28 Perennially Frozen Peatlands in the Western Arctic and Subarctic of Canada S. C. ZOLTA1' AND C. TARNOCAl2 Northern Forest Research Centre, Canadian Forestry Service, Department of the Environment, 5320-122 St., Edmonton, Alberta T6H 3S5 Received May 24, 1974 Revision accepted for publication August 19, 1974 Perennially frozen peatlands were divided into five morphological types: peat plateaus, polygonal peat plateaus, palsas, fen ridges and lowland polygons. One hundred and eight different peatlands were cored, measured and sampled. The internal structure of all but the lowland polygons suggests that the peat was deposited in wet fens unaffected by permafrost, and that permafrost developed only after a thin layer of Sphagnum covered them. The lowland polygons evolved in a permafrost environment. The study area was divided into four regions on the basis of predominance of different peatlands forms. Les tourbieres perpetuellement gelees ont ete divisees en cinq types morphologiques: les plateaux a tourbe, les plateaux polygonaux a tourbe, les palsas, les crétes marecageuses et les polygones de basse terre. Cent huit tourbieres differentes ont ete forties, mesurees et echantillonnees. La structure interne de toutes, sauf celle du polygone de basse terre, suggere que la tourbe a ete deposee dans un marais humide non affecte par le pergelisol, et que le pergelisol s'est developpe seulement apres qu'une mince couche de tourbe a Sphagnum les ait recourvert. Le polygone de basse terre s'est forme dans un environnement de pergelisol. L'aire etudie a ete divi see en quatre region en s'appuyant sur la predominance des differentes formes de tourbiere. [Traduit par le Journal] Introduction Permafrost occurs in all arctic areas of Canada (Brown 1967). South of this continuous permafrost zone unfrozen areas may be found in the dominantly frozen landscape; this zone was termed by Brown (1967) as widespread permafrost in a discontinuous permafrost zone. Still farther south, the permafrost bodies become less prevalent. At the southern fringe of permafrost, isolated permafrost lenses may be found in the localized permafrost zone (Zoltai 1971). Here permafrost is found only in peatlands. Farther north the incidence of permafrost in peatlands increases and some mineral soils may also be perennially frozen. In the widespread permafrost zone most unfrozen areas occur in wet depressions in peatlands, but in the continuous permafrost zone all lands are perennially frozen. Thus, while the most southerly incidence of permafrost is in peatlands, much of the unfrozen spots in the north are also in peatlands. Permafrost profoundly alters the characteristics of the peatlands by elevating them above the water table of the lowlands (Brown 1970). The previously water-saturated surface layers become 'Canadian Forestry Service, Edmonton Alta. T6H 3S5 'Canadian Soil Survey, Winnipeg, Man. R3T 2N2 Can. J. Earth Sci., 12, 28-43(1975) drained, allowing an entirely different vegetation to grow on them. The internal drainage of water through a lowland may be blocked by frozen lenses, altering the drainage pattern of the peatland. The mechanical characteristics of the peat are completely changed from its unfrozen state. But permafrost is a temperature condition which may not be permanent: changes in the environment may and do induce melting. The frozen peatlands are therefore dynamic systems which tend to reach an equilibrium in a given environmental setting. A thorough understanding of the natural system permits the predicting the effect of disturbances and minimizing unwanted consequences. In this paper the morphology and dynamics of perennially frozen peatlands are presented, based on field work during three summers. The main peatland types are described and their occurrence is related to a climatic zonation. Description of Study Area The study area lies north of 60°N latitude and extends between 118°W longitude and the Alaskan boundary (Fig. 1). Most of it is in the widespread, but discontinuous, permafrost zone (Brown 1967), with the most northern portion in the continuous permafrost zone, and the most CAN. J. EARTH SCI. VOL. 12, 1975 30 southern portion in the southern fringe of the permafrost area. The southern part is flanked on the west by the Mackenzie Mountains, where elevations may reach 3000 m ASL. The Richardson Mountains, with peaks up to 2000 m, form the boundary between Yukon and Northwest Territories in the northwest. The British Mountains have peaks up to 1750 m in the northern Yukon. The rest of the area is gently rolling, with local lowlands. These lowlands, lying east of the mountain ranges, were glaciated by the Laurentide glaciers during the Wisconsin stage (Hughes 1972). The mountains remained unglaciated, but glaciolacustrine basins were formed in the largest valleys of the unglaciated areas by meltwater from the Laurentide ice sheet. The climate is most severe in the north with an annual average temperature of — 10.7°C at Tuktoyaktuk and very low total annual precipitation (130 mm). The mean annual temperature becomes warmer southward with — 6.3°C at Norman Wells and — 3.8°C at Fort Simpson in the southern part. Precipitation also increases, reaching 311 mm at Fort Good Hope and 345 mm at Fort Simpson. The average number of days per year with frost is the greatest in the north (272 days at Tuktoyaktuk), decreasing to 239 days at Norman Wells and to 226 days at Fort Simpson (Burns 1973). Vegetation reflects the climate. Treeless tundra occurs on the coastal strip nearly as far south as Inuvik (Rowe 1959) and in the mountainous areas. Below the tree line open, stunted spruce forests with abundant ground lichen are prevalent. Southward from Norman Wells local broadleaved and mixedwood forests, typical of the boreal forest zones, appear with increasing frequency. At Fort Simpson boreal forests dominate, but subarctic spruce-lichen woodlands still occur on local highlands. ' Methods A total of 108 different peatlands were examined during a helicopter supported survey in June, July and August of 1971, 1972 and 1973. At each location one to four holes were cored until the mineral soil was reached, using a modified Hoffer probe (Brown 1965), which had an inside diameter of 22 mm. Samples of measured volume were taken at 10 to 20 cm intervals. A preliminary determination of the peat constituents and degree of decomposition was made, using the determination of rubbed fibre content developed by the National Soil Survey Committee of Canada (1970). A level transect was run along a relevant portion of the peatland between bore locations, using the water table in the nearby fen as datum. The elevation and thickness of the active layer was determined at 1 m intervals along the transect. The vegetation on various segments of the peatlands was recorded. In the laboratory the moisture content of the samples was determined by weighing the samples before and after drying at 80°C. The moisture content was expressed on a weight and volume basis by converting the volume of water into ice volume by using a factor of 0.917 for the density of ice (Pounder 1965). The plant remains were again examined for comparison with the field determination. Results Peat Types and Environments The dominant peatlands in the area are bogs and fens. Bogs are saturated with water nearly to the surface, but the water is not influenced by the mineralized groundwater of the surrounding area, resulting in a highly acid surface. Bogs are frequently covered by Sphagnum moss (Zoltai et a!. 1973). Fens develop in areas having restricted drainage that nevertheless have a slow internal water movement by seepage. The water is influenced by the mineral terrain and is slightly acid to slightly alkaline (Zoltai et al. 1973). Each of these peatlands have several forms in response to local drainage, nutrient and permafrost conditions, and hence support different vegetation associations. Changing environmental conditions in the past induced changes in the vegetation, the peatlands therefore consist of sequences of distinctive peat materials according to the environment at the time of deposition. Peat materials can be grouped into broad types, according to their floristic composition. Each material type has a corresponding vegetation association in the present environment, permitting an extrapolation of some environmental conditions from the peat material. The peat material types listed below were identified in 1300 samples. They occur in slightly- to moderately-decomposed states (fibric to mesic peat). The peat types are described briefly below and summarized in Table 1. ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS 29 138 136 134° 132 130° 128 /-70° • i CONTINUOUS t 6 ° 9 PERMAFROST ZONE r 68 0 / • ti P E EL / r R 41110 11 ..• IC 1 36 o"--,.......... \T` ) 67° • FG ) /* 134' 0 Fen ridges P olygonal peal •• af t • 1 • •• I. L. -,)-7..,_ 132' LEGEND cf) l 3o° / / 66 SC0 Nr/N,,_, W1 ° Esp R , 4,„ 'ulds I N Wells Op IONS" PER, -,AERosr • 12g°- 7 65 to o 1 plateau Peat plateau L Palsy 0 1 so 1 Low Center polygons 26° -7 •--T64 High tenter polygons R adiocarbon date. this paper AIL w, Radio carbon dote. other sources Town L 0 100 _ 0 63 • km ,ERA, blsco„, ' FRO ' INtio us ' S r sourN,,2c)NE t RN FR, NGE 124 r 62 • n." • 0- "pm. ,I& r 61 la I 0 60 78° Ft•Liard I — 2 2° 7200 F IG. 1. Location of peatlands sampled in the study area. Permafrost zones from Brown (1967). 32 CAN. J. EARTH SCI. VOL. 12, 1975 TABLE 2. Summary of peatland types and average thickness of peat in the study area No. of No. of bore peatlands holes Peat plateaus Polygonal peat plateaus Palsas (Regions II, III) Palsas (Region IV) Fen ridges Lowland polygons High center Low center Thickness of peat (cm) Ave. Max. Min. 49 12 18 10 5 83 34 31 12 7 217 218 267 355 246 371 365 442 646 381 84 90 140 225 165 8 6 11 18 155 66 282 210 130 25 calyculata (L.) Moench, Kalmia polifolia Wang.) and Betula glandulosa Michx. Tree remains (Picea mariana (Mill.) B.S.P. or Larix laricina (Du Roi) K. Koch) are rare. 3. Forest Peat This material develops on slightly betterdrained bogs under black spruce with the dominant peat formers being ericaceous shrubs, feather mosses and lichens. The forest peat is usually moderately decomposed (mesic), has a very dark brown to dark reddish-brown matrix, has an amorphous to very fine-fibered structure and may have a somewhat layered macrostructure. The subtypes of forest peat were separated based on the dominance of the plant material. Woody-Forest Peat The dominant peat formers are Picea mariana, ericaceous shrubs (Ledum spp., Vaccinium vitisidea L., Empetrum nigrum L. and Larix laricina). Present environment occurs on upraised perennially frozen peatlands. Feather Moss — Forest Peat The dominant peat formers are the feather mosses (Hypnum spp., Dicranum spp., Pleurozium spp. and Hyloconium spp.) associated with locally dense black spruce forest cover. The present peatland environment is perennially frozen and raised. Associated mainly with the southern type of peatlands. 3c. Lichen — Forest Peat The dominant peat formers are lichens (Cladonia spp., Cetraria nivalis (L.) Ach.), feather mosses and ericaceous shrubs. This peat material is deposited on the surface of the mature peat plateaus and palsas. It is better decomposed than the other forest peat types because of its high lichen content. Aquatic Peat This material usually develops in shallow lakes and ponds. The peat is primarily derived from various aquatic mosses, plants and algae. The material is slightly sticky, dark brown to black in color and is usually well-decomposed (humic). Aquatic peat is usually found at the bottom of the peat deposits. Mixed Peat This material is found in collapsed areas where, due to the thawing of permafrost, the peat banks are eroding and slumping into a water saturated area. During this process the different peat layers are mixed extensively resulting in a peat deposit where two or more types are usually intermixed. Peatland Forms Frozen peatlands occur in distinctive landforms. These are peat plateaus, palsas, polygonal peat plateaus, ridges in string fens (Zoltai and Pettapiece 1973, Tarnocai 1973) and low and high center polygons (Pewe 1966). A total of 108 peatlands were examined during this study, most in the very common peat plateaus (Table 2). Peat Plateaus Peat plateaus are perennially frozen peat deposits elevated about 1 m above the lowland water table (Brown 1970; Zoltai 1971). They are generally flat, having only minor surface irregularities. They occur as small (few m 2 ) to large (several km 2 ) islands in unfrozen fens, or as thick peat deposits on very slightly sloping mineral terrain. The vegetation in an undisturbed state are scattered black spruce (Picea mariana) and lichen, with ericaceous shrubs and Sphagnum cushions in some depressions. Labrador tea 31 ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS TABLE 1. Summary of peat types and corresponding present environments Peat type and subtype Sphagnum peat la Sphagnum (recurvum) lb Sphagnum (fuscum) Fen peat 2a Brown moss 2b Sedge 2c Sedge — brown moss 2d Woody sedge — brown moss 3. Forest peat 3a Woody 3b Feather moss 3c Lichen 4. Aquatic peat 5. Mixed peat Drainage Reaction Permafrost Very poor Imperfect to poor Acid Acid Absent Present in Regions I, II, III* Frequently absent in Region IV Very poor Circumneutral Poor Circumneutral Very poor Circumneutral Poor Circumneutral Imperfect Imperfect Imperfect Very poor Poor Acid to neutral Acid to neutral Acid Circumneutral Acid Absent in Regions II, III, IV Present in Region I Absent in Regions II, III, IV Present in Region I Absent in Regions II, III, IV Present in Region I Absent in Regions II, III, IV Present in Region I Present Present Present Absent Absent *See Fig. 11 for peatland regions. I. Sphagnum Peat This type of peat material develops on very wet to wet bogs with the dominant peat former being the Sphagnum spp. Sphagnum peat is usually undecomposed (fibric), light yellowishbrown to very pale brown in color and loose and spongy in consistency with the entire Sphagnum plant being readily identifiable. In the north somewhat decomposed (mesic) Sphagnum peat also occurs, characterized by darker colors. Two subtypes of Sphagnum peat (recurvum and fuscum) were separated based on the dominant species and the peat environment. la. Sphagnum (recurvum) Peat Sphagnum growing submerged in acid water in pure colonies, consisting of Sphagnum recurvum P.—Beauv., S. squarrosum Crome, S. cuspidatum Ehrh., etc. No permafrost. lb. Sphagnum (fuscum) Peat Sphagnum growing in moist to wet acid peat, .. associated with scattered ericaceous shrubs consisting of cushion-forming Sphagnum species, as S..fuscum (Schimp.) Klinggr. and S. rubellum Wils. Occurs on areas with or without permafrost. 2. Fen Peat This material develops on very wet fens with the dominant peat formers being Carex sp., Drepanocladus sp. and tamarack. Fen peat is usually moderately well-decomposed (mesic to humic), dark brown to very dark brown, and the fibers are fine to medium with a horizontally matted or layered structure. The subtypes of fen peat were separated based on the dominance of the plant material. Brown Moss – Fen Peat Vegetation grows submerged in peaty ponds of slightly acid to slightly alkaline reaction. No permafrost, except in far north. Composed of dark colored mosses of the Genera Drepanocla- dus, Calliergon, Aulacomnium. Sedge – FCI1 Peat Vegetation grows in water saturated peat where there is some influx of mineralized water, the pH being neutral. No permafrost, except in far north. Vegetation consists of Carex and some Eriophorum species. Sedge-Brown Moss – Fen Peat Vegetation grows in water saturated peat and in shallow ponds of slightly acid to slightly alkaline reaction, influenced by some influx of mineralized water. No permafrost, except in the far north. Vegetation is composed of Carex spp. and the mosses in Type 2a above. Woody Sedge-Brown Moss – Fen Peat Vegetation grows in water-saturated peat which is acid or slightly acid. No permafrost, except in far north. Vegetation consists of brown mosses (see above), Carex spp., ericaceous shrubs (Andromeda polifolia L., Chamaedaphne 33 ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS Marginal I d—Peat plateau — MES IC SEDGE PEAT MES IC WOODY SEDGE PEAT FIBR IC SPHAGNUM PEAT ME S IC SPHAGNUM PEAT FIBRIC FOREST PEAT FIBR IC BROWN MOSS PEAT HU M IC PEAT ka/ Nriy.7/ ,• MESIC BROWN MOSS PEAT AQUATIC PEAT .6,1Wagla, FIBR IC SEDGE FIBRIC SEDGE MOSS PEAT MINERAL SOIL MES IC SEDGE MOSS PEAT ICE ORGANIC-MINERAL MIXTURE PEAT FIG. 2. Edge of peat plateau, showing marginal ridge of frozen peat with aggrading permafrost. Location: 66'46' N. Lat. 13344' W. Long. (Ledum palustre L. ssp. groenlandicuni (Oeder) Hult.) dominates recently-burned peat plateaus. Morphological variations include peat plateaus with marginal ridges (Fig. 2) and peat plateaus with collapsing edges (Fig. 3). The ridges always occur parallel to the shore of a pond or very wet fen. Similarly, the edges collapse into very wet fens, and are marked by dead tress and a luxuriant growth of Sphagnum growing submerged in water. The internal structure of peat plateaus is generally consistent: a cap of somewhat decomposed Sphagnum or forest peat always overlies the main peat deposit (Figs. 2, 3). The bulk of the peat deposit is brown-moss or moss-sedge mixture, often with shrub remains or with aquatic peat near the base. Of the 38 peat plateaus examined north of Norman Wells only two varied significantly from this sequence by being composed mainly of Sphagnum peat. In the south, however, Sphagnum peat is the dominant material of many peat plateaus. Minor variations are common in all peat plateaus, and layers of different materials or similar materials in different states of decomposition may occur. Such variations may reflect dynamic changes and short term invasions by vegetation induced by peat accumulation, changes in water table levels, etc. observable in the living wetland communities. The average thickness of peat, measured in 49 different peat plateaus, is 217 cm (Table 2). Ice accumulations in the peat are rare, although thin (up to 20 cm) ice lenses may be encountered. Thicker ice layers are often present at the peat—mineral interface. Polygonal Peat Plateaus Polygonal peat plateaus resemble peat plateaus, as they are elevated about 1 m above the neighboring fens and lack any surface relief. They are, however, criss-crossed by trenches which form a polygonal pattern when viewed from above (Zoltai and Pettapiece 1973; 34 CAN. J. EARTH SCI. VOL. 12, 1975 L— Peat plateau CLADONIA Collapse scar SPHAGNUM ice wedges; apparently changes in hydrology or climate caused the permafrost to thaw. These wetlands, although still displaying a polygonal pattern, are not polygonal peat plateaus. The internal structure of the polygonal peat plateaus is similar to peat plateaus. The basal deposits are usually a woody sedge or aquatic peat, followed by brown moss or brown mosssedge peat. The top layer is composed of Sphagnum remains (Fig. 4), unlike the peat plateaus where forest peat is common. At two of the 12 locations, however, Sphagnum was the dominant material. The total thickness of peat, based on observations at 12 different sites, is 218 cm (Table 2). Palsas m I n, FIG. 3. Peat plateau with collapsing edge. Note thin, seasonally-frozen peat in wet depression. See Fig. 2 for legend. Location: 66"49' N Lat. 135 21' W. Long. Tarnocai 1973). The common diameter of the polygons is about 15 m. A wedge of pure ice extends under each trench downward for 2-4 m. Polygonal peat plateaus are all perennially frozen, with the permafrost extending into the mineral soil beneath the peat. They occupy level or depressed areas with occasional small depressions in which wet sedge or Sphagnum grows. The peat in these depressions is not frozen, but permafrost may occur at greater depths in the mineral soil. The average thickness of the peat is 218 cm, based on the examination of 12 different areas (Table 2, Fig. 1). The vegetation is mainly a thick carpet of lichens (mainly of the Genus Cladonia, Cetraria and Alectoria), with only a few scattered and stunted black spruce. The surface morphology of the polygonal peat plateaus is dominated by polygon trenches and the adjacent mound. The center of the polygon is level or slightly concave. The bedding of peat deposits is disturbed near the ice wedge; the bedding planes appear to curve upward as they approach the ice. In a narrow belt near Arctic Red River, polygonal pattern was noted in shrubby, wet fens. Probing failed to locate either permafrost or the Palsas are mounds of peat having a permafrost core. They rise 1 to 7 m above the surrounding wet peatland (Forsgren 1968), and have a diameter of less than 100 m (SjOrs 1961). In the study area their diameter varied between 10 and 30 m, and the greatest height observed was 475 cm above the water table of the neighboring fen. They invariably occur as islands or peninsulas in very wet fens or ponds. The undisturbed vegetation is similar to that of the peat plateaus: scattered black spruce with abundant fruticose lichen and some ericaceous shrubs. The average thickness of the peat in the north, based on the examination of 18 different palsas is 267 cm. In the south, the peat is thicker, the average thickness in 10 palsas being 355 cm (Table 2). Layers or lenses of pure ice are sometimes encountered, but they are generally less than 35 cm thick. Nearly pure ice is often found at the organic—mineral soil interface and thick (up to 1 m) pure ice layers are common in the underlying mineral soil. The sequence of peat sediments in palsas is ,„, Peat plateau — Flo. 4. Cross section of a polygonal peat plateau. See Fig. 2 for legend. Location: 6719' N. Lat. 133°40' W. Long. ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS 35 FIG. 5. Cross section of a palsa. Note thin seasonally-frozen peat layer at the base of palsa, found at the time of survey. See Fig. 2 for legend. Location: 67'06' N. Lat. 134'17' W. Long. similar to that in the peat plateaus. The basal deposits, above a thin mixed organic-mineral layer, are brown moss fen peat, often with sedges and with shrubby wood remains. They are capped by a thin (usually less than 50 cm) Sphagnum or forest peat layer (Fig. 5). The mineral soil underlying the palsas is always fine grained, being silt or silt and clay mixtures. Fen Ridges Many fens have a series of narrow, low, sinuous ridges that stretch across the fen at right angles to the direction of drainage (SjOrs 1963). The string ridges are slightly elevated above the fen (up to 25 cm) and are therefore somewhat better-drained, allowing shrub and even tree vegetation to grow on them. Thus while the vegetation of the fen is sedge and brown mosses, the ridges support shrubs such as dwarf birch (Betula glandulosa) and trees such as black spruce (Picea inariana) and tamarack (Larix laricina). North of the central portion of the study area permafrost lenses are found in some ridges, often at the nodes where several ridges meet. Further north permafrost becomes more frequent in the strings, and it extends into the underlying mineral soil. This is accompanied by a broadening of the ridges, until all that remains is a peat plateau with some oriented, oval hollows, the remnants of interridge depressions. The fen ridges with permafrost are similar to peat plateaus and support the same vegetation. Some ridges have only a thin permafrost lens (Fig. 6) and may be developing to a stage where the permafrost extends into the mineral soil, as observed on the wider, better-developed ridges. The peat sequence is to that of peat plateaus, including the surface cap of Sphagnum or forest peat. The average thickness of peat in ridges with permafrost extending into the mineral soil is 246 cm, based on data at five sites (Table 2). Lowland Polygons Polygonal terrain occurring in the lowlands of the tundra regions shows two basic types: poly- 36 CAN. J. EARTH SCI. VOL. 12, 1975 cunt er shoulder MSEDSGSE-1 O trench SPHAo ,4,, center shoulder BEN OGE-MOSS 1m lm F IG. 7. Cross section of polygon trough of a low center polygon. See Fig. 2 for legend. Location: 68°58' N. Lat. 133"48' W. Long. High center-1 lm F IG. 6. Cross section of a fen ridge. Note thin seasonally-frozen peat layer in wet fen. See Fig. 2 for legend. Location: 6655' N. Lat. 133'00' W. Long. gons with either low or high centers (Pewe 1966). The middle of the low center polygons is very wet, with standing shallow water during most of the thawed season. The central part of high center polygons is domed and is therefore relatively well-drained. The polygon trenches have similar vegetation in both types, dominantly Sphagnum spp. with some Labrador tea (Ledum palustre L. ssp. decumbens (Ait.) Hult.). The central part of low centre polygons supports sedge and submerged moss growth, while the centers of high centre polygons are often bare, or have some wind-trained dwarf birch, with scattered ground lichens. The morphology of a low center polygon resembles a bowl where the ridges pushed up by the ice wedge formed under the trough form a rim, creating a small pond (Fig. 7). Peat development is thin, averaging only 66 cm at six sites. Some Sphagnum peat overlies the sedge peat in trenches and on the shoulders, but sedge and sedge-moss peat is dominant in the center. Permafrost is found under the entire unit, even under the shallow central pool. The high center polygons form a dome, rising from the polygon trenches (Fig. 8). The diameter of the polygons varies, but averages about 8 m. The depth of peat is greater than in the low center polygons, the average depth at eight sites being 155 cm. The surface materials in the central part are usually too humified to permit identification. The main peat deposit is composed of sedge, brown moss and woody shrub remains. BgpE_ BIRCH :!*lt;;Nili;Z.• lm High L. Polygon center trench RE-BIRCH 4.Z••• F IG. 8. Cross section of a high center polygon. See Fig. 2 for legend. Location: 69°56' N. Lat. 131°18' W.. Long. In many low and high center polygons the peat is underlain by a thick layer of organic and mineral soil mixture. Almost half of the low center polygons examined showed such a layer with an average thickness of 44 cm and a range of between 22 and 88 cm. In the high center polygons, more than half showed the presence of this layer, having an average thickness of 152 cm, varying between 34 cm and 256 cm. Observations of lowland polygons exposed by shore erosion showed a pronounced mixing of organic and mineral materials in the lower half of the deposits. In addition, bedding planes usually curve up to the ice wedges, with smears and tongues of organic or mineral material intruding into the adjacent strata (Fig. 9). Moisture Content The moisture (ice) content of perennially frozen peat was determined on both a volume and a weight basis. Moisture content, when expressed as percentage of weight, shows a great deal of fluctuation (200 to 40 000%), and mean values include a wide spread of values for each peat type. Some fluctuations are caused by contamination by dust, volcanic ash and mineral ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS 37 Im DOMINANTLY MINERAL SOIL DOMINANTLY ORGANIC MATERI AL ICE FIG. 9. Cross section of wave-eroded polygons, showing contorted mineral soil near the ice wedges. Location: 69°23' N. Lat. 133°20' W. Long. soil particles. When expressed on a volume basis, these fluctuations disappear and the data show that most perennially frozen peat has a moisture content between 80 and 90%, with some as high as 98%. These values are the same as the moisture content of unfrozen peat in the study area. The moisture content of various peatlands shows little variation. The moisture content of a marginal ridge of a peat plateau (Fig. 10a, No. 1) differs little from the moisture content of the plateau interior 10 m away (Fig. 10a, No. 2). A layer of clear ice occurring in a palsa (Fig. 10b, No. 3) is the only significant difference from the associated peat plateau 20 m away (Fig. 10b, No. 4). Likewise the moisture content of a polygonal peat plateau (Fig. 10c, No. 6) and a high center polygon (Fig. 10c, No. 5) is similar, except for some thin ice layers in the polygonal peat plateau. The moisture content of the underlying mineral soil is difficult to determine because ice occurs in seams and layers of various thickness along with disseminated ice crystals. Distorted moisture data are obtained if the samples are small, and only averaged figures are obtained if the samples are large. In general, coarser textured soils had lower moisture content (50-60% by volume) than the fine-grained silt loams to clays (50-90%). Active Layer The maximum thickness of the active layer, the surface layer above the permafrost which thaws during the summer and refreezes in winter, can be determined only after the thermal season has ended. The timing of the study was not suitable for the direct measurement of the maximal active layer. It is felt, however, that by late summer (mid-August) the peat is sufficiently dry to insulate the permafrost, preventing any significant melting, and that late summer observations would approximate the maximum extent of the active layer. The maximum development of the active layer in peatlands by midsummer is remarkably uniform through the area. In the south, near Fort Simpson, it is about 50 cm, decreasing to 45 cm near Norman Wells, and further decreasing to 40 cm in the latitude of Ft. McPherson and to 38 cm near Tuktoyaktuk. In the north, the active layer in wet low center polygons is about 50 cm at this time. The active layer is not completely uniform in all areas and local variations as much as 20% were noted. These can be related to exposure (steep peat banks), topography (narrow ridges), or drainage (small, wet depressions; desiccation cracks). Age The "C age of eight peat deposits was determined by the radiocarbon laboratory of Brock University by analyzing peat samples from the base of the peat deposits (Table 3, BGS 159, 144, 140 and 149). At four of these locations the peat deposits were underlain by lacustrine materials containing or covering organic materials; this age was also determined (Table 3, BGS 139, 143, 142 and 148). At two locations peat samples were taken for age determination from immediately beneath the surface (3040 cm) of high center polygons (Table 3, BGS 196 and 216) and from the base of the peat deposits (Table 3, BGS 197 and 217). At one additional location a sample was taken from the base of a fibric Sphagnum layer at 55 cm below the surface of a polygonal peat plateau (Table 38 CAN. J. EARTH SCI. VOL. 12, 1975 MOISTURE BY VOLUME (9b) 100 80 90 80 90 100 60 70 80 90 100 Ind LEGEND 7117771 PERMAFROST TABLE xrcr MINERAL SOIL FIG. 10. Volumetric moisture content of various peatlands: (a) Peat plateau: 1—marginal ridge; 2—near center, (b) Palsa and peat plateau complex: 3—palsa; 4—peat plateau, (c) 5—high center polygon; 6—polygonal peat plateau. 3, BGS 147). A date was obtained from the top of a Sphagnum layer on a peat plateau, immediately below a forest peat layer (Table 3, BGS 218). Discussion Peatland Development Similarities in the internal structure of peat plateaus, polygonal peat plateaus, palsas and fen ridges indicate that their development followed the same pattern. Reconstructing the environment from the deposits suggests three general avenues of peatland development. One had a shallow pond in the initial stage, as shown by basal deposits of organic detritus, marl or gastropods. These deposits were followed by aquatic moss and sedge communities, still showing the influence of mineralized water (Korpijaakko et al. 1972). Shrub remains are enclosed in this peat, especially near the surface. The peat deposits are capped by Sphagnum peat, showing a transition to an elevated bog condition which was no longer in contact with mineralized water. A second developmental sequence is similar, but the basal aquatic peat is lacking. There may be a thin mixed organic—mineral layer at the base, followed by brown moss-sedge deposits with or without woody shrub remains. In some instances there is a shrubby layer at the base, followed by sedge-moss deposits. These sequences suggest gradual peat build-up in a poorly drained basin, where the water table was always at the surface and there was some influx of water relatively rich in cations. Tree remains are scarce, but are occasionally present. Near the top of the sequence there is an abrupt change to Sphagnum or forest peat, suggesting an elevation of the surface above the water table and the invasion of trees. A third sequence shows thick Sphagnum deposits resting on either detrital aquatic or on moss-sedge peat. This sequence is rarely encountered in the north and may be local. The 39 ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS TABLE 3. Radiocarbon age of basal organic and peat deposits Location 67°16' & 135°14' Peat plateau 65°59' & 135°03' Peat plateau 66°10' & 134°18' 67°41' & 132°05' 66°13' & 130°52' Peat plateau Polygonal peat plateau 69°15' & 138°02' Peat plateau High center polygon 69°07' & 132°56' High center polygon 61°50' & 122°13' 68°04' & 139°50' 65°50' & 129°05' 65°15' & 126°42' 69°30' & 135°47' Age (yrs.) Peatland type section Peat plateau Basal peat Basal organic Basal peat Basal organc Basal peat Basal organic Surface peat Basal peat Basal organic Basal peat Surface peat Basal peat Surface peat Basal peat Surface peat Basal peat Basal peat Basal peat Basal peat equivalent communities are found near collapsing edges of peat plateaus in small basins, which are completely enclosed by the peat plateau and have no connection to the regional water table. Forest peat, with tree and shrub remains, is often found at the surface. An identical sequence of thick Sphagnum peat is common in the southern third of the area. It appears that the Sphagnum peatlands can remain free of permafrost more readily in the south than farther north, allowing the accumulation of Sphagnum peat. Whatever the initial sequence of peat formation is, all were deposited in a permafrost-free environment. Sphagnum peat near the surface signals a significant change in the vegetation, which included the development of an insulating peat layer and the growth of trees. A similar sequence is found at the southern fringe of permafrost (Zoltai 1972) where the importance of tree cover in intercepting snow, thereby enhancing permafrost development, was evident (Zoltai and Tarnocai 1971). The encroachment of permafrost under the somewhat better-drained fen ridge illustrates this dynamic process (Fig. 6). Initially, the ridges in patterned fens do not contain permafrost (Zoltai 1971). In the study area, however, permafrost is often established under them, because they are slightly better drained than the inter-ridge areas, providing a suitable habitat 8190 9960 10 470 14 410 5910 10 820 2710 7200 8610 5600 8260 10 100 3150 6020 2650 6430 6120 3960 4140 ± 60 ± 80 ± 80 + 110 ± 60 ± 80 ± 60 ± 60 ± 100 ± 70 ± 110 ± 130 ± 90 ± 100 ± 80 ± 140 ± 120 ± 50 ± 140 Lab no. BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS BGS GSC I 159 139 144 143 140 142 147 149 148 146 196 197 216 217 218 372 3735 GSC 513 Source This report 77 99 91 If 11 99 77 79 99 91 77 77 99 99 51 77 99 99 99 59 97 99 • 77 Dyck et al. 1966 Mackay et al. 1973 Korpijaakko et al. 1972 Lowdon et al. 1971 for cushion-forming Sphagnum mosses and scattered trees. The decreased snow cover on the Sphagnum cushions and the presence of insulating moss allows the seasonal frost to persist during the summer, and hence to become permafrost. Once initiated, permafrost will form rapidly as the ridge is further elevated by the expansion caused by the freezing of the water in the peat. Evidences of permafrost being established in unfrozen peatlands are abundant. In countless cases thin layers of permafrost were found under small Sphagnum cushions, often with a single small tree, on wet, permafrost-free fens. These eventually become small peat plateaus which may merge to become large peat plateaus. In the northern half of the main study area marginal ridges around ponds or wet fens are common. These marginal ridges are interpreted as belts which were recently affected by permafrost. These ridges sometimes produce a striking concentric ring around small ponds that were filled in by peat and became affected by permafrost (Zoltai and Pettapiece 1973). The edges of many peat plateaus are collapsing, as shown by submerged, dead trees where the peat slumped into the fen and by the luxuriant growth of Sphagnum recurvum in the acid waters at the collapsing face. It is not clear what initiates the thawing. Perhaps a tree uprooted by wind, a deep desiccation crack, or a fire may cause local melting which may spread 40 CAN. J. EARTH SCI. VOL. 12, 1975 along the edge of the peat plateau. Although collapsing edges occur throughout the forested part of the area, they are far more common in the southern half of the area than in the north. Sphagnum (recurvum) peat is restricted to collapse scars in the present environment. The occasional occurrence of such peat in now perrennially frozen peat plateaus indicates a collapse and re-establishment of peat plateaus. Additional indication of such collapse cycles comes from the presence of thin (50 cm) beds of Sphagnum (fuscum) peat in some peat plateaus, overlain by fen peat and finally capped by more Sphagnum (fuscum) peat. Such Sphagnum beds are associated with permafrost in the present environment. Such evidences point to cyclic development and collapse of peat plateaus and palsas; indeed, in some instances the emergence of small peat plateaus from collapse scars within large peat plateaus was observed. The internal structure of lowland polygons suggest that many were deposited in a permafrost environment. Excessive mixing of organic and mineral soils is a common phenomenon under arctic conditions (Zoltai and Pettapiece 1973). Thus mixing and the presence of tongues of different materials at the organic—mineral soil interface suggest soil movements that are common in the active layer above the permafrost table. Permafrost now underlies all components of the lowland polygons, and all observations suggest that this condition occurred while the polygons were developing. High center polygons have been regarded as frost-free conditions. The bedding planes in the peat are often contorted near the ice wedges, showing that the ice wedges developed after the peat was laid down. The floristic composition of the peat is similar to that of peat plateaus, with brown moss, sedge and the occasional thick Sphagnum deposits. Thus both the floristic composition and internal structure suggest that these peatlands first developed in a permafrostfree environment, later became elevated into peat plateaus and then ice wedges developed in them. Moisture Content Palsas, peat plateaus and polygonal peat plateaus are all elevated above the level of the nearby fens. The thickness of peat is nearly the same. With the exception of palsas where segregated ice layers may occur, the moisture content of the frozen peat is about the same as the unfrozen peat, hence the elevation is due neither to thicker peat deposits nor to ice accumulation in the peat. Ice accumulation, however, is significant in many palsas. The moisture content of the underlying frozen mineral soil is far greater than in unfrozen, water-saturated mineral soil. The moisture content of silty clay under unfrozen fens averages 45% by volume, but in the frozen state it frequently reaches 80 to 9070 . Additional moisture accumulates in the frozen mineral soil which would account for most of the elevation of the frozen peatlands. This vaulting of the peatlands is best illustrated in palsas which in this area always occur as small islands or peninsulas in very wet fens or ponds. Unfrozen water is available along most or all of the perimeter and water migrates into the frozen mass due to a thermal gradient (Hoekstra 1966), as was found in a study farther south (Zoltai and Tarnocai 1971). The pronounced marginal ridges around wet fens and ponds may be due to the same process. In most peat plateaus, however, the perimeter of the frozen—unfrozen interface is low in proportion to the mass of the peat plateau, hence water an eroding, melting phase where the ice wedges are inactive (Price 1972). However, the consistently greater thickness of peat in high-center polygons suggests that peat formation contributes to the different surface morphology. In the field a complete range of low-center polygons to high-center polygons was observed, with the polygon shoulders becoming thicker and the enclosed pools smaller as the peat accumulates, until the surface becomes level (Fig. 9). The development of a domed center, characteristic of penetration is low. Collapsing margins will the high-center polygons, may be due to partial negate any marginal ice accumulations. Thus melting of the ice wedge during a senescent stage little or no height increment takes place after the (Price 1972). In some instances, near lakeshores initial development. or lips of plateaus, the polygon trenches may be overdeepened by running water (Pewe 1966). Age of Peat Deposits The radiocarbon ages of basal organic deIn polygonal peat plateaus no basal mixing of organic and mineral soil was observed, indi- posits (Table 3) show that the continental glacier cating that the peat was deposited under perma- had melted from the areas east of the mountains ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS 41 ARCTIC OCEAN /400 138° 1360 REGION I — Dominant peatlands: lowland polygons REGION II — Dominant peatlands: polygonal peat plateaus REGION III— Dominant peotionds, peat plateaus, palsas REGION IV— Dominant peatlands: peat plateaus, palsas, bogs, fens, collapse scors FIG. 11. Peatland regions of the Mackenzie River valley. and initial organic material accumulation began between 14 400 and 10 000 years ago. The main peat build-up began one to several thousand years later, mainly between 10 500 and 5600 radiocarbon years ago. Regional trends are difficult to discern, as local circumstances such as basin formation, erosion, base drainage, etc. played a dominant role in permitting the peat accumulation. Generally, the oldest basal peat deposits occur near the mountains and the ages tend to be younger eastward. The ages of the surface peat 2710 and 2650 years before present (BGS 147, 218), indicate the time of establishment of Sphagnum cap at those sites, followed by permafrost development. The period around 3500 years B.P. and 2400 years B.P. were times of climatic deterioration in northern Canada (Nichols 1969), and the dates 2710 and 2650 years B.P. are probably related to these fluctuating climatic conditions. The meager data permit only speculation on the chronosequence of regional peatland development. Apparently, peatland development began soon after the melting of the continental glaciers and peat accumulation proceeded at a rapid rate especially beginning about 8000 years ago. Permafrost was present, but it was less widespread both in the north and in the south than at the present. A minor cooling some 3000 to 4000 years ago produced an increase in peat plateaus, restricting peat accumulation to unfrozen fens. Polygonal peat plateaus probably CAN. J. EARTH SCI. VOL. 12, 1975 42 developed at this time. Peatlands in the tundra were continuously subject to permafrost after the melting of continental glaciers. In the more southern parts of Canada the melting of continental glaciers was followed by a dry and warm period, permitting only restricted peat accumulation between 7500 and 6000 years ago (Terasmae 1972). This was followed by a wetter and then a cooler period when rapid peat accumulation took place. In the north, however, the climate was favourable for peat accumulation during the warm period (8000 to 4000 years ago), but peat formation was reduced during the cooler period beginning about 4000 years ago. Such shifting of regions of peat accumulation in accordance to climatic changes occurs throughout the peatland regions of Canada (Terasmae 1972). Peatland Regions Field observations show that different perennially-frozen peatlands occur in different broad regions, and these regions can be characterized by the commonly occurring peatland forms. The western Arctic and Subarctic of Canada were divided into four broad regions (Fig. 11) on the basis of the present survey. These regions are aligned in broad east—west trending belts, suggesting a latitudinal temperature gradient. The regions can be briefly characterized as follows: Region dominated by lowland polygons, whether in low center, high center or intermediate forms. Other peatlands are rare; these include thin sedge fens. Region dominated by polygonal peat plateaus. Other peatland forms include peat plateaus, associated frozen or unfrozen bog pools and patterned fens. Outliers of polygonal peat plateaus occur farther south in exposed or mountainous areas. Region dominated by peat plateaus and palsas, with few collapse edges. Other peatlands include associated unfrozen fens, bog pools, polygonal peat plateaus, as well as patterned and unpatterned fens. Region dominated by peat plateaus and palsas, with frequent collapse edges. Large proportion of unfrozen peatlands occur; these include associated fens, bog pools and collapse scars, as well as patterned and nonpatterned fens and flat bogs. Conclusions (1) Peat landforms, having developed under the influence of permafrost are distinctive and can be readily characterized within the study area. The distribution of various perennially frozen peatlands is similar within peatland regions and follow a climatic zonation. The internal structure of perennially frozen peatlands suggests that most peat was deposited in nonpermafrost environment, and permafrost development followed the establishment of a Sphagnum cap at a later date. The peat in lowland polygons accumulated under permafrost conditions. The internal structure and surface morphology of some peat plateaus suggest that they underwent at least one cycle of collapse and reconstruction. (6) The main period of peat accumulation occurred between 8000 and 4000 years ago, and many peat plateaus were affected by permafrost for the first time about 3000-4000 years ago. Acknowledgments The data for this report were obtained as a result of investigations carried out under the Environmental—Social Program, Northern Pipelines, of the Task Force on Northern Oil Development, Government of Canada. The cooperation and logistics support by the Geological Survey of Canada, especially Drs. 0. L. Hughes and N. W. Rutter, are gratefully acknowledged. J. E. 1965. Permafrost investigations in Saskatchewan and Manitoba. Nat. Res. Counc., Div. Build. Res., Ottawa, Tech. Pap. 193. 36 p. 1967. Permafrost in Canada. Geol. Surv. Can., Map 1246A. 1970. Occurrence of permafrost in Canadian peatlands. Proc. 3rd. Int. Peat Congr. Quebec, Canada, 1968. pp. 174-181. BURNS, B. M. 1973. The climate of the Mackenzie Valley — Beaufort Sea. Vol. I, Environ. Canada, Atmos. Environ., Climatol. Studies No. 24, p. 227. DUCK, W., LOWDON, J. A., FYLES, J. G., and BLAKE, W. JR. 1966. Geological Survey of Canada radiocarbon dates V. Radiocarbon, 8, pp. 96-127. FORSGREN, B. 1968. Studies of palsas in Finland, Norway and Sweden, 1964-1966. Biul. Peryglac., 17, pp. 117-123. HOEKSTRA, P. 1966. Moisture movements in soils under temperature gradients with the cold-side temperature below freezing. Water Resour. Res., 2, pp. 241-250. HUGHES, 0. L. 1972. Surficial geology of northern Yukon Territory and northwestern District of Mackenzie, Northwest Territories. Geol. Surv. Can., Pap. 69-36, 11 p. KORPIJAAKKO, M., KORPIJAAKKO, M. L., and RADFORTH, N. W. 1972. Ice-biotic relationship in frozen peat. BROWN, R. ZOLTAI AND TARNOCAI: FROZEN PEATLANDS • 4 Proc. 14th Muskeg Res. Conf. 1971. Nat. Res. Counc., Assoc. Comm. Geotech. Res., Tech. Mem. No. 102, pp. 111-120. LOWDON, J. A., ROBERTSON, I. M., and BLAKE, W. JR. 1971. Geological Survey of Canada radiocarbon dates XI. Radiocarbon, 13, pp. 255-324. MACKAY, J. R. and MATHEWS, W. H. 1973. Geomorphology and Quaternary history of the Mackenzie River valley near Fort Good Hope, N.W.T., Canada. Can. J. Earth Sci., 10, pp. 26-41. NATIONAL SOIL SURVEY COMMITTEE OF CANADA. 1970. The system of soil classification for Canada. Can. Dep. Agric., Ottawa. 249 p. NICHOLS, H. 1%7. Pollen diagrams from sub-arctic central Canada. Science, 155, pp. 1665-1668. 1969. Chronology of peat growth in Canada. Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclimatol., Palaeoecol., 6, pp. 61-65. Ptwt, T. L. 1966. Ice wedges in Alaska—classification, distribution, and climatic significance. Proc. Permafr. Int. Conf., Lafayette, 1963. Nat. Acad. Sci., Nat. Res. Counc., Publ. 1287, pp. 76-81. POUNDER, E. R. 1965. The physics of ice. Pergamon Press, Oxford. PRICE, L. W. 1972. The periglacial environment, permafrost, and man. Assoc. Am. Geogr., Comm. College Geogr., Res. Pap. No. 14, 88 p. ROWE, J.S. 1959. Forest Regions of Canada. Can. Dep. North. Aff. Nat. Res., For. Br., Bull. 123, 71 p. 43 SJORs, H. 1961. Forest and peatland at Hawley Lake, northern Ontario. Nat. Mus. Can., Bull. 171, pp. 1-31. 1963. Bogs and fens on Attawapiskat River, north ern Ontario. Nat. Mus. Can., Bull. 186, pp. 45-133. TARNOCAI, C. 1973. Soils of the Mackenzie River area. Envir. Soc. Comm., North. Pipelines, Task Force on North. Oil Dev., Govt. Canada. Rep. 73-26, 136 p. TERASMAE, J. 1972. Muskeg as a climate-controlled ecosystem. Proc. 14th Muskeg Res. Conf., Kingston, 1971. Nat. Res. Counc., Tech. Memo. No. 102, pp. 147-158. ZOLTAI, S. C. 1971. Southern limit of permafrost features in peat landforms, Manitoba and Saskatchewan. Geol. Assoc. Can., Spec. Pap. No. 9, pp. 305-310. 1972. Palsas and peat plateaus in central Manitoba and Saskatchewan. Can. J. For. Res., 2, pp. 291-302. ZOLTAI, S. C. and TARNOCAI, C. 1971. Properties of a wooded palsa in Northern Manitoba. Arctic Alpine Res., 3, pp. 115-129. ZOLTAI, S. C. and PETTAPIECE, W. W. 1973. Terrain, vegetation and permafrost relationships in the northern part of the Mackenzie Valley and northern Yukon. Envir. Soc. Comm., North. Pipelines, Task Force on North. Oil Dev., Rep. No. 73-74, 105 p. ZOLTAI, S. C., POLLETT, F. C., JEGLUM, J. K. and ADAMS, G. D. 1973. Developing a wetland classification for Canada. 4th North American For. Soils Conf., 1973, Quebec, 20 p.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz