G E U S F R A N Y T G E O L O G I Oil and gas exploration in the Nor th Sea: OUR UNQUENCHABLE THIRST FOR ENERGY THE ABC’S OF OIL THE ABC’S OF THE NORTH SEA “PLAYS” AND RESOURCES IN THE NORTH SEA N R . 2 & 3 O K T O B E R 1 9 9 6 O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A The natural background and our unquenchable thirst for energy Kai Sørensen 25 *1 SE: Sustainable energy NG: Natural gas We in the western world have developed an unrealistic attitude towards energy. Our entire culture is based on accessible and inexpensive energy. There is, however, a price to be paid. Combustion of fossil fuels, particularly oil and coal produce atmospheric pollution and CO2. Today, no one can afford to close their eyes to the consequences. *2 20 SE NG Oil 10 T.O.E.*10 6 15 5 0 50 55 60 65 70 75 2 80 85 90 94 Year While there has been a general trend of steadily increasing consumption since WW II, the consumption curve fell twice during the 1970’s (see figure 1: *1 and *2). This was the result of the creation of OPEC together with OPEC’s aim to use oil as an economic weapon. Most people are familiar with these events. However, few are aware that after a steep increase in prices immediately following the formation of OPEC, much to the delight of oil companies and oilproducing coKuwait* untries, the spiIran* ralling prices Iraq* quickly lost Abu Dhabi* momentum, Saudi Arabia* and in the 10 Venezuela* years since the Libya* huge drop in Nigeria* prices at the end of 1986, Russia prices actually North Sea fell. The expla0 10000 20000 30000 40000 nation for this Million tons phenomenom * OPEC - member country can be found in Figure 2.A column chart depicting OPEC’s oil reserves compared to the North Sea re- the North Sea serves. (Gas is not included). Source: BP Statistical Review of World Energy, June 1995) and Alaska. The G E O L O G I NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Politicians attempt to alter our energy consumption habits, with both whips and carrots, but the results are unimpressive. The majority of people are not prepared to pay the price, a higher cost of fossil fuels or a change in our lifestyle. Our consumption of fossil fuels can thus be used as an indicator of our true will to change our existing habits to become more environmentally conscious. In Denmark, as in other western countries, the figures for fossil fuel consumption speak for themselves: our consumption of oil, coal and gas has increased year by year since the Second World War (WW II). Coal Figure 1.The curve depicts the Danish energy consumption since WW II, calculated in tons of oil equivalents t.o.e). period during the 1970’s when the crisis was becoming serious for non-OPEC countries coincided with increasing fossil fuel production in the North Sea and Alaska. During the 1980’s production from these two regions was so large that OPEC’s weapon was virtually ineffective. In the future, however, our ability to hold oil-producing countries and oil prices in check may be limited, as can be observed from figure 2 which depicts the remaining, known oil reserves in the North Sea compared to those of the Opec countries and Russia. The development and expansion of the huge North Sea oil and gas production in the course of a decade is the subject of this theme issue. It has a lot to do with geology. Bear in mind that geology is “the heart of the matter” in the world’s largest industry. O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A The ABC’s of Oil Depth in km oil I G O L O Under natural conditions (figure 3) hydrocarbons in a reservoir are present in the following three ways:as a liquid capped by gas; as a liquid; or as a gas.Liquids which are produced to the surface separate into three components: oil, gas and water.There can be large quantities of gas dissolved in the oil under the conditions which exist in the reservoir.When the gas in a reservoir is extracted to a surface,several kilometres above the reservoir, some of the gas will condense to a liquid referred to as condensate which resembles gasoline/petrol. Gas formed from carbon-rich source rocks, for example coal, contains only small amounts of higher hydrocarbons and produces only a small amount of condensate when produced to the surface.This is referred to as “dry gas”. Gas which is formed in marine mudstone (shale) is rich in higher hydrocarbons, and large quantities of condensate are produced at the surface. Such a gas is described as being “wet” or “rich”.Oil which is formed from the same type of source contains a large quantity of dissolved gas (light oil).The Danish North Sea fields contain both wet gas and light oil.The southern part of the North Sea contains only dry gas. E Nature has now done its work – transforming the organic material into hydrocarbons, causing the oil to migrate and creating a suitable reservoir to act as a trap for the oil or gas.The rest is up to the geologist who must find the reservoir. Once the reservoir is discovered it is referred to as a discovery. When production starts of a discovery, it is then referred to as a field. G Rocks in which oil and gas form are called source rocks, and the sites where organic material is transformed into hydrocarbons are referred to as “kitchens”. The pore spaces which are found between the sedimentary rock’s mineral particles are normally filled with groundwater.The oil and/or gas migrate from a kitchen up into the overlying rocks by displacing this water. If the pore spaces in the overlying rock are large, numerous, (a porous rock type) and evenly distributed (the rock is permeable, meaning that fluids can flow easily through the pore spaces/fractures) then it is possible for hydrocarbons to accumulate, and they can be produced (pumped or piped) to the surface. A porous and permeable rock type where oil or gas accumulates is called a reservoir. Hydrocarbons can be trapped here if the natural geometric configuration of the reservoir is suitable and if the reservoir has been sealed by an impermeable formation called the cap rock so that the hydrocarbons cannot migrate further. NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 gas “Window" for the formation of Oil and gas are hydrocarComposition in the well stream at the surface bons, formed through an Gas anoxic transformation of Condensate algae and more developOil ed plants, which, through Water 0 fortunate circumstances, have been preserved in the underground’s sedi1 mentary deposits. If the conditions are suitable, 2 if temperatures are sufficiently high and large 3 Migration route quantities of organic material are available, first 4 oil and thereafter gas can Sandstone be produced. Gas can reservoir Marine shale also form directly from 5 (oil source rock) carbon-rich organic material. These transforma6 Coal (gas source rock) tions are complicated An oil kitchen located Oil + condensate kitchen Gas condensate kitchen processes, for example: over a dry gas kitchen the most hydrogen-rich organisms (algae) are transformed into oil, the product with the fewest hydrogen atoms (a Figure 3.The complexity of a hydrocarbon system. Both the source rocks and the reservoirs are found at various depths.The migration route from the kitchen to a trap (or reservoir) can be short or long. Permutations general atomic formula of CH2), while the in the geologic configurations and hydrocarbon-water compositions presented here result in a complicated fimost carbon-rich material (land plants) eld situation, both in terms of finding and exploiting hydrocarbons. forms gas, the most hydrogen-rich final product (atomic formula CH4). 3 O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A The ABC’s of the North Sea 180 MaBP It is not possible to describe the geologic history of the North Sea briefly. Instead the ten main events (in a petroleum geology sense of the word) will be summarised in the following section. The numbers in parenthesis (1) in the text refer to the pictograms in figure 4. G E O L O G I NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 In the early Permian period, northwest Europe was a hot, barren landscape like the Sahara today.Ephemeral lakes which formed during periods of precipitation turned saline. Briefly stated: it was a harsh environment. There was, however, desert sand (2) which was rounded and well-sorted and which today is preserved in the sub-surface of the southern part of the North Sea .This desert sand covered the remains of the Carboniferous fern-forests (1) preserving them as a record of more humid times and as a reminder of the changeability of the earth’s climate. The early Permian landscape was later inundated by the sea. In northwestern Europe an inland sea formed and with the continuing warm and dry climate it became hypersaline and salt precipitates formed (3). During the end of the Permian period, almost 1 kilometer of salt was deposited in the central part of this basin. Coal deposits later formed gas, which migrated upwards and accumulated in the desert sand which was sealed by the overlying salt deposit.This combination of circumstances, a source rock, a reservoir and a seal or impermeable cap rock is called a “play”.This term will be useful to our understanding of the geological history as well as the hydrocarbon exploration history in the North Sea. The saline Permian basin was connected to the ocean.There was an ocean north of present day Scandinavia and Greenland (remember, that the Atlantic ocean did not exist at this time) and an ocean south of Europe called the Tethys Sea.This sea is another important key in understanding the geology of the North Sea, because during much of the Mesozoic this sea inundated the North Sea area, bringing marine sediments with it.The Permian period ended with a continent-continent collision which formed the Ural mountain chain, and 4 165 MaBP 60 MaBP Present in front of this, a dry alluvial plain towards the North.“Redbeds” were deposited in this landscape.To the south, marine carbonates were deposited in the shallow shelf waters of the Tethys Sea.Throughout the Triassic period this sea sometimes inundated the land, time followed by a retreat over northwest Europe. At the end of the Triassic period a shelf sea spread over most of northwest Europe and it was first in the middle of the Jurassic period that land masses (where the North sea is today) emerged from this sea in connection with a short volcanic pulse. Sand in the form of huge delta complexes (4) was deposited along the coasts of this land which stretched from present-day Bornholm-Skåne northwestward to the Shetland Isles. The delta plains spread seaward, only to be inundated again by the sea.This Middle Jurassic sand is the most important reservoir for North Sea oil, particularly in the Norwegian and English parts of the northern North Sea. During the Upper Jurassic period large parts of the North Sea were again below sea level.The region under the middle of the North Sea became a fault zone (5) forming a deep depression in an extensive shelf sea. This fault zone, also called a rift zone in analogy with the rift valley systems which exist today in, for example east Africa, had three main rift branches (figure 8): • The Viking Graben • The Central Graben • The Moray Firth There were, however, a large number of individual faults which played an important role in the formation of hydrocarbon traps of the Jurassic reservoirs, as well as indirectly forming younger traps.At the end of the Jurassic period conditions changed in the sea covering the three rift branches and in the deepest, or most isolated parts mud with a high content of marine algae was deposited. Today this mudstone (shale) is the dominant oil source rock (6) and is known in England as the Kimmeridge Clay. The most important “plays” in the North Sea north of a line from Esbjerg to Hull (figure 8) have this source rock in common. During the Upper Jurassic period there was rift activity, and deposits which would later become excellent source rock were laid down. For these two reasons the Upper Jurassic period stands out as an important time in hydrocarbon history.The story, however, is not finished. Sand, which later would become sandstone reservoir rock (7) was also deposited during the Upper Jurassic period. After formation of the large central O I L G A S E X P L O R A T I O N Mid North Sea High I N T H E Central graven N O R T H S E A B Norwegian-Danish basin 1 2 3 Norway 4 A 5 50 km B Tertiary Upper Jurassic Triassic Cretaceous Lower Jurassic Upper Permian Reflection time in seconds 0 England In northwestern Europe this chalk deposition was suppressed during the transition I G O L tion of oil and gas in hundreds of established discoveries.The fact that the eastern part of Denmark (figure 5) did not subside during the Neogene is the geological explanation for the lack of success in hydrocarbon exploration in the Danish region east of the central North Sea.With the use of models it is possible to relatively accurately “date” the formation of oil in the North Sea. A large percentage of all the oil which has been found was formed in the last 10 million years. The number of discoveries in the North Sea (over 700) are not just the result of fortunate coincidences regarding the formation of source rock, reservoirs and traps.The explanation lies in the fact that the North Sea is still actively subsiding.This means that oil and gas continue to form, also today.At the same time, the ability of the traps to retain hydrocarbons increases due to the continually increasing pressure. It is the history of the Neogene which determines whether exploration of sedimentary basins in the North Sea area will be a success or a fiasco. Neogene subsidence creates favorable conditions for the formation and trapping of hydrocarbons while Neogene uplift does the opposite. The Norwegian-Danish basin is a fiasco of the latter type. O During the Upper Jurassic and Lower Cretaceous period the transport of eroded material to the North Sea gradually decreased and finally stopped completely during the Lower Cretaceous. At the end of the Cretaceous period the Tethys Sea shelf extended northward,and carbonates were deposited over the majority of this shelf. In Denmark, these deposits are referred to as “skrivekridt” or white chalk. Parts of this chalk series can have reservoir characteristics (8). from the Cretaceous to the Tertiary because the initial spreading of the ocean floor in the North Atlantic created new land along the coasts of this newly formed ocean.The most noticeable land mass was created near the present-day British Islands. Large quantities of erosional material derived from this new land mass were washed out into the North Sea where they formed the North Sea’s classic reservoir: sand from the early parts of the Tertiary (Paleocene and Eocene). This reservoir (9) was one of the first to be found during hydrocarbon exploration in the North Sea. Particularly the Scandinavian peninsula, and perhaps the distant Carpathians and the Alps supplied huge quantities of erosional material to the North Sea at the end of the Tertiary.Today, these deposits are kilometer-thick and contain large quantities