HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION “CITY OF HOMES” City of Huntington Woods | Oakland County | Michigan | March 20 16 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Acknowledgements Bob Paul, Mayor Amy Sullivan, City Manager CITY COMMISSIONERS Bob Paul, Mayor Allison Iverson Jeff Jenks Jules Olsman Joe Rozell SENIOR ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERS Howard Collens Lynn Feinberg Susan Klein Cathy Marchione James Speir Sue Tower Susan Witus PLANNING CONSULTANT I HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Table of Contents Executive Summary………………………....................................................................................................... iv Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… v Part 1: Background Data ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….1 Age Trends…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 1 Age Projections.…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..2 Household and Projections………………………………………………………………………………………………… 3 Building Trends………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5 Housing Costs……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 6 Conclusions……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 6 Part 2: Existing Studies……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 7 Huntington Woods Older Needs Assessment (2012)…………………………………………………………. 7 City of Huntington Woods Master Plan (2014)…………………………………………………………………… 8 City of Huntington Woods Needs Assessment (2015)………………………………………………………… 10 Part 3: Housing Options………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 12 Architectural Style……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 12 Living Space……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 13 Build a Home for “The Ages”…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 14 Alternative Housing Types of Older Adults and Seniors……………………………………………………… 15 Part 4: Land Use and Zoning…………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 28 Land Use……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 28 Zoning…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………32 Potential Locations…………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 32 II SECTION 1 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Tables Table 1. Population Forecast by Age Group, Huntington Woods, 2010-2040 Table 2. Building and Demolition Permits Issued, Huntington Woods, 2000-2015 Table 3. Average Listing Home Prices from Realtor and Movoto, Huntington Woods, 2015 Table 4. Median Home Value from Zillow, 2015, and American Community Survey, Huntington Woods, 2009-2013 Table 5. Land Use of Huntington Woods, 2014 Table 6. Land Use of Huntington Woods Compared to Surrounding Communities, 2014 Table 7. Existing Senior Housing and Service Facilities around Huntington Woods Table 8. Permitted Residential Land Uses in Select Zoning Districts, Huntington Woods Figures Figure 1. Population, Huntington Woods Figure 2. Population by Age Group, 2015 Figure 3. Household Types, Huntington Woods, 2000 Figure 4. Household Types, Huntington Woods, 2010 Figure 5. Household Types with and without Seniors, Huntington Woods, 2000 Figure 6. Household Types with and without Seniors, Huntington Woods, 2010 Figure 7. Housing Alternatives, Huntington Woods Figure 8. Existing Land Use, Huntington Woods, 2014 Figure 9. Existing Senior Housing and Service Facilities around Huntington Woods Figure 10. City of Huntington Woods Zoning Map Figure 11. Housing Options Strategy III 3 5 6 6 28 30 31 32 1 2 4 4 4 4 8 29 31 34 35 SECTION 1 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Executive Summary With an aging population, Huntington Woods is looking at alternative housing options to better accommodate the current baby boomers who desire to age in their community, but also accommodate the housing preferences of other age cohorts. Considering new ways in which Huntington Woods can help seniors and older adults remain in the City is important for the health and strength of not just the housing market, but the entire community. This report investigates housing options for the citizens of Huntington Woods. Introducing new housing types does not mean changing the quality and character of the City’s neighborhoods. These alternative housing options can be designed and constructed with the existing residential character in mind. The first step is to understand how these various housing options create supportive living spaces for residents of all ages and abilities. This current study builds on existing reports including an Older Needs Assessment from 2012, the City’s 2014 Master Plan Update, demographic background data, and a 2015 Needs Assessment regarding the municipal complex and alternative housing types to support an older population. A focus of this report is to describe a variety of potential housing types. The housing types fall into one of three categories: attached single family, detached single family, and senior housing facilities. This report provides a source of information for Huntington Woods regarding alternative housing options and the benefits and challenges that accompany each housing type. Zoning and land use information is included in the last section to provide a resource for subsequent phases of study. Understanding and analysis of existing land use patterns and zoning regulations will help the City determine the best approach to expanding housing options in the City in a way that is compatible with the existing residential fabric. IV SECTION 1 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Introduction The City of Huntington Woods is known as a “City of homes.” Residential land use accounts for over half of the City’s land area and approximately 97% of all properties. Residents are proud of their tidy, tree lined residential streets and the charming architectural character found among the 2,354 single family homes located in Huntington Woods. In fact, almost 60% of all Master Plan online survey respondents said they never plan on leaving the City. What will happen as residents get older? Will senior residents be forced to leave their community to find other housing options? Will empty nesters opt for smaller footprints and less maintenance? Is the City designed for Aging in Places? In order to address these questions, the City of Huntington Woods’ Senior Advisory Committee conducted an evaluation of housing options for an aging population in late 2015. The evaluation was designed to assess current conditions and identify changing housing needs for the City’s aging populations. The Phase 1 study was conducted in four parts: Part 1 was an analysis of background data on the City of Huntington Woods. Part 2 was a review of existing needs assessments and the 2014 Master Plan Update. Part 3 was the analysis of alternative housing options for older adults and seniors. Part 4 was an analysis of land use patterns and zoning districts, including adjacent communities. V SECTION 1 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Part 1 Background Data The current population of the City of Huntington Woods is estimated at 6,354 people, based on 2014 SEMCOG estimates. According to the U.S. Census, the City of Huntington Woods had a population of 6,238 in 2010. While this 2010 population count represents over a 1% increase in population since 2000, historic data reveals that the City’s population has been in a slow decline since the 1960s. By 2040, the City’s population is projected to increase to 6,439, according to 2014 SEMCOG projections (December 2014 Community Profile). This projection equates to a 3.1% increase in population between 2010 and 2040. As stated in the 2014 Master Plan, population that is either static or increasing at a slow rate is a typical phenomenon of inner ring suburbs that is likely the result of several factors, including families having fewer children, the presence of empty nest households aging in place (and living longer), and the lack of developable land for new homes. Furthermore, the relationship between demographic change and the housing market is inseparable. Figure 1. Population, Huntington Woods 7,000 6,000 People 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 2000 Census 2010 Census Dec. 2014 (SEMCOG) 2040 Forecast (SEMCOG) Source: U.S. Census Bureau and SEMCOG 2040 Forecast produced in 2010 Age Trends While population trends provide a general picture of the community, age demographic trends and projections provide better insight into the housing needs and choices of particular age groups or age cohorts. For instance, the baby boomer cohort, people born between 1946 and 1964, is of particular interest to a study on housing options for an aging population. In 2000, the baby boomers were 34 to 54 years old. In 2010, they were 44 to 64. Today, boomers are part of the City’s senior population. 1 PART 1 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION In 2000, the senior population, adults 65 years and older, was 779 and in 2010 it was 846. This 8.6% increase in seniors is a result of the pre-baby boom generation living longer and aging in place. Today, there are an estimated 991 seniors living in Huntington Woods. In 2010, children (0-17 years) made up 27.4% of the total population in the City of Huntington Woods, while the number of people 65 years and older were 13.6 percent. Figure 2. Population by Age Group, Huntington Woods, 2015 75+ 6% 65-74 10% Under 5 6% 5-17 18% 60-64 9% 18-24 6% 25-34 6% 35-59 39% Source: U.S. Census Bureau and SEMCOG According to the data: The Southeast Michigan Council of Governments (SEMCOG) estimates by the year 2035, the City can expect to see a decline of 24% in is population under 18 and an increase of 72% in its senior population. The SEMCOG projection forecasts that in 20 years, the over 65 population will comprise almost 25% of the City’s total population—up from 13.5% in the 2010 Census. In the next twenty-five years, the population of children (0-17 years) and adults (25-59 years) will decrease, while the young adult (18-24 years) and senior population (65+ years) will increase considerably. Projections by SEMCOG indicate that by 2040 the number of children under the age of eighteen (18%) will represent 22.7 percent of the population. On the other hand, the number of people 65 years and older will increase by 885, with this age group representing 26.9 percent of the 2040 population. This projection shows a 104.6 percent increase in the senior population. For the first time in Huntington Woods history, by 2040 there will be more people over 65 years of age than 18 or younger. 2 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Table 1. Population Forecast by Age Group, Huntington Woods, 2010-2040 2010 2040 Change % Change Age Census Forecast 2010-2040 2010-2040 Under 5 399 325 -74 -18.5% 5-17 1,309 1,138 -171 -13.1% 18-24 243 399 156 64.2% 25-34 458 386 -72 -15.7% 35-59 2,508 2,016 -492 -19.6% 60-64 475 444 -31 -6.5% 65-74 471 908 437 92.8% 75+ 375 823 448 119.5% Source: U.S. Census Bureau and SEMCOG 2040 Forecast produced in 2010 Household and Projections The City of Huntington Woods currently has 2,369 households, based on 2014 SEMCOG estimates. According to the U.S. Census, there were 2,354 households in 2010. As noted in the 2014 Master Plan, while the population of Huntington Woods slowly declined from 19602000, the number of households (2,354 in 2010) remained relatively constant in recent years. This can be attributed to the City’s shrinking average household size: the average number of persons per household decreased from 3.58 in 1970 to 2.58 in 2000. From 2000 to 2010, Huntington Woods saw a modest increase in household size up to 2.65 person per household. This shift may be the result of “empty nesters” moving out of the community or adult children (ages 18-24) returning home to live with parents. The number of householders living alone remained essentially unchanged between 2000 and 2010. The number of households with children, under 18 years of age, decreased from 910 in 2000 to 895 in 2010, reflecting a 1.6% decrease in the number of households with children. However, the proportion of households with children remained the same (38%). 3 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Figure 3. Household Types, Huntington Woods, 2000 Figure 4. Household Types, Huntington Woods, 2010 With Children 910 38% 1,006 42% Live alone, <65 With Children 895 38% 992 42% Live alone, 65+ 186 279 8% 12% Two or more persons without children Live alone, <65 Live alone, 65+ 215 252 9% 11% Two or more persons without children Source: U.S. Census Bureau and SEMCOG The number of households with seniors increased from 543 in 2000 to 608 in 2010, reflecting a twelve (12%) percent increase in the ten-year period. In addition, the number of households with seniors living alone also increased from 186 in 2000 to 215 in 2010, reflecting a 15.6 percent increase. Whether living alone or with others, the number of households with seniors, persons 65 years and over, increased in actual numbers (from 543 to 608 households) and as a percentage of all households (from 23% to 26%) between 2000 and 2010. Figure 6. Household Types with and without Seniors, Huntington Woods, 2010 Figure 5. Household Types with and without Seniors, Huntington Woods, 2000 543 23% 1,838 77% 608 26% With Seniors, 65+ With Seniors, 65+ Without Seniors, 65+ 1,746 74% Without Seniors, 65+ Source: U.S. Census Bureau and SEMCOG 4 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION By 2040, the City of Huntington Woods is projected to increase to 2,409 households, according to SEMCOG projections (December 2014 Community Profile). Building Trends According to SEMCOG, there have been 43 building permits issued from 2000 to 2015. The permits were all for single family homes; no other housing types were issued a building permit. With little developable land, new construction is often accommodated through demolition of existing homes. During the last fifteen years, 23 demolition permits were issued with a net total of 20 additional homes. Without land use and housing policy changes, the total number of housing units in the City is unlikely to change significantly in the coming decades. Table 2. Building and Demolition Permits Issued, Huntington Woods, 2000-2015 Year 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2000-2015 Single Family Two Family 3 1 4 0 5 8 2 3 1 1 1 0 2 2 7 3 43 Attached Condo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Multi Family 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 Total Units 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 1 4 0 5 8 2 3 1 1 1 0 2 2 7 3 43 Total Demos 0 1 1 0 6 4 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 2 3 3 23 Net Total 3 0 3 0 -1 4 2 2 0 1 1 0 1 0 4 0 20 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Housing Costs Housing prices have steadily increased as the economy improved over the last six years. According to the U.S. Census, housing value in Huntington Woods is increasing and with a median value of $270,000, it remains higher than all neighboring communities and Oakland County as a whole ($177,600). In 2010, 1,583 housing units have mortgages; almost one third cost more than 30% of household income on a monthly basis. The average listing price is listed below from Realtor and Movoto. Table 3. Average Listing Home Prices from Realtor and Movoto, Huntington Woods, 2015 Average Listing Price Realtor from November 2015 $418,700 Movoto from November 2015 $405,000 Source: Realtor and Movoto The following chart lists the median home values from Zillow and the American Community Survey: Table 4. Median Home Value from Zillow, 2015, and American Community Survey, Huntington Woods, 2009-2013 Median Home Value Zillow from September 2015 $330,000 American Community Survey 2009-2013 $250,500 Source: Zillow and American Community Survey Conclusions In summary, the overall population of Huntington Woods is aging. For the first time in Huntington Woods history, by 2040 there will be more people over 65 years of age than 18 or younger. While the number of households is staying relatively constant, the household size is decreasing. With a shift in resident demographics, providing more housing options may help retain some of the population and cater to the aging baby boom population. 6 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Part 2 Existing Studies This current study builds on a larger discussion of aging and senior needs within the City of Huntington Woods. In 2012, the City conducted a needs assessment survey for older adult residents, 50 years and older. Aging population was also one of main topics in the City’s 2014 Master Plan Update planning process. As a result of these findings, the City conducted a follow-up needs assessment in 2015 specific to the municipal complex and alternative housing types to support an aging population. These studies and the relevant findings are discussed below in the order in which they were conducted, starting with the 2012 Older Needs Assessment. Huntington Woods Older Needs Assessment (2012) This report was created in partnership with Wayne State University’s Institute of Gerontology. It summarizes the survey findings of the Older Adult Assessment Survey that was distributed to households in Huntington Woods to adults 50 years and older. The 59 question survey included questions on activity level, health, self-care, daily needs, home maintenance services, education, exercise, transportation, and housing alternatives. The survey also asked for information on age, sex/gender, marital status, length of residency, and best methods for future communication. The intent of the survey was to assess the needs of older adults, evaluate current services, and help the Senior Advisory Committee prioritize their efforts and make data-driven decisions. The survey was sent to 1,817 residents 50 years and older. The City received 698 surveys, for a 38% response rate. In 2010, there were 2,319 residents 50 years and older, therefore this survey represents approximately 30% of the City’s older adult population at that time. Based on the sample of resident respondents, Huntington Wood’s older adult population tends to be married, independent, and relatively healthy. Some of the survey questions addressing health and independence of respondents were self-reported, which may not be accurate since respondents might want to be perceived as more healthy or independent. Looking towards the future, healthy older adult respondents found difficultly in anticipating future needs and desires if they were to become ill or disabled. While a majority of respondents felt they were totally independent, about half stated they would use home maintenance and repair services if they were available and made affordable. Comments revealed that several respondents already pay for private services to take care of their home. The majority of respondents (73-100%) reported non-usage of current services offered by Huntington Woods, with the two exceptions being the library (88% said they have used) and concerts in the park (73% said they have attended). In a third of cases, respondents did not have knowledge that certain services existed. Delivery of information about services is an important link in facilitating the needs and desires of an older population. Since single family homes need continuous maintenance, owning a home often means more work and expenses than other housing options. When asked about other housing alternatives, 35% of respondents expressed interest in one or more of the following housing options: condominiums, rental apartments/coops, housing with meals or other services, assisted living, continuum of care, or nursing homes. Of these, 7 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION independent living arrangements including condominiums, rental apartments, and housing with limited services were preferred to more traditional senior housing models. Figure 7. Housing Alternatives, Huntington Woods 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% No, 70 Yes, 30 Source: Huntington Woods Older Needs Assessment (2012) In conclusion, the study provided the following recommendations to the City of Huntington Woods: Consider a way to facilitate the provision of home maintenance assistance to its older residents. Consider supporting the construction of congregate housing for older adults in the city. Continue to promote civic engagement, venues for social interaction, health and exercise, and opportunities for volunteers for its older citizens. Increase awareness of programs, services and other related resources via preferred mode to inform older adults. City of Huntington Woods Master Plan (2014) The 2014 Master Plan was an update of the 2008 Master Plan. During the planning process, the City’s Planning Commission utilized two approaches for gathering public input: an online survey and a public workshop. One of the key findings from the 2014 update was the significant impact of an aging population on the City’s services, infrastructure, and land use patterns. Like many communities around the State and the nation, the City’s population is aging. Changing demographics in the City of Huntington Woods will have implications on housing, transportation, and municipal services. When the City asked stakeholders “What three needs are unmet?,” the responses 8 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION commonly included seniors and housing. In the following figure, the larger each word is, the more often it was mentioned in responses. Figure 8. Master Plan survey responses to the question: “What needs are unmet by the City?” According to the data: The Southeast Michigan Council of Governments (SEMCOG) estimates by the year 2035, the City can expect to see a decline of 24% in is population under 18 and an increase of 72% in its senior population. The SEMCOG projection forecasts that in 20 years, the over 65 population will comprise almost 25% of the City’s total population—up from 13.5% in the 2010 Census. The Master Plan is the community’s vision statement and its recommendations take the form of goals and objectives. The following goals relate to planning for an aging population: Create opportunities for accessible attached housing at a scale that is compatible with the existing neighborhood. Ensure that there are a range of housing options to meet the needs of Huntington Woods residents, both now and in the future. It will be important to focus on opportunities to address housing while maintaining the character of the existing single family neighborhoods. Direct the development of dense infill housing, such as townhomes and condominiums, to Woodward Avenue. Continue to provide single family, detached dwellings in a range of sizes and values. In the future, Huntington Woods will continue to offer both starter homes and homes for move-up or secondtime homebuyers. Assist older residents so that they may remain in their homes as they age. Consider development of housing for seniors in a planned location within Huntington Woods. Retain neighborhood commercial nodes in planned locations on 11 Mile Road and Coolidge Highway. Require commercial development to be sensitive to adjacent residential uses in Huntington Woods and neighboring communities. Educating the community about elements of Universal Design can illustrate that many home improvements will benefit residents of all ages. Keep parks and open space accessible to as many residents as possible. 9 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Update zoning and land use barriers to provide housing and modify the parking requirements. These requirements should be updated to reflect the context of land use, and should include consideration of shared parking and opportunities for public transportation. City of Huntington Woods Needs Assessment (2015) This report provides an assessment of the municipal complex located on Eleven Mile Road and explores the opportunities to upgrade municipal facilities and, at the same time, provide age-specific housing for the City of Huntington Woods. The first part of this report provides an overview of conditions of the facilities in the municipal complex. The second part of this report built upon the 2012 study regarding the agespecific housing needs for the community and explored options to develop housing at the municipal complex site. Municipal Complex Most of the City’s municipal services are located in the municipal complex. The three acre complex includes parking areas and four buildings: City Hall, the Department of Public Safety, the Department of Public Works, and the Parks Department storage facility. One objective of the study was to understand how the existing municipal facilities meet the variety of departmental needs. This information was based on faceto-face interviews and written responses to a questionnaire provided to staff. If the City were to move or redevelop the municipal complex, there might be an opportunity for new development, which could include a variety of housing options for an aging population. Age-Specific Housing Needs This portion of the study followed up on the results of the 2012 Older Needs Assessment and, through focus group discussions, explored in greater depth the liveability of Huntington Woods. One concept that was evaluated was visitability. Visitability is aimed at improving neighborhoods and social interactions by increasing awareness of a home’s access for those with mobility issues. Respondents were 10 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION asked if they had made any changes to the home to accommodate mobility concerns and the majority (81%) did not. In addition, a majority of responses realized their home cannot easily accommodate a friend or family member with mobility limitations (61%). Without having homes that could be visited by those with limited mobility, aging residents may not be able to successfully live out the rest of their lives in their home. Housing concerns included ability to keep up with outside maintenance (74%), stairs in the home (56%), single floor living (34%), and narrow doors and hallways (24%). A wider variety of housing options have the opportunity to reduce the impact of these housing concerns. The survey asked, “if there were alternative housing options in Huntington Woods for residents over age 55, such as attached townhomes or condominiums, would you consider moving?” A majority of participants said yes (66%). However, some residents questioned the need for alternatives, saying there is no room and this type of development is not consistent with the community character. There are possibilities to create functional spaces that meet the needs of older adults while also keeping the characteristics of the community intact. Redevelopment Options The study concluded with a brief exploration of the idea of leveraging the City’s municipal complex property to allow development of both new City facilities along with a senior housing project. Several case study examples were provided that focused on projects that were accomplished through public-private partnerships. In conclusion, the study provided the following recommendations to the City of Huntington Woods: Review areas to potentially relocate the Department of Public Works that would accommodate equipment. Entice higher density development in this location. Identify locations for opportunity for development of municipal services and senior housing on Woodward Avenue. Explore and understand additional opportunities for the funding of housing through the Michigan State Housing and Development Authority (MSHDA). Understand how planning for service delivery from a satellite campus could allow the City to move some of its facility needs off-site. Research and understand the variety of housing types available, Understand the footprint and area needs for the various housing type and where they should be located. Understand where there may be available property in the City including vacant lots and lots that are ripe for redevelopment. Explore opportunities to promote a variety of housing types that will make Huntington Woods an “age-friendly” community. 11 PART 2 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Part 3 Housing Options According to the 2012 Older Adults Needs Assessment and the 2014 Master Plan Update, the City’s older residents would like to see housing options and senior services designed to meet the needs and desires of an aging population. Housing options include remaining in one’s own home as well as expanding the range of choice in new housing. Older adults and senior residents wish to retain a sense of belonging, purpose, independence, and identity, and all of these things start at home. Huntington Woods is known as a “City of homes.” Home is different than housing type. The word home conveys images of safety and security. This section looks at expanding our definition of home to include other housing types that may be more supportive to an aging population when compared to single family detached dwelling units. Residential architecture is defined by three components: Architectural style Living space Housing type While this study focuses on housing type, it is important to address the issues of form and function. Form is what gives Huntington Woods its charming residential character and function is what gives residents the ability to live comfortably and independently in their home. The function of a home, without modification, may not accommodate the needs of aging residents. Therefore, two key concepts of visitability and universal design are also discussed as elements of living space. Architectural Style The architectural environment of Huntington Woods is characterized by the quality, variety, charm, and historic allure of its homes. Streets are lined with beautiful overarching trees, adding to the distinctive atmosphere of the City. accessory buildings, they regarding building City’s personality. Even if architectural style will guidelines and standards. To ensure consistent quality and similar styles without sacrificing diversity and character, Huntington Woods has in place the Planning Commission’s Guidelines for Residential Properties. As residents make exterior changes and add must comply to certain standards materials and style that preserve the housing function or type changes, the remain intact and uphold the City’s 12 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Furthering historic charm, Huntington Woods contains the Hill Historic District, which consists of 108 detached houses generally built in the 1920s and 1930s. A majority of the homes reflect the Tudor architectural style, however, a wide variety of styles are represented. One particular home, the Fred A. Baker house on LaSalle Boulevard, is listed on the State Register of Historic sites. Built in 1896, this house expressed the Colonial Revival style. Huntington Woods is comprised of primarily colonial revival, bungalow and ranch style homes. Throughout the community there are also several examples of Tudor revival. This style, very popular in Detroit and surrounding early subdivisions, is typified by features that include steeply pitched roofs, battlements, decorative half timbering, arches in entry doors and windows, facades, dominated by one or more prominent cross gables, and decorative leaded glass windows, usually in groups with multi-pane glazing and cut leaded glass. Other styles that are spread throughout as well include Dutch colonial, French country, and contemporary styles. Living Space A functional living space provides comfort. Living space includes the interior and exterior spaces of one’s home. Functionality has to do with the ease of daily activity made possible by the physical arrangement and design of space. While people can adapt to a variety of physical environments, as we age our mental sharpness, physical mobility and capabilities, as well as our financial means may diminish and over time these changes may make a once comfortable space feel overwhelming, debilitating, or unsafe. Functional spaces for aging adults may include features that promote accessibility, safety, and independence. When designing or modifying a living space to accommodate aging in place, the following features should be considered: B U I L D I N G S T O R I E S . Stairs and steps are a hazard for tripping and falling. Sturdy handrails should always accompany stairs. Ideally, a home should have a full bathroom, kitchen, and bedroom on the first floor to accommodate aging adults. Ability to install ramps and lifts should be possible if stairs are unavoidable. S Q U A R E F O O T A G E O F H O M E . A smaller home requires less funds and indoor/outdoor maintenance. Older adults may find as the age that they use less of their house since some areas may become inaccessible. D O O R S A N D W I N D O W S . Injuries often occur when windows or doors are difficult to open or close. H A L L W A Y S A N D D O O R W A Y . Enough room should be provided so older adults can maneuver through their home risk free, even if they are using an assistive device such as a walker or wheelchair. L I G H T I N G . Good visibility enables persons to see uneven spots in flooring. B A T H R O O M S . Installing hand rails in the bath and by the toilet provide another injury prevention feature. 13 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION These features are linked to the concept of Visitability and Universal Design, both of which make spaces more accessible, safe, and convenient for everyone, not just for the elderly. Visitability is a first step towards making homes more inclusive, and one which can empower a homeowner to age in place. Coined in the 1980’s, the term “visitability” is used to describe a few basic, affordable design options which broaden the equity in housing accessibility without necessarily stressing full accessibility for persons with disabilities, or older adults. Unlike full accessibility, which may require significant home Build a Home modification or purpose-built structures designed for the most severe of accessibility demands, visitability is a focused effort to encourage three for “The Ages” design features in new home construction which address home access By 2040, there are expected to be inequities: almost 80 million senior accounting Each unit must have at least one no-step entrance; All doors and hallways wide enough to navigate through with a walker or wheelchair; and, There must be a bathroom on the first floor big enough to get into a wheelchair, and close the door. The three design elements listed above are far more important to the functionality and safety of a home than many traditional full-accessibility standards, such as lower mirrors and sinks, etc. These features are critical to even permit the entry of a disabled or aging person into the structure. While full accessibility in all homes may be an unreasonable goal financially and aesthetically, visitability is an affordable, nearly invisible, responsible expectation. Visitability will broaden the appeal of all new housing to include older adults, and allow residents to remain in their homes once they begin to demand assistance. for 21 percent of the population. The existing housing stock isn’t equipped to safely accommodate that many older people – too many steep staircases, narrow walkerunfriendly doorways, and slippery step-in bathtubs and showers. Forward-thinking homeowners are making necessary improvements to their home now – and those changes will benefit people of all ages, not just seniors. According to a 2015 survey by HomeAdvisor, 56 percent of homeowners who hired a pro for aging-related projects were younger than 65, and 10 percent were younger than 50. Source: “The Real State of Real Estate”, Consumer Reports, March 2011 The National Association of Home building defines Universal Design as “the design of products and environments to be usable by all people to the greatest extent possible, without need for adaptation or specialized design”. This philosophy is intended to help systems function better for a wider range of people. Universal Design is a response to the diversity of human populations, like older adults, their abilities, and their needs. The seven principles of universal design are as follows: E Q U I T A B L E U S E : The design is useful and marketable to people with diverse abilities. F L E X I B I L I T Y I N U S E : The design accommodates a wide range of individual preferences and abilities. S I M P L E A N D I N T U I T I V E U S E : Use of the design is easy to understand, regardless of the user's experience, knowledge, language skills, or current concentration level. P E R C E P T I B L E I N F O R M A T I O N : The design communicates necessary information effectively to the user, regardless of ambient conditions or the user's sensory abilities. T O L E R A N C E F O R E R R O R : The design minimizes hazards and the adverse consequences of accidental or unintended actions. L O W P H Y S I C A L E F F O R T : The design can be used efficiently and comfortably with minimum fatigue. 14 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION S I Z E A N D S P A C E F O R A P P R O A C H A N D U S E : Appropriate size and space is provided for approach, reach, manipulation, and use regardless of user's body size, posture, or mobility. There are a number of specific techniques that can be used to implement the principles of universal design. However, these techniques can be generalized as follows: M A K E T H I N G S E A S I E R T O G R A B : The use of lever-style hardware instead of doorknobs makes doors easier to open. The same holds true for lever-style faucets. I N S T A L L F R I E N D L Y F L O O R S : Non-skid flooring or low pile carpeting reduces the potential for slips and falls and for smoother operation of a wheelchair or walker. I M P R O V E L I G H T I N G : Dark rooms, hallways and stairs are all recipes for accidents. Increasing lighting throughout the home will increase safety and help prevent dangerous falls. M A K E C O U N T E R S A N D C A B I N E T S A C C E S S I B L E : Roll-out shelving in cabinets and lowing countertops reduce the need for bending or stretching. B U I L D B E T T E R B A T H R O O M S : The number one room in which accidents occur are in the bathroom. Absent a walk-in shower, strategically placed grab bars will also improve safety. While aging in place modifications allow older adults to stay in their homes longer, incorporating universal design into new residential construction creates living spaces that can accommodate the full spectrum of ability and mobility where everyone can feel safe, independent, and comfortable. Currently, visitability and universal design are not requirements of the Michigan Building Code. However, there are a number of strategies that the City could employ to encourage building techniques that embrace both concepts on a voluntary and/or incentive basis: 1) Preparation of educational materials that demonstrate more common and cost effective techniques. 2) Provide free consultation to homeowners considering incorporating visitability and universal design in a remodeling project. 3) Develop streamline permitting and certain specific fee waivers for incorporating visitability and universal design in remodeling projects. 4) Develop a certification program that recognizes remodeling projects that incorporate visitability and universal design. Alternative Housing Types of Older Adults and Seniors The following alternative housing options were picked because they are the most likely to fit into Huntington Woods’ character and lot sizes. As the “City of homes”, Huntington Woods wants to maintain its quaint demeanor. With alternative housing options, this goal can still be achieved while providing growth to the housing market. A variety of housing types also means retention of residents who no longer can afford or maintain a single family home, but still want to remain in the City. With a few exceptions regarding senior housing facilities, the types of housing were also chosen to fit the restrictions of smaller lot sizes to preserve the character of the community. This report explores three categories of housing types for older adults and seniors: detached units, attached units, and senior housing facilities. 15 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION A detached home means that a home is free of any shared walls and stands alone. The stand-alone homes included in this report are bungalow courts, small homes oriented around a shared courtyard, and accessory dwelling units, a second small living unit on the same grounds as an existing home. An attached home means that a home shares a common wall usually on both sides of the property. Included in this report are duplexes or townhomes, two homes either built stacked or side-by-side, and multi-plexes, five to ten unit apartment buildings. Senior housing facilities can be either detached, as a planned residential community, or attached like assisted living or continuing-care accommodations. Often the reason families are looking into different housing options is that their older family members need help on a daily basis. Depending upon the level of care needed, options include assisted-living residences and nursing homes. For those planning for the future, but not needing the amount of care associated with assisted living or nursing homes, older adults can turn to continuing-care and planned residential communities. DETACHED DWELLING UNITS Bungalow court Accessory dwelling unit ATTACHED DWELLING UNITS Duplex / Townhome Multi-plex SENIOR HOUSING FACILITIES Adult foster care homes Assisted living Accessory dwelling unit Bungalow court Duplex 16 Assisted living PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION FOR RESIDENTS For each housing option presented on the following pages there is a table labeled “for residents”. The “for residents” section may help citizens choose what would be the best possible alternative to their current home. The chart explains the pros and cons to living in a specific housing type. As residents age, their needs and desires may change. This section gives residents the ability to choose the best option that would fit their current and future needs. One-floor storied homes with a smaller footprint would best fit the needs to an aging adult who might not be able to traverse stairs or maintain a larger home. Questions for residents to consider Do I want a more social living arrangement? Do I need assistance or additional care? If so, how much? Do I want a house with a smaller footprint? How much housing maintenance can I manage? Do I want a cheaper living option? FOR THE CITY For each housing option presented on the following pages there is a table labeled “for the City”. The City of Huntington Woods has different limitations than what a resident might consider. The zoning code currently does not allow several of these different housing types. With Huntington Woods being welldeveloped, housing types with smaller footprints are going to be more feasible than larger structures. Therefore, a bungalow court would be easier to execute than a planned residential community. Using housing options that fit into the existing residential scale and character, such as duplexes and accessory dwelling units, are the first step to creating a variety of housing types, maintaining a comfortable level of residential density, and allowing residents to age in their community safely and confidently. Questions for the City to consider Do we want more variety of housing types? Do we want more housing stock growth? Do we want to change our zoning code to allow for more options? Accessory dwelling unit Duplexes 17 Bungalow court PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION BUNGALOW COURT Number of units 5-10 units Typical Unit Size 500-800 sq. ft. On street parking 5-7 spaces Off street parking 0-1 space/unit This building type consists of a series of small, detached structures, providing multiple units arranged to define a shared court that is typically perpendicular to the street. The shared court takes the place of a private rear yard and is an important community-enhancing element. Bungalow courts provide a unique social aspect since they are close together with other similar structures. This blend of having a private space, but communal outdoors generates a micro-community. Depending on street parking, this type of housing may not be an ideal option due to the City ordinance about not parking on the street overnight. As a smaller one-story building, bungalows would allow older adults to maintain their own home while providing a safe environment for living. As long as the bungalow court design is compatible with the standards and guidelines of the Planning Commission, this provides for some additional variety and charm for the City. Since most of the City is already developed, finding the right lot with enough space poses a challenge. However, this type of housing provides an additional way for higher density, keeping a wider range of citizens in the community, and has the potential for housing stock growth. For residents: Pros One story living Smaller square footage Shared maintenance Sense of neighborhood and community Less cost compared to a single family home Feel safer with others nearby Cons No personal yard Limited parking For the City: Benefits Sense of neighborhood and community Housing stock growth Keep a wider range of citizens in the community Higher density Variety of housing 18 Challenges Zoning Available space PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT Number of units 1 Typical Unit Size 500-1,200 sq. ft. On street parking Off street parking 1 1 Accessory structures are typically located at the rear of a lot providing space for a small residential unit, home office, or other small commercial or service use. This unit could be above a garage or at ground level. Accessory dwelling units are less costly and easier to maintain than their larger counterparts. These units are ideal for multigenerational families seeking privacy. Owners of the original home on the lot will also gain additional income from their renters. Having close contact with the original home owner provides increased safety and security. Accessory dwelling units can be designed to blend in with the surrounding architecture, maintaining compatibility with established neighborhoods and preserving community character. With Huntington Woods being well-developed, this type of housing is well-designed for larger lots and creates infill on an individual property basis. Since most of the City is already developed, finding a location for an accessory dwelling unit would be easier to place. There are enough larger lots in the community where this type of housing would be ideal. As a different type of housing, accessory dwelling units provide an additional way for higher density, keeping a wider range of citizens in the community, and have the potential for housing stock growth. For residents: Pros One story living Smaller square footage Less maintenance and cost Owners renting can receive additional income Generational housing for older relatives Feel safer with others nearby Cons Relying on landlord to make repairs, if renting Limited parking For the City: Benefits Sense of neighborhood and community Infill for the community Housing stock growth Keep a wider range of citizens in the community Variety of housing 19 Challenges Zoning Ensuring neighborhood compatibility PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION DUPLEX Number of units 2 Typical Unit Size 1,000-1,200 sq. ft. On street parking 1 Off street parking 1 A duplex is a small to medium-sized structure that consists of two dwelling units, one next to the other or stacked on top of each other, both of which face and are entered from the street. Owning an entire duplex requires also having tenants in one of the units. While this may provide an extra source of income, older residents would be required to attend to house repairs and upkeep. Renting a space in a duplex, would allow for relief from household maintenance. Generally, side-by-side duplexes do not have a bedroom, bathroom, and kitchen facilities on the first floor. A stacked duplex allows one of the units to be on ground floor; a better option for aging residents. As Huntington Woods already has zoning for two-family residences, duplexes would be the least unusual of the housing options. As long as the duplex still possesses the stylistic approaches as the rest of the community does, according to the standards and guidelines of the Planning Commission, this provides for some additional variety for the City. Since most of the City is already developed, finding space poses a challenge. However, this type of housing provides an additional way for higher density, keeping a wider range of citizens in the community, and has the potential for housing stock growth. For residents: Pros Possibility of one story living Smaller square footage Less maintenance and cost Rent or own both units Feel safer with others nearby Cons Generally includes second story No bathroom, bedroom and kitchen on first floor Relying on landlord to make repairs, if renting If owned, have to maintain upkeep For the City: Benefits Variety of housing Infill for the community Housing stock growth Keep a wider range of citizens in the community Already accepted in the zoning code Higher Density 20 Challenges Available space PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION MULTI-PLEX Number of units 4-10 units Typical Unit Size 1,000-1,200 sq. ft. On street parking 3-5 spaces Off street parking 1.5 spaces / unit maximum A multi-plex is a medium structure that consists of 4-10 side-by-side and/or stacked dwelling units, typically with one shared entry or individual entries along the front. Small multiplexes provide a unique social aspect since they are close together. This blend of having a private space, but communal outdoors generates a micro-community. With shared walls, some privacy is reduced. Without street parking, this type of housing may not be an ideal option. This would also involve having entire units on the second floor which is not preferred for many aging residents. However, having multiple older residents in a similar housing situation would garner attention from more routine services that aid in transportation and health. For residents: Pros Cons Generally includes second story No bathroom, bedroom and kitchen on first floor in some units Possibility of one story living Smaller square footage Less maintenance and cost Sense of neighborhood and community Possibility for routine check ups Feel safer with others nearby For City: Benefits Variety of housing Infill for the community Housing stock growth Keep a wider range of citizens in the community Higher density 21 Challenges Zoning Available space PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION ADULT FOSTER CARE HOME Number of units 1 unit Typical Unit Size 1,000-2,500 sq. ft. The State of Michigan categorizes and licenses adult foster care homes as residential settings that provide 24-hour personal care, protection and supervision for individuals who are developmentally disabled, mentally ill, physically handicapped or aged who cannot live alone but who do not need continuous nursing homes. There are many adult foster care homes that specifically cater to seniors. Cost can vary based on the services provided. Privacy is not guaranteed because double occupancy in rooms are common. For residents: Pros Care and security Residential Setting Cons Cost Not in own home Double Occupancy, possibly with stranger Inconsistent service For City: Benefits Serves a need Maintains single-family character Challenges 22 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION ASSISTED LIVING Number of units 10-70 units Typical Unit Size 500-1,200 sq. ft. Residents who need assistance with daily activities such as bathing, grooming, and dressing, but are otherwise independent and not in need of full time nursing may want to consider assisted living options. The average entry age for residents is about 80 years old, so the population is generally all older adults. With a minimum of ten and as many as 30 full-time staff per 100 residents, there is care provided in emergencies. Privacy is not guaranteed with 40-70% of units being double-occupancy. From the City’s point of view, assisted living would be an option to fulfill the needs of the elderly. For residents: Pros Care and security for residents Smaller square footage No maintenance Sense of neighborhood and community Activities provided for social interaction Cons Cost Not in own home Lack of diversity in age Double occupancy possibility with a stranger For City: Benefits Variety of housing Keep a wider range of citizens in the community Attract others to the City Activities provided for social interaction Sense of neighborhood and community 23 Challenges Zoning Available space Lack of diversity in age PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Part 4 Land Use and Zoning The purpose of the Phase 1 study was to assess the existing conditions and provide information on possible housing options that could be made available to Huntington Woods residents through land use and zoning changes. While land use and zoning is part of the background data, it is also the bridge to the next phase of study which looks at feasibility, site selection, and implementation. This report provides an overview of land use patterns and zoning for the City. It also provides land use information for the surrounding communities, with a particular focus on housing options, including attached single family, multiple family, and senior housing facilities. Land Use Huntington Woods’ primary land use is single-family residential. Multiple-family residential land use, while permitted by zoning, is not currently provided in the City. Table 5. Land Use, Huntington Woods, 2014 Land Use Area (Acres) Area (%) Single-Family Residential 482.4 51.6 Multiple-Family Residential 0.0 0.0 Mobile Home Park 0.0 0.0 Commercial/Office 3.0 0.3 Industrial 0.0 0.0 Public/Institutional 7.9 0.8 Recreation/Conservation 224.3 24.0 Mixed Use 7.0 0.8 Reclamation Plan 0.0 0.0 Water 2.9 0.3 Railroad Right-of-Way 0.0 0.0 Road Right-of-Way 207.2 22.2 Total 934.8 100.0 Source: Oakland County Economic Development and Community Affairs 24 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Figure 8. Existing Land Use, Huntington Woods, 2014 Source: Oakland County Note: Oakland County provides countywide generalized land use data to allow for comparisons between communities. The City of Huntington Woods is less than 1.5 square miles. The small size is reflected in the land use data for the community. For some residents who cannot “Age in Place” (remain in their home) because of physical or financial limitations staying close to their community may be enough. The surrounding Cities of Berkley, Ferndale, Oak Park, Pleasant Ridge, Royal Oak, and Southfield offer some additional housing options including single family attached, multiple family, and senior housing; options not readily available within the City of Huntington Woods. Using data from the Oakland Land Use Statistics profiles, Table 6 provides a comparison of residential land uses across these seven communities. This comparison does not provide any qualitative information but it does show that there is a general lack of housing options for an aging population in and around the City of Huntington Woods. 25 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Table 6. Land Use of Huntington Woods Compared to Surrounding Communities, 2014 Single Family Single Family Multiple Family Total Detached Attached Land Use Land Use Land Use Parcels Parcels Parcels Parcels Acres Percentage Percentage Percentage Huntington Woods Berkley Ferndale Oak Park Pleasant Ridge Royal Oak Southfield 2,430 51.30% 1 0.00% 0 0 2,490 934.8 6,445 8,780 9,483 55.80% 45.9% 45.10% 0 1 0 0 0.00% 0 16 94 66 0.20% 0.09% 4.70% 7,124 9,966 10,293 1,663.4 2,498.7 3,316.7 1,140 60.70% 0 0 2 0.10% 1,247 363.8 20,941 46.90% 1 0.00% 391 5.10% 22,863 7,555.9 17,024 39.10% 6 0.00% 163 8.20% 19,483 16,819.0 Source: Oakland County Economic Development and Community Affairs Note: Land Use Percentage is the total land use for the community including non-residential land uses. As discussed in Part 3, different housing types provide varying levels of service and support for an aging population. Figure 10 shows the name and location of housing options and senior service facilities within a mile of the City boundary. 26 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Figure 9. Existing Senior Housing and Service Facilities around Huntington Woods Table 7. Existing Senior Housing and Service Facilities around Huntington Woods Name Oxford Park Towers Royal Oak Manor Barton Towners Co-Op Apartments Meadowlark Home Care Medilodge of Southfield Genesis Home Care Solaire Active Adult Community Hilton Convalescent Home Irvine Head Injury Home Visiting Nurse Association Type Independent Living Independent Living Independent Living Home Health Care Service Assisted Living Facility Home Health Care Service Independent Living Assisted Living Facility Assisted Living Facility Home Health Care Service 27 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Zoning A majority of Huntington Woods is zoned for residential use. The City has seven (7) zoning districts that permit residential land use: R1A, R-1B, R-1C, R-1D, R-1E, Zone 2, and Zone 2A. Dimensional requirements aside, the alternative housing options discussed in this report would only be permitted in two of the seven districts: Zone 2 and Zone 2A. As shown in Figure 12, there are two parcels zoned Zone 2 - One and Two Family. One parcel at the northwest corner of Coolidge and Ludlow is the site of the City’s only duplex and the other parcel is the site of the Municipal Complex, discussed in Part 2 of this report. There are 16 parcels zoned Zone 2A – Transitional Office. These parcels are located along the Woodward Avenue and are currently occupied by commercial/office uses. Adjusting the Zoning Ordinance to accommodate alternative housing options in more areas of the community is the first step in terms of implementation. Well-crafted regulations will expand housing options for City residents while protecting the character of the existing residential neighborhoods. Table 8. Permitted Residential Land Uses in Select Zoning Districts, Huntington Woods Single-family dwelling (one per lot) State-licensed residential facility R-1A, R-1B, R-1C, R-1D, and R-1E Single Family Zone 2 One and Two Family Permitted Permitted Permitted Permitted Two-family dwelling Zone 2A Transitional Office Permitted Multiple-family Permitted Senior housing and assisted living facilities Permitted Source: Huntington Woods Zoning Ordinance Potential Locations Over 97% of properties in Huntington Woods are single-family residential uses. The current zoning does not allow for many of the various housing options discussed in this report. Older Huntington Woods residents wish to stay within the city but are unable to do so because housing options do not exist. In order to provide for additional housing opportunities for seniors, zoning and land uses changes need to be considered. As a single-family community, providing additional housing options can be met with opposition. However, a diverse housing stock is critical to maintaining lifecycle communities. For many older adults, the housing problem is not the need for on-site care, but rather, simply the need for a smaller, more easily maintained residence. As outlined in the 2014 City of Huntington Woods Master Plan and the 2012 and 2015 City of 28 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Huntington Woods Needs Assessment Survey, there is an identified community desire and need to increase the availability of single-story homes (with universal design), townhouses, apartments, and condos to provide adequate senior housing. Land use and zoning changes do not simply happen in windowless rooms – they should be public processes involving neighborhood members that can raise intense emotions and strong opinions. A community conversation in Huntington Woods needs to occur about potential locations and types for senior housing. To assist in the community conversation, discussed below are potential locations and types to consider for senior housing. All locations will require a public education process regarding the intent and neighborhood impacts. Potential Locations for empty-nester and senior housing include: Location Woodward Avenue Eleven Mile Road Coolidge Highway Type Townhomes Apartment Mixed use buildings (first floor commercial, upper floor residential) Issues to Consider Limited property depth Ensuring appropriate buffer to adjacent singlefamily residents Townhomes Limited property depth Ensuring appropriate buffer to adjacent singlefamily residents Limited property depth Ensuring appropriate buffer to adjacent singlefamily residents Locations Number of units permitted on a lot Ensuring appropriate land use transition and compatibility Must consider city hall and public safety programming needs Ensuring appropriate buffer to adjacent singlefamily residents Apartments Townhomes Mixed use buildings Bungalow Court West of Scotia Road City Hall Property Varied senior housing options including apartments and mixed use building 29 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Figure 10. City of Huntington Woods Zoning Map 30 PART 4 HUNTINGTON WOODS HOUSING OPTIONS FOR AN AGING POPULATION Figure 11. Housing Options Strategy 31 PART 4
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz