computational flow modeling for optimizing industrial fan

European Conference on Computational Fluid Dynamics
ECCOMAS CFD 2006
P. Wesseling, E. Oñate, J. Périaux (Eds)
TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2006
COMPUTATIONAL FLOW MODELING FOR OPTIMIZING
INDUSTRIAL FAN PERFORMANCE CHARACTERISTICS
W.K. Ng* and M. Damodaran **
Division of Thermal and Fluids Engineering
School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering
Nanyang Technological University,
50 Nanyang Avenue, Singapore 639798
*Graduate Student
e-mail: [email protected]
**Associate Professor
e-mail: [email protected]
Key words: Industrial Centrifugal Ventilation Fan, Sliding Mesh Model
Abstract. The paper describes the computational flow analysis inside industrial ventilation
fans to facilitate computational design to achieve optimal fan performance characteristics
eventually. Finite volume computation using the notion of sliding meshes with rotational
zonal grids is used to solve the unsteady Navier-Stokes equations to simulate internal flow
inside both a single inlet and double inlet centrifugal fan for operational conditions specified
by an industry vendor. Fan performance characteristics are extracted and verified with
experimental data provided by the vendor and also shows the impact of various turbulence
models on the predictions. The impact of two fan blade section profiles, namely a blunt edge
section and an airfoil section on the performance are also assessed.
1
INTRODUCTION
Much work has been done by various researchers in the application of Computational
Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to turbomachinery flows. The state of the art of this practice is shown
in Lakshiminarayana1, Elder et al.2 and in Horlock and Denton3. Many parameters such as
efficiency, pressure rise, flow coefficient, work input, rotor blade tip speeds, and geometrical
ratios characterise the operational performance of industrial ventilation fans. While many of
these parameters could be obtained by routine wind tunnel tests for specific fan geometries,
the routine use of CFD technology in industrial applications enables the possibility of
complementing the experimental methods of obtaining the fan performance characteristics of
ventilation fans. Flows in these fans are complex, viscous, unsteady and three-dimensional
and CFD enables a better understanding of the flow phenomena which would otherwise be
impossible or expensive to gather experimentally. In this work, fan performance
characteristics is obtained from CFD simulation of a centrifugal industrial fan unit
manufactured by Kruger4 in order to gain insight into the complex flowfields and also to set a
stage for its use in blade shape design studies at a later stage. In this work, the sliding mesh
model which assumes that the flowfield is unsteady is used since it can accurately predict the
fan performance characteristics such as the presence of rotating stall and assess the effect of
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
rotation on the gauge static pressure distribution at outlet and surface pressure distribution on
blades and the impeller unit. While most often the unsteady solution that is sought in a sliding
mesh model is time-periodic with the unsteady solution repeating itself over a period related
to the moving domains, transient analysis of the flowfield as a result of a sudden reduction in
rotational speed on fan performance characteristics can also be assessed.
2 NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF FAN FLOWFIELDS
The flow inside the industrial fan configuration is computed by a finite volume discretisation
of the Navier Stokes equations, the general form of which can be written as follows:
t
where Q
QdV
V
V U Q D dA
A
( , V, E )T , D (0, , V
q )T , S
(1)
SdV
V
(0,
g , 0)T and
pI
where
is the
density of the fluid which can be assumed a constant for incompressible flow, V is the fluid
velocity of the control volume, E is the total energy, D is the non-convective terms, S is a
source term, p is the pressure,
is the shear stress tensor, q is the heat fluxes from
conduction and other heat sources and U is the velocity of the control volume which is zero
for the inertial frame of reference. Since the operational speeds of the industrial fan are in the
low speed regimes, incompressible flow field assumption is made for these simulations. These
equations are discretised into an algebraic form over all the cells in the computational mesh
representing the domain of calculation. These sets of algebraic equations are then solved
using the Fluent5 flow solver.
3 MESH GENERATION
The configuration of the single inlet and double inlet industrial fan are as shown in
Figures 1(a) and 1(b) respectively.
(a)
(b)
Figure 1: Configuration of (a) Single inlet (b) Double inlet centrifugal fan
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
The rotating part which is the impeller has plates on which the blades are arranged. The
impeller is then installed in a casing (volute). Flow enters through the eye of the impeller and
leaves through the rotating blade passages out to the casing towards the outlet.
The geometrical fan configurations shown in Figure 1 are provided by the industries in
Parasolid6 format and imported into Gambit7 software for the purpose of meshing. The
geometry of the blade and its sectional profile influence the fan performance characteristics.
The blades are arranged on a impeller plate. On each plate, there are 11 blades arranged
equidistantly. The double inlet fan has 22 blades on both sides of the impeller plate. With
such a blade arrangement, it is possible to use structured mesh for grid generation according
to Roth & Peikert8. The impeller plate is divided into 11 sections and meshed with
quadrilateral face mesh as shown in Figure 2(a). Using the Cooper scheme, the quadrilateral
volume mesh for one section is created by projecting the quadrilateral face mesh upwards.
This volume mesh for one section is copied and rotated about the X-axis to create structured
volume meshes for the impeller as shown in Figure 2(b).
Blade 7
Blade 8
Blade 6
Blade 9
Blade 5
Blade 10
Blade 4
Blade 11
Blade 3
Blade 1
Blade 2
(a) Division of blade arrangement into 11 sections
with quadrilateral face mesh for one section
(b) Completed volume mesh for blade
arrangement plate
Figure 2. Steps in creating volume mesh for blade arrangement plate which includes (a) division of blade
arrangement plate into 11 sections with quadrilateral face mesh for one section and (b) completed volume
mesh for blade arrangement plate
As the sliding mesh model is used for numerical flow simulation, interfaces need to be
created between different fluid zones such that one fluid zone remains stationary, while the
other fluid zone is rotating with the specified rotation velocity. For the rotating reference
frame Eqn (1) is written in terms of the absolute velocities i.e.
t
QdV
V
V U Q D dA
A
SdV
(2)
V
where U
r is the relative velocity,
is the angular velocity of the rotating frame/zone.
Figure 3 shows the interface location between the blue and grey fluid zones. The purple
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
coloured fluid zone and the light blue coloured fluid zones for the blade arrangement are
rotating about X-axis with the rotation velocity. The grey coloured fluid zone is set to be
stationary. According to Casey9, it is advisable that the computational domain covers the
region upstream and downstream of the blade stages. Figure 3 shows that the grid structure in
the upstream and downstream regions of blade stages i.e., the grey coloured areas. Structured
volume meshes are created for the single and double inlet fans. As far as possible mesh
skewness has been kept low for improved accuracy. The quality of the volume meshes is
checked by doing grid dependence studies and other mesh quality tests.
moving fluid zone
stationary
fluid zone
Interface
between
moving fluid
zone and
stationary
fluid zone
Figure 3. Interface between stationary fluid
zone and moving fluid zone
4 INITIAL AND BOUNDARY CONDITIONS
The volume flow rate extracted from the fan has been fixed by using the gauge static
pressure at the pressure inlet boundary. The stagnation pressure at the outlet is an unknown.
Since the inlet is exposed to atmospheric air, the inlet has gauge total pressure 0 Pa. Using
Bernoulli equation, as shown in equation (3); the gauge static pressure at inlet for a certain
2
volume flow rate was calculated and inputted at the pressure inlet boundary i.e. P
PT
2
where P is the gauge static pressure at inlet in Pa, PT is the gauge total pressure at inlet in Pa,
is the density of air at 1.22kg/m3,
is the velocity at the inlet obtained by dividing the
volume flow rate by the total inlet area. The problem has to be set up with a rotating reference
frame for the moving fluid zones first before activating the sliding mesh model. In the rotating
reference frame (moving reference frame), the rotational velocity is specified from the
operational conditions of the fan. The blade surfaces and rotating impeller walls are set as
moving walls but the rotating velocity is zero relative to adjacent fluid zone. This is because
the adjacent fluid zone surrounding the impeller blades are already sliding with the prescribed
rotational velocity. The moving fluid zones which are attached to the blade and impeller
surfaces are set to the specified rotational velocity about the axis of rotation of the impeller.
The impeller will rotate clockwise with respect to the outlet in the direction, which expels air
towards the outlet. After the solution has converged for the moving reference frame, the
sliding mesh model is started to achieve the steady state solution for the ventilation fan. The
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
unsteady solver is activated and a suitable time step is selected such that the cyclic behaviour
of the ventilation fan is captured. The unsteady solution will exhibit a cyclic behaviour after
the initial start up phase has passed. It takes several revolutions of the rotor before the solution
reaches steady state convergence. A suitable time step for the unsteady computation using
60
sliding mesh is computed as t
where N is the angular speed of rotation in rpm and n is
Nn
the number of time steps for the fan to complete one revolution. For the case of the fan
operating at 2500 rpm, the time step sizes for unsteady state iteration and mesh motion are
both of the O(10 4 ) seconds. The computation is done using the segregated solver. Since the
realizable k
model produces non-physical turbulent viscosities in situations when the
computational domain contains both rotating and stationary fluid zones which are sliding
meshes, it is not advisable to use realizable k model for sliding mesh model and hence the
standard k model has been selected for this study.
5
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
5.1 Computed Steady State Flow Fields in Single Inlet Fan
It is useful to plot the pressure contour at the outlet as the gauge total pressure will be
used later to compute the total efficiency of the single inlet fan. The total efficiency of the fan
PT Q
is defined as t
where Q is discharge in m3/s, BHP is brake horsepower in watts and
BHP
PT is gauge total pressure in Pa. Figure 4 shows that there is uneven gauge total pressure
distribution at the outlet. This is because the geometry of single inlet fan is not symmetrical
about Y-axis. The flow simulation result gives a gauge total pressure of 2140.107 Pa at the
outlet and it is very accurate when compared with the experimental result which gives
2200Pa.
Figure 4. Contour plot of gauge total pressure at outlet for
0.95m3/s, 2500rpm Average gauge total pressure: 2140.107 Pa
The presence of high computed vorticity at the blade tip region is shown in Figure 5.
This implies that the blade tips could be redesigned to minimize flow separation and improve
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
the performance of the fan. Rotating stall could be observed when the computed flow fields in
the blade passages are animated into a video format. Rotating stall occurs because of the lack
of air to fill in between the blade passages. As a result, the flow is shared unequally such that
some blade passages have large flow rates while other blade passages record lower flow rates.
The stall cells always rotate in the direction of the spinning rotor. Stall will run in the
direction in which the angle of incidence is increased. For the rotating blades, it means that
the stall cells moves backward relative to the rotating blades. This means that when the
rotating blades are rotating clockwise as shown in Figure 6, the stall cells are rotating in an
anti-clockwise direction relative to the blades. The rotation of the stall cells is in the same
sense as the rotor but at a greatly reduced speed. These observations proved that the sliding
mesh model serves as a good representation of flow in this complete fan configuration.
Blade 5
Blade 4
Blade 3
Blade 6
Blade 2
Blade 7
Blade 1
Blade 8
Blade 9
Figure 5. Contour plot of vorticity magnitude at blade
arrangement (3 D view) for 0.95m3/s, 2500rpm
Blade 11
Blade 10
Figure 6. Contour plot of static pressure for blade
passages (Top view) for 0.95m3/s, 2500rpm
The computed streamlines of the flow leaving immediately aft of the impeller blades
are shown in Figures 7(a) and 7(b) respectively. Flow separation with presence of shed
vortices can be seen.
.
Rotation
direction
Detaching
flows at
blades with
presence of
vortices
Unsymmetrical
streamlines due
to effects of
rotation
(a) Top View
(b) Zoom in 3 dimensional view
Figure 7. Comparison between streamline aft blade arrangement in (a) top
view and (b) zoom in 3 dimensional view for 0.95m3/s, 2500rpm
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
Figure 8 shows the computed streamlines emanating from the blade unit to the outlet along
the extension tube at the outlet
Figure 8. Streamline aft blade for 0.95m3/s, 2500rpm
Computed skin friction lines are plotted from the computed flow variables which
insight gained from plot of skin friction lines throws light on the flow separation from the
blade surfaces. Figures 9(a) and 9(b) show the plot of computed skin friction lines on the
pressure and the suction side of a blade respectively. It has been observed that different blades
have different patterns of skin friction lines due to presence of rotating stall, which creates an
uneven fluid distribution.
Figure 9. Plot of skin friction line on (a) pressure side and (b) suction side of Blade 11 for 0.95m3/s, 2500rpm
Figure 10 compares the impact of using different turbulence models on the variation of gauge
total pressure at the outlet against volume flow rate for single inlet fan operating at 2500rpm.
Figure 11 compares the plot of computed total efficiency against volume flow rate with the
experimental results measured by the vendor of the fans. Both the experimental results and
flow simulation results showed the maximum total efficiency when the volume flow rate is
1.9m3/s.
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
Standard K Epsilon
Experimental Result
Standard K Omega
RSM
K Epilson Realizable
Gauge Total Pressure at outlet (Pa)
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
Volum e Flow Rate (m 3/s)
Figure 10. Plot of gauge total pressure at outlet against volume flow rate for single inlet
fan running at 2500rpm for different turbulence models
Standard K Epsilon
Experimental Result
Standard K Omega
RSM
K Epilson Realizable
8.00E+01
7.00E+01
Total Efficiency
6.00E+01
5.00E+01
4.00E+01
3.00E+01
2.00E+01
1.00E+01
0.00E+00
0
1
2
3
4
Volume Flow Rate (m3/s)
Figure 11. Plot of total efficiency for single inlet fan running at
2500rpm for different turbulence models
The total efficiency of the single inlet fan at 1.9m3/s for flow simulation result is 73.8 %
which is close to the experimental result of 76.7 %. Figure 12 shows the plot of computed
gauge total pressure at outlet against volume flow rate for single inlet fan running at different
rpm. The surge line connects the surge points corresponding to different rpm. Effective fan
operation should not exceed the surge line but should be near to the surge line to avail the
maximum efficiency.
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
4500
Surge line
1200rpm
1800rpm
2500rpm
2900rpm
3600rpm
Gauge Total Pressure at outlet (Pa)
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
-500
Volum e Flow Rate (m 3/s)
Figure 12. Plot of gauge total pressure at outlet against volume flow rate for single
inlet fan running at different rpm with Standard K Epsilon Turbulence Model
.
5.2 Computed Steady State Flow Fields in Double Inlet Fan
Figure 13 shows the computed gauge total pressure contours at the outlet for the
extension tube for a flow rate of 1.2m3/s and fan rotating at 2200rpm. Since the double inlet
fan has its top and bottom blade arrangements aligned midway to each other, there is
asymmetry in the pressure distribution at the outlet.
Figure 13. Contour plot of gauge total pressure at
outlet for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
Average gauge static pressure: 1737.845 Pa
Figure 14. Contour plot of gauge static pressure and
blade arrangement on the impeller (3 D view) for
1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
The surface pressure distribution of the impeller blades as shown in Figure 14 also shows the
presence of rotating stall cells. Computed surface pressure contours on the blade pressure and
suction sides are shown in Figures 15(a) and (b) respectively.
A
G
H
B
C
I
D
E
J
F
L
K
(b) Suction side
(a) Pressure side
Figure 15. Contour plot of gauge static pressure at (a) pressure side and
(b) suction side of blade for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
Midline IJ of
Suction side
Tip line AB of
Pressure side
Midline CD
of Pressure
side
Tip line GH of
Suction side
Hub line KL of
Suction side
Hub line EF of
Pressure side
(a) Pressure side
(b) Suction side
Pressure side has higher
gauge static pressure
than suction side
(c) Both sides
Figure 16. Spanwise plot of static pressure along line on (a) pressure side, (b) suction
side and (c) both sides of blade surfaces for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
Figure 16(a) and (b) shows the surface pressure distribution at various spanwise stations near
the hub, mid-span and tip stations shown in Figure 15(a). It can be seen that gauge pressure
distribution does not vary significantly across the span of the blade. The spanwise plot of
gauge static pressure along the blade surfaces at the three spanwise stations as shown in
Figure 16(c) shows that the pressure side of blade has a higher gauge static pressure than the
suction side of the blade. In addition, the gauge static pressure increases from C to D and I to
J such that the blade edge farther away from the centre of rotation has a higher pressure. For
any fan, the minimum pressure occurs at the centre of rotation of the fan wheel and the
maximum pressure occurs just at the discharge side of the wheel. This means the rotating
plate has a low-pressure region while the outlet has a high-pressure region.
B
A
A
B
(a) Pressure side of blade
(b) Suction side of blade
Figure 17. Contour plot of vorticity magnitude at (a) pressure side and (b)
suction side of blade for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
Figure 17(a) and (b) show the computed vorticity contours on the blade surfaces. The plot of
the variation of the magnitude of vorticity along the lines A-A and B-B in the spanwise
direction indicated in Figure 17(a)-(b) is shown in Figure 18.
A
Blade tips observed to have
higher vorticity magnitude
B
A
B
Figure 18. Plot of vorticity magnitude along lines on blade surfaces for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
Higher vorticity regions are seen near the blade tip regions embedded into the impeller as in
Figure 19. Figure 20 shows a plot of computed streamlines emanating from the blades and
rotating impeller section and these are coloured according to the magnitude of the vorticity.
As swirling flow takes in these regions, this implies that the blade tip shape also influences
fan performance. According to Figure 21 and Figure 22, flow separation occurs at high
vorticity magnitude regions.
Figure 19. Contour plot of vorticity magnitude on
blades and rotating impeller plate for 1.2m3/s,
2200rpm
Figure 20. Streamlines emanating from blades and
rotating impeller for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
Figure 21 shows the plot of computed gauge total pressure at outlet against volume
flow rate for double inlet fan running at 2200rpm.
Gauge Total Pressure at Outlet (Pa)
2000
1800
Flow Simulation Result
1600
Experimental Result
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Volum e Flow Rate (m 3/s)
Figure 21. Plot of gauge total pressure at outlet against
volume flow rate for double inlet fan running at 2200rpm
Figure 22 compares the plot of computed total efficiency against volume flow rate
with the experimental results measured by the vendor of the fans. Both the experimental
results and flow simulation results showed the maximum total efficiency when the volume
flow rate is 3.33.m3/s. The total efficiency of the double inlet fan at 3.33m3/s for flow
simulation result is 73.9 % which is close to the experimental result of 76.1 %.
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
Flow Simulation Result
8.00E+01
Experimental Result
Total Efficiency
7.00E+01
6.00E+01
5.00E+01
4.00E+01
3.00E+01
2.00E+01
1.00E+01
0.00E+00
0
2
4
6
8
Volume Flow Rate (m3/s)
Figure 22. Plot of total efficiency for double inlet fan running at 2200rpm
In order to compare the performance of a single and a double inlet centrifugal fan, both fans
are run at 2200 rpm. Figures 23 and 24 compares respectively the computed and experimental
variations of gauge total pressure and efficiency with volume flow rate.
Double Inlet fan flow simulation result
Double inlet fan experimental result
Single inlet fan flow simulation result
Single inlet fan experimental result
8.00E+01
Double inlet fan flow simulation result
Double inlet fan experimental result
Single inlet fan flow simulation result
Single inlet fan experimental result
1800
1600
7.00E+01
6.00E+01
1400
Total Efficiency
Gauge Total Pressure at Outlet (Pa)
2000
1200
1000
800
600
5.00E+01
4.00E+01
3.00E+01
2.00E+01
400
1.00E+01
200
0.00E+00
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Volum e Flow Rate (m 3/s)
Figure 23. Plot of gauge total pressure at outlet against
volume flow rate for single inlet fan and double inlet fan
running at 2200rpm
0
2
4
6
8
Volume Flow Rate (m3/s)
Figure 24. Plot of total efficiency for single inlet fan and
double inlet fan running at 2200rpm
It can be seen that the double inlet fan generates a higher gauge total pressure than the single
inlet fan for the same rpm and volume flow rate. Since the double inlet fan has two impellers
instead of one impeller, it will generate a higher static pressure rise. The single inlet fan is not
suitable for high volume flow rate as it can be seen from Figure 23 that the gauge total
pressure at the outlet decreases drastically at higher volume flow rate as the single inlet fan
has a smaller outlet area when compared with the double inlet fan. By having the same
volume flow rate, the flow velocity through the outlet of the single inlet fan has to be higher
than that of the double inlet fan, which will cause a drastic drop in gauge total pressure at the
outlet. Figure 24 shows that the single inlet fan has a higher total efficiency than the double
inlet fan despite giving out a lower gauge total pressure at the outlet. This is because the
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
single inlet fan has a much lower power requirement than the double inlet fan. To rotate the
impellers at the same rpm, the double inlet fan requires more power as it is turning two
impellers instead of one. The higher gauge total pressure at the outlet for the double inlet fan
is not enough to compensate for a much higher power requirement. The single inlet fan has a
much lower total efficiency at higher volume flow rate due to a sudden reduction of gauge
total pressure at the outlet. Hence the single inlet fan has a higher total efficiency than the
double inlet fan at low volume flow rates but a lower total efficiency at high volume flow
rates. The double inlet fan gives a higher gauge total pressure at the outlet but has a lower
total efficiency due to a higher power requirement. Hence, for industrial purposes, the double
inlet fan is desirable when a higher gauge total pressure is desired. The single inlet fan is
desirable at low volume flow rates as it gives a higher total efficiency.
5.3 Computed Flow Fields in Double Inlet Fan Using Airfoil Blade Sections
Bleier10 observed that centrifugal fans which use blades made up of airfoil sections
have the highest efficiencies of all centrifugal fans. Hence, it is possible to replace the blunt
blade sections used in the single inlet and double inlet fans discussed in scetions 5.1 and 5.2
with airfoil blades as shown in Figure 25 so that improved efficiencies could be obtained. A
computation was done for the same double inlet fan using an airfoil profile for the blade as
specified by the vendor. The computed pressure contours at the outlet of the fan using blades
with airfoil sections is shown in Figure 26.
Figure 25. Plot of total efficiency for double
inlet fan running at 2200rpm
Figure 26. Contour plot of gauge total pressure at
outlet for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
Average gauge total pressure: 1647.416 Pa
The double inlet centrifugal fan using blunt edge blades outlined in section 5.2 has a gauge
total pressure of 1737.845 Pa which is higher than the gauge total pressure at the outlet for the
fan using airfoil section blades which is 1647.416 Pa for the same volume flow rate and rpm.
The power required for rotation for the airfoil blade fan is lower than the blunt bladed fan.
The total efficiency of the airfoil blade fan is 51.1 % which is slightly lower than the total
efficiency of blunt bladed fan at 52.1 %. This discrepancy is due to the flow simulation result
for airfoil bladed fan giving a lower gauge total pressure at the outlet when compared with
experimental result. Figure 27 shows that for the fan using airfoil section blades, the flow
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
between the blade passages is shared more equally such that there is an almost equal
distribution of gauge static pressure in each blade passages.
Blade 4
Blade 3
Blade 2
Blade 5
Blade 6
Blade 1
Blade 11
Blade 7
Blade 8
Detaching
flows at
blades with
presence of
vortices
Blade 10
Blade 9
Figure 27. Contour plot of static pressure
for blade passages (Top view) for 1.2m3/s,
2200rpm for ADA 450
Figure 28. Streamline aft blade arrangement in
zoom in 3 dimensional view for 1.2m3/s,
2200rpm for airfoil blade fan
Figure 28 shows the presence of flow separation and vortices between blade passages
for the airfoil blade fan. Figures 29 and 30 show that the blunt edged bladed fan has a higher
vorticity magnitude than that from the airfoil bladed fan.
Figure 29. Contour plot of vorticity magnitude for
double inlet fan blade for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
Average vorticity magnitude: 1864.045 1/s
Figure 30. Contour plot of vorticity magnitude of
airfoil blade for 1.2m3/s, 2200rpm
Average vorticity magnitude: 1589.1339 1/s
Dimensionless plot of computed gauge total pressure vs. volume flow rate for airfoil bladed
fan is compared with experimental data provided by the vendor. Figure 31 shows that the
gauge total pressure at the outlet increases with decreasing volume flow rate until the surge
point is reached for the airfoil blade fan, while the blunt bladed fan has a higher gauge total
pressure than the airfoil bladed fan for the corresponding volume flow rate. Figure 32
compares the computed total efficiency vs. volume flow rate curves for the airfoil bladed fan
and double inlet fan. Differences between flow simulation result and experimental results can
be observed although the trends are very similar. It appears by comparing the experimental
results that the total efficiency of the airfoil bladed fan is higher than that of the blunt bladed
fan due to a lower power requirement. Comparing flow simulation results, the airfoil bladed
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
fan has a higher total efficiency than the blunt bladed fan at high volume flow rates. However,
the blunt bladed fan can reach a higher maximum efficiency than the airfoil bladed fan. This
is also observed by comparing the experimental results between the airfoil bladed fan and
blunt bladed fan.
2000
8.00E+01
7.00E+01
1600
6.00E+01
1400
Total Efficiency
Gauge Total Pressure at Outlet (Pa)
1800
1200
1000
800
600
Airfoil Blade fan Flow Simulation Result
Double Inlet fan Flow Simulation Result
400
Airfoil Blade fan Experimental Result
Double Inlet fan Experimental Result
200
5.00E+01
4.00E+01
3.00E+01
2.00E+01
Airfoil Blade Fan Flow Simulation Result
Double Inlet Fan Flow Simulation Result
1.00E+01
Airfoil Blade fan Experimental Result
Double Inlet fan Experimental Result
0.00E+00
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Volum e Flow Rate (m 3/s)
Figure 31. Plot of gauge total pressure at outlet against
volume flow rate for airfoil blade fan and double inlet fan
running at 2200rpm
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Volum e Flow Rate (m 3/s)
Figure 32. Plot of total efficiency for airfoil blade
fan and double inlet fan running at 2200rpm
6 CONCLUSIONS
Industrial fan performance characteristics have been investigated using CFD on a sliding
mesh model. Generally, the computed results appear to be reliable and similar to the
experimental fan performance characteristics provided by the vendor. However, there are
some differences in values of gauge total pressure at outlet and total efficiency due to the
difference in setup and measurement between wind tunnel results and numerical simulated
results. The airfoil bladed fan has a higher gauge total pressure at the outlet with less power
required for rotation of the fan. Since airfoil blades have a lower level of vorticity than the
blunt bladed fan, there are fewer vortices in the flow field around an airfoil bladed fan. The
blunt bladed fan has a slightly higher gauge total pressure than the airfoil bladed fan for the
corresponding volume flow rate. However, the total efficiency of the airfoil bladed fan is
higher than that of blunt bladed fan due to a lower power requirement. Blunt bladed fan can
achieve a higher maximum total efficiency than the airfoil bladed fan. The experimental result
is obtained by running the ventilation fan at a certain rpm. The Fan Law is then applied to
calculate the corresponding gauge static pressure at the outlet. The gauge dynamic pressure is
calculated by using empirical formulae. This gauge dynamic pressure is then added to the
gauge static pressure to obtain the gauge total pressure. Hence, the experimental result is
based on the assumption of the applicability of the Fan Law and the formula for the
calculation of gauge dynamic pressure. Moreover, the experimental result is obtained in a
wind tunnel test, which is different from the flow simulation setup. This could explain why
there is a difference between experimental and flow simulation result and this matter needs to
W.K. Ng and M. Damodaran
be addressed in the future. Further work on the numerical simulation of the airfoil bladed fan
is being done to address the discrepancies with the experimental data by refining the grids.
The blade shape design optimisation and fan performance optimisation program will be
developed on top of this simulation program using the notions of reduced order modelling
techniques for design.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This work is partially funded by Kruger Ventilation Industries, Singapore, which also
provided inputs on their fan design geometries and experimental data for this work.
REFERENCES
[1] B. Lakshminarayana, Fluid Dynamics and Heat Transfer of Turbomachinery , Wiley &
Sons, 1996.
[2] R. Elder, A. Tourlidakis and M. Yates, Advances of CFD in Fluid Machinery Design ,
Wiley & Sons, 2003.
[3] J. H. Horlock and J. D. Denton, A Review of Some Early Design Practice Using CFD
and a Current Perspective , Journal of Turbomachinery, Vol 127, Issue 1, pp 5-13, Jan 2005.
[4] Kruger Ventilation Industries Official Website, 2006, Singapore, URL Source Link:
http://www.krugerfan.com/centri_bdb.php
[5] Fluent Inc. (2003). Fluent 6.1 User s Guide. Centarra Resource Park, Lebanon, USA
[6] UGS Global HQ(2003), Parasolid 11.o User s Guide, 5800 Granite Parkway, Suite 600,
Plano, TX 75024, USA.
[7] Fluent Inc. (2003). Gambit 2.1 Modelling Guide. Centarra Resource Park, Lebanon, USA.
[8] M. Roth & R. Peikert: Flow Visualization for Turbomachinery Design, Swiss Center for
Scientific Computing, Switzerland.
[9] M. Casey (2004): Thematic Area 6: Best Practice Advice for Turbomachinery Internal
Flows. QNET-CFD Network Newsletter Volume 2, No.4, Switzerland, July 2004.
[10] F. P. Bleier: Fan Handbook: Selection, Application, and Design. McGraw-Hill, 1998