Philosophical Review
!"#$"%&'()*+$+,"-.
/)+012345&'6"+"2'7"*8$"4
91)2:"&';0"'60$,141<0$:=,'!"#$"%>'?1,@'ABC>'D1@'A'3E=*@>'AFFG5>'<<@'AHFIAJC
6)K,$40"-'KL&'Duke University Press'1*'K"0=,M'1M'Philosophical Review
9+=K,"'N!O&'http://www.jstor.org/stable/2185882 .
/::"44"-&'PCQABQPBAA'PB&HR
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
Duke University Press and Philosophical Review are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to The Philosophical Review.
http://www.jstor.org
!""#$%&'(&)*$
:+99$692+8$,02,;$1<13$/7;$01$=2+9/$
+,$-./$,01$23,14$5-,$,01/1$+3678.2,+5+9+/,/$
,7$/11$07:$0+>0$,01$/,2?1/$/07-9@$A1299B$51CD$
7=$@1<+7-/$673E$
@A2:$2,,13,+73$,7$,01$.7//+5+9+,B$
*-60$+3678.2,+5+9+/,/$
F-@>E$
316,+73/$51,:113$7-A$81,2.0B/+629$@1/+A1/$23@$ 7-A$81,2.0B/+629$
73$,01$G-1/,+73$
23@;$87A1$>131A299B;$
813,/C$*.16-92,+73$73$,0+/$.7//+5+9+,B;$
:23,/$+3$.9261;$82B$A2+/1$@7-5,/$257-,$
7=$:02,$079@/$7-A$81,2.0B/+629$
H2,023I/$7<1A299$.A7>A28C$)013$+,$6781/$,7$,01/1/$257-,$,01$32,-A29$7AE$
@1A;$=7A$1J28.91;$/781$7=$:0+60$H2,023$@+/6-//1/;$:1$82B$=119$@7-5,=-9$
2==16,+<1$
2,,+,-@1/$,7:2A@/$,018C$
:01,01A$:1$A1299B$02<1$23B$/19=E/,23@+3>$
)1$82B$=+3@$7-A/19<1/$,0+3?+3>$
,02,$+=$:1$:23,$23B$,01/1/$+3$81,2.0B/+6/$
,01B$2A1;$,02,$2A1$.A1/-..7/1@$+3$
,7$51$,A-1;$,01/1$2A1$F-/,$,07/1;$:02,1<1A$
7-A$673,+3-+3>$,7$67361+<1$7=$7-A/19<1/$23@$7-A$.9261$+3$,01$:7A9@$8-60$
,0+/;$,013$,01A1$:+99$51$
2/$:1$26,-299B$@7C$(=$:1$@7$=+3@$7-A/19<1/$,0+3?+3>$
+32@1G-2,1$@2,2$=7A$/781$.+1618129$2..9+62,+73/$7=$H2,023I/$.A7>A28C$
23@$<1AB$A12@2591$ K+=$@+==+6-9,D$
23$ +3,A+>-+3>;$
!-,$H2,023$02/$:A+,,13$
7=$.0+97/7.0B;$2/$2$-3+=+1@$2..9+62,+73$7=$
577?C$L3@$0+/$602A26,1A+M2,+73$
0+/$.A7>A28;$623$/-A<+<1$
@7-5,/$257-,$+,/$.+1618129$2..9+62,+73C$N01$2+8$
7=$2$/19=E6A+,+629$
:7A9@E$
2/$H2,023$/11/$+,;$+/$,01$673/,A-6,+73$
7=$.0+97/7.0B;$
+=$:1$A192,1@$,7$.0+97/7.0BI/$.A7.7/+,+73/$P.-A19B$67>3+E$
<+1:C$O1A,2+39B$
23@$:1A1$37,$2997:1@$,7$,2?1$2667-3,$7=$,01$,1AA7A;$
/2B;$,02,$/781$
,+<19B;P$
,02,$+,$
+3@-61$+3$-/;$,013$.0+97/7.0B$:7-9@$37,$1367-A2>1$,01$6B3+6+/8$
/-5F16,$,02,$+,$/781,+81/$+/C$
/781,+81/$@71/4$37A$67-9@$+,$51$,01$/2,+/=B+3>$
Q&HH(R&%$S"%H*!T$
O0A+/,+$
O7991>1;$
"J=7A@$
O7A.-/$
'79C$VWX;$H7C$V$KQ23-2AB$
VYYZD$
N01$U0+97/7.0+629$
%1<+1:;$
#H")[&\]&$(H$ R[^_`$ a"\&[(H]$ NS&$ \THLa(O*$ "R$ &U(*N&a(O$
*NLN&*C$!B$U&N&%$ ]L%\&HR"%*C$ O285A+@>1`$a(N$UA1//;$VYbbC$U.C$J+;$cdZC$
S7:$/07-9@$731$>7$257-,$6023>+3>$731I/$8+3@e$N0+/$G-1/,+73$02/$6781$
+3$1.+/,18797>B;$
3-851A$7=$:7A?1A/$
,7$766-.B$,01$2,,13,+73$7=$2$>A7:+3>$
577?$02/$29E$
+3,199+>1361C$]@A@13=7A/I/$
.0+97/7.0+629$97>+6;$23@$2A,+=+6+29$
.7/+,+73$+3$,01$=+19@C$L$/+M2591$57@B$7=$
2$@+/,+3>-+/01@$
A12@B$12A31@$+,/19=$
,7$678.2A1$]2A@13E$
02/$>A7:3$-.$2A7-3@$+,C$K(,$+/$+3/,A-6,+<1$
9+,1A2,-A1$
R+J2,+73$
=7A/I/$:7A?$:+,0$(/226$[1<+I/$@1<197.813,$7=$/+8+92A$,0181/$+3$N01$
23@$+,/$^3@7+3>`$
(3G-+AB$
KO285A+@>1$^3+E$
!19+1=/$
N0A7->0$
O023>+3>$
7=$!19+1=$
.7/+,+73$+3$,01$=+19@$+/$:199$
<1A/+,B$
UA1//;$VYYVDCD$ N01$577?I/$@+/,+3>-+/01@$
@1/1A<1@`$+,$2A,+6-92,1/$2$ /+8.91$5-,$+3>13+7-/$,017AB$7=$519+1=$6023>1$
:0+60$02/$:+@1/.A12@$2..9+62,+73/$,7$.A75918/$+3$.0+97/7.0B$23@$2A,+=+6+29$
+3,199+>1361C$
/+8.91$87@19$7=$2$
,017AB$
7=$519+1=$6023>1$A19+1/$73$2$<1AB$
]2A@13=7A/I/$
VfY$
!""#$%&'(&)*$
2$/,2,1$7=$519+1=$5B$2$/1,$7=$/13,1361/$
/,2,1$7=$519+1=C$N01$87@19$A1.A1/13,/$
(3$+,/$+3,13@1@$
61A,2+3$8+3+829$673/,A2+3,/C$
7=$23$75F16,$923>-2>1$/2,+/=B+3>$
519+1<1@$
,01$/1,$673/+/,/$7=$,01$/13,1361/$2661.,1@$7A$=-99B$
+3,1A.A1,2,+73;$
+8.7/1/$
5B$,01$/-5F16,$:07/1$/,2,1$7=$519+1=$+/$51+3>$87@191@C$]@A@13=7A/$
/,2,1/$7=$519+1=`$,01B$2A1$,7$
6A+,1A+2$
73$,01$/1,/$A1.A1/13,+3>$
,:7$A2,+7329+,B$
697/1@C$"=$67-A/1;$,01/1$A1G-+A1813,/$2A1$
51$673/+/,13,$23@$@1@-6,+<19B$
+@129/C$N01$
+3,13@/$,018$,7$51$A1>-92,+<1$
37,$,A-1$,7$9+=14$5-,$]@A@13=7A/$
,02,$+/;$
+@129+M1@$/,2,1/$7=$519+1=$2A1$,7$51$,07->0,$7=$2/$1G-+9+5A+-8$/,2,1/;$
/,2,1/$7=$519+1=$:0+60$2A1$/,2591$-3@1A$299$=7A61/$7=$+3,1A329$6A+,+6+/8C$
7==1A/$
2$,A+.2A,+,1$
]+A@13=7A/$
/,2,1;$
7=$,0+/$87@19$7=$23$1.+/,18+6$
(3$,1A8/$
7=$6023>1/$7=$519+1=C$"31$?+3@$7=$519+1=$6023>1$A1/-9,/$=A78$,01$
,B.797>B$
:0+60$+/$673E$
7=$+3=7A82,+73$
7A$,1/,+873B;$
75/1A<2,+73$
26G-+/+,+73;$,0A7->0$
:+,0$,01$1J+/,+3>$57@B$7=$519+1=/C$N0+/$+/$87@191@$+3$]2A@13=7A/I/$
/+/,13,$
,01$31:$+3=7A82,+73;$
,7$
=A281:7A?$
5B$2@@+3>$2$/13,1361$L;$A1.A1/13,+3>$
,01$1J+/,+3>$57@B$7=$519+1=;$A1.A1/13,1@$5B$,01$519+1=$/1,$#;$23@$=7A8+3>$
7=$
,01$@1@-6,+<1$697/-A1$7=$,01$1J.23@1@$/1,C$N0+/$+/$62991@$,01$1J.23/+73$
#$5B$LC$L37,01A$?+3@$7=$519+1=$6023>1$A1/-9,/$=A78$,01$26G-+/+,+73$7=$+3E$
:+,0$,01$1J+/,+3>$
57@B$7=$519+1=/C$N0+/$623E$
:0+60$+/$+3673/+/,13,$
=7A82,+73$
/+361$,01$2@@+,+73$7=$,01$31:$+3=7A82,+73$
37,$51$87@191@$+3$,01$/281$:2B;$
N7$87@19$,0+/$?+3@$7=$519+1=$
L$,7$,01$519+1=$/1,$#$A13@1A/$+,$+3673/+/,13,C$
6023>1$,01$2@@+,+73$7=$L$,7$,01$519+1=$/1,$#$02/$,7$51$26678.23+1@$5B$2$
N01$A1<+/+73$+/$,7$51$
A1<+/+73$7=$,01$1J.23@1@$/1,$,7$A13@1A$+,$673/+/,13,C$
9+8+,1@$+3$+,/$1J,13,`$+,$+/$,7$51$,01$912/,$6023>1$,02,$+369-@1/$L$5-,$912<1/$
N0+/$?+3@$7=$519+1=$6023>1$+/$62991@$,01$8+3+829$
,01$519+1=$/1,$673/+/,13,C$
/11/$23$+8.7A,23,$
673316,+73$51,:113$,0+/$
7=$#$5B$LC$]@A@13=7A/$
A1<+/+73$
?+3@$7=$519+1=$6023>1$23@$,01$2661.,2361$7=$61A,2+3$?+3@/$7=$673@+,+7329/;$
L$,0+A@$?+3@$7=$519+1=$6023>1$766-A/$:013$/781$
37,259B$67-3,1A=26,-29/C$
519+1=$L$+3$,01$1J+/,+3>$
57@B$7=$519+1=/$#$+/$>+<13$-.;$=7A$1J28.91;$,7$>+<1$
,01$31>2,+73$7=$L$2$012A+3>$:+,07-,$51>>+3>$,01$G-1/,+73C$N0+/$?+3@$7=$
L$=A78$,01$519+1=$/1,C$(3$7A@1A$,7$
519+1=$6023>1$+/$87@191@$5B$A1,A26,+3>$
.A1/1A<1$,01$@1@-6,+<1$697/-A1$7=$,01$519+1=$/1,;$+,$82B$51$ 3161//2AB$,7$
LC$(3$?11.+3>$:+,0$2$.A+36+.91$
2/$:199$7,01A$/13,1361/$:0+60$+8.9B$
A1,A26,$
7=$+3=7A82,+7329$
A1G-+A1/$,02,$,0+/$.A761//$7=$A1,A26E$
167378B;$]+A@13=7A/$
519+1=/$2/$.7//+591C$N0+/$?+3@$7=$519+1=$
2/$823B$7=$,01$1J+/,+3>$
,+73$.A1/1A<1$
7=$#$:+,0$A1/.16,$,7$LC$
6023>1$+/$62991@$,01$673,A26,+73$
/11?/$,7$1J.9+62,1$,01/1$?+3@/$7=$519+1=$6023>1$5B$/,2,+3>$
]@A@13=7A/$
A2,+7329+,B$
.7/,-92,1/$=7A$1260$?+3@C$N01$.7/,-92,1/$01$.A1/13,/$=7A$1J.23E$
/+73/$+8.9B$,02,$,01$1J.23/+73$7=$#$5B$L$+/$/+8.9B$,01$/1,$7=$97>+629$673E$
/1G-1361/$7=$,01$-3+73$7=$#$23@$LC$!-,$,01$.7/,-92,1/$=7A$A1<+/+73/$23@$
S+/$/,A2,1>B$
:+,0$,01/1$
673,A26,+73/$
@7$37,$B+19@$/-60$1J.9+6+,$@1=+3+,+73/C$
,017A18/$=7A$,018`$01$
?+3@/$7=$519+1=$6023>1$+/$,7$.A7<1$A1.A1/13,2,+73$
@1/6A+51/$61A,2+3$673/,A-6,+73/$,02,$+3,-+,+<19B$
A1.A1/13,$,01$A1/.16,+<1$
,01$2..A7.A+2,1$.7/,-E$
?+3@/$7=$519+1=$6023>1$23@$/07:/$,02,$,01B$/2,+/=B$
VdW$
!""#$%&'(&)*$
.92,1/C$
(3$.2A,+6-92A;$
01$/07:/$07:$,7$673/,A-6,$
673,A26,+73$
=-36,+73/$
=A78$
23$7A@1A+3>$7=$/13,1361/$7=$2$519+1=$/1,$+3$,1A8/$7=$,01+A$1.+/,18+6$13E$
,A1360813,C$
KN01$1.+/,18+6$13,A1360813,$
7=$2$/13,1361$+/$,+1@$,7$+,/$1JE$
.9232,7AB$
.7:1A$23@$7<1A299$+3=7A82,+7329$
<29-1C$(,$+/$37,$,+1@$,7$+,/$.A75E$
25+9+,B;$
/+361$299$,01$/13,1361/$+3$,01$519+1=$/1,$02<1$.A7525+9+,B$
VCD$S1$/07:/$
,02,$,01$673,A26,+73$
=-36,+73/;$
673/,A-6,1@$
+3$,1A8/$
7=$,0+/$7A@1A+3>;$
/2,+/=B$
,01$.7/,-92,1/$=7A$673,A26,+73/$
23@$,02,$=7A$23B$=-36,+73$
/2,+/=B+3>$
,01$.7/E$
,-92,1/$,01A1$+/$23$-3@1A9B+3>$
7A@1A+3>$7=$/13,1361/$,02,$>131A2,1/$,01$
=-36,+73$5B$8123/$7=$,01$>+<13$673/,A-6,+73C$K(,$,-A3/$7-,$,02,$A1<+/+73/$
23@$673,A26,+73/$
2A1$+3,1A@1=+32591;$
/7$,02,$,01$2..A7.A+2,1$A1.A1/13,2,+73$
,017A18/$=7A$A1<+/+73/$
623$51$@1A+<1@$=A78$,07/1$=7A$673,A26,+73/CD$
N01$/1673@$.2A,$7=$,01$577?;$673/+/,+3>$
7=$,01$92/,$=7-A$602.,1A/;$
+/$,2?13$
-.$:+,0$2..9+62,+73/$7=$,01$,017AB$
7=$519+1=$6023>1$,7$2$3-851A$7=$.0+97E$
/7.0+629$+//-1/C$]@A@13=7A/$
1J.97A1/$,01$+@12$,02,$.A7.7/+,+7329$97>+6$623$
51$A2,+7329+M1@$5B$+8.7/+3>$61A,2+3$.92-/+591$A1G-+A1813,/$
70$07:$1J.23E$
/+73/$/07-9@$.A7611@C$S1$ 673/+@1A/$23$1.+/,18797>+629$2..A7260$,7$673E$
@+,+7329/$,02,$,-A3/$73$%28/1BI/$,1/,;$32819B$,01$+@12$,02,$2$673@+,+7329$
L$Eg$ !$+/$2661.,1@$+3$2$519+1=$/B/,18$
F-/,$+3$62/1$,01$8+3+829$A1<+/+73$
7=$#$
311@1@$,7$2661.,$L$82?1/$!$2661.,2591C$]2A@13=7A/$
.A7<1/$23$+8.7A,23,$
,A+<+29+,B$
A1/-9,$67361A3+3>$%28/1BI/$,1/,;$:0+60$02/$5113$ ,01$/-5F16,$7=$
8-60$@+/6-//+73C$S1$/07:/$,02,$,01A1$+/$37$373,A+<+29$
519+1=$A1<+/+73$
/B/,18$
,02,$/2,+/=+1/$
%28/1BI/$,1/,$23@$,01$=7997:+3>$
.92-/+591$,01/+/$257-,$519+1=$
A1<+/+73;$
:0+60$01$6299/$,01$.A1/1A<2,+73$
673@+,+73`$(=$2$/13,1361$!$+/$26E$
61.,1@$+3$2$519+1=$/B/,18$
#$23@$+=$L$+/$673/+/,13,$
:+,0$,01$519+1=/$+3$#;$,013$
!$/07-9@$51$ 2661.,1@$+3$,01$8+3+829$6023>1$7=$#$311@1@$ ,7$2661.,$LC$
KN01$A192,+73/0+.$
51,:113$,0+/$,A+<+29+,B$
A1/-9,$23@$[1:+/I/$=287-/$,A+<+29+,B$
A1/-9,$+/$23$+3,1A1/,+3>$
G-1/,+73;$:0+60$]@A@13=7A/$
@+/6-//1/$5A+1=9BCD$
S1$
,0+3?/$,02,$,01$:2B$7-,$7=$0+/$,A+<+29+,B$
A1/-9,$+/$,7$A1,2+3$,01$.A1/1A<2,+73$
673@+,+73$23@$>+<1$-.$%28/1BI/$,1/,C$N01$=+329$,:7$602.,1A/$7=$,01$577?$
,2?1$-.$+//-1/$,7$@7$:+,0$1J.9232,+73$23@$62-/2,+73`$,017A+1/$7=$1J.9232E$
,+73$23@$62-/2,+73$2A1$.A1/13,1@$:0+60$82?1$613,A29$-/1$7=$519+1=$673E$
,A26,+73/$,7$=7A8-92,1$2661.,2361$673@+,+73/$=7A$1J.9232,7AB$23@$62-/29$
692+8/C$]2A@13=7A/I/$
@+/6-//+73/$7=$,01$2..9+62,+73/$7=$0+/$,017AB$
7=$519+1=$
6023>1$2A1$29:2B/$+3/+>0,=-9$
23@$29:2B/$A1:2A@$697/1$A12@+3>C$
(,I/$+3/,A-6,+<1$
,7$678.2A1$]@A@13=7A/I/$
2..A7260$,7$519+1=$6023>1$,7$
,01$7A,07@7J$!2B1/+23$2..A7260;$,01$613,A29$,131,/$7=$:0+60$2A1$,02,$2$
519+1=$/B/,18$
+/$,7$51$ 87@191@$5B$2$ /-5F16,+<1$.A7525+9+,B$
=-36,+73$23@$
519+1=$A1<+/+73$+/$,7$51$ 87@191@$5B$673@+,+7329+M2,+73C$a23B$=12,-A1/$7=$
]2A@13=7A/I/$
623$51$A1673/,A-6,1@$
,017AB$
:+,0+3$/-60$2$.A7525+9+/,+6$
,01E$
7ABC$(3$2$<1AB$+3,1A1/,+3>$
602.,1A$73$.A7525+9+/,+6$
87@19/;$]@A@13=7A/$
2,E$
,18.,/$
/781$7=$,0+/$A1673/,A-6,+73C$
S1$82?1/$,01$613,A29$2//-8.,+73$,02,$
2$519+1=$/B/,18$
#$623$51$>131A2,1@$=A78$2$/-5F16,+<1$.A7525+9+,B$
=-36,+73$
U$5B$,2?+3>$,01$81851A/$7=$#$,7$51$299$23@$739B$,07/1$/13,1361/$:0+60$
VdV$
!""#$%&'(&)*$
07:$61A,2+3$.A7525+9+/,+6$
V$5B$UC$S1$@1873/,A2,1/$
2A1$2//+>31@$.A7525+9+,B$
23@$673,A26,+73$
>131A2,1$,01$
7.1A2,+73/$23297>7-/$,7$1J.23/+73;$A1<+/+73;$
2..A7.A+2,1$?+3@/$7=$6023>1/$,7$519+1=$/1,/C$(,$,-A3/$7-,$,02,$,01$.A7525+E$
5-,$,01$23297>-1/$7=$
9+/,+6$23297>-1$ 7=$1J.23/+73$+/$673@+,+7329+M2,+73;$
A1<+/+73$23@$673,A26,+73$@7$37,$67AA1/.73@$,7$23B$/,23@2A@$.A7525+9+/,+6$
7.1A2,+73/C$
@71/$37,$.A7<+@1$23B$2A>-813,$=7A$,01$613,A29$2//-8.,+73$
]2A@13=7A/$
=-36,+73$
>131A2,1/$2$519+1=$/1,C$"31$
257-,$,01$:2B$+3$:0+60$2$.A7525+9+,B$
,7$A1G-+A1$,02,$
.2A,$7=$,0+/$2//-8.,+73$/118/$,7$51$@-5+7-/`$+,$+/$,77$/,A73>$
VC$N7$
739B$+=$+,$02/$.A7525+9+,B$
2$/13,1361$51$2661.,1@$+3$2$519+1=$/B/,18$
/13,1361$:0+60$B7-$2661.,;$/2B;$,02,$,01$
/11$,0+/;$
673/+@1A$/781$673,+3>13,$
/.12?+3>$=A78$,01$"<29$"==+61$+/$!+99$O9+3E$
B7-$/11$73$,191<+/+73$
+3@+<+@-29$
V$,7$,0+/$/13,1361;$B7-$:7-9@$51$6788+,,1@$
,73C$(=$B7-$2//+>31@$.A7525+9+,B$
:02,$B7-$/07-9@$92,1A$912A3C$!-,$6912AE$
,7$2661.,+3>$,0+/$/13,1361$37$82,,1A$
13>+311A1@$
02<1$691<1A9B$
9B;$+=$B7-$:1A1$,7$912A3$,02,$2$>A7-.$7=$/6+13,+/,/$
B7-$
2$A757,$,7$977?$23@$26,$9+?1$O9+3,73$23@$+3/,2991@$+,$+3$,01$"<29$"==+61;$
+/$O9+3,73C$
B7-$/11$73$,191<+/+73$
8+>0,$
>+<1$-.$,01$519+1=$,02,$,01$+3@+<+@-29$
V$,7$,0+/$519+1=$+3$,01$=+A/,$
*7$+,$62337,$51$,02,$B7-$2//+>31@$.A7525+9+,B$
V;$
/13,1361$@71/$37,$A1G-+A1$.A7525+9+,B$
.9261C$L661.,2361$7=$2$673,+3>13,$
91<19;$/1,$5B$673E$
<29-1$1J611@+3>$/781$,0A1/079@$
2$.A7525+9+,B$
5-,$81A19B$
5-,$]2A@13E$
,1J,C$"=$67-A/1;$,0+/$+/$2$.7+3,$7=,13$82@1$5B$/781$!2B1/+23/;$
2,,13,+73$,7$+,C$
=7A/$@71/$37,$.2B$/-==+6+13,$
/,A73>$673@+,+73$A1>2A@+3>$
)02,$02..13/$+=$:1$>+<1$-.$]@A@13=7A/I/$
2661.,2361$23@$A1.9261$+,$:+,0$,01$:12?1A$673@+,+73$813,+731@$+3$,01$92/,$
+,$516781/$2..A7.A+2,1$,7$-/1$673@+,+7329+M2,+73$
.2A2>A2.0e$R7A$731$,0+3>;$
@71/$37,$-/1$673@+E$
N01$A12/73$,02,$]@A@13=7A/$
,7$87@19$519+1=$A1<+/+73C$
+/$37,$:199$@1=+31@$
=7A$,0+/$.-A.7/1$+/$,02,$673@+,+7329+M2,+73$
,+7329+M2,+73$
+3$,01$,B.+629$
62/1/$7=$519+1=$A1<+/+73E,02,$+/;$,01$62/1/$+3$:0+60$,01$31:$
57@B$7=$519+1=$#$23@$/7$02/$
L$+/$+3673/+/,13,$
:+,0$,01$1J+/,+3>$
+3=7A82,+73$
:+,0$#$+/$
W;$73$0+/$2667-3,C$!-,$+=$:1$2997:$,02,$+3673/+/,136B$
.A7525+9+,B$
,013$:1$82B$-/1$673@+,+73E$
678.2,+591$:+,0$02<+3>$2$373M1A7$.A7525+9+,B;$
62/1/$7=$519+1=$A1<+/+73C$N01$+@12$:7-9@$51$
29+M2,+73$,7$87@19$,01$,B.+629$
U$>131A2,1/$,01$519+1=$/1,$#;$,013$,01$.A75E$
=-36,+73$
,02,$+=$,01$.A7525+9+,B$
73$L;$UL;$
>131A2,1/$,01$519+1=$
6
73@+,+7329+M+3>$
75,2+31@$
=-36,+73$
5B$
25+9+,B$
:7-9@$.A1/1A<1$
7=$#5B$LC$N0+/$/->>1/,+73$
/1,$:0+60$+/$,01$8+3+829$A1<+/+73$
,01$1J61.,+73/$
92B/$@7:3$=7A$A1<+/+73/;$
87/,$7=$,01$.7/,-92,1/$]@A@13=7A/$
,7$87@19$
2
9/7$51$.7//+591$
23@$1+>0,0$
K
(,$82B$
=7-A,0$
.
7/,-92,1/C$
51+3>$,01$
7=$673,A26E$
@1=+3+,+73$
+3$2$/+8+92A$:2B$5B$-/+3>$]@A@13=7A/I/$
673,A26,+73/$
=-36,+73/$+3$,1A8/$7=$A1<+/+73$.A7525+9+,+1/CD$N01$ .7+3,$
,+73$.A7525+9+,B$
01A1$+/$,02,$5B$>+<+3>$-.$,01$/,A73>$673@+,+73$73$2661.,2361;$+,$/07-9@$51$
,7$:02,$]@A@13=7A/$
/2B/;$,7$-/1$7,07@7J$!2B1/+23$81,0E$
.7//+591;$673,A2AB$
7@/$,7$87@19$A1<+/+73/$K23@$.1A02./$673,A26,+73/DC$
L>2+3;$,01$6023>1$,7$,01$:12?1A$673@+,+73$73$2661.,2361$/01@/$/781$
Vdc$
!""#$%&'(&)*$
A1/-9,$A1>2A@+3>$%28/1BI/$,1/,C$L/$813E$
9+>0,$73$ ]@A@13=7A/I/$,A+<+29+,B$
,02,$%28/1BI/$,1/,$+/$,01$6-9.A+,$+3$,01$/+,-2,+73$23@$,01$
,+731@;$01$,0+3?/$
673E$
673@+,+73$,01$+337613,$.2A,BC$(3@11@;$,01$.A1/1A<2,+73$
.A1/1A<2,+73$
.7/,-92,1$01$92B/$
@+,+73$+/;$-3@1A$:12?$673@+,+73/;$1G-+<2913,$,7$,01$=7-A,0$
23@$+/$13,2+91@$2/$2$/.16+29$62/1$5B$,01$1+>0,0$.7/,-92,1C$
@7:3$=7A$A1<+/+73/$
S7:1<1A;$:+,0+3$2$!2B1/+23$673,1J,$+3$:0+60$519+1=$A1<+/+73$>71/$5B$673E$
,01$
23@$2661.,2361$@71/$37,$A1G-+A1$82J+829$.A7525+9+,B;$
@+,+7329+M2,+73$
N01$1J28.91$257-,$,01$O9+3,73E9+?1$
A757,$
673@+,+73$97/1/$+,/$.92-/+5+9+,BC$
.A7<+@1/$2$67-3,1A1J28.91$,7$,01$673@+,+73C$T7-A$519+1=$/,2,1$+/$/-60$,02,$
B7-$2661.,$,02,$,01$+3@+<+@-29$B7-$/11$73$,191<+/+73$+/$O9+3,734$,01$+3=7AE$
A757,$23@$+3/,2991@$+,$+3$,01$
02<1$5-+9,$2$O9+3,73E9+?1$
82,+73$,02,$/6+13,+/,/$
673/+/,13,$
:+,0$,0+/$519+1=$/,2,14$5-,$+=$B7-$:1A1$,7$
"<29$"==+61$+/$=7A8299B$
B7-$8+>0,$37$
A1<+/1$B7-A$519+1=$/,2,1$,7$2667887@2,1$,0+/$+3=7A82,+73;$
B7-$/11$/.12?+3>$=A78$
973>1A$A1,2+3$B7-A$7A+>+329$519+1=$,02,$,01$+3@+<+@-29$
,01$"<29$"==+61$+/$O9+3,73C$a7A17<1A;$2997:+3>$,02,$A1<+/+73$766-A/$5B$673E$
7=$%28/1BI/$,1/,;$
:0+60$,013$
29/7$/,A13>,013/$
,01$.92-/+5+9+,B$
@+,+7329+M2,+73$
7=$673@+,+7329/$>71/$
,02,$2661.,25+9+,B$
+/$1G-+<2913,$,7$L@28/I/$0B.7,01/+/$
2$0B.7,01/+/$
:0+60$+/$28.9B$673=+A81@$5B$9+3E$
5B$673@+,+7329$.A7525+9+,B;$
>-+/,+6$1<+@1361C$*7;$73$,01$.A1/13,$/->>1/,+73;$,01$:2B$,7$2<7+@$]2+A@13E$
=7A/I/$,A+<+29+,B$
A1/-9,$+/$,7$A1,2+3$%28/1BI/$,1/,$5-,$>+<1$-.$,01$.A1/1A<2,+73$
2AA+<1/$2,$,01$7..7/+,1$A181@B$5162-/1$7=$0+/$8+/E$
673@+,+73C$]@A@13=7A/$
,2?13$2@01A1361$,7$,01$A1G-+A1813,$,02,$2661.,2361$A1G-+A1/$82J+829$
.A7525+9+,BC$
L$87A1$678.91,1$678.2A+/73$:+,0$!2B1/+23$2..A72601/$:7-9@;$($,0+3?;$
N0+/$+/$37,;$
/1A<1$2/$2$67AA16,+<1$
,7$/781$2/.16,/$7=$]+A@13=7A/I/$,017ABC$
,7$@1,A26,$=A78$,01$577?;$:0+60$02/$29A12@B$82@1;$23@$:+99$673E$
07:1<1A;$
<29-2591$673,A+5-,+73$
,7$,01$
,+3-1$=7A$/781$,+81$,7$82?1;$23$1J,A1819B$
@+/6-//+73$7=$519+1=$6023>1C$
U&N&%$ a&Hh(&*$
H2,+7329$^3+<1A/+,B$
L-/,A29+23$
VYYZD$
%1<+1:;$
'79C$VWX;$H7C$V$KQ23-2AB$
N01$U0+97/7.0+629$
L$*T*N&a$"R$U%L]aLN(O$(\&L[(*aC$'79C$V;$S^aLH$#H")[&\]&$(H$
UA+361,73$
(\&L[(*N(O$U&%*U&ON('&C$!B$H(OS"[L*$%&*OS&%C$UA+361,73`$
^3+<1A/+,B$
UA1//;$VYYcC$U.C$J+<;$XXfC$
2/$,0+/$+/$A1.A1/13,1@$5B$-/;$
N01$602A26,1A$7=$,01$.0B/+629$:7A9@$+3$+,/19=;$
+,/19=$
P+/$37,$/02.1@$731E/+@1@9B$
5B$,01$32,-A1$7=$,01$75F16,$7=$+3<1/,+>2,+73$
5B$
5B$,01$67>3+,+<1$+3/,A-813,29+,+1/$
K75F16,+<+/8D;$7A$/02.1@$731E/+@1@9B$
5-,$A1.A1E$
:07/1$8123/$:1$2@@A1//$,01$.A75918/$2,$+//-1$K/-5F16,+<+/8D;$
7=$,01$,:7$
/13,/$23$+3,1A26,+73$
51,:113$,01$,:7$+3$:0+60$,01$673,A+5-,+73/$
VdX$