Report of TPE Glacial Mass Balance Flagship Station Workshop in Guangzhou By TPE Glacial Mass Balance Flagship Station Working Group February 20-21, 2012 1. Overview and assessment The Third Pole, like the Arctic and Antarctica, is drawing on increased attention among the international academic communities, the decision makers and the public. Centered on the Tibetan Plateau, the Third Pole region stretches from the Pamir and Hindu Kush in the west to the Hengduan Mountains in the east, and from the Kunlun and Qilian mountains in the north to the Himalayas in the south. It covers over 5,000,000 km2 in total and with an average elevation surpassing 4000 m. The Third Pole region, with its huge geographic presence and high topography, impacts the atmospheric circulation patterns over and beyond Eurasia. It contributes to humidity in East and South Asia, while to aridity in Central Asia. The Third Pole environment is currently experiencing unique changes in the cryosphere, atmosphere, hydrosphere, and biosphere, which would seriously impact the social and economic sustainability in the region. The Third Pole holds the largest ice mass outside the Arctic and Antarctic regions. These glaciers are mostly at the headwaters of big rivers such as the Yangtze, Yellow, Brahmaputra, Mekong, Indus, Ganges, Salween Amu Darya, Irrawaddy, and Tarim in Asia. Some of these glaciers extend north into the arid and desert region, and are the main water sources for arid central Asia, especially for the Tarim Basin and Qaidum Basin. Some extend south into the warmer, wetter forests and concentrate around the Yarlung Tsangpo Rivers in the upper reaches of the Brahmaputra, benefiting the local residents while also causing glacial disasters and other water related problems. Recent studies have found that glaciers in the Third Pole region are experiencing diversified and alarming changes, with the smallest magnitude of retreat in the interior of the region dominated by the continental climate, while the greatest one in the southeastern Tibetan Plateau prevailed by the maritime climate. With climate changes, glaciers are expected to experience even more dramatic changes, which may bear large on local wellbeing of the region. However, insufficient understandings or even misunderstandings of the magnitude of glacial retreat and its impact on the water cycle still exist. This leads to horrendous “forecast” of a melting-out scenario of the entire Himalayan glaciers by 2035 in the 4th IPCC report. This also leads to different interpretations of the causes of the glacial lake expansion flood (GLEF) and glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF). Some scientists attribute variations in glaciers and lakes to the rising temperature, while others ascribe them to increasing precipitation and weakening evaporation. Among the key research questions proposed by the TPE, two are directly related to glaciers: 1) How is environmental change of the Third Pole impacting the cryosphere (glaciers, snow and permafrost), atmosphere, hydrosphere, and biosphere? 2) What is the status of ice (glaciers, snow and permafrost) on the Third Pole and how will glacial retreat and mass balance changes affect the water and energy cycle and its components, and what are their environmental impacts and associated geohazards? During the technical meeting of Flagship Stations at the Third TPE workshop, there were four presentations of the total seven ones talking about the glacial mass balance flagship stations. This indicates the importance of studying glacial status in the region. Of the seven working groups including glacier, lake, river, stable isotope, high elevation precipitation, ecology, human activities, land-atmospheric interaction, the scientists interested in glacier study had the common idea to hold a Glacial Mass Balance Flagship Station Workshop. After intensive discussion among scientists, three co-chairs organized the workshop in Guangzhou February 19-22, 2012. The participants of the workshop reported the ongoing mass balance studies in the Third Pole region and assessed the status of mass balance measurement. The workshop focused very much on the data of glacial mass balance. Profs. Yao and Fujita and other participants pointed out that in the glacial mass balance studies of the third pole region, the main problem we are facing is the lack of exchange of data which results in duplicated work in some glaciers. Therefore, it is very important to share the measuring data among different groups. Based on win-win principles, all participants agreed to share the data they have. The participants agreed to collect previous glaciological data to establish a database. Data obtained from future field work will be added to the database. After the training course in Nepal, Fujita will share the data including GPS and mass balance data of Yala glacier and two other glaciers. Prof. Yao suggested that the general information should be provided based on the uniform guideline. The participants intensively discussed about the coordination of overlapping glacial mass balance measurement. The Yala Glacier in Nepal is a good example of coordination. There are several groups working on the Yala Glacier now. After discussion at the workshop, Bi-annual measurements of glacial mass balance over the glacier will be jointly carried out during pre-monsoon and post-monsoon periods by the TPE and the academic institutions in Nepal (KU, TU and DHM). The TPE will be responsible for pre-monsoon measurement, and the Nepalese organizations will organize the other field observation in post-monsoon. The AWS coordination is another good example. There are several AWSs now at Kanjing. After discussion at the workshop, participants agreed to share the data of DHM at Kanjing station and the TPE AWSs can be set at higher elevation. Participants proposed that the total number and area of glaciers in Third Pole region are unclear. Therefore, there is an urgent need to collect and compile the glacier inventory from different countries in the Third Pole region, including China, Nepal, India, Pakistan, Tajikistan, Afghanistan, Bhutan and Myanmar. Dr. Tayal proposed that cross-validation of inventory is necessary to check the overlap and missing area. Prof. Liu Shiyin will finish and publish the second Chinese glacier inventory by the end of this year. Mr Jilani discussed the work on glacier inventory in Pakistan. Five glaciers in Tajikistan influenced by the westerlies have been measured by DGPS in August 2011 by TPE and will be continued. The participants assessed the uncertainties of different methods in mass balance studies including observations, satellite images and GPS measurement. The participants suggest to use Landsat(TM, not ETM) images for glacier inventory in the Third Pole region, due to its free access. All glacial-related issues point to the necessity of long-term observation and monitoring stations and to one of the TPE priorities, that is to establish long-term observation and monitoring stations, particularly Glacial Mass Balance Flagship Stations within the Third Pole region. 2. Ongoing glacial mass balance observations in the Third Pole region Glacial mass balance measurement was very few before the century in the Third Pole region. Discontinuous measurements have been carried out for the Qiyi Glacier since the 1970s and for the Kangwure and Yala Glacier since 1990s. The Dongkmadi Glcier and the Meikuang Glacier have been measured continuously since 1989. Starting from 2006, glaciers for glacial measurement have been increasing. Starting from 2006, glaciers for glacial measurement have been increasing. So far, 24 glaciers have been discussed for mass balance measurement. The Urumqi Glacier No. 1 has been identified as reference glacier. 1. Parlung No.10 Glacier (China/southeastern TP) COORDINATES: 29º17´N/96º54´E Photo taken by W. Yang, 2008 Parlung No.10 Glacier is located within the headwaters of the Parlung Zangbo River, a tributary of the Brahmaputra River in southeastern Tibetan Plateau. It is a valley temperate glacier flowing from 4,910 to 5,625 m, with an area of 2.1 km2 and a length of 3.5 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the north-east. The mass balance investigations on Parlung No.10 glacier began in the year of 2005/2006, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 11 measuring stakes have been distributed on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show strong mass losses between 2005/06 and 2008/09, with an average of -781 mm w.e. 2008/09 is the most negative mass balance year we have measured (-1575 mm w.e.). The ELAs in the past four years have shifted from 5,419m to 5,500m, and nearly reached the glacier summit in 2008/09. 2. Parlung No.12 Glacier (China/southeastern TP) COORDINATES: 29º18´N/96º54´E Photo taken by W. Yang, 2008 Parlung No.12 Glacier is located within the headwaters of the Parlung Zangbo River, a tributary of the Brahmaputra River in southeastern Tibetan Plateau. It is a small temperate cirque glacier flowing from 5,130 to 5,265 m, with an area of 0.2 km2 and a length of 0.6 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the north-east. The mass balance investigations on Parlung No.12 glacier began in the year of 2005/2006, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). From 1980 to 2005, the Parlung No. 12 Glacier retreated about 700 m in length and its area reduced by approximately 55.3%. Its two branches separated from each other sometime before 2006 and two moraine lakes emerged at its terminus. A total of 5 measuring stakes have been distributed on the right branch of this glacier. The maximum depth of this glacier is about 40 m measured by Ground Penetrating Radar. During field observations from 2006 to 2010, the glacier thinned by 9.5 m. The ELAs have already risen beyond the glacier summit during the period of measurement. This glacier is now suffering from significant mass deficit. 3. Parlung No.94 Glacier (China/southeastern TP) COORDINATES: 29º23´N/96º59´E Photo taken by W. Yang, 2008 Parlung No.94 Glacier is located within the headwaters of the Parlung Zangbo River, a tributary of the Brahmaputra River in southeastern Tibetan Plateau. It is a typical temperate valley glacier flowing from 5,000 to 5,635 m, with an area of 2.5 km2 and a length of 2.9 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the north-west. The mass balance investigations on Parlung No.94 glacier began in the year of 2005/2006, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). The number of measuring stakes over the whole glacier has progressively increased from 16 stakes in 2005 to 28 stakes in 2010. The Bn were negative for each year of the past five balance years, but differ in magnitude significantly between years. The 2005/2006, 2007/2008 and 2008/2009 balance years show particularly high mass deficits, while the 2006/2007 and 2009/2010 balance years show much less mass loss. The 2008/2009 balance year stands out from the other hydrological years, with an annual mass balance of -2018 mm w.e. The ELAs in the past five years have shifted from 5,333m to 5,600m, and nearly reached the glacier summit in 2008/09 4. Parlung No.390 Glacier (China/southeastern TP) COORDINATES: 29º21´N/97º01´E Photo taken by W. Yang, 2008 Parlung No.390 Glacier is located within the headwaters of the Parlung Zangbo River, a tributary of the Brahmaputra River in southeastern Tibetan Plateau. It is a temperate cirque glacier flowing from 5,160 to 5,460 m, with an area of 0.5 km2 and a length of 1.2 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the south-east. The mass balance investigations on Parlung No.390 glacier began in the year of 2006/2007, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 5 measuring stakes have been distributed along the central axis of this glacier. Recent mass balance results show strong mass losses between 2006/07 and 2009/10, with an average of -1019 mm w.e. 2008/09 is the most negative mass balance year we have measured (-1673 mm w.e.). The ELAs in the past four years have shifted from 5,335m to 5,500m, and nearly reached the glacier summit in 2008/09. 5. Qiyi Glacier (China/Qilian Mountain) COORDINATES: 39º15´N/97º45´E Photo taken by J. C. Pu, 2008 The Qiyi Glacier is located on the northern slope of Qilian Mts. It is a sub-continental valley glacier. Its area is 2.87 km2, with a length of 3.8 km. Its altitudinal range is between 4,304 and 5,159 m. Mass balance measurement first started in 1974/75 and measured discontinuously since. A total of 28 measuring stakes were set up on the glacier. The mass balance is much more negative (-648 mm) in 2009/10, comparing with that in 2007/08 (-105 mm) and 2008/09 (-74 mm). 6. Xiaodongkemadi Glacier (China/Tanggula Mountain) COORDINATES: 33º10´N/96º28´E Photo taken by J. C. Pu, 2008 The Xiaodongkemadi Glacier is located at the headwaters of the Dongkemadi River, a tributary at the upper reaches of the Buqu River near the Tanggula pass. It is a continental valley glacier. The Glacier is 1.8 km2 in area, with a length of 2.8 km (Figure S11a). The elevations of the summit and terminus of the glacier are 5,926 and 5,380 m, respectively. A total of 25 measuring stakes were set up on the glacier. The most significant phenomena of the Xiaodongkemadi Glacier is negative net balance in 2009/10 (-1,066 mm), which is higher than that in 2007/08 (-80 mm) and 2008/09 (-91mm) by one order 7. Naimona’nyi Glacier (China/West Himalayas) COORDINATES: 30º27´N/81º20´E Photo taken by T. Yao, 2006 Naimona’nyi Glacier is located in the northern slope of West Himalayas. It is a valley glacier flowing from 7,520 to 5,465 m, with an area of 7.8 km2 and a length of 7.7 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the North. The mass balance investigations on Naimona’nyi glacier began in the year of 2004/2006, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the beginning of October). A network of at present 30 measuring stakes has been set on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show strong mass losses between 2004/06 and 2009/10 (the year 2006/07 is absent), with an average of -556 mm w.e. The year 2007/08 is the most negative mass balance (-718 mm w.e.) year in the monitoring period. The ELAs in that period have shifted from 6,146 m to 6,478 m. 8. Muztag Ata Glacier (China/ Muztag Ata Mts.) COORDINATES: 38º14´N, 75º03´E Photo taken by L. Zhu, 2010 The Muztag Ata Glacier is located in West Kunlun Mountain. This glacier has an area of 0.96 km2, with a length of 1.8 km (Figure S10a). Its altitudinal range is between 5,235 and 5,940 m. A total of 13 measuring stakes have been spatially distributed on this glacier. Due to lack of measurement in 2009, we take the average between 2008/09 and 2009/10 for 2008/09 and 2009/10, respectively. The spatial distributions of net balance are positive almost on the whole glacier during the period, except in 2002/03 9. Gurenhekou Glacier(China/ Nyainqentanglha Mts.) COORDINATES: 30°11′N/90°28′E Photo taken by W. Yu, 2007 Gurenhekou Glacier lies on the southern slope of West Nyainqentanglha Mountain Range, near the town of Yangbajin, flowing towards southeast. The glacier spans an elevation range from 6040 and 5525 m a.s.l. It is a valley sub-continental, with an area of 1.4 km2 and a length of 2.9 km. The mass balance investigations on Gurenhekou glacier began in the year of 2004/2005, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 12 measuring stakes have been distributed on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show mass losses between 2004/05 and 2010/11, with an average of -328 mm w.e. 2008/09 is the most negative mass balance year we have measured (-839 mm w.e.). The ELAs in the past seven years have shifted from 5,680m to 5,850m. 10. Zhongxi Glacier(China/ Nyainqentanglha Mts.) COORDINATES: 30°52′N/91°27′E Photo taken by W. Yu, 2009 Zhongxi Glacier lies on the northern slope of East Nyainqentanglha Mountain Range, Tibetan Plateau, near Nam Co Lake. It is a valley sub-continental glacier, with an area of 1.6 km2 and a length of 2.6 km. The glacier faces north. The elevations of the glacier head and terminus are 6210 and 5376 m a.s.l, respectively. The mass balance of Zhongxi glacier was measured in 2007-2011, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 15 measuring stakes have been distributed on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show mass losses between 2007/08 and 2010/11, with an average of -426 mm w.e. 2008/09 is the most negative mass balance year we have measured (-1045 mm w.e.). The ELAs in the past four years have shifted from 5,618m to 5,934m. 11. Kangwure Glacier(China/ Middle Himalayas) COORDINATES: 28°28′N /85°49′E Photo taken by W. Yu, 2009 Kangwure Glacier lies on the Middle Himalayas Range, near the Xixiabangma Mountain. It is a flat-top sub-continental glacier flowing towards northeast, with an area of 1.9 km2 and a length of 3.1 km. The glacier spans an elevation range from 6060 and 5690 m a.s.l. The mass balance of Kangwure glacier was started to observe in 2009, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 16 measuring stakes have been distributed on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show mass losses between 2009/10 and 2010/11, with an average of -162 mm w.e. 2009/10 is the most negative mass balance year we have measured (-300 mm w.e.). The ELAs in the past two years have shifted from 5,861m to 5,971m. 12. Xiagangjiang Glacier(China/ western TP) COORDINATES: 31°33'N/85°08'E Photo taken by W. Yu, 2011 Xiagangjiang Glacier lies on the western Tibetan Plateau. It is a valley sub-continental glacier flowing from 6,200 to 5,786 m, with an area of 0.6 km2 and a length of 1.1 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the east. The mass balance investigations on Xiagangjiang glacier began in the year of 2008/2009 using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 13 measuring stakes have been distributed on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show strong mass losses between 2009/10 and 2010/11, with an average of -442 mm w.e. The ELAs in the past two years have shifted from 5,989m to 6,096m. 13. Mengdagangri Glacier(China/ southern TP) COORDINATES: 28°28'N/90°36'E Photo taken by W. Yu, 2010 Mengdagangri Glacier lies on the southern Tibetan Plateau. It is a valley sub-continental glacier flowing towards north, with an area of 2.1 km2 and a length of 2.4 km. The glacier spans an elevation range from 6,200 and 5,432 m a.s.l.. The mass balance investigations on Mengdagangri glacier began in the year of 2007/2008 using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 12 measuring stakes have been distributed on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show strong mass losses between 2007/08 and 2010/11, with an average of -352 mm w.e. 2008/09 is the most negative mass balance year we have measured (-1027 mm w.e.). The ELAs in the past four years have shifted from 5,635m to 5,941m. 14. Yala Glacier(Nepal/ Middle Himalayas) COORDINATES: 28°14'N/85°37'E Photo taken by W. Yu, 2010 Yala Glacier lies on the Middle Himalayas Range. It is a plateau-shaped temperate glacier flowing from 5,700 to 5,250 m, with an area of 1.7 km2 and a length of 1.4 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the south-west. The mass balance investigations on Yala glacier began in the year of 2010/2011, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). A total of 8 measuring stakes have been distributed on this glacier. Recent mass balance results show positive mass gain of +112 mm w.e. in 2010/11. 15. Meikuang Glacier(China/ Eastern Kunlun Mt.) COORDINATES: 35°40' N/94°11'E Meikuang Glacier lies on the eastern Kunlun mountain. It is a sub-continental glacier flowing from 5,520 to 4,810 m, with an area of 1.1 km2 and a length of 1.8 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the north. The mass balance investigations on Meikuang glacier began in the year of 1988/1989, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). The mean ELA was 5040 m a.s.l. 16. Qiangtang No.1 Glacier(China/Qiangtang Plateau) COORDINATES: 33°17' N/88°41'E Qiangtang Glacier lies on the Qiangtang Plateau. It is a continental glacier flowing from 6,050 to 5,800 m, with an area of 2.35 km2 and a length of 2.6 km. The surface is mainly exposed to the south-east. The mass balance investigations on Qiangtang glacier began in the year of 2010/2011, using the direct glaciological method in fixed period (in the end of September). 17. East Rathong Glacier(India/ Middle Himalayas) COORDINATES: 28°40'N/88°40'E This glacier experiences the strongest influence of the monsoon circulation. Snow Accumulation between June and September accounts for around 80% of annual accumulation, because it is wet in summer due to monsoon and dry in winter. But, the ablation season also occurs simultaneously, which leads to immediate melting of accumulated snow. This causes difficulty in direct observations of accumulation and ablation separately. 18. Kolahai Glacier(India/ Kashmir) COORDINATES: 34°10'N/75°20'E This Glacier is located in the western Himalaya and is characterized by the frontal activities of westerly winds in winter and by dry subtropical climate in summer. 19. Ali (China/ west Tibet Plateau) COORDINATES: 34°31'N/80°20'E 20. Yak Archa (Tajikistan/ Pamir) COORDINATES: 38°59'N/68°33'E 21. Zortash (Tajikistan/ Pamir) COORDINATES: 38°24'N/72°51'E 22. Sachen (Pakistan/ Karakorum) COORDINATES::35°19'N/76°45'E Altitude range:3640-5780m; 23. Deosai (Pakistan/ Karakorum), COORDINATES::34°55'N/75°49'E Altitude range:4680-5100m Yak Archa Muztag Ata Qiyi Zortash Sachen Deosai Meikuang Qiangtang No.1 Ali Kolaho Xiaodongkemadi Xiagangjian Naimona’nyi Zhadang Zhongxi Kangwure Parlung glaciers Mengdagangr Yala Figure East Rathong Locations of monitoring glaciers for mass balance observations on the Tibetan Plateau Table Detailed information on the glaciers for recent mass balance measurement in the TP region Glacier number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Glaciers Parlung No.10 Parlung No.12 Parlung No.94 Parlung No.390 Xiaodongkemadi Qiyi Naimona’nyi Muztagh Ata No. 15 Gurenhekou Zhongxi Kangwure Mengdagangri Xiagangjiang Yala Meikuang Qiangtang No.1 East Rathong 2.1 0.2 2.5 0.5 1.8 2.8 7.8 Maximum elevation (m a.s.l.) 5625 5265 5635 5460 5926 5088 7520 Minimum elevation (m a.s.l.) 4910 5130 5000 5160 5380 4295 5465 1 1.4 1.6 1.9 2.1 0.6 1.7 1.18 2.35 5940 6040 6210 6060 6200 6200 5700 5520 6050 5235 5525 5376 5690 5423 5786 5250 4810 5800 3925 Latitude (N) Longitude (E) Area (km2) 29°17´ 29°18´ 29°23´ 29°21´ 33°10´ 39°15´ 30°27´ 96°54´ 96°54´ 96°59´ 97°01´ 92°08´ 97°45´ 81°20´ 38°14´ 30°11´ 30°52′ 28°28′ 28°28′ 31°33' 28°14' 35°40' 33°17' 27°40' 75°03´ 90°28′ 91°27′ 85°49′ 90°36' 85°08' 85°37' 94°11' 88°41' 88°40' Length (km) Orientation Locations 3.5 0.6 2.9 1.2 2.8 3.8 7.7 NE NE NW SE S/SW N N Southeast TP/China Southeast TP/China Southeast TP/China Southeast TP/China Tanggula Mt./China Qilian Mt./China West Himalayas/China 1.8 2.9 2.6 3.1 2.4 1.1 1.4 1.9 2.6 W SE N NS N E SW N SE S West Kunlun Mt./China Nyainqentanglha Mt./China Nyainqentanglha Mt./China Middle Himalayas/China Southern TP/China Western TP/China Middle Himalayas/Nepal Eastern Kunlun Mt./China Qiangtang Plateau/China Middle Himalayas/India 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Kolahoi Ali Kizyldangi Dih Sachen Deosai Phender Rikha Samba Koxkar Muji Glacier Kangsiwa Glacier Kunjirapu Glacier Chhota Shigri Dokriani Urumqi Glacier No.1 34°10' 34°31' 38°26' 36°53' 35°19' 34°55' 35°58' 75°20' 80°20' 73°33' 74°54' 76°45' 75°49' 72°49' 41°47' 80°06' 32.20 N 30°50′ 77.50 E 78°47′ N Kashmir/India Western Tibetan Plateau/China Pamir/Tajikistan Karakorum/Pakistan Karakorum/Pakistan 5780 5100 3640 4680 83.56 6040 3060 30.6 S 15.7 0.568 6263 5220 4050 4952 9 1.7 N E/SE Karakorum/Pakistan Karakorum/Pakistan Himalaya/Nepal Southern Tianshan/China Pamir/China West Kunlun/China Karakorum/China Western Himalaya Himalayas 3. Proposed sites for Glacial Mass Balance Flagship Stations in the Third Pole region The participants discussed issues relating to glacier mass balance flagship stations and proposed the sites. 1. Criteria for Flagship Station Two groups of criteria are proposed: Group one: climatic information and mass balance 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) Geographically representative, atmospheric circulation systems Small to medium size glacier, between 2 and 10 km2 Clean, debris free and no crevasses Easily accessible Single branch Ice caps should be considered Group 2: Water resources from ice 1) Debris covered glacier 2) Large glacier 2. What to measure Beside the Mass balance by traditional method including annual mean mass balance, specific mass balance with altitude, accumulation area and ratio for subsequent years, ELA, stake position map, the following measurements are recommended: 1) Ice volume by new technologies such as satellite data 2) Ice surface profile by GPS and Radar 3) Ice thickness 4) Glacial melting discharge 5) DEM Radar measurement 6) Meteorological data 7) Ice temperature 8) Ice velocity 3. How many sites to be measured 29 sites are proposed for glacier mass balance flagship stations (see the table for details). 4. Principles of implementation 1) Regular measurement at least annual 2) Inexpensive, cost-effective 3) To be carried out by the local institutions, with outside help 4) Sharing of instruments such as GPR, drill system for measuring stakes 5. Funding Yala is funded to 2017, Rikha Samba is funded to 2015; Kizyldangi in Tajikistan is funded to 2017; Kolahoi is funded to 2014; Muztagh Ata and Gilgit will be continue to 2030; Urumqi Glacier No.1 will be continued to around 2100. All other sites in China are funded at least to 2017. Two other sites in India and two candidate sites in Bhutan are looking for funding. 3. TPE community academic knowledge sharing The participants discussed about TPE community academic knowledge sharing and proposed the following: 1) TPE mass balance data combined with other data 2) Respect the data owner and share the data after two or more years of the data acquisition 3) Data provided with the publication of papers 4) Data published should be cited on the principle of the original data provider 5) Mass balance data from china will be shared after publication 6) ICIMOD HKH cryosphere knowledge hub 7) Indian scientist will check the national data sharing policy 8) Data users properly cite the data which are published or co-author a paper. 9) With respect to Pakistan mass balance data combined with other data will be forwarded to concerned authority in Pakistan for its international publication 10) Further discussion can be made at the forthcoming conference and workshop on cryosphere knowledge HKH region during 14-18 May
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz