ComprehensivecompilationofRandomizedControlledTrials(RCTs)involving
Psychodynamictreatments(PDT)
PeterLilliengren,PhD,assistantprofessor
DepartmentofPsychology,StockholmUniversity,SWEDEN
http://w3.psychology.su.se/staff/peli/indexeng.html
Lastupdated:2016-08-17
#
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Reference(primaryandsecondaryarticles)
Patientsample
PDT-model
Comparisongroup(s)
Abbass,A.,Sheldon,A.,Gyra,J.,&Kalpin,A.
(2008).Intensiveshort-termdynamic
psychotherapyforDSM-IVpersonality
disorders:arandomizedcontrolledtrial.J
NervMentDis,196,211-216.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18340
256
Ajilchi,B.,Nejati,V.,Town,J.M.,Wilson,R.,&
Abbass,A.(2016).EffectsofIntensiveShortTermDynamicPsychotherapyondepressive
symptomsandexecutivefunctioninginMajor
Depression.TheJournalofNervousand
MentalDisease,204(7),500–5.
http://doi.org/10.1097/NMD.0000000000000
518
Alstrom,J.E.,Nordlund,C.L.,Persson,G.,
Harding,M.,&Ljungqvist,C.(1984).Effectsof
fourtreatmentmethodsonsocialphobic
patientsnotsuitableforinsight-oriented
psychotherapy.ActaPsychiatrica
Scandinavica,70,97–110.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/61488
43
Alstrom,J.E.,Nordlund,G.,Persson,G.,
Harding,M.,&Lundquist,C.(1984).Effectsof
fourtreatmentmethodsonagorophobic
womennotsuitableforinsight-oriented
psychotherapy.ActaPsychiatrica
Scandinavica,70,1–17.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/61470
66
Amianto,F.,Ferrero,A.,Pierò,A.,Cairo,E.,
Rocca,G.,Simonelli,B.,…Fassino,S.(2011).
Supervisedteammanagement,withor
withoutstructuredpsychotherapy,inheavy
usersofamentalhealthservicewith
borderlinepersonalitydisorder:atwo-year
follow-uppreliminaryrandomizedstudy.BMC
psychiatry,11(1),181.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articleren
der.fcgi?artid=3260092&tool=pmcentrez&ren
dertype=abstract
Andersson,G.,Paxling,B.,Roch-Norlund,P.,
Ostman,G.,Norgren,A.,Almlöv,J.,…
Silverberg,F.(2012).Internet-Based
PsychodynamicversusCognitiveBehavioral
GuidedSelf-HelpforGeneralizedAnxiety
Disorder:ARandomizedControlledTrial.
Psychotherapyandpsychosomatics,81(6),
344–355.
Personalitydisorders
(mixed)
IntensiveShort-Term
DynamicPsychotherapy
(ISTDP;Davanloo,1990)
Minimalcontact
Depression
IntensiveShort-Term
DynamicPsychotherapy
(ISTDP;Davanloo,1990)
Waitlist
Socialanxietydisorder
(SAD)
Supportivedynamic
psychotherapy(Dewald,
1964)
Prolongedexposure(in
vivow.therapist)/+
relaxationtherapy
Agoraphobia(inwomen
notsuitableforinsightorientedpsychotherapy)
Supportivedynamic
psychotherapy(Dewald,
1964)
Prolongedexposure(in
vivow.therapist)/+
relaxationtherapy
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
SequentialBriefAdlerian
Psychodynamic
Psychotherapy(SB-APP;
Fassino,2008;2009)
Supervisedteam
management
GeneralizedAnxiety
Disorder(GAD)
IPDT(SUBGAP;Silverberg,
2005)
ICBT(Paxling,2011)
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22964
540
Arnevik,E.,Wilberg,T.,Urnes,O.,Johansen,
M.,Monsen,J.T.,&Karterud,S.(2009).
Psychotherapyforpersonalitydisorders:
short-termdayhospitalpsychotherapyversus
outpatientindividualtherapy-arandomized
controlledstudy.EuropeanPsychiatry :The
JournaloftheAssociationofEuropean
Psychiatrists,24(2),71–8.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19097
870
Arnevik,E.,Wilberg,T.,Urnes,Ø.,Johansen,
M.,Monsen,J.T.,&Karterud,S.(2010).
PsychotherapyforPersonalityDisorders:18
Months’Follow-UpoftheUllevålPersonality
Project.JournalofPersonalityDisorders,24(2),
188–203.
http://guilfordjournals.com/doi/pdf/10.1521/
pedi.2010.24.2.188
Bachar,E.,Latzer,Y.,Kreitler,S.,&Berry,E.
M.(1999).Empiricalcomparisonoftwo
psychologicaltherapies.Selfpsychologyand
cognitiveorientationinthetreatmentof
anorexiaandbulimia.JPsychotherPractRes,
8,115-128.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10079
459
Baldoni,F.,Baldaro,B.,&Trombini,G.(1995).
Psychotherapeuticperspectivesinurethral
syndrome.StressMedicine,11(July1994),79–
84.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/s
mi.2460110115/abstract
Balottin,U.,Ferri,M.,Racca,M.,Rossi,M.,
Rossi,G.,Beghi,E.,…Termine,C.(2014).
Psychotherapyversususualcareinpediatric
migraineandtension-typeheadache:asingleblindcontrolledpilotstudy.ItalianJournalof
Pediatrics,40(1),6.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24444
140
Barber,J.P.,Barrett,M.S.,Gallop,R.,Rynn,
M.a,&Rickels,K.(2011).Short-termdynamic
psychotherapyversuspharmacotherapyfor
majordepressivedisorder:arandomized,
placebo-controlledtrial.TheJournalofclinical
psychiatry,1–8.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22152
401
Zilcha-Mano,S.,Dinger,U.,McCarthy,K.S.,
Barrett,M.S.,&Barber,J.P.(2013).Changes
inwell-beingandqualityoflifeina
randomizedtrialcomparingdynamic
psychotherapyandpharmacotherapyfor
majordepressivedisorder.Journalofaffective
disorders,1–5.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24176
534
Barkham,M.,Rees,A.,Shapiro,D.A.,Stiles,
W.B.,Agnew,R.M.,&Halstead,J.,etal.
(1996).Outcomesoftime-limited
psychotherapyinappliedsettings:replicating
Personalitydisorders
(mixed)
Short-TermDayHospital
Psychotherapy(DHP;no
specificreference)
OutpatientIndividual
Psychotherapy
Bulimia
SelfPsychological
Treatment(basedon
Kohut,1984)
CognitiveOrientation
Treatment(Kreitler&
Kreitler,1990)
Urethralsyndrome
STDP(Malan,1979;
Davanloo,1980)
TAU
Idiopathicheadache
(children/adolescents618yrs)
STPP(Aliprandietal,1990)
TAU
Depression
SupportiveExpressive
Therapy(Luborsky,1984)
1.Placebo
2.SSRI/SNRI
Depression
PsychodynamicinterpersonalTherapy
(Hobson,1985)
CBT(noreference)
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
theSecondSheffieldPsychotherapyProject.J
ConsultClinPsychol,64,1079-1085.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/89166
39
Barkham,M.,Shapiro,D.A.,Hardy,G.E.,&
Rees,A.(1999).Psychotherapyintwo-plusonesessions:outcomesofarandomized
controlledtrialofcognitive-behavioraland
psychodynamic-interpersonaltherapyfor
subsyndromaldepression.JConsultClin
Psychol,67,201-211.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10224
730
Bassett,D.L.,&Pilowsky,I.(1985).Astudyof
briefpsychotherapyforchronicpain.J
PsychosomRes,29,259-264.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article
/pii/0022399985900522
Bastos,A.G.,Guimaraes,L.S.P.,&Trentini,C.
M.(2014).Theefficacyoflong-term
psychodynamicpsychotherapy,fluoxetineand
theircombinationintheoutpatienttreatment
ofdepression.PsychotherapyResearch :
JournaloftheSocietyforPsychotherapy
Research,(July2014),1–13.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25041
333
Bastos,A.G.,PintoGuimarães,L.S.,&
Trentini,C.M.(2013).Neurocognitivechanges
indepressedpatientsinpsychodynamic
psychotherapy,therapywithfluoxetineand
combinationtherapy.JournalofAffective
Disorders,1–10.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24103
853
Bateman,A.,&Fonagy,P.(1999).
Effectivenessofpartialhospitalizationinthe
treatmentofborderlinepersonalitydisorder:
arandomizedcontrolledtrial.TheAmerican
JournalofPsychiatry,156(10),1563–9.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10518
167
Bateman,A.,&Fonagy,P.(2008).8-Year
Follow-UpofPatientsTreatedforBorderline
PersonalityDisorder:Mentalization-Based
TreatmentVersusTreatmentAsUsual.The
AmericanJournalofPsychiatry,165(5),631–8.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18347
003
Bateman,A.,&Fonagy,P.(2009).Randomized
controlledtrialofoutpatientmentalizationbasedtreatmentversusstructuredclinical
managementforborderlinepersonality
disorder.AmJPsychiatry,166,1355-1364.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19833
787
Ben-Itzhak,S.,Bluvstein,I.,Schreiber,S.,
Aharonov-Zaig,I.,Maor,M.,Lipnik,R.,&
Bloch,M.(2012).TheEffectivenessofBrief
VersusIntermediateDurationPsychodynamic
PsychotherapyintheTreatmentof
AdjustmentDisorder.JournalofContemporary
Psychotherapy,42(4),249–256.
Depression
(subsyndromal)
PsychodynamicinterpersonalTherapy
(3sessions;Barkham&
Shapiro,basedonHobson,
1985)
CBT(Becketal1979;Beck,
1995)
Chronicpain
12sessionsPDT
(noreference)
Supportivepsychotherapy
(noreference)
Depression
Long-termpsychodynamic
psychotherapy(LTPP;
Gabbard,2004;2010)
1.Fluoxetinealone
2.LTPP+fluoxetine
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Mentalizationbased
treatment(MBT;Bateman
&Fonagy,2004)
TAU
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Mentalizationbased
treatment(MBT;Bateman
&Fonagy,2004)
StructuredClinical
Management(SCM)
Adjustmentdisorder
BriefPsychodynamic
Psychotherapy(12
sessions;Malan,1979)
BriefPsychodynamic
Psychotherapy(Iyrs;
Malan,1979)
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
http://www.springerlink.com/index/10.1007/s
10879-012-9208-6
Beresnevaite,M.(2000)Exploringthebenefits
ofgrouppsychotherapyinreducing
alexithymiaincoronaryheartdiseasepatients:
apreliminarystudy.Psychotherapyand
Psychosomatics,69,117–122.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10773
774?dopt=Abstract
Beutel,M.E.,Dippel,A.,Szczepanski,M.,
Thiede,R.,&Wiltink,J.(2006).Mid-Term
EffectivenessofBehavioraland
PsychodynamicInpatientTreatmentsof
SevereObesityBasedonaRandomizedStudy.
PsychotherapyandPsychosomatics,75(6),
337–345.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17053
334?dopt=Abstract
Beutel,M.E.,Scheurich,V.,Knebel,A.,Michal,
M.,Wiltink,J.,Graf-Morgenstern,M.,…SubicWrana,C.(2013).Implementingpanic-focused
psychodynamicpsychotherapyintoclinical
practice.Canadianjournalofpsychiatry.
Revuecanadiennedepsychiatrie,58(6),326–
34.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23768
260
Beutel,M.E.,Weissflog,G.,Leuteritz,K.,
Wiltink,J.,Haselbacher,a.,Ruckes,C.,…
Brahler,E.(2013).Efficacyofshort-term
psychodynamicpsychotherapy(STPP)with
depressedbreastcancerpatients:resultsofa
randomizedcontrolledmulticentertrial.
AnnalsofOncology,1–7.
http://annonc.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/doi/10.1
093/annonc/mdt526
Weißflog,G.,Brähler,E.,Leuteritz,K.,Barthel,
Y.,Kuhnt,S.,Wiltink,J.,…Beutel,M.E.(2015).
Doespsychodynamicshort-term
psychotherapyfordepressedbreastcancer
patientsalsoimprovefatigue?Resultsfroma
randomizedcontrolledtrial.BreastCancer
ResearchandTreatment.
http://link.springer.com/10.1007/s10549-0153494-0
Bloch,M.,Meiboom,H.,Lorberblatt,M.,
Bluvstein,I.,Aharonov,I.,&Schreiber,S.
(2012).Theeffectofsertralineadd-ontobrief
dynamicpsychotherapyforthetreatmentof
postpartumdepression:arandomized,
double-blind,placebo-controlledstudy.The
Journalofclinicalpsychiatry,73(2),235–41.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22401
479
Bögels,S.,Wijts,P.,Oort,F.,&Sallaerts,S.J.
(2014).Psychodynamicpsychotherapyversus
cognitive-behaviortherapyforsocialanxiety
disorder:Anefficacyandpartialeffectiveness
trial.DepressionandAnxiety,31(5),363–373.
http://doi.wiley.com/10.1002/da.22246
Bressi,C.,Porcellana,M.,Marinaccio,P.M.,
Nocito,E.P.,&Magri,L.(2010).Short-term
psychodynamicpsychotherapyversus
Alexithymia(inpatients
withcoronaryheart
disease)
Grouppsychotherapy
(noreference)
Psychoeducation
Severeobesity
Individualin-patientPDT
(Localprogram,no
reference)
In-patientCBT(Local
program,noreference)
Panicdisorder
PanicFocused
Psychodynamic
Psychotherapy(PFPP;
Milrod)
CBT
Depression(inbreast
cancerpatients)
Supportive-expressive
therapy(Haselbacher,
Barthel,Brähleretal.,
2010;basedonLuborsky,
1984)
TAU
Depression(postpartum)
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDT;
Malan,1979)+placebo
meds
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDT;
Malan,1979)+Sertraline
Socialanxietydisorder
(SAD)
STDP(Malan,1979;also
Luborsky1984)
CBT(Clark&Wells,1995)
Mixedsample
(depressionandanxiety)
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDT;
Malan,1976;Osimo&
TAU
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
treatmentasusualfordepressiveandanxiety
disorders:arandomizedclinicaltrialof
efficacy.TheJournalofNervousandMental
Disease,198(9),647–52.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20823
726
Brockman,B.,Poynton,A.,Ryle,A.,&Watson,
J.P.(1987).Effectivenessoftime-limited
therapycarriedoutbytrainees.Comparisonof
twomethods.BrJPsychiatry,151,602-610.
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/151/5/602
Brodaty,H.,&Andrews,G.(1983).Brief
psychotherapyinfamilypractice.Acontrolled
prospectiveinterventiontrial.BrJPsychiatry,
143,11-19.
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/143/1/11.shor
t
Brom,D.,Kleber,R.J.,&Defares,P.B.(1989).
Briefpsychotherapyforposttraumaticstress
disorders.JConsultClinPsychol,57,607-612.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25716
25
Budman,S.H.,Demby,A.,Redondo,J.P.,
Hannan,M.,Feldstein,M.,&Ring,J.,etal.
(1988).Comparativeoutcomeintime-limited
individualandgrouppsychotherapy.IntJ
GroupPsychother,38,63-86.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080
/00207284.1988.11491085
Burnand,Y.,Andreoli,A.,Kolatte,E.,
Venturini,A.,&Rosset,N.(2002).
Psychodynamicpsychotherapyand
clomipramineinthetreatmentofmajor
depression.PsychiatrServ,53,585-590.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11986
508
Burns,A.,Guthrie,E.,Marino-Francis,F.,
Busby,C.,Morris,J.,Russell,E.,…Byrne,J.
(2005).BriefpsychotherapyinAlzheimer’s
disease.BritishJournalOfPsychiatry,187(2),
143–147.
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/187/2/143.sho
rt
Chavooshi,B.,Mohammadkhani,P.,&
Dolatshahee,B.(2016).ARandomizedDoubleBlindControlledTrialComparingDavanloo’s
IntensiveShort-TermDynamicPsychotherapy
asInternet-DeliveredVersusTreatmentas
UsualforMedicallyUnexplainedPain:ASixMonthPilotStudy.Psychosomatics,57(3),
292–300.
http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0
033318216000025
Chavooshi,B.,Mohammadkhani,P.,&
Dolatshahee,B.(2016).EfficacyofIntensive
Short-TermDynamicPsychotherapyfor
MedicallyUnexplainedPain:APilotThreeArmedRandomizedControlledTrial
ComparisonwithMindfulness-BasedStress
Reduction.Psychotherapyand
Psychosomatics,123–125.
http://www.karger.com/?doi=10.1159/00044
1698
Malan,1992)
Mixedsample
Interpretivetherapy
(Mann&Goldman,1982)
Cognitive-analytictherapy
(CAT;Ryle,1979;1982)
Mixedsample
STDP(Balant,Malan&
Sifneos)
1.Familypractitioner
2.Notreatment
PTSD
BriefPsychodynamic
Therapy(Horowitz,1976)
1.TraumaDesensitization
(nospecificreference)
2.Hypnotherapy(no
specificreference)
Mixedsample
Time-limitedindividual
psychoterhapy(Mann,
1973)
Time-limitedgroup
psychotherapy(Budman&
Bennett,1983)
Depression
PDT+clomipramine,
(unclearwhichmodel,
Safran&Muranis
mentionedamong
references)
Supportivecare+
clomipramine
Alzheimersdisease
PsychodynamicInterpersonaltherapy
(Hobson,1985)
TAU
Medicallyunexplained
pain(MUP)
Internet-deliveredISTDP
(Abbass,2015)
TAU
Medicallyunexplained
pain(MUP)
IntensiveShort-Term
DynamicPsychotherapy
(ISTDP;Abbass,2015)
1.Mindfulness-based
stressreduction(MBSR;
noreference)
2.TAU
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
Chavooshi,B.,Mohammadkhani,P.,&
Dolatshahee,B.(2016).Telemedicinevs.inpersondeliveryofintensiveshort-term
dynamicpsychotherapyforpatientswith
medicallyunexplainedpain:A12-month
randomized,controlledtrial.Journalof
TelemedicineandTelecare,0(0),1–9.
http://jtt.sagepub.com/lookup/doi/10.1177/1
357633X15627382
Clarici,A.,Pellizzoni,S.,Guaschino,S.,
Alberico,S.,Bembich,S.,Giuliani,R.,…
Panksepp,J.(2015).Intranasaladminsitration
ofoxytocininpostnataldepression:
implicationsforpsychodynamic
psychotherapyfromarandomizeddoubleblindpilotstudy.FrontiersinPsychology,06,
1–10.
http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/
fpsyg.2015.00426/abstract
Clarkin,J.F.,Levy,K.N.,Lenzenweger,M.F.,
&Kernberg,O.F.(2007).Evaluatingthree
treatmentsforborderlinepersonality
disorder:amultiwavestudy.AmJPsychiatry,
164,922-928.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17541
052
Levy,K.N.,Meehan,K.B.,Kelly,K.M.,
Reynoso,J.S.,Weber,M.,Clarkin,J.F.,&
Kernberg,O.F.(2006).Changeinattachment
patternsandreflectivefunctionina
randomizedcontroltrialoftransferencefocusedpsychotherapyforborderline
personalitydisorder.JournalofConsultingand
ClinicalPsychology,74(6),1027–40.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17154
733
ConnollyGibbons,M.B.,Thompson,S.M.,
Scott,K.,Schauble,L.a,Mooney,T.,
Thompson,D.,…Crits-Christoph,P.(2012).
Supportive-expressivedynamicpsychotherapy
inthecommunitymentalhealthsystem:A
piloteffectivenesstrialforthetreatmentof
depression.Psychotherapy(Chicago,Ill.),
49(3),303–16.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22962
971
ConnollyGibbons,M.B.,Gallop,R.,
Thompson,D.,Luther,D.,Crits-Christoph,K.,
Jacobs,J.,…Crits-Christoph,P.(2016).
ComparativeeffectivenessofCognitive
TherapyandDynamicPsychotherapyfor
MajorDepressiveDisorderinacommunity
mentalhealthsetting.JAMAPsychiatry,
19104,1–8.
http://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2016.1
720
Cooper,P.J.,Murray,L.,Wilson,A.,&
Romaniuk,H.(2003).Controlledtrialofthe
short-andlong-termeffectofpsychological
treatmentofpost-partumdepression.I.
Impactonmaternalmood.BrJPsychiatry,
182,412-419.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12724
244
Medicallyunexplained
pain(MUP)
IntensiveShort-Term
DynamicPsychotherapy
(ISTDP;Abbass,2015)
Internet-deliveredISTDP
(ID-ISTDP)
Depression(postpartum)
Psychodynamicapproach
(non-manualized?)+
oxytocine
Psychodynamicapproach
(non-manualized?)+
placebo
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Transference-Focused
Psychotherapy(TFP;
Kernberg)
1.DBT(Linehan,1991)
2.Supportivetreatment
(Rockland,1992)
Depression
Supportive-expressive
therapy(manualadapted
fromLuborsky,1984)
TAU
Depression
Supportive-expressive
therapy(Book,1998;
Luborsky,1984)
CBT(Beck,1995)
Depression(postpartum)
Psychodynamictherapy
(Crameretal,1990;Stern,
1995)
1.TAU
2.Non-directive
counseling(Holdenetal,
1989)
3.Cognitive-Behavioural
Therapy(Hawtonetal,
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
Murray,L.,Cooper,P.J,Wilson,A.,&
Romaniuk,H.(2003).Controlledtrialofthe
short-andlong-termeffectofpsychological
treatmentofpost-partumdepression:2.
Impactonthemother-childrelationshipand
childoutcome.BritishJournalofPsychiatry,
182,420–7.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12724
245
Covi,L.,&Lipman,R.S.(1987).Cognitive
behavioralgrouppsychotherapycombined
withimipramineinmajordepression.
PsychopharmacolBull,23,173-176.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36023
15
Covi,L.,Lipman,R.S.,Derogatis,L.R.,Smith,J.
E.,&Pattison,J.H.(1974).Drugsandgroup
psychotherapyinneuroticdepression.AmJ
Psychiatry,131,191-198.
http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/abs/10.11
76/ajp.131.2.191
Creed,F.,Fernandes,L.,Guthrie,E.,Palmer,
S.,Ratcliffe,J.,&Read,N.,etal.(2003).The
cost-effectivenessofpsychotherapyand
paroxetineforsevereirritablebowel
syndrome.Gastroenterology,124,303-317.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12557
136
Hyphantis,T.,Guthrie,E.,Tomenson,B.,&
Creed,F.(2009).Psychodynamicinterpersonal
therapyandimprovementininterpersonal
difficultiesinpeoplewithsevereirritable
bowelsyndrome.Pain,145(1-2),196–203.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19643
544
Crits-Christoph,P.,Gibbons,M.B.C.,
Narducci,J.,Schamberger,M.,&Gallop,R.
(2005).InterpersonalProblemsandthe
OutcomeofInterpersonallyOriented
PsychodynamicTreatmentofGAD.
Psychotherapy:Theory,Research,Practice,
Training,42(2),211–224.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/0
033-3204.42.2.211
Crits-Christoph,P.,Siqueland,L.,Blaine,J.,
Frank,A.,Luborsky,L.,&Onken,L.S.,etal.
(1999).Psychosocialtreatmentsforcocaine
dependence:NationalInstituteonDrugAbuse
CollaborativeCocaineTreatmentStudy.Arch
GenPsychiatry,56,493-502.
http://archpsyc.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx
?articleid=1673777
Crits-Christoph,P.,Gibbons,M.B.C.,Gallop,
R.,Ring-Kurtz,S.,Barber,J.P.,Worley,M.,…
Hearon,B.(2008).Supportive-Expressive
PsychodynamicTherapyforCocaine
Dependence:ACloserLook.Psychoanalytic
Psychology :TheOfficialJournaloftheDivision
ofPsychoanalysis,AmericanPsychological
Association,Division39,25(3),483–498.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articleren
der.fcgi?artid=2786223&tool=pmcentrez&ren
dertype=abstract
1989)
Depression
TraditionalGroupTherapy
(basedon
“psychodynamicInterpersonal”theories
butwithnoreference)
1.CBTgrouptherapy
(Beck,1979;Covi,1982)
2.CBTgrouptherapy+
Imipramine
Depression(chronic)
Psychodynamically
orientedgrouptherapy
(noreference)+
medicationorplacebo
Briefsupportivecontact+
medicationorplacebo
Irritablebowel
syndrome
PsychodynamicInterpersonalTherapy
(PIT;Hobson,1985)
TAU/SSRI
Generalizedanxiety
disorder(GAD)
SupportiveExpressive
Therapy(Luborsky(1984)
Supportivetherapy
(Borkovec&Matthews,
1988;Borkovec&Costello,
1993)
Cocainedependence
SupportiveExpressive
Therapy(Luborsky(1984)
+groupdrugcounseling
(Mercer&Woody,1992)
1.Cognitivetherapy
(Beck,1993)+groupdrug
counseling(Mercer&
Woody,1992)
2.Groupdrugcounseling
alone
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
Cummings,J.G.,&Wittenberg,J.V.(2008).
Supportiveexpressivetherapy-Parentchild
version:anexploratorystudy.Psychotherapy
Theory,Research,Practice,Training,45,148164.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22122
414
Dare,C.,Eisler,I.,Russell,G.,Treasure,J.,&
Dodge,L.(2001).Psychologicaltherapiesfor
adultswithanorexianervosa:randomised
controlledtrialofout-patienttreatments.BrJ
Psychiatry,178,216-221.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11230
031
deJonghe,F.,Hendriksen,M.,vanAalst,G.,
Kool,S.,Peen,J.,&Van,R.,etal.(2004).
Psychotherapyaloneandcombinedwith
pharmacotherapyinthetreatmentof
depression.BritishJournalofPsychiatry,185,
37-45.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15231
554
deJonghe,F.,Kool,S.,vanAalst,G.,Dekker,J.,
&Peen,J.(2001).Combiningpsychotherapy
andantidepressantsinthetreatmentof
depression.JournalofAffectiveDisorders,
64(2-3),217–29.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11313
088
Dekker,J.J.M.,Koelen,J.A.,Van,H.L.,
Schoevers,R.A.,Peen,J.,Hendriksen,M.,…
DeJonghe,F.(2008).Speedofaction:the
relativeefficacyofshortpsychodynamic
supportivepsychotherapyand
pharmacotherapyinthefirst8weeksofa
treatmentalgorithmfordepression.Journalof
AffectiveDisorders,109(1-2),183–188.
http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0
165032707003588
Dekker,J.,Van,H.L.,Hendriksen,M.,Koelen,
J.,Schoevers,R.A.,Kool,S.,…Peen,J.(2013).
