EisensteinFs Misunderstood Geometric Proof of the

,ti?t|i?<t t?_iht|LL_ BiL4i|hU hLLu Lu
|i "@_h@|U +iUThLU|) AiLhi4
+i?@h_ w@Mi?M@Uih
#@_ a i?}i**i)
#iT@h|4i?| Lu @|i4@|U@* 5Ui?Uit
i i UL 5|@|i N?iht|)
w@t hUitc  HHff
dL**i}i @|i4@|Ut aLh?@* 2D Ebbec 2beo

W?|hL_U|L?
Ai "@_h@|U +iUThLU|) AiLhi4 @t T*@)i_ @ Ui?|h@* hL*i ? |i _ii*
LT4i?| Lu ?4Mih |iLh)c @?_ uLh4i_ |i €ht| _iiT *@ }Lih??} Th4i
?4Miht W|t ?4ihLt ThLLut uhL4 4@?) _t|?U| TL?|t Lu i |it|u) |L
|t TLt|L? @| |i i@h| Lu |i tMiU| Ai |iLhi4 @t _tULihi_ M) ,
*ihc @?_ hit|@|i_ M) wi}i?_hi ? |ih4t Lu |i t)4ML* ?L Mi@h?} t ?@4ic
M| @t €ht| ThLi? M) B@tt Ai i}| _gihi?| ThLLut B@tt TM*ti_
? |i i@h*) Hfftc uLh @| i U@**i_ |i 6?_@4i?|@* AiLhi4c ihi uL*
*Li_ M) _L3i?t 4Lhi MiuLhi |i Ui?|h) @t Lihc ?U*_?} uLh }i? M)
BL||L*_ ,ti?t|i? ? |i )i@ht HeeeD h @4 t |L |@!i @ ?i *LL!
@| ,ti?t|i?<t }iL4i|hU ThLLuc ? U i Thiti?|t @ T@h|U*@h*) Mi@|u*
@?_ iUL?L4U@* @_@T|@|L? Lu B@tt< |h_ ThLLuc @?_ |L _h@ @||i?|L? |L
@** |i @_@?|@}it Lu t ThLLu Lih B@tt<c 4Lt| Lu U @i @TT@hi?|*)
ihi|LuLhi Mii? Lih*LL!i_
3 Wkh dxwkruv zrxog olnh wr wkdqn Nhlwk Ghqqlv iru klv dvvlvwdqfh lq orfdwlqj vrxufhv/
Wrp Krhnvhpd dqg Fduro Zdonhu iru wkhlu hqwkxvldvwlf vxssruw ri wkh Krqruv frxuvhv
zklfk ohg wr wklv zrun/ dqg Mrh ]xqg iru whoolqj xv zkhuh wr orrn1

W| t @h_ |L 4@}?i |L_@) |i ti?t@|L? U@ti_ M) ,ti?t|i? i? i
Mht| TL? |i 4@|i4@|U@* Lh*_ W? |i @|4? Lu Hec @| @}i |i?|)c
|t ti*u|@}| 4@|i4@|U@? @_ M@hi*) hiUii_ t } tULL* Uih|€U@|i
@?_ i?|ihi_ |i 6hi_hU`*i*4t N?iht|) Lu ih*?c i? i ThL_Ui_ @
LL_ Lu TM*U@|L?tc ?t|@?|*) 4@!?} 4 L?i Lu |i *i@_?} 4@|i4@|U@?t
Lu |i i@h*) ??i|ii?| Ui?|h) ? a*) ec Heec B@tt hL|i |L Bih*?}c
t@)?} RW @i hiUi?|*) 4@_i |i @^@?|@?Ui Lu @ )L?} 4@|i4@|U@?c
,ti?t|i? uhL4 ih*?c L U@4i ihi | @ *i||ih Lu hiUL44i?_@|L? uhL4
O4ML*_| At 4@?c L t t|** ih) )L?}c i M|t ih) i Ui**i?| |@*i?|c
@?_ ** Uih|@?*) @Uii }hi@| |?}t deo W? Hee ,ti?t|i? UL?|hM|i_
?L *itt |@? S Lu |i 2. 4@|i4@|U@* @h|U*it ? VL*4i 2. Lu hi**i<t
aLh?@*c @?_ M) t |h_ ti4it|ih @t @ t|_i?| i @_ hiUii_ @? L?Lh@h)
_LU|Lh@|i uhL4 hit*@ dbo L| B@tt @?_ |i }hi@| tUi?|t| @?_ i T*Lhih
*i @?_ih L? O4ML*_| 4@_i }hi@| igLh|tc uLh |i 4Lt| T@h| ? @?c |L
LM|@? hiUL}?|L? @?_ €?@?U@* tiUh|) uLh |i 4TLihti_ ,ti?t|i?
B@tt hL|i |L O4ML*_| |@| ,ti?t|i?<t |@*i?| @t R|@| U ?@|hi
Mit|Lt TL? L?*) @ ui ? i@U Ui?|h) do Oi __ LM|@? @ TLt|L?
@t @ h@|_L3i?| E?t@*@hi_ *iU|hih @| |i N?iht|) ? ih*?c @?_ @t
ii?|@**) @_4||i_ |L |i ih*? U@_i4) Lu 5Ui?Uit ? i@h*) HD2 | M)
|i? t *ui*L?} TLLh i@*| @_ tihLt*) _i|ihLh@|i_c @?_ *@|ih |@| t@4i
)i@h i _i_c @}i_ 2bc Lu |MihU*Ltt BL||L*_ ,ti?t|i? t|@?_t | Mi*
@?_ B@*Lt @t @?L|ih ??i|ii?| Ui?|h) 4@|i4@|U@* }i?t | @ |h@}U
@?_ tLh| *ui dc bo
,ti?t|i?<t }iL4i|hU ThLLu @TTi@hi_ ? hi**i<t aLh?@* ?_ih |i ||*i
BiL4i|htUih iit _it 6?_@4i?|@*|iLhi4t u
h _i ^@_h@|tUi? +it|i
dDo W| t ?|4@|i*) UL??iU|i_ |L B@tt< |h_ ThLLu ETM*ti_ ? dSo @?_
|h@?t*@|i_ ? dfo @?) i TLt|L?t Lu ,ti?t|i?<t ThLLuc Mi}???} | dc
2oc @i LMtihi_ L?*) L?i Lu |t |hii }iL4i|hU @tTiU|tc @?_ @i Lih*LL!i_
|i L|ih 4TLh|@?| _gihi?Uit Mi|ii? |i |L ThLLut Ai hit*| @t Mii?
@ u@*hi |L hiUL}?3i @?_ u**) @TThiU@|i @** |i @)t ? U ,ti?t|i?
}hi@|*) t|hi@4*?it @?_ **4?@|it B@tt< ThLLuc @?_ |ihiM) hii@*t |t
itti?Ui 6Lh ?t|@?Uic B@tt< |h_ ThLLu t M@ti_ L? @ hit*| !?L? @t
B@tt< wi44@c @?_ ,ti?t|i? @t T@h|U*@h*) T*i@ti_ | @ tLh|U| i
uL?_ |L @L_ |i |iU?U@*|it ?L*i_ ? @TT*)?} |G
RW __ ?L| hit| ?|* W uhii_ 4) }iL4i|hU ThLLu uhL4 |i
wi44@ L? U | t|** _iTi?_i_c @?_ | t ?L tL t4T*i |@|
2
| U@? Mi UL44?U@|i_ ? @ ULT*i Lu *?it d.c TT .eo
`i Mi*ii |@| |i i*i}@?Ui Lu ,ti?t|i?<t ThLLu _itihit _i @TThiU
@|L?c @?_ i Thiti?| | ihi @*L?} | @ UL4T@htL? |L B@tt< |h_ ThLLu
2
,ti?t|i?<t hLLu
AL ti| |i t|@}ic i hiU@** @ ui UL?ti^i?Uit Lu |i u@U| |@| |i hit_i
U*@ttit 4L_*L @ Th4i R uLh4 @ €i*_ ~R 6ih4@|<t w||*i AiLhi4c |@|
KR   E4L_ R uLh @?) ?|i}ih K ?L| _tM*i M) Rc L*_t MiU@ti |i
?L?3ihL hit_i U*@ttit uLh4 @ EU)U*U }hLT Lu Lh_ih R  ?_ih 4*|T*
U@|L? `i? R t L__c |i t^@h?} 4@T % $ %2 @t !ih?i* ic jc tL
|t 4@}ic |i t^@hit Lh ^@_h@|U hit_it 4L_*L Rc uLh4 @ tM}hLT Lu
Lh_ih R 2  @?_ |i ?L?hit_it uLh4 |t ULti| Ai ^@_h@|U
U@h@U|ih Lu @
K
hit_i U*@tt K 5 ~R t tTiU€i_ M) |i wi}i?_hi t)4ML*G R '  u K t @
3
3
W
R3 2
^@_h@|U hit_i 4L_ R @?_ RK '  u ?L| 6hL4 K 2
' c | uL**Lt
R 
R 
2
|@| K 2 '  uLh @?) K 5 ~R | u K ' S c |i? K 2 ' SR  ' c tL
R 
|i ^@_h@|U hit_it @hi @** hLL|t Lu |i TL*)?L4@* % 2 '  5?Ui |t
TL*)?L4@* U@? @i ?L 4Lhi |@? R 2  hLL|t ? |i €i*_ ~R c i UL?U*_i
|@| |t hLL|t
|i ^@_h@|U hit_it A@| tc i @i ,*ih<t
@hi iR @U|*)

K
2
uLh @?) ?|i}ih K ?L| _tM*i M) R
h|ihL?G R K
Ai "@_h@|U +iUThLU|) AiLhi4 UL4T@hit |i ^@_h@|U U@h@U|ih Lu
|L Th4it | hitTiU| |L i@U L|ih
3
3
W
3
3
3
3
"@_h@|U +iUThLU|) AiLhi4 Wu R @?_ ^ @hi _t|?U| L__ Th4itc
|i?
# $# $
R  ^ 
R
^
' E 2 2 ^
R
3
u
3
Oihi t ,ti?t|i?<t ThLLuc U*Lti*) uL**L?} ML| t L? *@?}@}i @?_
?L|@|L? EU i UL?i?i?|*) @?_ tUUittu**) @Mtit
L?t_ih |i ti| @ ' 2c ec Sc c R  wi| o _i?L|i |i hi4@?_ih
E4L_ R Lu @? @hM|h@h) 4*|T*i ^@ Ai? | t @TT@hi?| |@| |i *t| Lu
?4Miht Eo o @}hiit | |i *t| Lu ?4Miht @c T |L 4*|T*it Lu R E6Lh
U*i@h*) i@U Lu |i ?4Miht Eo o @t ii? *i@t| TLt|i hit_ic @?_ u
|ihi ihi _T*U@|L? @4L?} |iti hit_itc i}
E^@ ^@ E^@ ^@ c
|i? @ @ 5?Ui |i @<t @hi _t|?U|c | uL**Lt |@| @ n @ fc U
U@??L| LUUh t?Ui f @ n @ 2R @?_ @ n @ t ii? At
^
R3
2
\
@
\
o
E4L_ R
\
@?_
S
\
@ E o o
E4L_ Rc
S
R3
uhL4 U | uL**Lt |@| ^ 2 E o E4L_ R +iU@**?} ,*ih<t h
R 
|ihL? |@| ^R ^ 2
E4L_ Rc |t ThL_Uit
3
# $
^
R
S
' E o c
E
tL L?i 4@) uLUt tL*i*) L? |i T@h|) Lu |t i TL?i?| *i@h*)
[
^@ ' R
% &
[ ^@
R
n
[
oc
E2
ihi d o t |i }hi@|it| ?|i}ih u?U|L?
5?Ui |i i*i4i?|t @ @hi @** ii?c
S
S k ^@ l
@?_ R t L__c | uL**Lt |@| o E4L_ 2c @?_ |t
R
# $
^
R
S
^@
' E d R o EOihi ,ti?t|i? hi4@h!t |@| t?Ui T |L |t TL?| ^ ?ii_ ?L| @i Mii? @?
L__ Th4ic M| 4ihi*) @ ?4Mih hi*@|i*) Th4i |L Rc L?i U@? i@t*) LM|@?
|i ,h}@?3?}tt@|3 2R ' E
@t @? i ihUti uLh |i hi@_ih
R2 3
H
uhL4 |i @MLi uLh4*@ At i *i@i
,ti?t|i? ?L tit @ }iL4i|hU hiThiti?|@|L? Lu |i i TL?i?| ? |t
*@t| i^@|L? |L |h@?tuLh4 | |Ui *i hi|@??} |t T@h|)G At i TL?i?|
t ThiUti*) |i ?4Mih Lu ?|i}ih *@||Ui TL?|t | ii? @MtUtt@t *)?} ?
|i ?|ihLh Lu |h@?}*i ( ? |i 6}hi E?L|i |@| ?L *@||Ui TL?|t *i
L? |i *?i L?t_ih @? ii? @MtUtt@ @ : R*2 5?Ui |i ?4Mih Lu
e
)
a
^ 6
)'E^%T
w
O ^%2
#
k
T%2
!
T
*@||Ui TL?|t
k l L? i@U @MtUtt@ ? |i ?|ihLh Lu hiU|@?}*i (8 t ii?c |i
?4Mih ^@
R Lu *@||Ui TL?|t L? |i @MtUtt@ Mi*L @t |i t@4i T@h|)
@t |i ?4Mih Lu *@||Ui TL?|t @MLi At ? |h? t |i t@4i @t |i
?4Mih Lu TL?|t *)?} Mi*L L? |i L__ @MtUtt@ R @ At L?i|LL?i
ULhhitTL?_i?Ui Mi|ii? ii? k@MtUtt@t
? |h@?}*i Ma @?_ L__ @MtUtt@t
S ^@ l
? Mg ?L 4T*it |@|
R > E4L_ 2c ihi > t |i ?4Mih Lu
TL?|t ?t_i |h@?}*i Mgc @?_ |t R^ ' E> +iiht?} |i hL*it Lu R @?_ ^ )i*_t R^ ' ED c ihi D t |i ?4Mih
Lu TL?|t ?t_i |h@?}*i Mu 5?Ui |i |L|@* ?4Mih Lu TL?|t ?t_i ML|
|h@?}*it t t4T*) R 2  ^ 2  c L?i 4@) ?L UL?U*_i |@|
3
3
# $# $
R
^
^
R
' ED n> ' E
R3 u ^3
2
2
,i? |i ?Lh4@**) 4L_it| ,ti?t|i? UL*_ ?L| hit|h@? t T*i@thi |
|t ThLLuG
ROL *U!) }LL_ ,*ih L*_ @i UL?t_ihi_ 4ti*uc @_ i
TLttitti_ |iti *?it @ML| tii?|) )i@ht @}L d.c T .eo
D
,ti?t|i? ihtt B@tt
B@tt 4ti*u UL?t_ihi_ t |h_ ThLLu |L Mi |i 4Lt| _hiU| @?_ ?@|h@*
Lu t _i4L?t|h@|L?t W? ?|hL_U?} | i t@_G
R6Lh @ L*i )i@h |t |iLhi4 |Lh4i?|i_ 4i @?_ @MtLhMi_ 4)
}hi@|it| igLh|t ?|* @| *@t| W LM|@?i_ @ ThLLu w@|ih W U@4i
@UhLtt |hii L|ih ThLLut U ihi M*| L? i?|hi*) _gihi?|
Th?UT*it W _L ?L| it|@|i |L t@) |@| ?|* ?L @ ?@|h@*
ThLLu @t ?L| Mii? ThL_Ui_ W *i@i | |L |i @|Lh|it |L _}i
i|ih |i uL**L?} ThLLu U W @i hiUi?|*) Mii? uLh|?@|i
i?L} |L _tULih _itihit |t _itUhT|L? dfc T o
`*i ,ti?t|i? itti?|@**) uL**Lt |i t@4i L|*?i @t B@ttc i@U ui@
|hi Lu t @TThL@U _tT*@)t }hi@| U*@h|) @?_ ?t}|c @?_ Lgiht @? i*i}@?|
i *i tLh|i??} |i T@| |@!i? M) B@tt
B@tt< |h_ ThLLu Mi}?t | t wi44@c U t@)t |@|
# $
^
R
' Ek c
E
| k LM|@?i_ @t uL**LtG wi|
R
Rn Rn
j @?_ E ' i
c
c c R j
D ' ic 2c c
2
2
2
Ai? k t _i€?i_ |L Mi |i ?4Mih Lu *i@t| TLt|i hit_it Lu |i ti| ^D
U *i ? E
W?t|i@_ Lu t?} B@tt< wi44@c ,ti?t|i? _ihit i^@|L? Ec | |i
S
@*}iMh@U i ThittL? o ? |i i TL?i?|c U t |i? 4Lhi i@t*) UL?ih|i_
?|L |i !i) i^@|L?
# $
S ^@
^
' E d R o c
Ee
R
UL44L? |L ML| ThLLutc |@? t i^@|L? E `*i ,ti?t|i?<t @*}iMh@U
i TL?i?| t i@t*) |h@?tuLh4i_ ?|L |i i TL?i?| ? Ee @ E2c B@tt 4t|
it|@M*t @ ?4Mih Lu |iU?U@* ThLTih|it Lu |i }hi@|it| ?|i}ih u?U|L?
@?_ @TT*) |i4 |L hi*@|i k |L |i i TL?i?| ? Ee ,ti?t|i?<t ti Lu |i
ti| @ ' 2c ec Sc c R c @t LTTLti_ |L B@tt< Dc @**Lt 4 |L UL?| |i
S
t@4i i*i4i?|t @t B@tt< wi44@c M| @ |i i ThittL? oc *i@_?} ^U!*)
|L EeG
S
RAi 4@? _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? 4) @h}4i?| @?_ |@| Lu B@tt t
|@| W _L ?L| __i |i ?4Miht *itt |@? R ?|L |Lti *itt |@?
R*2 @?_ |Lti }hi@|ih |@? R*2c M| h@|ih ?|L ii? @?_ L__
L?it d.o
,ti?t|i? ?L @TT*it
t |L U*iih }iL4i|hU |h@?tuLh4@|L?t |L UL?
S k ^@ l
ih| |i i TL?i?|
R ?|L |i ?4Mih Lu *@||Ui TL?|t ? |h@?}*i Mg
E4L_ 2 u|ih _L?} |i t@4i uLh R^ c )i*_?} |i ?4Mih Lu *@||Ui TL?|t
? Muc |i ThLLu t UL4T*i|i_ t4T*) M) UL?|?} |i *@||Ui TL?|t ? hiU|
@?}*i gMu B@ttc L? |i L|ih @?_c ? itti?Ui TihuLh4t |i t@4i |L
|h@?tuLh4@|L?tc @?_ UL?|?}c |L| @@*?} 4ti*u Lu |i }iL4i|hU Thi
ti?|@|L? Oi @U|@**) UL?|t |i *@||Ui TL?|t t?} @*}iMh@U ThLTih|it Lu
|i }hi@|it| ?|i}ih u?U|L? At 4@!it |i hi4@?_ih Lu t ThLLu *i?}|)
@?_ ?L??||ic @?_ uLhUit 4 |L UL?t_ih tiT@h@|i U@tit _iTi?_?} L? |i
UL?}hi?Ui U*@ttit Lu R @?_ ^ E4L_ e E6Lh @ 4Lhi _i|@*i_ UL4T@htL?c tii
dHo
+iuihi?Uit
do B @U4@??c i_ihi ~@*i?|iLhic AiM?ihc wiT3}c bf2bfc
hiTM*ti_ M) i*ti@c i vLh!c bSH
d2o @4}@h|c NMih
_@t "@_h@|tUi +iUThL3|@|t}iti|3c ~i|tUhu| u
h
@|i4@|! ?_ )t! f EHHDc Ot|LhtU*|ih@htUi M|i*?}c
Sb2..
do k+ ih4@??c BL||L*_ ,ti?t|i?G #i `U|}t|i? #@|i? ti?it
wiMi?t ?_ `h!i?tc @|i4@|tUi `ih!i( BL||L*_ ,ti?t|i?c i
vLh!c i*ti@ M* Lc b.Dc TT bbb2b
deo k+ ih4@??c @h* 6hi_hU B@yc Vih*@} O iU!c 
?Ui?c
bbfc T ..
dDo B ,ti?t|i?c BiL4i|htUih iit _it 6?_@4i?|@*|iLhi4t u
h _i
^@_h@|tUi? +it|ic hi**i<t aLh?@* 2H EHeec 2eS2eb
4 Prvw
prghuq h{srvlwlrqv ri Hlvhqvwhlq*v surri suhvhqw rqo| wklv qdo frxqwlqj dujx0
phqw/ uhsodflqj klv wzr jhrphwulf wudqvirupdwlrqv e| dojheud1
.
dSo 6 B@ttc L44i?|@|L?it 5LUi|@|t +i}@i 5Ui?|@h4 BL||?}i?
tt S EHfHc BL||?}i?( @*tL `ih!ic BL||?}i?c H.Sc @?_ 2c TT
H
d.o Oh|3 @?_ 6 +_L E,_tc hiui L? B ,ti?t|i? @?  5|ih?c
tTT*i4i?| |L ~i|tUhu| u
h @|i4@|! ?_ )t! ef EHbDc Sb
2f
dHo + w@Mi?M@Uih @?_ # i?}i**i)c B@ttc ,ti?t|i?c @?_ |i R|h_
ThLLu Lu |i "@_h@|U +iUThLU|) AiLhi4G ,? !*i?it 5U@tTi*c
@|i4@|U@* W?|i**}i?Uihc |L @TTi@h
dbo 6 +_L E,_ ,?i |LML}h@Ti L? BL||L*_ ,ti?t|i? |
,h}@?3i?_i? L}h@TtUi? L|3i?c ~i|tUhu| u
h @|i4@|! ?_
)t! ef EHbDc eSH
dfo # , 54|c 5LhUi LL! ? @|i4@|Utc #Lihc i vLh!c bDbc
TT 2H
H