Vibrational structure, spin-orbit splitting, and bond dissociation

THE JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 127, 104307 共2007兲
Vibrational structure, spin-orbit splitting, and bond dissociation energy
of Cl2+„X̃ 2⌸g… studied by zero kinetic energy photoelectron spectroscopy
and ion-pair formation imaging method
Juan Li, Yusong Hao, Jie Yang, Chang Zhou, and Yuxiang Moa兲
Department of Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China and Key Laboratory for Atomic and
Molecular Nanosciences, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
共Received 25 May 2007; accepted 23 July 2007; published online 12 September 2007兲
The isotopomer-resolved vibrational and spin-orbit energy structures of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 have been
studied by one-photon zero kinetic energy photoelectron spectroscopy. The spin-orbit energy
splitting for the ground vibrational state is determined as 717.7± 1.5 cm−1, which greatly improves
on the accuracy of the previously reported data. This value is found to be in good agreement with
the ab initio quantum chemical calculation taking account of the inner shell electron correlation. The
first adiabatic ionization energy 共IE兲 of Cl2 is determined as 92 645.9± 1.0 cm−1. Using the ion-pair
formation imaging method to discriminate signals of Cl+共 1D2兲 from those of Cl+共 3 P j兲, the threshold
+8
cm−1.
for ion-pair 共Etipp兲 production, Cl+共 1D2兲 + Cl−共 1S0兲 ← Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲, is determined as 107 096−2
By using the determined IE and Etipp for Cl2 and also the reported IE and electronic affinity for
chlorine atom, the bond dissociation energies of Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 and Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 have been determined
+8
+8
and 31 935.1−2
, respectively. © 2007 American Institute of Physics.
as 19 990−2
关DOI: 10.1063/1.2772273兴
I. INTRODUCTION
In comparison with the extensive studies of the neutral
chlorine molecule, our present knowledge about the structure
of its cation, Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲, is limited, and has been obtained
mainly from two kinds of experimental studies. One is the
photoelectron spectroscopy 共PES兲 and threshold photoelectron spectroscopy 共TPES兲.1–6 The other is the emission spectra of Cl+2 : Ã 2⌸u → X̃ 2⌸g.7–9 The most recently reported
TPES spectrum has a resolution around 13 meV or
100 cm−1.6 The spin-orbit splitting for Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 was found
to be very close to the vibrational energy spacing.1–6 Because
of this, the fully spin-orbit resolved vibrational bands have
not been obtained until now. The emission spectra have
much higher resolution than the PES and TPES spectra.
However, the spin-orbit energy splittings for Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲
have not been obtained from the emission studies since perpendicular transitions that involve the two different spinorbit components 共⌬⍀ = ± 1兲 have not been observed. In addition to this, the absolute vibrational numbering was
difficult to obtain in the emission spectra. Huberman has
assigned the vibrational quantum numbers of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 in
the emission spectra based on observed isotopic shifts of the
vibrational energy levels,7 but Tuckett and Peyerimhoff argued that Huberman’s vibrational numbering was not reliable
since the isotopic shifts measured by Huberman were not
accurate enough to distinguish the vibrational numbers.8
Later studies by the PES spectra and higher resolution emission spectra preferred Huberman’s assignment; however,
a兲
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed. Electronic mail:
[email protected]
0021-9606/2007/127共10兲/104307/8/$23.00
there has been no unambiguous experimental evidence as
yet.4,8,9 Therefore, a more accurate study is necessary to determine the spin-orbit energy splitting and resolve the controversies in the assignment of the vibrational spectra.
One-photon zero kinetic energy 共ZEKE兲 photoelectron spectroscopy, which has a resolution better than 1 cm−1, is a good
tool to study these questions.10–13 The ZEKE method can
also provide an ionization energy 共IE兲 as accurate as ±2 cm−1
for Cl2, which is about one order of magnitude more accurate
than the IE measured previously by PE and TPES
methods.1–6
In this paper, we present a vibrationally resolved study
of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 using the ZEKE spectroscopic method and
extreme ultraviolet 共XUV兲 coherent radiation. From the
analysis of the ZEKE spectrum, we obtained the spin-orbit
resolved vibrational structure for Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 and an accurate
IE value for Cl2.
In addition, the bond dissociation energy of Cl2
共D0共Cl2兲兲 is an important quantity for its thermochemistry.
The presently often used D0共Cl2兲 derived from a method
similar to extrapolation is 19 997.2± 0.3 cm−1.14,15 The extrapolation was done by combining a model for the long
range potential of diatomic molecule and the vibrational energy levels measured experimentally 共␷ = 9 to 42, 49, 52, and
55兲 for Cl2.15,16 A direct measurement of D0共Cl2兲 was also
reported by measuring the kinetic energy release of the photofragments in the photodissociation of Cl2.17 However, its
uncertainty was about ±0.02 eV or 160 cm−1, which is much
larger than that from the extrapolation method. Recently, we
have reported a direct measurement for the bond dissociation
energy of F2.13 This measurement was done by measuring
the threshold for ion-pair production 共Etipp兲 via ion imaging
127, 104307-1
© 2007 American Institute of Physics
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp
104307-2
J. Chem. Phys. 127, 104307 共2007兲
Li et al.
method. By combining the Etipp and the known IE and electron affinity 共EA兲 of F atom, D0共F2兲 was determined with an
accuracy of 1 meV or 8 cm−1. In that paper, the Etipp was
obtained by measuring the kinetic energy release of photofragments at the photon energies around Etipp.
For Cl2, the following ion-pair production process is
possible:18
XUV
Cl+共 3 P j, 1D2兲 + Cl−共 1S兲 ←—— Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲.
共1兲
In this paper, we report our experiments to measure the Etipp
for the production of Cl+共 1D2兲 using the velocity map imaging method.19 Instead of measuring the kinetic energy release
of photofragments, we measure the efficiency of producing
Cl+共 1D2兲 fragments with very low kinetic energies by integrating the signals only in the center of the imaging. We call
this threshold ion-pair kinetic energy 共TIPKE兲 spectrum.
Combining the Etipp determined by TIPKE, the known IE and
EA of the Cl atom, and also IE of the Cl2 determined in this
work, we have determined the bond dissociation energies of
Cl2 and Cl+2 .
II. EXPERIMENT
The details of our XUV/Vacuum ultraviolet 共VUV兲 photoelectron and photoion spectrometer have been described
previously, so only a brief summary is given here.12,13,20,21
For ZEKE experiments, coherent XUV radiation was generated using the resonance enhanced four-wave sum mixing
共2␻1 + ␻2兲 in a pulsed Xe jet. A Nd:YAG 共yttrium aluminum
garnet兲 共20 Hz兲 pumped two dye laser system was used in
the experiments. One beam produced by doubling the dye
laser frequency was fixed to match the two-photon resonance
共2␻1兲 frequency of the Xe 5p5共 2 P3/2兲6p关1 / 2兴0 ← 共5p6兲 1S0
transition at 80 19.0 cm−1. The wavelength of the other dye
laser beam 共␻2兲 was tuned from 810 to 610 nm, in which the
range of 810– 750 nm was obtained by Raman shifting the
dye laser output from 606 to 572 nm using a H2 Raman cell.
The apparatus consists of four vacuum chambers: 共A兲
frequency mixing chamber, which houses a pulsed Xe 共Kr兲
jet 共diameter= 1 mm兲; 共B兲 monochromator chamber, which
houses a gold coated toroidal grating; 共C兲 ionization chamber, which is equipped with time-of-flight tubes for ions
共110 cm兲 and electrons 共26 cm兲; in this chamber, a MCP
共microchannel plate兲 detector was installed to monitor the
XUV intensities; and 共D兲 molecular beam source chamber,
which houses a pulsed valve 共orifice diameter= 0.7 mm兲 to
produce a pulse molecular beam. The beam enters the ionization chamber through a skimmer 共orifice diameter
= 1 mm兲.
The electron signals from the pulsed field ionization and
the XUV radiation signals were fed into two identical boxcars 共SR 250, Stanford Research Systems兲 and transferred to
a personal computer. The electric pulses to synchronize the
two pulse valves and the Nd:YAG laser were provided by a
digital delay generator 共DG 535, Stanford Research Systems兲. The pulsed voltages to ionize the Rydberg molecules
were provided by another DG 535 with high voltage option
共±32 V output兲, and the actual ionization electric field used
was about 0.75 V / cm with a typical delay of 3 ␮s relative to
the XUV laser pulse. The resolution of our ZEKE spectrum
in this configuration was better than 1 cm−1.13 The effects of
the applied electric field in decreasing the threshold of ionization energies have been corrected for all reported spectra
in the following discussions.
For imaging experiments on the ion-pair formation, the
XUV radiation was generated using resonance enhanced sum
mixing 共2␻1 + ␻2兲 in a Kr jet. One of the laser beam 共␻1兲
from the tripling of the dye laser was fixed to match the
two-photon resonance line of Kr, 4p5共 2 P3/2兲5p关1 / 2兴0
← 共4p6兲 1S0 共94 092.9 cm−1兲. The other dye laser was tuned
from 767 to 771 nm. The imaging plane is perpendicular to
the molecular beam, and the distance from it to the XUV
laser beam and molecular beam interaction point is 110 cm.
The imaging quality dual MCP 共North Night Vision, Nanjing
Branch兲 has an effective size of 쏗46 mm and a channel pitch
of 15 ␮m. The phosphor screen was coated with P43.
To obtain the field-free velocity map imagings, two electric pulses 共PVM-4140, DEI兲 with a delay of ⬃400 ns relative to the XUV pulse were used to extract the Cl−, and the
relative voltages of the two pulses satisfied the requirements
of the velocity map conditions.19 Mass gate was not used to
select Cl− since no other negative ion signals were found in
our experiments. However, some electron signals did present
from ionization of Cl2. These signals had been eliminated by
adding a magnetic field outside the time-of-flight tube, which
did not change the image of Cl−. The ion images were captured by a deep cooled charge-coupled device camera with a
resolution of 1024⫻ 1024 pixel2 共Andor DU-434兲.
The gas sample was a mixture of He or Kr with Cl2 共He
or Kr 95%, Cl2 5%兲, and the stagnation pressure was about
1000 Torr at room temperature. In the experiments, the pressures for the beam source and ionization chamber were
around 2 ⫻ 10−5 and 2 ⫻ 10−7 Torr, respectively. The rotational temperature of the supersonic cooled Cl2 beam is less
than 10 K. The frequencies of the dye lasers were calibrated
using He/ Ne and He/ Ar optogalvanic lamps.
III. THEORETICAL CALCULATIONS
In order to have a better understanding of the experimental data, we have calculated the spin-orbit energy splitting,
vibrational constants of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲, and also the bond dissociation energies of Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 and Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 using the MOL22
PRO 2006.1 quantum chemistry software package. All our
calculations employed the uncontracted aug-cc-pV5Z basis
sets 共AV5Z兲, and the angular momentum function types in
the basis functions are restricted to the f functions. The calculations used the D2h instead of the D⬁h symmetry group
for the sake of technical simplicity.22
In the MOLPRO package, the spin-orbit energy splitting is
calculated by a perturbation method using the unperturbed
zero-order wave function, which is from the multireference
internally contracted configuration interaction 共MRCI兲 wave
function. The perturbation operator is the full Breit-Pauli
spin-orbit operator.23 We calculated the reference functions
for MRCI by complete active space self-consistent field
共CASSCF兲 method. To reproduce the experimental results
for the spin-orbit energy splitting, we found that the inner-
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp
104307-3
Structure of Cl2+共X兲 by ZEKE spectroscopy
J. Chem. Phys. 127, 104307 共2007兲
TABLE I. The parameters used in the fitting for the first vibrational band of
the ZEKE spectrum of Cl2.
Rotational constantsa 共cm−1兲, B+ / B⬙
0.2695/ 0.2439
Rotational temperature 共K兲
6
92645.9± 1.0
Band origin 共IE兲 共cm−1兲
Gaussian function, FWHM= 0.6
Instrumental resolution 共cm−1兲
−717.7
Spin-orbit coupling constant A+0 共cm−1兲b
Scaling factors r共⌬J兲
r共−5 / 2兲 = 3 , r共−3 / 2兲 = 2 , r共−1 / 2兲 = 1
r共1 / 2兲 = 4 , r共3 / 2兲 = 3
a
The rotational constants for neutral and cation are from Ref. 14.
The spin-orbit coupling constant was fixed in the fitting, which is from the
energy spacing between the first vibrational bands of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,3/2兲 and
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,1/2兲, see Table III.
b
FIG. 1. 共Color online兲 The first vibrational band of the ZEKE spectrum for
transition Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,3/2 , ␷+ = 0兲 ←
—— Cl2共X 1⌺+g , ␷⬙ = 0兲. The upper curve is
the experimental data, and the lower curve is the semiempirical simulation,
which aims to determine the band origin or IE. The rotational branches are
labeled by ⌬J = J+ − J⬙. On the x axis at the top are the XUV photon energies
relative to IE共Cl2兲, and on the x axis at the bottom are the XUV photon
energies. The parameters used in the fitting are shown in Table I.
shell electron correlation 共2s2p兲 of Cl atom should be taken
into account, or 2 core orbitals, 16 active orbitals, and 208
external orbitals were used in the calculation.
To obtain the vibrational constants, we have calculated
the potential energy curve 共PEC兲 of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 using the
spin unrestricted open-shell coupled cluster theory with triple
corrections 共UCCSD-T兲 as defined by Deegan and
Knowles.24 The internuclear distance for the PES ranges
2.0– 7.6a0. The vibrational energy levels were then calculated by solving the one-dimensional Schrödinger equation
using the so-called Fourier grid Hamitonian method.25 For
all the calculated points in the PEC, 具S2典 ⬇ 0.753. It is found
that the energy calculation was not converged for internuclear distance longer than 7.6a0. Fortunately, the energy at
7.6a0 共−918.9032 hartree兲 is different from that of the dissociation limit, Cl共 2 Pu兲 + Cl+共 3 Pg兲 共−918.9046 hartree兲, only by
about 0.04 eV. It is thus expected that the calculated vibrational energy levels will be not affected much by this defect.
The bond dissociation energy of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 共D0共Cl+2 兲兲
was obtained by calculating the energy difference between
the dissociation limit of Cl共 2 Pu兲 + Cl+共 3 Pg兲 and the ground
vibrational state of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲. The same method has been
applied to calculate the bond dissociation energy of
Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲. The ionization energy of Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 共IE 共Cl2兲兲
was obtained by calculating the energy difference between
the ground vibrational states of Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 and Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲.
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
A. The first adiabatic ionization energy „IE… of Cl2
The upper curve in Fig. 1 shows the first vibrational
band of the ZEKE spectrum for the transition
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,3/2 , ␷+ = 0兲 ← Cl2共X 1⌺+g , ␷⬙ = 0兲. Although the spec-
trum is not rotationally resolved due to the small rotational
constants of Cl2, we can label the rotational branches
共⌬J = J+ − J⬙兲 in the figure. To determine the IE accurately
from a ZEKE spectrum that is not rotationally resolved, the
band origin should be located. This usually requires simulation of the band profile using the rotational line strengths for
ZEKE spectrum. Here we use a semiempirical method to fit
the measured band just for obtaining the accurate IE as we
have done previously.12,21
The rotational energy levels for Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 are calculated according to26
EJ* = B␷+
冋冉 冊
J+ +
1
2
2
−1±
1
2
冑 冉 冊 冉 冊册
4 J+ +
1
2
2
+
A␷+ A␷+
B␷+ B␷+
−4
,
共2兲
where A␷+ and B␷+ are the spin-orbit coupling and rotational
constants of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 with vibrational quantum number ␷+,
respectively. Since A␷+ is negative, the ⫾ represent levels for
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,1/2兲 and Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,3/2兲, respectively. We assume
that the rotational line strength is given by
冉 冊
I共J+,J⬙兲 = r共⌬J兲共2J⬙ + 1兲 ⫻ exp −
E J⬙
kTrot
,
共3兲
where r共⌬J兲 are scaling factors for different rotational
branches, which are adjusted to give the best fit of the experimental spectrum, k is Boltzmann’s constant, and Trot is
the rotational temperature of the molecular beam.
The lower curve in Fig. 1 is a semiempirical fitting with
parameters listed in Table I. The IE共Cl2兲 is thus accurately
determined as 92 645.9± 1.0 cm−1 共11.4866± 0.0002 eV兲.
The IE共Cl2兲 has also been measured previously by various
experimental methods, and Table II lists some of the reported
data along with our data. It is seen that the accuracy of our
data improves on previous values by more than one order of
magnitude.
Peyerimhoff and Buenker have calculated IE共Cl2兲 by
means of the multireference single- and double-excitation
configuration interaction 共MRDCI兲 method with full CI
estimation.27 Their calculation result was 11.44 eV, which is
in very good agreement with our experimental data. Our calculated result at the level of UCCSD-T/AV5Z is 11.415 eV,
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp
104307-4
J. Chem. Phys. 127, 104307 共2007兲
Li et al.
TABLE II. The first adiabatic ionization energy 共IE兲 of Cl2.
IE 共eV兲
Method
Ab initio calculation
MRDCIa
UCCSD-T/AV5Zb
Experimental resultc
PIEd
PESe
PESe
TPESf
ZEKEg
Reference
11.44
11.415
27
This work
11.48共1兲
11.480共5兲
11.51共1兲
11.481共3兲
11.4866共2兲
2
4
3
6
This work
a
By means of MRDCI method with full CI estimation.
Calculated by the energy difference between the ground vibrational states
of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 and Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲, see text.
c
The numbers in the parentheses are the uncertainties of the last digits.
d
Photoionization efficiency spectroscopy.
e
Photoelectron spectroscopy.
f
Threshold photoelectron spectroscopy.
g
Zero kinetic energy photoelectron spectroscopy.
b
which is also listed in Table I. To see the accuracy of this
method, we also calculated the ionization energy of Cl共 2 Pu兲
at this level 共spin-orbit coupling was not accounted兲, which
is 12.783 eV, in comparison with the experimental value of
12.97 eV.28
B. ZEKE spectrum of
Cl2+„X̃ 2⌸g…
35
Figure 2 shows a survey ZEKE spectrum of Cl2 in the
energy range of 92 570– 96 510 cm−1. A total of six vibrational bands for Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,3/2兲 and five vibrational bands for
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,1/2兲 have been observed, respectively. The relative
intensities among different vibrational bands have been normalized according to those from TPES,6 while the relative
intensities in the same vibrational bands are normalized to
the XUV radiation intensities in our experiments. It is seen
from Fig. 2 that after the first vibrational band there are two
FIG. 2. 共Color online兲 The survey ZEKE spectrum of Cl2. The spin-orbit
and vibrational band assignments are shown in the figure. On the x axis at
the top are the XUV photon energies relative to IE共Cl2兲, and on the x axis at
the bottom are the XUV photon energies. The vibrational band ␷⬙0 represents
excitations from the vibrational ground state of the neutral to nth vibrational
states of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲.
closely spaced vibrational bands. It is due to the fact that the
vibrational energy spacing is similar to the spin-orbit energy
splitting. The previously measured PES and TPES spectra
could not resolve the adjacent bands fully.1–6 The assignments for the spin-orbit resolved vibrational bands are also
shown in Fig. 2. It is seen from Fig. 2 that with increasing
vibrational quantum number the bands become broader. This
is due to the isotopic shifts of Cl2. To see this more clearly,
Fig. 3 shows an expansion of Fig. 2. Panels 共a兲 and 共b兲 of
Fig. 3 are for 2⌸3/2 and 2⌸1/2, respectively. The isotopic shift
effect will be discussed in the next section.
Table III lists all the band origins of the ZEKE spectrum
for the transition 35Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 ← 35Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲. Having determined the band origins, the vibrational energy spacings,
⌬G␷++1/2, and spin-orbit energy splittings, ⌬Eso共␷兲, can be calculated easily, and they are also listed in Table III.
For ␷+ = 0, the spin-orbit energy splitting is
717.7± 1.5 cm−1. The most recently reported data of spinorbit energy splitting from TPES were 766 cm−1, which was
based on the spectrum with no spin-orbit resolved structure.6
Therefore, the accuracy for the spin-orbit energy splitting of
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 has been improved greatly in the this work. This
improvement should benefit the calculation of effective rotational constants for Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲.9 The accurate IE and spinorbit energy splitting obtained in this paper are also critical
for the correct assignment of Rydberg states of Cl2.29
Using the band origins listed in Table III, we determined
the vibrational constants ␻+e and ␻+e ␹+e for 35Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸3/2兲 and
35 +
Cl2 共X̃ 2⌸1/2兲, respectively,
E = Te + ␻+e 共␷ + 1/2兲 − ␻+e ␹+e 共␷ + 1/2兲2 .
共4兲
The spectroscopic constants obtained are listed in Table IV.
Previously reported results from the emission spectra and the
TPES spectra are also listed in Table IV. The reported spectroscopic constants from the emission spectra were determined from the R band heads of the vibational bands, and
those from TPES spectra are from the vibrational band contour centers.6,7
To obtain further understanding of the experimental data,
we have calculated the spectroscopic constants using quantum chemical ab initio methods as introduced in Sec. III. The
spin-orbit energy splitting was calculated at the level
CASSCF/MRCI/AV5Z. The PEC for calculating the vibrational constants, ␻+e and ␻+e ␹+e , was obtained at the level of
UCCSD-T/AV5Z. Table IV lists the calculation results.
To reproduce the experimentally measured spin-orbit
splitting, we found that the inner-shell electron correlation of
Cl共2s2p兲 should be taken into account. This inner-shell correlation effect has been found also in other molecules with
third row elements.23 The calculation results are listed in
Table IV. It is seen that the calculated spin-orbit energy splitting, 708 cm−1, is in good agreement with the experimental
data, 717.7± 1.5 cm−1. The bond length used in the spin-orbit
calculation is 3.609a0, which is the equilibrium geometry
structure optimized at the same level with the spin-orbit calculation.
From Table IV, it is seen that the spectroscopic constants
␻+e and ␻+e ␹+e derived from the band origins of our ZEKE
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp
104307-5
Structure of Cl2+共X兲 by ZEKE spectroscopy
J. Chem. Phys. 127, 104307 共2007兲
FIG. 3. 共Color online兲 The ZEKE
spectrum of Cl2. The vibrational bands
due to different isotopomers of 35Cl2,
35
Cl 37Cl, and 37Cl2 are indicated.
Panel 共a兲 is for transition to
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,3/2 , ␷+ = 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5兲, and
panel 共b兲 is for transition to
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g,1/2 , ␷+ = 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , 4兲.
The
signal intensities are normalized for
each vibrational band but are not normalized among different bands.
spectrum are in good agreement with those from the emission spectra.7 Unlike the emission spectra, the vibrational
numbering in the ZEKE spectrum can be assigned ambiguously. This demonstrates that the previous vibrational number assignments by Huberman is correct, which was based on
the isotopic shifts of vibrational energy levels in the emission
spectra of à 2⌸u → X̃ 2⌸g.7
C. Isotopic shifts of the vibrational energy levels for
Cl2+„X̃ 2⌸g…
Molecular chlorine has three isotopomers, 35Cl2,
Cl37Cl, and 37Cl2 with relative abundance of
57.41%:36.72%:5.87%, respectively. The vibrational energy
shifts of isotopomers are clearly seen in panels 共a兲 and 共b兲 of
35
Fig. 3. The assignments of the vibrational bands due to different isotopomers are also shown in Fig. 3, and the numerical results from the spectrum are listed in Table V. The assignments have been done with the guidance of theoretical
predictions.
Two methods have been used to calculate the isotopic
shifts. The first is the ab initio method. The PECs for different isotopomers should be the same in the BornOppenheimer approximation. The vibrational energy levels
for different isotopomers can be calculated by taking account
of their different reduced masses. The calculated isotopic
shifts using the PEC obtained at the level of UCCSD-T/
AV5Z 共see Sec. III兲 are listed in Table V.
The second method is more frequently used and also
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp
104307-6
J. Chem. Phys. 127, 104307 共2007兲
Li et al.
TABLE III. The band origin IE␷, vibrational energy spacing ⌬G␷++1/2, and spin-orbit energy spacing ⌬Eso共␷兲 of
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 determined by the ZEKE spectrum. The units are in cm−1. The uncertainties are ±1.5 cm−1, except
the position at the first IE, which has uncertainty of ±1 cm−1.
2
⌸g,3/2
2
⌸g,1/2
␷+
IE␷
⌬G␷++1/2
IE␷
⌬G␷++1/2
⌬Eso共␷兲
0
1
2
3
4
5
92 645.9a
93 286.4
93 920.6
94 549.0
95 171.1
95 786.1
0
640.5
634.2
628.4
622.1
615.0
93 363.6
94 003.1
94 637.1
95 264.0
95 885.6
0
639.5
634.0
626.9
621.6
−717.7
−716.7
−716.5
−715.0
−714.5
a
The uncertainty is ±1 cm−1.
much simpler. The spectroscopic constants ␻e and ␻e␹e for
two different isotopomers i and j have the following
relationships:30
␻e共j兲 = ␻e共i兲␳共i, j兲,
共5a兲
␻e␹e共j兲 = ␻e␹e共j兲␳2共i, j兲,
共5b兲
␳共i, j兲 = 冑␮i/␮ j ,
共5c兲
where ␮i and ␮ j are the reduced masses for isotopomers i
and j, respectively. The isotopic shift for vibrational band
共␷+ , ␷⬙兲 of isotopomers i and j is
⌬i,j = ¯␯0共i; ␷+, ␷⬙兲 − ¯␯0共j; ␷+, ␷⬙兲 = 关␻+e 共i兲共␷+ +
− ␻e⬙共i兲共␷⬙ +
1
2
兲
兲兴关1 − ␳共i, j兲兴 − 关␻+e ␹+e 共i兲共␷+ + 21 兲2
− ␻e⬙␹e⬙共i兲共␷⬙ + 21 兲2兴关1 − ␳2共i, j兲兴.
共6兲
1
2
For small ␷+ and ␷⬙, we have
⌬i,j ⬇ 关␻+e 共i兲共␷+ +
1
2
兲 − ␻e⬙共i兲共␷⬙ + 21 兲兴关1 − ␳共i, j兲兴.
which corresponds to the production of Cl+共 3 P j兲 fragments,
and a small ring in the center with strong signal intensities,
which corresponds to the production of Cl+共 1D2兲. In other
words, it means that the ion-pair formation has two channels
corresponding to production of Cl+共 3 P j兲 and Cl+共 1D2兲, respectively. In Fig. 4, the image on the right side shows the
enlarged image section inside the square of the left side. It is
noted that the black-and-white contrast in the left image is
saturated in order to show more clearly the weak Cl−共 3 P j兲
components.
From Fig. 4, it is easily seen that the dissociation is a
so-called parallel transition at this photon energy for production of both Cl+共 3 P j兲 and Cl+共 1D2兲, and the ion-pair formation should occur via the transition to a state with ⌺+u symmetry in the Franck-Condon region. However, in this paper,
we will focus on the energetics of the dissociation and not
discuss the details of dynamics.
To determine the threshold for production of Cl+共 1D2兲
共7兲
Using the known ␻e⬙ 共564.9 cm−1兲 and ␻+e determined in this
work, the isotopic shifts for vibrational band 共␷+ , 0兲 can be
evaluated, and the results are listed in Table V.
As can be seen, the experimental measured isotopic
shifts are in good agreement with the theoretical and model
predictions.
D. Threshold for ion-pair production „Etipp… and the
bond dissociation energy of Cl2„X 1⌺+g… and Cl2+„X̃ 2⌸g…
In the previous measurements, Berkowitz et al. found
that the signals of ion-pair production efficiency 共IPPE兲 increased greatly at the thermochemical threshold for formation of Cl+共 1D2兲.18 Since they measured the total ion signals
of Cl+ that include both Cl+共 3 P j兲 and Cl+共 1D2兲 fragments,
there was no concrete experimental evidence to show that the
increase of signal was only from Cl+共 1D2兲. Using the velocity map imaging of photofragments,19 we can determine the
kinetic energy of the fragments and hence discriminate signals of Cl+共 1D2兲 from those of Cl+共 3 P j兲. Figure 4 shows the
velocity map imaging of 35Cl− from the ion-pair production
of Cl2 under field-free condition at 107 115.2 cm−1. The polarization of the XUV laser is indicated in Fig. 4. The image
has a large outer ring with very weak signal intensities,
TABLE IV. The experimental and calculated spectroscopic constants for
35 +
Cl2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 共units are in cm−1兲.
Method
Ab initio calculation
UCCSD-T/AV5Za
CASSCF/MRCI/AV5Zb
Experimental result
TPESc
2
⌸g,1/2
2
⌸g,3/2
Emmision spectrumd
2
⌸g,1/2
2
⌸g,3/2
ZEKEe
2
⌸g,1/2
2
⌸g,3/2
Te+
␻e+
␻e+␹e+
Reference
640.93
2.938
This work
This work
634.7
646.0
2.87
3.62
644.77
645.61
2.988
3.015
645.7
646.9
3.04
3.15
708
6
766
0
7
This work
717.7
0
a
The level to calculate the PEC in the vibrational energy level calculation,
see text.
b
The level to calculate Te+ or the spin-orbit energy splitting. The equilibrium
bond length is 3.609a0 and the inner-shell correlation 共2s2p兲 is taken into
account, see text.
c
From the threshold photoelectron spectroscopy. The uncertainty reported
was 3 meV 共24 cm−1兲.
d
From the emission spectra of à 2⌸u → X̃ 2⌸g.
e
From the zero kinetic energy photoelectron spectroscopy. The uncertainties
are ±1.5 cm−1.
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp
104307-7
Structure of Cl2+共X兲 by ZEKE spectroscopy
J. Chem. Phys. 127, 104307 共2007兲
TABLE V. The isotopic shifts observed in the ZEKE spectrum of Cl2.
Expt.a
Model calc.b
共 ␷ + , ␷ ⬙兲
⌬35,35/35,37d
⌬35,35/37,37d
共0,0兲
共1,0兲
共2,0兲
共3,0兲
共4,0兲
共5,0兲
9.3
17.5
25.5
33.5
42.2
18.7
35.5
53.5
Ab initio calc.c
⌬35,35/35,37d
⌬35,35/37,37d
⌬35,35/35,37d
⌬35,35/37,37d
0.5
9.4
18.1
26.9
35.8
44.6
1.1
18.8
36.6
54.3
72.0
89.8
8.6
16.9
25.2
33.3
41.2
17.2
34.1
50.7
67.0
83.1
a
From the zero kinetic energy photoelectron spectroscopy. The uncertainties are ±1.5 cm−1.
Calculated by Eq. 共7兲. The vibrational frequency ␻e⬙ for neutral is from Ref. 30.
c
From the vibrational energy level calculations, see Sec. IV C for details.
d
⌬i,j = ¯␯0共i ; ␷+ , ␷⬙兲 − ¯␯0共j ; ␷+ , ␷⬙兲 represents the isotopic shift between isotopomers i and j for vibrational transition 共␷+ , ␷⬙兲.
b
+ Cl−共 1S0兲, we scanned the XUV laser and recorded a series
of Cl−共 1S0兲 images for different excitation photon energies.
We then integrated the intensities of Cl−共 1S0兲 fragments in
the images with total translational energies less than 40 cm−1
共the circle in the enlarged image in Fig. 4 shows the fragments with kinetic energy of 40 cm−1兲, which correspond to
the production of Cl+共 1D2兲. The result is shown in Fig. 5.
Because of the very low signals, the curve in Fig. 5 is not
isotopomer resolved. We call this a threshold ion-pair kinetic
energy spectrum 共TIPKE兲. The signals in the TIPKE rise
from the base line to its maximum value in only 10 cm−1,
which represent the threshold for ion-pair production. The
signals in the spectrum also decrease after 20 cm−1 at the
top, which arise from the kinetic translational energy of the
fragment atoms in the integration area. The sharp rising
structure is very different from the broad structure of the
ion-pair production efficiency spectrum in the threshold region of Cl+共 1D2兲 and also Cl+共 3 P j兲 reported by Berkowitz et
al.18 The reason for this is due to the very low temperature of
our molecular beam 共6 K兲, the high resolution of our XUV
laser 共0.15 cm−1兲, and also the discrimination of signals us-
ing imaging. This allows us to determine the threshold
for producing Cl+共 1D兲 fragments, Etipp关Cl+共 1D2兲兴, as
+8
cm−1, which is also shown in Fig. 5. The upper
107 096−2
uncertainties were mainly from a small residence static electric field, which may be present due to the large extraction
electric field 共⬃200 V / cm兲 in our experiments, although this
field was applied 400 ns after the XUV laser pulse.
Having determined Etipp关Cl+共 1D2兲兴, the bond dissociation energy of Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 can be determined using the following formula:
D0共Cl2兲 = Etipp关Cl+共 1D2兲兴 − E关Cl+共 1D2兲兴 − IE关Cl共 2 P3/2兲兴
+ EA关Cl共 2 P3/2兲兴,
共8兲
where E关Cl+共 1D2兲兴 is the energy level of Cl+共 1D2兲 relative to
Cl+共 3 P2兲, IE 关Cl共 2 P3/2兲兴 is the ionization energy of Cl共 2 P3/2兲,
and EA 关Cl共 2 P3/2兲兴 is the electronic affinity of Cl共 2 P3/2兲.
These values are 11 653.58, 10 591.0, and 29 138.59 cm−1,
respectively.28,31 D0共Cl2兲 is therefore determined as
+8
+10
cm−1 or 2.4784−3
eV, which supports the previous
19 990−2
value of 19 997.2共3兲 cm−1 or 2.479 34共4兲 eV derived by
combining a model of the long range potential of diatomic
molecule and the vibrational energy levels measured experi-
FIG. 4. Velocity map imaging of Cl− under field-free condition for ion-pair
XUV
—— Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲. The extraction elecproduction: Cl+共 3 P j , 1D2兲 + Cl−共 1S0兲 ←
tric field for Cl− fragments was applied about 400 ns after the XUV laser
pulse. The XUV photon energy is 107 115.2 cm−1 or 19 cm−1 above the
threshold for producing Cl+共 1D2兲. The polarization of XUV laser is indicated
in the figure. The image on the right shows an enlarged portion of the image,
which is inside the square of the left. The circle in the enlarged image shows
the fragments with total kinetic energy of 40 cm−1. It is noted that the
black-and-white contrast on the left image is saturated in order to show
more clearly the weak Cl−共 3 P兲 components.
FIG. 5. Threshold ion-pair kinetic energy spectrum for Cl+共 1D2兲
XUV
—— Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 under field-free condition. The spectrum was
+ Cl−共 1S0兲 ←
obtained by integrating signals of Cl−共 1S0兲 with total kinetic energies less
than 40 cm−1, or signals inside the circle as shown in Fig. 4. The arrow
indicates the threshold of ion-pair production for producing Cl+共 1D2兲.
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp
104307-8
J. Chem. Phys. 127, 104307 共2007兲
Li et al.
TABLE VI. The bond dissociation energies of Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 and Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲
共units are in eV兲.
Method
Ab initio calculation
MRDCIa
UCCSD-T/AV5Zb
Modelc
Photodissociationd
ZEKE and ion-pair imaginge
D0共Cl2兲
2.455
2.370
2.479 34共4兲
2.474共20兲
+10
2.4784−3
D0共Cl+2 兲
3.535
3.744
+10
3.9594−3
Reference
27
This work
15 and 16
17
This work
a
By means of MRDCI method with full CI estimation. The D0共Cl+2 兲 was not
present in the original paper, and was calculated from the theoretical results
of IE共Cl2兲, IE共Cl兲, and D0共Cl2兲, which were presented in the paper.
b
The zero-point energy corrections have been taken into account, see text.
c
Derived by combining a model about long range potential of diatomic
molecule and the vibrational energy levels measured experimentally 共␷ = 9 to
42, 49, 52, and 55兲.
d
By measuring the translational energy release of fragment in the photodissociation of Cl2.
e
The D0共Cl2兲 and D0共Cl+2 兲 were calculated using Eqs. 共8兲 and 共9兲, respectively. The IE共Cl2兲 and Etipp共Cl2兲 are determined in this work. The IP共Cl兲
and EA共Cl兲 are from the reported values 共Refs. 28 and 31兲.
brational numbering assignment of emission spectra by
Huberman is correct.7 Using the ion-pair formation imaging
method to discriminate signals of Cl+共 1D2兲 from those of
Cl+共 3 P j兲, the threshold for ion-pair 共Etipp兲 production:
Cl2共X 1⌺+g 兲 → Cl+共 1D2兲 + Cl−共 1S0兲
+8
096−2
is
determined
as
−1
107
cm . By using the determined IE and Etipp for Cl2
and also the reported IE and electronic affinity for chlorine
atom, the bond dissociation energies of Cl2 and Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲
+8
+8
and 31 935.1−2
cm−1,
have been determined as 19 990−2
respectively.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work is funded by Project No. 20673066 supported
by the National Science Foundation of China, Project No.
306020 supported by the Key grant Project of Chinese Ministry of Education, and Scientific Research Program of Tsinghua University.
1
mentally 共␷ = 9 to 42, 49, 52, and 55兲 for Cl2.
The bond dissociation energy for D0共Cl+2 兲 can be calculated according to
14,15
D0共Cl+2 兲 = D0共Cl2兲 + IE关Cl共 2 P3/2兲兴 − IE共Cl2兲.
共9兲
Using the IE共Cl2兲 and D0共Cl2兲 determined in this work and
also the reported IE关Cl共 2 P3/2兲兴,28 D0共Cl+2 兲 is determined as
+8
+10
cm−1 or 3.9594−3
eV. Table VI lists the bond dis31 935.1−2
sociation energies of Cl2 and Cl+2 determined by us and also
other reported values.
Peyerimhoff and Buenker have calculated the D0共Cl2兲 by
means of the multireference single- and double-excitation
configuration interaction 共MRDCI兲 method with full CI
estimation.27 Their calculation result was 2.455 eV, which is
in good agreement with our experimental data. The bond
dissociation energy of Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲, although not reported in
their paper, can be derived from their reported theoretical
results of IE共Cl兲 共12.52 eV兲, IE共Cl2兲 共11.44 eV兲, and
D0共Cl2兲. Our calculated results at the level of UCCSD-T/
AV5Z, as introduced in Sec. III, are also listed in Table VI,
along with the theoretical results by Peyerimhoff and
Buenker.
V. SUMMARY
The one-photon ZEKE spectrum of Cl2 has been recorded using coherent XUV light. The isotopomer-resolved
vibrational energy levels and spin-orbit energy splittings for
Cl+2 共X̃ 2⌸g兲 have been determined. The first adiabatic ionization energy 共IE兲 of Cl2 is determined as 92 645.9± 1.0 cm−1.
The spin-orbit energy splitting for the ground vibrational
state is determined as 717.5± 1.5 cm−1. These data are found
to be in good agreement with the ab initio quantum chemistry calculations taking account of the inner-shell electron
correlation.
The vibrational constants determined in this work provided concrete experimental evidence that the previous vi-
A. B. Cornford, D. C. Frost, C. A. Mcdowell, J. L. Ragle, and I. A.
Stenhouse, J. Chem. Phys. 54, 2651 共1971兲.
V. H. Dibeler, J. A. Walker, K. E. McCulloh, and H. M. Rosenstock, Int.
J. Mass Spectrom. Ion Process. 7, 209 共1971兲.
3
A. W. Potts and W. C. Price, Trans. Faraday Soc. 67, 1242 共1971兲.
4
H. Van Lonkhuyzen and C. A. De Lange, Chem. Phys. 89, 313 共1984兲.
5
T. Reddish, A. A. Cafolla, and J. Corner, Chem. Phys. 120, 149 共1988兲.
6
A. J. Yencha, A. Hopkirk, A. Hiraya, R. J. Donovan, J. G. Goode, R. R.
J. Maier, G. C. King, and A. Kvaran, J. Phys. Chem. 99, 7231 共1995兲.
7
F. P. Huberman, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 20, 29 共1966兲.
8
R. P. Tuckett and S. D. Peyerimhoff, Chem. Phys. 83, 203 共1984兲.
9
J. C. Choi and J. L. Hardwick, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 137, 138 共1989兲; 145,
371 共1991兲.
10
C. Y. Ng, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 54, 101 共2002兲, and reference therein.
11
E. W. Schlag, ZEKE Spectroscopy 共Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1996兲.
12
Y. Mo, J. Yang, and C. Chen, J. Chem. Phys. 120, 1263 共2004兲.
13
J. Yang, Y. S. Hao, J. Li, C. Zhou, and Y. Mo, J. Chem. Phys. 122,
134308 共2005兲.
14
K. P. Huber and G. Herzberg, Constants of Diatomic Molecules 共Van
Nostrand, New York, 1979兲.
15
R. J. Le Roy and R. B. Bernstein, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 37, 109 共1971兲.
16
Y. V. Rao and P. Venkateswarlu, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 9, 173 共1962兲.
17
P. C. Samartzis, I. Sakellariou, T. Gougousi, and T. N. Kitsopoulos, J.
Chem. Phys. 107, 43 共1997兲.
18
J. Berkowitz, C. A. Mayhew, and B. Ruscic, Chem. Phys. 123, 317
共1988兲.
19
A. T. J. B. Eppink and D. H. Parker, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 68, 3477 共1997兲.
20
Y. Hao, C. Zhou, and Y. Mo, J. Phys. Chem. 109, 5832 共2005兲.
21
J. Yang, J. Li, and Y. Mo, J. Chem. Phys. 125, 174313 共2006兲.
22
H.-J. Werner, P. J. Knowles, R. Lindh, F. R. Manby, M. Schütz et al.,
MOLPRO, Version 2006.1, a package of ab initio programs 共see http://
www.molpro.net兲.
23
A. Berning, M. Schweizer, H.-J. Werner, P. J. Knowles, and P. Palmieri,
Mol. Phys. 98, 1823 共2000兲.
24
M. J. O. Deegan and P. J. Knowles, Chem. Phys. Lett. 227, 321 共1994兲.
25
C. C. Marston and G. G. Balint-Kurti, J. Chem. Phys. 91, 3571 共1989兲.
26
R. N. Zare, Angular Momentum 共Wiley, New York, 1998兲.
27
S. D. Peyerimhoff and R. J. Buenker, Chem. Phys. 57, 279 共1981兲.
28
J. E. Sansonetti and W. C. Martin, Handbook of Basic Atomic Spectroscopic
Data
共http://www.physics.nist.gov/PhysRefData/Handbook/
index.html兲
29
M. S. N. Al-Kahali, R. J. Donovan, K. P. Lawley, and T. Ridley, J. Chem.
Phys. 104, 1833 共1995兲.
30
G. Herzberg, Spectra of Diatomic Molecules, Molecular Spectra and Molecular Structure Vol. I 共D. Van Nostrand, Princeton, NJ, 1950兲.
31
U. Berzinsh, M. Gustafsson, D. Hanstorp, A. Klinkmuller, U. Ljungblad,
and A. M. Martensson-Pendrill, Phys. Rev. A 51, 231 共1995兲.
2
Downloaded 26 Oct 2007 to 130.208.167.39. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright, see http://jcp.aip.org/jcp/copyright.jsp