
In any event, at the conclusion of the appeal hearing, it appeared that there was
unconfirmed medical information in the case materials related to the issue of the length of time
that typically accrues between the initiating event for osteomyelitis, and the presentation of signs
and symptoms of the condition. As noted above, after the hearing, I asked the Tribunal’s MLO
to try to obtain further authoritative medical information which addressed this question. In
response, MLO provided a medical article, through “Wolters Kluwer” and “UpToDate”, which
are medical information services. The article is entitled “Overview of osteomyelitis in adults,
authored by Tahaniyat Lalani. The document provided stated, near its beginning:
All topics are updated as new evidence becomes available and our peer review process is
complete. Literature review current through: April 2015 | This topic last updated:
Oct. 22, 2014.
[33]
The article included the following information:
Page: 7
Decision No. 756/13
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY – Osteomyelitis can occur as a result of hematogenous seeding,
contiguous spread of infection to bone from adjacent soft tissues and joints, or direct
inoculation of infection into the bone as a result of trauma or surgery….
….
Clinical Manifestations –
….
Acute osteomyelitis typically presents with gradual onset of symptoms over several
days….
[34]
[35]
On the basis of the addition medical information provided by MLO, I am not able to
attribute weight to the view that osteomyelitis “takes 6 – 12 weeks to present itself”, whether or
not this information was correctly attributed to Dr. Lau by the Board’s EA. In light of this
information provided by MLO, I am satisfied that the timing of the presentation of signs and
symptoms of osteomyelitis by the worker, in January 2010, does not detract from the probability
that the trauma sustained by the worker on January 11, 2010 contributed significantly to her
development of osteomyelitis.
I note that, in his post hearing written submissions, the employer’s representative stated:
The article referenced above notes that acute [osteomyelitis] can present with symptoms
over several days. But this is in relation to contiguous spread of infection from
surrounding “infected” tissues or direct inoculation of infection into the bone due to
trauma or surgery. We submit there was no direct inoculation of surrounding microbes
into the bone when [the worker] stubbed her toe.
However, we submit there was a contiguous spread into the bone over time.
[The worker] had pre-existing neuromas either side of the left 3rd toe. This is an infection
or caused by an infection. This resulted in surgery in August 2010. Out contention is that
this is the reason for the bone infection via a contiguous spread from surrounding tissues.
[36]
I am not able to attribute weight to this aspect of the employer’s submission. The
representative has not provided a medical basis for his view. In particular, the statement that the
worker’s neuromas were “an infection or caused by infection” does not appear to be supported
by medical authority. Dr. Hellyer’s report, dated May 15, 2012, provided a description of the
clinical causes associated with Morton’s neuroma. The portion of her report relating to this
aspect of the case, on page 3 of her report, concluded by stating:
…Various factors have been implicated in the precipitation of Morton’s neuroma
including the following:
a. As a result of chronic nerve stress and irritation, particularly with excessive toe dorsal
flexion.
b. Poorly fitting and constricting shoes.
c. Biomechanical causation. Certain activities carry excessive risk of toe dorsiflexion
such as prolonged walking, running, squatting and demi-pointe position in ballet.
With the frequent dorsiflexion that occurs while walking and climbing stairs, her job as a
letter carrier would have caused the development of Morton’s neuroma.
[37]
I note that the question of whether the worker’s Morton’s neuroma was caused by workrelated factors is not an issue before me in this appeal, however, I conclude from the information
provided by Dr. Hellyer, that the development of the worker’s Morton’s neuroma was not related
Page: 8
Decision No. 756/13
to “infection” as submitted by the employer’s representative. Accordingly, I am not able to
attribute weight to this aspect of the employer’s submission.
[38]
[39]
I also note that Dr. Hellyer stated that the worker’s earlier Morton’s neuroma, and the
surgical treatment for that condition would cause a “decreased area of sensitivity and numbness”
and that this could result in the situation where the worker “did not realize that an ulcer was
present.” I agree that the worker’s pre-existing Morton’s neuroma probably contributed to the
development of her osteomyelitis, in this manner, or otherwise. I do not consider the fact that the
Morton’s neuroma occurred in close proximity to the location of the development of subsequent
osteomyelitis (i.e., at the middle toe on the left foot), to be a coincidence, in that I agree that it is
likely that the pre-existing condition contributed to the subsequent development of osteomyelitis.
Nevertheless, based on the medical information referred to above, I find that, on a balance of
probabilities, the accident that occurred on January 11, 2010, also made a significant contribution
to the development of the worker’s osteomyelitis. Dr. Hellyer stated in her report that “most
cases of osteomyelitis do occur related to trauma.” I have also taken into account the fact that
the worker’s signs and symptoms of osteomyelitis presented within the timeframe which the
article provided by the Tribunal’s MLO indicated was typical for this condition, and that the
timing of the onset of the condition is consistent with a relationship to the trauma to the left foot
that occurred on January 11, 2010.
For these reasons I find that, on a balance of probabilities, the worker’s workplace
accident which occurred on January 11, 2010, made a significant contribution to the
development of her osteomyelitis and that she is entitled to benefits for osteomyelitis. The Board
is directed to determine the nature and extent of the benefits to which the worker is entitled for
osteomyelitis.
Page: 9
Decision No. 756/13
DISPOSITION
[40]
The appeal is allowed.
1.
The worker is entitled to benefits for osteomyelitis.
2.
The Board is directed to determine the nature and extent of the benefits to which the
worker is entitled for osteomyelitis.
DATED: September 10, 2015
SIGNED: M. Crystal