What Are Galaxy Clusters?

Galaxy Clusters, Dark Energy and
Structure Formation
Joe Mohr
Department of Astronomy
Department of Physics
University of Illinois
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Overview
l Introduction to Galaxy Clusters
l Galaxy Clusters and the Matter Density
l Cosmology with the Sunyaev-Zel’dovich Effect
l Studying Dark Energy with Galaxy Cluster
Surveys
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
What Are Galaxy Clusters?
Galaxy clusters are the most massive,
collapsed structures in the universe.
They contain galaxies, hot, ionized
gas (107-8K) and dark matter.
z=1 cluster from Gladders & Yee
HST
Chandra
Image
Image
of Abell
of Zw3158
2218
In typical structure formation scenarios,
low mass clusters emerge in
significant numbers at z~2-3
Clusters are good probes, because they
are massive and “easy” to detect
through their:
• X-ray emission
• Sunyaev-Zel’dovich Effect
• Gravitational lensing
• Light from galaxies
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
X-ray
SZE
DT(R)
1 s T me
Ix (R) == 4-2
ne2R)
(l,kR)L(T
dlÚ ndle (l,
e)
B Te (l, R)
p (1+mze)c42 mÚH
Tcmb
Dual Nature of Galaxy Clusters
l It’s critical- for almost any analysis- to keep in mind that clusters are young
objects and yet as a population they exhibit striking regularity
l Evidence for cluster-subcluster merging abounds:
» Fabricant: “Galaxy clusters are not scaled up globular clusters!”
» Statistical studies of (x-ray flux limited samples of) galaxy clusters reveal
that more than half exhibit merger signatures
l Statistical studies of (x-ray flux limited samples of) galaxy clusters reveal
regularity
» Implications:
population on the whole is relaxed
while mergers are common, recent major mergers must be relatively rare
†
†
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Evidence for Regularity:
X-ray Size-Temperature Relation
l For an X-ray flux limited sample of
45 galaxy clusters:
» log(RI)= 0.93 log(T/6 keV) - 0.07
» Raw Scatter in R I: 15% (Intrinsic:
10%)
l Galaxy Cluster Regularity
» Cluster scatter around ST relation
is similar to elliptical/S0 galaxy
scatter around the Fundamental
Plane
» Observed regularity in X-ray
properties reflects underlying
regularity in the dark matter
Abell 2319
X-ray Flux Limited Sample
PSPC image spanning energy range
0.5:2.0 keV
Mohr & Evrard, 1997, ApJ 491, 38
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Cluster Mass-Temperature Scaling Relations
l Emission weighted mean temperature is a good predictor of galaxy
cluster mass (~20% scatter)
Mohr, Mathiesen &
Evrard 1999
X-ray Flux Limited Sample
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Finoguenov, Reiprich &
Boehringer 2001
What are clusters good for?
l Studies of the matter density using galaxy clusters have often
focused on the baryon fraction and the mass to light ratio
» Baryon fraction: (1) Know WB from deuterium abundance and
CMB. (2) Use clusters to estimate the universal baryon fraction.
(3) Estimate Wm
Wm =
Wb
fb
» Mass to light ratio: (1) Measure the luminosity density of the
universe. (2) Measure the mass to light ratio in clusters, which
are systems whose
† mass can be readily measured. (3) Assume the
cluster and universal mass to light ratios are the same. (4)
Estimate Wm
Wm =
j ML
r crit
» Comparing the two estimates of Wm provides a test of the
assumptions built into both approaches:
†
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
2MASS + X-ray Cluster Data
Cluster Baryon Fraction
Lin, Mohr & Stanford, in preparation
K band Mass to Light Ratio
Combined with the K-band
luminosity density of the universe
(Kochanek et al 2001), we get
Wm=0.31
Combined with Wb (Burles &
Tytler 1999), we get Wm=0.27
The two estimates differ by ~15%, and are
consistent within the uncertainties.
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Cluster Mass to Light Ratios
» Star formation efficiency must be
similar
» Typical K band stellar mass to light
ratio must be similar
» All this despite the gross
differences between galaxies inside
and outside clusters… amazing…?
l Consider now a direct
measurement of M/L in clusters
and the field:
Rines et al 2001
l Taking the baryon fraction
argument to be on firmer
footing, we note that the
agreement of the two estimators
implies that the K band mass to
light ratio in clusters does not
differ much from the K band
mass to light ratio of the
universe
l Our results are in good
agreement with Rines et al 2001
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
What About Galaxy Cluster Surveys?
o The idea of surveying for galaxy clusters has been around a
long, long time (consider Abell)
o Surveys provide a list of detected clusters, and with such a
list one can measure:
•
•
•
•
•
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Cluster surface density
LogN-LogS
Angular distribution
Redshift distribution
(Mass) function
Example:
Local Abundance/Mass Function
Reiprich & Boehringer 2001
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Example:
Evolution of Cluster Abundance
Henry 1997
It doesn’t make sense to talk about abundance at redshifts
z>0.1 unless a cosmological model is specified.
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
The Galaxy Cluster Redshift Distribution
Cluster redshift distribution probes:
1) volume-redshift relation
2) abundance evolution
3) cluster structure and evolution.
f(M) contains the connections between the
well understood theory of the
formation of massive halos and the
real world observations.
Mass Selection Function
dN(z)
dV
dn ( M , z)
2•
=
n ( z) = c d A2 (1+ z) Ú dM f ( M )
H ( z)
dM
dzdW dz dW
0
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Abundance
Volume Element
Volume
Abundance
The Volume-redshift Relation
Volume Element
Redshift Distribution
dV
2
= H c( z ) d A2 (1+ z) d µ
A
dzdW
d A (1+ z) is proper distance
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Ú
dz'
0
E (z')
z
H ( z) = H o E(z) is the Hubble parameter
Cluster Abundance Evolution
Redshift Distribution
Comoving Abundance
As we probe to higher redshift, clusters “disappear” much faster
in a high density universe, because structures grow faster.
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
A Case Study:
The BIMA SZE Cluster Survey
l During the 1997-1998 season, the Carlstrom team
observed 7 fields, searching for clusters and attempting to
detect the anisotropy of the CMB
l Solid angle- 250 arcmin2 is large for arcminute scale CMB
mapping, and considering the SZE sensitivity to high
redshift clusters, this survey sweeps out as much volume
to z~2 as a 130 deg2 survey sweeps out to z~0.1
l This is currently the SZE survey with the highest
sensitivity for galaxy clusters, and yet none were detected
SZE flux from Cluster
2
Stot = -4 knm sc T4 Tcmb d12
e
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
A
fICM M vir Te
m em p
n
Cluster Selection in the BIMA Cluster Survey
l Lin & Mohr use mock
observations of hydro
simulations of clusters to
estimate survey sensitivity
l f(M) is modeled as
Gaussian in log(M)
Calculate the mean number of clusters expected
•
N =
dn
Ú dW Ú dV Ú dM f ( M ) dM ( M,z)
0
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
†
Variation of Sensitivity with Position and Redshift
l For each field we used mock observations to calculate the survey
sensitivity as a function of position within the field and as a function of
redshift
Lin & Mohr, 2002
We used hydro simulations output at appropriate redshift-- structural evolution included.
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Constraints from the BIMA
Deep Field SZE Survey
Lin & Mohr, ApJ 2003
l Analysis of 7 “deep” SZE fields
observed with BIMA in a study of
CMB anisotropy on ~2’ scale
l No cluster detected at 95%
confidence or greater
l This is no surprise, if we normalize
spectrum of density fluctuations
with COBE and the matter density
is subcritical!
WM £ 0.65
at 95%confidence
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Galaxy Cluster Constraints on Wm
l A range of cluster properties indicate that we are
living in a low matter density universe:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Baryon fractions
Mass to light ratios
Local cluster abundance
Evolution of cluster abundance to z~1
Absence of z~1 galaxy clusters in BIMA SZE survey
Evolution of cluster scaling relations out to z~1
An Accelerating Universe
Past and ongoing work with
Type Ia SNe, CMB and
clusters points to a flat,
accelerating universe
Now we need tools to
determine the nature of the
dark energy and matter
The redshift distribution of
galaxy clusters is a tool
well suited to studies of
the dark energy equation
of state
Bahcall et al 1999, Science
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Dark Energy and Its Equation of State
Density Parameter
Equation of State
Parameter
Expansion History
Wi =
8pGr i
3H 2
Ê a ˆ-3(1+w )
p
w ≡ where r E µ Á ˜
r
Ë a0 ¯
H( z) = Ho E ( z) where
3
E 2 ( z) = W m (1+ z) + (1- W m - WE )(1+ z)
2
3 (1+ w )
+W E (1+ z)
Expansion history of the universe depends on the amount and nature of dark energy
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
How Can One Study the Dark Energy?
1. Measuring (relative) distances or volumes out to z~2
2. Measuring the growth rate of cosmic structures
3. Detecting the very large scale, low amplitude feature in
the power spectrum of density fluctuations
4. Laboratory experiments?
5. Theoretical progress
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Sensitivity of Cluster Redshift Distribution to
Dark Energy Equation of State
w constraints:
Raising w at fixed WE:
» decreases volume surveyed
» decreases growth rate of
density perturbations
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Volume effect
Growth effect
Cosmological Constraints:
Comparing Model and Observation
Constraints derived from
likelihood comparison of
redshift distributions
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Two High Yield Cluster Surveys
l High yield cluster surveys can
in principle deliver percent
level constraints on the equation
of state of the dark energy and
many other cosmological
parameters of interest
Majumdar & Mohr, 2002
Haiman, Mohr & Holder 2000
Holder, Haiman & Mohr 2001
Weller et al 2001
Levine et al 2002
Hu & Kravtsov 2002
Majumdar & Mohr 2002
l Requirements:
» Large solid angle survey
» Control of systematics
Duet X-ray survey
10 4 deg 2 survey of SDSS region
Employs XMM flight spare mirror
and ACIS-like detectors
South Pole Telescope SZE survey
4000 deg 2 survey from South Pole
Employs 8m telescope and bolometer array
Now funded by NSF
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Cluster Surveys are Self-calibrating
l These two surveys, each yielding ~15,000
clusters, contain enough information to
constrain the interesting cosmological
parameters and solve for the structure of
galaxy clusters simultaneously!
l Assumptions required:
1.
2.
3.
Hierarchichal structure formation is correct
A mass-X-ray luminosity relation exists (or
a mass-SZE luminosity relation exists)
Crude redshift estimates are available for
each cluster detected in the survey
We estimate parameter uncertainties using the Fisher matrix formalism.
Survey
Wm
Priors
w
Wtot
h
s8
0.010
n
Wb
Norm Slope
0.032 0.050 0.004
DUET
0.018 0.008 0.163 0.013 0.032 0.048 0.004 32%
0.006
SPT
0.015 0.009 0.166 0.013 0.032 0.048 0.004 21%
0.006
2
b
2
x
L
Self-calibrating character of cluster surveys was first shown by Jose Diego et al in an analysis
of local cluster data. Levine et al. applied it to large cluster surveys.
But there is a big caveat:
This analysis assumes that the redshift evolution of cluster structure is known!
f ( z) 4 pd = AM E ( z)
†
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Importance of Cluster Structural Evolution
l If we allow for the fact that we do not know a priori how cluster structure evolves
with redshift, then we cannot know how the mass-observable relations evolve
Then mass estimate of a cluster with a particular flux at redshift z is less accurate
l Net result:
Uncertainties on the equation of state grow by a factor of 1.5 to 3 for these surveys
Survey
w
s8
0.018 0.008
0.163
0.013
0.018 0.008
0.249
0.015 0.009
0.166
0.026 0.009
0.451
Wm
Priors
SPT
DUET
Wtot
h
n
Wb
0.032
0.050
0.004
0.032
0.048
0.020
0.032
0.013
0.032
0.044
0.032
0.010
Norm
Slope
0.004
32%
0.006
0.048
0.004
35%
0.006
0.048
0.004
21%
0.006
0.048
0.004
51%
0.010
g
f x ( z) 4 pdL2 = AM b E 2 ( z)(1+ z)
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
†
Tight constraints on w require that we understand how the
structure of galaxy clusters evolves with redshift.
g
0.460
1.300
Followup to Measure
Cluster Structural Evolution
l Problem: Uncertainties in cluster structural evolution make it more difficult to
connect observables (i.e SZE or X-ray flux) to the cluster mass. Mass estimates
are required to do cosmology with surveys
l Solution: Use detailed followup measurements in the X-ray, SZE or
optical/near-IR to provide an additional mass estimate for the clusters
»
Detail: You cannot measure a mass without knowing the distance to the
cluster, and that requires knowing the cosmological parameters. The real
observable is actually the mass divided by the angular diameter distance!
M(r) = -r
M f (q ) =
k B T Ê d ln r d lnT ˆ
+
Á
˜
Gmm p Ë d ln r d ln r ¯
M (r)
k T Ê d ln r d lnT ˆ
= -q B Á
+
˜
dA
Gmm p Ë d ln q d ln q ¯
†
We model followup using this mass-like observable, which could be obtained
from X-ray, SZE or even dynamical measurements. We assume these
measurements can be obtained with a 30%, 1s uncertainty.
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
†
Let’s Examine the Effects of Survey Followup
l With followup measurements on a fraction
of the cluster sample, one dramatically
improves the constraints on the equation of
state!
No followup
1% followup
10% & 100% followup
100% followup + flat Universe
l Self-calibrating:
With followup of as little as 1% of the sample,
the cluster survey allows one to solve for
w and the structural evolution of galaxy
clusters simultaneously
l Complementary:
Parameter degeneracies differ from SNe
l Competitive!
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
Majumdar & Mohr, 2002
o
o
o
o
What Does the Future Hold?
l DUET- (Unsuccessful) NASA Midex proposal
» Very positive science ratings. Hertz said something like “Clearly the
science is so compelling that we have to find a way to make this happen.”
» We will make another attempt!
l Planck Surveyor SZE Survey
» Very interesting- large beam size (5-10arcmin) means only most massive
clusters will be detected
l South Pole SZE Telescope (SPT)
» Recently funded by NSF- 6yr timescale
» PI John Carlstrom (U Chicago)
Co-PI’s at 5 institutions: CfA: Tony Stark; Berkeley: Bill Holzapfel & Adrian Lee;
Case Western Reserve: John Ruhl; U Illinois: Joe Mohr; U Chicago: Steve
Meyer
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02
(What was it I said, anyway?)
l Reviewed cluster cosmology
l Showed some 2MASS and X-ray data that indicate that Wm is low,
and that (perhaps surprisingly?) the star formation efficiency and
typical stellar K band M/L is the same in clusters and in the field
l Highlighted analysis of the deepest SZE survey to date: together
with COBE normalization, the lack of z~1 clusters in the survey
requires that we live in a low matter density universe
l Detailed the latest thinking about how we hope to use future cluster
surveys to study the amount and nature of the dark energy. Bottom
line is stay tuned, because the future surveys look very promising!
CfA Colloquium, Oct‘02