| The case for single-issue constituencies |1 Nathan Shapiro Turning

ships and the need for at least symbolically
portraying their process as democratic, these contemporary institutions are being efficiently driven
by a clear vision of management by objective, so
' that the result, i.e., the product is weighted as a
higher value than the system of decision making,
that of process.
:
>
1
(
I
I
j
'
i
The most significant result of these changes to the
community relations field will be the changing
sources of power within the Jewish community. Increasingly, that authority will be diffused allowing
for a greater number of participants and a further
weakening of the consensus base within Jewish
communal life. It is also quite apparent that as the
style in which this field operates, changes, the substance of this discipline will be altered. The irony
of some of this is that at a time when American
Jews need to return to grassroots political organizing in order to rebuild coalitions, offset AmericanArab gains, and to reassert the Jewish urban
agenda, we seem to be moving toward a greater degree of centralized decision-making managed by a
number of providers of service whose interests are
highly specific and may be more narrow than what
is called for at this moment in Jewish life.D
| The case for single-issue constituencies
|1 Nathan Shapiro
j
j
i
[I
ii
j
!
r
i'
!
•
|i
(i
I
|
|
Steven Windmueller's article, dealing with a fundamental shift in the community relations field, addresses an issue that a number of Jewish activists
have been keenly aware of for some years. Many of
the reasons that he highlights are easily identified
and historically present in all mature communities.
Our community, of course, has a long and proud
history of involvement and action in the plight of
our brothers and sisters, wherever they may be—as
well as concern for other distressed communities,
whether isolated or not from the rest of the civilized world. There is, however, one element in our
modern world which is contributing to the development of single-issue groups. That is, the speed with
which information is available and verifiable.
Today, it is not unusual to learn of Russian Jewish
activists involved in causes like Ethiopian Jewry,
even though they may live in Leningrad. The telephone system reaches every location in our world,
and facsimile transmission, transistor radios and
portable telephones have become relatively inexpensive and available on an ever-growing basis.
A sophisticated and dedicated group of activists
• can easily reach out to thousands of like-minded
,1
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ^ —
j NATHAN SHAPIRO heads the activities of the
American Association for Ethiopian Jewry.
f 149
fellows through the acquisition of purchased mail
lists. They can communicate inexpensively with the
use of word processing programs and laser printers,
in a most personal and immediate way, to explain
their cause and gain support. Such a group of activists can mount political efforts by targeting key
congressmen and senators, who are always sensitive to legitimate social issues representing Western
concerns.
As a result of the new dynamics, which allows for
a small group of activists to mount large-scale,
public grassroots campaigns for single issues, the
"traditionalists" within the established Jewish community relations field are now forced to address issues that in the past were often overlooked.
Therefore, decision-making is no longer in the sole
domain of a few national Jewish leaders. Issues of
interest and concern to the American Jewish public
are now brought directly to the attention of all
within the Jewish community relations field. As a
result, issues that in the past were shelved are now
placed on the agenda by the Jewish public itself.
The ability of activists to be effective on single issues should be welcomed by the Jewish community
at large. The focus and expertise that a single-issue
group can bring to a problem, although sometimes
traumatic and divisive, as in the case of the Carmelite nuns next to Auschwitz, can be singularly
effective. Obsession with an issue can bring with it
a sophistication and sensitivity to the nuances of a
cause which will not be compromised (either for
good or bad) by the overall concerns of the community at large.
I believe this is healthy and constructive for the
Jewish people as a whole, and expect that we will
see more, not less, of this type of action in the
future. •
Turning inward, benefits and problems
Lawrence Rubin
Steve Windmueller is precisely right in observing
that the Jewish community's political approach is
becoming increasingly centralized in decisionmaking and narrow in focus. He is also correct in
observing that this is occurring at the very time
when the issues we face demand a more expansive
and inclusive model.
Nevertheless, it must be conceded that the current
structure reflects a reasonable organizational response to changes in the political culture of Jewish
LAWRENCE RUBIN helps direct the work of the
National Jewish Community Relations Advisory
Council.