Selfish Routing with Atomic Players

!#"%$&('*)+-,.
/103254687:9<;:9.=<>@?:ACBED
F#G8HJILKNMOPQH@RSKTGUWVYX[Z]\_^8`ba[Zdce\gfh`fbi[jJjJZ@ffk^linm8o_p[pnmrqsjJo_`bqt\QX[f
_\ ^d`anZupnvqtjJZ\Q^wo_XTo_vjaCxgyz`banZ{\gvfh`h|}jJogfhZ~vo_`bqt\€<Z#`k{-ZJZ@X
`banZw\Q‚kZ(j`qrƒgZd^linXTj`bqt\QXƒLo_mtinZ@f\_^Xn\QX[jJ\„\Qp<ZJvoL`bqtƒQZYZ@…Cinqtmrqt‚|
vbqso]o_XT†‡\Qp‚`qrc1oLyzqsfN`\ˆfhZ@mЉ<fha‡v\Qi‚`qrX[‹gŒnLoYj#msoQffhqsjJoQmQce\‚†‚ZJm
\_^8an\L{ŽqtX[†‚Z@pTZ@X[†‚Z@Xg`XnZ#`k{-\Qvi[fbZJvfEv\Qi‚`Z`bvoL‘jqrX1o‡jJ\QX‚|
‹QZ@fh`bZ(†’XnZ#`k{-\Qv8“”d\L{Z@ƒQZJv(oQmrce\Cfk`•oQmrmZ#–‚qtfh`bqtXn‹—{-\Qv˜\gX
`banqsfW`\Qpnqsj™lZg“ ‹T“rš ›n<œn8(žlŸWogfbfbinceZ@f]omtoQvb‹gZ‡pT\gpninmsoL`bqt\QX—\Q^
ƒQZJvxefhc1o_mtm<XnZ#`k{-\Qv iTfhZ@vf@Cfb\`a[oL`-`ba[Zwogj`bqt\QXTf*\Q^
o•fbqrXn‹gmrZ
qrX[†nqrƒ„qs†‚i[o_mga[o¡ƒQZ:XnZ@‹Qmtqr‹gqr[mrZEqtcep[oQj#`
\QX¢`anZ*j#\Cfk`NqtX[jJinvbvZ@†w„x
\_`ba[ZJvfJ“W£anqsfYogfbfbincep‚`qr\gX„yzqtX—‹goQceZ¢`banZ@\Qvx~`ZJvc+qtXn\gmr\g‹QxQ
`ba[o_``anZW‹goQceZ-qsf¤<¥_¤<¦_§¨¥_© ª¬«}yzqsfE\gCƒ„qt\Qi[fbmtx‡Xn\_`8ki[fh`bqr‰To_[mrZ
qrX—o_mtmNo_p[pnmrqsjJo_`bqt\QX[f@“
­}X `ba[qtf:Xn\Q`bZg_{Z-pnv\LƒQZ*`ba[o_``anZ„Xn\L{WX•inp[pTZ@vET\ginX[†nf
\QXz`ba[Z®pnvqtjJZ®\_^o_XTo_vjaCx¯^l\QvXn\gX[oL`\Qceqsj®fhZ@mЉ<fha°v\Qi‚`qrX[‹
‹go_ceZ(fYj@o_vvbx\LƒQZ@v]`b\uoL`\Qceqsj fbZJmr‰Tfba˜v\Qi‚`qrXn‹‹goQc+Z(fJ8pnv\_|
ƒCqs†‚Z(†X[Z#`k{-\Qvi[fbZJvf]o_vZ¢pTZ@vbceqr`h`bZ(†`b\1v\Qi‚`Z¢`bvoL‘jw^lvoQj|
`bqt\QX[oQmrmtx\LƒQZ@vEc1o_X„xp[o_`ba[f@“E±YiTo_mtqŠ`oL`bqtƒQZ@mrxgL`ba[qtf²^¬oQj`²c1oQQZ@f
`banZ(fhZ³Z#–‚qsfk`qrX[‹´<\Qi[X[†nf—ce\QvZ’vb\gni[fh`@µ´`banZ@x¶†‚\zXn\Q`®†‚Z#|
pTZ@X[†·\gX¸`ba[Zuogfbfbincep‚`qr\gX¯\_^Yo€mso_v‹QZ~p<\Qp[inmto_`bqt\QXŽ\_^dXnZJ`h|
{\gvb—i[fbZJvf@‚ki[fh`\QX’`banZogfbfbincep‚`qr\gX˜`a[oL`‡`vo_‘1jej@o_X’TZ
vb\gi‚`bZ(†^lvoQj#`bqt\QX[oQmrmtxQ“
¹°a[qrmtZº`anqsf»ˆoL`b\gceqtj¼fbpnmtqŠ`b`oQnmrZ(Œ½ce\‚†‚ZJm’a[ogf&<ZJZJX
fk`i[†‚qtZ@†¾<Z#^l\gvbZ¼qtX¾`anZ¼`voQX[fhp<\Qvb`o_`bqt\QX¾fj#qtZJX[jJZ»šŠ¿QÀ_ž3
XnZ#`k{-\Qv„qrXn‹š Á_ž¨o_XT†º`anZJ\gvbZJ`bqsjJoQmj#\Qcepnin`bZJvŽfbjJqrZ@X[j#Z¼šÂ(ž
j#\Qcec inXnqr`bqtZ@f@]`ba[Z@fbZ€o_vZ®`anZ€‰[vfh`<\Qi[X[†nf\QX°`anZ’pnvbqsj#Z
\_^—o_X[oQvja„xÃqtXÄ`anqsf¯ce\‚†‚ZJm3“ÂÅ £a[Z°\QXnmtxº\Q`banZ@v·fhqtceqrmso_v
vbZ(fhinmr`u^l\Qv`ba[qtf—ce\‚†‚Z@m¢`ba[o_`®{Z¸o_vZ³o¡{-oQvbZ€\_^ qsfu\QX[Z’\Q^
ÆW\Qin‹gan‹goQv†nZJXÇoQX[†¶£o_v†‚\Cf€šÂ(ž¨¢{Wan\°fhan\L{-Z@†°`ba[o_`—`banZ@qrv
ˆhnqsj#vqŠ`ZJvqtoe<\Qi[X[†nŒ~^l\QvdX[\QX[o_`b\Qceqsj•fbZJmr‰Tfba—vb\gi‚`bqtXn‹~‹Co_ceZ@f
jJo_vvqrZ(f\LƒgZJv`b\e`anZoL`\Qceqtj¢fbpnmtqŠ`b`o_[mrZj@oQfbZQ“
ÈqtX[o_mtmtxQN{-Z X[\_`bZ+`a[oL`¢\QX³o~XTo_qtƒQZ+mrZ@ƒQZJm:\ginv¢vbZ(fhinmr`¢qtf
anqr‹ganmtx´qtXC`binqr`bqtƒQZgµ·ce\Lƒ„qrX[‹¸^lvb\gcÉo¯Xn\gX[oL`\Qceqsj®ce\‚†‚ZJmw`b\
o_X·o_`b\Qceqsj~\gXnZj@o_XŽTZƒ„qrZ@{Z(†¯oQf qt†nZJXC`bqr^lx„qrXn‹’‹Qv\Qi[p[f•\Q^
ÊËÌkÍLÎϬÐ3ÑWÌkÒ#ÐWÓÔ*Õ8ÓÑWÍ¡Ö(ÐSÌkÏ]×@ØkÙÂÌkÒ¡ØkÌ#Ú×#ШÎÒ(ÔrÓÏ3Û~Ü
Ò¡Ù Ý#ÌkÏ3Þ3Ù Ðàß#Ú.á#âã
:ä ÎÐSÌkÞå8Ö¡ÙÂæÂÛ¡ÙÂÒ¡ç¡Ú]×JШÎÒ@ÔtÓÏSÛCÚYÕ8èêéá#ëìí(îï×@Ö(Í¡Í_ÓÏSÐSÌhÛ·ÙÂÒ³ÍLÎϬÐeð#ß
ñ:òóŽçÏ3ÎÒJÐdòììì(ôkáõlìáõ¨ô}õlì#öãí(îu÷¢ÓÞSÐWÓÔÐ3ø¡ÙÂÞWÏSÌkÞ3ÌhÎÏ3بøùNÎÞWÛ¡ÓÒ(Ì
ù
ø¡ÙÂæÂÌ
Ð3ø(ÌEÎÖ(ÐSø¡ÓÏ
ù.ÎÞ8Ý(ÙÂÞSÙ Ð3ÙÂÒ¡çÜ:Õ~å8ÌkÏ3úÌkæÂÌ}ßJÚ(Þ3Ö¡Í(ÍQÓϬÐ3ÌkÛYðJßdÎÒYò:×@û
ü ÓÞ¬Ð3 Û¡ÓJØ}Ð3ÓÏ3Îæ‚ûLÌkæÂæÂÓbù
Þ3ø¡ÙÂÍgîTýTÑ]ÎÙÂæsþ‚ÿ bÿ Lî
ÌhϬßÏ3ÌkØkÌkÒJÐSæ ß#Únèù.ÌkÏ3ð(֡بøCÚnè bÎÏhڂÎÒ¡Û ý<͡ެÐ3ÌkÙÂ
Ò tÍ_ÌkÏ3ÞSÓÒLÎæ8ØkÓѐõ
ÑÖ¡Ò¡ÙÂØhÎÐSÙÂÓÒC!Ú Ö¡Ò¡Ì*ãììá ".Í¡Ï3ÓhÝ#ÌkÛ¢Ò¡ÌhÎÏ3æ ßdÑ]ÎÐSبø¡ÙÂÒ¡çÖ(Í¡Í_ÌhÏÎÒ¡Û¢æÂÓhù.ÌkÏ
ð_ÓÖ¡Ò(Û¡Þ-ÓÒ+ÐSø¡ÌdÍ¡Ï3ÙÂØkÌ]ÓÔÎÒLÎÏ3Ø3øJß+ÙÂÒeÎÐSÓÑWÙÂØWÞ3Ìkæ #LÞ3ø+Ï3ÓÖ(ÐSÙÂÒ¡ç‡ç#ÎÑWÌkÞ
ù
ø¡ÌkÏSÌEÌbÎØ3ø‡Í¡æ Îhß#ÌkÏ
Ñ-Ö¡Þ¬ÐNÏ3ÓÖ(ÐS̲٠Ð3ÞNÐ3Ï3Î $WزÓҢΐÞSÙÂÒ¡çæÂÌEÍLÎÐSøC&î %àҢ͡ÎÏSõ
ÐSÙÂØkÖ¡æ ÎÏbÚÐ3ø¡Ì}ßÍ¡Ï3ÓhÝ#ÌkÛÐSøLÎÐTÐSø¡Ì.Ö¡Í(ÍQÌkÏ[ð_ÓÖ¡Ò¡Û¡ÞTÓÔLÐ3ø¡ÙÂÞnÍLÎÍ_ÌkÏ[Ò¡Ó:æÂÓÒ¡çÌkÏ
ø(ÓæÂÛYù
ø¡ÌkÒYÔrÏ¨ÎØ}ÐSÙÂÓÒLÎæ„Ï3ÓÖ@Ð3ÙÂÒ¡ç-ÙÂÞ
Ò(ÓÐÎæÂæÂÓhù.ÌkÛCî
p[vbZ@ƒCqt\QiTfhmtxqtX[†‚Z@pTZ@X[†‚Z@Xg`‡o_XT†—Xn\QXTj#\„\Qp<ZJvoL`qrƒgZ‡`bvoL‘jqtXC`b\
fbqtXn‹QmtZYfh`bvoL`ZJ‹Qqsj]oQ‹QZJXC`fJ(“ '„an\ginmt†n*X ) `-`ba[ZdqtXnZ#‘j#qtZJXTj#x1\_^.`anZ
Z(…Cinqrmtqtnvbqtincê<Zw†nZ@j#vZ@ogfhqtXn‹qtX`banZ¢†‚ZJ‹gvbZ@Zd\Q^j#\„\Qp<ZJvoL`qr\g,X +
­¨^ `banqsfu{-ZJvZ’oQmr{o¡x‚f`anZ¸jJoQfbZQY`ba[Z’c1oQqrX vbZ(fhi[mŠ`u\_^ `banqsf
X[\_`bZ1{-\Qi[mt†’^l\gmrmt\L{ÄqtceceZ@†‚qsoL`ZJmtx˜^lv\Qc pnvZJƒ„qr\gi[f¢{-\Qv˜\QX
X[\QX[o_`b\QceqsjefhZ@mЉTfba³vb\gi‚`bqtXn‹—‹Co_ceZ@f@“”]\L{-ZJƒgZJv(
j#\ginXC`bZJvZ#–„|
oQcepnmrZ(f‡`\—`banqsfqtXC`binqr`bqt\QXŽo_vZ1CX[\L{WX&šŠ¿ž¨“˜£anqsfX[\_`bZjJo_X
<Z1qtXg`ZJvpnvZ#`bZ(†³oQf¢pnv\Lƒ„qrXn‹`ba[qtf‡qtXC`binqr`bqt\QX¯jJ\QvvbZ(j`w^lvb\gc o
¥ .0§ 1h«¦ 02¢p<ZJvfbpTZ(j`bqtƒQZgNvoL`ba[ZJv¢`baTo_X’\QX¸o_X’qrXTfk`o_X[jJZ#|¨CxC|
- /
qtX[fh`oQX[j#Z¢[ogfhqsfJ“
U ;-xŽoQ>
X =}¦_§¨¥_© ª¬?
« 0A@CBŠªà§S§}E¦ DBF2HG¯ªà¤ 0§¨¦_¤<« 2JW{Z
354687 KNM 6:9 <
ceZ(o_X1o¢`bvqtpnmrZ™ IKJML!JNJŸ„{WanZ@vbOZ I qsf*o‡†‚qtvbZ(j`Z@†+‹Qvo_pnae{Wqr`ba
™¬Xn\_`¸XnZ(j#Z(fbfo_vqrmtxƂqsfk`qrX[j#`Ÿ³fb\Qinvj#ZŽƒQZ@vh`qtjJZ@Q
f PR JTSSTSJRU
V
oQX[†’fhqtXn®ƒgZJvb`bqsj#Z@Wf PYX Å JSTSSTJMXMUZVZ[\L~qsf‡oƒQZ(j`b\gv¢qrX[Å †nZ#–‚Z@†’„x
fb\Qi[vjJZ#|}fhqtXn‡p[oQqrvfJQ{WanZJvZWpnmso¡xQZJ^v ]c•i[fh`E^lvogj`qr\gX[o_mtmrx•vb\gi‚`bZ
LY_•i[XnqŠ`f\_^‡`bvoL‘j®^lvb\g`
c RY_•`bQ
\ XH_H[o_XTa
† N®qsfo·ƒQZ(j`b\gv~\Q^
jJ\gfh`]^linX[j#`bqt\QX[f@<\QXnZ•^l\QvdZ(oQja—Z(†‚‹QZ\Qb^ Ied“ cdfYqsfYfh`oQX[†no_v†.
{-Z+{WqrmtmEoQffhinceZ `ba[o_`‡Z@oQja®^linX[j`qr\ge
X NTfqsf¢o~Xn\gXnXnZ@‹goL`qrƒgZQ
X[\QX[†‚Z(j#vZ@ogfhqtXn‹[o_XT†°j#\QXC`qrX„in\gi[fe^linX[j#`bqt\QXN“ã\¯Z@ogfhZu`anZ
ZJ–‚pT\Cfhqr`bqt\QXNT{Z•{WqrmtmoQmtfb\oQffhi[c+Z`ba[o_`dZ@ogjaujJ\gfh`]^linX[j#`bqt\QX
qsf]†‚Fq g8ZJvZJXC`bqso_nmtZo_XT†—j#\QX„ƒgZ#–.“*£anZ(fhZ•ogfbfbincep‚`qr\gX[fJ[{Wanqtja
a[\Qms†¢qrXoQmrmg\_^„`banZ*c+\Cfk`pT\gpninmso_voQpnpnmtqtj@oL`qr\gX[f.\_^„`anZ²ce\‚†‚ZJm3
j@o_XTZ‡{-Z@oQQZ@XnZ@†fh\gc+Z@{Wa[oL`(“
È[\QvoQXqtX[fk`o_X[jJZ•™ IKJhL!JhNJŸ#‚Oo iU 2¦ 0ª DBj2lkW¥ -?
m jJ\QcepnvqtfbZ@f
n Xn\gXnXnZ@‹goL`qrƒgZWƒQZ(j`b\gvf m !
Å JSTSSJ m g{WanZ@vbZ m _ qtf_ †‚Z#‰[X[Z@†e\QX
`anOZ RY_lo| XH_8p[oL`a[\f pq_8\_U C^ I o_XT† foL`qtfh‰[Z@lf rts^u/v,w m syx LT_b“È[\Qv
o z[\L{ m  m f x r _F| Å r s(u/v w m s _ †‚Z@Xn\_`Z@f‡`anZ`\_`o_lm zT\L{
{
\gXeZ@†‚‹gZd}C“£anZwj#\Cfk`bN s ™ m ŸE\Q^.o¢pToL`ba~¶{Wqr`ba1vZ@fbp<Z@j`*`b\•o
zT\L{ m qtf`anZ•fbinc r f uEsKNfL™ m fŸ\Q^`anZj#\Cfk`fW\_^:qŠ`fWZ@†n‹QZ@f@“
£a[Z-jJ\gfh^` € _ ™ m Ÿ
`b\wpnmto¡xgZJv ].qtf:†‚ZJ‰[XnZ@†•„Wx ras^u/U vCw:N s ™ m Ÿ m s _ “
£a[Z•j#\Cfk` €e™ m Ÿ\_^²Ko z[\L{ m qtfd†‚Z#‰[X[Z@†—„‚
x r _j| Å € _ ™ m Ÿ\Qv(
Z(…CinqrƒLoQmrZ@Xg`mrxg r f uEƒ N f ™ m f Ÿ m f “
c„z[\L{ m qsfe¦_b
§ …•!¦ 0M†‡2ˆ‰‚ª B ª D.ª ‰‚© N\gvdqsf¢
o …•!¦ 0h†Šk¥ - 
qr^:^l\QvYZ@oQjaupnmso¡xQZ@qv ] m _ ceqtXnqrcejq ‹JZ(Œf €_™ m Ÿ{WanZ@Xu`banZ•\_`ba[ZJv
zT\L{]Ž
f P m V |*_‡o_vZanZJms†¯‰[–„Z(†.“·¹°a[ZJX n x ¿Q*`ban{
Z ’dogfha
Z(…Cinqrmtqtnvbqso®oQvb‘ Zp[vbZ(j#qsfhZ@mrx€`banZ\Qp‚`qrc1oQbm z[\L{]f@“
“ cdf n•”—–
oQX[“
† LY_ ”™˜ ^l\gvwoQmrm:pnmso¡xQZ@vf ].{Z vbZ(j#\LƒQZ@v]`anZec+\gvbZ {Z@mrmr|
fh`biT†‚qrZ(†Xn\QX[o_`b\gc+qsj¢fhZ@mЉ<fhavb\gi‚`bqtXn‹e‹goQceZQ“
š*vbZ@ƒCqt\QiTf{-\Qvfban\L{]f-`ba[o_`WZJƒQZ@vbx~qrX[fh`oQX[j#Z‡og†‚ceqŠ`f]oL`
mtZ@ogfk`\QXnZ ’doQfb›a z[\L{&š À‚(Á_ž¨“£anlZ @C.ª¬« 2dM¥ i¦_¤</¦ .b« †œlž8™ IKJML!JNJŸ
\Q^o_XÄqrXTfk`o_X[jJZ ™ IKJML!JhN@Ÿ’qtf³fbindp €e™ m Ÿ Ÿ/€e*™ m Ÿ#e{WanZJvZ·`anZ
fbinpnvZJc inc¾vo_Xn‹gZ@fY\LƒQZJ›v ’dogfh¡
a z[\L{]f m oQX[†®^lZ(oQfbqr[mrWZ z[\L{]f
^ ’YoQfba z[\L{]f qtX´o_`b\Qceqsj~fbpnmtqŠ`b`o_[mrZ
m “Ž£anZi[Xnqt…CinZ@XnZ@ff+\_
rq X[fh`oQX[j#Z(fqtf:Xn\Q`E{Z@mrm‚inXT†‚ZJvfk`\„\„†š ÀnLÁLž¨goQX[†{-ZWo_vZ*`anZJvZ#|
^l\QvZ¯o_mtmr\L{WqtXn‹Ž`banZ¯p<\gffbqrnqtmtqŠ`kxÇ`ba[o_`€o_X qtX[fk`o_X[jJZ¯oQ†‚ceqr`f
c•inmr`bqtpnmtZ ’YoQfbayz[\L{]f@“e’d\_`bZ`baToL`1o®<\QinX[†·\QX¸`anZpnvbqsj#Z
\_^No_X[oQvja„x+o_pnpnmtqtZ@f@g„xe†‚Z#‰[X[qŠ`qr\gXNQ`\/¦ BBZ’dogfhKa zT\L{]f²\_^NoQX
qrX[fh`oQX[j#Zg“¹’Z†‚ZJXn\Q`bZ1„x U‚™ NŸY`anZmso_v‹QZ(fk`‡pnvqtjJZe\_^Wo_X‚|
o_vjaCx\‚jJjJinvbvqtXn‹qtX€o_X˜qrX[fh`oQX[j#Z {WqŠ`a n pnmto¡xgZJvfdoQX[†®j#\Cfk`
^linX[j`qr\gX[fqtXz`ba[Z€fbZ#` E<
“ '„qrceqtmtoQvbmtxQ ™ Ÿ1†nZJXn\Q`bZ@f1`banZ
mtoQvb‹gZ@fh`h|¨pT\Cfbfbqr[mrZ:pnvqtjJZ²\_^[oQX[o_vja„x]qtX•oWXn\gX[oL`\Qceqtj²qrX[fh`oQX[j#Z
{WqŠ`aj#\Cfk`^linX[j#`bqt\QX[f-qtX E“E£anZYƒLoQmrinZ ™ Ÿ²qsfCX[\L{WX1^l\Qv
ceoQX„x¯fhZJ`f Eµ^l\QveZ#–no_cepnmtZQqŠ`qsf+Á _À˜qr^ &qsf+`ba[Z®fhZJ`e\Q^
oL‘1XnZ¢\QvWj#\gX[jJo¡ƒgZ]^linXTj`bqt\QXTf‡š ›„T¡ž3noQX[†qtf +™ :Ÿmt\Q‹ „Ÿ-qr^
qtf`banZ~fbZ#` \_^]p<\QmtxCX[\QceqtoQmtf{WqŠ`a¸Xn\QXnX[ZJ‹go_`bqtƒQZjJ\CZJ‘j#qtZJXC`f
o_X[††‚ZJ‹gvbZ@Z‡oL`Wce\gfh` ®š œ¡ž3“
£a[Z¢fh`bvi[j#`binvZ¢qrXna[ZJvZJXC`-qtX—Wo ’YoQfb
a zT\L{°`ba[o_`]pTZ@vbceqr`f
T\ginX[†nfW\gX~`anZ‡pnvqtjJZ¢\_^Eo_X[oQvja„xeqtf]qt†‚Z@XC`bqr‰[Z@†qtX`anZ‡XnZJ–C`
pnvb\gpT\Cfhqr`bqt\QX
“´­}X´`anZ®fk`oL`ZJceZJXC`\_^w`ba[Z—pnvb\gpT\Cfhqr`bqt\QXzo_XT†
`ban_ v\Qin‹gan\Qin`w`anqsfXn\Q`bZQqŠ^ m qtf‡^lZ@oQfbqtnmrZe^l\gv~_ ™ IKJhL!JhNJŸ#
`anZJX
N f ™ m fJŸW†‚ZJX[\_`bZ(fW`anZ•ZJ–„p[vbZ(fbfbqr\gX NTfL™ m fŸ
m f N f ™ m fŸ#“W­}XC`bi‚|
qŠ`qrƒgZJmtxQ N _f qtfN`banZ²jJ\gfh`N\_^‚Z@†‚‹glZ }E^lv\Qc¶pnmto¡xgZJv ]) f.pTZ@vfbp<Z@j`qrƒgEZ [
fhZ@ZešÂ(ž.^l\gv^linvb`banZ@vd†‚qsfbjJi[fbfbqt\QX\_^
`anqsfWqrXC`inqŠ`qr\gXN“
i m ª 01¦ …•!
¦ 0M†Š_ kW¥ - i#!¥ .1™ IKJML!JhN@Ÿ W§ †2#¤
U
_
+
©
à
ª
[
¤
à
ª
+
©
ª
T
2
d
0
r
r
E
u
ƒ
N
™
Ÿ m f ¥ !2.!¦ BB/i2!¦ 0ª DBF2bk¥ - 0
f m f (
_j|
f
m
Å
i#¥/.•™IKJhL!JhNJŸ
!#"%$'&()
+*
-,
/.
m
!0
*vb\gpT\Cfhqr`bqt\QX+¿:^l\Qmtmt\L{]f8^¬o_qtvbmtxdZ(oQfbqrmtxW^lv\QcÇ`banZ*†nZ#‰[Xnqr`bqt\QX
\_^*o YoQfba{z[\L{¼oQX[†—\Qi[vYoQffbincep‚`bqt\QX—`a[oL`‡j#\Cfk`d^linX[j`qr\gX[f
o_vZwjJ\QX„ƒQZJ–8noQX[†{Z¢\Qceqr`do ^l\QvceoQm.pnv\C\Q^k“
OI 6 O 9 H U깒Z’Xn\L{¾pnv\LƒQZ—\Qi[vc1o_qtX&vZ@fbinmr`@W`a[oL`
`banZwpnvqtjJZY\Q^o_X[oQvja„xeqtXoL`\QceqsjYfbpnmtqŠ`b`o_[mrZwqrXTfk`o_X[jJZ@f-qtf-Xn\
mtoQvb‹gZJvY`ba[oQX˜`a[oL`‡qtX€Xn\gX[oL`\Qceqsj qtX[fh`oQX[j#Z(fJ“+Èn\Qvc1o_mtmrxg.{Z
{Wqrmtmfban\L{&`anZ‡^l\gmrmt\L{WqrX[‹[n{WanZ@vbZo~fhZJ` ’\Q^:jJ\gfh`W^linX[j`qr\gX[f
qtf¸ªà¤ †n¥_©e¥ Z2JC¤ 2/¥ ‰:0qr^+qr`€jJ\QXC`oQqrX[f—fb\QceZ¯jJ\gfh`^li[X[j`qr\g<
X N
fbo_`bqsfk^lx„qtXn‹ N_™ ˜ Ÿ ˜ “
!¥ .1!¦ BB n ¿˜¦L¤ —ªà:¤ †n¥_©e¥ 2#&¤ 2/¥ ‰:0K02J§ 0
H¥ i«
¥ 0&§ i‰‚¤<«J§Sª¬¥_¤ 0 Un™ Ÿ
™ Ÿ
£a[ZJ\QvZJc › qsf `bqt‹QaC` qtX `ba[Z fbZJX[fbZ `a[oL`
mrqtŽc U
U‚™ Ÿ
™ Ÿ [Ç`banqsf an\Qms†nf&<Z@j@o_i[fbZºZ@ƒQZ@vbx
Xn\QX[o_`b\gc+qsj—qtX[fh`o_XTj#Z˜j@o_X°Z g8Z@j#`bqtƒQZ@mrxz<ZLjbfbqtc•inmsoL`Z@†nŒ³„x
o_X oL`b\gceqtj€\QXnZ³{Wqr`ba fhin‘1jJqrZ@XC`bmtx&c1o_X„x°pnmso¡xQZJvf@“ '„qtX[j#Z
™ Ÿ x ¿Y^l\Qvo_mtm En£anZJ\gvbZ@cꛕqsfX[\_`-`bqt‹QaC`-{Wa[ZJX n x ¿Q“
£Å anZ]jJogfhZ\_^8qtXg`ZJvceZ@†‚qsoL`Z n qsf:Xn\Q`²xQZ#`²i[X[†‚ZJvfh`b\„\‚† [gfbZJZš Lž
^l\QvWce\QvZ‡†‚Z#`o_qtmtf@“
£a[Z‡QZJx1qs†‚Z(o qtXu\Qinvpnv\„\_^\_^£a[ZJ\QvZJc»› qsf-`banZ†nZ#‰n|
XnqŠ`qr\gXu\_^Eo_XqrXC`bZ@vbceZ(†‚qto_`bZ¢Z#–‚pnvZ@ffbqr\gX~`a[oL`]qsfZ@ogfhqtmrxj#\Qc+|
p[o_vZ@†•`b\¢<\_`ba Uwo_X[† _`k{-\YƒLo_mtinZ(f:`ba[o_`²fhZ@ZJcĆnqŠ‘j#i[mŠ`
`b\j#\gcep[o_vZ-†nqrvZ@j#`bmtxQQqtXep[o_vb`*†‚inZ`anZ]j#\ginXC`bZ@vbqtXC`binqr`bqtƒQZZ#–„|
o_cepnmtZ@f‡\Q^¢šr¿#ž¨“£a[qtf‡qtXC`bZ@vbceZ@†nqto_`bZ1Z#–‚pnvZ@ffbqr\gXN
{Wanqsja³{Z
{WqrmtmNinXnqtc1o_‹gqrX[o_`bqtƒQZ@mrxj@o_mtm CU„nqsfW†‚ZJ‰[XnZ@†uogf-^l\Qmtmr\L{]f@“
š
’
1
32
4
4
5
76
98
:<;>=%?=A@CB?(ED
+*
LK
F
GF
IH
9J
76
!0
I
M
?N
!¥ . ¦ «¥ 0§ i‰‚¤<«J§3ª¬¥L¤ N &U‚™ N@Ÿ
fbinp P m f N f ™ m f ŸhŸnš/m f N f ™ m f Ÿ r _jU | Å ™ m f _ m f _ ŸHN _f ™ m f Ÿ¨žAV - †2.h2
§ †2W0‰Y@&.h2#©Š‰‚© ª 0•U §}¦ Z2#¤¸¥ !2.1¦!BB:U ¤8¥L¤1}¤&2 g¦_§Sª !2Š.h2¦!_ B¤‰‚©Š1
D2.0 m fYJ m f Å JTSSSJ m f Jlm fYJlm f Å JTSSTSJbm f 0‰[«†Ž§ †n¦_§Œr _ m f x m f
¦_¤ r _ m f _ x m f /¥ .•¦ 02J§ ÇH¥ i «!¥ 0C§ i‰‚¤8«#§3ª¬¥L¤ 0 CU‚™ NŸ
fbinp u U ™ NJŸ
YZ#‰[X[qŠ`qr\gX·Àuqtf•ce\_`bqtƒLoL`Z@†³„x®`anZ~fb\_|}jJo_mtmtZ@†³o_X[oQvja„x
ƒLoQmrinZ’\_^š ›ndœ(žni‚`®†‚\„Z@fXn\Q`ufbZJZ@c `b\°oQ†nc+qr`—oŽfbqrcepnmtZ
qtXC`bZ@vbpnvZ#`oL`qr\gXN“ ’]Z@ƒQZ@vh`anZJmtZ@ffJ¡oQf{-Z²{Wqrmtm‚fhZ@ZQ¡qr`
‰n`ffbX„in‹Qmtx
qtXC`b\+`ba[Z‡pnvb\„\Q^
^lvo_ceZJ{-\Qv1\_^š ›nTœ(ž¨“
.b¥@M¥ i€M¥ i &†2!
¥ .h2J© ·ÈqŠ– n ¿€o_X[†°oŽfhZJ` \Q^•j#\Cfk`
^li[X[j`qr\gX[fJ“¹’Z€X[Z#–„`ufban\L{ `baToL` U‚™ Ÿ CU‚™ Ÿ“»VYinv
p[vb\„\_^\_^`banqsf¸{WqtmrmTZ&oQmr\gXn‹ `banZ&fo_ceZ°mtqrX[Z@f¯ogf’`ban\CfhZ
qtX¶š ›‚²œ(ž¨oQX[†¯{Wqtmtm-vZJmtx³\QX š²v\Qp<\gfbqŠ`qr\gX&¿Q“ Z#`—™ IKJML!JNJŸ
<Zo_XuqtX[fh`o_XTj#Z‡{Wqr`ba n pnmto¡xgZJvfo_X[†uj#\Cfk`W^li[X[j`qr\gX[fWqtX`anZ
fbZ#` :“ NZ#` m TZ’o ’dogfha z[\L{¾oQX[† m o_X°\gp‚`bqtc1o_Om zT\L{
^l\gv®™ IKJhL!JhNJŸ#“¶Èn\gvZ@ogjaŽZ(†‚‹Q{
Z }C-`banZ®†nZ#‰[Xnqr`bqt\QX°U \Q^ U _ ™ Ÿ
qtce_ pnmt_ qrZ(fu`ba[o_` m f N f ™ m f Ÿ m f N f ™ m f hŸ Ÿ U ™ Ÿ r _F| Å ™ m f
“ '„i[c+ceqtXn‹¯\LƒgZJv1o_mtm]\_^¢`anZ—Z@†‚‹gZ@foQX[†zo_pnp[mrxC|
m f HŸ N f ™ m f Ÿ#8
qtXn
‹ š*vb\gpT\Cfhqr`bqt\QX¸¿`banZ@X˜x„qrZ@mt†[f €e™ Um Ÿ x r f uEƒ>m f N f *™ m f Ÿ
Å r f uEƒ m fNfL™ m fŸ r f uEƒr _F| Å *™ m f _ m f _ MŸ N _f ™ m f#Ÿ
€e™ m ŸhŸ CU„™ Ÿ#[fha[\L{WqrXn‹+`a[oL` U‚™ Ÿ
CU‚™ NŸ#“
£\1j#\QcepnmtZ#`Zd`anZ¢pnv\C\Q^k‚{Zwc•iTfk`]fban\L{°`baToL` CU‚™ Ÿ
™ Ÿ#“•£anqsf‡o_ce\QinXC`f]`\ZJ–‚anqr[qŠ`qrXn‹T8^l\Qv¢ZJƒgZJvxupT\Cfbfbqr[mrZ
fbZ#`b`bqtXn‹u\_^`banZ1p[oQvoQceZ#`bZ@vfYqtX YZ#‰TXnqŠ`qr\gX’À[
oXn\QXToL`b\gceqtj
qtX[fh`oQX[j#Z]{Wqr`bafhi‚‘jJqrZ@Xg`mrxemso_v‹QZWpnvqsj#Zd\Q^
o_X[oQvja„xg“ YZ#`oQqrmsf
\Q^`anqsf oQvb‹ginceZJXC`o_vZ1\QceqŠ`b`bZ(†¸†‚inZ1`\˜fhpToQj#ZjJ\QX[fh`bvo_qtXC`f
oQX[†jJo_X<Z¢^l\QinX[†qtX¸š _ž3“
¹°anqtmtZY`anqsfXn\_`ZYZ g<Z(j`bqtƒQZ@mrxfbZ#`b`bmtZ@f-`anZ¢pnvbqsj#Zw\_^o_X[oQvh|
ja„x1qtXo_`b\QceqsjYfbpnmtqŠ`b`oQnmrZ¢qtX[fh`o_XTj#Z@f@„qrXC`ZJvZ@fh`bqtXn‹+…CinZ(fk`qr\gX[f
vZJc1oQqrXuo_<\Qi‚`]fbi[jaqrX[fh`oQX[j#Z(fJb“ '‚ZJZ1š _žN^l\Qv]†nZ#`oQqrmsf@“
6 A6 I 6 GP 6
OP=AQ$>#"?%$SR>(ED
T*UN
W
![
IH
/.
/0D
^] `_
N
V
Z*
YX
\6
.
>
7*%N
WV
0
a
b
dc
iF
fehg
jJkN
ml
n
il
EN
F
TN
X
F
o`prq
_/s
/N
F
X
9JdN
5N
9J
Ga
%a
M
Wt
2
M
u
4
vxw7y<zA{I|}~€!h‚%}!hƒ„zA{^…?}†‡†ˆ~‰~€‚‡ŠŠ{Œ‹^Ž}L<Y‘“’/”h‚ˆ†ˆ‚ˆ•Š€‚ˆ”h–˜—}Ž}L™
ƒŠ“šZ‘+›+{œhž\Ÿ! h¡5¢£7¤#¥§¦!¨Z©ªr«­¬ ¦L®T¯“°Z¦®!®Š¥>w“±!±Zw!{
v ¦LyY²Š{W³{9|!‰€‘+}Z¥E´{9zA{9zZŽµ`”h†ˆ¶r¥}ƒ¸·{W¹{z`~€‚ˆ‘7»º
!›‰‘+›+{
zZ‘+†x¼h›‰µ»€r”Z~€‚ˆh½
‚ˆ„+}!—}+‚x~Ž}~€‘“ƒ»h‘7~¾!€¿`›+{Y‹I}!—Š—§‘“}‚ˆ
ÀÂÁ%Ã
{
v ªyY…{?‹9{Ä9}€¿T‘­“{º
”Іˆ~€‚ˆ—І‡‘Å‘“’/”Š‚‡†ˆ‚ˆ•Š€‚ˆ”Š–Æ•§‘7µ}“Ç`‚‡€›!„h‘­~‰™
¾€¿Z›+{œhž\Ÿ! h¡5¢£7¤#¥¦r¦Z©\w“«­¬ ªr±L°T®TÈ`¥?w“±rÉ!ÉZ{
v ®!yY´{ËÊWŽƒŠ}Z¥¸³{„³Ìr–P¥d}!hƒÍ·{Âz`µh‚ˆ–<¿`‚ˆ^{
|!–<—§‘7~€‚x™
~€‚ˆÇT‘G€r”Z~€‚‡Š½Î‚ˆÏ–E”h†x~€‚x™Ð”h›‰‘7Â7r–<–E”Ёh‚ˆ“}L~€‚‡!ÑŠ‘7~Ò¾!€¿`›+{
Ó\Ô%ÔÔ?ÕZÖ×IÀ
œ§ØLÙ9¥^wr©Ð¨r«­¬ ¨`w+¯L°Z¨!¦`w!¥w+±r±!ªZ{
v ¨LyY‹9{A³W!”h½!µh½T}LŽƒŠ‘+{‹µŠ‘—Z€‚ˆ+‘Ú}}L€­µ/ÛP‚ˆ›‚ˆhƒŠ‘+—§‘+hƒŠ‘+/~
!Ú?~€µŠ‘h‘7~¾€¿Å~€!—§r†ˆr½Û/{ÌÜ × ¢h¢h¥ÈTÝ`©Ð¦r«­¬ ª!®Zw­°`ª!È!®Z¥¦¯r¯!ªZ{
v ÈyY‹9{Þ³Ìr”нrµh½r}ŽƒZ‘+^{
—h†‡}+Û/‘7€›+{
zZ‘+†x¼h›‰µß€r”Z~€‚‡Š½à¾‚x~€µá}~€!–<‚‡
…?€‘+†ˆ‚‡–<‚ˆh}‰Û
ÇT‘7€›‰‚ˆr¥â}LÇ!}!‚ˆ†‡}!•Іˆ‘ãÚ䍀r–
å/æTæ!çè\éTé!æ!å`ê/ë!ìTí?î‰ïæ`ðñTò`ë!ìTó>îêrórôZéŠõ“æ`ö7÷é {
v ÝLyY‹9{³W!”h½!µh½T}LŽƒŠ‘+¸}ƒù¹ú
ø {̋}ŽƒZr›+{ÞÄW“¾û•}!ƒj‚‡›Œ›‰‘+†x¼›‰µ
€r”Z~€‚‡Š½/üdÜ Ö×IÀ
¥h®r±Š©Ð¦r«­¬ ¦ªrÈL°`¦r¨±Z¥I¦!¯!¯T¦`{