Vol. 46, No. 2 Printed in U.S.A. T U B AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PATHOLOGY Copyright © 1906 by The Williams & Wilkins Co. CREATINE PHOSPHOKINASE DETERMINATION BY THE NINHYDRIN REACTION FLUORESCENT REX B. CONN, J B . , M.D., AND VICENTE ANIDO, M.D. Department of Pathology, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia Creatine phosphokinase (CPK) (adenosine triphosphate [ATP] creatine transphosphorylase) catalyzes the reaction: Creatine + ATP <=* Creatine-P0 4 + ADP The enzyme is present in large quantities in skeletal and heart muscle, and measurement of its serum levels has proven valuable in the diagnosis of myocardial infarction and certain types of muscular dystrophy. 6 ' 7| 8 It has a definite advantage over other enzyme tests used for this purpose in that neither pulmonary disease nor hepatic disease produce elevated serum levels of CPK. Several methods for determining CPK have been proposed. These methods are based upon 1 or another of the following principles: A. Measurement of creatine phosphate (CP) formation in the forward reaction by the determination of "apparent" inorganic phosphate in CP with a colorimetric method.10 B. Measurement of ATP produced in the reverse reaction by utilization of it in ahexokinase-glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase coupled reaction. The reaction rate is followed by spectrophotometric measurement of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH) production.12 Glucose + ATP *± Glucose-6-P0 4 + ADP Glucosc-6-P0 4 + NADP+ <=* 6-phosphogluconate + NADPH + H+ C. Measurement of adenosine diphosphate (ADP) production in the forward reaction by a coupled pyruvate kinaselactate dehydrogenase system which can be followed spectrophotometrically by measurReceived, January 31, 1966. This investigation was supported in whole by Public Health Research Grants R01 AM 09372-01 MET from The National Institute of Arthritis and Metabolic Diseases and R01 12884-01 from The National Institute of General Medical Sciences. ing the disappearance of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH). 15 Phosphoenolpyruvate + ADP <=* Pyruvate + ATP Pyruvate + NADH + H+ <=± Lactate + NAD+ D. Measurement of creatine produced in the reverse reaction by means of the diacetyl reaction.1, "• 6 ' 8 The kinetics of creatine phosphokinase are complex, and there is disagreement on optimal substrate concentrations, product inhibition, activation by sulfhydryl groups, anion inhibition, and on what constitutes the "true" substrate of the enzyme. In addition, a much higher concentration of enzyme is apparently needed to catalyze the forward reaction than the reverse reaction at comparable rates. Because of the apparent clinical usefulness of the CPK determination, we wished to study some of the problems related to its measurement and to adapt a previously described fluorometric method for measuring creatine 2,3 to the determination of CPK. Utilization of the reverse reaction appeared most suitable, first because a given enzyme concentration produces a greater activity in this direction,6 and second, because utilization of the forward reaction would require measurement of a small change in a relatively large creatine concentration, rather than the production of small quantities of creatine, as would take place in the reverse reaction. In our experience the fluorescent ninhydrin reaction has proved more useful for the measurement of creatine than has the diacetyl reaction. Sax and Moore14 have recently reported the use of the fluoresccnt-ninhydrin reaction for assay of CPK activity. Our results are in agreement with theirs, although the conditions selected in the present report resulted in a higher enzymatic activity and we believe that they represent more nearly 177 178 CONN AND ANIDO optimal conditions for the determination of CPK. METHODS A series of experiments was made, to determine the optimal conditions for measurement of CPK activity. Normal human serum contains only small amounts of CPK, and it was more convenient in these experiments to use either rabbit serum or purified rabbit CPK dissolved in buffer. Critical results were confirmed with human serum. The final concentrations used in the incubation mixture were: Tris buffer, 0.05 M; magnesium, 0.02 M; Cysteine, 0.01 M; CP, 0.02 M; and ADP, 0.02 M...The volume of the incubation mixture selected for routine use was 1.0 ml., including 0.1 ml. of serum. A 10-min. incubation period at pH 6.8 and 37 C. produced optimal results. A separate serum blank containing all of the above ingredients except ADP, for which water was substituted, was included for each specimen to compensate for any creatine present originally in the serum, added in the CP, or formed by nonenzymatic hydrolysis. After incubation, creatine was measured by the fluorescent-ninhydrin method. This method has proved to be simple and sensitive and to have very good precision. A Ba(OH) 2 -ZnS04 filtrate is made, and an aliquot of filtrate is treated with ninhydrin in a highly alkaline solution. The resulting fluorescence is read at 525 in/* with an excitation beam at 410 my.. A slight modification was necessary to adapt the reaction for enzyme assay. The high magnesium concentration in the buffer interfered with the fluorescent reaction. This problem was eliminated by chelating the magnesium with ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA), which in turn required a change in concentration of the Ba(OH) 2 used in protein precipitation. REAGENTS All reagents are prepared with deionized, glass-distilled water. Tris (0.1 M) magnesium (0.04 M) buffer. Dissolve 1.21 Gm. of tris (hydroxymethyl) aminomethane, buffer grade, and 0.S6 Gm. of magnesium acetate, Mg(CH 3 COO) 2 -4H 2 0 Vol. 46 in approximately 60.0 ml. of water. Adjust the pH to 6.8, using 0.1 N acetic acid. Dilute to 100 ml. This solution is stable but the pH should be checked occasionally. Cysteine (0.05 M). Dissolve O.OSS Gm. of cysteine (L-cysteine hydrochloride • H 2 0) in approximately 6.0 ml. of water; adjust the pH to 6.8, using 0.1 N NaOH; and dilute to 10 ml. with water. Cysteine deteriorates rapidly and it is essential that this solution be made up immediately before use. Attempts to preserve cysteine solutions by freezing were not completely successful, and freshly-prepared solutions are recommended. Creatine phosphate (0.2 M). Dissolve 0.654 Gm. of CP (creatine phosphate, sodium salt hydrate) in 8.0 ml. of water. Adjust the pH to S.0, using glacial acetic acid. (There is some breakdown of creatine phosphate if it is stored at lower pH.) Dilute to 10 ml. and freeze in small aliquots in tightly stoppered tubes. ADP solution (0.2 M). Dissolve 0.S9S Gm. of ADP (adenosine-5'-diphosphate, sodium salt) in 8.0 ml. of water. Adjust pH to 6.S, using 0.1 N NaOH. Dilute to 10.0 ml. and freeze in small aliquots in tightly stoppered tubes. EDTA solution (0.00314 M). Dissolve 1.17 Gm. of disodium EDTA in 1 liter of deionized water. This is stable at room temperature. Zinc sulfate (5 per cent iv/v). Dissolve 50 Gm. of zinc sulfate (ZnS0 4 -7H 2 0) in 1 liter of deionized water. This is stable at room temperature. Barium hydroxide (0.35 N). Dissolve 55.0 Gm. of barium hydroxide (Ba(OH) 2 8H 2 0) in 1 liter of water and store at room temperature in a buret protected by sodalime tubes. The Ba(OH) 2 is more concentrated, because of the EDTA, than in the Somogyi filtrate; however, the procedure for balancing the Ba(OH) 2 and Z11SO4 is similar. To titrate mix 1.0 ml. of ZnS04 with 7.0 ml. of EDTA, 0.7 ml. of buffer, 0.3 ml. of water, and 4 drops of phenolphthalein. Add Ba(OH) 2 in drops, with continual agitation (1.0 ml. of Ba(OH) 2 should exactly neutralize the mixture). Adjust the Ba(OH) 2 or Z11SO4 concentration if necessary. Aug. 1966 179 FLUOROMETRIC CPK ASSAY Ninhydrin (1.0 per cent w/v alcoholic). Dissolve 1.0 Gm. of ninhydrin ( 1 , 2 , 3 , triketohydrindene • H 2 0) in 100 ml. of 95 per cent ethyl alcohol. This is stable for approximately 1 week in the refrigerator. Potassium hydroxide (10 per cent w/v). Dissolve 100 Gm. of potassium hydroxide in 1000 ml. of deionized water. Filter and store at room temperature. Quinine standard. Dissolve 2 mg. of quinine sulfate in 1 liter of 0.1 N H2SO4. Store at room temperature. This is a stable fluorescent standard used for calibration of the fluorometer, and the exact concentration is not critical. Creatine standards, (a). Stock standard (10 mM. per liter). Dissolve 0.1492 Gm. of creatine monohydrate in 100 ml. of water. Freeze in small aliquots. (b). Working standard (0.01 mM. per liter). Dilute the stock creatine standard 1:1000. Prepare a fresl/solution every day or 2. PROCEDURE 1. For each specimen and control, prepare 2 tubes containing: Tris-Mg buffer, 0.5 ml.; cysteine, 0.2 ml.; CP, 0.1 ml.; and serum, 0.1 ml. 2. Bring all tubes to 37 C. by placing them in a water-bath for a few minutes. 3. To start the reaction, add 0.1 ml. of ADP to 1 tube. Add 0.1 ml. of water to the other tube for the blank. 4. Incubate for 10 min. at 37 C. 5. Prepare filtrates by adding to each tube 7.0 ml. of EDTA, 1.0 ml. of Ba(OH) 2 (mix well), and 1.0 ml. of ZnSCi. 6. Filter through Whatman No. 1 filter paper (or centrifuge at high speed for 5 min.). 7. Pipet into cuvets 2.0 ml. of filtrate (or supernatant), 1.0 ml. of ninhydrin, and 1.0 ml. of KOH. Standards and a standard blank are also prepared by using 2.0 ml. of standard and 2.0 ml. of water, respectively, instead of filtrate. S. Take fluorometric readings exactly 5 min. after the addition of KOH. 9. Calcidaliojis. Subtract serum blank reading from unknown reading. Subtract standard blank from standard. Reading of unknown Reading standard y 10 nM. per liter 1000 10 ml. 1 10 min. 0.1 ml. = pM of creatine formed per min. per ml. Units per ml. of serum = juM per min. per ml. X 1000 Fluorometry Fluorescence was measured with a Photovolt Fluorometer consisting of a lineoperated Multiplier Photometer Model 520-M and Fluorescence Unit Model 54. The excitation beam at 410 mn was isolated with Corning glass filters No. 3S50 and No. 5S50 used together. The emission beam at 525 mji was isolated with Corning glass filters No. 33S5 and No. 97S2 used together. Other photofluorometers and spectrophotofluorometers have also been found to be satisfactory. With the reagents described, fluorescence reaches a maximum at 5 min. after addition of KOH and then declines slowly. Because of this instability of the fluorescent compound, it is convenient to use the stable quinine standard to set the instrument at a convenient sensitivity, and then settings may be verified whenever this is desired. The readings for the quinine standard are not used in any calculations. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Several factors combine to make the determination of CPK somewhat more exacting than many of the enzyme assays performed routinely in the clinical laboratory. Labile, expensive substrates require more than routine care in preparation. The enzyme itself is inhibited by numerous substances, and scrupulously clean glassware is a prerequisite for reliable results. All reagents should be prepared with deionized, glass-distilled water, to avoid possible heavy-metal contamination. I t is also recommended that suitable control solutions (rabbit serum is satisfactory) be included with each batch, and that a reagent blank as well as a blank for each unknown be run. Duma and Siegel5 and Sax and Moore14 180 Vol. 46 CONN AND ANIDO recommend omission of the serum blank. Although creatine in serum is sufficiently low that it would not cause a significant error in a sample with a grossly elevated CPK activity, it may produce an error of 10 to 20 per cent in the normal range. The serum blank also provides a valuable check on technic and reagents. Selection of Buffer The prerequisites for buffer selection were negligible inherent fluorescence, absence of interference in the fluorescent ninhydrin reaction, and absence of interference in the enzyme system. The first 2 conditions are easily evaluated. To evaluate the third condition, different buffers were set up in comparable incubation mixtures, and the activity of purified CPK was assayed with each buffer. Numerous compounds and ions have an inhibitory effect upon CPK, and an empiric approach to buffer selection was necessary. The buffer resulting in the highest measured enzyme activity was considered to be most suitable. Tris buffer resulted in highest activity. Acetic acid, rather than hydrochloric acid, is used to adjust the pH to avoid inhibition by chloride ions. The buffer concentration may be varied over a range of 0.02 M to 0.20 M without appreciable effect on the reaction rate under the conditions described. Effect of pH The optimal pH for the forward and reverse reactions differs appreciably.11 In the reverse reaction, as used in the present experiments, the optimal pH was found to be 6.8. This was the pH selected for use, although in certain applications it might not be the most satisfactory. When the pH of the incubation mixture is below 7.0, the spontaneous breakdown of CP is accelerated. Inclusion of a blank compensates for this; however, the sensitivity of the assay is decreased because of the difficulty in measuring very small changes in creatine concentration in the presence of larger quantities of creatine in the serum, in the creatine phosphate, and in that formed by nonenzymatic hydrolysis. Even with the low CPK activities found in normal serum, however, these factors were never great enough to produce appreciable interference. Effect of Temperature and Incubation Time Two incubation temperatures were evaluated, 25 C. and 37 C. The latter was chosen because it resulted in greater enzymatic activity under the conditions selected. The 10-min. incubation period was selected for convenience. Product formation was found to be directly related to time of incubation if the substrate concentration remains sufficiently high to maintain zeroorder kinetics. Substrate Concentrations A series of cross-experiments was performed, in which the concentrations of CP, ADP, and Mg were varied independently. Because of the inhibitory effects of chloride and sulfate ions,13 magnesium diacetate was used to supply magnesium ions. I t was found that at the concentrations used, the optimal concentration of each substrate was not independent of the others. Figures 1 and 2 illustrate the concentration-activity curves obtained for CP and ADP, respectively. The inhibitory effect of high ADP concentrations noted by other investigators was not seen under the conditions selected, although a marked inhibitory effect was present under other conditions of incubation. The reason for this variable effect is not clear and is under further study. The concentrations of CP and ADP selected are higher than those used in other described methods. Chappell and Perry 1 used 0.004 M CP, 0.002 M ADP, and 0.005 M Mg. Sax and Moore16 used 0.0075 M CP, 0.003 M ADP, and 0.010 M Mg. Earlier workers used lower concentrations of CP and ADP. In view of the rather low CPK activity in normal serums, it appears to be advisable to use substrate concentrations which produce optimal activity. The higher substrate concentrations also seem to permit measurement of greater CPK activities, while maintaining zero-order kinetics. Effect of Cysteine In agreement with Ennor and Rosenberg, 6 cysteine was found to have a negligible Aw/. 1966 181 FLTJOROMETR10 CPK ASSAY effect on the forward reaction, but its effect on the i'everse reaction was to enhance the measured activity as much as 100 per cent. In the concentrations used (after protein precipitation), cysteine had no inherent fluorescence and did not interfere with measurement of creatine. In very high concentrations cysteine reacted with ninnydrin to give a blue color, with subsequent interference in the fluorometric measure- 0.02 Q03 0.04 CREATINE PHOSPHATE ( M O I E S / I . ) FIG. 1. The effect of varying concentrations of creatine phosphate on creatine phosphokinase activity. Concentrations of other constituents are as described in the text. 0.01 0.02 ADP 003 0.04 (MOIES/I.) FIG. 2. The effect of varying concentrations of adenosine diphosphate on creatine phosphokinase activity. Concentrations of other constituents are as described in the text. 182 CONN AND ANIDO ments. In addition to enhancing CPK acactivity, sulfhydryl compounds also appeared to make time curves more linear and results more reproducible. Measurement of Creatine Formed High concentrations of magnesium were found to interfere seriously with the measurement of creatine by the fluorometric technic. This interference apparently is due to destruction of an intermediate compound, o-carboxyphenylgloxal,3 rather than to quenching of fluorescence. The concentration of magnesium, after the dilution which occurs during protein precipitation, is low enough so that this interference is not great; however, the addition of EDTA completely eliminates such interference. EDTA itself has negligible fluorescence at the wave lengths used, and does not interfere with measurement of creatine. In the method outlined, a 10 per cent excess of EDTA is used. An additional advantage of using EDTA is that removal of Mg++ ions stops enzymatic activity. Although we were unable to confirm it, Chappell and Perry 1 have reported that residual CPK activity may be present in Ba(OH) 2 -ZnS04 filtrates. None of the other constituents in the incubation mixture was found to interfere with measurement of creatine. CP does not react with ninhydrin in the fluorogenic reaction, and it is stable in alkaline solutions. Large amounts of free creatine in the creatine phosphate would tend to reduce the sensitivity of the method, but would introduce no error, since the inclusion of CP in the blank compensates for any free creatine. The same factors hold true for the presence of creatine in the serum samples. The amount of free creatine in CP obtained from some sources was very high. CP from Sigma Chemical Co. (St. Louis, Missouri) produced consistently low reagent blanks. Previous experiments have shown that the fluorescent ninhydrin reaction takes place equally well in aqueous and in alcoholic solutions, although the fluorescence produced is somewhat greater in the latter. In the present method aqueous KOH is used because of ease in preparation, but there is a slight sacrifice hi the degree of fluorescence produced. Vol. 46 Creatine for preparation of standards may be recrystallized by the method of Hunter; 9 however, several lots of creatine hydrate from Eastman Organic Chemicals (Rochester, New York) have been tested, and recrystallization was not found to be necessary. Although the diacetyl reaction has been used in several colorimetric procedures for measuring CPK, sulfhydryl groups seriously interfere with this reaction and it is not entirely suitable for CPK assay. The groups' inhibitory effect has been decreased or removed by treatment with /j-chloromercuribenzoate and increased in the tune allowed for color development to 60 min.8 We have found no interference by sulfhydryl groups in the fluorescent reaction described above. In very high concentrations they will produce a quenching effect, and cysteine in very high concentrations will produce a blue color in the cuvet. Linearity and Precision of the Method The limits of linearity for the fluorometric CPK assay are determined at the lower end by the minimal amount of creatine which can be measured accurately in the presence of the free creatine introduced with the CP and serum and by nonenzymatic hydrolysis. The upper limit is determined by the maximal product formation or substrate utilization that can occur without a change in reaction rate. An additional consideration at the upper limit is the linearity of the fluorogenic reaction which is subject to concentration quenching. The latter was found to be linear to a concentration of creatine which would represent a serum CPK activity of 1.5 JX moles per min. per ml. of serum (1500 units per ml.). Higher concentrations of creatine can be measured accurately by merely diluting the Ba(OH)2-ZnSO-4 filtrate before carrying out the fluorogenic reaction. Linearity of the enzyme reaction itself was assessed by measuring the activities of serial dilutions of a highly active rabbit muscle CPK preparation. The reaction produced linear results to an activity corresponding to 2.0 /mioles per min. per ml. of serum (2000 units per ml.). This represented utilization of 10 per cent of the substrate during the 10-min. Aug. 1966 183 FLUOBOMETKIC CPK ASSAY TABLE 1 NORMAL VALUES FOB SEBUM CREATINE PIIOSPHOKINASE* Men Fluorescent ninliydrin (this report) Fluorescent ninliydrin14 Diacctyl 8 Spectrophotonietric12 Spectrophotometries Spectrophotonietric7 Reverse Reverse Reverse Reverse Forward Forward Women Mean Range ± 2<r Mean Range ± 2<r 73.8 27.2 40.2 6.4 28.7-189.7 13-57 5.5-74.7 2.3-17.7 58.4 25.8 27.0 3.8 31.5-108.7 13-52 14.3-39.7 0.9-16.0 ot 0.8J * All values have been converted to units used in the present method. Units per ml. of serum per min. per ml. X 1000. f Sex not specified. | No sex difference. period, and with slightly greater enzyme concentrations the reaction became nonlinear. In the method described, if the enzyme activity of a serum specimen is greater than 1500 units per ml., a dilution of the nitrate is necessary. If the activity is greater than 2000 units, the entire procedure should be repeated with a dilution (in buffer) of the original serum. To determine precision of the method, the coefficient of variation was calculated from 35 duplicate determinations on human serums with CPIv values within the normal range. The coefficient of variation was 5.2 per cent. Precision was also assessed on a frozen human serum pool. Thirteen determinations on the pool carried out over a 12-day period had a coefficient of variation of 6.2 per cent. Our data suggest some instability of CPK in frozen serum when it is stored for periods longer than 2 weeks. Normal Values Table 1 lists the normal range for 30 male and 31 female subjects selected from the laboratory staff and blood donors. The data for both groups was skewed; however, a log transformation gave a normal distribution, and the means and 95 per cent normal ranges are calculated from the transformed data. For purposes of comparison, the normal values determined by several other investigators are included. Normal values from earlier publications are considerably lower than those presented.12 i&l Where it is possible, the originator of the method is quoted, and publications giving normal values on patients are excluded. I t may be seen that much lower values are obtained by methods using the forward reaction, which is to be expected from the behavior of the enzyme.6 A significant difference in CPIv values between sexes was noted when methods employing the reverse reaction were used, whereas no such difference was seen if the forward reaction was used. Men appear to have not only higher CPK values than women, but also a greater dispersion of values. The marked differences in normal ranges obtained by different methods appear to be a function of the incubation conditions selected. Our own values are higher than other published values, and we believe that this is a reflection of more optimal conditions of incubation. I t is clear that whenever results of CPK measurement are reported or published it is imperative that the conditions of assay be precisely defined. SUMMARY A method for the assay of serum creatine piiosphokinase (CPK) activity which is based upon a previously described fluorometric method for measurement of creatine is described. The effects of variation in conditions of incubation are described, and published normal values obtained by means of different methods are compared. The present method gives higher normal values 184 CONN AND ANIDO for serum CPK activity, which seem to be due to more optimal conditions of incubation. The fluorometric method for measuring creatine in the CPK assay appears to be superior to the diacetyl method previously used. Acknowledgments. Mrs. Beverly Barnett, M.T. (ASCP), and Mrs. Gerda Carney rendered technical assistance, and Dr. Roger Flora gave advice pertaining to statistical analysis. REFERENCES 1. Chappell, J. B., and Perry, S. V.: Creatine phosphokinase: assay and application for the micro-determination of the adenine nucleotides. Biochem. J., 57: 421-427, 1954. 2. Conn, R. B., Jr.: Fluorimetric determination of creatine. Clin. Chem., 6: 537-548, 19G0. 3. Conn, R. B., Jr., and Davis, R. B.: Green fluorescence of guanidinium compounds with ninhydrin. Nature, 1SS: 1053-1055, 1959. 4. Dreyfus, J. C , and Schapira, G.: Technique de dosage de la creatine phosphokinase du serum. Rev. frang. etud. clin. biol., 6: 700703, 1901. 5. Duma, R. J., and Siegel, A. L.: Serum creatinine phosphokinase in acute myocardial infarction. Arch. Intern. Med., 115: 443451, 1965. 6. Ennor, A. H., and Rosenberg, IT.: Some properties of creatine phosphokinase. Biochem. J., 57: 203-212, 1954. Vol. 46 7. Hess, J. W., MacDonald, R. P., Frederick, R. J., Jones, R. N., Neely, J., and Gross, D.: Serum creatine phosphokinase (CPK) activity in disorders of heart and skeletal muscle. Ann. Intern. Med., 61: 1015-1028, 1964. 8. Hughes, B. P.: A method for the estimation of serum creatine kinase and its use in comparing creatine kinase and aldolase activity in normal and pathological sera. Clin. Chim. Acta, 7: 597-603, 1902. 9. Hunter, A.: Creatine and Creatinine. London: Longmans Green and Co., Ltd., 1928, p. 54. 10. Kuby, S. A., Noda, L., and Lardy, H.: Adenosinetriphosphate-creatine transphosphorylase. J. Biol. Chem., 209: 191-201, 1954. ' 11. Kuby, S. A., and Noltmann, E. A.: ATPcreatine transphosphorylase. In Boyer, P. D., Lardy, H., and Myrbiick, R.: The Enzymes, Vol. 6. New York: Academic Press, Inc., 1962, pp. 515-603. 12. Nielsen, L., and Ludvigsen, B.: Improved method for determination of creatine kinase. J. Lab. & Clin. Med., 62: 159-168, 1963. 13. Nihei, T., Noda, L., and Morales, M. F.: Kinetic properties and equilibrium constant of the adenosine triphosphate-creatine transphosphorylase-catalyzed reaction. J. Biol. Chem., 236: 3203-3209, 1961. 14. Sax, S. M., and Moore, J. J.: Fluorometric measurement of creatine kinase activity. Clin. Chem., 11: 951-958, 1965. 15. Tanzer, M. L., and Gilvarg, C.: Creatine and creatine kinase measurement. J. Biol. Chem., 234: 3201-3204, 1959.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz