Withdrawal users` perceptions of and experience with contraceptive

ARTICLE IN PRESS
Midwifery (2006) 22, 274–284
www.elsevier.com/locate/midw
Withdrawal users’ perceptions of and experience
with contraceptive methods in Manisa, Turkey
Emre Yanikkerem, MSc (President of Midwifery Department)a,,
Hatice Acar, MScb, Emel Elem (Midwife)c
a
Celal Bayar University, Manisa School of Health, Turkey
Koceli University School of Health, Turkey
c
Denizli Private Eye Hospital, Turkey
b
Received 9 September 2004; received in revised form 17 December 2004, 16 March 2005 and 4 April 2005; accepted 26
April 2005
KEYWORDS
Withdrawal;
Coitus interruptus;
Contraception;
Family planning
education
Summary
Objective: to gain an understanding of the knowledge, perceptions and experiences
of using contraceptive methods among Turkish withdrawal users.
Design: population-based, cross-sectional and descriptive study using a questionnaire conducted face to face.
Setting: women who live in the Number 6 primary health unit area in Manisa,
Turkey.
Participants: 276 women who used the ‘withdrawal’ method for contraception.
Measurements and findings: almost all women were aware of modern contraceptive
methods. The condom, intrauterine contraceptive device (IUCD) and oral contraceptives were the most known methods. The most common reasons for using
‘withdrawal’ were that this method was reliable, husbands preferred it, it was
healthier, easier to use or more convenient than other methods.
Conclusion and implications for practice: it is important for midwives and nurses to
recognise the effects of cultural beliefs on women’s contraceptive use. Educational
programmes should be individualised to meet the specific needs of women and their
partners.
& 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Introduction
An estimated 1.38 billion women in the world are of
childbearing age. During most of this time, women
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: [email protected] (E. Yanikkerem).
are sexually active but do not want to have children
(United Nations, 1997). More than a quarter of
women who become pregnant have either an
unwanted birth or termination of pregnancy. About
230 million women worldwide are in need of
effective birth control methods (The Alan Guttmacher Institute, 1999).
0266-6138/$ - see front matter & 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.midw.2005.04.001
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Withdrawal users’ perceptions of and experience with contraceptive methods in Manisa, Turkey
Although rapid population growth in Turkey first
became a problem around 1950, the government
prohibited the sale and distribution of contraceptive methods, as well as family planning
education, until 1965, when the first law on
population control was introduced. This law permitted the sale, distribution and use of contraceptive methods, and encouraged family planning
education. Voluntary sterilisation and abortion
were not permitted until 1983 (Aytekin et al.,
2001). Then, the total fertility rate decreased from
6% to 2.6%, and the population growth rate
decreased from 2.6% in 1965 to 1.5% in 1998
(Turkish Population and Health Survey, 1998;
Aytekin et al., 2001). In 2003, the total fertility
rate was 2.2% (Turkish Population and Health
Survey, 2003).
‘Withdrawal’ (coitus interruptus) remains one of
the most widely used temporary contraceptive
methods in the world (McLaren, 1990). It has
played a key role in facilitating fertility decline in
many developed countries before the introduction
of modern contraceptives, and it continues to be
adopted extensively in South-eastern Europe and
the Near East (McLaren, 1990; Kulczycki, 2004). In
Turkey, which sits astride both these regions,
withdrawal remains the most commonly practised
means of contraception, and is perhaps more
frequently used there than in any other developing
country (UN, 2000).
National surveys indicate that withdrawal is the
most widely used method in Rumania (35%), Turkey
(27%) and the Czeck Republic (24%) (Network,
1996). Use of withdrawal prevalence differs across
Muslim societies. According to the Demographic
Health Survey data from predominantly Muslim
countries in the early 1990s, withdrawal use ranged
from 0–1% in Niger, Senegal, Egypt, Indonesia and
Pakistan, to 3% in Morocco and Bangladesh and 4%
in Jordan (Karim, 1997).
In Turkey, many health institutions give contraceptive counselling. Family planning services and
primary health care units give free information on
contraceptive methods to individuals or couples,
and these units provide contraceptive methods free
of charge or with very little self-payment. Private
practice gynaecologists and general practitioners,
as well as nurses and midwives at maternity
consultations in hospitals, are the main providers
of information about contraceptive methods. Family planning nurses carry out counselling, intrauterine contraceptive device (IUCD) insertion, and
distribution of oral contraceptives and condoms.
Family planning counselling is also the duty of
midwives who visit families in their homes regularly. In addition, condoms, oral contraceptives,
275
emergency pill, injections and spermicide are
available over-the-counter. However, in Turkey,
although families do not want to have a large
number of children, and modern methods of family
planning are easily available, families still use
traditional methods. The rate of using traditional
methods was 33.4% in 1968 and about 26.4% in
2003, respresenting a small decrease (Turkish
Population and Health Survey, 2003). According to
annual statistics, the withdrawal usage rate was
16.8% in 1978, 25.0% in 1983, 25.7% in 1988, 26.2%
in 1993, 24.4% in 1998 and 26.4% in 2003 (Kulczycki,
2004; Hancioglu, 1997; Turkish Population and
Health Survey, 2003).
However, in Turkey, male sterilisation, female
sterilisation, oral contraceptives, IUCDs, injectables, implants, the diaphragm and male and
female condoms were accepted as modern methods
of contraception (Turkish Population and Health
Survey, 2003). Almost all women know about at
least one modern method. The most widely known
modern contraceptive methods are the IUCD (98%),
oral contraceptives (98%), male condom (90%),
female sterilisation (90%) and injectables (82%).
Among traditional methods, the withdrawal method is the most widely recognised method (94% for
women who had ever been married and currently
married women, respectively), and more than 60%
of women have used withdrawal at some time
(Turkish Population and Health Survey, 2003).
Despite this finding, only 42.5% of currently married
women of reproductive age used modern methods.
The IUCD was the most commonly used method, the
male condom the second and oral contraceptives
the third (Turkish Population and Health Survey,
2003). Although modern contraceptive use has
become more widespread among educated women,
one-half of women with secondary or higher
education used a traditional method or no method
at all (Turkish Population and Health Survey, 1998;
Kulczycki, 2004). It is known that 24% of married
women have had a termination of pregnancy
(private health institution statistics not included).
One month after termination, 30.7% of women
were not using any method of contraception, and
26.4% were using the withdrawal method. Termination of pregnancy tended to be used as a contraceptive method (Turkish Population and Health
Survey, 2003). These findings indicate that there
are still high unmet needs in family planning in
Turkey.
Previous studies have been unable to explain why
withdrawal remains the most preferred method of
fertility regulation in Turkey. The aim of this study
was to (1) investigate the reasons for using withdrawal and (2) to gain a better understanding of
ARTICLE IN PRESS
276
users’ knowledge, perceptions and experiences of
modern methods of contraception. In addition, the
findings from this study in Manisa, Turkey, provide
in-depth baseline information as well as comparative data for future studies that explore and
document reproductive health.
Methods
Design and participants
This research was undertaken in the city of Manisa,
Turkey. The area of Manisa is 13,810 km square and
the total population is 1,261,643 (Manisa Director
of Health, 2003). Manisa is located in the western
part of Anatolia, between the Spil Mountain and
Gediz River. Manisa is a developed city, with
agriculture, trading and industry. However, it also
has many immigrants from eastern Turkey. According to the Manisa population and health mid-2003
study report (Manisa Director of Health, 2003),
Manisa has 344,986 women between the ages of
15–49 years. The crude birth rate (births per 1000
of population in a given year) is 39.6; the induced
abortion rate is 30.1 (abortion per 1000 of population), maternal mortality rate (per 100,000 live
births) is 42.3 (Manisa Director of Health, 2003).
The rate for women aged 15–49 years using
contraception (modern methods) was 37.1 (per
100 women). Forty per cent of women did not use
any contraceptive methods (Manisa Director of
Health, 2003).
Of the primary care units in Manisa centre
providing family planning services, one primary
care unit was randomly selected, Number 6 primary
health unit, for this study. As contraceptive use
out-of-wedlock is extremely low in Turkey, only
married women were included in the study. The
study population consisted of 1551 married women
aged 15–49 years who, according to the Manisa
Director of Health statistics (Manisa Director of
Health, 2003), used the withdrawal method. We
calculated that 20% of the population should be
included in the study (overall 311 women). We used
the ‘systematic sampling method (Sümbüloglu and
Sümbüloglu, 1990) to calculate the sample size:
(universe/sample) interval – 1551/311 ¼ 4.9. Using
the health-centre records, the profile forms of
married women between the ages of 15 and 49
years were arranged according to their street
addresses. The first card was chosen randomly
and then every fifth card was selected.
In Turkey, all women aged 15–49 years are
recorded in primary health units. Twice a year,
E. Yanikkerem et al.
midwives and nurses are required to visit all these
women at home. During these visits, the midwives
and nurses complete health cards and, in particular, ask about women’s use of contraception. During
the visits, the midwives and nurses ascertain who is
pregnant, the number of babies and the number of
women who are in the postpartum period. Women
who were currently pregnant, or trying to become
pregnant, were not included in our study. Twentyseven women declined to participate in the study.
The researchers visited the homes on three occasions but did not find eight women at home.
Therefore, the study sample included 276 women,
an 88.8% response rate. The study was carried out
between May and July of 2004. We conducted the
questionnaires face-to-face. We believed that
these reasons affect the response rate.
Questionnaire and interview
This descriptive, population-based and cross-sectional study, which aimed to determine the knowledge, attitudes, and practices relating to
contraception methods, was conducted among
withdrawal users using a questionnaire that was
designed on the basis of the published literature.
The questionnaire had three parts. The first
covered socio-demographic characteristics (e.g.
age, education and employment) and women’s
background reproductive health. The second part
consisted of information about why women used
the withdrawal method and attitudes to this
method. The third part consisted of questions
about knowledge, experiences of and attitudes to
contraceptive methods and knowledge of the
menstrual cycle. The face validity of the questionnaire was obtained by asking expert opinion.
The opinions of one primary health unit’s practitioners, a university lecturer in women’s health and
diseases and a primary health unit midwife.
Changes to the questionnaire were made according
to the experts’ suggestions. Some questions were
removed from the questionnaire, and the revised
questionnaire was then tested for readability and
relevance on 15 women. It was found to be
acceptable.
The researchers conducted the face-to-face
questionnaires in the women’s homes. When the
questionnaire was completed, the participants
were encouraged to ask the research team questions about modern contraceptive methods, and
the researchers gave the women education on
modern contraceptive methods. During the education sessions, the researchers used techniques such
as oral presentation, asking–answering, discussion
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Withdrawal users’ perceptions of and experience with contraceptive methods in Manisa, Turkey
and demonstration. After we completed the questionnaire and education session, some women
talked to us about their contraception experiences.
Although we had not planned our study to be a
qualitative study, we noted women’s experiences
and feelings. Because we found the women’s
experiences and opinions of importance, we then
decided to share their perceptions about this
method. At the end of the education session, the
researchers gave the women a brochure about
modern methods of contraception. Women who
were eager to use modern contraceptives were
invited to the primary health unit, and researchers
gave condoms and oral contraceptives to women
who wanted to use these methods. These question
and answer sessions lasted between 30 mins and
an hour.
The data were collected using face-to-face
interviews. This enabled the researchers to establish rapport with the participants and allowed the
researchers to observe as well as listen. In our
study, the findings from the questionnaires better
enabled us to understand the withdrawal users’
experiences concerning contraception and women’s attitudes to and knowledge of all methods.
Nevertheless, the researchers had a chance to
correct women’s misunderstanding of contraceptive methods. However, face-to-face interviews
require effort and commitment. While we gathered
the data, we came across some difficulties. For
example, although researchers showed women an
identity card, some women were not prepared to
respond, saying: ‘I have no time’ or ‘I have a
specialist doctor’.
Ethics of research
In Manisa, ethical review and access to undertake a
study are provided by the same authority, in this
case the medical administrative authorities and the
Health Directorate. The participants were informed
about the study, and their verbal permission to
participate was obtained. We explained the purpose of the reserach to the women and, before
each interview, we reminded the women that they
could withdraw from the interview at any time and
that confidentially and anonymity would be protected at all times. We also explained to the
women that their names were not written on the
completed questionnaire.
Analysis
Data were analysed using the Microsoft Excel
programme. Statistical analysis was carried out
277
using frequency distributions and cross tabulations.
Researchers evaluated the data using EPI INFO
(Version 6.04b).
Findings
Characteristics of the sample
The mean age of the women was 35.3 (standard
deviation [SD] ¼ 8.1) years (minimum ¼ 18 years
and maximum ¼ 49 years) (Table 1). Two-thirds of
the women only had elementary education or less,
89.9% of women did not work outside the home for
financial remuneration, and 86.6% had social
guarantee for health care. Forty per cent of the
women said that they had been married for 10
years or less. The average length of marriage was
14.7 (SD ¼ 8.8) years. A small proportion of them
were patriarchal family type, and the average
number of people in each household was 4.1
(SD ¼ 1.3). Reproductive history showed that
20.7% of women had more than three children,
48.2% had two children. The average number of
children was 1.9 (SD ¼ 0.7). Mean age of the
women at first pregnancy was 21.6 (SD ¼ 3.8)
years, and the average number of live births per
woman was 2.1 (SD ¼ 1.1). Of the women, 105
(38%) reported having had at least one unwanted or
unplanned pregnancy. One out of four women
reported that they terminated a pregnancy because
it was unplanned. When we asked the women
whether they had been using a contraceptive
method when their last unwanted or unplanned
pregnancy occurred, almost half of them (48.6%)
said that they were practising withdrawal (Table 1).
Familiarity with, experiences of and
attitudes to contraceptive methods
Almost all of the women (n ¼ 273) were aware of
modern contraceptive methods. Condom, IUCD and
oral contraceptives were the best-known methods.
Since the onset of their sexual life, all except one
had used one or several contraceptive methods
(IUCD, condom, injection or oral contraceptives).
The most frequently used were the condom, oral
contraceptives and IUCD (Table 2). When we asked
the women why they stopped using modern
methods, the women stated the following as their
main reasons: stopped using IUCD because of health
problems (n ¼ 25), stopped taking oral contraceptives because of their potential side-effects
(n ¼ 50); stopped using the condom because of
the unwillingness of their husband (n ¼ 33); and
ARTICLE IN PRESS
278
E. Yanikkerem et al.
Table 1
89.9
10.1
The women reported that the IUCD (28.6%) was
the most reliable method for them (Table 2).
However, 38.5% of women thought that this method
caused many side-effects. Although 15.1% of the
women believed that oral contraceptives were
reliable, 56.3% of the women believed that this
method caused side-effects. Twelve per cent of the
women found condoms reliable, but 3.7% of the
women considered that there were side-effects to
the use of condoms. These percentages determined
women’s perception of the method (which may or
may not be partly based on experience).
86.6
13.4
Reasons for withdrawal preference
Profiles of withdrawal users.
N
Age of women (Years)
o35
134
X35
142
Education of women
Elementary or less
184
Elementary or more
92
Women’s occupation
Unemployed
248
Employed
28
Social guarantee
Guarantee
239
No guarantee
37
Education of partner
Elementary or less
136
Elementary or more
140
Partner’s age (years)
o35
88
X35
188
Income status
Good
59
Middle
186
Bad
31
Married (number of years)
p10 years
112
410 years
164
Family type
Nucleus
252
Patriarchal
24
Number of children
0–1
86
2
133
X3
57
Experienced curettage
Experienced
69
Not experienced
207
Experienced unwanted pregnancy
Yes
105
No
171
Total
276
%
48.6
51.4
66.7
33.3
49.3
50.7
31.9
68.1
21.4
67.4
11.2
40.6
59.4
91.3
8.7
31.2
48.2
20.7
25.0
75.0
38.0
62.0
100.0
Women used contraceptive methods while
experienced unwanted pregnancy
No method
42
40.0
Withdrawal
51
48.6
Oral contraceptive
2
1.9
IUD
6
5.7
Calendar method
3
2.9
Injection
1
1.0
Total
105
100.0
105 women experienced unwanted pregnancy.
stopped using the female barrier methods (n ¼ 3)
or spermicide (n ¼ 10) because their application
was difficult.
One of the objectives of our study was to determine
why couples prefer withdrawal, even though other,
more effective methods, are available without any
charge, and family planning counselling and education have been in existence in Manisa for more than
25 years. As can be seen in Table 3, when asked
their main reason for using withdrawal rather than
other methods, the most common reason was that
the women found this method reliable. Nearly onethird of the users said that their husband wanted to
use withdrawal. A quarter of the women stated
that it was healthier, easier to use or more
convenient than other methods. Almost one in five
users indicated problems with other methods,
about one in six women said that the method cost
them no money. Other reasons were that the
method did not contain hormones, it was easy to
give up this method, women had health problems,
health-care providers suggested this method, they
were afraid to use another method, they lacked
confidence in modern methods, and did not use
another method. The average number of years
of usage of the withdrawal method was 10.6
(SD ¼ 7.9) (range 1–32).
Women’s attitudes to, and practice of, the
withdrawal method
It was reported by 84.4% of the women that they
were satisfied with this method (Table 4). According to the women, 69.9% of their husbands were
pleased with this method. More than half of the
women (53.6%) claimed that the withdrawal method was effective. Almost 70% of the women
reported that the decision to use withdrawal had
been made jointly with their husband. However,
just over a quarter of them reported that withdrawal disturbed their sexual health, and 65.2% of
them said that they were afraid of conceiving while
they were using this method. Only 36.2% of the
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Withdrawal users’ perceptions of and experience with contraceptive methods in Manisa, Turkey
Table 2
279
Familiarity, experiences and attitudes among women for family planning methods.
Methods
Familiarity
with methods
Oral contraceptive
IUD
Condom
Monthly injectable
Three-monthly injectable
Female sterilisation
Calendar method
Spermicide
Vasectomy
Female barrier methods
(diaphragm, cervical cap, female
condom, sponge)
Norplant-implants
Contraceptive
method used
before
withdrawal
Found
contraceptive
methods
reliable
Belief in sideeffects of
methods
N
%
N
%
N
%
N
%
272
273
270
232
210
242
172
162
136
35
98.6
98.9
97.8
84.1
76.1
87.7
62.3
58.7
49.3
12.7
88
70
88
4
4
—
17
14
—
3
32.4
25.6
32.6
1.7
1.9
8.6
41
78
33
17
14
59
10
6
22
7
15.1
28.6
12.2
7.3
6.7
24.4
5.8
3.7
16.2
20.0
153
105
10
42
42
12
5
4
4
2
56.3
38.5
3.7
18.1
20.0
5.0
2.9
2.5
2.9
5.7
134
48.6
1
0.8
13
9.7
6
4.5
9.9
8.6
‘Contraceptive method used before withdrawal’, ‘found contraceptive methods reliable’ and ‘belief in side-effects of
methods’ are taken from women’s familiarity with methods. These columns refer to women’s perception of the method (which
may or may not be partly based on experience).
Table 3
Main reason for using withdrawal method.
Reasons
N
%
This method is reliable
My husband wants to use this method
This method is easier to use
This method has fewer side-effects than other methods
This method is not costly
This method does not contain hormones
It is easier to give up this method
I had health problems
Health-care providers suggested this method
I am afraid of using another method
I lack confidence in modern methods
I do not want to use another method
92
86
71
63
46
40
33
22
15
10
9
4
33.3
31.2
25.7
22.8
16.7
14.5
12.0
8.0
5.4
3.6
3.3
1.4
Average of year usage withdrawal method
women correctly knew the most fertile period of
their menstrual cycle. Only 4% of these withdrawal
users used a condom during their ovulation period,
and only 13.4% of the women were aware of
emergency contraception (Table 4).
Contraception education
After completing the questionnaire, the researchers provided the women with education on modern
10.677.9 (1–32)
methods of contraception. After the education
session, those women who wanted to use oral
contraceptives or condoms were provided with a
supply. Those who wanted to use an IUCD were
given an appointment to attend the health centre.
However, after educating the women, 159 (57.6%)
wanted to continue using the withdrawal method.
During discussions with the women, they told us
that there were numerous rumours and misunderstandings surrounding oral contraceptives. For
example, that they can cause serious side-effects,
ARTICLE IN PRESS
280
Table 4
E. Yanikkerem et al.
Women’s attitudes and practice towards withdrawal method.
Women are pleased with this method
Yes
No
Husbands are pleased this method
Yes
No
Withdrawal is effective
Yes
No
Who prefers withdrawal
Only women
Only husband
Both spouses
Women enjoy sexual intercourse while using this method
Yes
No
Women fear becoming pregnant while using this method
Yes
No
Women know their period of ovulation
Yes
No
Women use condoms during their period of ovulation
Yes
No
Women are familiar with emergency contraception
Yes
No
Total
such as cancer, back pain, headaches, dizziness,
fatal abnormalities, infertility, hair loss and weight
gain. Women who had negative opinions reported
that the IUCD could be felt by both the woman and
the man, perforates the uterus, causes pain and
migrates from the uterus into the abdomen, and
that condom use causes frigidity. Some of the
women who had used condoms before stated that
they stopped using these methods because of their
husbands’ unwillingness. Some women reported
that they did not enjoy having sex when they used
the pill or condoms. Twenty-six women explained
that they experienced abnormal haemorrhage
while using the IUCD. Sixteen women pointed out
that oral contraceptives and depo-provera had such
side-effects as bleeding irregularities and amenorrhea. Some women believed that amenorrhea is
associated with many problems, including fatigue,
headaches and weakness. One woman declared
that, ‘without a period at all, I feel I am like men’,
and that irregular bleeding is associated with
similar problems too. Some women noted that
condoms are not good for women’s health, as they
N
%
233
43
84.4
15.6
193
83
69.9
30.1
148
128
53.6
46.4
17
67
192
6.2
24.3
69.6
203
73
73.6
26.4
180
96
65.2
34.8
100
176
36.2
63.8
11
265
4.0
96.0
37
239
276
13.4
86.6
100.0
believed that the plastic composition may dry,
inflame or burn the womb.
In our findings, most of the users were content
with withdrawal and did not want to change
method. Many women said ‘this method was
effective’, ‘my husband could manage it successfully, I did not need to use modern methods, I have
not conceived previously using withdrawal’, and ‘I
did not experience unwanted pregnancy while
using this method’.
Discussion
This study has some limitations. First, the study was
carried out in one area of one region in Turkey.
Therefore, these findings cannot be generalised to
the whole of the region, let alone the whole of
Turkey. Second, the sample size is small. The latter
due to lack of financial support. However, this is the
first study that has investigated the knowledge of,
and attitudes to, contraceptive methods among
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Withdrawal users’ perceptions of and experience with contraceptive methods in Manisa, Turkey
women who used the withdrawal method in Manisa,
Turkey. Few data are associated with withdrawal
users’ attitudes to, and knowledge of, contraception in our country. Despite these limitations,
our findings are important for the understanding of
social attitudes and behaviour in different regions
for the development of health-promotion policies.
In addition, collecting this type of information is
essential for making informed policy decisions, and
for planning, monitoring and evaluating programmes in reproductive health. The key study
finding was that a sample of women had inadequate
knowledge of contraceptive methods, although
almost all women were familiar with them.
According to our findings, another important point
is that almost half of withdrawal users wanted to
continue to use the same method after the contraceptive education, and most of them believed that
this method was effective.
Goldberg and Toros (1994) and Yurdakul and Vural
(2002) noticed that traditional contraceptive method use was widespread across all demographic,
socio-economic and geographic groups in Turkey. All
age groups practised the method extensively. The
proportion of withdrawal users among currently
married illiterate women of reproductive age was
twice as much as among the women who had more
than primary education. When withdrawal users’
profiles were investigated in our study, this method
was used by all age, demographic and socioeconomic groups.
In our study, almost all married women had heard
of modern contraceptive methods and used some
form of contraception. In one study in the
Philippines, the proportion of women who knew at
least six effective methods but were not using
effective methods was reported to be 24% and 14%
in the Dominican Republic (Bhushan, 1996).
In our study, many Turkish women are suspicious
of modern contraceptive methods, especially hormonal contraceptives. When we gave the education
sessions, we realised that the women needed more
accurate and complete contraceptive information
and counselling. In Turkey, the main reasons for
giving up oral contracetpives and the IUCD were
health problems and potential side-effects of these
methods, whereas condoms stopped being used
because spouses did not like them, and couples
wanted to use a more effective method (Turkish
Population and Health Survey, 1998). These earlier
results are consistent with the findings of the
present study.
Turkish men do not participate in the education
programmes for family planning for traditional
reasons, although they play an important role in
birth control. The status of women has become a
281
vocal issue of debate in Turkey, where men have a
more dominant decision-making role and one out of
three women said that their husbands wanted to
use this method.
In this study, withdrawal users believed that the
method was quite effective, had no side-effects
and was easy to practice. According to some study
findings, most couples considered that the major
reason for their using withdrawal was health and
the side-effects of modern methods (Goldberg and
Toros, 1994; Türkistanlı, 1998; Westoff and Bankole, 1998). In 1988, about half of traditional
method users believed that their method was as
effective as modern methods (Goldberg and Toros,
1994). Other reasons for using withdrawal are
partners’ preferences (Goldberg and Toros, 1994;
Karim, 1997; Türkistanlı, 1998; Yurdakul and Vural,
2002; Kulczycki, 2004), lack of knowledge and
access to modern methods (Goldberg and Toros,
1994; Westoff and Bankole, 1998; Kulczycki, 2004)
and the cost of modern methods (Goldberg and
Toros, 1994, Türkistanlı, 1998). Kulczycki (2004)
stated that withdrawal users and their spouses
believed in the efficacy and merit of the method,
seven out of 10 withdrawal users considered the
method effective in preventing pregnancy, and
most users (56%) considered the method easy to
practice (Kulczycki, 2004). Westoff and Bankole
(1998) found that the reasons for not using
effective methods were hesitancy about the desired time of the next birth, health problems and
objection of men to family planning (Westoff and
Bankole, 1998). Thus, our findings are congruent
with other published studies.
When we asked current withdrawal users if they
and their husbands were content with the method,
women reported that they and their husbands were
generally satisfied with the method that they were
using. The women reported that the decision to use
withdrawal was a joint one. According to the Turkish
Population and Health Survey (1998), almost three
of every four withdrawal users said that they and
their wives preferred the method to other methods.
This suggests that the decision to adopt withdrawal
is usually a jointly negotiated agreement by the
couple, rather than a husband’s imposition or a
woman’s choice alone. Akin (1999) also found that
virtually the same proportion of women (86–87%) in
urban Ankara as in eastern rural Turkey reported
that the couple jointly made their contraceptive
choices. In addition, in Istanbul, Angin and Shorter
(1998) concluded that reproductive decision making
is typically joint and co-operatively negotiated and
implemented by couples.
In this study, a few women were able to detect
the time of ovulation correctly. One type of
ARTICLE IN PRESS
282
counselling that would be helpful is fertility
awareness. ‘If women know their menstrual cycle
and are aware of pregnancy high-risk periods, then
withdrawal can work with modern natural family
planning’ (Bulut and Toubia, 1999, p. 260). Bulut
and Toubia (1999) found that about one in four
withdrawal users said they did not know their
fertile period, and another third identified their
fertile time incorrectly. Almost half of contraceptive users were using withdrawal, either alone
or in combination with other methods. Education
about fertility awareness is especially important for
young, sexually active men and women, a group
that tends to use withdrawal. Withdrawal can
result in high pregnancy rates, particularly in this
group, because using the method successfully
requires sexual experience. Women using withdrawal need to track their menstrual cycles very
carefully so that they know whether they might
become pregnant. In our study, results showed that
a few women had known about emergency contraception. Couples using withdrawal should consider
looking into information about emergency contraception, in case any sperm should be exposed to
the vagina by accident.
Although it is difficult to characterise the useeffectiveness of withdrawal, existing data indicate
that long-term use is significantly more effective
than first-year use (Goldberg and Toros, 1994).
When both partners are willing to practice the
method and have gained some experience, the
reliability increases. Instead of insisting on using
‘modern’ methods for couples who continue to use
withdrawal, it is better to help determined withdrawal users by recommending ways of more
effective use, such as using condoms during fertile
days. In our study, only one out of 25 withdrawal
users reported using withdrawal in combination
with the condom in fertile days. According to
Kulczycki (2004), women alone preferred the withdrawal method, and almost nine out of 10
respondents did not use it with another method
(Kulczycki, 2004).
The scientific assertion that withdrawal has a
relatively high failure rate is based on reports from
only a few studies, primarily conducted in North
America, and with small sample sizes that may not
be representative (Vessey et al., 1982; Trussell and
Kost, 1987). Failure rates may be markedly lower in
societies in which withdrawal is practised more
consistently and more widely. In one study among
typical users, about 19% would fail during the first
year (Trussell and Kost, 1987; Trussell and Kowal
1998). In another study in England, Vessey et al.
(1982) found only a 7% failure rate, based on 674
women and 45 unintended pregnancies. The high
E. Yanikkerem et al.
level of withdrawal use is commonly presumed to
be responsible for a high abortion rate. Abortion is
legal, available and widely resorted to as a back up
in the event of an unwanted pregnancy (Gürsoy,
1996; Bulut and Toubia, 1999). However, in Turkey,
the true incidence of abortion is clearly underestimated by survey statistics, because before 10
weeks the procedure is legal. In our study findings,
participants had unplanned pregnancy with the 38%
ratio and, although women were using withdrawal,
almost half of them conceived, and these pregnancies resulted in curettage.
Of the women who were currently using withdrawal, 42.4% of women said that they were eager
to use modern methods; but 57.6% of them were
determined to continue with their method. Westoff
and Bankole (1998) stated that three-fifths of
women using traditional methods wanted to use
the same methods in the future. In fact, investigations on this subject revealed high rates of
prolonged use of traditional methods. In a study
in Bangladesh, 86% of women who had been using
traditional methods were still using the same
methods 3 years after education for family planning
(Johnson and Macke, 1996). A previous study in
Turkey found that almost half of traditional-method
users preferred to use a different method (Goldberg and Toros, 1994; Yurdakul and Vural, 2002).
Our study found that education helps women to
make better use of available information, so that
they are quicker to pick up and adopt new and
more effective methods. Women who have been
married less than 10 years, and who have found this
method unreliable, adopt methods that are more
effective. Older women may be less receptive to
new ideas, and prefer to use methods that were
common when they were younger. In addition,
findings indicate that women who had as many
children as they wanted preferred to use an
effective contraceptive method. These findings
show that the younger generation preferred smaller
families. It is a general expectation that, as the
education level of women increases, the use of
modern contraceptive methods increases, as in our
findings. Women with higher education were
reluctant to talk about how modern contraceptive
methods work to prevent pregnancy, and about the
length of their effectiveness. It was determined in
Bangladesh that women who completed secondary
education used modern methods twice as frequently as did illiterate women (Johnson
and Macke, 1996). This study’s findings showed
that most women (n ¼ 122) who experienced
curettage because of unwanted pregnancy did
not change their behaviour and did not want to
use effective birth control methods. Clearly, this
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Withdrawal users’ perceptions of and experience with contraceptive methods in Manisa, Turkey
problem requires further attention of educators
and counsellors in family planning.
Previous researchers have identified the main
obstacles to modern contraceptive use as, husbands’ opposition to their use, poor communication
between spouses about their use, health concern
and fear of side-effects and dissatisfaction with
sexual sensation when they use them (Rosenfield et
al., 1993; Turkish Population and Health Survey,
1998; Nagase et al., 2003; Sadana and Snow, 1999).
The present study observed that obstacles to
contraceptive use were similar to those found by
previous studies.
During the talk about contraceptive methods,
women focused on the length of effectiveness,
mode of administration and cost as the most
important attributes. However, during discussions
based on their actual experience with contraceptive technologies, women focused on the
method’s suitability, particularly gauged by sideeffects and complications. Some women were
silent and looked embarrassed during this part of
the discussion about family planning methods. As
expected, because of these women’s experiences
with side-effects and complications associated with
hormonal contraceptive methods available in Turkey, women asked specific questions about the
potential side-effects resulting from oral contraceptives. Many participants complained about the
side-effects of modern contraceptives and were
afraid to use them. Some women, as expected,
explained that prior experiences of relatives and
friends about family planning methods influenced
their choice. The findings of this study also showed
that women were not in favour of surgical
sterilisation and condoms in that the former was
costly and their spouses rejected the latter. These
findings may explain that women use traditional
methods because their options for contraception
are limited.
In 1988, side-effects or health concerns accounted for a large portion of the relatively high
first-year discontinuation rates for pills and injections (21% and 29%, respectively) (Goldberg and
Toros, 1994). Also, in 1998, one in three contraceptive users stopped using their method within 12
months of adoption (Turkish Population and Health
Survey, 1998). The IUCD discontinuation rate was
the lowest (9%) among all methods, compared with
38% for withdrawal, and 56% for the pill (Kulczycki,
2004). As found in other studies, the few women
who could most easily tolerate bleeding irregularities said that the midwife had informed them in
advance of potential side-effects (Snow et al.,
1997). These findings are similar to our study and
show the importance of quality counselling; it is
283
important that health personnel have an unbiased
approach toward all methods and give accurate
information about side-effects and health problems. In addition to this, for some time, health
personnel did not consider withdrawal as a contraceptive method, and tried to dissuade people from
using it.
It is important for midwives and nurses to
recognise the effect of cultural beliefs on the
contraceptive use of women. Midwives and nurses
should assess these beliefs when taking a woman’s
history in order to implement appropriate intervention. Midwives and nurses should provide
information about the different methods of contraception and correct any misinformation about sideeffects. John Hopkins University researchers stated
that successful educational programmes might be
beneficial in clinics and in the community, in places
of employment and in people’s homes (Population
Reports, 1994). Midwives and nurses must assess
the needs of the women before planning educational programmes. Educational programmes need
to target the husband, mother, family members and
friends, because these people may influence the
women’s contraceptive behaviour, or they may be
supportive of the women using a method of
contraception.
References
Akin, A., 1999. Cultural and psychosocial factors are affecting
contraceptive use and abortion in two provinces of Turkey. In:
Mundigo, A., Indriso, C. (Eds.), Abortion in the developing
world. Zed Books, London.
Angin, Z., Shorter, F.C., 1998. Negotiating reproduction and
gender during the fertility decline in Turkey. Social Science
Medicine 47, 555–564.
Aytekin, N.T., Pala, K., Irgil, E., et al., 2001. Family planning
choices and some characteristics of coitus interruptus users
in Gemlik, Turkey. Women’s Health Issues 11, 422–447.
Bhushan, I., 1996. Understanding unmet need. Center For
Communication Programs Working Paper (Draft). Baltimore,
Maryland, Center For Communication Programs, Johns
Hopkins School of Public Health www.jhuccp.org/pubs/wp/
4/4.pdf.
Bulut, A., Toubia, N., 1999. Abortion services in two public
sector hospitals in Istanbul, Turkey: how well do they meet
women’s needs? In: Mundigo, A., Indriso, C. (Eds.), Abortion
in the developing world. Zed Books, London.
Goldberg, H.I., Toros, A., 1994. The use of traditional methods of
contraception among Turkish couples. Studies in Family
Planning 25, 122–128.
Gürsoy, A., 1996. Abortion in Turkey: a matter of state, family, or
individual decision. Social Science Medicine 42, 531–542.
Hancioglu, A., 1997. Fertility trends in Turkey: 1978–1993. In:
Hacettepe University, Institute of Population Studies (HIPS)
and Macro International (MI), (Eds.), Fertility trends,
women’s status, and reproductive expectations in Turkey:
results of further analysis of the 1993 Turkish demographic
and Health Survey. HIPS and MI, Calverton, MD.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
284
Johnson, T., Macke, B.A., 1996. Estimating contraceptive needs
from trends in method mix in developing countries. International Family Planning Perspectives 22, 392–396.
Karim, M.S., 1997. Reproductive behaviour in Muslim countries.
DHS Working Papers No: 23. Macro International and New
York: United Nations Population Fund, Calverton, MD.
Kulczycki, A., 2004. The determinants of withdrawal use in
Turkey: a husband’s imposition or women’s choice. Social
Science and Medicine 59, 1019–1033.
Manisa Director of Health, 2003. Manisa Population and health
mid-2003 study report. http://www.manisa.saglik.gov.tr/
yillik_2003. Last accessed 6 May 2005.
McLaren, A., 1990. A history of contraception: from antiquity to
the present day. Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
Nagase, T., Kunii, O., Wakai, S., et al., 2003. Obstacles to
modern contraceptive use among married women in southern
urban Maldives. Contraception 68, 125–134.
Network, 1996. Fertility awareness. contraceptive update:
withdrawal popular in some countries. 17 (1). http://
www.fhi.org/en/RH/Pubs/Network/v17_1/nt1717.htm
Population Reports, 1994. Family planning lessons and challenges: making programs work 22: 2–27, Population Information Program, Center for Communication Programs, The
Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland.
August 1994.
Rosenfield, J.A., Zahorik, P.M., Saint, W., et al., 1993. Women’s
satistification with birth control. Journal of Family Practice
36, 169–172.
Sadana, R., Snow, R., 1999. Balancing effectiveness, side effects
and work: women’s perceptions and experiences with
modern contraceptive technology in Cambodia. Social
Science Medicine 49, 343–358.
Snow, R., Garcia, S., Kureshy, N., et al., 1997. Attributes of
contraceptive technology: women’s preferences in seven
countries. In: Ravindaran, T.K.S., Beren, M., Cottingham,
E. Yanikkerem et al.
J. (Eds.), Beyond acceptability: users’ perspectives on
contraception. World Health Organization Geneva, 36–48,
Reproductive Health Matters Special Publication.
Sümbüloglu, K., Sümbüloglu, V., 1990. Biostatistics. Hatipoglu
publishing house, Ankara, p. 229.
The Alan Guttmacher Institute, 1999. Sharing responsibility:
women, society, and abortion worldwide, New York. http://
www.eldis.org/static/DOC8118.htm
Trussell, J., Kost, K., 1987. Contraceptive failure in the United
States: a critical review of the literature. Studies in Family
Planning 18, 273–283.
Trussell, J., Kowal, D., 1998. Essentials of contraception. In:
Hatcher, R.A., Trussell, J., Steward, F., et al. (Eds.),
Contraceptive technology. Ardent Media, New York.
Turkish Population and Health Survey, 1998. Hacettepe Institute
for Population Studies. Hacettepe University. HIPS, Ankara.
Turkish Population and Health Survey, 2003. Hacettepe Institute
for Population Studies. Hacettepe HIPS, University Ankara.
Türkistanlı, E., 1998. The role of nurse counsellor about family
planning catch to missing opportunity. Quality symposium in
education and practice of nursing and midwifery. Erciyes
University Press, Kayseri.
UN, 2000. Levels and trends in contraceptive use as assessed in
1998. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, St/ESA/
SER.A/190, United Nations, New York.
United Nations, 1997. The sex and age distribution of the world
populations: The 1996 Revision. United Nations, New York.
Vessey, M., Lawless, M., Yeates, D., 1982. Efficacy of different
contraceptive methods. The Lancet 8276, 841–842.
Westoff, C., Bankole, A., 1998. The time dynamics of unmet
need; an example from Morocco. International Family
Planning Perspectives 24, 12–14.
Yurdakul, M., Vural, G., 2002. Reasons for using traditional
methods and role of nurses in family planning. Contraception
65, 347–350.