Exocytosis, endocytosis and membrane recycling in Tetrahymena thermophila ARNO TIEDTKE, PETER HUNSELER Institute of/.oology, University of Minister, Schlofipkitz 5, D-4400 Minister, FRG JORGE ELORIN-CHRISTENSEN and MONICA FLORIN-CHRISTENSEN Center for Parasite and Vector Research, Xational University of La Plata, Calle 2, Xo. 5S4, 1900 La Plata, Argentina Summary Mutant and wild-type cell lines of Tetrahymena thermophila were used to investigate a possible connection between acid hydrolase secretion and the major processes through which membranes are recycled in this ciliated protozoon. These processes consist of food vacuole formation (endocytosis), and food vacuole egestion and mucocyst release (both exocytosis). We have found that a mutant (MS-1, see") blocked in hydrolase secretion is not blocked in either food vacuole formation or egestion and that it has normal mucocyst exocytosis. Another line of experiments with wild-type cells showed also that hydrolase secretion and endocytosis are independent of each other. Thus, sucrose (0-1M) did not interfere with hydrolase secretion, but blocked food vacuole formation. Furthermore, release of acid hydrolases was selectively stimulated by dibucaine without any effect on food vacuole egestion. Finally, exocytosis of mucocysts could occur without simultaneous release of acid hydrolases, as when cells were exposed to (M5 M-NaCl, which evokes a massive secretory response of mucocysts. Our results demonstrate that formation and egestion of food vacuoles and exocytosis of mucocysts are unrelated to secretion of acid hydrolases. Furthermore, they suggest that secretion of acid hydrolases is not a secondary effect of membrane recycling through these processes. Introduction should fuse with the plasma membrane before release of enzymes. Here, we investigate a possible connection of this process with other events taking part in membrane traffic in Tetrahymena. Release of acid hydrolases to the extracellular medium by the ciliate Tetrahymena has been the object of many studies (Blum & Rothstein, 1975; Muller, 1971; Nilsson, 1979). Muller (1972) found that released acid hydrolases originate from the denser of two populations of lysosomes and considered this release to be secretion. We have recently substantiated this view and shown that enzyme release is enhanced by Ca 2+ mobilizing agents and that the hydrolases are liberated without loss of other cytoplasmic components (Tiedtke el al. 1984). The cellular route of the hydrolases is unknown. To date, lysosomal enzymes are not known to pass the membrane of the lysosome (Creek & Sly, 1984) and therefore vesicles that contain lysosomal enzymes Journal of Cell Science 89, 515-520 (1988) Printed in Great Britain © The Company of Biologists Limited 1988 Key words: membrane recycling, secretion, acid hydrolases, Tetrahymena thermophila. Materials and methods Strains The wild-type strains B i l l and B VII, and the mutant MS-1 of Tetrahymena theniiophila blocked constitntively in release of lysosomal enzymes (Hiinseler el al. 1987«), were used in this study. The phenotype of MS-1 is caused by a recessive single gene mutation (Tiedtke et al. 1987). Culture conditions The cells were grown in PPYS medium: 1% proteose peptone (Difco), 0 1 % yeast extract (Difco), 0003 % sequestrene (Geigy). Cell cultures were inoculated at initial concentrations of 2x 104 cells ml"' and grown at 30°C in a shaker 515 1A B Fig. 1. Bright-field micrographs of T. themiophila containing food vacuoles labelled with India ink. A. The initial stage of the formation of an India ink-labelled food vacuole; B, distribution of labelled food vacuoles after 20-30min incubation with 0-05% India ink; C, accumulation of food vacuoles at the posterior end of the cell as observed after a chase of 30 min. (90 revs min~ ) up to cell concentrations around 8X 10 s cellsml~'. Cell-free supernatants were collected by centrifugation (3 min, 600g) of the cell suspensions into a cushion of 10% (w/v) Ficoll. Evaluation of egestion rates Cells in PPYS medium were labelled with India ink (005 % final concn) for 20 min at 30°C. During this pulse the cells ingested India ink particles and contained many black food vacuoles. The cells were then washed twice with PPYS medium to remove remaining India ink particles, resuspended in fresh PPYS medium and incubated at 30°C for 30min. At the end of this chase period many labelled food vacuoles were observed in the posterior parts of the cells ready for egestion through the cytoproct (Fig. 1A-C). In this way, egestion could be followed from the start of the experiment. The wild-type (B VII) and the mutant MS-1 cell suspensions were adjusted to Sx 103 cells ml" 1 following the pulse-labelling with India ink. At each time point indicated four samples of cells were removed and OS ml of each sample was fixed for food vacuole countings, the remaining cell suspensions were centrifuged and the cell-free supernatants were collected on ice for assays of enzyme activity. Out of each fixed sample 60 cells were chosen randomly and the number of labelled food vacuoles per cell was found. To measure the action of dibucaine on the egestion of labelled food vacuoles, wild-type cells ( B i l l ) were washed after a chase of 30 min in PPY'S medium into lOniMTris-HCl, pi I 6-0. The cells were exposed to the drug at 25°C for 15 min and then processed for food vacuole counting and enzyme assays as described above for control cells not treated with the drug. Dibucaine treatment Solutions of 6mmoll~' of dibucaine (Sigma) in lOmMTris- IICI, pi I 6 0 , were freshly prepared before each experiment. At pi I 6-0 but not at higher pH values dibucaine was readily soluble. No meaningful pH variations were observed during the experiments in spite of the reduced buffer capacity of Tris- IICI at pi I 6 0 . Cultures of the wild type ( B i l l ) were 516 A. Tiedtke et al. adjusted to 1-5x10''cells ml ' after the end of the 30-min chase period and samples of one ml (containing cells with labelled food vacuoles) were added to 15-ml centrifugation tubes containing 2ml of the corresponding drug solution. The drug concentrations before addition of the cells were I -5 times the final concentration indicated in Results. Control experiments were performed identically using the corresponding buffer without drugs. The tubes with the cells were placed in a tilted rack to ensure aeration of the cell suspension. Immediately before the end of the incubation periods small samples were withdrawn and the status and behaviour of the drug-treated cells were controlled under a microscope. Samples for food vacuole countings and enzyme assays were withdrawn as described above. The data were statistically analysed with the help of Student's /-test. Alcian Blue-induced mucocyst exocytosis The method is based on previous observations of the sccretagogue activity of this dye (Tiedtkc, 1976). It consisted of exposing cell suspensions starved for 2 h to 0-1 % Alcian Blue and observing in the light microscope the blue-stained mucocyst aggregates around the cells and in the medium. The question whether the Alcian Blue treatment also caused an enhanced secretion of acid hydrolases was not investigated: the Alcian Blue remaining in the supernatant interacts strongly with proteins and prevents meaningful enzyme determinations. Exposure to 0-1 M-sucrose Wild-type cells ( B i l l ) were washed twice in lOmMTris H O , pH7-4, and the washed cell suspension adjusted to 10 6 cellsml~' was divided into two portions. One was mixed with an equal volume of 02M-sucrose in 10niMTris- HC1, pH 7-4, while the other received the same volume of buffer without sucrose. Each of these suspensions was immediately divided in two. One was used to measure released enzyme activities and the other to follow food vacuole formation after addition of India ink (0-05%, final concn). The cells were incubated at 25°C and samples were withdrawn at 30 and 60 min for food vacuole countings and enzyme assays. Exposure to 015 M-NaCl In this experiment washed B i l l cells in 10 mM-Tris'1IC1, pH 7-4, were either mixed with an equal volume of the same buffer or the same buffer supplemented with 03M-NaCl, under continuous stirring. Suspensions were allowed to stand at 25°C for 2min and centrifuged. Supernatants were collected for enzyme assays and mucocyst inspection. Inspection of mucocysts Samples of the supernatants of both control and NaCl-treated cells were exposed to cationized ferritin after addition of an equal volume of 2mM-MgCl2. Observation of mucocysts stained in this way was performed using a Zeiss Photomicroscope. For electron microscopy (EM), the samples were spread on carbon-coated grids, negatively stained with a 1 % aqueous solution of uranyl acetate and observed with a Siemens Elmiskop at 60 kV. Enzyme assays Enzyme activities of the cell-free supernatants were assayed at 37CC, using /)-nitrophenyl-conjugated substrates for acid phosphatase (EC 3.1.3.2), A'-acetyl-j8-D-hexosaminidase (EC 3.2.1.52), cr-mannosidase (EC 3.2.1.24) and <r-glucosidase (EC 3.2.1.20) at final concentrations of lOmmoll" 1 , according to Tiedtke (1983«). One milliunit (1 ml)) is defined as the amount of enzyme that releases 1 nmol of />-nitrophenol per min at 37°C. Isocitrate dehydrogenase (IDH, EC 1.1.1.42) was assayed colorimetrically according to the supplier's information (Biochemica Information II, Boehringer-Mannheim). Isocitrate dehydrogenase, a sensitive cytosolic marker enzyme of Telrahyniena (Borden el al. 197S), was measured during the drug experiments to exclude cell lysis as a source of released lysosomal enzymes. Results Acid hydrolase secretion (AHS) and egestion of marked food vacuoles in the wild-type and a mutant blocked in AJiS Food vacuoles of wild-type (B VII) and mutant (MS-1) cell lines were pulse-labelled with India ink. After the 30-min chase period that allows the food vacuoles to collect at the posterior end, the cells were incubated for 3h at 30°C in nutrient medium. Samples were removed every 30 min for determinations of enzyme activity and every 60 min for estimation of number of food vacuoles per cell. The results are shown in Fig. 2. It can be observed that the mean number of food vacuoles decreased gradually in the wild type and in the mutant MS-1 blocked in AHS. Although the initial mean number of food vacuoles was slightly higher in the wild type (10 per cell) than in the mutant (9 per cell) both strains released a similar number of marked food vacuoles per unit of time, indicating that MS-1 was not impaired in egestion of food vacuoles. In spite of this the mutant did not release /3-hexosaminidase and acid phosphatase (and other lysosomal enzymes, data not shown) above the background levels characteristic for this mutant. Mucocyst exocytosis in wild-type and mutant cells Mucocyst secretion was induced in wild-type ( B V I I ) and mutant (MS-1) cells by exposure to Alcian Blue. T h e cell lines were alike in their release of mucocysts, showing that MS-1 has normal mucocyst exocytosis. Influence of dibucaine on release of acid hydrolases and egestion of marked food vacuoles Table 1 shows the results of exposure of wild-type cells (B III) to 100 or 200/iM-dibucaine on release of four lysosomal enzymes and egestion of labelled food vacuoles. The drug considerably stimulated the release of acid phosphatase, /3-hexosaminidase, cv-glucosidase and O'-mannosidase. The mean number of remaining /3-Hexosaminidasc 200 BVII 10 100 200 X. Acid phosphatase 10 >B VII 100 Ms-1 Fig. 2. Egestion of food vacuoles and kinetics of release of acid hydrolases in the wild type (B VII) and the mutant MS-1, blocked in release of acid hydrolases during 3 h in nutrient medium. The mean number of food vacuoles ± standard deviation from four independent experiments are shown. Open columns, wild type (B VII); hatched columns, MS-1. The standard deviation of each point in the kinetics of release of /3-hexosaminidasc and acid phosphatase was below 10%. food vacuoles per cell was, however, similar in control and drug-treated cells showing that food vacuole egestion was not increased by dibucaine. These results point to an uncoupling of AHS and food vacuole egestion. Dibucaine also stimulated AHS in the mutant MS-1 in about the same proportions as it did in wild-type cells. Mutant cells treated for 15 min with dibucaine 1 (IOOJUM) released 0-51 ± 0-03 mU ml" of acid phosphatase and 0-47 ± 0-027 mU ml"' of j3-hcxosaminidase. The activities released by the cells not treated with dibucaine were 0-16 ± 0"01 mil ml""' and 0-18 ± 0-005 mU ml"', respectively. This represents a 3-2-fold stimulation of acid phosphatase and a 2-6-fold stimulation of /3-hexosaminidase release. The corresponding increases in wild-type cells were 2-97-fold for Membrane recycling in Tetrahymcna 517 Table 1. Influence of dibucaine on the egestion offood vacuoles and the release of acid hydrolases in the wild type (Bill) ofT. thermophila Acid phosphatase /3-Hexosaminidase cv-Glucosidase cv-Mannosidase Mean number of food vacuoles per cell* 1-07 ±0-045 318 ± 0-27 5-33 ± 0 1 1 1-12 ±0-07 2-5 ±0-03 3-1610-13 1-33 ±0-09 4-36 ±0-35 7-12±0-64 1-83 + 0-10 3-52 + 0-14 5-0±0-19 8-3 ±0-8 8-9±0-4 8-98 ±0-02 Released enzyme activities (mil ml ') and mean numbers of labelled food vacuoles per cell Control 100/iM-dibucaine 200;iM-dibucaine • T h e mean number of labelled food vacuoles at the beginning of the drug treatment was 11-3 ± 0-3. Release of acid hydrolases by the drug-treated cell suspensions is significantly higher (I3<0-005) than release of acid hydrolases in the untreated control suspension. The mean numbers of food vacuoles per cell are not significantly different from control samples in dibucaine-treated cells. Data were analysed with the help of Student's /-test. acid phosphatase and 2-23-fold for /3-hexosaminidase (Table 1). Addition of sucrose and effects on food vacuole formation and AIIS Incubation of wild-type cells (B III) in buffer contain ing O'lM-sucrose completely prevented food vacuol formation during a 60-min period. Control cells formei 10-6 ± 0-8 vacuoles per cell within the same period Release of acid phosphatase and /?-hexosaminidase wa identical in treated and non-treated cells. high rates of endocytosis and exocytosis. We have dealt here with a Tetrahymena mutant that is blocked in acid hydrolase secretion (AHS), which can grow and multiply normally (Hiinseler el al. 1987c;). This mutant •r NaCl induced inucocyst exocytosis Massive exocytosis of mucocysts can be induced by brief (2min) exposure of the cells to 150mM-NaCl Discharged mucocysts stayed in the supernant afte centrifugation. They were detected in the light micro scope as rod-like structures after negative staining witl cationized ferritin (Fig. 3A). The identity of these rod as decondensed mucocysts matrices was verified b EM. Samples negatively stained with uranyl acetat exhibited the regular fibrillar pattern and uniform siz characteristic of decondensed mucocysts matrices (Fig 3B). Supernatants of control preparations only oc casionally contained mucocysts. As summarized ii Table 2, the NaCl treatment induced massive exocy tosis of mucocysts but did not stimulate AHS. Treat ment with 150mM-NaCl rapidly immobilized the cell and caused osmotic shrinkage. However, the cell recovered from this treatment when diluted 10-foli with 10mM-Tris- HC1, pH 7-4, at the end of the 2-mii incubation. Cells resumed normal shape and motilit during the following 2h. Discussion Membrane recycling is the means by which a cell maintains its plasma membrane surface constant in spite of processes that continuously add and withdraw portions of it. This is an obvious need for cells with 518 A. Tiedtke et al. Fig. 3. Mucocysts in the supernatant of NaCl-trcatecl Tetrahvmena. The cells were incubated for 2min in lOniMT r i s H C l , pH7-4, plus ISOmM-NaCI and then sedimented. A sample of the supernatant was mixed with an equal volume of 2mM-MgCl2 and negatively stained with cationized ferritin (A) or uranyl acetate (B). Bars: A, 11 flm; B, 1 fim. Table 2. Secretion of acid hydrolases by Tetrahymena after a 2-min incubation in 10mMTrisHCl, pill-4, with and without 150mM-NaCl Released enzyme activities (mUml" 1 ) Control NaCl Acid phosphatasc /3-Hexosaminidase 0-83 ±0-07 0-55 ±0-06 0-80 ±0-09 0-43 + 004 Secretion of acid hydrolases is significantly lower (P< 0-005) in NaCl-treated cells. has membrane recycling as shown by its ability to form and egest food vacuoles, and to discharge mucocysts. We can therefore conclude that membrane recycling can proceed without acid hydrolase release (AHS) in Tetrahymena. In other words, membrane recycling is not a sufficient condition for acid hydrolase release. We have also tested the possibility that blockage of release of hydrolases in this mutant could be due to deficient dissociation of the enzymes from receptors at the plasma membrane after exocytosis. In such a case, it should be expected that hydrolases accumulate on the cell surface. We used the method described by Gottlieb & Dwyer (1981) for determination of membrane surface enzymes and found that MS-1 has a significantly lower content of acid phosphatase and /3-hexosaminidase activities on the cell surface than wild-type cells (unpublished data). Since biosynthesis of lysosomal enzymes is not impaired in this mutant (Hiinseler et al. 19876), the mutation probably affects the behaviour of the vesicles containing acid hydrolases, preventing their fusion with the plasma membrane. This emphasizes the view that AHS is separate from the mainstream of membrane recycling in Tetrahymena. Dissociation of food vacuole formation from AHS in wild-type cells was obtained by exposure to ( H M sucrose, which blocks the former but not the latter. This result agrees with the study by Silberstein (1979) on a Tetrahymena mutant cell line that is blocked in food vacuole formation but secretes essentially normal amounts of acid hydrolases. It also confirms the report by Miiller (1975) of the independence of AHS from the contractile vacuole activity, which, unlike AHS, is inhibited in media with high osmolarity. It was proposed that the acid hydrolases left the cells via the egested food vacuoles. Rothstein & Blum (1974) based this view on a simultaneous stimulation of AHS and food vacuole egestion mediated by catecholamine antagonists. Our results, however, both with the mutant MS-1 and with the wild-type cells exposed to dibucaine, which may enhance enzyme release by an increase in cytoplasmic free Ca 2+ (Tiedtke et al. 1984), demonstrate that egestion of vacuoles is unrelated to AHS. This seems to be the case also for both Dictyostelium (Dimonde/c//. 1984) and Acanthamoeba (Hohman & Bowers, 1984). We must point out that the secretory mutant MS-1 can grow on bacteria as sole food source as fast as the wild-type cells (Hiinseler el al. 1987a). It has, therefore, a normal intracellular digestion process, i.e. fusion of lysosomes with food vacuoles. Such fusion has recently been demonstrated by Fok & Schokley (1985) in Tetrahymena growing in PPY medium. As a consequence, we can conclude that retrieval or inactivation of lysosomal enzymes must take place prior to egestion, since MS-1 normally egests food vacuoles but does not release enzymes. Evidence for retrieval of lysosomal enzymes has been obtained for another ciliate, Paramecium caudatum (Allen & Fok, 1984). A possible role for mucocyst exocytosis in AHS was suggested by the finding of acid phosphatase activity associated with these organelles (Tiedtke & Gortz, 1983). The method employed, however, permitted no quantification of the amounts of enzyme released in this way. Our present experiments, in which exposure to 0-15M-NaCl results in massive discharge of mucocysts without enhancement in AHS, show that these two processes are essentially independent. This agrees well with our previous observation that another secreted hydrolase, /3-hexosaminidase, is not associated with discharging mucocysts, as shown by immunostaining with specific antibodies against this enzyme (Tiedtke, 19836). As to the biological role of the secreted hydrolases, their exploitation in extracellular digestion has already been shown for Tetrahymena (Rasmusscn et al. 1986). The observations presented here suggest that AHS, at least in Tetrahymena, should be regarded as an independent cellular event and not just as an incidental consequence of membrane recycling, as Hohman & Bowers (1984) proposed for Acanthamoeba castellani. We thank Dr L. Rasmussen for critical reading of and for many helpful comments on the manuscript. Support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft to A.T. is gratefully acknowledged, M.F.-C. was the recipient of a HcinrichHertz-Stiftung fellowship, and J.F.-C. of an EM BO shortterm fellowship. References ALLEN, R. D. & FOK, A. K. (1984). Retrieval of lysosomal membrane and acid phosphatase from phagolysosomes of Paramecium caudatum. J. Cell Biol. 99, 1955-1959. BORDEN, D., MILLER, E. T . & NANNEY, D. L. (1975). Electrophoretic analysis of evolutionary relationships in Tetrahymena. Evolution 31, 91-102. BLUM, J. J. & ROTHSTEIN, T. L. (1975). Lysosomes in Tetrahymena. In Lysosomes in Biologv and Pathology Membrane recycling in Tetrahymena 519 (ed. J. T. Dingle, R. T. Dean & W. Sly), pp. 33-45. Amsterdam: North Holland. CREEK, K. E. & SLY, W. S. (1984). The role of the phosphomannosyl receptor in the transport of acid hydrolases to lysosomes. In Lysosomes in Biology and Pathology (ed. J. T. Dingle & R. T. Dean), vol. 7, pp. 63-82. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. DIMOND, R. L., BURNS, R. A. & JORDAN, K. B. (1981). Secretion of lysosomal enzymes in the cellular slime mold, Diclvostelium discoideum. J. biol. Client. 256, 6565-6572. FOK, A. K. & SCHOKLEY, B. V. (1985). Processing of digestive vacuoles in Telrahyniena and the effects of dichloroisoproterenol. jf. Pivlozool. 32, 6-9. GOTTLIEB, M. & DWYER, D. M. (1981). Protozoan parasite of humans: Surface membrane with externally disposed acid phosphatase. Science 212, 939-941. HOHMAN, T. C. & BOWERS, B. (1984). Hydrolase secretion is a consequence of membrane recycling. J7. Cell Biol. 98, 246-252. HONSELER, P., SCHEIDGEN-KLEYBOLDT, G. & TIEDTKE, A. (1987«). Isolation and characterization of a mutant of 'I'elrahvmena ihennophila blocked in secretion of lysosomal enzymes..7. Cell Sci. 88, 47-55. HONSELER, P., TIEDTKE, A. & VON FIGURA, K. (19876). Biosynthesis of a secreted lysosomal hydrolase of Telrahyniena ihennophila. Comparison of the wild type with a secretion deficient mutant line. Eiir. J. Cell Biol. 43 (Suppl. 17), 28. MOLLER, M. (1971). Lysosomes in Telrahyniena pyrifonnis. II. Intracellular distribution of several acid hydrolases. Ada biol. hung. 22, 179-186. MOLLER, M. (1972). Secretion of acid hydrolases and its intracellular source in Telrahyniena pyrifonnis. J. Cell Biol. 52, 478-487. MOLLER, M. (1975). Effect of increased osmolarity and of protein synthesis inhibitors on the release of hydrolases of Telrahyniena pyrifonnis. J. Pmtozool. 22, 21 A. 520 A. Tiedtke el al. NlLSSON, J. R. (1979). Phagotrophy in Telrahyniena. In Biochemistry and Physiology of Protozoa (ed. S. H. Hutner), vol. 2, pp. 339-379. New York: Academic Press. RASMUSSEN, L., TOFTLUND, H., FLORIN-CHRISTENSEN, M. & FLORIN-CHRISTENSEN, J. (1986). Utilization of phosphate compounds for growth of Tetrahymena. Experientia 41, 1593-1594. ROTHSTEIN, T. L. & BLUM, J. J. (1974). Lysosomal physiology in Tetrahvmena. III. Pharmacological studies on acid hydrolase release and the ingestion and egestion of dimethyl-benzanthracene particles. J. Cell Biol. 62, 844-859." SILBERSTEIN, G. B. (1979). Acid hydrolases and their release in food vacuole-less mutants of Tetrahymena thennophila.J. Pmtozool. 26, 519-524. TIEDTKE, A. (1976). Capsule shedding in Tetrahymena. Naturwissenschaften 63, 93. TIEDTKE, A. (1983«). Purification and properties of secreted N-acetyl-/3-D-hexosaminidase of Telrahyniena thennophila. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 75B, 239-243. TIEDTKE, A. (19836). A lysosomal enzyme associated with the cell surface of Tetrahymena thennophila. J. Pmtozool. 30, 44A. TIEDTKE, A., FLORIN-CHRISTENSEN, M. & FLORIN- CHRISTENSEN, J. (1984). Release of lysosomal enzymes in Tetrahymena: a Ca 2+ dependent secretory process. J. Pmtozool. 31, 41A. TIEDTKE, A. & GORTZ, H.-D. (1983). Acid phosphatase associated with discharging secretory vesicles (mucocysts) of Telrahvniena thennophila. Eur. J. Cell Biol. 30, 254-257. TIEDTKE, A., SCHEIDGEN-KLEYBOLDT, G. & HONSELER, P. (1987). Selection and characterization of mutant cells of Tetrahymena blocked in secretion of lysosomal hydrolases. Eur. J. Cell Biol. 43 (Suppl. 17), 59. (Received 24 September 1987 -Accepted, in revised fonn, 16 December 19S7)
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz