Water usage from a long-term perspective

Water usage from a long-term perspective:
dependence on natural water has decoupled in Spain.
Jessie Heemskerk, 2014
This dissertation is submitted as part of a MSc degree in
Water: Science and Governance at King’s College London
Student card number [1332884]
KING’S COLLEGE LONDON
UNIVERSITY OF LONDON
DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY
MSc DISSERTATION
I, Jessie Heemskerk hereby declare (a) that this Dissertation is my own original work and
that all source material used is acknowledged therein; (b) that it has been specially prepared
for a degree of the University of London; and (c) that it does not contain any material that has
been or will be submitted to the Examiners of this or any other university, or any material that
has been or will be submitted for any other examination.
This Dissertation is 9393 words.
Signed: ...................................................................
Date: 12 September 2014........................................
II
Abstract
Spain is the most arid country in Europe. Coupled with a strong growth in the demand of
natural water, Spain’s economic and social security is impeded by local water scarcity. This
research provides a long-term analysis of total water consumption, which is defined as the
sum of virtual water flows, desalination, reuse and natural water abstraction. The purpose of
the study is to identify the political processes and regulations associated with Spain’s
engagement with its increasing demand for water. The study shows that there has been a
strong increase in virtual water usage, which decoupled Spain’s growth in water needs from
its abstraction of water from the natural environment. Regional natural water deficits were
resolved via increasing reclamation of wastewater and desalination. It is shown that the
decoupling model of Gilmont applies to Spain; the country experienced the same generic
processes as other semi-arid political economies
Keywords: Decoupling, Spain, Virtual Water
III
List of Contents
Abstract .................................................................................................................................................III
List of Tables.......................................................................................................................................... V
List of Figures........................................................................................................................................ V
List of Abbreviations............................................................................................................................. VI
Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................................. VII
1. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 1
2. Literature Review .............................................................................................................................. 4
2.1 Natural Resource Decoupling ....................................................................................................... 5
2.2 Methodologies for quantifying water use ...................................................................................... 7
3. Methodological Approaches ............................................................................................................. 9
3.1 Natural Water Decoupling ............................................................................................................ 9
3.2 Calculating Virtual Water Decoupling ....................................................................................... 11
3.2 Data Collection and Limitations ................................................................................................. 13
4. Spain as a case study for decoupling.............................................................................................. 16
4.1 Decoupling water usage in Spain ............................................................................................... 17
4.2 Virtual water decoupling ............................................................................................................ 21
4.3 Natural Water Decoupling .......................................................................................................... 25
4.3.1. Desalination ............................................................................................................................ 25
5. Conclusions ...................................................................................................................................... 30
Appendix I: Ethics Screening Form and Risk Assessment Form ................................................... 32
Appendix II: Virtual Water Flow Calculation ................................................................................. 34
Appendix III: Green and Blue Water in Spain................................................................................. 36
Appendix IV: Natural Water Usage 1980-2010 ................................................................................ 37
List of References ................................................................................................................................ 38
IV
List of Tables
Table 1: Comparison of different sources of virtual water flows
22
List of Figures
Figure 1: The intersection of Natural Water Decoupling in the literature
4
Figure 2: UNEP’s perspective of Resource and Impact Decoupling
6
Figure 3: Conceptual model of natural water decoupling
9
Figure 4: Average Annual Run-Off per Basin
16
Figure 5: The Decoupling of Natural Water in Spain
17
Figure 6a: Virtual water flows of crops and animal products
23
Figure 6b: Virtual water flows of crop products
24
Figure 6c: Virtual water flows of animal products
24
Figure 7a: Long-term analysis of volumes of desalination
25
Figure 7b: Desalinated Water per sector 1985 to 2006.
26
Figure 8: Trends of volumes of reclaimed wastewater
29
V
List of Abbreviations
AQUA
Water Policy of 2004 (Gestión y la Utilización del Agua)
CAP
Common Agricultural Policy
CEDEX
Spanish Ministry of the Environment and Rural and Marine
CV
Vapour Compression
EEC
European Economic Community
ED
Electro-Dialysis
EU
European Union
GDP
Gross Domestic Product
MAMRM
Spanish Ministry of Agriculture
Mm3
Million cubic metre
MSF
Multi-Stage Flash
NVW
Net Virtual Water Flows
OECD
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
OEEC
Organisation for European Economic Co-operation
OI
Reverse Osmosis
SNHP
National Hydrological Plan
UNEP
United Nations Environment Programme
VWE
Virtual Water ‘Exports’
VWI
Virtual Water ‘Imports’
WBCSD
World Business Council for Sustainable Development
WFE
External Water Footprint
VI
Acknowledgements
I would like to express my special thanks to Professor Tony Allan and Dr. Michael Gilmont
for their generous guidance, patience and on-going encouragement. I would like to thank
Professor Alberto Garrido for sharing his vast knowledge on Spanish water policy. I thank dr.
Elena López-Gunn for the kind visit and all the great advice she gave me on finding the right
literature. To dr. Ashok Chapagain, for explaining how to calculate the Water Footprint and
showing me where I could find the right data. I also thank my colleagues, for their peerreview and constructive criticism. My parents, Pepijn, and friends for their support in all
forms and shapes.
VII
Water usage from a long-term perspective:
dependence on natural water has decoupled in Spain.
1. Introduction
This dissertation will analyse the extent to which the trend in natural water usage has been
decoupled from the trend in total water consumption in Spain for the period 1960 to the
present. The decoupling framework is a long-term analysis of the total water consumption.
This approach can be used to understand how political paradigms and regulations emerge to
cope with challenges - such as those of Spain concerning its increasing demand for water.
Two main forms of decoupling have been identified in other semi-arid political economies.
The first is ‘virtual water decoupling’, where the pressure on internal water resources is
reduced through ‘importing’ water embedded in goods and commodities. The second is
‘natural water decoupling’, in which the total water supply is increased through reclaimed
wastewater and desalination (Gilmont, 2014). Having an understanding of how water
consumption patterns relate to economic growth and water scarcity is vital as it enables
society to intervene on the basis of evidence to develop effective management policies
(Rijsberman, 2006).
The attention of conventional water planning is on blue water; also referred to as
natural water in this dissertation. Blue water is water in surface flows (streams, rivers),
surface storage (aquifers, lakes, dams), and in non-saline inland seas (Allan, 2001). However,
the principal water consuming activity of humans is agricultural production, which depends
largely on green water. Green water is precipitation that is stored as moisture in the
unsaturated zone or temporarily stays on top of vegetation. A share of the precipitation does
not run off or recharges the groundwater, but is stored in the soil as moisture or temporarily
stays on top of the plant canopy or soil. Eventually, green water is evaporated or transpires
through plants. Thus, green water resource is the “evaporation and transpiration consumptive
water usage of biomass”, and is moisture in the unsaturated zone (Falkenmark and
Rockström, 2006, p.129). Green water cannot be re-allocated, whereas blue water can also be
used for industrial or urban consumption. Blue water can easily get overexploited, which has
negative impact on the environment (Yang et al., 2007). Therefore, both green and blue water
consumption patterns in Spain are examined.
1
Over the past century, global water consumption has expanded quickly: during the
twentieth century water usage increased six fold, whereas the world population only tripled
(Andelman and Pauker, 2009). The current demand has created a situation in which water
scarcity exists locally: 1.2 billion people are lacking access to safe and affordable water.
Globally groundwater levels are dropping, and basins are becoming increasingly polluted
(Gleick et al., 2006; Cosgrove and Rijsberman, 2000). The future of this trend is not clear.
However, the world population is growing, diets are changing, and it is probable that rapid
urbanisation and industrialisation will continue. Nonetheless, multiple renowned studies see
an increasing water scarcity as one of the major risks for our future (World Economic Forum,
2014; McKinsey, 2009). For example, to eradicate hunger by 2030 an extra water requirement
of 4,200 km3/year is necessary. If this volume is accounted for by irrigation only, this would
lead to a doubling of the blue water abstraction causing high levels of depletion of rivers and
aquatic ecosystems (Falkenmark and Rockström, 2006)
A limited supply of natural water, coupled with a strong growth in demand, restricts
human capacity to grow and develop (Duarte et al. 2014a). Water is a pivotal resource for
many aspects of human prosperity: energy and industrial production, agriculture and human
health are all dependent on the availability of water (UNEP, 2012). Traditionally, economic
growth or the capacity of an economy to produce goods and services is coupled to an
increased usage of natural resources. However, about 25% less material input was needed to
produce one unit of real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in 2002 compared to 1980 (UNEP,
2012). This relationship between economic and resource growth illustrates the power of
decoupling. It demonstrates the opportunity for growth to occur without a corresponding
increase in pressure on natural resources
Gleick (2002) has argued that the connection between water and economic growth can
also be decoupled. In the United States, the blue water abstraction rose ten fold between 1900
and 1980, whereas the GDP rose by a factor of 20. However, by 1995 the levels of blue water
consumption dropped significantly and were back at the level of 1975. Some of this decrease
can be explained by technological developments. For example, steel production consumed
about 250 tonnes of water per tonne steel during the 1930s, whereas today’s production plants
usage levels dropped to 3.5 tonnes of water per tonne steel (Gleick, 2002).
2
Using the framework of Gilmont (2014), this dissertation will research the extent of
decoupling between the trend of natural water usage from the trend of total water
consumption in Spain. Spain is chosen as a case study because of its specific climatic
conditions: it is one of the most arid countries of the European Union, and faces water
problems in many of its regions (Garrido and Llamas, 2010). No other study has yet applied
the decoupling framework to Spain, which makes this research original. In addition, Spain is
a relatively data rich country with multiple detailed data sources available on water
abstraction facilitating analysis. The timeframe of the analysis is constrained by data
availability, and spans the period from the 1960s to the present.
In this study the following questions will be addressed: (i) what are the preferred
methods for quantifying natural water decoupling, and can they be effectively deployed?; (ii)
has virtual water and natural water decoupling occurred in Spain?; and (iii) are the trends in
water usage in Spain linked to changes in its political economy? The structure of this study is
as follows: Chapter Two provides a literature review, and places the framework of decoupling
in the wider context of resource decoupling research and studies on water scarcity. Chapter
Three presents and critiques the methods and data used. Chapter Four discusses the results of
the analysis and reviews them. Chapter Five provides concluding comments.
3
2. Literature Review
This chapter will provide hydrological, technological, and political economy contexts by
placing natural water decoupling within the broader literature. The decoupling method as
used in this dissertation operates at the interface of two different fields (see Figure 1). On the
one hand, there is a growing literature on resource decoupling, especially of international
strategic public policy documents. On the other hand, natural water decoupling builds upon
methodologies for quantifying water usage, such as the water footprint analysis. In the
following order, this chapter will address natural resource decoupling literature, then
methodologies for quantifying water usage. The last part will discuss the relevance of natural
resource decoupling. Gilmont’s (2014) model enriches the literature as it creates
understanding of how political paradigms are connected to differentiations in a country’s total
water consumption over time.
Figure 1: The intersection of Natural Water Decoupling in the literature. Source: Own
elaboration.
4
2.1 Natural Resource Decoupling
Natural Resource Decoupling is an analytical approach that identifies the quantity of resource
inputs - such as water and minerals - into productive activities such as food production,
manufacturing, and service provision. It analyses the extent to which economic development,
environmental degradation, and resource depletion are connected, and how this link can be
broken (European Environment Agency, 2012). Since 2000, the term ‘natural resource
decoupling’ has gained currency, and has been used in studies of international strategic public
policy. It is an integral part of the Europe 2020 environmental goals (European Environment
Agency, 2012), the UNEP Green Economy Initiative (Fischer-Kowalski et al., 2011) and the
OECD environmental Strategy for the First Decade of the 21st Century (OECD, 2001).
The European Environment Agency (2012) for example, defined this concept as
breaking the link between ‘environmental bads’ and ‘economic goods.’ This definition clearly
shows the underlying normative belief: the optimum is to increase economic growth while
lowering environmental depletion. Logically, the ontological presumptions of decoupling are
(a) that there is a connection between resource usage and economic growth and (b) that it is
its pursuit to break, understand, or alter this connection. The literature based on these
ontological presumptions is growing, and Gilmont’s (2014) model shares this line of
reasoning.
The idea of disconnecting resource usage from economic growth is not a new notion,
according to UNEP (2011) it started to develop during the early 1990s. Concepts like
decoupling can be identified under the terminology of eco-efficiency in reports of the World
Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD) and the EU’s Lisbon Strategy for
Growth and Jobs (Fischer-Kowalski et al., 2011). Next to these international strategic public
policy documents, the academic literature on specific resources has also evolved. There is
extensive literature on how economic growth has modified or is related to natural resources.
The main focus is the linkage between energy consumption and Gross Domestic Product
(GDP) (Stern, 2011; Kander and Lindmark, 2004; Mielnika and Goldemberg, 2002; Jorgsen
and Clarck, 2012). In addition, a well-developed research area is carbon dioxide emission
(Zhang, 2000 and Lu et al., 2007).
5
UNEP (2011) has completed a comprehensive work on resource decoupling, where
decoupling is defined as: “using less resources per unit of economic output and reducing the
environmental impact of any resources that are used or economic activities that are
undertaken (Fischer-Kowalski, 2011, p. xiii).”
Figure 2 displays all the essential elements identified by UNEP. However, this
approach is not fully applicable to water resources. Impact decoupling is hard to measure for
water, as water is too dynamic. For example, the environmental impact of water usage can be
transferred via virtual water and recycling (Gilmont, 2014). Next to this, an important
problem occurs when taking GDP as an indicator of economic growth. In the most classical
form, GDP is determined by the output of the factors of production of land, natural resources,
labour, and capital. In our current economy, water resources only play a minor contribution to
the formation of the GDP. For example, the agricultural sector uses all the green water and
most of the blue water, while it pays the lowest price (Allan, 1999). Therefore GDP cannot be
seen as a proxy for economic growth within the decoupling model.
Figure 2: UNEP’s perspective of Resource and Impact Decoupling.
Source: Fischer-Kowalski et al., 2011, p xiii.
6
2.2 Methodologies for quantifying water use
Water as a resource is very dynamic, it has large temporal, spatial, and quality variances, and
this impacts its value to people and the ecosystem (Rijsberman, 2006). To take Central India
as an example: during the monsoon period between June and September there is abundance of
water that can have devastating consequences such as floods. On the same location, during the
summer period, which is between March and May, a drought may occur of a magnitude that
can ruin entire crop productions. These peaks are not always represented in data such as the
annual water availability. Therefore, other methods are needed to display the reality of water
shortage or abundance (Rijsberman, 2006). Over the past thirty years many different methods
are developed to measure water usage and to determine if it is under stress (Brown and
Matlock, 2011). But how exactly can water scarcity be defined? This concept is contested.
Currently, there is no consensus in the literature on how to define water scarcity (White,
2012). For the purpose of this dissertation the UN definition will be used:
The point at which the aggregate impact of all users impinges on the supply or quality
of water under prevailing institutional arrangements to the extent that the demand by
all sectors, including the environment, cannot be satisfied fully (Cosgrove and
Cosgrove, 2012).
One of the earlier and widely used works to measure water stress is the ‘Falkenmark
Indicator,’ also known as the ‘Water Scarcity Index’ (Falkenmark, 1989). It categorises per
capita usage from ‘no stress’ (> 1,700 m3) to ‘absolute scarcity’ (<500 m3) based upon
national annual averages. Even though this method is still used by the media, its validity is
questioned in academic literature questions as it does not account for variation in human
demand due to different lifestyle, nor does the national annual averages account for seasonal
differences (White, 2012).
Shiklomanov (1991 and 1993) was the first to separate water abstraction into
agricultural, industrial, and domestic sectors. This division gives a good insight in the
differences in quantities, as roughly 70% of the freshwater withdrawals are for agricultural
usage (Brown and Matlock, 2011). Over time many different water resource vulnerability
indices have been developed, of which the model of Vörösmarty et al.,(2005) and Sullivan et
al., water poverty index (2003) can be considered as highly impactful (UNEP, 2012 and
Rijsberman, 2006). Strengths of the indices named above are that they have incorporated
ecological sustainability and geospatial and climate data into their models. However, these
7
approaches do not show the changes over time, but only provide a snapshot of the state of the
water bodies in that point of time.
2.3 Natural Water Decoupling
Little research has focussed on water consumption from a long-term perspective. For Spain
Garrido et al. (2010) researched the virtual water flows for the period between 1997 and 2005.
Recently, Duarte et al. published a series of works which all performed a long-term analysis.
They analysed the water footprint of Spanish agriculture between 1860 and 2010 and Spanish
virtual water trade between 1849 and 1935 (Duarte et al. 2014b; 2014c). Smith et al. (2011),
Gleick (2002) and Gilmont (2014) conceptualised the decoupling for water resources. Smith
et al. (2011) examined the practical benefits of decoupling economic growth from freshwater
extraction. Gleick (2012) analysed the link between the total water withdrawals and GDP for
the United States. Gilmont (2014) developed a framework, and applied it to the case study
Israel, making a distinction between decoupling of the rate of water usage from the rate of
economic growth and decoupling of the rate of natural water consumption from the total use
of natural water available to an economy. An added value of decoupling opposed to the
theories described above is that it gives insight in consumption patterns over time. It creates
understanding of the usage patterns that have caused scarcity and it incorporates the
dependence on virtual water imports (Gilmont, 2014).
8
3. Methodological Approaches
3.1 Natural Water Decoupling
Figure 3 displays the conceptual of model of water decoupling (Gilmont, 2014). The premise
is that semi-arid political economies experience a similar sequence of resource-usage and
political paradigms. Allan (2001) developed the five paradigm descriptive model. In the premodern phase water resources are not regulated centrally and used locally. The hydraulic
mission is the start of a centralised management of water. Engineers govern water and
hydraulic works are developed based on the idea that engineering mobilisation of water
benefits economic growth. The practice of this paradigm is characterised by large hydraulic
projects and environmental problems are not a concern. This perspective changes when
environmental degradation becomes evident; a need to react is the main characteristic of the
environmental paradigm. The economic, environmental, and political paradigms are
intertwined. Within these approaches, the common factor is to aim for optimum allocation
and integrated management. Multiple stakeholders govern water usage, and policies are not
merely designed by engineers. Strategies in the reflexive modernity paradigm seek to balance
between social, economic, and environmental concerns (Allan 2001 and Gilmont 2012).
Figure 3: Displays a conceptual model of natural water decoupling.
Source: Adjusted from Gilmont (2014).
9
The Natural Water Supply forms the baseline of the analysis. Natural Water is freshwater
derived from surface and groundwater and is divided into usage per sector (domestic,
industrial and agricultural). It is extracted from environmental sources of surface and
groundwater and it is measured in terms of the annual gross amount extracted (Gilmont,
2014). According to UNEP (2012, p20) abstraction means that the water is unavailable for
reuse in the same basin or irretrievable, for instance through evapotranspiration or
contamination. Which is true in most instances, though, return flows are not always accounted
for.
As argued in the introduction, population and economic growth involve an increasing
requirement of water. In a semi-arid country there comes a time when the local water sources
will not be able to meet the demand, the financial and environmental costs will be to high to
abstract more water. When a country stops policies targeting food self-sufficiency and starts
importing virtual water via crops and products, Virtual Water Decoupling occurs. This is
measured with the ‘Water Footprint’ method of Hoekstra and Chapagain (2008), which is
described in section 3.1.
Natural Water Decoupling is the process of increasing the real water available by
treatment of water that is by nature not suitable for consumption by humans or for agricultural
usage and is origins from a new source. In the case of Israel and Spain this new water comes
from reclaimed wastewater and desalination (Gilmont, 2014). Reclaimed wastewater is in
Spain defined as “water that has undergone the wastewater treatment process or a process set
out in the corresponding effluent disposal permits to attain the quality to its final intended
purpose” (Royal Decree 1620, 2007 p2). Desalination is in essence a process whereby
seawater and brackish water is converted into a usable water resource, this can be preformed
via different techniques as such as reverse osmosis (AEDYR, 2014). Natural Water
Decoupling enlarges the Total Water Supply, it can either elevate environmental pressures if
the blue water resources are over exploited or meet to growing demand for water.
The line Total Water Consumption in figure 3 represents the cumulative natural water
supply, reclaimed wastewater, desalinated water and net virtual water ‘flows’. This represents
the total volume of water consumed in a country at a certain period in time.
10
3.2 Calculating Virtual Water Decoupling
Tony Allan introduced the term ‘virtual water’ in 1993 as the volume of water required to
produce commodities, goods, and services (Allan 1998 and 1999). International trade
transfers commodities between countries. While there is often no physical movement of
water, virtual water is re-allocated by trade flows. Virtual water trade can benefit countries to
save resources domestically, and creates a global comparative advantage as water is unequally
distributed over space and time (Garrido et al., 2010).
Closely linked to virtual water is the water footprint. This concept is developed by
Hoekstra in 2002, and is defined as “total volume of freshwater that is used to produce the
goods and services consumed by the individual or the community (Hoekstra and Chapagain,
2004, p8.).” The water footprint enables us to understand the true volumes consumed by a
person, business, or country as it looks at both the direct, and indirect water used. A large
share of the products we consume are produced in other countries. These products require
water. Therefore, natural water abstraction alone does not show the total water consumption
levels. With the water footprint one can understand how high the real water consumption is.
By this, one can assess if a country is dependent on other countries’ water resources in their
total water consumption (Hoekstra et al., 2012). Hence, this method is an important tool to
understand the total water consumption.
Mekonnen and Hoekstra (2011a and 2011b) published the water footprint coefficient
for nearly all crop and animal products, based upon averages for the period 1996-2005. Every
water footprint coefficient consists out of three different ‘colours’; these are green, blue and
grey water. The ‘colours’ represent that various water components have different
characteristics. As shortly discussed in the introduction, green water is water in the biosphere.
For the green water coefficients of the water footprint, green water is measured as: “the
volume of rainwater that is evaporated during the production process (Hoekstra and
Chapagain, 2008, p.20).” Blue water coefficients represent “the volume of surface or
groundwater that evaporated as a result of its production (Hoekstra and Chapagain, 2008,
p.20).” The third ‘colour’ of water is grey, which “is the amount of water needed to dilute
pollutants” (Hoekstra and Chapagain, 2008, p.20). As this research focuses on quantity, grey
water is not relevant and will not be assessed further and only green and blue water are
analysed.
This research builds on the approach of Hoekstra et al. (2012), and uses the methods
presented in the water footprint assessment manual to measure the ‘net virtual water flows’ of
11
Spain. The water footprint of consumption can be calculated with a top-down or bottomapproach. The top-down approach is used by this research as this gives a direct connection
with water agriculture and trade policies. In the top-down approach estimates are based upon
country averages. Water used to produce imports in the producing country are subtracted by
the water used for producing export commodities (Hoekstra et al., 2012). This in contrast to
the bottom-up approach, in which all goods and services consumed by a countries inhabitants
are multiplied by their water needs at the site of production (Garrido et al., 2010).
There are two ways to look at the volume of water consumed outside the country; (a)
the ‘external water footprint’ (WFE, m3/year), and (b)‘net virtual-water flows’ (NVW,
m3/year). The external water footprint evaluates the volume of water resources used in other
countries by measuring the difference between virtual water ‘imports’ (VW I) and virtual
water ‘re-exports’ (VWRE).
(3.1)
VWRE is hard to measure in Spain, as virtual water is imported in the form of crops and ‘reexported’ in the form of livestock. In addition, the data on other re-export is also not
available. Therefore, the NVW is used to analyse virtual water decoupling in the main model.
This is the difference between virtual-water ‘imports’ (VWI) and virtual water ‘exports’
(VWE)
(3.2)
The VWI is calculated as:
[
]
(3.3)
“In which Ti [Ne,p] represents the imported quantity of product p from exporting nation Ne
(product units/time) and WFprod [Ne,p] the water footprint of product p as in the exporting
nation Ne (volume/product unit) (Hoekstra et al., 2012, p57)”
The VWE is calculated as:
(3.4)
“In which Te[p] represent the quantity of product p exported from the nation (in our case
Spain) and WFprod[p] the average water footprint of the exported product p (volume/product
unit) (Hoekstra et al., 2012, p57).” Annex II: Virtual Water Calculation gives access to the
data analysis done in this research and describes process and limitation in detail.
12
3.2 Data Collection and Limitations
The Natural Water Supply data originate from the OECD statistical database (2014) for the
period 1980 -2012. The OECD statistical database is comprised of a broad range of statistics
about all the OECD countries. The data is collected at national level. The Spanish abstraction
data is divided into fresh surface and fresh ground water abstraction, which is further divided
per sector usage. The abstraction figures include water removed from any source both
permanently and temporarily and include drainage and mine water. Excluded is water usage
for hydroelectric generation. Next to this seawater, brackish swamps, lagoons, and estuaries
are not considered surface water (OECD statistical database, 2014). The OECD states that the
data account for groundwater abstraction aquifer recharge. However, it is unclear whether this
refers to natural recharge or artificial recharge. Surface water abstraction includes “all water
that flows over, or rest on the surface of a landmass”. Thus artificial watercourses such as
irrigation canals, drainage systems and artificial reservoirs and rainwater collection are also
included (OECD statistical database, 2014, p.1). The data for Spain on the agricultural side
only include irrigation before 2000. In addition, the total excludes the fishing sector data.
(OECD, 2014 a, META DETA). The abstraction levels before 1980 are not as well
documented. Shiklomanov (1999) and UNESCO (1999) made assumptions on the abstraction
levels based upon different sources, which are used for the period 1960-1980. Not all authors
agree on the exact data and a distinction is made between withdrawals and consumption.
Nevertheless, Shiklomanov (1999) is currently the best available source.
Natural Water Decoupling in Spain consists of desalination and wastewater
reclamation. In 2007 the Ministry of Environment and Rural and Marine Affairs started to
regulate water reuse and to collect the data centrally. Before this data was collected by the
river basin organisations (RBOs), and only estimates could be made around that time. In 2005
a large inventory about the reuse practices was done and a management guide was developed.
Not all data is publicly available, however there is enough to discover the trends and
developments. The reuse activities are specified per region, type of regeneration, and usage.
The usage classification is divided into five; irrigation, municipal uses, recreational,
industrial, and ecological (Iglesias et al.,2008). Data originates from Iglesias (2008), Iglesias
et al. (2010) and Castro (2010). During a visit at the Spanish Ministry of the Environment and
Rural and Marine Affairs, the volumes of wastewater reclamation where discussed. The
predictions of made in 2005 for 2015 and 2021 are not very likely to be met, which will be
discussed in more detail in section 4.3.1. The data for desalination is collected via the Spanish
13
Desalination and Water Reuse Association and the International Desalination Association
(AEDYR, 2014 Alejo, 2008, Graco, 2004).
The methodology for the Virtual Water Decoupling follows Hoekstra and Chapagain
(2008). The volume of water embodied in crops and animal products is taken from Mekonnen
and Hoekstra (2011a, 2011b and 2012). The water demand for crops is quantified by blue,
green and grey water and takes the average for the period 1996-2005. The data is specified
per regions; this research used the country averages (Mekonnen and Hoekstra, 2011b). Trade
data related to crops and animals products are obtained from the international trade database
UN-Comtrade and are specified in tonnages. The UN-Comtrade database uses the SITC code
to index products. The SITC coding is also used on the PC-Tas cd, which Hoekstra and
Chapagain (2008) use in their work. A full overview of the virtual water calculation can be
found in Annex II.
The coefficients of virtual as determined by Hoekstra and Chapagain (2008) are the
average for the period 1996-2005. However, the virtual water flows are calculated up 1960. It
is a limitation of this study that the virtual water coefficients are not recalculated for the
period before 1960. Due to time and resource restrictions this was not possible. It is logical
that the virtual water content of for example a crop or animal products changes over time.
Productivity and climates have changed over time. Duarte et al. (2014b) also faced this
problem: the study analysed virtual water imports for the period 1849 up to 1935. In essence,
the virtual water coefficient is based upon evapotranspiration and yields. Duarte et al. (2014b)
adapted the coefficients according to Dalin et al. (2012) and Konar et al. (2013). The data is
unfortunately not publicly available, nor is it from the same period. Therefore, other studies
could not be used to overcome this limitation.
In the decoupling model the natural water supply data is blue water, whereas the net
virtual water flows consists out of green and blue water. This is a second limitation of this
research. There is a volume of green water used for the production of crops and animal
products in Spain that is consumed by Spanish inhabitants, which is not accounted for. Thus
the natural water supply is higher in reality, nonetheless there is no reliable detailed source to
provide these figures. Duarte et al. (2014c) did estimate the green and blue water embodied in
Spanish production between 1860 and 2008, see appendix III.
14
Water data can be ambiguous and highly politicized. In addition, abstraction always
leaves out sources of water such as illegal pumping, leakage, or free users as fire fighters and
hospitals. The data used in this research is at no point an exact reflection of the total water
consumed in Spain. Nevertheless, the goal is to create insight into macro trends and increase
the understanding how water consumption changes over time. The linkage to political
reflexivity and management is more important and the data forms an essential supporting
basis.
15
4. Spain as a case study for decoupling
In this chapter the results of the decoupling analysis of Spain are presented. First, a brief
introduction into the physical, demographical and institutional organisation of Spain is
provided to create a better understanding of the context of the decoupling analysis. Secondly,
the decoupling of natural water usage is analysed. After this, the virtual water decoupling and
natural water decoupling are examined in more depth.
Spain’s total surface area is about 506,000 km2 and the climate is characterized by
diversity. Not only in terms of landscape and vegetation, but especially the hydrological
environment encompasses large temporal and regional differences. The annual rainfall is a
good example of these differences. The national average is 684 mm per year. While on the
Canary Islands, the average rainfall is approximately 302 mm/yr. The northern regions on the
contrary, experience maximums of 2,282 mm/yr, see figure 4. The fluctuation in precipitation
volumes fluctuations in-between seasons are above European averages, the volumes of are
significantly lower than in the winter than during the summer (Garrido and Llamas, 2010).
Just as every other Western-European country, the Spanish population has risen
sturdily over the past decades. In 1960 the population was 30 million, 20 years later in 1980
the population was 38 million, during the turn of the century the population was 41 million.
Currently, Spain has nearly 47 million inhabitants (INE, 2014). The demographics are
characterised by an uneven distribution of the population. Since 1950, an internal migration
from the rural areas to the coast and industrial cities occurred. An important pull factor of the
urbanisation is the better economic conditions in this area (Gomez et al., 2008).
The country is dived into 17 autonomous communities and two autonomous cities.
With decentralised power, Spain can be seen as a quasi-federal state (Loughlin, 2008). The
organisation of the water management has a long history, and emerged as a response to the
diverse hydrological climate (De Stefano and Llamas, 2012). There are two types of river
basin organisations: river basin authorities and hydraulic administrations. The administrative
boundaries of the autonomous regions do not overlap with the hydrological basins, nor with
the agricultural regulators. This creates difficulties in the water management, which will be
addressed in more detail below.
Figure 4: Average Annual Run-Off
per Basin. Source: Adjusted from
Garrido et al., 2008
16
4.1 Decoupling water usage in Spain
Figure 5 displays the analysis of decoupling of natural water usage in Spain. The natural
water supply is the surface water and groundwater abstracted in Spain, or blue water. The
volumes of desalinated and reclaimed wastewater are shown in the total water supply. Total
water consumption illustrates the net virtual water flows, which is the difference between the
virtual -green and blue- water ‘imports’ and ‘exports’. Since 1962, Spain has demonstrated
both types of decoupling. The total water consumption and the natural water supply were
coupled between 1962-1977. The data shows rapid virtual water decoupling when Spain
transferred into a democracy. The natural water decoupling is a more graduate process that
accelerates at the turn of the century.
Figure 5: The Decoupling of Natural Water in Spain.
The total water consumption and the natural water supply where coupled between 1962-1977.
The first decoupling occurred during the transition to a democracy in 1978. The natural water
decoupling is seen to be a graduate process where the trend accelerates after 1999.
Source: Own elaboration. Data origins from different sources, more details see chapter 3.4.
Natural Water Supply: 1962-1980 Shiklomanov (1999); 1980-2012 OECD statistical database
(2014). Total Water Supply: Desalination Gasco (2004); Effluent Iglesias (2008) & Castro
(2010). Virtual Water Flows: UNCOMTRADE & Hoekstra and Mekonnen (2012).
17
The resource development as seen in figure 5 are a result of a complex political process,
especially, in arid and semiarid countries water. As Lopez-Gunn (2009, p.372) puts it
strikingly “water tends to stabilize those in power and can become a powerful symbol in
politics, as part of national and regional identities, past, present and future. Water is therefore
a prime object of appropriation for symbols and identity in relation to territory and
territoriality and is increasingly and frequently used in sub-national politics.” In the political
dimension there are four periods of time distinguished that are all characterized by there own
political economical paradigms. These are: Franco’s Hydraulic Mission (1939-1975); the
Decoupled Hydraulic Mission (1976-1984); First Reflexive Modernity (1985-1998) and True
Reflexive Modernity (1999-2013)
1939-1975 Franco’s Hydraulic Mission
At the end of the Civil War in 1939, Spain was in a sorrow state, infrastructures was heavily
damaged and resources where scarce. This is when General Francisco Franco came to rule, he
stayed in power single-handedly until his death in 1975. Which made him the longest ruling
dictator in Europe of the 20th century. Franco’s regime was based upon a statist ideology,
economic interventionism and high levels of state control and regulation. His political
ambition was to repair the damaged infrastructures and improve irrigation. The General
Public Works Plan (Plan General de Obras Publicas) of 1940 aimed to construct 1,162 dams
with a water storage capacity of 78,00 Mm3 between 1940 and 1960 (Cuadrado-Roura,
2010). This is an example of a policy that can be placed within the ‘hydraulic mission’
paradigm. The hydraulic mission in characterised by a centrally controlled vision to develop
hydraulic infrastructures (Allan, 2001).
Figure 5 shows a strong increase in the NVW ‘flows’ after 1977. This indicates high
levels of food self-sufficiency during Franco’s ruling and rapid opening of the trade economy
during the turn into democracy. However, when placing this data into a political historical
analysis it tells a different story. Franco’s autarky and policy of food-self sufficiency lasted up
to 1959. In 1957 a new ministerial chamber was assigned which concluded that the
protectionist policy was unsustainable in the changing European political landscape. Spain
became a member of the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation (OEEC) and in
1959 the stabilisation plan was approved. The stabilisation plan was a set of policies, which
opened the Spanish market for international trade, such as establishing a balance of trade
(Cuadrado-Roura, 2010). The plan was the start of a prosperous economic period with high
levels of international trade. Donge (1979) named the period between 1959-1974 “Spanish
18
economic miracle” because of the impressive economic development. The economic miracle
story does not match with the low levels of NVW ‘flows’ between 1962 and 1976. Therefore,
it is likely to assume that this part of the data is inaccurate. The discrepancies can be
explained in two ways. Either, Spain did not report the traded volumes and commodities
properly to the UN, due to the political situation. Or a mistake in the calculation was made, as
the coding system was different during this time (see annex II). Further research needs to be
done to investigate this in depth. Even though, it is plausible to assume that the real values of
traded virtual water between 1962 and 1977 are higher than the results of figure 5 show, we
cannot be certain. Therefore, this research sticks to being guided by the data and set the real
virtual water decoupling at 1978, especially because this is also when Spain became a
democratic state.
Franco strongly influenced and completely redesigned the hydraulic landscape.
According to Swyngedouw (2006) the Franco’s water policies where seen as a ‘remedy’, it
would improve the national economy, disintegration and social malaise. It was aimed to ‘regenerate’ Spain’s unevenly distrusted hydrologic environment and ‘modernize’ agricultural
production. “Hydraulic interventions and the mobilization of the country’s erratic waters were
conceived as a means to rationalize production, to serve as a wedge to permit structural land
reform, and to facilitate access to land and water for the landless peasants (Swyngedouw,
2006, p.182). The availability of water became articulated and experienced as a problem of
state ‘voluntarism’, rather than resulting from ‘natural’ scarcity. If problems of scarcity
existed, this was simply because of the incapacity of the state to perform its functions
adequately. State management of water generated a sense of unlimited potential availability.”
Dams and irrigation works where built at a fast rate. The larger waterworks where all
funded by the state. During this period, Spain experienced a rapid increase in the number of
dams; The capacity of water storage at the beginning of Franco’s regime was around 744 Hm 3
and in 1970 the accumulated reservoir capacity was as much as 22.000 Mm3 (Duarte et al.,
2014c). The national Water Plan was set up as a strategy to overcome the drought in the south
and was shaped by engineers. Environmental problems or concerns for water quality where
not on the agenda (Lopez Gomez et al.,2008)
19
Decoupled Hydraulic Mission (1976-1984)
After Franco’s decease in 1975 it took up to 1978 for Spain to form the new
democratic constitution. This process was relatively peaceful, however existing elites tried to
hold on to their power. Both the hydraulic and agricultural administration succeeded to keep
their influential positions (Swyngedouw, 2014). The hydraulic elite was formed by the Corps
of Engineers (Cuerpos) which was a closed group of men, that captured key positions within
Spanish hydraulic bureaucracies (Lopez-Gunn, 2009). The crops of engineers where founded
in 1799, and in there technocratic approach was kept up to the 90’. With key positions in the
River Basin Authorities they dominated Spanish water policy. The objective was the to
control the fields and rivers and create hydropower capacity (Lopez-Gunn, 2009). Figure 5
shows that the hydraulic mission remained unquestioned and the natural water usages
increased steadily (Garrido and Llamas, 2010).
First Reflexive Modernity (1985-1998)
In 1985 the water usage in Spain peaked at a volume of 35.750 Mm3, in the same year a new
Water Act was accepted. The following years shows a decline natural water usage. This
decline could be seen a logical result of the 1985 Water Act, legislation that succeeded in a
lowering of the natural water abstraction. However, Garrido and Llamas (2010), Swyngedouw
(2006; 2014) and (Lopez-Gunn, 2009) all argue that the hydraulic paradigm remained
unquestioned up to the early 90’. According to Garrido and Llamas (2010) the 1985 law
maintained regulations to support farmers. They continue to have cheap access to water, and
where subsided with houses, tractors and capital. The Water Act stipulated that engineers
governed water allocation and ‘the Cuerpos’ was still in power.
Nonetheless, the natural water abstraction between 1985 shows a clear decline to
1993, after which it rises, to peak again in 1999. A possible explanation for the decline in
water abstraction can also be a series of droughts in 1986, 1990 and 1993 (Downing et al.,
2002). Water problems became noticeable to many Spaniards and the attention in the public
grew (Garrido and Llamas, 2010). In 1986 Spain became a member of the EEC, the preassessor of the European Union. Together with this process the voices of environmentalist and
regionalist got stronger, and the attention for wetlands and ecosystems grew (Swyngedouw,
2006).
20
Second Reflexive Modernity (1999-2013)
The 1999 Water Framework and 2000 EU water framework directive (WFD) where the start
of a new phase during which the country embarked on a search for a new balance between the
limits of the natural water supply and the environment and the economic demands (Gomez et
al., 2008). As figure 5 shows, from that point onwards the natural water abstraction levels
decline. In 2010 the natural water abstraction was 27,244 Mm3/yr, which is around the same
level of 1994 (28,282 Mm3) and 1976 (27,500 Mm3). The main goal of the WFD is to
improve the water bodies by 2015. As member of the EU, Spain had to comply with this
regulation and improve the state of her water bodies. This externally pressured them into a
more environmentally focussed water management (Garrido and Llamas, 2010). Figure 5 also
clearly indicated a strong diversification of the total water consumption since 1999. The
virtual water decoupling and the natural water decoupling are discussed below. In appendix
III the ground and surface water abstraction are set out per sector. This shows that the
groundwater abstraction decreased stronger after 1999 than the surface water abstraction.
4.2 Virtual water decoupling
In this part the virtual water decoupling of Spain is analysed, as noted in both in chapter 3 and
section 4.1 this method has its limitations. Therefore, this part will first compare the results
presented in this research to other literature. Before, analysing the political process involved
with virtual water decoupling.
There are three main studies identified that have studied Water Footprints in Spain
(Hoekstra and Mekonnen, 2012; Garrido et al., 2010; Duarte et al. 2014c). The results and
conclusions of all three studies differ, even when, the same calculation is done. Pivotal in
science is that research is replicable and the results are the same, which is one of the reasons
why the Water Footprint method is contested (Ansink, 2010; Wilchens 2012). Nonetheless,
the Water Footprint is currently the best available method to show a countries dependence on
virtual water ‘imports’. An essential part of this research is Spain’s dependence external water
resources. Virtual water flows show how a country becomes increasingly or decreasingly
dependent on green and blue water from other countries. Likewise, virtual water ‘imports’ can
contribute to reducing the internal blue water abstraction and halt environmental degradation.
Even though, the results of the Water Footprint are not perfect, they have the merit of existing
and contribute to understanding of the macro water consumption trends.
21
Table 2 shows that the results of this research are in-between the volumes of Garrido
et al. (2010) and Hoekstra and Mekonnen (2012). Aldaya et al. (2010) explained the variance
between the results of these authors in two ways. Garrido et al. (2010) used the MIAMAR
data, while Hoekstra and Mekonnen use UN-Comtrade data (the PC-TAS CD). This research
is based upon UN-Comtrade data, just as Hoekstra and Mekonnen. Garrido et al. incorporated
regional level and climate data. This research also accounts for the origin of the product at the
import side. Therefore, it is logical that the results of this study are in between the other
studies. An added value of Hoekstra and Mekonnen’s research is that is it comparable with
other countries. While a strong asset of Garrido’s work, is the focus on regional climate
differences and the high level of detail. The virtual water trade calculations of Duarte et al.
(2014b) cover 1849-1935 and are thus not comparable to our research.
Table 2: Comparison of different sources of virtual water flows
Virtual water
‘Imports’
Crop products
(Mm3/year)
Source:
Hoekstra and
Mekonnen (2012)1
Garrido et all
(2010)2
Own elaboration3
Virtual Water
‘Imports’
Animal Products
(Mm3/year)
Green
Blue
Total
37,090
4,598
41,689
Total
24,830
Green
Blue
Total
32,403
2,369
34,772
Virtual Water
‘Exports’
Crop products
(Mm3/year)
Hoekstra and
Mekonnen (2012)1
Green
Blue
Total
Garrido et all
(2010)2
Own elaboration3
13,755
7,959
21,714
Green
Blue
Total
13,005
5561
18,566
-
Total Virtual Water
‘Exports’
(Mm3/year)
Green
Blue
Total
40,910
5,753
46,663
-
Total
31,099
3,792
263
4,054
-
Green
Blue
Total
36,195
2,632
38,827
Virtual Water
‘Exports’
Animal Products
(Mm3/year)
5,768
870
6,638
Virtual Water
‘Exports’
Industrial
products
(Mm3/year)
Green
Blue
218
Total
218
-
5,506
682
6,118
Green
Blue
Total
Green
Blue
Total
-
Green
Blue
Total
3,819
626
4,445
Virtual Water
‘Imports’
Industrial
products
(Mm3/year)
Green
Blue
529
Total
529
Green
Blue
Total
Total Virtual Water
‘Exports’
(Mm3/year)
Green
Blue
Total
19,523
9,048
28,571
-
Total
18,299
-
Green
Blue
Total
18,511
6,243
24,774
1
Hoekstra and Mekonnen (2012) Averages for the period 1996-2005. Original data also includes Grey water.
Garrido et al. (2010) Averages for the period 1997-2006
3
Averages for the period 1996-2005. Totals exclude Industrial products
2
22
Figure 6a displays the virtual water ‘flows’ of crop and animals products for the period 1962
up to 2013. In figure 6b and 6c animal and crops products are shown separately. Overtime,
there is a strong increase of both the imports and exports. Spain imports products with a larger
green to blue water ratio. While, exporting products that have a relatively large blue water
component. Net, Spain is a blue water exporter and a green water importer. Especially, the
green water imports have experienced a linear growth. Garrido et al. (2010) combined the
virtual water analysis with the economic value of the products. The green water crops that
Spain imports are of low economic value, such as cereals and grains and are mainly used as
food for animals. The crop exports typically have a high economic value, such as olives and
oranges and other citrus fruits.
Since 1962 the types of crops have changes, which influenced by the Common
Agricultural Policy (CAP) of the EU. The CAP subsides products, for Spain mainly olives,
and supports water saving techniques (Aldaya et al., 2009). Whether the growth in animal
production is caused by specific policies is hard to determine, open trade policy and
production specialization seem the most likely explanation (Garrido et al., 2012).
Figure 6a: Displays the virtual water flows of crops and animal products for the period 19622013. The imports and exports of blue and green water are stacked. The “net virtual water imports
“ line denotes the “virtual water imports” – the “virtual water exports.” Source: Own elaboration.
23
Figure 6b: Shows the virtual water flows of crops products for the period 1962-2013. Source:
Own elaboration.
Figure 6c: Shows the virtual water flows of Animal products for the period 1962-2013. The
net virtual water ‘flows’ is negative as the exports are larger than the imports. Source: Own
elaboration.
24
4.3 Natural Water Decoupling
Natural water decoupling consists out of desalination and reclaimed wastewater, which will
be discussed separately.
4.3.1. Desalination
The first water desalination plant was built in Spain in 1964 on the Island Lanzarote, and is
one of the earliest commercial plants ever built (Palomar and Losada, 2010). Ever since,
Spain has experienced a fast growth of desalination plants. Currently, the country desalinates
4,5 million m3 salt and brackish water per year, which ranks them as the top 4 desalinating
country globally (AEDYR, 2014). The largest share of the plants were built in the coastal
areas, as this is the region where there are large temporal differences in water demand due to
tourist and irrigated agricultural. While at the same time, the coastal region suffers from
overexploitation and irregular river flows (Palomar and Losada, 2010). Figure 7a displays a
progress of the volumes of desalinated water since 1964, which shows a rapid increase over
time. Figure 7b shows usage of desalinated water per sector. In Spain there are four dominant
techniques used for desalination: multi-stage flash (MSF), electro-dialysis (ED), reverse
osmosis (OI) and vapour compression (CV). Multi-stage flash and reversed osmosis are the
most used and account for around 98% of the total capacity in Spain, this is comparable with
world averages (Dickie, 2007). MSF is one of the earlier techniques for desalination. The
reversed osmosis technique is first introduced in the 80’ ever since this technique has
improved rapidly. The costs have declined due to higher membrane efficiency, which required
lower energy and chemical usage.
Figure 7a: displays the development of the capacity of desalination in Spain.
Source: Gasco, 2004.
25
Figure 7b: Volume of Desalinated Water in Spain m3/day for the period 1985 to
2006. Source: Alejo, 2008
Since the introduction of the desalination technique the Spanish government has been actively
involved with the promotion and regulation of desalination. However, the political
involvement really caught on in 1983. Gasco (2004) argues that the Spanish state support for
desalination is two sided, on the one hand the subsidies on the price of desalinated water, and
on the other hand by public investments in infrastructure and desalination plants.
In 1983 Spain set up a new policy to promote the desalination industry. Desalinated
water should cost the same as the average price of drinking water. With a subvention policy
the prices where held at an artificially low level. The exact price was determined yearly by the
General Budget Law and differs per region. Generally speaking, the more desalination plants
in a region, the price for desalinated water is higher (Garco, 2004). Since 1983 different
ministries have controlled the subsidies, since 2001 it is in the portfolio of the Ministry of the
Environment (Graco, 2004).
26
The 1985 Spanish Water Law also gave an incentive to public-investments in the desalination
industry. Part of the Water Act 29/1985 and Spanish National Hydrological Plan was an
increase in investments in hydrological infrastructures and the desalination industry in general
(Garco, 2004). This incentive can also be detected back to the data after 1985 a rapid increase
in the volume of desalination occurred, as described above.
In March 1996 a change of government lead to the halt of the implementation of a
National Hydrological plan that focussed on an increase in wastewater reuse and desalination.
Only in when 2000 Plan AGUA was developed there was a new attention for desalination by
the government (Graco, 2003)
In 2004 plan AQUA (Actuaciones para la Gestión y la Utilización del Agua) was
accepted, which stands for Actions for the Management and Use of Water. This programme
set the stage to a larger development of unconventional water sources. A total investment of
3,900 million euro will help to develop 24 different projects which includes new desalination
plants and upgrading old ones, details are set out in ‘Politica del Agua: Balance,’ released by
the MMA in December 2006. All the facilities were built near the coastline where it could
help increase the supply especially during the summer. The goal was to increase the total
supply to one million cubic meters per day by 2008 (Downward and Tailor, 2005). Currently,
private companies construct most of the desalination plants, this is especially true for plants
with lower capacities. International Spanish companies are market leaders in the field of
desalination plants (Palomar and Losada, 2010).
27
4.3.2. Reclaimed wastewater
Wastewater has been used for centuries as a source of irrigation in Spain. Because of the
Mediterranean climate and the lack of rain it has been essential during the dry period of the
year to irrigate crops. The wastewater was not treated and used raw or was diluted in river
flows and predominantly used for agricultural purposes. Up to 1970 the reuse occurred locally
and was demand driven, this can be seen as a more indirect form water re-usage (Angelakis et
al.,1999). The wastewater reclamation examined in this research focuses on a direct and
managed use of treated effluents. In Spain wastewater reclamation is defined as “water that
has undergone the wastewater treatment process or a process set out in the corresponding
effluent disposal permits to attain the quality to its final intended purpose (Royal Decree
1620/2007, 2007. Pp2).”
In 1970 the first water reuse facility was built in Spain, which was the start of a more
direct, managed and planned system of wastewater reclamation. In 1995 a decree on
wastewater reuse was drafted, which created legislation and a strategic plan for future
development of reuse facilities. Nevertheless, a change in government in 1996 paralyzed the
adoption of a National Hydrological Plan of which the wastewater reuse decree was a part
(Angelakis et al., 1999). Between 1970 and 2007 water reuse was decentralise organized and
managed by River Basin Plans and Regional Hydrological Programmes. There is no clear data
on the levels of reuse for this period of time. Graco (2004) estimated the wastewater reuse
constant at 8% of the total urban water supply.
The Spanish Ministry of the Environment and Rural and Marine Affairs, better known
under the Spanish acronym CEDEX, started to develop a wastewater strategy in 2005. Before
this, only two decree’s addressed water reuse shortly. Royal Decree 1/2001 determined that
the Government should establish the basic conditions for water reuse and Royal Decree
849/1986 that regulated the reuse in the Public Domain. The goal was to improve the
management and planning evolving around reuse and centralise and regulating the current
practices. Part of this programme was to compile data and get insight in the reuse activities in
autonomous regions, see Figure 8. Iglesias Esteban (2008) and colleagues collected data in
2005 by consulting from different River Basin Plans and Regional Reuse Programmes for the
years 2001 and 2004. This explains most likely the difference with 2006, as it would not be
logical that the amount of reused water declines. The volumes in 2015 and 2021 are
predictions made by CEDEX (Castro, 2010). In a meeting with CEDEX it was made clear
that current developments are behind schedule and the volumes in 2015 and 2021 are not
likely to met bet.
28
Figure 8: displays reclaimed wastewater in Spain. Up to 2006 volumes per sector
after 2009 total volume. Source: Iglesias, 2008 and Castro, 2010.
In December 2007 the legal framework Royal Decree (1620/2007) was accepted. This decree
sets the standards for the reuse of treated wastewater. The Royal Decree had roughly 3
purposes (a) to protect the quality of the water bodies, which is also a demand of the EU
framework. (b) To ensure and the safety of reclaimed water, and create trust among the public
in the quality of reused water. And (c) to increase the quantity of water reuse, this was to be
promoted by developing a new management tool. This management tool is called the National
Water Reuse Plan (NWRP) and also aimed to address the current problems. At the moment
stakeholders do not fully comply with the requirements of Royal Decree 1620/2007. Next to
this, there is a discharge to the sewage should be improved and a share of the water rights are
in the process of updating (Castro, 2010).
29
5. Conclusions
The purpose of this dissertation is to explore the extent to which the trend in natural water
usage has been decoupled from the trend in total water consumption, in Spain for the period
1960 to the present. This effort hopes to make a contribution to the literature, as it the first
research that applies the natural water decoupling model of Gilmont to Spain. The natural
water decoupling model provides a long-term analysis of total water consumption, which is
defined as the sum of virtual water flows, desalination, reclaimed wastewater and natural
water abstraction. This long-term analysis gives insight in how water consumption patterns
change over time. In addition, it shows how a countries dependence on virtual water evolves.
The hypothesis of natural water decoupling, based upon Allan’s (2001) five-paradigm
model, is that semi-arid economies have a comparable sequence of reflexive political
paradigms to coop with a rising demand of natural water. Earlier research has shown that the
case of Israel complies with this model; the current study reveals that it can also be applied to
Spain.
The main results from the data analysis are that Spain experienced a strong increase in
natural water abstraction up to 1985. The period after the 1985’ Water Act and up to the
1999’ Water Law Reform shows an initial drop, after which, natural water usage rises. At the
turn of the century up to the present, Spanish natural water abstraction revealed a gradual
decline. The total water consumption, on the other hand, increased significantly. Both natural
water decoupling and virtual water decoupling are achieved. This diversification of water
consumption lowered the pressure on the internal blue water resources, especially the
groundwater abstraction has dropped. Virtual Water Decoupling is rapidly introduced after
the fall of dictator Francisco Franco. Ever since, Spain increasingly imports green-water
intensive crops. While, exporting blue water intensive crops and animal products. Natural
water decoupling took ground after the 1999 Water Law Reform and the 2000 European
Water Framework directive. The plan AQUA of 2004, fully commits to the future of
desalination and water reuse. AQUA sets ambitious goals, with the aim to alleviate the
pressure on the blue water resources. Spain has successfully managed to lower national blue
water abstraction, by diverging the water consumption. An important outcome is that the
current natural water usage is at a level comparable to the mid 1970s.
30
Virtual water decoupling and natural water decoupling helped Spain meet its social
and economical demands, while improving the sustainability of the water resources of the
ecosystem. Implications of the results signify that Spain experienced a growing dependence
on virtual water imports and techniques to utilise alternatives for the natural water supply.
This dependence can be evaluated in two ways. On the one hand, virtual water imports
provide global optimal allocation of water usage, on the other hand, it can be seen as a
geopolitical risk. However, currently water is not a major factor in international trade (Yang
et al., 2007). Wastewater reclamation and desalination should also be put in perspective. Both
techniques require high amounts of energy, which cause other environmental negative
externalities, such as CO2 emissions. However, especially desalination is becoming
increasingly efficient.
The findings of this research suggest that there is a principal set of reflexive of polices
that semi-arid political economies accomplish in order allocate the growing water
consumption. An interesting opportunity for future research is expanding number of case
studies. It would be interesting to see how other semi-arid countries engage in the process of a
growing demand for natural water and how the reflexive political strategies compare.
31
Appendix I: Ethics Screening Form and Risk Assessment Form
32
33
Appendix II: Virtual Water Flow Calculation
The data from Mekonnen and Hoekstra (2011a and 2011b) provides information concerning
the average volume of water required per crop or per animal product. It is based upon
averages for the period 1996-2005. The water footprint assessment manual (aldaya et al.
2012) explains in detail how the water demand coefficients are obtained. The data online
accessible via the following link: http://www.waterfootprint.org/?page=files/WaterStatProductWaterFootprints
In this research the ‘Net Virtual Water Flow’ (NWV) is calculated, this is the difference
between Virtual Water ‘Imports’ (VWI) and the Virtual Water Exports (VWE) (Garrido et al.,
2010).
The VWI is calculated as:
[
]
“In which Ti [Ne,p] represents the imported quantity of product p from exporting nation Ne
(product units/time) and WFprod [Ne,p] the water footprint of product p as in the exporting
nation Ne (volume/product unit) (aldaya et al., 2012, p57)”
The VWE is calculated as:
“In which Te[p] represent the quantity of product p exported from the nation (in our case
Spain) and WFprod[p] the average water footprint of the exported product p (volume/product
unit) (aldaya et al., 2012, p57)”
34
The quantity of products exported and imported from nations, or the trade data is obtained
from the UN Comtrade database, which uses the SITC coding also used by Mekonnen and
Hoekstra (2011a and 2011b). The bulk download tool is used to gather a batch in which all
imported and exported commodities are noted as reported by Spain for the period 1962-2013.
Unfortunately, no re-export or re-import is recorded in the data.
In order to calculate the virtual water ‘imports’ and ‘exports’ an excel sheet is built that
matches the virtual water content per country for each imported volume of a commodity. The
‘calculation sheets’ and data from UNcomtrade and Mekonnen and Hoekstra are online
available at:
https://drive.google.com/#folders/0Bx2MC9oIES3ELUpWUDJBczJxMm8
During the years the coding system of commodities have changed and have become more
detailed. For example, in SITC rev 3 tomatoes are subdivided into canned, dried and fresh.
Whereas SITC rev 1 only knows the category tomatoes. The Spanish trade data uses SITC 1
between 1962-1977, SITC 2 for 1978-1987 and SITC 3 from 1988 onwards. Hoekstra and
Mekonnes use SITC 3 coding system for the virtual water content. With the usage of the
conversion table of UN Comtrade virtual water coding is adjusted in order to calculate the
values before 1988. During this process a few complications where experienced. For example,
in the SITC 2 data, code S2-29199 (Animal Products, nes; dead animals unfit for human
consumption) was included in the data, which increased the volumes strongly. This was
removed, as it is not part of human consumption. There is still a high peak in the animal
imports for 1988 and 1989, which is likely caused by the SITC 2 conversion. In the SITC 1
conversion, problems evolved around crop products, the values where extremely high.
Therefore, the SITC 3 calculation sheet is used for the Crop import and export for the period
1962-1977.
The first calculation of the crop imports showed strong fluctuations between 19901999. A further analysis showed that the country coding caused the variability. Therefore the
world averages where used; unfortunately this removed the regional differences in green and
blue water of crop imports for the period 1990-1999. The rest of the results do include
regional differences.
35
Appendix III: Green and Blue Water in Spain
Figure III shows the green and blue water embodied in Spanish agricultural production.
Appendix III: Green and blue water embedded in Spanish agricultural
production, for the period 1860-2008. Source Duarte et al. 2014c, p.10.
36
Appendix IV: Natural Water Usage 1980-2010
37
List of References
Allan, J.A. (1993) Fortunately there are Substitutes for Water Otherwise our Hydro-political
Futures would be Impossible.In Priorities for Water Resources Allocation and
Management.London, United Kingdom: ODA: 13–26.
Allan, J. A. (1998) Virtual water: A strategic resource, global solutions to regional deficits.
Groundwater 36(4): 545-546.
Allan, T. (1999) Productive efficiency and allocative efficiency: why better water
management may not solve the problem. Agricultural water management, 40(1), 7175.
Allan, J. A. (2001) The Middle East water question: Hydropolitics and the global economy.
London: I.B. Tauris.
Ansink, E. (2010) Refuting two claims about virtual water trade, Ecological
Economics, 69(10), 2027-2032.
AEDYR (2014) Spanish Desalination and Water Reuse Association. [Online] accessible at:
“http://www2.technologyreview.com/microsites/spain/water/docs/
Spain_desalination.pdf”
Alejo, E. (2008) New Technologies in Spain. MIT Technology Review.
Andelman D. A. and Pauker B. (2009) Water Wars? A Talk with Ismail Serageldin. World
Policy Journal, 26, 43-63.
Brown, A., and Matlock, M. D. (2011) A review of water scarcity indices and methodologies.
The Sustainability Consortium, White paper, (106), 19.
Cosgrove, W.J., and Rijsberman, F.R., (2000) World Water Vision: Making Water
Everybody’s Business. Earthscan Publications, London, UK.
Cosgrove, C. E., and Cosgrove, W. J. (2012) The United Nations World Water Development
Report –The Dynamics of Global Water Futures: Driving Forces 2011–2050 (Vol. 2).
UNESCO.
Cuadrado-Roura, J. R. (2010). Regional Economy and Policy in Spain (1960–1975) (pp. 1951). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
De Stefano, L., & Llamas, M. R. (Eds.). (2012). Water, agriculture and the environment in
Spain: can we square the circle?. CRC Press.
Dalin, C., Konar, M., Hanasaki, N., Rinaldo, A., Rodriguez-Iturbe, I., (2012) Evolution of the
global virtual water trade network. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 109, 5989–5994.
Duarte, R., Pinilla, V., and Serrano, A. (2014a) Looking backward to look forward: water use
and economic growth from a long-term perspective. Applied Economics 46, 212-224.
Duarte, R., Pinilla, V., and Serrano, A. (2014b) The effect of globalisation on water
consumption: A case study of the Spanish virtual water trade, 1849–1935. Ecological
Economics, 100, 96-105.
Duarte, R., Pinilla, V., and Serrano, A. (2014c) The water footprint of the Spanish agricultural
sector: 1860-2010. Sociedad Espanola de Hisotria Agraria- Documentos de Trabajo.
DT-SEHA n.1408.
Dickie, P. (2007) Making Water. Desalination: option or distraction for a thirsty world? WWF
Global Freshwater Programme. Gland: Zwitserland.
Downing, T., Olsthoorn, A., & Tol, R. S. (Eds.). (2002). Climate, change and risk. Routledge.
Donges, . (1976). La industrializacio n de Espan a. Barcelona: Ed. Oikos-Tau.
European Environment Agency (2012) Towards efficient use of water resources in Europe.
Rapport EEA Report No 1/2012. Brussels.
Falkenmark (1989) The massive water scarcity threatening Africa-why isn't it being
addressed. Ambio 18, no.2: 112-118.
Falkenmark, M., & Rockström, J. (2006). The new blue and green water paradigm: Breaking
38
new ground for water resources planning and management. Journal of water resources
planning and management, 132(3), 129-132.
Fischer-Kowalski, M.; Swilling, M.; von Weizsäcker, E.U.; Ren, Y.; Moriguchi, Y.; Crane,
W.; Krausmann, F.; Eisenmenger, N.; Giljum, S.; Hennicke, P.(2011) Decoupling
Natural Resource Use and Environmental Impacts from Economic Growth, A Report
of the Working Group on Decoupling to the International Resource Panel. United
Nations Environment Programme: Geneva, Switzerland.
Gasco, G. (2004). Influence of state support on water desalination in Spain.Desalination, 165,
111-122.
Garrido, A., and Llamas, M. R. (2010) Water policy in Spain. CRC Press/Balkema.
Garrido, A., Llamas, M. R., Varela-Ortega, C., Novo, P., Rodríguez-Casado, R., and Aldaya,
M. M. (2010) Water footprint and virtual water trade in Spain: Policy implications
(Vol.35). Springer.
Garrido, A.., Llamas, R. M., Varela-Ortega C., Novo P., Casado, R.R and Aldaya, M.M.
(2008)Water Footprint and Virutal Water Trade: Policy Implications (Guadina Water
Footprint). Presented at Seminar for the external evaluation of the preliminary results.
Madrid.
Gómez, C. L., Martín, I., & Alcácer, C. (2008). Water policy in Spain: A portrait. Water
Culture and Water Conflict in the Mediterranean Area n83. P45-53.
Gilmont (2012) Water Paradigms. W&WP MSc Seminar 23 november 2012. London.
Gilmont, M. (2014) Decoupling dependence on natural water: Reflexivity in the regulation
and allocation of water in Israel, Uncorrected Proof for Water Policy,1–23.
Gilmont M. (2013) Presentation: The concept of decoupling and its capacity to explain in
WSG Seminar.
Gleick, P. H. (2002). Water management: Soft water paths. Nature, 418(6896), 373-373.
Gleick, P.H., Wolff, G.H. and Heather, C. (2006) The World’s Water 2006 -2007: The
Bienial Report on Freshwater Resources. Washington, DC: Island Press.
Hoekstra, A.Y. and Chapagain, A.K. (2008) Globalization of water: Sharing the planet’s
freshwater resources. Blackwell Publishing. Oxford, UK.
Hoekstra, A.Y., Chapagain, A.K., Aldaya, M.M., Mekonnen, M.M., (2012) Water footprint
assessment manual: Setting the global standard. Earthscan: London, UK.
INE (2014) Instituto Nacional de Estadistica Spanish Statistical Office. [Online] Accessible
at: http://www.ine.es/welcoing.htm (accessed: 24-07-2014).
Iglesias, R., Ortega, E., Batanero, G.,and Quintas, L. (2010) Water reuse in Spain: data
overview and costs estimation of suitable treatment trains. Desalination, 263(1), 1-10.
Iglesias Esteban, R., and Ortega de Miguel, E. (2008) Present and future of wastewater reuse
in Spain. Desalination, 218(1), 105-119.
Jorgenson, A. K., and Clark, B. (2012) Are the Economy and the Environment Decoupling? A
Comparative International Study, 1960–20051. American Journal of
Sociology, 118 (1), 1-44.
Kander, A. and Lindmark, M., (2004) Energy consumption, pollutant emissions and growth in
the long run: Sweden through 200 years. European Review of Economic History 8,
297-335.
Konar, M., Hussein, Z., Hanasaki, N., Mauzerall, D.L., Rodriguez-Iturbe, I. (2013) Virtual
water trade flows and savings under climate change. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. 17,
3219–3234.
Loughlin, J. (2008). Federal and local government institutions. Comparative Politics, 264287.
Lopez-Gunn, E. (2009). Agua para todos: A new regionalist hydraulic paradigm in
Spain. Water Alternatives, 2(3), 370-394
39
Lu, I. J., Lin, S. J., and Lewis, C. (2007) Decomposition and decoupling effects of carbon
dioxide emission from highway transportation in Taiwan, Germany, Japan and South
Korea. Energy Policy, 35(6), 3226-3235.
MAMRM (2010a) Guía para la Aplicación del R.D. 1620/2007 por el que se establece el
Régimen Jurídico de la Reutilización de las Aguas Depuradas. Online Available at:
http://www.magrama.gob.es/es/agua/temas/concesiones-y-autorizaciones/
GUIA_RD_1620_2007__tcm7-178027.pdf
MAMRM (2010b) Plan Nacional De Reutilizacion de Aguas. Online Avialable at:
http://www.magrama.gob.es/es/calidad-y-evaluacion-ambiental/participacionpublica/version_preliminar_pnra231210_tcm7-153069.pdf
McKinsey, S. (2009) Charting Our Water Future: Economic Framework to Inform Decision
Making. 2030 Water Resources Group.
Mielnik, O., and Goldemberg, J. (2002) Foreign direct investment and decoupling between
energy and gross domestic product in developing countries. Energy policy, 30(2), 8789.
Mekonnen, M.M. and Hoekstra, A.Y. (2011a) National water footprint accounts: the green,
blue and grey water footprint of production and consumption, Value of Water
Research Report Series No.50, UNESCO-IHE, Delft, the Netherlands.
Mekonnen, M.M. and Hoekstra, A.Y. (2011b) The green, blue and grey water footprint of
crops and derived crop products, Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 15(5): 15771600.
Mekonnen, M.M. and Hoekstra, A.Y. (2012) A global assessment of the water footprint of
farm animal products, Ecosystems, 15(3): 401–415.
OECD (2001) Environmental Strategy for the First Decade of the 21st Century. OECD: Paris
France. Available at: http://www.oecd.org/environment/indicators-modellingoutlooks/1863539.pdf [Accessed 07/07/2014].
OECD Statistical Database (2014) The OECD Statistical database. [Online] accessible at:
http://stats.oecd.org/
OECD (2014) Freshwater abstractions Countries Metadata. The OECD statistical database
Palomar, P., & Losada, I. J. (2010). Desalination in Spain: recent developments and
recommendations. Desalination, 255(1), 97-106.
Rijsberman, F. R. (2006) Water scarcity: fact or fiction?. Agricultural water
management, 80 (1), 5-22.
Royal Decree 1620 (2007) Spanish Regulations for Water Reuse. Spanish State Official
Journal, BOE no. 294, of 8 December 207, pages 50,639 to 50,661.
Shiklomanov, I. A. (1991) The world’s water resources. In Proceedings of the international
symposium to commemorate. 25, 93-126.
Shiklomanov, I. A. (1993). World water resources. Water in Crisis. New York, Oxford.
Shiklomanov, A. (1999) Spain: Dynamics of water use in Spain by estimates of SHI (1998).
[Online] Accessible at webworld.unesco.org/water/ihp/db/shiklomanov/part’3/HTML/
Tb_21’SP.html
Smith, M.H., Hargroves, K. and Desha, C. (2011) Decoupling economic growth from
freshwater extraction. In: Cents and Sustainability: Securing our Common Future
by Decoupling Economic Growth from Environmental Pressures. Smith,M.,
Hargroves, K. & Desha, C. (eds). Earthscan, London.
Stern, D.I. (2011) The role of energy in economic growth. Annals of the New York Academy
of Sciences, 1219, 26-51.
Sullivan, C.A., Meigh, J.R., Giacomello, A.M., Fediw, T., Lawrence, P., Samad, M., Mlote,
40
S.,Hutton, C., Allan,J.A., Schulze, R.E., Dlamini, D.J.M., Cosgrove, W.J., Delli
Priscoli, J., Gleick, P., Smout, I., Cobbing, J.,Calow, R., Hunt, C., Hussain, A.,
Acreman, M.C., King, ., Malomo, S., Tate, E.L., O’Regan, D., Milner, S., Steyl, I.,
(2003) The water poverty index: development and application at the community scale.
Nat. Resour.Forum 27, 189–199
Swyngedouw, E. (2006) Technonatural revolutions: the scalar politics of Franco's hydro‐
social dream for Spain, 1939–1975. Transactions of the Institute of British
Geographers, 32(1), 9-28.
Swyngedouw, E. (2014). 'Not A Drop of Water...': State, Modernity and the Production of
Nature in Spain, 1898-2010. Environment and History, 20(1), 67-92
UNEP (2012). Measuring water use in a green economy. A Report of the Working Group on
Water Efficiency to the International Resource Panel. Available at:
http://www.unep.org/resourcepanel/Portals/24102/Measuring_Water.pdf
[Accessed 10/02/2014].
Vörösmarty, C. J., Douglas, E. M., Green, P. A., and Revenga, C. (2005) Geospatial
indicators of emerging water stress: an application to Africa. AMBIO: a Journal of the
Human Environment, 34(3), 230-236.
World economic Forum (2014) Global Risks 2014, Ninth Edition. World Economic Forum
Publication: Geneva.
White, C. (2012) Understanding water scarcity: Definitions and measurements. GWF
Discussion Paper 1217, Global Water Forum, Canberra, Australia.
Wichelns, D. (2010) Virtual water: A helpful perspective, but not a sufficient policy
criterion. Water Resources Management, 24(10), 2203-2219.
Yang, H., Wang, L., Zehnder, A.J.B., 2007.Water scarcity and food trade in the Southern and
Eastern Mediterranean countries. Food Policy 32, 585-605.
Zhang, Z. (2000) Decoupling China’s carbon emissions increase from economic growth: An
economic analysis and policy implications. World Development, 28(4), 739-752.
41