Whatisthebestsequentialtreatmentstrategy
inthetreatmentofdepression?Adding
pharmacotherapytopsychotherapyorvice
versa?PsychotherapyandPsychosomatics,
82(2),89–98.
http://www.karger.com/doi/10.1159/000341
177
Dekker,J.,Molenaar,P.J.,Kool,S.,VanAalst,
G.,Peen,J.,&deJonghe,F.(2005).Dose–
effectrelationsintime-limitedcombined
psycho-pharmacologicaltreatmentfor
depression.PsychologicalMedicine,35(1),47–
58.
http://www.journals.cambridge.org/abstract_
S0033291704002685
Doering,S.,Hörz,S.,Rentrop,M.,Fischer
Kern,M.,Schuster,P.,&Benecke,C.,etal.
(2010).Transference-focusedpsychotherapy
v.treatmentbycommunitypsychotherapists
forborderlinepersonalitydisorder:
randomisedcontrolledtrial.BrJPsychiatry,
196,389-395.
Oppositionaldefiant
disorder/disruptive
behaviordisorder
(children)
SupportiveExpressive
Therapy–ParentChild
(SET-PC;Wittenberg,
adaptedfromLuborsky,
19854)
TheIncredibleYears
ParentingProgram
Anorexia
Focalpsychoanalytic
psychotherapy(Dare,
1995;Malan,1979)
CognitiveAnalytic
Therapy(Ryle,1990;
Treasureetal,1995)
Familytherapy(nospecific
reference)
Depression
ShortPsychodynamic
SupportivePsychotherapy
(deJonghe,2005)
ShortPsychodynamic
SupportivePsychotherapy
+antidepressants
Depression
ShortPsychodynamic
SupportivePsychotherapy
(deJonghe,2005)+
medication
Medicationalone
Depression
ShortPsychodynamic
SupportivePsychotherapy
(deJonghe,2005)
Pharmacotherapy
Depression
ShortPsychodynamic
SupportivePsychotherapy
(deJonghe,2005)
8sessions+medication
ShortPsychodynamic
SupportivePsychotherapy
(deJonghe,2005)
16sessions+medication
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Transference-focused
psychotherapy(TFP;
Kernberg)
TAU(experienced
therapists)
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20435
966
Driessen,E.,Van,L.H.,Don,F.J.,Peen,J.,
Kool,S.,Westra,D.,…Dekker,J.J.M.(2013).
TheEfficacyofCognitive-BehavioralTherapy
andPsychodynamicTherapyintheOutpatient
TreatmentofMajorDepression:A
RandomizedClinicalTrial.AmericanJournalof
Psychiatry,170(9),1041-1050
http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/abs/10.11
76/appi.ajp.2013.12070899
Driessen,E.,Van,H.L.,Peen,J.,Don,F.J.,
Kool,S.,Westra,D.,…Dekker,J.J.(2014).
Therapist-ratedoutcomesinarandomized
clinicaltrialcomparingcognitivebehavioral
therapyandpsychodynamictherapyformajor
depression.JournalofAffectiveDisorders,
170C,112–118.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25240
140
Durham,R.C.,Murphy,T.,Allan,T.,Richard,
K.,Treliving,L.R.,&Fenton,G.W.,etal.
(1994).Cognitivetherapy,analytic
psychotherapyandanxietymanagement
trainingforgeneralisedanxietydisorder.BrJ
Psychiatry,165,315-323.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/79945
00
Emmelkamp,P.M.G.,Benner,A.,Kuipers,A.,
Feiertag,G.A.,Koster,H.C.,&VanApeldoorn,
F.J.,etal.(2006).Comparisonofbrief
dynamicandcognitive-behaviouraltherapies
inavoidantpersonalitydisorder.BrJ
Psychiatry,189,60-64.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16816
307
Fairburn,G.,Kirk,J.,Connor,M.O.,&Cooper,
P.J.(1986).Acomparisonoftwopsychological
treatmentsforbulimia.Behaviourresearch
andtherapy,24(6),629–643.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article
/pii/0005796786900586
Faramarzi,M.,Azadfallah,P.,Book,H.E.,
Tabatabaei,K.R.,Taheri,H.,&Shokri-Shirvani,
J.(2013).Arandomizedcontrolledtrialofbrief
psychoanalyticpsychotherapyinpatientswith
functionaldyspepsia.Asianjournalof
psychiatry,6(3),228–34.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23642
981
Faramarzi,M.,&Book,H.E.(2015).TheEffect
ofPsychotherapyinImprovingPhysicaland
PsychiatricSymptomsinPatientswith
FunctionalDyspepsia,IranJournalof
Psychiatry,43–49.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26005
480
Fonagy,P.,Rost,F.,Carlyle,J.-A.,Mcpherson,
S.,Thomas,R.,Fearon,R.M.P.,…Taylor,D.
(2015).Pragmaticrandomizedcontrolledtrial
oflong-termpsychoanalyticpsychotherapyfor
treatment-resistantdepression :theTavistock
Depression
Short-term
psychodynamic
supportivepsychotherapy
(deJonghe,2005)
Cognitive-Behavior
Therapy(CBT;Molenaaret
al.,2009)
Generalizedanxiety
disorder(GAD)
Analytic-based
psychotherapy(nospecific
reference)
CognitiveTherapy/
AnxietyManagement
training(Beck&Emery,
1985)
Avoidantpersonality
disorder
BriefDynamicTherapy
(BDT;Malan,1979;also
referencetoLuborsky,
1984)
CBT(Beck&Freeman,
1990;Emmelkampetal,
1992)
Bulimia
Short-termFocal
Psychotherapy(Rosen,
1979)
CBT(Fairburn,1985)
Functionaldyspepsia
Briefpsychodynamic
therapy(Book,1998)
basedonLuborsky(1984)
+standardmedical
therapy
TAU(medicaltherapy)
Depression(treatment
resistant)
Long-TermPsychoanalytic
PSychotehrapy(LTPP;
Taylor,2015)
TAU
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
AdultDepressionStudy(TADS).World
Psychiatry,14(3),312-321
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26407
787
Fonagy,P.,Sleed,M.,&Baradon,T.(2016).
RandomizedControlledTrialofParent-Infant
PsychotherapyforParentsWithMentalHealth
ProblemsandYoungInfants.InfantMental
HealthJournal,37(2),97-114
http://doi.wiley.com/10.1002/imhj.21553
Gallagher-Thompson,D.,&Steffen,A.M.
(1994).Comparativeeffectsofcognitivebehavioralandbriefpsychodynamic
psychotherapiesfordepressedfamily
caregivers.JConsultClinPsychol,62,543-549.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/80639
80
Gallagher,D.E.,&Thompson,L.W.(1982).
Treatmentofmajordepressivedisorderin
olderadultoutpatientswithbrief
psychotherapies.Psychotherapy:Theory,
Research,andPractice,482-490.
http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/pst/19/4/482
/
Garner,D.M.,Rockert,W.,Davis,R.,Garner,
M.V.,Olmsted,M.P.,&Eagle,M.,etal.
(1993).Comparisonofcognitive-behavioral
andsupportive-expressivetherapyforbulimia
nervosa.AmJPsychiatry,150,37-46.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/84175
78
Gelder,M.G.,Marks,I.M.,&Wolff,H.H.
(1967).Desensitizationandpsychotherapyin
thetreatmentofphobicstates:acontrolled
inquiry.BritishJournalofPsychiatry,113(494),
53–81.
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/cgi/doi/10.1192/bjp.11
3.494.53
Gersons,B.P.,Carlier,I.V,Lamberts,R.D.,&
vanderKolk,B.a.(2000).Randomizedclinical
trialofbriefeclecticpsychotherapyforpolice
officerswithposttraumaticstressdisorder.
JournalofTraumaticStress,13(2),333–47.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10838
679
Ghorbani,N.,Dadsetan,P.,Ejei,J.,&Motiyan,
H.(2000).Theconsequencesofovercoming
resistanceandemotionaldisclosureon
lymphocyteT-helperandT-suppressorand
psychologicalpathology.JournalofPsychology
(Persian),3,368–89.
Giesen-Bloo,J.,vanDyck,R.,Spinhoven,P.,
vanTilburg,W.,Dirksen,C.,&vanAsselt,T.,et
al.(2006).Outpatientpsychotherapyfor
borderlinepersonalitydisorder:randomized
trialofschema-focusedtherapyvs
transference-focusedpsychotherapy.Arch
GenPsychiatry,63,649-658.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16754
838
vanAsselt,A.D.I.,Dirksen,C.D.,Arntz,A.,
Giesen-Bloo,J.H.,vanDyck,R.,Spinhoven,P.,
Parentswithmental
healthproblems
Parent-infant
psychotherapy(PIP)
Standardcare
Depression(among
familycaregivers)
BriefPsychodynamic
Therapy(Mann,1973)
CBT(Becketal.,1979;
Lewinsohnetal,1985;
Gallagheretalm1981)
Depression
Briefrelational/insight
psychotherapy(Bellak&
Small,1965)
Behavioraltherapy/
Cognitivetherapy
(Lewinsohnetal,1976;
Gallagheretal.,1981)
Bulimia
Supportive-expressive
psychotherapy(Luborsky,
1984)
CBT(Fairburn,1985)
Phobicstates
Psychotherapy(no
reference)
1.Desensitization(Wolpe)
2.Grouppsychotherapy
(Foulkes)
PTSD
Briefeclectic
psychotherapy(BEP;
Gersons&Carlier,1994;
ManualincludesbothCBT
andPDTcomponents)
Waitlist
Students
ISTDP(Davanloo,1990)
Simpleverbaldisclosure
groups(SVD)
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Transferencefocused
psychotherapy(TFP;
Clarkin,Yeomans,&
Kernberg,1999;Yeomans,
Clarkin,&Kernberg,2002)
Schema-focusedtherapy
(Young,1994;Youngetal,
2003)
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
…Severens,J.L.(2008).Out-patient
psychotherapyforborderlinepersonality
disorder:cost-effectivenessofschemafocusedtherapyv.transference-focused
psychotherapy.TheBritishJournalof
Psychiatry :TheJournalofMentalScience,
192(6),450–7.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18515
897
Gilboa-Schechtman,E.,Foa,E.B.,Shafran,N.,
Aderka,I.M.,Powers,M.B.,Rachamim,L.,…
Apter,A.(2010).Prolongedexposureversus
dynamictherapyforadolescentPTSD:apilot
randomizedcontrolledtrial.Journalofthe
AmericanAcademyofChildandAdolescent
Psychiatry,49(10),1034–42.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articleren
der.fcgi?artid=2945239&tool=pmcentrez&ren
dertype=abstract
Gowers,S.,Norton,K.,Halek,C.,&Crisp,A.H.
(1994).Outcomeofoutpatientpsychotherapy
inarandomallocationtreatmentstudyof
anorexianervosa.IntJEatDisord,15,165177.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/81735
62
Gregory,R.J.,Chlebowski,S.,Kang,D.,
Remen,A.L.,Soderberg,M.G.,&Stepkovitch,
J.,etal.(2008).Acontrolledtrialof
psychodynamicpsychotherapyforcooccurringborderlinepersonalitydisorderand
alcoholusedisorder.Psychotherapy:Theory,
Research,Practice,Training,45,28-41.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/0
033-3204.45.1.28
Grothe,C.,Bering,R.,SpieB,R.,Luneburg,E.,
&Fischer,G.(2003).Mehrdimensionale
PsychodynamischeTraumaterapie(MPTT)
ForschungsergenbnissezurStandardversion.
ZeitschriftfurPsychotraumatologie,
Psychotherapiewissenschaftund
PsychologischeMedizin1(2),27–43.
Gunderson,J.G.,Frank,A.F.,Katz,H.M.,
Vannicelli,M.L.,Frosch,J.P.,&Knapp,P.H.,
etal.(1984).Effectsofpsychotherapyin
schizophrenia:II.Comparativeoutcomeof
twoformsoftreatment.SchizophrBull,10,
564-598.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/61512
46
Guthrie,E.,Creed,F.,Dawson,D.,&
Tomenson,B.(1991).Acontrolledtrialof
psychologicaltreatmentfortheirritablebowel
syndrome.Gastroenterology,100,450-457.
http://www.gastrojournal.org/article/00165085(91)90215-7/pdf
Guthrie,E.,Creed,F.,Dawson,D.,&
Tomenson,B.(1993).Arandomisedcon-
trolledtrialofpsychotherapyinpatientswith
refractoryIrritableBowelSyndrome.British
JournalofPsychiatry,163,315–21.
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/163/3/315
Guthrie,E.,Kapur,N.,Mackway-Jones,K.,
PTSD(adolescents)
Time-limiteddynamic
therapy(TLDP-A;Shefler
etal,1995)
Prolongedexposure(Foa)
Anorexia(adolescents
andyoungwomen)
Shorttermindividual+
familyinterviews(Koss&
Butcher,1986)
Assessmentonly
Borderlinepersonality
disorder+alcoholuse
disorder
Dynamicdeconstructive
therapy(Gregory&
RemenI)
TAU
PTSD
Mehrdimensionale
Psychodynamische
Traumaterapie(MPTT;
Fischer,2000)
1.EMDR(Shapiro,1995;
1998)
2.Waitlistcontrol(?)
Schizophrenia
Exploratory,insight
orientedpsychotherapy
(AdaptedfromFrommReichmann)
Reality-adaptive,
supportivepsychotherapy
Irritablebowel
syndrome
PsychodynamicInterpersonalTherapy
(PIT;Hobson,1985)
Supportivelistening
Self-poisoning
Psychodynamic-
TAU
73.
74.
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
Chew-Graham,C.,Moorey,J.,&Mendel,E.,et
al.(2001).Randomisedcontrolledtrialofbrief
psychologicalinterventionafterdeliberateself
poisoning.BMJ,323,135-138.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articleren
der.fcgi?artid=34723&tool=pmcentrez&rende
rtype=abstract
Guthrie,E.,Moorey,J.,Margison,F.,Barker,
H.,Palmer,S.,&McGrath,G.,etal.(1999).
Cost-effectivenessofbriefpsychodynamicinterpersonaltherapyinhighutilizersof
psychiatricservices.ArchGenPsychiatry,56,
519-526.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10359
466
Hall,A.,&Crisp,A.H.(1987).Brief
psychotherapyinthetreatmentofanorexia
nervosa:Outcomeatoneyear.BritishJournal
ofPsychiatry,151,185-191.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36901
08
Hamilton,J.,Guthrie,E.,Creed,F.,Thompson,
D.,Tomenson,B.,&Bennett,R.,etal.(2000).
Arandomizedcontrolledtrialof
psychotherapyinpatientswithchronic
functionaldyspepsia.Gastroenterology,119,
661-669.
http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0
016508500145949
Hardy,G.E.,Barkham,M.,Shapiro,D.a,Stiles,
W.B.,Rees,a,&Reynolds,S.(1995).Impactof
ClusterCpersonalitydisordersonoutcomesof
contrastingbriefpsychotherapiesfor
depression.Journalofconsultingandclinical
psychology,63(6),997–1004.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/85437
22
Hellerstein,D.J.,Rosenthal,R.N.,Pinsker,H.,
Samstag,L.W.,Muran,J.C.,&Winston,A.,et
al.(1998).Arandomizedprospectivestudy
comparingsupportiveanddynamictherapies.
Outcomeandalliance.JPsychotherPractRes,
7,261-271.
http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/1998-12001001
Hersen,M.,Himmelhoch,J.M.,Thase,M.E.,
&Bellack,A.S.(1984).Effectsofsocialskill
training,amitriptyline,andpsychotherapyin
unipolardepressedwomen.BehaviorTherapy,
15(1),21–40.
http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0
005789484800398
Hoffart,A.,&Martinsen,E.W.(1990).
Exposure-basedintegratedvs.Pure
psychodynamictreatmentofagoraphobic
inpatients.Psychotherapy:Theory,Research,
Practice,Training,Vol27(2),210–218.
http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/1990-29285001
Høglend,P.,Amlo,S.,Marble,A.,Bøgwald,K.
P.,Sørbye,O.,&Sjaastad,M.C.,etal.(2006).
Analysisofthepatient-therapistrelationship
indynamicpsychotherapy:anexperimental
InterpersonalTherapy
(PIT;Hobson,1985)
Mixedsample
PsychodynamicInterpersonalTherapy
(PIT;Hobson,1985)
TAU
Anorexia
Combinedindividualand
familypsychotherapy(no
reference)
Dietaryadvice
ChronicFunctional
Dyspepsia
PsychodynamicInterpersonalTherapy
(PIT;Hobson,1985)
Supportivetherapy
(Guthrie,unpub.)
Depression+
personalitydisorder
clusterC
PsychodynamicInterpersonalTherapy
(PIT;Hobson,1985)
CBT(Firth&Shapiro,1985)
Personalitydisorders
(clusterC)
ISTDP(Davanloo,1980)
BriefAdaptiveTherapy
(Winston?)
Depression
Time-limiteddynamic
therapy(noreference)+
placebo
1.Socialskilltraining+
placebo
2.Amitriptyline
Agoraphobia
Integrativebehaviouralpsychodynamictreatment
Psychodynamicoriented
grouptherapy
Mixedsample
Psychodynamic
psychotherapywith
transference
interpretation(Höglend,
Psychodynamic
psychotherapywithout
transference
interpretation(Höglend,
81.
82.
83.
84.
studyoftransferenceinterpretations.AmJ
Psychiatry,163,1739-1746.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17012
684
Høglend,P.,Bøgwald,K.-P.,Amlo,S.,Marble,
A.,Ulberg,R.,Sjaastad,M.C.,…Johansson,P.
(2008).Transferenceinterpretationsin
dynamicpsychotherapy:dotheyreallyyield
sustainedeffects?TheAmericanJournalof
Psychiatry,165(6),763–71.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18413
707
Huber,D.,Henrich,G.,Gastner,J.,&Klug,G.
(2012).MustAllHavePrizes?TheMunich
PsychotherapyStudy.InPsychodynamic
PsychotherapyResearch.
http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F
978-1-60761-792-1_4#page-1
Huber,D.,Huber,D.,Zimmermann,J.,
Henrich,G.,&Klug,G.(2012).Comparisonof
cognitive-behaviourtherapywith
psychoanalyticandpsychodynamictherapyfor
depressedpatients–Athree-yearfollow-up
study.ZeitschriftfürPsychsomatic,(58),299–
316.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22987
495
Huber,D.,Henrich,G.,Clarkin,J.,&Klug,G.
(2013).Psychoanalyticversuspsychodynamic
therapyfordepression:athree-yearfollow-up
study.Psychiatry,76(2),132–49.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23631
544
Hubschmid,M.,Aybek,S.,D,M.,Maccaferri,
G.E.,D,M.,Chocron,O.,…D,M.(n.d.).
Efficacyofbriefinterdisciplinary
psychotherapeuticinterventionformotor
conversiondisorderandnonepilepticattacks.
GeneralHospitalPsychiatry,37(5),448–455.
doi:10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2015.05.007
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.genhosppsych.201
5.05.007
Jantschek,G.,Zeitz,M.,Wirsching,M.,Klor,H.
U.,Studt,H.H.,Rasenack,J.,…Disease,T.G.
S.G.onP.I.inC.(1999).Effectof
psychotherapyonthecourseofCrohn’s
disease.PsychosomaticInterventioninCD,
1289–1296.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/99303
93
Keller,W.,Pritsch,M.,VonWietersheim,J.,
Scheib,P.,Osborn,W.,&Balck,F.,etal.
(2004).Effectofpsychotherapyandrelaxation
onthepsychosocialandsomaticcourseof
Crohn'sdisease:mainresultsoftheGerman
ProspectiveMulticenterPsychotherapy
TreatmentstudyonCrohn'sDisease.J
PsychosomRes,56,687-696.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15193
965
Johansson,R.,Björklund,M.,Hornborg,C.,
Karlsson,S.,Hesser,H.,Ljótsson,B.,…
Andersson,G.(2013).Affect-focused
1995)
1995)
Depression
Psychoanalysis(nonmanualized)
1.LTPP(non-manualized)
2.CBT(non-manualized;
patientsnotrandomly
assignedtothisgroup)
Motorconversion
disorderand
nonepilepticseizures
Interdisciplinary
psychotherapeutic
intervention
(PsychodynamicInterpersonaltherapy
basedonGuthrie,1999)
Standardcare
Crohn’sdisease
PDT+relaxation+drug
treatment(nomanualwas
usedbutreferenceto
Luborsky,1984)
Drugtreatment
Depressionand/or
anxiety
IPDT(Affect-focused;
basedonFrederick,2009)
Onlinetherapistsupport
andclinicalmonitoring
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
psychodynamicpsychotherapyfordepression
andanxietythroughtheInternet:a
randomizedcontrolledtrial.PeerJ,1,e102.
https://peerj.com/articles/102
Johansson,R.,Ekbladh,S.,Hebert,A.,
Lindström,M.,Möller,S.,Petitt,E.,…
Andersson,G.(2012).PsychodynamicGuided
Self-HelpforAdultDepressionthroughthe
Internet:ARandomisedControlledTrial.(A.
Bruce,Ed.)PLoSONE,7(5),
http://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0038
021
Jørgensen,C.R.,Freund,C.,Bøye,R.,Jordet,
H.,Andersen,D.,&Kjølbye,M.(2012).
Outcomeofmentalization-basedand
supportivepsychotherapyinpatientswith
borderlinepersonalitydisorder:arandomized
trial.ActapsychiatricaScandinavica,1–13.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22897
123
Klein,D.F.,Zitrin,C.M.,Woerner,M.G.,&
Ross,D.C.(1983).TreatmentofPhobias.II.
Behaviortherapyandsupportive
psychotherapy:arethereanyspecific
ingredients?ArchivesofGeneralPsychiatry,
139–145.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/61307
51
Kleinman,P.H.,Woody,G.E.,Todd,T.C.,
Millman,R.B.,Kang,S.Y.,&Kemp,J.,etal.
(1990).Crackandcocaineabusersin
outpatientpsychotherapy.NIDAResMonogr,
104,24-35.
Knekt,P.,&Lindfors,O.(2004).Arandomized
trialoftheeffectoffourformsof
psychotherapyondepressiveandanxiety
disorders.Helsinki:Kela.
https://helda.helsinki.fi/handle/10250/3315
Knekt,P.,Lindfors,O.,Ske,L.S.Ä.,&Virtala,E.
S.A.(2013).Randomizedtrialonthe
effectivenessoflong-andshort-term
psychotherapyonpsychiatricsymptomsand
workingabilityduringa5-yearfollow-up.
Nordicjournalofpsychiatry,67(1),59-68.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.3109
/08039488.2012.680910
Knekt,P.,Virtala,E.,Härkänen,T.,Vaarama,
M.,Lehtonen,J.,&Lindfors,O.(2016).The
outcomeofshort-andlong-term
psychotherapy10yearsafterstartof
treatment.PsychologicalMedicine,1–14.
http://www.journals.cambridge.org/abstract_
S0033291715002718
Lindfors,O.,Knekt,P.,Virtala,E.,&Laaksonen,
M.a.(2012).Theeffectivenessofsolutionfocusedtherapyandshort-andlong-term
psychodynamicpsychotherapyonself-concept
duringa3-yearfollow-up.TheJournalof
NervousandMentalDisease,200(11),946–53.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23124
178
Depression
IPDT(SUBGAP;basedon
Silverberg,2005)
Psychoeducation+
support
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Mentalization-Based
Therapy(MBT;Bateman&
Fonagy,2001)
Supportivegrouptherapy
Phobias
Supportivetherapy
(dynamicallyoriented;no
reference)
Behaviortherapy(no
reference)
Cocaineabuse
Supportive-Expressive
Therapy(Luborsky,1984)
Familytherapy+para
professionallyledgroup
therapy
Depressionand/or
anxiety
STPP(Malan,1976;
Sifneos,1978)
1.Sollution-focused
therapy
(deShazeretal,1986)
2.LTPP(Gabbard,2004)
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
95.
Lindfors,O.,Knekt,P.,Heinonen,E.,Härkänen,
T.,Virtala,E.,&TheHelsinkiPsychotherapy
StudyGroup.(2015).Theeffectivenessof
short-andlong-termpsychotherapyon
personalityfunctioningduringa5-yearfollowup.JournalofAffectiveDisorders,173,31–8.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25462
393
Maljanen,T.,Knekt,P.,Lindfors,O.,Virtala,E.,
Tillman,P.,&Härkänen,T.(2016).Thecosteffectivenessofshort-termandlong-term
psychotherapyinthetreatmentofdepressive
andanxietydisordersduringa5-yearfollowup.JournalofAffectiveDisorders,190(July),
254–263.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22611
089
Knijnik,D.Z.,Blanco,C.,Salum,G.A.,Moraes,
C.U.,Mombach,C.,Almeida,E.,…Eizirik,C.L.
(2008).Apilotstudyofclonazepamversus
psychodynamicgrouptherapyplus
clonazepaminthetreatmentofgeneralized
socialanxietydisorder.EuropeanPsychiatry :
TheJournaloftheAssociationofEuropean
Psychiatrists,23(8),567–74.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18774
274
Knijnik,D.Z.,Kapczinski,F.,Chachamovich,E.,
Margis,R.,&Eizirik,C.L.(2004).
Psychodynamicgrouptreatmentfor
generalizedsocialphobia.RevistaBrasileirade
Psiquiatria(SãoPaulo,Brazil :1999),26(2),
77–81.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15517
057
Kompoliti,K.,Wilson,B.,Stebbins,G.,
Bernard,B.,&Hinson,V.(2013).Immediate
vs.delayedtreatmentofpsychogenic
movementdisorderswithshort-term
psychodynamicpsychotherapy:Randomized
clinicaltrial.Parkinsonism&relateddisorders,
7–10.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24120
952
Kool,S.,Dekker,J.,&Duijsens,I.(2003).
Efficacyofcombinedtherapyand
pharmacotherapyfordepressedpatientswith
orwithoutpersonalitydisorders.Harvard
reviewofpsychiatry,133–142.
http://informahealthcare.com/doi/abs/10.108
0/10673220303950
Kornblith,S.,Rehm,L.,W,O.M.,&Lamparski,
D.M.(1983).Thecontributionofselfreinforcementtrainingandbehaviroal
assigmentstotheefficacyofself-control
therapyfordepression.CognTherRes,7,499528.
http://link.springer.com/10.1007/BF01172888
Kramer,U.,deRoten,Y.,Perry,J.C.,&
Despland,J.-N.(2013).Changeindefense
mechanismsandcopingpatternsduringthe
courseof2-year-longpsychotherapyand
psychoanalysisforrecurrentdepression:a
pilotstudyofarandomizedcontrolledtrial.
Socialanxietydisorder
(SAD)
Psychodynamicgroup
therapy(Malan,1976)+
clonazepam
Clonazepam
Socialanxietydisorder
(SAD)
Psychodynamicgroup
therapy(Malan,1976)
Credibleplacebogroup
Psychogenicmovement
disorders
ISTDP(Davanloo,1980)
Neurologicalobservation
andsupport
Depression
STDP(deJonghe,2005)+
pharmacotherapy
Pharmacotherapy
Depression
Psychodynamicgroup
therapy(Wolf,1965;
Bernard&Klein,1977)
Self-reinforcement
trainingandbehavioral
assigments(Rehm,1977)
Depression(recurrent)
Supportive-Expressive
Therapy(Luborsky,1984)
Allpatientswerealso
givenpharmacological
treatment
1.Cognitivetherapy
(Beck,1995)
2.Psychoanalysis
(Robertson,2002).
96.
97.
98.
99.
100.
101.
TheJournalofnervousandmentaldisease,
201(7),614–20.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23817
160
Lanza,M.L.,Anderson,J.,Boisvert,C.M.,
LeBlanc,A.,Fardy,M.,&Steel,B.,etal.
(2002).Assaultivebehaviorinterventioninthe
VeteransAdministration:psychodynamic
grouppsychotherapycomparedtocognitive
behaviortherapy.PerspectPsychiatrCare,38,
89-97.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1
744-6163.2002.tb00662.x/abstract
LaPonite,K.,&Rimm,D.C.(1980).Cognitive,
assertive,andinsight-orientedgroup
therapiesinthetreatmentofreactive
depressioninwomen.Psychotherapy:Theory,
Research&Practice,17(3),312–321.
http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/pst/17/3/312
/
Lau,M.,&Kristensen,E.(2007).Outcomeof
systemicandanalyticgrouppsychotherapyfor
adultwomenwithhistoryofintrafamilial
childhoodsexualabuse:arandomized
controlledstudy.ActaPsychiatrScand,116,
96-104.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17650
270
Lawson,D.M.(2010).Comparingcognitive
behavioraltherapyandintegratedcognitive
behavioraltherapy/psychodynamictherapyin
grouptreatmentforpartnerviolentmen.
Psychotherapy:Theory,Research,Practice,
Training,47(1),122–133.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/a
0018841
Leichsenring,F.,Masuhr,O.,Jaeger,U.,
Rabung,S.,Dally,A.,Dumpelmann,M.,…
Streeck,U.(2016).PsychoanalyticInteractionalTherapyversusPsychodynamic
TherapybyExpertsforPersonalityDisorders:
ARandomizedControlledEfficacyEffectivenessStudyinClusterBPersonality
Disorders.PsychotherapyandPsychosomatics,
71–80.
http://www.karger.com/?doi=10.1159/00044
1731
Leichsenring,F.,Salzer,S.,Beutel,M.E.,
Herpertz,S.,Hiller,W.,Hoyer,J.,…Leibing,E.
(2013).PsychodynamicTherapyandCognitiveBehavioralTherapyinSocialAnxietyDisorder:
AMulticenterRandomizedControlledTrial.
AmericanJournalofPsychiatry,170(7),759767.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23680
854
Leichsenring,F.,Salzer,S.,Beutel,M.E.,
Herpertz,S.,Hiller,W.,Hoyer,J.,…Leibing,E.
(2014).Long-TermOutcomeof
PsychodynamicTherapyandCognitiveBehavioralTherapyinSocialAnxietyDisorder.
AmericanJournalofPsychiatry,171(10),10741082.
3.Clinicalmanagement
(Csank,2002;Novaliset
al.,1993).
Cognitivebehaviorgroup
therapy(Nospecific
reference)
Maleveteranswith
historyofassault
Psychodynamicgroup
psychotherapy(nospecific
reference)
Depression
Insight-orientedgroup
therapy(Noreference)
1.Cognitivegrouptherapy
(Beck,19767)
2.Assertivenesstraining
(noreference)
Womenwithchildhood
sexualabuse
Analyticgrouptherapy
(Foulkes,1986)
Systemicgrouptherapy
(Holme,1999)
Violentmen
IntegrativeCBTpsychodynamicgroup
therapy(Strupp&Binder,
1984)
CBT(Lawson,2001)
Personalitydisorders
(clusterB)
PsychoanalyticInteractionalTherapy
(Streeck,2016)
Psychodynamictherapy
byexperts
Socialanxietydisorder
(SAD)
Supportive-Expressive
Therapy(Luborsky,1984)
CBT(Clark&Wells,1995)
102.
103.
104.
105.
106.
107.
108.
109.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25016
974
Leichsenring,F.,Salzer,S.,Jaeger,U.,Kächele,
H.,Kreische,R.,&Leweke,F.,etal.(2009).
Short-TermPsychodynamicPsychotherapy
andCognitive-BehavioralTherapyin
GeneralizedAnxietyDisorder:ARandomized,
ControlledTrial.AmJPsychiatry,166,875881.
http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/article.aspx?ar
ticleID=101023&atab=7
Salzer,S.,Winkelbach,C.,Leweke,F.,Leibing,
E.,&Leichsenring,F.(2011).Generalized
AnxietyDisorder:12-MonthFollow-Up.
CanadianJournalofPsychiatry,56(8).1-10.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24229
481
Lemma,A.,&Fonagy,P.(2013).Feasibility
studyofapsychodynamiconlinegroup
interventionfordepression.Psychoanalytic
Psychology,30(3),367–380.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/a0
033239
Lerner,A.,Sigal,M.,Bacalu,A.,&Gelkopf,M.
(1992).Shorttermversuslongterm
psychotherapyinopioiddependence:Apilot
study.IsraeliJournalofPsychiatryandRelated
Sciences,29(2),114–9.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15267
56
LevyBerg,A.,Sandell,R.,&Sandahl,C.(2009).
Affect-focusedbodypsychotherapyinpatients
withgeneralizedanxietydisorder:Evaluation
ofanintegrativemethod.Journalof
PsychotherapyIntegration,19(1),67–85.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/a
0015324
Liberman,R.P.,&Eckman,T.(1981).Behavior
therapyvsinsight-orientedtherapyfor
repeatedsuicideattempters.Archivesof
GeneralPsychiatry,38(10),1126–1130.
http://archpsyc.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx
?doi=10.1001/archpsyc.1981.0178035006000
7
Lindauer,R.J.L.,Gersons,B.P.R.,VanMeijel,
E.P.M.,Blom,K.,Carlier,I.V.E.,Vrijlandt,I.,
&Olff,M.(2005).Effectsofbriefeclectic
psychotherapyinpatientswithposttraumatic
stressdisorder:Randomizedclinicaltrial.
JournalofTraumaticStress,18(3),205–212.
http://doi.wiley.com/10.1002/jts.20029
Linnet,J.,&Jemec,G.B.(2001).Anxietylevel
andseverityofskinconditionpredicts
outcomeofpsychotherapyinatopic
dermatitispatients.IntJDermatol,40,632636.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11737
422
Lipsitz,J.D.,Gur,M.,Vermes,D.,Petkova,E.,
Cheng,J.,Miller,N.,…Fyer,A.J.(2008).A
randomizedtrialofinterpersonaltherapy
Generalizedanxiety
disorder(GAD)
Supportive-Expressive
Therapy(Luborsky,1984)
CBT(Borcovec&Rucio,
2001,Brown,1993)
Depression
OnlineGroupDynamic
InterpersonalTherapy
(OLDIT;Fonagy&Target,
2008)
Internetdiscussiongroup
Opiatedependence
Short-TermDynamic
Psychotherapy(Luborsky,
1989;Mann,1973;
Davanloo,1978)
Long-TermDynamic
Psychotherapy(Karasu,
1989)
Generalizedanxiety
disorder(GAD)
Affect-FocusedBody
Psychotherapy(Monsen&
Monsen,2000)
TAU
Repeatedsuicide
attempts
Insight-Oriented
Psychotherapy
BehaviorTherapy
PTSD
Briefeclectic
psychotherapy(BEP;
Gersonsetal.,2004;
ManualincludesbothCBT
andPDTcomponents)
Waitlist
Atopicdermatitis
(anxiety)
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(Malan,
1992)
Control(TAU?)
Socialanxietydisorder
(SAD)
Psychodynamic
SupportiveTherapy
(Lipsitzetal.,2006)
InterpersonalTherapy
(Klermanetal.,1984;
Weissmanetal.,2000)
110.
111.
112.
113.
114.
versussupportivetherapyforsocialanxiety
disorder.DepressionandAnxiety,25(6),542–
553.
http://doi.wiley.com/10.1002/da.20364
Lock,J.,Grange,D.Le,&Agras,W.(2010).
Randomizedclinicaltrialcomparingfamilybasedtreatmentwithadolescent-focused
individualtherapyforadolescentswith
anorexianervosa.ArchivesofGeneral
Psychiatry,67(10),1025–1032.
http://archpsyc.amaassn.org/cgi/reprint/67/10/1025.pdf
Lorentzen,S.,Ruud,T.,Fjeldstad,A.,&
Høglend,P.(2013).Comparisonofshort-and
long-termdynamicgrouppsychotherapy:
randomisedclinicaltrial.TheBritishjournalof
psychiatry :thejournalofmentalscience.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24029
539
Lorentzen,S.,Ruud,T.,Fjeldstad,A.,&
Høglend,P.a.(2014).Personalitydisorder
moderatesoutcomeinshort-andlong-term
groupanalyticpsychotherapy:Arandomized
clinicaltrial.TheBritishJournalofClinical
Psychology/theBritishPsychologicalSociety,
1–18.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25178
520
Fjeldstad,A.,Høglend,P.,&Lorentzen,S.
(2015).PatternsofChangeinInterpersonal
ProblemsDuringandAfterShort-termand
Long-termPsychodynamicGroupTherapy:A
RandomizedClinicalTrial.Psychotherapy
Research,3307(November),1–12.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080
/10503307.2015.1102357
Ludwig,G.,Krenz,S.,Zdrojewski,C.,Bot,M.,
Rousselle,I.,Stagno,D.,…Stiefel,F.(2013).
PsychodynamicinterventionsincancercareI:
psychometricresultsofarandomized
controlledtrial.Psycho-oncology,23,65-74.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23983
096
Maina,G.,Forner,F.,&Bogetto,F.(2005).
Randomizedcontrolledtrialcomparingbrief
dynamicandsupportivetherapywithwaiting
listconditioninminordepressivedisorders.
PsychotherPsychosom,74,43-50.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15627
856
Maina,G.,Rosso,G.,Crespi,C.,&Bogetto,F.
(2007).Combinedbriefdynamictherapyand
pharmacotherapyinthetreatmentofmajor
depressivedisorder:apilotstudy.
PsychotherapyandPsychosomatics,76(5),
298–305.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17700
050
Maina,G.,Rosso,G.,&Bogetto,F.(2009).
Briefdynamictherapycombinedwith
pharmacotherapyinthetreatmentofmajor
depressivedisorder:long-termresults.Journal
ofAffectiveDisorders,114(1-3),200–7.
Anorexia
AdolescentFocused
Therapy(AFT,Robinetal.)
TreatmentsFamily-Based
Treatment(FBT;Lockeet
al.,2001)
Anxietyandpersonality
disorders
Long-Term
PsychodynamicGroup
Terapy(Lorentzen,2013)
Short-Term
PsychodynamicGroup
Terapy(Lorentzen,2013)
Mixeddepressionand
anxiety(incancer
patients)
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(Mann,
1973;Davanloo,1994)
Waitlist
Depression(mildto
moderate)
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDP;
Malan,1979)
1.BriefSupportive
Psychotherapy(BSP;
Novalisetal.,1993))
2.Waitlist
Depression
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDP;
Malan,1963;1976)
+medication
BriefSupportive
Psychotherapy(BSP;
Novalisetal.,1993)
+medication
115.
116.
117.
118.
119.
120.
121.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18728
001
Maina,G.,Rosso,G.,Rigardetto,S.,Chiadò
Piat,S.,&Bogetto,F.(2010).Noeffectof
addingbriefdynamictherapyto
pharmacotherapyinthetreatmentof
obsessive-compulsivedisorderwith
concurrentmajordepression.Psychotherapy
andPsychosomatics,79(5),295–302.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20616
624
Marmar,C.R.,Horowitz,M.J.,Weiss,D.S.,
Wilner,N.R.,&Kaltreider,N.B.(1988).A
controlledtrialofbriefpsychotherapyand
mutual-helpgrouptreatmentofconjugal
bereavement.AmJPsychiatry,145,203-209.
http://ps.psychiatryonline.org/data/Journals/
AJP/3483/203.pdf
Martini,B.,Rosso,G.,Chiodelli,D.F.,DeCori,
D.,&Maina,G.(2011).Briefdynamictherapy
combinedwithpharmacotherapyinthe
treatmentofpanicdisorderwithconcurrent
depressivesymptoms.Clinical
Neuropsychiatry,8(3),204–21.
http://www.clinicalneuropsychiatry.org/pdf/0
4_martini.pdf
McCallum,M.,&Piper,W.E.(1990).A
controlledstudyofeffectivenessandpatient
suitabilityforshort-termgroup
psychotherapy.IntJGroupPsychother,40,
431-452.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22283
49
McLean,P.,&Hakstian,A.(1979).Clinical
depression:comparativeefficacyofoutpatient
treatments.JConsultClinPsychol,47,818836.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/38996
5
McMain,S.F.,Links,P.S.,Gnam,W.H.,
Guimond,T.,Cardish,R.J.,&Korman,L.,etal.
(2009).Arandomizedtrialofdialectical
behaviortherapyversusgeneralpsychiatric
managementforborderlinepersonality
disorder.AmJPsychiatry,166,1365-1374.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19755
574
McMain,S.,Guimond,T.,&Streiner,D.
(2012).DialecticalBehaviorTherapy
ComparedWithGeneralPsychiatric
ManagementforBorderlinePersonality
Disorder:ClinicalOutcomesandFunctioning
Overa2-YearFollow-Up.AmericanJournalof
Psychiatry,650–661.
http://www.neuro.psychiatryonline.org/articl
e.aspx?articleid=1148702&RelatedWidge
tArticles=true
Meyer,A.E.,&Bolz,W.(1981).TheHamburg
shortpsychotherapycomparisonexperiment.
Forewardandintroduction.Psychother
Psychosom,35,81-84.
http://www.karger.com/doi/10.1159/000287
OCD+depression
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDP;
Malan,1979)
+medication
Medicationonly
Bereavement
BriefDynamic
Psychotehrapy(BPD;
Malan,Sifneos;Mann)
MutualSelf-HelpGroups
Panicdisorder+
depression
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDP;
Malan,1963)
+medication
BriefSupportive
Psychotherapy(BSP)
+medication
Mixedsample
Short-term
psychoanalytically
orientedgroup
psychotherapy(STG;
manualmentionedbutno
specificreference)
Waitlist
Depression
Short-Term
Psychotherapy(Marmor,
1975;Wolberg,1967)
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Generalpsychiatric
management,dynamically
informedtherapy
(Gunderson,1984)
1.Relaxationtherapy(no
reference)
2.Behaviortherapy
(McLean,1976)
3.Drugtherapy
DialecticalBehavior
Therapy(DBT;Linehanet
al.,1991)
Mixedsample
Psychodynamicconflictcenteredtime-limited
psychotherapy(no
reference)
Waitlist
122.
123.
124.
125.
126.
127.
128.
129.
484
Miller,L.C.,Barrett,C.L.,Hampe,E.,&Noble,
H.(1972).Comparisonofreciprocalinhibition,
psychotherapy,andwaitinglistcontrolfor
phobicchildren.JournalofAbnormal
Psychology,79(3),269–279.
http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/abn/79/3/269
/
Milrod,B.,Chambless,D.L.,Gallop,R.,Busch,
F.N.,Schwalberg,M.,McCarthy,K.S.,…
Barber,J.P.(2015).PsychotherapiesforPanic
Disorder:ATaleofTwoSites.TheJournalof
ClinicalPsychiatry,10065,1–9.
http://www.psychiatrist.com/jcp/article/page
s/2015/aheadofprint/14m09507.aspx
Milrod,B.,Leon,A.C.,Busch,F.,Rudden,M.,
Schwalberg,M.,&Clarkin,J.,etal.(2007).A
randomizedcontrolledclinicaltrialof
psychoanalyticpsychotherapyforpanic
disorder.AmJPsychiatry,164,265-272.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17267
789
Monsen,K.,&Monsen,J.T.(2000).Chronic
PainandPsychodynamicBodyTherapy:A
ControlledOutcomeStudy.Psychotherapy:
Theory,Research,Practice,Training,37(3),
257–269.
http://psycnet.apa.org/index.cfm?fa=buy.opti
onToBuy&id=2000-02713-007
Montag,C.,Haase,L.,Seidel,D.,Bayerl,M.,
Gallinat,J.,Herrmann,U.,&Dannecker,K.
(2014).APilotRCTofPsychodynamicGroup
ArtTherapyforPatientsinAcutePsychotic
Episodes:Feasibility,ImpactonSymptomsand
MentalisingCapacity.PloSOne,9(11),
e112348.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articleren
der.fcgi?artid=4231093&tool=pmcentrez&ren
dertype=abstract
Munroe-Blum,H.,&Marziali,E.(1995).A
controlledtrialofshort-termgrouptreatment
forborderlinepersonalitydisorder.JPersonal
Disord,9,190-198.
http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/1996-17928001
Muran,J.C.,Safran,J.D.,Samstag,L.W.,&
Winston,A.(2005).Evaluatinganalliancefocusedtreatmentforpersonalitydisorders.
Psychotherapy:Theory,Research,Practice,
Training,42(4),532–545.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/0
033-3204.42.4.532
Safran,J.D.,Muran,J.C.,Samstag,L.W.,&
Winston,A.(2005).Evaluatingalliancefocusedinterventionforpotentialtreatment
failures:Afeasibilitystudyanddescriptive
analysis.Psychotherapy:Theory,Research,
Practice,Training,42(4),512–531.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/0
033-3204.42.4.512
Nader-MohammadiMoghadam,M.Atef
Vahid,M.K.,Asgharnejad-Farid,A.A.,
Phobia(children)
Playpsychotherapy
(Lippman,1956)
Reciprocalinhibition
Panicdisorder
Panic-Focused
Psychodynamic
Psychotherapy(PFPP;
Milrodetal,2001)
1.CBT(Craske,2000)
2.Appliedrelaxation(Öst
&Westling,1995)
Panicdisorder
Panic-Focused
Psychodynamic
Psychotherapy(PFPP;
Milrodetal,1997)
Appliedrelaxation(Öst&
Westling,1995)
Chronicpain
Psychodynamicbody
therapy(Monsen&
Monsen,1999)
TAU
Schizophrenia
Psychodynamicart
therapy(Dannecker,2010)
TAU
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Time-limitedgroup
therapy(Marziali&
Munroe-Blum,1995)
Individualpsychodynamic
psychotherapy(Kernberg,
1975)
Personalitydisorders
(mixed;mainlyclusterC)
BriefRelationalTherapy
(BRT;Safran&Muran,
2000)
1.Short-TermDynamic
Psychotherapy(STDP:Pol-
lack,Flegenheimer,&
Kaufman,1992)
2.Cognitive–behavioral
therapy(CBT;Turner&
Muran,1992;Beck,Free-
man,&Associates,1990)
Socialanxietydisorder
(SAD)
AffectPhobiaTherapy
(APT;McCulloughetal.,
1.Sertraline
130.
131.
132.
133.
134.
135.
136.
Shabani,A.,&Lavasni,F.(2015).Effectiveness
ofShort-termDynamicPsychotherapyversus
SertralineinTreatmentofSocialPhobia.Iran
JournalofPsychiatry,9(2),2–6.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26288
643
Nijdam,M.J.,Gersons,B.P.R.,Reitsma,J.B.,
deJongh,A.,&Olff,M.(2012).Briefeclectic
psychotherapyv.eyemovement
desensitisationandreprocessingtherapyfor
post-traumaticstressdisorder:randomised
controlledtrial.TheBritishJournalof
Psychiatry :TheJournalofMentalScience,
200(3),224–31.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22322
458
Ojehagen,A.,Berglund,M.,Appel,C.P.,
Andersson,K.,Nilsson,B.,&Skjaerris,A.,etal.
(1992).Arandomizedstudyoflong-termoutpatienttreatmentinalcoholics.Psychiatric
treatmentversusmultimodalbehavioural
therapy,during1versus2yearsoftreatment.
AlcoholAlcohol,27,649-658.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12924
38
Pierloot,R.,&Vinck,J.(1978).Differential
outcomeofshort-termdynamic
psychotherapyandsystematic
desensitizationsinthetreatmentofanxious
outpatients:Apreliminaryreport.
PsychologicaBelgica,18,87-98.
http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/1980-32873001
Piper,W.E.,Azim,H.F.,McCallum,M.,&
Joyce,A.S.(1990).Patientsuitabilityand
outcomeinshort-termindividual
psychotherapy.JConsultClinPsychol,58,475481.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22121
85
Piper,W.E.,Debbane,E.G.,Bienvenu,J.P.,&
Garant,J.(1984).Acomparativestudyoffour
formsofpsychotherapy.JConsultClinPsychol,
52,268-279.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/64253
78
Piper,W.E.,Joyce,aS.,McCallum,M.,&
Azim,H.F.(1998).Interpretiveandsupportive
formsofpsychotherapyandpatient
personalityvariables.Journalofconsulting
andclinicalpsychology,66(3),558–67.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10224
738
Piper,W.E.,McCallum,M.,Joyce,aS.,Azim,
H.F.,&Ogrodniczuk,J.S.(1999).Follow-up
findingsforinterpretiveandsupportiveforms
ofpsychotherapyandpatientpersonality
variables.Journalofconsultingandclinical
psychology,67(2),267–73.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10224
738
Piper,W.E.,McCallum,M.,Joyce,A.S.,Rosie,
2003)
2.Waitlist
PTSD
Briefeclectic
psychotherapy(BEP;
Gersonsetal,2004;
ManualincludesbothCBT
andPDTcomponents)
Eyemovementand
reprocessing(EMDR;De
Jonghetal,2004)
Alcoholdependence
“Psychiatrictreatment”
Multimodalbehavior
basedonpsychodynamic
therapy(Lazarus,1981)
principles(Luborsky,1984)
Anxiety
Short-TermDynamic
Psychotherapy(Malan,
1963)
Systematicdesensitization
(Wolpe,1969)
Mixedsample
STDP(Malan,1976;Strupp
&Binder,1984)
Waitlist
Mixedsample
Short-termindividual(STI;
Malan,1976)
Mixedsample
Interpretive
psychotherapy(Piper,
Azim,Joyce,&McCallum,
1993)
1.Short-termgroup(STG)
2.Long-termindividual
(LTI)
3.Long-termgroup(LTG)
Nonmanualsused
Supportivepsychotherapy
(Piper,Azim,Joyce,&
McCallum,1993)
Complicatedgrief
Interpretivegroup
Supportivegrouptherapy
137.
138.
139.
140.
141.
J.S.,&Ogrodniczuk,J.S.(2001).Patient
personalityandtime-limitedgroup
psychotherapyforcomplicatedgrief.IntJ
GroupPsychother,51,525-552.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11582
899
Piper,W.E.,Ogrodniczuk,J.S.,Joyce,A.S.,
Weideman,R.,&Rosie,J.S.(2007).Group
compositionandgrouptherapyfor
complicatedgrief.JournalofConsultingand
ClinicalPsychology,75(1),116–25.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17295
570
Piper,W.E.,Ogrodniczuk,J.S.,Joyce,A.S.,&
Weideman,R.(2009).Follow-upoutcomein
short-termgrouptherapyforcomplicated
grief.GroupDynamics:Theory,Research,and
Practice,13(1),46–58.
http://doi.apa.org/getdoi.cfm?doi=10.1037/a
0013830
Poulsen,A.(1991).Psychodynamic,time
limitedgrouptherapyinrheumaticdisease--a
controlledstudywithspecialreferenceto
alexithymia.PsychotherPsychosom,56,12-23.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18915
75
Poulsen,S.,Lunn,S.,Daniel,S.I.F.,Folke,S.,
Mathiesen,B.B.,Katznelson,H.,&Fairburn,C.
G.(2013).ARandomizedControlledTrialof
PsychoanalyticPsychotherapyorCognitiveBehavioralTherapyforBulimiaNervosa.The
Americanjournalofpsychiatry,1–8.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24275
909
Reneses,B.,Galián,M.,Serrano,R.,Figuera,
D.,FernandezDelMoral,A.,López-Ibor,J.J.,…
Trujillo,M.(2013).AnewTimeLimited
PsychotherapyforBPD:PreliminaryResultsof
aRandomizedandControlledTrial.Actas
españolasdepsiquiatría,41(3),139–48.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23803
797
Ridsdale,L.,Godfrey,E.,Chalder,T.,Seed,P.,
King,M.,Wallace,P.,&Wessely,S.(2001).
Chronicfatigueingeneralpractice:is
counsellingasgoodascognitivebehaviour
therapy?AUKrandomisedtrial.TheBritish
JournalofGeneralPractice :TheJournalofthe
RoyalCollegeofGeneralPractitioners,
51(462),19–24.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articleren
der.fcgi?artid=1313894&tool=pmcentrez&ren
dertype=abstract
Robin,AL.,Siegel,P.T.,&Moye,a.(1995).
Familyversusindividualtherapyforanorexia:
impactonfamilyconflict.TheInternational
JournalofEatingDisorders,17(4),313–22.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/76204
70
Robin,A.L.,Siegel,P.T.,Moye,A.W.,Gilroy,
M.,Dennis,A.B.,&Sikand,A.,etal.(1999).A
controlledcomparisonoffamilyversus
individualtherapyforadolescentswith
therapy
(nospecificreference)
(nospecificreference)
Rheumaticdisease
Time-limitedgroup
therapy(Foulkes,1975)
Waitlist
Bulimia
Psychoanalytic
Psychotherapyforbulimia
nervosa(Lunn&Poulsen,
2012)
CBT(Fairburn,2008)
Borderlinepersonality
disorder
Representationfocused
Psychotherapy(PRFP;
(Trujillo,2001;2010)
TAU
Chronicfatigue
Counselling
“…allcounsellorsuseda
psychodynamicapproach
andallcognitivebehaviour
therapistsusedCBT”(p.
20)
CBT
Anorexia
Ego-orientedindividual
therapy(EOIT)
(Robin,Siegel,Moye,
Koepke,&Tice,1994)
Behavioralfamilysystems
therapy(BFST;Robinet
al.,1994,1996)
142.
143.
144.
145.
146.
147.
148.
anorexianervosa.JAmAcadChildAdolesc
Psychiatry,38,1482-1489.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10596
247
Rosenbaum,B.,Harder,S.,Knudsen,P.,
Køster,A.,Lindhardt,A.,Lajer,M.,…Winther,
G.(2012).SupportivePsychodynamic
PsychotherapyversusTreatmentasUsualfor
First-EpisodePsychosis:Two-YearOutcome.
Psychiatry,75(4),331–41.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23244
011
Harder,S.,Koester,A.,Valbak,K.,&
Rosenbaum,B.(2014).Five-yearfollow-upof
supportivepsychodynamicpsychotherapyin
first-episodepsychosis:long-termoutcomein
socialfunctioning.Psychiatry,77(2),155–68.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24865
198
Rosser,R.,Denford,J.,Heslop,A.,Kinston,W.,
Macklin,D.,&Minty,K.,etal.(1983).
Breathlessnessandpsychiatricmorbidityin
chronicbronchitisandemphysema:astudyof
psychotherapeuticmanagement.Psychol
Med,13,93-110.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/68444
71
Rosso,G.,Martini,B.,&Maina,G.(2012).
Briefdynamictherapyanddepression
severity:Asingle-blind,randomizedstudy.
Journalofaffectivedisorders,1–6.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23174
499
Rossouw,T.I.,&Fonagy,P.(2012).
Mentalization-basedtreatmentforself-harm
inadolescents:arandomizedcontrolledtrial.
JournaloftheAmericanAcademyofChildand
AdolescentPsychiatry,51(12),1304–1313.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23200
287
Salminen,J.K.,Karlsson,H.,Hietala,J.,
Kajander,J.,Aalto,S.,&Markkula,J.,etal.
(2008).Short-termpsychodynamic
psychotherapyandfluoxetineinmajor
depressivedisorder:arandomized
comparativestudy.PsychotherPsychosom,
77,351-357.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18701
831
Salomonsson,B.,&Sandell,R.(2011).A
randomizedcontrolledtrialofmother–infant
psychoanalytictreatment:I.Outcomesonselfreportquestionnairesandexternalratings.
InfantMentalHealthJournal,32(2),207–231.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/i
mhj.20291/full
Salzer,S.,Cropp,C.,Jaeger,U.,Masuhr,O.,&
Streeck-Fischer,a.(2013).Psychodynamic
therapyforadolescentssufferingfromcomorbiddisordersofconductandemotionsin
anin-patientsetting:arandomizedcontrolled
trial.Psychologicalmedicine,1–10.
Schizophrenia
Supportive
Psychodynamic
Psychotherapy(SPP;
Rosenbaum,2009)
TAU
Breathlessnessand
psychiatricmorbidity(in
patientswithchronic
bronchitisand
emphysema)
Analyticalpsychotherapy
(Nospecificreference)
1.Notreatment
2.Nursesupport
Depression
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDP;
Malan,1976)
BriefSupportive
Psychotherapy(BSP;
Novalisetal.,1993)
Self-harm(adolescents)
Mentalization-based
treatmentforadolescents
(MBT-A;Rossouw,
unpublished)
TAU
Depression
Short-term
psychodynamic
psychotherapy(STDP;
Malan,1976;Mann,1973)
Fluoxitine
Motherswhoworry
aboutchild
Mother–infant
psychoanalytictreatment
(MIP;Norman,2001;
2004)
ChildHealthCenterCare
(TAU)
Mixedsampleof
adolescentes
Psychoanalytic-
interactionalmethod
(PiM;Streeck&
Leichsenring,2009;
Leichsenringetal.,2010)
Waitlist/TAU
149.
150.
151.
152.
153.
154.
155.
156.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24229
481
Sanchez,V.C.,Lewinsohn,P.M.,&Larson,D.
W.(1980).Assertiontraining:effectivenessin
thetreatmentofdepression.JClinPsychol,36,
526-529.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/73728
26
Sandahl,C.,Herlitz,K.,Ahlin,G.,&Rönnberg,
S.(1998).Time-limitedgrouppsychotherapy
formoderatelyalcoholdependentpatients:A
randomizedcontrolledclinicaltrial.
PsychotherapyResearch,8,361-378.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080
/10503309812331332467
Sandahl,C.,Lundberg,U.,Lindgren,A.,
Rylander,G.,Herlofson,J.,Nygren,A.,&
Asberg,M.(2011).Twoformsofgroup
therapyandindividualtreatmentofworkrelateddepression:aone-yearfollow-up
study.Internationaljournalofgroup
psychotherapy,61(4),539–55.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21985
258
Sattel,H.,Lahmann,C.,Gündel,H.,Guthrie,
E.,Kruse,J.,Noll-Hussong,M.,…Henningsen,
P.(2011).Briefpsychodynamicinterpersonal
psychotherapyforpatientswith
multisomatoformdisorder:randomised
controlledtrial.TheBritishjournalof
psychiatry :thejournalofmentalscience,60–
67.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22075
651
Saunders,D.G.(1996).Feminist-cognitive
behavioralandprocess-psychodynamic
treatmentsformenwhobatter:interactionof
abusertraitsandtreatmentmodels.Violence
Vict,11,393-414.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/92102
79
Scheidt,C.E.,Waller,E.,Endorf,K.,Schmidt,
S.,König,R.,Zeeck,A.,…Lacour,M.(2012).Is
briefpsychodynamicpsychotherapyin
primaryfibromyalgiasyndromewith
concurrentdepressionaneffective
treatment ?Arandomizedcontrolledtrial.
Generalhospitalpsychiatry.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23218
844
Schnyder,U.,&Müller,J.(2011).BriefEclectic
PsychotherapyforPTSD:ARandomized
ControlledTrial.TheJournalofClinical…,564–
566.
http://europepmc.org/abstract/MED/2152712
7
Shaffer,H.J.,LaSalvia,T.A.,&Stein,J.P.
(1997).ComparingHathayogawithdynamic
grouppsychotherapyforenhancing
methadonemaintenancetreatment:a
randomizedclinicaltrial.AlternTherHealth
Med,3,57-66.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/92107
Depression
“Traditional”Group
Therapy
(Nospecificreference)
Assertiontraining
Alcoholdependence
Time-limitedgroup
psychotherapy(Foulkes,
1964)
Cognitive-behavioural
grouptherapy(Annis,
1986;Marlatt&Gor-don,
1985;Sandahland
Ronnberg,1990)
Depression(workrelated)
Focusedpsychodynamic
grouptherapy(FGT;
Sandahl&Lindgren,2003)
1.CognitiveGroup
Therapy(nospecific
reference)
2.Comparisoncondition
Multisomatoform
disorder
Psychodynamicinterpersonal
psychotherapy(Guthrie,
2011;Henningesen,2011)
Enhancedmedcialcare
Violentmen
Process-psychodynamic
grouptherapy(PPT;
Browne,Saunders,&
Staecker,inpress)
Feminist-groupCBT(FCBT;
Browne,Saunders,&
Staecker,inpress)
Fibromyaligia+
depression
Psychodynamicinterpersonal
psychotherapy(Hobson,
1985;Goldbergetal.,
1984;Guthrie,2013)
TAU
PTSD
Briefeclectic
psychotherapy(BEP;
Gersonsetal,2004;
ManualincludesbothCBT
andPDTcomponents)
Minimalattentioncontrol
Opiateaddiction
Dynamicgroup
psychotherapy
Hathayogatherapy
157.
158.
159.
160.
161.
162.
163.
164.
77
Shapiro,D.A.,Barkham,M.,Rees,A.,Hardy,
G.E.,Reynolds,S.,&Startup,M.,etal.(1994).
Effectsoftreatmentdurationandseverityof
depressionontheeffectivenessofcognitivebehavioralandpsychodynamic-interpersonal
psychotherapy.JConsultClinPsychol,62,522534.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/80639
78
Shapiro,D.,&Firth,J.(1987).Prescriptivev.
ExploratoryPsychotherapyOutcomesofthe
SheffieldPsychotherapyProject.TheBritish
JournalofPsychiatry,151,790-799
http://bjp.publicaciones.saludcastillayleon.es/
content/151/6/790.short
Shapiro,D.a,&Firth-Cozens,J.(1990).Twoyearfollow-upoftheSheffieldPsychotherapy
Project.TheBritishjournalofpsychiatry,157,
389–91.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22452
69
Shaw,C.M.,Margison,F.R.,Guthrie,E.A.,&
Tomenson,B.(2001).Psychodynamic
interpersonaltherapybyinexperienced
therapistsinanaturalisticsetting:Apilot
study.EuropeanJournalofPsychotherapy,
Counselling,andHealth,4,87–101.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080
/13642530110040091
Shefler,G.,Dasberg,H.,&Ben-Shakhar,G.
(1995).Arandomizedcontrolledoutcomeand
follow-upstudyofMann'stime-limited
psychotherapy.JConsultClinPsychol,63,585593.
http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/ccp/63/4/585
/
Simpson,S.,Corney,R.,Fitzgerald,P.,&
Beecham,J.(2003).Arandomizedcontrolled
trialtoevaluatetheeffectivenessand
costeffectivenessofpsychodynamic
counsellingforgeneralpracticepatientswith
chronicdepression.PsycholMed,33,229-239.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12622
302
Sjodin,I.,Svedlund,J.,Ottosson,J.O.,&
Dotevall,G.(1986).Controlledstudyof
psychotherapyinchronicpepticulcerdisease.
Psychosomatics,27,187-91,195.
http://www.psychosomaticsjournal.com/articl
e/S0033-3182(86)72711-4/abstract
Sleed,M.,Baradon,T.,&Fonagy,P.(2013).
NewBeginningsformothersandbabiesin
prison:Aclusterrandomizedcontrolledtrial.
Attachment&HumanDevelopment,15(4),
349–67.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23550
526
Sloane,R.B.,Staples,F.R.,Cristol,A.H.,
Yorkston,N.J.,&Whipple,K.(1975).Shorttermanalyticallyorientedpsychotherapy
versusbehaviortherapy.AmericanJournalof
Depression
Psychodynamicinterpersonal
psychotherapy(Hobson,
1985;Goldbergetal.,
1984)
CognitiveTherapy(CT;
Beck,Rush,Shaw,and
Emery,1979)
Deressionandanxiety
Exploratorytherapy(no
specificreference)
Prescriptivetherapy(no
specificreference)
Mixedsample
Psychodynamicinterpersonal
psychotherapy(Hobson,
1985)
Waitlist
Mixedsample
Time-Limited
Psychotherapy(TLP;
Mann,1973)
Waitlist
Depression(chronic)
Psychodynamic
counselling(Burton,1998)
Generalpractice
Pepticulcerdisease
Short-TermDynamic
Therapy(Malan,1976)
Medication
Highriskmothers(and
theirbabies)inprison
Attachment-based
intervention(Baradon,
2006)
Standardhealthandsocial
care
Anxietyorpersonality
disorder
Short-TermAnalytically
OrientedPsychotherapy
(nospecificreference)
1.Waitlist
2.BehaviorTherapy
(nospecificreference)
165.
166.
167.
168.
169.
170.
171.
172.
Psychiatry,132,373-377.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11195
88
Smyrnios,K.X.,&Kirkby,R.J.(1993).Long
termcomparisonofbriefversusunlimited
psychodynamictreatmentswithchildrenand
theirparents.JConsultClinPsychol,61,10201027.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/81134
79
Snyder,D.K.,Wills,R.M.,&Grady-Fletcher,a.
(1991).Long-termeffectivenessofbehavioral
versusinsight-orientedmaritaltherapy:a4yearfollow-upstudy.JournalofConsulting
andClinicalPsychology,59(1),138–41.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20021
29
Sørensen,P.,Birket-Smith,M.,Wattar,U.,
Buemann,I.,&Salkovskis,P.(2010).A
randomizedclinicaltrialofcognitive
behaviouraltherapyversusshort-term
psychodynamicpsychotherapyversusno
interventionforpatientswith
hypochondriasis.PsycholMed,1-11.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20380
779
Stanton,A.H.,Gunderson,J.G.,Knapp,P.H.,
Frank,A.F.,Vancelli,M.L.,&Schnitzer,R.,et
al.(1984).Effectsofpsychotherapyin
schizophrenia:I.Designandimplementation
ofacontrolledstudy.SchizophrBull,10,520563.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/61512
45
Steinert,C.,Bumke,P.J.,Hollekamp,R.L.,
Larisch,A.,Leichsenring,F.,Mattes,H.,…
Kruse,J.(2016).Treatingpost-traumaticstress
disorderbyresourceactivationinCambodia.
WorldPsychiatry,15(2),182–183.
http://doi.org/10.1002/wps.20312
Svartberg,M.,Seltzer,M.H.,&Stiles,T.C.
(1998).Theeffectsofcommonandspecific
factorsinshort-termanxiety-provoking
psychotherapy:apilotprocess-outcome
study.JNervMentDis,186,691-696.
http://journals.lww.com/jonmd/Abstract/199
8/11000/The_Effects_of_Common_and_Speci
fic_Factors_in.5.aspx
Svartberg,M.,Stiles,T.C.,&Seltzer,M.H.
(2004).Randomized,controlledtrialofthe
effectivenessofshort-termdynamic
psychotherapyandcognitivetherapyfor
clusterCpersonalitydisorders.AmJ
Psychiatry,161,810-817.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15121
645
Svedlund,J.,Sjodin,I.,Ottosson,J.O.,&
Dotevall,G.(1983).Controlledstudyof
psychotherapyinirritablebowelsyndrome.
Lancet,2,589-592.
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articleren
der.fcgi?artid=3240791&tool=pmcentrez&ren
dertype=abstract
Childrenwithmixed
problems
Time-limitedbrief
psychotherapy(Smyrnios,
Kirkby,Smyrnios,&
Picone,1987)
Time-unlimited
psychotherapy(Klein,
1975;Segal,1978)
Coupleswithrelational
problems
Insight-OrientedMarital
Therapy(IOMT;nospecific
reference)
BehavioralMartial
Therapy(BMT;nospecific
reference)
Hypochondriasis
Short-Term
Psychodynamic
Psychotherapy
(Nospecificreference)
1.Cognitive-behavioural
Therapy(CBT;Salkovskis,
1989;Warwick,1989;
Salkovskisetal.2003)
2.Waitlist
Schizophrenia(nonchronic)
Expressive,insightorientedpsychotherapy
(EIO;Stanton,inpress)
Reality-adaptive,
supportivetherapy(RAS;
May,1968)
PTSD
Resource-Oriented
TraumaTherapy(see
article)
Waitlist
Mixedsample
Short-termanxietyprovokingpsychotherapy
(STAPP;Sifneos,1992)
Non-directive
Psychotherapy(NDP;
utveckladesspecifictför
studien)
Personalitydisorder
(ClusterC)
Short-TermDynamic
Psychotherapy(STDP;
McCulloughVaillant,1997)
CognitiveTherapy(CT;
Beck&Freeeman,1990)
IBS
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(Malan,
1979)
Treatmentasusual(TAU)
(medical)
173.
174.
175.
176.
177.
178.
179.
Szapocznik,J.,Rio,A.,Murray,E.,Cohen,R.,
Scopetta,M.,&Rivas-Vazquez,A.,etal.
(1989).Structuralfamilyversus
psychodynamicchildtherapyforproblematic
Hispanicboys.J.Consult.Clin.Psychol.,57,571578.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27941
77
Behavioralproblems
amongboys
Individualpsychodynamic
childtherapy(IPCT)
(Adams,1974;Cooper&
Wanerman,1977)
1.StructuralFamily
Therapy(SFT;Minuchin&
Fishman,1981;Minuchin,
Montalvo,Guerney,
Rosman,&Schuman,
1967)
2.Recreationalcontrol
condition
Groupcognitive-behavior
therapy(GCBT;Wilfleyet
al.,1996)
Tasca,G.,Ritchie,K.,Conrad,G.,Balfour,L.,
Gayton,J.,&Lybanon,V.,etal.(2006).
Attachmentscalespredictoutcomeina
randomizedcontrolledtrialoftwogroup
therapiesforbingeeatingdisorder:An
aptitudebytreatmentinteraction.
PsychotherapyResearch,16,106-121.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080
/10503300500090928
Thompson,L.W.,Gallagher,D.,&
Breckenridge,J.S.(1987).Comparative
effectivenessofpsychotherapiesfor
depressedelders.JConsultClinPsychol,55,
385-390.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35979
53
Bingeeatingdisorder
Grouppsychodynamic
interpersonal
psychotherapy(Tascaet
al.,2002;Strupp&Binder,
1984;Malan1979)
Depression(among
elderly)
Briefpsychodynamic
therapy(Horowitz&
Kaltreider,1979)
Thyme,K.E.,Sundin,E.C.,Stahlberg,G.,
Lindstrom,B.,Eklof,H.,&Wiberg,B.,etal.
(2007).Theoutcomeofshort-term
psychodynamicarttherapycomparedto
short-termpsychodynamicverbaltherapyfor
depressedwomen.Psychoanalytic
Psychotherapy,21,250-264.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080
/02668730701535610
Trowell,J.,Joffe,I.,Campbell,J.,Clemente,C.,
Almqvist,F.,&Soininen,M.,etal.(2007).
Childhooddepression:aplacefor
psychotherapy.Anoutcomestudycomparing
individualpsychodynamicpsychotherapyand
familytherapy.EurChildAdolescPsychiatry,
16,157-167.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17200
793
Garoff,F.F.,Heinonen,K.,Pesonen,A.-K.,&
Almqvist,F.(2012).Depressedyouth:
treatmentoutcomeandchangesinfamily
functioninginindividualandfamilytherapy.
JournalofFamilyTherapy,34(1),4–23.
http://doi.wiley.com/10.1111/j.14676427.2011.00541.x
Trowell,J.,Kolvin,I.,Weeramanthri,T.,
Sadowski,H.,Berelowitz,M.,&Glaser,D.,et
al.(2002).Psychotherapyforsexuallyabused
girls:psychopathologicaloutcomefindings
andpatternsofchange.BrJPsychiatry,180,
234-247.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11872
516
Vinnars,B.,Barber,J.P.,Norén,K.,Gallop,R.,
&Weinryb,R.M.(2005).Manualized
Depression(among
women)
Short-Term
PsychodynamicVerbal
Therapy(Mann,1973)
Depression(children)
FocusedIndividual
Psychotherapy(Malan&
Osmimo,1992;Davanloo,
1978)
SystemsIntegrative
FamilyTherapy(ByungHall,1995;Will,1985)
Trauma(sexuallyabused
girls)
Individualtherapy
(Unclearwithno
reference)
Psychopedagogical
/analyticgrouptherapy
Personalitydisorder
(mixed)
Supportive-Expressive
Psychotherapy(SE;
Non-manualizedPDT
1.CognitiveTherapy(CT;
Beck,Rush,Shaw,&
Emery,1979)
2.BehavioralTherapy(BT;
Gallagher&Thompson,
1981;Lewinsohn,1974)
3.Delayed-treatment
control
Artpsychotherapy
(noreference)
180.
181.
182.
183.
184.
supportive-expressivepsychotherapyversus
nonmanualizedcommunity-delivered
psychodynamictherapyforpatientswith
personalitydisorders:bridgingefficacyand
effectiveness.AmJPsychiatry,162,19331940.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16199
841
Vinnars,B.,Gallop,R.,&Barber,J.P.(2009).
DoPersonalityProblemsImproveDuring
PsychodynamicSupportive-Expressive
Psychotherapy?SecondaryOutcomeResults
FromaRandomizedControlledTrialfor
PsychiatricOutpatientswithPersonality
Disorders.Psychotherapy,46,362–375.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20161
588
Vitriol,V.G.,Ballesteros,S.T.,Florenzano,R.
U.,Weil,K.P.,&Benadof,D.F.(2009).
Evaluationofanoutpatientinterventionfor
womenwithseveredepressionandahistory
ofchildhoodtrauma.PsychiatrServ,60,936942.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19564
224
Watzke,B.,Rüddel,H.,Jürgensen,R.,Koch,U.,
Kriston,L.,Grothgar,B.,&Schulz,H.(2010).
Effectivenessofsystematictreatment
selectionforpsychodynamicandcognitivebehaviouraltherapy:randomisedcontrolled
trialinroutinementalhealthcare.TheBritish
JournalofPsychiatry :TheJournalofMental
Science,197(2),96–105.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20679
260
Watzke,B.,Rüddel,H.,Jürgensen,R.,Koch,U.,
Kriston,L.,Grothgar,B.,&Schulz,H.(2012).
Longertermoutcomeofcognitive-behavioural
andpsychodynamicpsychotherapyinroutine
mentalhealthcare:Randomisedcontrolled
trial.Behaviourresearchandtherapy,50(9),
580–587.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22750
189
Wiborg,I.M.,&Dahl,A.A.(1996).Doesbrief
dynamicpsychotherapyreducetherelapse
rateofpanicdisorder?ArchGenPsychiatry,
53,689-694.
http://archpsyc.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx
?doi=10.1001/archpsyc.1996.0183008004100
8
Wiltink,J.,Dippel,A.,Szczepanski,M.,Thiede,
R.,Alt,C.,&Beutel,M.E.,etal.(2007).Longtermweightlossmaintenanceafterinpatient
psychotherapyofseverelyobesepatients
basedonarandomizedstudy:predictorsand
maintainingfactorsofhealthbehavior.J
PsychosomRes,62,691-698.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17540
227
Winston,A.,Pollack,J.,McCullough,L.,
Flegenheimer,W.,Kestenbaum,R.,&Trujillo,
M.,etal.(1991).Briefpsychotherapyof
personalitydisorders.JNervMentDis,179,
Luborsky,1984)
Depression(+childhood
trauma)
Briefpsychodynamic
psychotherapy
(Kudleretal,2003;Davies
etal,1994)
TAU
Mixedsample
Psychodynamicbrief
grouptherapy(Heigl-Evers
etal.,1997)
Cognitive-behavioural
grouptherapy(Fiedler,
2001)
Panicdisorder
BriefDynamic
Psychotherapy(BDP;
Davanloo,1978;Malan
1976;1979;Strupp&
Binder,1984)
Clomipraminalone
Severeobesity
Psychodynamicinpatient
treatment(nomanualbut
referenceto:Levine&
Luborsky,1981)
Behavioraltreatment
(nospecificreference)
Personalitydisorders
(mixed)
Short-TermDynamic
Therapy(STDP;Davanloo,
1980;Alsoreferenceto
Mann,Malan,andSifneos)
BriefAdaptive
Psychotherapy(BAP;
Pollacketal.,1991)
185.
186.
187.
188-193.
http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/1991-25198001
Winston,A,Laikin,M.,Pollack,J.,Samstag,L.
W.,McCullough,L.,&Muran,J.C.(1994).
Short-termpsychotherapyofpersonality
disorders.TheAmericanjournalofpsychiatry,
151(2),190–4.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22217
220
Woody,G.E.,Luborsky,L.,McLellan,A.T.,
O'Brien,C.P.,Beck,A.T.,&Blaine,J.,etal.
(1983).Psychotherapyforopiateaddicts.Does
ithelp?ArchGenPsychiatry,40,639-645.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/68473
32
Woody,G.E.,Luborsky,L.,Mclellan,A.T.,&
O’Brien,C.P.(1990).CorrectionsandRevised
analysesforPsychotherapyinMethandone
Patients.ArchGenPsychiatry,47,788-789.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23785
51
Woody,G.E.,McLellan,A.T.,Luborsky,L.,&
O'Brien,C.P.(1995).Psychotherapyin
communitymethadoneprograms:Avalidation
study.AmericanJournalofPsychiatry,152,
1302-1308.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/76536
85
Zipfel,S.,Wild,B.,Groß,G.,Friederich,H.,
Teufel,M.,Schellberg,D.,…Zwaan,M.De.
(2013).ArticlesFocalpsychodynamictherapy,
cognitivebehaviourtherapy,andoptimised
treatmentasusualinoutpatientswith
anorexianervosa(ANTOPstudy):randomised
controlledtrial.TheLancet,383,127–137.
http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/ar
ticle/PIIS0140-6736(13)61746-8/abstract
Opiatedependence
Supportive-Expressive
Psychotherapy(SE;
Luborsky,1977;
unpublishedmanual)
Cognitive-Behavior
Therapy(CBT;Beck,
unpublished)
DrugCounseling(DC;
Stockdale&Hargrove,
unpublishedmaterial,
1977)
Opiatedependence
Supportive-Expressive
Psychotherapy(SE;
Luborsky,1984)
Drugcounseling
Anorexia
Focalpsychodynamic
therapy(FPT;Schauenburg
etal.,2009)
1.Enhancedcognitive
behaviourtherapy(CBT-E;
Fairburn,2008)
2.OptimisedTAU