Waterloo Region Profile Statistics, Trends & Forecasts Towards understanding implications for the future Background Document For the 2011 – 2014 Strategic Planning Process Draft – Updated February 4, 2011 For internal planning purposes – not for circulation WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 1 Background In order to effectively plan for the future we need to review a broad range of information on issues and trends that are likely to impact the community and this organization over the short, medium and long term. This summary is one piece of information that will help generate conversation as we begin to identify priorities for our future. We will need to hear different perspectives of those experts working in the field as well as learn and listen to the lived experiences of individuals in the community in order to understand if this information is still relevant and what implications it may have for the future. Purpose This profile is designed to provide background information on significant statistics, forecasts and trends, which begin to paint a picture of the emerging opportunities and challenges for the community and the organization as we being to plan for future priorities. This background information is intended to help inform discussions and decisions about future strategic objectives and actions. The Waterloo Region Profile has 7 main sections: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Demographics The Natural Environment Managing growth Health and Social Well-being Human Services Infrastructure Service Excellence Data Sources For the most part information found in sections 1 – 7 is compiled mostly from Region of Waterloo staff reports: 2006 Census Bulletins completed by Planning, Housing and Community Services: http://www.region.waterloo.on.ca/web/region.nsf/DocID/A288897047333422852573700060C1D7 ?OpenDocument Health Status reports completed by Public Health: http://chd.region.waterloo.on.ca/web/health.nsf/DocID/D2A33208D1CE83BB85256EED005C331 0?OpenDocument Transportation planning reports completed by Planning, Housing and Community Services, as well as Transportation and Environmental Services: http://www.region.waterloo.on.ca/web/region.nsf/c56e308f49bfeb7885256abc0071ec9a/b035cc0 357b6e3e585256e440068bc7b!OpenDocument and Rapid Transit information found at: http://rapidtransit.region.waterloo.on.ca/ Social Services Reports: http://www.region.waterloo.on.ca/web/social.nsf/DocID/8A471D6B587030678525700C004DF718 ?OpenDocument#spre In some cases additional information was obtained from community reports and statistics and where this is the case they are noted as such. Some of this work was done in partnership with Ernie Ginsler from Ginsler and Associates. It is recognized that the information will not comprehensive or all inclusive; rather it is a selection of relevant information which may provide useful context for planning. It is also recognized that in some cases the 2006 census data will not provide as reliable information as it has in previous census years, as the world has changed due to the recession. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 2 Waterloo Region Profile Issue Highlights - Executive Summary Demographics: Growing, Aging, Diversifying Our population growth rate surpasses both the provincial and national averages and is the sixth highest in Ontario. With a population of just over half a million, Waterloo Region is one of the fastest growing areas in Ontario and is projected to grow from 542,100 in 2010 to 729,000 people by 2031. The population over age 75 is the fastest growing segment of the population, and as the front end of the baby boom hits 65 in 2011, that will begin a seniors boom that will last 20 years. Our economic base is making a fundamental shift. Manufacturing and processing jobs which totaled 50,000 in 1987 now total 40,000 despite significant job growth in the last two decades. Jobs in the service sector, finance and administration, and education are taking their place, with the service sector providing significantly more jobs than any other. Service jobs tend to be characterized by lower wages, fewer benefits, and greater part-time employment. Growth in the immigrant population far outpaced that in the non-immigrant population, and is expected to be the most significant source of population growth across Canada in the future. Despite being the home of two leading universities, and a leading community college, high school completion rates and post-secondary education rates sit at the provincial and national averages. Environment: Diverting Waste, Saving Water, Protecting our Land, Improving our Air The Rapid Transit plan will shift people from cars to transit, reducing greenhouse gases. We continue to reduce water consumption even as we grow. It will be important to continue on this track both to conserve water, but also to save on greenhouse gases produced in its purification. We continue to successfully divert waste from our landfill – a 51% reduction since 1989. We need to work with community partners to plan to meet our provincially mandated GHG emission targets in 10 years. We must design our communities in ways that promote health. Growth Management: Growing Quickly, Facing Changes in Culture Home ownership is increasing despite increases in housing prices, however new housing starts have been decreasing. Rental housing starts have been flat for a number of years. Most land in the Region is devoted to agricultural use, although agriculture-related jobs are few and declining – even in the townships. Although direct employment numbers on the farm are minimal, the impact of our access to agricultural land and product on employment across the entire food industry, from research, processing and end users is enormous. 790,000 people visited friends and relatives in 2009 – our largest tourist category. Our cultural workforce has declined and the income of full-time, full-year workers in culture has declined as well. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 3 Healthy and Safe Communities: Safer than Most, Challenged by Health Issues, Widening Income Gap, and Workforce Changes During the recession we moved from having one of the lowest unemployment rates in the country to one of the highest. Our unemployment rate has been declining rapidly through 2010. Our median family incomes are higher than in many communities; however we have a persistent poverty rate of 10% to 11%. Incomes of new immigrants (<5 years) have been decreasing. Low income is associated with poor nutrition, and both are associated with low birth weights, reduced life expectancy, increased infant mortality, and diminished success in school. Major chronic diseases and injuries account for over 33% of direct health care costs. Although chronic diseases are among the most common and costly health problems facing Canadians, they are also among the most preventable. Our population is engaging in less healthy behaviour. This includes decreased physical activity and less fruit and vegetable consumption. As a result, our percentage of people who are overweight or obese has increased by 4.1 per cent. Unsurprisingly then, the percentage of our population with diabetes, asthma and high blood pressure has also increased by 1.4 per cent, 0.8 per cent and 2.6 per cent respectively. Life expectancy trend over the last 100 years has continued to rise, however with obesity, diabetes and high blood pressure rates also on the rise this long winning streak may be coming to an end. A nutritious diet in Waterloo Region cost a family of four $168.45 in 2010, up from $120.78 in 2006. Both violent and non-violent crimes have been on a downward trend here and across Canada for a number of years. Generally, our crime rates are below those of major Canadian communities. Our community is still lacking in general and specialist physicians, and will continue to lag for some time. Our rapid growth rate compounds the difficulty. Human Services: Early Learning Challenges, Affordable Housing Challenges 30% of our grade 8 students are below the provincial standard for reading. Only a small percentage of children from birth to age 5 have access to licensed child care. This will be change with the unfolding of full-day school for children age 4-5, but we will still be lacking spaces for children age birth through three. Almost a quarter of our households spent 30% or more of their income on housing. 30% is the recommended ceiling. The private market is building very little housing that could be classified as affordable for low- to middleincome earners. We have fewer low-income seniors than the Ontario average. Ontario has a slightly higher rate of disabilities than the Canadian average. Disabilities increase as age increases. About 47% of seniors report some limitation in their daily activities. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 4 Many people have few savings. The median income from interest for all savers in the Kitchener CMA was $310 in 2008, down from $320 in 2007. Infrastructure: Meet Current Needs and Future Growth: Growing Transit Use, Mounting Road Pressure Annual transit ridership has increased from 9.5 million rides in 2000 to 16.5 million rides in 2009. 4.8% of residents used transit to get to work in 2006. Forecasts of future travel demands in 2031 suggest that the transportation network would need to be expanded by about 25% to ensure all roadways are operating at no more than 100% of their capacity. We will need to significantly increase transit service and usage to meet future transit demands in a sustainable way. Rail and bus transit connecting Waterloo Region with the GTA are expected to increase over the next few years. We need to continue to expand our active transportation infrastructure (bikes, walking). Our physical infrastructure (roads, water and wastewater systems) are aging, and will have significant repair and replacement needs in the future. Service Excellence: Challenges of Accountability, Accessibility, and Participation During the past year, businesses, governments and people around the world have been shocked by the wave of the global financial crisis. Public service organizations are expected to take on new responsibilities to provide services and support citizens and the economy and do so under a spotlight on performance. With the expanded role of public service organizations in their daily lives, citizens expect organizations to make significant changes quickly and adapt to the new reality of this role. Public expectations are increasing as the bar has been raised in terms of customer satisfaction – being satisfied is no longer good enough. Because service is critical in shaping the public‟s confidence in government, it is vital that the focus on service increase, not diminish. The challenge for the public sector is bigger now than ever before and even more complex in a two tier system. Changing demographics of customers - in terms of growth of demand and the changing nature of demand, e.g., language diversity are also other factors impacting the need to prioritize and improve service, as is new legislation regarding access for people with disabilities. 44% stated that governments have a more difficult task than the private sector – as they must protect the public interest as well as meet the needs of citizens. Median charitable donation for tax-filers who claimed donations was the same as the Ontario median, at $300. The proportion of Waterloo Region tax-filers who claim donations decreased from 31.2% to 27.8% from 1997 to 2008, although it is still higher than the Provincial and National rates. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 5 Our volunteer rate decreased from 45% of adults to 41% of adults between 2004 and 2007 – a rate that is significantly lower than either the Provincial or National rates. 69% of Canadians think that “knowing where to start” is the biggest challenge in getting government services. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 6 1. Demographics: Growing, Aging, Diversifying Officially established on January 1, 1973 Waterloo Region includes the three cities of Cambridge, Kitchener and Waterloo, and the townships of North Dumfries, Wellesley, Wilmot, and Woolwich, blending a unique balance of urban and rural centres. Located in the heart of Southwestern Ontario Waterloo Region covers 1369 square kilometers. With a population of just over half a million, Waterloo Region is one of the fastest growing areas in Ontario and is projected to grow from 542,100 in 2010 to 729,000 people by 2031. Internationally known for its leading-edge technology and advanced manufacturing industries, innovative educational institutions, vibrant agricultural communities and the historically significant Grand River, Waterloo Region continues to earn its reputation as a forwardthinking community and as an attractive place to live, work and play. Waterloo Region is currently the fourth largest urban area in Ontario and the 10th largest urban area in Canada. Our population is aging As of 2006, people 65 years or older numbered over 55,000 and comprised 11.6% of the Region‟s total population. Some of the highest percentage increases in the ten years from 1996 to 2006 occurred in the population over the age of 75. More recently, in the five years from 2001 to 2006, those over 80 years of age had the highest per cent increase among all age groups, reflecting a steady increase in life expectancy. The demographic group known as the Baby Boomers (those born between 1946 and 1966) is a significant segment of the Region‟s population, both in terms of absolute numbers and growth. Numbering 137,710 people in 2006, this segment, aged between 40 and 59 years represents almost a third of the total population, as shown in Table 1. Within the Boomers, the largest absolute counts were individuals who are between 40 and 44 years old, and were still two decades (now fifteen years) away from the years typically associated with retirement. Over the ten year period from 1996 to 2006, the single largest percentage increase within any age group also occurred in this Baby Boomer group, specifically in the age bracket from 55 to 59. Table 1: Population Growth by Select Age Groups, 2001 and 2006 Age Group 0-4 Population 2001 27,960 Population 2006 29,345 Absolute growth 1,385 % Growth 5% 5-19 93,845 96,910 3,065 3% 20-39 133,770 138,180 4,410 3% 40-59 117,580 137,710 20,130 17% 60-79 53,820 60,610 6,790 13% 80+ 11,520 15,350 Source: Statistics Canada, Census 2001 and 2006 3,830 33% Higher proportion of women with increasing age The overall population distribution in Waterloo Region is almost even between the sexes, with 49.3% males and 50.7% females in 2006. However, the balance changes with increasing age. The difference in population distribution by sex is particularly evident in age groups above 80 years, where females make up 65% of the population. Our children and youth population is decreasing Of the total population, 126,255 or 26.4% are under the age of 20. Since 1996, this demographic group has been decreasing as a percentage of the total population. In absolute numbers, children from 0 to 4 WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 7 have demonstrated a slight rebound over the period from 2001 to 2006, overall statistics show this age group has declined as a per cent of the total population, falling from 7.3% in 1996 to 6.1% in 2006. The demographic imbalance caused by low birth rates and an aging population will alter the functioning labour markets. Organizations will need to: Modify their products and services to meet the needs of an older customer base. Attract and retain older workers. Establish flexible working arrangements that allow employees of all ages to meet personal and familial demands. Provide older employees with opportunities for continuous learning so they remain creative and current. Young workforce The group aged 25 to 54 years, who make up the majority of the workforce, increased their involvement by just 6.5% from 2001 to 2006. The Region has a relatively young workforce – the median age for the employed population in Waterloo Region (over 15 years) was 39.5 years, the lowest across all of Ontario. Employment forecasts Employment is forecast to grow to approximately 359,000 jobs by the year 2029, from 257,655 in 2006. A further 14,880 people (4% of this age group) was unemployed and 108,460 (28%) were not in the labour force. Full time employment (more than 30 hours worked per week) between 2001 and 2006 actually decreased by 14%, while part time employment increased over the same timeframe by a remarkable 112% and affected nearly all employment sectors. Employment by industry One approach to analyzing employment is by categorizing jobs by industry or sector. In 2006, „manufacturing‟ accounted for almost one quarter of all jobs held by Waterloo Region‟s workforce, representing 60,375 employees. This was a decrease of 2,020 jobs (3.2%) from 2001. „Retail trade‟ was the second largest employment sector for the Region‟s residents, accounting for half as many jobs as „manufacturing‟. This sector grew from 2001 to 2006 by 3,395 employees. „Healthcare and social assistance,‟ together with „educational services‟ made up the next largest portion of employment at approximately 20,000 jobs each. There is a structural change in employment. In previous recessions (80-82, 91-92) the sectors that lost jobs came back, but manufacturing has been falling since well before the recent recession and won‟t be coming back in the same way. High youth unemployment – the expanding parts of the economy either demand more education than they have, or pay at the low end of the scale and have few benefits. Employment by Occupation Another method used to measure employment is by considering occupation types. Occupations related to „sales and service‟ employs the largest segment of Waterloo Region‟s population, with a total of 58,875 people in 2006, followed by „business, finance and administration‟ and „trades, transport and equipment operators‟ occupations. Because „manufacturing‟ was the top industry of employment when looking at jobs by industry, it is not surprising that occupations related to manufacturing rank high as well. Farming is 1.3% of the total labour force in Waterloo Region There were 1,444 farm operations based out of Waterloo Region in 2006, employing approximately 3,510 people and accounting for 1.3% of the total labour force. The total number farm operators across the Region increased from 1,955 reported in 2001 to 2,035 in 2006. The average age for a farm operator in 2006 was 47 years, below both the provincial and national averages. Half (51%) of all farm operators WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 8 work full-time on their operation, spending on average more than 40 hours per week working on the farm. Of the remaining operators, 23% spend between 20 and 40 hours, while 27% spend less than 20 hours per week. Total gross farm receipts in 2005 for all farms in Waterloo Region totaled almost $400 million. The average of approximately $275,000 per farm, is surpassed provincially only by Niagara Region. Our population is becoming more diverse Immigration is an important component of population growth in Waterloo Region. In 2006, there were 105,375 residents who were born outside of Canada which accounted for 22.3% of the Region‟s total population. From 2001 to 2006 the immigrant population in Waterloo Region grew by 13.6%, almost twice the growth seen in the nonimmigrant population. Over the same time period, the non-immigrant population grew by 7.3%. The arrival of foreign-born residents to Waterloo Region will continue to be influential in the evolving characteristics of our local population in terms of population growth, age, language and cultural composition. A big proportion of immigrants are new to Waterloo Region Immigrants who arrived over the most recent five-year span made up 16.2% of the total immigrant population in Waterloo Region. Almost 70% of immigrants to Canada from 2001 to 2006 settled in Canada‟s three largest metropolitan areas, Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver. However, Waterloo Region was one of the top ten destinations in Canada, and top five in Ontario. Europe remains the most common place of birth for the total immigrant population Europe remains the most common place of birth for the total immigrant population in Waterloo Region, representing just over half of the population born outside of Canada. However, other regions have begun to emerge as key contributors to our population. As of 2006, Asia and the Middle East represent the birth places for more than a quarter of Waterloo Region‟s immigrant population, while the United States, Central America, South America, the Caribbean and Bermuda, and Africa account for most of the remaining quarter. Waterloo Region’s diversity continues to grow In 2006, the population of Waterloo Region reported 195 different ethnic origins. Individually, the most widely reported ethnic origin was English, followed closely by Canadian and German. While English is the most prevalent mother tongue spoken by three quarters of the population, in 2006 there were 106,855 people whose mother tongue was a nonofficial language, an increase of 21% from 88,495 people in 2001. Projections of Foreign Born Kitchener, CMA 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 Knowledge of Official Languages Remains High 0 Foreign Born Foreign Born Visible Minority Visible Minority Despite the increased prevalence of nonofficial 2006 2031 2006 2031 languages, Waterloo Region‟s knowledge of English Waterloo Region Canada and French remains high. In total, 98.5% of the Region‟s population has knowledge of at least one of Canada‟s two official languages. Among those, 91.8% knew English only. Knowledge of these languages has remained consistent since 2001. Although French is not as well known, the Census showed that 6.7% of the Region‟s population had some knowledge of the French language. Source: Statistics Canada, http://www.statcan.gc.ca/daily-quotidien/100309/t100309a1-eng.htm Aboriginal People increased in Waterloo Region In 2006, 4,810 people in Waterloo Region reported having an Aboriginal identity, specifically North American Indian (First Nations People), Métis or Inuit. This represented 1% of the total population. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 9 The changing face of families in our region There were 114,385 census families led by either a married couple or common-law couple in Waterloo Region. Married couples were more likely to have children compared to common-law families. Contributing to the changing face of families, common-law relationships increased from 12,060 in 2001 to 14,538 in 2006. This 21% increase is similar to trends seen on a national level where record numbers of common-law marriages were identified. Noteworthy changes were apparent in lone parent families, with an increase of 13% over values in 2001. Single parent families make up 15% of all families in the Region. From 2001 to 2006, increases occurred in all forms of family structure except for married couples with three or more children. This decline of larger families is consistent with the overall decline in fertility since the 1960‟s. Across the Region, there are more married people than unmarried people. Unmarried is defined as having never been legally married or having been divorced, widowed or separated. This statistic differs from the national trend: 2006 marked the first Census that indicated there were more unmarried than married people in Canada. Although the majority of our population is married, the single or never legally married group has increased 34% from 1996 and 17% from 2001. This was the largest increase across all categories and supports the trend of people waiting longer to get married. Within the Kitchener Census Metropolitan Area (CMA), 480 couples were in a same-sex relationship. Of these, 400 were considered common-law while 80 were legally married. Female same-sex relationships outnumbered male same-sex relationships by a ratio of 5:1. Children over the age of 25 at home increased Among census families, the average number of children living at home was 2.1, remaining the same from the 2001 Census. Nevertheless, a significant change was seen in the ages of these children living at home; children over the age of 25 at home increased by a remarkable 23%. The average Proportion of the Population (15+) with a family size in the Region is 3.0, the same as the Post-Secondary Education: 2000-2009 provincial average. 60 Less than half of the Region’s population above 50 15 has achieved post-secondary education 40 Just less than half of the Region‟s population above 30 the age of 15 has achieved some type of post20 secondary education. This represents a total of 10 181,735 people within that age bracket. A high 0 percentage (92%) of these earned their post2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 secondary certificate within Canada. Waterloo Waterloo Region Ontario Canada Region places 9th in Ontario in terms of the number „10 of people who hold a university certificate above the bachelor‟s degree level. Just over 92,000 people in Waterloo Region have no education certificate; this represents 24% of the total population 15 years and over. More specifically, 44% of all people 65 years and over hold no certificate, while only 16% of all people between 25 and 64 have less than a high school education. Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, available by special request program A050705. The level of education achieved by residents in Waterloo Region does correlate to the labour force activity. Numbers indicate that the population with less than a high school education (hold no education certificate) have the lowest participation rate by more than 20% and at the same time have the highest rate of unemployment. The population that has achieved a post-secondary education has a much lower rate of unemployment. Of this group (fifteen years and over with a post-secondary education), the group that has the highest rate of participation in the labour force and therefore lowest unemployment rate hold a non-university certificate (i.e. college diploma). WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 10 Households Characteristics In 2006, there were 470,705 people living in private households in Waterloo Region. Over 70% of these households were home to one family, while less than 2% were home to multiple families. The remaining 28% of households consisted of people living alone or with non-relatives. This group showed the largest per cent increase between Censuses. Population moves around Almost 200,000 residents of Waterloo Region moved during the five year period between 2001 and 2006. This represents 44% of the Region’s population. The five-year mobility rate for Waterloo Region is similar to that of Canada and Ontario which stand at 41%. From 2001 to 2006, Census data shows that 47,495 people moved to Waterloo Region from other areas in Canada. During the same period, 41,760 people moved away, resulting in a net gain of 5,735 people to the Region through internal migration. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 11 2. Environment: Diverting Waste, Saving Water, Protecting our Land, Improving our Air Health is impacted by air quality Over the past several years ambient levels of some air pollutants have decreased in Ontario. However, Ground-level ozone (a key component of smog) is still a problem in many cities within Ontario. The Ontario Ministry of the Environment estimates that the transportation sector in Ontario is responsible for 65 per cent of the emissions of nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds, which are the main components in smog (ground level ozone) and are related to a variety of health problems. Between 2002 and 2006, in Cambridge, Kitchener and Waterloo there were an estimated 677 hospital admissions for cardiovascular problems and an estimated 255 admissions for respiratory problems related to acute exposure of nitrogen dioxide in the air. Future trends for air quality Although the Region of Waterloo has no direct authority over air quality in this community, there are several Regional programs and initiatives oriented towards public health protection and reduction of air emissions within the community. For example, Reduce the Juice is a community-based social marketing campaign aimed at changing behaviour around vehicular idling. In 2008, over 1500 pledges to reduce idling were signed by local residents during the campaign. Other Regional programs oriented towards improving air quality in the Region include promotion of transit and active transportation (e.g. cycling, walking) by reducing traffic congestion. The introduction of rapid transit in Waterloo Region will nearly triple transit ridership along the Central Transit Corridor. The Region‟s rapid transit project will reduce greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants, by shifting travel to transit and out of private cars. The shift away from auto usage is projected to reduce annual greenhouse gas emissions by more than 9,000 tonnes in 2014 and more than 14,000 tonnes in 2031. In addition, the project will reduce annual Criteria Air Contaminants by 325 tonnes in 2031. These pollutants contribute to poor air quality and damage human health. The reduction in pollutants with rapid transit will reduce hospital admissions, saving the health care system an estimated $10.5 million during the first 25 years of the project. Reducing the use of pesticides will promote the health, safety and well-being of people in our community In 2006, Council enacted a pesticide reduction by-law that became effective January 1st, 2007. Council directed that a review of the by-law and related enforcement be carried out after 2 years (end of 2008). In June of 2008, the Ontario legislature passed the Cosmetic Pesticides Ban Act. This act lays out the framework for a ban on the sale and use of pesticides for cosmetic purposes across Ontario. The act will apply to all of Ontario and replace any municipal by laws Megalitres of Treated Water per currently in place. The province‟s cosmetic pesticides ban 100,000 Population came into effect on Earth Day, April 22, 2009. The provincial ban overrides municipal pesticide bylaws, 14000 protecting all Ontarians, not just those in some 13500 13000 communities. It also establishes one clear set of rules, 12500 which makes it easier for Ontario businesses to follow. 12000 11500 Water Consumption is reduced but efforts still needed Waterloo Region consumed 54,266 ML of water in 2009, 2,000 ML less than 10 years ago. As population has increased by almost 100,000 people over the past decade, the water consumption per capita has decreased significantly during this period. The Region of Waterloo 11000 10500 10000 2006 2007 Waterloo Region 2008 Ontario Median 10 Source: OMBI 2008 WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 12 influences community water consumption via its many water conservation and efficiency programs such as the water conservation by-law, toilet rebate/replacement and rain barrel programs. Other influences on community water consumption include changes in industrial, commercial and institutional practices, economic trends, leakage control. Reduced water consumption decreases the large energy demand needed to provide essential water services and in turn reduces air and GHG emissions associated with Regional operations. Need for continued protection of natural areas The Region uses the following environmental land designations to protect sensitive landscapes and biological diversity: Environmental Sensitive Policy Areas (ESPA), Environmental Sensitive Landscapes (ESLs), and Forests and Woodlots managed by the Region. In 2009 two new ESLs were proposed as part of the new Regional Official Plan (pending final provincial approval) bringing the total land protected under this designation to approximately 16,500 hectares or 165 km2. Preservation of sensitive environmental areas is consistent with the goals of the Regional Growth Management Strategy. Regional lands protected under these environmental designations also play an ecosystem related role by influencing air and water quality. These designations are a result of environmental stewardship efforts of Regional staff in collaboration with area municipalities, the GRCA, private landowners and the citizen based Ecological and Environmental Advisory Committee. More waste is being diverted for reuse and recycling In 2009, the amount of residential waste reaching our landfill was as low as 2001 levels despite steady population growth. Residential waste diversion reached 51% in 2009 up significantly from 37% in 1999. This means more waste is being diverted for reuse and recycling than being disposed in our local landfill through effective diversion programs such as blue box and more recently the green bin. Total waste reaching our landfill (including industrial, commercial and institutional sources) has decreased by 51% since 1989. Waste diversion programs are prolonging the useful life of the local land allocated to landfill space and provide feedstock‟s into recycled products (e.g. metals, plastics). Collaboration with community partners will be needed to reduce Greenhouse gases (GHG) Ontario‟s committed GHG emission targets with significant reductions required in the next 10 years. A recent FCM report indicated that municipalities have direct or indirect control of 44% of GHG emissions in Canada. Earlier in 2010, Regional Council recognized the importance of Climate Change by committing to the FCM Partners for Climate Protection program as well as the Regional Carbon Initiative developed by a local non-profit group called Sustainable Waterloo. Both initiatives require an inventory of emissions and action plan including reduction targets. By the end of 2010, the corporate inventory and reduction plan (Regional operations) should be complete for Council‟s consideration in the New Year. In 2011, collaborative work will be needed to develop a community GHG inventory and action plan with other local stakeholders in order to fulfill the Region‟s strategic commitment to FCM and Sustainable Waterloo. Controls on summer watering and other measures have helped us decrease the amount of treated water used from 12,200 megalitres per 100,000 residents in 2006 to 11,500 in 2008. This was 9% below the provincial rate. Ground-Level Ozone monitoring indicates that for most days between January and October, 2009, levels measured at noon in Kitchener were above the 20 level, with numerous peaks at 50 or greater. Only 3 days were above 65ppb. Only one day had particulate matter over 30 (ug/m3). The Design of Our Neighbourhoods Impacts Our Health The built environment includes buildings, roads, homes, parks, and other structures that form the physical character of a place. It includes those things which are human-made (streets, sidewalks, railroad tracks, bike lanes) as opposed to those that are naturally occurring. Individual choices about how to get to places are influenced by the built environment, the size of our family, our age, health, attitudes, schedule, and the social conditions in which we live. Factors such as the distance between home and work, the look and feel of the neighbourhood and streets, the presence or absence of stores, recreation facilities, and parks affect the choice of whether to walk, cycle, take transit, or drive. These transportation WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 13 choices have long-term impacts on our health, air quality and physical well-being. Regular physical activity can reduce the risk of heart disease, colon cancer, and diabetes by as much as 50 per cent. It decreases the impact of osteoporosis, arthritis and is a critical step in avoiding becoming overweight or obese. Some other interesting Waterloo Region environmental statistics: The percentage of households with programmable thermostats increased from 55% in 2007 to 62% in 2007. In 2007, 74% of households used compact fluorescent light bulbs and 48% used fluorescent tubes. 65% of households had a low-flow showerhead and 55% had a low-volume toilet in 2007. WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 14 3. Growth Management: Growing Quickly; Facing Challenges in Culture Our population is growing About 534,900 people live in Waterloo Region, including full time University and College students (yearend 2009 estimate). The majority of its population resides in the cities of Region of Waterloo Population Projection Cambridge, Kitchener and Waterloo. Since 1994, the Region's population has grown on average 1.8 per cent, 800,000 per year and has consistently been ranked as one of the fastest growing 700,000 communities in Canada. From 2001 to 2006, the Region‟s population increased by 9%, representing about 600,000 8,000 people per year, compared to an 8.2% increase from 1996 to 2001. 500,000 The 9% increase made Waterloo Region the sixth fastest growing municipality in Ontario, outpacing 400,000 both the provincial and national growth rates. The Region‟s absolute 300,000 population change surpassed that of 2001 2006 2011 2016 2021 2026 2031 Toronto, Ottawa and Hamilton. Dwelling Counts and Growth The 2006 Census reported 187,088 total private dwellings in Waterloo Region, an increase of 12% from 2001. The largest per cent increase over the five-year period occurred in the Township of Wilmot (17.3%) and the cities of Waterloo (14.7%), Kitchener (11.6%) and Cambridge (11.3%) On a provincial scale, the Region ranked seventh in terms of per cent growth of occupied private dwellings after York, Halton, Peel, Simcoe, Durham and Muskoka. The majority of dwellings in Waterloo Region remains single-detached houses. Singles account for 57% of total dwellings, similar to 55% of Canada‟s total dwellings and 56% of dwellings in Ontario. While singles dominate, the type of dwellings being constructed in the Region continues to evolve. Over the past five years, row houses have seen the biggest per cent increase, growing by 17%, followed by apartments with less than 5 storeys at 12%. The age of the Region‟s housing stock is relatively young, with 75% of our housing built after 1960. Home ownership is a key indicator of the current economic environment of an area. From 2001 to 2006, despite a significant increase in housing prices, the home ownership rate in Waterloo Region increased by 16%. Proportionally the percentage of those households renting dropped. The home ownership rate in Waterloo Region is 71%. As a comparison, the national ownership rate is 68% and the provincial ownership rate is 71%. New rental construction New rental construction has been more-or-less flat for a number of years; new home construction has been declining. The total value of building permits issued in 2009 for new construction in Waterloo Region was $876.4 million, a decrease of 13 per cent from 2008 values. However, this was still the third highest value recorded in the last 10 years. Total new construction value was comprised of WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 15 approximately 63 per cent in the residential sector, and 37 per cent in the non-residential. CMHC (spring 2010) projects significant increases in purchase and rent costs. In residential activity, permits were issued for 2,770 units in 2009, down 7 per cent from the 2,968 units in 2008. Relative to long-term trends, the 2,770 units are 11 per cent below the 30-year regional average of 3,099 units. The value of these permits, however actually increased 5 per cent to $548.2 million from $521.6 million in 2008. Value of Building Permits 1,200 $ millions 1,000 800 600 400 200 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Month 2007 Value of Building Permits 2008 Value of Building Permits 2009 Value of Building Permits 2010 Value of Building Permits Agriculture represents the largest land use activity in Waterloo Region In 2006, over 65% of all land classified by Statistics Canada was farmland, representing 226,384 acres (91,614 hectares). Across the Region, the number of farms between 2001 and 2006 stabilized after the large decrease in the previous 5-year timeframe. Trends over a twenty year time period show a decline of about 12% in the number of farms whereas the area of farmland only decreased by 5%. In 2006, of the total farm area for all land tenure types, 69% was owned by operators in Waterloo Region, while 31% of the land was leased, rented, crop shared or used through other arrangements. For agricultural land, crop production was the predominant land use in 2006, representing almost 80% of agricultural land. This is down slightly from its share in 2001. Livestock farming was the predominant farm type in 2006, accounting for about 74% of all farms or 1,068 total farms throughout Waterloo Region. Most land in the Region is devoted to agricultural use, although agriculture-related jobs are few and declining – even in the townships. Although direct employment numbers on the farm are minimal, the impact of our access to agricultural land and product on employment across the entire food industry, from research, processing and end users is enormous. Are we a tourist destination? Overnight visits to Waterloo Region dipped between 2006 and 2007, but increased significantly between 2007 and 2008. 790,000 people visited friends and relatives in 2009 - our largest tourist category (the other categories being pleasure visits and business visits). This was followed by overnight pleasure visits at 331,000 and overnight business visits at 97,000. Total visitor spending in the South-Central Region of Ontario, which includes Waterloo Region, was $1.1B in 2008. The largest expenditure categories were restaurants and bars ($250M), vehicle operations ($200M), clothing ($160M), and accommodation ($126M). WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 16 The Ontario Ministry of Tourism projects a small decline in same-day visits province-wide to 2011, followed by a slow increase to 2014. The 2014 number is only one-half per cent higher than 2009. Overnight visits province-wide are projected to increase by 6% from 2009 to 2014. Are we supporting arts and culture? Municipal spending on culture in Ontario increased from $877M in 2003 to $1.1B in 2007. That's an increase of 25% in just four years. Closer to home, the per cent of the local workforce employed in cultural industries has gone up and down between 2000 and 2009, however in 2009 it was almost exactly the same as in the year 2000. During that period, our cultural workforce hovered around 1.5% of total employment, while the provincial average was around 2.2%. Between 2000 and 2005, the median earnings of full-time, full-year cultural services employees in Waterloo Region declined in constant dollars from $42,700 to $40,500. In 2009 and 2010 budgets the Region increased funding for arts and culture initiatives by $500,000. Of this additional funding, $400,000 was allocated to Regionally supported arts and culture organizations and $100,000 was to support the start-up of the “Creative Enabling Organization” – one of the key recommendations of the “Creative Enterprise” initiative. Library use increases Despite ongoing predictions that online information access would make libraries obsolete, per-capita circulation at the three city systems continues to trend upwards. 4. Healthy and Safe Communities: Safer Than Most; Challenged by Health Issues, Widening Income Gap, and Workforce Changes Increase in prevalence of chronic diseases (from Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, May 2007) Chronic diseases are long-term diseases that develop slowly over time, often progressing in severity, and can often be controlled, but rarely cured. They include conditions such as cardiovascular diseases (heart disease and stroke), cancer, diabetes, arthritis, back problems, asthma, and chronic depression. Chronic diseases may significantly impair everyday physical and mental functions and reduce one‟s ability to perform activities of daily living. Worldwide, chronic diseases have overtaken infectious diseases as the leading cause of death and disability. Non-communicable diseases now account for 59% of the world‟s 57 million annual deaths, and 46% of the global burden of disease. Chronic disease is most frequent among older Ontarians, since chronic diseases can take decades to develop. Statistics Canada estimates that major chronic diseases and injuries account for over 33% of direct health care costs. In Ontario, chronic diseases account for 55% of direct and indirect health costs, which includes years of healthy life lost from premature death and lost productivity from disability as well as direct health care costs. Chronic Disease can be Prevented, Detected and Managed Although chronic diseases are among the most common and costly health problems facing Canadians, they are also among the most preventable. Major chronic diseases such as cardiovascular disease (heart disease and stroke), diabetes, arthritis, asthma, and osteoporosis share common risk factors and conditions. A small group of modifiable behaviours and intermediate biological factors/risk conditions (e.g., physical inactivity, unhealthy diet, tobacco, alcohol, hypertension, high cholesterol, and being overweight) account for a substantial proportion of chronic disease. These modifiable factors are influenced and shaped by societal, economic and physical conditions. Changing health behaviors and biological factors have the potential to reduce chronic disease in Ontario significantly. For example: WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 17 A tobacco-free society would prevent more than 90% of lung cancer deaths and 30% of all other cancer deaths. With healthy eating, regular exercise, and not smoking, up to 90% of type 2 diabetes, 80% of coronary heart disease, and one-third of cancers can be avoided. Healthy Behaviours Based on data from the 2007 Canadian Community Health Survey, our population is engaging in less healthy behaviour than in 2003. These include decreased physical activity and less fruit and vegetable consumption. As a result, our percentage of people who are overweight or obese has increased by 4.1 per cent. Unsurprisingly then, the percentage of our population with diabetes, asthma and high blood pressure has also increased by 1.4 per cent, 0.8 per cent and 2.6 per cent respectively. The per cent of people who have 5 drinks or more twelve times a year has also increased to 23.5%. The per cent of non- smokers exposed to second-hand smoke has decreased slightly, but at 8.3 per cent it is much higher than the provincial average of 5.7 per cent. A similar trend among preventive behaviours is also emerging. From 2005 to 2007, the percentage of residents getting flu shots and the per cent of residents who had contact with their medical doctor in the past year decreased both in the WWLHIN and Ontario. However, between 2007 and 2008, the percentage of people who had a mammogram, cervical cancer screening and fecal occult blood test increased. Although these trends suggest that our population should be less healthy than they were two to four years ago, the percentage of WWLHIN residents who rated their overall health as very good or excellent has increased between 2003 and 2007 from 60.9% to 62.6%. A similar inconsistency appears in the area of mental health. While there was a decrease in the percentage of people who report having a lot of life stress, there was also a decrease in the percentage of people who rated their overall mental health as very good to excellent. Life expectancy of Canadians likely to decrease due to chronic diseases Life expectancy of Canadians continued to rise from 78 years in 1996 to 81 years in 2006. This is part of a trend over the last 100 years, which saw a decline in premature mortality extending the average life by three decades since the beginning of the last century. Obesity, diabetes and high blood pressure are on the rise suggesting that this long winning streak may be coming to an end. What we spent, where it went, what we got Canadian health care spending in 2008 was $172 billion, or 10 per cent of GDP. This is nearly 60 per cent more than a decade ago. It now consumes more than 40 per cent of some provincial budgets. The aging population is responsible for about a 1 per cent annual increase in health spending. The rest is due to inflation, population growth and more intensive services for various conditions. Governments have invested in training more health care professionals. In 10 years the entering class of medical students increased by 68 per cent, and the entering calls of nursing students by 51 per cent. Drugs were the fastest growing expenditure in health care, having increased by 136 per cent since 1998. There continues to be an increase in the shift from inpatient to out patient surgery (up 30.6 per cent). Forces that have shaped Health Care in Canada Health care changes for three main reasons: policy, need and innovation. There are always tensions between what is possible and what is affordable. At the end of the1990‟s, governments WATERLOO REGION PROFILE FOR 2011 -2014 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS 829684 Version: v15 18 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 were beginning to reinvest in health care after a period of mid-decade restraint. In the last decade: Access to care and reducing wait times became a focal point. Trends in technology development included a move to less invasive surgery and increased use of diagnostic imaging. There were significant changes in the use of products and services, in part due to innovation and need. The number of cardiovascular drug prescriptions increased from 32 million in 1998 to 71 million in 2008. Age standardized hip and knee replacement rates increased 24% and 83% respectively. There is speculation that knee replacement increases may be related to obesity. Ambulance calls have increased Over the last five years (2004-2009), ambulance calls have increased 20% from 29,064 to 34,797. More than double the population growth over the same period, call volume growth is likely due to the growing aging and ailing population. In 2009, the ROW provided the fewest number of EMS hours per 1,000 population among OMBI communities (196 vs. a mean of 359), but at the same time responded to many fewer EMS calls than the provincial mean (67/1,000 vs. the OMBI mean of 100). The gap between providing 55% of the provincial mean in service hours, and dealing with 67% of the mean demand for service, is being addressed through the EMS Master Plan beginning in 2011. Waterloo Region moved from one of the strongest labour markets in Ontario to one of the weaker in the Province In February of 2010 the Workforce Planning Board of Waterloo Wellington Dufferin (WPB) produced a profile report of the labour market in the Region of Waterloo. The report indicates that the economic downturn is having, and will continue to have, a measurable impact on the Region‟s local labour market. Waterloo Region has been particularly affected, moving from one of the strongest labour markets in Ontario to, at one point in the last year, one of the weaker labour markets in the province. Unemployment rose from 5% in late 2007 to a high of 10.5% in August 2009. 12.0% 11.0% 10.0% 9.0% 8.0% 7.0% 6.0% 5.0% 4.0% Jan-08 Feb-08 Mar-08 Apr-08 May-08 Jun-08 Jul-08 Aug-08 Sep-08 Oct-08 Nov-08 Dec-08 Jan-09 Feb-09 Mar-09 Apr-09 May-09 Jun-09 Jul-09 Aug-09 Sep-09 Oct-09 Nov-09 Dec-09 Jan-10 Feb-10 Mar-10 Apr-10 May-10 Jun-10 Jul-10 Aug-10 Sep-10 Percent Monthly Unemployment Rate Month Canada USA Ontario Kitchener CMA Recently, the labour market has been rebounding. The Region lost over a thousand manufacturing sector jobs from October 2008 to October 2009 and has been dealing with many temporary layoffs in Document #: 829684 v15 19 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 manufacturing and other employment sectors. As a result in great part, the Ontario Works caseload is 35% higher than it was in September 2008. The downturn will have a significant impact upon those workers with less than a grade 12 education, as they will find it difficult to find new employment or employment at a comparable wage if displaced. Employers will be able to demand higher skill sets and levels of education for jobs that would have required fewer qualifications/skills in the past. A weakened local labour market has underscored the need for education, skill development and training for local citizens to (re)enter the labour force. Employment across Canada and in Ontario in the last year (July '09-'10) has increased. However, not all employment areas have increased. Canadian jobs have decreased in Manufacturing (7,300), information and cultural industries (11,600), educational services (9,500), and arts, entertainment, and recreation (5,300). Areas which increased Canada-wide include construction (33,900), finance and insurance (24,700), professional, scientific, and technical services (17,100), and health care and social services (32,200). Employment in Selected Occupations: Kitchener CMA 19 87 19 88 19 89 19 90 19 91 19 92 19 93 19 94 19 95 19 96 19 97 19 98 19 99 20 00 20 01 20 02 20 03 20 04 20 05 20 06 20 07 20 08 20 09 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Machine operators and assemblers in manufacturing, including supervisors Occupations unique to processing, manufacturing and utilities Sales and service occupations Business, finance and administrative occupations Source: Waterloo Region Workforce Planning Board Need for Staff with specific skills Immigration is an increasingly important component of population growth in Canada, with over 200,000 immigrants arriving in Canada each year. According to a report from Statistics Canada, immigrants were responsible for more than two-thirds (69%) of the population growth that occurred between 2001 and 2006. Results from the Census show low education-job match rates among internationally-educated immigrants in 2006. In fact, among the 881,600 internationally-educated immigrants who reported a postsecondary credential in a field of study that would normally lead to work in one of the targeted occupations identified by the Foreign Credential Recognition (FCR) Program at Human Resources and Skills Development Canada (HRSDC), only about one in five reported Document #: 829684 v15 20 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 working in the best corresponding occupation. This proportion increased to 41% when considering occupations requiring similar or higher skill levels. Source: "Characteristics and Labour Market Outcomes of Internationally-educated Immigrants", Statistics Canada http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/81-595-m/81-595-m2010084-eng.pdf The Growth of Science and Technology Our high tech sector is a strategic asset that increasingly defines a key attribute of our community. In 2006, Waterloo Region was rated the seventh best research community in Canada. Interestingly, despite our strong university base, university research was a smaller component of our success than in Top 10 Research Communities, our competitors, and corporate R&D formed a 2006* larger part. More recently, the University of Waterloo brought in over $650 million in 100 80 research grants between 2005 and 2009. 60 40 20 0 to ria n ilt o Vi c at .. Ha m on to n Ed m . ga ry r-W he ne Ki tc Ci ty Ca l ve r be c Q ue ea u nc ou in w aG at l O tta Va To on tre a M ro nt o In 2009 Research in Motion, the country's largest research and development investor spent over $1.1 billion on that activity. In the same year, Open Text spent another $133 million. These investments, and those of the rest of the high-tech sector translate directly into increased employment, demand for housing, University Research Corporate R&D and potentially increased use of our arts, culture, * Score out of 100 Source: Re$earch Infosource Inc. recreation, and sport resources. It should also be noted that many in the high-tech community will have high expectations for government services, both in quality and cost-effectiveness. Although Waterloo continues to be the focus of this activity, a second hub is forming in the Kitchener core. To continue our strong performance, we must ensure that the infrastructure needs of the research and development community are anticipated and met. It needs to be pointed out, however, that the growing emphasis on technology will inevitably leave behind a proportion of the working age population with limited capacity to succeed in this environment. Are we supporting arts and culture? Municipal spending on culture in Ontario increased from $877M in 2003 to $1.1B in 2007. That's an increase of 25% in just four years. A recent report by Environics Research Group says that 82% of the Canadian public support government spending on arts and culture and 91% find arts facilities important to community quality of life. Closer to home, the percent of the local workforce employed in cultural industries has gone up and down between 2000 and 2009, however in 2009 it was almost exactly the same as in the year 2000. During that period, our cultural workforce hovered around 1.5% of total employment, while the provincial average was around 2.2%. Between 2000 and 2005, the median earnings of full-time, full-year cultural services employees in Waterloo Region declined in constant dollars from $42,700 to $40,500. In 2009 and 2010 budgets the Region increased funding for arts and culture initiatives by $500,000. Of this additional funding, $400,000 was allocated to Regionally supported arts and culture organizations and $100,000 was to support the start-up of the “Creative Enabling Organization” – one of the key recommendations of the “Creative Enterprise” initiative. Document #: 829684 v15 21 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 People with disabilities in the workforce More than half (56 per cent) of people with disabilities are in the workforce, either employed (48 per cent) or actively seeking work (eight per cent). But women with disabilities are at a particular disadvantage vis-a-vis the labour market. Even with education levels comparable to those of men, such women are not well represented in the labour force. The employment rate for women with disabilities is 40.7 per cent, about two -thirds of the rate for non-disabled women and about 15 per cent less than for men with disabilities [Canada 1994]. Source: THE DISABILITY INCOME SYSTEM IN CANADA: OPTIONS FOR REFORM, Caledon Institute, 2003 Document #: 829684 v15 22 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 Source: Projecting the Economic Impacts of Increased Accessibility in Ontario, Martin Prosperity Institute Ontario Works caseload 35% higher The year 2009 was challenging given the significant growth in the Ontario Works caseload and the accompanying service demands. As of July 2010, the Ontario Works caseload was 35% higher than the beginning of the recession (September 2008) and 23% higher than January 2009. The service demands associated with the increased numbers and the changing profile of Ontario Works participants had a significant impact on services. Monthly Caseload 10,000 Caseload 9,000 8,000 7,000 6,000 Jul-10 May-10 Mar-10 Jan-10 Nov-09 Sep-09 Jul-09 May-09 Mar-09 Jan-09 Nov-08 Sep-08 Jul-08 May-08 Mar-08 Jan-08 5,000 Month ODSP OW Our income rates have improved but not for everyone in our Region Approximately 10.2 per cent of individuals and 11 per cent of families in Waterloo Region lived in low income in 2006. The income gap between people in low income and people with higher incomes in Waterloo Region is widening. Waterloo Region is well known for its strong technology sector and vibrant economy; however, data indicates that there are a large number of people living with low income, and that the income gap is continuing to widen significantly (Workforce Planning Board of Waterloo Wellington Dufferin, 2010). In 2006, 10.2 per cent of individuals and 11 per cent of families in Waterloo Region lived in low income (Region of Waterloo Public Health, 2010). In addition, the unemployment rate in Waterloo Region transitioned from one of the lowest in Canada, to one of the highest between 2008 and 2009 (due in part to our high participation rate)(Workforce Planning Board of Waterloo Wellington Dufferin, 2010). The unemployment rate has decreased significantly over the last few months. Poverty disproportionately effects certain population groups Poverty impacts certain populations such as children, single-parents, new immigrants, Aboriginals, and persons with disabilities. Incomes vary considerably between sexes across the region. Males over 15 had a median total income of $38,436 while the median total income for females was $22,517, a difference of $15,919. After taxes, the difference between median incomes of males and females was $12,210. Document #: 829684 v15 23 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 Individuals between 18 and 24 years in private households are at the highest risk of falling below the lowincome cut-off (after tax). In Waterloo Region there are 6,715 people in that age bracket who are considered low income, representing 13.8% of the population between 18 and 24 years. As of 2005-2006, immigrant income for new (within 5 years) immigrants has been decreasing when compared to the Canadian-born workforce and when compared to older immigrants. This is not just a Waterloo Region problem new immigrant income has decreased throughout Canada. Living in Poverty Can Mean the Difference Between Sickness and Health The Low Income Cut Off (LICO) is a commonly used measure of low income produced by Statistics Canada. It is a relative measure and reports the income level at which household needs for food, clothing, and shelter will take, on average, a share of after-tax income that is 20 per cent higher than the average family. Table 1: Percentage of certain segments of the population in Waterloo Region living under the after-tax LICO, 2005 Population Percentage living under LICO Overall population 7.5 Recent Immigrants (1996-2001) 33.5 Aboriginal households 23.8 Unattached person 15 years and older 21.8 Female-headed lone parent families 20.3 Children under 6 9.8 Male-headed lone parent families 7.7 Direct link between living in poverty and poor health The link between living in poverty and poor health has been shown; in fact, there is conclusive evidence that poverty is not just associated with poor health but is a primary cause of poor health among Canadians. One of the key factors leading to low-income is the lack of a high-school education, and in this area we fare only slightly better than the Ontario and National levels. A study which compared neighbourhoods across Canada based on income found that for low income neighbourhoods compared to high ones: Life expectancy is five years shorter for men and 1.6 years shorter for women Infant mortality rates are 61 per cent higher Low birth weight rates are 43 per cent higher. Low birth weight is a very important measure of health status as it is consistently related to the experience of chronic diseases such as heart disease and type 2 diabetes in adulthood. The same study looked at differences in mortality due to chronic diseases between low- and high-income neighbourhoods. For each of the chronic diseases studied, only cirrhosis in females and prostate and breast cancer were higher in high-income neighbourhoods. For each of the other conditions, mortality rates are higher in lower income neighbourhoods. Canadian children living in poverty are more likely to develop a variety of illnesses, be injured, have stunted growth, and experience developmental challenges. They are more likely to end up in the Document #: 829684 v15 24 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 hospital, have mental health problems, do poorly in school, and leave school early. When children grow up in poverty, they carry the effects with them into adulthood. They have a higher risk of health problems throughout their lives, no matter what their circumstances later in life. For Some People in Waterloo Region, a Nutritious Diet is Out of Reach Having a low income does not cause food insecurity, however, food insecurity is far more likely to exist in low-income households. Food insecurity means more than not having enough to eat. It can also include worrying about having enough to eat, or not eating the desired quality or variety of food due to lack of money. In 2010, the cost of the Nutritious Food Basket in Waterloo Region for a “reference family of four” was $168.45 per week. Even with minimum wage increases and the recent elimination of the National Child Benefit claw-back, some families living on low incomes still do not have enough income to cover their most basic food needs. In Ontario, food bank usage has increased by 15 per cent since 2001. In Waterloo Region, approximately 25,000 people use the food bank each year and almost 50 per cent of those are children. Food Insecurity has broad ramifications Healthy eating is a significant factor in reducing the risk of developing a variety of chronic conditions including heart disease, cancer, obesity, diabetes, hypertension (high blood pressure), osteoporosis, anemia, dental decay and some bowel disorders. In Waterloo Region, one in five people in food insecure households report their health as poor or fair (20.7%) compared to 9.3 per cent of residents from food secure households. School Success is impacted by food security Children who live in food insecure households are more likely to have growth and development problems, are more likely to be absent from school, and have difficulty concentrating and learning. Poor nutrition impacts Poor Birth Outcomes Poor nutrition during pregnancy affects health during infancy, in childhood and throughout the life cycle. The nutritional status of pregnant women and the amount of weight gained are directly related to the newborn‟s birth weight and health outcome. Low birth weight babies are at increased risk of mortality in early infancy as well as physical and mental handicaps. Waterloo Region Crime rates are lower than average Police-reported crime in Canada continues to decline. Both the severity and the volume of crime decreased in 2009, continuing the general decrease seen over the past decade. According to Statistics Canada, the crime rate in Waterloo Region also has been dropping over the past ten years. The rate was 7,392 per 100,000 in 1998, by 2003 it was 6,266 per 100,000 and it dropped further to 5,174 per 100,000 in 2008." However, violent crime rate has risen slightly in recent years and in the previous year our crime rate increased. It is not yet clear if this increase is a trend or a one year situation. This increase was not unexpected though as given the changes in unemployment rate within Waterloo Region we expect to see a slight and temporary increase in the property crimes. It is also important to note that all of this data is based upon police reported crimes which is considered a significant undercount of actual crimes. Hate Crimes Police-reported hate crimes in Waterloo Region increased by 182% between 2007 and 2008 (from 11 to 31). 52% were based on race/ethnicity and 48% on religion in 2008. Hate crimes based on religion formed a significantly larger proportion of all hate crimes in Waterloo Region than in any of the other 10 largest communities in Canada. It is impossible to tell from the raw statistics whether this increase is a one-time anomaly or part of a trend (hate crimes increased provincially and nationally as well, but not as Document #: 829684 v15 25 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 steeply). We also don't know whether reported hate crimes increased because of the number of crimes or because residents feel safer reporting, but this is something we should be following. Physicians (General/Family Physicians and Specialists) per 100,000, 1998-2008 250 200 150 100 50 0 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Waterloo Region Ontario Canada Source: Canadian Institute for Health Information, Health Indicator Reports. Improved health care services still needed in Waterloo Region Waterloo Region continues to fall well below the number of general and specialist physicians for the size of our community. In 2008 we had 72 general and family physicians per 100,000 residents compared to 86 for Ontario overall. We had 57 specialists per 100,000 residents compared to 92 for Ontario – a significant difference. The rates for both general and specialist physicians have held relatively steady for a number of years. Two factors help to explain our difficulty in closing the gap. First, we are a rapidly growing community. Between 2001 and 2006 our population grew by 9% compared to 6.6% for Ontario. This means that we have to significantly increase the number of doctors we have just to keep up with our population growth. The second factor is that we don't have a teaching hospital to attract and hold specialists. In the next few years, the new medical school in Kitchener should help to partly close the gap in general and family practitioners. The faculty members will increase the number of specialists as well. 5. Human Services: Early Learning Challenges, Affordable Housing Challenges Access to Affordable Licensed Early Learning and Child Care Spaces is Limited Early learning and child care which occurs in the infant, toddler and preschool years is the first stage in lifelong learning and these early experiences shape the child for the rest of their life. There is a wealth of research that now shows that children who take part in high quality early childhood education programs will learn better in school: “Results from a number of studies demonstrate that child care quality matters. In fact, the importance of child care quality is one of the most robust findings in developmental psychology. Children who experience high-quality care have higher scores on achievement and language tests, show better social skills and fewer behavioural problems [than children who experience low-quality care].” ~McCartney, 2004, p. 2 The table below shows the percentage of Waterloo Region children with access to a licensed early learning and child care space by age category. Age Category # of Children1 # of Licensed Early Learning and Child Care (LELCC) Spaces2 Percentage of Children with Access to a LELCC Space Birth to Five 34,795 6,059 17% Six to Twelve 43,265 3,049 7% Birth to Twelve 78,060 9,109 12% 1 Statistics Canada, 2006 Census Document #: 829684 v15 26 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 Centre Based Spaces: As of March 31, 2010. Home Based Spaces: Calculations based on the Region of Waterloo Home Child Care caseload as of January 12, 2010. Wee Watch estimates are based on the Region of Waterloo Home Child Care caseload as of January 12, 2010. Subsidized child care need continues to grow The number of subsidized spaces available to families in need of financial assistance continues to grow. There has been a 1.4% net increase in centre based early learning and child care spaces from 2009 2010 (up to August 2010). Demand for fee subsidy exceeds funding in 2010. An average of 2,900 families were determined eligible for fee assistance with child care costs while the current funding allows for 2,700 children per month. Demand for Child Care Subsidy Ju ly Au gu Se st pt em be r O ct ob er N ov em be D r ec em be r M ay Ju ne Ap ril 2010 2009 2008 2007 Ja nu a Fe ry br ua ry M ar ch # Children 3100 3000 2900 2800 2700 2600 2500 2400 2300 2200 2100 2000 Months Are our students prepared for a future that will demand high literacy skills? Readiness to Learn Just under 70% of our grade 6 students are at or above the standard in the Provincial reading test. Of course this means that 30% are below the standard. This puts their future at risk. According to the Ontario Ministry of Education, "Adult literacy is a serious issue in Ontario. The International Adult Literacy and Skills Survey (2003) found that 16 per cent of adults in the province do not have basic literacy skills; an additional 26 per cent would benefit from literacy upgrading." 57% of adults in % children without special needs who are Waterloo Region (or almost 200,000 not ready for school based on the E.D.I.* individuals) are functioning below Level 3, instrument, 2007 which is generally considered to be the 35 “desired level” of competence for coping 30 with the increasing skill demands of the 25 emerging knowledge and information 20 economy. This percentage is higher than 15 the averages for Ontario and Canada, 10 however no data is available for 5 comparable communities. 0 In at least 1 area W aterloo Region In at least 3 areas Canada * The Early Instrument (EDI) is a survey used to measure school Document #:Development 829684 v15 readiness in five fundamental learning areas Source: Ontario Early Years Data Centre 27 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 Literacy is linked to economic and social performance, both individually and for society as a whole. Literacy levels determine the kind of jobs people find, the salaries they make and their ability to upgrade their work skills and maintain employment. Many individuals with low literacy skills are underemployed, and unemployment is three times more likely for adults in the lowest level of literacy than for the general population. In Waterloo Region, approximately 20% of those collecting Employment Insurance and 40% of social assistance recipients fall into the lowest level of literacy. Higher literacy rates are also associated with improved levels of health and increased public and civic participation. The duration of residence in Canada does not appear to impact on the performance of immigrants on the literacy survey, perhaps due to the higher education and skill requirements placed on more recent immigrants. It is reasonable to assume that local literacy levels have remained the same since 1994 (i.e. lower than the provincial and national averages) given that Federal and Provincial literacy budgets have changed very little in recent years and no significant investment in literacy services has been made at the local level. Affordability of housing is becoming more of a factor for some in our Region In Waterloo Region, 23% of households (owned or rented) spent 30% or more of their household income on major household payments. Of these 40,820 households, half are rented and half are owner-occupied (owned). The number of owner-occupied households who spent 30% or more of their income on shelter costs rose by 33.7% from 2001 to 2006, while rented households spending this amount increased by 7.3% over the same time period. People must have enough income to sustain the minimum standards for rent, utilities, food, health, clothing, education, transportation and recreation. As housing stability increases, the risk of homelessness decreases. 7% increase in emergency shelter bed nights 7% decrease in the number of people returning to shelters within one year Significant increase in minimum wage, modest increase to OW and ODSP shelter rates Increase in vacancy rate Decrease in waiting list for Community Housing Increase in the number of Community Housing units kept pace with population growth, private market rent units lagging behind Charities are reporting increased demands for their services and/or difficulty fulfilling their mission (Report by Imagine Canada, 2010) More than half of charities are reporting increased demands for their services and/or difficulty fulfilling their mission. Compared to 2009, more charities are reporting that their existence is at risk (29% vs. 22%) and/or increased demand (54% vs. 45%). On average, charities report that revenues have dropped by 1.1% while expenditures have increased by 3.8%. Operating charities report that the average number of paid staff has decreased by 4.4% Compared to older adults in Ontario, older adults in Waterloo Region are younger, and, have less formal education and similar health status. By 2028, the proportion of older adults in Waterloo Region is projected to grow by 88.9 per cent from 112,164 to 211,911, or from 22.0 per cent to 30.8 per cent of the overall population. During this same period the number of older adults in Ontario is expected to grow by 69.2 per cent, from 24.9 per cent to 33.3 per cent of the total population. These cities account for 87.1 per cent of the older adult population in the Region. Document #: 829684 v15 28 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 One-quarter to one-half of Waterloo Region older adults have less than a high school certificate, diploma or degree. In 2006, Waterloo Region had fewer older adults living with low income compared to Ontario (3.1 per cent vs. 5.9 per cent). Approximately 80 per cent of older adults in Waterloo Region rated their general health as good or very good and 73.2 per cent rated their mental health as very good or excellent. With respect to mental health, the highest rates of Emergency Department (ED) visits amongst older adults in 2008 were for anxiety disorders and substance abuse disorders. Where cause of death was a mental health condition, dementia and Alzheimer‟s Disease were most often the cause of death amongst older adults in Waterloo Region. Influenza was the most common infectious disease among older adults and in 2007-08, 83.0 per cent of adults 65 years and older with a chronic condition and 69.3 per cent of adults the same age without a chronic condition, had received an influenza vaccination in the previous year. In terms of health and lifestyle behaviours, less than one-half of older adults in Waterloo Region ate the recommended amount of vegetables and fruit per day in 2007-08. Furthermore, about two-thirds of them were overweight or obese and 96.0 per cent of older adults lived in food secure households. Approximately 15 per cent were current smokers. In 2007-08, 98.5 per cent of Waterloo Region older adults reported having a regular medical doctor and 98.9 per cent reported consulting with a health professional during the past year. There are a range of housing options available to older adults in Waterloo Region, including community housing, retirement homes, long-term care homes and recently opened supportive housing at Sunnyside Home. In 2006, the majority of older adult households in Waterloo Region had access to a private vehicle and a licensed driver and preferred motor vehicles as a mode of transportation. Older adults tend to stay socially active as evidenced by the fact that in 2003 about one-half were members of a voluntary organization, while almost 80 per cent volunteered on a monthly basis. Similarly, in 2006, about 95 per cent reported providing unpaid house work, while about one-quarter provided unpaid child care and almost 30 per cent provided unpaid care or assistance to other older adults. Ontario has a disability rate that is higher than the national average In 2006 4.4 million Canadians reported limitations in their everyday activities, indicating a national disability rate of 14.3%. Ontario has a disability rate that is higher than the national average, with 15.5% of residents reported activity limitations. The rate of disability in Ontario increases as people age. While 3.7% of children under 15 years of age and 12.6% of adults aged 15-64 report limitations in daily activities, 47.2% of seniors aged 65 years and older report limitations in daily activities. More than half (56.3%) of people aged 75 years and older reported having an activity limitation. Rate of disability in Ontario increases by age The type of disability experienced by people will change with age. The three most common disabilities experienced by children under 15 years of age are chronic, learning, and speech, while the three most common disabilities experienced by adults 15 years of age and older are pain, mobility, and agility. Decreases in saving for retirement Statistics Canada reports on "savers" – individuals who earn interest income from Canada Savings Bonds, term deposits, bank accounts, treasury bills, investment certificates, earnings from life insurance policies, as well as foreign interest and dividend income. With deficit and debt pressure on senior levels of government, residents who do not prepare for retirement in advance, or who need to add to their employment income are likely to increase. Document #: 829684 v15 29 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 The median income from interest for all savers in the Kitchener CMA was $310 in 2008, down from $320 in 2007. The percentage of income from interest on investments for residents age 65 and older was 52% in 2007 and 54% in 2008. 6. Infrastructure: to meet current needs and future growth: Growing Transit Use, Mounting Road Pressure, Quality of life is directly impacted by the quality of our infrastructure, including roads, airport, public transit, water supply, waste water treatment and solid waste management. Sustainable infrastructure needs to be maintained, renewed, replaced and expanded for new growth in order to maintain this quality of life. Other infrastructure owned by the Region (e.g. Regional buildings, housing, child care centers, etc.) also needs to be adequately maintained, replaced and expanded in a timely manner. The Region of Waterloo will work with all orders of government and our community partners to plan, improve and enhance infrastructure, find sufficient resources and include environmental considerations throughout infrastructure development and implementation. Transit service in the Region of Waterloo had not kept pace with urban growth Since completion of the last Transportation Master Plan in 1999, annual transit ridership has increased from 9.5 million rides in 2000 to 16.5 million rides in 2009; a 74% increase or 6.3% growth annually. % Workers Using Public Transit, Transit ridership growth over this period has 2001, 2006 outpaced population growth significantly, with Region 14 of Waterloo population increasing by 1.85% per year 12 between 2000 and 2009. The 2006 Census indicated 10 that 4.8% of residents used public transit to get to 8 work which is up from 3.9% in 2001. 6 4 Growing congestion on the road network If the Region continues to address growing 0 congestion through road expansion projects only, 2001 2006 forecasts of future travel demands in 2031 suggest Waterloo Region Ontario that the transportation network would need to be expanded by about 25% to ensure all roadways are operating at no more than 100% of their capacity. This represents close to 500 new lane-kilometres of road widening within the urban areas of Kitchener, Waterloo and Cambridge. To put this into context, the six-lane section of Hespeler Road between Highway 401 and Munch Ave currently represents about 20 lane-kilometres of road. To add 500 new lane-kilometres to the Regional Road network is the equivalent of building 25 new Hespeler Roads. 2 Source: Statistics Canada Community Profiles, 2001 and 2006 By 2031, a total of 84 new lanes of capacity would be required across these key screenlines address future growth. This is on top of the 16 lanes of capacity that have been added in the past few years through completion of projects such as Ira Needles Boulevard, Fischer Hallman Road and Highland Road. This additional level of new road construction would have significant impacts on stable neighbourhoods and the community as a whole The limited inter-regional transit service into Waterloo Region Represents a transportation network deficiency that limits transportation choices and opportunities for many longer distance travelers to / from the Region. Presently, rail passenger service is limited to three VIA trains per day connecting Kitchener to the GTA. Both GO Transit and VIA Rail have been undertaking studies in preparation for increasing service in this corridor. The Region has also completed Document #: 829684 v15 30 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 a study indicating the feasibility of extending GO Transit rail service from Milton to Cambridge. GO Transit has introduced bus service to Mississauga and Greyhound provides service to Toronto. Need to continue to fund active transportation infrastructure The 2006 Census indicated that approximately 43% of residents in the Kitchener Census Metropolitan Area live less than 5 kilometres from their place of employment. This provides a significant market opportunity for active forms of transportation including public transit, cycling and walking. According to Statistics Canada, cycling increased by 45% between 2001 and 2006. Driving most common mode of transportation to work Across the Region, commuting as the driver of a vehicle was the most common mode of transportation used in getting to work in 2006. Although the absolute number of people driving to work in a car, truck or van has increased over five years, more sustainable modes of transportation have seen a notable rate of growth. More sustainable modes of transportation accounted for 12% of the modal split in 2006, up from 10% in 2001. Driving to work in a vehicle was the only mode of transportation that had a decrease from 2001 to 2006 in terms of its percentage share of the modal split. Data from the 2006 Census indicates that at least 80% of the employed labour force living in Waterloo Region also works in the Region. Furthermore, at least 50% work in the same municipality as they reside. The City of Guelph is the most frequent destination for workers traveling from Waterloo Region, attracting almost three times the number of Regional commuters as the next most common destination, as well as being the primary city where commuters working in Waterloo Region live. After the City of Guelph, the areas to the east of Waterloo Region such as the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) are the most common workplace destinations for commuters coming from the Region while commuters coming to Average income by commuter type, the Region for employment originate primarily from 2006 areas in the south such as Hamilton, Brant and Brantford. 60,000 50,000 Transit must become a sought-out option for more than those who can't afford a car. Currently much of the ridership consists of students and other lowincome travelers. 40,000 30,000 20,000 10,000 0 Although the Greater Toronto Area does attract a significant number of employees who commute from Waterloo Region, large increases have been seen in the percentage of people who live in the GTA and are commuting to Waterloo for work. Residents of the GTA traveling to jobs in Waterloo Region increased 59% from the number of commuters traveling the same way in 2001. Waterloo Region Car, truck, van, as driver Public transit Bicycle Taxicab Document #: 829684 v15 Canada QLRS Car, truck, van, as passenger Walked Motorcycle Other method 31 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 7. Service Excellence: Addressing the Challenges of Accountability, Accessibility, and Participation Public expectations are increasing Research indicates that service quality scores in all levels of government are increasing but this does not mean that the public sector can relax its efforts to improve. Citizens' expectations are increasing and they demanding a higher level of customer service. The bar has been raised in terms of customer satisfaction – being satisfied is no longer good enough. Because service is critical in shaping the public‟s confidence in government, it is vital that the focus on service increase, not diminish. The challenge for the public sector is bigger now than ever before and even more complex in a two tier system. Changing demographics of customers - in terms of growth of demand and the changing nature of demand, e.g., language diversity are also other factors impacting the need to prioritize and improve service, as is new legislation regarding access for people with disabilities. Research is showing that the broader public is demanding a higher level of customer service each year and the citizens of Waterloo Region are not different from those Canadians surveyed. They too are looking for a higher level of customer service from our employees. This may even be more difficult for the Region as a survey conducted by the ICCS also revealed that: “44% stated that governments have a more difficult task than the private sector – as they must protect the public interest as well as meet the needs of citizens” and 62% (Ontario) stated they felt they should receive a higher level of service from government than they do from the private sector.” Latest research (2005) shows that government services show a steady improvement and that some public sector services out perform similar private sector services. Citizen engagement is decreasing The percentage of eligible voters casting ballots in the 2006 municipal elections was 26.58%. Volunteer rates and donations are decreasing Median family income in Waterloo Region, at $74,000 in 2006, was 7% higher than the Provincial median, yet the median charitable donation for tax-filers who claimed donations was the same as the Ontario median, at $300. The proportion of Waterloo Region tax-filers who claim donations decreased from 31.2% to 27.8% from 1997 to 2008, although it is still higher than the Provincial and National rates. Total donations by Waterloo Region residents decreased from a high of $167M in 2006 to $146M in 2008 – a decrease of 12.6% in two years. We are not making up for our diminishing donations with increased volunteer time, either. Our volunteer rate decreased from 45% of adults to 41% of adults between 2004 and 2007 – a rate that is significantly lower than either the Provincial or National rates. Rapid changes in public and volunteer expectations Volunteers play an integral role in the delivery of services and programs on behalf of the Region. Volunteer involvement in programs and services adds to the quality of life of all citizens and strengthens our communities. Volunteer programs at the Region provide a chance for citizens to become involved in their communities. In turn, volunteers provide an important link to our community by promoting and supporting Regional programs and services. Recent government initiatives requiring police checks for any volunteer who works with the public, and for the fingerprinting of those whose birth dates coincide with known offenders may impact significantly on the willingness of many volunteers to continue their service to the community. Document #: 829684 v15 32 DRAFT Waterloo Region Profile - 2010 Access to Government Information 69% of Canadians think that “knowing where to start” is the biggest challenge in getting government services. Systems to support effective service e.g., web sites have significant potential for providing easy access to information. (However, currently 20% of households lack Internet access from home.) Citizens use of government websites is up, mirroring overall increase in Internet use. The highest reason for visiting a government website is “to get information.” 54% of citizens use other ways (besides websites) to obtain information from government: o 41% called on the phone o 22% went to a government office o 15 received information by mail or fax. o 14% visited other government sites o 11% used email o 2% used other means. In 2007, Ekos Research surveyed individuals about their channels for service delivery. The research indicated that the telephone was still the most popular channel; however, the research also indicated that it is the telephone channel that most people have encountered problems with. Web site visits (to the Region‟s website) per 100,000 population is decreasing for the Region of Waterloo‟s website. It was 3.3 hits/capita in 2004 and decreased to 2.7 hits per capita in 2006. Waterloo Region residents reported that newsletters are the most preferred source of communication (OMNIBUS) followed by direct mailings, the local daily paper, the Region‟s website, and television. Less interest was given to email, local weekly paper and radio. People with disabilities rate access at 57 out of 100 compared to non-disabled citizens at 65 Citizen Engagement at Council The number of open and closed Council and Committee meetings remained fairly steady from 2007 to 2009. In 2009, however, the number of delegations, both to Council and the P&W Committee spiked. In Access to Council and Committees 2009, there were a significant number of delegations regarding the Regional 250 Official Plan. This is a good indication 200 that the public is engaged in planning 150 for the future of the Region. 100 50 0 # Closed Council Meetings # Open Council Meetings # # Closed # Open # Delegations Committee Committee Delegations to Council Meetings Meetings to Committee 2007 Document #: 829684 v15 2008 2009 33
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz