Table of Contents Introduction……………………………………………………………………........1 Industry Overview………………………………………………………………2-8 Client Profile & Competitor Analysis……………………………………9-17 Comparative Analysis……………………………………………………….18-19 Consumer Analysis………………………………………………………….20-23 Consumer Insights………………………………………………………….24-29 Survey…………………………………………………………………………….30-31 Results……………………………………………………………………………32-41 Recommendations…………………………………………………………..42-45 Appendix I……………………………………………………………………..46-48 Appendix II………………………………………………………………….…49-55 References………………………………………………………………………56-57 Will Haven, Lucy Ross, Jessica Stephens, Lauren West & Bonnie Willard Redbox is leading the way in the premier industry of DVD rental kiosks. With Coinstar as its established parent company, redbox is currently surpassing its competitors with its number of self-service kiosks. Redbox’s growing popularity is facilitated by its physical distribution, which places the kiosk in high traffic locations such as WalMart, Kroger, McDonalds and Walgreens. Due to redbox’s standing as the progressive option for DVD rental, its decision to target the 18-24 year old demographic was evident. This demographic embodies the idea of innovation, experimentation, and dependency on technology, all of which are imperative to transform an introductory product into a nationwide brand. The following report provides secondary and primary research in order to construct an accurate glimpse of redbox and its emergent status within the 18-24 year old target market of the DVD rental industry. This report includes the description and results of eighty self-administered surveys completed by samples of the target market. Based on an analysis of these results, the report concludes with recommendations designed to assist redbox in more effectively reaching its 18-24 year old target market. 1|Page Industry Size: aspects of competition, the prices throughout Revenue & Product Life Cycle the entire industry were forced to drop. This also explains why DVD, GAME & VIDEO RENTAL MARKET DVD, Game, and Video Rental Revenue 12000 the number of units sold increased but the revenue has continued to decrease (1). The heightened competition can be predicted to cause an improvement in the PLC 10000 stage of the DVD, Game, and Video Rental 8000 6000 Revenue in Millions of Dollars 4000 2000 2014 2011 2008 2005 0 Graph 1, Source: (1) As shown in Graph 1, the estimated Industry as well. Prices are lower and new innovations are being introduced causing increases competition. Once kiosks become more successful and begin to gain its own loyal customer base it could single-handedly cause the industry to revert back to the maturity stage of the PLC. size of market in 2010 is $7. 724 billion. The DVD RENTALS pattern of revenue over the past five years has shown a constant annual decrease. It is also Number of DVD Rentals predicted to decrease in the following five years. The graph shows that the DVD, game, and video rental industry is currently in the decline stage of the product life cycle (PLC). The pressures of competition cause the 200 Number of DVD Rentals in Millions 100 0 2000 2002 2004 2006 decline. Not only were more brick-and-mortar companies beginning and lowering their Graph 2, Source: (1) prices, new methods of selling caused From 2000 until 2005 the industry was increasingly high competition in other ways. steadily growing because it was a new product Companies like Netflix emerged and cable and being introduced to the market and new satellite companies began marketing video competitors were being introduced as well. streaming. In order to keep up with the many Thus, prices were lower and the demand was 2|Page higher. During 2005 and 2006 the number of cycle. At this point, sales revenue is DVD rentals leveled off showing that it was at continuing to rise while competitors are its mature stage in the PLC. However, in 2007 entering the market. However, redbox has to the graph shows a decline to a value of 171.2 approach its marketing and advertising in a million DVD rentals. This shows evidence of way to attract new customers detract from its new competitors and the oncoming recession competitors (2). of the economy beginning in 2008 (2). Video Rental Kiosk According to Adams Media Research, “Kiosk rental sales are expected to rise 42% to $1.3 billion this year” (3). The total number of DVD rental kiosks in 2007 was 10, 000. In 2012 there is predicted to be 50,000 kiosks. Over the course of five years the industry is predicted to grow by five times its size (2). The amount of DVD rental revenue in Graph 3, Source: (58) 2007 that came from kiosks was $200-250 million. The revenue is expected to reach $1.5-2 billion in 2012 (2). During the years 2007 -2012 as shown in graph 3 the market for DVD rental kiosks will be in the growth stage of the product life cycle. At this point, sales revenue is continuing to rise while competitors are entering the market (2). The new technology, affordability and convenient locations make kiosks a pertinent aspect in the future of the changing DVD, Game, and Video Rental Market. During the years 2007 -2012 redbox will be in the growth stage of the product life 3|Page Competitors Thousands Number of Establishments the consumer can retrieve DVDs. The internet has broadened the area in which the consumer can attain his or her DVD (1). With 21 this in mind, research proves that the DVD 20.5 20 rental industry has a new standard: being 19.5 integrated with the internet. 19 Integration and the constant 18.5 18 Units availability of movies have created the next 17.5 generation of the movie rental industry (1). 17 This development increases convenience to the consumer, thus allowing these companies 16.5 16 to lead the industry. Dependence on the 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 internet allows Graph 4, Source: (1) consumers Redbox Competitors Kiosk to stream Blockbuster video Express Retail Movie Gallery Blockbuster Hollywood Video Stores Online Netflix iTunes Cable Encore HBO Mail Netflix Blockbuster Video On- Amazon AT&T Showtime straight to Factbox: 75% of Coinstar’s capital expenditures in 2009 were for redbox kiosks 51. his or her . PC and television. The improvements in technology makes it difficult for new Dish Network Demand companies or brands to enter the market if they are lacking in this area. Yet another area Exhibit 1 Competition within the DVD rental in which technology has become a determining aspect is self-service kiosks(1). industry is very stiff. The reason for such Not only is the competition based around the competition lies in the fact that the industry is convenience of the internet, it has also cutting-edge. As shown in Exhibit 1, there are become vital that companies offer consumer- numerous competitors within the market of friendly interactive technology. The fact that DVD rental but there is only room for a select the majority of the companies offer such few to shine. With the introduction of new innovative ideas to the consumer, such as self- technology, there are numerous ways in which service DVD rental kiosks, make it difficult for 4|Page competitors to enter the market without such and products. Redbox customers are no advancements. exception to this movement and are actively Looking back at the competition seeking quicker, more streamline results. The within the DVD rental industry, research self-service kiosks provide this modern feel states that it is based heavily on technology through instantaneous results. Redbox meets (1). Much of this industry is becoming its customers’ request for time flexibility via cutting-edge and is up-to-date with the 24-7 operational hours unlike the current technology like that of almost confinement of regular store times. This everything for advancement eliminates interactions with the consumer. employees which allow customer control over Given that the their own transactions (2). consumer today Also, redbox recognizes that the has an current recession continues to influence the innovative cultural environment in the U.S. consumers nature and that are searching for affordable desires entertainment are responsive to the concept convenience and new products, it is only of $1-per-night DVD rentals. The largest fitting that the DVD rental industry be percentage of such DVD rental consumers are complimentary to the consumer’s needs. cited by IBIS World as middle and high income households because their purchasing Social/Cultural Implications Redbox has successfully pegged two abilities are higher than the average household (1). Redbox is meeting this social vital facets concerning the average American segment by consumer: technological advancement and positioning affordability. The DVD rental industry has their always been based on the concept of low-cost kiosks in home entertainment, but redbox kiosks have routine taken that idea further and molded it to fit the locations current cultural environment in the U.S. for the With the continuous outburst of technology, the American consumer has come target market such as Wal-Mart, Kroger, McDonalds and Walgreens (2). to demand immediate access to information 5|Page Economic Environment Despite slight increases in the GDP, the American economic status continues to reflect the effects of the recent recession. The most recent release Factbox: 29% of redbox users generate a total household salary of $60-100k 53. shows that in the fourth quarter of 2009, the GDP increased at an annual rate of 5.9% (11). The Consumer Price Index stands at 202.416, up .616 from December 2009 (40). Unemployment slid from 10.0 in December 2009 to 9.7 in January 2010(41). The Consumer Confidence Interval for January 2010 is at 55.9, up from 53.6 in December (42). The consumer confidence has two components: the present situation index and the expectation index. Any reading about the recession, and this growth trend is predicted to continue into 2010 (43). Redbox in particular has taken the initiative of creating a brand that pinpoints the cautious consumer with $1 per night rentals (2). Analysts attribute the increased popularity of the DVD rental market to $1 per night rental kiosks (43). The cost conscious consumer is able to not only receive an initial low price for the DVD but also to personally determine the amount of overage charges (2). January 2010 Economic Statistics Gross Domestic Product Consumer Price Index Consumer Confidence Interval Unemployment Rate Increased at an annual rate of 5.9% according to the fourth quarter of 2009 report. 202.416 (Up from 201.8 in December 2009) 55.9 (Up from 53.6 in December 2009) 9.7 (Down from 10.0 in December 2009.) Exhibit 2, Source: (6) Regulatory and Legal Issues The Entertainment Merchants 90 is considered a strongly positive outlook on the economy. While these figures do Association (EMA) regulates the DVD rental indicate an increase, they are still a far cry industry. According to the EMA’s public from the CCI’s prior to the recession. This policy, it states reveals that consumers are still weary of the that its priority is stability in the economy and are not as to execute the confident in their purchases. Frugality has first sale doctrine that protects the DVD moved into a more primary position within rental retailer’s rights to sell and/or rent the consumers’ minds. lawfully made copies without any limitations. The DVD rental market has found a The association also provides enforcement of niche within these economic difficulties as movie ratings that include restrictions being the affordable entertainment option. provided by Motion Picture Association of According to Standard & Poor’s, there has America (MPAA) concerning violent material been an increase between DVD rentals and (18). 6|Page Given permission by the U.S. Constitution, Congress has the authority to making copies of DVDs and re-selling them under a non-licensed business. ratify Section 109 of the Copyright Act that the code of the first sale of doctrine is codified Factbox: Redbox is among the top 10 credit-card processors in the country 54. in. The first sale Technological Developments Technological developments have doctrine gives the played a crucial role in the DVD rental DVD rental industry industry in the past six years. DVD consumer independence to spending has opened a new market in the rent and/or sell from industry creating a sales concern for rental the copyright holder retail stores with the introduction of user that includes no obstructions. The Copyright friendly and cost saving rental kiosks, such as Act further explains how digital media also redbox. The self-service kiosks provide a $1- applies (19). per-night rental rate, having the brick-and- For the past 22 years, the EMA has mortar retailers running for their money (28). placed a parental empowerment program Blockbuster has started their own rental kiosk amongst the sales of DVDs in the rental program to affiliate themselves with the new industry. The policy states that the sales of technological advancement (30). “R”-rated movies in the DVD rental industry The developments of digital are prohibited under the age of 17 without the downloading and on-demand rental services, consent of a legal guardian (19). problems and opportunities have risen for the An implication the DVD kiosk industry DVD rental industry. Advancements such as faces is consumer responsibility of age video-streaming movie appropriate legal consent using a self-service rental, by companies like kiosk. The kiosks prompts if one is over 17- Amazon and Netflix, years-old when it is applicable to a sale, but provide in-home have no way to identify and control the sales convenience for renters. By obtaining a to minors who agree to the terms and use the subscription membership to the parent service without a legal guardian. The sale of company, video-streaming rentals are an “R”-rated movie has then been made, unlimited based on the company’s movie which is against EMA policy. Another libraries for one monthly fee. This technology implication of the industry is the act of creates another area for competition to the consumers purchasing and unlawfully DVD rental industry (21, 29). 7|Page In November 2009, redbox announced self- maintained, hence retailers avoiding a test site in partnership with Sonic Solutions' additional employee wages. Also because the Roxio CinemaNow that allows frequent devices are self-sufficient, they provide redbox consumers to be given vouchers to excellent customer service avoiding any acquire digital downloading movie delivery human error and satisfactory purchases (2). providing more efficient customer service in Growth will undoubtedly occur with hopes of starting their own digital delivery this self-service and video streaming business (20). movement but also in the works is the ability Redbox and Blockbuster Express have to digitally download and transfer movies on taken advantage of the Blu-ray movement and to SD cards or memory sticks. Rather than have contributed the new disk form of DVD having a physical rental into their kiosks. Redbox started this disk, renters will be able to download movies service at the end of 2008 selling for the very from a kiosk and plug them into their own same price as a regular DVD at $1. home entertainment systems (23). Blockbuster Express rents Blu-ray for $2-pernight (22, 30). The industry has found this new opportunity to have long-term effects because it decreases the chances of having physical Growth Potential & Opportunities Through ever expanding problems with their products. The SD cards will be effective in the sense that consumers developments comes potential and will no longer worry about inconvenient opportunities for growth in the DVD rental defects with the products such as nicks and industry. Now is the time for redbox to be a scratches. Also the part of the market because the average DVD kiosk retailer consumer will enjoy the benefits of obtaining will no longer have a product faster, having 24-7 access, self– the concern over non- servicing convenience, and enjoying the use of returned DVDs technology on the rise. Not only is redbox shortening their cosmetically trendy, making it attractive to supply. The the consumer eye, but it also presents further advantages of this appeal for prospective retailers. The self- new break will open servicing kiosks allure additional foot traffic even further outlets for consumer viewing like into stores increasing its revenue with the cell phones and other portal devices that are extra service it provides. The kiosks are also adapted to the SD card method (27). 8|Page Client and Key Competitors The evolving DVD rental industry is an night price, Blockbuster Express has the advantage of a loyal customer base aggressive market with competitors vying for versus redbox’s brand name which is strong customer bases. Companies are independent from its parent company, attempting to meet the Coinstar. Netflix also consumer demands of contends for a top spot in convenience, up to date the industry. Netflix technology and bypasses tangible affordable prices DVDs renting revenue to through diverse means provide online video- such as brick-and- streaming that has shaken mortar stores, kiosks, the DVD rental market mailing services and online video-treaming. since its commencement. Netflix’s in home Since redbox has opted to develop its brand in streaming concept replaces the hassle of DVD the up-and-coming kiosk realm, its key return dates and travel time of an alternative competitors must also be comparatively kiosk experience with the ability to download innovative. Blockbuster Express and Netflix movies onto personal computers or are following the redbox innovation televisions through internet connection. movement. Blockbuster Express, a self-service kiosk branch of the parent company Blockbuster, is working to increase its number of kiosk locations. Although Blockbuster Express and redbox kiosks share the same premise of convenience and $1-per 9|Page Redbox Brand Snapshot - - Concept originated in 2002 within McDonald’s Ventures, LLC, which was working to identify new ways to drive traffic to McDonald’s and provide added convenience to consumers First market test launched in 2004 in Denver, Colorado-area McDonald’s restaurants In November 2005, Coinstar, Inc. announced an agreement with McDonald’s Ventures, LLC, to invest in redbox. The agreement gave Coinstar a 47.3 percent share of the company and made redbox a separate company from McDonald’s In February 2009, Coinstar announced its intent to purchase the remaining stake of redbox from McDonald’s and other minority interest holders. Parent company Coinstar, Inc. is headquartered in Bellevue, Washington Coinstar, Inc. was founded in early 1991 Redbox’s top five accounts as of June 2009 are: 1) Walmart 2) McDonalds 3) Walgreen’s 4) Supervalu 5) Ahold Blockbuster Express Brand Snapshot - Blockbuster was founded in 1985. Blockbuster is headquartered in Dallas, Texas. Blockbuster and NCR Corporation released Blockbuster Express kiosks 2008. Quickly rolling out to as many as 10,000 locations in 2010. Can be found in some of the top grocery, convenient and drug stores in the U.S. Netflix Brand Snapshot - Netflix was founded in 1997. Netflix is headquartered in Los Gatos, California. The company offers over 90,000 DVD rentals for rent. In 2007, began offering a movie download and viewing by PC service Reached 12.3 million subscribers by the end of 2009 Exhibit 3, Sources: 10, 28, 29, 30, 49, 50 10 | P a g e Size Sales Revenue Redbox is in the growth stage of the PLC. At this point people are trying the 1600 product so the sales revenue and locations 1200 are continuing to rise. Competitors are also 1000 beginning to enter the market. However, 800 redbox entered the market after Netflix, 600 forcing Netflix to enter the maturity stage of the PLC. In the maturity stage the Revenue ($) 1400 Net Flix Revenue in Millions Redbox Revenue in Millions 400 200 0 awareness of Netflix has reached its limit 2006 2007 2008 2009 and the sales have started to stabilize. Blockbuster Express is currently Graph 4, Sources: 4, 7, 8, 15, 16 *Blockbuster Express is expected to be profitable in 2011 entering the market in the introduction Locations stage. There is a considerably smaller 25000 locations and no 20000 Blockbuster Express is 10000 Blockbuster Express Kiosk Locations 5000 currently trying 2006 0 to raise awareness of its brand in order to encourage potential consumers to try its new renting Graph 5, Sources: 2, 9, 10,12, 13, 14, 15 *No physical location numerical data is available for Netflix video-streaming outlet. This is more difficult since they have direct competition with redbox Netflix Outlets who is already established in the market. Blockbuster Express has to find innovative 2010 statistics. Redbox Kiosk Locations 15000 2009 stable revenue Kiosk Locations 2008 The first drive-up redbox kiosks started at a Denver, Colorado McDonalds Drive-Thru 56. number of 2007 Factbox: Digital Playing Consoles Devices Digital Video Recorders ways to compete with redbox through price, LG Electronics Microsoft’s Xbox 360 placement, promotions, and other Samsung’s Blu-ray Sony’s PS3 competitive strategies. Roku TIVo Nintendo’s Wii Exhibit 4, Source: 4 11 | P a g e Redbox needs to ensure that it does not lose customers to Blockbuster Express or Netflix. Since Blockbuster Express is a more direct competitor redbox needs to take advantage of being in the market first in order to retain the customers loyal to its brand. Obtaining customers complications of because Netflix they are cause already committed subscribers. Blockbuster Express is a direct source of competition for redbox. Concerning locations of the two DVD kiosk companies, redbox far exceeds the opposition. Blockbuster Express is just entering the market and is unable to compete through number of locations yet. They have a strong and loyal customer base from the brick-andmortar foundation of the company which could eventually make them more successful than redbox. However, since redbox has already managed to issue contracts with the locations they currently occupy it will be hard for Blockbuster Express to gain the advantage over redbox. Netflix, Inc. is the world's largest subscription service streaming movies, which has accumulated more than 12 million subscribers (5). Despite the fact that Netflix is an existing company in the DVD, video and game rental industry, redbox’s revenue has soared past that of Netflix in the past year. This shows that redbox is creating serious competition in the market and growing successful at a rapid pace. These numbers are even more substantial considering the major advantage of Netflix’s subscriber base. It is more difficult for redbox to make sales from these dedicated Netflix users. Thus, reiterating the threat self-service kiosks cause to pre-existing companies in the market. The DVD rental industry began to enter the decline stage of the PLC during 2006 and 2007. The development of DVD rental kiosks can be predicted to take the industry back to the maturity stage of the PLC. Redbox is currently in the growth stage and is already beginning to positively affect the industry. The introduction of competitors will create a rise in DVD rentals because it will cause lower prices resulting in more purchases. 12 | P a g e Forecast Redbox and its competitors have ongoing plans to ensure growth and expansion. Redbox and Blockbuster Express are placing more kiosks in the market in hopes of increasing brand awareness and availability to consumers. Redbox exceeded its year-end projections and now has more than 22, 210 DVD rental kiosks (21) . Blockbuster acquired competitor DVDPlays 1,300 kiosks in the U.S. and Canada and will revamp them with the Blockbuster Express brand (21). Netflix is currently in negations with movie industry studios to secure access to more titles. “Netflix has a powerful brand and slick With the increasing number of streaming technology. But to stay relevant the company needs access to much more of the studios' digital content” (44). kiosks, brands are utilizing technologic advancements such as the application shown above to provide the consumer with a way to locate thousands kiosks in their area and also to view the DVD selection available within each kiosk. Factbox: A typical redbox kiosk in a grocery store accounts for approximately 480 visits a week, rental and returning. Of these trips, 52% are specifically to visit redbox 39. 13 | P a g e Marketing Mix Evaluation redbox Product Price Physical Promotion distribution DVD rental $1 DVD pernight Grocery stores: Kroger, WalMart, Publix, Winn-Dixie, Harris Teeter Coupons, special offers available with redbox online sign-up $1 Blu-ray per-night Drugstores: Walgreens, CVS iphone applications Fast-food restaurants: McDonalds Facebook & Twitter fan pages 150 new releases 350 classics No membership required. Reservation capabilities online. Blockbuster Express DVD rental Gas stations: Exxon Mobile 22,000 kiosks $1 pernight DVD Grocery stores: Brookshire, Food City, Bashas 900 available Drugstores: Deane Read No membership required. Reservation capabilities online. Netflix videostreaming $25 maximum fee Video streaming 17,000 available titles $2 per-night Blu-ray $25 maximum fee $9 monthly unlimited fee Some new releases Membership required Special offers available with Blockbuster express online sign-up 2,500 kiosks Facebook & Twitter fan pages PC One month free trial Mac Online codes TV through licensed contracted devices Facebook & Twitter fan pages Digital Playing devices Game consoles Digital Video Recorders: TiVo Exhibit 5, Sources: 4, 24, 25, 28, 29, 30, 57 Redbox has several marketing mix advantages over its competitors. Each of the three competitors products are similar by providing DVD consumers the same merchandise, but redbox has given consumers the most cost-effective options with an all-around $1 per-day strategy. Also, redbox provides a wider array of locations to physically find its kiosks compared to Blockbuster Express. In regards to promotion, all three competitors offer a number of outlets when considering incentives. 14 | P a g e Advertising As technology continues to be a vital part of the consumer’s life, there are many opportunities to enforce brand identity with companies such as redbox, Blockbuster Express, and Netflix via websites and other forms of media. For example, each of these products uses multiple means of advertising through Facebook, Twitter, and other media. According to Ad$pender, in 2008 redbox spent $289.00 on its total advertising while Netflix spent $67,414.20 on its combined areas of advertisement (35). Its figures are notable because although redbox does not have high advertisement expenditures or web publicity, its product is located where the desired consumer can see them easily. Redbox kiosks are located outside of Kroger, Walgreens, Walmart, and McDonald’s franchises. Redbox’s desired target market visits these locations on a regular basis, thus providing advertising without the need of a third party. Each of the competitors has established themselves on the internet with web pages that provide information to the potential renter. Redbox’s homepage is clear cut and uniformed. It has a uniform maroon coloring and is easy for the consumer to read and digest (28). Both Netflix and Blockbuster Express are also well put together, but are cluttered compared to redbox which can make it appear less professional to the desired consumer (29, 30). Redbox and Netflix are more established brands, thus Blockbuster Express is playing catch up in awareness. Another way to measure product popularity is through social media websites like Facebook and Twitter. Redbox has 43,783 fans on the main Facebook group page. While Blockbuster Express has only 266 fans (31, 33). In comparison, Netflix leads with 86,925 fans (32). Each of these products has a Twitter page as well. In addition to internet advertising, Netflix has commercials that can be viewed on YouTube or Hulu. One of the commercials with the 15 | P a g e most views is about a father and son who visit The official web sites of redbox and a stranger’s house and watch a Netflix movie. Blockbuster Express use a similar setup In a sense, Netflix provides a way for (28,30). Each highlight $1-per-night rental strangers to connect (34). Redbox and prices as well as the offer of a free DVD after Blockbuster do not offer commercials for signing up for weekly emails that provide viewing in these locations. YouTube is an updates and special ideal advertising placement because the video offers. Netflix is itself is free advertising. There is also room on currently offering a the sides of actual web pages to have free one-month trial of advertising. Netflix purchases these areas to DVD by mail and advertise, especially when the site is instant streaming promoting either redbox or Blockbuster (38). services (29). All three promotions are placed Netflix has also used Facebook to promote its on the forefront of the websites. In addition brand which could explain why they have a to its website, redbox is also exploiting cell noticeably larger number of fans phone usage by sending texts that advertise on Facebook. With one simple click the current deals (28). consumer is transferred from the website to the Netflix homepage. Facebook also has a young target market which makes it profitable for Netflix to advertise there. Netflix provides an easy delivery service for consumers who do not want to leave home. Promotion Redbox and its competitors are Public Relations Redbox is actively using public relations to keep its users informed about the recent disputes with the movie production industry. Redbox’s $1-per-night rental price caused many movie production companies to fear that a distribution deal with redbox will result in lower profits. Attempts to prohibit redbox from providing new releases to its following an increasing trend of utilizing web consumers by companies such as 20th Century based and social media tools to promote their Fox and Warner Home brands. These promotions center around Video are being met with lawsuits from themes of price points, free trials, and redbox. The official redbox site provides a updates. 16 | P a g e page of recent press releases that follow the image for their latest kiosk brand Blockbuster positive distribution deals with such Express. corporations as Summit Entertainment, Paramount Home Entertainment, NCircle Target Audiences Redbox and its competitors are all Entertainment, Lionsgate and Sony Pictures targeting the accompanying the preexisting struggles with psychographic of 20th Century Fox and Warner Home Video the convenience (10). seeking consumer Blogging has also become a popular Factbox: 44% of redbox users attend college 53. by promoting the form of new media public relations. Both idea of instant results without the hassle. redbox and Netflix offer a blogging segment Redbox and Blockbuster Express also narrow on their official websites. “Redblog” is a movie their audience by also targeting the price- critique forum written by three authors, conscious consumer through their $1-per- whose profiles appear on the site, where the night rental price, whereas Netflix appears to public is able to read movie reviews as well as be targeting families that are seeking at- comment with their own opinions (45) . “The home-entertainment and are able to commit Netflix Blog” provides to a stable payment plan. Also, Blockbuster current updates about technology and various Express is delving even further into the price- movie news effecting Netflix and also allows conscious consumer psychographic by placing for the customers’ interjections (46). its kiosks on college campuses (47). Another “The Blockbuster Corporate” web-page provides a news and public relations section important psychographic of all three competitors is that consumers are more that enables the company technologically savvy. Kiosks and instant to announce various video-streaming are fairly new developments updates such as new in the DVD rental industry and therefore releases, pre-order options of new releases, require an audience willing to experiment and quarterly fiscal reports for the parent with previously unfamiliar technology. They company (48). When compared to redbox are targeting this segment by advertising and Netflix, Blockbuster is lagging “innovation” through hotspots such as in communication advancements with its Twitter, Facebook and various blogs. customers, resulting in an underdeveloped 17 | P a g e Comparative Analysis The idea of kiosks is a cutting-edge breakthrough in the DVD rental industry. Redbox is the most impactful company in the current market. There are several traits of redbox, Blockbuster Express and Netflix video streaming that will and negative ways. Some key deciding strengths in these areas; however, its attempting to close the employee/customer checkouts. Also, while both its competitors offer 24-7 convenience, the broader base of kiosk locations gives redbox an edge. Cost-effective compared to Blockbuster significantly larger Express kiosks number of kiosks Blu-ray fees and Netflix’s available at grocery and convenience stores such No membership fee commitment compared to Netflix video-streaming. location and pricing. competitors are and errors that accompany monthly subscription. factors for customers Redbox has definite time. These kiosks also eliminate the hassle Redbox has a market in both positive include convenience, return the DVD at a more convenient Redbox’s Benefits influence the companies in the hindrances for the customer, allowing them to gap. redbox as Wal-Mart, Kroger and Walgreens. Another area in which Availability of redbox locations far exceed redbox is at the the number of locations that Blockbuster forefront of the industry Express has distributed. is through its Redbox’s variety of promotional tools positioning as the surpasses Netflix video-streaming and economically friendly rental company. Blockbuster Express. Redbox offers a $1-per Redbox provides customer convenience, which is one of the primary premises of the self-service kiosk industry. It is accomplishing this through 24-7 kiosks that are available beyond typical store hour constraints. The extended hours and elimination of return rates causes fewer night rental price. This system allows the customer to determine their charges based on when they return the DVD. Despite all its advantages, redbox does lack the established customer base and wide DVD variety that its competitors possess. 18 | P a g e Blockbuster Express Blockbuster Express is redbox’s most similar competitor. It $1-per-night rental is also confined to the single device that the Redbox’s Weaknesses also offers convenient 24-7 kiosks as well as available in any internet connected space, but DVD selection available per redbox kiosk movie was downloaded to thereby losing the mobility that a DVD possesses. While it addresses the pricing. Blockbuster is approximately only 55% of what a Express’ strength is the Blockbuster Express kiosk can hold. encounters limitations Majority of redbox kiosks are placed because only 12% of this from its parent inside locations, such as grocery online library is company, Blockbuster. stores, making 24-7 availability limited available for brand loyalty inherited Consumers may be more comfortable using this brand because they to only outside kiosk locations. Since online streaming is not an demand for convenience, it streaming (57) Also, many customers have are already familiar with available option with redbox, the the company. company cannot reach additional flaws with video customers with the service that Netflix streaming making it does provide. less desirable despite Advertisements for redbox are heightened convenience. In However in comparison to redbox, Blockbuster Express is lagging in its number of kiosk locations, offering less availability to its extremely limited in comparison to Blockbuster and Netflix. customers which could be considered a weakness. Netflix Netflix offers a different approach than redbox and Blockbuster Express with its noticed quality regards to price, Netflix rental system requires a monthly subscription for $9.00 which includes unlimited downloads for that period. While Netflix’s higher price may discourage frugal customers, it promotes a more loyal customer base. in-home streaming of movies. Netflix streaming has the advantage of being 19 | P a g e Movie Renters In the past few years, researchers have studied the spending habits of DVD rental users. In general, Americans who rent movies more often are more likely to see films within the first two weeks of release (37). Simmons went on to report that from those who watch movies in the first two weeks, they will then rent from Blockbuster, Hollywood Video, and Netflix (37). Redbox, in particular, has been steadily increasing its amount of rentals. Its target market, according to NPD demographic, reports that 52% of redbox’s consumers are female, 63% have at least one child, and 51% have a household of at least four people (39). These figures are parallel to the product placement that redbox uses. By placing its kiosks outside of regularly visited stores such as Wal-mart, Walgreens, and Kroger, redbox draws families and generates business for the retailers as well (39). Redbox provides an easy and convenient one-stopshop for families on the go to rent a movie for one night, or more if they wish (36). The way redbox allocates their pricing is profitable because two nights of redbox is still cheaper than a new release at Blockbuster. In the past year, the amount of people renting from DVD kiosks has grown by almost 50%. According to Simmons, redbox and its dvd kiosk competitors are keeping pace with Netflix’s rental growth (36). Along with redbox, Blockbuster Express is installing self-service kiosks in grocery stores, drug stores and other locations. The parent company predicts Blockbuster Express will have up to 10,000 working kiosks by the end of 2010. While Blockbuster Express was growing, the foot traffic of Blockbuster dropped 16% in the last year. In addition to less store action, there was relatively no noticeable increase of online renters, which then lead to the many store closings (36). While Blockbuster was not improving, Netflix was growing. As Simmons Research reported, “As of October 12, 2009 Netflix.com had almost three times as many as monthly visitors as Blockbuster.com” (36). Netflix is the third most popular way of renting among consumers who watch movies within two weeks of opening weekend (37). 20 | P a g e DVD Kiosk Customer The population of 18-24 year olds in the According to the 2007 TNR Survey Findings: Grocery retail-based DVD rental kiosks have broad consumer appeal among men and women of all ages and life stage classifications, especially those 30 to 54 years of age and families with children. The rental kiosk value proposition to consumers is simple and compelling, driven by both lower movie rental costs and unmatched convenience -- the "single trip" benefit. Reflecting the growth potential for the kiosk market, awareness is still developing -- approximately 1/3 of all consumers surveyed indicated awareness of the self-serve DVD kiosk concept, but only 5% of the respondents had rented through one. Awareness and rental usage in more developed markets is substantially higher. Kiosk adopters would most likely migrate from Exhibit 7, Source: 52 and mortar" rental sources to the traditional "brick grocery or rental kiosk. Over 1/3 of DVD renters are frequent grocery shoppers, many visiting their grocery store on a daily basis. U.S. in the year 2010 is 30,163,000 and increases annually until it peaks in 2013 at 30,575,000 people. For the next four years the population of 18-24 year-olds will continue to rise. Consequently, redbox will most likely remain in the growth stage of the PLC during this time. In the year 2014, when the population of the age group begins to decline redbox could expect to enter the maturity stage of the PLC. During this decline period, redbox should tailor its selling strategies to align lifestyles of its target market. Lifestyles of the average 1824 year olds tend to be fast-paced and economically restricted. For example, redbox could execute two-for –one rental periods. Target Market Size This way redbox can be reassured of gaining profits even at this stage of decline. Total US Population of 18-24 Years Old 30,800 30,600 Total US Population of 18-24 Years Old in Thousands 30,400 30,200 30,000 29,800 2010 2012 2014 Graph 6, Source: 17 21 | P a g e Target Market & Entertainment-Related Behavior Movie Genres Rented on DVD % Action/Adventure Animation Comedy Drama Family Horror Musical Romance Sci Fi Suspense Thriller Urban Online Activites in the Past 30 Days Download Music Files Play/Download Online Games Watching Streaming Video (TV/MVIE-LKE BRDST) Rent Video Games Usually Rent Video Games 39 14 42 31 30 21 6.62 20 13 7.97 19 14 60% of the target market that is utilizing the internet to download or stream their daily usage items such as music, online games and TV. This indicates that the target market is comfortable and willing to explore innovative technology that meets their wants. Outlook for redbox Through the consumer analysis research, the target market of 18-24 year olds would be a successful segmentation to pursue. The outlook is desirable because of redbox’s predicted steady growth and maturity stage of the PLC for the next several years. According to the its marketing mix, advertising and 29 21 9.77 promotional tactics will be most beneficial in order to gain 18-24 year olds brand loyalty for when redbox enters the maturity stage. This desired consumer is a part of the most highly connected age group (26). The number of 9 Exhibit 9, Source: 6 According to Exhibit 9, redbox should concentrate on providing more comedy and action/adventure DVDs in its kiosks since these are the two most rented genres by the target market of 18-24 year olds. The data also denotes that redbox should investigate online rental options as implied by the nearly users for social media outlets that redbox has, such as Facebook and Twitter, skyrocket amongst this target market and redbox should use them constructively. Also, with the multitude of physical distribution locations that the target market comes across, the lucrative product will be profitable. With the use of technology, 22 | P a g e redbox can take advantage of DVD Has the target market grown up in a movie-renting household? product distribution Is movie night a family affair? with its cutting edge What makes this desired market choose equipment and the use of promotional tools to one genre over another? draw in this particular audience and have them as brand loyal customers. Does the target market like snacking while watching movie rentals? Does target market want a one-stop, convenient DVD rental pickup that also Next Steps fulfills multiple needs? Research is necessary to uncover why Rent alone? Or in groups? Netflix and Blockbuster customers have not Is renting associated with activities? switched to redbox and then attempt to Cooking? Dating? Exercise? capture those consumer interests. In order to gain further insight into the 18- 24 year old market and their beliefs, attitudes and decision- making process related to renting movies, we recommend that further research address the following: Spending behaviors of target market How often does the target market watch movies? Weekly? Monthly? Daily? How would target market prefer to obtain movie rentals? Self-serve? Online? What are 18-24 year olds means of transportation? Walking? Bus? Personal car? Friends? What time of day does target market usually make the decision to rent movies? Morning? Noon? Evening? Midnight? 23 | P a g e Overview In the spring of 2010, an Advertising/Public Relations Research Methods class at the University of Tennessee decided to uncover the inner thoughts of the young adult DVD renter. The subsequent section of the project will unearth the common thoughts, feelings, reasoning, and gender differences of the redbox target market through personal qualitative interviews given by each group member. Each interview, which can be seen in Appendix I, was given to a member of the 18-24 year old target market who was not a fellow advertising or public relations major, or was aware of the topic project. In order for the process to be unbiased, each group member did not reveal the client until the end of the interview. The goals of the quantitative research were to identify the target market, classify the factors that motivate purchases, what are the unique characteristics of each renter, and The Main Areas of Questioning: • How participants decide to rent a movie and what influences them • What rental outlets participants use and why it’s important • If the participant has heard of or used any DVD kiosks • If the participant has used redbox and if so, their level of satisfaction These goals were accomplished by asking questions concerning how participants decided to rent a movie, refer to Appendix 1, if there was any emotion linked to the decision and their awareness of DVD kiosks, especially redbox. Interviewers were not seeking number responses as much as deeper feelings and personal experiences. They achieved this by asking participants how and why by digging deeper into stories that were shared. Six of the participants were students while four were non-students. There were an even split of five males and females. All of them were between the ages of 18-24. determine if there are any problems with the category, client or competitors. 24 | P a g e Results Deciding how/ when to Rent a Movie The decision process for renting movies was commonly associated with certain times or activities. The majority of males and females interviewed said that they most often rent movies weekends, when they do not have many plans or when they have time to relax. Some males mentioned their mood influences them when deciding when to rent a movie and especially what kind of movie they wanted to rent. A 24year-old male said, “When I decide to rent a movie it always depends on my mood. I figure out if I am in the mood for a comedy, an action film, or romantic comedy and then I go from there.” One male stated that marketing for new releases strikes his attention and usually tempts him to rent out of curiosity. Social reasons is the most common reason that females rent movies. Other females responded that they rent movies when there is nothing they like on TV. Many of the respondents also rent movies when they are on dates or eating with a group of people. Two common foods mentioned were popcorn and pizza. An approximately equal amount of people make decisions about renting a movie alone as those whose decisions involve other people. When asked what outlet they usually rent from, most respondents replied redbox and mentioned renting at Blockbuster in the past before using redbox. One male and one female responded that they used Netflix. The male used videostreaming through his Xbox and the female used the video streaming through her television. Rental Outlets Several respondents said they liked redbox because it was more convenient and cheaper than its competitors. Females seem to commonly define convenience as quick or easy. Males placed emphasis on the fact that redbox was close to places they usually shopped, thus more convenient. However, both genders also implied that convenience was based on the distance from their place of living and the 24-hour a day access. As stated earlier, Blockbuster was the other venue mentioned most. The respondents said they used Blockbuster mostly because it was familiar. The majority said the main reason they switched to redbox was to avoid late fees. 25 | P a g e When asked why the payment plan effects his because it’s convenient to be at a place where decision, a 21-year-old male said he liked I can get multiple things and being in control of how much he pays, “It not have to stop at another makes me choose redbox over Blockbuster store to pick up a movie.” because I’m in control of the payments rather This statement could be an than the upfront five dollars.” indication that some redbox Some customers would not rent people mentioned from redbox if they were that they did like not located at some of the the larger selection places they normally that Blockbuster shop. offers but still said redbox was DVD Kiosks preferred. All of the 18-24 The locations, year olds interviewed speed, and cost of renting movies were all important to the respondents. When asked why these things mattered to them, the majority of males and females said that the one dollar cost is a drastic difference from five dollars. A 19-year old male said, “If you are going to get the same product, you always try to get it at the cheapest price. It’s simple economics.” Many males also mentioned that they were tight on money since they were currently in college. Concerning the importance of location, a 23 year-old female said, “I rent from redbox generally when I come across it while at Walmart or Walgreens. I guess that’s important knew of redbox. Two females and one male mentioned other DVD kiosks brands they have seen but they have never actually rented a movie from them. The kiosks mentioned included Blockbuster Express, Kroger, and DVD Play. However, all of them implied they only know of one of these kiosk locations. When asked if DVD kiosks were for somebody like them, everyone said yes. Again, most often males and females mentioned convenience in reference to the quick process, closeness and number of locations and 24-hour availability as the main reasons. 26 | P a g e Since college students are usually maintaining a hectic schedule, it’s no surprise generation and also because the selection limits the classics.” that several respondents prefer kiosks because they find it quick and easy. For example, a 24 year-old female states, “DVD Redbox All of the respondents have tried kiosks are definitely for someone like me. redbox. When asked what prompted them to They are so accessible and easy. People my try redbox, four out of the five males, as well age are always looking for ways to do things as one female, said location. Most of their easier and kiosks make it easier on us.” answers were similar to what this 21-year-old Many males and females said that the high- male said. “The first time I used it I was technology made coming out of Wal- them feel DVD mart with my friends kiosks were good and we saw it and for people their age. decided to try it.” A 21-year-old male Another male said, “It was cool to said that he decided to run these machines yourself, you know like use redbox for the first time because he was the self check-outs at the grocery store.” curious. Also, some said that they liked the fact One female also said that she began that they don’t have to interact with people renting from redbox because of the amount of when they rent movies from a kiosk. A 19- locations and out of curiosity as well. She year-old female said, “ I like to go in and get went on to say, “They are all over the place in out with what I need without having to deal my hometown and I thought it would be with people that I don’t have to.” interesting to try one A 23-year-old female believes that the day.” However, there limited selection of the kiosks is another was much less reason why they are most appropriate for her consistency with the generation. She said, “I would probably not females as to why recommend them to my grandmother because they tried redbox. Price and friends were two of the selection. The movie selection that is of the other responses. When evaluating their provided in kiosks I think may be experience, all of the respondents were inappropriate for my grandmothers 27 | P a g e “If I’m ready to get home and just pleased with their redbox came to grab a quick movie , I don’t want to experience. The two stand there while you talk to complaints from your mom about the new movies that just customers concerning came out or fight with your kids about what their experience were not movies they can or can’t have for whatever directly caused by reason. The worst is when old people are redbox. trying to use it for the first time and don’t A 24-year-old male said he had a good understand how to use it. Instead of asking experience overall but had one complaint for help or stepping aside they just stand about the other customers using redbox. there looking at it.” 28 | P a g e Another complaint came from a 19year-old female. “I love redbox, and my experiences are all good except the one time I had to buy the DVD since I forgot to return it.” However, this is something that could happen with any other venue and it would also cost more. After asked about what prompted them to use redbox and how their experience was, they were asked what they liked and disliked about redbox. The answers to these questions were repetitive of those that were mentioned in the rental outlets portion because so many of the respondents said that redbox was their most common outlet for renting movies. Key Insights 1. Deciding How/When to Rent a Movie Males: bored or to relax Females: social reasons Both male and female: weekends Most individuals rent from redbox and occasionally Blockbuster and Netflix 2. Rental Outlets Convenience- quick and easy vs. one-stop-shop Distance from home and 24 hour access Late fees vs. selection 3. Who DVD Kiosks are for Everyone in the target market (18-24) 4. Redbox Half of sample tried due to convenient location Overall good experiences except for poor selection Exhibit 10 29 | P a g e Method Sample Profile Through consumer insight, the population of 18-24 year olds has been noted as the standout target market for redbox. This is the chosen sample profile based on the relationship between what redbox provides and the attitudes and behaviors desired by the consumer segment for products and services. This profile was analyzed based on a sampling fr ame, a description of how (or from where) the sample was acquired. The sample size included approximately 80 completed surveys based on participation of an equal amount of men and women and approximately 20-25 non-students. In order to be included in the sample size there was a screening process. The qualifications required the sample to be between the ages of 18 and 24 and also have rented a movie in the past 30 days. The sample did not include anyone who was interviewed for the Qualitative Research or communications or marketing students. Also the sample excluded anyone outside the age range of 18 and 24 or anyone who has not rented a movie in the past 30 days. Research Objectives Survey Question Number(s) When was the last time 18-24 year olds rented a movie? 1, 2, 3 What influences 18-24 year olds in their choice of where/how to rent a movie (rental channel)? 4 Which influence is most important? 4a, 4b, 5 Which of the five main rental channels has 18-24 year olds ever used? Used in the last 30 days? For each of the main five main rental outlets, will 1824 year olds usage increase, decrease or have no change in the next few months? Which brand of movie rental have they used the most in the past six months? 6, 7 What brands of DVD rental kiosks have they ever used? 10, 10a Attitudes about DVD rental kiosks If they have never used a DVD rental kiosk, why not? 10b, 10c Attitudes about redbox 11 How do these questions differ based on gender and student status? 12, 13, 14 8 9 30 | P a g e Data Collection Method sections, 14 questions, which included 65 The process used to conduct the study variables. The survey, which can be found in was a self-administered survey. The method Appendix II, was approximately five minutes was a non-probability sampling, long. The subset method of a self-administered, in which the likelihood of being non-probability sampling survey that was chosen is unknown because chosen was subject to both strengths and sampling unit is selected at the weaknesses. interviewer/researcher's The strengths to this approach contain discretion. The data collection tactic the option for the sample to have administered was through convenience completed the survey based on his or her own sampling, where the sample was selected based timely manner. Also, based on judgment, the on the researcher’s judgment that the person is chances of choosing the qualified sampling representative of the 18-24 year old population. profile increased in comparison to a probability The researchers selected locations sampling method. In addition, the strengths of where they encountered frequent amounts of this design was its clarity. The survey is legible 18-24 year olds. The locations chosen were a and organized. local university and workplaces, which were The weaknesses to this technique are cleared by a manager. Selected, were subject to not possess the advantages of being individuals that self-administered a five minute completely random, such as the elimination of survey in exchange for a small reward. Surveys bias by the interviewer. In addition, the were dispensed on the same weekday to allow survey was open to misinterpretation by the no bias. sample, as opposed to an intervieweradministered approach. The sample may have Survey Design Survey Method The survey began by asking broad questions about consumer renting habits, DVD rental outlets and narrowed into questions specific to redbox. The self-administered survey was composed of four also failed to provide all findings due to an incomplete survey, whereas in an intervieweradministered approach completion of answers would be urged. A further possible weakness was that the seven pages may have appeared visually lengthy to a prospective individual causing them to have abandoned the survey. 31 | P a g e Objective 1: The last time the target market rented a movie. Table 1 The Last Time 18-24 Year Olds Rented a Movie 1 Week Ago 2 Weeks Ago 3 Weeks Ago About a Month Ago Frequency 30% 25% 22.5% 22.5% Number of Times Rent Movie Per Month Less than Once a Month 1 Time 2-3 Times 4-5 Times More than 5 Times Frequency 26.3% 31.3% 31.3% 7.5% 3.8% When Target Market Rents Most Often On the Weekends During the Week Frequency 77.5% 22.5% Table 2 Table 3 Discussion Over half, 55%, of the target market has rented a DVD within the past two weeks (See Table 1). Concerning the number of times that one rents a movie per month, our research shows that the majority, 62.6%, of the target market rents one to three times a month. However, over a quarter of the respondents said that they rent a movie less than once a month (See Table 2). It could be assumed that this finding is a result of the declining US economic status since 2008 mentioned in the situation analysis (See “Economic Environment”, Pg. 6). In the qualitative surveys there was also evidence that many of the respondents from the 18-24 year old 32 | P a g e demographic were more conservative with their money and did not have much leisure time. This is proven by the research, 77.5% of respondents that stated they most often rent DVDs on the weekends (See Table 3). On the other hand, 22.5% said they usually rented DVDs during the week. The most common day of the week mentioned was Tuesday with 8.8%. This could possibly be due to the lack of work load presented early in the week and perhaps using it as a way to relax before having to complete work due at the end of the week. Objective 2 and 3: What Influence the Target Market Table 4 Degree of Influence Friend Significant Other Roommate Family Media 1 1.3% 16.3% 10.0% 6.3% 12.5% 2 5.0% 1.3% 5.0% 12.5% 2.5% 3 11.3% 12.5% 15.0% 18.8% 18.8% 4 32.5% 20.0% 27.5% 23.8% 28.8% 5 20.0% 20.0% 11.3% 8.8% 7.5% Mean 3.9 3.4 3.4 3.2 3.2 5 13.8% 6.3% 6.3% Mean 4.3 3.6 3.5 *71.3% respondents stated that their rental decision is usually influenced by others. *1 being no influence and 5 being strong influence. ***Enter in text to mention coworker Table 5 Reason to Rent Interest in Movies Relaxation Boredom 1 0% 2.5% 1.3% 2 0% 3.8% 6.3% 3 3.8% 3.8% 6.3% 4 13.8% 13.8% 10.0% *28.8% said that they were not influenced by others, therefore answered what prompts them to rent. *1 being no influence, 5 being strong influence 33 | P a g e Table 6 Most Important When Choosing Rental Outlet Distance Needed to Travel Price Selection Membership Return Policy Late Fees Technology Hours of Operation Time Spent on Rental Process Frequency 33.8% 32.5% 12.5% 6.3% 6.3% 3.8% 2.5% 1.3% 1.3% Discussion The research shows that the most influential people to the target market while making a DVD rental decision are their friends with an average of 3.93 (See Table 4). However, that is not a very strong influence because on this particular scale three means the respondent felt that the influence was neutral. Out of the people that said others do not influence their rental decisions, the leading reason is interest in movies with an average of 4.32 (See Table 5). Over 65% of the sample felt that distance needed to travel or price were the most important factors when choosing a DVD rental channel (See Table 6). The concern can be linked back to the decline in the US economy since 2008 as well. The importance of distance needed to travel puts an emphasis on number of locations as another source of competition for the industry (See Graphs 4 & 5, Exhibit 4, Pg.11). 34 | P a g e Objective 4 & 5: Usage of Rental Channels Table 7 Used Rental Channel Frequency Ever Used Frequency Past 30 Days Self- Service Kiosk Retail Location Video Streaming Online Rental Mailing Service 75.0% 98.8% 43.8% 40.0% 30.0% 63.8% 38.8% 22.5% 15.0% 15.0% Discussion When asked what rental locations they have ever used, the largest portion of the sample, 98.8%, has used retail locations. However, only 38.8% of the respondents have used them in the past 30 days (Table 7). This is most likely because retail locations were the only way to rent movies before the other channels developed. It is also proof that retail locations like Blockbuster are in the decline phase of their PLC (Industry Overview) and thus is innovating new ways to compete within the market. 75.0% constructs the second largest amount of respondents. These people stated that they have used self-service kiosks before and 63.8% said that they have used one in the past 30 days (Table 7). Concerning the product life cycle, this proves that self-service kiosks are in the growth stage. Online rentals, mailing services and video streaming are all newer ways to rent than retail locations but older than self-service kiosks. Over the past 30 days, these three channels include 52.5% of the respondents. This finding is crucial because it shows that retail locations are currently the least popular way of renting DVDs. 35 | P a g e Objective 6: Expected Usage in the Next Few Months Table 8 Rental Channel Self-Service Kiosk Video Streaming Online Rental Mailing Service Retail Locations 1 11.3% 15.0% 12.5% 16.3% 26.3% 2 0% 1.3% 5.0% 3.8% 11.3% 3 40.0% 66.3% 68.8% 70.0% 48.8% 4 26.3% 12.5% 8.8% 3.8% 10.0% 5 22.5% 5.0% 5.0% 6.3% 3.8% Mean 3.5 2.9 2.9 2.8 2.5 *On a scale of 1 (decrease usage) to 5 (increase usage) Discussion The findings for expected usage is complimentary to the findings of the respondents who have used the channels ever and in the past 30 days. With an average of 3.49 self-service kiosks are expected to have the most increase in usage in the next few months, in fact they are the only channel that shows any increase at all. Retail locations are expected to have the most decrease in the near future with an average of 2.54 (Table 8), further proving that self-service kiosks are in the growth stage of the product life cycle (See Pg. 3). Objective 7: Brand Used Most in the Past 6 Months Table 9 Brand redbox Frequency 47.5% Blockbuster Netflix Blockbuster Express Movie Gallery Hollywood Video Amazon On-Demand 18.8% 16.3% 3.8% 3.8% 2.5% 1.3% *Mention Comcast On-demand in discussion 36 | P a g e Discussion The brand that was used the most by the sample in the past six months was redbox, 47.5% of the respondents indicated this. Netflix and Blockbuster make up the second largest portion of the respondents with a combined 35.1% (See Table 9). The solidifies the prediction from the competitor analysis that Netflix, Blockbuster Express and redbox are the leading competitors in the DVD rental market (See Pg. 4). Even though the statistics are based upon Blockbuster’s retail locations, the usage of self-service kiosks are likely to rise. Thus, due to brand loyalty Blockbuster Express could become a leader in self-service kiosk competition (See Table 8). Objective 8: Brands of Self-Service Kiosks Ever Used Table 10 Brands redbox Frequency 75.0% Blockbuster Express DVD Now 7.5% 2.5% *Out of 76.3% of respondents that have used a self-service kiosk. Discussion An overwhelming 75% of the sample said redbox was a brand of self-service kiosk that they have used (See Table 10). Blockbuster and DVD Now are not even close in the comparison. However, this explained by Blockbuster Express’ current status in the introduction stage of product lifecycle. It is expected for redbox to have higher rate of usage since it is an established brand in the growth stage of the product life cycle (See Exhibit 3, Pg. 9). 37 | P a g e Objective 9: Attitudes About Self-Service Kiosks. Table 11 Area of Satisfaction Price Hours of Operation Distance Needed to Travel Technology Time Spent on Rental Process Return Policy Late Fees Selection 1 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1.3% 0% 3.8% 2 2.5% 1.3% 1.3% 1.3% 5.0% 3.8% 8.8% 13.8% 3 2.5% 7.5% 10.0% 16.3% 10.0% 15.0% 26.3% 23.8% 4 13.8% 17.5% 28.8% 25.0% 32.5% 23.8% 20.0% 25.0% 5 55.0% 47.5% 33.8% 31.3% 26.3% 30.0% 18.8% 7.5% Mean 4.6 4.5 4.3 4.2 4.1 4.1 3.7 3.3 *Out of 76.3% of respondents that have used a self-service kiosk. *On a scale of 1 (very dissatisfied) to 5 (very satisfied) Discussion According to the surveys, the area with the most satisfaction for self-service kiosks was price with an average of 4.64 (See Table 11). This finding is symmetrical with the qualitative surveys; there was a collective agreement that those who used self-service kiosks did so because they are less expensive. The importance of price reflects back to the client profile stating that redbox’s target audience is price-conscious consumer (See “Target Audiences”, Pg. 16). Another area of high satisfaction was hours of operation, with an average of 4.51%. As discussed in the competitor analysis this is a strong advantage that self-service kiosks have over retail locations. This gives more explanation behind the results of Table 7 and Table 8. Consumers were least satisfied with the selection of DVDs at the self-service kiosks with an average of 3.25% (See Table 11). The qualitative survey results also found dissatisfaction with the selection of selfservice kiosks compared to retail locations (See “DVD Kiosks”, Pg. 29). In contrast, the target market still chooses to use self-service kiosks over retail locations. It can be interpreted from the results that the price and hours of operation is more important when deciding where to rent DVDs to the sample than selection is. 38 | P a g e Objective 10: Usage and Attitudes of redbox Table 12 Area of Satisfaction Price Hours of Operation Distance Needed to Travel Time Spent on Rental Process Return Policy Technology Late Fees Selection 1 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 3.8% 2 1.3% 1.3% 1.3% 1.3% 7.5% 1.3% 11.3% 15.0% 3 3.8% 7.5% 10.0% 13.8% 12.5% 20.0% 26.3% 21.3% 4 18.8% 22.5% 28.8% 37.5% 23.8% 26.3% 18.8% 25.0% 5 51.3% 43.8% 35.0% 22.5% 31.3% 26.3% 18.8% 10.0% Mean 4.6 4.5 4.3 4.1 4.1 4.1 3.6 3.3 *Out of 75% of the respondents that have ever used redbox. Discussion The findings for the areas of satisfaction for redbox are similar to those of self-service kiosks in general. This strengthens the finding that out of those that have used a self-service kiosk, the majority have used the redbox brand (See Table 10). There is less than a .06 difference between the means of price, hours of operation and selection when comparing self-service kiosks to the redbox brand (See Table 11 and 12). Therefore, we can apply the same conclusions as objective 9. 39 | P a g e Influences on Rental Decisions by Gender Table 13 Women (Mean) Men (Mean) t-value Sig. To what degree does your significant other influence your rental decision? 3.7 3.0 1.803 .077 To what degree do media influence your rental decision? 3.6 2.9 1.912 .061 To what degree does boredom prompt you to rent a movie? 3.1 3.9 -1.086 .085 Question *On a scale of 1 (no influence) to 5 (strong influence). Discussion The research shows that women are more influenced by their significant others when deciding to rent a DVD with an average of 3.74 compare to the men’s average of 3.03 (See Table 13). The qualitative research also supported this finding; women mentioned often associating movies with date nights. Women are also more influenced by media than men. This could be due to the constant marketing efforts towards women via magazines, specialized television networks. The females that participated in the qualitative research also stated that award shows could influence their rental decisions; such shows are often focused toward the female audience as well. Boredom prompts men with an average of 3.91 to rent DVDs more than women with an average of 3.08 (See Table 13). This could be related to the more social 40 | P a g e lifestyle of 18-24 year old females versus the more secluded lifestyle of 18-24 year old males (See “Key Insights”, Pg. 30). The lifestyles of males are also reflected in the research concerning the expected usage of rental channels in the next few months. Statistically, men were more likely to increase their usage of online rental services with an average of 3.13 compared to the average of women at 2.65. Rental Outlet Used in the Past 30 Days by Gender Table 14 Women % Men % ChiSquare Sig. Rented Online 25.0 75.0 3.529 .060 Mailing Service 16.7 83.3 6.28 .012 Rental Outlet Used in the Past 30 Days *Statistics based on the respondent using the channel in the past 30 days Discussion In the past 30 days men have rented through online rental services three times as much as women. Also, they are over five times more likely to rent movies via mailing services than women (See Table 14). This again can be related back to the findings that men are more likely to increase their usage of online rental services in future. It is possible to conclude that men prefer to rent from their place of residence opposed to women, thus giving better insight into the gender differences concerning the definition of convenience (See Rental Outlets, Pg. 27). 41 | P a g e Recommendations Females Influenced More by Their Significant Other Segmentation of the 18-24 year old a 3.03 on the same scale. Redbox should utilize this information to appeal to this more tapered target market of 18-24 year old females by incorporating “Date Night at target market is a standout recommendation Home” themes into advertisement and for redbox. One of the segments that surfaced promotional campaigns. Redbox also has the from the quantitative data focuses on females opportunity to expand the “Date Night at and the findings that they are most influenced Home” theme to by their significant other when renting a include the movie. The data from survey concept of “dinner research indicates that on average women rate and a movie” by the influence of their significant other exploiting the concerning their rental decision as a 3.74 on a preexisting relationships that exist between 5 point scale (1 being no influence and 5 being its parent company, Coinstar, and various strong influence). As opposed to men, who restaurant venues to create promotional rated the influence of their significant other as 42 | P a g e alliances (59). A single coupon that combines interview with a 23-year old female, when both groceries for dinner and movie discounts asked to describe how she decides to rent a from a rental outlet such as redbox and movie she recalled that after watching the several established grocery Academy Awards she later stores could help boost the opted to rent a certain movie appeal of the “Date Night from a redbox and cited the at Home” theme for media as the main source of female consumers. Such persuasion for her decision. promotions should be With the current swarm of dispatched during the media traffic surrounding the early part of and throughout the weekend 18-24 year old target market, aggressive because survey research concluded that 77% advertisement placements for redbox in of females rent on weekends as opposed to on media hotspots noteworthy to women should the weekdays. be implemented to increase visibility and Females More Influenced by Media make the brand more recognizable to this key The second recommendation for base of female consumers. Competitors such redbox also further expands on the previously as Blockbuster Express and Netflix are mentioned female consumer base. The already capitalizing on these media outlets for research shows that females are more brand exposure, and redbox should follow influenced by the media than their male suite to stay competitive and prominent in the counterparts. On average, they rated the consumer’s mind. influence of media as a 3.56 on a 5 point scale (1 being no influence and 5 being strong influence). Males More Likely to Rent Due to Boredom Research also Men, on the other hand revealed that males are a rated the influence of media statistically significant target as a 2.93 on the same scale. for a redbox advertisement There are several media campaign. One of the outlets such as magazines qualities of the male and television networks specifically tailored to consumer that redbox should play into is that women that can be used to effectively reach men are more likely to rent when they are this female market. In one qualitative bored. The statistics show 43 | P a g e that men rate the influence of boredom as a have used online rental services three times as 3.91 on average on a 5 point scale (1 being no much as females within the past 30 days. In influence and 5 being addition, men will use strong influence). This online rental services is a more substantial more than females in rating than the females the next few months as that were sampled, well. On a 5 point scale, who rated boredom as men rated the expected a 3.08 on the same usage of DVD rental scale. Redbox should outlets during the next conduct more in depth few months as a 3.13 on research to determine average (1 being decrease what activities males typically engage in when usage and 5 being increase usage). Women they’re bored in order to determine what rated their expected change of usage as a 2.65 media outlets would prove most effective in on the same scale. During the qualitative reaching them during this time. Once these interview one 19-year old male, who is a channels have been identified a creative Netflix user, defined online renting as the campaign will be necessary to direct and ultimate convenience for him by explaining encourage the male consumer to select movie that if he’s already decided to stay in and renting from redbox as a solution to their watch a movie than he would prefer to avoid boredom. going out to rent, “If I have to go out of my Males More Likely to Increase Usage way then it defeats the purpose.” The prime of Online Rental within the Next Few competitor in online rental is Netflix. Because Months The next recommendation for reaching the male segmentation of the target of Netflix’s present domination in this industry, we recommend that redbox launch a strong counter campaign to draw in male market of 18-24 year olds target market. An example is to more boldly advertise tactic for such a campaign redbox on online sites. would be to offer the Quantitative research incentive of a free month of specified that males redbox rentals if the customer cancels their existing Netflix 44 | P a g e subscription. This segment of male online renters is not limited to its contemporary importance in the industry, but is also Males More Likely to Use Mailing Service valuable for redbox’s future business outlook. The final recommendation for Online renting has the potential to expand in successfully reaching the 18-24 year old target the future due to the continual advancements market is to offer male customers an in technology, and must alternative to using therefore be considered rental mailing services. by redbox in future 83.3% of male expansion plans in participants were more order to remain current likely to use mailing with the technologically services for their rental savvy 18-24 year old needs. Redbox needs to market. The statistical design a campaign that evidence that this will highlight its online consumer base is willing movie reservation to experiment with new option as a combatant technology such as to the present mailing online rental also gives rental system. The an indicator towards the campaign should types of promotional compare online movie avenues that will be reservation to mailing successful in reaching services by emphasizing this segment. Redbox is advised to increase the immediacy of reserving a DVD online and its promotions for online rental services in then retrieving it from a convenient redbox technologically advanced as well as male kiosk as opposed to the more time consuming specific media channels such as e-mail, text process of requesting, receiving, and messages, social networking sites and returning the DVD by mail. websites geared toward male audiences. 45 | P a g e Appendix I: Qualitative Interview Guide REDBOX INTERVIEW GUIDE Background Information: Gender : Female or Male Age: _______________ Status: Student Non-Student Deciding to Rent a Movie Tell me about how you decide to rent a movie. [Note: If s/he has trouble getting started, ask the person to think about the last time s/he rented a movie.] [Here are some “prompt” questions to cover if the person doesn’t address them.] Do you have certain days of the week or occasions that prompt you to rent a movie? Group Question- Tell me what activities you associate with renting. Was anyone else involved in the decision to rent? Tell me about it. From where do you usually rent? Probe: Anywhere else? Group Question- Would you consider yourself brand loyal to any of these companies? 46 | P a g e Rental Outlets (Ask this line of questions for each of the outlets your respondent named as “usually rents from” – see above) You said that you usually rent from (name outlet). Why do you rent from (name outlet)? Probe: Why is that important to you? Probe: Any other reasons? Why is that important? What do you like about (name outlet)? Probe: Could you elaborate? Probe: How much does this feature influence you to rent from here? What do you dislike about (name outlet)? Probe: Is that important to you? Why or why not? You said you also rented from (name outlet – from the opening questions). Ask the above series of 3 questions again for each rental outlet named. DVD Kiosks Say: You can now rent dvds from self-service kiosks at a variety of places around town. Can you name any of these kiosks? Probe: Can you think of any other brands of dvd kiosks? Are dvd kiosks for someone like you? Probe: Why or why not? (You’re going to have to do your own follow-up here depending upon what they say.) 47 | P a g e Redbox If they have not named redbox yet in the interview, ask: o Have you ever heard of redbox? [If yes] – tell me what you know. [If no} – conclude the interview. Have you ever rented a dvd from redbox? (Note: They may have already addressed this under the Rental Outlets questions above.) If they have tried redbox: o Tell me about your experience. o What prompted you to rent from redbox? o What did you like about redbox? o What did you dislike about redbox? If they have not tried redbox: why haven’t you rented from redbox? (Probe here to really find out what might be the hindrance. You want to see if it’s something that could be addressed through the Marketing 4P’s – especially if it’s related to communication.) 48 | P a g e Appendix II: Quantitative Survey Directions: Please complete the following survey to your best ability. If you do not know an answer, do not fill in a random number. Instead, leave it blank. Thank you for participating in the survey. Your answers will only be used for research purposes. Section 1: DVD Rental Habits 1. When was the last time you rented a movie? (Circle one) 1 1 week ago 2 2 weeks ago 3 3 weeks ago 4 About a month ago 5 More than a month ago 2. How often in a month do you rent movies on average? (Circle one) 1 Less than once a month 2 1 time 3 2-3 times 4 4-5 times 5 More than 5 times 3. When do you rent movies most often? (Circle one) 0 During the week If so, which day usually? ______________________ 1 On the weekends 49 | P a g e 4. Is your rental decision usually influenced by others? (Circle one) 1 Yes (Go to 4a) 0 No (Go to 4b) 4a. If yes, please rate the degree that these factors influence you. (Circle a number for each) No Influence Strong Influence Neutral Significant Other/Spouse 1 2 3 4 5 Family 1 2 3 4 5 Media (e.g. ads, reviews) 1 2 3 4 5 Friend 1 2 3 4 5 Room mate 1 2 3 4 5 Other 1 2 3 4 5 4b. If no, how much influence do the following have on your decision to rent a movie? (Circle a number for each) No Strong Influence Neutral Influence Boredom 1 2 3 4 5 Relaxation 1 2 3 4 5 Interest in Movies 1 2 3 4 5 Other 1 2 3 4 5 50 | P a g e 5. What is most important to you when choosing a rental outlet? (Choose only one) 1 Distance needed to travel 2 Price 3 Time Spent on Rental Process 4 Employee Assistance 5 Hours of Operations 6 Technology 7 Return Policy 8 Selection 9 Membership 10 Late Fees 11 Other: ________________________ 6. Have you ever rented from the following: (Circle choice for each) Yes No Retail Locations 1 0 Online Rental 1 0 Mailing Services 1 0 Video Streaming 1 0 Self-Service Kiosks 1 0 51 | P a g e 7. Have you rented from the following in the past 30 days? (Circle choice for each) Yes No Retail Locations 1 0 Online Rental 1 0 Mailing Services 1 0 Video Streaming 1 0 Self-Service Kiosks 1 0 8. Rate your expected usage of DVD rental outlets for the next few months. (Circle a number for each) Decrease No Increase Usage Change Usage Retail Locations 1 2 3 4 5 Online Rental 1 2 3 4 5 Mailing Services 1 2 3 4 5 Video Streaming 1 2 3 4 5 Self-Service Kiosks 1 2 3 4 5 9. Which brand of movie rental outlet have you used the most in the past six months? (Choose only one) 1 Amazon On-Demand 2 Blockbuster 3 Blockbuster Express 4 DVD Now 5 Hollywood Video 6 iTunes 7 Movie Gallery 8 Netflix 9 Redbox 10 Other 52 | P a g e Section 2: DVD Rental Kiosks 1. Have you ever used a DVD rental kiosk? 1 Yes (Go to 1a & 1b) 0 No (Go to 1c) 1a. If yes, what brands have you used? (Circle choice for each) Yes No Blockbuster Express 1 0 DVD Now 1 0 DVD Play 1 0 Redbox 1 0 Other 1 0 1b. If yes, rate your satisfaction with DVD rental kiosks in the following areas. (Circle a number for each) Very Dissatisfied Neutral Satisfied Very Dissatisfied Satisfied Neutral Satisfied Distance Needed to Travel 1 2 3 4 5 Price 1 2 3 4 5 Time Spent on Rental Process 1 2 3 4 5 Hour of Operations 1 2 3 4 5 Technology 1 2 3 4 5 Return Policy 1 2 3 4 5 Selection 1 2 3 4 5 Late Fees 1 2 3 4 5 53 | P a g e 1c) If no, what is the main reason you have never rented from a DVD kiosk? (Choose only one) 1 Never heard of them 2 Skeptical of new technology 3 Impersonal 4 Privacy Concerns 5 Brand loyal to another company 6 Other: _______________ Section 3: Redbox 1. Have you ever used redbox? (Circle one) 1 Yes 0 No If yes, rate your satisfaction with redbox in these areas. (Circle a number for each) Very Very Dissatisfied Dissatisfied Satisfied Neutral Neutral Satisfied Satisfied Distance Needed to Travel 1 2 3 4 5 Price 1 2 3 4 5 Time Spent on Rental Process 1 2 3 4 5 Hour of Operations 1 2 3 4 5 Technology 1 2 3 4 5 Return Policy 1 2 3 4 5 Selection 1 2 3 4 5 Late Fees 1 2 3 4 5 54 | P a g e Section 4: Demographics 1. What is your gender? (Circle one) 1 Female 0 Male 0 No 2. How old are you? 3. Are you a student? (Circle one) 1 Yes 55 | P a g e References 1. IBISWorld (Pg. 12, 14, 16, 33) 2. MarketResearch (Pg. 12, 36, 52, 111, 114) 3. http://www.businessweek.com/technology/content/feb2010/tc2010022_125668.htm 4. http://www.annualreports.com/Company/3736?n=netflix (pg. 1) 5. http://ir.netflix.com/ 6. Simmons Research Data 7. http://www.insideredbox.com/redbox-parent-coinstar-reports-more-than-1-billion-in-2009-revenue/ 8. http://www.homemediamagazine.com/financial/ncr-blockbuster-express-revenue--line-withexpectations-17392 9. Video Business; 5/11/2009, Vol. 29 Issue 18, p3-20, 2p, 1 color (RDS) 10. http://redboxpressroom.com/ 11. http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/national/gdp/gdpnewsrelease.htm 12. http://www.usatoday.com/tech/products/2009-08-11-rental-dvd-redbox_N.htm 13. http://www.betanews.com/article/Blockbuster-gains-ground-in-rental-kiosk-turf-war/1253116199 14. Hollywood Reporter, 405 (49): 6, August 05, 2008. ISSN: 0018-3660 (RDS) 15. http://www.annualreports.com/Company/1935 16. http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/technology/2009/01/if-you-stream-i.html 17. U.S. Census Population Projection : (NP-T3) 18. http://www.entmerch.org/priorities.html 19. http://www.entmerch.org/positions.html 20. Video Business; 11/16/2009, Vol. 29 Issue 44, p5-5, 1/8p, 1 color 21. Video Business; 12/14/2009, Vol. 29 Issue 46, p5-5, 1/4p 22. Video Business; 12/1/2008, Vol. 28 Issue 48, p5-5, 1/6p 23. http://www.selfservice.org/the-perspective? category=18 24. Video Business; 5/4/2009, Vol. 29 Issue 17, p13-13, 1p, 1 color 25. Drug Store News; 10/12/2009, Vol. 31 Issue 12, p51-51, 1/3p 26. Communication Research; Oct2008, Vol. 35 Issue 5, p602-621, 20p 27. http://www.fastcompany.com/blog/chris-dannen/techwatch/blockbuster-rent-movies-sd-cards-why 28. http://www.redbox.com/ 29. http://www.netflix.com/ 30. http://www.blockbusterexpress.com/ 56 | P a g e 31. http://www.facebook.com/#!/redbox?ref=ts 32. http://www.facebook.com/#!/netflix?ref=ts 33. http://www.facebook.com/#!/InsideBlockbusterExpress?ref=ts 34. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nW609P8usA 35. Ad$pender.2008. Report of Netflix and redbox. 36. Simmons Market Research. DVD/Blu-Ray Rentals Increases at Grocer. November 17, 2009. 37. Simmons Market Research. It’s Titanic in scale! Experian Information Solutions, Inc. 2009. 38. “Blockbuster to Start Renting Movies on SD Cards”. November 10 2009. Posted by Sean from Fast Company. 39. Video Business; 5/4/2009, Vol. 29 Issue 17, p14-14, 3/5p, 1 graph 40. http://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/cpi.pdf 41. http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm 42. http://www.conference-board.org/economics/consumerConfidence.cfm 43. Standard & Poor’s Industry Surveys: Movies & Home Entertainment, Sept. 10, 2009 (Pg. 3, 4) 44. Business Week: 1/11/2010, issue 4162, p. 54-55, 2p 45. http://blog.redbox.com/redblog/2010/02/my-entry.html#comments] 46. http://blog.netflix.com/ 47. http://www.selfserviceworld.com/article.php?id=23760&site=6 48. http://www.blockbuster.com/corporate/news 49. Coinstar.com 50. Blockbuster.com 51. Video Business. 8/10/2009, Vol. 29. Issue 30, p 1-19, 2p. 52. http://www.globenewswire.com/newsroom/news.html?d=116181 53. http://www.quantcast.com/redbox.com 54. http://franchise.njoynow.com/blog/2009/08/13/red-box-grows/ 55. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12484567/ 56. Nation's Restaurant News; 1/23/2006, Vol. 40 Issue 4, p4-49, 2p, 2 color 57. Video Business; 9/14/2009, Vol. 29 Issue 35, p6-21, 2p, 1 color 58. Self-service trend in 2010. KioskMarketplace. 05 Jan 2010. 59. http://www.coinstar.com/us/html/A4-2 57 | P a g e 56 | P a g e 57 | P a g e 58 | P a g e 59 | P a g e
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz