Sylvia’s pizzas are hand crafted in the traditional Neapolitan
method. Our dough is prepared using “00” flour, salt, yeast
and water. Once made, it then rests for at least two hours,
which allows it to mellow into the perfect texture and flavor.
We have selected only the finest ingredients for our pizzas: we
start with making our own mozzarella, procuring fresh produce
from our local farmers and obtaining only the highest quality
meats.
Our Wood-fired oven is the only of its kind in the Greater
Lafayette area. It is fired with cured hardwood which enhances
the flavor of anything that is cooked in it. Our pizzas are
cooked at approximately 650 degrees and finished off in the
dome of the oven, which reaches temperatures of up 1,000
degrees. This process produces an infusion of all the flavors that
you have selected for your pizza and finishes with a delicate
smoky taste, a truly unique experience.
Starter
Meatballs $7
Garlic Knots $3/$5
s
Tossed with Fresh Garlic Oil and
Our Marinara Sauce and
Fresh Herbs. Italian Cheese Sauce $2
Our Marinara $1
Parmesan Cheese and Herbs
Antipasto Plate $13
Spicy Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni,
Artichokes, Olives, Roasted
Mushrooms and Peppers with Our
Fresh Mozzarella
Bruschetta $12
Crusty Italian Bread, with Tomato
Relish and Fresh Basil & Olive
Tapenade with Our Fresh Mozzarella
Calamari Fritti $12
Golden Brown with Our Marinara
Soup & Salads
Winter Caprese $12
Italian Chop $13
Fresh Roasted Red and Golden
Beets, layered between Our Fresh
House Made Mozzarella and
Garnished with Pickled Onions
Mixed Greens, Capicola, Salami,
Pepperoni, Artichokes, Red Onions, Bell
Peppers, Banana Peppers, Tomatoes,
Olives, Cucumbers and Our Fresh
Mozzarella
Roasted Vegetable
Side Salad $5
Fresh Roasted Vegetables with Field
Greens, Toasted Walnuts and Feta
Cheese with Cran-Apple Vinaigrette
Mixed Greens with Red Onions,
Tomatoes, Cucumbers and
Croutons
Soup Del Giorno, Cup $4 Bowl $6
All of Our Soups are made in House.
Your Server Will Tell You About
Tonight’s Selection
We take great pride in making ALL of our dressings in house.
Strawberry Balsamic · Gorgonzola · Italian
Caesar · Ranch · Balsamic Vinaigrette · Cran-Apple Vinaigrette
Vegan friendly or can be made vegan.
Signature Pizzas $14
12” pizza’s topped with hand squeezed tomatoes (unless noted by *)
and our fresh mozzarella
Fungi *
Bianco Formaggio *
Wood Roasted Shiitake, Crimini, and
Oyster Mushrooms, with
Basil Pesto and Tomatoes
Ricotta, Provolone, Parmesan, White
Cheddar, and Our Fresh Mozzarella
Carni
The Veggie *
House Made Italian Sausage, Spicy
Capicola, Genoa Salami, Peppadew
Peppers and Basil
Roasted Red Pepper Sauce, with Green
Peppers, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Tomatoes,
Black Olives and Shaved Onions
Meatball
House Made Sausage
Fennel Sausage, Peppadew Peppers
and Shaved Onions
Our House Made Meatballs,
Pepperoni and Four Cheese Blend
Jimmy’s Favorite *
Pepperoni
Basil Pesto, Roasted Garlic and
Caramelized Onions
Our Classic Jumbo, Old World Style
and Giantonio Pepperoni
Specialty Pizzas $15
All of our pizzas are 12” and topped with our fresh mozzarella
Sorry, No Substitutions to our Specialty Pizzas
Pulled Pork
Hot or Not
Smoked Pork, and Hickory BBQ
Sauce with Garlic Ricotta and
Caramelized Onions
Roasted Red Pepper Sauce, Pepperoni,
Capicola, Jalapeno Peppers, Banana
Peppers and Our Fresh Mozzarella Cheese
Bacon Formaggio
Chicken Florentina
Garlic Ricotta Sauce, Wood Roasted
Mushrooms, Spinach and Bacon with
Provolone, White Cheddar, and Our
Fresh Mozzarella
Roasted Chicken, House Made Italian
Sausage, Fresh Spinach, Peppadew
Peppers, Caramelized Onions,
Tomatoes and Roasted Mushrooms
with a Garlic Ricotta Sauce
Harvest
The Greek
A Mixture of Fresh Roasted Vegetables
with Squash, Eggplant and Fennel
Sausage with dollops of Ricotta
Olive Tapenade, Capicola, Salami,
Artichokes, with Feta Cheese and
Pistachio Nuts
Pizza Del Giorno
Your Server Will Tell You About Tonight’s Selection
**Any of our pizzas can be made “gluten-free” however, we are not a gluten free kitchen.
Cross-contamination could occur and our restaurant is unable to guarantee that any item
can be completely free of allergens. Please consult with your health care practitioner before
consuming any food or drink.
Vegan/Vegetarian friendly or can be made that way.
Build Your Own Pizza $12
12” pizza’s topped with hand squeezed tomatoes and our fresh mozzarella.
Each additional topping $2
Anchovies, Artichokes, Banana Peppers, Basil Pesto, Bleu Cheese, Brussel
Sprouts, Caramelized Onions, Chicken, Extra Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, Genoa
Salami, Gorgonzola, House Made Sausage, Jalapenos, Olives, Pepperoni,
Shaved Red Onions, Roasted Garlic, Roasted Peppers, Spicy Capicola,
Spinach, Hand Squeezed Tomatoes, Wood Roasted Mushrooms
Wood Roasted Calzones $10
Served with Marinara Sauce. Add Side Salad or Soup $2
Stromboli
Roasted Veggie
Tomatoes, Broccoli, Artichokes, Wood
Roasted Mushrooms, Shaved Brussel
Sprouts, Peppers with Fresh Basil Pesto
and Our Fresh Mozzarella
Our House Made Italian Sausage,
Pepperoni, Red Pepper Sauce,
Peppadew Peppers, Red Onions, and
Our Fresh Mozzarella
God Father
Pulled Pork, Geno Salami, Capicola, Pepperoni, Hand Squeezed
Tomatoes, Red Onions, Peppadew Peppers and Our Fresh Mozzarella
Pasta
Served with a Garlic Knot
Spaghetti and Meatballs $13
Our House Made Meatballs and Marinara with Spaghetti
Sylvia’s Fettuccini $14
Breast of Chicken, Red Onions, Tomatoes, Artichokes
and Peas in a Parmesan Cream Sauce
Build Your Own Pasta $14
Choose One Pasta, One Sauce and One Meat
Penne ∙ Spaghetti ∙ Fettuccini
Our Classic Marinara ∙ Fresh Basil Pesto ∙ Creamy Alfredo · Carbonara
Italian Rope Sausage ∙ Breast of Chicken ∙ Smoked Bacon · Shrimp (add $2)
Choose up to Three Ingredients*
Artichokes ∙ Fresh Basil ∙ Banana Peppers · Broccoli ∙ Brussel Sprouts ·Garlic ∙
Olives ∙ Peas · Peppadew Peppers · Red Onions ∙ Roasted Peppers ∙ Spinach ∙ Hand
Squeezed Tomatoes ∙ Wood Roasted Mushrooms
*additional ingredients $1 each
Pasta Del Giorno
Your Server Will Tell You About Tonight’s Selection
Vegan/Vegetarian friendly or can be made that way.