RELATION OF AMINO PROTEIN COMPONENTS AND ACIDS TO PORK QUALITY 1 FREE W. R. USBORNE,2 JAMES D. KEMP AND W. G. MOODY 3 University o] Ken'tucky, Lexington ORK quality must be adequately defined, p and objective, quantitative methods must be available before proper standards and guidelines can be established and improvements can be made. A better understanding of the fundamental relationships of muscle proteins and their components to pork quality might contribute to a more precise and knowledgeable definition and methodology. Hegarty et al. (1963) fractionated beef muscle proteins and showed that sarcoplasmic protein per total fibrillar protein nitrogen and soluble fibrillar protein nitrogen were correlated with tenderness. Hill (1962) found more stroma and myofibril protein nitrogen and less sarcoplasmic protein nitrogen in beef muscle when compared with pork and lamb muscles. Ma et al. (1961) studied the free amino acid composition of various beef muscles and concluded that the more tender cuts had a higher leucine and isoleucine content. Several amino acids have been associated with beef flavor (Batzer et al., 1962). The objectives of this research were (a) to study the changes that take place from the raw to the cooked product in the various protein nitrogen components and free amino acids of porcine muscle and (b) to study the relationships of these nitrogen components and free amino acids to color, firmness, texture, marbling, flavor, juiciness, tenderness, WarnerBratzler shear values and over-all satisfaction of the 1. dorsi muscle from five weight groups of closely related hogs. Materials and M e t h o d s The animals in this experiment and the procedures used were the same as those reported by Usborne et al. (1968). In addition, the drippings from cooking were collected and analyzed for free amino acids. After cooking, the drippings were poured into a beaker, the fat allowed to rise, and then 1 T h e investigation reported in this paper (67 5-82) is in connection with a project of the Kentucky Agricultural Experiment Station and is published with apprnval of the Director. 2 Present address: Department of Animal Science, University of Minnesota, St. Paul. s The authors gratefully acknowledge the assistance of the University of Kentucky Computing Center in analyzing data. ~90 each sample was refrigerated overnight. The solidified fat was carefully removed and the remainder saved for free amino acid analyses. A 2.5-ml. sample of the drippings was diluted to 25 ml. with distilled water and a 0.75-ml. aliquot was used in the final analysis. Analysis of variance and simple and partial correlations were conducted following the method of Steel and Torrie (1960). Partial correlations were calculated to eliminate the effect of liveweight differences. The treatments were raw vs. cooked pork for the protein nitrogen components, and raw vs. cooked pork and the drippings vs. raw plus cooked pork for the free amino acids. Correlation coefficients for all possible combinations of variables in this study were presented by Usborne ( 1967 ). Only pertinent partial correlation coefficients are given in this paper. Results and Discussion Protein Nitrogen Components. All the protein components with the exception of total nitrogen and collagen showed a significant ( P ~ . 0 1 ) change from the raw to the cooked state, as shown in table 1. A comparison of the raw and cooked values revealed that the sarcoplasmic protein, non-protein, residual connective tissue protein and soluble fibrillar protein nitrogens decreased about 1O0%, 33 %, 43.5% and 75%, respectively, in the cooked I. dorsi muscle. The decrease in soluble proteins is in general agreement with work by Ginger et al. (1954) and Griswold (1955). These decreases were compensated for by a tremendous increase in the percent total fibrillar protein nitrogen fraction. Apparently the heat denatured and coagulated all of the sarcoplasmic protein, most of the soluble fibrillar protein and some of the residual connective tissue protein. Some of the nonprotein nitrogen could have been volatilized, and this may have contributed to the aroma of the cooked pork. New flavor compounds also may have been formed from the raw components. Many of the compounds responsible for meat aroma and flavor have 591 P R O T E I N COMPONENTS AND I'ORK QUALITY T A B L E 1. M E A N S AND S T A N D A R D D E V I A T I O N S OF P R O T E I N C O M P O N E N T S State of muscle ~' Raw Cooked Variables Mean S.D. Mean S.D. Significance % % % % % % % 12.17 22.41 9.89 14.44 9.49 46.40 6.86 1.11 2.10 0.80 3.30 11.78 0.00 6.58 8.17 2.33 78.60 7.05 1.02 0.00 0.37 3.95 0.35 3.47 0.75 ., ** ** ** ** ** .. total nitrogen" sarcoplasmic protein nitrogen b non protein nitrogen b residual connective tissue protein nitrogen b soluble fibrillar protein nitrogen b total fibrillar protein nitrogen b collagen nitrogenb 2.21 2.59 0.68 Of muscle on dry weight basis. b Of total nitrogen. c N=20. ** P~.01. been identified (Hornstein and Crowe, 1964; Landmann and Batzer, 1966). The means and standard deviations of the quality and palatability characteristics referred to throughout this study appear in table 2. Marbling was the most variable of all the components. Selected partial correlation coefficients for the raw pork protein nitrogen components are shown in table 3. Percent T A B L E 2. M E A N S AND S T A N D A R D D E V I A TIONS OF Q U A L I T Y AND P A L A T A B I L I T Y CHARACTERISTICS State of musCe Raw Variables Quality characteristics Lean color ~ Lean firmness b Lean texture ~ Marb ling ~l Cooked Mean S.D. 2.70 2.85 1.95 6.55 0.57 0.75 0.60 1.47 Palatab ility characteristics Tenderness ~ Warner-Bratzler shear r Flavor ~ Juiciness ~ Over-all satisfaction ~ Mean S.D. 7.96 4.71 7.72 7.10 7.60 0.30 0.83 0.20 0.40 0.26 9 Color: 2 -pale, 3--uniformly grayish pink. ~*Firmness: 2--soft, 3 firm, 4 very firm. e Texture: 1--coarse, 2--medium, 3 fine, d Marbling: 5--small, 6--modest, 7 moderate. e 9--like extremely; 1----dislikeextremely. r Ng. force to shear 2.54-cm. core. total nitrogen in the l. dorsi muscle showed significant partial negative correlation coefficients with marbling, flavor, juiciness and over-all satisfaction. The amount of total nitrogen in lean meat seemed to play an important role in influencing the palatability characteristics as exemplified by the high negative partial correlations between the percet total nitrogen and the palatability charac- teristics. The percent sarcoplasmic protein nitrogen was significantly correlated with firmness, juiciness and over-all satisfaction. The percent soluble fibrillar protein nitrogen of raw pork was significantly correlated with marbling, but not with tenderness or WarnerBratzler shear values as Hegarty et al. (1963) found with beef. Tenderness differences were perhaps too small in this pork study to justify a valid comparison. A significant partial correlation coefficient also was found between the percent residual connective tissue protein nitrogen and juiciness. Protein nitrogen components from cooked pork were not significantly correlated with quality and palatability characteristics. If partial correlation coefficients were used as an indication of relativity between the protein-nitrogen components and the quality and palatability traits, the percents of total nitrogen and sarcoplasmic protein nitrogen of raw T A B L E 3. S E L E C T E D P A R T I A L C O R R E L A T I O N COEFFICIENTS--RAW MUSCLE PROTEIN COMPONENTS VS. QUALITY TRAITS Variables P a r t i a l correl ation coefficients Percent total nitrogen v s . m a r b l i n g Percent total nitrogen v s . flavor Percent total nitrogen v s . juiciness Percent total nitrogen v s . over-all satisfaction Percent sacroplasmic protein nitrogen v s . firmness Percent sacroplasmic protein nitrogen v s . juiciness Percent sacroplasmic protein nitrogen v s . over-all satisfaction Percent soluble fibrillar protein nitrogen v s . ma rbl i ng Percent residual connective tissue protein nitrogen v s . juiciness * P<.05, ** P < . O I , - - . 44* --. 51" - - . 79** - - . 72 ** 0.58** 0,51" 0.45* 0.47* - - . 58** 592 USBORNE, K E M P AND MOODY TABLE 4. MEANS AND STANDARD DEVIATIONS OF FREE AMINO ACIDS State of muscle Raw (R) Cooked (C) Drippings (D) Variables (Molar %) Mean S.D. Mean S.D. Mean S.D. Serine Glutamic acid Valine 5.68 5.74 3.91 0.83 1.48 0.70 6.60 7.86 4.50 0.74 1.10 0.58 6.23 7.21 4.72 0.60 1.15 0.65 Isoleucine Leucine Tyrosine 2.21 4.27 3.39 0.39 0.65 0.86 3.42 7.82 4.35 0.38 1.15 0.75 2.97 6.27 3.25 0.39 0.55 0.66 Phenylalanine 2.17 0.45 3.69 0.41 2.64 0.47 Lysine Arginine Glycine 2.04 1.77 20.01 0.63 0.45 5.07 2.74 2.74 16.59 0.45 0.40 3.43 2.54 2.39 15.43 0.41 0.38 3.10 Alanine 26.19 3.46 20.87 2.10 26.34 2.69 Methionine 3.49 2.26 2.43 0.27 1.52 0.68 Proline Aspartic acid Threonine Histidine Total free amino acids (~moles/gm. muscle) P<.05. ~ P%.Ol. 6.77 1.62 5.38 3.94 5.92 4,97 1.40 0.98 0.99 0.90 5,00 1.34 5.86 4.18 8.41 0.88 0.51 1.10 0.73 0.97 5.53 1.45 6.43 5.07 32.50 0,63 0.52 0.58 1.52 5.77 pork were the most important of the traits studied. Free Amino Acids. Means and standard deviations of the free amino acids are given in table 4. There was much variation in the individual observations for some of the free amino acids, as indicated by the large standard deviations. Serine, glutamic acid, valine, isoleucine, leucine, tyrosine, phenylalanine, lysine and arginine proportions were significantly ( P < . 0 1 ) higher in cooked than in raw pork. The increase in these amino acids was probably the result of protein degradation. Whether selectivity was taking place in freeing the amino acids could not be determined. Glycine, alanine, and methionine ( P < . 0 i ) ; and proline ( P < . 0 5 ) significantly decreased in the cooked pork. I t has been shown that heat from cooking does not destroy these amino acids (Schweigert e t a l . , 1949, 1951). These amino acids could have contributed to the formation of new flavor compounds (Batzer e t a l . , 1962; L a n d m a n n and Batzer, 1966). Also, this decrease could have been due to their concentration remaining fairly constant, and because other free amino acids increased proportionally, these would have decreased. There was no significant difference Significance R vs. C** Rvs. C** R vs. C** D vs. R+C ** R vs. C** R vs. C** R vs. C** D vs. R+C ** R vs. C** D vs. R-[-C * R vs. C** R vs. C** R vs. C** D vs. R+C** R vs. C** D vs. R+C ** R vs. C** D vs. R+C** Rye. C* None Dvs. R-[-C* D vs. R+C** D vs. R-t-C** between the total free amino acids of raw and cooked pork, although the total was higher for the cooked product. When the free amino acids in the drippings were compared with those in the raw plus cooked pork, valine (P~.01), alanine (P~.01), threonine (P~.05), histidine ( P ~ . 0 1 ) , and the total free amino acids ( P ~ . 0 1 ) were significantly higher and tyrosine ( P ~ . 0 1 ) , phenylalanine ( P ~ . 0 5 ) , glycine ( P ~ . 0 1 ) , and methionine ( P ~ . 0 1 ) were significantly lower. There can be so m a n y variables--such as the initial level of the free amino acids in the muscle, the rate of heating during cooking, the moisture content of the meat, the solubilities of the amino acids, and the p H of the meat and drippings--which could influence the general amino acid pattern that it would be difficult to draw any definite conclusions without more detailed studies. Selected partial correlation coefficients for the free amino acids from raw pork v s . the quality and palatability characteristics are given in table 5, Glutamic acid was significantly correlated with texture, flavor and tenderness. Leucine showed a highly significant positive correlation with tenderness. Some indication of the relation of leucine to tender- 593 PROTEIN COMPONENTS AND PORK QUALITY TABLE 5. SELECTED PARTIAL CORRELATION COEFFICIENTSIRAW MUSCLE FREE AMINO ACIDS V S . QUALITY TRAITS Variables Glutamie acid vs. texture Glutamic acid vs. flavor Glutamic acid vs. tenderness Leucine vs. tenderness Serine vs.. tenderness P henylalanine vs. tenderness P~'.O5. ~ P<.OI, Partial correlation coefficients -- .49" --. 52 0.44* 0.56"* 0.50* 0.51" ness in beef has been reported by Ma e t a l . (1961). Serine and phenylalanine also were correlated with tenderness (P < .05). Table 6 gives selected partial correlation coefficients for the free amino acids from cooked pork v s . quality and palatability characteristics. The amino acids were most frequently correlated with flavor, followed by juiciness and over-all satisfaction. Tyrosine and g!utamic acid were negatively correlated ( P < . 0 1 ) , aspartic acid and serine were negatively correlated ( P ~ . 0 5 ) , while glycine was positively correlated ( P < . 0 5 ) with flavor. T y r o s i n e and glutamic acid also were negatively correlated ( P ~ . 0 5 ) with juiciness and over-all satisfaction. The high negative correlations with flavor showed that as the amounts of these amino acids increased, flavor scores decreased. One interpretation could be that these amino acids contributed to new compounds during cooking. Three of the five significantly correlated free amino acids (glutamic acid, serine and glycine) were the same that Batzer e t a l . (1962) found in a hydrolyzate from a glycoprotein which served as a precursor in beef flavor. Also, a Maillard-type reaction may be occurring between certain amino acids and carbohydrates (Hornstein TABLE 6. SELECTED PARTIAL CORRELATION COEFFICIENTS--COOKED MUSCLE FREE AMINO ACIDS V S . QUALITY TRAITS Variables Tyrosine vs. flavor Tyrosine vs. juiciness Tyrosine vs. over-all satisfaction Glutamic acid vs. flavor Glutamic acid vs. juiciness Glutamic acid vs. over-all satisfaction Aspartie acid vs. flavor Serine vs. flavor Glycine vs. flavor P<,05. r P<.01. Partial correlation coefficients --. 57** --. 46* --. 60"* --. 66** --. 54 --. 48 --. 54* --.46* 0.49* and Crowe, 1964; Tart, 1966). This reaction is believed to contribute to flavor production in meat. Lysine was significantly correlated with marbling, glycine with color of muscle, and aspartic acid with tenderness when the free amino acids of the drippings were correlated with the quality and palatability characteristics as shown in table 7. No apparent reasons are available for these significant correlations. Protein Nitrogen Components vs. Free Amino A c i d s . Selected partial correlation co- efficients between the free amino acids and the protein nitrogen components of raw pork are given in table 8. Free threonine was significantly ( P < . 0 5 ) correlated with the percent total nitrogen and arginine with the non-protein nitrogen. Glycine ( P < . 0 5 ) , valine ( P < . 0 1 ) and leucine ( P < . 0 5 ) were significantly correlated with the percent collagen nitrogen. Glycine also was negatively correlated with the percent residual connective tissue protein nitrogen. TABLE 7. SELECTED PARTIAL CORRELATION COEFFICIENTS--FREE AMINO ACIDS FROM DRIPPINGS V S . QUALITY TRAITS Variables Lysine vs. marbling Glycine vs. color of lean Aspartic acid vs. tenderness P~.o5. Partial correIation coefficients --. 46* 0.46* 0.45* When the partial correlation coefficients of the free amino acids v s . the protein nitrogen components of the cooked meat were summarized, several of the amino acids were correlated with the percent collagen nitrogen of the total nitrogen. These partial correlation coefficients appear in table 9. Alanine was negatively correlated (P ~ . 0 5 ) with percent total nitrogen. Proline ( P < . 0 1 ) and glycine ( P ( . 0 5 ) were positively correlated with the percent collagen nitrogen content. These two amino acids alone contribute approximately 45% of the total amino acids found in collagen (White e t a l . , 1964). Leucine and methionine ( P < . 0 5 ) and valine, isoleucine and phenylalanine ( P < . 0 1 ) also were correlated with the percent collagen nitrogen but in a negative respect. The free amino acids in the drippings were compared with the protein nitrogen components of cooked pork. Selected partial correlations are shown in table 10. Glycine was nega- 594 USBORNE, KEMP AND MOODY T A B L E 8. S E L E C T E D P A R T I A L C O R R E L A T I O N COEFFICIENTS--RAW MUSCLE FREE AMINO ACIDS VS. R A W P R O T E I N C O M P O N E N T S Variables Threonine vs. % total nitrogen Arginine vs. % non protein nitrogen Glycine vs. % collagen nitrogen Valine vs. % collagen nitrogen Leucine vs. % collagen nitrogen Glycine vs. % residual connective tissue nitrogen Partial correlation coefficients 0.44* 0.53* 0.70** --.46" - - . 46* - - . 65** * P<.05. ** P~.OI. tively correlated ( P < . 0 5 ) with the percent non protein nitrogen, tyrosine and isoleucine ( P < . 0 5 ) with the percent collagen nitrogen, and alanine ( P < . 0 5 ) with the percent total nitrogen. Whether there is any significance in the relation of each individual free amino acid to the percent collagen nitrogen is questionable. However, sew_~n of the free amino acids from cooked pork and two from the drippings were significantly correlated with collagen. Those amino acids which were negatively correlated are present in collagen in only small amounts. It is difficult to make any definite statements about the relation of tenderness, collagen and the free amino acids since there was little difference in tenderness and the percent collagen nitrogen failed to change significantly from the raw to the cooked product. There was no free amino acids significantly correlated with tenderness in the cooked product even though many were correlated with collagen. In raw pork, leucine was the only free amino acid which was significantly correlated with both tenderness and collagen nitrogen content. Concentrations of free leucine, possibly, could be used as an iindicator of tenderness, but more evidence is needed from a wider range of conditions. T A B L E 9. S E L E C T E D P A R T I A L C O R R E L A T I O N COEFFICIENTS--COOKED MUSCLE FREE A M I N O ACIDS VS. C O O K E D P R O T E I N COMPONENTS Variables Manine vs. % total nitrogen Proline vs. % collagen nitrogen Glycine 'vs. % collagen nitrogen Leucine vs. % collagen nitrogen Methionine vs. % collagen nitrogen Valine vs. % collagen nitrogen Isoleucine vs. % collagen nitrogen Phenylalanine vs. % collagen nitrogen * P~.05. ** P~.01. Partial correlation coefficients - - . 54* 0.60** 0.52* --.44* - - . 55* - - . 56** - - . 59"* - - . 66** Summary Four closely related litters of five Hampshire barrows each were raised under the same conditions and distributed among five slaughter weight groups so that each litter was represented in each group. Various quality and palatability characteristics, certain protein nitrogen components, and 16 individual free amino acids were determined on raw and cooked samples of the I. dorsi muscle. The drippings from cooking also were analyzed for the free amino acids. The percents of soluble fibrillar protein nitrogen, sarcoplasmic protein nitrogen, non protein nitrogen, and residual connective tissue protein nitrogen decreased in the cooked product when compared to the fresh state by T A B L E 10. S E L E C T E D P A R T I A L C O R R E L A T I O N C O E F F I C I E N T S - - F R E E A M I N O ACIDS F R O M D R I P P I N G S VS. C O O K E D P R O T E I N COMPONENTS Variables Glycine vs. % non protein nitrogen Tyrosine vs, % collagen nitrogen Isoleucine vs, % collagen nitrogen Alanine vs. % total nitrogen Partial correlation coefficients - - .45* --.45* - - . 56** - - . 61"* P<.05, ** P~.0I. about 75%, 100%, 33% and 43.5% respectively. The percent total nitrogen increased about 45.4%, and the percent collagen nitrogen remained almost constant from the raw to the cooked state. Proportions of free glycine, alanine, methionine and proline decreased in the cooked product while proportions of free serine, glutamic acid, valine, isoleucine, leucine, tyrosine, phenylalanine, lysine and arginine increased. When the free amino acids in the drippings were compared with those in the raw plus cooked muscle, valine, alanine, threonine, histidine, and the total free amino acids were higher and tyrosine, phenylalanine, glycine and methionine were lower. Significant partial correlation coeff• were found for percent of total nitrogen of raw pork with marbling (--.44"), flavor (--.51"), juiciness (--.79**) and over-all satisfaction (--.72**). Such coefficients also were found for percent sarcoplasmic protein nitrogen of raw pork with firmness (0.58"), juiciness (0.51") and over-all satisfaction (0.45*); free glutamic acid of raw pork with flavor (--.52*) ; free glutamic acid (--.66"*), tyrosine (--.57"*), aspartic acid (--.54*), PROTEIN COMPONENTS AND PORK QUALITY serine (.46*) and glycine (0.49*) of cooked pork with flavor; free glutamic acid (0.44*), leucine (0.56"*), serine (0.50*) and phenylalanine (0.51") of raw pork and aspartic acid (0.45*) of the drippings with tenderness. Significant partial correlation coefficients also were found for free glycine (0.70**), valine (--.46*) and leucine (--.46*) in raw pork along with free proline (0.60"*), glycine (0.52"), leucine (--.44), methionine (--.55"), valine (--.56"*), isoleucine (--.59**) and phenylalanine (--.66**) in cooked pork and tyrosine (--.45*) and isoleucine (--.56**) in the drippings with the percent collagen nitrogen. Various individual free amino acids in cooked pork were most frequently correlated with flavor followed by juiciness and over-all satisfaction. Literature Cited Batzer, O. F., A. T. Santoro and Vq. A. Landmann. 1962. Identification of some beef flavor precursors. J. Agr. Food Chem. 10:94. Ginger, I. D., J. P. Wachter, D. M. Doty, B. S. Schweigert, F. J. Beard, J. C. Pierce and O. G. Hankins. 1954. Effect of aging and cooking on the distribution of certain amino acids and nitrogen in beef muscle. Food Res. 19:410. Griswold, R. M. 1955. The effect of different methods of cooking beef round of commercial and prime grades. II. Collagen, fat, and nitrogen content. Food Res. 20:171. Hegarty, G, R., L. J. Bratzler and A. M. Pearson. 595 1963. The relation of some intracellular protein characteristics to beef muscle tenderness. J. Food Sci. 28:525. Hill, F. 1962. Fibre composition of tough and tender muscles of meat animals. Nature 196:65. Hornstein, I. and F. F. Crowe. 1964. Meat flavor-a review. J. Gas Chromatogr. 2:128. Landmann, W. A. and O. F. Batzer. 1966. influence of processing procedures on the chemistry of meat flavors. J. Agr. Food Chem. 14:210. Ma, R. M., M. B. Matlack and R. L. Hiner. 1961. A study of the free amino acids in bovine muscle. J. Food Sci. 26:485. Schweigert, B. S., B. A. Bennett and B. T. Guthneck. 1951. Further studies on the amino acid composition of pork and lamb cuts. J. Biol. Chem. 190:697. Schweigert, B. S., B. T. Guthneck, H. R. Kraybill and D. A. Greenwood. 1949. The amino acid composition of pork and lamb cuts. J. Biol. Chem. 180:1077. Steel, R. G. D. and J. H. Torrie. 1960. Principles and Procedures of Statistics. McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York. Tarr, H. L. A. 1966. Flavor of fesh foods, p. 190-202. R. F. Gould (ed.). Flavor Chemistry. Am. Chem. Soc., Washington, D. C. Usborne, W. R. 1957. The relation of certain protein components and free amino acids to quality of porcine muscle from five different weights of hogs. Ph.D. Dissertation. Univ. of Ky., Lexington. Usborne, W. R., James D. Kemp and W. G. Moody. 1968. Effect of liveweight on quality, proximate composition, certain protein components and free amino acids of porcine muscle. J. Animal Sci. 27:584. White, A., P. Handler and E. L. Smith. 1964. Principles of Biochemistry (3rd ed.). The Blakiston Division, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz