What Does Adaptation Look Like?

What Does
Adaptation Look
Like?
Examples from Michigan’s
Management of Deer
Christopher L Hoving
Michigan DNR, Wildlife
Michael Notaro
University of Wisconsin-Madison
June 25, 2014
Adaptation Example
!  Not
adaptation “program”
!  Management
!  Climate
! 
challenge
change is being considered explicitly
Managing winter habitat for deer in Michigan’s Upper
Peninsula
Learning Trajectory
!  Initially
climatology-driven
Start with query about climate data needs
!  Provide data for projections for 2050 or 2100
!  Caveats
! 
!  Shifted
to user-driven
Ask about major projects
!  Translate into values and vulnerabilities
!  Coach user to explore adaptive alternatives
!  Provide data, if necessary
! 
Initial
But what
I really
wanted…
No not
that
either
Typical Caveats
!  Projections
!  Depends
!  These
are not predictions
on emissions scenario
are statistical downscaling results
!  Assumes
past processes continue into future
!  What about new lake ice regime?
To a Wildlife Manager
!  !"#$%&&'(
()
!  *"+,-./001
#2)
!  3"445$%+66)
!  7"44&$26⌧
11,)
Userdriven
!  Ask
wildlife
managers
about their
concerns
!  Deer
survival
in winter
!  Manager
concerns are
primarily
about deer,
not climate
Why
Deer?
!  Michigan
DNR
has trust
management
responsibility
for deer in
Michigan.
!  Deer
are worth
$500 million in
economic
activity for
Michigan.
Deer
Biology 101
1.  Don’t
freeze
2.  Don’t get eaten
3.  Don’t starve
Deer Wintering Complexes (DWC) have mature
conifer trees to trap heat and block snow.
!  Protection from freezing.
!  Some protection from predators.
!  Little food.
Lake effect snowfall has increased
as winter precipitation has increased
and lake ice has decreased.
Draft Deer Winter Range
Deer Wintering Complex (DWC)
Non-winter Range
(vacated by deer in winter)
Conditional Winter Range
Reminder: This map represents the winter range
Based on the primary migration patterns.
A particular location depending on weather and
Other factors can have individual representing
Multiple migration patterns. i.e. a DWC will
also have some resident and conditional deer
but the majority of the individuals will be obligate
migrators.
Resident or non-migratory
Winter Range
Deer Winter Range and
Climate Change
! 
Obligatory: Deer must migrate when snow depth
> 10” for >90 days.
! 
! 
! 
Conditional: Deer migrate only during severe winters.
! 
! 
! 
Winter habitat complexes are critical to deer survival.
Forest harvest affected in delineated DWCs.
Winter habitat complexes not used consistently.
Forest harvest no longer restricted in conditional range.
How fast will line between obligatory and conditional
DWR shift this century?
!  Downscaled
projections for days with
snow depth > 10”
!  2040-2069, “mid-21st century”
!  Two models to try to bracket uncertainty
Now what?
!  Some
climate impacts are high certainty for
mid-21st century
More flooding
!  Birds and mammals shift north ~ 1-2 km per year
! 
!  This
is not a high certainty impact.
Past is not a reliable guide to the future.
!  What management makes sense under
different scenarios?
! 
Climate-sensitive decisions
!  DWC
term
will be valuable short-term, not long-
Snow depth duration is long now
!  Existing mature trees are valuable now
!  Seedlings now will mature when snow depth
duration is shorter
! 
!  What
are the cost-effective tools to protect
DWC from harvest for next 25 years?
! 
Purchase, conservation easement, or private
landowner agreement?
Christopher Hoving, Adaptation Specialist
517-284-6192
[email protected]
twitter.com/pcrucifer
C. Hoving, Michigan DNR