Measurement of Systemic Power Efficiency of Microwave Heating

World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical, Computer, Energetic, Electronic and Communication Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012
!3/AC@3;3<B=4&GAB3;71$=E3@ 447173<1G =4
!71@=E/D33/B7<5>>:71/B7=<
,73 "CB2316/B=@< $C/<5<53@<;/9 &C@/;/B3 6/:3@;E7ACB9C:
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012 waset.org/Publication/8267
!71@=E/D363/B7<5>@=13AA6/A033<23D3:=>32/0=CB
A7FBGG3/@AE67:3;3/AC@3;3<BAGAB3;6/A/:A=>@=5@3AA32 31/CA3 =4
7@@/27/B7=< =4 6756 4@3?C3<1G =4 ;71@=E/D3 @3A3/@163@A 6/D3 033<
CB7:7H32 ;/<G 1=AB:G B316<71/: 7<AB@C;3<B ;3/AC@7<5 >/@/;3B3@A B=
3D/:C/B3 B63 >3@4=@;/<13 =4 ;71@=E/D3 63/B7<5 AGAB3; '63@34=@3
B67A >/>3@ 7A 7<B3<232 B= >@3A3<B /< 3/A73@ /<2 43/A70:3 3447173<1G
;3/AC@3;3<B;3B6=2B1/<63:> 7<A>31B7<53447173<1G=4 ;71@=E/D3
63/B7<5 AGAB3; E7B6 5==2 /11C@/1G E67:3 B63 ;3B6=2 1/< /:A= 57D3
@343@3<13B= =>B7;7H7<5>@=132C@34=@;71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;4=@
D/@7=CA:=/2;/B3@7/:
!3/AC@3;3<B !71@=E/D3 63/B7<5 &GAB3;71 >=E3@
3447173<1G
"'%#('#"
!
%#*) 63/B7<5 AGAB3; 7A <=B =<:G />>:732 /A
6=CA36=:2/>>:7/<13/:A=E723:G CA32 7<7<2CAB@7/:/@3/A
7< B63A3 2/GA AC16 /A 4==2 7<2CAB@G 3<D7@=<;3<B B@3/B;3<B
;3271/:B@3/B;3<B/<2163;71/:>@=13AA
!71@=E/D3 63/B7<5 CA3A ;71@=E/D3 3<3@5G B= >@=13AA
;/B3@7/: !71@=E/D3 7A / D3@G A6=@B E/D3 =4 3:31B@=;/5<3B71
3<3@5GE67164@3?C3<1G7A!HB=H<=@23@B=53B
;71@=E/D3 3<3@5G 6=CA36=:2 >=E3@ 7A 1=<D3@B32 B= /
>@3BBG 67563@ D=:B/53 /<2 6756 1C@@3<B !/5<3B@=< B63
53<3@/B=@ =4 ;71@=E/D3 3<3@5G E7:: 53<3@/B3 B63 @3?C7@32
!H =4 ;71@=E/D33<3@5G0GCA7<5AC1667563@D=:B/53
E67167A E7:2:G CA324=@;71@=E/D363/B7<57<;=AB 1=C<B@73A
H7A/<=B63@=>B7=<7<A=;31=C<B@73A '63@/>7216/<53=4
3:31B@=;/5<3B71473:2 5=3AB6@=C56E/B3@ ;=:31C:3A =@ ;=7ABC@3
=4 ;/B3@7/: B=/4431BE/B3@ ;=:31C:3E6716 7A>=:/@;=:31C:3
=A17::/B7<5 /:=<5E7B616/<53A=4B633FB3@</:3:31B@71473:2E7B6
6756A>332A7<1327443@3<B >=:/@7BG ;=:31C:3AE=C:2=@73<B/B3
E7B6>@=>3@>=:/@7BG7<B63 3:31B@=;/5<3B71 473:2&C16;=B7=<
1/CA3A ;=:31C:3 4@71B7=< E6716 B/93A >:/13 ;7::7=<A =4 B7;3A
3/16 A31=<2 3<13 B63;71@=E/D33<3@5G1/<031=<D3@B32B=
63/B 3<3@5G 7< ;327C; B= @/7A3 B63 B3;>3@/BC@3 =4 ;/B3@7/:A
11=;>:7A67<5 63/B7<5 >C447<5 /<2 / A3@73A =4 >6GA71/: /<2
163;71/: >@=13AA3A /<2 A= ;71@=E/D3 63/B7<5 7A
/1673D32'6@=C56=CBB633<B7@3;71@=E/D363/B7<5>@=13AA7<5
3<3@5G ;CAB 5= B6@=C56 BE= B7;3A =4 3<3@5G B@/<A4=@;/B7=<
E6716 7<1:C23A 3:31B@71 3<3@5G B@/<A4=@;/B7=< B= ;71@=E/D3
3<3@5G/<2;71@=E/D33<3@5GB@/<A4=@;AB=63/B3<3@5G
< B63A3 2/GA /:: 7<2CAB@73A /7; B= 231@3/A3 >@=2C1B 1=AB
<3@5G A/D7<5 7A / ;/8=@ 7AAC3 7< B63 >@=2C1B7=< 16/7<
=E3D3@ ;71@=E/D3 3<3@5G 7A / A>317/: 3<3@5G A=C@13 B6/B
1=C:2 1/CA3 C<3F>31B32 27A/AB3@ B= 6C;/< 63/:B6 '6CA 7B 7A
1@7B71/:B=;3/AC@3 >3@4=@;/<13=4;71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;
E67:37B7AE=@97<5
'=57D3 /< 3F>:717B ;3/AC@7<5AGAB3;71>=E3@3447173<1G=4
B63 ;71@=E/D3 63/B7<5 AGAB3; B67A >/>3@ >@3A3<BA / 43/A70:3
AGAB3;71>=E3@3447173<1G;3/AC@3;3<B;3B6=2 4=@;71@=E/D3
63/B7<5AGAB3;E6716 /::=EA CA3B63@3AC:BA=4;3/AC@3;3<B/A
/@343@3<13B==>B7;7H3B63>@=132C@3=4>@=13AA7<5;/B3@7/:
!&(%!"'# !"&!
31/CA3 =4 7@@/27/B7=< 2C@7<5 ;71@=E/D3 63/B7<5 AGAB3;
=>3@/B7=< 23:71/B3 ;3/AC@3;3<B 7<AB@C;3<BA /@3 @3?C7@32 B=
A31C@3 A/43BG =4 =>3@/B=@A 4@=; @/27/B7=< 6/@; <2 A31C@7BG
>@=B31B7=< 7A 23;/<232 B== '63A3 @3?C7@3;3<BA /@3 <=B
/44=@2/0:3 4=@ /::CA3@A <=@23@B=1/@@G=CB;3/AC@3;3<BE3
A3>/@/B3 B63E6=:3AGAB3;B=B6@33>/@BA/AA6=E<7<75A=
B6/B E3 1/< CA3 1=;;=< 7<AB@C;3<BA B= 1=;>:3B3 /
;3/AC@3;3<B /<2 >@=B31B =>3@/B=@ 4@=; 6/@; '63 >@=132C@3
/:A=;33BA B6323;/<2=4/11C@/1G
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 6(3) 2012
!
!
!
75 7/5@/;=4;3/AC@7<5>/@/;3B3@A=427443@3<BA31B7=<A=4
;71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;
!
:31B@713<3@5G7A4@=;B63CB7:7BG>=E3@AGAB3; 63@3/A
7<1723<B>=E3@7A23:7D3@327<B=B63;71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;
7A57D3<0G
,737A E7B6'63&7@7<26=@<<B3@</B7=</:'6/73@;/<@/2C/B3&16==:=4
<57<33@7<5'&7<5!=<59CB(<7D3@A7BG=4'316<=:=5G"=@B6/<59=9
!('"/<59=9 '6/7:/<23;/7: 03<03<@7D3@6=B;/7:1=;
"$C/<5<53@<;/9 7A E7B6 '63 &7@7<26=@< <B3@</B7=</: '6/73@;/<
@/2C/B3 &16==: =4 <57<33@7<5 '&7<5 !=<59CB (<7D3@A7BG =4
'316<=:=5G"=@B6/<59=9!('"/<59=9 '6/7:/<2
&6/:3@;E7ACB9C: 7A E7B6 '63 &7@7<26=@< <B3@</B7=</: '6/73@;/<
@/2C/B3 &16==: =4 <57<33@7<5 '& 7<5 !=<59CB (<7D3@A7BG =4
'316<=:=5G"=@B6/<59=9!('"/<59=9 '6/7:/<2
!
!71@=E/D33<3@5G 7A53<3@/B320G;/5<3B@=<E67167A
AC>>=@B32 0G >3@7>63@/: 17@1C7B /<2 B@/<A4=@;3@A C@7<5 B67A
=>3@/B7=<>/@B=4B@/<A;7BB323<3@5G7A/0A=@032 0G>3@7>63@/:
17@1C7BA /<2 B@/<A4=@;3@A E6716 7A 47@AB 3<3@5G :=AA 7< B63
346
scholar.waset.org/1999.5/8267
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical, Computer, Energetic, Electronic and Communication Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012
63/B7<5 AGAB3; '63 ;=@3 >3@7>63@/: 17@@1C7B /<2 63/DG
B@/<A4=@;3@A B63 ;=@3 3<3@5G E/A /0AA=@032 &= B6/B
/>>@=>@7/B317@1C7B23A75<7A/<7;>=@B/<B1=<113@<
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012 waset.org/Publication/8267
&7<13 B63 B@/<A4=@;3@ 7A ;/23 =4 :=AAG 433@@7B3 ;/B3@7/: A=
B6/B 7B7A /;/8=@3<3@5G/0A=@>B7=<=0831B7<B667A>/@B/<3<3@5G
:=AA 7A 1=<A723@/0:3 6756 /:=<5 E7B6 ;711@=E/D3 63/B7<5
=>3@/B7=< :31B@=<71 17@1C7B 1=<AC;>B7=< 7A A;/::3@ 0G
1=;>/@7A=< E7B6 B@/<A4=@;3@ 7<271/B3A B63 AC; =4 B63A3
:=AA3A !3/AC@7<5 B63 1=<27B7=< =4 / ;/5<<3B@=< 7A 274471C:B
E63<7B7AE=@97<5B7A/4:/E=4B67A ;3/AC@3;
;3<B B 1/<<=B 03
=D3@1=;3 E7B6=CB/2D/<1327<AB@C;3<B&=E
E3CA3@/B32>=E3@
=4 A>317471/B7=< =4 ;/5<3B@=< B= 7<271/B3 ;//5<3B@=<JA =CB>CB
>=E3@ 7AB=7<271/B3>=E3@3447173<1G7<BB67A>/@BB;3/<A
6=E ;C16>=E3@7A B@/<A4=@;32B= ;71@=E//D3 3<3@5G 7<B67A
>/@BB7A23A1@70320G
!
3:7D3@32 ;71@=E/D33<3@5G7AB@/<A;7BB32B=1/D7BG B6@=C56
E/D35C7233@3 )")31B=@"3BE=@9 <</:GH3@7ACA32B=
;3/AC@3&B=9<=E6=E;C16>=E3@E/A@344:31B320/19B=B63
;/5<3B@=< 7<271/B32 0G < 1=;;==< 1/A3A A;/::
>@=>=@B7=<=43<3@5G7A@34:31B320/19B=;71@@=E/D353<3@/B=@
D7/3<3@5GB@/<A;7AA7=<>/B6 B1=C:203<355:7570:3E7B65==2
;/B167<5 23A75< '= 3D/:C/B3 3<3@5G :=AA 2CC@7<5 B63 63/B7<5
=>3@/B7=< B63 3F>3@7;3<B /:A= 1=<A723@A B677A :=AA '67A AB3>
1=C:2032=<3034=@3 >3@4=@;7<5 B63 ;3/AC@@3;3<B <A723B63
E= >/@BA =4 =0831B
1/D7BG ;71@=E/D3 3<3@5G 7A /0A=@032 0G BE
/<2 B@/<A4=@;32B=63/B3<3@5GE67167<1:C233A;3B/::71E/::=4
1/D7BG =B63@ >@=B31B7=< ;3B/::71 =0831BA /<2 B63 ;/B3@7/: B6/B
E3 E/<B B= >@=13AA 0A=@032 >=E3@ E=C:22 03 7<271/B32 0G
E6716 /@3 E/:: /0A=@>B7=< ;//B3@7/: /0A=@>B7=<
/<21/D7BG/0A=@>B7=<@3A>31B7D3:G '637@ @3::/B7=<A/@3A6=E<
0G
@
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 6(3) 2012
@=; 3?C/B7=<A /0=D3 CA3@ 1/<
< 9<=E 6=E ;C16 3<3@5G
:=A3A=<B63 ;3B/::71 =0831BA2C@7<5B633<3@5GB@/<A4=@;/B7=<
G '6CA>@=>3@:G16==A7<5
=4;71@=E/D33<3@5GB=63/B3<3@5G
;/B3@7/: 4=@ 1/D7BG /<2 =B63@ ;3BB/::71 =0831BA 1=C:2 7<17B3
23A75<3@AB=B/93 B67A3<3@5G:=AA 7<BB=/11=C<B
! !
&GAB3;71 >=E3@ 3447173<1G 7A 3/AG B= 53B D7/ B63 ;/B3@7/:
/0A=@>B7=< 3<3@5G 27D7232 0G B63 AC>>:G >=E3@ /A A6=E<
03:=E
'6CA4@=;/0=D33?C/B7=<AE3533B/A7;>:3 @3:/B7=<
*3 1/< @32C13;=@3 1=;>:3F;
;3/AC@3;3<B4=@B6363/B7<5
AGAB3;B=;/93B67A;3B6=2 >@/1B71//0:3E67:3E3/AAC@3B=53B
03BB3@ /11C@/1G '6CA E3 <332 B=
= 1=<A723@ A=;3 B316<71/:
>@=0:3;AB6/B1=C:21/CA3/11C@/1G 1=;>@=;7A3
#
!&(%!"'$%#(% #!%#*)'"
'=3<AC@32/B/4@=;27443@3<B>/@@B=463/B7<5AGAB3;E=C:2
03 1=::31B32 7< @3/:B7;3 '63 ;3/AC@3;3<B
;
23A75< 6/A /
A=4BE/@37<B3@4/13B=1=;>:3B3B67ABB/A9 A7;>:7473227/5@/;
7AA6=E<03:=E
75 7/5@/; =4B63;3/AC@3;3<BAG
GAB3;=4;71@=E/D363/B7<5
AGAB;
'63 ;3/AC@3;3<B >@=13AA CA3A !71@=1=<B@=::3@
!
;=2C:3 B=
1=::31B2/B/=4AC>>:G>=E3@7<@3/:BB7;34@=;>=E3@;3B3@/<2
B3;>3@/BC@3 =4 63/B32 ;/B3@7/: 034=@3
0
/<2 /4B3@ 63/B7<5
=>3@/B7=<
'67A
1=C:2
933>
CA3@
4/
/@
/E/G
4@=; B63 63/B7<5
AGAB3; 7< =@23@ B= >@3D3<B >=B3<
<B7/: ;71@=E/D3 @/27/B7=<
2/;/53 (A7<5)";3/AC@3A&=4B3AB321/D7BG034=@3B63
<5 B= 27443@3<B D=:C;3A =4
;3/AC@3;3<B AB/@B7<5 1=@@3A>=<27<
:=/2'63< D/:C3A=4&/@3 A/D327<B=1=;>CB3@;3;=@G4=@
1/:1C:/B7=< =;>CB3@1=::31BA 2/B/ /<21/:1C:/B7=<B=>@=2C13
;3/AC@3;3<B @31=@2 C3 B= 274433@3<B 3D/:C/B7=< AB/<2/@2
3F>3@7;3<BA1=C:216==A303<16;/@@9=447F3263/B7<5B7;3=@
/>>@=F7;/B3 3<2 B3;>3@/BC@3 =44 B63 63/B32 =0831B =@
347
scholar.waset.org/1999.5/8267
B3;>3@/BC@3@7A7<5@/B3=4B6363/B32 ;/B3@7/: 7<B6347F32B7;3
7<B3@D/:!3/AC@3;3<B@3AC:BA1/<03>@3A3<B332/A/B/0:3E7B6
/::@3AC:BA=@0327A>:/G32/A/5@/>6=4/D3@/553B3;>3@/BC@3=4
B6363/B32 =0831BAC>>:G>=E3@/<2 =B63@ 4=@@;A=427A>:/G7<5
;3B6=20GCA7<51=;>CB3@>@=5@/;;7<5
( /<2 1=;>CB3@
C3 B= 1=;;C<71/B7=< 23:/G 03BE33< !
/<2 1=;>CB7<5 23:/G 7< B63 1=;>CB3@ >@=5@@/; E3 <332 B=
1/:70@/B3B67AB=>@3D3<B;3/AC@3;3<B3@@=@
+$%!"' +!$ &
'3;>3@/BC@33:A7CA335@33
447173<1G
75 &GAB3;71$=E3@447173<1G=4B63!71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;/A
4C<B7=<=4B63 @7A7<5B3;>3@/BC@3;3/AC@332 /A:7B3@=4B63E/B3@E/A
63/B32
3/B7<5'7;3&31=<2
;71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;/A
75 &GAB3;71$=E3@447173<1G=4;
4C<1B7=< =4B6363/B7<5B7;3 /4B3@ ::7B3@=4B63E/B3@E/A63/B32
447173<1G
'63 3F>3@7;3<B =4 ;3/AC@3;3<B AGAB3;
; =4 ;71@=E/D3
63/B7<5AGAB3;CA3AE/B3@/A:=/2B=23;=<AB@@/B3;3/AC@3;3<B
>@=132C@3 /<2 1/:70@/B7=< =>3@/B7=< =4
4 / 1=;;3@17/:
;AC<5 ;/5<3B@=<
;71@=E/D3 63/B7<5 AGAB3; E6716 CA3A &/;
#!& B6/B @/B32 >=E3@ 7A * '63 663/B7<5 AGAB3; 7A
;C:B7>:3 ;=23 1/D7BG E6716 27;3<A7=< 7AA 13<B7;3B3@ '= 23;=<AB@/B3 27443@3<B />>:71//B7=< 3F>3@7;3<B
E/A 1/@@732 =< / :/0;/23 63/B7<5 AGAB33; B 6/A BE=
;/5<3B@=<A =4 @/B32 >=E3@ * 4@=; !
'63
1/D7BGJA 27;3<A7=< 7A 13<B7;
;3B3@ F>3@7;3<B
A3BA@==; B3;>3@/BC@303BE33<
I
3:A7CCA 235@33/<2B63
AB/@BB3;>3@/BC@3=4E/B3@:=/203BE33<
I
3:A7CA235@33
/A 3<D7@=<;3<B =463/B7<5=>3@/B7=<
=@1=;;3@17/:63/B7<5AGAB3;E/B3@:=/22=4;:>:/132
7< 03/93@ E/A 63/B32 7< 27443@3<B B7;3 =@ :/0;/23 63/B7<5
AGAB3; E/B3@ :=/2 =4 :7B3@ >:/132 7< B63 1/D7BG <2
3F>3@7;3<B@3>3/BA/::A/;3>@=132C@3A4=@1==;;3@17/:=<3=<
7B
*/B3@7A /5==2 /0A=@>B7=<=0831B (AC/::G7B7ACA32/A:=/2
B= 3D/:C/B3 >3@4=@;/<13 =4 ;71@=E/D3 63//B7<5 AGAB3; BA
A>317471 63/B 1=C:2 03 1=<A723@32 E6716 E==C:2 16/<53 E7B6
B3;>3@/BC@3@7A3 CBB6316/<537A A;/::3@ E6716 E=C:2 <=B
/4431B/11C@/1G;C16
!3/AC@3;3<B@3AC:BA/@3A6=E<7<75C@3B=75C@3 '63G
/@31/:1C:/B320G3?C/B7=<A/<2 ::>>/@/;3B3@A<33232
/@34@=;3?C/B7=<I B27A>:/GAB6/B>==E3@3447173<1G=4
A/;3 D=:C;3 =4 :=/2 7A 231@3/A7<5 E67:3 B663 63/B7<5 B7;3 7A
7<1@3/A7<5!3/<E67:3B3;>3@/BC@3 =4:=/277A7<1@3/A7<5 '63
:=E3@D=:C;3A=4E/B3@:=/2B63:=E3@B63>>=E3@3447173<1G
'63 7<1@3/A7<5 B3;>3@/BC@3 >3@ ;7<CB3 9333>A />>@=F7;/B3
AB/0:3 1=@@3A>=<27<5 B= A>317471 ;/B3@7/: $
$=E3@ 3447173<1G
231@3/A3 B <=B3A B6/B 1=<D31B7=< =4 B63 663/B 3<3@5G 4@=;
;71@=E/D33<3@5GB= 1/D7BG;3B/::71E/::A7A77<1@3/A32
'63;3/AC@3;3<BAGAB3;1/</:A=57D3A=;
;3/2D713AB=CA3@
3F13>BB316<71/:AC>>=@B/0=CBB63;71@=E/D3363/B7<5AGAB3;
!3/AC@3;3<BAGAB3;1=C:257D3A=;3A3<A3 /0=CB6=E;C16
>=E3@ 3<3@5G E=C:2 03 1=<AC;32 =< 13@B//7< :=/2 /<2 6=E
;C163<3@5G:=A3A7<3/16 >/@B=4;71@=E/D3363/B7<5AGAB3;
(A3@ 1/< 23A75< /< =>B7;C; >@=13AA7<5 ;
;3B6=2 B= >@=13AA
;/B3@7/: 23>3<2A=<@3AC:BA=4B63;3/AC@3;33<B
)=:C;3A=4*/B3@ =//2;7::7:7B3@
75 &GAB3;71$=E3@447173<1G=4B63!71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;/A
4C<B7=< =4 27443@3<BD=:C;3A=4BB63E/B3@E/A63/B32
447173<1G
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012 waset.org/Publication/8267
)
447173<1G
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical, Computer, Energetic, Electronic and Communication Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012
'3;>3@/BC@33:A7CA
35@33
75 &GAB3;71$=E3@447173<1G=4B63!71@=E/D363/B7<5AGAB3;/A
4C<B7=< =4 B63@7A7<5 B3;>3@/BC@3;3/AC@@32 /A:7B3@=4B63E/B3@E/A
63/B32 7<:/0;/233AGAB3;
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 6(3) 2012
348
scholar.waset.org/1999.5/8267
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Electrical, Computer, Energetic, Electronic and Communication Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012
447173<1G
-
.
-.
-.
-.
-.
-.
-.
447173<1G
International Science Index, Electrical and Computer Engineering Vol:6, No:3, 2012 waset.org/Publication/8267
75 &GAB3;71$=E3@447173<1G=4;71@=E/D3663/B7<5AGAB3;/A
4C<1B7=< =4B6363/B7<5B7;3 /4B3@ :7B3@=4B63E//B3@E/A63/B32 7<
:/0;/23AGAB3;
!71@=E/D3 #D3<L =;>CB3@ /<2 C
CB=;/B7=< <57<33@7<5 '63
<2<B3@</B7=</:=<43@3<13=<
K%$#%' # !%#*) #)"
#
') !# '&'
$%#(%")&''#"&L &3>B3;03@
&
!3B/F/A K!71@=E/D3 63/B7<5
5L $=E3@ <57<33@7<5 =C@</:
&$'!%
C;7<5'/<53<5/= /<2!7<5 /C
C K!%#*)'""
## $%#&&"L )"
"& " #$%#&&"
""%"
K=;>/@7<5 3<3@5G CA3 7< ;71@=E/D
D3 =D3<A E7B6 B@/27B7=</: 3:31B@71
4C3::32 ;3B6=2AL !/@93B '@/<A4=@;/B7=< $@=5@/;;3 &C>>=@B7<5 (
=D3@<;3<B$=:71G=<&CAB/7</0:3$@=2
2C1BA
&%=03@BA 3@/@2 K3D3:=>;33<B /<2 D/:C/B7=< =4 !71@=E/D3
3/B7<5=4>>:3!/A6A/$@3B@3/B;33<B'=$@3AA7<5L=C@</:=4==2
$@=13AA<57<33@7<5)=:C;3
AAC3!/@16
"C/<G/7"$C/<5<53@<;/9&6/:33@;E7ACB9C: K"=D3: =E=AB
!/5<3B@=< $=E3@ =<B@=: 4=@ !711@=E/D3 3/B7<5 >>:71/B7=<AL
:31B@71/: <57<33@7<5:31B@=<71A =;
;>CB3@ '3:31=;;C<71/B7=<A /<2
<4=@;/B7=<'316<=:=5G'#"
<B3@</B7=</:=<43@3<13=<
*2/;A97 !7B:7<A97 K3B3@;7<
</B7=< =4 447173<1G =4 '63
!71@=E/D3 <3@5G />>:71/B=@L !711@=E/D3A %/2/@ /<2 *7@3:3AA
=;;C<71/B7=<A
!#"
B6<B3@</B7=</:=<43@3<13=<
)=:C;3A=4*/B3@ =/2;7::7:7B3@
75 &GAB3;71$=E3@447173<1G=4;71@=E/D3663/B7<5AGAB3;/A
4C<1B7=< =4 27443@3<BD=:C;3A=4 B63E/B3@ :=/2 E/AA63/B32 7<:/0;/23
AGAB3;
) #" (&#"
&GAB3;71>=E3@3447173<1G=4B63 ;71@=E/DD3 63/B7<5AGAB3;
7A<=B/1=<AB/<BD/:C3/<223>3<2A=<;/<G4//1B=@AAC16/AB63
B3;>3@/BC@3/<2;/AA=4;/B3@7/:>=A7B7=<==4;/B3@7/:7<B63
1/D7BG/<216/@/1B3@7AB71=4;/B3@7/: '63@34=@@3E3<332@3>3/B
;3/AC@3;3<B ;/<G B7;3A E7B6 E/B3@ :=/2 B= 1/:70@/B3 B63
AGAB3;'67A>/>3@7A>@3A3<B7<5/;3B6=2B66/B7A43/A70:3/<2
>@/1B71/0:3 7< B63 473:2 B 1/< 63:> CA3@A @/>>72 /<2 @3:/B7D3:G
/11C@/B3B=9<=E>=E3@1=<AC;>B7=<=4B63;
;71@=E/D363/B7<5
AGAB3; E7B6=CB ;=@3 ;71@=E/D3 9<=E:3253 !3/<E67:3 B63
;3B6=2B=>@=13AA
;3B6=2E=C:263:>CA3@B=;/93/<=>B7;C;;
;/B3@7/:
"#* !"'
'63 /CB6=@A E=C:2 :793 B= 3F>@3AA 5@/B77BC23 4=@ /:: B63
AC>>=@BA /<2 AC553AB7=<A 4@=; % B3/; ;
;3;03@A /B '63
&7@7<26=@< <B3@</B7=</: '6/73@;/< @/22C/B3 &16==: =4
<57<33@7<5'&7<5!=<59CB(<7D3@A77BG=4'316<=:=5G
"=@B6/<59=9!('" '6/7:/<2 %%"&
-.
$@/27> C;/@ &/26C "7B/7$/: K%3D73E=4<2C1B7==<==97<5 /3/:B6
/H/@2A @33 '==: B= ;>@=D3 <3@5G 447173<<1G /A 1=;>/@32 B=
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 6(3) 2012
349
scholar.waset.org/1999.5/8267