DALHOUSIE
REVIEW
CONTENTS OF VOLUME LI
.
•
v .
t ■
H A L IF A X , N O V A S C O T IA
CANADA
Published Quarterly by
Dalhousie University Press Limited
Annual Subscripion $4.00
$22
THE DALHOUSIE REVIEW
C O N TEN TS OF VOLUM E LI
. >.
A R TIC LES
s,
..
B aker, R. J. Natural Selection, Onomastics, and Population Control: The
Shufflebottom Hypothesis ...................................................................................
332
D ial, R oger L. Mao Tse-Tung: On his Rationality and Marxist Legitimacy..
E dwards, D uane, Flem Snopes and Thomas Sutpen: Two Versions of Re­
spectability ...............................................................................................................
190
559
E rskine, J. S.
A Religion of the Golden Age ..........................................................
361
F ong, D avid.
Macaulay: The Essayist as Historian
............................................
38
G odfrey, D enis. Wordsworth in the Twenty-First Century...............................
G uanatstein, J. L. The “Man of Secrets” in Canada, 1934 ............................
345
505
G ridceman, N. T . Uncle Sam Bonapartes..................................................................
H ays, P eter L. The Dance of Love and Dance of Death in R om eo and Juliet
H enighan, T . J. T . E. Lawrence’s Seven Pillars of W isdom : Vision as Pattern
J ensen, J. V ernon. Interrelationships within the Victorian “X Club” ...........
K ing, E. H. James Beattie’s Essay on Truth (1770): An Eighteenth-Century
‘Best-Seller’ ..................................................................................................................
K ramer, D ale. Hardy’s Prospects as a Tragic Novelist........................................
L ane, J r. L auriat. Dickens and Melville, Our Mutual Friends ....................
L auber, J ohn. Heroes and Anti-Heroes in Jane Austen’s Novels ....................
L eland, D oris. Dorothy Livesay: Poet of Nature....................................................
Liv, L eo Y. A Nuclear China and World Order......................................................
Liu, L eo Y. A Nuclear China and World Order ..................................................
L oewenstein, P rince J ohn. Gossip about Adam ..................................................
M artyn, H owe. Education, Culture, and International Tourism .......................
M endel, S ydney. Dissociation ofSensibility..............................................................
d’O mbrian, N icholas J. Comparative Studies and Military History: A Key
to The Future of Historical Scholarship in the University........................
P anel, B arbara C. Laughter as a Path into Comedy...........................................
P ullen, C harles H. Gulliver:Student ofNature....................................................
R avindra, R avi. Time in Christian and Indian Traditions.................................
R eichap.d, H ugo M. The Elegist Who Sang for All He Was W o rth ...............
Rogers, K atharine M. The Context of Arnold’s Plea for Birth Control in
Culture and Anarchy ..............................................................................................
R ubenstein , J ill . Symbolic Characterization in T h e Lady o f the L a\ e.........
R udrum, A lan. Philosophical Implications in Lawrence’s W omen in L ov e....
S chofield, S tephen . Aristocratic Crumble—Caused by a Canadian................
S mith , R owland. The Spanish Civil War and The British Literary R ig h t...
S tephen , S idney J. Adam in Exile. A. M. Klein’s “Portrait of the Poet as
Landscape” ..................................................................................................................
T homas, W. K. W e’re Still Sinking, Sir! ...............................................................
i.
337
532
49
539
390
178
315
489
404
228
228
475
374
218
18
251
77
5
24
463
366
240
31
60
553
520
THE DALHOUSIE REVIEW
623
W ard, W. P eter. The Acadian Response to the Growth of British Power in
Nova Scotia, 1749-1755 .........................................................................................
W ing, G eorge. The Shakespearean Voice of Conscience in Brave N ew World
Z uckermann, J oanne P. Tennyson’s In M emoriam as Love Poetry..................
165
153
202
R EV IEW A RTIC LES
F lynn, T . E. Henry James’s Journey from the Interior........................................
L inkletter, Zilpha. Nova Scotia: Laggard or Haven .....................................
M ackay, R. A. The Mackenzie King S ag a.............................................................
R aspa, A. N. New Literature: October, 1970 ......................................................
96
105
257
584
SH O R T STO R IES
P layfair, R hoda E lizabeth. One for the Money .............................................
V alcardson, W. D. An Act of Mercy.......................................................................
571
413
V E R SE
B ailey, A lfred G. Noroua...............................................................................................
B allowe, J ames. Black G irl............................................................................................
B eum , Robert. Where Will You Sail?.......................................................................
C oakley, M ichael. Ragmuffin ....................................................................................
Hansel and Gretel Park...............................................................
Non-Distance ................................................................................
C ook, R. L. Enigma .........................................................................................................
D arcy, L ouise. At The Year’s E n d ..........................................................................
D ouglas, G ilean. Chorale of Mountain Spring. View from a High Rise
F einstein, R obert. Country D ream ............................................................................
G arrett, J ohn. Sub-Culture ..........................................................................................
G om, L eona. Seven Poem s The Food of L o ve.....................................................
Consolation ...................................................................
.....................
Assignation .................................................................
Lhude Sing O Canada............................................
The Homestead Quarter............................................
What Strange Songs.................................................
Pennies .........................................................................
H owe, C harles H. Corrupted F lo ra ..........................................................................
Cindaratellite ................................................................................
K eane, M ary. Manes/Scada ............................................................................................
K ohler, R ichard. Words of Passage........................................................................
Macleod, A listair. Just Passing Through ..............................................................
R ansom, C herra S. The Siren ......................................................................................
S utherland, F raser. Thirty-Third Annual New Glasgow Music Festival
Folk Song Section ...................................................................................................
S waim , A lice M. A Murmur of Remembering.....................................................
T eitel, J ay. Poem .............................................................................................................
425
94
272
269
270
271
580
426
579
92
581
265
266
266
267
267
268
268
91
580
264
426
92
581
583
91
423
624
THE DALHOUSIE REVIEW
T homas, P eter . H um ility.....................................
W hite , G erald N. Reunion.............................................
W right, D avid. Poem ......... ....... ................................. ....:......... :...............................
Zwicker, R. L. The Collector and Commons..........................
........ ....... .........
BOOK R EV IEW S
s,
95
427
582
90
...
Birney, Earle. Rag & Bone Shop. McClelland & Stewart Ltd., 1971. (Doug­
las Barbour) ......................................................................................
Brandabur, Edward. A Scrupulous M eanness: A Study o f Joyce's Early
Wor\s. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1971. (M. A. K lug)....
Buitenhuis, Peter. T he Grasping Imagination. Toronto: University of Tor­
onto Press, 1970. (T . E. Flynn).......................................................................
Bumsted, J. M. H enry Alline, 1748-1784. Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1971. (Bruce Fergusson).......................................................................
Butler, David and Pinto-Duschinsky, Michael. T he British General Election
o f 1970. London: Macmillan, 1971. (Robert Boardman) ....................
Careless, J. M. S. (Ed.) Colonists and Canadiens. Toronto: Macmillan of
Canada, 1971. (W . L. Morton) ..................................................................
Carroll, David. G eorge E liot: T he Critical H eritage. London: Routledge &
Kegan Paul, 1971. (G . M. H arvey)...............................................................
Champlain, Samuel De. Voyages to N ew France, 15994608. Trans, by
Michael Macklem, Introd. by Edward Nutes. Oberon Press, 1971. (J.
S. Erskine) ......... ...................................................................................................
Voyages to N ew France, 1615-1618. Oberon Press, 1970. (J. S.
Erskine) ...................................................................... ............................ :...............
Cook, Ramsay. T h e M aple L e a f Forever: Essays on Nationalism and Politics
in Canada. Toronto: Macmillan o f Canada, 1971. (J. M. Beck).......
Cowan, James C. D. H. L aw rence’s American Journey. A Study in Litera­
ture and Myth. Cleveland/London: The Press of Case Western Re­
serve University, 1970. (David M. Monaghan).........................................
Douglas, John. Mandalas. Toronto: Coach House Press, 1970. (Douglas
Barbour) ....................................................................................................................
Davey, Frank. Weeds, Toronto: Coach House Press, 1970. (Douglas Bar­
bour) ....................................................................:....................................................
......... . Four Myths for Sam Perry. Vancouver: Talonbooks, 1970. (Doug­
las Barbour) .................................................:....................... ............ ......................
Edgar, Irving I. Shakespeare, M edicine and Psychiatry: An Historical Study
in Criticism and Interpretation. New York: Philosophical Library Inc.,
1970. (A. L. Murphy)........................................................... ............................
Emerson, Ralph W. T h e Journals and Miscellaneous N otebooks o f Ralph
W aldo Emerson. Vol. VIII, 1841-1843. Ed. by W . H. Gilman and J.
E. Parsons. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1970. (E . J. Rose)
592
96
453
594
602
430
601
117
288
278
133
133
116
612
THE DALHOUSIE REVIEW
Fairley, Barker. Goethe's Faust. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1970.
(Alan D. Latta) .....................................................................................................
Fielden, Charlotte. Crying As She Ran. Toronto: Macmillan of Canada,
1970. (Michael Benazon) .................................................................................
Ford, Madox Ford. Your Mirror to my T im es: T h e Selected Autobiographies
and Impressions o f F ord Madox Ford. Ed., with an Introduction, by
Michael Killigrew. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1971. (Christopher
X. Ringrose) ...........................................................................................................
Frye, Northrop. T h e Stubborn Structure: Essays on Criticism and Society.
Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 1970. (Roger C. Lewis)...
Fuss, Peter & Shapiro, Henry. N ietzsche: A Self-Portrait From H is Letters.
Harvard University Press, 1971. (C. J. Terry).........................................
Gasparini, Len. Cutty Sar\. Quarry Press, 1970. (Douglas Barbour)............
George, Roy E. A L eader and a L aggard: Manufacturing Industry in N ova
Scotia, Quebec and Ontario. Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
1970. (Zilpha Linkletter)
..............................................................................
Gibbs, Robert. Earth Charms H eard So Early. Fredericton: Fiddlehead
Books, 1970. (Douglas Barbour).....................................................................
Harris, Michael. Text for Naust^a. Montreal: Delta, Canada 1970. (Doug­
las Barbour) ...........................................................................................................
Johnson, Samuel. L ife o f Savage. Ed. by Clarence Tracy. Oxford: Claren­
don Press, 1971. (Patrick O’Flaherty) ..........................................................
Keeler, Wally. W alking On the Greenhouse R oof. Montreal: Delta, Canada,
1970. (Douglas Barbour) ..................................................................................
King, T . J. Shakespearean Staging, 1599-1642. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
University Press, 1971. (L . R. Star)...............................................................
Lachs, John. T h e Ties o f T im e. Montreal: Delta, Canada, 1970. (Douglas
Barbour) ....................................................................................................................
Lamb, W. Kaye (Ed .) T h e Journals and Letters o f Sir A lexander M ackenzie.
Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1970. (Roy Daniells) ........................
Landow, George P. T h e Aesthetic and Critical Theories o f John Ruskin.
Princeton University Pres, 1971. (Michael Beatty)...................................
Layton, Irving. N ail Polish. Toronto, McClelland & Stewart, 1971. (Doug­
las Lochhead) ..........................................................................................................
Leaska, Mitchell A. Virginia's W oolf’s 'Lighthouse'. A Study in Critical
M ethod. New York: Columbia University Press, 1970. (David M.
Monaghan) ................................................................................................................
Maurice, Frederick Denison. Sketches o f Contemporary Authors 1828. Edited
by A. J. Hartley, Archon Books, 1970. (Govind Narain Sharma).........
Mayne, Seymour. Mouth. Quarry Press, 1970. (Douglas Barbour) ............
McNamara, Eugene. Outerings. Montreal: Delta, Canada, 1970. (Douglas
Barbour) ....................................................................................................................
625
273
297
614
109
438
133
105
133
133
608
133
436
133
590
449
280
126
301
133
133
526
THE DALHOUSIE REVIEW
McRitchie, Kenneth. T h e Bandit. Toronto: Coach House Press, 1970.
(Douglas Barbour) ................................................................................................
Millgate, Michael. T hom as H ardy. His Career as a Novelist. New York:
Random House, 1971. (David Baron) ........................................................
Moir, John S. Character and Circumstance'. Essays in H onour o f Donald
Grant Creighton. Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1970. (George A.
Rawlyk) .................... ......:........................................................................................
133
596
276
Moore, Brian. T h e Revolution Script. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart,
1971. (A. N. Raspa) ......... :...........................................................................
Moore, John Rees. Masks o f L ov e and Death-. Yeats as Dramatist. Ithaca
and London: Cornell University Press, 1971. (D . E. S. Maxwell).......
290
Morton, W. L. (Ed .) M onck Letters and Journals, 1863-1868: Canada from
Government H ouse at Confederation. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart,
1970. (P . B. W aite).............................................................. .............................
435
O’Driscoll, Robert. T heatre and Nationalism in Twentieth-Century Ireland.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1971. (Norman H. MacKenzie)
433
Penlington, Norman. Ed., On Canada: Essays in H onour o f Frank H . Under­
hill. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1971. (P. B. W aite).......
Phillips, D. Z. Death an d Immortality. London: Macmillan (Toronto: Mac­
millan of Canada), 1970. (Hilton Page) ..................................................
Pickersgill, J. W. and Forster, D. F., T he M ackenzie K in g Record, Vols. Ill
& IV. Toronto: University of Toront Press, 1970. (R . A. MacKay) ...
Purdy, Al. L ove In A Burning Building. McClelland & Stewart Ltd. 1970.
(Douglas Barbour) ..........
Randall, John Herman Jr., Plato: Dramatist o f the L ife o f Reason. Montreal:
McGill University Press. New York and London: Columbia Univer­
sity Press, 1970. (F . Hilton Page)................................................................
Rosenblood, Norman. Ed. Shaw . Seven Critical Essays. Toronto: Univer­
sity of Toronto Press, 1971. (J. Percy Sm ith).............................................
Runciman, W. G. Sociology in its Place and Other Essays. Cambridge Uni­
versity Press, 1970. (J. Graham Morgan)..................... ................................
Seary, E. R. Place N am es o f the Avalon Peninsula o f the Island o f N ew ­
foundland. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1971. (Lloyd A.
Duchemin) ............
Siemens, Reynold. T he W ordsworth Collection: D ove Cottage Papers F ac­
similes: A Catalogue. University of Alberta Press, 1971. (A. J. Hart­
ley) ................................................
Smith, Denis. Bleeding H earts . . . Bleeding Country. Edmonton: M. G.
Hurtig, 1971. (A . N. Raspa) .......................................................................
Swinburne, Richard. T h e Concept o f Miracle. London: Macmillan (Tor­
onto: Macmillan of Canada), 1970. (Hilton Page) .................................
584
113
598
257
289
121
114
128
428
441
584
598
THE DALHOUSIE REVIEW
Talbott, Stobe. (Ed. & Trans.) K hrushchev Rem em bers. Toronto: Little,
Brown & Co., 1970. (Laurence D. Stokes)..................................................
Thatcher, David S. N ietzsche in England 1890-1914. Toronto: University
of Toronto Press, 1970. (L . Tum m on)..........................................................
Theall, Donald F . T he M edium is the Rear View Mirror'. Understanding
M cLuhan. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1971. (Dennis
Duffy) ...........................................................................................................................
Thompson, Dennis F. T h e D em ocratic Citizen: Social Science and D em o­
cratic Theory in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge Uni­
versity Pres, 1970. (W . R. Mathie).................................................................
Thompson, R. W. International T rade and Domestic Prosperity: Canada
1926-38, Canadian Studies in Economics No. 22. Toronto: Univer­
sity of Toronto Press, 1970. (Paul B. Huber)...........................................
Toorn, Peter Van. Leew ay Grass. Montreal: Delta, Canada, 1970. (Doug­
las Barbour) ................................................................................................................
Vallieres, Pierre. The English version of W hite N iggers o f Am erica (N egres
d'A m erique). Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1971. (A. N. Raspa)
Winks, Robin W. T h e Blacks in Canada: A History. New Haven: Yale
University Press, with McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1971. (James
W . St. G. W alker).................................................................................................
Woodring, Carl. Politics in English Romantic Poetry. Cambridge: Harvard
University Press, 1970. (C. J. Myers)...............................................................
Yates, J. Michael. T h e Great Bear L a k e Meditations. Ottawa: Oberon Press,
1970. (Douglas Barbour) ....................................................................................
627
130
122
119
443
118
133
292
282
274
133
d a l iio u s ie r e v ie w
Back Numbers Now Available!
CURRENT SUBSCRIPTIONS
quarterly
annual subscripts
3-year subscriptior
single issues
$ 4.
$10.
$ 1
BACKFILES
Microfilm
vols. 1-45. 1921-1965
13 reels
$125.
single reels
$ 10.
( 2 - 3 yr$. per)
vols. 46-51. 1966-19/1
smglc reels
(1 y r . per)
$ 10.
Paporbound
vols. 1 51. 1921-1971
single issues $2 - $5.
price varies accordlog to quantity available; no: all issues
are available.
Dalhousie University Press Limited
Izaak Walton Killam Library - 1413
Dalhousie University
Halifax, Nova Scotia. Canadj
Ph. 424-2541
U niversity News
. . . o new tabloid newspaper
slished every two weeks during
the academic year.
it has two objectives:
It contains news about Dalhousie and other universities
First, to better inform both
the university community and
the public at large of the
activities, achievements, oper­
ations and problems at the
university.
in the area, about higher edu­
cation in general, photos, a
bulletin board which w ill list
the scope and variety of uni­
versity
activities,
many of
which are open to the public,
Second, to be a v e h i c l e
and it publishes an opinion
through which official univer­
page that invites letters of
sity viewpoints could be pre-
topical and valid comment
and conservative criticism.