of sand, but because there is no shales to seal these sands they have no commercial interest. Nevertheless, this late Tertiary (Neogene) history plays a crucial role for the oil geology in the North Sea. Subsidence in this late part of the Tertiary brought the North Sea’s source rocks down to depths where oil and gas could form in large quantities (10). This steady subsidence which continued during the Quarternary and which still occurs today has resulted in an effective preserva- E land mass (where the North Sea is today) during the Middle Jurassic,the sea inundated the entire North Sea area. However, due to simultaneous tectonic activity, the depositional conditions during the Upper Jurassic were quite varied.There was a varied landscape in the area close to the present day North Sea with land areas located close to shallow ocean areas which were wide or narrow. Marine sand, which later became marine sandstone was deposited in these “shelves”. Occasionally, sand was “pumped” out of these shallow regions into deeper basin regions by turbidites as a result of tectonic activity. NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Figure 5. Profile through the Central Basin and the Norwegian-Danish Basin, based on a seismic profile. G A A N D 5 O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A Plays and Resources in the North Sea Neogene Million years 0 10 Eocene 50 Paleogene TERTIARY Paleocene Upper 9 CRETACEOUS Lower 100 8 JURASSIC 6 Middle 150 5 Lower Upper 7 4 Upper Zechstein N M TRIASSIC Ø 200 250 Lower PERMIAN 300 CARBONIFEROUS Upper 2 1 Figure 4. Episodes in the North Sea’s oil geology. Details are found in the text. G E O L O G I NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 3 It’s ideas that find oil A “play”, as defined previously, is a set of circumstances which can lead to the formation of an extractable deposit of oil or 6 gas in the underground.A play may be speculative, meaning that it has not yet been proven by way of a discovery, or it may be established.The term play can also be understood as a number of prospects in which the “the set of circumstances” are assumed to be fullfilled.Thus the word play can be used in two ways: to refer to something concrete – a number of discoveries and/or prospects; or something abstract – a set of circumstances/geological conditions. Think of Plato and his distinction between the idea of a chair and all chairs! Once this concept of duplicity is understood, then it is also possible to understand the central dictum in oil exploration: “It’s the ideas that find oil”. The North Sea’s exploration history can be described with the help of half a dozen plays, five of which contain more than 95% of the hydrocarbon resources (figure 6). The following discussion will concentrate on these five plays and the regions (“fairways”) where the “set of circumstances” of a play are met. Since 1964, approximately 2,700 exploration wells have been drilled in the North Sea, resulting in 800 discoveries. The extractable oil and gas resources in these discoveries (reserves), calculated in oil equivalents, are equal to 100 billion barrels (b.o.e.). Approximately 6 barrels equal 1 cubic meter. These resources are produced at a steadily increasing rate. Each year approximately 3 billion b.o.e. of oil and gas are produced at the surface, clearly surpassing the rate at which new resources can be located. The North Sea can be divided into two separate provinces, a southern province called the “Carboniferous Gas Province” and a northern province which will be referred to here as the “Jurassic Rift Province”. The carboniferous coal in the southern province has been a source of a large number of gas discoveries including the region’s largest, the Dutch Groningen field. In the northern province, which was affected by tectonic activity in the Jurassic period, the Upper Jurassic Kimmeridge Clay is a source of both oil and gas. The Carboniferous Gas Province: The Permian Play All the plays in the Carboniferous Gas Province in the southern North Sea and Holland have the common characteristic that gas was formed from Carboniferous coal. The North Sea’s exploration history really starts in the early 1960’s with the recognition of the immense size of the Groningen gas field and the possibility that this play’s fairway extended out into the North Sea. At the same time technological advances were making oil exploration and production at sea possible. Off-shore production of hydrocarbons was undertaken first in the relatively protected Maracaibo Lake in Venezula and then in the Gulf of Mexico. Thus, hydrocarbon exploration in the North Sea was only feasible due to the technological advances which evolved first in the Gulf of Mexico, and later, as initial exploration in the North Sea was fruitful, also there. Today the challenges associated with exploration and production of oil from the North Sea are some of the driving forces behind technological developments within the oil industry. Although there are potentially more reservoirs in the southern gas province, the Early Permian sandstone contains the majority of the resources due to the following: its thickness (up to 300 m); its ideal reservoir characteristics (highly porous and permeable); and the reservoir’s effective seal by overlying impervious Permian salt. Although there are good sandstones from the Triassic age in the southern North Sea, these have been cut off from gas migration from the Carboniferous coal by the overlying Permian salt. The southern North Sea’s dominant play is a Lower Permian sand with dry gas from the Carboniferous coal which is effectively sealed by salt.This salt cap rock is so effective that gas fields in certain areas of the southern North Sea have remained intact during periods with significant uplift.A large part of the gas reserves in this play are produced by a consortium composed of Shell and Exxon, whereas BP and other companies first became aware of this play after the largest discoveries had been made. In the exploration history of a play, the A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N largest discoveries will be made early on, and thus it is important for oil companies to constantly be aware of any new developments. More than half of the approximately 4,000 billion m3 of gas which has been found in the Carboniferous Gas Province was located in the Groningen field, and more than 95% of the gas reserves accumulated in early Permian sandstone (referred to locally as Rotliegend). Discoveries are still made in the Rotliegend sandstone, often in smaller structures which were on the exploration “waiting list”. Exploration of new plays continues, with some success, but the gas reserves in the Carboniferous Gas Province are declining markedly. In the European market these declining supplies are replaced with gas from the northern North Sea’s Jurassic Rift Province where the Norwegian gas fields are important. The Jurassic Rift Province Initial exploration in the North Sea led to the belief that it was a gas province. This belief sheds light on the statement “I will drink all the oil there is in the North Sea” – which was attributed to a number of people including the director for N.G. U. in Norway and BP’s head geologist in England. The statement was decidedly apocryphal. A few years after the initial exploration, at I N T H E NL Sum S E A Play UK N Paleogene 1037 313 - - 1350 97 61 826 320 - 1207 38 Upper Jurassic 1034 1468 - - 2502 124 Middle Jurassic 1814 2237 40 - 4091 119 Permian 825 - - 3699 4524 294 Other 353 34 - 231 618 127 Total 5324 4888 360 3930 14592 799 Cretaceous DK N O R T H Other Finds Figure 6. Resources per play per country, calculated in t.o.e..The Permian play is exclusively gas.The other plays are gas and oil.The values are the sum of the total reserves found.The produced volumes are not deducted from the reserves (as is the case in figure 2). Source: Spencer, Leckie & Chew, 1996). the end of the 1960’s, oil was discovered in the northern North Sea, first in the chalk formation in the Danish and Norwegian regions of the North Sea, and soon after in the Paleocene sand in the English sector. Oil in the Jurassic sandstone was found in 1971 and in the following years. Thus, it would be correct to state that the most important plays in the North Sea were established within a five year period from the end of the 1960’s to the beginning of the 1970’s. The reason for this order of events is due primarily to the advances in the quality of No seal seismic data. In the early days of oil exploration it was not possible to “see” much deeper than the top of the chalk, and consequently it was this formation and the overlying Paleogene section which were explored first. In the following section the stratigraphy will be used as a framework to discuss the plays, starting with the Middle Jurassic play followed by the Upper Jurassic, Cretaceous and the Paleogene plays. The Middle Jurassic Play As mentioned previously, it was not possible to “see” the deep-lying Jurassic layer Fairway NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 O I L No reservoir 0 Tertiary 2 I O Triassic G Cretaceous Depth in km 1 Salt Sand L 3 O Coal Dry well Gas discovery G Figure 7.The Permian gas play. E 4 7 O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A Viking Graben Magnus Statfjord Brent Norway Troll Faults/fault zone (Jurassic Rift) Oseberg Shetland Limit of the Kimmeridge Clay 125 km Frigg Piper Discovery in Paleogene sandstone Cretaceous Chalk Upper Jurassic sandstone Middle Jurassic sandstone Permian sandstone Miller Brae Morr u The J ay F irt Rift h ra ss Forties ic Ula R if t P Ekofisk Gr Denmark e l nc ra vi e ro C nt ab en Fulmar Tyra Esbjerg NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Dan Th Hull e C a r bonife rous Ga s Pr o vin c e rn the Groningen G I N or and mian s wer Per of the Lo t i lim O South er L Great Britain n limit of the Upper P erm ian s a Germany lt E O Holland G Figure 8. Discoveries in the North Sea.The discoveries (approximately 700 in the 5 main plays) are distributed among the main fairways: the Jurassic Rift Province and the Carboniferous Gas Province.The source rocks are the Kimmeridge Clay and the Carboniferous coal, respectively. Source: Spencer, Leckie & Chew, 1996 8 O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N Lyell Ninian I N T H E N O R T H Brent S E A Osebjerg 0 Viking Graben Tertiary Kimmeridge Clay 4 Depth in km 2 Cretaceous (shale) Lower Jurassic, Triassic & older sediments 6 Oil and gas discovery Oil discovery behave so tactically. The Middle Jurassic sandstone was named the Brent Formation (in the northern-most region of the North Sea). In the following few years a large number of discoveries were established in this play including the following: Statfjord, Oseberg, Snorre, and Gullfaks in the Norwegian region; Brent, Beryl, Cormorant, Lyell, and Ninian in the English region. Smaller discoveries were also made southwest of Norway in the Danish region (Harald and Lulita) and deep in the Steep, narrow shelf Turbidite Wide, sanddominated shelf Brae Miller & Magnus Gr abe G n Figure 10.The Upper Jurassic play.The three main types of reservoirs are found in the fields named in the diagram. 9 E O L O ing I Troll Vik G with the seismic techniques available in the 1960’s. In the most northern region of the North Sea it was possible to see to the bottom of the Cretaceous section (Cretaceous deposits in that region are composed of shale.) Although the topography of this surface was very pronounced, there was no indication of the nature of the underlying formations. The most widely accepted theory was that the bottom of the Cretaceous surface was underlain by bedrock. In other words, the pronounced structures were a type of Shetland islands overlain by shale deposits. Petroleum geologists’ and oil companies’ interest in this region was already high because there had been some huge discoveries for example, the Ekofisk discovery in a chalk formation, and the Forties discovery in the Paleocene sand. When Shell drilled an exploratory well in 1971 and found oil, the dream of the North Sea as a significant oil province became a reality.The well, called the Brent Discovery Well, was drilled through more than 200 m of sandstone, and oil was present throughout the reservoir. Shell sealed the well without testing it. It was not necessary, Shell knew it had a gigantic discovery. Shell waited for the next round of licensing and applied for licences to all the blocks into which this play might extend. Today, no oil company involved in North Sea exploration would be permitted to Moray Firth. This play had the characteristic that the source rock was younger than the reservoir rock, and it was only possible for the oil to migrate into the reservoir because fault tectonics during the Upper Jurassic brought the source and reservoir rocks into contact with each other, as illustrated in the Middle Jurassic play figure (figure 9). Thirty billion b.o.e. have been found in this play, the majority of it oil.The two largest fields, Brent and Statfjord, contain a third of these resources.The remaining hydrocarbon resources are distributed among 117 discoveries. NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Figure 9.The Middle Jurassic play.The yellow layer represents the “Brent” sandstone. O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N Paleogene sand hinders sealing I N T H E N O R T H S E A Source rock not matured Fairway 0 gas Tertiary 2 Gas cap Oil-saturated chalk p 4 Salt 6 Triassic 8 Oil discovery Only one percent of these resources are Danish. Only after the Danish Underground Consortium was forced to relinquish exploration areas in the beginning of the 1980’s exploration of the Jurassic formations in Denmark started. Upper Jurassic Plays Sea level rose after deposition of the Middle Jurassic deltaic sandstone around the uplifted central land mass (in the pres- W. Ekofisk Tertiary ha S e alin g s Ekofisk le Chalk G E O 2 km 200 m O L Impermeable chalk Figure 12. High porosity and saturation under the structural closure in one of the Norwegian chalk fields 10 ent-day North Sea). The entire land mass was inundated by the sea during the Upper Jurassic period.At the same time a number of faults were reactivated. Thus, the geologic picture of Upper Jurassic period is complex with regions subsiding while other areas experienced uplift. One could refer to this time as a “geologist’s paradise” because the tectonic activity, deposition of reservoir sand as well as source rocks all took place during the Upper Jurassic. It could also be said that this geologic time period has a special place in the hearts of all North Sea oil geologists. High oil saturation G I NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Figure 11.The Chalk play. In every oil province there is at least one main challenge. In the Northern North Sea the main challenge is to find reservoir rocks. In the southern North Sea area the challenge is to find structural closures below the impervious cap rock of the Upper Permian salt. In the Northern North Sea the stratigraphic focus of the main problem is the Upper Jurassic. The reservoirs in the other plays are relatively sim- Oil & gas discovery Dry well ple to understand and thus also simple to find and to explore.The Upper Jurassic reservoirs are complex. In fact, there is no single Upper Jurassic play, but rather several, because the reservoirs are so different from each other.The number of plays is the result of the geomorphology of the Upper Jurassic. The two main elements are the following: 1.The Upper Jurassic coastlines 2.The morphology of the sea bed (bathymetry) The significance of these two elements is illustrated in the Upper Jurassic play figure (figure 10). Since the Upper Jurassic reservoirs are all marine in origin, there is some justifications for regarding the Upper Jurassic discoveries as belonging to one play. But researchers and exploration geologists require a more nuanced understanding of this period. In some areas the marine shelf A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N was narrow and tectonically connected to a fault.This results in one type of reservoir. In other areas the marine shelf was wide and experienced long-term inundations where fluctuations in sea level produced pronounced short-term variations in coastline location. Finding the latter type of sandstone reservoir is extremely difficult. In addition to the tectonic activity during the Upper Jurassic period, the North Sea area also experienced recurring earthquakes. Earthquake activity can be inferred from faults as well as the presence of a particular type of sediment, called turbidites. Turbidite sediments begin as shallow water sediments which are loosened, often by earthquakes, and transported in the form of suspensions into deeper water. In principle then, there are three main types of reservoirs: marine sandstones deposited on narrow shelves associated with faults; sandstones deposited on wide shelves with labile coastlines; and turbidites deposited in deep water. The majority of resources in the Upper Jurassic play were discovered in sandstone deposited on wide labile shelves. These include the following: the Norwegian Troll field, which is the most productive field in the play and I N T H E N O R T H S E A 1500 1000 Cretaceous N, DK + UK 500 Million t.o.e. O I L Tertiary UK 0 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 Year Figure 14. Discovery curve for the Cretaceous and Tertiary.The figure illustrates that the large discoveries are made early in the history, and that the majority of discoveries are made within about five years. Politically imposed limitations on exploration can shift this picture, but at that time in the exploratory history of the North Sea when the large chalk reservoirs in Norway and Denmark was found there was little political interference. The Tertiary discovery curve for England is completely different from the above curve. Initially, the English Tertiary curve has a “typical” steep shape indicating a large number of discoveries over a short period, followed by a flattening out.Then in the 10-year period between 1985-95 the curve rose steeply as the volume of found resources doubled, the result of a number of moderate sized discoveries.This increase in discoveries was due to new technology (3D seismic) and an improved understanding/interpretation of the geology (seismic- and sequence stratigraphy). Source: Spencer, Leckie & Chew, 1996. also the world’s largest producing offshore gas field; the English Piper and Fulmar oil fields; as well as the Norwegian Ula and Gyda fields. These play’s total resources are estimated to be 20 billion b.o.e., of which almost one half, approximatley 1250 No cap rock over reservoir billion cubic meters of gas are found in the Troll field. Three discoveries have been made in Upper Jurassic sandstone within the Danish North Sea area, the Gert, Ravn and Elly.The reserves in these discoveries are, however, by North Sea standards very Fairway No migration 0 East NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 West Depth in km Neogene Discovery in a stratigraphic trap 2 Paleogene a la Frigg Creraceous I a la Forties Middle/Upper Jurassic Triassic & older G Shetland’s bedrock platform Gas discovery Oil discovery O L O 4 Dry well G E Figure 13.The Paleogene play.The majority of the sand (with the exception of that on the Shetland’s platform) was deposited as turbidites.There is also sand in Neogene deposits, but this contain no hydrocarbons due to lacking cap rock. 11 O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N small. Many of the Brae Trend discoverys are associated with narrow shelves. The turbidite sediments which were transported long distances out to sea, form the main reservoirs in discoveries such as the Claymore, Miller and Magnus Fields in the Moray Firth and the Viking Graben. I N vement created a migration route through the lower region of the chalk, and probably also created the reservoir characteristics. Not all the upper region of the chalk within the play’s fairway is of reservoir quality. Figure 12 illustrates the variation in oil saturation and porosity in a Norwegian chalk field. G E O L O G I NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 The Upper Cretaceous Play Oil and gas discoveries were first made in the chalk formations in the Danish region of the North Sea (Anne in 1966, Roar and Tyra in 1968) and oil was found in the Norwegian region (Valhall) in 1967. In December 1968 the first gigantic oil field discovery in the North Sea was made, the Ekofisk field, located in Upper Cretaceous chalk. These events were epoch-making in two respects. First, the discoveries proved that, at least in the northern part of the North Sea, there was an oil province with the potential to be extremely profitable. Second, the discoveries indicated that parts of the chalk formation has reservoir characteristics. The reservoir in this play was deposited after formation of the many faults which play a definitive role in formation of traps in nearly all of the Jurassic discoveries in the North Sea. Nevertheless, this play is dependent upon structuring throgh salt deformation as depicted in figure 11. These strange pillar-like features were formed out of Permian salt.This extremely mobile salt became even more so during the intense tectonic movement during the Upper Jurassic period and was forced upwards forming a large number of salt pillars (diapirs). Other diapirs which were formed during the Triassic period became active again.The rapid growth of the diapirs ceased prior to deposition of the chalk, but their tops ended close to the surface.The majority of the oil discoverys in chalk were trapped in a structure which arose from compression over nearly immobile salt structures.The discoveries in chalk are concentrated in two relatively narrow fairways (see figure 8), one located entirely in the Norwegian area and the other located entirely in the Danish region. The chalk play’s fairway is limited to the Central Graben where the salt was thick enough to be deformed and the source rocks were thick. In addition, the salt mo- 12 The oil saturation in the two fields is high directly below the structural closures.This indicates that the reservoir quality decreases with distance from the structure and that this deterioration is so pronounced that the chalk changes from being a reservoir to functioning as its “side seal” away from the structure. The narrow fairways and the restriction of reservoir quality chalk to the areas over the salt diapirs can best be explained with the model discussed in the following section. One of the characteristics of a good chalk reservoir is believed to be the early migration of oil into the chalk. Thus, the early formation of oil is a prerequisite, and this is most likely in the deepest parts of the Central Graben. All of the commercial discoveries in chalk are located in the immediate vicinity of the deepest parts of the Central Basin. A good transport corridor is also a precondition to ensure that the chalk’s total volume (matrix) can be filled with oil. Fracture formation in connection with the deformation in the units over the diapirs created this network of “highways” for migration. Nearness to the deepest part of the Central Graben limits this play in the east-west direction and towards the south. The play does not continue to the north because a new reservoir (next section) formed on top of the chalk, so that in this area the chalk lacks a seal.The majority of the Danish oil and gas reserves are found in chalk. The Tertiary Play Until about 1995 there were no discoveries in the Tertiary formations in the Danish region of the North Sea, but Statoil’s Siri discovery changed this situation. Almost one hundred discoveries, located in Tertiary sands of Paleocene and Eocene ages have been made in the English and Norwegian regions of the North Sea. T H E N O R T H S E A Discoveries continue to be made in this play. Thus 4 out of 9 discoveries in the Norwegian region in 1995 were in this play.The most important geologic precondition for this play was uplift of the northwestern part of England-Scotland and the “Shetlands region” in connection with formation of the North Atlantic. Huge quantities of sand which were eroded from these uplifted land masses were deposited in a relatively narrow shelf east of the present-day Shetland islands. Sand from this shelf was pumped out in the form of turbidites into the deep regions of the North Sea both into the Viking Graben and through the Moray Firth out into the Central Graben.This play’s fairway is thus easy to understand: the area where the play works is limited to the extent of the sand in combination with access to a “kitchen”. The Tertiary discoveries (see figure 13) can be divided into three types of traps. The first type is a structural trap where the Paleocene sand is draped over an underlying raised feature. The gigantic Forties field, which together with the Ekofisk field heralded the oil bonanza of the North Sea, are found in this type of trap. The thick sand in the Forties field is composed of turbidites.The entire Tertiary section compressed under its own weight and this thick sand was folded over a underlying bedrock ridge, in the same way that the chalk structures were formed by compression over salt diapirs.The second type of trap is composed of some of the Tertiary turbidites which are stacked on top of each other, so that they, together with the overlying clay seal form structural traps. The largest gas field in this play, the Frigg field, was found in this type of trap. While the sand in Forties is from the Paleocene, the sand in the Frigg is from the Eocene. In the northern North Sea the quantity of sand decreases through the oldest part of the Tertiary (Paleogene).The third type of discovery in the Paleogene are found in stratigraphic traps where a lateral seal forms via lithological changes from the reservoir (sandstone) to the non-reservoir rock (shale). This last type of discovery is difficult to locate, as evident from the curve of Tertiary discoveries in the English region of the North Sea (figure 14). O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A Figure 15. Size of a gas field and three oil fields in the North Sea compared to the size of the island of Funen in Denmark. Dan Troll Dan Ekofisk Statfjord 13 NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 I G There are some areas in the North Sea where “infrastructure” is in place. Infrastructure refers to the production platform, where the well steam can be separated into its various components (water, oil and gas) as well as an oil and gas transport system (for example a pipe or loading system to a tanker vessel). If these facilities are in place, then it may be profitable to exploit a small discovery with reserves of 1-2 million cubic meters. Thus, this discussion makes it clear that size is a very relative term when considering the commercial profitability of an oil field. O The Ekofisk chalk reservoir contains the same volume of “in place” ressources as the Statfjord field. The degree of recovery at the Ekofisk field is 40%, and although this is exceptionally high for a chalk reservoir, it means that in practical terms the producible Ekofisk reserves are less than those of the Statfjord field.The largest Danish oil field, the Dan, has “in place” reserves of 500 million cubic meters, but with an anticipated degree of recovery of only 20%, the extractable resources will be approximately 100 million cubic meters. L The North Sea’s largest oil field, the Statford, originally had “in place” ressources of more than 1,000 million cubic meters and covered an area of approximately 140 km2. Prior to production, it was expected that about 40% of these reserves could be extracted. However, after production commenced the expected degree of recovery has been increased upwards to 60% Everyday 100,000 cubic meters of oil are produced from the Statfjord field which is more than twice the volume of the total Danish oil production in the North Sea. O reservoir thickness (200 m) and then subtracting the deduction for edge effects: 8,000,000 x 200 = 1.6 billion cubic meters – edge effects (where the reservoir thins towards the field limit) = 1.2 billion cubic meters. The average porosity is over 20%, which is a good porosity for a sandstone field.This gives a pore volume of 250 million cubic meters. A good reservoir has a saturation of over 80%, meaning that more than 80% of the fluid in the pore spaces is oil. Based on this assumed oil saturation, the oil volume in the reservoir would be over 200 million cubic meters.With today’s technology it is possible to recover more than 50% of the original “in place” reserves. Finally, the fact that the volume of oil shrinks during the process of extraction to the surface must be considered. These calculations demonstrate that the Fulmar oil field could contain 80 million cubic meters of oil even though it’s surface area was so limited. E An oil field with an area of less than 10 km2 can be large if the reservoir is thick and of good quality. Fulmar is a good example of this type of field. Before production started, the Fulmar field was estimated to contain reserves of 80 million cubic meters of oil, although the field area is less than 10 km2. This apparently improbable situation can be explained with a few simple calculations. If a total reservoir volume in the field is calculated by multiplying the area (8 km2) by the Something about Size G What makes an oil field large? There are three simple elements. First, there must be a suitable quantity of source rock present. This condition is more than met in the central and northern North Sea and in the southern gas province. An incompletely filled reservoir volume within these areas has seldom been attributed to insufficient source rocks.A second condition of a large oil field is that the reservoir must be thick. The thickest reservoirs in the North Sea are found in Upper Jurassic sandstone and conglomerates in structural traps created due to faulting (Brae type, figure 10). In these fields the reservoir thickness is often greater than the height of the column of oil. Thus, in the fields with an exceptionally thick reservoir the bottom reservoir regions are water-filled. The reservoirs of the North Sea giants can be 200-300 meters thick, while some reservoirs are only a few meters thick. Many fields on land, where a small discovery can be commercially viable have a thickness under 10 meters.Additionally, the area of the trap can vary widely. The Troll field which is the largest gas field in the North Sea, covers an area of 700 km2. O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A Oil, the sisters and … S OCIETY G E O L O G I NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Denmark started oil production from the Dan field in 1972 and became self sufficient early in the nineties. Coal is still imported, but today Denmark exports both gas and oil.The degree of total energy self sufficiency in Denmark is now over 100% of which 8% is supplied by renewable resources, and the remainder is supplied by oil and gas. In terms of the national economy, Denmark’s increasing energy self sufficiency together with falling oil prices has put Denmark in the good company of other countries with strong economies. One could ask why the multi-national oil companies, the survivors of “The seven sisters” and the new oil moguls have such a prominent role in the industry.Wouldn’t it be possible for a country such as Denmark to create a stateowned oil company, the profits of which would supply the national coffers? In order to answer these questions we must understand the undertaking of a large oil company. The large multi-national oil companies find the hydrocarbons.They finances construction of the production plants, where raw oil and gas are refined, as well as construction of storage and transportation networks. The oil companies earn money by selling the processed hydrocarbons to consumers.This chain of activities requires large amounts of capital and is associated with numerous financial risks. It is the element of risk which protects the oil companies from being absorbed into the public sector. Politicians in capitalistic countries refuse to take responsibility for the financial risks associated with hydrocarbon exploration, production and transportation. The multi-national oil companies distribute their risk throughout the world, and this is an economic necessity in the oil industry.Today, even countries with many years experience with stateowned oil companies such as Venezuela, former USSR countries and Iran, to name a few, invite multi-national companies to participate in exploration and production.This trend may change, but it is unlikely until oil reserves are severely reduced. In the meantime we must learn to live with the multi-national oil companies.The task of each nation is to do this in a way which is most beneficial to its citizens. 14 T HE E NVIRONMENT The discussion regarding the final disposal of the Brent Spar platform, and similar oil-related issues in the news media may have lead to a belief that oil activities in the North Sea are associated with huge environmental risks. In fact, the countries surrounding the North Sea have regulated activities to such an extent that adverse environmental effects associated with exploration and production are minuscule in comparison to many other environmental threats. Similarly, oil contamination on beaches can, almost always, be linked to tanker vessels which clean their holds en route to the North Sea. Now and then a ship runs aground, and crude oil washes ashore.Again, the problem is not hydrocarbon recovery, but rather the limited possibilities available to politicians to regulate ships and shipping traffic.The major environmental problem associated with oil and gas arises when these hydrocarbons are combusted. In the North Sea region and in the hydrocarbonconsuming parts of the world this environmental issue is, in reality, a lifestyle issue (see figure 1) and not a problem which can be solved by demanding that oil companies change their practices. In other parts of the world, where public authorities lack the power to impose or enforce environmental legislation, hydrocarbons may be produced under less stringent environmental control.Thus, we can help the environment in two ways: 1. By decreasing our energy consumption 2. By helping hydrocarbon-producing developing nations to formulate environmental laws and assist them in enforcing them against oil companies. By decreasing our energy consumption, particularly of fossil fuels we will also extend the period in which oil can be purchased for a reasonable price. Falling oil production in the North Sea and Alaska must be expected in the near future. We and our governments must decide whether we will act now and plan for a future with expensive oil, or whether we will wait passively until the energy crisis comes. R ESEARCH It is our duty as a society to ensure that precious non-renewable hydrocarbon resources are utilised in a way that is best for the society as a whole.What is good economy for an oil company is not necessarily the same for a society. It may be better to produce 20 million tons of oil from a field with a few production wells over 15 years rather than to produce 30 million tons over 20 years with more wells. In order to enter into a constructive discussion with multi-national oil companies regarding exploitation of these resources society must develop knowledge and competence within a number of fields. GEUS is the Danish authorities’ “professional right hand” in these discussions. We have earned this role partly through work undertaken on behalf of the Danish Energy Agency (Energistyrelsen) and through scientific investigations and research. Furthermore GEUS provides consulting services to oil companies.This last activity is important because it gives GEUS the opportunity to follow both the technological and scientific developments within the fields of hydrocarbon exploration and production. The relevance of our consulting services would quickly deteriorate without these updates.Additionally, these consulting projects uncover problems or points of dispute which may be relevant research projects. Clearly the triangle of interconnected activities - research – expert advisor – consulting work is not just an economic necessity, it also ensures that GEUS’s competence evolves simultaneously with that of the oil industry.This is crucial to GEUS’s ability to assist authorities in regulating the hydrocarbon industry. It also means that GEUS has a certain independence to refuse projects which are not relevant to our fields of interest, allowing us to select projects which are both relevant and which will further develop our competence. This is an ongoing process.There are still some areas of petroleum geology, exploration and production where our knowledge is lacking, but we are constantly striving to keep our scientific knowledge current, not only for ourselves, but also for the sake of society. O I L A N D G A S E X P L O R A T I O N I N T H E N O R T H S E A late in a reservoir rock.As a concrete term a play refers to any number of es tablished discoveries or prospects where existing geological evidence in dicates that the requirements for a play are present, or are likely present. The set of conditions include a source rock, a porous and permeable reservoir covered by a seal and with a suitable natural configuration so that hydrocarbons cannot migrate out of the trap. Prospect: A hydrocarbon trap which has not yet been investigated by exploratory drilling. Red beds: sedimentary strata composed primarily of sand and clay with a characteristic red colour derived from the presence of the iron-rich mineral hematite, which coats the individual grains. Reflector: refers to a surface which separates two rock formations each with different seismic characteristics.A reflector is found during a seismic investigation where sound waves are shot through the underground and reflected back from these surfaces. Reservoir: a porous and permeable geological layer which contains oil and gas. Rift zone: a regional scale system of down-throwing faults in the earth’s crust. Salt diapir: a column of salt which has risen through the overlying rock formations from a salt layer which is often located 2-6 km under the top of the salt columns.The diapirs are typically 1-5 km in diameter and the driving force for their movement is buoyancy due to the low density of salt Shelf: the slightly-sloping, underwater region of a continent located between the shoreline and the continental slope.The width of the continental shelf is normally delineated by an ocean depth of 200 m, or by the edge of the continental slope. Shelf sea: a shallow sea situated on the continental shelf which rarely exceeds a depth of 2-300 m, for example the North Sea. Source rock: all the types of rock in which oil and gas can form. Stratigraphic trap: a trap for oil or gas which is the result of lithologic changes in a rock formation or changes in its extent rather than structural configuration. Structural trap: a trap for oil or gas which is the result of folding, faulting or other deformation. Tectonic activity: movement in the earth’s crust for example earthquakes, faulting and other deformations which occur due to forces involved in tectonics. Test: an experimental production of oil or gas to the surface after a discovery has been made during exploratory drilling. Trap: any type of barrier (lithological or structural) to upward movement (migration) of oil or gas allowing these to accumulate in underlying formations.A trap includes reservoir rock and an impermeable cap rock. Turbidite: a sediment deposited by a turbidity current, which is a tongueshaped current of suspended material which flows from shallow waters to deeper water after being loosened, often by an earthquake. Wet/rich gas: a natural gas containing liquid hydrocarbons. L O G I Cap rock: a low permeability rock formation through which hydrocarbons are unable to migrate.The cap rock acts like a seal, trapping the hydrocarbons in the underlying formation. Deltaic: deposited in a delta environment. Dry gas: natural gas with a low content of liquid hydrocarbons. Exploration well: a well which is drilled to determine whether a prospect contains producable hydrocarbons. Often an exploration well recovers only water. Fairway: an area where all the components of a play are present. Fault: a fault or fault zone along which there has been displacement of the sides relative to one another parallel to the fracture. Hypersaline: a liquid having a salt content which is much higher than that of normal ocean water. Hydrocarbons: a general term referring to organic material composed exclusively of carbon (C ) and hydrogen (H). Kitchen: refers to the area in the underground where hydrocarbons form. Light oil: oil with a low specific gravity. Mesozoic: formed during the earth’s middle age (Triassic, Jurassic and Cretaceous). Migration: the movement of hydrocar bons from their source rock (the kitchen) through permeable rocks to a reservoir. Migration route: the path taken by the majority of the hydrocarbons from the kitchen to a reservoir. Morphology: the shape and structure of any given surface. Play: as an abstract concept a play refers to a set of conditions which must met in order for hydrocarbons to accumu NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Dictionary G E O This theme issue, Oil and Gas Exploration in the North Sea, was written by head of department Kai Sørensen. Prior to his employment at GEUS, he was employed at Statoil, first as a senior geologist in Stavanger (Norway) and later as Exploration Manager in Denmark. He has also taught at Århus University and Denmark’s Technical University. He has been a visiting researcher at Imperial College in London, at M.I.T. in Boston and at Cornell University. Kai Sørensen is the head of the geophysical department at GEUS. 15 Review of Gree nland activities 2000 New publication from GEUS Articles in Review of Greenland activities bulletins are available as pdf-files from 1996 to present at the GEUS website. www.geus.dk/publications/publ-dk.htm OF GREEN LAND SURVEY B ULLETIN 18 9 • 2001 Review of Gr eenland activi ties 2000 Geology of Gree nland Survey Bull ti The annual Review of Greenland activities is a special bulletin regarding research in Greenland and off-shore areas, including the north Atlantic and Arctic. It contains review articles on primary activities written in a style that enables other than professionals to get an all-round impression of GEUS research in Greenland. GEOLOGY GEOLOGICAL SURVEY OF MINISTRY OF DENMARK AND ENVIRONMEN GREENLAN T AND ENER D GY G E U S The following articles contain statistics regarding the number of discove ries and hydrocarbon resources: A.M. Spencer, G.G. Leckie & K.J. Chew: North Sea hydrocarbon plays and their resources (an article in a Geological Society Special Publication on northwestern Europe’s hydrocarbon industry by K.W. Glennie and A. Hurst, 1996. Figures 6, 8 and 13 are based on numbers found in this article. The Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland is a research and advisory institute in the Ministry of the Environment. The primary goal of the institute is to conduct scientific and practical investigations of the environment and energy-related subjects, as well as geological mapping of Denmark and Greenland. GEUS can also be contracted to conduct investigations on behalf of others under normal terms of business. GEOLOGY –News from GEUS is edited by geologist Knud Binzer and Klaus Hinsby in collaboration with an editorial group at the institute. Consultant: Marianne Vasard Nielsen. A subscription to GEOLOGY – News from GEUS can be ordered free of charge by contacting Knud Binzer.The magazine has 4 issues each year. Only selected issues are available in English. An in-depth description of the petro- Write, telephone, or email: GEUS Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland Thoravej 8 DK-2400 Copenhagen NV, Denmark Tel: + 45 38 14 20 00 Fax: + 45 38 14 20 50 Email: [email protected] Website: www.geus.dk G O L O E G leum geology and exploration history of the North Sea: K.W. Glennie (ed.) Introduction to the Petroleum Geology of the North Sea. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford 1990 (3rd edition). GEUS Publications All GEUS publications can be purchased at Geografforlaget (the Geographic Publishing Company). They may be contacted via telephone: +45 63 44 16 83 or telefax: +45 63 44 16 97, email: [email protected], or website: www.geografforlaget.dk Their address is: Geografforlaget, DK-5464 Brenderup ISSN 1396-2353 Production: H.K. Pedersen, GEUS Printing: From & Co. Cover photo: Statoil A/S Illustrations: Carsten Thuesen Translation: MapleLeaf Miljøtekniske Oversættelser. I NYT FRA GEUS 2&3/96 Further Reading GEUS is pleased to provide further information regarding the topics discussed in this issue, or other topics of a geological nature. It is permitted to reproduce sections of this issue on the condition that the information is properly referenced. G E U S
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz