ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS Dealing with Addiction Disease in Dentistry FINAL REPORT ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS Dealing with Addiction Disease in Dentistry O C TO B E R 1 2-1 3 , 20 1 2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The disease of addiction plays no favourites. Dentists, like other health care professionals, are susceptible to this disease just like others in the general population. The latest statistics from the United States have at least 15-18% of the dental profession struggling with addiction disease. There is no reason to believe that the problem is any less here in Canada. The stakes are even higher for dentists than for other individuals who are addicted. Because if a dentist’s addiction is left untreated, it could not only threaten their own lives and family stability, but place patients and their practices in jeopardy too. For too long, there have been almost insurmountable barriers of shame that prevent dentists from seeking help. Society imposes stigma – and its damage – on addicts and their families because many of us still believe that addiction is a character flaw or weakness that probably can’t be cured. Stigma is the reason there is so much social and legal discrimination against people with addictions. It explains why addicts and their families hide the disease. People who need the help are often afraid to speak up. This stigma is one of the meanest and most difficult aspects of addiction because it makes it harder for individuals and families to deal with their problems and get the help they need. 2 EXCECUTIVE SUMMARY ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS What I am asking you to focus on … is not the shame of the illness which is what you see in your daily regulatory roles but rather remember the dignity of recovery. Dr. Graeme Cunningham Wellness Consultant Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario People who are victims of stigma internalize the hate it carries, transforming it to shame and hiding from its effects. Too often, people with alcohol and drug problems and their families begin to accept the ideas that addiction is their own fault and that maybe they are too weak to do anything about it. In many ways, hiding an addiction problem is the rational thing to do because seeking help can mean losing a job, your social status, the friendship of your colleagues, or even your family. Dentists with substance abuse problems could also lose more because they are usually single practitioners, and if the dentist goes down, so does the practice The profession needs to spread the word that addiction is an illness, not a moral failing, to create a culture within dentistry where no dentist is confronted by a prevailing sense of helplessness in the face of addiction. Dentists don’t choose to abuse psychoactive substances or adopt abusive behaviours like gambling, sex, etc. Addiction is not the result of a lack of willpower. Addiction is an illness, not a moral weakness. Yet the stigma against people with addictions is so deeply rooted that it continues even in the face of the scientific evidence that addiction is a treatable disease. 3 EXCECUTIVE SUMMARY ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS We have learned more about the neural biology of addiction in the past five years that in the past 500 years. Dr. Paul Earley Medical Director State of Georgia Physicians Health Program It’s puzzling why some people become addicted and others do not. No single answer has been found. It seems that people develop addictions through a mixture of factors such as: • genes • the way a person’s brain works • difficulties during childhood • mental health problems • stress • cultural influences. While researchers continue to study the mysteries of addiction, some things are clear: nobody chooses to become addicted, and addiction is not simply due to personal weakness or character flaws. The latest scientific evidence is clear: addiction is a brain disease with underlying neurology; it is not simply a behavioural problem. It is a chronic disease. Neuroscience has substantially advanced the understanding that addiction is an organic neurobiological condition that affects perceptual, emotional and motivational processes in the brain. In addition, there are complexities involved because of the psychological, social, and economic determinants involved in the onset of addiction. The societal impact of addiction is staggering. The cost of substance abuse in Canada is estimated at $40 billion per year according the Canadian Centre for Mental Health and Addiction. 4 EXCECUTIVE SUMMARY ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS If you remember nothing else, remember two things after your two days here: this is an illness that is chronic and relapsing and recovery is possible with the right treatment. Dr. Graeme Cunningham RCDSO Wellness Consultant The impact of this devastating disease on individual dentist lives, practices and families is enormous. In no way do the statistics capture the human toll of family devastation, broken hearts, broken dreams and financial ruin. There is good news though. With the right support, people with addictions can lead healthy and productive lives. In fact, the current recovery rate for health care professionals is up to 90 % after five years. This incredibly positive outlook for addicted dentists was the culmination of a two-day conference on October 12 and 13 in Toronto entitled, On the Road To Wellness: Dealing with Addiction Disease in Dentistry. The conference was sponsored and organized jointly by the Canadian Dental Regulatory Authorities Federation and the Canadian Dental Association. During the conference, the nearly 80 participants gained a shared knowledge of the science of addiction and a fundamental understanding of its implications for practice and policy. The conference PowerPoint presentations and handouts are in the appendices. There were wide-ranging roundtable discussions on how to best support the well-being of the single most valuable asset in the nation’s oral health care system – the dentist. Other key themes of the roundtables included the appropriate role of regulators and professional associations in addressing substance abuse and what the barriers are for each group in offering assistance. 5 EXCECUTIVE SUMMARY ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS If you get no other take home message, is is coordination… that single combination of compassion and control is what makes people shift and get better. Dr. Paul Earley Medical Director State of Georgia Physicians Health Program As the conference closed on late Saturday afternoon, it was clear that both regulators and the provincial dental associations had accepted the challenge to use the insight and knowledge gained to accept the responsibility for change. It was agreed that the right support means a reliance on a non-punitive approach to supporting the addicted health professional. Meeting the incredible challenge of reduction of barriers to dentists seeking and accessing care for addictions must be balanced with an appropriate framework to protect the public from harm. As leaders in the dental community in this country, both the regulators and the provincial professional associations agreed to shoulder the responsibility to be in the vanguard of a much-needed transformation. 6 EXCECUTIVE SUMMARY ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS FUTURE DIRECTIONS This is not a professional issue, nor a regulatory issue, it is a human issue. Dr. Rob Sutherland President, Canadian Dental Association Our ability to respond is only limited by our imagination. Dr. Peter Trainor President, Canadian Dental Regulatory Authorities Federation The two-day event wrapped up with comments from the CDRAF President Dr. Peter Trainor and CDA President Dr. Rob Sutherland as together they synthesized the roundtable discussions on how regulators and the professional associations and looked forward to the future. The key points of their joint presentation were: EDUCATION & COMMUNICATION These are the first critical steps of a successful strategy. Leaders in the dental community and the broader profession need to gain a basic understanding of the nature of the problem and the opportunities for success. COMPLEXITY By pooling and coordinating resources, the probability of success is improved. Addiction disease is a complex problem that will require complex solutions, not a one-off effort. There will need to be recognition of the geographical/language realities of the country so that some provinces are not disadvantaged. MANAGING OUTCOMES It is important to take the strength of our existing resources and maximize them. It is critical to achieve the best outcomes in the most efficient way possible as effective solutions will be expensive. SYNERGY/TEAMWORK There is need for a synergy of commitment with a collaborative and coordinated response with defined roles for regulators and professional associations. It is important to capitalize on the current momentum to move forward together with a sense of urgency. 7 EXCECUTIVE SUMMARY FOR MORE INFORMATION Canadian Dental Regulatory Authorities Federation Irwin Fefergrad Executive Director [email protected] 416.710.9571 Canadian Dental Association Dr. Benoit Soucy Director of Clinical and Scientific Affairs [email protected] 613.523.1770 ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS 8 EXCECUTIVE SUMMARY ON THE ROAD TO WELLNESS APPENDIX Tab 1 What is it about dentists? Health & Addiction Dr. Carolyn Thomson Tab 2 Anecedotal Perspectives from BC Experience of Member Counselling Support Dr. John T. Palmer Tab 3 Addiction in the 21st Century: A Treatable Brain Diseases Dr. Paul Earley Tab 4 Addiction in Caregivers Dr. Graeme Cunningham Tab 5 CV of Dr. Graeme Cunningham Tab 6 CV of Dr. Paul Earley Tab 7 CV of Dr. John Palmer Tab 8 CV of Dr. Carolyn Thomson What is it about dentists? Health & Addiction Dr. Carolyn Thomson, MD, CCFP, FCFP Co‐ordinator, Professionals Support Program Doctors Nova Scotia 2 Personalities Dentistry attracts people with… Introvert Thinker • • • • Perceptive Sensor compulsive personalities unrealistic expectations unnecessarily high standards of performance require social approval and status Intuitive Judgmental Feeler Extrovert 3 4 General Health Healthy Behaviours • Good to excellent health 88% BUT • Report poor general health 10% • Poor physical state 30% • Overweight 27.6% • Obese 7.4% Exercise 59% Breakfast Sleep Snack Smoking 73% 61% 20% 10% Alcohol Average BMI 90% 61% Myer and Myer 2004 5 6 Musculoskeletal Disorders • • • • Other Health Issues High prevalence 87.2% over 12 months Low back pain (LBP most common) Shoulder pain Wrist pain 7 • • • • • Allergic contact dermatitis Respiratory sensitivity Eye injuries Auditory damage Hepatitis B: vaccine uptake 8 Ten most commonly reported minor ailments Nitrous Oxide • Chronic exposure can produce serious risk • Possible risks to the hematological, reproductive, hematological, hepatic and renal systems • Increase cancer risk • Most common: peripheral neuropathy Usage • USA and Japan – 50% • Denmark – 45‐50% • UK – 30‐40% 9 • Backache or pains in the back 62.3% • Nervy, tense or depressed* 60.0% • Heartburn, wind or indigestion 59.4% – More male • Headache* 58.3% – More female – * Correlates with work stress Key Point Burnout and poor health are strongly related. To deal preventatively with burnout in dentistry, pay attention to physical health. How could dentists let these things happen to themselves? 12 More female • Cough, catarrh or phlegm 38.4% • Dry, itchy or tired eyes 34.4% • Blocked or runny nose 32.9% • Rashes, itches or other skin trouble 28.7% • Difficulty in sleeping* 48.6% 10 11 • Feeling tired for no apparent reasons* 48.2% Vulnerability • • • • • • • Genetic factors Dynamics of family of origin Personal history‐ exposure/response to trauma Variations in brain chemistry Personality characteristics Cultural norms Religious beliefs 13 Depression • US – Lifetime prevalence ‐ 17% – One year prevalence ‐ 10% • Occurs more often in women and lower socio‐economic status • Only female pediatric dentists and periodontists more depressed than male counterparts ‐ JADA 2005 14 Anxiety What are the costs? • • • • Personal suffering Impaired relationships Days lost from work Impact on quality of care • Not the mild, brief anxiety caused by a stressful event • Affects 19 million Americans • Most common GAD and Panic Disorder • Prevalence not increased in dentists 15 16 Suicide in Dentists Suicide in Dentists • Not all those with depression suicidal but most suicides linked to depression • Little valid evidence that dentists are more prone to suicide than the general population • Some data: female dentists more vulnerable? • Suicide rate among dentists higher than those of other occupations • New studies required to introduce the demographic variables – previous psychiatric morbidity – opportunity factor – stressors not related to work JADA June 2001, Roger Alexander International Dental Journal, 2012 ‐ Sancho FM 17 18 Top Ten Suicide Rates Key Point 1. Food Batchmakers 2. Physicians and Health Aides 3. Lathe and Turning Machine Operators 4. Biological, Life and Medical Scientists 5. Social Scientists and Urban Planners 6. Dentists 7. Lawyers and Judges 8. Guards/Sales Occupations 9. Tool and Die Makers 10. Police and Public Servants 19 Professional training and licensure do not confer immunity from the realities of our humanity and the potential to experience illness, grief, family problems, stress, trauma or depression. 20 National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism Addiction “A disease process characterized by the continued use of a specific psychoactive substance despite physical, psychological or social harm." 21 • Lifetime prevalence of alcohol dependence in the general population 13.3 % • 12‐month prevalence of addiction 4.4 % • Rates in healthcare professionals similar to general population • Differences related to drugs of choice • Reflects familiarity with particular drugs and access • Little evidence dentists at greater risk than GPs 22 Contributing Factors • • • • • High stress Unrealistic and perfectionistic expectations of oneself Grandiose feelings of invulnerability Knowledge about and access to drugs Other – – – – 23 stressful environments long hours excessive professional demands demands of patients and staff The Addicted Dentist 80‐85% addicted dentists prefer drugs over alcohol Others: – tobacco – stress reducers “upper” and “downers” – narcotics including nitrous oxide (hardest to shake) and benzodiazepines Most common: – alcohol – hydrocodone – N2O 24 • • • • • • Personality Profile of Addicted Dentist Key Points Dissatisfied with career choice Fear of causing pain Low professional self‐esteem Obsessive‐compulsive & perfectionistic behaviour High need for control (but feeling out of control) Avoidant style in interpersonal relationships • The onus is on the dental staff, friends and family to recognize the onset of the individual’s personality changes and to encourage the affected individual to seek help. • Be aware of your own risk factors. Dr. Jerry Gropper Talbott Marsh Recovery Campus 25 Good News: • Studies indicate a better than 86% five‐year recovery success rate for the dental profession 26 Why should we care? Stress • Common cause of early retirement • Job dissatisfaction • Poor working relationships Stress can be defined as the biological reaction to any adverse internal or external stimulus physical, mental or emotional – that tends to disturb the organism's homeostasis. Can be +ve or –ve. 27 28 Stress Feelings of low self‐esteem, depression and anxiety and hopelessness. Younger dentists more prone. Stress Sex differences Parents Work issues Patients often create less stress for dentists than running behind schedule • Minor psychiatric symptoms: 32% vs 17.8% in GP • Teaching: decreased stress • • • • Myers and Myers 2004 29 30 Biggest cause of stress Running behind schedule and coping with difficult, uncooperative patient. 31 Three Dimensions of Burnout “Gradual erosion of the person” • Emotional Exhaustion • Depersonalization • Loss of professional satisfaction 32 Prevention • • • • Commitment, self‐efficacy, resourcefulness and hope May have to address at organizational level Cognitive – behavioural strategies Exhaustion more easily treated 33 Addressing Burnout: The “3R” Approach • Recognize • Reverse • Resilience 34 Key Point Burnout is easier to prevent than to treat. 35 Stigma Associated with experiencing personal difficulties Feelings of shame or guilt can be a self‐imposed stigma Powerful deterrent People often shun what they don’t understand Common view of mental illness Recovery→profound feelings of personal frustration and failure • Depressed people seek treatment in only 40% of cases • • • • • • 36 37 39 Stigma In Closing High proportion of depressed dentists are not receiving treatment for their illness. • We need to understand ourselves better so we can better help our colleagues. • Can address their need for help, while allowing them to maintain their professional image and reputation. 38 Anecdotal Perspectives from the BC Experience of Member Counselling Support Dr. John T. Palmer Director, Dental Professional Advisory Program British Columbia Dental Association 2 UBC Intake Survey Fall 2011 Medical and Dental 3 4 How well would you say that you know yourself? A. B. C. D. E. 5 Learning about Self Extremely well Quite well Not sure Not very well Hardly at all A. B. C. D. Self‐reflection Dialogue with others Objective feedback Using stories or fables as a template E. Comparing myself with others survey responses 6 Test Goals? The kind of subjects you prefer When studying for an examination, I usually aimed to get 100%. A. B. C. D. E. I’m drawn toward subjects where the right answer is always clear: where there’s less room for teacher bias to affect my evaluation. Agree strongly Agree Uncertain/no opinion Disagree Disagree strongly 7 A. B. C. D. E. Agree strongly Agree Uncertain / no opinion Disagree Disagree strongly 8 Your Current Theory of Intelligence Mindset Indicate your degree of agreement with the following statement: You can learn new things, but you can’t really change your basic intelligence. A. Agree strongly B. Agree somewhat C. Disagree somewhat D. Disagree strongly 9 10 Experiencing Failure • The challenge of learning from failure. • Theory of intelligence (Entity or Incremental) highly correlated with how we deal with failure. • If you believe intelligence is fixed, you’re at higher risk for having a maladaptive response to failure (e.g using secondary strategies to cope). 11 Research on Coping Styles • Primary and secondary responses to coping with failure • Both approaches involve attempts to repair impact on self esteem experienced when we fail. • Secondary means are ineffective in producing a better outcome going forward. (Dweck) 12 Here's what you said about your personal strengths Personal strengths What “strength” word would you choose to best describe what personal quality has brought you to succeed in your application to dental school? 13 14 When asked about what they would value most in practice What You Value in Colleagues What strength would you value most in a professional colleague? 15 16 What you think patients will value in you We asked what you think patients value What strength would patients value most in a treating physician or dentist? 17 18 Specific contributors in substance use clients Strengths that can tumble into liabilities • Independence (grandiosity) – A need to be in control either actively, by competitiveness, aggressive control or passively by opting out. • Perfectionism – An anxiety‐driven quest to be perfect in the eyes of others (or ourselves). Can be technically productive but interpersonally damaging. Harsh self‐ shaming. • Tendency to hyper‐focus (obsess) and lose the bigger picture. 19 • • • • High anxiety levels + low trust Black and white (categorical) thinking Shame Tendency to isolate 20 How do we help? • Respect personhood • Foster trust • Minimize shaming 21 23 22 Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Addiction in the 21st Century: A Treatable Brain Disease Presentation Outline Addiction in the 21st Century: A Treatable Brain Disease • Part II: Addiction Characteristics • Part III: Addiction Neurobiology Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Earley Consultancy, LLC and Medical Director, Georgia PHP, Inc. Atlanta, Georgia USA www.paulearley.net • Part I: History of the Addiction Concept • Part IV: Effective Addiction Treatment www.earleyconsultancy.com Historical Perspective Part I History of the Addiction Concept • Late 1800s – Inebriety was thought to be a primary medical illness. Various medical & spiritual remedies we tried with marginal success. • 1930s – With the emergence of psychoanalysis, alcoholism was viewed to be a symptom of other psychiatric diseases. • 1954 – AMA declares alcoholism a primary disease. Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Earley Consultancy, LLC Atlanta, Georgia USA • 1960s – Alcoholism treatment centers emerge to treat the illness. Historical Perspective Historical Perspective • 1970s – The addiction movement had to define and • 2000s – The neurobiology of addiction comes into differentiate itself in order to promote itself as a primary illness. • 1980s – The addiction concept was slowly redefined from problematic drinking to a disease caused be certain chemicals and behaviors. Our initial understanding of the brain circuits of addiction evolve. Addiction is differentiated from physical dependence. Portions of this material are copyrighted. sharp definition. The exact neural circuitry of addiction is demarcated. Additional addictive processes (compulsive sex, gambling and food binging) are discovered to exhibit the same abnormalities with the neural circuitry of chemical addiction. • 2010s – A few medications appear that help with the primary focus of addiction: craving and relapse prevention. Page 1 Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Addiction in the 21st Century: A Treatable Brain Disease Symptoms and Drug Use Prime mover according to Psychodynamic Theory Accepting Addiction as a Disease • Multigenerational culture bias • Behaviors of addicts and alcoholics Symptom Drug Use • Failure of early treatment efforts • Initial marginalization of addiction treatment Much more critical for initial abstinence and recovery Addiction is an International Health Problem Part II Addiction Characteristics • Ten percent of all people become addicted throughout their lifetime in western cultures (lifetime prevalence). • Addiction-related disease accounts for one-third of all hospital days. Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Earley Consultancy, LLC Atlanta, Georgia USA • Addicts and addiction related crimes are the largest cause of nonviolent crime and incarceration. Addiction Nomenclature Physiological Dependence versus Addiction • Addictionists use the term addiction to • Physiological refer to alcohol and drug dependence and less technical terms, such as: alcoholism, chemical dependence and drunkenness as well as the behavioral addictions (e.g. – gambling and sexual addiction) • The term Addict is often used to describe the drug addict or alcoholic. Portions of this material are copyrighted. Dependence – Occurs in all individuals – Is a characteristic of certain drugs – Craving occurs during drug withdrawal • Addiction – Occurs in 10% of the population – Is a characteristic of certain people with certain drugs – Craving is tied to many emotional and cognitive triggers, occurring long past the withdrawal time Page 2 Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Addiction in the 21st Century: A Treatable Brain Disease The Etiology of Addiction Genetic Proclivity The Cycle of Addiction Acute reinforcing stage (Intoxication) Earlier Life Trauma Addiction Personality and Psychiatric Disease Environment and Access Preoccupation & Anticipation Withdrawal & Negative Affect Koob & Le Moal (2005) Plasticity of reward neurocircuitry and the 'dark side' of drug addiction. Nature Neuroscience. 8:1442-4 The Using/Shame Cycle Part III Addiction Neurobiology Using Urge to change strong affect Consequences & Guilt Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Shame Addicting Molecules Nicotine Earley Consultancy, LLC Atlanta, Georgia USA Is there a single pathway to addiction? Alcohol • Drugs of abuse have very different structures and neurotransmitter targets in the brain, but they all exhibit: Heroin Cocaine – – – – – – acute reward chronic reward sensitization negative withdrawal symptoms associative cue learning incentive motivation (relapse) • A progression from impulsive to compulsive drug use (which defines the progression from abuse into addiction). Nestler, EJ. Nature Neuroscience 2005; 8(11):1445-49 Portions of this material are copyrighted. Page 3 Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Addiction in the 21st Century: A Treatable Brain Disease Neurochemistry of Wanting Dopamine Reward Circuit Nucleus accumbens Ventral tegmental area (VTA) 20 Nestler, EJ. Nature Neuroscience 2005; 8(11):1445-49 Neural Adaptation to Drug use After extended drug exposure Normal Dendrites Nestler, E., Malenka, R. The Addicted Brain. Scientific American 290(3): 78 (2004) 22 Cue-induced Craving Amygdala not activated Amygdala activated Anterior Part IV Effective Addiction Treatment Posterior Watching a Nature Video Portions of this material are copyrighted. Watching a Cocaine Video Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Earley Consultancy, LLC Atlanta, Georgia USA Page 4 Paul H. Earley, M.D., FASAM Addiction in the 21st Century: A Treatable Brain Disease The Addictionectomy Substance Abusing Patient Treatment A Desirable Model Continuing Care / Monitoring Early Detection of Relapse Hospital Detox. Residential Rehab IOP Rehab Outpatient Cont Care AA & Tele Monitoring Non-substance Abusing Patient Modified from A. Thomas McLellan, Ph.D. Courtesy of A. Thomas McLellan, Ph.D. Taper (and increase) Treatment as needed Elements of Effective Treatment • Viewing addiction though same lens as other chronic diseases. Intensity Current treatment • Combination of effective initial intervention and disease management using contingency contracting. • Intervene on co-morbid psychiatric and life issues Best practice treatment Time simultaneously. • Judicious use of non-addicting medications. • Knowing that one size does not fit all. • Long term disease management. Education and Consultation Contact Dr. Earley: – Web site: www.paulearley.net – by phone: (404) 492-7669 – by E-mail: [email protected] Portions of this material are copyrighted. Page 5 References – Addiction in the 21st Century Anton, R; O’Malley, S; Ciraulo, D; Cisler, R; Couper, D; Donovan, D; Gastfriend, D; et al Combined Pharmacotherapies and Behavioral Interventions for Alcohol Dependence: The COMBINE Study: A Randomized Controlled Trial JAMA, May 3, 2006; 295: 2003 - 2017. Bechara , A. Decision making, impulse control and loss of willpower to resist drugs: a neurocognitive perspective. Nature neuroscience. 8 (11), 1458-63 (Nov 2005) Bechara, A; Damasio, H; Damasio, A. Role of the amygdala in decision-making. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. 985, 356-69 (Apr 2003) Berglind, W., et. al. Dopamine D1 or D2 receptor antagonism within the basolateral amygdala differentially alters the acquisition of cocaine-cue associations necessary for cue-induced reinstatement of cocaine-seeking. Neuroscience. 137 (2), 699-706 (2006). Everitt, B.; Cardinal, R.; Parkinson, J.; and Robbins, T. Appetitive Behavior: Impact of Amygdaladependent Mechanisms of Emotional Learning. Annals of the N/Y/ Academy of Sciences. 985:233250. (2003). Goldstein, R; Volkow, N; Wang, G; Fowler, J; Rajaram, S. Addiction changes orbitofrontal gyrus function: involvement in response inhibition. Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuropsychology 12(11) 8 August 2001 2595-2599 Kilts, K, et al. Neural Activity Related to Drug Craving in Cocaine Addiction Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2001;58:334-341. Hall, F.S., et al., Molecular mechanisms underlying the rewarding effects of cocaine. 2004. p. 47-56. Hyman, S. Addiction: a disease of learning and memory. Am J. Psychiatry 162:114-23 (2005). Koob, G, Le Moal, M. Plasticity of reward neurocircuitry and the ‘dark side’ of drug addiction. Nature Neuroscience 8:11 1442- 1444. Nov 2005. Nestler, EJ. Is there a common molecular pathway for addiction? Nature Neuroscience 2005; 8(11):1445-49 Schoenbaum, G., M.R. Roesch, and T.A. Stalnaker, Orbitofrontal cortex, decision-making and drug addiction. 2006. p. 116-24. See , R, et al. Drug addiction, relapse, and the amygdala. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. 985, 294-307 (Apr 2003) Stocker, S. Studies Link Stress and Drug Addiction. NIDA Notes. Volume 14, Number 1 (April, 1999) Sugase-Miyamoto, Y; Richmond, BJ. Neuronal signals in the monkey basolateral amygdala during reward schedules. J Neurosci. 2005 Nov 30;25(48):11071-83. Addiction in Caregivers Graeme M. Cunningham, MD, FRCPC RCDSO Wellness Consultant 2 Caregiver Impairment Prevalence “One who is unable to practice giving care with reasonable skill and safety to patients because of physical or mental illness, including deterioration through the aging process, characterologic or psychiatric difficulties, excessive use of alcohol or other drugs and sero‐positivity for HIV and Hep C.” • 10% were daily drinkers • 9.3% had 5 drinks a day at least once in past year • 17.6% had self‐prescribed benzodiazephines in past year • 17.6% had self‐prescribed opiates in past year • 8% reported dependency in their lifetimes Hughes PH, Brandenburg N., Prevalence of Substance Use Among US Physicians. JAMA 1992;267:2333‐8 3 4 Prevalence in Dentists • • • • • 5 Psychological Characteristics of Caregivers Alcohol 12‐19% Opiates‐hydrocodone and oxycodone 37% Nitrous Oxide‐almost exclusively in dentists 5% Nicotine Street drugs – cocaine 10% • • • • • • • 6 Dedication/Focus Delayed Gratification Workaholics Guilt Prone Exaggerated Responsibility Limited Emotional Expressiveness Regularly Suppress Anger Psychological Characteristics of Caregivers Female MDs/Dentists • Obsessive/Compulsive Traits – – – – • Just as compulsive, but value relationships more than male MDs/Dentists • 75 ‐ 80% do own housework • Frequently feel guilty • Try to be ‘Superwoman’ Perfectionist Demanding Impatient Hyperconscientious • Difficulty with Fun – (it’s OK if we make work of it!) • I am my Work 7 8 Risk factors for Caregivers • • • • • • • Genetic tendency Isolation Specialty Childhood “tapes” Enablers Smoking Pedestal profession 9 Issues Specific to Professionals • • • • • • • • Terminal uniqueness Difficulty in patient role Tendency to intellectualize Severe guilt and shame Entrenched denial Tendency to self‐medicate Threatened loss of licence Return to work issues 10 Homewood Experience Drugs used in order of frequency: – Nicotine – Alcohol – Opioids • codeine, morphine, dilaudid, percocets, oxycontin – Benzodiazepines – Cocaine – Antihistamines 11 Work‐related Issues • • • • • • 12 Incorrect narcotic counts Alteration of narcotic vials Patient complaints of ineffective pain relief Large volumes of wastes Discrepancies in orders,progress notes and mars Many corrections on narcotic records Suggestive Signs • • • • • • • Crippling anxiety Frequent bathroom relief Desire to work alone Deteriorating appearance Always wearing long sleeves Appearing when off duty Marked mood swings 13 Clues to Recognition • Change of personality • Loss of efficiency and reliability • Increased sick days • Complaints from patients, particularly about a changed attitude • Development of indecision 14 More Clues to Recognition • Mood swings, suicidal ideation • Memory loss, blackouts after parties • Inappropriate prescribing – large doses – long‐term narcotics • Offering to waste patient’s supply • Changes in routine • Sloppy charts and writing (worse than usual) • Desire to work alone • Long sleeves in hot weather • Frequent bathroom breaks • In when should be off duty 15 Impaired Health Professionals Programs • • • • • • • • • Assessment Recovery Program Peer Group Therapy Mirror Image Therapy 12‐Step Mutual Help Family Treatment Process Addictions Relapse Prevention Special Issues 16 Value of Peer Group Therapy Assessment • Multidisciplinary • History • • • • • • 17 • Professional and social isolation • Physical changes • Heavy “wastage” of drugs • MD giving analgesics • Unpredictable work habits Usual Medical Hx Alcohol/Drugs Emotional Spiritual Family Collateral • Drug Screening • Psychological Assessment • Psychiatry • Group/Peer Exposure • 12‐Step Exposure “This group scares me.” • • • • • • • • 18 Confront denial/support recovery Chemical‐free coping skills Issues of trust and friendship Confront terminal uniqueness Deal with “GOD” issues Dump secrets Transition to 12‐step process Communication/listening skills Group Work – Health Professionals Issues Process Addictions “God, now they want me to talk in front of 50 people!” “Are they or aren’t they?” • • • • • • Access/safe environment Licensing/disciplinary issues Returning to work Recovery checklist Advocacy contract Clinical histories 19 • • • • 20 Return to Work : Practical Issues • Full restoration of work capacity may require 4‐6 months even though symptom‐remission begins in 4‐6 weeks • Issues of disability insurance and finances • Challenges in gradual return to work: practical arrangements and monitoring • Attitudes of others in the workplace 21 Typical Contract • Agreement on diagnosis • Attendance at AA, Caduceus, Addiction Doctor, after‐care group • Attendance at family doctor • Random urine monitoring expectations • Advocacy role of treating doctor • Clear consequences of breach of contract • Third‐party reporting where necessary 22 Typical Work Issues • • • • • 23 Gambling Sexual Excitement Food Location of continuing employment Need for “buddy” system Narcotic issues Home nursing Need for external reports Re‐Entry to Practice • Properly treated physicians in recovery are no more, and probably less of, a risk to patients than the general physician population Pelton C, Lang DA, Nye GS et al. Physician Diversion Program: Experience with Successful Graduates. J Psychoactive Drugs 1993;25(2):159‐6 24 Re‐Entry to Practice Issues that arise for colleagues The Homewood Experience “I thought I’d be good to myself and take three days off before I go back.” • Average return to work is three months • Emergency, night, and weekend work avoided wherever possible for the first six months • Phase in with part‐time • Clean office ‐ no mood altering drugs • Avoid drug reps • Tell those who ‘need to know’ 25 • • • • • • 26 Summary • Health professionals are different. • They require and deserve specific treatment paths. • These paths offer a 73% ‐ 90% recovery rate at five years. 27 Anger and resentment Fear Uncertainty Over‐protectedness Minimizing the professional’s needs Family of origin stuff In Closing • We need to understand ourselves better so we can better help our colleagues. • Can address their need for help, while allowing them to maintain their professional image and reputation. 28 CURRICULUM VITAE (Revised March 2010) NAME: Graeme MacCallum Cunningham HOME ADDRESS: 24 Latenda Place Guelph ON N1G 3B8 (519) 823-2323 OTHER PERSONAL DATA: D.O.B. 04/07/43 Married, 5 children EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND: 1967 1970 1971 1975 1983 1988 1997 2001 2009 M.B., Ch.B. University of Glasgow, Scotland M.R.C.P. (U.K.) L.M.C.C. F.R.C.P. (C) F.R.C.P. (GLASG) Certificant, American Society of Addiction Medicine Fellow, American Society of Addiction Medicine Certificant, Canadian Society of Addiction Medicine Certificant, American Board of Addiction Medicine CURRENT STATUS AT McMASTER: 1991 - 1998 Assistant Clinical Professor, Department of Medicine, McMaster University 1998 - 2008 Associate Clinical Professor, Department of Psychiatry, McMaster University 2009 Clinical Professor, Department of Psychiatry, McMaster University 1 REV. March 2010 PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS: Ontario Medical Association Past Chairperson District 9 Past Chairperson Section of Internal Medicine Past Chairperson Section of Addiction Medicine Canadian Medical Association American Board of Addiction Medicine Canadian Society of Addiction Medicine Past Board member for Ontario College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario President, 2002 - 2003 HONOURS: 2000 “Courage to Come Back Award” presented by the Centre for Addiction & Mental Health, Toronto, Ontario. “Honorary Life Membership Award”, Canadian Society of Addiction Medicine. 2004 The award is inscribed: “Canadian Society of Addiction Medicine HONOURARY LIFE MEMBERSHIP AWARD presented to Dr. Graeme Cunningham on the occasion of the 16th Anniversary of our Society, in recognition of his dedicated service and visionary leadership provided to the field of Addiction Medicine 2 REV. March 2010 EMPLOYMENT HISTORY: House Physician to Professor E.M. McGirr August 1967 January 1968 University Department of Medicine, Glasgow Royal Infirmary. House Surgeon to Professor W.A. MacKay February 1968 August 1968 University Department of Surgery, Glasgow Royal Infirmary Faulds Research Fellow August 1968 August 1969 University Department of Medicine, Glasgow Royal Infirmary Senior House Office in Medicine August 1969 April 1970 Glasgow Royal Infirmary Registrar in General Medicine April 1970 October 1970 Glasgow Royal Infirmary Family Physician October 1970 December 1973 Parry Sound, Ontario Senior Resident, Internal Medicine 1974 - 1975 University of Toronto Chief Resident, Internal Medicine 1975 - 1976 St. Michael's Hospital, University of Toronto Teaching Fellow 1976 - 1977 University of Toronto Consultant Internist 1977 - 1988 Timmins, Ontario Senior Resident, University of Toronto, Medicine of Addictions 1988 - 1989 Addiction Research Foundation, Toronto Director, Homewood Addiction Division Homewood Health Centre 1990 - 2010 Guelph, ON 3 REV. March 2010 SCHOLARLY AND PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES: Chairman, Section of Internal Medicine Ontario Medical Association 1982 - 1986 Member, Committee on Hospitals Ontario Medical Association 1984 - 1987 Chairman, District Nine Ontario Medical Association 1985 - 1987 Member of Board of Directors Timmins Chamber of Commerce 1984 - 1985 Past Chief of Staff General Hospital, Parry Sound, ON 1980 - 1982 Past Chief of Medicine St. Mary's General Hospital, Timmins, ON 1982 - 1986 Past Director, Intensive Care Unit St. Mary's General Hospital, Timmins, ON 1982 - 1985 Consultant Ontario Heart Foundation 1981 - 1989 Inspector, Medical Review Committee Board Member Ministry of Health 1985 - 2000 Canadian Society of Addiction Medicine 1992 - 1996 Chair, Advisory Committee Physician Health Program Ontario Medical Association 1995 - 2000 Member of Council College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario 1999 - 2004 Chair, Methadone Governance Committee Province of Ontario 1999 – 2004 Member, Executive Committee College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario 2000 – 2004 Vice-President College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario 2001 – 2002 President College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario 2002 - 2003 Past-President College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario 2003-2004 AREAS OF INTEREST: Teaching of Addiction Medicine, Assessment and Treatment of Addicted Physicians. 4 REV. March 2010 COURSES TAUGHT: (I) Undergraduate - Electives in Addiction Medicine for all undergraduate units. I act as preceptor/supervisor. A teaching handbook in Addiction Medicine has been developed. The electives are of varying lengths of 1 day to 3 weeks. Project CREATE is a joint effort of the five Ontario Medical schools to develop teaching modules in Addiction Medicine for all clinical services. I have assisted in the development of the module for E.R. physicians and for the recognition of stress and substance misuse in medical students. (ii) Postgraduate. A Fellowship position in Addiction Medicine has been developed in the Homewood Addiction Division. Goals, objectives and an evaluation tool for this Fellowship have also been developed. I am the supervisor of the Fellow-in-training and it is a yearlong position. In 1993 & 1994, I helped organize and chair two international symposia in Addiction Medicine at the University of Guelph. In 1995, I assisted the University of Ottawa in curriculum development and teaching in Addiction Medicine. In 1996, I organized and chaired the 7th Annual Scientific meeting of the Canadian Society of Addiction Medicine. Since January 2000, I am responsible for all Addiction Medicine Teaching in the Department of Psychiatry at McMaster University. This involves 24 hours of workshops/academic year. LIFETIME PUBLICATIONS: Peer Reviewed: "The Effect of Oral Anticoagulant Drugs on Platelet Aggregation in the Chandler's Tube", (1965) Cunningham GM, McNichol GP, Douglas AS. Lancet l, 279. "The Effect of Glyvenol (CIBA) on Pain and Capillary Fragility in Rheumatoid Arthritis", (1969) Dick WC, Cunningham GM, Nuki GK, Whaley KW. Annals of Rheumatic Diseases, 28, 187. "The Effect of Oxygen on the Fibrinolytic Enzyme System in Vivo:, (1971) - Cunningham GM, Boyd GD, McNichol GP. Journal of Clinical Pathology, 8, 705. "Drug-Induced Internuclear Opthalmoplegia", (1983) - Cunningham GM. Canadian Medical Association Journal, Vol. 128, 892. "Recovery from Chemical Dependency - The Process and Role of the Physician" Medicine North America - 1991, 1946-1951 "Developing an Office Management Plan for the Alcoholic Patient" - Canadian Journal of Diagnosis - 1992, 77-89 5 REV. March 2010 "Prescription Drug Abuse - Identifying the Prescription Drug Addict" - Canadian Journal of Diagnosis - 1992, 63-81 "Paying Attention To Substance Abuse In Physicians" - Canadian Journal of Diagnosis - 1993, 7688 "A Program to Treat Impaired Physicians - Graeme M. Cunningham, Annals of Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada - 1994, 27, 219-221 “Physicians as Patients” – D. Whitney, G. Cunningham, S. Abdool – 2001, Psychiatry Rounds 5:7. Book Chapters: 1996 The Substance-Abusing Physician - Identification and Management. The CMA Guide to Medical Administration in Canadian Hospitals. D. Gellman, Editor. 2000 The Impaired Physician - Management of Alcohol, Tobacco and other Drug Problems. Bruna Brands, Editor. Letter to the Editor - Alcohol Misuse Among Doctors (1997) Cunningham, G.M., British Medical Journal 314, 1833 - 1834. Unpublished Documents: (a) Naltrexone in the Treatment of Alcohol Dependence - A Canadian Trial (1997) Authors: M.K. Romach, E.M. Sellers, G. Somer, M. Landry, G. Cunningham, R. Jovey, C. McKay, J. Boislard, C. Mercier, J. Pepin, J. Perrault, E. Lemire, F. Bastien, R. Baker, W. Campbell, D. Ryan. (b) The Outcome of Treatment of 100 Alcohol Dependent Adults using the Addiction Severity Index - A study undertaken jointly with the University of Pennsylvania. 6 REV. March 2010 PRESENTATIONS AT MEETINGS: Date March 1, 1991 March 26, 1991 April 23, 1991 April 29-30, 1991 June 14, 1991 Sept. 5, 1991 Oct. 23, 1991 Oct. 24, 1991 Oct. 25, 1991 Nov.18, 1991 Nov. 20, 1991 Nov. 21, 1991 Dec. 3, 1991 March 4, 1992 April 7, 1992 April 11, 1992 April 15, 1992 April 23, 1992 April 26, 1992 (Invited = I) (Contributed = C) Location Seminar - Owen Sound, Addictions and the Community St. Joseph's Hospital Quarterly Medical Staff Meeting Hamilton, Ontario Toronto and District Correctional Services Annual Meeting Concerns Canada - Seminar on Prescription Drug Abuse Topic Clinical Perspectives of Alcoholics Anonymous. Impaired Physicians - Risks and Treatment. Discussion of Detoxification Techniques Keynote Speaker and Workshop leader in Prescription Drug Abuse Issues. Seminar on Recovery The Ontario Chapter of the College of Family Practice Annual Spring Meeting, Minaki Lodge, Ontario. Annual Meeting of the Ontario Parole Treatment of Substance Abuse in Board Prisoners Telemedicine Canada - Toronto Office Management of Alcoholism. Ontario Alternate Housing Committee Annual Conference Canadian Medical Society on Alcoholism and Other Drugs Annual Meeting Concerns Canada Drug Awareness Week Seminar London, Ontario. Lecturer at Queen's University Kingston General Hospital Dual Disorders Workshop Queen Street Mental Health Centre Telemedicine Canada Journal Club in Medicine. Half day at the University of Guelph. University of Toronto - Mental Health half day for residents and interns College of Family Physicians - Manitoba Chapter, Winnipeg Manitoba Ontario Hospital Association Chief of Staff Seminar Concerns Canada Canadian Association of Medical Directors of Teaching Hospitals Sept. 25, 1992 Canadian Anaesthesia Society Annual Meeting 7 REV. March 2010 I/C I I I I I I I Workshop on Dual Disorders I Workshop leader on Prescription Drug Abuse. C Keynote speaker. The Disease of Addiction. The Impaired Physician. I Annual Dual Disorder Meeting C I I Seminar on Drug Addiction C Physician Impairment I The Office Management of Substance Abuse Physician Impairment I Prescription Drug Abuse I Physician Impairment I Substance Abuse in Anaesthetists I I Nov. 7, 1992 Nov. 11, 1992 April 23, 1992 April 26, 1992 Sept. 25, 1992 Nov. 7, 1992 Nov. 11, 1992 Nov. 13, 1992 Nov. 22, 1992 Feb. 10, 1993 Feb. 11, 1993 March 11-13, 1993 April 19, 1993 May 29, 1993 June 11, 1993 Oct. 22, 1993 Jan. 21, 1994 Feb. 5, 1994 March 23, 1994 March 29, 1994 April 24, 1994 Ontario Association of Physicians in the Correctional Services. Grand Rounds, St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto Concerns Canada Ambulatory Detoxification Techniques. Physician Impairment. I Prescription Drug Abuse. I Canadian Association of Medical Directors of Teaching Hospitals Canadian Anaesthesia Society Annual Meeting Ontario Association of Physicians in the Correctional Services Grand Rounds, St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto Ontario Chapter, Canadian College of Family Practice Annual Meeting Canadian Medical Society on Alcoholism and Drugs Annual Meeting, Vancouver British Columbia. Multidisciplinary Half-Day, McMaster University Grand Rounds, Kitchener-Waterloo Hospital 14th Annual Winter Symposium McMaster University - Dalhousie University, Deerfield Beach, Florida Basic Seminar for Physician Managers, Ontario Hospital Association Ontario Medical Association Annual Meeting Addictions '93 - University of Guelph Physician Impairment I Substance Abuse in Anaesthetists I Ambulatory Detoxification Techniques Physician Impairment I Detoxification Techniques I Recovery from Addiction! The Role of the Physician C Physician Impairment I Physician Impairment I "Grand Rounds in Medicine" I Physician Impairment I Physician Support Programs I Detoxification Techniques C Annual Meeting - Physicians Support Program, British Columbia Medical Association City-Wide OB-GYN Rounds, Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto Ontario Medical Students Weekend, McMaster University, Hamilton Telemedicine Conference Recovery from Addiction; Programme Components I Physician Impairment I Physician Stress and Substance Abuse Practical Management of the Alcoholic in the Office Addiction in Anaesthetists I Substance Abuse in the Operating Room I College of Physician and Surgeons of Ontario, Leaders in Anaesthesia Day Operating Room Nurses Annual Meeting, Ottawa 8 REV. March 2010 I I I I May 10, 1994 June 10, 1994 Norfolk General Hospital, Medical Grand Rounds Ontario Association of Medical Radiation Technologists Hamilton, ON Addictions '94 - University of Guelph June 10, 1994 Addictions '94 - University of Guelph May 13, 1994 July 19, 1994 McMaster University Institute in Addiction Studies Sept. 17, 1994 Canadian Medical Society on Alcoholism Ottawa, Ontario Sept 19, 1994 International Conference on Physician Health Plenary Session, Ottawa Ontario October 6, 1994 Basic Medical Officers Course Armed Forces Base, Barrie Oct. 14,1994 Address to Law Enforcement Officers College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario Oct. 22, 1994 12th Annual Renascent Centre Symposium Plenary Presentation Jan. 30, 1995 Ontario Psychiatric Association Annual Meeting March 29, 1995 Address to the Council, College of Nurses of Ontario April 8, 1995 Canadian Association of Chief Residents in Medicine Annual Meeting, Vancouver, British Columbia April 12, 1995 Basic Program for Physician Managers Ontario Hospital Association, Toronto April 18, 1995 Federation of Health Care Colleges Working Group Annual Meeting Mitchener Institute, Toronto April 28, 1995 Workshop American Society of Addiction Medicine Annual Meeting, Chicago, Illinois May 18, 1995 Addictions Teaching Session University of Ottawa May 24, 1995 Telemedicine Canada Medical Detox Techniques I Impairment in Health Professionals I Methadone Maintenance in I.V. Drug C Users The Health Professional Marriage C The Homewood Treatment Program I Drug Testing in the Workplace C Treatment of Impaired Physicians C Relapse Prevention I Physician Prescribing Issues I Addiction and Relapse I Group Therapy for Addicted Doctors C Incapacity in Nurses Due to Substance Abuse Resident Stress & Substance Abuse I Impaired Physicians - The Role of the Chief of Staff Fitness to Practice Issues I Group Therapy for Addicted Doctors C I I I July 17, 1995 Physician Impairment and Intercollegial Responsibility Substance Abuse in Nurses, Its Identification and Treatment 36th Annual Institute on Addiction Studies Workshop on Dual Disorders Sept. 29, 1995 Basic Medical Officers Course Substance Abuse in Physicians I Oct. 16, 1995 Canadian Medical Society of Alcohol & Other Drugs. Annual Meeting, Banff, Alberta Prescription Drug Abuse in Women and Physician Prescribing Practices C 9 REV. March 2010 I I Nov. 1, 1995 Feb. 8, 1996 April 20, 1996 April 22, 1996 British Medical Association Annual Meeting. York, England International Conference on Physician Health Chandler, Arizona Workshop for Family Doctors, Toronto The Politics of a Physician Support Programme The Role of Spirituality in the Recovery from Addiction Alcoholism in Office Practice C C I I April 26, 1996 Annual Meeting, Dupont Pharmaceuticals Plenary Session - The Varied Victoria, B.C Presentations of Addiction Ontario Bar Assistance Programme Addiction in the Legal Profession April 26, 1996 Keynote Speaker I Annual Meeting of the Addiction Intervention Association Sept. 19, 1996 Workshop for Medical Society of Prince Office Management of Alcoholism Edward Island October 1996 Chairperson, Organizing Committee, Annual Meeting Canadian Society of Toronto, ON Addiction Medicine January 1997 Women’s Health Conference Toronto, Issues of Addiction in Women, Their Ontario Recognition and Treatment Workshop presentation. February 1997 Annual Meeting, College of Family The Office Management of Practice, Alberta Chapter Plenary Alcoholism Session June 1997 Monthly Medical Rounds Henderson Impairment in Health Professionals General Hospital, Hamilton July 1997 Institute for Addiction Studies, The Pharmacotherapy of Drug McMaster University Plenary Addiction Presentation August 1997 Annual Meeting of the Canadian Bar Impairment in the Legal Profession Association, Ottawa Plenary Session September 1997 Medical Grand Rounds. Kings Health Recognition of Alcoholism in Office Centre, Toronto Practice September 1997 Basic Medical Officer Course, Base Physician Impairment Borden, Barrie, Ontario Plenary Session October 1997 Twenty-First Annual Meeting, British Physician Impairment, Recognition Doctors and Dentists in Recovery Group. and Management Brighton, England Plenary Session November 1997 Input 97. A conference for Employee What’s New in Alcoholism? Assistance Program Providers. Ottawa, Ontario Plenary Session Jan. 17, 1998 Canadian Association of Insurance Alcoholism - Morbidity and Morality Underwriters Annual Meeting, Toronto. Plenary Session Feb. 4, 1998 Basic Medical Officers Course, Base Addicted Health Professionals Borden, Barrie March 4, 1998 College of Physicians & Surgeons of Sexual Addiction Manitoba 10 REV. March 2010 I I C I I I I I I I C I I I I April 30, 1998 International Conference on Physician Paper - The Politics of a Physician Health. Health Program C May 11, 1998 Canadian Society of Medical Underwriters Alcoholism Morbidity & Morality Plenary Session I May 20, 1998 Annual Day at Newport Plenary Session Annual Meeting, American Bar Association Addictive Issues into the 21st Century, Vancouver B.C. Addicted Doctors I Impairment in Lawyers I 1.Sexual Addiction (workshop) 2.Physician Impairment (workshop) 3.Spirituality & Addiction (workshop) Recovery & Spirituality I Physician Impairment I Addiction & Mental Health in the General Hospital Addiction and the Search for Normalcy Substance Abuse in the Workplace I Identification & Management of Alcoholism (workshop) Physician Impairment I Evaluating Drug Dependency I Review of Methadone Policies I Substance Abuse in Nurses I Addiction in Physicians I Spirituality in Addiction Medicine I Spirituality in Addiction Sexual Addiction - Workshop Impaired Physicians I The Psychology of the 12-steps I August 1, 1998 August 21-22, 1998 Sept. 10, 1998 Oct.17 - 19, 1998 Nov. 2, 1998 Nov. 6, 1998 Nov. 19, 1998 November 25 26, 1998 Dec. 2, 1998 Jan. 18, 1999 Jan. 27, 1999 April 13, 1999 Annual Meeting Wayside House of Hamilton British Doctors & Dentists Annual Meeting, Manchester, England Annual Meeting, Ontario Medical Association Pragma Council, University of Waterloo 9th Annual Seminar on Substance Abuse in the Workplace Community Addiction Agencies Annual Meeting, Saskatchewan Multidisciplinary Academic Day, McMaster University Canadian Insurance Underwriters Seminar, Ottawa ON Ontario Methadone Prescribing Host C.P.S.O., Toronto ON Addictions, P.E.I April 14, 1999 Grand Rounds, Department of Psychiatry, McMaster University April 29, 1999 Ruth Fox Course for Physicians, New York, NY Aug.12-14,1999 Foundation for Medical Excellence, Vancouver B.C. Sept. 17, 1999 Annual Meeting, Canadian Psychiatric Association, Toronto Oct. 16, 1999 British Doctors & Dentists Annual Meeting, Cambridge, England Nov. 22, 1999 OMA, Physician Health Program Annual Meeting, Toronto 11 REV. March 2010 I I I I I The Politics of a Physician Health I Program Feb.13-14, 2000 Substance Abuse Symposium for Medical Professionals, Montgomery, AL Feb. 17, 2000 Physicians at Risk, McMaster University, Hamilton February 27 ALU Seminar, San Diego, California 29, 2000 March 29 2000 International Conference on April 2, 2000 Physician Health April 28 - April Washington Physicians Health Program 30, 2000 October 5 - 7, Addiction Update, Foundation for 2000 Medical Excellence, Vancouver, B.C. October 18 - 21, British Doctors, Dentists Group 25th 2000 Annual Conference, Cheltenham, England. February 2 - 4, Addiction Update Conference, 2001 Montgomery, Alabama, USA March 1, 2001 Southwest Addiction Conference, Windsor District Health Council, Windsor, Ontario June 4, 2001 Addiction Intervention Association, Annual Conference, Toronto, Ontario June 13, 2001 Insurance Underwriters of Southern Ontario June 20 – 22, Federation of Medical Licensing Assoc. 2001 Canada, Annual Meeting, St. Johns, NFL August 16 – 18, Addictive Issue Update, Foundation for 2001 Medical Excellence, Vancouver, B.C. Oct. 4–6, 2001 Nov. 19-21, 2001 Nov. 22, 2001 Feb. 8, 2002 April 12, 2002 June 12, 2002 June 27, 2002 August 17, 2002 Spirituality and Addiction Medicine I Chiefs of Staff I Recognizing Alcoholism and Treating Alcoholism Sexual Addiction, the Secret of the 90's Sexual Addiction, the Secret of the 90's Prescription Drug Abuse Workshop Sexual Addiction - Plenary Spirituality in Addiction Medicine I Spirituality in Addiction Medicine I Recognition & Treatment of Alcoholism I Substance Abuse in the Workplace I Substance Abuse in the Workplace I The Disruptive Doctor I Prescription Drug Issues Workshop Sexual Addiction – Plenary Spirituality & Addiction – Plenary Recovery & the Family Doctor I 26th Annual Addiction Conference, Harrogate, England “Update” Annual Canadian EAP Substance Abuse in the Workplace Conference, Ottawa, Ontario 39th Annual Scientific Assembly, Ontario Recovery & the Family Doctor College of Family Physicians Toronto, ON Addiction Issues in PTSD, Guelph, ON Toronto MEDICO-LEGAL Society Annual Meeting Annual Presidents & Chiefs of Staff Day, College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario, Toronto Annual Retreat, Talbott Recovery Campus, Atlanta, Georgia Addiction Conference, Aberdeen University, Scotland 12 REV. March 2010 I I I I I I I I Addiction in Lawyers I Physician Impairment I 3 PLENARY Presentations I 2 PLENARY Presentations I Sept. 23, 2002 World Drug Forum, Montreal, Quebec Oct. 27, 2002 “Spirituality and Health” University of Toronto Mental Health and Addiction Annual Meeting – Canadian Psychiatric Association, Banff, Alberta Dinner Meeting, Medical Staff, Windsor, Ontario Annual Meeting, College of Veterinarians of Ontario Annual Meeting, Federation of Licensing Medical Authorities, Quebec City Annual Meeting, College of Physicians & Surgeons of Prince Edward Island Grand Rounds, McMaster University Nov. 2, 2002 Nov. 7, 2002 Nov. 21, 2002 June 7, 2003 Oct. 1, 2003 Oct. 8, 2003 Nov.20, 2003 Jan.16, 2004 Annual Scientific Assembly, Ontario College of Family Practice “Physician Heal Thyself” Jan.21, 2004 “Substance Abuse in the Workplace” Feb. 4, 2004 Nov. 17-18, 2004 “Hospital Rounds” “Treatment of Impaired Physicians” (2) “The Psychology of the 12 Steps” Feb 28 – Nov 2005 March 9 – 10, 2005 “Addiction Treatment: Costs and Benefits” “Addiction Treatment” April 12, 2005 Grand Rounds, Medicine April 27, 2005 Grand Rounds April 28, 2005 “Disruptive Physicians” April 29, 2004 “Chronic Pain of Addiction” June 2004 – March 2005 Six presentations, contracted by College of Family Practice, to OCFP Regional Meetings covering the Province of Ontario. “Disruptive Physicians, the Ontario Experience” Oct. 13, 2004 13 REV. March 2010 Medicine & the 12 Steps I C “Chronic Pain and Opioids” I “Addiction in Health Professionals” I “The Disruptive Physician” I “Addiction and the C.P.S.O.” I “A Pot-Pouri of College Issues” I “Physician Heal Thyself” – Keynote Presentation Annual Dinner – St. Joseph’s Hospital, Hamilton – Medical Staff Guelph Chamber of Commerce Annual Meeting Homewood Health Centre Annual Meeting B.C. Physicians Health Programme, Vancouver, British Columbia American Life Underwriters Association, New Orleans, U.S Annual Meeting of Regina Regional Health Authority, Regina, Saskatchewan. Hamilton General Hospital I Henderson Hospital, Hamilton, Ontario Annual Meeting of Canadian Association of Rural Physicians, Montreal, Quebec Annual Meeting, O.M.A. Section of Chronic Pain. I I I I I I I I I I I Joint AMA – CMA International Meeting of Physician Health in Chicago I Nov. 12, 2004 “Treatment of Addiction, the Canadian Experience” Annual Meeting of the New England Professional Group, Maine I April 30 – May 2, 2005 Keynote Speaker I May 5, 2005 Grand Rounds, Medicine June 10, 2005 Grand Rounds June 17, 2005 Grand Rounds Nov. 2, 2005 “High Risk Chronic Pain Patients” Nov.17, 2005 Keynote Presentation Dec. 7, 2005 “Issues of Physician Health” Feb. 1, 2006 Keynote Presentation March 22, 2006 “Issues of Physician Health” April 24, 2006 Managing Employees with Substance Abuse Conference “Workplace Substance Abuse Issues” Annual Meeting of British Columbia Physician Health Programme, Vancouver, British Columbia Southlake Regional Hospital, Newmarket, Ontario Queen’s University, Dept. of Psychiatry, Kingston, Ontario Ottawa University, Dept. Of Psychiatry, Ottawa, Ontario Presentation to Family Physicians in North Toronto Western Canadian Conference in Addiction & Mental Health, Vancouver, British Columbia Post Graduate N.A.D. Day, McMaster University Regional Conference on Methamphetamines, Prince George, British Columbia Family Medicine Residency Core Day, University of Toronto Richmond, British Columbia Union Standards Association, Keynote Presentation Ontario Hospital Association Toronto, Ontario The College of Family Physicians of Canada Annual Meeting, University of Newfoundland & Labrador The American Bar Association National Conference, San Francisco, California 56th Annual Conference of the Canadian Psychiatric Association, Presentation Western Canadian Conference on Addictions and Mental Health 7th Annual Conference Principles of Treatment of Addiction and Substance Abuse Lexington, Kentucky I June 22, 2006 Oct. 16, 2006 Oct. 18, 2006 “Managing Addictions in the Workplace” Keynote Presentation Oct. 27, 2006 “Issues of Substance Abuse in the Legal Profession” Nov.12, 2006 “Issues of Physician Health” Nov. 18, 2006 “Myths and Misconceptions of Addiction” Keynote Presentation Jan.26-27, 2007 14 REV. March 2010 I I I I I I I I I I I I C I I March 15, 2007 Keynote Presentation on “Methamphetamine Dependency” Addiction Medicine for Family Physicians Big Land Health Conference, Goose Bay, Labrador Vancouver Island Health Authority, Victoria, British Columbia Whistler, British Columbia I Toronto, ON I Guelph, ON I May 20, 2007 The Physician Health Program of British Columbia Annual Education Conference St. John’s Rehabilitation Hospital Grand Rounds Networking Breakfast at Guelph Chamber Conference Addiction Conference Kitimat, British Columbia I June 15, 2007 Annual Education Day I Oct. 21, 2007 Association of Home Office Underwriters of America Annual Conference Presentation of “Treatment of Addictions” Department of Anesthesia & Critical Care Clinical Day Issues of Substance Department of Psychiatry, Goderich, Ontario Toronto, Ontario British Columbia Psychiatric Association Annual Meeting Southlake Regional Hospital I 2007 - Canadian Centre of Substance Abuse National Conference, Edmonton, Alberta Toronto, Ontario C Homewood Health Centre, Guelph I Bellwood Addiction Treatment Centre, Toronto, Ontario Regional Rehabilitation Program, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario Annual Meeting New Brunswick College of Family Practice I Ruth Fox Course – Ruth Fox Course is part of the American Society of Addiction Medicine Annual Meeting Monthly Meeting of Medical Staff, Windsor, Ontario Grand Rounds Department of Medicine, University of Western I March 30, 2007 April 28, 2007 May 14, 2007 May 17, 2007 Nov. 3, 2007 Nov. 10, 2007 Nov. 26, 2007 Nov. 29, 2007 Jan. 21, 2008 Feb.11, 2008 Mar. 27, 2008 April 4-5, 2008 April 10, 2008 April 24, 2008 The Evolving Role of Pharmacotherapy in Alcoholism The Evolving Role of Pharmacotherapy in Alcohol Addiction Management, Grand Rounds The Management of Alcohol Dependence Management of Chronic Pain and Addiction 1. Presentation is the 12 Steps, their clinical relevance 2. Withdrawal Management 3. Myths and Misconceptions in Addiction Spirituality and Recovery The Evolving Role of Pharmacotherapy in Alcohol Addiction Management May 12, 2008 Pain and Addiction Clinical Opponents or Siblings 15 REV. March 2010 I I I I I I I I I July 25, 2008 Presentation on Addiction in the Legal Profession Sept. 4, 2008 Alcoholics Anonymous – “What Does the Science Tell Us” Sept. 26, 2008 Treatment of Alcohol Addiction in the Elderly Oct.17, 2008 Nov.5, 2008 Pain and Addiction – Opponents on Siblings Presentation, Addiction and Pain Nov. 6, 2008 Addiction in Nurses Nov. 13, 2008 Keynote Presentation – Addiction Medicine Overview and Update – Workshop – Treating the Substance Dependent Dr. Saul Cohen Memorial Lecture Nov. 17, 2008 Nov. 20, 2008 Nov. 26, 2008 Dec. 3, 2008 Jan. 16, 2009 Mar. 6, 2009 April 23, 2009 May 29, 2009 Oct. 1, 2009 1) Substance Abuse in the Workplace 2) The Management of Addiction in the Community and in Residential Treatment Chronic Pain in Addiction: Issues, Management and the Perspective of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario Mental Health Issues in Today’s Workforce “Management of the Difficult Adolescent. Drug & Alcohol Issues.” Physician Health, Spirituality and Recovery Keynote Presentation: Alcoholic Anonymous, a Design for Living that Really Works Intervening and Managing Addictions in the Workplace Chronic & Addiction. Problems and Solutions Oct. 27, 2009 Keynote Presentation: Managing Addictions in the Workplace. 16 REV. March 2010 Ontario Annual Meeting of the Ontario Lawyer’s Assistance Program I Annual Meeting of the Canadian Psychiatric Association, Vancouver, B.C. 54th Annual Scientific Assembly, College of Family Practice, Saskatchewan, Saskatoon Neuroscience Update, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario McMaster University – Academic Pain Day Ontario Nurses Association Union Annual Meeting, Toronto, Ontario Canadian Conference in Addiction 5th Annual Meeting C Credit Valley Hospital, Mississauga, Ontario Substance Abuse Seminar to the Substance Abuse Representatives of the major Automotive Unions I I I I I I I Interdisciplinary Pain Rounds, University of Western Ontario I Homewood Employee Health Annual Conference Walter School District, Delta, B.C. Ultimate Education Annual Meeting Alberta Medical Association Annual Spring Meeting, Edmonton, Alberta Embrace the Future of Addiction, Salvation Army Harbor Light Addictions Conference,Toronto,ON Workplace Mental Health Toronto Board of Trade First Canadian Trade, Toronto, Ontario Canadian Healthcare Anti-Fraud Association, Toronto, ON Drug and Alcohol Council for Safe Alberta Workplaces, Edmonton, I I I I Nov. 6, 2009 Nov. 19, 2009 Jan. 13, 2010 Feb. 24, 2010 Feb. 26, 2010 Concurrent Workshop: Are Addictions a Symptom of an Underlying Root Cause “There is a Solution” Chronic Pain Stress in Addictions: Problems & Solutions Addiction Medicine Perspectives: Addiction & Disability Alcoholics Anonymous: What does the science tell us? Keynote Presentation: Physician Heal Thyself: A Doctor’s Story Workshop Presentation: Alcoholics Anonymous: What does the Science Tell Us Alberta Winnipeg, MB Opening Speaker at the conference I Critical Incident Reenactment Conference, Hamilton Place Medical Legal Conference – Canada Pension Plan Disability, Ottawa, ON Psychiatry and Behavioral Neurosciences Grand Rounds, McMaster University, Department of Psychiatry Banff Alberta 55th Annual Scientific Assembly, Alberta College of Family Physicians I ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSIBILITIES: As Director of the Addiction Division at the Homewood Health Centre, I am responsible for a budget using a program management model of $7.5 million dollars annually as well as 100 full-time multi-disciplinary staff members. I head the Management Team and I am ultimately responsible to the Executive of the Homewood Health Centre for revenue generation and academic marketing. As a member of Council of the College of Physicians & Surgeons, and President of the College for 2003, I have had extensive administrative experience both of self-regulation of the medical profession as well as in the development of a governance model for the Province’s self-regulatory body. I also chaired a working group that developed the first clinical guidelines in the use of Methadone in chronic non-cancer pain.These are the first such guidelines in North America. I chaired the Search Committee for the appointment of the new Registrar of the College of Physicians & Surgeons. As part of my intense interest in physician health, I led the development of the Physician Health Programme of the Ontario Medical Association in 1995. As chair of the Standards Committee of the Canadian Society of Addiction Medicine, I led in the development of national standards to allow for assessment and examination of physicians knowledgeable and practicing in the field of Addiction Medicine. 17 REV. March 2010 I I I OTHER RESPONSIBILITIES: President, Timmins & District Shriners Club, (1984). Member, Granite Masonic Lodge, #356, Parry Sound, Ontario (1978-current) Board Member, Wellington & Dufferin District Health Council (1996 - 1999) 18 REV. March 2010 PAUL H. EARLEY, M.D., F.A.S.A.M. Talbott Recovery Campus 5448 Yorktowne Drive Atlanta, Georgia 30349 USA [email protected] www.talbottcampus.com www.paulearley.net Office Voice: 678.251.3188 Office Facsimile: 770.991.4909 PERSONAL INFORMATION Date of Birth Place of Birth March 29, 1954 Cincinnati, Ohio EDUCATION 1971 to 1975 1976 to 1980 1980 to 1981 1981 to 1984 1992 to 1995 B.A. in Biology, Reed College, Portland, Oregon M.D., University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Cincinnati, Ohio Internship in Internal Medicine, Good Samaritan Hospital and Medical Center, Portland, Oregon Residency in Neurology, University of Oregon Health Sciences Center, Portland, Oregon Three year training for certification in PBSP Psychomotor Therapy PROFESSIONAL STATUS Board Certified in Addiction Medicine by the American Board of Addiction Medicine, 2009 Fellow of the American Society of Addiction Medicine, December, 1996 Diplomate of the National Board of Medical Examiners, July 1, 1981. Licensed to practice medicine in Georgia (license #30454). Licensed to practice medicine in Oregon (license #12784). Certified through examination by the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM), 1986 (cert. 000029). Recertified, December, 1996 ASAM Certified Medical Review Officer, 1996 WORK HISTORY Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 2 - 2007 to Present Medical Director, Director Healthcare Professionals Program, Talbott Recovery Campus, Atlanta, Georgia USA 1991 to 2006 Program Director of Adult Addiction Medicine, Ridgeview Institute, Smyrna, Georgia. 1991 to 2006 Medical Director of the Ridgeview Impaired Professional’s Program, Ridgeview Institute, Smyrna, Georgia. 1991 to 2006 President and Senior Partner at Earley Associates, a 4 member group practice in founded in 1986 with offices in Smyrna and Alpharetta Georgia. The practice specialized in Addiction Medicine, the care of Impaired Professionals, and Professional Wellness. 2002 to 2005 Chief Science Officer, CMHC Systems, Inc. CMHC Systems is the leading provider of clinical and financial software solutions to the behavioral healthcare industry (see Computers in Medicine heading below). 1994 to 2002 Founder and Chief Science Officer, Earley Corporation. Earley Corporation developed clinical management software for the behavioral healthcare industry. (See Computer Software heading below) 1986 to 1991 Program Director, Counterpoint Center (Adult Addiction Medicine Program) at CPC Parkwood Hospital, Atlanta, Georgia. 1984 to 1991 Physician, Private Practice, Specializing in Addiction Medicine and Eating Disorders, Atlanta and Decatur, Georgia 1984 to 1985 Associate Medical Director, Eating Disorders Program and Substance Abuse Treatment Unit, Decatur Hospital, Decatur, Georgia. 1977 to 1980 Research Associate in Neurology and Electrodiagnostics. University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Cincinnati, Ohio 1975 to 1976 Research Associate in Neuroendocrinology. Reed College, Portland, Oregon Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 3 - PUBLICATIONS Earley, P. Physicians Health Programs and Addiction among Physicians in the American Society of Addiction Medicine’s Principles of Addiction Medicine, Fourth Edition (eds Ries, Miller, Fiellin, Salitz) Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins, 2009. Regger, J., Ansseau, M., Gustin, F., Pirard, S., Van Deun, P., Seghers, A., Earley, P. Besson, J. and Gastfriend, D. Adaptation and validation of the ASAM PPC-2R criteria in French and Dutch speaking Belgian drug-addicts. Paper at CPDD Conference, 2004. Talbott, G.D., Earley, P. Addiction in the Health Professional Section 9, Chapter 5 in the American Society of Addiction Medicine’s Principles of Addiction Medicine, Third Edition. (eds Graham, Schultz, Mayo-Smith, Ries, and Wilford) ASAM Press, 2003. Substance Abuse Related Disorders a chapter in the monograph Problem Physicians, a National Perspective a monograph published by the problem physician workgroup and subsequently endorsed by physician health programs across the United States (First Edition 1995, second edition 1998). Earley, Paul H., Fishman, Michael L. The Road to Recovery: Chemical Dependence and Treatment Today. Insight Magazine, 18(2), Fall, 1997. Earley, Paul H., Fishman, Michael L. The M-Deity Syndrome: Help for the Impaired Health Professional. Insight Magazine, 16(2), Fall, 1995. Harris, Steve, Earley, Paul H. The Icarus Phenomenon: Power Dilemmas on the Road to Manhood. Insight Magazine, 14(1):6-9, 1993. Fishman, Michael L., Earley, Paul H. Nicotine Dependence in Treatment Centers: The Next Challenge. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 1993. Earley, Paul H. The Changing Face of Addiction: Is Everything I do an Addiction? Insight Magazine, 12(3):2-7, 1992. Earley, Paul H. The Cocaine Recovery Book, Newbury Park, California: Sage Publications, 1991. Earley, Paul H. The Cocaine Recovery Workbook, Newbury Park, California: Sage Publications, 1991. Earley, Paul H., Dickey, C. The Cocaine Addict, Principles of Identification and Treatment. Mental Health Notes of the Georgia Division of NMHA, 40:5-7 (1986). Earley, Paul H. Implementation of the Morrow M26 Hard Disk System in the S100 Environment. Microsystems 3:26 (1981). Arch, S., Earley, P. and Smock, T. Biochemical Isolation and Physiological Identification Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 4 - of the Egg-Laying Hormone in Aplysia californica. Journal of Gen. Physiol. 68:197-210 (1976). Arch, S., Smock, T. and Earley, P. Precursor and Product Processing in the Bag Cells of Aplysia californica. Journal of Gen. Physiol.68:211-225 (1976). Earley, Paul H. Isolation and Characterization of Hormonal Proteins Synthesized in the Bag Cells of Aplysia californica B.A. Thesis, Reed College, Portland, Oregon (1975). MEDIA APPEARANCES Close to Home a five part series produced for public television by the award winning documentary filmmaker Bill Moyers featured Paul Earley and his work at Ridgeview Institute in Part 3 – Changing Lives. Premiered nationally on the Public Broadcasting System on March 29, 1998. Oprah Winfrey Show. Invited as expert and appeared on an Oprah Winfrey Show to discuss the Bill Moyer’s documentary: Close to Home, Chicago, Illinois, August, 1998 Turning Point: from Hollywood to Main Street Appeared in this ABC News hour long prime time special as an expert on heroin addiction. May, 1995. Oprah Winfrey Show. Invited as expert and appeared on an Oprah Winfrey Show focused on heroin addiction, Chicago, Illinois, October, 1994. PRESENTATIONS Ten Emotionally Unintelligent Things that Health Care Providers Do. One hour plenary presentation at the Health Care Consortium of Georgia’s Annual Meeting. March 2011. An Introduction to RecoveryMind Training. One hour presentation at the Arizona Chapter of the American Society of Addiction Medicine’s Annual Meeting. February, 2011. Brain Models and Psychotherapy. Three hour training before the Imago Training Faculty at Annual Imago International Conference, November, 2010. What really happens in Addiction Treatment? One hour presentation at the Louisiana Psychiatric Association fall conference. November, 2010. Relationships and Recovery. Three hour Workshop presenting with Wanda Faurie, Ph.D. at the North Carolina Physicians Health Program Biennial Retreat, October 2010. Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 5 - Assessing Readiness to Return to Work: the MPARI Project, One hour Presentation at the AMA/CMA International Conference on Physician Health, Chicago, Illinois, October 2010. Clinical Presentation: Injectable Naltrexone in the Treatment of Opioid Dependence before the FDA Advisory Board considering expanding the indication of Vivitrol for the treatment of Opioid Dependence, September 2010. The Assessment and Treatment of Alcohol Problems in Commercial Pilots One hour presentation at the annual HIMS Conference in Denver Colorado, September 2010. Controversies and Lessons Learned From The Treatment of Addiction in Physicians. 2010 New Advances in Addiction Medicine Conference in Phoenix, AZ, March, 2010. Addiction in the Workplace: Improving Patient Outcomes. Second Annual Mississippi Addiction Conference in Jackson, MS, January 2010. 96-Hour Assessment for Pharmacy Professionals. Southwestern Pharmacists Recovery Network Conference in Sedona, AZ, September 2009. Recognizing and Diagnosing Alcoholic Physician and Treating the Addicted Physician: The Talbott Model. Keynote address and presentation at Ardere, Non Bruciarsi, the Italian Conference on Physician Health sponsored by the Centro di Formazione Albert Schweitzer. Turin, Italy, September 2009. Addiction Memory and Craving: Clearing a Path to Recovery. American Dental Association Conference in Chicago, IL, September 2009. Teetering on the Brink of Collapse: Treating the Addicted Physician. Georgia Psychiatric Physicians Association Conference in Amelia Island, FL, August 2009. Conducted Two-Day Workshop for the Addiction and Recovery Ministry Conference in Langley, British Columbia, June 2009. Neurochemistry and Medications in Addiction Treatment. Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario Council Meeting in Toronto, Ontario, May 2009 Pearls in Assessing the Impaired Dentist. Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario Council Meeting in Toronto, Ontario, May 2009. Addiction in the Operating Room. Wake Forest University in Winston Salem, North Carolina, May 2009 Current Controversies in the Treatment of Physician Impairment. 2009 Federation State Physician Health Programs Annual Meeting and Conference in New Orleans, Louisiana, April 2009. Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 6 - Current Dilemmas in the Treatment of the Impaired Professional. AP Webinar - Vendom Group in Atlanta, Georgia, April 2009. All Day Training Program. 2009 SCSCSW Conference in Charleston, South Carolina, February 2009. Addiction as a Chronic Disease: The Challenge of Best Practice and the Best Care Environments. 2009 SECAD Conference in Atlanta, Georgia, February 2009. Current Dilemmas in the Treatment of Impaired Professionals. 2009 SECAD Conference in Atlanta, Georgia, February 2009. Changes in Addiction Treatment – The Good, Bad and the Indifferent. 2009 CAPTASA Conference in Lexington, Kentucky, January 2009. A literature review of addiction in physicians. 2008 International Conference on Doctors Health in London, England, United Kingdom, November 2008. Course Director. ASAM Review Course in Addiction Medicine in Chicago, Illinois, October 2008. Addiction Craving and Addiction Memory: Clearing a Path to Recovery. EAPA’s 2008 Annual World EAP Conference in Atlanta, Georgia, October 2008. Assessment and Triage of the Opioid Addict. 2008 Florida Academy of Family Physicians Summer Break Away Conference in Naples, Florida, June 2008. What Makes a Case Difficult? Learning From Our Experience. 2008 Federation of State Physician Health Programs in San Antonio, Texas, April 2008. How to Recognize and Intervene Effectively on the Spectrum of Addictive Disorders. 15th Annual A&D Conference in Columbia, South Carolina, January 2008. Is Buprenorphine Maintenance Recovery? Presentation at SECAD 2007 in Atlanta, Georgia. November 2007. Trauma and Memory. 2007 Carolinas Conference on Addiction and Recovery in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. November 2007. The Neurochemistry of Addiction and the Hope of New Medications. EAPA meeting in San Diego, California. October 2007. The Neurochemistry of Addiction and the Hope of New Medications. Presentation at Cape Cod Symposium on Addictive Disorders. September 2007. Deception in the Evaluation of the Professional Patient. Southeastern Regional Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 7 - Conference of the Federation State Physician Health Programs, Virginia Beach, Virginia. September 2007. The Impaired Physician. Presentation at Orange County Medical Society in Orlando, Florida. September 2007 Addiction Memory in Addiction Recovery and Medications and Brain Neurochemistry Two presentations at the Neuroscience Meets Recovery annual conference in Las Vegas, Nevada. March 2007. Addiction Memory in Addiction Recovery. Three hour workshop at the Southeastern Conference on Addiction (SECAD) December 2006. Medications and Brain Neurochemistry: New Hope in the Treatment of Addiction. Two hour presentation at the National Employee Assistance Professionals Association, September 2006. PPC-2R – Where has it come and where are we going? Presentation at the National Association of Addiction Treatment Providers National Conference Phoenix Arizona May 22, 2005. ASAM PPC-2R Assessment Software Research: Evidence for a New International Standard. Symposium at the American Society of Addiction Medicine’s 36th Annual Medical Scientific Conference April 16th, 2005 Evaluating Impairment in Psychologists, Lecture at the 2004 Association of State and Provincial Psychology Boards. October 22, 2004. ASAM: Patient Placement Criteria Presentation at the 2004 NAADAC Annual Conference, October 7, 2004. The Crucible of Addiction Treatment Where the Twelve Steps, Psychotherapy and Pharmacotherapy Collide - Workshop at the National Association of Addiction Treatment Providers (NAATP) Conference, May 18, 2004 Same conference in a three hour workshop to 100 participants at Ridgeview Institute, Sept 12, 2004. Not in the Service of Your Disease: The Life Work of Thomas Butcher, Ph.D. Presented at the Southeastern Conference on Alcohol and Drugs (SECAD), December 3, 2003. Evidence-based Medicine and Behavioral Health - Talk at the CMHC user Group meeting in Columbus Ohio, May 3, 2003. Similar talk presented May 15, 2004. What’s New in Addiction Medicine: Recent Developments in Medications and Addiction Assessment, 2003 Presented at the Southeastern Conference on Alcohol and Drugs (SECAD), December 4, 2002 Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 8 - The Therapeutic Community: Its Power and Purpose in the Treatment of Disease. Three hour workshop presented with Branko Radulovacki, M.D., 11 October 2002 at Ridgeview Institute, Atlanta, Georgia. Addiction and the Health Professional. Grand Rounds presentation to North Georgia Medical Center July, 2002, Gainesville, Georgia. The ASAM PPC-2R Algorithm Software. Workshop at the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) annual Medical-Scientific Conference, April, 2002. Attorneys and Diseases of Self-Care. Presentation to the NOSSCAR Conference, June, 2002. Interacting with the Addicted Patient - Tricks of the Trade. Three hour experiential workshop for 80 participants, presented June, 2001, Ridgeview Institute, Atlanta, Georgia. The Drug Menagerie. A three part series of talks, totaling over 10 hours of training presented in April, August and October, 2000 at Ridgeview Institute to physicians, psychologists and masters level therapists for training in Addiction Medicine. Computers and Internet Addiction. Presentation to the Southeastern Conference of the National EAP Professionals, September 2000. Outpatient Detoxification - Ambulatory Detoxification in an Outpatient Setting. One Hour Presentation at Ridgeview Institute, Smyrna, Georgia, January 8, 1997. Clinical Technologies - Design Issues in Measuring Outcomes with Various Treatment Populations. Two Hour Presentation at Clinical Technologies Conference, Phoenix, Arizona, November 11 - 14, 1996. Appropriate Prescribing of Controlled Substances. Two Hour Presentation at Mercer University School of Pharmacy, Atlanta, Georgia, October 8, 1996. New Paradigms in the Treatment of Addiction. Two Hour Presentation at Ridgeview Institute’s Clinical Series for Professionals, August 23, 1996. Managing Medications in Physician Patients. Two Hour presentation at 1996 International Conference on Physician Health Sponsored by AMA, February 7-10, 1996, Chandler, Arizona. Georgia Licensing Board, Medical Society, and Treatment Centers Working Together with Problem Physicians: A Cooperative Paradigm. Two Hour presentation at the 1996 International Conference on Physician Health Sponsored by AMA, February 7 - 10, 1996, Chandler, Arizona. Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 9 - Appropriate Prescribing of Controlled Substances - Mechanisms for Proper Practice within the System. 4.5 Hour Training and Lecture for Center for Substance Abuse Education, Mercer University, Atlanta, Georgia. The ASAM PPC-2: Criteria for Diagnosis and Treatment. One Hour Presentation to Mississippi Association of Recovering Pharmacists for Addiction: Your Personal & Professional Responsibility, Conference, Jackson, Mississippi, October 15, 1995. Identification, Treatment and Ethical Dilemmas in the Care of Impaired Professionals. Two Hour Workshop presented to the Alabama Psychological Association Annual Meeting, Gulf Shores, Alabama, May, 1995. New Paradigms for the Care of Addicted Physician Assistants. Two Hour Workshop at the 1995 International Conference of Physician Assistants, Las Vegas, Nevada, May, 1995. Addiction Training of House Staff - Medical Center of Central Georgia, Macon, Georgia, August, 1995. Facets of Substance Abuse - Theories and Research/Application and Treatment Facets of Substance Abuse - Clinical Pharmacology and Assessment/Continuum of Care and Outcome Research. Three day Workshop Preserving and Expanding our Profession, The American Psychological Association, New Orleans, Louisiana, March, 1995. Identification of Addictive Disease in the Primary Care Setting. In-house staff training at The Medical Center of Central Georgia, September, 1994. Creating a Smoke-free Environment and Counseling Techniques for Creating Change in Staff and Patients. Four hours of presentation at The 2nd Annual Southwest Conference on Nicotine Dependence, June 5, 1993, Houston, Texas. The Impaired Physician. One hour presentation at: Saving our own - The Impaired Healthcare Professional, May 14, 1993, Atlanta, Georgia. Nicotine Dependence: Making Your Facility Smoke Free. Three hour conference at The 24th Annual Medical-Scientific Conference of the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM), May 1, 1993, Los Angeles, California. Understanding Addictions: Assessment and Therapy. Six hour workshop at the Annual Meeting of the Georgia Psychological Association, April 14, 1993, Atlanta, Georgia. Addiction and Medication Management - The Dual Diagnosis Dilemma. One hour presentation at the medical staff meeting of Ridgeview Institute, April 7, 1993, Smyrna, Georgia. Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 10 - New Hope for Treatment Failures: Rethinking Addiction Treatment. One hour presentation on the dual diagnosis, childhood trauma, and the use of experiential treatment for addicted populations. A Ridgeview Education Series Lecture. January 29, 1993, Smyrna, Georgia. Documentation in the 90's: Patient Records Workshop. All day workshop concerning improving the quality of the medical record in medical treatment. September 28, 1992, Detroit, Michigan; September 30, 1992, Kansas City, Missouri; October 2, 1992, Atlanta, Georgia. Addressing Nicotine in Chemical Dependency Programs and Nicotine Dependence Treatment in Addicted Patients. Two 1 hour presentations at the Fifth National Conference of Nicotine Dependence, American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM). The Goals and Directions of the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM). Presentation at the First Annual Georgia ASAM and Georgia aaPaa Joint Scientific Conference, October 4, 1991, St. Simons, Georgia. Cocaine Addiction: Treatment Strategies for the 1990's. Presentation at the Northeastern Conference on Addictions (NECAD), May 21, 1991, Newport, Rhode Island. Is Nicotine Dependence Like Other Addictions? Presentation at the First Annual Southeastern Conference on Nicotine Dependence. March 22, 1991, Atlanta, Georgia. A Neurobiological and Behavioral Approach to the Treatment of Cocaine Addiction. Three hour conference at The 21st Annual Medical-Scientific Conference of the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM), April 23, 1990, Phoenix, Arizona. Cocaine: The Addiction of the 1980's and Current concept in cocainism. Two seminars to the Professional Development Series, August 17, 1989, New Orleans, Louisiana. The Therapy of Cocainism, An Integrated Approach. Three hour workshop at The 20th Annual Medical-Scientific Conference of the American Medical Society on Alcoholism and Other Drug Dependencies (AMSAODD, now ASAM), April 30, 1989, Atlanta, Georgia. The Neurophysiology of Addiction and Denial. Presentation at the International PRIDE Conference, April 11, 1989, Atlanta, Georgia. Drug Specific Relapse Prevention. Lecture at The Seventh National Impaired Nurse Symposium, March 12, 1989, Atlanta, Georgia. Cocainism: Using the Scientific Literature to Redefine Treatment. Three hour workshop at The 19th Annual Medical-Scientific Conference of the American Medical Society on Alcoholism and Other Drug Dependencies (AMSAODD, now ASAM), April 22, 1988, Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 11 - Arlington, Virginia. The Disease of Addiction. Presentation at the International PRIDE Conference, April 14, 1988, Atlanta, Georgia. The History and Physiology of Cocaine; the Central Nervous System Effects of Cocaine; and the Inpatient Treatment of Cocaine Dependence. Three lectures at Cocaine: A Seminar for Professionals The University of Alabama Conference Series, June 4, 1987, Birmingham, Alabama. Cocaine, the Addiction of the 1980s. Feature speech at the Southeastern Regional conference of ALMACA (Association of Labor/Management Administrators and Consultants on Alcoholism), February 23, 1987, New Orleans, Louisiana. Dealing with Addiction in Your Practice: the Nuts and Bolts. Forum Presentation with Judith Knight Earley, Ph.D. at the Georgia Psychological Association Mid-Winter Conference, February 6, 1987, St. Simons, Georgia. The Diagnosis and Treatment of Eating Disorders Fall Workshop Series, National Association of Social Workers. Eight hour seminar with Judith Knight Earley, Ph.D., September 19, 1986, Atlanta, Georgia. The Neuropsychology of Starvation and the Treatment of Eating Disorders. Four hour seminar at the Division E Conference of the Georgia Psychological Association, 1986, Atlanta, Georgia. The Treatment of Addictions in the Ethnic Community. Lecture at the yearly conference on Mental Health in the Ethnic Community, Mental Health Association of Metropolitan Atlanta, 1985. Sociocultural aspects of a New Disease Epidemic. Lecture to the Emory University Freshman Class concerning eating disorders, 1985-88 academic years. The Assessment and Treatment of Eating Disorders in the Inpatient Milieu. Lecture at the University of Georgia, June 3, 1985, Athens, Georgia. Computerization of the Neuroscientific Laboratory. Lecture and Seminar at the 23rd Annual Academy of Neurology Meetings, 1983, San Diego, California. PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS Medical Association of Georgia. American Medical Association. Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 12 - American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM): Board of Directors, Director at Large, 2011 to Present Director, ASAM Board Certification Review Course, 2010 to Present Chair, Physicians Health Committee, 2009 to Present Board of Directors, ex-officio 1995 to 1997, Regional Director, 1997 to 2005 Certification Examination Test Development Committee, 1989 to 1993. State Chapters Committee, Chairman, 1990 to 2001 Georgia Chapter of the American Society of Addiction Medicine (Georgia ASAM) President of the Georgia Chapter of ASAM, 1989 to 1996 National Psychiatric Alliance, Outcomes Research Project, 1993 to 1997. Phi Beta Kappa Scholastic Fraternity. CAREER SPECIALIZATION Addiction Medicine Physician Health Long-term therapy of Addiction Recovery Computers in Medical Care, computers as tools for change in behavioral medicine. COMPUTERS IN MEDICINE 1989 Developed TxPlan® Clinical Management Software the first comprehensive software designed to use the treatment plan to guide daily treatment by a multidisciplinary treatment team in inpatient and outpatient behavioral healthcare settings. 1990 Founded Earley Corporation to continue developing TxPlan and market the product to the behavioral healthcare industry. 1995 TxPlan installed in over 200 organizations throughout the United States. 1997 - 1999 TxPlan II developed for the Windows environment and Microsoft SQL Server. Development partially funded by SBIR Grant #R44AA11235 from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA). Dr. Earley was the principle investigator in this grant. Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Paul H. Earley, M.D. Page - 13 - 2000 Lead developer on the computerized version of the American Society of Addiction Medicine’s Patient Placement Criteria for the treatment of Psychoactive Substance Disorders, Version 2, Revised (ASAM PPC-2R). Development funded in part by SBIR Grant #R44-AA12004 from NIAAA. Dr. Earley was the principle investigator in this grant. 2002 Earley Corporation merged with CMHC Systems, Inc. Dr. Earley becomes Chief Science Officer of CMHC Systems, Inc. His work at CMHC Systems continues to focus on the computerization of the ASAM PPC-2R. 2003 Participated in the French and German-speaking European conference on Addiction. Presented research findings on the PPC2R in conjunction with the University of Liege, Belgium. 2009 to Present Research coordinator in the joint United States / Norwegian research team on the applicability of the ASAM PPC-2R Computer Software for the Trondheim District, Norway. Version 3.1, Feb 2011 Curriculum Vitae (Short Version) John T. Palmer, 32597, Verdon Way, Abbotsford, British Columbia, Canada, V2T7Y3 Phone (Home): 604 853 4370 (Work): 604 853 0089 (Fax) : 604 853 0992 Email: [email protected] EDUCATION Master’s Degree in Counselling (Trinity Western University) – June 2001 - focus on Marriage & Family and Addiction counselling. Continuing Clinical Counselling Education Seminars and Workshops to maintain active registration as a Clinical Counsellor with the British Columbia Association of Clinical Counsellors (2001 – 2012). This includes: Western Canadian Conference on Addictions and Mental Health (2003 – 2010) Biennial National Institute on Dentist Well-BeingAmerican Dental Association (2001- 2009) Gottman Method Couples’ Therapy (Levels I&2) Emotionally Focused Therapies for Individuals and Couples (Externships completed) Motivational Interviewing for Addictions Cognitive Therapies for Addictions, Depression and Anxiety Disorders. Batchelor of Dental Surgery (University of Dundee, Scotland) 1973 (with merit in Dental Jurisprudence) Current Position Director: Dental Profession Advisory Program (DPAP Counselling) BC Dental Association (2001 – present) Adjunct Faculty Member, Dean’s Office, UBC Faculty of Dentistry (appointed 2011) John T. Palmer Curriculum Vitae (March 2012) Relevant Work Experience General dental practice (1973 – 1976) Manchester, England (1976 – 1996) St, John’s, Newfoundland Providing individual counselling and proactive mental health educational seminars, and workshops to members of the BC Dental Association and BC Certified Dental Assistants Association (2001 – present). Advocating for Registrants of the BC College of Dental Surgeons who are under sanction by the College and undergoing treatment for impairment as a result of physical illness, mental illness or substance use/ dependency. (2001 – present). Seminar Co-presenter: UBC Faculty of Dentistry Orientation Week – “Taking Care of Yourself in Dental School” (2001 – Present) Presentation of workshops on Motivational Interviewing, American Dental Association Biennial National Institute on Dentist Well-Being (2005, 2007). Invited Closing Speaker, 2007. CAROLYN THOMSON, MD, CCFP, FCFP 23 Caitland Court, Halifax, NS B3N 3K1 Cell: (902) 483-1380 ٠ [email protected] PROFILE Passionate about physician health as reflected in continuing medical education and advocacy within the medical community. Recognize and support the unique wellness needs of physicians and their families. Balancing roles as a family physician, faculty member and educator at Dalhousie Family Medicine and coordinator of the Professionals’ Support Program at Doctors Nova Scotia As former hospital department head, have developed exceptional organizational, planning, and administrative skills while continuing to provide a high standard of patient care Experienced physician with demonstrated expertise in program development as a CME consultant as a champion for the Primary Maternity Care Program at the IWK Health Centre. . EDUCATION RESIDENCY IN FAMILY MEDICINE Dalhousie University Medical School, Halifax, NS Chief Resident 1990 – 1991 INTERNSHIP IN FAMILY MEDICINE Dalhousie University Medical School, Halifax, NS 1989 – 1990 MEDICAL DOCTOR DEGREE Dalhousie University Medical School, Halifax, NS Lawrence Max Green Memorial Award in Obstetrics 1985 – 1989 BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN BIOLOGY – Cum Laude Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS 1982 – 1985 RELEVANT CONTINUING MEDICAL EDUCATION National and International Conferences on Physician Health, (2004, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011) Leadership and Physician Health Workshop, Dr. Mamta Gautam, Halifax, NS (2003) Physician Health for Physician Leaders, Canadian Medical Association (2004) Intensive Coach Training Program, College of Executive Coaching, Phoenix, Arizona (2007) Physician Coaching Advanced Training Program, Physician Coaching Institute, Seattle, Washington, (2007) Annual Forum on Primary Health Care, Toronto, ON (2006) Physician Manager Institute – Levels I and II (2006, Levels III and IV (Sept. 2007), Canadian Medical Association AGM Canadian Society of Physician Executives, Ottawa, ON (2007 & 2010) CAROLYN THOMSON, MD, CCFP, FCFP Page 2 Problem Based Small Group Learning, The Foundation for Medical Practice Education, Hamilton, ON (2000 – 2007) Psychotherapy & Counseling for Family Physicians, University of Toronto, (2011-2012) WORK EXPERIENCE COORDINATOR, PROFESSIONALS’ SUPPORT PROGRAM Doctors Nova Scotia December 2009- Present The PSP program provides confidential support and resources for physicians, dentists, veterinarians and their families that are struggling with substance abuse, mental illness, burnout, stress and family issues. It also provides education around health and wellness topics and advocacy for those facing regulatory and legal issues. CHIEF, FAMILY MEDICINE IWK Health Centre, Halifax, NS May 2006 – December 2011 Department of Family Medicine consists of 100+ community-based and academic family physicians that provide maternity, newborn, and pediatric emergency care at the IWK Health Centre. The department is affiliated with Dalhousie University Department of Family Medicine. Reporting directly Executive Leadership Team, provide leadership and strategic direction to department members, and oversee the administration and functioning of the department which includes Antenatal Clinics, Newborn Care Service, and Primary Maternity Care Program. Conceptualized and developed an innovative pilot – Primary Maternity Care Program – a collaborative care model aimed at decreasing workload and burnout of all family doctors in the community while providing a high standard of maternity/neonatal care in the hospital. Act as an advocate for family doctors to ensure their interests are represented within the hospital and in the community through committee participation and relationship development with stakeholders, other departments, nursing staff, executive leadership team, Doctors Nova Scotia, etc. Actively participate in the strategic planning and resource allocation and utilization for the IWK Health Centre, with a dual role as Chief of Family Medicine and as a practicing family physician. Lead the development of the department’s mission, objectives, strategic plans and operating budget Annually review the professional conduct, competence, performance, and qualifications of departmental members for purpose of making recommendations for reappointments, change of privileges, and possible disciplinary actions Facilitate and support teaching, continuing education, and research within the department Hold and chair regular executive and departmental meetings FACULTY/ DALHOUSIE FAMILY MEDICINE Halifax, NS Clinical practice, teaching and obstetrics 2009-Present FAMILY MEDICINE/OBSTETRICS 1997 – 2009 Sunnyside Family Practice, Bedford, NS A group practice of six family physicians serving a diverse practice population from newborns to geriatrics, with an individual caseload of up to 3,000 patients CAROLYN THOMSON, MD, CCFP, FCFP Page 3 Provide leadership to colleagues and staff on partnership practices, locum coverage, human resources, and patient satisfaction 1994 – 1997 PARTNER, FAMILY MEDICINE/EMERGENCY/OBSTETRICS R.B. White Clinic, Penticton, BC A group practice of 25 partners and associates who provide both inpatient and outpatient care in a small community SHIP PHYSICIAN – EMERGENCY/PRIMARY CARE Holland America Line, Seattle Washington, DC 1993 – 1994 1993 EMERGENCY ROOM PHYSICIAN Saint John Regional Hospital & St. Joseph’s Hospital, Saint John, NB FAMILY MEDICINE/EMERGENCY/OBSTETRICS (LOCUMS) Hokianga Health Service, Northland, New Zealand Dr. Russell Meads, Ohope, New Zealand Fourth Avenue Family Practice, Tauranga, New Zealand 1992 – 1993 FAMILY PRACTICE/OBSTETRICS (LOCUM) Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS 1991 – 1992 EMERGENCY ROOM PHYSICIAN Department of Emergency, Victoria General Hospital, Halifax, NS 1991 – 1992 CURRENT MEMBERSHIPS Certificant, Canadian College of Family Physicians Fellow, Canadian College of Family Physicians N.S. College of Family Physicians College of Physicians and Surgeons of Nova Scotia Department of Family Medicine, Dalhousie Family Medicine Canadian Medical Association Doctors Nova Scotia Canadian Physician Health Network COMMITTEES: Steering Committee, Capital Health District Department of Family Practice (2006-07) Educational Consultant (development and facilitation of programs), Continuing Medical Education for Family Physicians (1999-2009) National Committee on CME, Canadian College of Family Physicians (1998-03) CME Representative and Accreditor, N.S College of Family Physicians (1998-03) Doctors Nova Scotia Negotiation Steering Committee (2001) Interdisciplinary Working Group on Legislation of Midwifery in Nova Scotia (1997-98) Council Member, Capital Health District Department of Family Medicine (2008- 2011) District Department of Family Medicine Executive (2008-2011) CAROLYN THOMSON, MD, CCFP, FCFP IWK Committees: Chair, Executive Committee Department of Family Medicine Medical Advisory Committee Women's and Newborn Health Program Operations Committee Family and Newborn Health Committee Neonatal Care Committee Models of Care Committee Nova Scotia Reproductive Care Program Peer Review Midwifery Committee Page 4
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz