Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences 2016, July. 5(2): 24-30 ISSN 1110-2047, www.alexjvs.com DOI: 10.5455/ajvs.215533 Ascorbic acid Supplementation Improves the Quality of Meat Characteristics in Sahel Bucks Exposed to Long Distance Road transport Khalid T. Biobaku1, Jibir M2, Ismail A. Odetokun 3 Onifade K. Idowu4, Ismaila M. Sani4, Agaie B. Mohammed4 1Department of Veterinary Pharmacology and Toxicology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Ilorin, Ilorin, Nigeria, 2 Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Usmanu Danfodiyo, University, Sokoto, Sokoto State, Nigeria, 3Veterinary Public Health and Preventive Medicine, University of Ilorin, Nigeria, 4 Department of Veterinary Pharmacology and Toxicology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Usmanu Danfodiyo, University, Sokoto, Sokoto State, Nigeria Abstract Key words: Anti-stress, Welfare, dressing percent, pH, Chevon This study assessed the meat quality of Sahel bucks treated with ascorbic acid and exposed to long term transportation stress during harmattan period. The animals were transported using; high and low stocking density. A total of 32 animals (16 for both the high and low stocking rate) were used for the study .Four goats were used in each of the treatment groups. Animals in groups 1, 2 and 3 were treated with ascorbic acid at 400, 300 and 200 mg/kg orally, while animals in group 4 were the control nontreated group. Ascorbic acid was administered prior and midway into the experimental journey. Twenty four animals were slaughtered, 3 from each group for assessment of goat meat (chevon) characteristics. Goats treated with 400mg and 200mg/kg ascorbic acid had higher dressing percentage compared to those treated with 300mg/kg (P<0.05). Excitatory score at slaughter was significantly (P<0.05) higher in group treated with 400mg/kg compared to groups treated with (200 and 300mg/kg). The ultimate pH in the group administered 400mg/kg was lower (P<0.05) compared to the other treatment groups (200mg/kg and 300mg/kg). The ultimate pH on dressing percent, excitatory score at slaughter and on ultimate pH of the meat at low stocking density is significantly (P<0.05) lower compared to the high stocking density. There was an interaction between the dose of ascorbic acid and stocking rate. The study showed that, ascorbic acid possesses anti-stress property that could be used to improve food animal welfare and chevon quality. Corresponding Author: Ismaila M. Sani, [email protected] 1. INTRODUCTION Several studies have demonstrated the effect of ascorbic acid on biochemical and other signs of various types of stress and toxicities in domestic animals including goats (Adenkola et al., 2016; Adenkola et al., 2009; Ayo et al., 2006; Minka and Ayo, 2010). Vitamin C is a six carbon ketolactone structure; it is related to glucose and other hexoses. Ascorbic acid is reversibly oxidized in the body to dihydro-ascorbic acid. The latter compound possesses full Vitamin C activity (Joel et al., 2001). Stress provokes significant rise in the serum level of ascorbic acid, and a reduction in its concentration in skin, lungs and adrenal glands (Zulkifli et al., 2000) showed that, the mechanism by which ascorbic acid alleviates stress is not fully understood. However, ascorbic acid is thought to improve the humoral and cellular immunity, and thus, increase resistance to infection, defense mechanism and anti-oxidant status of the animal and reduce the detrimental effects of certain eicosanoids (Stilborn et al., 1988). The elimination of reactive oxygen species could likely be one of modes of ascorbic acid anti-stress activity (Minka and Ayo, 2008). Previous studies in the tropics had also shown that ascorbic acid improved the mood of transported Sokoto red goats and this effect was thought to be due to the involvement of ascorbic acid in the synthesis of neurotransmitters involved in the neuro-chemical balance during neuronal activity of the brain (Ayo et al., 2006). Transportation is an inevitable husbandry practice, which livestock are subjected to as a result of marketing and the need to slaughter them for meat in 24 Biobaku et al., / Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences 2016, July. 50(2):24-30 abattoirs, often located outside the places where the animals are reared (Pineiro et al., 2007; Rajesh et al., 2003). In general, animals perceive any unusual manipulation including transportation as stressful, and this may ultimately have a negative influence on their welfare. Transportation is an unfamiliar and threatening event in the life of an animal. It involves handling, loading, confinement and unloading which are unavoidably stressful and can lead to distress, injury or even the death of the animal (von Borell et al., 2007) Road transportation represents a critical phase in animal production and utilization. It is often considered as one of the main causes of physical stress and it adversely affects production economically and compromising the animals welfare (Minka and Ayo, 2008). Ruminants require ascorbic acid from time to time and some reports suggest that the deficiency of ascorbic acid could manifest as scurvy in man, calves however had scurvy like skin lesions as symptoms of ascorbic acid deficiency. Ascorbic acid is important in increasing the resistance against respiratory diseases (Eldridge and Winfield, 1988). Young ruminants require more ascorbic acid during cold stress and plasma concentration is needed to be increased to confer immunity to protect the animals (Jagos et al., 1977) . (Hemingway, 1991) reported that, ascorbic acid prevents neonatal calve diarrhoea and scours. With the aforementioned facts, the use of ascorbic acid in stress alleviation cannot be over emphasized in animal husbandry , .many studies had been conducted on its uses in stress alleviation in animals in transportation .But there is dearth of information as regards to posological consideration and its effects on meat product which might be the most practicable usage of pharmacological consideration to stakeholders in the livestock industry .The fact that ascorbic acid is safe in animals and man is a merit. The objective of this study is to evaluate different doses of ascorbic acid on meat characteristics of Sahel bucks subjected to stress at high and low stocking rates. Thirty-two apparently healthy Sahel bucks were used for the experiment. Their ages ranges between one and half and two years, weighed between 10-14 Kg and had their universal body score of 3. The animals were purchased from livestock markets of Sokoto State, acclimatized for two weeks and were clinically examined and treated prophylactically using albendazole (Albenzole, Agbara Industries ,Lagos, Nigeria) and a combination of penicillin and streptomycin (penstreptomycin® Kepro, Holland) . The bucks were fed groundnut hay, cowpea husk and corn residue the animals were also served with clean fresh water ad libitum , and were allowed to move freely semi extensively in a pen with an estimated stocking rate of above 2m2/goat. Vital parameters and blood samples were obtained as basal parameters while weights was taken once weekly in their two weeks of acclimatization to monitor their health. 2.2 Experimental Design, drug administration and carcass assessment A total number of 32 animals were used in the study comprising of 8 groups of four bucks per group,. Group I: Are bucks treated with Ascorbic acid at 400mg/kg orally administered (PO); Group II: Were treated with ascorbic acid at 300mg/kg PO; Group III : ascorbic acid at 200mg/kg PO; while Group IV : were the control non-treated group. Each of treatments has low and high stocking rates respectively. The animals were stocked using a high stocking density which was not in conformity with standard international regulation and a standard low stocking rate which is in line with the Animal Disease Control Act of 1988 of Nigeria and is in agreement with standard international regulations for transportation of goats. Thus, 16 animals were experimented upon for high stocking rate and 16 stocked using low stocking rate. Three animals each per group were slaughtered and were used to assess the effect of ameliorative supplementation of ascorbic acid on meat product in transportation of Sahel buck. The Ascorbic acid oral tablets y were graded and administered orally (Adenkola et al., 2011; Ayo et al., 2006), at the beginning of the journey at Sokoto and at Jebba mid-way in to the experimental journey. A transportation and health certificate was obtained from the Veterinary unit of Ministry of Forestry and Animal Health of Sokoto State where the study began. The bucks used in the experiment were acclimatized and were used to handling to ensure that the animals would not be psychologically affected by handling at loading. The Sahel bucks were handled with care and 2. MATERIALS AND METHODS 2.1 Experimental Animals Ethical permission for experimentation given by a board at the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Usmanu Danfodiyo University, Sokoto, Nigeria. While monitoring of husbandry practices was carried out by a personnel from Department of Animal Science of the University. 25 Biobaku et al., / Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences 2016, July. 50(2):24-30 were loaded by four people. Between 09:00 to 10:00h. The animals at low stocking rate were stocked at 0.30m2per animal; while the animal at high stocking density was stocked at 0.15m2 per animal. The animals transported at low stocking density were in line to international guidelines on transportation of animals. While the high stocking rate was the stocking rate used routinely by marketers which is not standard. The floor the truck was cushioned using sorghum leaves and saw dust to avoid the animals to come in contact with urine and faeces in order to avoid sliding and also to minimize the risk of transmission of diseases. Along the journey at Jebba town located along latitude 90o.06' and 9o55' N and longitudes 4 o 02' and4o 05’E. The animals transported that were stocked using the low stocking density was rested 12 hours into the journey and were fed with groundnut hay and wheat bran and water ad libitum , in conformity with the Animal Disease Control Act of 1988, of Nigeria and with the international guidelines for loading and transportation. While animals that were transported at high stocking was to simulate non standard used by marketers. Twenty four animals were slaughtered in all, 3 bucks per group using “halal” method which involves the severing of the jugular vein, carotid arteries trachea and oesophagus and other structures covered by the investing fascia of the neck as adopted by(Jibir et al., 2012).The animal was shaved using shaving blade as an operation of carcass preparation in South west, Nigeria. After which the animals is inflated using a pumping machine specified for usage. The shaving operation is carried out using a razor or shaving knife at 30o-60o to the skin, in a direction of the hair strands. A piece of herbal® soap (Nigeria) containing aloe vera and water was used for washing and lubrication during shaving. The head was removed at the atlanto-occipital joint and the fore and hind limb at the carpal and tarsal joints. The meat yield parameters including live weight carcass weight shrinkage percentage, dressing percentage and empty body weight were assessed using the method of (Jibir et al., 2012; Kannan et al., 2002) .Cooking loss test was conducted in which a chop from the semi-membranous muscle measuring a length and breadth of 5cm each and is of 1cm thickness. The weight was taken using a Metlers digital balance. The percentage loss in weight and Meat pH was determined using a method described by (Pethick et al., 2005).Water holding capacity of semimembranous was assessed using filter paper (Wierbicki & Deatherage, 1958). Meat colour assessment of rectus abdominis was carried out using the method of (Colomer-Rocher et al., 1987). 2.3 Statistical Analysis Analysis of data was carried out using SPSS version 16 and ANOVA of General linear model was used for the analysis and P<0.05 was considered significant. 3. RESULTS Results of different doses of ascorbic acid and stocking rate on various meat characteristics is presented in table 1 below. There was no significant (P>0.05) difference in shrinkage. Ascorbic acid at the dose of 400 and 200mg/kg gives comparatively higher (P<0.05) dressing percentage than the dressing percentage in animals administered with 300mg/kg. Excitatory score value at slaughter was significantly (P<0.05) higher with the high dose compared with lower doses of 200mg/kg and 300mg/kg. The ultimate pH in the group administered with 400mg/kg was lower (P<0.05) when compared to the other two treatment groups (200mg/kg and 300mg/kg). The ultimate pH at low stocking density is significantly (P<0.05) lower ultimate pH when compared to the high stocking density. Figure 1 shows that high dose of ascorbic acid (400mg/kg) at low stocking rate increases the dressing percentage, while the same dose at the high stocking rate decreases the dressing percentage. The low dose (200mg/kg) of ascorbic acid at low and high stocking rate produced contrary effect on the dressing percentage. Figure 2 shows that at low dose (200 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid low stocking rate there was increased excitatory score at slaughter, while the high stocking rate decreased the level of the excitatory score at slaughter. The medium dose (300 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid at low stocking density also decreased the excitatory score at slaughter, while high stocking rate increased the excitatory score. Medium dose (300 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid at low stocking rate decrease in the pH of chevon while the same dose at high stocking rate increased ultimate pH . Figure 3 also showed that at low dose (200 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid and low stocking rate, the pH was higher while at high stocking rate it lowered the pH. The high dose (400 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid at high stocking rate increased the pH which at low stocking rate lowered the pH . 26 Biobaku et al., / Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences 2016, July. 50(2):24-30 Table 1: Effects of ascorbic acid doses and stocking rate on meat characteristics of Sahel bucks exposed to long term transportation stress Meat characteristics Shrinkage % Dressing % Excitatory score at slaughter Empty body weight (kg) Water holding capacity % Ph Colour Cooking loss % Dose 400mg/Kg 300mg/Kg 17.62 19.25 69.45a 52.38b a 4.00 3.50b 8.90 9.75 45.53 48.13 5.82c 6.00b 80.00c 86.67b 46.75 44.39 200mg/Kg 17.80 66.92a 3.50b 8.78 48.13 6.27a 100.00a 41.10 SEM 3.80 2.96 0.00 0.38 3.07 0.14 12.17 2.22 Stocking rate High Low 17.84 18.600 82.66 62.06 3.76a 3.67b 9.31 9.00 48.52 44.66 6.26a 5.80b 97.78 80.00 43.61 44.56 SEM 3.11 2.42 0.01 0.32 2.50 0.17 9.94 1.813 Interaction NS * * NS NS * NS NS Values with different superscripts abc along the same row differ significantly (P<0.05) Higher values of luminosity of meat colour indicate lighter (pink) lower values indicate daker (congested) colour. NS means no interaction. While * means interaction (P<0.05) Figure 1: Interaction of ascorbic acid dose and stocking rate on dressing percent. High: (400mg/kg), Low: (200mg/kg), medium: (300mg/kg) 27 Biobaku et al., / Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences 2016, July. 50(2):24-30 Figure 2: Interaction of ascorbic acid dose and stocking rate on excitatory score at slaughter. High: (400mg/kg), Low: (200mg/kg), medium :( 300mg/kg) Figure 3: Interaction of ascorbic acid and stocking rate on pH. High (400mg/kg), Low (200mg/kg), medium: (300mg/kg) 4. DISCUSSION In this study, ascorbic acid improves behaviour and excitability score of the animal exposed to stress this would further improve the animal welfare to prevent excess water loss, and reduced shrinkage. It could be explained by the fact that the neuro-endocrine network regulates fluid adjustment through the hypothalamohypophyseal connection. So ascorbic acid minimizes anxiety that could be detrimental to neurons. The stress ameliorative property of ascorbic acid could be due to its neuro-protective and anti-oxidative property. This finding is in agreement with previous observation of (Kannan et al., 2002; Minka and Ayo, 2010) in short term transportation of goats. The high dose also had a non-significant effect on dress percentage. These findings were also reported by(Young et al., 2003) who observed no significant difference in some meat characteristics. Similarly, the supplement must have 28 Biobaku et al., / Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences 2016, July. 50(2):24-30 improved the protein tryptophan in meat (Christensen and Redig, 1993) this also might improve the meat quality. It could be suggested that, ascorbic acid might have elicited its effect by improving the biochemical parameters including electrolytes .This prevents soreness of muscle preventing dark-firm-dry syndrome due to transport. The metabolism of glycogen in the muscles might be influenced by ascorbic acid since there is an association between synthesis of endogenous ascorbate and glucose in the body thus, ascorbic acid would decrease loss of glucose and glycogen utilization that could be detrimental to meat quality and storage live(Kannan et al., 2002; Minka and Ayo, 2010). Similarly, (Young et al., 2003) reported that, ascorbic acid reduce stress-induced deterioration of chicken meat quality. The ascorbic acid also influenced the colour of chevon. This could be due to the effect of ascorbic acid on the myoglobin in the muscles, it could be inferred that metabolic role of ascorbic acid prevented the depletion endogenous ascorbic acid which enhanced metabolism and the appropriate transportation of oxygen to the myocytes. This with cytoprotective property of ascorbic acid prevented the compromise in the walls of the capillaries and arterioles supplying the muscle tissue. The explanation is that ascorbic acid is suggested to have decreased insignificantly pro-inflammatory cytokines and modulates other anti- inflammatory cytokines including: IL-6, TNF, IL-1β, and IL-α. Ascorbic acid also decreased insignificantly cortisol level at short term transportation stress in Kalahari goats (un-published data). This would also protect the muscle tissues against the dark- firm-dry syndrome after transportation stress and this would improve the reflection of light on the meat surface and luminosity evident of light coloured meat and better quality. The effect of ascorbic acid on meat quality from another perspective might be due to inhibition of the activation of nuclear factor Kappa and β, which is a mediator responsible for inflammation. Ascorbic acid is also associated with inhibition of other tissue necrosis factors – alpha (LaLonde et al., 1997). This might likely be one of the reasons for its alleviation of long term transportation–induced stress and its value for improvement of meat quality. Ascorbic acid at the dose of 400mg/kg was better in improving the dressing percentages at low density stocking. This could be due to the fact that higher doses of ascorbic acid would have improved the antioxidants concentration in the cells of animals. In the same vein the ascorbic acid at higher doses improves upon the adaptability in the animals and also prevents dehydration(Minka & Ayo, 2010).The shrinkage of the meat could have been decreased by the ascorbic acid at 400mg/kg as could be correlated to the dressing percentage(Kannan et al., 2002). The lower dose of 200mg/kg of ascorbic acid did not improve the quality even at low stocking density. This might be explained by the biochemical phenomenon of not increasing the antioxidants concentration enough to adjust to counteract the pro-oxidants simulated by the stress of transportation .This suggestion is in agreement with (Adenkola et al., 2009; Adenkola & Okoro, 2015). The low dose (200 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid at low stocking rate increased the excitatory score at slaughter, while the high stocking decreased the level of the excitatory score at slaughter. The medium dose (300 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid at low stocking density decreased the excitatory score at slaughter, while at high stocking rate it increased the excitatory score. The dose of ascorbic acid in this case is not a factor that could directly affect the excitatory score at slaughter and it could be said that a categoric assumption cannot be made as per the influence of ascorbic acid on excitatory score. But it could be correlated to the work of (Ayo et al., 2006) who reported that, ascorbic acid influence the excitability score of Sokoto red goats. Other work further supports the fact of its stress alleviating effect.(Adenkola et al., 2011). This therefore means that the dose of 200 mg/kg improved the excitability score at slaughter in the animals used in this study. This effect could be due to the fact that high doses in ruminants increase the plasma level of ascorbic acid which coupled with the endogenously synthesized ascorbic acid which might increase the excretion of ascorbate and this might decrease the bioavailability of ascorbic acid and the area under curve as previously observed in sheep (Black & Hidiroglou, 1996). This might account for the ineffectiveness of the higher doses on the excitatory score. The medium dose (300 mg/kg) of ascorbic acid at low stocking rate decreased the pH while at high stocking rate increased pH. The dose therefore improved the pH of the meat unlike other doses at the low stocking and high stocking rates. The dose of 300 mg/kg could be could be suggested to be useful conservation of glycogen and decrease in muscle glucose which could account for the decrease in pH and this improves the ultimate pH of meat. In conclusion the 400mg/kg of ascorbic acid improved dressing percentage at low density stocking, 29 Biobaku et al., / Alexandria Journal of Veterinary Sciences 2016, July. 50(2):24-30 Kannan, G., Terrill, T., Kouakou, B., Gelaye, S., Amoah, E. 2002. Simulated preslaughter holding and isolation effects on stress responses and live weight shrinkage in meat goats. J. Ani Sci. 80(7): 1771-1780. LaLonde, C., Nayak, U., Hennigan, J., Demling, R. 1997. Excessive liver oxidant stress causes mortality in response to burn injury combined with endotoxin and is prevented with antioxidants. J of Burn Care & Res. 18(3): 187-192. Minka, N., Ayo, J. 2008. Haematology and behaviour of pullets transported by road and administered with ascorbic acid during the hot-dry season. Res in Vet. Sci. 85(2): 389-393. Minka, N.S., Ayo, O.J. 2010. Serum biochemical activities and muscular soreness in transported goats administered with ascorbic acid during the hot-dry season. Eur J of Translational Myol. 20(4):193-203. Pethick, D., Davidson, R., Hopkins, D., Jacob, R., D'Souza, D., Thompson, J., Walker, P. 2005. The effect of dietary treatment on meat quality and on consumer perception of sheep meat eating quality. Animal Prod Sci. 45(5):517524. Pineiro, M., Pineiro, C., Carpintero, R., Morales, J., Campbell, F.M., Eckersall, P.D., Toussaint, M.J., Lampreave, F. 2007. Characterisation of the pig acute phase protein response to road transport. The Vet Journal. 173(3):669-674. Rajesh kumar, B., Muralidharan, M., Ramesh, V., Arunachalam, S., Sivakumar, T. 2003. Effect of transport stress on blood profile in sheep. Ind Vet J. 80(6), 511-514. Stilborn, H., Harris, G., Bottje, W., Waldroup, P. 1988. Ascorbic acid and acetylsalicylic acid (aspirin) in the diet of broilers maintained under heat stress conditions. Poultry Sci 67(8): 1183-1187. von Borell, E., Langbein, J., Després, G., Hansen, S., Leterrier, C., Marchant-Forde, J., Marchant-Forde, R., Minero, M., Mohr, E., Prunier, A. 2007. Heart rate variability as a measure of autonomic regulation of cardiac activity for assessing stress and welfare in farm animals—a review. Physiol & Behavi. 92(3): 293-316. Wierbicki, E., Deatherage, F. 1958. Water content of meats, determination of water-holding capacity of fresh meats. J Agric and Food Chem. 6(5): 387-392. Young, J.F., Stagsted, J., Jensen, S.K., Karlsson, A., Henckel, P. 2003. Ascorbic acid, alpha-tocopherol, and oregano supplements reduce stress-induced deterioration of chicken meat quality. Poultry Sci. 82(8): 1343-1351. Zulkifli, I., Abdullah, N., Azrin, N.M., Ho, Y. 2000. Growth performance and immune response of two commercial broiler strains fed diets containing Lactobacillus cultures and oxytetracycline under heat stress conditions. British poultry sci 41(5):593-597. the 200mg/kg increased the excitatory score at slaughter, while the 300 mg/kg improve the ultimate pH of the meat by decreasing the pH which might improve shelf life of the meat. 5. References Adenkola, A., Adah, A., Ambali, S. 2016. The Effects of Vitamins C and E on Erythrocyte Osmotic Fragility, Serum Malondialdehyde concentrations and Surface Erythrocyte Sialic Acid in Rams following Road Transportation. Alexandria J. Vet. Sci. 48 (2): 9-17 Adenkola, A., Ayo, J., Sackey, A., Adelaiye, A. 2011. Eight hours road transportation and ascorbic acid administration effects on haematological parameters of pigs during the harmattan season.ABJNA. 2: 1143-1150. Adenkola, A., Ayo, J.O., Sackey, A.K.B., Adelaiye, A.B., Minka, N.S. 2009. Excitability scores of pigs administered ascorbic acid and transported during the harmattan season. Vet. Arhiv, 79(5): 471-480. Adenkola, A., Okoro, L. 2015. Serum malondialdehyde concentration, rectal temperature and excitability score in road transported rams administered with vitamins C+ E combination and vitamin C. N V J. 35 (2) 995·1006 Ayo, J., Minka, N., Mamman, M. 2006. Excitability scores of goats administered ascorbic acid and transported during hot-dry conditions. J Vet Sci . 7(2): 127-131. Black, W., Hidiroglou, M. 1996. Pharmacokinetic study of ascorbic acid in sheep. Can J Vet Res 60(3): 216. Christensen, L., Redig, C. 1993. Effect of meal composition on mood. Behavioral neurosci. 107(2): 346. Colomer-Rocher, F., Morand-Fehr, P., Kirton, A. 1987. Standard methods and procedures for goat carcass evaluation, jointing and tissue separation. Livestock Prod Sci 17: 149-159. Eldridge, G., Winfield, C. 1988. The behaviour and bruising of cattle during transport at different space allowances. Animal Production Science, 28(6), 695-698. Hemingway, D.C. 1991. Vitamin C in the prevention of neonatal calf diarrhea. The Can Vet J 32(3):184. Jagos, P., Bouda, J., Dvorrak, R. 1977. [Ascorbic acid levels in the bronchopneumonia of calves]. Veterina medicina, 22(3): 133-136. Jibir, M., Jibrila, I., Garba, S., Isa, A., Omojola, A. 2012. Carcass and Lean Quality Characterization of the Autochthonous Goats in the Semi-arid Zone of Northwestern Nigeria. I JM S. 2(2): 34. Joel, G.H., Lee, E.L., Alfred, G. 2001. Goodman and Gilman’s the pharmacological basis of therapeutics. International edition, 10th edition, Mc Grow Hill, 971. 30
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz