Chapter 15 - University of North Florida

Introduction
¾ What is extrusion of metals?
Chapter 15
Extrusion and Drawing of Metals
Alexandra Schönning, Ph.D.
Mechanical Engineering
University of North Florida
ƒ Forcing of a billet through a die
ƒ Can create solid and hollow
cross sections
ƒ A semi-continuous process
(each billet is extruded
individually).
• Discrete products by cutting
into desired lengths
○ Gears, brackets, coat hangers
ƒ Carried out at room temperature
or at elevated temperature.
ƒ Often combined with forging
process
¾ What is drawing of metals?
ƒ Changing or reduction of the
cross section of a rod, wire, or
tube by pulling it through a die
¾ What products are made
using drawing?
ƒ Rivets, bolts, screws
ƒ Round and non-round profiles
ƒ What is the difference between
extrusion and drawing?
• Push or draw…
• Fasteners, parts for bicycles,
cars, …
¾ What is made using
extrusion?
Figures by
Manufacturing Engineering and Technology
Kalpakijan and Schmid
ƒ Railings for slidng doors, tubing
¾ What material is generally
extruded?
ƒ Aluminum, copper, steel,
magnesium, lead, plastics
direct extrusion process
Page 15-1
Example of products made using extrusion
Page 15-2
The extrusion process
¾ Names of the process
ƒ Extrusion
ƒ Direct extrusion
ƒ Forward extrusion
¾ Other types of extrusion
processes
ƒ Indirect extrusion
• The die moves toward the billet
¾ What are the process steps?
ƒ Round billet is placed in a
chamber
ƒ The billet is forced through the
die using a hydraulically driven
ram or a pressing stem
ƒ Die opening may have round or
non-round cross section
ƒ Hydrostatic extrusion
• The billet is smaller in diameter
than the chamber.
• The billet is surrounded by a
fluid
• The pressure is supplied by a
ram
• Friction is low
ƒ Impact extrusion
Figure 15.2 Extrusions, and examples of
products made by sectioning off
extrusions. Source: Kaiser Aluminum.
Page 15-3
Extrusion Variables
¾ Geometric Variables
ƒ Die angel, α
ƒ Extrusion Ratio: R
Extrusion Force
¾ Circumscribing circle
diameter (CCD)
¾ The extrusion force
required depends on
• Ao/Af: Ratio of the cross
sectional area of the billet to the
A of the extruded part
¾ Temperature
¾ Speed of ram
¾ Lubricant type
Page 15-4
ƒ Diameter of the smallest circle
that the cross section can fit
within.
¾ Shape factor
ƒ Billet material strength
ƒ Extrusion ratio
ƒ Friction billet/chamber
and billet/die
ƒ Temperature
ƒ Speed
F
Ao⋅ k⋅ ln
Ao 
 Af 
¾ k = extrusion constant
ƒ Metal and temperature
dependent
ƒ One of the variables
determining the complexity of
extrusion
ƒ Ratio of perimeter of extruded
product to the cross sectional
area.
• Circle has the smallest shape
factor
Page 15-5
Page 15-6
1
Metal Flow in Extrusion
¾ Effects the mechanical
properties of the part
¾ The metal flows
longitudinally, resulting
in an elongated grain
structure
Extrusion Practice
¾ What materials are extruded?
¾ Dead zone
¾ Straitening and twisting
ƒ Aluminum, copper, magnesium,
alloys, steels
ƒ Metal at corners is almost
stationary
¾ Extrusion ratio R = Ao/Af
ƒ 10 to 100
ƒ Lower for less ductile materials
ƒ At least R=4 to work the
material in the plastic region
¾ Length of extruded materials
ƒ May be required for small cross
sections
¾ Die angle causes a butt end
ƒ Remains in the chamber after
operation is complete
ƒ Cut off as scrap
¾ Stepped extrusion
ƒ Extruding the billet partially in
one die and then one or more
dies
ƒ < 7.5 meters typically
ƒ 30 meters max
¾ CCD (circum scribed
diameters)
ƒ 6 mm – 1m for Aluminum
¾ Ram speeds
ƒ Up to 0.5m/s
ƒ Lower for aluminum, copper
ƒ Higher for steels
Page 15-7
Page 15-8
Hot Extrusion
Die Designs and Die Materials
¾ Square dies
¾ Why hot extrusion?
ƒ For metals that don’t have sufficient
ductility at room temperature
ƒ Reduce the required extrusion force
¾ Disadvantages and problems
ƒ Die wear due to high operating
temperatures
ƒ Cooling of the billet in the chamber –
non-uniform extrusion
ƒ Created by fitting a
mandrel to the ram
ƒ Wall thickness, typically
• Creates a die angle
• Reduce effects of problem by heating the
die prior to extrusion
(a)
• > 1 mm Al
• > 3 mm carbon steel
• > 5 mm stainless steels
(c)
ƒ Oxide film develops on surface
• May be abrasive
• Affects the flow pattern of the metal
• Reduce/remove this problem by using a
dummy block in front of the ram
¾ Tubes
ƒ Used for non-ferrous
metals
ƒ Dead metal zones develop
direct extrusion process
(b)
○ Oxidized layer is left in the container
• Reduce/remove this problem by heating
the billet in an inert-atmosphere furnace
Die design: tapered
Page 15-9
Hollow Sections
¾ Welding chamber
methods using special
dies.
¾ How does this method
work?
ƒ Metal divides and flows
around the supports of the
internal mandrel.
Page 15-10
Good vs. Bad Cross Section
¾ What materials does this
work for?
ƒ Materials that reweld well
under high pressure
• Aluminum
¾ Lubricants can’t be used
ƒ Prevents rewelding
¾ Important
ƒ Symmetry of cross section
ƒ Eliminate sharp corners
ƒ Keep section thickness
uniform
ƒ Avoid extreme change in
the dimensions of the
cross section
• This results in strands
ƒ Rewelding of the strands
occur within the chamber
after the supports and
before the die
• High pressure makes this
possible
Figure 15.10 Poor and good examples of cross-sections to be extruded. Note the importance of
eliminating sharp corners and of keeping section thicknesses uniform. Source: J. G. Bralla (ed.);
Handbook of Product Design for Manufacturing. New York: McGraw-Hill Publishing Company, 1986.
Used with permission.
Page 15-11
Page 15-12
2
Die Materials and Lubrication
Cold Extrusion
¾ Often involves different manufacturing operations such
as direct and indirect extrusion and forging.
¾ Used in making
¾Die materials
ƒ Hot worked die steels
ƒ Coatings may be applied to extend life
ƒ Tools and components in cars, motorcycles, bicycles,
appliances…
¾Lubrication
ƒ Glass: a glass cylinder is placed in the die entrance of
the chamber. The billet heats the glass and the
molten glass acts as a lubricant at the die interface.
ƒ Jacketing or canning
• If the metal is likely to stick to the container walls, then the
billet can be enclosed by a thin-walled container of a softer
metal.
¾ Advantages over hot extrusion
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
Improved mechanical properties through work-hardening
Good control of dimensional tolerances
Improved surface finish
Elimination of need for billet heating
¾ Disadvantages
ƒ Stress magnitudes on the tools are high Æ wears the die
¾ Lubrication
ƒ Applied to the workpiece
Page 15-13
Page 15-14
Examples of Cold Extrusion
Impact Extrusion
¾ Typically considered a
cold extrusion process
¾ Components
ƒ Die
ƒ Blank (or slug)
ƒ Punch
¾ Punch forces the blank to
extrude backward
Page 15-15
Page 15-16
Hydrostatic Extrusion
Extrusion Defects
¾ Incompressible fluid surrounds the billet
¾ Surface cracking
ƒ At high temperatures:
ƒ Vegetable oils are used
• Resulting from too high
temperature, friction, speed
• Surface starts to crack and then
tear
¾ Billet is a little smaller than the container
¾ Usually at room temperature
¾ Advantage
ƒ At lower temperatures
ƒ No container wall friction
ƒ Brittle materials can be extruded using this method since the
ductility increases with the hydrostatic pressure
ƒ Small die angles and high extrusion ratios can be used
¾ Disadvantage
ƒ Tooling is complex
ƒ Results in minimal industrial applications
Page 15-17
• Bamboo defect
○ The billet may temporarily
stick, the pressure increases and
the billet moves forward.
¾ Pipe effect
¾ Internal Cracking
ƒ Due to tensile stresses at the
center line in the deformation
zone
ƒ Tendency of center cracking
• Increases with increased die
angle
• Increases with increased
amount of impurities
• Decreases with increasing
extrusion ratio and friction
ƒ Surface oxides and impurities
are drawn to the center of the
billet (like a funnel)
ƒ Minimize by making the flow
pattern more uniform (reduce
friction and temperature
gradients)
Page 15-18
3
The Drawing Process
Extrusion Equipment
¾Most common are horizontal hydraulic presses
¾ What is it?
ƒ Speed of the operation can be controlled
ƒ The cross-section of a round
wire/rod is reduced in size or
changed in shape by pulling it
through a die.
¾Cold extrusion
ƒ Typically vertical hydraulic presses
ƒ More economical as they require less floor space
¾ Variables
ƒ Amount of reduction in crosssectional area
ƒ Die angle
• Optimum angle for minimum
drawing force can be computed.
• Other product quality dimensions
may require a different angle.
¾ Drawing force (F)
Ao 
F Yavg⋅ Af ⋅ ln
 Af 
ƒ Yavg: average stress of material
drawn
ƒ Af: exit cross-sectional area
ƒ Ao: initial cross-sectional area
¾ Max reduction in cross-sectional
area: 63%
ƒ Friction along die/workpiece
ƒ Drawing speed
Figure 15.17 General view of a 9-MN
(1000-ton) hydraulic-extrusion press.
Source: Courtesy of Jones & Laughlin
Steel Corporation.
Page 15-19
Page 15-20
Drawing Process / Practice
¾ Drawing of other shapes
ƒ Initial cross section is typically
round or square
ƒ Mandrels can be used for
internal cavities
ƒ Ironing can be used to obtain
flat sheets (a wedge shaped die
is used)
Die Design
¾ Drawing speed
ƒ Material dependent
ƒ 1 m/s to 50 m/s (fine wire)
¾ Typically reductions in area
are kept below 45%
¾ Sizing operations
ƒ Small reduction in area
ƒ Used primarily to improve
surface finish and dimensional
accuracy
¾ Annealing may be necessary
between passes to maintain
sufficient ductility in the
material
¾ Bundle drawing
ƒ Numerous wires can be drawn
at the same time.
ƒ Can result in wires as fine as
4µm.
¾ Die angles usually range
from 6o to 15o
¾ Typically have two
angles: approach and
relieve angle
¾ Basic design has been
developed through trial
and error
¾ The land gives the final
dimension of the product
¾ Die materials
ƒ Tool steels
ƒ Diamonds
• Used for fine wire
• Used as inserts
Page 15-21
Page 15-22
Lubrication
Defects and Residual Stresses
¾Wet drawing
¾ Defects
ƒ Similar to those of
extrusion
ƒ Dies and the rods are completely immersed in the
lubricant
• Common is center cracking
¾Dry drawing
ƒ Seams are common
ƒ The surface of the rod is coated with the lubricant
(soap)
• Longitudinal scratches or
folds in the material
¾Coating
¾ Residual Stresses
ƒ Common in cold drawn
products
ƒ Sometimes to an
advantage; sometimes to a
disadvantage
ƒ Warping may occur if
material is removed
ƒ Rod or wire is coated with a soft metal acting as
lubricant
¾Ultrasonic vibration of the dies and mandrel
ƒ Reduce forces, improve surface finish, and improve
die life
Page 15-23
Page 15-24
4
Drawing Equipment
Roll Straightening
¾ Draw bench
ƒ A single die
ƒ Used for diameters
> 20 mm
ƒ Lengths < 30 m
Figure 15.22 Schematic illustration of roll straightening of a drawn round rod (see also Fig. 13.7).
¾ Bull block
ƒ Usually multiple dies are
used
ƒ Lengths = several
kilometers
Page 15-25
Page 15-26
5