Wesleyan University
WesScholar
Division II Faculty Publications
Social Sciences
11-2012
Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism:
Survival Singing, Relief Telethons, and the Haiti
Earthquake
Elizabeth McAlister
Wesleyan University, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://wesscholar.wesleyan.edu/div2facpubs
Part of the Anthropology Commons, Ethnomusicology Commons, Other Race, Ethnicity and
post-Colonial Studies Commons, and the Television Commons
Recommended Citation
McAlister, Elizabeth. "Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism: Survival Singing, Relief Telethons, and the Haiti Earthquake,”
Small Axe: A Caribbean Platform for Criticism 39 (Nov 2012): 22-38.
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Social Sciences at WesScholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Division II Faculty
Publications by an authorized administrator of WesScholar. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected].
Soundscapes of Disaster
and Humanitarianism:
Survival Singing, Relief Telethons,
and the Haiti Earthquake
Elizabeth McAlister
,]LY`IVK`ZH`Z[OLLHY[OX\HRLZ[HY[LK^P[OZV\UK-VY[OPY[`Ä]LZLJVUKZHKLHMLUPUNYVHY
ÄSSLK[OLHPY0[ZV\UKLKHZPMHWSHUL^HZSHUKPUNVU[OLYVVM0[WV\UKLKSPRLZVTLIVK`^HZ
\ZPUNHQHJROHTTLYPUZPKL[OLOV\ZL;OLNYV\UKZOVVRHUKI\PSKPUNZJVSSHWZLK4PSSPVUZVM
WLVWSLZJYLHTLKH[VUJL¸;OLJSHTVYVM[OV\ZHUKZVMSV\KZJYLHTZVM[LYYVYHUKJYPLZVM
WHPUHYPZLHZPMMYVTHZPUNSLZ[VTHJO¹@HUPJR3HOLUZ^V\SK^YP[L1
0Z[VVKH[HUHUN\PZOLKYLTV]LHZ[OL^VYZ[KPZHZ[LYPU[OL(TLYPJHZZ[Y\JR[OLJLU[LY
VM/HP[PVU1HU\HY`(ZHU(TLYPJHU0^HZYLK\JLK[V^H[JOPUNHUKSPZ[LUPUNMYVTH
KPZ[HUJL^P[OT`/HP[PHUWHY[ULYHUKV\YJOPSKYLU0[PZHZ\YYLHSWLYZWLJ[P]LHZTHU`RUV^
0[PZHSZVVUL[OH[PZTHKLWVZZPISLI`KPNP[HS[LJOUVSVN`:\ZHU:VU[HN^YP[LZ[OH[¸ILPUN
HZWLJ[H[VYVMJHSHTP[PLZ[HRPUNWSHJLPUHUV[OLYJV\U[Y`PZHX\PU[LZZLU[PHSTVKLYUL_WLYPLUJL[OLJ\T\SH[P]LVMMLYPUNI`TVYL[OHUHJLU[\Y`HUKHOHSM»Z^VY[OVM[OVZLWYVMLZZPVUHS
@HUPJR3HOLUZ¸/HP[PVY;OL/LHS[OVM4PZLY`¹PU4HY[PU4\UYVLKHaiti Rising: Haitian History, Culture and the
Earthquake of 20103P]LYWVVS!3P]LYWVVS<UP]LYZP[`7YLZZ small axe 39 ࠮ November 2012 ࠮ DOI 10.1215/07990537-1894078 © Small Axe, Inc.
39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂23
ZWLJPHSPaLK[V\YPZ[ZRUV^UHZQV\YUHSPZ[Z¹2)\[^OH[JHU^LRUV^PM^LSPZ[LU[V[OLZV\UKZ
VMKPZHZ[LY&
;OPZUL^ZYLWVY[VU5)*Z[\UULKTL!H^VTHUUHTLK1HUL[[L^OVOHKILLU[YHWWLK
HSVULPU[OLKHYRMVYÄ]LKH`Z^HZIYV\NO[V\[MYVT[OLY\IISL singing;OLQV\YUHSPZ[YLWVY[PUN [OL Z[VY` MVJ\ZLK VU [OL YVTHU[PJ KYHTH[PJ WLYZWLJ[P]L VM 1HUL[[L»Z O\ZIHUK ^OV
KLZWP[L[OLL]PKLUJLVMHÅH[[LULKI\PSKPUN^HZZ\YLOPZILSV]LK^PML^HZHSP]L/L^V\SK
UV[SLH]L[OLZP[L0[^HZH[HSLVMLUK\YPUNSV]LHUKSV`HS[`HZ^LSSHZHWHYHISLHIV\[MVYLPNU
(TLYPJHUYLZJ\L^VYRLYZ^OVJ\[1HUL[[LMYLL;OLZLNTLU[^HZHO\THUPU[LYLZ[Z[VY`VM
HZPUNSLYLZJ\LÄSTLKMVYH5VY[O(TLYPJHUH\KPLUJL^OV[OLTZLS]LZTPNO[ILMHTPSPHY^P[O
[OLJ\S[\YHSMYHTLZVM(TLYPJHUZHZIV[OYVTHU[PJHUKYLZJ\LYZ)\[MVYTL[OLZLNTLU[^HZ
HWV^LYM\SZ[VY`HIV\[HZLUZVY`VYPLU[H[PVU[VZPUNPUNHUKP[ZYLSH[PVUZOPW[VZLSMWYLZLY]H[PVU
HUKZ\Y]P]HSPU/HP[P3
1HUL[[LZHUNPU-YLUJO!¸5LWHZH]VPYWL\YKLSHTVY[¹¸+VUV[ILHMYHPKVMKLH[O¹:OL
^HZZPUNPUNHO`TUJVTTVUS`OLHYKH[M\ULYHSZHUKPU4HZVUPJ[LTWSLZPU/HP[P4)LMVYLZOL
JV\SKÄUPZOHQV\YUHSPZ[ILU[V]LYOLYZ[YL[JOLYHUKPU[LYY\W[LK[OLZPUNPUNTLZZHNL1HUL[[L
^HZKLSP]LYPUN[V[OLHZZLTISLKJYV^K/LHZRLKOLY¸+PK`V\[OPUR`V\^V\SKSP]L&¹;VV
WVSP[LUV[[VHUZ^LY1HUL[[LYLZWVUKLK¸@LZ¹HUK[\YULKOLYMHJLHUK[OLX\LZ[PVUHYV\UK
[VOPT¸>O`UV[&¹
0MLS[H^LHUKYLZWLJ[MVY[OPZIYH]LZ\Y]P]VYVMHOVYYPÄJVYKLHSZPUNPUNHTLZZHNLVM
Z[YLUN[OHUKJLY[P[\KL@L[[OLUHYYH[P]LHYJVM[OLUL^ZZ[VY`MVJ\ZLKVUV[OLY[OPUNZ·VU
SV]L YLZJ\L HUK [OL ZLUZH[PVUHSPZ[ KYP]L VM ZV T\JO QV\YUHSPZT! ¸/V^ H^M\S KPK P[ MLLS&¹
0U[LYY\W[PUN1HUL[[L»ZZVUN[VPU[LYYVNH[LOLYKLUPLKOLY[OLVWWVY[\UP[`[VM\SS`L_WYLZZOLY
[YP\TWOV]LY[OPZOHYYV^PUNL_WLYPLUJLQ\Z[HZP[YLM\ZLK[VHSSV^[OLSPZ[LUPUN]PL^LY[VSPUNLY
PUOLHYPUNOLYZV\UKOLYZVUN;OLTVTLU[PSS\Z[YH[LZ^OH[(SSLU-LSKTHUJHSSZ¸[OLPUHKTPZZPIPSP[`VMHSPLUZLUZVY`L_WLYPLUJL¹PU^OH[OL[LYTZ¸J\S[\YHSHULZ[OLZPH¹/LJHSSZH[[LU[PVU
[V[OLLKP[PUNV\[VM¸KPZJVUJLY[PUNKPZJVYKHU[HUKHUHYJOPJZLUZVY`WYLZLUJLZ¹[OH[^V\SK
KPZY\W[[OL\UZWVRLUY\SLZNV]LYUPUNW\ISPJSPML50U[OLNLUYLVM[OLO\THUPU[LYLZ[YLZJ\L
Z[VY`SL[[PUNHZ\Y]P]VYZPUNMVY[VVSVUNZLLTLKUV[[VÄ[[OLZJYPW[WYLKL[LYTPULKHZP[^HZ[V
Z[PJR[VHMHTPSPHYZ[VY`HIV\[KPZHZ[LYYLZJ\LYVTHUJLHUKZWVRLU[LZ[PTVU`0Z[PSS^VUKLY
>OH[^V\SK1HUL[[L»ZZVUN[LSS\ZPM[OL`OHKSL[OLYJVU[PU\LZPUNPUN&
@L[HZVULMVYTVMT\ZPJ^HZZPSLUJLKHUV[OLY^V\SKILWYVTV[LKPUHUPU[LYYLSH[LK
WYVJLZZVMT\[PUNHUKHTWSPM`PUN[OLZV\UKZJHWLZVMKPZHZ[LY[OH[0^PZO[VJVUZPKLYPU[OPZ
LZZH`;OL¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^!(.SVIHS)LULÄ[MVY,HY[OX\HRL9LSPLM¹[LSL[OVUVM1HU\HY`
^HZ[OLTVZ[^PKLS`IYVHKJHZ[[LSL[OVUPUOPZ[VY`0[YHUHJJVYKPUN[VHMHTPSPHYTVKLS[OH[OHZ
:\ZHU:VU[HNRegarding the Pain of Others5L^@VYR!7PJHKVY
5)*5L^Z7VY[H\7YPUJL¸1HUL[[L/HP[P9LZJ\L:PUNPUN¹1HU\HY`^^^`V\[\ILJVT^H[JO&]$:O2.45
]`KVMLH[\YL$YLSH[LKHJJLZZLK-LIY\HY`(ZLJVUKYLWVY[VMZVTLVULIYV\NO[MYVT[OLY\IISLZPUNPUNPZ
recounted by the Sidney Morning HeraldH[^^^ZTOJVTH\^VYSKVUL^LLRVUHSP]LHUKZPUNPUNPUX\HRLY\IISL
20100120-mkvh.html and www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/us_and_americas/article6994649.ece.
,YVS1VZ\tPU[LY]PL^I`H\[OVY4PHTP-SVYPKH1\S`
(SSLU-LSKTHU¸6U*\S[\YHS(ULZ[OLZPH!-YVT+LZLY[:[VYT[V9VKUL`2PUN¹American EthnologistUV !
͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
I`UV^ILJVTLHZJYPW[LKYP[\HS!P[^HZHUHLZ[OL[PJPaLKZWLJ[HJSLVMJLSLIYP[PLZWLYMVYTPUN
LTV[PVUHSS`L]VJH[P]LT\ZPJQ\_[HWVZLKHNHPUZ[Z[VYPLZHUKPTHNLZVMZ\Y]P]VYZ\UKLYNVPUN
L_[YLTLZ\MMLYPUN;OL[LSL[OVUPZHU(TLYPJHUPUUV]H[PVUHS[OV\NOUV^THU`JV\U[YPLZWYVK\JL[OLTHUKHO`IYPKMVYT!WHY[]HYPL[`ZOV^WHY[KPZHZ[LYQV\YUHSPZTHUKWHY[O\THUP[HYPHUM\UKYHPZPUN0[PZ^PKLS`IYVHKJHZ[HUKWYLLTW[Z\Z\HSS`ZJOLK\SLKWYVNYHTTPUN0U[OPZ
JHZL[OLLU[PYLTLKPHZWOLYLWH\ZLK[VHPY[OPZZPUNSLL]LU[
;OL¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^¹[LSL[OVU^HZHZUHWZOV[VMTHPUZ[YLHTTLKPHYLWYLZLU[H[PVUZ
VM/HP[PPU[OLJVU[L_[VM[OLX\HRLHUKHJOHUJL[VVIZLY]L\UKLYS`PUNSVNPJZVM(TLYPJHU
HUKV[OLYH[[P[\KLZ[V^HYK/HP[PHUKP[ZWLVWSLHZ[OL`YLZWVUKLK[V[OLKPZHZ[LY0HYN\LOLYL
[OH[[OPZ[HRLUMVYNYHU[LKMVYT\SH^OLYLI`LU[LY[HPUTLU[PZVMMLYLKPUYL[\YUMVYKVUH[PVUZ
[V^HYKYLSPLMHPKOHZHUHJV\Z[PJKPTLUZPVU[OH[YL]LHSZP[ZJOHYHJ[LYHZHUHY[PMHJ[VMJ\YYLU[ULVSPILYHSLJVUVTPJSVNPJ0U[OPZJ\S[\YHSHYLUHZOHWLKI`ULVSPILYHSPZTPUKP]PK\HSZHYL
JHSSLKVUPU[OLWYP]H[LZWOLYL\ZPUNLTV[PVUHSHWWLHSZ[VYLSPL]LZ\MMLYPUN[OYV\NOWYP]H[PaLK
O\THUP[HYPHUHPK(UKZPUJL[OL[HYNL[LKSPZ[LULYZHYLWV[LU[PHSKVUVYZP[PZ[OLTVZ[WVW\SHY
THPUZ[YLHTT\ZPJ[OH[PZMLH[\YLKZ\UNI`ILZ[ZLSSPUNHY[PZ[Z)\[PU[OLJV\YZLVMWYVK\JPUNYLSPLMJVUJLY[ZKPZHZ[LYZ\Y]P]VYZ»V^U]VPJLZSHTLU[ZHUKZVUNZHYLT\[LKL]LUHZ
PTHNLZVM[OLPYMHJLZHUKIVKPLZHYLOPNOSPNO[LK4`HUHS`ZPZH[[\ULZP[ZLSM[VH\KPVZWOLYLZ
HZ[OL`HYLWSH`LKHNHPUZ[[OL]PZ\HSYLNPZ[LY·[OL^H`[OH[/HP[PHUX\HRLZ\Y]P]VYZHUKPU[LYUH[PVUHSJLSLIYP[PLZ^LYLYLJVYKLKH\YHSS`HUKYLWYLZLU[LK]PZ\HSS`PUVYKLY[VYHPZLTVUL`
MVYKPZHZ[LYYLSPLM6U[OLVULOHUK0[\ULPU[VT\ZPJTHKLI`/HP[PHUZMVY/HP[PHUZJSVZL
[V[OLLWPJLU[LYPU[OLKPYLJ[HM[LYTH[OVM[OLX\HRLZ\JOHZPU[OLJHZLVM1HUL[[L6U[OL
V[OLYOHUK0SPZ[LU[VT\ZPJTHKLI`TVZ[S`5VY[O(TLYPJHUZMVYTVZ[S`V[OLY(TLYPJHUZ
PU[LSL[OVUWLYMVYTHUJLZMHYH^H`PU5L^@VYRHUK3VZ(UNLSLZHUK3VUKVU^LLRZHM[LY
[OL L]LU[ 1\_[HWVZPUN [^V ZV\UKZJHWLZ·[OL /HP[PHU Z[YLL[Z HUK [OL [LSL[OVU·WYLZLU[Z
[OLVWWVY[\UP[`[VIYPUN[VNL[OLYYLJLU[ZJOVSHYZOPWVU[OL]PZ\HSP[`VMZ\MMLYPUN^P[O^VYR
VUT\ZPJHUKLTV[PVUPUVYKLY[VL_WSVYL[OLSPURZIL[^LLUZPUNPUNHUKTLHUPUNTHRPUN
IL[^LLUO\THUP[HYPHUPZTHUKJ\S[\YLIL[^LLU(TLYPJHUJP]PSYLSPNPVUHUKULVSPILYHSPZTHUK
IL[^LLU[OLWOV[VQV\YUHSPZTVMKPZHZ[LYHUK[OLT\ZPJVSVN`VM[OLKPZHZ[LYYLSPLM[LSL[OVU
Singing for Life in Haiti
:PUNPUN [\YULK V\[ [V IL HU`[OPUN I\[ HU HUVTHSV\Z YLHJ[PVU I` H X\HRL Z\Y]P]VY UHTLK
1HUL[[L7LVWSLILNHU[VZPUNHSVULHUKPUNYV\WZ[OL]LY`L]LUPUNVM[OLLHY[OX\HRL4`
MYPLUKZ^OVSP]LPU7VY[H\7YPUJL[^LL[LK[OLL]LUPUNHM[LY[OLX\HRL[OH[WLVWSL^LYLZPUNPUN
PUNYV\WZHM[LY[OLZ\U^LU[KV^UHZ[OL`MHJLKHU\UJLY[HPUM\[\YLV\[KVVYZ(SS[OLPU[PTHJPLZVMSPML^LYL[OY\Z[PU[VY\IISLZ[YL^UW\ISPJZWHJLZ"T\ZPJPHU9PJOHYK4VYZL[^LL[LK
¸;OLZ[YLL[ZHYL/HP[P»ZSP]PUNYVVTBHUKDILKYVVT¹6-VYLPNUQV\YUHSPZ[ZILNHU[VYLWVY[VU
9PJOHYK4VYZL;^P[[LYWVZ[1HU\HY` !P.M.,[^P[[LYJVT9(4OHP[P
39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂25
/HP[PHUZ»\ZLVMT\ZPJ[VOVSK[OLTZLS]LZ[VNL[OLY[OYV\NO[OL[YH\TH;OLIYVHKJHZ[ZMLH[\YLKWLVWSLZPUNPUN*H[OVSPJHUK7YV[LZ[HU[O`TUZ;OLKPZ[PUJ[P]LZVUNZVM[OL(MYV*YLVSL
YLSPNPVUVM[OLTHQVYP[`RUV^UHZ=VKV\^LYLUV[^PKLS`H\KPISLPUKV^U[V^UW\ISPJZWHJLZ
H[LSSPUNWPLJLVML]PKLUJLMVY[OLVUNVPUNZ[PNTHH[[HJOLK[V[OH[[YHKP[PVU
6U1HU\HY`Q\Z[MV\YKH`ZHM[LY[OLKPZHZ[LY*55YHUH¸KL]LSVWPUNZ[VY`¹[OH[MLH[\YLKHSHYNLNYV\WVMWLVWSLZPUNPUNO`TUZHUK^HSRPUN[OYV\NO7VY[H\7YPUJL7¸;V\[IHNH`
KtQnI`LU¹[OL`ZHUN¸,]LY`[OPUNPZHSYLHK`ÄUL¹0[^HZHUL]HUNLSPJHS7YV[LZ[HU[O`TU[OH[
HZZLY[LK[OH[ILJH\ZL[OL`^LYLZH]LK^P[O1LZ\ZZP[[PUNVUOPZ[OYVULHUKPUJVU[YVSHSS^HZ
^LSS0UKLJSHYPUN[OH[[OPUNZ^LYLÄULL]LUPU[OLTPKZ[VMKL]HZ[H[PVUHUKJOHVZ[OLNYV\W
IYVHKJHZ[HU\UZOHRHISL*OYPZ[PHUMHP[O;OLWYVJLZZPVU^HZYLTHYRHISLLUV\NO[OH[*55
KLLTLKP[H¸KL]LSVWPUNZ[VY`¹`L[UVIVK`PU[LY]PL^LK[OLTHYJOLYZHUK>VSM)SP[aLYZLLTLK
\UHISL[VPU[LYWYL[[OLZP[\H[PVU9LWVY[LYZL]LY`^OLYLJVTTLU[LKVU[OL¸YLZPSPLUJLVM[OL
/HP[PHUWLVWSL¹HWOYHZL[OH[^V\SKILJVTL\IPX\P[V\ZI\[[OL`^V\SKYHYLS`LSHIVYH[LVU
^O`HUK\UKLY^OH[OPZ[VYPJHSJVUKP[PVUZ/HP[PHUZOH]LOHK[VILYLZPSPLU[
4`SH[LYJVU]LYZH[PVUZ^P[OU\TLYV\ZX\HRLZ\Y]P]VYZHIV\[[OL^PKLZWYLHKW\ISPJZPUNPUNYL]LHSLK[VTLHZLUZVY`JHWHJP[`MVYZPUNPUN[OH[/HP[PHUZWVZZLZZLKZWLHRPUNNLULYHSS`
L]LUPU[OLX\HRL»ZHM[LYZOVJRZ[V^OPJOMVYLPNULYZZLLTLKUV[LU[PYLS`ZLUZP[PaLK,_[LYUHS
VIZLY]LYZPUJS\KPUNHYN\HIS`T`ZLSMJ\S[P]H[LHUH\YHSattunementHKQ\Z[LK[V^HYKJLY[HPU
JVKLZ HUK OHIP[Z [OH[ YLUKLYZ V[OLY ZV\UK^H`Z PUJVTWYLOLUZPISL 9LWLH[LKS` Z\Y]P]VYZ
[VSKTL[OH[[OLPYKPZ[YLZZK\YPUN[OLX\HRL^HZZVPU[LUZL[OH[[OL`OHK[V[YHUZMVYTP[PU[V
HZVUNPUVYKLY[V^P[OZ[HUKP[¸6\JOHU[LW^VISLTSHU¹¸@V\ZPUN[OLWYVISLT¹¸0M`V\
KVU»[OH]L[OPZYLHJ[PVUPUZ[PSSLKPU`V\`V\JHUUV[\UKLYZ[HUKP["P[»ZPUL_WSPJHISL¹ZHPKHTHU
RUV^UHZHZVUNSLHKLYPUOPZJVTT\UP[`,]LU[OLUPJRUHTL/HP[PHUZNH]L[V[OLX\HRL·
goudougoudou·YLWYVK\JLZP[ZZLUZVY`X\HSP[`PUHYO`[OTPJYLNPZ[LY
/HP[PHU X\HRL Z\Y]P]VYZ ZHUN [V YLJVUZ[P[\[L [OLTZLS]LZ HZ PUKP]PK\HSZ HUK [V YLJVUZ[P[\[L [OL NYV\WZ·MHTPSPLZ ULPNOIVYOVVKZ JVUNYLNH[PVUZ HUK JVTT\UP[PLZ·[V ^OPJO
[OL`ILSVUN-VYPUKP]PK\HSZZPUNPUNPZZ`UVU`TV\Z^P[OKLLWIYLH[OPUNHUKH[LJOUPX\LMVY
YLMVJ\ZPUNHKPZ[YLZZLKWZ`JOL¸;OLHPY`V\\ZLPUZPUNPUNPZ[OLHPY[OH[SL[Z`V\MLLS^OH[»Z
NVPUNVUPUZPKL`V\0[»ZH[VVS[OH[SL[Z`V\MVJ\Z`V\YTPUK¹ZHPK/HP[PHU[YHKP[PVUHSZPUNLY
4PTLYVZL)LH\IY\U¸:V\UKPZHMVYTVMLULYN`:PUNPUNPZH[VVS^L\ZL[VTHUPW\SH[LLULYN`
0[»ZH^H`VMJVU[YVSSPUN[OLLULYN`HYV\UK`V\[VILHISL[VJVU[YVS[OLLULYN`PU`V\YZLSM¹8
)LH\IY\UWVPU[Z\Z[V[OLPKLH[OH[/HP[PHUX\HRLZ\Y]P]VYZ\ZLK[OLLTIVKPLK[LJOUPX\L
VMZPUNPUN[VVYPLU[[OLTZLS]LZPU[OLMHJLVMZ\KKLUHUK]PVSLU[Y\W[\YL,[OUVT\ZPJVSVNPZ[Z
^YP[LHIV\[OV^MVYZVTLZVJPL[PLZT\ZPJTHRPUNHSSV^ZHNYV\W[VMVYT[VNL[OLYPUHZWLJPHS
YLSH[PVUZOPWTLKPH[LKI`YO`[OTJYLH[PUN¸HZWLJPHS^VYSKVM[PTL¹PU^OPJOHSS[OLWHY[PJPWHU[ZHYLZ`UJOYVUPaLKPUIYLH[OTV]LTLU[HUK]VPJL.YV\WZPUNPUNLUNHNLZ[OLZLUZVY`
*55¸KL]LSVWPUNZ[VY`¹VMWLVWSLZPUNPUNPU[OLZ[YLL[ZVM7VY[H\7YPUJL1HU\HY`"ZLL^^^`V\[\ILJVT
^H[JO&]$@O9.))KS4MLH[\YL$YLSH[LKHJJLZZLK1\S`
4PTLYVZL)LH\IY\UPU[LY]PL^I`[OLH\[OVY7VY[H\7YPUJL/HP[P ͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
L_WLYPLUJL VM [OL PUKP]PK\HS HUK Z`UJOYVUPaLZ [OL PUKP]PK\HS ^P[O [OL NYV\W9 Assembled
WLVWSLZPUN[VIYLH[OLLULYN`[OYV\NO[OLIVK`![OLPUKP]PK\HSIVK`HUK[OLJVSSLJ[P]LIVK`
;OL`ZPUN[VYLIHSHUJL[OLTZLS]LZ
:PUNPUN^VYRZZWH[PHSS`HZ^LSS4\ZPJHSWYVJLZZPVUZ[OYV\NOKV^U[V^U7VY[H\7YPUJL
ZHUNSPMLIHJRPU[VZWHJLHUKOLSWLK[VTHRL[OL[LYYP[VY`PUOHIP[HISL:PUNPUN[VNL[OLYVYPLU[LKPUKP]PK\HSZHZHJVSSLJ[P]LJYLH[PUNHUKVJJ\W`PUNHZOHYLKWSHJL;O\ZUPNO[S`ZPUNPUN
PUTHU`LUJHTWTLU[ZPU[OLX\HRLaVULHUKTHYJOLZ[OYV\NOW\ISPJHYLHZOLSWLKNYV\WZ
[VTHYRV\[ZWHJL[VNL[OLYHUK[HRLV^ULYZOPWVM[OH[ZWHJL;OYV\NOZPUNPUN/HP[PHUWLVWSL
PUJVYWVYH[LK[OLJP[`IHJRPU[V[OLPYSP]LZ10
(JVTTVU[OV\NO[^HZ[OH[[OLX\HRL^HZ[OLILNPUUPUNVM[OLHWVJHS`WZL>YV[LVUL
MYPLUKPUHULTHPS¸;OLWLVWSLPUT`ULPNOIVYOVVKHYLZH`PUN[OPZPZ[OLZLJVUKJVTPUN·P[
MLLSZSPRL[OLHWVJHS`WZL¹0UZL]LYHSVM[OLYLJVYKPUNZWLVWSLZLU[[VTL0OLHYKZPUNLYZ
L]VRPUNIPISPJHSPTHNLZVMKLZ[Y\J[PVUHUKWSHJPUN[OLTZLS]LZHZHJ[VYZPUHUHUJPLU[Z[VY`0U
HU¸H\KPVWVZ[JHYK¹[OH[579IYVHKJHZ[VU1HU\HY`^VTLUHUKNPYSZZHUNH^LSSRUV^U
O`TUPU[OL/HP[PHUYLWLY[VPYL!¸1LYPJOVTPYH`SHRYHaL¹¸1LYPJOV[OL>HSSZ(YL*Y\TISPUN¹11
0U[OLIPISPJHSZ[VY`1LYPJOVPZ[OLÄYZ[JP[`[OL0ZYHLSP[LZJVTL[V^OLU[OL`LU[LY[OLWYVTPZLK
SHUKVM*HUHHU.VKOLSWZ1VZO\HHUK[OL0ZYHLSP[LZ[LHYKV^UP[ZOPNO^HSSZZV[OL`JHU
JVUX\LY[OLJP[`HUKWVZZLZZ[OLSHUK;OL`KV[OPZI`ISV^PUN[Y\TWL[ZHUKNP]PUNHSV\K
ZOV\["[OL`KV[OPZ[OYV\NOZV\UK[OYV\NO[OLO\THU]VPJL:L]LYHSTPSSLUUPHSH[LYL]HUNLSPJHS*OYPZ[PHUZPU7VY[H\7YPUJLYLHJOLKMVY[OPZPTHNLHUKZHUN[OLHUJPLU[JP[`VM1LYPJOVPU[V
[OLPYJP[`7VY[H\7YPUJLILJHTL [OLIPISPJHSJP[`HUKP[ZKLZ[Y\J[PVU^HZ[OL^PSSVM.VK;OL
ZPUNLYZWLYMVYTLK[OLYVSLVMHYPNO[LV\ZHUKZHUJ[PÄLKWLVWSLZPUNPUNHUKJOHU[PUNKV^U
[OL^HSSZVM[OLJP[`ZV[OH[[OLPY.VKJV\SKWVZZLZZP[;OL*YLVSLS`YPJZ^LU[VU[VUHTLV[OLY
[YV\ISLZ·O\UNLYWV]LY[`HUKZPJRULZZ·I\[[OLUKLJSHYLK¸;OLYLPZUV[OPUN1LZ\ZJHUUV[
JY\TISL¹0U[OLMHJLVM[OPZKL]HZ[H[PUNJH[HZ[YVWOLX\HRLZ\Y]P]VYZWYVK\JLK[OLPYV^U
YLSPNPV\ZT\ZPJ[VMHZOPVUHJVZTPJTLHUPUNV\[VM[OLKPZHZ[LYHUK[VJVUULJ[[OLTZLS]LZ
[V[OLIPISPJHSZ[VY`HZ[OLUV^JOVZLUWLVWSLVM.VK
=VKV\JVUNYLNH[PVUZHSZVZHUNI\[SLZZH\KPIS`;OL`^V\SKSH[LYZH`[OH[L]HUNLSPJHSZ
JHTWPUNULHY[OLTH[[LTW[LK[V¸ZPUN[OLTKV^U¹HUKKYV^UV\[[OLPY=VKV\ZVUNZ^P[O
7YV[LZ[HU[O`TUZ9L]LY[PUN[VHNLVSK[HJ[PJZVMJV]LY[WYHJ[PJLZKL]LSVWLKK\YPUNZSH]LY`
HUKWVZ[ZSH]LY`YLWYLZZPVU=VKV\JVUNYLNH[PVUZMLS[ZHMLYZPUNPUN[OL*H[OVSPJO`TUZ[OH[
HYLHSZVWHY[VM[OLPYSP[\YN`;OL`ZHUN[OLZPTWSL]LYZPVUVM¸(]L4HYPH¹JVTTVU[V/HP[PHU
*H[OVSPJTHZZLZ0[[LSSZ\ZHSV[[OH[[OLTLTILYZVM[OLTHQVYP[`YLSPNPVUVM[OLUH[PVUMLS[
]\SULYHISLHUKZ[PÅLK;OL*H[OVSPJHUK-YLUJOPKLU[PÄLKLSP[LZOH]LSVUN^HNLKJHTWHPNUZ
1VOU)SHJRPUNHow Musical Is Man?:LH[[SL!<UP]LYZP[`VM>HZOPUN[VU7YLZZ 10 0[OHUR)LYUPJL1VOUZVU9LHNVUMVYOLYPUZPNO[[OH[ZPUNPUNOLSWZJVU[YVSZWHJLZH`PUN[OH[^OLU(TLYPJHUJP]PSYPNO[Z
WYV[LZ[VYZIYVRLPU[VZVUNK\YPUNZP[PUZ[OL`[VVRV^ULYZOPWVM[OLZWHJLHUKJV\U[LYHJ[LK[OLHNNYLZZPVUZVMZOLYPMMZ
11 5H[PVUHS7\ISPJ9HKPV(\KPV7VZ[JHYK1HU\HY`^^^UWYVYN[LTWSH[LZZ[VY`Z[VY`WOW&Z[VY`0K$.
>`JSLM1LHUPUZLY[LK[OPZO`TU»ZS`YPJPUOPZ[YHJR¸.OL[[V9HJPUL¹MYVT[OLMasquerade album in 2002.
39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂27
VMYLWYLZZPVUHNHPUZ[=VKV\,]HUNLSPJHSJVUNYLNH[PVUZ[OH[]PL^=VKV\JVUNYLNH[PVUZHZ
HK]LYZHYPLZ[VILZPSLUJLKHYLHSZVPU[LYUH[PVUHSS`JVUULJ[LKHUK^LSSVYNHUPaLKHUKTVYL
HPK^HZÅV^PUN[V[OLT12
Singing for Haiti on TV
0TTLKPH[LS`HM[LY[OLX\HRLOP[>`JSLM1LHU.LVYNL*SVVUL`HUK4;=L_LJ\[P]LZLU]PZPVULK
H[LSL[OVU[VZ\WWVY[KPZHZ[LYYLSPLMPU/HP[PHUK[OLWYVK\J[PVUJHTL[VNL[OLYX\PJRS`)YVHKJHZ[SP]L[LUKH`ZHM[LY[OLX\HRL¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^¹^HZ[OLTVZ[^PKLS`]PL^LK[LSL[OVU
PUOPZ[VY`0[LMMLJ[P]LS`[VVRV]LY[OLTLKPHZWOLYLHUK^HZHPYLKJVTTLYJPHSMYLLVUL]LY`
THQVYUL[^VYRHUKJHISLJOHUULSPUJS\KPUN()*5)*-V_*55),;[OL*>*4;/)6
HUK=/HZ^LSSHZ4;=5L[^VYRZ>VYSK^PKL^OPJOYLHJOLZTPSSPVUOV\ZLOVSKZHUK
*550U[LYUH[PVUHS^OPJOYLHJOLZTPSSPVU0[^HZ[OLÄYZ[<:IHZLK[LSL[OVU[VHPYVU4;=
PU*OPUH130[^HZHSZVIYVHKJHZ[V]LY[OL0U[LYUL[VU@V\;\IL4`:WHJL/\S\HUK(63HUK
on the /\MÄUN[VU7VZ[^OPJOJVTWPSLK\WKH[LK[^LL[ZMYVTVYNHUPaH[PVUZPU/HP[P0U/HP[P
Z\Y]P]VYZJV\SKSPZ[LUPUVU[OLYHKPV·PM[OL`OHKVUL3PRL¸3P]L(PK¹[^LU[`Ä]L`LHYZLHYSPLY
P[^HZHT\S[P]LU\LL]LU[^P[O.LVYNL*SVVUL`OVZ[PUNPU3VZ(UNLSLZ>`JSLM1LHUOVZ[PUN
PU5L^@VYR1H`AHUK)VUVWLYMVYTPUNPU3VUKVUHUK*55»Z(UKLYZVU*VVWLYYLWVY[PUN
SP]LMYVTKV^U[V^U7VY[H\7YPUJL6M[OLLPNO[LLUT\ZPJHSU\TILYZQ\Z[[^V^LYLI`/HP[PHU
HY[PZ[Z!>`JSLM1LHUHUKJOHU[L\ZL,TTLSPUL4PJOLS
;OL ¸/VWL MVY /HP[P 5V^¹ [LSL[OVU \UMVSKLK PU H MVYT\SHPJ WH[[LYU [OH[ PU[LYZWLYZLK
T\ZPJHS WLYMVYTHUJLZ ^P[O JLSLIYP[PLZ YLHKPUN Z[VYPLZ HIV\[ [OL JV\YHNL VM Z\Y]P]VYZ HUK
^P[O ZOVY[ ZLNTLU[Z I` *55»Z (UKLYZVU *VVWLY PU /HP[P W\[[PUN *55 PU [OL HTIPN\V\Z
WVZP[PVUVMOLSWPUNYHPZLTVUL`MVYVYNHUPaH[PVUZ[OL`^LYLJV]LYPUN;OLILULÄJPHYPLZ^LYL
HSSUVUNV]LYUTLU[HSYLSPLMVYNHUPaH[PVUZ![OL9LK*YVZZ<50*,-<UP[LK5H[PVUZ>VYSK-VVK
7YVNYHT@tSL/HP[P-V\UKH[PVU6_MHT(TLYPJH7HY[ULYZPU/LHS[OHUK[OLUL^S`MVYTLK
*SPU[VU)\ZO/HP[P-\UK1\Z[VULVYNHUPaH[PVU^HZ/HP[PHU!@tSL[OLJOHYP[`>`JSLM1LHUHUK
OPZJV\ZPU1LYY`+\WSLZZPZOHKMV\UKLKPU*HZO^HZ^OH[^HZJHSSLKMVY"]PY[\HSS`HSSHPK
HUKYLZJ\LVYNHUPaH[PVUZ^LYLWSLHKPUNMVYTVUL`HUKUV[JSV[OLZNVVKZVYL]LU]VS\U[LLY
HZZPZ[HUJL0UKLLK[OL[LSL[OVUYHPZLKHYLJVYKHTV\U[!<:TPSSPVUI`[OLKH`HM[LY[OL
IYVHKJHZ[ SHYNLS` [OYV\NO UL^ [LJOUVSVNPLZ·[L_[TLZZHNLK KVUH[PVUZ HUK KV^USVHKLK
T\ZPJHSWLYMVYTHUJLZMVY
JLU[ZVYSH[LY<:
MVY[OL^OVSLHSI\TMYVTP;\ULZ9OHW-
ZVK`HUKV[OLYZ;OLHSI\TMYVT[OL[LSL[OVU^HZYLSLHZLKZVVUHM[LY[VHU\TILYVULZSV[
VU[OLWVWT\ZPJJOHY[ZPULPNO[LLUJV\U[YPLZ)L[^LLU[OPZHUKV[OLY[LSL[OVUZZ\WLYTHYRL[
12 -VYHUHUHS`ZPZVM[OLHU[HNVUPZTVM/HP[PHUL]HUNLSPJHSZ[V^HYK=VKV\ZLL,SPaHIL[O4J(SPZ[LY¸-YVT:SH]L9L]VS[[VH
)SVVK7HJ[^P[O:H[HU!;OL,]HUNLSPJHS9L^YP[PUNVM/HP[PHU/PZ[VY`¹Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses 41, no. 2
!¶
13 .PS2H\MTHU¸1H`A1\Z[PU;PTILYSHRL)VUV[V/LHKSPUL4;=»Zº/VWLMVY/HP[P»;LSL[OVU¹^^^T[]JVTUL^ZHY[PJSLZ
QH`aQ\Z[PU[PTILYSHRLIVUVOLHKSPULT[]ZOVWLOHP[P[LSL[OVUQO[TSHJJLZZLK1\S`
͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
KYP]LZHUKV[OLYJHTWHPNUZHULZ[PTH[LKOHSMVMHSSOV\ZLOVSKZPU[OL<UP[LK:[H[LZTHKL
HKVUH[PVU[V[OL/HP[PYLSPLMLMMVY[14
;OL¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^¹[LSL[OVU^HZHYN\HIS`HUPTWVY[HU[L]LU[PU[OH[[OLLU[PYL
[LSL]PZPVUPUK\Z[Y`KL]V[LKP[ZLSM[VKLTVUZ[YH[PUNJVUJLYUHUKJVTWHZZPVUMVYX\HRLZ\Y]P]VYZI`YHPZPUNM\UKZMVY[OLPYYLSPLM0[HSSV^LKVYKPUHY`JP[PaLUZ[OYV\NOV\[[OL]PL^PUNW\ISPJ
ZWOLYLHTLHUZ[VOLSW0U[OLJYP[PX\L[OH[MVSSV^Z0I`UVTLHUZ^HU[[VZH`[OH[[OPZHUK
V[OLY[LSL[OVUZZOV\SKUV[OH]LILLUZ[HNLK[OH[WLVWSLZOV\SKUV[OH]LJVU[YPI\[LKVY
[OH[LMMVY[ZH[O\THUP[HYPHUYLSPLMZOV\SKUV[OH]LILLUTHKL)\[0KV^PZO[VJVU[YPI\[L[V
[OLVUNVPUNPU[LYYVNH[PVUMYVTTHU`KPZJPWSPUHY`WLYZWLJ[P]LZVMO\THUP[HYPHUPZTHUKP[Z
JVU[YHKPJ[PVUZH[[OPZJ\S[\YHSZP[L[OH[MVYTZHUL_\ZVMWVW\SHYT\ZPJJVUZ\TW[PVUJLSLIYP[`
O\THUP[HYPHUPZTHUK(TLYPJHUJP]PSYLSPNPVU![OLKPZHZ[LYYLSPLM[LSL[OVU
/\THUP[HYPHU VYNHUPaH[PVUZ L_PZ[ WYLJPZLS` [V Y\ZO [V [OL HPK VM Z\MMLYPUN WVW\SH[PVUZ
;OL[LSL[OVU]PL^LY^OVPZUV[HWYVMLZZPVUHSO\THUP[HYPHUJHUHJ[[VHSSL]PH[LZ\MMLYPUNI`
JVU[YPI\[PUNTVUL`[O\ZM\SÄSSPUN[OLPYTVYHSVISPNH[PVU[VYLZWVUK;OL[LSL[OVU^HZKLZPNULK
[V M\UULS JVTWHZZPVU PU[V TH[LYPHS YLSPLM [V WYV]PKL H ^H` MVY H NSVIHS W\ISPJ [V YLZWVUK
Z\WWVY[P]LS`K\YPUNHUV]LY^OLSTPUN[YHNLK`;OPZSVNPJOHZILJVTLM\UKHTLU[HS[V^OH[
2LP[O;LZ[LYJHSSZ¸JVTTVUZLUZLO\THUP[HYPHUPZT¹150[ZSVNPJPZWYLTPZLKVU[OLPKLH[OH[
KPZHZ[LYZHYLHMHJ[VMSPMLLHY[OX\HRLZ]VSJHUVLZÅVVKZKYV\NO[HUKMHTPUL^HYHUKZV
VU HUK [OH[ ^OLU KPZHZ[LY Z[YPRLZ WYVMLZZPVUHS O\THUP[HYPHU HNLUJPLZ Z[LW PU ^P[O YLSPLM
)`]PY[\LVM[OPZPU[LY]LU[PVUHULTLYNLUJ`ZP[\H[PVUJHUILYLZVS]LKHUKHZVJPL[`JHUIL
YL[\YULK[V¸UVYTHS¹166YKPUHY`WLVWSLPU[\YUJHUJVU[YPI\[L[V[OLJH\ZL[OYV\NOJOHYP[HISL
KVUH[PVUZ;OL[LSL[OVUZLLTZ[OLWLYMLJ[]LOPJSL[VWYLZLU[HWSLHMVYZ\WWVY[HUK[VJVSSLJ[
JVU[YPI\[PVUZX\PJRS`"SHYNLHUKZTHSSKVUVYZHSPRLJHUTLL[[OLPYMLS[YLZWVUZPIPSP[PLZ[VOLSW
;VIV[OPUZWPYLHUK[OHUR[OLKVUVYZJLSLIYP[PLZWLYMVYTHUKTHRLHWWLHSZ@L[[OPZZLLTPUNS`VI]PV\ZYLSH[PVUZOPWIL[^LLULU[LY[HPUTLU[HUKO\THUP[HYPHUPZTPZUV[PUL]P[HISL"P[OHZ
HZWLJPÄJOPZ[VY`HUKOHZKL]LSVWLKPUYLZWVUZL[VLJVUVTPJTHYRL[JVUKP[PVUZ
0[[\YUZV\[[OH[THZZTLKPHOHZWSH`LKHJLU[YHSYVSLPU[OLOPZ[VY`VMO\THUP[HYPHUPZT
LZWLJPHSS`PU[OL<UP[LK:[H[LZ0UHZ[\K`VM[OLAmerican Red Cross Magazine and other
ZV\YJLZ2L]PU9VaHYPVZOV^ZOV^PU[OLLHYS`[^LU[PL[OJLU[\Y`¸[OLTHZZTLKPHP[ZLSMWSH`LK
HJY\JPHSYVSLPUYLZOHWPUN(TLYPJHU^H`ZVMZLLPUNMLLSPUNHUKYLZWVUKPUN[VZ\MMLYPUNI`
[YLH[PUN]PVSLUJLHUKWHPUHZWSLHZ\YLWYVK\JPUNJVTTVKP[PLZ¹17*OHYP[PLZZ\JOHZ[OL9LK
14 *OHYP[`5H]PNH[VY¸/HP[P,HY[OX\HRL!6UL@LHY3H[LY¹^^^JOHYP[`UH]PNH[VYVYNPUKL_JMT&IH`$JVU[LU[]PL^JWPK$
HJJLZZLK1\S`
15 2LP[O;LZ[LYHumanitarianism and Modern Culture<UP]LYZP[`7HYR!7LUUZ`S]HUPH:[H[L<UP]LYZP[`7YLZZP_6U[OL
JVTWSL_P[`VMO\THUP[HYPHUWYVJLZZLZZLL+H]PK9LPMMA Bed for the Night: Humanitarianism in Crisis5L^@VYR!:PTVU
HUK:JO\Z[LY
16 *YHPN*HSOV\U¸(>VYSKVM,TLYNLUJPLZ!-LHY0U[LY]LU[PVUHUK[OL3PTP[ZVM*VZTVWVSP[HU6YKLY¹Canadian Review of
Sociology and AnthropologyUV!¶ /LYL*HSOV\ULSHIVYH[LZVU[OLWYLTPZLZ[OH[THRL\W[OL¸ZVJPHS
PTHNPUHY`¹VMLTLYNLUJPLZHUKWVPU[ZV\[[OL^H`ZNSVIHSWYVJLZZLZIV[OL_HJLYIH[LHUKTHRLPU]PZPISLKPZ[HU[
[YV\ISLZKLLTLKLTLYNLUJPLZ
17 2L]PU9VaHYPV¸͎º+LSPJPV\Z/VYYVYZ»!4HZZ*\S[\YL[OL9LK*YVZZHUK[OL(WWLHSVM4VKLYU(TLYPJHU/\THUP[HYPHUPZT¹
American QuarterlyUV!
39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂29
*YVZZIVYYV^LKUHYYH[P]LHUK]PZ\HSZ[YH[LNPLZMYVTTV]PLZHUKW\SWTHNHaPULZ^OLU[OL`
MV\UK[OLTZLS]LZJVTWL[PUN^P[O[OLZLUL^JVTTLYJPHSWYVK\J[ZMVY[OLH[[LU[PVUVM[OL
W\ISPJ¸-YVT[OPZWVPU[VU¹9VaHYPVJVU[PU\LZ¸M\UKYHPZLYZ^V\SKOH]L[VKL]V[LHZT\JO
H[[LU[PVU[VHK]LY[PZPUNHZ[VL[OPJZHUK[VºLU[LY[HPUTLU[»HZ[VLK\JH[PVU¹;OPZTVKLYU
O\THUP[HYPHUPZT ILJHTL H ^PKLZWYLHK WOLUVTLUVU ¸H[ [OL ]LY` TVTLU[ [OH[ H ZLUZH[PVUHSPZ[PJTHZZTLKPHILNHU[VKVTPUH[L(TLYPJHUJ\S[\YL¹HUK[OL[LSL[OVUPZP[ZJ\YYLU[
neoliberal iteration.18
0U [OPZ JVTWSL_ HUK JVU[YHKPJ[VY` [LYYHPU PU ^OPJO LU[LY[HPUTLU[ ZLY]LZ HZ H JLU[YHS
JH[HS`Z[LUJV\YHNPUN[OLW\ISPJ[VZOV\SKLY[OLYLZWVUZPIPSP[`VMÄUHUJPUN[OLYLSPLMVMTHZZ
Z\MMLYPUNWVW\SHYTLKPHZ\JOHZ[OL[LSL[OVUZLY]L[VZL[[OLUHYYH[P]L]PZ\HSHUKH\KP[VY`
[LYTZ[OH[TV[P]H[LNP]PUN¸;OLTLKPHKLÄULZ[OLTVYHSZWHJLPU^OPJO[OLV[OLYHWWLHYZ
[V\ZHUKH[[OLZHTL[PTLPU]P[LZJSHPTZJVUZ[YHPUZHULX\P]HSLU[TVYHSYLZWVUZLMYVT\Z
[OLH\KPLUJL¹^YP[LZ9VNLY:PS]LYZ[VUL19(M[LY[OLLHY[OX\HRL[OL/HP[PVM*55WYLZLU[LK
[OYV\NOV\[ [OL [LSL[OVU ^HZ [OL TVYHS MYHTL^VYSK MVY /HP[P PU [OL THPUZ[YLHT (TLYPJHU
YLZWVUZL [V [OL X\HRL ;OL TVYHS PTWLYH[P]L ^HZ HY[PJ\SH[LK TVZ[ Z\JJPUJ[S` I` .LVYNL
*SVVUL`^OVZHPK¸;OL/HP[PHUWLVWSLULLKV\YOLSW°°0[»ZHIPN^VYSKV\[[OLYLHUK^LHSS
OH]LHSV[VMYLZWVUZPIPSP[`[VSVVRV\[MVYWLVWSL^OVJHU»[SVVRHM[LY[OLTZLS]LZ¹20
([ÄYZ[*SVVUL`»Z^VYKZZLLTVI]PV\ZS`[Y\L·[OL/HP[PHUWLVWSLULLK¸V\Y¹OLSWHUK
¸^L¹OH]LHTVYHSYLZWVUZPIPSP[`[VOLSW[OLT>LJHUHSZVVIZLY]L[OH[HZ*SVVUL`HY[PJ\SH[LK[OLTVYHSJVU[LU[^HZMYHTLKPUKPZ[PUJ[S`WH[LYUHSPZ[PJ[LYTZ![VSVVRV\[MVY[OVZL^OV
JHUUV[SVVRHM[LY[OLTZLS]LZ;OL]PL^LY[OL(TLYPJHU^V\SKWYV]PKL¸[OLSVVRPUNHM[LY¹
;OLZ\NNLZ[PVU[OH[(TLYPJHUZOH]LIV[O[OLJHWHJP[`HUKYLZWVUZPIPSP[`[VHJ[L]LU[OYV\NO
ZHJYPÄJLI`]PY[\LVMHNYHUKOPZ[VYPJTPZZPVUVMILPUNH¸SPNO[[V[OLUH[PVUZ¹PZHSVUNZ[HUKPUN
VULHUKMVYTZ[OLJVYLVM(TLYPJHUJP]PSYLSPNPVU0U[OLSVNPJVM[OL[LSL[OVU[OLLTLYNLUJ`
HUKP[ZZ\MMLYPUNPZOHWWLUPUNZVTL^OLYLLSZLHUK(TLYPJHUZH[OVTLZOV\SKTLL[[OLPY
YLZWVUZPIPSP[`[VOLSW
;OYV\NO[OLZLPTWSPLKSVNPJZ[LSL[OVUZ[LUK[VWYLZLU[HZ[HYRKP]PKLIL[^LLU[OL]PL^LY
HUK [OL WLVWSL Z\Y]P]PUN H JH[HZ[YVWOPJ L]LU[ IL[^LLU [OL ]PJ[PT HUK [OL Z[HY VU Z[HNL
IL[^LLU[OLHMÅPJ[LKHUK[OLZH]LK[OL\UMVY[\UH[LHUK[OLMVY[\UH[L>OLUHKPZHZ[LYOP[ZH
OPZ[VYPJHSS`VWWYLZZLKVYJVSVUPaLKWVW\SH[PVU[OLJSLHYKP]PKLLJOVLZVSKLYJVSVUPHSPZ[[YVWLZ
VMWVVYWV^LYSLZZUH[\YHS]PJ[PTZ^OVJHUUV[OLSW[OLTZLS]LZHUKYLX\PYLYLZJ\LI`[OL
Z[YVUN(TLYPJHUZOH]LSVUNYLWYLZLU[LK/HP[PHZHJOHV[PJHUK]PVSLU[UH[PVUVM\UY\S`HUK
\UNV]LYUHISLTHZZLZ[YHWWLKPULU[YLUJOLKWV]LY[`HZ¸[OLWVVYLZ[JV\U[Y`PU[OL>LZ[LYU
OLTPZWOLYL¹;OL[LSL[OVU^YV[L[OL[YVWLZVM]PVSLUJLV\[VM[OLZJYPW[HUKMVJ\ZLKVU[OL
18 Ibid., 429.
19 9VNLY:PS]LYZ[VULMedia and Morality: On the Rise of the Mediapolis*HTIYPKNL!7VSP[`7YLZZ"JP[LKPU;LZ[LY
Humanitarianism and Modern Culture, 43.
20 .LVYNL*SVVUL`¸;OL:[VY`)LOPUKº/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^»͎¹4;=5L^Z^^^T[]JVT]PKLVZUL^ZNLVYNL
JSVVUL`^HU[Z[VOLSW[OVZL^OVJHU[OLSW[OLTZLS]LZQO[TS
PK$HJJLZZLK1\S`
͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
PUUVJLUJLHUKISHTLSLZZULZZVM/HP[PHUZ:[PSS[OLJV\U[Y`ILJHTLVUJLHNHPU[OLZP[LVM
Z\MMLYPUNOLSWSLZZPUJVTWL[LUJLHUKULLKMYLLVMOPZ[VYPJHSJVU[L_[
;OLZ\JJLZZVM[OLMVYT\SH·TLHZ\YLKPUKVUH[PVUZJVSSLJ[LK·OPUNLZWYLJPZLS`VU[OL
KLOPZ[VYPJPaH[PVUVM[OL]PJ[PTZHUK[OLKLWVSP[PJPaH[PVUVM[OLKPZHZ[LY;OL[LSL[OVUÅH[[LULK
[OL/HP[PX\HRLPU[VjustHUH[\YHSKPZHZ[LY`L[THU`WVPU[V\[[OH[[OL/HP[PX\HRL^HZUV[ZV
ZPTWSL;LSL[OVUZLNTLU[ZL_WSHPULKUV[OPUNVM[OLZ[Y\J[\YHSJH\ZLZVM[OLOPNOKLH[O[VSSZ
;OLZLJH\ZLZSPLTVZ[KPYLJ[S`PU/HP[P»ZPUHKLX\H[LOV\ZPUNHYLZ\S[VMWV]LY[`SHYNLS`[PLK[V
PU[LYUH[PVUHSKLI[HUKPULX\P[HISL[YHKLKLHSZ;OLV]LYJYV^KPUN[OH[WYV]LKZVSL[OHSK\YPUN
[OLX\HRLPZHKPYLJ[JVUZLX\LUJLVMPU[LYUH[PVUHSIHURPUNPUZ[P[\[PVUZ»ULVSPILYHSZ[Y\J[\YHS
HKQ\Z[TLU[ WYVNYHTZ HUK [OL Z\IZLX\LU[ JVSSHWZL VM [OL /HP[PHU HNYPJ\S[\YHS ZLJ[VY [OH[
Z[LTTLKMYVT<:PTWVY[ZIV[OVM^OPJOJH\ZLZLUVYTV\ZY\YHS[V\YIHUTPNYH[PVU/HP[PHU
WV]LY[`PZHSZVHKPYLJ[SLNHJ`VM[OLWVSPJPLZVM[OL-YHUsVPZHUK1LHU*SH\KL+\]HSPLYKPJ[H[VYZOPWZ^OPJO[OL<UP[LK:[H[LZHJ[P]LS`Z\WWVY[LKHZHI\S^HYRHNHPUZ[-PKLS*HZ[YV»Z
*\IH;OL[LSL[OVUZJYPW[^OPJOTPNO[OH]L^VYRLK[VLK\JH[L[OLW\ISPJHIV\[/HP[PHUOPZ[VY`Z[\JR[V[OLZPTWSLJVTTVUZLUZLMYHTLVMUH[\YHSKPZHZ[LY7YLZ\THIS`KLS]PUNPU[V
SVUN[LYT WYVISLTZ MVY ^OPJO [OL <UP[LK :[H[LZ ILHYZ YLZWVUZPIPSP[` TPNO[ THRL WV[LU[PHS
JVU[YPI\[VYZMLLSSLZZUVISLPU[OLPYYVSLZPU¸[OLSVVRPUNHM[LY¹)\[HZ2H[OLYPUL4J2P[[YPJRHUK
*S`KL>VVKZHYN\LHIV\[/\YYPJHUL2H[YPUHWYLZLU[PUNHJYPZPZPU[LYTZVMUH[\YHSKPZHZ[LY
¸VUS` ZLY]LK [V UH[\YHSPaL WVVY HUK ISHJR HNVU` KPZ[YLZZ HUK KLH[O¹21 0U [OL HIZLUJL VM
OPZ[VYPJHSL_WSHUH[PVUISHJRHUKWVVYWLVWSLZLLT[VILWLYWL[\HSS`PUULLKHUK^OP[LZHUK
Americans their natural rescuers.
-VYHSSVMP[ZWVZP[P]LHJJVTWSPZOTLU[Z[OL¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^¹[LSL[OVUHSZVYLWYVK\JLK THU` VM [OL Z`TIVSPJ KLNYHKH[PVUZ [OH[ OH]L ILLU KPZJLYULK I` V[OLYZ ^OV ^YP[L
HIV\[IV[OKPZHZ[LYWOV[VQV\YUHSPZTHUKKPZLHZLJ\YL[LSL[OVUZ+PZHIPSP[`YPNO[ZHK]VJH[LZ
OH]LJYP[PX\LKHUU\HS[LSL[OVUZMVYJOPSKOVVKKPZLHZLWH[PLU[ZMVYYLPUMVYJPUNZ[LYLV[`WLZVM
[OL¸WP[PHISLWVZ[LYJOPSK¹VY¸PUZWPYH[PVUHSKPZHISLKWLYZVU¹22;OLLHY[OX\HRLYLSPLM[LSL[OVU
SPRL^PZLTV]LZIHJRHUKMVY[OIL[^LLUPTHNLZVMZ\Y]P]VYZHZVIQLJ[ZVMWP[`Z\JOHZHJOPSK»Z
IHUKHNLKMHJLHUKVMZ\Y]P]VYZVYYLZJ\LYZHZZV\YJLZVMPUZWPYH[PVUZ\JOHZ1HUL[[L>OH[
PZ TVYL ZLNTLU[Z VU UL^Z IYVHKJHZ[Z HUK [LSL[OVUZ [`WPJHSS` MVJ\Z VU YLZJ\LZ HUK [OL
OLYVPJ(TLYPJHUVY,\YVWLHUYLZJ\LYZ;OL[OV\ZHUKZVM/HP[PHUZ^OVK\NSV]LKVULZMYVT
Y\IISL^LYLWHZZLKV]LYPUMH]VYVMMVYLPNUYLZJ\LWYVMLZZPVUHSZZ\JOHZ[OL3VZ(UNLSLZ
ÄYLÄNO[LYZ^OVZLPUMYHYLKJHTLYHZHUKZWLJPHSPaLK[VVSZHSSV^LK[OLT[VMYLL1HUL[[LHUK
V[OLYZ;OLZLOLYVPJ]VS\U[LLYZNH]LWYVMV\UKS`VM[OLTZLS]LZHUK[OLPYZ[VYPLZHYL^VY[O`
VMH[[LU[PVU"`L[ZVHYL[OLZ[VYPLZVM[OLJV\U[SLZZ/HP[PHUZ^OVWLYMVYTLKYLZJ\LVWLYH[PVUZ
^P[OML^LYZWLJPHSPaLK[VVSZHUKSLZZMVYTHS[YHPUPUN;OL]PL^LYTVZ[SPRLS`HUVU/HP[PHU
21 2H[OLYPUL4J2P[[YPJRHUK*S`KL>VVKZ¸5V6UL2UV^Z[OL4`Z[LYPLZH[[OL)V[[VTVM[OL6JLHU¹PU2H[OLYPUL4J2P[[YPJR
HUK*S`KL>VVKZLKZBlack Geographies and the Politics of Place*HTIYPKNL4(!:V\[O,UK
22 1VZLWO7:OHWPYVNo Pity: People with Disabilities Forging a New Civil Rights Movement5L^@VYR!;PTLZ 39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂31
PZPU]P[LK[VZOHYL[OLWLYZWLJ[P]LL_JP[LTLU[HUK[YP\TWOVM[OLYLZJ\LYHUK[VHKK[V[OL
momentum with a contribution.
0UYLSPLM[LSL[OVUZ[OLZ\MMLYPUNIVK`PZÄN\YLKUV[HZP[LVMZLSMKL[LYTPUH[PVUI\[YH[OLY
HZHZPNU![OLIVK`PUKL_LZHJ[P]LHUKYLZPK\HSTLHUPUNZVMPUQ\Y`]PJ[PTOVVKVYULLK23;OL
Z[\KPVIHJRKYVWMVYTHU`VM[OL¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^¹[LSL[OVU»ZT\ZPJHSHJ[ZMLH[\YLKSHYNLY
[OHUSPMLWVY[YHP[ZVMZPUNSLMHJLZTVZ[S`^VTLUVYJOPSKYLU,HJOMHJL^HZLP[OLYPUQ\YLKVY
Z[YLHRLK^P[O[LHYZVY^HZ[OH[VMHZTHSSJOPSKSVVRPUNPUHU\W^HYKNHaL(Z3PPZH4HSRRP
^YP[LZ^VTLUHUKJOPSKYLUHYLYLWYLZLU[LKHZPUUVJLU[ZPUO\THUP[HYPHUYLWYLZLU[H[PVUZHUK
^P[OV\[OPZ[VYPJHSVYWVSP[PJHSJVU[L_[[OL`ILJVTLW\YLT\[LHUKZWLLJOSLZZ¸L_LTWSHY`
]PJ[PTZ¹24;OLPTHNLZYLK\JL[OL]PJ[PTZ[VMHJLZ^P[OSHYNLOH\U[PUNL`LZ[OLLMMLJ[VM^OPJO
PZ[VPUZ[HU[PH[L[OLYLSH[PVUZOPWIL[^LLU[OL]PJ[PTHUK[OLZWLJ[H[VY25
;OLIVKPLZHUK]VPJLZ[OH[HYLNP]LUV]LY^OLSTPUNS`TVYL[LSL[OVUL_WVZ\YLHYL[OVZL
VM[OLJLSLIYP[PLZZHMLS`YLTV]LKMYVT[OLKPZHZ[LY0U[OL¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^¹[LSL[OVU[OL
JLSLIYP[PLZ»IVKPLZHUKMHJLZ^LYLOPNOSPNO[LKPU[OLWLYMVYTHUJLZ[\KPVHZHNSV^OLHS[O`
HUK ILH\[PM\S LZWLJPHSS` Z[YPRPUN ^OLU Q\_[HWVZLK ^P[O PTHNLZ VM PUQ\YLK X\HRL ]PJ[PTZ
;OLWSLHZ\YLVM]PL^PUNHUKOLHYPUN[OLILH\[`VMHUHY[PZ[SPRL)L`VUJLQ\_[HWVZLKHNHPUZ[
[OLISVVKPLKMHJLZVM[OLLHY[OX\HRLZ\Y]P]VYZWYVK\JLZ[OL¸J\S[\YHSHULZ[OLZPH¹^OLYLI`
KPZHZ[LY]PJ[PTZVYYLM\NLLZILJVTL¸NLULYHSP[PLZVMIVKPLZIV\UKLKZ[HY]PUN°°°BDWYLZZLK
HNHPUZ[[OL[LSL]PZPVUZJYLLU¹;OLZLÄN\YLZVMTPZMVY[\ULILJVTL[OLTVYHSVWWVZP[LVM[OL
(TLYPJHU]PL^LY^OVPZVMMLYLK[OLVWWVY[\UP[`MVYLUKSLZZWO`ZPJHSYLMVYTZHUKYLUL^HSZ
[OYV\NO[OLJVTTLYJPHSPaLKTLZZHNLZHIV\[L_LYJPZLKPL[JVZTL[PJZHUK[YH]LS-LSKTHU
WVPU[ZV\[[OH[[OPZ¸]PZ\HSWVSHYP[`IL[^LLU[OLYLMVYTHISLIVKPLZVM[OLVIZLY]LYHUK[OL
KL[LYTPULK KLMVYTLK HUK YLK\JLK IVKPLZ VM [OL VIZLY]LK¹ JYLH[LZ [OL ]LY` YLSH[PVUZ VM
WV^LY[OH[PU[\YULZZLU[PHSPaL[OL[LSL]PZLKZ\MMLYLYPU[VHUH[\YHS]PJ[PT^P[OV\[HNLUJ`
RUV^SLKNLVYOPZ[VY`26;OLZV\UK[YHJRPU[\YUYLPUMVYJLZ[OPZWVSHYP[`ZPUJL[OLKPZHZ[LY
]PJ[PTZ»V^U]VPJLZHUKZVUNZHYLHIZLU[MYVT[OLIYVHKJHZ[
0UHJVTWSPJH[LK[YPHUN\SH[PVU[OLSPZ[LUPUN]PL^LYPZJVUZ\TPUNIV[O[OLHIQLJ[IVKPLZ
VM[OLPUQ\YLKHUK[OLO`WLYHLZ[OL[PJPaLKIVKPLZHUKZVUNZVM[OLJLSLIYP[PLZ^OPSLILPUN
LUJV\YHNLK[VQVPU[OLZ[HYZPUNP]PUN[V[OLZ\MMLYLYZ;OLJHSJ\S\ZVM]PL^PUNPUQ\Y`HUKWHPU
HSVUNZPKL]PZ\HSILH\[`HUKH\KP[VY`WSLHZ\YLPZHKLSPJH[LVUL[OH[[OL[LSL[OVUTH_PTPaLK
[VÄUHUJPHSZ\JJLZZ=PZ\HSHUKH\YHSYLNPZ[LYZ^VYRLK[VNL[OLY^P[O[OLLTV[PVUHS[VZW\Y
[OLW\ISPJ[VNP]LTVYL
23 6U[OLIVK`HZZP[LHUKZPNUZLL(UNLSHAP[V¸)VK`¹Material ReligionUV!¶
24 3PPZH/4HSRRP¸:WLLJOSLZZ,TPZZHYPLZ!9LM\NLLZ/\THUP[HYPHUPZTHUK+LOPZ[VYPJPaH[PVU¹Cultural Anthropology 11,
UV !
25 :LLHSZV1V,SSLU-HPYHUK3PZH7HYRZ¸(MYPJHVU*HTLYH!;LSL]PZPVU5L^Z*V]LYHNLHUK(LYPHS0THNPUNVM9^HUKHU
9LM\NLLZ¹Africa TodayUV!
26 -LSKTHU¸6U*\S[\YHS(ULZ[OLZPH¹
͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
;OLYLPZHUHMMLJ[P]LWVSP[PJZH[^VYRPUIYVHKJHZ[PUNPTHNLZVMKPZHZ[LYZPU[OPZULVSPILYHS
WLYPVK^OLU[OLHSSL]PH[PVUVMTHZZZ\MMLYPUNKLWLUKZSHYNLS`VUWYP]H[LZLJ[VYYLZV\YJLZ
/LYL ^L JHU ZLL [OH[ [OL <: ULVSPILYHS SVNPJZ [OH[ JVUULJ[ [OL WLYZVUHS HUK [OL WVSP[PJHS
L_[LUKPU[V[OLNSVIHSZWOLYLPU^OH[3H\YLU)LYSHU[JHSSZ¸[OLJVTWYLZZPVUVMUH[PVUHSSPML
PU[VHWWHYH[\ZLZVMPU[PTHJ`¹27;LSL[OVUZPU]P[L[OLSPZ[LUPUN]PL^LY[VKVUH[L[VPU[LYUH[PVUHS
YLSPLM^OPSLJVUZ\TPUNLTV[PVUHSS`L]VJH[P]LZVUNZHUKPTHNLZVMKPZHZ[LY;OL[LSL[OVU»Z
L_LJ\[P]LWYVK\JLY1VLS.HSSLUZHPKOL^VYRLK^P[O[OLHY[PZ[Z[VÄUKZVUNZ[OH[^V\SKÄ[
[OLL]LU[»Z[VUL¸;OL`»SSILZPUNPUNZVUNZ[OH[[OL`OH]LHULTV[PVUHSJVUULJ[PVU[VHUK[OH[
ILZ[YLÅLJ[[OLPYMLLSPUNZHIV\[[OPZ[YHNPJZP[\H[PVU¹OLZHPK28
4\ZPJ JHYYPLZ U\TLYV\Z LTV[PVUHS HZZVJPH[PVUZ [OH[ JHU IL JVU]L`LK [OYV\NO OHYmony, rhythm, melody, timbre, and tonality. Such emotionality is socially conditioned and
associational.294\ZPJSPRLVKVYZJHUIYPUNTLTVYPLZÅVVKPUN[VTPUKHZJVNUP[P]LZJPLUJL
KLTVUZ[YH[LZ LTWPYPJHSS`30 *LSLIYP[` HY[PZ[Z ^OV WLYMVYT K\YPUN [LSL[OVUZ NLULYHSS` ZPUN
[OLPYV^UWVW\SHYZVUNZ[OH[[OL`JVUZPKLYHWWYVWYPH[L[V[OLZP[\H[PVUZ\JOHZ4HKVUUH
^OVZHUN¸3PRLH7YH`LY¹VY[OL`ZPUNHUV[OLY^LSSRUV^UZVUNVYTLKSL`Z\P[HISLMVY[OL
VJJHZPVUZ\JOHZ)Y\JL:WYPUNZ[LLU^OVZHUN7L[L:LLNLY»ZJP]PSYPNO[ZHU[OLT¸>L:OHSS
6]LYJVTL¹0U[OLVUS`ZVUNJVTWVZLKMVY[OLVJJHZPVUHUK[OLVUS`VUL[VPUJS\KL-YLUJO
S`YPJZ1H`A9POHUUH)VUVHUK[OL,KNLZHUN¸:[YHUKLK/HP[P4VU(TV\Y¹^OPJOYHURLK
ÄYZ[PUP;\ULZKV^USVHKZI`[OLUL_[TVYUPUN
;OLSPZ[LUPUN]PL^LYPZH[VUJLJVUZ\TPUNHWVW\SHYZVUNPU[OLTVTLU[HUKHZZVJPH[PUNP[UVZ[HSNPJHSS`^P[OWYL]PV\ZTLTVYPLZ6MJV\YZLT\ZPJ»ZTLHUPUNPZWVS`]HSLU[HUKJHU
JVUQ\YLKPMMLYLU[HZZVJPH[PVUZ[VTHU`WLVWSLH[KPMMLYLU[[PTLZ;OPZUVZ[HSNPHPZWYLJPZLS`
^OH[KYP]LZ[OLHMMLJ[P]LTVTLU[\TVMWLYMVYTHUJLZ>OLU1\Z[PU;PTILYSHRLZHUN3LVUHYK
*VOLU»Z¸/HSSLS\QHO¹OLHSSV^LK`V\UN]PL^LYZ[V[OYPSSH[OPZWYLZLUJL^OPSLVSKLY]PL^LYZ
YLTPUPZJLK ^P[O H MHTPSPHY ZVUN HUK THU` MV\UK TLHUPUN PU [OL THU` IPISPJHS YLMLYLUJLZ
[OYV\NOV\[[OLS`YPJZ
3PRL^PZLTHU`(TLYPJHUZ0ZWVRL^P[OYLWVY[LKHWV^LYM\SYLHJ[PVUVMUVZ[HSNPHZHKULZZHUKWVPNUHUJ`^OPSL^H[JOPUN:[L]PL>VUKLYWLYMVYT7H\S:PTVU»Z OP[¸)YPKNL
V]LY;YV\ISLK>H[LY¹^P[OHNVZWLSJOVPYIHJRPUNOPT>VUKLY»ZWHY[PJPWH[PVUPUWHY[PJ\SHY
SLU[P[ZLSM[VU\TLYV\ZHZZVJPH[PVUZMVY(TLYPJHUHUKV[OLY]PL^LYZ![OL ZHUK Z
LYHZJP]PSYPNO[ZZ[Y\NNSLZHUK[OLZ[YLUN[OVM[OLISHJRJO\YJOTP_LKPU^P[OKLJHKLZVM
WLYZVUHSTLTVYPLZVMSPMLHUKSV]LSPZ[LUPUN[V:[L]PL>VUKLY7H\S:PTVUWLYMVYTLK¸)YPKNL
V]LY;YV\ISLK>H[LY¹MVY[OL¸;YPI\[L[V/LYVLZ¹[LSL[OVUHM[LY "UV^[OL]PL^PUNSPZ[LULY
27 3H\YLU)LYSHU[The Queen of America Goes to Washington City: Essays on Sex and Citizenship+\YOHT5*!+\RL
<UP]LYZP[`7YLZZ 28 +LUPZL4HY[PUHUK4H[LH.VSK¸:[HYZ[V;\YU6\[MVY/HP[P;LSL[OVU-YPKH`¹Los Angeles Times1HU\HY`
29 (UUHILS1*VOLU¸4\ZPJHZH:V\YJLVM,TV[PVUPU-PST¹PU7H[YPR51\ZSPUHUK1VOU(:SVIVKHLKZMusic and
Emotion: Theory and Research6_MVYK!6_MVYK<UP]LYZP[`7YLZZ
30 2SH\Z9:JOLYLYHUK4HYJLS9ALU[ULY¸,TV[PVUHS,MMLJ[ZVM4\ZPJ!7YVK\J[PVU9\SLZ¹PU1\ZSPUHUK:SVIVKHMusic and
Emotion, 369.
39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂33
TPNO[JVUULJ[>VUKLY»ZWLYMVYTHUJL^P[OV[OLYTVTLU[ZPU[OLPYV^UOPZ[VY`3PRL>VUKLY»Z
TVZ[VM[OLT\ZPJHSWLYMVYTHUJLZ^LYLLTV[PVUHSS`TLHUPUNM\SZVUNZ^P[OZPTWSLZ[YPWWLK
KV^UHYYHUNLTLU[Z;OLHJV\Z[PJYLNPZ[LY[OH[[OLHYYHUNLTLU[ZHJOPL]LKSLU[ZVSLTUP[`[V
[OLL]LU[HUKTHKL[OLWYVK\J[PVUZPTWSLY
4\ZPJHSZV^VYRZ[VPUÅ\LUJLLTV[PVU[OYV\NOLTWH[O`^P[O[OLHMMLJ[WLYMVYTLKI`[OL
HY[PZ[PUZSV^LKHJV\Z[PJHYYHUNLTLU["PUMHJPHSL_WYLZZPVU"PU]VJHS[PTIYLHUKJHKLUJL
;HRLMVYL_HTWSL[OLILH\[PM\SWLYMVYTHUJLVM¸/HSV¹I`)L`VUJL/LY YLSLHZLOHK
ILLUHSV]LZVUN¸)HI`0*HU:LL@V\Y/HSV¹:OLSH[LYJOHUNLK[OLS`YPJHZH[YPI\[L[V
4PJOHLS1HJRZVU!¸4PJOHLS0JHUZLL`V\Y/HSV¹:PTPSHYS`H[¸/VWLMVY/HP[P5V^¹ZOLZHUN
¸/HP[P0JHUZLL`V\Y/HSV@V\RUV^`V\»YLT`ZH]PUNNYHJL¹+YH^PUNVU*OYPZ[PHUPTHNLY`
/HP[PILJVTLZHUHUNLSVYZHPU[HUK[OL/HP[PHUWLVWSLHYLZHUJ[PÄLK[OYV\NO[OLPYPUUVJLU[
Z\MMLYPUN.P]LYZ[V/HP[PYLSPLMPU[\YUHYLYLKLLTLK[OYV\NOZHJYPÄJLMVY/HP[P0U[OPZZSV^LK
KV^UHJV\Z[PJ]LYZPVU^P[O*VSKWSH`»Z*OYPZ4HY[PUVUWPHUV)L`VUJL»ZWLYMVYTHUJL[YPNNLYLKHRPUKVMLTV[PVUHSJVU[HNPVU![OLSPZ[LULYJV\SKPKLU[PM`^P[O[OLZPUNLYHUKYLZWVUK
LTWH[OL[PJHSS`HJJVYKPUN[V[OL[PTIYLHUKTLZZHNLVM[OLZVUN
3PRL)L`VUJL»Z¸/HSV¹THU`[LSL[OVUZVUNZ^LYLSV]LZVUNZPU^OPJOZVTLHZWLJ[Z
VM[OLS`YPJZ^LYL[OV\NO[[VILHWWYVWYPH[LPUHKKYLZZPUN[OL[YHNLK`;OLZPTWSLJOVY\ZVM
*VOLU»Z¸/HSSLS\QHO¹WYLZ\THIS`JVTWLUZH[LKMVY[OLZL_\HSIVUKHNLPTHNLY`PU[OL]LYZLZ
HUK[OLZ\IZ[P[\[PUNVMHaitiMVYbabyPU)L`VUJL»ZZVUNHSSV^LKOLY[VYLW\YWVZLOLYS`YPJZ
MVY[OLVJJHZPVU)\[^OH[KVLZP[TLHU[OH[UVZ[HSNPJSV]LZVUNZOH]LILJVTLHWYPTHY`
TVKLVMLU[LY[HPUTLU[[OYV\NO^OPJOP[PZHWWYVWYPH[L[VYHPZLM\UKZMVYKPZHZ[LYYLSPLM&;OL
LTV[PVUHSJOHYNLVMHSV]LZVUNPZH^H`VMRUV^PUNSVJH[LKPU[OLWYP]H[LYLHSTVMHMMLJ[
HUK[OLPU[PTHJPLZVMIPVNYHWO`:\JOZVUNZ\Z\HSS`L]VRLHWHPYVMSV]LYZUV[HJVSSLJ[P]L
TV]LTLU[HUK^OLU[OLSPZ[LULYPKLU[PÄLZ^P[O[OLT\ZPJOLVYZOLPKLU[PÄLZ^P[OHÅLL[PUN
JH\ZL;OL[LSL[OVU»ZTVYHSPTWLYH[P]L[V^HYKYLZWVUZPIPSP[`MVYZ\MMLYPUNNSVIHSULPNOIVYZ
PZZVVM[LUJV\JOLKPU[OLPKPVTVMUVZ[HSNPHHUKYVTHU[PJSV]L;OPZTHRLZZLUZL^OLU^L
JVUZPKLY[OH[[OLULVSPILYHSLJVUVTPJZ[Y\J[\YLWYLZLU[S`NV]LYUPUN[OL<UP[LK:[H[LZHUK
I`L_[LUZPVU[OL(TLYPJHZPZM\UKHTLU[HSS`HWYVJLZZVMWYP]H[PaPUNW\ISPJSPML·VMZVJPHS
ZLY]PJLZVMPUZ[P[\[PVUZVMJP[PaLUZOPW(MMLJ[P]LSPMLPZHY[PJ\SH[LK^P[O[OPZWYVJLZZ(Z(UUH
4J*HY[O`HYN\LZ¸,TV[PVUPZH[Y\[OLMMLJ[WYVK\JLKHSVUN^P[OSPILYHSPZT»ZPKLHSVMIV\UKLK
PUKP]PK\HSPZT¹31(UPUKP]PK\HSJHUNP]L[VKPZHZ[LYYLSPLMPUWHY[[OYV\NOH[YPHUN\SH[PVUVMPTHNPULKYLSH[PVUZ![OLZ\MMLYPUNVM[OL]PJ[PTYLSH[LZ[V[OLNP]LY»ZWYP]H[LPU[PTH[LZ\MMLYPUNV]LY
YVTHUJL6[OLYZOH]LHYN\LK[OH[[OPZRPUKVMLTV[P]PZTPZ[OLWYPTHY`TVYHSKPZJV\YZLVM
[OLHNLVUL[OH[JVSSHWZLZTVYHSQ\KNTLU[ZPU[VL_WYLZZPVUZVMWYLMLYLUJLHUKMLLSPUNHUK
[O\ZPZTVYLJVUJLYULK[VPUÅ\LUJLH[[P[\KLZ[OYV\NOLTV[PVU[OHUILSPLMZ^P[OHYN\TLU[32
¸2LLW/HP[PPU`V\YOLHY[Z¹ZHPKH[L_[TLZZHNLMYVT2HUZHZJYVZZPUN[OL[LSL[OVUZJYLLU
31 (UUH4J*HY[O`¸9LHSP[`;LSL]PZPVU!(5LVSPILYHS;OLH[LYVM:\MMLYPUN¹Social TextUV!
32 ;LZ[LYHumanitarianism and Modern Culture, 88.
͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
;VILZ\YLV[OLYLTV[PVUZHYLH[^VYRILZPKLZYVTHU[PJSV]L(]PL^LY»ZNP]PUNHSZVWP]V[Z
VUHJVTWSPJH[LKMVYTVMJVTWHZZPVUVUL[OH[LJOVLZL]HUNLSPJHSJHSSZMVYJOHYP[HISLNP]PUN
;OPZJHSSJHYYPLZ[OLSVUNPUNMVY¸NLU\PULJVTT\UP[`¹HUKNP]PUN[VNL[OLY^P[O¸HOH\U[LK
ZLUZLVMV[OLYPUN¹33;LSL[OVUWLYMVYTHUJLZHYLKLZPNULK[VHJ[P]H[LV\YJVTWHZZPVUHUK
TVIPSPaLYLSPLMJHWP[HS)\[HZ,SPaHIL[O:WLSTHUHYN\LZ¸*VTWHZZPVUH[LWLVWSLBHYLDHISL[V
RLLW[OLZ\MMLYLYZKHUNSPUNH[HKLSPJPV\ZHUKJY\LSKPZ[HUJL¹;OLYLPZHS^H`Z[OLKHUNLYVM
¸T\[PUN[OLZ\MMLYLYVMTHRPUNOPTVYOLYHUºVIQLJ[»VMJVTWHZZPVU¹340U[OLYLSPLM[LSL[OVU
[OL Z\MMLYLYZ ^LYL X\P[L SP[LYHSS` T\[LK HUK [OLPY ]VPJLZ V]LYK\IILK ^P[O [OVZL VM T\ZPJ
PUK\Z[Y`Z\WLYZ[HYZ
>OLU[OLPTHNLVMZ\MMLYPUNPZHJJVTWHUPLKI`T\ZPJLTV[PVUPZPU[LUZPÄLKHUK[OL
YLZVS\[PVU[V[OLZ\YNLVMLTV[PVUHSP[`PZ[VJHSSVY[L_[HKVUH[PVU¸;OLYLPZZOHTLHZ^LSSHZ
ZOVJRPUSVVRPUNH[[OLJSVZL\WVMHYLHSOVYYVY¹^YP[LZ:VU[HN35;OLVUS`^H`[VYLJVUJPSL[OL
ZOHTLPZ[VKVZVTL[OPUN[VHSSL]PH[LP[@L[ZOHTLTH`IL[OLPU]LYZLVMHUV[OLYLTV[PVU[OH[
PUZWPYLZKVUH[PVUZ0M(TLYPJHUZHYL¸SVVRPUNHM[LY¹[OVZL¸^OVJHUUV[SVVRHM[LY[OLTZLS]LZ¹
P[PZHJSHZZPJZLUZLVM(TLYPJHUYLZWVUZPIPSP[`[OH[HUPTH[LZTHU`NP]LYZ7H\S3VUNTVYL
THRLZ[OLWVPU[[OH[[LSL[OVUZHYLYP[\HSZVM(TLYPJHUJP]PSYLSPNPVU/L^YP[LZ[OH[¸[LSL[OVU
KVUH[PVUPZHJVSSLJ[P]LYP[LKLZPNULK[VLUHISL(TLYPJHUZ[VKLTVUZ[YH[L[V[OLTZLS]LZ[OH[
[OL`Z[PSSILSVUN[VHTVYHSJVTT\UP[`[OH[[OL`OH]LUV[Z\JJ\TILK[VTH[LYPHSPZT[OH[[OL`
HYLNP]LYZ^OVM\SÄSS[OLPYVISPNH[PVUZ[V[OLPYULPNOIVYZ¹/LNVLZVU[VZH`[OH[¸[OLJLYLTVUPHSJV\U[LYPTHNL[VJVUZWPJ\V\ZJVUZ\TW[PVUPZJVUZWPJ\V\ZJVU[YPI\[PVU¹+\YPUN[OL/HP[P
[LSL[OVUP[^HZHUUV\UJLK[OH[.LVYNL*SVVUL`HUK:HUKYH)\SSVJROHKLHJONP]LUHTPSSPVU
KVSSHYZ[V[OLJH\ZLHZOHK)YHK7P[[HUK(UNLSPUH1VSPL;OLZLTVTLU[Z\UKLYZJVYL[OL^H`
M\UKYHPZLYZHYLUH[PVUHSPZ[YP[\HSZPU^OPJOVYKPUHY`JP[PaLUZWLYMVYT[OLPYTVYHSZ[HUKPUNHUK
[OLPYW\ISPJ]PY[\L36*P]PSTPUKLKHUKJVTWHZZPVUH[L(TLYPJHUZNP]L[V[OLYLSPLMLMMVY[HUK
[OLWYVWLYH\[OVYP[PLZKV[OLPYQVI[VOLSW4LHU^OPSL[OLTLKPH[VYWYPLZ[Z^OVJVUULJ[[OL
Z\MMLYPUN]PJ[PTZ[OLYLSPLMHNLUJPLZHUK[OLPUKP]PK\HS(TLYPJHUKVUVYZHYL[OLX\HZPKLP[PLZ
VM(TLYPJHUJP]PSSPML![OLJLSLIYP[PLZ
Wyclef Jean, Sound Rebel, Celebrity Haitian Humanitarian
>`JSLM 1LHU VJJ\WPLZ ZL]LYHS WVZP[PVUZ ZPT\S[HULV\ZS` [OH[ HYL \Z\HSS` KPZ[PUJ[ HUK [OPZ
HSSV^LKOPZPU]VS]LTLU[PU[OL[LSL[OVU[VKLWHY[MYVT[OLWH[LYUHSPZ[PJHZWLJ[ZVM[OLZJYPW[
)VYUHUKYHPZLK\U[PS[OLHNLVM[LUPUHKPZ[YPJ[Q\Z[V\[ZPKL[OL/HP[PHUJHWP[HS>`JSLMOHPSZ
33 4LSHUP4J(SPZ[LY¸>OH[0Z@V\Y/LHY[-VY&(MMLJ[HUK0U[LYUH[PVUHSPZTPU[OL,]HUNLSPJHS7\ISPJ:WOLYL¹American Literary
HistoryUV!
34 ,SPaHIL[O=:WLSTHUFruits of Sorrow)VZ[VU!)LHJVU "JP[LKPUPIPK¶
35 :VU[HNRegarding the Pain of Others, 42.
36 7H\S23VUNTVYL¸*VUZWPJ\V\Z*VU[YPI\[PVUHUK(TLYPJHU*\S[\YHS+PSLTTHZ!;LSL[OVU9P[\HSZVM*SLHUZPUNHUK
9LUL^HS¹PU+H]PK;4P[JOLSSHUK:OHYVU3:U`KLYLKZThe Body and Physical Difference: Discourses of Disability (Ann
(YIVY!<UP]LYZP[`VM4PJOPNHU7YLZZ ¶
39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂35
MYVTHZLJ[VYVM[OLISHJRTHQVYP[`HUKUV[MYVT[OLLSP[L/PZYPZL[VZ\WLYZ[HYKVT^P[O[OL
Z\JJLZZVM[OLOPWOVWNYV\W[OL-\NLLZHSSV^LKOPT[V]H\S[V]LY[OL/HP[PHUJSHZZHUKJVSVY
OPLYHYJO`[VHWVZP[PVUH[[OLZVJPHSHUKLJVUVTPJaLUP[O/LPZHSZVHYN\HIS`IV[OH/HP[PHU
Z\Y]P]VYVM[OLX\HRL»Z[YH\TH^OV^LU[[VJVSSLJ[HUKI\Y`JVYWZLZPU[OLX\HRL»ZHM[LYTH[O
HUKHU(TLYPJHUT\ZPJPHU^VYRPUN[VPUZWPYLJOHYP[HISLNP]PUN(MYPLUKHUKHY[PZ[PJJVSSHIVYH[VYVMTHU`V[OLYJLSLIYP[PLZ)YHK7P[[(UNLSPUH1VSPL.LVYNL*SVVUL`HUKJV\U[SLZZV[OLYZ
>`JSLMSLU[HOPU[VMPTTLKPHJ`[V[OL[LSL[OVUZJYPW[HUK[OLHY[PZ[Z»HKSPIILKJVTTLU[Z/L
ZLLTLK[VLTIVK`Q\Z[VULKLNYLLVMZLWHYH[PVUIL[^LLU/HP[PHUZ\Y]P]VYZHUK[OLJLSLIYP[PLZ
^VYRPUN[OL[LSL[OVU0U[\YUOLHSSV^LK[OLH\KPLUJLHUPTHNPULKWLYZVUHSJVUULJ[PVU
>`JSLM»Z HJ[ MVY [OL [LSL[OVU ^HZ H ÄUHSL [OH[ ZOV^JHZLK H X\PU[LZZLU[PHSS` /HP[PHU
VYPLU[H[PVU[VT\ZPJ/LWLYMVYTLKHKPZ[PUJ[S`/HP[PHUT\ZPJNLUYLHUK^HZ[OLVUS`HY[PZ[
[VZPUNPU2YL`~S[OLSHUN\HNLVM/HP[P»ZTHQVYP[`9V\UKPUNV\[[OL[LSL[OVUPU[OLSHZ[ZLNTLU[HZZPTPSHYS`5L^6YSLHUZUH[P]L+Y1VOUOHKKVULMVY[OL/\YYPJHUL2H[YPUH[LSL[OVU
>`JSLM^VYLHSHYNL/HP[PHUÅHNHZHZJHYMHUKHWWLHYLK^P[OHM\SSIHUKVM/HP[PHUT\ZPJPHUZ
PUJS\KPUNOPZZPZ[LY4LSR`VU]VJHSZHUKOPZJV\ZPU1LYY`VUIHZZ/LILNHUPU,UNSPZO^P[O
[OLPJVUPJ1HTHPJHU9HZ[HMHYPZVUN¸)`[OL9P]LYZVM)HI`SVU¹I`[OL4LSVKPHUZ;OPZWPLJL
IHZLKVU7ZHSTL]VRLK[OLHUJPLU[0ZYHLSP[LZ»)HI`SVUPHUL_PSLHUKZVYYV^PTWSPJP[S`
ZP[\H[PUN[OLX\HRLKPZHZ[LY^P[OPUHOPZ[VY`VM[OLZ\MMLYPUNVM(MYV*HYPIILHUZPU[OL4PKKSL
7HZZHNLHUKZSH]LY`[PTLZ3PRLOPZWLYMVYTHUJLMVY[OL]PJ[PTZVM ^OLYLOPZYLUKP[PVU
VM¸9LKLTW[PVU:VUN¹^HZ¸HWV^LYM\SºTPUVYP[`YLWVY[»[OH[W\[YHJLHUKPTWLYPHSPZTH[[OL
OLHY[VM[OLTH[[LY¹>`JSLMIYV\NO[HZWHYRVMOPZ[VYPJP[`HUK7HU*HYPIILHUZLUZPIPSP[`[V
[OLL]LUPUN37(M[LYH]LYZLVM¸)HI`SVU¹OLZLN\LKPU[VOPZV^UKPYNLSPRLJVTWVZP[PVUPU
2YL`~S¸@tSL¹¸*Y`¹HZSV^HUKL]VJH[P]LZVUN[OH[Z\TTVUZ¸0M`V\OH]LH]VPJLZOV\[
V\[PM`V\OH]L[LHYZJY`V\[¹
(M[LY H ZOVY[ [PTL OL Z[VWWLK [OL IHUK HIY\W[S` PU H YLOLHYZLK PU[Y\ZPVU ZOV\[PUN
¸,UV\NO^P[O[OLTVWPUNSL[»ZYLI\PSK/HP[P¹3PRLHJVY[LNLVM5L^6YSLHUZQHaaTLUJVTPUN
IHJRMYVT[OLJLTL[LY`[OLIHUKI\YZ[PU[VYHYH·[OLL_OPSHYH[PUNWHYHKLT\ZPJMYVT[OL
/HP[PHUJV\U[Y`ZPKL7SH`LKVUOHUKMHZOPVULKIHTIVVHUKTL[HSOVYUZHUKOHUKKY\TZ[OPZ
WHYHKPUNT\ZPJHSMVYTPZZPUN\SHY[V/HP[P0[MVYTZ[OLZV\UKZJHWLVMHJHYUP]HSLZX\LMLZ[P]HS
HUKHYLSPNPV\ZYP[\HSHSS^YHWWLKPU[VVUL4VZ[]PL^LYZ^V\SKIL\UH^HYL[OH[YHYHT\ZPJPZ
WSH`LKPUM\ULYHSZPU[OL/HP[PHUJV\U[Y`ZPKLHUKZ\YLS`OLHYKP[HZ[OL\WILH[JLSLIYH[VY`
sound that it also is.38
9HYHT\ZPJWYV]PKLZHWV^LYM\SHUKKPZ[PUJ[ZVUPJHZZVJPH[PVUMVYTVZ[/HP[PHUZ7YVIHIS`KH[PUNIHJR[V[OLT\ZPJHSIHUKZVM[OLTHYVVUHYTPLZ^OVYLZPZ[LKZSH]LY`[OL]LY`
ZV\UKVMYHYHOHZSVUNILLUJVUZPKLYLKI`LSP[LZ[VIL\UY\S`IYHZOHUKSV^IYV^5VV[OLY
37 1LMMYL`4LSUPJR9/11 Culture: America Under Construction5L^@VYR!1VOU>PSL`HUK:VUZ 38 -VYTVYLVU[OLOPZ[VY`HUKJVU[L_[VM9HYHZLL,SPaHIL[O(4J(SPZ[LYRara! Vodou, Power, and Performance in Haiti and
Its Diaspora)LYRLSL`!<UP]LYZP[`VM*HSPMVYUPH7YLZZ
͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
UH[PVUWSH`ZYHYHILZPKLZ+VTPUPJHUZULHY[OL/HP[PHUIVYKLYHUKZVP[ZZPUN\SHYS`WP[JOLK
OVYUZOH]LILJVTLHUH\YHSPUKL_VMPKLU[P[`9HYHT\ZPJOPZ[VYPJHSS`OHZWYV]PKLKH]LU\L
MVYNYV\WZ[VZH`^OH[PUKP]PK\HSZJV\SKUV[[VZLUKTLZZHNLZVMWVW\SHYVWPUPVUVYWVSP[PJHS
Z[YH[LNPJJVUZLX\LUJL\UKLY[OLJV]LYHUKWYV[LJ[PVUHMMVYKLKI`SHYNLWHYHKPUNNYV\WZ
9HYHPZ[OLYLMVYLHUVWWVY[\UP[`MVY[OLHY[PZ[Y`VMJVKLKZWLLJOHUK>`JSLM»Z[LSL[OVU
YHYHKLSP]LYLKZL]LYHSWVPNUHU[ZOV\[V\[ZÄYZ[[V(UKLYZVU*VVWLYVM*55HUKUL_[[V2PUN
2PUV[OLSLHKZPUNLYMVY[OLIHUK7OHU[VT^OVOHKILLUY\TVYLK[VILKLHKI\[^HZUV[
5L_[>`JSLMJHSSLK[OLUHTLZVM1PTT`6-HU-HUHUK3P[[SL*SPMM6US`[OVZLJSVZLS`MVSSV^PUN[OLUL^ZMYVT/HP[P^V\SKRUV^[OLZL/HP[PHUYHWWLYZ^OVOHKKPLKPU[OLX\HRL;OL
WLYMVYTHUJL^OPSLVU[OLNSVIHSZ[HNLILMVYLTPSSPVUZ^HZHSZVHUPUZPKLYHMMHPYHTVTLU[
VM¸K\HSHKKYLZZP]P[`¹39^OVZLTLZZHNLZ^LYLMVYTLTILYZVM[OL/HP[PHUKPHZWVYH
;OL YHYH S`YPJ JVTWVZLK MVY [OL VJJHZPVU Z^P[JOLK IHJR [V ,UNSPZO 0[ YO`[OTPJHSS`
HZZLY[LK¸,HY[Oquake, we see the earth shakeI\[[OLZV\SVM[OL/HP[PHUWLVWSLP[^PSSUL]LY
break¹9LHJOPUN[V[V\JO[OLWZ`JOPJKL]HZ[H[PVUVMZVTHU`/HP[PHUZ>`JSLM»ZZVUN^HZH[
VUJL/HP[PHU[V/HP[PHUHUK(TLYPJHU[V(TLYPJHUTLKPH[PUNZL]LYHSVYPLU[H[PVUZ[V[OLX\HRL
HUKP[ZT\ZPJ/LHUKOPZT\ZPJPHUZWYVK\JLKHZVUPJPU[LY]LU[PVUPU[V[OLJ\S[\YHSHULZ[OLZPH
[OH[OHKJOHYHJ[LYPaLK[OLYLZ[VM[OL[LSL[OVU>`JSLMPUNLUPV\ZS`PUZLY[LK[OLSV\KHUHYJOPJ
ZLUZVY`WYLZLUJLVM[OL¸PU`V\YMHJL¹T\ZPJVM[OLWVW\SHYJSHZZLZ[OPZM\ULYHY`JLSLIYH[PVU
MLZ[P]HSPU[V[OLZV\UKZJHWLVM[OL[LSL[OVUHZP[ZÄUHSHJ[9LM\[PUN[OLHZZVJPH[PVUVM/HP[PHUULZZHZHT\[LZPNUVMZ\MMLYPUN>`JSLMJOVZL[OLVSKLZ[HUKSV\KLZ[T\ZPJVMYLZPZ[HUJL[V
IYVHKJHZ[/HP[PHUULZZHZHZP[LVMHJ[PVUHUKHNLUJ`
6MJV\YZL>`JSLM^HZVUS`HISL[VTHRL[OPZPU[LY]LU[PVUZ\JOHZP[^HZILJH\ZLVMOPZ
Z\WLYJLSLIYP[`Z[H[\Z)VYUPUH[OH[JOLKOV\ZL^P[OV\[LSLJ[YPJP[`OLPZUV^HU(SPZ[JLSLIYP[`^OVOHZILJVTLHYV]PUN/HP[PHUHTIHZZHKVYSLJ[\YLKH[.VVNSLOLHKX\HY[LYZ^VUHU
H^HYKH[/HY]HYKWSH`LKMVYH)HYHJR6IHTHPUH\N\YHSIHSSHUKMV\UKLKHO\THUP[HYPHU
UVUNV]LYUTLU[HSVYNHUPaH[PVU/LL]LUW\[PUHIPKMVY[OL/HP[PHUWYLZPKLUJ`PUVUS`
[VILKPZX\HSPÄLK\UKLYYLZPKLUJ`YLX\PYLTLU[Z
0[ZLLTZ[LSSPUN[OH[JLSLIYP[PLZ^V\SKW\SS[VNL[OLYMVY[OLTVZ[^PKLS`IYVHKJHZ[[LSL[OVU
PUOPZ[VY`[VILULÄ[/HP[P[OLISHJRYLW\ISPJSVUNJVUZPKLYLK[OL¸TVZ[(MYPJHU¹UH[PVUPU[OL
*HYPIILHU/HP[POHZHYN\HIS`JVTL[VVJJ\W`HZPTPSHYWVZP[PVU[V[OH[VM[OLT`[OPJHS¸(MYPJH¹
VMJLSLIYP[`O\THUP[HYPHUPZT*SVVUL`SPRLV[OLYJLSLIYP[PLZOHZILJVTLPU]VS]LK^P[O]HYPV\Z
JH\ZLZPU(MYPJH[V[OLL_[LU[[OH[¸(MYPJH¹OHZILJVTL[OLTHPUMVJ\ZVMJVTTVUZLUZL
O\THUP[HYPHUPZT ;OL ZJHYL X\V[LZ HYV\UK Africa YLMLY OLYL [V H T`[OPJHS HUK UH[\YHSPaLK
VIQLJ[VM>LZ[LYU[OV\NO[JVTWYPZPUNHULU[PYLJVU[PULU[PUULLKVMKLI[YLSPLMMHJPSP[H[LK
I`)VUVM\SSVM^HY[VYUHYLHZJOPSKZVSKPLYZMHTPULYLM\NLLJHTWZ(0+:NPYSZPUULLKVM
LK\JH[PVUI`6WYHO>PUMYL`HUKVYWOHUZPUULLKVMHKVW[PVUI`4HKVUUHHUK(UNLSPUH
39 4PROHPS)HRO[PUSpeech Genres and Other Late EssaysLK*HY`S,TLYZVUHUK4PJOHLS/VSX\PZ[[YHUZ=LYU>4J.LL
(\Z[PU!<UP]LYZP[`VM;L_HZ7YLZZ 39 • November 2012 • Elizabeth McAlister |͂37
1VSPL40 ;OL THPU MVJ\Z VM *SVVUL`»Z JVUZPKLYHISL O\THUP[HYPHU ^VYR OHZ ILLU PU +HYM\Y
:\KHU^OLYLOLPUZ[HSSLKHWYP]H[LZH[LSSP[L[VTVUP[VYTPSP[HY`TV]LTLU[ZVU[OLUVY[OZV\[O
IVYKLYPUVYKLY[VWYL]LU[HUV[OLYNLUVJPKL41:PUJL[OLLHY[OX\HRL/HP[POHZILJVTLHRPUK
VMTL[VU`TMVY(MYPJHPU[LYTZVMIV[OYLWYLZLU[H[PVUHUKJLSLIYP[`YLZWVUZL>`JSLM1LHU»Z
O\THUP[HYPHU ^VYR PU /HP[P OHZ H[[YHJ[LK V[OLY Z[HYZ [V [OL JV\U[Y` Z\JO HZ )YHK 7P[[ HUK
(UNLSH1VSPL0U[\YU)LU:[PSSLYHUK:LHU7LUUOH]LPU]VS]LK[OLTZLS]LZPUWVZ[X\HRL/HP[P
HZOH]LJV\U[SLZZ*OYPZ[PHUTPZZPVUHYPLZ
Epilogue: Muted Haitian Audiospheres and
American Evangelical Fundraising
/HP[PHU X\HRL Z\Y]P]VYZ NH[OLYLK LU THZZL [V ZPUN VU [OL VULTVU[O HUUP]LYZHY` VM [OL
KPZHZ[LYÄSSPUN[OLHYLHVM7VY[H\7YPUJLHYV\UK[OLJVSSHWZLKWHSHJL(JVSSLJ[P]LVM[YHUZUH[PVUHSL]HUNLSPJHS7YV[LZ[HU[VYNHUPaH[PVUZOLSKH[OYLLKH`YL]P]HS[VJVTTLTVYH[L[OL
KPZHZ[LYHUK[VUHYYH[LP[HZHWHY[VM.VK»ZWSHU[VYLKLLT/HP[P;OLL]LU[[VVR[OLWSHJLVM
*HYUP]HS^OPJOMLSSVULTVU[OHM[LY[OLX\HRL7HZ[VYZPU[LYZWLYZLKZLYTVUZHUKZWLLJOLZ
^P[OO`TUZ^OPJO[OL]HZ[JYV^KZHUN[VNL[OLY6U[OL[OPYKKH`0[OV\NO[0YLJVNUPaLK[OL
ZVUN1HUL[[LOHKZ\UNHZZOL^HZSPM[LKV\[MYVT\UKLY[OLJVSSHWZLKI\PSKPUN!¸5LWHZH]VPY
WL\YKLSHTVY[¹;OLS`YPJZHZZ\YLK[OH[.VK^PSSKLSP]LYOPZWLVWSLHUKIYPUN[OLT[OYV\NO
HU`Z[Y\NNSL(Z[OLL]LU[^LU[VU[OLJYV^KZHUNTVYLLULYNL[PJHSS`KLZWP[LZ[HUKPUNMVY
[OYLLKH`ZHUKKLZWP[L[OLPYMHZ[PUNPUYLWLU[HUJL/HUKZPU[OLHPYZPUNPUNSV\KS`HUKZ^H`PUN[OLJYV^KNH]LVMMHULULYN`[OH[]LYNLKVU[OLSP]LS`H[TVZWOLYLVM*HYUP]HS;OV\ZHUKZ
HUK[OV\ZHUKZVMWLVWSL^LYLZPUNPUNVULZVUN[VNL[OLYTV]PUN[OLPYIVKPLZ^P[OVULNYLH[
W\SZL6UJLHNHPU/HP[PHUZ\Y]P]VYZKLWSV`LKZPUNPUNHZH\UPM`PUNOLHSPUNTLHUPUNTHRPUN
HUKJVTT\UP[`I\PSKPUN[LJOUPX\L
3H[LYZVTLVM[OLZWVUZVYPUN(TLYPJHUTPZZPVUHYPLZJYLH[LKH]PKLV[VJLSLIYH[L[OL
L]LU[;OLMVV[HNLZOV^LK[OLZX\HYL[OLTHZZLZVMWLVWSL[OLWHZ[VYZ[OLZR`SPUL;OL
ZV\UK[YHJRPUJS\KLKOHUKZJSHWWPUNJSHWWPUNMVY[OL[YHUZMVYTH[PVUVM/HP[P)\[HZ[OLÄST
MVJ\ZLKVU[OLWLVWSLZPUNPUNLKP[VYZK\IILK[OLZJVYL^P[O(TLYPJHUT\ZPJHUKUHYYH[PVU
I`HU(TLYPJHUWHZ[VY;OLLULYNL[PJZPUNPUNVM[OLLUVYTV\ZJYV^K^HZV]LYK\IILK^P[O
[OLZSV^LTV[PVUHSZ[YHPUZVMJVU[LTWVYHY`(TLYPJHU¸WYHPZLHUK^VYZOPW¹T\ZPJ<ZLKMVY
M\UKYHPZPUNQ\Z[SPRL[OL[LSL[OVU[OL]PKLVRevival in HaitiT\[LK/HP[PHU]VPJLZZPUNPUN/HP[PHU
ZVUNZHUKSPRL[OL[LSL[OVUWYLZLU[LK(TLYPJHUT\ZPJHUK(TLYPJHU]VPJLZPU[OLPYWSHJL
,]LUHZ/HP[PHUZZHUN^PKLS`PUYLZWVUZL[VKPZHZ[LY[OLZLTLKPHYLUKLYLK[OLT\UHTWSPÄLKHUKT\[L;OL[LSL[OVUHUK[OLL]HUNLSPJHS]PKLVIV[OHTV\U[[VTLKPHWYVK\J[Z[OH[
^VYRI`SL]LYHNPUN[OLLTV[PVUZVM(TLYPJHUT\ZPJHSVUNZPKLPTHNLZVM/HP[PHU]PJ[PTZ[V
40 ;LZ[LYHumanitarianism and Modern Culture, ix.
41 1VOU(]HSVU¸;^LU[`-PYZ[*LU[\Y`:[H[LZTHU!*LSLIYP[`+PWSVTH[.LVYNL*SVVUL`¹Newsweek, 28 February 2011, 18.
͂|͂Soundscapes of Disaster and Humanitarianism
YHPZLTVUL`;OL`WYLZLU[[OLTLKPH[LKZ\MMLYPUNVM/HP[PHUIVKPLZHZHWVPNUHU[WSLHZ\YL
[VILJVUZ\TLKI`SPZ[LUPUN]PL^LYZ;OLZLTLKPHWYLZLU[KPZHZ[LY[OYV\NOHUHULZ[OL[PaLK
(TLYPJHU^H`VMRUV^PUNKP]VYJLKLU[PYLS`MYVTH/HP[PHUWLYZWLJ[P]LMYVT*HYPIILHUUHYYH[P]LZZLUZVY`WLYJLW[PVUZOPZ[VYPLZ\UKLYZ[HUKPUNZVYV^ULYZOPW:[PSS/HP[PHUZ\Y]P]VYZ
ZPUNVUHSVULHUK[VNL[OLYJYLH[PUN[OLPYV^UH\KPVZWOLYLZVYPLU[PUN[OLTZLS]LZHNHPU
Acknowledgments
0^V\SKSPRL[V[OHURH\KPLUJLZH[[OL<UP]LYZP[`VM=PYNPUPH=HZZHY*VSSLNLHUK[OL5L^@VYR<UP]LYZP[`
JVUMLYLUJL ¸5LVSPILYHSPZT 9LSPNPVU HUK [OL )VK`¹ MVY [OLPY JVTTLU[Z HUK PU WHY[PJ\SHY 4PTLYVZL
)LH\IY\U @HYPTHY )VUPSSH 1LHU3\J ¸+QHSVRP¹ +LZZHISLZ 4HJHYLUH .VTLa)HYYPZ 3H\YH /HYYPUN[VU
1HUL[1HRVIZVU,YVS1VZ\t4PJOLSSL2PZSP\R*OLSZL`2P]SHUK4HY`1HUL9\ILUZ[LPUHUK4HYR:SVIPU