CHARACTERISTICS OF CLIFFS BY BREEDING D.E. AND PRAIRIE RUNDE AND S.H. NEST SITES USED FALCONS ANDERSON ABSTRACT - Datafromover400PrairieFalcon(Falco mexicanus) eyriesin 8 states showa consistent patternof eyrie placement relativeto heightand aspectof nestcliffs.Meaneyrieheightaveraged 63% of meancliff height.Mean exposure of eyriesandnestcliffstendedtobesoutherly withnosignificant differencebetween eyrieandcliffexposures. Potholes werethemostfrequently usednestsites.Patterns of occupancy andnestsuccess in Wyomingwerestatistically independent of physical habitatvariables measured. However,eyriesontallexposed buttesconsistently hadhighfailure ratesthatappearedweatherrelated.Attributes of Wyomingeyriesarepresented andsuggestions madefor creatingnew eyriesfor Prairie Falconsasa managementtool. We summarized and compared data on nest each cliff was estimatedwith a large protractor and was either cliffs and eyries used by the Prairie Falcon(Falco vertical(85-95ø),overhung(<80 ø)or underhung( >100% Cliffs are dataavailablein the literatureand originaldata from eyries active between 1982 and 1984 in Wyoming. Our objectivewasto documentthe variation in nestcliffs and eyriesusedby thesefalcons and to identify consistentpatterns of use. In our study,we examinedthe association betweenphysicalnestinghabitatand patternsof eyrieoccupancy were classedas: canyonwalls,buttes or mountains,rimrock or ridges,and isolatedrock outcrops. Standardstatistics are presentedfor mostvariables.Statistics from other studies,if not reported, were calculatedfrom frequencytablesor raw data. We analyzedour data usingone-way ANOVA and Chi-square(X2) to examinerelationshipsbetween physicalvariablesand historiesof nest success and occupancy within and among years.In among-yearanalyses,we only includedsiteswith complete3-yr histories. Data suitablefor circularstatisticalanalysis(Batschelet1981; and nest success. We discuss attributes Zar 1984) were available for Montana, Utah, New Mexico, Idaho, mexicanus)in the western United States. Included of Prairie Colorado and Wyoming. Grouped data were analyzed as suggestedby Batschelet(1981); 954 confidenceintervalswere estimatedby interpolation(Batschelet(1981: Fig. 5.2 1). We used usedRayleigh'stestto determinestatisticalsignificanceof mean exposuresto infer nonrandomorientations(Zar 1984). Concentration (r), or lengthof the meanvectorascalculatedby circular methods,rangesfrom 0 to 1andisaffectedbyvariationin circular data, samplesize,and grouping.Valuesof r near 1indicatedata pointscloselyconcentrated aboutthe meanangle. Falconnestcliffsand eyries,and suggestguidelines for creatingnew falcon eyries. STUDY AREA AND METHODS Data from 8 stateswere considered:Washington(Decker 1931), Wyoming-Colorado(Enderson1964), Montana (Leedy 1972), Utah (Porter and White 1973), New Mexico(Platt 1974), Oregon (Denton 1975), Idaho (Ogden 1973; Ogden and Hornocker 1977), and Colorado (Williams 1981). We collecteddata from eyriesand associated cliffsin southern RESULTS Wyoming known to have been activebetween 1982 and 1984. We defineeyrieastheareain andimmediately aroundthenestscrape. Eyries. -- Dimensionsof eyriesfrom the present Nestcliff wasthe rock formationaboveand belowthe eyrie. A study were summarized(Table 1), and comparable singlenestingterritorymaycontainseveralseparatenestcliffsand eyriesthat are occupiedand defendedin different years.We to Williams (1981) and Porter and White (1973). climbedto eyriesby ladderor rope;nestcliff measurements were Williams(1981) reported eyrie lengthsand widths taken from below. Variablesmeasuredat eyriescenteredon the nestscrape,if recognizable, or on the approximatecenterof the eyrie. These includedroof (or overhang)height,width,length,and percent coverage of nestscrapebyroof or overhang.We measuredareaof bothentranceand floorwitha transparent25 cm2grid. Slopeof both floor and ceilingwere measuredwith a clinometer.Eyrie exposurewasmeasuredby placinga compass in the nestscrape and taking readingsalong a horizontalplane to both outside edges.From theseazimuths(correctedfor declination)we calculatedmeanandextentof horizontalexposure.Finally,eyrieswere classedas either potholes,horizontalledgesor shelves,vertical cracks or crevices, and stick nests. Nest cliff measurements focusedon that portionof the cliff directlyaboveand belowthe eyrie.Variablesincludedcliff and eyrieheight,inclination of thetoeslopebelowcliff(determined by clinometer), and aspectperpendicular to the cliff. Verticalityof whichaveraged78.9 cm (SE -- 7.63) and 81.1 cm (SE = 9.52), respectively.Both meanswere significantly less than measurementsfrom Wyoming (tTest; P<0.01). Roof heights of Colorado eyries (Williams 1981)averaged83.2 cm (SE = 12.04), and weresignificantlygreater(t-Test; P < 0.01) than we found. The Coloradodatayieldedan averagefloor area of 6821 cm2 (SE = 1198.22). Area within 8 eyries averaged 15,000 cm2 in Utah (Porter and White 1973). Our estimate of area lies between these,but statistical comparisons couldnotbe made. Floorsof most (80%) Wyomingeyries sloped downwardstowardsthe front at 5-10ø.Conversely, most(84%) eyrie roofsor overhangsslopedto the 21 RAPTORRESEARC•20 (1):21-28 22 RUNDE ANDANDERSON VOL.20, No. 1 Table 1. Attributesof Prairie Falconeyriesin southernWyoming,1982 to 1984. VARIABLE MEAN Height (cm) Width (cm) SE RANGE N 47.9 3.62 11-193 68 91.2 7.45 18.313 70 Length(cm) 135.4 8.82 43-400+ 71 Floor (cm2) 9325 769.83 1600-29275 70 Entrance (cm2) 5375 975.12 875-53500 56 Floor Slope(o) 7.4 0.78 -10-35 67 Roof Slope(o) - 12.3 2.23 -65-45 56 rear at a wide range of angles(Table 1). All eyries we examined,exceptfor 2 (3%), had overhanging rock or ceilingsprotectingthe nestscrape.Percent coverageof nestscrapeswasfrequently 100%,and averaged93%. Acrosstheir range, Prairie Falconsnestedmost frequently in potholesor on cliff ledges.Crevices and sticknestswereusedlessfrequently(Table2). Nest cliffs. -- Heights of eyriesand nest cliffs variedwidely.Relativeto meancliff heights,mean eyrie heightsvaried from 60-70% (Table 3). Mean heightsof eyriesfrom 8 studieswerehighlycorrelated with mean heightsof cliffs (R2 = 0.99; P < 0.001), and averaged 63% of mean cliff height. Minimum cliff and eyrie heightsreportedin these studieswere 2.1 m and 0.8 m, respectively.Signifi- Table 2. Typesof eyriesusedby nestingprairie falcons. STATE POTHOLE 1 CREVICE2 LEDGEa STIC KNEST REFERENCE n (%) n (%) n (%) n (%) WY 29 (41) 17 (24) 18 (25) 7 (10) CO 2 (14) 9 (64) 3 (21) .... 24 (19) 26 14 (39) 7 (19) .... 4 (19) 9 Williams (1981)4 ID 76 (60) OR 15 (42) NM 8 (39) UT 26 (36) 7 (10) 23 (32) (16) 22 MT 18 (37) 18 (37) 9 (18) 4 (8) CO-WY 20 (56) 16 (44) 6 (43) 1 (7) 7 (50) 200 (45) 105 (24) 69 (16) WA 65 (15) This study (21) Ogdenand Hornocker(1977) (43) Platt (1974) Denton (1975)4 Porter and White (1973) Leedy(1972) Enderson (1964) 'Includes sites listed as caves, holes and cavities. 2Includes sites listed as vertical cracks. aIncludessiteslistedashorizontalshelves.Includesa few siteswith sticknests present. 4Datanot reported but sticknests used. Decker (1931) SPRING 1986 PRAIRIE FALCON NESTCHARACTERISTICS 23 Table3. Meanheightsof PrairieFalconeyriesand nestcliffs. CLIFF HEIGHT (m) EYRIE HEIGHT (m) PERCENT 1 MEAN (n) RANGE 14.6 (71) 53.7 (14) 4.3- 34.6 36.9 (49) 3.7- 122+ 14.0 (21) 30.4 MEAN (n) RANGE HEIGHT REFERENCE 9.8 (71) 2.9- 30.6 67 This study 32.1 (14) 10 -90 60 Williams ( 1981) 22.9 (41) 2.1 - 61+ 62 Denton (1975) 2 6- 35 8.6 (21) 3 61 Platt (1974) (126) 2.3- 122+ 19.8 (126) 2.4- 122+ 65 Ogden(1973)2 31.0 (44) 2.1 - 154.4 19.6 (51) 0.8- 137.2 63 Porter and White (1973) 38.1 (57) 9.2- 92+ 24.4 (57) 3.1- 76.2 64 Leedy (1972)a 15.8 (36) 7.7- 38.7 11.1 (36) 7O Enderson (1964) 29.3 (418) 2.1 - 154.4 18.5 (417) 63 Grand 15 - 140 - 30 ..... 0.8- 137.2 Mean = Mean x 100% 'Percent height eyrie height Mean cliff height 2Values biased lowassomeverytalleyriesandcliffswereexcluded. SApproximatevalues. canflymore Wyomingeyrieswere in the upper fidence intervals could be calculated, intervals tbr one-halfof thecliffsthanin thelowerone-half(X2; eyrieexposureand cliff aspectoverlappedexten- P < 0.005).But the upperandmiddleone-thirdof sively(Appendix;Fig. 3) Overall,meaneyrie ascliffswereusedequally. pectsaveraged161.2ø(r = 0.24);meancliff aspects Inclination of toeslopes rangedfrom0-36ø. Most averaged158.3ø(r = 0.19).Due to largedisparities (57%)cliffswerevertical(85-95ø), thoughmany in samplesizes,thesegrand meansare biasedto- (34%)sloped backintothehill( > 100ø). Only9% wardour datafrom Wyoming. wereoverhung(< 80ø). Aspectsof cliffsand eyriesin Wyomingranged We found nestcliffsfairly evenlydistributed from 0 - 360ø(Fig.2). We lumpedeyrieexposures among volcanicbuttes or mountains(34%), into2 groups(northeastandsouthwest facing)and sandstonecanyons(30%) and isolatedrock out- foundthat70.2%facedsouthwest; closetothepercrops(25%).Fewoccurred on lowrimrock(11%). centage(69.4%) of eyriesthat facedsouthwestin In Oregon,Denton(1975)reportedeyriesonbluffs Utah (Porterand White 1973; Fig. 16). Extentof (38%),ridges(29%),canyons (24%)andoutcropshorizontalexposureof eyriesweexamined(Fig.3) (9%). Exposureof eyriesand cliffs. -- Exposuredata rangedfrom 5 - 160ø,and averaged54 __+ 12ø (r = 0.83). Williams(1981) reported"anglesof view" rangingfrom 30 - 170øandaveraging122--+3ø(r = 0.74). from6 of the8 westernstates areshownin Figure1 NeitherANOVA nor X2 testsrevealedany sig- (Appendix). Except for Utah and New Mexico, as- nificant(P>0.05) relationships amongphysical pectsof bothcliffsandeyrieswasreported.In no traits,includingexposures, of Wyomingeyriesand casedid the distributions of eyrieandcliff aspects historiesof nestoccupancy and success. This held differ significantly(X2;P > 10). When 95% confi- true bothwithinand amongyears. 24 RusI•, ^si• Asi•,]•sos 560* 270* VOL. 20, No. 1 560* 01 o 5 270 5 04 0.5 o Figure1. Meanaspectof PrairieFalconeyries(A) or nestcliffs(B) in Montana,Colorado,Wyoming,Utah,Oregonand New Mexico.Vectorlengthsare proportionalto degreeof concentration (r) aboutmeanaspect(Appendix). 560ø 360* Figure2. Frequency histograms of eyrieexposure(A) andcliff aspect(B) for PrairieFalcons in southernWyoming, 1982-1984. SPRING 1986 PRAIRIE FALCON NEST CHARACTERISTICS 25 360 ø 360 ø 27 90 ø 27 90 ø 214ø/,.,.. '•' I• •' "--..... .... •168 ø Figure3. Meansand 95% confidenceintervalsfor (A) extentof exposureand (B) cliff aspect(brokenline) and eyrie exposure(solidline),for PrairieFalcons in southernWyoming,1982-1984. DISCUSSION Comparedto other westernraptors,Prairie Falconshavenarrow nestsiterequirements.They nest almostexclusively on rockcliffs(cf., MacLarenet al. 1984). Nest cliffs used vary widely in height, location andaspect.Yet in the studiesexamined,Prairie Falconsdemonstratedsome consistentpatterns in their useof eyries.Mean eyrieand cliff heightswere stronglycorrelatedand distributionsof eyrie and cliff aspectswere similar. We do not infer habitat selectivitybecausedata on availabilityof potential eyriesand nestcliffshaveneitherbeencollectedby us nor presentedin the studieswe cite. Eyries. -- Potholes,reported most frequently, provide excellent shelter from both inclement weather and direct sunlight, but are not always available.In our experience,potholesoccurmost frequentlyin sandstone, whileledgesand vertical cracksaremorecommonin granite,basaltand conglomeratecliffs.Verticalcracksand crevicesalso provideexcellentshelterand shade,but may be subjectedto chillingdrafts.Nestsin creviceswere reportedinfrequentlyin the literaturebut were commonin our studyarea. Nest cliffs. -- Mean eyrie heights, as percentage of mean cliff heights,were surprisinglyconsistent and indicateextensiveuseof nestsites60 - 70% up cliff faces.Further studyis neededto explain this narrowrangeof eyrieheightsrelativeto cliff heights. By nestingin the upper reachesof verticalcliffs, Prairie Falcons should be safe from mammalian predators. Such a location also provides a commandingview of the territory and of potentialprey or predators.Dependingon aspectand prevailing winds,updraftsalongcliffsmayaid the falconswhen leavingthe nestto hunt or defend territory. Convective updrafts may form more frequentlyon southfacingcliffsastheyradiatemore heatthan cliffswith other aspects. Exposure. -- Prairie Falconshave long been known to neston cliffs with southerlyaspects(e.g., Dawson 1913). Sixty-oneand 42% of the eyries studied by Enderson (1964) and Ogden (1973) facedsouth.But their data, asreported, could not beincludedin our circularstatistics analyses.With 2 exceptions(Platt 1974; Denton 1975), the studies examinedindicatedsoutherlymeanaspects(Fig. 1). Although cliff and eyrie exposurevaried widelyin 26 RUNDEANDANDERSON VOL.20, NO. 1 most studies,Rayleigh'stest indicated significant nonrandomnessin most cases(Appendix). Mean exposureswere often only weaklysignificant(P • 0.10) due to wide rangesof exposuresand because most data t¾omthe literature were grouped into broad exposureclasses. Aspectsof nestcliffsin New Mexico and eyries in Oregon were random (Rayleigh'stest;P > 0.10). Excludingthese,mean cliff aspectranged t¾om144 - 288ø, and mean aspect of eyriesranged from 143 - 226ø. Prairie Falconsdo use north-lacingcliffs and eyries(Figs. 1 and 2). In fact, Tyler (1923) reported that most Prairie Falcon eyries in southern California had northerly aspectsand none were southerly.He attributed thisto a scarcityof south-facingcliffs and an abundanceof north-facing cliffs. Our results demonstratea tendencyfor Prairie Falconsto use southerly aspects,but do not demonstrateany benefit in termsof nestsuccess. Eyrie configuration and locationon the cliff mayoverrideeffortsof cliff aspect(Ellis 1982).Data on availabilityof potential cliffsandeyrieswith differingaspects areneededto concludethat falconsactivelyselectsouth-lacing lower shelteredcanyons,rims and outcrops(18 38%). However,X2 testsfailed to confirm a signifi- southwest-lacing eyriesfailed in 1980. Williamsattributed this to localweatherpatterns. Bioticthctorslikelyplaya larger role than physicalhabitatin determiningoccupancy and nestsuccessin Prairie Falcons.Though not confirmedby statisticalanalyses(X2; P>0.10), nesting Greathorned Owls (Bubo virginianus)were often associatedwith unoccupiedand unsuccessful falcon territoriesin our studyarea. Although we did not quantifyaccessibility of eyriesto mammalianpredators,thismaybean importantfactor(Ogdenand Hornocker 1977). Abundanceof prey clearlyall fectsPrairie Falconproductivityand nestsuccess. Townsend's Ground Squirrel (Spermophilus cliffs. townsendi)densities in Idaho accounted for over The microclimatewithinan eyrieisaffectedbyits exposure and cliff aspect; southerly exposures likely help to moderatecold temperaturesduring incubationand brooding. Solar heating of nest scrapesmay lessenthe energy requirementsof incubatingandbroodingfalcons.The majority(97%) of eyries we examined had overhead protection. Most eyriesexaminedby Enderson(1964), Leedy (1972), Platt(1974), Ogdenand Hornocker(1977) and Williams (1981) were similarly sheltered. Overheadshademay be important during midday sincenestlingsexposedto direct sunwhen temperaturesare near 32øC may die (Nelson 1969). Such temperatures are unusual during the nestling period in our studyarea, but useof shadedeyries may increasenestlingsurvival at lower elevations 98% of the annualvariationin Prairie Falconproductivity(USD1-BLM 1979). Managementimplications.-- Mitigationfor loss of suitablenestingcliffs due to energy,urban, or recreationaldevelopmentmay be neededin some nest sites. Such sites were rapidly colonizedin California(Boyceet al. 1980)and Alberta(Fyfeand Armbruster 1977). Becausethe size of the nonbreedingpopulationof Prairie Falconsmay be as high as 25% of the breeding population(Runde in prep.) substantial populationincreases seempossible, but will dependupon the localavailabilityof prey and foraginghabitat. The data presentedhere suggestlocatingnew nestsiteson south-lacingcliffsabouttwo-thirdsup and latitudes. the cliff. Area of the floor should be at least 7,000 We believeshelterfrom late springstormsto be more important than protectionfrom heat stressin our Wyoming study area. Such stormswere associatedwith a high rate (64%) of nestingfailure on buttesin 1983. A springsnowstormthissameyear was followed by desertion of all 5 active nestson buttesin a smallarea of northeasternWyoming(J. Squirespers.comm.).In our studyarea, territories on tall exposedbuttesconsistently sufferedhigher cmz,and slopegently(5-10ø)to the front. Overhead covershouldbe present,and horizontalexposure shouldbe about 54ø (Fig. 3A). If eyriesare to be createdon mine highwallsas part of habitatreclamationor mitigation,their legal,hydrological,and physical constraints must first be addressed (Tessman1984). The data in Table 3 suggestthat cliffs,or highwalls,selectedfor eyrie creationbe at rates of nestfailure (43 - 64%) than thoselocated on We suggestthat newlycreatedeyriesbe clustered cant association(P > 0.10) between nest successand cliff location. In our study, neither cliff nor eyrie aspectappearedto determinepatternsof eyrieoccupancyor nestsuccess (seealsoOgdenand Hornocker 1977). Eyrie, but not cliff, aspectapparentlyaffectednest successin Colorado (Williams 1981) where all 5 areas. An obvious solution is the creation of new least 2.1 m tall. SPRING 1986 PRAIRIE FALCONNEST CHARACTERISTICS 27 together to mimic nesting territories with several NELSON,M.W. 1969. Statusof the peregrine falcon in alternate nest sites. These new territories could be spacedapproximately1-2 km apart unlessvisual barriersare presentto separatethem. In this situation, we have seen successful nests as close as 150 m. the Northwest.Chp. 4 In J.J. Hickey (Ed.). Peregrine FalconPopulations: Their biologyand decline. Univ. of WisconsinPress,Madison. 596 pp. OGDEN,V.T. 1973. Nesting density and reproductive success of prairie falconsin southwesternIdaho. M.S. Thesis.Univ. of Idaho, Moscow.39 pp. OGDEN, V.T. AND M.G. HORNOCKER. 1977. Nesting Our data showthat in a 3-yr period overone-half of the eyrieswere only occupied1 yr, and 23% were occupied2 yrs. Similar findingswere reported by densityand reproductivesuccess of prairiefalconsin ELderson(1904) and Ogden (1973). We suggest southwestern Idaho.J. Wildl.Manage.41:1-11. that 2 or 3 nest sitesbe provided per cliff. The PLATT,S.W. 1974. Breeding statusand distribution of the prairie falcon in northern New Mexico. M.S. abilityto usealternateeyrieswithin a nestingterriThesis. Oklahoma State Univ., Stillwater. 68 pp. tory may help to reducedirect competitionfor nest siteswith owls,and may decreasethe frequencyof PORTER,R.D. AND C.M. WHITE. 1973. The peregrine falconin Utah, emphasizingecologyand competition parasiticinfestations. with the prairie falcon.BrighamYoungUniv. Sci.Bull. 28:1-74. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS TESSMAN,S. 1984. Habitat reclamation proceduresfor Tricia MacLaren helped locate and collect data from the surface mines in Wyoming. Pages 185-195. In R.D. Wyoming eyries. Richard Guenzel programmedthe circular Comer etal. (Eds.). Proc. of the Symposium:Issues statistics calculations. JamesELderson,GraingerHunt, Larry Irand Technology in the Management of Impacted win,JamesMosherand KarenSteenhofreviewedearlierversions Western Wildlife. Steamboat Springs, Colo. Nov. of thispaper.This studywassupportedby theBLM, the Wyoming CooperativeFishand Wildlife ResearchUnit, USFWS,National Wildlife Federation, and the late Robert Runde. LITERTURE CITED BATSCHELET,E. 1981. Circular statistics in biology. AcademicPress.New York. 366 pp. BOYCE,D.A., JR., L. FISHER,W.E. LEHMAN,B. HIPP ANDJ. PETERSON. 1980. Prairie falcons nest on an artificial 15-17, 1982. Thorne Ecol. Inst. Tech. Pub. 14. Boulder, Colo. 250 pp. TYLER,J.G. 1923. Observationson the habits of the prairie falcon.Condor25:95-97. U.S.D.I. - B.L.M. 1979. SnakeRiver Birds of Prey Special ResearchReport to the Secretary of Interior. Boise,Idaho. 142 pp. WILLIAMS,R.N. 1981. Breeding ecologyof prairie falcons at high elevationsin central Colorado. M.S. Thesis.Brigham Young Univ. Provo, Utah. 44 pp. ZAR,J.H. 1984. BiostatisticalAnalysis.SecondEdition. PrenticeHall. EnglewoodCliffs, NJ. 736 pp. ledge.RaptorRes.14:46-50. DAWSON, W.L. 1913. The nestingof the prairie falconin San Luis ObispoCounty. Condor15:56-62. Wyoming Cooperative Fisheries and Wildlife Research Unit, DECKER,F.R. 1931. Prairie falcon's nest. The Oologist 48:96. DENTON,S.J. 1975. Statusof prairie falconsbreedingin Oregon.M.S.Thesis.OregonStateUniv., Corvallis.58 Received1 May 1985;Accepted20 September1985 PP. ELLIS, D.H. 1982. The peregrine falcon in Arizona: Habitat utilization and management recommendations. Inst. Raptor Stud.Res.Pap. No. 1. ENDERSON,J.H.1964. A studyof the prairiefalconin the centralRockyMountain region.Auk 81:332-352. FYFE,R.W. ANDH.I. ARMBRUSTER. 1977. Raptor managementin Canada.Pages282-293.In R.D. Chancellor (Ed.). Proc. of the World Conferenceon Birds of Prey. Vienna, 1975.ICBP. 442 pp. LEEDY,R.R. 1972. The statusof the prairie falcon in western Montana: specialemphasison possibleeffects of chlorinated hydrocarboninsecticides.M.S. Thesis. Univ. of Montana, Missoula.96 pp. MAcLAREN, Department of Zoology and Physiology, University of Wyoming, Box 3166, University Station, Laramie, Wyoming 82071. P.A., D.E. RUNDE AND S.H. ANDER- SON. 1984. A recordof tree-nestingprairie falconsin Wyoming.Condor86:487. 28 RUNDEANDANDERSON VOL. 20, No. 1 Appendix: Mean aspectof Prairie Falconeyriesand Prairie Falconnestcliffs. MEAN STATE SIGNIFICANCE ASPECT 1 r VALUE LEVEL 2 N Wyoming 180ø_31ø 0.41 P< 0.001 67 Presentstudy Colorado 200 ø+ 60 ø 0.44 P < O. 10 Oregon 255ø O.18 P >0.10 Utah 2260-+ 34 ø 0.36 P < 0.01 14 36 49 Williams (1981) Denton (! 975) Porter and White (1973) Montana 143ø-+ 33 ø 0.34 P< 0.001 49 Leedy (1972) REFERENCE Eyries Cliffs Wyoming 191+ 23ø 0.40 P< 0.001 71 Presentstudy Colorado 200ø+ 60 ø 0.44 P<0.10 Oregon 288ø+ 51ø 0.28 P < 0.10 New Mexico Montana 353 ø 144 ø+ 35 ø 0.07 0.34 P >0.10 P< 0.01 15 36 21 Williams (1981) Denton (1975) Platt (1974) 45 Leedy(1972) •With 95% confidence interval, when calculable. ZRayleigh's test.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz