AN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION ON CHARACTERISTIC PROPERTIES OF FIBRE REINFORCED CONCRETE CONTAINING WASTE GLASS POWDER AS POZZOLANA S.M. Chikhalikar, Govt. of Maharashtra, India S.N. Tande, Walchand, College of Engineering, India 37th Conference on OUR WORLD IN CONCRETE & STRUCTURES: 29 - 31 August 2012, Singapore Article Online Id: 100037017 The online version of this article can be found at: http://cipremier.com/100037017 This article is brought to you with the support of Singapore Concrete Institute www.scinst.org.sg All Rights reserved for CI‐Premier PTE LTD You are not Allowed to re‐distribute or re‐sale the article in any format without written approval of CI‐Premier PTE LTD Visit Our Website for more information www.cipremier.com th 37 Conference on Our World in Concrete & Structures 29-31 August 2012, Singapore AN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION ON CHARACTERISTIC PROPERTIES OF FIBRE REINFORCED CONCRETE CONTAINING WASTE GLASS POWDER AS POZZOLANA S.M. Chikhalikar* and S.N. Tande† Executive Engineer, Govt. of Maharashtra, Nashik, India e-mail: <[email protected]> Keywords: Fibre reinforced concrete, Glass powder, Pozzolana, Strength, Temperature; Abstract: The production of one tone of cement liberates one tone of carbon dioxide and it is enhancing the global warming. There is a need to replace a part of cement by some pozzolanic material to reduce the consumption of cement and the environmental pollution can be checked to some extent. Some of the industrial wastes like fly ash, silica fume, blast furnace slag etc have already established their usage in concrete. Recently the research has shown that the waste glass can be effectively used in concrete either as glass aggregate or as a glass pozzolana. Waste glass when grounded to a very fine powder shows some pozzolanic properties because of silica content. Therefore the glass powder to some extent can replace the cement and contributes for the strength development and also enhances durability characteristics. The main objective of this experimentation is to study the effect of replacement of cement by waste glass powder on workability and strength properties of steel fibre reinforced concrete. Cement is replaced by glass powder in different percentages like 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and 40%. Strength properties of steel fibre reinforced concrete (SFRC) such as compressive strength, tensile strength, flexural strength and impact strength were studied. 1 INTRODUCTION The usefulness of fiber reinforced concrete (FRC) in various civil engineering applications is indisputable. Fiber reinforced concrete has so far been successfully used in slabs on grade, shotcrete, architectural panels, precast products, offshore structures, structures in seismic regions, thin and thick repairs, crash barriers, footings, hydraulic structures and many other applications. Compared to other building materials such as metals and polymers, concrete is significantly more brittle and exhibits a poor tensile strength. Based on fracture toughness values, steel is at least 100 times more resistant to crack growth than concrete. Concrete in service thus cracks easily, and this cracking creates easy access routes for deleterious agents resulting in early saturation, freezethaw damage, scaling, discoloration and steel corrosion. The concerns with the inferior fracture toughness of concrete are alleviated to a large extent by reinforcing it with fibers of various materials. The ______________________________ † Associate Professor, Applied Mechanics Department, Walchand College of Engineering Sangli-416415, Maharashtra, INDIA, e-mail: <[email protected]> S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande resulting material with a random distribution of short, discontinuous fibers is termed fiber reinforced concrete (FRC) and is slowly becoming a well accepted mainstream construction material. Significant progress has been made in the last thirty years towards understanding the short and long-term performances of fiber reinforced cementitious materials, and this has resulted in a number of novel and innovative applications. There are currently 200,000 metric tons of fibers used for concrete reinforcement. Table 1 shows the existing commercial fibers and their properties. Steel fiber remains the most used fiber of all (50% of total tonnage used) followed by polypropylene (20%), glass (5%) and other fibers (25%). In recent times animal hair has been used to strengthen plaster. Patent records show that cement systems containing steel fibres were introduced early in this century. In the past 20 years, there has been a renewed interest in the science and application of fibre reinforced concretes. The organic and in-organic fibres can be advantageously used in concrete. In recent years, intensive research has resulted in advances and innovation in the technology of fibres such as steel, glass, polypropylene, carbon etc., and more basic knowledge has been gained on the behavior of cement concrete containing these fibres. 2 LITERATURE REVIEW The concrete industry has been making use of industrial mineral wastes like fly ash, silica fume and blast furnace slag as pozzolana by replacing a part of cement. While Pozzolanic reaction adds to the strength of concrete and the utilization of these materials brings about economy in concrete manufacture. It has been estimated that several million tons of waste glasses are generated annually worldwide. The key sources of waste glasses are waste containers, window glasses, windscreen, medicinal bottles, liquor bottles, tube lights, bulbs, electronic equipments, etc. Only a part of this waste glass can be recycled. A majority of the waste glass remains unutilized. The earlier research works carried out by various researchers are as follows. [1] Meyer C, Egosi N. and Andela C. , in their paper entitled “Concrete with waste glass as aggregate” have discussed about the use of waste glass as aggregate in concrete industry. This paper discusses the various steps that need to be taken by recyclers to collect the glass, separate it from the other materials, clean it and crush it to obtain the appropriate grading to meet [2] the specifications for specific applications. Bin Mu and Christian Meyer , in their paper entitled “Flexural behavior of fibre mesh-reinforced glass aggregate concrete”, have studied the flexural responses of concrete specimens with crushed waste glass as aggregate and reinforced either with randomly distributed short fibres or with continuous fiber mesh, are compared for equal fibre volume ratios. The results indicate that fibre efficiency increases with their concentration near the tension face and fibre mesh is considerably more effective in bending than randomly distributed [3] fibers. Christian Meyer , in his paper entitled “Glass concrete” has studied to improve certain [4] properties of concrete products and create new market opportunities. Ahmad Shayan , in his paper entitled “Value-added Utilization of Waste Glass in Concrete” has dealt with effective use of [5] waste glass in concrete and recycling of glass. Byars E.A., Zhu H.Y. and Morales B. , in their paper entitled “Conglasscrete I ” have discussed about the use of waste glass as aggregate and the possibility of ASR. Post-consumer and other waste glass types are a major component of the solid waste stream in many countries and most is currently land filled. Ravindra Dhir, Tomdyer, [6] Albert tang and Yongjun cui , in their paper entitled “Towards maximizing the value and sustainable use of glass” have dealt with minimization of waste generation and disposal by recycling waste generation and its disposal in land fill sites is unsustainable. Caijun Shi and [7] Yanzhong Wu , in their paper entitled “Mixture proportioning and properties of self-consolidating lightweight concrete containing glass powder”, have studied the design and properties of selfconsolidating lightweight concrete. Glass powder and ASTM Class F fly ash are added to produce aggressive paste to increase the flowability and segregation resistance to the concrete. Chi Sing [8] Lam et al , in their paper entitled, “Enhancing the performance of pre-cast concrete blocks by incorporating waste glass - ASR consideration”, have indicated that recycled crushed glass [9] (RCG) aggregate can be used in non-structural elements. Ziad Bayasi and Henning Kaiser , have conducted an experimental investigation on “Steel fibres as crack arrestors in concrete”. This experiment investigates the cracking behaviour of steel fibre reinforced concrete (SFRC). Concrete mixtures containing steel fibres in volume fractions (Vf) of 0, 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 percent [10] were investigated. De Gutierrez R.M. et al , in their paper entitled “Effect of pozzolans on the performance of fibre-reinforced mortars”, have found that randomly oriented short fibres have been shown to increase tensile strength and retard crack propagation of cement based materials such as fibre-reinforced mortars for diverse applications, especially in aggressive environments. S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande 3 TYPES OF FIBRES a) Metallic Fibres: Some of the metallic fibres used in concrete are steel fibre, low carbon steel fibre, galvanized iron fibre and aluminum fibre. Among these fibres steel fibre is one of the most commonly used fibres.Steel fibres for use in concrete are available in different shapes, sizes and types. Many different types of fibres, with round, rectangular and crescent shaped cross sections are commercially available. They range in ultimate strength from 345 to 2070 MPa. Fibre size ranges from 13 × 0.25 mm to 64 × 0.76 mm. b) Non Metallic Fibres: In this classification we come across many fibres such as asbestos, glass, carbon, polypropylene, recron, nylon, acrylic, aramid, kevlar, coconut coir, sisal, sugar cane bagasse, bamboo, jute, wood and vegetables. Among these fibres glass, carbon and polypropylene fibre are most commonly in use. i. Glass Fibres: Glass fibre is a recent introduction in making fibre concrete. Commonly used glass fibres are round and straight and have diameters of 0.0005 to 0.015 mm, but these fibres may be bonded together to produce glass fibre elements with diameters of 0.13 to 1.3 mm. It has very high 2 tensile strength of 1020 to 4080 N/mm . ii. Carbon Fibres: These fibers are very small in diameter and are generally used in shorter lengths. They are also manufactured as continuous mats and continuous straight fibres. They can be manufactured in strength as high as steel with a density only one-fifth that of steel. iii. Polypropylene Fibres: Polypropylene fibres are specially engineered for use in concrete and mortar as a micro reinforcement system. They posses very high tensile strength, but their low modulus of elasticity and higher elongation do not contribute to the flexural strength. iv. Asbestos Fibres: Asbestos fibres have a thermal, mechanical and chemical resistance making it suitable for sheets, pipes, tiles and corrugated roofing elements. Asbestos cement products contain about 8 to 16 percent by volume of asbestos fibres. 4 PROPERTIES OF STEEL FIBRE REINFORCED CONCRETE a) Compressive Strength: Compressive strength is little influenced by steel fibre addition, with increase in strength ranging from 0 to 15 percent for up to 1.5 percent volume of fibres. It is mainly controlled by the concrete matrix design. b) Tensile Strength: Effect depends on alignment , aspect ratio, smoothness etc, increases upto133% & for randomly dispersed fibres upto 60%. c) Flexural Strength: Elements incorporating steel fibres have higher flexural stiffness (reduced deflections) and smaller crack widths when subjected to service loads. Increase in flexural strength is ranging from 0 to 20 percent up to 1.5 percent by volume of fibres. d) Toughness: The toughness indices for SFRC vary greatly depending on the position of the crack, the type of fibre, aspect ratio, the volume fraction of the fibre and the distribution of the fibres. Significant increase in the toughness of concrete with fibres, sustains multiple hammer blows without breaking into pieces as compared with normal concrete. It can be demonstrated by loading SS beam (structural integrity is not lost) e) Corrosion: When using steel fibres in concrete, attention has to be given to the question of corrosion of the fibres. As the steel volume locally is very small when fibres are used, only limited expansion forces develop due to the corrosion and normally no spalling occurs. f) Creep & Shrinkage: The addition of steel fibres decreases the shrinkage and creep. 5 MATERAILS USED The Main objective of this experimentation is to study the effect of replacement of cement by waste glass powder on workability and strength properties of steel fibre reinforced concrete. Cement is replaced by glass powder in different percentages like 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and 40%. Strength properties of steel fibre reinforced concrete (SFRC) such as compressive strength, tensile strength, flexural strength and impact strength were studied. The following materials are used for experimentation to study durability and strength properties of fibre reinforced concrete containing waste glass powder as pozzolana with proper mix-design carried out based on individual material properties. S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande • Cement: 43 grade Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) with specific gravity of 3.15, initial setting time 100 minutes, final setting time 300 minutes,7days compressive strength 35 MPa and 28 days compressive strength 48 MPa, complying with IS:8112-1989 IS:8112 1989 was used. • Fine aggregate: Locally available sand with specific gravity of 2.62 falling under zone II complying with IS:383-1970 1970 was used. • Coarse aggregate: Locally available coarse aggregate with specific gravity of 2.93 complying with IS:383-1970 was as used. • Superplasticiser: Conplast SP430 complying with IS:9103 and IS:2645-1975 IS:2645 was used. Dosage used was 1% by weight of cement. • Glass powder: Obtained by crushing the waste glass in a cone crusher mill and sieved through 600 micron sieve was used. • Steel el fibres: Corrugated steel fibres of length=40 mm, width=2.2 mm, thickness=0.5 mm and aspect ratio=80 were used. • The mix design has been carried out for M20 grade as per IS 10262-1982 10262 1982 and mix proportion is 0.45 : 1: 1.34: 3.2 6 TEST RESULTS Table 1 shows the experimental test results for workability, initial & final setting time and compressive strength of steel fibre reinforced concrete (SFRC) with 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and 40% replacement of cement by glass powder. It also indicates the percentage increase increase or decrease in compressive strength of concrete. Fig.1, Fig.2, Fig.3 and Fig.4 shows the graphical variation of slump, compaction factor, Vee Bee degree and compression strength of SFRC respectively for various percentage such as 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and and 40% replacement of cement by glass powder. % replacement of cement by waste glass powder Slump in mm Compaction factor Vee bee Initial degree setting in (sec.) time (min.) Final setting time (min.) Compressive % increase strength (fck) or decrease (MPa) in fck 0% 80 0.81 110 40 420 36.12 - 10% 100 0.82 70 42 425 37.54 +4 20% 125 0.84 60 48 440 41.91 +16 30% 115 0.83 68 52 450 39.53 +9 40% 100 0.80 75 60 470 33.56 -7 Table 1: Workability, Initial & Final Setting time and Compressive Compressive strength test results of SFRC Fig.1: Variation of slump Fig.2: Variation of compaction factor S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande Fig.3: Variation of Vee Bee degree Fig.4: Variation of compressive compressive strength of SFRC Table 2 shows the experimental test results for tensile strength and flexural strength along with percentage increase or decrease in tensile and flexural strength for steel fibre reinforced concrete (SFRC) with 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% % and 40% replacement of cement by glass powder. Fig.5 and Fig.6 shows the graphical variation of tensile and flexural strength of SFRC respectively for 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and 40% replacement of cement by glass powder. % replacement of cement by glass powder Tensile strength(MPa) % increase or decrease in tensile strength Flexural strength(MPa) % increase or decrease in flexural strength 0%(Ref. mix) 5.93 - 6.10 - 10% 6.09 +3 6.74 +10 20% 6.64 +12 7.42 +22 30% 6.49 +9 6.18 +1 40% 5.84 -2 5.44 -11 Table 2: Results of tensile strength and flexural strength Fig.5: Variation of tensile strength of SFRC Fig.6: Variation of flexural strength of SFRC S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande Table 3 shows the experimental test results for average impact energy and percentage increase or decrease in impact energy required to cause first crack and final failure with respect to reference mix for 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and 40% replacement of cement by glass powder. Fig.7 shows the graphical variation variation of impact strength of SFRC for 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and 40% replacement of cement by glass powder. Percentage replacement of cement by glass powder Average impact energy required to cause (N (N-m) first crack final failure first crack final failure 0%(Ref. mix) 4551.16 4945.42 - - 10% 5166.66 5385.16 +14 +9 20% 5823.83 6325.65 +28 +28 30% 5443.42 5955.25 +20 +20 40% 4952.33 5830.75 +9 +18 Percentage increase or decrease in impact energy with respect to reference mix. Table 3: Results of impact strength Fig.7: Variation of impact strength of SFRC 7 THEORETICAL FORMULATION The mathamatical formulation for calculation of compressive compressiv strength, tensile strength, flexural strength and impact strength is developed as follows, Mathematical modeling for compressive strength σcus = 0.96(4E-05x4 - 0.0036x3 + 0.0924x2 - 0.444x + 36.089) Where σcus = Compressive strength of steel fibre reinforced concrete Mathematical modeling for tensile strength σts = 0.96(4E-06x4 - 0.0004x3 + 0.0116x2 - 0.0602x + 5.9282) Where σts = Tensile strength of steel fibre reinforced concrete Mathematical modeling for flexure strength σfs = 0.98(4E-06x4 - 0.0003x3 + 0.0033x2 + 0.0724x + 6.0722) Where σfs = Flexural strength of steel fibre reinforced concrete S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande Mathematical modeling for impact strength σis = 0.98(0.0031x4 - 0.295x3 + 6.9876x2 + 12.956x + 4924.6) Where σis = Impact strength of steel fibre reinforced concrete x = Percentage replacement of cement by waste glass powder 8 TEST RESULTS OF SFRC CONTAINING WASTE GLASS POWDER AS POZZOLANA WHEN SUBJECTED TO SUSTAINED ELEVATED TEMPERATURES For the resistance to sustained elevated temperature, specimens after 60 days of curing were transferred to an oven where in a temperature of 300˚C and 550˚C was maintained for 12 hours. Before transferring them into the oven they were weighed accurately. After subjecting them to 300˚C and 550˚C for 12 hours they were cooled and again weighed accurately. The percentage weight loss was calculated and the specimens were tested for their respective strengths. Table 4, 5, and 6 shows results for copmressive, tensile and flexural strength respectively for SFRC subjected to 0˚c, 300˚C for 12 hours and 550˚C for 12 hours with 0%, 10%, 20%, 30%, 40% and 50% replacement of cement by glass powder. % replaceme nt of cement by glass powder 0% SFRC without subjecting to temp Compressi % ve strength increas (MPa) e or decreas e of comp strength 36.12 - SFRC subjected to 300˚C for 12 hours SFRC subjected to 550˚C for 12 hours Average Comp Percentag % Average Comp % % percentag strengt e decreas percentag strengt increas decreas e weight h increase e of e weight h e or e of loss (MPa) or comp loss (MPa) decreas comp decrease strength e of strength of comp comp strength strength 7.77 35.53 2 8.58 33.27 8 10% 37.54 +4 6.78 35.93 +1 5 7.45 35.09 +5 7 20% 41.91 +16 6.10 40.44 +14 4 7..27 38.65 +16 8 30% 39.53 +9 6.39 38.33 +8 3 7.49 36.44 +9 8 40% 33.56 -7 6.60 30.06 -15 10 7.85 29.61 -11 12 50% 32.22 -11 7.06 28.44 -20 12 8.12 27.77 -17 14 Table 4: Results of compressive strength % replaceme nt of cement by glass powder SFRC without subjecting to temp Tensil % e increas strengt e or h decrea (MPa) se of tensile strengt h SFRC subjected to 300˚C for 12 hours Average Tensil percenta e ge weight strengt loss h (MPa) % increas e or decrea se of tensile strengt h SFRC subjected to 550˚C for 12 hours % Average Tensil decreas percenta e e of ge weight strengt tensile loss h strength (MPa) when subject ed to temp. 25 9.76 3.73 % increas e or decrea se of tensile strengt h % decreas e of tensile strength when subject ed to temp. 37 0% 5.93 - 7.94 4.45 10% 6.09 +3 6.60 4.90 +10 20 8.22 3.93 +5 35 20% 6.64 +12 6.17 5.28 +19 20 7.59 4.71 +26 29 30% 6.49 +9 6.71 5.04 +13 22 7.64 4.45 +19 31 40% 5.84 -2 7.33 4.62 +4 21 8.60 3.42 -8 41 50% 5.73 -3 7.47 4.48 -1 22 9.65 3.25 -13 43 Table 5: Results of tensile strength S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande % SFRC without SFRC subjected to 300˚C for 12 hours SFRC subjected to 550˚C 550 for 12 hours subjecting to replaceme nt of temp cement by Flexur % Average Flexur % % Average Flexur % % glass al al increas percenta al increas decreas percenta increas decreas powder strengt e or e or e of ge weight strengt e or e of ge weight strengt h decreas loss h decreas flexural loss h decreas flexural (MPa) e of e of strength (MPa) e of strength (MPa) flexural flexural when flexural when strength strength subjecte strength subjecte d to d to temp. temp. 0% 6.10 7.95 4.70 23 8.79 3.70 39 10% 6.74 +10 7.36 4.90 25 27 8.15 3.90 +5 42 20% 7.42 +22 6.09 5.40 +15 27 6.57 4.60 +24 38 30% 6.18 6.51 5.00 +6 19 7.36 4.00 +8 35 +1 40% 5.44 -11 7.56 4.80 +2 12 7.75 3.90 +5 28 50% 5.00 -18 7.79 4.60 -2 8 8.15 3.62 -2 28 Table 6: Results of flexural strength Graph 8, 9 & 10 shows graphical variation of copmressive, tensile and flexural strength respectively for SFRC subjected to 0˚c, 300˚C ˚C for 12 hours and 550˚C for 12 hours with 0%, 10%, 20%, 20% 30%, 40% and 50% replacement of cement by glass powder. Fig.8: Variation of compressive strength of SFRC with & without subjecting to sustained elevated temperature Fig.9: Variation of tensile strength of SFRC with & without subjecting to sustained ed elevated temperature Fig 10: Variation of flexural strength of SFRC with and without subjecting to sustained elevated temperature S.M. Chikhalikar and S.N. Tande 8 CONCLUSIONS The following conclusions are drawn based on the experimental results: 1. The 20% replacement of cement by waste glass powder will result in higher strengths for SFRC. 2. The 20% replacement of cement by waste glass powder gives better workability to SFRC. 3. The initial setting time and final setting time increases with the increase in percentage replacement of cement by waste glass powder 4. The mathematical equations can be used to find the strengths of SFRC 5. Higher strengths can be achieved when 20% cement is replaced by glass powder in SFRC. 6. The 20% replacement of cement by glass powder in SFRC induce better resistance to sustained elevated temperature of 300˚C for 12 hours 7. The 20% replacement of cement by glass powder in SFRC induce better resistance to sustained elevated temperature of 550˚C for 12 hours 8. Strength properties will be seriously affected when SFRC produced by replacing cement by glass powder is subjected to sustained elevated temperature of 550˚C for 12 hours. 9. The use of glass powder as pozzolana can be recommended where the steel fibre reinforced concrete structures are subjected to a temperature range of 300˚C to 550˚C such as ovens. REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] Meyer C, Egosi N. and Andela C., Concrete with waste glass as aggregate, Proceedings of ICFRC International Symposium Concrete Technology Unit of ASCE and University of Dundee, March 2001. Bin Mu and Christian Meyer, Flexural behavior of fiber mesh-reinforced glass aggregate concrete, ACI Material Journal, Septemer-October 2002, pp 425-433 Christian Meyer, Glass concrete, Concrete International, June 2003, pp 55-58. Ahmad Shayan and Aimin Xu, Value-added utilization of waste glass in concrete, Cement and Concrete Research 34(2004) 81-89. Byars E.A., Zhu H.Y. and Morales B. (2004), Conglasscrete I ,The Waste & Resources Action Programme, March 2004, www.wrap.org.uk. Ravindra Dhir, Tomdyer, Albert tang and Yongjun cui, Towards maximizing the value and sustainable use of glass, The Waste & Resources Action Programme, January 2004, www.wrap.org.uk. Caijun Shi and Yanzhong Wu, Mixture proportioning and properties of self-consolidating lightweight concrete containing glass powder, ACI Material Journal, Septemer-October 2002, pp 355-363. Chi Sing Lam, Chi Sun Poon and Dixon Chan, Enhancing the performance of pre-cast concrete blocks by incorporating waste glass - ASR consideration, Cement and Concrete Composites 29(2007) 616-625 Ziad Bayasi and Henning Kaiser., Steel Fibres as Crack arrestors in Concrete, The Indian Concrete Journal, March2001, pp.215-219. De Gutierrez R.M., Diaz L.N. and Delvasto S., Effect of pozzolans on the performance of fiberreinforced mortars, Cement and Concrete Composites 27 (2005) pp 593-598 B.R. Patagundi and K.B. Prakash, Effect of chloride and sulphate attack on the properties of concrete containing waste glass powder as pozzolana, Indian Concrete Journal, Dec. 2008 nd Nemkumar Banthia, Fiber Reinforced Concrete, proc.,2 interanational symp.Concrete technonlogy for Sustainable development with Emphasis on Infrastructure, Hyderabad ,India feb27 to March3 , 2005.pp.333-349. IS : 10262-1982 “Recommended guide line for concrete mix design”. SP 23: 1982 Hand book on concrete mixes IS 456:2000 Plain and Reinforced Concrete-Code of practice IS 9013:1978 Method of making, curing and determining compressive strength of cured concrete test specimen.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz