Geophys. J. Int. (1996) 127,635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation of the Zimbabwe and Kaapvaal cratons, the Limpopo Belt and the Mozambique basin 0.Gwavava,' C. J. Swain2 and F. Podmore' 'Department of Physics, University of Zimbabwe. PO Box MP167, Mount Pleasant, Harare, Zimbabwe ' Western Mining Corporation Limited, 55 McDonald Street, Kalgoorlie WA6430, Australia Accepted 1996 July 16. Received 1996 June 17; in original form 1994 June 7 SUMMARY The Bouguer gravity anomaly map of the Zimbabwe and Kaapvaal cratons, the Limpopo Belt and the Mozambique basin shows a regional gravity high in the southeast. Superimposed on this gravity high is a line of elongate gravity highs that is coincident with the Lebombo-Nuanetsi-Sabi volcanics. Gwavava et al. ( 1992) argue that the regional anomaly over this region is the effect of Mesozoic crustal thinning and igneous activity during the breakup of Gondwana. Lithospheric extension resulted in crustal thinning by at least 4 km beneath the central Limpopo Belt. 2-D Fourier transforms of Bouguer gravity and topography data have been used to obtain the admittance and coherence throughout the region. Assuming a regionally compensated isostatic model comprising two layers with statistically independent surface and subsurface loading, the predicted coherence was compared to the observed coherence to obtain the best estimate of the effective elastic thickness of the lithospheric plate. This coherence analysis reveals that the Archaean cratons have a minimum effective elastic thickness of about 56 km, whereas that of the area beneath the Mozambique basin is only about 22 km, a value similar to that obtained in other East African rift basins. Hence, the stable cratonic areas are more rigid than the area beneath the Mozambique basin, which was subjected to Mesozoic crustal extension and thinning. An isostatic anomaly map has been computed by filtering the Bouguer gravity in the wavenumber domain with the square root of the predicted coherence function of the whole area generated from the best-fitting two-layer model with an effective elastic thickness of 52 km. The isostatic anomaly map is characterized by ( 1 ) a zone of positive isostatic anomalies over the Lebombo-Nuanetsi-Sabi area, which are partly due to crustal thinning and partly to basic plutons emplaced in the upper crust, both resulting from an extensional episode associated with Gondwana breakup, (2) positive isostatic anomalies over the Southern Marginal Zone of the Limpopo Belt, which we interpret as being due to dense granulites within the upper crust, (3) negative isostatic anomalies over the Northern Marginal Zone of the Limpopo Belt, which may have resulted from recent rapid erosion, and (4) negative isostatic anomalies over the Mozambique basin, which are due to the gravity effect of low-density Cretaceous and Tertiary sediments. Key words: crust, gravity anomalies, isostasy, lithosphere. INTRODUCTION The concept of isostasy requires that topography (surface loads) above sea level be hydrostatically compensated by a deficit of mass below sea level. In Airy's (1855) model, compensation is achieved by variation of the crustal thickness such that the crust-mantle interface (Moho) mirrors the topography, whereas in Pratt's (1855) model hydrostatic equilibrium is attained by lateral changes in the density of blocks of constant 0 1996 RAS depth. Both models involve local compensation, in that the compensating mass occurs directly below the surface load, and loads have no effect on adjacent lithosphere. The Airy and Pratt models imply that the crust has no strength, an assumption that is not generally correct since the crust can support surface loads regionally over a long geological timescale. To overcome this problem, a third type of isostatic model, known as the flexure model, is used that assumes an elastic lithosphere overlying a weak, fluid 635 636 0. Gwavava, C. J. Swain and F. Podmore asthenosphere. The lithosphere responds to surface and subsurface loads by plate flexure, so the compensating masses are distributed over a region around the surface load. Hence compensation is regional. The flexural response of the lithosphere is governed by its flexural rigidity, which, for the thinplate model used here, is a function of its effective elastic thickness. Moreover, as pointed out by Forsyth (1985), any general regional isostatic model should also consider subsurface as well as surface loads. The approach developed by Dorman & Lewis (1970) to understand the isostatic compensation mechanism is to study the linear relationship between the Bouguer gravity and topography in the wavenumber domain. This makes it possible to distinguish, on the basis of wavelength, between topographic features that are isostatically compensated and those that are supported by the lithospheric plate. The 'isostatic response function', or admittance, contains information on the isostatic state of the lithosphere. Assuming a regional model of isostasy, the admittance can be interpreted in terms of the flexural rigidity of the lithosphere, e.g. McNutt & Menard (1982). Another more robust function to compute is the coherence, which is defined as the ratio of the square of the cross-spectrum of Bouguer gravity and topography to the product of the powers of gravity and topography at a given wavenumber. As with the admittance, a predicted coherence can be computed by assuming some isostatic model. The admittance and coherence functions have been used to study isostasy in other parts of the world such as North America, Australia and East Africa. Since the flexural response of the lithosphere to a load depends strongly on its effective elastic thickness, T,, or its equivalent flexural rigidity, D, the admittance and coherence have been used in this study to estimate the effective elastic thickness of the lithosphere. Table 1 gives values of T, obtained by various authors for North America, Australia and East Africa. The results in Table 1 show that estimates of the continental flexural rigidity obtained from the admittance technique ( 1019-1022Nm) are biased towards low values compared to those obtained from using the coherence technique ( lOZ3-lOz5 Nm). Values of the flexural rigidity obtained by the coherence technique are in good agreement with estimates from studying individual features ( 1023-1025Nm) such as mountain ranges (Karner & Watts 1983; Stern & ten Brink 1989), sedimentary basins (Watts, Karner & Steckler 1982) and lakes (Passey 1981; Nakiboglu & Lambeck 1983; Bills & Table 1. Effective elastic thickness May 1987). Forsyth (1985) and Bechtel et al. (1990) attribute the bias towards low flexural rigidities using the admittance technique to ( 1 ) assuming only surface loading when subsurface loading could also be important, (2) the strong weighting of provinces with large topographic relief and (3) averaging over several different geological provinces with different flexural rigidities. At the time of undertaking the present study there were no other isostatic studies of this region of southern Africa to enable us to understand the thermomechanical evolution of its lithosphere. The region is extremely interesting since it includes a large area of very old rocks (3.5 to 2.6 Ga) forming the Archaean cratons, the Limpopo Belt with some rocks as old as those of the cratons but highly deformed and metamorphosed, and the Mesozoic Mozambique sedimentary basin filled with recent sediments. The objectives of this study are to use Bouguer gravity and topography data to: (1) obtain the admittance and coherence to enable us to distinguish topographic features that are isostatically compensated from those that are uncompensated; (2) estimate the flexural rigidity of the lithospheric plate assuming a regional compensation model and investigate the possibility of variation of the effective elastic thickness of the plate beneath the Archaean cratons and the Mozambique basin; (3) investigate the relative importance of surface and subsurface loading; (4) obtain an isostatic anomaly map. GEOLOGY The Zimbabwe and Kaapvaal cratons (Fig. 1 ) are Archaean low-grade granite-greenstone terrains, which have formed a stable unit since about 2300 Ma (Piper, Briden & Lomax 1973; McElhinny & McWilliams 1977), comprising greenstone belts of different ages, various mafic and ultramafic intrusions, together with a variety of granites and gneisses. The greenstone belts are the folded remnants of volcanic-sedimentary piles and, for the most part, have been metamorphosed to greenschist facies. The Archaean rocks of the Zimbabwe craton range in age from about 3500 to 2600 Ma (Nisbet, Wilson & Bickle 1981). The Great Dyke intruded the Zimbabwe craton at about 2460Ma (Hamilton 1977); the Bushveld Igneous T.for some continental areas. Area Tectonic region Method T.(km) D (Nm) Reference Australia Continental Australia Continental Australia Cratonic Australia East coast Australia Admittance Admittance Coherence Coherence <5 <1 130 15-35 < lo2' <5 x 16' 2 x 1025 (3-38) x 10'' Cochran (1980) McNutt & Parker (1978) Zuber et al. (1989) Zuber et al. (1989) Continental USA Continental USA Precambrian Shield Admittance Admittance Coherence 5-10 > 100 102'-102* < 102' < 1025 Banks et al. (1977) Cochran (1980) Bechtel et al. (1987) Kenya East African Rift East African Rift Coherence Coherence 25-30 < 25 (1.4-2.4) 1023 1.4 x 1023 Forsyth (1985) Bechtel et al. (1987) East Africa Stable cratonic regions Rift Valley Coherence Coherence 64-90 21-36 >2.3 x 1025 (8.2-41.5) x loz2 Ebinger et al. (1989) Ebinger et al. (1989) N. America <5 + 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Africa 27O 2B0E 20" 3F' 637 33' 32OE Legend International boundar) ---- El Aeolian sands Cretaceous sediments Igneous complex - Karoo voicanics Proterozoic sediments Bushveld Complex Great Dyke Paragneiss Gneiss - Greenstones Granitk AHA' Gravity profiles X++Y Seismic traverse fl-N Reststtvity profile 0 210 2PE 29' 30° 31 O 32"E 330 50 100 150 k m 3 40 Figure 1. Geological map of the Limpopo Belt and surrounding areas. NMZ =Northern Marginal Zone of the Limpopo Belt; CZ = Central Zone of the Limpopo Belt; SMZ = Southern Marginal Zone of the Limpopo Belt. A-A': gravity profiles (Gwavava 1990);X-Y seismic traverse (Stuart & Zengeni 1987); M-N resistivity profile (Van Zijl 1978). Complex, which intrudes the Kaapvaal craton, is dated at about 2000 Ma (Hunter & Hamilton 1978). The Limpopo Belt (Fig. 1) consists of Archaean rocks that have undergone high-grade metamorphism and polyphase deformation resulting in the formation of high-grade gneisses and granulites. The rocks were subjected to a major episode of metamorphism and deformation from about 2900 to 2500 Ma (Van Breemen & Dodson 1972; Hickman & Wakefield 1975) and a second event at about 2000 Ma (Van Breemen & Dodson 1972), which is shown only in mineral ages and palaeomagnetic studies. The Belt can be subdivided on both structural (Cox et al. 1965) and stratigraphic (Watkeys 1983) grounds into a Northern Marginal Zone consisting of high-grade equivalents of the Zimbabwe craton granite-greenstone terrains, a Central Zone made up mainly of mylonites and amphibolite-facies gneisses, and a Southern Marginal Zone of reworked Kaapvaal craton granitegreenstone material forming high-grade metamorphic rocks. On the eastern side of the Limpopo Belt and overlying the Karoo sediments are Karoo volcanics forming the LebomboNuanetsi-Sabi volcanics, dated between 160 and 200 Ma 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 (Hales 1960; Gough et al. 1964). The Karoo basalts in Zimbabwe, which also include rhyolites in the south, have a regional strike in an ENE direction and a gentle southerly dip of 2" to 8" (Swift et al. 1953). The volcanics along the Lebombo monocline comprise a lower basaltic group, a middle rhyolitic group and a less-extensive upper basaltic group; they dip eastwards beneath sediments of the Mozambique rift basin at between 5" and 20", reaching a maximum value of 30" to 60" before flattening out to the east (Du Toit 1929; White & McKenzie 1989); they have a thickness that is thought to increase eastwards and is estimated to be between 6 and 13 km along the coast (Eales, Marsh & Cox 1984). Associated with the extrusive rocks are intrusive complexes, which include gabbros, granophyres, granites, syenites and carbonatites. The Nuanetsi-Sabi area has a linear set of ring complexes, dated between 190 and 200 Ma (Gough et al. 1964), paralleling the ENE faulting trend of the Limpopo Belt. The Mozambique basin in the eastern part of the study area is bounded to the west by the Zimbabwe and Kaapvaal cratons. It is an asymmetric, pericontinental rift basin that developed along the East African margin and contains 638 0.Gwavava, C.J. Swain and F, Podmore Mesozoic and Cenozoic sediments that thicken eastwards (Coster, Lawrence & Fortes 1989). The post-Karoo section consists of mid-Jurassic to Tertiary marine, continental and deltaic sediments. shows a regional gravity high, which has an amplitude of about 1400gu in the southeast. Superimposed on this longwavelength feature, up to 350 km wide, are two lines of shortwavelength gravity highs coincident with the Lebombo and Nuanetsi-Sabi volcanics. The Bouguer anomalies are generally negative over the Mozambique sedimentary basin. Gwavava et al. (1992) modelled three profiles crossing the Limpopo Belt and one profile across the Mozambique basin. The crustal models were controlled by surface geology, seismic refraction results (Stuart & Zengeni 1987) and densities from outcrops. The lower-crust and upper-mantle density values in the Limpopo Belt were fixed at 2800 and 3400 kg m-3 using the seismic refraction results. In Mozambique, borehole information was used to constrain the thickness of the sediments to 3 km towards the southeastern end of profile B-B'. Gwavava et al. (1992) interpreted the positive gravity anomaly over this area largely in terms of Mesozoic crustal thinning associated with the breakup of Gondwana. The 34 km thick crust beneath the Zimbabwe craton and the Northern Marginal Zone of the Limpopo Belt thins in a SSE direction by at least 4 km beneath the central Limpopo Belt (see Fig. 6a), in accordance with the results from the seismic refraction study (along line A-A in Fig. 5) of Stuart & Zengeni (1987). Using the idea that lateral changes in densities can occur from the interior of a continent PREVIOUS GEOPHYSICAL STUDIES From a resistivity profile crossing the Limpopo Belt between the two cratons, Van Zijl (1978) suggested a horizontal Moho at a depth of 40 km and a hydrated lower Frust at a depth of 25 to 40 km (Fig. 2). Stuart & Zengeni (1987) carried out a seismic refraction study across the northern and central parts of the Limpopo Belt in Zimbabwe. The Moho of the Northern Marginal Zone, which had reverse coverage, was found to be at a depth of 34km with a P-wave velocity of 8.4kms-' (Fig. 3). In the Central Zone the Moho has a lower apparent velocity of 7.8 km s-', which is due to the Moho dipping northwards at about 6". This implies that within the Central Zone the Moho rises from a depth of 34km to 29km. Alternatively, this can be viewed as crustal thinning in a southerly direction. Gwavava et al. (1992) present results from a recent gravity survey in the study area compiled with data from surrounding countries (see Fig. 4). The Bouguer anomaly map (Fig. 5) Kaapvaal, Craton ! Limpopo B e l t I : Zimbabwe Craton M 20 E 2 -5 40 fa 0 - 0.01 60 - 80 Zone 4 20 t' - 0.05 - 30 1 I Figure 2. Resistivity profile across the Limpopo Belt (Van Zijl 1978). Present-day crustal thickness is assumed to be 40 km. Zone 3 is at a depth of 25 km beneath the Limpopo Belt. _____ E -r: 20 E - f 0 - 40 -I-- ---5.7 k m l s 6.5 kmls - - - - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _5_. 8 _km/_s- 6.4 k m l s L ,@ "c5. .?is 3 -____ _________' - - __---_ - , -,<,-.7:. :. ::: : : : : : .. .. : : : : : : : : : . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... : : .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . .* ............................ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 . 4 k m l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................................................ ................................................................ - Figure 3. Crustal model deduced from seismic studies (Stuart & Zengeni 1987). Note that the crustal thickness under Rutenga is about 34 km and thins beneath the Central Zone to about 29 km. 0 1996 RAS, GJL 127, 635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Africa 19a S 190 200 20’ 639 S .. ..... Legend Gravity s t a t i o n s ---- lnternatlonal boundary 210 210 2 20 220 23O S 23O 240 240 25O 259 0 100 50 150km S Figure 4. Gravity-station distribution map of the study area. Reprinted from Gwavava et al. (1992) with kind permission of Elsevier ScienceNL, Sara Burgerhartstraat 25, 1055 KV Amsterdam, The Netherlands. to its margin (Boillot 1981), Gwavava et al. (1992) argued that it is possible that the upper-mantle density under the Mozambique basin could be lower than that under the Limpopo Belt. Thus they presented an alternative model to Fig. 6(a) showing that the crust under the Mozambique basin could be even more highly extended and attenuated to a thickness of only about 22 km (see Fig. 6b). The latter model would then be consistent with a tighter fit of Antarctica against the Sabi and Lebombo monoclines if an anomalous low-density upper mantle (3100 kg m-3) exists under the Mozambique basin. Heat-flow measurements of direct relevance to this study were made by Ballard & Pollack (1987) in southern Africa and Nyblade et al. (1990) in East and southern Africa. Both studies show a general trend of increasing heat flow away from the centres of Archaean cratons into surrounding younger Proterozoic and Pan-African mobile belts. Nyblade et a/.. (1990) give a mean heat flow of 4 7 + 2 m W m - ’ for the Archaean Kaapvaal and Zimbabwe cratons. They report a single site in the northern margin of the Limpopo Belt with a heat-flow value of 49mWm-’. At the time of writing this paper there were no published heat-flow data for the Mozambique sedimentary basin. Heat flow can be interpreted directly in terms of lithospheric thickness (Chapman & Pollack 1977) and so is highly relevant. 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 D E F I N I T I O N S OF ISOSTATIC RESPONSE A N D COHERENCE F U N C T I O N S We use the Fourier amplitudes of Bouguer gravity, B(k), and topography, H(k), in the wavenumber (k) domain to obtain the power and cross-spectra of the two data sets and then use them to define the admittance and coherence. Several authors (e.g. Dorman & Lewis 1970; McKenzie & Bowin 1976; Forsyth 1985; Bechtel, Forsyth & Swain 1987; Lambeck 1988) give a more detailed explanation of most of the expressions quoted below. Defining the following: power of gravity Eo = (B(k)B*(k)) power of topography El= (H(k)H*(k)), cross-spectrum Co = (B(k)ff*(k)) 9 (1) 3 where the angle brackets ( ) denote azimuthal averaging over discrete wavenumber bands, the asterisk repesents a complex conjugate, and the magnitude of the wavenumber k in the horizontal x-y plane is k = Ikl= (kz + kc)”’. (2) The isostatic response function is given by Q(k)= Co/Ei > (3) 0.Gwavava, C . f. Swain and F. Podmore 640 0 28OE I 4 30° 290 I 1 I I 31O I 1 32OE 1 I 330 I 1 \ /I 1 19O 19" 5 5 Legend ---- International boundary Balane 20- Bouguer gravity contours a t intervals o f 20 mGals. Gravity profile -. 200 2 00 A 210 210 +---I A' 220 23O 23O 5 well GD Great Dyke MG Mberengwa greenstone belt 0 I 22" -1 0 50 1 100 , l5Okm 1 5 240 240 25" 25O 2 Figure 5. Bouguer anomaly map of the Limpopo Belt and surrounding areas. Reprinted from Gwavava et al. (1992) with kind permission of and the observed coherence is y; = C ; / E o E 1 . (4) An unbiased estimate of the observed coherence used in this study is Y2=(nY6-1)k-1), (5) where n is the number of independent Fourier coefficients within a wavenumber band (Munk & Cartwright 1966). Unlike the observed coherence, which is always positive, the unbiased coherence can be negative if the product of n and y; is less than unity. This happens when both n and yg are small. The error in the observed coherence is Ay2 = ( 1 - yi)( 2y$")1'2 (6) (Bendat & Piersol 1980). A theoretical isostatic model has an admittance that attains a value of the Bouguer slab correction (-27cGp) at long wavelengths and zero at short wavelengths (see Banks, Parker & Huestis 1977; Ebinger et al. 1989). For a flexure model the predicted coherence between Bouguer gravity and topography (1) is unity for long-wavelength topography, implying that the plate is too weak to support the loads and therefore surface and subsurface loads are fully locally compensated; (2) is zero for short-wavelength features, i.e. the loads are completely supported by the strength of the plate and are therefore not compensated; and (3) changes from unity to zero in the rolloff region, implying some regional compensation. The transition from high to low coherency depends to a large extent on the flexural rigidity of the plate, to a small extent on the ratio of bottom-to-top loading (for a two-layer model), and is almost independent of the depth of bottom loading (Forsyth 1985; see Fig. 10). The observed coherence can therefore be matched to the predicted coherence to yield an estimate of the flexural rigidity. DATA SETS The 6679 irregularly spaced gravity values (Gwavava 1990) in the area from 27" to 34"E and 18" to 25"s (see Fig.4) were interpolated using minimum curvature (Swain 1976) onto a 1/12O regular grid (9.2 km) to produce an 85 x 85 array. The topography data were obtained by digitizing by hand the mean elevations from 1 :250 000 relief maps on a 1/12" square grid (Gwavava 1990). The topography has values of over 1000 m in the northern and western parts of the area and gradually decreases to about 50 m in the southeastern corner of the area (see Fig. 7). 0 1996 RAS, G J I 127, 635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Africa I 20 40 0 Observad x Calculated G r a v i t y 641 Gravity -40 d m c rn L -60 -80 a, 3 7 -100 0 m -120 -1 40 -160 I 0 I 50 I 100 I I I I I I 200 250 300 Distance in k m 150 B I 350 400 0 E + 10 0" 30 .-c f 20 a. / 3600 Oensity model 40 20 .-c -20 =E -40 m m -60 & -80 1 cn m -100 -120 -140 -160 I 0 1 1 1 50 100 150 I 200 250 300 , Distance in km 51 I I 350 400 1 Density model Figure 6. (a) A simple 2.5-D interpretation of profile B-B (Gwavava et al. 1992). The surface of the density model represents the topography. Density in kg m-3. (b) Alternative model of profile B-B showing that the crust is highly extended and attenuated. Crustal thickness beneath B on the craton is about 34 km, whereas that beneath B is about 22 km. 0 1996 RAS, G J I 127, 635-650 642 0. Gwavaua, C. J. Swain and F. Podmore , 27E 28E g 29E I 3GE I 31E 32E I I 33E I 341 I 1.3: 1BS 19s 19s 20s 20s 21 s 21 s 22s 22s 23s 23s 24s 24s 25s 25s I L I I I I I I !7E 28E 29E 30E 31 E 32E 33E 34E -5 100 150 km Figure 7. Topography map of the study area. Contour intervals at 50 m. The gridded gravity and topography data were mirrored along the northern and eastern boundary and then Fourier transformed using the FORTRAN subroutines of Banks ( 1979), which utilize a fast Fourier transform algorithm (Singleton 1969). Prior to Fourier transformation, the mean of each data set was removed. To compute the admittance and coherence, the cross and power spectra were estimated by taking azimuthal averages in wavenumber bands chosen such that the midpoints of these bands were at approximately logarithmic intervals. The mean wavenumber at which the admittance and coherence were estimated was obtained by weighting each wavenumber within a wavenumber band with the product of the power of the Bouguer gravity and the power of the topography rather than taking the mid-point of a wavenumber band. FLEXURAL MODEL A N D COHERENCE TECHNIQUE We used a two-layer elastic-plate model (with loads both at the surface and at the Moho) for which we have calculated the theoretical coherence, and hence estimated its effective elastic thickness, using the theory outlined by Forsyth ( 1985). Other authors who have based their interpretation on this formulation include Bechtel et al. (1987), Ebinger et al. (1989) and Zuber, Bechtel & Forsyth (1989). The coherence technique is carried out in the wavenumber domain, in which the elasticplate equation has a very simple form. In summary, it involves first downward continuing the gravity to find the Moho relief ( W ) ,then, for a given rigidity (5),solving for the initial surface topography ( H I ) and Moho relief (WI),from which the components of relief on these interfaces due to loading at both top and bottom can be found: H=HT+HB and W=WT+WB, (7) where HT and H B are components of the surface topography due to top and bottom loading respectively. WT and WB are similarly defined with respect to the Moho relief. Once WZ and H I are known, the ratio f of initial bottomto-top loading at every wavenumber k can be found from Ap WI f=- PoHI ’ (8) where A p is the density contrast between the mantle and crust, of densities pm and p o respectively. The theoretical coherence is then calculated, after upward continuing the Moho relief to get its gravity effect at the surface, and compared to the observed coherence at each wavenumber to get a root-meansquare misfit. This calculation is repeated for a range of D values to find a best estimate in a least-squares sense of 5. Note that load maps and components of relief are then available for this 5 value leaving no isostatic anomalies. Note also that there is no unique solution for H I and WI at the longest wavelengths, for which the plate is weak and top and bottom loading are indistinguishable. There is thus a locally compensated long-wavelength component of topography HC. 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Africa 643 Effective elastic thickness from the coherence technique RESULTS Admittance The admittance Q(k) (see Fig. 8) of the mirrored data shows a response that is: (1) mainly negative for topographic features with wavelengths greater than 200 km; and (2) close to zero for features with wavelengths less than 200 km. Features with wavelengths greater than the unreflected size of the data set (770 km) may not be present in the data. There are large errors, especially in the fall-off region, which is an indication of departures from the single isostatic model assumed to represent the map area. These are most likely to be variations in D or in the ratio of subsurface to surface loading (f),which both strongly affect the admittance (Forsyth 1985). Coherence The observed coherence (Fig.9) falls from unity to zero somewhere between wavelengths of 770 to 300 km, i.e. at longer wavelengths than for the Kenya curve. According to our flexural model the data imply that at wavelengths longer than about 450-770 km the plate bends under loads, while at wavelengths shorter than 300 km topography is supported by the strength of the plate (lithosphere). A comparison of Figs 9 and 10, to get an initial estimate of the effective elastic thickness of the plate (T,), shows that T, lies in the range 35 to 55 km for a model with f = 1, ,z = 35 km, po = 2670 kg m-3 and A p = 600 kg m-3. A more reliable estimate of the elastic thickness is described in the next section. A computer program (Forsyth, personal communication) to determine iteratively the effective elastic thickness and loads for a two-layer model (summarized above) was used with data for the whole area. The study area was then divided into two tectonic areas (i.e. one block covering the cratons and another the sediments in Mozambique), where we expect uniform T, in each area. The effective elastic thickness of each subregion was similarly determined for mirrored data. The size of each block had to be made sufficiently large to observe coherence values approaching unity at long wavelengths, as well as the transition wavebands. Since the size of the area was only 770 x 770 km, it was necessary to have the two subregions overlapping (see Fig. 1). The model parameters used in the inversion program are listed in Table 2 and the results in Table 3. Note that there are no predicted coherences at the longest wavelengths, for which the observed coherences approach unity as these wavebands are affected by the mirroring process. The authors tried several bigger block sizes for both the cratonic area (up to 900 x 900 km) and the Mozambique sedimentary basin (up to 370 x 600 km) in order to obtain realistic error estimates of T,. For the whole area, Fig. 11 shows that the coherence estimates have been made at more closely spaced wavenumbers than in Fig. 9 in an attempt to constrain T, more tightly. The range of T, values (50-57 km) implies a flexural rigidity of the lithospheric plate of 1.11-1.65 x Nm. For the cratonic areas, a 5" square block (27" to 32"E by 19" to 24"s) consisting mainly of the Zimbabwe and Kaapvaal cratons with part of the Limpopo Belt in between the cratons was selected (see Fig. 1). A large portion of the area covered by the Lebombo-Nuanetsi-Sabi volcanics was also included on the eastern side to give a sufficiently large area. The coherence for the cratonic area (Fig. 12) yields an effective elastic I I I I I -0.10 -0 .08 I I I i 0.08 Wavenumber x 2 rad/km Figure 8. Isostatic response function of the Bouguer gravity and topography. The response is generally negative for topographical features of wavelengths greater than 200 km. 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 644 0. Gwavava, C. J. Swain and F. Podmore Wavelength 1.10 1 .oo I,I 1000 1 , I 1 I 1 1 , I i n km 100 I llil ' I I I I - 0.90- 0.80 0.70 - 0.60C (u L 0.50- a, LZ 8 0.40- 0.300 . 2 00.10 - 0.00I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 I I 1 1 1 0.01 Wavenumber x 2 1 1 0.1 rad/km Figure 9. Observed coherence curve. Upper curve is for Kenya (Swain 1979) and lower curve is for this study. Wavelength a, U C 1 .oo - 0.90 - 0.80 - 0.70 - i n km 0.60 - a, L a, 0.50 S 0 V 0.40 - - 0.30 - 0.20 - 0.100.00- V . Wavenumber x 27T 1 rad/km Figure 10. Theoretical coherence curves assuming a flexure model with a bottom-to-toploading ratio off = 1, effective elastic thickness T.= 5 to 100 km and depth to Moho of 35 km. thickness in the range 52-62 km. The observed coherences for wavelengths less than 200 km lie on the theoretical curve for T,= 22 km (Fig. 13), indicating the possible influence of a weaker plate, probably due to the inclusion of the LebomboNuanetsi-Sabi volcanics, an area of thinned crust (Gwavava et al. 1992). For the Mozambique sedimentary area a 3" square area was chosen extending from 30.5" to about 34"E and 21" to 24.5"s. The coherence technique gives an effective elastic thickness of 22 1 km. The negative coherence (Fig. 13) can be explained by the lowest Bouguer anomalies in this area correlating with the lowest elevation due to a large thickness of low-density sediments. A bigger block of this area, which includes a sizeable portion of the craton on the western part of the sedimentary 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Africa Table 2. Two-layer model parameters for the inversion program. Parameter -m Po Pm E G g P Isostatic anomalies Definition Value Depth to Moho Average crust density Mantle density Young’s modulus Gravitational constant Gravitational acceleration Poisson’s ratio 34 km 2800 kg m-3 3400 kg IT-^ 1.0 x 10” Nm-’ 6.67 x lo-” m3 kg-ls-’ 9.8 m s-’ 0.25 The two-layer model assumed, although adequate for estimating T, (Forsyth 1985), is certainly an oversimplification as it explains the gravity anomalies having no topographic correlation in terms of Moho relief. This includes ones with relatively short wavelengths like the Sabi-Nuanetsi-Lebombo anomalies, which are at least partly due to upper-crustal intrusions (Gwavava et a/. 1992). (It is worth noting here that the downward continuation is stabilized at short wavelengths by allowing ekz a maximum value of 5, i.e. a minimum wavelength of 133 km.) The load maps are misleading because these intracrustal density contrasts have not been considered, and are not presented here; instead, we give an isostatic anomaly map. In order to generate isostatic anomalies, a filter was designed using the square root of the coherence (Banks & Swain 1978) of the best-fitting elastic-plate model with a T, of 52 km. It is easier to generate theoretical coherence curves using a constant ratio f . Several values o f f were tried and it was found that f = 1.5 best reproduced the observed coherence. This filter gives an estimate of the attraction of the compensating masses, which is subtracted from the Bouguer anomaly to obtain isostatic anomalies. The isostatic anomalies (Fig. 14) range from -600 to + 1000 gu (1 gu=O.l mGal). The Lebombo-Nuanetsi-Sabi area has large positive isostatic anomalies. These positive isostatic anomalies are a combination of the gravity effects of the Moho shallowing rapidly southeastwards (and overcompensating the fall in elevation, which is gentle and occurs further north) and uncompensated igneous intrusions. The Great Dyke and the Bushveld Igneous Complex also exhibit positive isostatic anomalies, and these represent the gravity effect of uncompensated masses within the upper crust. Table 3. Effective elastic thickness T,. Area T,(km) T- (km) T,,, (km) rms Whole area Cratons Mozambique (small block) Mozambique (big block) 52 56 22 34 50 52 21 29 57 62 23 39 0.137 0.160 0.203 0.043 Note: (1) rms is the root mean square of the misfit between the observed and predicted coherence. Tminand T,, are the minimum and maximum elastic-plate thicknesses that fit the same number of points in the fall-off region as the best-fitting model. ET: (2) Flexural rigidity D = 12(1 - p Z ) ’ ~ basin, gave a T, estimate of 34 km. These T, values are similar to the ones obtained using the coherence technique (21-44 km) for the East African Rift zones (Bechtel et al. 1987; Ebinger et aZ. 1989), for eastern Australia (Zuber et al. 1989) and for Afar (Ebinger et a/. 1989). Ebinger (personal communication, 1993) has re-analysed the Afar area with more data, and the results suggest a still-weaker lithosphere with T, less than 10 km. W a v e l e n g t h i n km 1 10 1000 1111 I I I 100 I I I I I I I I .- I ~--PPeO~cteC a oherence o a s e r v s d cOnBrenCe 1.oo 0.90 0.80 0.70 0.60 I c al 0.50 L al .c 8 0.40 0.30 0.20 0.10 1 0.00 -0.10 1 1 I 1 I J 1 1 1 0.001 I 1 - 1 I I I I I I I 0.01 Wavenumber x 2 I I I I I I l-r rad/km Figure 11. Observed (solid line) and predicted (dashed line) coherence curves for the whole area. Best estimate of T, = 52 2 km. 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 645 646 0.Gwavava, C . J. Swain and F. Podrnore w t venumber 2 T rad/km Figure 12. Observed (solid line) and predicted (dashed line) coherence curves for the cratonic areas including the Limpopo Belt. The perturbation of the curve for wavelengths of less than 200 km is probably due to the inclusion of the Lebombo-Nuanetsi-Sabi volcanic area. W a v e l e n g t h i n km 1000 o - - - P r e d i = t e e Caneience m - o ~ s e r v e ac o n e ~ e n c e 0.90 0.00 0, 7 01 a, 0.60 U C al L @.I c 0 u 0.50 - 0.40 - 0.30 - 0.20 - 0.10 - 0.00-0.10 I I I I ' 0.001 I U I Wavenumber 2 I l l l l ~ C d.01 rad/km Figure 13. Observed (solid line) and predicted (dashed line) coherence curves for the Mozambique sedimentary area. There are negative isostatic anomalies of up to - 300 gu over the Mozambique basin. These are due to the gravity effect of low-density Cretaceous and Tertiary sediments. A large zone of negative anomalies extends NE from about 30.5"E, 20.5"s.This zone coincides with the southward downslope from the watershed (see Figs 15 and 16), which is relatively recently eroded and probably has not yet had time to adjust isostatically to this erosion. 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127,635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Africa 27E 28E 29E 30E 31 E 32E 33E I I I I I I 647 34E I 185 18s 195 19s 205 20s 215 21s 222 22s 232 235 242 24s 25s 255 I I I I I I I 27E 28E 29E 30E 31 E 32E 33E 50 I 34t 100 150 0 krn Figure 14. Isostatic anomaly map of the study area obtained by filtering the gravity with the square root of the coherence. Contour intervals at 10 mGals. Note: 1 mGal = 10 gu. la1 ..1500 ~ E I r" Pm 500 I I 5 so0 - 1 : -- r -500 Figure 15. N-S profiles showing components of the topography along 31"E. Note that h = h, ih, 4- hb. The Southern Marginal Zone at about 29.5"E, 23.5"s has a positive isostatic anomaly of more than 300 gu, which may be due to dense upper-crustal rocks (granulites). Immediately north of this high is a low reaching -200 gu. The steep linear gradient between the two anomalies appears to mark the Soutpansberg fault zone. 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127,635-650 18's 1 19" 2 o y 2lP-l 210 + 2c 25"s Figure 16. N-S profiles showing components of the topography along 32"E. Note that h = h, + h, + hb. Components of topography Although we do not show the load maps, because our twolayer model attributes all the isostatic anomalies except the shortest wavelengths to Moho relief, we think that the components of topography are instructive. Two N-S profiles 648 0. Gwavava, C . J . Swain and F. Podmore (Figs 15 and 16), each 770 km long, illustrate the components of topography due to surface and subsurface loading. The present topography h is the sum of the locally compensated topography h, and topography due to surface loading h, and to subsurface loading hb. Both profiles show that a large fraction of the present topography is locally compensated, probably by density variations in the upper mantle. For these profiles, surface and subsurface loadings seem to have about equal importance in the development of the topography (i.e. f z 1). In Fig. 15 the subsurface loading profile hb implies 2 to 3 km of crustal thinning, in rough agreement with the model of Gwavava et al. (1992) along profile A-A. DISCUSSION A regional isostatic compensation model was used to study isostatic compensation in the region. The model assumes that the lithosphere behaves as an elastic plate, responding to surface and subsurface loads by flexure. Using the coherence between Bouguer gravity and topography it was found that loads with wavelengths greater than about 500 km (Fig. 11) are fully locally compensated, and for these wavelengths surface and subsurface loads are thus indistinguishable; loads with wavelengths in the range 300 to 500 km are partially regionally compensated (i.e. partly supported by the plate) and loads with wavelengths less than 300 km are uncompensated, i.e. they are completely supported by the strength of the lithosphere. An effective elastic thickness (T,) of the lithospheric plate of 52 + 5/-2 km was obtained for the model that best fits the observed coherence. This gives a flexural rigidity D of about 1.25 x Nm. The coherence technique when applied to two tectonically different subregions, the cratons and the Mozambique basin, yielded different elastic-plate thicknesses. The value of 56 km for the cratonic area is felt to be a minimum value since it includes the Limpopo Belt, for which T, is almost certainly smaller than for the cratons. Bearing this in mind, we feel there is no discrepancy with the values of 60 to >90 km obtained for cratonic areas in Sudan, Zaire and Congo (Ebinger et al. 1989). The Mozambique rift basin, containing Cretaceous and Tertiary sediments, has an elastic-plate thickness in the range 21-39 km, which is significantly lower than the value obtained for the cratonic area. Ebinger et al. (1989) found similar values for rifted zones of East Africa (T,=21-36 km). Using 2.5-D modelling, this area of Mozambique was shown by Gwavava et al. (1992) to have a thinner crust than the cratons by 4 to 12 km (Figs 4a, b). Although T, does not relate directly to crustal thickness, a thin elastic plate agrees with the idea that the lithosphere under the Mozambique sedimentary area was stretched and thinned during the breakup of Gondwana, and we feel it offers support to the alternative 2.5-D gravity model (Fig. 4b) involving greater crustal thinning and a low-density (3100 kg m-3) uppermost mantle beneath the Mozambique basin. The difference in elastic-plate thickness for the cratonic area and the Mozambique basin supports the contention that stable cratons are underlain by relatively strong lithosphere compared to younger rifted or stretched continental crust. The difference in plate strength for the two subregions implies that there exists a transitional region where the strength of the lithosphere increases rapidly to the north and west: this transitional region lies beneath the Lebombo-Nuanetsi-Sabi volcanics. We would therefore expect a difference in thermal lithospheric structure between the Archaean cratons and the Mozambique basin i.e. low heat flow in the cratons and high heat flow in the Mozambique basin. The map of isostatic anomalies (Fig. 16) shows prominent zones of positive and negative isostatic anomalies corresponding to areas with uncompensated masses either in the upper crust, the lower crust or at the Moho. The area with thinned crust and magmatic intrusions, the Lebombo-Nuanetsi-Sabi area, stands out as a zone of positive isostatic anomalies on the map (Fig. 15). It is interesting to note that the SMZ (Fig. 1) is characterized by positive isostatic anomalies, whereas negative isostatic anomalies occur over the NMZ. This difference is interpreted as being due to granulites of the SMZ being significantly denser than granulites of the NMZ. Densities of granulites in the NMZ were found by Gwavava (1990) to be about 2690 kg m-3, which is close to that of granites on the Zimbabwe craton (2670 kg m-’)). If this slight increase in density (20 kg m-3) is assumed to apply to a layer 5.8 km thick (Stuart & Zengeni 1987), the upper crust there would give rise to a positive anomaly of only about 5Ogu. This is very small compared to the isostatic anomalies of up to 400 gu observed over the SMZ. CONCLUSIONS These results reveal that the lithosphere is relatively stronger under the Archaean stable cratons than beneath the Mesozoic Mozambique basin. This difference in elastic behaviour of the lithosphere is linked to the separation of Antarctica from Africa during the breakup of Gondwana, which started in the Jurassic. The breakup of Gondwana resulted not only in stretching and thinning of the lithosphere, but also in extensive rifting and volcanism. Basins such as the Mozambique basin developed during the Karoo rifting, and as the basins were loaded with sediments the crust flexurally subsided. The main conclusions from this paper are as follows. (1) The Archaean cratons have an effective elastic thickness of at least 56 km compared with values in the range 21-39 km for the Mozambique basin. (2) We deduce from the coherence function of the whole area that for topographic features with wavelengths greater than about 500 km the lithosphere behaves as though it were weak, whereas features of wavelength less than 300 km are completely supported; features of intermediate wavelength are partially supported by the plate. (3) The isostatic anomaly map is characterized by an outstanding zone of positive anomalies along the Lebombe Nuanetsi-Sabi volcanics zone, which is due to a combination of crustal thinning and basic intrusions emplaced in the upper crust. This zone also marks the transition between the strong lithosphere of the cratons and the weak lithosphere under the Mozambique basin. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS A major part of this paper comes from a Doctor of Philosophy study by OG. We thank the University of Zimbabwe Research 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127, 635-650 Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Africa Board for funding the study. We also thank the British Council for financial assistance through the Universities of Zimbabwe and Leeds link scheme which enabled OG to carry out some of the interpretation at the University of Leeds. REFERENCES Airy, G.B., 1855. On the computation of the effect of the attraction of mountain-masses as disturbing the apparent astronomical latitude of stations of geodetic surveys, Phil. Trans. R . Soc. Lond., 145, 101-104. Ballard, S. & Pollack, H.N., 1987. Diversion of heat by Archean cratons: a model for southern Africa, Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 85, 253-264. Banks, R.J., 1979. Two dimensional data analysis using a library of FORTRAN IV subroutines, Unpubl. report, University of Lancaster. Banks, R.J. & Swain, C.J., 1978. The isostatic compensation of East Africa, Proc. R. Soc. Lond., A, 364, 331-352. Banks, R.J., Parker, R.L. & Huestis, S.P., 1977. Isostatic compensation on a continental scale: focal versus regional mechanisms, Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 51, 431-452. Bechtel, T.D., Forsyth, D.W. & Swain, C.J., 1987. Mechanisms of isostatic compensation in the vicinity of the East African Rift, Kenya, Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 90, 445-465. Bechtel, T.D., Forsyth, D.W., Sharpton, V.L. & Grieve, R.A.F., 1990. Variations in effective elastic thickness of the North American lithosphere, Nature, 343, 636-638. Bendat, J.S. & Piersol, A.G., 1980. Engineering Applications o j Correlation and Spectral Analysis, John Wiley, New York, NY. Bills, B.G. & May, G.M., 1987. Lake Bonneville: constraints on lithospheric thickness and upper mantle viscosity from isostatic warping of Bonneville, Provo, and Gilbert stage shorelines, J. geophys. Res., 92, 11 493-1 1 508. Boillot, G., 1981. Geology of the Continental Margins, Longman, New York, NY. Chapman, D.S. & Pollack, H.N., 1977. Regional geotherms and lithosphere thickness, Geology, 5, 265-268. Cochran, J.R., 1980. Some remarks on isostasy and the long-term behaviour of the continental lithosphere, Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 46, 266-274. Coster, P.W., Lawrence, S.R. & Fortes, G., 1989. Mozambique: a new geological framework for hydrocarbons exploration, J. Petrol. Geol., 12, 205-230. Cox, K.G., Johnson, R.L., Monkman, L.J., Stillman, C.J., Vail, J.R. & Wood, D.N., 1965. The geology of the Nuanetsi Igneous Province, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond,, A, 257, 71-218. Dorman, L.M. & Lewis, B.T.R., 1970. Experimental isostasy, 1, Theory of the determination of the Earth’s isostatic response to a concentrated load, J . geophys. Rex. 75, 3357-3365. Du Toit, A.L., 1929. The volcanic belt of the Lebombo-a region of tension, Trans. R . Soc. S . Ajr., 18, 189-217. Eales, H.V., Marsh, J.S. & Cox, K.G., 1984. The Karoo Igneous Province: an introduction, Geol. Soc. S. Afr. Spec. Publ., 13, 1-26. Ebinger, C.J., Bechtel, T.D., Forsyth, D.W. & Bowin, C.O., 1989. Effective elastic thickness beneath the East African and Afar plateaus and dynamic compensation of the uplifts, J. geophys. Res., 94, 2883-2901. Forsyth, D.W., 1985. Subsurface loading and estimates of the flexural rigidity of continental lithosphere, J . geophys. Res., 90, 12 623-12 632. Gough, D.I., Brock, A., Jones, D.L. & Opdyke, N.D., 1964. The paleomagnetism of the ring complexes at Marangudzi and Mateke Hills, J. geophys. Res., 69, 2499-2507. Gwavava, O., 1990. A regional gravity study of the Limpopo Belt and mechanisms of isostatic compensation in the region, D. Phil. thesis, University of Zimbabwe. Gwavava, O., Swain, C.J., Podmore, F. & Fairhead, J.D., 1992. 0 1996 RAS, G J I 127, 635-650 649 Evidence of crustal thinning beneath the Limpopo Belt and Lebombo monocline of southern Africa based on regional gravity studies and implications for the reconstruction of Gondwana, Tectonophysics, 212, 1-20. Hales, A.L., 1960. Research at the Bernard Price Institute of Geophysical Research, University of the Witswatersrand, Johannesburg, Proc. R. Soc. Lond., A, 258, 1-26. Hamilton, J., 1977. Sr isostope and trace element studies of the Great Dyke and Bushveld Mafic Phase and their relation to early Proterozoic magma genesis in southern Africa, J . Petrol., 18, 24-52. Hickman, M.H. & Wakefield, J., 1975. Tectonic implications of new geochronologic data from the Limpopo Belt at Pikwe, Botswana, southern Africa, Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 86, 1468-1472. Hunter, D.R. & Hamilton, P.J., 1978. The Bushveld Complex, in Evolution of the Earth’s Crust, pp. 107-173, ed. Tarling, D.H., Academic Press, London. Karner, G.D. & Watts, A.B., 1983. Gravity anomalies and flexure of the lithosphere at mountain ranges, J . geophys. Res., 88, 10 449-10 477. Lambeck, K., 1988. Geophysical Geodesy: the Slow Deformations ojthe Earth, Oxford University Press, New York, NY. McElhinny, M.W. & McWilliams, M.O., 1977. Precambrian geodynamics-a palaeomagnetic view, Tectonophysics, 40, 137-159. McKenzie, D.P. & Bowin, C., 1976. The relationship between bathymetry and gravity in the Atlantic Ocean, J. geophys. Res., 81, 1903- 1915. McNutt, M.K. & Menard, H.W., 1982. Constraints on yield strength in the oceanic lithosphere derived from observations of flexure, Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 71, 363-394. McNutt, M.K. & Parker, R.L., 1978. Isostasy in Australia and the evolution of the compensation mechanism, Science, 199, 773-775. Munk, W.H. & Cartwright, D.E., 1966. Tidal spectroscopy and prediction, Phil. Trans. R . Soc. Lond. A,, 259, 533-581. Nakiboglu, S.M. & Lambeck, K., 1983. A reevaluation of the isostatic rebound of Lake Bonneville, J. geophys. Res., 88, 10 439-10 447. Nisbet, E.G., Wilson, J.F. & Bickle, M.J., 1981. The evolution of the Rhodesian craton and adjacent Archaeau terrain: tectonic models, in Precambrian Plate Tectonics, pp. 161-183, ed. Kroner, A,, Elsevier, Amsterdam. Nyblade, A.A., Pollack, H.N., Jones, D.L., Podmore, F. & Mushayandebvu, M., 1990. Terrestrial heat flow in East and Southern Africa, J . geophys. Res., 95, 17 371-17 384. Passey, Q.R., 1981. Upper mantle viscosity derived from the difference in rebound of the Provo and Bonneville shorelines: Lake Bonneville basin, Utah, J . geophys. Res., 86, 11 701-11 708. Piper, J.D.A., Briden, J.C. & Lomax, K., 1973. Precambrian Africa and South America as a single continent, Nature, 245, 244-248. Pratt, J.H., 1855. On the attraction of the Himalaya Mountains and of the elevated regions beyond them, upon the plumb line in India, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., 145, 53-100. Singleton, R.C., 1969. An algorithm for computing the Mixed Radix FFT, IEEE Trans. Audio Acoust., AU17, 93-103. Stern, T.A. &ten Brink, U.S., 1989. Flexural uplift of the Transantarctic Mountains, J. geophys. Res., 94, 10 315-10 330. Stuart, G.W. & Zengeni, T.G., 1987. Seismic crustal structure of the Limpopo mobile belt, Zimbabwe, Tectonophysics, 144, 323-335. Swain, C.J., 1976. A FORTRAN IV program for interpolating irregularly spaced data using the difference equations for minimum curvature, Comput. Geosci., 1, 231-240. Swain, C.J., 1979. Gravity and seismic measurements in Kenya, PhD thesis, University of Leicester. Swift, W.H., White, W.C., Wiles, J.C. &Worst, B.G., 1953. The geology of the Lower Sabi Coalfield, S. Rhodesia Geol. Suru. Bull., 40. Van Breemen, 0. & Dodson, M.H., 1972. Metamorphic chronology of the Limpopo Belt, southern Africa, Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 83, 2005-201 8. Van Zijl, J.S.V., 1978. The relationship between the deep electrical resistivity structure and tectonic provinces in southern Africa. Part 1. 650 0. Gwauava, C. J. Swain and F. Podmore Results obtained by Schlumberger soundings, Trans. Geol. SOC. S. AJr., 81, 129-142. Watkeyi, M.K., 1983. Brief explanatory notes on the provisional geological map of the Limpopo Belt and environs, Geol. Soc. S . Afr. Spec. Publ., 8, 5-8. Watts, A.B., Karner, G.D. & Steckler, M.S., 1982. Lithospheric flexure and the evolution of sedimentary basins, Phil. Trans. R . Soc. Lond., A, 305, 249-281. White, R. & McKenzie, D., 1989. Magmatism at rift zones: The generation of volcanic continental margins and flood basalts, J. geophys. Res., 94, 7685-7729. Zuber, M.T., Bechtel, T.D. & Forsyth, D.W., 1989. Effective elastic thicknesses of the lithosphere and mechanisms of isostatic compensation in Australia, J. geophys. Res., 94, 9353-9367. 0 1996 RAS, GJI 127,635-650
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz