More than just a movement problem

DEVELOPMENTAL COORDINATION DISORDER:
MORE THAN JUST A MOVEMENT PROBLEM
Professor Beth Hands
WHAT IS DCD?
 Performance
in daily activities that require motor
coordination is substantially below that expected
given the person’s chronological age and measured
intelligence This may be manifested by marked
delays in achieving motor milestones (e.g., walking,
crawling, sitting), dropping things, “clumsiness”,
poor performance in sports, or poor handwriting.
 This disturbance significantly interferes with
academic achievement or activities of daily living.
 The disturbance is not due to a general medical
condition (e.g., cerebral palsy, hemiplegia, or
muscular dystrophy)
DSM5, 2013
HOW IS IT MANIFESTED?
Poor fine motor skills (e.g., writing)
 Poor gross motor skills (e.g., running)
 Speech may lack fluency
 Abnormal muscle tone (hypo/hyper tonia)
 Poor body awareness (kinaesthesis)
 Difficulties with gross motor sequencing

DCD

Prevalence estimates of between 5% and 19%
depending on measure and age group

Gender differences - findings are inconclusive but some
suggestion of higher prevalence in boys
CONSEQUENCES…. THE EVIDENCE

Physical consequences


Social consequences


Low physical fitness
Social isolation
Psychological consequences


Reduced self esteem
Perceived motor competence
BACKGROUND TO THE AMPITUP PROGRAM
Adolescents with DCD have low physical fitness
 Aerobic fitness
 Muscle strength
 Muscle endurance
 Flexibility
 Body composition
(Hands & Larkin, 2006)
POSSIBLE REASONS?
Long term limited participation in physical activity
 Inefficiency and inconsistency of movement patterns
 Movement overflow
 Early fatigue
 Low levels of motivation

A NEGATIVE CYCLE.....
Low Fitness
Modifiable
factors
Mediating Variables
Low Motor
Competence
Individual:
Genetic predisposition
Self-perceptions
Physical maturity
Environment:
Social pressures
Physical constraints
Hypoactivity
Hands and Larkin (2002)
THE AMPITUP PROGRAM
13 weeks/semester
 Twice per week
 90 minutes per session







30 mins hydrotherapy
pool/week
Cardio
Strength
Flexibility
Skill development
1:1 training
AMPITUP: YEARLY CYCLE
AMPitup
13 weeks
Pre Int 1
Post Int 1
8 week
break
Pre Int 2
AMPitup
13 weeks
Post Int 2
13 week break before commencing each new
year
A TYPICAL AMPITUP SESSION
10 mins
10 mins
20 mins
10 mins
10 mins
30 mins
30 mins
Warm –up ergometer (bike, treadmill, cross trainer)
Mat work- balance, steps, fit balls, boxing
Strength and resistance (machines, weights)
Cardio ( ergometers, stairs…)
Strength and resistance ( machines , weights)
Hydrotherapy pool – group work, strength, cardio
OR
Mat work, cool down
PERCEIVED EXERTION RATING

































DO ADOLESCENTS WITH DCD HAVE LOWER BONE MINERAL DENSITY
MEASURES THAN TYPICALLY DEVELOPING ADOLESCENTS?
BACKGROUND
•
Low bone strength, bone mass, and cortical
thickness are related to increased fracture risk
(Clark, Tobias & Ness; Davies, et al.,2005; Ma & Jones, 2003a).
•
Risk factors for low BMD include low vitamin D,
low calcium, obesity and low physical activity.
•
Adolescents with motor difficulties (DCD) have
low levels of physical activity and therefore may
be at risk of low BMD and subsequently
increased fracture risk.
BACKGROUND

Limited research into the relationship between motor
coordination and fracture incidence

Low coordination was associated with wrist and
forearm fractures in 321 children between 9-16 years
(Ma, Morely & Jones; 2004).

In a sample of 49 adolescents attending our clinic,
48.1% reported frequent falls and 22.4% have had one
or more fractures.
Therefore exercise-induced gains in bone mass in children and
adolescents may be critical (Kohrt, Bloomfield, Little, Nelson & Yingling, 2004).
PERIPHERAL QUANTITATIVE COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY (PQCT)
Minimal radiation exposure
Tibia and Radius Measures




volumetric bone mineral
density
3D Bone geometry
Bone strength -Stress Strain
Index (SSI) and Fracture Risk
Cortical and trabecular bone
compartments, muscle mass
Radius 66%
(Cortical)
PQCT SCANS
Radius 4%
(Trabecular)
Cortical
Bone
Trabecular Bone
PQCT NORMATIVE DATA
Radius 4% trabecular
Radius 66% cortical
Radius 4% total density
SSI 66%
Bone Mineral Density measures (N = 21)
Site
Measure
Radius
4% Trabecular density
(mg/cm3)
Z-score
M (SD)
192.14 (40.02)
-1.60 (1.29)
1042.65 (73.84)
-0.36 (1.41)
66% SSI
190.87 (45.23)
-1.13 (0.72)
4% Trabecular density
(mg/cm3)
273.30 (35.64)
-0.31 (1.34)
1035.62 (49.95)
0.01 (1.04)
1746.32 (427.21)
-0.78 (0.90)
66% Cortical density (mg/cm3)
Tibia
Raw Score
M (SD)
66% Cortical density (mg/cm3)
66% SSI
SELF PERCEPTIONS AND DCD
Can a 13 week individually tailored exercise intervention
improve self-perceptions in the physical domain among
adolescents with DCD?
PHYSICAL SELF PERCEPTION PROFILE (PSSP) AND
PERCEIVED IMPORTANCE PROFILE (PIP) (FOX & CORBIN, 1990)
•
PSPP:
Comprising five 6 item subscales
▫ Four of these (sports competence (SC), physical conditioning (PC),
attractiveness of body (AB), and physical strength (PS)) assess
perceptions within specific sub domains.
▫ A fifth subscale measures global physical self–worth (PSW), that
reflects feelings of satisfaction with the physical self
▫
•
PIP:
▫
Participants also completed the Perceived Importance Profile which
consists of four 2 item subscales that measure level of importance
attached to each domain of PSW.
X
X
CHANGES IN PHYSICAL SELF-PERCEPTIONS (N = 35)
16
*
*
14
12
Pre
Post
10
8
Physical selfworth
* p<.05
Physical
condition
Sport
competence
Attractive
body
Physical
strength
IMPORTANCE RATINGS (N = 35)
5.3
5.2
5.1
5
4.9
Pre
4.8
Post
4.7
4.6
4.5
4.4
Physical
condition
Attractive body
Physical
strength
Sport
competence
PREDICTORS OF PHYSICAL SELF WORTH (PSW)
Pre test:

Attractive Body and Physical Strength were predictors of PSW
(F=22.915, p<.001)
Post test:

Attractive Body, Physical Strength and Physical Condition were
predictors of PSW (F=22.78, p<.001)
CONCLUSION
•
•
•
•
The observed improvements in specific sub-domains of physical
self-worth were directly related to the focus of the intervention.
Participants showed increases in perceptions of physical condition
(PC), and physical strength (PS) as well as actual improvements in
fitness and strength.
Changes in physical self perceptions can be facilitated by an
individually tailored intervention in a supportive environment that
focuses on fitness and strength, and that these can occur after a
relatively short period of time.
Results demonstrate the effectiveness of appropriate programs for
adolescents with DCD when positive attitudes towards exercise are
encouraged.
EXPERIENCES OF ADOLESCENTS WITH DCD WITH BULLYING
To determine the prevalence of bullying among
adolescents with DCD, identify the impact of the
bullying and the type of coping strategies used.
PREVALENCE AND TYPE

Prevalence

12/15 participants (80%) reported being bullied
75% of the males
 86% of the females


Type of bullying
name calling
 exclusion
 being punched or pushed
 nasty stories spread.

COPING STRATEGIES
Active strategies:
told an adult (75%)
 told a friend (33%)
 made new friends (25%)

Passive strategies:
avoided or ignored bullies (43%)
 dealt by self (43%)

WHY WERE THEY BULLIED?
 Academic
delay or learning difficulties
 Appearance – lack of worldliness, new to school,
perceived weakness, not athletic, not as
psychologically able.
Parents believed this contributed to low self esteem and social isolation
“...these other kids can kind of pick up on these children with learning
difficulties, sweetness, innocence, lack of worldliness; because they do
have quite a beautiful side to them. But some other kids can pick up on
that and hone in on it and see it as a weakness, whereas it’s actually a
lovely quality.”
MEASURING PHYSICAL FITNESS
 Children
and adolescents with DCD have lower
physical fitness (Cairney et al, 2007; Hands & Larkin, 2002, 2006).
 Most fitness tests require a reasonable level of
coordination to perform.
 Potential confounders to the measurement of fitness
in adolescents with DCD:


Poor coordination (Hands & Larkin, 2002)
Variable and inconsistent movement patterns
2011; Smits-Engelman et al., 2001)
(King et al,
THE QUESTIONS:
Are we using the right tests to measure physical fitness
in children and adolescents with DCD?
 What tests are best able to detect change
(improvement/regression)?

THE PARTICIPANTS
Age (mths)
MAND NDI
BMI (wt/ht2)
(mean)
Waist circumference (cm)
Note: No significant group differences
Males
Females
25
166.70
65.50
22.21
80.08
15
166.0
59.00
21.88
77.20
RESULTS
PWC170/kg
MSFT (shuttles)
Vertical jump (ins)
SBJ (ins)
Curl ups (n)
Chest pass (cm)
Grip strength (kg)
Sit and reach (cm)
Trunk lift (cm)
Balance (secs)
Pre
1.91
Post
2.01
LMM
.52
19.36
23.63
41.78
24.22
24.84
42.89
.054
.62
.65
11.97
364.30
19.56
391.94
.02
.33
33.86
15.71
19.78
57.25
41.04
16.94
22.05
60.78
.03
.53
.13
.50
LMM adjusting for occasion, gender, age and number of sessions attended
MULTI STAGE FITNESS TEST
Catley & Tomkinson, 2011
LONGITUDINAL FITNESS MEASURES:
MULTI STAGE FITNESS TEST
40
35
No. of shuttles
30
25
Ollie
20
Lauren
15
10
5
0
Pre1
Post1
Pre2
Post2
Pre3
Post3
CURL-UPS
Catley & Tomkinson, 2011
LONGITUDINAL FITNESS MEASURES:
SBJ AND CURL UPS
60
SBJ
50
40
Curl
ups
30
20
10
0
Pre1
Post1
Pre2
Ollie
Post2
Lauren
Pre3
Post3
SESSION X SESSION CHANGES
Measured
increases in
• work loads
• repetitions
• ergometer
times
PARENTS TOLD US….
•
•
95% parents agreed or
strongly their child had
improved in both fitness
and confidence
Overall improvements in
▫ Weight loss
▫ Ability to focus on
homework
▫ Improvement in school
grades
▫ Greater level of
cooperation
•
•
•
In a recent cross country
run, he did better than
expected and attributed it
to his training and
increased fitness
Scott is emotionally calm
and co-operative on
AMPitup nights
Sally is less reluctant to
run, jump, move around,
since starting AMPitup
ARE WE USING THE RIGHT TESTS?
SO WE ADDED SOME OTHER TESTS..
Pre
Post
p
Plank (secs)
36.11
66.93
.013
1RM leg press (kg)
81.25
95.13
.13
1RM chest press (kg) 25.87
34.95
.019
CONCLUSIONS
Tests differ in coordinative demands
 Strength measures require less coordination as the movement
is constrained by equipment, however best aerobic fitness test
still unclear.
 External cues – cadence tapes, visual feedback, knowledge of
results help, motivation
 Tests need a close alignment with exercise program – same
machinery, undertaken by known coach.
 Practice the test
 Inability to generalise to different setting

FUTURE DIRECTIONS
Generalisability of improvement
 Transference into community facilities
 Young adults and DCD
 Impact of DCD on mental health
