FOtt,\tt\o.J
-(sEtittt'LI,lt(l)r
IN I'HI' AITN,IEDT.'OR(]ES
TITIBTINAL
. ITEGt( ) \,- \I-U E N ( ' t I .K O [ _ K . t\ . {
otil)[_R_
SHnF]T'
A I ' l ' l . l C A T I O \ N o . l { . A .\ o . l 0 / 2 0 1 5
{ \ V i t h o . A . N o .{ 5 / 2 0 1 5 }
A P I , L I C ' r \ N '(lS
')
( ' o l r t r S )P r a d e e pK o c l i h a r
I T E S P O N D T j N( s" I)
I r r . r r oonf ' l n d i a & ( - ) t h e r s
I-egalPractitioner
for A p p e l l a n1r s )
Lcgal practitioncr1or Ilesporrdc.nt-s
\ 4 r S .K . C h o u d h u r n
\lr
\ r . r r r dl l h l r r r . l r r r . r
- -[---
oRpl,rrs(tprur,_iililit rrr_
OrderSerialNuntbcr:
I ) a l c d: ( X rI 0 l ( j l 5
l \ { r . S . K . ( ' h o u d h u ^ - [ . , 1 .c . . r r s c i
u p p c a r -fsi i r t r r ea p p r r e
a'r
\rr
A t t a n d I l h a n d a r i .L d . c t r L t t t s caip p c a r i n g
l i r r t l r e r L ' s p o r d e n tfsi l c s i r l r l l r ,
ol appeiirancc*hicli rtrar hc tul.cr.r
on recortl.
I - h cp r c s e ' t I { er r c * . { p p l i c a r i . , h a : b e e '
llled trr the lrctrtrt,rcr
s e e k i n gr e r i e " i , 1 ' t h e ( ) r d c rd a t c dr r " i
. r u . r cr 0 r 5 p a s s e ci n
j t) .\ -ri rrt
'l'lic
201-5'
a p p l i c a ' r i n r h a to . . \ . h a t rs o u g h rr i r r .l i r i l . * i r s
r c r r er : .
(a)
Q u a s h i l t uo l ' t h c r n t | ) L l r _-l l ul er c i e rc l a t c tll7 . l l . l 0 l - + .
(b)
Q L r a s h i nog1 ' t h e( o L r r rl r i l n q u i r r a - \i t \ l ( ) l i i t c cl l L r l el g 0
(c)
Q L r a s h i nogl t h c s u l n l l l r r \ o l c r i c l e r r c c
\ \ h i l e c l c a l i n rr r r l h i h v . j ( ) n t c r . r l i oo ln l h r : p e l r t r ( ) 1 c r
l 1 t i r u( ) \ .
t h c I r i b u n a l h i i d o b s c r rc d t l r i r t t h c o r c l e
r o l ' i r t t a c l r n rnet . u l t r ei t r :
t n r p u { t c d i r t h c p r e s c r t [ t . . - \ . .c a n r r , l
b c s c t ; r : i t 1 c . r ' h c p r u -ri : r l ( ) r
c l u a s h i n gt l t e a t t a c h t l t c r o
t tr d e r h , r sb c en c i i s r l i s s c . - l\.\ h i l e
dculrl! \\ ltlr
t l l e p r a r e r l i l r e l L t a s h i t t lgt c ( ' o u r t o l ' I n c F r i r r
i t h u s t r e c no b s e r . \ e (tlh . r l
t h e p e t i l i o n e rh a s n o r q u c s l i o r r c ,t,hi i s o r c l e r
ir tlic o..\. ljlccl hr lrinr
\ \ ' h a t h a s b e e ns t l t t c di i t i h t t ) r ' r i c ' t r l ' t ] r el r i h L r r i l l
r: tliatliic i-rclrrr.rrcr-,
p r a - \ e r l i l r . 1r r a s h i n gt i r r ' ( . o i r 1 1t r l ' l n r l
i r r i . ) \ \ . r . . L l l : l ) r ) \ c t l, l ' h r l i r r .
I r i b t r r r a li n i t s o r c l e rp a s s e col n ( ) i ( ) - i . l ( ) l - 1r.l r
r , a r . l i c r . ( \. .) p r el c l r . c r l . r r
t h c p e t i t i o n e r r"i.i t h l t c l i t ' c c t i o inr r L h ce o n r p c t c l ) t
a i r t h o r i t rt o d i s p o s ci r t
(l)
t h e p r a r c r o l ' t h e p e t i t i o n c r .I'hc cornpetenl
allthol-itrpassctii-rn()r.dL,r
d a t e d1 9 . t ) 6 " 1 0 1r n
. 1t e r n t so 1 t h eo r d c rt r 1 ' t l - rI cr i b u n a l .
r i h r c hl r a sn o t
beeninrpLrgned
in the ( ).A .i:i o 1 'l 0 l - 5 . I h e I r i b u l a l d i d p o l
, . l \c i - 1 1 \
f i n d i n gi n r e s p c cor 1 ' t h i si s s r _ r c .
-l'hc
petitioner'splea is that olrt cll t l t r c e p r a rc r s
s o L r g hht r h r n r .
onl\ one pra\cr i.e.thc .rdcr .f'att.rchr.lrcrnt
h a s b e e na ' s ' u c r e d h r t h i
'l'ribu'al.
lle statesthat thc r'pur.ed orclerpassedbr
thc co'rpcrer)t
a u t h o r i t r o n 1 9 . 6 . 1 0 1 . 1i s. a l r c a d l t h e s i r b j c c r n a t t e r
o l c h a l l er r g c r n t h r , '
t h e o . A . r ' i h i c hh a sn o t b c e nr o r - r s i c l e rbcrdr h r : I r i b u n a r .
Ihe Iribunlr
o b s e r re d t h a t t h e o r d c r e r a t r : cll9 . 6 . 1 0 1 - rp a s s e c l
b1 thc c()nr|crcnr
aLlthorit\is not thc sutr"lect
rnitltcrol'challcn-ue
\\'e har e hcard the lcar.nccl
coLutsclfirr btrth thc.Lrarlre
s
.,\dntittedlr the prare :. ol' thc
[ ) c t t t t ( ) r ) e rl t t r c l u i r s l t i n g r r l t h r ,
attachntcntrtrder has hcen consitlcrctib r t i r c I r i b L r n a l .
n h i c h h r r s[ . r . . : c n
re.jected. I n s , t l r a s l i r c t i n d i ' g r e c r r c r e h
c r t h i s I r i b . r a r r r r a rt h c
( ' o u r 1o l l n c l u i r r \ \ a s l t o t
t h c s L L [ - l . jlc] tcat t t c to l ' c l t a l l c n s ci s r . t o lt L r ter r r r l i r
c o r r e c t . I ' h e p e t i t i o r r e hr a d i n p a g c l l a n t J l l
o f ' t h c ,o . A . q u e s t r t , n c t l
t l t e t r r r l c rp u s : c J h - r t l r uu ( ) l l p c c u t a u t h o r i t r o n I r )
6 " ] 0 1 _ 1 .I h i : . r : l , r c c r
h a s n o t b c c n t a k c n r r r t t rc r . r n s i d t : r . l t ibo-rrrt h r ' I r - i t r r i n a l
\ \ ' i t h r . c \ l ) r r rt ( )
t h e l a s t p r a \ e r t i l ' r h e p c t l t r ( ) n c l - l o rs c i l r n g a - s i d e
i h c s r r n u n a r ro l
e v i d e n c e .t i t c I r i L r u n u l ' r a sr . r o 1
r n a d ca n - r l i n d i r r g t I t i l c d i s n t i s r r n ut h t ,
(-)..,\.
I n r i e n o l ' t l t ea b o rc . i i c f i n d c r r ( ) r sa p p a r c n t r l l t
t h e l u ec t r l 1 h , . ,
r e c . r d . r i h i c h r e q u i r e t . h g , . g , , . , . , r a U\ \ c . t h e r . e l i r r c .
recallllre ,,r..lcr.
d a t c d ] j . 0 6 . 1 0 1 5 p a s s e dh - r r h i : I r i b L r n a al n c lr h e o . . , \ .
i s r e s r o r . erd( ) r r \
o r i g i n a ll r l e a n d n u r n b e r .I t e r i c r \ l s i i c c o r d i n s l ia l l , r i e . l
'l'he
the O'A'
l e a r n e dc o u n s c il i r r t h c a p p l r c a n pt r . a r sl u r t d u ) r s : r r i r
ol
r \ t i c r l r e a rri t s b o t h s i c l e sl n c i c o l r s r d c l r r r gt h c t u c l : . u r t i
c l r c L u l l s t a n c e( )sl ' t h cc a s c -r i c I ' ir t d t h a t i t i s u 1 l t c a s el i l r
a c l n r i s s r oann r i
u ' e a d m i t i t a c c , r d i n g l _. r i - i r cr e: ; p o . d c n r ss h a l l t i l e
r . c p l r* i t h i . l . L r r
(j)
\\eeks. I-heapplicantnra\ tilc rejoinderthcrealtcr"
ii riesr)\lesrfe:
'lhc
l e a r n e ccl o u n s e il o r t h e a p p i i c a r rpt r a r s l o r a n l n t c n n i ( ) r ' d r - ' r
a s p r a \ c d l i r r t n t h e O . A . ( ' o n s i d e r i n st .l - r cc r r c u n t s t a n c eosi ' t h c L i l : v . \ \ ,1 '
d i r e c t t h a t a n r p r o c e e d i n gh c i d i n t h c n r e a n t i n r cs h a l l b e s L r h ; c el 9
r ti'rc
r e s u l ro t ' t h e O . A .
[ - i s tt h e m a t t e ro n - ] 3 .I I . l 0 l - i .
1l-t (ien (irlltant \loortlrr )
\ l e r r r b e(rA d r r r r n r s t r act t) \
_
og
L,-1_
( . l r - r s t i cScu n i l I l i r l rr
\ l e r n b c r I J L r d i s r ari