Validation of the NWCSAF PPS cloud products

no. 04/2005
Remote sensing
report
Remote sensing
Open
Restricted
Confidential
!! "
% $
#
"$
& '
(
) * $
## "
"
+
, $ ##
-" $ .
/ $
.
" $ . +
,
/ $ $ ) * $ * *0 $ $ (
$ # " $$ . #
0 .$
$ +!
!
* $ * !! , / 0
*# *
- . 1
." 2 $
$#
#
"
$ $ *
) * $ 3"
$
2"
$ /
$ ( $ # # $ $/
$ $0 $
# "
"
!! #
"$
$ # " 0$ /
$ $ .
"
"
$ + 1 34,
/ #
$ (
$ $ .
" $
) * $
!! "
#
"$
0 " "
.
"
"
$5 0
$ "
/
" $$ "
"
# $
6 *
$ .5
7665) * $ 5
5
-" $
.5 !! 5 08 " / " $$ "
5
/
!
999999999999999999999999999999999
4 $
+7
"
$:
6 *
999999999999999999999999999999999
/;
% $
$ .,
6 $
Postal address
P.O Box 43 Blindern
N-0313 OSLO
Norway
Office
Niels Henrik Abels vei 40
Telephone
+47 2296 3000
Telefax
+47 2296 3050
"
7 /
+< "
< / #*
e-mail: [email protected]
internet: met.no
< #
Bank account
7694 05 00601
*
,
Swift code
DNBANOKK
report no. 04/2005
(
) * $
" $ .+
" 0
"
0
0
0
- "
!
"
#
@
## "
"
/ $$ ) * $ =$
#
"$ $./
+
, $ ##
) * $ * *0
# . $> #> --$-
-" $ .
$ $ 1
* $
$
/
$
.
*
$ # . $
$ - 5 - #
"
$
3
$
"
#
$ $
!
!
* $ * +!! ,
$
"
$
$5 $ $
1
$
"
&
+1 &, $ $ * 2 $
$
/ 0
? *
- . 1
." 2 $
+ 12, $ $ $
/ 0
$
"
* $;
"
# .
3"
$ 2"
+3 2
,
12 $ / /
(
1 &$ /
0
*# *
12
*
$ " $
.
0
$ #
50
$
"
*
$
$
12
/
## "
1 &$ ( !!
- $
3 2
# 8 " $
**
1 &$ - - $
2*# *
$$ .
0
$ #
$
0 ./
" "
./
#
"$
"
# 0 * "
$
. $
. $
,
$5
( $ # # $
$ # "$ $ *
12
(
: $"
+!&)$,5 0
# " $$ .
"
$/
# $"
"
"
-
!! "
#
!!
$ $ $" 0
< 00
"
$
0 $
*
$ ( $
"
"
$ 3
!3) 4 /
:
5 $ * ? *
$ $ 0
$
!!
-
!&)
*
766
"
*
"
$" 0
( 0
!! $ ! # (
#? $
$
"
+
* $;
"
#
1 34 +& ' 5
$ .
0,
5
05
5
0,
" &
.) * $
.
@
* $
* #
$ *
$ $ $
!
$
"
* $; .
( $#
* $; " $$ $ " # ?
$
" $$
$$ " " /
" $
"
* $;
"
5 "
( " $$ $ $
Table 1 NWCSAF PPS cloud mas numbers and description.
A # " $$
$
"
"
$
-
0 $
#
0
+ 0 *" ,5
*
$
$" 0
" *
Page 1
re po r t no . 04 / 20 05
- 2" "
*
B A " $$
2
" /
" $$ "
/ 0
766 "
$5 0$ /
. *
5
!
*#
$
$
"
C
! $
" $$
.
* $#
"/ #
$ 2
?
$ .
/
*
5$
"
#
0 $
$ * $;$
$
( *
. $
$
$
*
? $/ $
/
$ *
# # " $$ . .
#
$
/
$
$# " "
$"
0 . ? *
$ $ < 00
+
5
05
5
0,
!&)
#
" $$ $,
!! $ $
"
" $$ $
766
" $$ $
$ ( $
./
# .
$ /
"
( 0
( $
# $ 2
@
$
+ "
"
* $; $
."
Table 2 Class number and description of the NWCSAF PPS cloud type product.
A # " $$
$
-"
*
B
D
C
2" "
*
$
-"
$ $
*
-"
$ " *
4 -"
$ $
4 -"
$ " *
*
* / "
$ $
1
* / "
$E" *
7.
# @
"
$ $
7.
# @
"
$E" *
.
# @
"
$ $
.
# @
"
$ " *
B (
"
*
*
*
*
*
$
$
$$ #
"
*
$
D ( "; "
Page 2
*
1
"
C
*
*# $
"
$
-"
$
report no. 04/2005
A " $$
(
*
/ $
*
*#
"
. $
$
$ *
"
"
$
$
*#
"
$$
$
$
* $;
< 00
+
* $;5 0 *
!
$ $
*
* $; #
"
# 0 * "
$ (
?
!
5D 5
! 5
$ *
( # # $
/
$ *
$ $
$ *
$
/
$
5
05
5
0,
!
!&)
!! $ $
"
#
@
$
"
# #
" $ #
*
6((3 +)A1)( (
!
#> --- *
$ $
" *# $
* $#
"
"$ ( *
# *#
$ $# "
$$
$$
< 00
"
!&)
/ 0
# (
+
5
05
*#
766
726
" . / ; $
##
$ $ ##
5
.
(
"
$
.
( $
/
$
# 8 -#$ ,
*# / "
0,
!
766 "
# $# $
$$
!! $ $
$
.$ # 0 0
< 00
+
# "#
."
$#
1 A :+
5 C
$ " $$ $
5
05
5
" .
& F,5
( $ ##
"
$
0,
#
( # $
*# *
12 - $ #
*
.
2"
*
!! /
- $ / 0 (
# .
$ *# *
( *
$
$ $
12 - $ #
.
766 # " $$ . $ $ * - "
*# *
- $0
$" 0
& ' +
,
/
$
#*
/
3"
"
* $;
*
*# *
766
4 /
(
!! $ @
$ "" $$
!! +)A1)( (
!
#>
" . / ; $ "
# 8 -#$ , 4 /
:
$
7665 726
1
- $
/ 0
* 5
!! $ "
* $;
.
- $ .
*
"" #
766 4 /
$
766
*
$@
3 2
/ #*
- $ $ # $$ 0 .
*
12
766 # " $$ . $ $ * ( $ - $
# $$ 0
# *#
$
.
# "#
."
$
(
"
@
(
$
*# *
$ $ $ .
13 &62: * (
"
13 &62: $
0 *
"
!
$
12 $ *
"
,
"
"
/ $ $
$
* $;
"
12
# .
*
" "
*
$ *# *
$
.
$
.
"
(
--- *
A $ $
"
#
( $ $ 0
"
#
!
- " $
$ / 0
) 1
&62: (
"
7264 1 *
+:8' .
5
5
!! /
- " "
5 !&)$
,
$
!& / BB +
!&
Page 3
re po r t no . 04 / 20 05
<
.
*# *
!! $ "
#
*
$ #
3 2
# 8 "
*
$#
* $; # 5 172 # " $$
$ *
$ $ 12 :
$
/ $ $
$ #
* 5
766
!!5 G .$0 . # " " +G !(, 1 * $$
)
.
766
$
12 & ' +
,# $ $
!!
#
#
3 2
$ ( $
"
*
!! $ 12=$ # " $$ . /
*
$ *0 "
# - $$ $ "
(- *
"
!
*#
$ " $ .
766 # 5
. "
$#
# - $
0 /
$ " $
" $ $ "
0$ /
12 0 " " 5 *
.
$ " $ @ "
?#
"
# 8 " E
!!
766 - $
$
@
* $
# )A1)( (
$
(3
$ $ - $ ##
0
- 0 ?#
- $ ##
)!
!
. # " * # # 8 "
$ - $ / # 0
<
!! $ .
12
$ *$ $ " ** #
$ $ " " ";
$0
7264 1 $
172 30$ /
" *# $
$ #$
## #
172 - $
3 2
"
! # 5 0
.
0
$ * +1)3 ,
0
;
.
(
/
5
766 #
! #
. *
.5 "
" 0
$
* 8
$ " $ (
" $
"
$ 50
0 /
0 $$
766
$" 0
"
& ' +
,
& ' +
,5
766 # " $$ . "
"
!!
3 2
$ 766
766 ! " $$ . ! "; .
$ * *0 $ $ ( $
!
2
$ 76!(
"
$ 3
4 / :5 0
1)(3!
* ## . *
$
# 8 "
.
< 1 !5
0 $
A & !63
$ $
( $
$ 1
." 2 $
+<12,5 $ . $ * # $
3
4 / : ( $$ / 0
/ #
*
" $
$
#
2 $#
#.
!! /
" $ /
$ $
*#
$
#.
$ ;
.
# "#
"
*# *
- 0 *# *
+ /
*$
12
"
$
0
;
" $$ "
3 2
#
; # "
<
. $
."
$$ 0 *# *
!!
$ /
"$
#.
!!
$ $
0 , ( $ #.
- /
#.
# " $$ 2 $ $# "
.
#.
# " $$ (
"
# *#
"
(- $ *# #
#
( $ $
"$
"
$ 0
& ' +
3"
$
12=$ < .
$$
*
."
;
1
#
.
$ -$
< " *0
(
.
Page 4
"
#
# " $$ . "
* $; #
"
"
# #
"5
3 2
# 8 "
*
, (
# $
$ " #
$
2"
$$
$ 0
$ +<2
, "
$ # " 0$ /
$5 5
"
* $;
" $$ $
$ -$
"
$#
- " " $$ $
."
$
#
.
( 0
12
0
# $
#
$
- .
$ $ "
#
"
" $ $0
/ 0
* "
"
$
#
"
!
766
3"
" /
>
A(
"
# #
" * $ * . 50
-
" $$ $
$ #
"$
( 0
# $
2 $
report no. 04/2005
<2
"
+
*
# $
." /$
" $
$
$
-
$
12,
*
$- "
*
Figure 1 Cloud mask output from the NWCSAF PPS software as implemented at NMI.
$
%
$#
*
$ .
* " $ $ * + 1 34, - " "
$
$5
766 4 /
5
!! "
#
"
$#
*
$ . 0
- " .
1 34 /
+& ' 5
0, ( "
"
08 " $
$
" $
*$ # "
7264 1
!
#
* $ - " $
$
7<
*
Page 5
re po r t no . 04 / 20 05
- "
# #
$ "" $$ 0
"
$
*
$
$ "
$
-
6 +6 < /
#*
( *5
, $ .
Figure 2 Cloud type output of the NWCSAF PPS software as implemented at NMI.
2
/
"
$
0
# $
$/
# " $$ 8 0 - $ $
$ "
$ "
"
# " $$ )?" #
" 0 /
$
# $
@
"
# " $$ ( * ? * * *
"
-
2
" *# $
$
"
- 0
6
"
# " $$ . * .
* 8
$$ $ * /
0 $
!! "
!!
<
$,
0 .
1 34 7<
.
Page 6
"
$"
@
"
" .
* /
# $ $ +" $
" $ 0
#
/
. # " $$ .
" $
$
* ?* * *
"
- $#
* 08 " $ 0 $
- $
1 34 / 5 $ * ?
*
7<
$
$
" / .
* $5
0 $ "
$ .
.
/
# . ** .
report no. 04/2005
(
B
* #
/
$
0
. ? *
$" $ -
-
0
. C
<
.
$#
$
" $
$" 5
- .
$ # "$
$$
/
( $
( 0
1 $
$ $
$ / *
"
0$ /
$5 0
$ * ; 0
.$*
*
/
7 - / 5
$
/ 0
$
# # $ $ $$
$ $
$ .$*
*
/
0
$
/
"
#
"$
$ / $
$
$
/
0 $ ( $
$" / * $
- 5 *
$
5$ *
$
$
# $$
*
# "
*
$
$
Table 3 Stations used in the NWCSAF PPS validation.
D : .
$
3$
&
*
B
)
*
B
)
*
/ .
B )
3
B
:
$$
CC
" 8 /
:8' '
D G
$
#
D
D)
*
D
C
)
BD
B
C
6' $
0
*
B B
C 6 ..
D
)
B
0
.
B D
B
G/ *$; .
B
$
BD
.$/
$;
C
.$*#
)
.$* 0
D)
.$* 0
C D)
.$*#
D)
.$*#
D )
B C
00
*
*
G8 / ;
.
) .$*
)
BC
H $
BD
B
BC BD
D
;
G $
BD
.$* 0
.$* 0
) .$*
*
) .$*
*
B
D)
.$*#
B
)
.$*#
B D
)
.$*#
&
1 $
" *
# 0 *$ "
& ' +
( /
# $
1)3 4 /
#
$ $ *
$
*
#
"$- " *.
,5 0
$ 0 $
#
1 $
"
"
*
12 $
@
"
$$ $
#
766 # " $$ .
0 -
#
!! #
"$ .
? *
* ## 8 "
( $ / " $
*$ . *
$
0
$$
12 ( $
$
* G !(
1)3
!!
Page 7
re po r t no . 04 / 20 05
* 5
G !( 1)3
766 $- " $
.
!! $ I
$
# " $$ .
$
( $ " $ $
!! "
7< $
.
; # 0
*0
#
* $"
. # " $$
1 34
"
# " $$
#
: #? $
#
$
.
* ?* *
$
$ . *$5 " $$ $
" $$ $" #
$
'
6 $ $
# $
$ $ . *$
# $
0
*0 $ ( "
$#
./
( 0
.
.
" 0 -
.
$ -$
/
$ $
" /
0$ /
$ (
## #
- #
$ -$ $ $
" *#
$"
*
$$
$$
0
* $ # *
" $$
"
.
2
*0 $
!! "
# #
$ -$ $ $
/ " $ $
$
# 2 $
0$ /
?
"
"
"
$ .$ # "$
$5*
0$ /
"
" /
$
$
$
(
/
"
.
$ ## $
?# "
$5
"
$
$ $ -$ * $
"
#
? $ 0 - 2 ? $ # " $$ 5
"
$
" $5
C
/
$
"
# $
$ " $$
$ $" 0
( 0
(
- #
"
.
/ " $ $
$ $ -$
!! " $$ "
*
.
$"
# $
"
" $$ "
$
/
$*
"
" $$
$ , (
*
@
/
*#
B5 5
0 -
*0
$ #
/
.
#
#
"
- $ $ " $$ "
"
#? $ $/
-$
*"
$
$ $ 0$ /
## #
*
/ " $ #? $$ * "
#? $
$"
+ $# "
"
50
$# 0 0
0 $ /
# 0 *
$ " $$
. #? $"
" $"
$ *$ 0
## $
5
.
+$
5
$
*
$
( 0
" *
$ -$
/
$ $
, (
## #
$ -$ $ $
*
*"
$"
2 $
$
$ $
/
$
5
"
* 5@
: $
$/
$# $
- / "
$
(
- #
"
$ 0 /
* $" $$ "
.
"
" $$
$
/ " $ $
$+ $
-"
$$ 0 /
-
-"
$$ *$
#
$*
*
*. $ * $
.
(
$*
# $ $
!! "
# .
#? $ $"
- / "
$ -$
$ $
.
#
$ -$ $ $
" $
## #
- #
./ . / "
$ (
#
*
"
" /
# 8 .
Page 8
";
" *
* "
, ""
.
* < 00
* " $$ $ *# *
"
$
( *
.
$ $
*
$
$ 0 /
# "-
"
$ 0 /
$
50
* $ "
$ 0$ /
.
/ "
$5
"
"
$
*
/ $ * # 0 *$
.
.
$
$
#
$
0
"
# $5
" $$ $
+# $ " ** ,
!!
@
*
*
*$ 0
@
/
"
$$ "
(
## #
$ -$
. "
$5 $ 0/ $
.
$
$ *0 "
( $ *# $
/
-$ # ""
#
$ # $ . " ./
" **
$
$ # "$
$
$5 0
$
-
report no. 04/2005
(
- #
$*$
-
$ -$
#
.
$ $
* $"
"
-
$ /
*
$
$
* / "
$
$ $
50
$
.
"
10000
4000
0
Frequency
N=0
0
5
10
15
20
NWCSAF PPS cloud type index
0e+00 4e+04 8e+04
Frequency
N=8
0
5
10
15
20
NWCSAF PPS cloud type index
Figure 3 Validation results for clear and overcast situations. See Table 2 for
textual description of class numbers.
(
$ $ 0 /
" $
"
"
50
$$ ?
$# " "
$
/ 0
#> --- 0 * . /
$5 * $$ $5 $
*$
"
. " 0 ./
(
(
@
""
/ * $
$
" +)I + ,, - "
$" 0
$ $
*
/
0 "
/ /
@
0* " "
"
0
0
$
. / $
/
0
/
$ 0
/
@
/ /
"
# $
+$# $
0
9- 09# . * , ?
!! "
#
- .
13
*
" $
$
" *#
.
"
"
" $ *
$ +$
0 " $
,
+ ,
: $ $"
+)I + ,, - "
0$ / "
. $ +$
$ $ 0 " $
@
"
"
. $ " *#
*0
,
+ ,
Page 9
re po r t no . 04 / 20 05
! 0 0
+$
0 " $
"
,
+)I + ,, - "
$
- -
*
$ "
. $
+ ,
$
" $
*
,
+)I + ,, - "
$
-
*
$
-
. " $ +$
!
0
+ ,
Table 4 Contingency table representing the relation between satelite classification and synoptic
observation of cloudy or clear areas.
B B
D
D
&/
$ $ ( 0
0 C 5
# 0 0
" *#
0 /
#
" .
)I + , + ,
$ C
"
$
"
"
$
""
BC
"
$
"
$
/ " $
"
# " 0$ /
0
*
#? $
$
C 5
$
*
0 $ $
(
$
!!
" (
( "
$ /
*
$ "
0 .$
&/
"
# .
"
- /
"
# $
<
.
$$
$
( $ 0 .$5 . @
"
#
7<
$5 "
* $ *#$ $ # " # $
$ "
"
/ 0 "
"
$
" * .$ $" 0
0 /
. . " "
.
0
#
$
- .
(
$5
. .5
0
*
5 $
$$ $ .
-
( $ # " # #
* 0 *
0$ / $ $
- $ "
50
" $ $
0 $
0$ /
3
$0 $ / . $ "
/
* .
.
"
$
Page 10
$#
*
$ .
$ / $
1 34
" " $ $$ 0 .$
$ / 0
" *#
* $$ . . $ +
* . " / . ,5
" $ .
$
!! #
"$
/ 0
"
"
7 - / 5
# $ "
$
$ $
/
$ $ *
0
"
"
$# "
0$ /
/
/
$ $.
!! $ #
*
#? $"
# $ $" 0
$
$#
5
$
/
-#?
.
*
"
0
-
@
" *# ?
$
# " #
0$ /
.
(
/ $
*
"
0$ / $ "
$ *
#
0 $ ( $ $"
$
@
*
- *
*
report no. 04/2005
.
* ;
" $ $
#
"
.
( /
7 - / 5
-
*
/ 0
/
" " " $ $5 $
"
"
$ 0 " * ( $
$ "
"
- " - $
# $$ 0
$
-
$
*
*"
$
$
!! "
# .
$ - / " *# "
0
$"
"
$
$ /
- "
$
$# $
"
$5
$ . $ # " 0$ /
$
/
"
. $
$@ $
"
"
$ "
- "
$ $
*. 0
$
#
*
?#
"
$
$.
( $ $
*#
$# " " "
.
!! "
# $3 2
2 4AJ +$
- / $
"
0
$
" ,
# " $$ .
(
.
@
/
/ /
-
$
$.
# 0 0
3 "
.
$*
CC 5 CC , $
/ 0
*
"
/ " $
$ +
" *# $
"
" / $ #
*
-
"
C
"
$
0
*
*
" *
$ "
0
$ 0
"
$
# ? $ $ *$
0 @
*
0$ /
$ *
$
+G $$ 5
" *# $
$#
*
7 - / 5 $
$ # " * $ * ,
$ 5
/
$ $ "
# /
/
0
< 00
$
1
+
, $ -$
"
" / $
"
" $ "
"
$#
*
. /.
"
"
"
*. 0 #
*
$ .
"
1
* " 8 $*
( $$ - - $
$
$
$$
- # " $$ ( $5 $
*.
/
.
*0
"
# ? $ * $" $$
$"
" $
.
- 0 " /
$ .
* $
"
!! / $
.3
.
$
$$
- $
.
; - .
!! "
#
*.
"
3 2
#
"$
" ( *#
5 $
- / $
"
" 5
.- / $
"
"
$
0 $ 0
. $$
"
$
$ $ $
$ .
0
$0 /
$ $.
"
$0 0
$ $.
( *
$ $
$ $
*$
"
# . #
$
" *# " $
$
! *#
$
7 - / 5
/
/
"
$
" $$ # "* $ * $
$# $ 5 *
"
" $
12 / 0
*# *
( $ $
" $ $ $
$$
/$ F
*
." #
"$ : $"
- *
"
$
" $
;
!!
#
.
- $ # " 0$ /
$5 /
766
* .
!
# (
" $ "
" $$
$
!! #
"
(
*
"
.
*
#
"5 # $
.
- " $$ $
$ 0*
# $
* ; $ " $ @
"
"
$
#
"
"
$ + 1 34, 2
"
"
0$ / . . *
5
7665
!5
3 2
2
3 2
<42 08 " $
$
( $# * $ $
.
*$
"
"
$
( $
$
"
"" $$ 0
* 6 +6 < / #*
( *5
,- "
-$ .
$ $ "$
. # "$ 1
*
$ $ * $./
$
$
+
,
& ' +
0,
Page 11
re po r t no . 04 / 20 05
100
50
0
Frequency
150
N=8 and only low clouds
0
5
10
15
20
NWCSAF PPS cloud type index
600
200
0
Frequency
N=8 and only medium clouds
0
5
10
15
20
NWCSAF PPS cloud type index
Figure 4 Validation results for cloudy situations containing only low and
medium level clouds (upper and lower panel respectively). See Table 2 for
textual description of class numbers.
)
( $$
$$ !! "
# .
/ $ .
" - $
* $" $$
."
#? $ $"
(
/
"
$ $ *$ 0
. $
*
* " $ +"
$ 0 / ,
*
"
- $ " $$
. "
#? $ $
"
$ $ 0$ / 5 0 " *#
*0
# ? $ $ # 0 * $ *$ 0 $$
( "
"
* $" $$ "
$
2 & ' +
5
,
( $
$
*# *
12
) * $
!!
<
$ " *
( $- *# *
"
Page 12
$
$# $
" "
- " "
#
$* $
"
0
$ * # 0 *$
0 $"
766 # " $$ .
12 $0
0
$ .
766
*
G .$0 . # " " 1)3
7 - / 5
- *# *
766 # " $$ . 0 $
#
$ 1
." 2 $
< 1 !$ / 0
#
* / *
# 0 *$ "
# $
$
(
$
$
- "
" $ # 0 *$
" $ F
report no. 04/2005
/
/ 0
#
*
/
/
?
(#
"$ ( $" $ $
12
" 5
0 # $
- "
$/
? $
*#
0
#
*
3 2
#
0e+00 4e+04 8e+04
Frequency
N=8 and high clouds
0
5
10
15
20
NWCSAF PPS cloud type index
150
50
0
Frequency
N=8 and high thin clouds
0
5
10
15
20
NWCSAF PPS cloud type index
Figure 5 Validation results of cloudy situations containing only high level
clouds (upper and lower panel shows all high level clouds and only thin Cirrus
respectively). See Table 2 for textual description of class numbers.
Page 13
re po r t no . 04 / 20 05
Bjørge, D., Haugen, J. E., Homleid, M., Vignes, O., and Ødegaard, V., 2003: Updating the HIRLAM
numerical weather prediction system at met.no 2000-2002, DNMI Research Report, No. 145, , ISSN
0332-9879, Norwegian Meteorological Institute, Oslo, Norway, 7 March 2003, 25pp.
Christoffersen, A., Foss, A., Godøy, Ø., Korsmo, H., and Schulze, J., 2003: Interactive collocation of
AVHRR training data, DNMI Research Note, No. 93, ISSN 0332-9879, Norwegian Meteorological
Institute, Oslo, Norway, 8pp.
Dybbroe, A., K.-G. Karlsson, M. Moberg, and A. Thoss, 2000a: Scientific Report for the SAFNWC Mid
Term Review, SAF/NWC/SMHI/MTR/SR/1 Issue 1.0, 21 February 2000, Swedish Meteorological and
Hydrological Institute, SE-601 76 Norrkøping, Sweden, 148pp.
Dybbroe, A., Thoss, A. and Karlsson K.-G., 2000b. The AVHRR & AMSU/MHS products of the
Nowcasting SAF. Proceedings of the 2000 Eumetsat Meteorological Satellite Data Users’ Conference,
Bologna, Italy, pp. 729-736. ISBN: 92-9110-037-4.
Dybbroe, A., 2004: Improved navigation of Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer data at high
latitudes, SMHI-BPF/TEC/AVHRR/1, Version 1.0, 23 December 2004, Swedish Meteorological and
Hydrological Institute, SE-601 76 Norrkøping, Sweden, 45pp.
Dybbroe, A., Karlsson, K.-G. and Thoss, A., 2005a: NWCSAF AVHRR cloud detection and analysis
using dynamic thresholds and radiative transfer modelling - part one: Algorithm description, Accepted for
publication in J. Appl. Meteor.
Dybbroe, A., Karlsson, K.-G. and Thoss, A., 2005b: NWCSAF AVHRR cloud detection and analysis
using dynamic thresholds and radiative transfer modelling - part two: Tuning and validation, Accepted for
publication in J. Appl. Meteor.
Godøy,Ø., 2002: Validation of the SAFNWC PPS implementation at MI using similar products from
SMHI, DNMI Research Note, No. 83, ISSN 0332-9879, Norwegian Meteorological Institute, Oslo,
Norway, 12pp.
Godøy,Ø., 2003a: Some remarks concerning AVHRR processing at the Norwegian Meteorological
Institute, DNMI Research Note, No. 86, ISSN 0332-9879, Norwegian Meteorological Institute, Oslo,
Norway, 12pp.
Godøy, Ø., 2003b: Description of a collocation system for data from various meteorological observation
and prediction systems, DNMI Research Note No. 86, ISSN 0332-9879, Norwegian Meteorological
Institute, Oslo, Norway, 19pp.
Karlsson, K.G., 1993: Comparison of operational AVHRR-based cloud features with surface
observations. In: Proc. 6th European AVHRR Data Users' Meeting, belgirate, Italy, 28 June-3July, 1993,
EUMETSAT pp. 223-230.
Karlsson, K.G., 1995: Estimation of Cloudiness at High Latitudes from Multispectral Satellite
Measurements, Ambio, Vol. 24, No. 1, Feb 1995, Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences 1995.
R Development Core Team, 2004: R: A language and environment for statistical computing, Note 3900051-07-0, R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, 2004, http://www.R-project.org.
Page 14