The quest for perfection Optimising logistics with FTA Consultancy Services 2 Introduction Finding the answers with FTA Supply chain optimisation Solutions, guidance and advice from FTA Consultancy Services Mention the word ‘consultancy’ to most transport managers and they will fear a big bill heading their way. But quality advice from knowledgeable and professional experts needn’t cost the earth. When the consultant is from the Freight Transport Association you can be confident they are on your wavelength and will understand the pressures and the demands you are working under. Their job is to deliver reliable, compliant answers to your questions that fit with the real world of transport operations. Questions like, “How do we improve our fleet efficiency?” “Is our operation meeting required standards?” “How are we doing compared to other businesses in the sector?” “What can FTA suggest I do to avoid a recurrence of an incident?” FTA Consultancy Services helps members find the answers to these and other questions. We engage experienced and qualified experts who understand the special relationship between a trade association and its members. We will listen to you, understand what you are looking for and work with the business. Then we provide advice, guidance or solutions that are grounded in the real world of transport operations and practicalities of the industry. The following are the areas we are asked to work on most often. We provide advice, guidance or solutions that are grounded in the real world of transport operations and practicalities of the industry We have undertaken re-configuration exercises and vehicle/warehouse optimisation studies for SMEs seeking to answer questions like: “Are our trucks and storage in the best places in relation to our production lines and customers?” “Can I save money by changing the movements of inbound and outbound goods in my warehouse?” “What’s the best location for our new depot?” Benchmarking FTA operates cost and other performance benchmarks across a number of activities that help participants improve on their present performance and see how they measure against peer group standards, while at all times protecting their confidentiality and the anonymity of data. Engineering investigations Tapping into the wealth of knowledge and experience built over 50 years of delivering vehicle Introduction inspections for members, we specialise in deep investigations into vehicle engineering issues: “What was the cause of that collision?” “Why are the same faults recurring on my vehicles?” “Have I got my repair and maintenance arrangements right?” Health and safety The ever-present worry for every depot manager: “Am I am doing what’s expected of me for the health and safety of my staff, of contractors and other visitors to the site?” “What standards are in place at the other depots in the group?” Routeing and scheduling Still the best way of taking cost out of a distribution operation – make the required number of deliveries in the shortest time with the fewest vehicles. Using software and expertise normally only affordable by larger businesses, FTA provides a rapid turnaround and supporting guidance for even the smallest of fleets: “How do we work around all the delivery restrictions?” “Can we re-time deliveries to avoid the parking fines?” “What are the best routes to use given the size and weight of my vehicles?” Our aim is to find answers to your most pressing problems and provide them in a format that is easily understood and communicated throughout the business. Our consultants are happy to present to colleagues or board members and facilitate discussion about the findings, if that’s helpful. Read the examples and case studies in this document and see how other FTA members, large and small, have benefitted from the knowledge and the service that FTA’s consultancy can provide. To discuss the questions your business needs answering, call Karen Packham on 01892 552319. Every operation has questions... FTA has the answers. Inside... CASE STUDIES: Stena Line ................................................................................................................................................. 4 Imperial Commercials ..................................................................................................................... 5 ARI .................................................................................................................................................................... 6 Hovis .............................................................................................................................................................. 7 XL Joinery .................................................................................................................................................. 8 Connect Group ....................................................................................................................................... 9 Smiths Metal Centres ................................................................................................................... 10 A&R Vehicle Services ................................................................................................................... 11 INTERVIEW: Karen Packham ................................................................................................. 12 A-Z OF FTA CONSULTANCY SERVICES ............................................................................ 14 FURTHER INFORMATION ............................................................................................................ 16 3 4 Health and safety Stena Line is a major operator of freight and passenger vessels with UK port and terminal facilities in several locations, including Holyhead, Fishguard and Loch Ryan. It operates 22 routes in Northern Europe. Stena Line must organise its ports and operations in such a way that they are both efficient and very safe – a complex yet essential matrix which has to combine centralised policies with the needs and challenges of specific sites. For more than 10 years, it has commissioned FTA to audit each of the Stena sites, and to identify problem areas and potential solutions in line with HSE guidance on safety for vehicles, sites and drivers. The FTA audits collate large amounts of data, drawn from disparate sources, including customer, passenger and freight data, maps, plans, footage, interviews and observation. However, ports safety and environmental superintendent Kevin Riley says this is not what makes the FTA service so powerful. “Once FA has completed its report, it hosts a workshop for all the managers and staff Key benefits ● FTA audits are based on HSE standards and recommendations ● The consultant’s recommendations are clear, practical and deliverable. Workshops turn the reports into working practice with staff buy-in ● Dedicated and knowledgeable staff who understand road transport legislation in theory and practice responsible for procurement, maintenance and operations,” says Riley. “This is something no other consultant has ever offered. “It gives us a chance to discuss whether the alleged problems are real, argue about interpretation, brainstorm solutions and ultimately come up with an action plan which identifies how we will move forward, when and who is responsible.” Riley says this workshopping element turns the consultation report from a paper exercise into a living document destined to create change. The audits are repeated whenever operations move site, or an incident prompts investigation. “We invite FTA in to work alongside us, or in addition to us, because not only are they well versed in legal requirements but they offer us a new perspective, and potentially new answers,” he says. The workshops transform the report into working practice and allow us to allocate responsibility for the solutions. A report alone is no good unless it prompts action Kevin Riley, ports safety and environmental superintendent, Stena Line Health and safety I wanted someone who would tell me the things I didn’t know, watch for the things I couldn’t see, the things which could cause us problems. FTA just said: Yes. We can do that Derek Rooney, group HSE and compliance manager, Imperial Commercials Commercial vehicle sales and repair specialist Imperial Commercials tasked FTA with a thorough health and safety review of 36 of its sites. The 24/7 business features busy workshops and salesrooms, with commercial vehicles being brought in by customers and moved by staff, so needs to pay particular attention to the segregation of vehicles and pedestrians. Group HSE and compliance manager Derek Rooney had already commissioned one report which proved too superficial. Now he had very specific requirements for the investigation, ones which other major consultancy players wouldn’t meet. “I didn’t just want an audit of procedures, I wanted knowledgeable people to observe us for hours, to observe all those things managers don’t see,” says Rooney. “FTA agreed straight away and spent several hours at each site, observing colleagues, contractors and customers going about their business. They took photos, talked to staff and most importantly watched, to get a real sense of what happens in practice,” he says. The resultant report, which was completed in March 2015, made 1,521 recommendations across 36 sites, many of them along common themes: segregation of people and vehicles, controlling vehicle movements and site rules. The consultants prioritised their recommendations, and the vast majority have now been implemented. Having seen the terrible aftermath of a workplace incident, Rooney believes the £26,000 the consultancy cost was a small investment compared to the value of the people it will help protect. “I can’t express to you how I feel about health and safety anymore,” he says. “The value of this is that we are complying with the relevant legislation, our site rules are clear, and staff, visitors and contractors are more protected.” Key benefits ● FTA worked in the way we wanted ● The report was the most comprehensive offered ● The report was unflinching, impartial and professional 5 6 Benchmarking ARI is the largest privately owned fleet management company in the world. It handles HGVs, vans and ‘workhorse’ cars. When Matt Cranny joined the UK arm of the company as operations director in summer 2015, ARI had completed a major modernisation of its systems and processes. As a result, it seemed a good time to invite an external audit of its vehicle management against benchmarked industry standards. “We do not just check that the vehicle is fit for purpose but also the driver, in terms of licence qualification,” says Cranny. “We support the FTA Van Excellence scheme as an accredited partner, so we wanted to ensure that we met the high standards we espoused.” ARI commissioned a bespoke audit of its culture, people and systems. “It was an interesting process because the consultant did much of the expected assurance work but also challenged us to do more and to help our customers to maintain The consultant brought real-world insight, experience and a real depth of knowledge from both the customer and the supply side of our business Matt Cranny, operations director, ARI higher standards,” says Cranny. “So the auditing process was not just useful to our organisation internally but also gave us ways of adding value commercially.” The audit took two days and he says it was an exacting process. “The consultant had a genuine and very practical understanding of the industry. It was very different to dealing with a generic consultant or standard. He brought a real depth of knowledge from the customer and the supply side of the business,” says Cranny. ARI now intends to undergo an annual FTA audit. “The law gives you principles to follow but it is valuable to have external scrutiny to examine how Key benefits ● External challenge and validation has both commercial and compliance benefits. It was cost-effective given the importance of compliance ● Consultant rich in real-world, practical knowledge you interpret and comply with those. There is a huge authenticity and validation in the process FTA took us through that helps us ensure our own quality and protect our reputation.” Benchmarking Food manufacturer Hovis has a complex UK supply chain with each of its products coming from a dedicated factory into hub-and-spoke distribution centres for delivery to regional stores. Its 450 vehicles cover 30 million miles a year. With logistics such a large part of its activity, in 2011 it asked FTA to collaborate on a complete overhaul and benchmarking exercise for all of its logistics processes, including recruitment, operations and management of drivers and vehicles. “We wanted to create an audit that would be completely bespoke and very comprehensive, covering all our procedures, vehicle and employment compliance,” says Tony Stuart, Hovis head of logistics operations support. “We worked with FTA for several months to create a living document that is so in-depth it captures not just Key benefits ● FTA’s objectivity complemented Hovis’ in-house assessment ● The process was very thorough ●T he audits emphasise process, the reasons behind the process and the required action what people do, but how they do it and asks them to evidence it.” The audit takes three days to implement. Each month Hovis conducts a health check on each of its eight sites and the full audit is deployed annually. Most audits are conducted by Hovis staff but FTA always audits the in-house auditor’s site and one other to ensure consistency. Each site then has an action plan. “I’m confident we are now in the top 5% of all vehicle operators for compliance and safety,” says Stuart. “That’s down to the thorough work we did with FTA. Vehicle compliance is now ingrained and we are very good at identifying why procedures are used and the implications of ignoring them. “It was very important that we had an independent recognised body work with us. You need someone outside your sphere of operation to ensure clear, impartial sight,” says Stuart. “Many of the benefits are hard to quantify but it’s about culture and process. Our health checks, audits and the FTA monitors maintain the integrity of our culture.” Thanks to the work we did with FTA, vehicle compliance is now completely ingrained and our audits maintain the integrity of our management culture Tony Stuart, head of logistics operations support, Hovis 7 8 Routeing and scheduling FTA is easy to work with. They understand our business and they are impartial – they have no agenda about how they wish you to work Roy Parker, director of operations, XL Joinery West Yorkshire-based XL Joinery imports residential timber doors which it distributes to builders’ merchants, door specialists and DIY outlets. XL runs its own seven-strong fleet to handle most of its freight, only outsourcing deliveries to outlying areas. Increasingly, however, customers do not only want deliveries to store; they want XL to deliver direct to customers’ homes. Director of operations Roy Parker asked FTA to review the company’s policy of outsourcing home delivery to third parties. “We wanted a modelling project to see if it was feasible for us to undertake home delivery ourselves, looking at how many vehicles and drivers we would need and the costs involved,” Key benefits FTA’s analysis was: ● Quick, expedient, impartial, good value for money ● It allowed XL to test commercially and financially crucial decisions he says. “Previously we had assumed it was not, but market demands change so we wanted an impartial exercise to test our assumptions.” Parker provided FTA with 12 months’ history from which they produced sample modelling for two scenarios: XL doing all home delivery within its local region, and a UK-wide service. FTA proved that it would cost XL significantly more to undertake the work themselves compared to using third parties. “It confirmed our thinking and that it was still the right decision in the current marketplace,” says Parker. “It allowed us to quantify why we should continue to outsource home delivery. It was an important exercise because delivery is a small part of our sales value but an integral part of our service to customers.” He says FTA understood their business and charged less than many consultancies. “It was definitely good value for money,” he says. “Previously FTA has analysed our logistics operation in full to ensure that the two-thirds inhouse, one-third outsourced split was optimal. We would use FTA again to ensure that our logistics is operationally and financially optimal.” Supply chain Connect Group is a market leader in the specialist distribution of newspapers, magazines, books, and the supply of consumables to schools, nurseries, and care homes. Its turnover is £1.9bn. In 2014 Connect explored buying Tuffnells Parcels Express but first needed to ensure that the parcel company’s operations met with its own high standards for health and safety. Connect’s group head of health and safety Alex Hodson was charged with assessing Tuffnells’ risk management and ensuring that Connect understood the scope and cost of any work that might be needed at the 36 parcel depots before the bid could be finalised. “The issue was one of scale and time,” says Hodson. “We had a limited window as an exclusive suitor. In order to have an accurate assessment of the business completed within the time available, we needed additional support from workplace- FTA was uniquely qualified, experienced and resourced for this work. No one else in the market offers such professionalism of service or could respond with such speed and flexibility transport safety experts. When I suggested we partner with FTA there was instant agreement. We needed the report and findings to be beyond dispute and FTA’s expertise and brand was well known,” adds Hodson. Alex Hodson, group head of health and safety , Connect Group Connect completed the sale, for £113m, and has since been acting on FTA recommendations. Connect says FTA will periodically reassess the sites’ risk management standards. FTA conducted a paper-based analysis as well as site visits to many Tuffnells depots, assessing Tuffnells’ working practices against Connect’s standards. The consultants needed to maintain confidentiality while conducting their analysis because the prospective sale was not general knowledge among the Tuffnells’ workforce. FTA produced detailed reports with prioritised recommendations and cost estimates for the potential work. Key benefits ● FTA offered fast, flexible resource and an indisputable expertise and quality ● The reports facilitated the sale and shaped post-acquisition work ● The exercise had clear commercial value 9 10 Compliance Smiths Metal Centres is a leading stockholder of engineering metals and plastics, which it supplies to a range of industries including aviation, automotive and medical manufacturers as well as utilities. As a company with more than 250 employees and a turnover exceeding E50m, Smiths Metal was obliged to comply with the Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme (ESOS) in the autumn of 2015. “The ESOS was not widely publicised and few people knew more than the limited information on the government site,” says Smiths’ transport manager John Milicevic. “I attended an FTA workshop and later spoke to Karen Packham [FTA general manager, consultancy] who was very knowledgeable.” Smiths Metal uses FTA for all of its compliance and signage needs, and its regular vehicle inspections, so Milicevic was pleased to be able to entrust the Key benefits We use FTA services as part of our policies and procedures because of their integrity. They would not sign off on anything which was not compliant and best practice John Milicevic, transport manager, Smiths Metal Centres ● FTA was knowledgeable and handled everything for us ● Cost-effective compared to other consultancies ESOS audit to FTA as well. “FTA handled all the vehicle and transport auditing itself and managed the consultants who did the buildings audits,” says Milicevic. Smiths Metal runs 57 cars and 57 commercial vehicles across its 12 branches. “We have very robust systems for our transport and our energy usage, but FTA ensured they took screen prints and data to submit a thorough, evidenced report. “FTA made some useful recommendations, such as that we train our company car drivers in fuelefficiency, something which is already covered for our vocational drivers under their CPC training,” he says. FTA completed the audit and submitted it electronically on behalf of Milicevic who has since received his compliance assurance from the Environment Agency. Engineering investigation Black Country-based CV repair and maintenance centre A&R Vehicle Services uses FTA’s engineering investigation team to assess vehicles and trailers for major clients. It looks after fleet vehicles for major third-party logistics companies, often working for blue-chip accounts of their own. One of A&R’s contracts involves maintaining specialist trailers which carry abnormally wide and long loads for the aviation industry. A&R operations director Colin Bannister has repeatedly tasked FTA with assessing the condition, lifespan and refurbishment potential of such kit. “Trailers like these represent substantial investment for our clients and are very specific in purpose,” says Bannister. “It is important to get each one checked by an engineering consultant to see how much more life they have in them, and when the decision should be taken to replace them. We use Freight Transport Association because they have such strong recognition that Key benefits ● Detailed and comprehensive appraisal of each vehicle or trailer ● The appraisals allow optimal planning and best whole life costs for each asset our clients need no encouragement. They know they will get good value.” FTA looks at all aspects of the equipment including its roadworthiness, repair costs, potential refurbishment costs, residual value and a strategy for end-of-life and replacement. “The reports are very comprehensive, very detailed appraisals,” says Bannister. “I have been told they are the best in the industry and I can believe that. We are members of FTA for our own purposes but it is a very useful connection for our clients as well. “FTA is a good association for us to have. Being able to call on their engineering expertise is commercially valuable,” he says. We use FTA because they have such strong recognition that our clients need no encouragement. They know they will get good value Colin Bannister, operations director, A&R Vehicle Services 11 12 Interview The science of optimal change reviewing its legality, its safety and its efficiency before buying the company is crucial,” says Packham. “Transport is often the forgotten element on which the success of the venture can depend.” Logistics consultancy is both art and science. FTA general manager of consultancy Karen Packham tells Louise Cole that it’s not just about understanding transport, but people “The only source of knowledge is experience” is a quote widely attributed to Albert Einstein but it could just as easily have fallen from the mouth of Karen Packham as she explains the power of logistics consultancy to guide the decisions of any organisation involved with moving goods or people. “FTA has over 30 consultants. We’ve all had ‘proper jobs’, spending careers in logistics, ‘doing’ before we began advising,” she says. “That ensures three things. The first is a huge breadth and depth of experience. The second is individuals with very specialised expertise which companies may only need occasionally. And, thirdly, some of our consultants have retired from running fleets or running companies – but, instead of losing their decades of experience, through FTA they remain as a resource for the entire industry.” Decades of experience Packham started her own career in international transport three decades ago, before moving to FTA where she developed expertise in legal compliance, regional haulage and CPC, before project managing the Department for Transport’s Road Haulage Modernisation Fund. This provided advice and resources to 2,300 SME operators over 18 months. Her experience has taught her that those most needing consultancy help are the middle players – those with fleets big enough to need a good level of efficiency and organisation but who do not have the resources of major firms. “These mid-sized companies need cost-effective, qualified help,” she says. “Experience is at the heart of everything we do,” says Packham. “Our clients don’t want to buy theory. They want to buy practice. They need people who really understand how things work and what that looks like from the depot floor and from the boardroom.” Many logistics companies, FTA members or not, probably don’t appreciate quite how wide the range of its consultancy expertise is. FTA is renowned for its compliance work, including vehicle inspections, training, audits or benchmarking. However, it is equally qualified in areas more commonly seen as commercial or financial, even though for any company using transport, the quality of the logistics operation will often be a deciding factor between success or failure. Mergers and acquisitions are obvious examples, where due diligence is accepted industry and legal practice. Yet if the prospective acquisition is involved in transport, or its goods will require transport, a review of its logistics is an essential part of that due diligence – and one most financial auditors will lack the skills to complete. “If transporting goods to the customer is a significant part of the overhead, or of customer service, then Experience is at the heart of everything we do. Our clients don’t want to buy theory. They want to buy practice Packham will be focusing more resources on wider supply chain issues in 2016, including routeing and scheduling, fleet integrations, outsourcing and end-to-end supply chain analysis. “We are best known as road transport experts but FTA also has expertise in air freight, rail and shipping, as well as multi-modal logistics or modal shift.” Expanding the offering Her department did a significant amount of Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme (ESOS) work in the approach to last year’s deadline and already audits compliance and safety performance through Van Excellence and Truck Excellence. Packham hopes to soon be able to offer a similar scheme to the passenger transport industry. “Over the past decade the logistics industry has made great strides in terms of efficiency and yet there are still areas of confusion and poor practice. One of the issues we frequently observe is a poor understanding of logistics by other departments. Sales teams make promises logistics can’t keep. Finance teams restrict procurement for reasons which don’t gel with operational best value. Educating the different teams about how logistics works, what it costs and how to ensure efficiency can make a huge difference to the company’s overall performance,” says Packham. “There is also a huge need for help in the UK grey fleet market. It’s very complex in legislative terms – a real can of worms. And even companies who run excellent in-house fleets often struggle with grey fleet. There are examples of shockingly bad practice in the UK,” she says. Interview There are several reasons these issues can often be addressed more effectively by consultants than fleet managers, including cost, objectivity, buy-in and external validation. “Our consultants have no vested interest or involvement in the internal politics of the company,” says Packham. Integrity and objectivity Consultancy is often about identifying optimal change. Change can be challenging for anyone, so it is important to have an unimpeachable rationale FTA’s brand precedes it and the integrity of its consultants is unquestioned, which is of huge value in itself to many firms. “Internal voices can often be unheard or lack authority. We can translate between departments, run workshops for staff, present to the board or validate fleet decisions. Sometimes we connect different subsidiaries of the same company. One client had eight business units shipping separately in the UK with their empty trucks passing one another on the motorway. We saved them £3m a year. “Consultancy is often about identifying optimal change,” says Packham. “Change can be challenging for anyone, so it is important to have an unimpeachable rationale behind it. It also means our consultants have to be extremely sensitive to the knowledge level or feelings of staff, because we are often in situations where employment, or ways of working, may be about to change whether or not the workforce knows that.” It isn’t always a comfortable position. “We do collision investigations. Sometimes it is someone’s fault and it is our job to say so. We have to balance compassion with honesty. It can be very stressful but you can’t let that show.” Packham hopes her team’s work disseminates beyond its individual clients. “We want to spread best practice throughout the industry,” she says. “We can be a resource to make transport more profitable, safer and more efficient.” 13 14 FTA Consultancy Services The consultants These are just a few of the specialist consultants who deliver the spectacular results captured in this document Ian Laughlin Stephen Kelly Matt Barker Tony Bellia Cliff Cadman Senior Consultant: compliance, technical, environment and health & safety Senior Consultant: compliance, fleet management and logistics Health & safety and compliance Compliance and environment Compliance and environment Gordon Cameron Ric Charnley David Coleman Steve Daly Alan Granger Dangerous goods, health & safety and compliance Compliance and passenger transport Compliance and environment Compliance and training Compliance and logistics Peter Lambert David Mitchell Patric Parker Mark Sneezum Paul Whitehead Compliance and health & safety Compliance and logistics Compliance, best-value reviews and fleet management Compliance and environment Technical, health & safety and compliance FTA Consultancy Services A-Z of FTA Consultancy Services FTA Consultancy Services offers a wide range of services to meet the varying needs of transport users and providers including, but not limited to, the following: J Just-in-time deliveries, joint ventures, journey planning R Routeing and scheduling, research, road-risk management, risk assessments Benchmarking, best value reviews, best practice guides K Key performance indicators S Supply chain reviews, stores management, shared services, site safety reviews, strategy modelling, safe systems of work Contractor supply agreements, compliance, coaching, container shipping, contract development L Logistics and supply chain reviews, local authority reviews, Logistics Carbon Reduction Scheme T Telematics, transport optimisation, tendering, contractor selection, transport technology appraisal, transport efficiency reviews U Utilisation, urban logistics advice A Audits and accreditations, air freight B C D Dangerous goods audits, distribution centre reviews, depot reviews, due diligence Merger and acquisitions, management, mentoring, vehicle manoeuvring, modal shift E Engineering investigations, energy usage, ESOS, evaluation, expert witness M N Next steps, non-conformance rectification, niche markets, new ventures Vehicle specification, vehicle procurement, Van Excellence, value-for-money studies V F G Fleet management, fuel purchasing, fleet integration, fleet excellence Grey fleet, green audits H I O Operator licence compliance, operational efficiencies, outsourcing evaluation, O-licence applications, appeals and PIs PCN management, procedural reviews, procurement, policy reviews, pay, terms and conditions P Health and safety, health & safety audits and management Incident investigation, implementation, inventory management, interim management Quality assurance, qualifications, quiet delivery reviews Q W Warehousing, warehouse layout, warehouse audit, water transport, workshop audits X With X-ray insight, we see to the heart of operations Y Yes. We will answer your questions, understand your business and meet your needs Z We are zealous, about our industry, about excellence and about our work 15 FTA Consultancy Services for transport and logistics FTA consultants are available to help companies of all sizes with transport and logistics-related matters, including: ● Benchmarking ● Auditing ● Engineering investigation ● Supply chain creation or optimisation ● Legal compliance ● Health and safety ● Cost control ● Acquisitions and mergers FTA Consultancy Services offers unrivalled knowledge, practical solutions and a brand name which is synonymous with quality and integrity throughout UK business. FTA consultants are operationally flexible in order to achieve the clients’ full objectives, and also sensitive to the knowledge level and circumstances of those they are working among. FTA Consultancy Services prioritises practical, commercially savvy solutions and offers a range of options for making these real and valuable to the workforce, whether through resources, training or workshops. For more information on what FTA Consultancy Services can do for your business, or to discuss your unique requirements, please contact: General manager, consultancy and tendering, Karen Packham on: 01892 552319 or email [email protected] Freight Transport Association Limited Telephone: 01892 526171 Hermes House, St John’s Road, Fax: 01892 534989 Tunbridge Wells, Kent, TN4 9UZ Website: www.fta.co.uk Registered in England Number 391957 ©FTA 01.16/LC Produced and designed by White Rose Media Ltd All black and white photos featured on the front cover appear courtesy: Malcolm Group, Brittany Ferries, LondonWaste Ltd, Heathrow Airport Limited, East Midlands Ambulance Service NHS Trust and Transport for London
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz